Burow's solution is an aqueous solution of aluminum acetate, a mild astringent used topically in dermatology to soothe and dry weeping or oozing skin lesions through the application of wet compresses or soaks.[1] It is typically prepared by mixing solutions of aluminum sulfate and calcium acetate, which react to form an aluminum acetate solution (typically around 5% in traditional preparations), resulting in a clear, colorless, weakly acidic liquid.[2] Named after Karl August Burow (1809–1874), a German military surgeon and anatomist who developed it in the mid-19th century,[3] the solution has been employed since that era for its anti-inflammatory and antipruritic properties in treating conditions such as contact dermatitis, poison ivy rashes, and acute otitis externa.In clinical practice, Burow's solution is applied as a diluted soak (often 1:10 to 1:40) for 15–30 minutes several times daily to reduce inflammation, relieve itching, and promote drying of exudative dermatoses like those seen in hidradenitis suppurativa, paronychia, or tinea infections.[4][5][6] Its astringent action works by precipitating proteins on the skin surface, forming a protective barrier that aids in debridement and prevents secondary infection without significant systemic absorption.[7] While generally safe for short-term use, it is contraindicated in patients with aluminum hypersensitivity and should be used cautiously on large areas to prevent potential irritation or excessive dryness.[1] Over time, commercial formulations like Domeboro packets have standardized its preparation for home use, maintaining its role as a first-line adjunct therapy in outpatient dermatologic care.[2]
Composition
Chemical Components
Burow's solution is fundamentally an aqueous solution of aluminum acetate, a salt derived from aluminum and acetic acid, serving as its active astringent component. The primary form utilized is aluminum subacetate, present at a concentration of approximately 13% in the stock solution.[8] This composition provides the solution's therapeutic basis, with the aluminum ions contributing to protein precipitation on tissue surfaces.[1]The chemical formula for neutral aluminum acetate is \ce{Al(CH3COO)3}, corresponding to the molecular formula \ce{C6H9AlO6}. However, in Burow's solution, it typically exists as the basic subacetate form, \ce{Al(OH)(CH3COO)2}, which enhances stability in aqueous media.[9] These structures arise from the coordination of acetate ligands with aluminum, often in a hydrated state.[10]An alternative method of preparation involves combining aluminum sulfate tetradecahydrate (\ce{Al2(SO4)3 \cdot 14H2O}) and calcium acetate monohydrate (\ce{Ca(CH3COO)2 \cdot H2O}) in water, where they react to yield soluble aluminum acetate and insoluble calcium sulfate precipitate. For instance, commercial packets contain 1347 mg of aluminum sulfate tetradecahydrate and 952 mg of calcium acetate monohydrate per unit, which dissolve to form the active solution upon reconstitution.[11] This approach avoids direct handling of aluminum acetate while generating the same active species.[1]The original formulation developed in the 19th century employed lead acetate and alum (aluminum potassium sulfate), which similarly produced aluminum acetate through reaction, with lead sulfate precipitating out. This lead-based method was phased out due to risks of lead toxicity and absorption through the skin.[12] Modern iterations exclusively use lead-free aluminum salts to ensure safety.[13]
Formulation Variants
Burow's solution is commercially available in various formulations adapted for topical and otic use, often as modified versions to enhance stability and ease of preparation. One prominent over-the-counter variant is Domeboro, supplied as powder packets containing aluminum sulfate tetradecahydrate (1347 mg) and calcium acetate monohydrate (952 mg) per packet, which react in water to form aluminum acetate.[14] These packets are reconstituted by dissolving one to three in 16 ounces of water, yielding concentrations of 0.16% to 0.48% aluminum acetate for skin soaks or compresses.[14]For otological applications, a prescription ear drop formulation is available as Acetic Acid 2% in Aqueous Aluminum Acetate Otic Solution (NDC 24208-615-77), manufactured by Bausch + Lomb, which incorporates 2% acetic acid with aluminum acetate derived from aluminum sulfate, calcium carbonate, and glacial acetic acid.[15] This sterile solution is dispensed in 60 mL bottles with an otic tip for direct instillation into the external auditory canal.[15]In clinical practice, Burow's solution is commonly diluted for therapeutic soaks, with ratios such as 1:10 (stronger, approximately 0.5% aluminum acetate) or 1:40 (milder, approximately 0.13% aluminum acetate) achieved by mixing one packet of Domeboro in 1 pint of water for the latter.[11] A 13% aluminum acetate stock solution serves as a base for pharmacy compounding, allowing customization of concentrations for specific indications while maintaining astringent properties.[16]These formulations typically exhibit an acidic pH ranging from 3.5 to 5.0, which contributes to their antimicrobial effects and skin compatibility.[15]Stability is preserved under standard storage conditions, such as 15–25°C (59–77°F) away from freezing, with prepared solutions remaining effective for up to 5 months at 4°C without significant changes in pH, osmolarity, or activity.[17]
History
Development by Karl August Burow
Karl August Burow (1809–1874) was a prominent German surgeon and anatomist known for his contributions to operative techniques and wound care.[18] Born in Elbing, Prussia (now Elbląg, Poland), he initially studied theology for one semester before switching to medicine at the University of Königsberg, qualifying as a physician in Berlin in 1835.[18] Burow later became a professor of anatomy and surgery at Königsberg, where he advanced surgical education through detailed anatomical studies, and served as a military surgeon in the Prussian army during the 1860s. His career emphasized practical innovations in surgery, particularly in managing trauma and infections amid the era's limited antiseptic options.Burow developed his eponymous solution in the mid-1800s as a topical astringent for treating wounds and infections, drawing from his advocacy for open wound management to promote healing without closure.[19] This approach aligned with his broader surgical philosophy, which prioritized exposure and gentle antisepsis over traditional suturing methods prone to suppuration. The solution's creation stemmed from Burow's clinical experience in ophthalmology and general surgery, where he sought an effective, non-irritating preparation to soothe inflamed tissues and control suppuration. Originally formulated with lead acetate and alum, it represented a practical advancement in 19th-century topical therapy.
Early Medical Applications
Following its development in the mid-19th century, Burow's solution was initially employed as an astringent for managing chronic suppurative otitis media, where it helped dry exudates and reduce inflammation in the ear canal. German surgeon Karl August Burow introduced it specifically for this otological condition, leveraging its ability to promote healing in persistent suppurative discharges.[20] Early clinical reports highlighted its efficacy in alleviating symptoms of intractable ear infections, often applied as drops to control bacterial overgrowth without systemic effects.[21]The solution also found application in treating suppurative wounds and skin inflammations within surgical contexts, where it served to cleanse and constrict tissues, aiding in the management of post-operative oozing and minor traumatic lesions. In 19th-century European medical practice, diluted compresses of Burow's solution were routinely used to soothe irritated skin and prevent secondary infections in inflammatory dermatoses, reflecting its role as a versatile topical agent before the widespread adoption of antiseptics.[19] Given Burow's service as a militaryphysician in the Prussian army during the 1860s, the solution found applications in military medicine for wound care.By the late 1800s, concerns over the toxicity of the original formulation—primarily lead subacetate derived from lead acetate and alum—prompted a shift to aluminum-based variants, as lead absorption led to documented cases of systemic poisoning, including fatal outcomes in prolonged applications. This transition maintained the solution's astringent properties while mitigating risks, ensuring its continued relevance in early therapeutic protocols.[12][22]
Pharmacology
Mechanism of Action
Burow's solution, consisting primarily of aluminum acetate, functions as a topical astringent by inducing mild coagulation of proteins on the surface of skin and mucosal tissues. This protein precipitation occurs through the interaction of aluminum ions with tissue proteins, forming insoluble complexes that contract and harden the superficial layers without penetrating deeply into underlying structures.[9][23]The resulting tissue contraction leads to vasoconstriction of small blood vessels and a reduction in exudation, as the precipitated proteins create a protective barrier that limits fluid leakage from inflamed areas. This mechanism helps to dry and soothe irritated tissues by promoting osmotic withdrawal of water from the application site.[24][25]Additionally, the anti-inflammatory effects arise from the stabilization of tissue proteins, which decreases vascular permeability and mitigates swelling and redness associated with inflammatory responses. The solution's mildly acidic pH, typically around 4, enhances this protein coagulation by optimizing the solubility and reactivity of aluminum ions in an environment that favors surface-level interactions without causing excessive tissue damage.[26][27]
Antimicrobial Properties
Burow's solution demonstrates significant in vitro antibacterial activity against common pathogens associated with otitis externa and chronic suppurative otitis media, including methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus (MRSA) and quinolone-resistant Pseudomonas aeruginosa.[28] In comparative studies of topical eardrops, a 13% aluminum acetate formulation exhibited the highest antimicrobial efficacy and the lowest decimal reduction time (D10) values for eradicating MRSA, methicillin-sensitive S. aureus (MSSA), quinolone-resistant P. aeruginosa (QRPA), and quinolone-sensitive P. aeruginosa (QSPA), outperforming agents like 2% acetic acid and ciprofloxacin.[29] Similarly, modified 13% Burow's solution inactivated all tested Gram-positive bacteria within 5 minutes (except Enterococcus species) and all Gram-negative bacteria, including P. aeruginosa, within 30 seconds, with complete MRSA elimination in under 5 minutes—far surpassing 0.3% ofloxacin in speed and completeness.[16] These findings highlight its broad-spectrum inhibition of key otitis pathogens, supported by time-kill assays showing rapid reductions in colony-forming units (CFU/ml) for S. aureus (to 1/10³ within 15 minutes) and P. aeruginosa (to 1/10⁷ within 60 minutes).[16]The solution also possesses antifungal properties, particularly against Candida albicans, a frequent cause of otomycosis, though its potency is limited compared to dedicated antifungals. A broader evaluation of 13 otomycosis agents ranked 2% Burow's solution as minimally effective, showing little to no inhibition across 15 fungal and yeast species, in contrast to 1% clotrimazole, which demonstrated high efficacy against most tested fungi.[30] Modified formulations have inactivated Candida albicans within 2 minutes in time-kill studies, indicating utility as an adjunct for debris removal and mild fungal control in otomycosis, but not as a primary antifungal.[16]The antimicrobial mechanism primarily involves aluminum ions from the acetate complex, which induce ultrastructural damage to microbial cells at concentrations typical of 13% solutions (pH 3.1). Scanning and transmission electron microscopy reveal cell wall deformation, blebbing, collapse, and cytoplasmic membrane disruption in S. aureus and P. aeruginosa, leading to leakage of intracellular contents and bacterial death.[31] This ion-mediated oligodynamic effect, combined with the acidic environment, interferes with membrane integrity and essential enzyme functions, preventing microbial proliferation without reliance on antibiotic resistance pathways.
Clinical Uses
Dermatological Indications
Burow's solution is commonly employed as a wet compress or soak to alleviate symptoms of contact dermatitis, including reactions to poison ivy, poison oak, and poison sumac, by reducing inflammation, itching, and oozing through its astringent properties.[14][32] It is also indicated for minor skin irritations from insect bites and rashes caused by soaps or detergents, where applications help dry the affected area and provide symptomatic relief.In nail-related conditions, Burow's solution soaks are used for acute paronychia to promote drainage, reduce swelling, and protect the nail fold, typically applied in warm water for 10-15 minutes several times daily.[33] Similarly, for ingrown toenails, warm soaks with Burow's solution aid in softening the skin, alleviating pain, and preventing secondary infection in the early stages.[5][34]As an adjunctive therapy in atopic dermatitis and eczema flares, Burow's solution is applied via compresses to manage weepy or vesicular lesions, often in combination with topical corticosteroids to enhance anti-inflammatory effects and control acute exacerbations.[35][36] Its mild antimicrobial action against common skin flora further supports its role in preventing secondary infections during these treatments.[33]
Otological Indications
Burow's solution is commonly employed in the management of otitis externa, where it serves as an acidifying agent in ear drops or compresses to alleviate inflammation, control discharge, and prevent secondary bacterial infections. Clinical guidelines recommend its use, often in a 2% acetic acid formulation (such as Otic Domeboro), applied topically to the external auditory canal to dry the area and inhibit microbial growth.[37] In cases of severe inflammation, an ear wick saturated with 5% aluminum acetate solution may be inserted to enhance penetration and promote debridement.[38]For chronic suppurative otitis media (CSOM), Burow's solution is utilized through ear irrigations or drops to manage persistent otorrhea by reducing bacterial load and promoting epithelialization of the middle ear mucosa. Studies have demonstrated its antimicrobial efficacy against common pathogens like Pseudomonas aeruginosa and Staphylococcus aureus, with in vitro inhibition of growth observed at concentrations of 13% aluminum acetate.[8] A clinical trial evaluating quarter-strength (3.25%) and full-strength (13%) dilutions in active mucosal CSOM reported response rates of 75% and 80.8%, respectively, after two weeks of treatment, highlighting its role as an effective aural toilet adjunct without significant adverse effects when used externally.[39] Modified formulations, adjusted for pH stability, have shown resolution of refractory discharge in 100% of treated ears within an average of 5.4 weeks.[16]As an adjunctive therapy for otomycosis, Burow's solution aids in reducing associated bacterial overgrowth and debris in the external canal, though it exhibits limited direct antifungal activity. In vitro assessments against Candida and Aspergillus species indicate minimal fungicidal inhibition compared to targeted agents like clotrimazole or nystatin.[30] Clinical use as 5% aluminum acetate drops has been documented for symptomatic relief, but evidence supports its inferiority to specific antifungals, with cure rates for chronic ear infections incorporating fungal elements reaching only 70% versus higher efficacy (up to 85%) with azoles.[40][41]Application of Burow's solution requires caution in patients with perforated tympanic membranes due to potential access to the middle ear, where rare ototoxicity risks exist. Animal studies in guinea pigs have shown significant cochlear damage, including reduced compound action potentials, when the solution is applied directly to the middle ear for 30 minutes or longer, attributed to its acidic pH (around 3).[42] Human case reports describe acute sensorineural hearing loss following intratympanic administration of 8% concentrations, underscoring the need for dilution and avoidance of prolonged middle ear exposure.[43] Despite these risks, external use remains generally safe, with no widespread ototoxic events reported in standard otological protocols.[44]
Administration and Preparation
Compounding Methods
Burow's solution can be prepared in pharmacy settings or at home through reconstitution of commercial packets, such as Domeboro, which contain pre-measured amounts of aluminum sulfate tetradecahydrate and calcium acetate monohydrate. To reconstitute, dissolve one packet in 1 pint (473 mL) of water to yield a solution approximately 0.16% in aluminum acetate concentration suitable for topical use; stir until fully dissolved without straining or filtering the mixture.[14] This method provides a convenient option for immediate preparation.[11]In professional pharmacy compounding, Burow's solution may be formulated directly from aluminum acetate powder to create a stock solution. Dissolve 13 g of aluminum acetate powder in 100 mL of purified water, stirring gently until completely solubilized; this produces a 13% aluminum acetate solution, often used as a base for further dilution in clinical applications.[45] Alternatively, compound the solution by combining aluminum sulfate and calcium acetate in stoichiometric proportions in 100 mL of purified water; mix thoroughly to facilitate the double decomposition reaction that forms aluminum acetate in situ, allowing any insoluble calcium sulfate to settle without filtration for the final preparation.[1]Regardless of the preparation method, Burow's solution should be made fresh to maintain efficacy and minimize degradation. For reconstituted commercial products, store the prepared solution at room temperature in a tightly closed container, protected from light, and discard after 7 days. Compounded solutions should be used within their assessed stability period, typically 7 days, to ensure stability and prevent microbial contamination.[45][1]
Application Techniques
Burow's solution is typically applied topically in diluted form for therapeutic purposes, with methods varying by the affected area to ensure effective contact and absorption while minimizing irritation. For skin irritations, the most common technique involves preparing wet compresses using a 1:40 dilution of the solution. A clean gauze or soft cloth is soaked in the diluted solution, excess liquid is gently wrung out, and the compress is applied loosely to the affected area for 15 to 20 minutes, repeated 3 to 4 times daily as needed.[1][14]In otological applications, Burow's solution is used to address inflammation in the ear canal, often as a 5% solution applied via an ear wick 4 times daily for conditions like acute external otitis. Alternatively, it may be instilled as 4 to 5 drops of a diluted solution (such as 2%) into the ear canal 3 to 4 times daily, with the head tilted to allow penetration for several minutes.[38][40]For localized issues such as nail infections or extremity irritations, immersion soaks are recommended. The affected area, such as fingers or toes, is immersed in a basin containing the prepared solution (typically at a 1:20 to 1:40 dilution) for 20 minutes per session, with treatments repeated several times daily to promote drying and reduce swelling.[46][47]
Safety Profile
Adverse Effects
Burow's solution, a topical astringent containing aluminum acetate, is generally well-tolerated when used as directed, but it can cause local skin reactions. Common adverse effects include temporary burning or stinging upon application, itching, skin dryness, and mild inflammation or irritation at the site of use.[48][11][49]Rare adverse effects may occur, particularly in sensitive individuals. Allergic reactions to aluminum, manifesting as rash, hives, redness, swelling, or more severe symptoms like difficulty breathing, have been reported in those with metal hypersensitivities.[47][50] In otological applications, especially with perforated eardrums allowing access to the middle ear, Burow's solution has been associated with ototoxicity, including acute sensorineural hearing loss, as evidenced by case reports where hearing thresholds shifted significantly but partially recovered over weeks.[43][51]Regarding long-term risks, systemic absorption of aluminum from topical Burow's solution is minimal and unlikely to pose significant toxicity concerns, even with extensive use, due to its low penetration through intact skin.[49][52] Prolonged or repeated applications may exacerbate local dryness or sensitization, potentially leading to increased irritation over time.[47]
Contraindications and Precautions
Burow's solution is contraindicated in individuals with known hypersensitivity to aluminum acetate or any of its components, as this may lead to allergic reactions.[48][11][1]Precautions are necessary when using Burow's solution on sensitive skin, where dilution to concentrations of 0.13–0.5% is recommended to minimize excessive drying or irritation from prolonged exposure.[1] In otological applications, particularly with tympanic membrane perforations, close monitoring for potential ototoxicity is advised, although animal studies indicate no significant auditory threshold shifts with middle ear application.[53] Ophthalmic use is strictly prohibited, as the solution is intended solely for external topical application and contact with the eyes may cause severe irritation.[48][11][1]Regarding interactions, occlusive dressings should be avoided, as they may reduce the solution's efficacy by altering moisture levels and promoting over-drying or irritation.[48][11][1] Use should be discontinued if skinirritation worsens, with consultation of a healthcare provider recommended to prevent exacerbation of symptoms such as dryness.[48][11][1]