Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Bubble-net feeding

Bubble-net feeding is a specialized foraging technique primarily employed by humpback whales (Megaptera novaeangliae), in which the whales exhale streams of bubbles underwater to form cylindrical or spiral nets that corral schools of prey such as herring, capelin, or krill into a concentrated mass.^[1]^[2] This behavior, observed in both solitary individuals and coordinated groups, relies on the whales diving beneath the prey aggregation and spiraling upward while releasing air from their blowholes, creating rising bubble curtains that act as a temporary barrier, disorienting the prey and preventing escape to the surface.^[3]^[4] Once the prey is tightly contained, the whales lunge vertically through the center of the bubble net with mouths agape, engulfing the trapped biomass in a single gulp.^[1] The technique is culturally transmitted and learned rather than innate, varying in prevalence across humpback populations, with notable occurrences in regions like Southeast Alaska and the Antarctic.^[5] Recent biomechanical analyses indicate that bubble-net feeding demands exceptional maneuverability, enabled uniquely by humpback whales' elongated pectoral flippers and body morphology, which allow the tight, high-acceleration turns necessary to manufacture effective bubble structures—capabilities not shared among other baleen whale species.^[6]^[7] This foraging strategy exemplifies advanced tool use in marine mammals, as the bubbles function as manufactured barriers to enhance prey capture efficiency.^[8]^[1]

Mechanism and Technique

Core Process of Bubble Formation and Feeding

Bubble-net feeding begins with one or more humpback whales (Megaptera novaeangliae) diving beneath an aggregation of prey, typically at depths of 10 to 30 meters, though initiations can occur as shallow as 3 to 5 meters below the surface.^[9] The primary bubble-producing whale exhales air through its blowholes while executing a tight upward spiral, releasing a continuous stream of bubbles that form a cylindrical or helical curtain rising toward the surface.^[10] This spiral motion, often involving centripetal accelerations up to 0.46 m/s² in solitary feeders, generates an intricate network of bubbles with diameters ranging from small uniform clouds (4-7 meters across from single exhalations) to larger columns (1-1.5 meters diameter) arranged in rings up to 15 meters across.^[6]^[9] The rising bubbles create a visual and hydrodynamic barrier, as the opaque curtain traps prey by inducing avoidance behavior; fish perceive the bubble wall as an obstacle and congregate in the central cylinder, prevented from escaping laterally or surfacing due to the bubbles' interference with their movement.^[3] Bubbles are released in multiple columns of varying sizes, forming nets, curtains, or spirals that aggregate prey density, with acoustic and pressure effects potentially enhancing containment.^[11] In group efforts, specialized roles emerge, with bubble blowers maintaining the net while other whales position for the feed, though solitary whales can achieve similar structures through self-orchestrated spirals.^[12] Feeding concludes with the whales lunging vertically through the center of the bubble net, mouths agape to engulf the concentrated prey bolus, often breaking the surface in synchronized fashion.^[9] This lunge exploits the prey's milling confinement, maximizing intake efficiency; observations confirm whales targeting species like herring or krill herded into tight schools by the bubble barrier.^[3] The process typically cycles multiple times per bout, with bubble nets comprising about 8% of documented feeding events in historical surveys.^[9]

Variations in Bubble-Net Strategies

Humpback whales employ bubble-net feeding in both solitary and cooperative forms, with the former representing a rarer strategy observed in approximately 2.8% of foraging individuals during surveys from 2019 to 2021 in Alaskan waters.^[2] In solitary bubble-net feeding, a single whale exhales bubbles forming 1 to 6 internally tangential rings (mean of 3.1 rings), deployed at depths averaging 22.1 meters over about 80 seconds, creating a mesh with 1.2-meter spacing in the innermost ring to corral diffuse krill patches like Thysanoessa sp. and Euphausia pacifica.^[2] This configuration exploits prey avoidance of bubbles, concentrating them into a smaller area (innermost ring ~37 m²) and boosting intake per lunge by roughly sevenfold without elevating energetic costs beyond standard lunges.^[2] Cooperative bubble-net feeding, more prevalent in dense prey aggregations such as herring schools, involves 2 to over 10 whales coordinating to produce bubble curtains that herd fish toward the surface for simultaneous lunges.^[13] Group size modulates strategy: smaller pairs or triads often execute tighter spirals with divided roles—one whale blowing bubbles while others herd—enhancing prey containment, whereas larger groups (>4 individuals) distribute exertion but may increase individual dive variability and fatigue due to synchronization demands. Individual whales exhibit preferences for specific dive types within groups, such as single versus multiple bubble bursts per ascent, influenced by position in the formation; peripheral whales perform more vigorous maneuvers, correlating with higher oxygen consumption in larger assemblages. Some cooperative events feature double bubble-net formations, where whales generate concentric or overlapping rings to reinforce barriers against prey escape, observed in high-density feeding areas like Alaskan fjords during peak summer herring runs.^[14] These variations adapt to prey density and depth: solitary tactics suit shallow, scattered krill, while group strategies target vertically migrating fish schools, with underwater spiraling by a lead whale creating a vortex that funnels prey upward.^[3] Empirical tagging data confirm that bubble-net efficacy rises with complexity in groups, though solitary nets demonstrate comparable tool-like precision in ring calibration to minimize escape gaps.^[2]

Physiological and Evolutionary Basis

Adaptations Enabling Bubble-Net Feeding

Humpback whales possess 14 to 35 ventral throat pleats extending from the chin to the navel, enabling the buccal cavity to expand up to several times its resting volume during lunge feeding, which allows efficient engulfment of prey concentrated by bubble nets.^[15] These elastic grooves, combined with a muscular tongue and broad lower jaw, facilitate the rapid intake of large water volumes laden with fish or krill, followed by expulsion through overlapping baleen plates numbering 300 to 400 on each side, which filter out prey while expelling water.^[15] This rorqual-style engulfment capacity is critical for capitalizing on the temporary prey aggregations created by bubble nets, maximizing caloric intake per lunge.^[16] The whales' dual blowholes permit controlled underwater exhalation, producing streams of bubbles that rise to form curtain-like barriers or spiral nets, deterring prey from dispersing; this requires precise respiratory modulation during dives, supported by efficient myoglobin storage in muscles for prolonged submergence up to 10-15 minutes.^[17] Humpbacks often emit low-frequency vocalizations, such as "feeding calls," alongside bubbles to further herd prey, leveraging laryngeal adaptations for sound production underwater without surfacing.^[3] Morphological traits uniquely equip humpbacks for the tight, circular maneuvers essential to bubble-net construction, including elongated pectoral flippers generating lift forces of approximately 7800 N, which enable centripetal accelerations of 0.46 m s⁻² and superior turning performance compared to other baleen whales.^[18] Powerful flukes and pronounced spinal flexibility allow inward banking and sustained rolls during solitary or group spirals, reducing turning radii to corral prey patches that would otherwise be uneconomical for lunge feeding in less agile mysticetes.^[18] These features, absent or less developed in congeners like blue or fin whales, underpin the evolution of bubble-net feeding as a specialized foraging adaptation.^[6]

Uniqueness Among Baleen Whales

Bubble-net feeding is a foraging strategy documented exclusively in humpback whales (Megaptera novaeangliae) among baleen whales, with no observations of similar coordinated bubble entrapment in other mysticete species such as blue whales or right whales, which primarily rely on lunge or skim feeding.^[7]^[19] This exclusivity arises from humpback whales' unique morphological adaptations, notably their elongated pectoral flippers, which facilitate tight spiral trajectories and high centripetal accelerations—up to 0.46 m/s² in solitary feeding events—exceeding the hydrodynamic capabilities of other baleen whales based on comparative body plan analyses.^[20]^[7] A 2025 University of Hawaii study modeled these maneuvers, concluding that the flippers' leverage and control enable the precise bubble ring formation required, a feat unattainable by species with shorter, less maneuverable appendages.^[7] The behavior's sophistication, including learned cooperative variants with vocal cues for synchronization, further distinguishes it, as acoustic and visual signals integral to bubble-net execution have not been identified in other baleen whales' foraging repertoires despite extensive observational data from global populations.^[21]^[7]

Prey Targeting and Efficiency

Targeted Prey Species

Humpback whales employing bubble-net feeding primarily target dense aggregations of small, schooling prey that respond to bubble barriers by aggregating centrally, facilitating efficient capture. Common targets include euphausiid krill such as Thysanoessa spp. and Euphausia pacifica, which form swarms in regions like Southeast Alaska where solitary or group feeding occurs.^[1] In coastal North Pacific waters, Pacific herring (Clupea pallasii) schools are frequently corralled, as observed in Alaskan fjords where whales create tightening spirals to concentrate these fish before lunging.^[7] ^[22] Other schooling fish exploited via this method encompass juvenile salmon (Oncorhynchus spp.) and northern anchovies (Engraulis mordax), particularly in areas with high prey patchiness; whales synchronize bubble release and ascent to exploit these species' anti-predator responses, delaying jaw expansion until proximate to the school.^[8] ^[23] Prey selection aligns with local abundance, favoring species that panic upward or cluster against bubble walls, as documented in hydrodynamic studies of net formation.^[3] ^[9] This technique's efficacy stems from targeting prey with cohesive schooling behavior, enabling whales to ingest up to 3,000 pounds daily during peak foraging, though exact yields vary by prey density and net geometry.^[24] Regional variations highlight adaptability: krill-dominated feeds in Antarctic or Alaskan krill blooms contrast with herring-focused efforts in temperate herring runs.^[4] ^[25]

Foraging Success and Energy Dynamics

Bubble-net feeding significantly enhances foraging success in humpback whales (Megaptera novaeangliae) by concentrating prey into a confined area, enabling capture of up to seven times more prey per lunge compared to direct lunges on dispersed patches.^[2] This efficiency arises from the bubble net's structure, typically comprising 1–6 concentric rings (mean 3.1), which reduces the effective foraging area by a factor of 7.2 on average, increasing prey density proportionally while minimizing escapement through fine mesh sizes (1.2 m in innermost rings).^[2] In solitary executions, whales perform a single lunge per dive after net deployment, contrasting with up to 15 lunges required in non-net feeding scenarios, thereby optimizing intake from low-density krill or fish schools at depths of 10–37 m.^[2] Group-based bubble-net feeding further amplifies success through coordinated corralling, where participants share the effort of encircling prey, potentially yielding higher collective yields in dense aggregations. Energy dynamics favor bubble-net feeding as it incurs no additional expenditure relative to lunge feeding, with lunge speeds averaging 2.1 m/s—60% of those in non-net methods—and deployment speeds at 1.5 m/s, reflecting lower hydrodynamic demands.^[2] Breathing rates remain comparable (62.9 breaths/hour for net feeders vs. 75.1 for others), indicating sustained aerobic capacity without elevated metabolic costs, even as whales produce 7.3 times more bubbles per minute in inner rings to refine the trap.^[2] ^[26] In larger groups, individual energy outlay decreases due to reduced movement for prey herding, as roles specialize and distances traveled shorten, enhancing net caloric gain essential for building summer fat reserves (up to 50% body mass) before migration. This balance underscores bubble-net feeding's adaptive value in exploiting patchy resources, where prey energy yield (primarily from lipid-rich euphausiids) outweighs the minimal costs of bubble production and maneuvering.^[26]

Solitary Versus Cooperative Execution

Bubble-net feeding in humpback whales (Megaptera novaeangliae) occurs both solitarily and cooperatively, with the execution differing in scale, coordination, and energetic demands. In solitary instances, a single whale dives to approximately 22 meters depth and exhales bubbles in a clockwise spiral, forming 1 to 6 internally tangential rings with a mean of 3.1 rings, taking about 80 seconds to construct.^[1] The whale then lunges upward through the innermost ring at 2.1 m/s to engulf concentrated prey, such as krill, with the bubble-net acting as a tool that increases prey density by over sevenfold within the ring's 1.2-meter mesh.^[1] Cooperative bubble-net feeding involves groups typically ranging from 2 to over 20 individuals, who synchronize actions using vocalizations to herd prey and maintain the net's structure.^[27] One or more whales exhale bubbles to form the net while others circle below to corral fish schools, culminating in simultaneous lunges through the enclosure; this division allows larger nets and potentially higher prey capture per event, though individual roles remain consistent across group sizes, with less per-whale movement required in larger groups.^[28] Solitary execution, observed in only 2.8% of 742 humpback whales surveyed from 2019 to 2021 in Southeast Alaska, demands exceptional maneuverability enabled by humpback morphology, such as elongated pectoral flippers generating sufficient lift for tight turns exceeding 0.46 m/s² centripetal acceleration—capabilities not matched by other baleen whales.^[2]^[29] In contrast, cooperative efforts, more prevalent in regions like the Canadian Pacific and Alaskan waters, facilitate social learning and diffusion of the technique across populations, enhancing group foraging efficiency in dense prey patches.^[5] Both forms underscore the learned nature of the behavior, absent in non-practicing populations, with solitary variants highlighting individual innovation akin to tool use.^[1]

Evidence of Learned Behavior and Transmission

Bubble-net feeding exhibits characteristics of a culturally transmitted behavior among humpback whales, acquired through social learning rather than innate instinct, as evidenced by its uneven distribution across populations lacking corresponding genetic variation. Observations in Southeast Alaska, where the technique is prevalent, contrast with its rarity elsewhere, such as in the Gulf of Maine or until 2020 in Australian waters, indicating propagation via behavioral imitation within matrilineal or social groups rather than universal heritability.^[30]^[31] Empirical studies document calves developing proficiency by observing and mimicking adult performers, often mothers during foraging episodes, with longitudinal tracking revealing that juveniles initially participate peripherally before executing independent nets. For instance, acoustic and visual data from Alaskan pods show coordinated vocal cues—such as feeding calls—facilitating synchronized bubble release, a skill refined through repeated group interactions rather than solitary trial-and-error.^[32]^[33] Transmission extends beyond parent-offspring pairs, as non-maternal adults in cooperative groups demonstrate the behavior to unrelated calves, supporting models of cultural diffusion akin to those observed in humpback song propagation. Experimental simulations and prey capture efficiency metrics further corroborate that naive whales achieve higher success rates when exposed to demonstrated sequences, underscoring the adaptive value of observational learning in optimizing energy intake during seasonal migrations.^[30]^[34]

Geographic and Temporal Patterns

Primary Locations and Habitats

Bubble-net feeding by humpback whales (Megaptera novaeangliae) is predominantly documented in the summer feeding grounds of the North Pacific population, with Southeast Alaska serving as a primary hotspot. Observations cluster in coastal regions such as Frederick Sound, Chatham Strait, and areas near Sitka and Juneau, where whales exploit seasonal prey concentrations from late spring through early fall.^[35]^[36] This behavior has also been noted sporadically in other North Pacific sites like the Gulf of Alaska and near Seward, but Southeast Alaska accounts for the majority of recorded cooperative and solitary variants.^[37]^[13] The requisite habitats feature cold, productive temperate to subarctic marine environments with water temperatures typically ranging from 8–12°C, supporting dense patches of euphausiids (krill) or schooling fish like Pacific herring (Clupea pallasii).^[1]^[2] These areas often include fjords, straits, and sheltered bays with moderate depths (50–200 meters) that allow for vertical prey aggregation and bubble curtain formation without rapid dissipation. Upwelling-driven productivity and tidal mixing enhance prey availability, creating predictable foraging opportunities in nearshore zones.^[38] Such conditions are less prevalent in breeding grounds or open ocean, limiting bubble-net feeding to high-latitude summer ranges.^[36]

Seasonal and Environmental Triggers

Bubble-net feeding primarily occurs during the summer months in high-latitude feeding grounds, such as Alaskan waters and the British Columbia Inside Passage, aligning with humpback whales' annual migration northward from winter breeding areas in tropical regions. This seasonal window, typically spanning May to September for North Pacific populations, coincides with peak prey availability driven by extended daylight and enhanced phytoplankton blooms that support zooplankton and forage fish proliferation. During this period, whales engage in intensive foraging, consuming up to 1,500 kilograms of prey daily to replenish blubber reserves depleted during fasting migrations and breeding.^[13]^[24] Key environmental triggers include dense aggregations of schooling prey, such as Pacific herring (Clupea pallasii) or euphausiid krill, which form in response to oceanographic features like upwelling zones, tidal fronts, and areas of high chlorophyll-a concentration exceeding 5 mg/m³. These conditions concentrate nutrients, fostering prey patches suitable for bubble-netting, where whales detect and target schools via echolocation or visual cues, deploying the technique to corral evasive fish against the surface. Humpback whales adjust bubble-net deployment depth and configuration based on prey depth, water column stratification, and local currents, optimizing for densities where standard lunge feeding yields lower efficiency.^[39]^[8]^[1] Interannual variability in bubble-net frequency reflects fluctuating environmental drivers, including sea surface temperatures and prey condition; for example, cooler, nutrient-enriched years promote tighter prey schools, eliciting more frequent cooperative bouts, whereas warmer anomalies dispersing schools reduce observations. Acoustic monitoring in southeast Alaska has documented heightened activity during periods of stable stratification and moderate tidal flows, which maintain prey accessibility near the surface.^[40]^[41]

Scientific Research and Theories

Historical Discovery and Early Observations

The earliest documented observation of bubble-net feeding occurred in 1929, when Norwegian whaler A. Ingebrigtsen reported humpback whales (Megaptera novaeangliae) in the Norwegian Sea near Bear Island employing a circular bubble-releasing technique to capture krill shoals, describing how the whales swam in tightening spirals while exhaling air to form a rising "wall" or "net" of bubbles that confined prey near the surface.^[9] ^[42] Ingebrigtsen noted two primary methods used by the whales, with the bubble net serving to trap crustaceans by creating an underwater barrier that forced prey upward, though he did not explicitly frame it as cooperative foraging at the time.^[9] Systematic scientific study of the behavior emerged in the 1970s through observations in Southeast Alaska, where researchers Charles and Virginia Jurasz documented "bubble-netting" during field work beginning in 1974 near Shelter Island, identifying it as a coordinated feeding strategy involving groups of up to 14 humpback whales that exhaled bubbles in expanding spirals to corral herring or other schooling fish into dense balls for efficient lunging.^[43] ^[36] Their 1979 publication detailed the sequence: a lead whale initiates vocalizations and bubble columns, followed by others spiraling downward to 15-30 meters while releasing air, forming a net with diameters of 10-30 meters that surfaced as a visible ring, prompting synchronized breaches through the trapped prey.^[36] ^[9] These Alaskan observations, conducted via boat-based monitoring, revealed variations including single-revolution and multi-revolution nets, contrasting with earlier anecdotal reports and establishing bubble-net feeding as a learned, socially transmitted technique unique to humpbacks among baleen whales.^[9] Subsequent early studies in the early 1980s, such as those by Hain et al. in the western North Atlantic, expanded on Jurasz's findings by confirming bubble nets in different prey contexts like euphausiids, with shipboard surveys in May 1980 documenting nets formed by 1.5 to 2 complete revolutions and emphasizing the role of underwater vocalizations in coordination.^[9] These observations highlighted regional adaptations, with Alaskan humpbacks favoring herring-focused cooperative nets, while Atlantic populations showed more solitary or variant forms, underscoring the behavior's prevalence during summer feeding migrations but rarity in tropical breeding grounds.^[9]

Acoustic and Hydrodynamic Explanations

Hydrodynamic explanations for bubble-net feeding emphasize the physical properties of the rising bubble curtain in corralling prey. The exhaled bubbles, typically 1-5 cm in diameter and released in a spiral pattern, form a cylindrical barrier approximately 10-30 meters in diameter and up to 20 meters deep, generating turbulent upwelling flows and pressure gradients that deter fish from crossing outward.^[3]^[11] This containment is enhanced by the buoyancy-driven ascent of bubbles at rates of 1-2 m/s, creating a semi-permeable membrane where fish school tightly in the low-turbulence core to avoid the outer bubble-induced shear.^[11] Computational fluid dynamics models demonstrate that under typical ocean currents (0.1-0.5 m/s), the net maintains coherence for 10-30 seconds, sufficient for a lunge-feed, with bubble volume fractions of 0.01-0.05% producing the necessary hydrodynamic stability.^[11] In solitary foraging, this mechanism allows a single whale to manufacture the net as a temporary tool, increasing prey density by factors of 2-5 times within the corral.^[2] Acoustic explanations propose that bubble nets amplify or trap underwater sounds to enhance herding. Humpback whales emit "trumpet" calls (broadband pulses at 100-500 Hz, up to 160 dB re 1 μPa) during bubble release, which propagate through the bubbly medium with reduced attenuation due to the net acting as a cylindrical waveguide.^[11]^[3] Leighton et al. (2004) hypothesized that the spiral geometry focuses these calls into a "wall of sound," creating radial intensity gradients (up to 20-30 dB higher in the core) that startle fish, eliciting avoidance behaviors and concentrating schools centrally; fish like herring respond to such low-frequency pulses by milling or fleeing, transforming escape instincts into entrapment.^[44]^[45] Finite element simulations of sound propagation in bubble nets confirm enhanced reverberation within the spiral, with bubble resonance at 200-300 Hz matching feeding call frequencies, potentially disorienting prey over the 5-10 second net formation phase.^[46] Acoustic tags (DTAGs) deployed on feeding humpbacks record synchronized vocalizations with bubble exhalations, supporting coordination but leaving the prey-trapping effect as a hypothesis requiring further empirical validation via prey telemetry.^[3]^[47] These mechanisms are not mutually exclusive; hydrodynamic barriers may primarily contain prey visually and via flow, while acoustics provide a secondary sensory deterrent, with models indicating synergistic effects in prey density amplification.^[11] Observations from Southeast Alaska (2008-2010) link both to higher capture efficiencies in krill and herring schools, though direct causation remains inferred from indirect measures like net persistence and whale lunges.^[3]

Recent Empirical Findings

A 2024 empirical study in Southeast Alaska utilized animal-borne tags and unoccupied aerial systems to analyze 83 solitary bubble-nets produced by 23 humpback whales, revealing that these structures typically feature 1 to 6 concentric rings with a mean of 3.1 rings and an innermost ring area of 37.0 m², resulting in a greater than sevenfold increase in prey density from outer to inner rings.^[2] This concentration mechanism enhances foraging efficiency for low-density prey patches without elevating energetic costs, as lunge speeds averaged 2.1 m/s and breath rates 62.9 per hour during feeding events.^[2] Such solitary bubble-netting was rare, observed in only 2.8% of 742 whales surveyed from 2019 to 2021.^[2] In August 2025, a comparative analysis of turning performance across seven baleen whale species, drawing on suction-cup tag and drone data from 28 organizations, determined that humpback whales alone can execute the high-maneuverability spirals essential for bubble-net feeding due to their elongated pectoral flippers, which generate nearly 50% of the required turning force.^[7] Solitary bubble-net feeding humpbacks achieved centripetal accelerations of 0.46 m/s², surpassing the upper physiological limits of other species without excessive energy demands, underscoring a unique morphological adaptation for this behavior.^[29] Research published in 2024 documented a novel bubble-net foraging strategy among Western Antarctic humpback whales, present in every study year with an average prevalence of 30% in sightings and 19% of lunges, frequently associated with larger group sizes, suggesting an adaptive response to regional environmental conditions and prey availability.^[41]

Ecological Role and Human Interactions

Contributions to Humpback Population Health

Bubble-net feeding enhances the foraging efficiency of humpback whales (Megaptera novaeangliae) by creating bubble curtains that corral prey such as krill and small fish into concentrated patches, facilitating the capture of larger prey volumes during lunge ascents.^[4] This technique allows individual whales to achieve up to seven times more prey per gulp compared to non-tool-assisted lunges, conserving energy by reducing the number of foraging dives required.^[8] Measurements of breath rates, swimming kinematics, and lunge dynamics in solitary bubble-net feeders demonstrate that the increased prey density does not elevate energetic costs beyond standard lunge feeding, yielding a net positive energy balance.^[1] The caloric surplus from this behavior supports the accumulation of blubber reserves essential for humpback whales, which endure extended fasting periods during migration and breeding.^[13] Nutritional adequacy during summer foraging directly influences body condition, with deficiencies historically linked to reduced calving rates and population declines in the mid-20th century due to prey shortages and whaling pressures.^[48] By optimizing energy intake, bubble-net feeding contributes to improved maternal health, enhancing calf viability and overall reproductive success, which bolsters population recovery observed since international whaling protections in the 1960s and 1970s.^[13] In regions with prevalent bubble-net activity, such as Southeast Alaska, this strategy's prevalence correlates with sustained individual fitness, as evidenced by stable or increasing population segments amid variable prey availability.^[1] While direct causation between bubble-net adoption and broad population metrics remains under study, the technique's role in mitigating foraging inefficiencies underscores its adaptive value for long-term demographic health in a species dependent on high-lipid prey aggregation.^[2]

Impacts from Anthropogenic Disturbances

Underwater noise from commercial shipping has been shown to disrupt humpback whale foraging behaviors, including bubble-net feeding, by altering dive patterns and reducing feeding efficiency. In a study off the coast of southeast Alaska, increasing ship noise levels correlated with slower descent rates during dives and fewer side-roll feeding events, which are key components of coordinated bubble-net strategies; in 5 out of 18 focal groups, whales ceased observable feeding altogether during high-noise conditions.^[49] These acoustic disturbances mask the whales' vocalizations used for coordination in group bubble-net feeding and may elevate stress responses, potentially leading to reduced energy intake during critical foraging periods.^[50] Vessel traffic, including whale-watching boats and cargo ships, further exacerbates these impacts by altering humpback whale movement and behavior in feeding grounds. Research in Alaska's Frederick Sound indicated that proximity to vessels increased swim speeds, respiration rates, and path directness while decreasing dive durations, suggesting a shift away from energy-intensive bubble-net maneuvers toward avoidance or less effective foraging.^[51] In heavily trafficked areas like the Inside Passage, overlapping shipping routes with prime bubble-net sites heighten risks of vessel strikes, particularly for juveniles engaging in surface-oriented feeding, contributing to elevated mortality rates documented in strandings since 2016.^[52] Climate-driven changes in prey distribution pose longer-term threats to bubble-net feeding viability. Projections for southern hemisphere humpback populations indicate that warming oceans could reduce krill abundance—a primary target of bubble-net corralling—by up to 20-30% in key Antarctic feeding grounds by mid-century, forcing whales to expend more energy on alternative prey or suboptimal sites.^[53] In northern populations, such as those off Alaska, shifts in euphausiid (krill-like) aggregations due to sea ice loss have already correlated with expanded foraging ranges, potentially diluting the density of prey patches needed for efficient bubble-net formation.^[13] Fisheries bycatch and gear entanglement add direct physical impairments, with documented cases of humpbacks sustaining injuries that hinder bubble-net participation, as observed in necropsy data from entangled individuals showing compromised lunging ability.^[54]

Ecotourism Effects and Management

Whale-watching tourism in Southeast Alaska, a key habitat for bubble-net feeding, has expanded significantly, with vessel numbers tripling between 2000 and 2018, attracting crowds to observe this cooperative behavior. Vessel presence prompts short-term behavioral changes in humpback whales, including 38.9% greater path deviation, 6.2% higher swimming speeds, and 6.7% shorter inter-breath intervals, alongside elevated respiration rates with prolonged exposure.^[55] Feeding individuals typically sustain their activity states amid vessels, yet bubble-net groups frequently draw up to 30 boats, raising concerns for disruption of synchronized prey herding and lunging due to the technique's reliance on precise coordination.^[55] ^[56] These responses may impose energetic costs, potentially compounding during intensive summer feeding when whales consume up to 1,500 kg of prey daily to build fat reserves.^[57] The near-absence of tourism in Juneau during 2020, owing to COVID-19 restrictions, enabled baseline observations of undisturbed whales, contrasting with typical vessel-induced adaptations like accelerated breathing and erratic paths; ongoing analyses of stress hormones via biopsies further quantify subtle physiological burdens under normal ecotourism loads.^[58] While humpbacks exhibit some habituation, cumulative effects from high vessel density in feeding grounds could impair foraging efficiency and long-term population health, though direct cessation of bubble-net cycles remains undocumented.^[59] Federal regulations enforced by NOAA since 2003 mandate a minimum 100-yard (91-meter) approach distance to humpback whales across Alaskan waters, prohibiting faster vessel approaches or blocking paths, with violations incurring fines up to $125,000.^[60] In Glacier Bay National Park, where bubble-net feeding occurs seasonally, supplementary controls limit daily vessel entries to 158 and enforce one-way traffic lanes to curb harassment.^[60] Voluntary initiatives, such as the Whale SENSE program, train operators to idle engines near surfacing whales, yield right-of-way during feeding lunges, and cap group approaches, fostering self-regulation amid the industry's $2.1 billion annual economic value to Alaska.^[61] These measures prioritize sustaining bubble-net feeding as an indicator of ecosystem health while accommodating observation, with periodic efficacy assessments recommended to address evolving tourism pressures.^[55]

References

[1]
Solitary humpback whales manufacture bubble-nets as tools to ...
Aug 21, 2024 · In this study, we use observations from individually feeding humpback whales manufacturing bubble-nets in Southeast Alaska to examine how whales ...
[2]
Solitary humpback whales manufacture bubble-nets as tools to ...
Aug 21, 2024 · They do so by releasing air from their blowhole as they swim in a circular path below the surface. The rising bubbles form vertical curtains ...
[3]
Underwater components of humpback whale bubble-net feeding
Aug 9, 2025 · Bubble-net feeding involves the formation of one or more discrete bubble 'rings' used to corral and concentrate prey (e.g. fish, krill), ...
[4]
Humpback whales make custom fishing nets — out of bubbles - NPR
Sep 6, 2024 · The 50-foot whales blow circles of bubbles underwater, creating a net of air that entraps the krill. A new study shows that humpbacks can do this with ...
[5]
The diffusion of cooperative and solo bubble net feeding in ... - bioRxiv
Dec 18, 2024 · Using long-term observation data, scientists found that social learning significantly influenced the adoption of bubble netting, with a strong ...Missing: studies | Show results with:studies
[6]
The key to bubble-net feeding: how humpback whale morphology ...
Aug 15, 2025 · We found that solitary bubble-net feeding humpback whales exhibited centripetal accelerations (0.46 m s-2) that exceeded the upper limit ...Missing: peer- reviewed
[7]
Study finds humpback whales only ones capable of bubble-net ...
Aug 19, 2025 · The UH research shows humpbacks use their unique pectoral flippers to achieve this maneuver.
[8]
How humpback whales use bubbles as a tool - National Geographic
Aug 26, 2024 · Once the prey is tightly corralled, the whales lunge through the bubble-net with open mouths to swallow their meal. This feeding behavior has ...<|separator|>
[9]
[PDF] feeding behavior of the humpback whale
Whatever the precise mechanism, it seems reasonable to conclude that humpback whale bubble nets can, and do, effectively corral schools of prey. Whether bubble ...
[10]
The Secret to Humpback Whales' Bubble-Net Feeding: It's All in the ...
Aug 19, 2025 · In this behavior, a whale swims in a tight spiral while exhaling air through its blowhole, creating a rising ring of bubbles that corrals small ...
[11]
Simulation of humpback whale bubble-net feeding models
Feb 14, 2020 · A fully-coupled phase-averaging approach is used to model the flow, bubble dynamics, and corresponding acoustics.
[12]
The effect of group size on individual behavior of bubble‐net feeding ...
Jan 10, 2022 · In bubble-net feeding, individuals or groups of whales dive beneath an aggregation of prey and release a stream of bubbles through their nares ...
[13]
Humpback Whale - NOAA Fisheries
One specific feeding method, called "group coordinated bubble net feeding," involves using curtains of air bubbles to condense prey. Once the fish are ...
[14]
[PDF] June/July 2022 NYS Conservationist - NY.Gov
Photos below from June of that year show a large number of humpback whales feeding cooperatively in a double bubble-net formation. Similarly, the passive ...
[15]
[PDF] FEEDING MODES OF THE HU!v1PBACK WHALE, MEGAPTERA ...
To feed the humpback whale takes water and feed in through its mouth causing the pleated throat to swell and expand. (Fig. 2). The mouth is closed and water is ...<|separator|>
[16]
[PDF] Lunge filter feeding biomechanics constrain rorqual foraging ...
Aug 13, 2020 · ABSTRACT. Fundamental scaling relationships influence the physiology of vital rates, which in turn shape the ecology and evolution of ...
[17]
Blowing bubbles: An aquatic adaptation that risks protection of the ...
May 21, 2007 · The epicranial portion of the humpback whale nasal passageways is separated into two nasal openings (blowholes). There are no air-containing ...
[18]
The key to bubble-net feeding: how humpback whale morphology ...
Aug 19, 2025 · Bubble-net feeding involves the formation of one or more discrete bubble 'rings' used to corral and concentrate prey (e.g. fish, krill), ...
[19]
Humpbacks are the only whales that can feed with bubble nets
Aug 25, 2025 · Out of seven species of baleen whales, humpbacks are likely the only whales that can pull off the high-performance turns required for bubble-net ...
[20]
New publication: The key to bubble-net feeding: how humpback ...
Aug 19, 2025 · Our findings demonstrate how humpback whales are uniquely adapted to exploit prey patches that might otherwise be insufficient for capture by ...Missing: blowhole | Show results with:blowhole<|separator|>
[21]
Variation in feeding vocalizations of humpback whale Megaptera ...
Aug 7, 2025 · For example, bubble-net feeding humpback whales feeding on herring produce a sequence of calls that have similar frequency, duration and lack of ...Missing: uniqueness | Show results with:uniqueness
[22]
Bubble-Net Feeding - Prince of Whales
Jul 22, 2024 · It involves a group of whales blowing bubbles in a circular pattern to create a “net” that traps schooling fish like herring or krill. This ...Missing: targets | Show results with:targets
[23]
Predator-informed looming stimulus experiments reveal how large ...
Dec 23, 2019 · We found that humpback whales delay the expansion of their jaws until very close to schools of anchovies, and it is only at this point that the ...<|separator|>
[24]
Bubble-Net Feeding: Humpback Whales Feeding in Kenai Fjords ...
Bubble-net feeding is a complicated, highly synchronized effort that shows high biological intelligence. One whale usually leads the endeavor, diving deep then ...Missing: core mechanism
[25]
Drone footage of humpback whale bubble-net feeding off the coast ...
Feb 18, 2021 · Whales dive and begin blowing bubbles in a tightening spiral underneath their prey (typically small forage fish or krill) creating a “net” that ...<|separator|>
[26]
Humpback whales are excellent toolmakers to gather food
### Key Findings on Energy Use in Bubble-Net Feeding vs. Lunge Feeding in Humpback Whales
[27]
[PDF] VOCALIZATION AND COORDINATED FEEDING BEHAVIOR OF ...
The synchronized feeding on euphausiids within the bubble net and on herring without a bubble net seemed to be cooperative and structured. In the. 130 vertical ...Missing: peer | Show results with:peer
[28]
[PDF] The effect of group size on individual behavior of bubble-net feeding ...
Dec 5, 2021 · This is the author manuscript accepted for publication and has undergone full peer review but has not been through the copyediting, ...
[29]
https://journals.biologists.com/jeb/article-abstract/228/16/jeb249607/368911/The-key-to-bubble-net-feeding-how-humpback-whale
[30]
Do Whales Have Culture? Humpbacks Pass on Behavior
Apr 27, 2013 · In bubble-net feeding, a whale blows bubbles into a kind of net surrounding the prey, corralling them into dense schools. Then the whale lunges ...
[31]
Humpback whales have been spotted 'bubble-net feeding' for the ...
krill and fish — like a net, concentrating ...
[32]
Baleen Whales | Stellwagen Bank National Marine Sanctuary
Each year researchers learn more about bubble net feeding patterns and bottom feeding techniques (singly, in pairs, and in triads). Bottom feeding has ...
[33]
lobtail feeding in humpback whales, Megaptera novaeangliae
Underwater components of humpback whale bubble-net feeding behaviour. 2011, Behaviour. The social and reproductive biology of Humpback Whales: An ecological ...
[34]
[PDF] Use and prevalence of novel bubble-net foraging strategy in ...
Aug 22, 2024 · One strategy for which humpback whales are well known is their bubble-net feeding (BNF). An indi- vidual will dive below prey and emit bubbles ...
[35]
Photographing Humpback Whales Bubble-Net Feeding - NANPA
Mar 26, 2021 · Bubble-net feeding, where whales use bubbles to corral herring, occurs reliably in Sitka, Alaska, from late March to early April. Whales ...
[36]
[PDF] Novel Bubble-Cloud Feeding Behavior of a Humpback Whale ...
Numerous studies have described bubbling behaviors used to confuse, corral, and capture prey—mostly schooling fish (e.g., herring. [Clupea spp.]; Sharpe & Dill, ...Missing: peer- | Show results with:peer-<|separator|>
[37]
Humpback Whale (Megaptera novaeangliae) Species Profile
Bubble Net Feeding: They are also known for utilization of bubble nets, created by releasing air bubbles while swimming in circles beneath their prey, then ...
[38]
Humpback Whale: Science - NOAA Fisheries
One specific feeding method, called "group coordinated bubble net feeding," involves using curtains of air bubbles to condense prey. Once the fish are ...
[39]
The Role of Environmental Drivers in Humpback Whale Distribution ...
Studies focusing on humpback whales in feeding areas found preferences for areas of upwelling, high chlorophyll-a concentration and frontal areas with changes ...Introduction · Results · Methods Applied Relating... · Environmental Drivers...<|control11|><|separator|>
[40]
https://scholarworks.sjsu.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1328&context=etd_theses
[41]
Use and prevalence of novel bubble-net foraging strategy in ...
Aug 22, 2024 · The seasonal pattern and relatively recent emergence of BNF suggests that its use is likely tied to specific environmental conditions, which ...
[42]
[PDF] Humpback Whales Blow Poloidal Vortex Bubble Rings
Apr 15, 2025 · The rising bubble rose to the sur- face like a thick wall of air bubbles, and these formed a net”. (Ingebrigtsen 1929). ... Humpback Whale Bubbles ...Missing: Andreas | Show results with:Andreas
[43]
1974 | Shelter Island, Alaska - Twig technology
Jun 13, 2021 · || Pirotta, V. et al. (2021) First evidence of bubble-net feeding and the formation of 'super-groups' by the east Australian population of ...
[44]
[PDF] spiral bubble nets of humpback whales: an acoustic mechanism
In 2004, Leighton et al. [1] proposed that humpback whales use bubble nets as acoustics waveguides to create a sonic trap for prey. It had been known for ...
[45]
(PDF) An acoustical hypothesis for the spiral bubble nets of ...
Aug 9, 2025 · To maximise the energetic efficiency of lunge feeding, some humpback populations employ a unique behaviour known as bubble-net feeding, ...
[46]
Three-dimensional finite element simulation of acoustic propagation ...
In 2004, Leighton hypothesized that the acoustic calls emitted by humpback ... bubble net feeding by humpback whales. Publication types. Research Support ...Missing: production | Show results with:production
[47]
Evidence for acoustic communication among bottom foraging ...
Dec 16, 2014 · Wiley, D. et al. Underwater components of humpback whale bubble-net feeding behaviour. Behaviour 148, 575–602 (2011). Article Google Scholar.<|separator|>
[48]
Humpback whale mother-calf health assessed using drone tech
Dec 17, 2024 · It is believed that humpback whales were unable to acquire sufficient food, resulting in nutritional stress and declines in reproduction. "This ...
[49]
Evidence for ship noise impacts on humpback whale foraging ...
Aug 1, 2016 · We found significant effects on foraging, including slower descent rates and fewer side-roll feeding events per dive with increasing ship noise.
[50]
The Effects of Ship Noise on Marine Mammals—A Review - Frontiers
The documented effects include behavioral and acoustic responses, auditory masking, and stress. We identify knowledge gaps.
[51]
The Impact of Vessels on Humpback Whale Behavior - Frontiers
Feb 8, 2021 · The results presented here show increases in swim speed, respiration rate, and path directness in conjunction with decreasing dive times.
[52]
Vessel Strikes Found to Be Major Cause of Increased Whale ...
May 31, 2024 · The researchers suggest that increased vessel traffic in these regions, combined with foraging activities and inexperience of juvenile humpbacks ...Missing: ship | Show results with:ship
[53]
Future climate impacts put humpback whale diet at risk - Phys.org
May 23, 2024 · A new study led by Griffith University predicts that future climate change impacts could disrupt the krill-heavy diet that humpback whales in the southern ...Missing: effects | Show results with:effects
[54]
Humpback Whale: Conservation & Management - NOAA Fisheries
One specific feeding method, called "group coordinated bubble net feeding," involves using curtains of air bubbles to condense prey. Once the fish are ...
[55]
Humpback Whale Movements and Behavior in Response ... - Frontiers
Nov 19, 2019 · For example, bubble net feeding groups (i.e., highly conspicuous, and cooperative surface-feeding groups that release underwater bubble streams ...
[56]
Effects of whale watching on the activity budgets of humpback ...
May 14, 2018 · Whale watching can affect cetacean behaviour, and can in some cases lead to long-term negative effects on survival and reproduction.
[57]
Energetic Effects of Whale-Watching Boats on Humpback ... - Frontiers
Jan 10, 2021 · Whale watching can disturb critical behaviors such as lactation thus, reducing the energy transfer from the mother to the calf, affecting growth ...Abstract · Introduction · Materials and Methods · Discussion
[58]
Study of undisturbed humpback whales made possible by Juneau's ...
Minimal tourism in Juneau has created an opportunity for researchers to study the effects on humpback whales. Researchers are collecting data to create a ...
[59]
(PDF) Effects of whale watching on the activity budgets of humpback ...
Whale watching can affect cetacean behaviour, and can in some cases lead to long‐term negative effects on survival and reproduction. • The waters of Juneau ( ...
[60]
Give Whales Bubble Room in Alaska - NOAA Fisheries
Apr 12, 2023 · Don't burst their bubble! In Alaska, humpback whales are protected by federal regulations that prohibit approaches within 100 yards and vessel ...
[61]
New Study Shows Economic Importance of Alaska's Whale ...
Nov 19, 2020 · This study demonstrates that healthy whale populations underpin important economic activity for people, businesses, and communities throughout coastal Alaska.