Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Community Security Trust

The Community Security Trust (CST) is a British established to protect the Jewish community from , , and related threats through measures, incident monitoring, and advisory services. Registered as a in 1994 with origins tracing to decades of Jewish organizations predating and following the Second World War, CST deploys around 2,000 volunteers to guard synagogues, schools, and community sites across the , while partnering closely with police forces to enhance threat assessments and response capabilities. CST's core mission encompasses not only immediate security provision but also the promotion of intercommunal harmony by combating , with a particular emphasis on eradicating through data-driven reporting and public education. As the primary non-governmental authority on in , it has documented sharp rises in such events—such as over 4,000 in 2023—often correlating with geopolitical tensions, informing policy responses from government and . Its annual reports and expertise have been referenced in inquiries and ministerial speeches, underscoring its role in shaping national strategies against hate crimes targeting . While praised for bolstering communal resilience amid persistent threats, CST has faced scrutiny from some quarters over its incident classification criteria and perceived alignment with security perspectives, though official validations from authorities affirm its methodological rigor and operational efficacy. These efforts have positioned CST as a model of proactive minority self-protection, adapting to evolving risks like online extremism and post-7 October 2023 surges in physical attacks.

History

Founding and Origins

The Community Security Trust (CST) traces its roots to longstanding traditions of Jewish communal in the , which date back decades before and after the Second World War, amid rising antisemitic threats including fascist activities in the 1930s and post-war extremism. These efforts involved volunteer groups providing physical protection for synagogues, schools, and community events, often in response to organized violence and harassment targeting Jewish populations. In the modern era, CST's immediate predecessor was the Community Security Organisation (CSO), established under the auspices of the Board of Deputies of British Jews to coordinate security responses to antisemitic incidents. The CSO operated as a specialized arm focused on incident reporting, volunteer training, and liaison with law enforcement, gaining operational experience through events like the 1976 murder of Jewish community members in Golders Green. It achieved independence from the Board of Deputies in 1986, allowing for greater autonomy in addressing evolving threats such as far-left and Islamist antisemitism. CST was formally founded in 1994 as a registered , evolving directly from the CSO to provide a structured framework for security advice, physical protection, and research on . The organization was established via a dated 21 November 1994, with subsequent amendments to its governing documents in 1996 and later years to refine its operational mandate. This transition emphasized professionalization, including staff recruitment and volunteer networks, while maintaining continuity in threat assessment and community safeguarding.

Evolution and Key Milestones

Following its formal registration as a in 1994, the Community Security Trust evolved from voluntary initiatives—rooted in pre- and post-World War II Jewish community efforts—into a professional organization delivering structured security advice, training, and physical protections across the . This transition enabled CST to centralize resources, including the establishment of incident recording protocols that built on dating to 1984, fostering annual reports that track antisemitic trends and influence government policy. By the early , CST had expanded its remit to include research publications, such as the inaugural 2003 report on post-1967 terrorist incidents against Jewish targets, which compiled historical data previously uncollated in a single resource. A pivotal development occurred with the introduction of state-backed funding through the Jewish Community Protective Security Grant (JCPSG), initially allocated in the late 1990s and formalized for administration by the early 2000s to subsidize guards, systems, and site hardening at synagogues, schools, and community centers. Annual grant values grew from modest beginnings to £14 million by 2022, reflecting escalating threats and 's role in distributing funds to over 700 sites nationwide. This financial support facilitated operational scaling, including the buildup to over 100 paid staff and 2,000 volunteers, alongside the creation of a 24/7 National Control Centre for real-time threat monitoring and response coordination. Subsequent milestones highlight adaptations to intensifying , particularly Islamist extremism and far-left variants. In the , CST's advocacy contributed to enhanced partnerships and policy integrations, such as contributions to counter-terrorism strategies. The October 7, 2023, attacks on triggered a record surge in UK incidents—4,103 in 2023 alone—prompting emergency expansions: CST received an additional £3 million in October 2023, followed by £54 million in February 2024 for sustained protections, and up to £10 million more in October 2025 for staffing and equipment amid ongoing volatility. By 2024, commemorating three decades, CST had documented over 30,000 antisemitic incidents and suspicious activities, solidifying its status as a benchmark for community-led security amid persistent threats.

Mission and Principles

Core Objectives

The Community Security Trust (CST) primarily aims to protect British Jewish communities from antisemitism, terrorism, and related threats, enabling Jews to live securely and participate fully in society. This protection encompasses providing physical security measures, such as advice, training, and equipment for synagogues, schools, and other communal sites, as well as maintaining a 24/7 national control center for incident response. A key objective is to represent British Jews on matters of racism, antisemitism, extremism, policing, and security, including advocacy with government and law enforcement to enhance communal safety. CST seeks to promote good relations between and the wider by working toward the elimination of , with a particular focus on as a persistent form of bigotry that manifests in , , assaults, and . This involves supporting victims of antisemitic incidents through assistance and counseling, while avoiding by speaking responsibly on threats without or undue political alignment. Additionally, the conducts and promotes research into , , and related hatreds to inform , track trends, and benefit both the Jewish community and broader . These objectives are pursued non-partisanly, drawing on empirical incident and assessments rather than ideological preconceptions, with 's reports serving as a primary tool for evidencing the scale and nature of antisemitic activity—for instance, documenting over 4,000 incidents in some years amid spikes following geopolitical events. By facilitating Jewish communal life free from fear, addresses causal factors like unchecked and societal prejudices, prioritizing verifiable over narrative-driven interpretations.

Definitional Framework for Threats

The Community Security Trust (CST) establishes its definitional framework for threats to British Jewish communities around as the core peril, supplemented by related security risks such as and . is understood as , bigotry, , or against , aligning with the (IHRA) working definition, which characterizes it as "a certain perception of , which may be expressed as toward ," including rhetorical and physical manifestations directed at Jewish individuals, institutions, or property. This framework prioritizes of motivation, requiring incidents to demonstrate antisemitic intent rather than mere coincidence or general criminality. CST classifies antisemitic incidents—serving as proxies for broader threats—only as malicious acts targeting Jewish people, organizations, or property where verifiable confirms antisemitic , irrespective of the victims' actual Jewish status if perceived as such. Incidents undergo rigorous to exclude non-antisemitic events, such as routine crimes lacking ideological targeting or permanent online content without specific malice. Categories include:
  • Extreme violence: Life-threatening acts like grievous bodily harm, bombings, or stabbings.
  • Assault: Non-life-threatening physical attacks, including actual bodily harm or attempted assaults.
  • Damage and desecration of property: Antisemitic vandalism, such as swastikas or arson not posing immediate life threats.
  • Threats: Explicit verbal, written, or hoax threats against Jewish targets.
  • Abusive behaviour: Verbal or written antisemitic harassment, including graffiti or emails.
  • Literature: Malicious distribution of mass-produced antisemitic materials like leaflets or posters.
This categorization enables quantitative tracking, with CST's annual reports documenting surges, such as 4,103 incidents in 2023, the highest on record, often linked to geopolitical events like the October 7, 2023, Hamas attack on Israel. Beyond , the framework encompasses "related threats" from Islamist , state actors like , and domestic extremists (e.g., far-right or far-left), assessed via , police liaison, and communal reporting to inform proactive security measures. These definitions emphasize causal links between and action, distinguishing verifiable perils from unsubstantiated fears while critiquing overly broad or politicized interpretations that dilute focus on empirical harm.

Organizational Structure

Leadership and Governance

The Community Security Trust (CST) operates as a registered charity in (number 1042391) and (SC043612), governed by a board of trustees that provides strategic oversight and approves key activities, including the allocation of grants for security enhancements. The board convenes regularly to establish organizational priorities and ensure alignment with the charity's mission of protecting the Jewish community from and . Sir CBE serves as CST's chairman and founder, a position he has held since the organization's inception in 1994. A prominent British philanthropist and businessman, Ronson has emphasized physical and proactive measures against antisemitic threats throughout his tenure, drawing from historical experiences with fascist activities in the UK during the mid-20th century. In recognition of his contributions to Jewish community security and philanthropy, Ronson was knighted in the . Mark Gardner MBE has been CST's chief executive since September 2020, succeeding David Delew who led the organization from 2013 to 2020. Gardner joined CST's predecessor entity in 1989 and has held roles focused on analysis and incident response, including earning a commendation for coordinating safety during a 1999 neo-Nazi bombing incident. As CEO, he oversees operational execution of security services, policy advocacy, and partnerships with government and . Key senior leadership includes Dr. Dave Rich, Director of Policy since joining in 1994, who leads research on antisemitic incidents and , authoring reports and books such as Everyday Hate (2016). Amanda Bomsztyk serves as Northern Regional Director, managing for approximately 30,000 across and , with over 20 years of staff experience in crisis response following events like the 2015 attacks.

Staff, Volunteers, and Operations

The Community Security Trust (CST) employs over 110 professional staff members across its operations in the , including roles in , incident , coordination, and advisory services to Jewish institutions. These staff members support the organization's core functions, such as threat assessment and policy liaison with , operating from offices primarily in and . CST's volunteer force consists of over 2,000 fully trained active personnel drawn from diverse segments of the , who provide on-site physical at synagogues, schools, and other communal sites without charge. Volunteers receive specialized training in areas such as risk evaluation, , and emergency response, with ongoing assessments to maintain proficiency; they often collaborate directly with through briefings to ensure integrated local measures. Day-to-day operations emphasize proactive defense and rapid incident handling, with volunteers forming the frontline presence at vulnerable locations during high-risk periods like religious holidays or public events. Staff oversee volunteer deployments, conduct 24-hour monitoring of potential threats via dedicated communication channels, and facilitate post-incident debriefs to refine protocols, enabling CST to record and respond to thousands of antisemitic incidents annually while minimizing disruptions to community life. This hybrid model of paid expertise and unpaid dedication has sustained CST's capacity to secure hundreds of Jewish sites nationwide.

Activities

Security Services and Training

The Community Security Trust (CST) delivers physical security services to Jewish institutions and events across the , including volunteer-led guarding and the administration of government grants for commercial security personnel. In 2023, CST managed a £15 million grant to fund guards at 204 Jewish schools, over 269 synagogues, 26 communal buildings, 29 youth camps, and 7 multi-site operations, with an additional £3 million in emergency funding post-October 7, 2023, extending protection to Jewish commercial areas in and north . CST volunteers supplemented these efforts by providing thousands of extra guarding hours, including increased operations and patrols in high-risk areas. CST collaborates with police forces on targeted security measures, such as armed foot patrols in Jewish-populated areas of initiated in August 2016 following heightened threat assessments. These services, which encompass site assessments, emergency response planning, and protective equipment installation, are provided at no direct cost to recipients, funded through charitable donations and government allocations. CST's training programs equip community members and volunteers with skills to mitigate antisemitic and terrorist threats, offered free of charge to individuals and organizations without requiring membership. Core offerings include role-specific courses for communal building staff, administrators, caretakers, school and nursery personnel, rabbis, youth workers, university students, and dedicated security officers, covering threat recognition, , and incident response. Personal safety training addresses individual risk reduction, while the Streetwise program, developed in partnership with Maccabi GB, delivers street awareness workshops tailored for teenagers, reaching over 29,500 young people by 2023. Volunteer forms a of CST's operations, with approximately 2,000 active volunteers trained nationwide as of to safeguard hundreds of communal events annually. Programs emphasize practical competencies such as trauma management, resilience building, , theory, and techniques, conducted daily by full-time professional trainers and experienced volunteer instructors. Following the October 7, , Hamas attacks on , CST recorded over 1,700 inquiries from prospective volunteers, prompting expanded cohorts in , , and to address surging demand. Additional sessions target specialized groups, including Charedi communities and women's organizations, fostering broader awareness.

Incident Recording and Response

The Community Security Trust (CST) maintains a centralized system for recording antisemitic incidents reported to it by victims, witnesses, or third parties through channels including telephone, email, its website, social media, post, or in-person contact with staff and volunteers. An incident qualifies for recording if it constitutes a malicious act directed at Jewish individuals, organizations, or property, evidenced by antisemitic motivation, content, or targeting based on perceived Jewish identity; this criterion aligns with the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance (IHRA) working definition of antisemitism but applies a narrower standard than the broader criminal justice definitions of hate incidents, excluding general anti-Israel protests or activities lacking explicit anti-Jewish elements. In 2024, CST excluded 2,479 reports deemed insufficiently antisemitic from its tally, while recording 3,528 verified incidents—the second-highest annual total since systematic tracking began in 1984—following an initial surge after the October 7, 2023, Hamas attack on Israel. Verification involves assessing reports for evidential antisemitic intent, cross-checking to prevent double-counting across sources such as , community groups, or , and categorizing incidents by type: assaults (121 in the first half of 2025, up 41% from the prior year), and , threats, abusive behavior, and online abuse (which underpinned peak daily totals in 2024). Since 2001, has held third-party reporting status with forces under a information-sharing agreement, enabling anonymized data exchange to support investigations without compromising victim confidentiality. Reports originate diversely: 33% from direct victims, 20% from witnesses, and others from staff monitoring online abuse, security personnel, or partners like the Community Alliance to Combat Hate. Upon receiving reports, CST provides immediate guidance, directing callers to emergency services (999) or its National Emergency Number (0800 032 3263) for urgent threats, and non-emergency police (101) otherwise, while handling personal details under strict protocols. For verified incidents, CST facilitates victim support by liaising with if requested, offering security advice tailored to individual or communal risks, and contributing data to broader threat assessments that inform community alerts and preventive measures. Aggregated findings from these records feed into biannual and annual Antisemitic Incidents Reports, which analyze trends—such as 1,521 incidents in the first half of 2025, the second-highest six-month figure—and correlate spikes with events like escalations or domestic controversies, enabling evidence-based advocacy for enhanced policing and policy responses. This dual recording-response framework prioritizes empirical tracking over prosecutorial determinations, capturing non-criminal hate expressions to gauge underlying societal hostility.

Research and Monitoring

The Community Security Trust (CST) maintains a dedicated monitoring program for antisemitic incidents in the , systematically recording reports of anti-Jewish hatred since 1984. Incidents are defined as malicious acts directed at Jewish individuals, organizations, or property, supported by evidence of antisemitic motivation or content; this criterion is narrower than the criminal justice system's threshold for hate crimes and explicitly excludes non-antisemitic expressions of anti-Israel sentiment. Data collection relies on reports submitted to CST through multiple channels, including telephone, email, website forms, , postal mail, or in-person submissions, primarily from victims (33% of 2024 reports), witnesses (20%), staff at Jewish institutions (14%), and other community sources such as security personnel or partners. CST does not conduct proactive trawling of online platforms but includes reported online incidents only if they involve UK-based victims or witnesses and demonstrate antisemitic elements; in 2024, it excluded 2,479 potential cases lacking such motivation. As a third-party reporter with services since 2001, CST shares anonymized data under a national Information Sharing Agreement to aid while protecting reporter . CST publishes comprehensive annual and semi-annual Antisemitic Incidents Reports detailing recorded figures, categorized by type—such as assaults (6% of total in ), damage and , threats, abusive behavior (82%), and literature distribution—and broken down by geography, with accounting for over half of incidents in recent years. The report documented 3,528 incidents, the second-highest annual total, reflecting a 18% decline from 4,296 in 2023 but sustained elevation linked to the Israel-Hamas following the , 2023, attack, which correlated with 52% of cases. The January-June 2025 report recorded 1,521 incidents, the second-highest half-year figure, underscoring ongoing trends. Beyond raw incident logging, CST's incorporates analysis of patterns, including perpetrator demographics (e.g., increased reports of /North African or South Asian individuals during conflict peaks), sectoral impacts (e.g., 260 school-related incidents in ), and discourse monitoring via separate reports on antisemitic in and online spaces. Specialized briefings, such as the "Pathway to Terror" publication, examine individual cases of escalation to violence, drawing on incident to trace causal pathways. Suspicious behaviors, like information-gathering near Jewish sites (640 cases in ), are tracked separately due to inconclusive motivations, preventing inflation of incident counts. This research informs advisory roles, providing evidence-based guidance to government, police, politicians, media, and the Jewish community on threat trends, response strategies, and policy needs; CST emphasizes that reported figures likely underrepresent total occurrences due to unreported cases, particularly among minors.

Funding and Finances

Government Grants

The Community Security Trust (CST) receives funding from the UK Home Office through the Jewish Community Protective Security Grant (JCPSG), a program established to finance physical security enhancements at Jewish communal sites including synagogues, schools, and community centers. As the designated grant recipient, CST administers these funds, distributing them to eligible Jewish organizations for measures such as hiring commercial security guards, installing CCTV systems, access control, and perimeter defenses, separate from CST's own staff or volunteer personnel. The JCPSG originated in the early 2000s amid rising security concerns but has expanded significantly since 2015 with dedicated annual allocations. Funding amounts have escalated in response to increased antisemitic threats, particularly following events like the 7 October 2023 attacks on . In October 2023, the provided an additional £3 million, elevating the annual grant to £18 million specifically for commercial guards at Jewish institutions. This built on prior commitments, such as £14 million allocated in earlier cycles for similar protective purposes. In February 2024, Prime Minister announced a £54 million package over four years (2024–2028)—the largest single government investment in Jewish community security to date—administered via CST to sustain and expand these measures amid a reported surge in incidents. Further emergency support followed in October 2025, with up to £10 million injected to bolster security at synagogues and schools during a period of elevated risks, as confirmed during a visit by and to headquarters. These grants are performance-monitored by the , requiring to report on distribution and outcomes, and are ineligible for 's internal operational costs, focusing instead on direct community protections. Historical data from parliamentary submissions indicate that such funding has covered over 700 Jewish sites annually, with allocations prioritized based on threat assessments.

Community and Private Sources

The (CST) derives a substantial portion of its non-governmental funding from voluntary donations and legacies provided by members of the British Jewish community and private philanthropists. These contributions support core operational costs, including staff salaries, volunteer training, incident monitoring, research, and advisory services, which are distinct from grants allocated specifically for commercial security guards at Jewish sites. In the financial year ending 31 December 2023, donations and legacies generated £9.43 million in income, comprising approximately one-third of CST's of £28.21 million and marking a steady increase from £7.76 million the prior year. This voluntary funding is raised through direct appeals, committed giving programs, and bequests, with CST actively promoting legacies as a means for supporters to contribute significantly to long-term security efforts. Community-driven underscores the self-reliance of Jewish institutions in addressing antisemitic threats, supplementing state support amid rising incidents.

Impact and Effectiveness

Achievements in Threat Mitigation

The Community Security Trust (CST) has mitigated threats to British Jewish communities through physical security deployments, intelligence sharing, and targeted interventions. In 2024, CST volunteers and staff secured over 650 communal buildings and protected events at hundreds of sites, including 200 schools and 260 synagogues, utilizing government-funded guards to deter potential attacks. CST's intelligence efforts contributed to the referral of more than 145 individuals to counter-terrorism police, averting planned threats. Specific interventions have prevented violent incidents, such as in May 2024 when supported the arrests of three men plotting an Islamic State-inspired attack on in northwest . intelligence also aided convictions for offenses, including Gabriel Budasz receiving a 12-year sentence in October 2024 and Mohammed Ahmed a one-year sentence in December 2024, both linked to threats against Jewish targets. On October 2, 2025, volunteers at a confronted and halted a vehicle-ramming and stabbing attacker, preventing entry into the building and likely averting further casualties, though one volunteer was injured. Training programs have enhanced , with delivering 750 Streetwise workshops in 2024 to 23,000 Jewish youths, teaching threat recognition and response. The Stand Up! program reached 29,480 students in 93 schools, fostering bystander intervention against . Since 2006, has funded £19 million in upgrades, such as CCTV and reinforced doors at communal sites, reducing vulnerability to assaults. Collaborations with , regarded as a model of community-law enforcement partnership, have integrated volunteers into joint patrols, contributing to proactive threat neutralization.

Influence on Policy and Community Safety

The (CST) has shaped government policy on through its detailed incident reporting and analytical publications, which provide empirical data used by policymakers to assess threats and allocate resources. For instance, CST's annual antisemitic incident reports, documenting over 30,000 incidents since 1994, have highlighted surges such as the record 4,103 incidents in 2023—more than double the previous high—prompting parliamentary inquiries and security funding increases. responses, including the Home Office's adoption of CST metrics for monitoring hate crimes, reflect this data's role in evidencing the scale of threats linked to events like the , 2023, attacks. CST's policy advocacy includes submissions to select committees and direct consultations, influencing on and . In evidence to the Home Affairs Committee, CST emphasized the need for enhanced community cohesion assessments based on its monitoring of antisemitic patterns, contributing to frameworks like the UK's information-sharing agreement with the for real-time threat intelligence. This has informed policies such as the 2025 expansion of protective measures for places of worship, announced by Yvette following CST briefings on intimidation risks. Additionally, CST's recommendations have supported multi-year funding commitments, including a £54 million package in 2025 for Jewish community security enhancements, directly tied to its threat assessments. On community safety, CST's operational interventions—providing security training to over 1,000 volunteers annually, installing protective equipment at hundreds of sites, and conducting risk assessments—have demonstrably reduced vulnerabilities for Jewish institutions. Its program extends this expertise to non-Jewish groups facing hate or , fostering wider societal through shared protocols on and response. Evaluations indicate these measures have thwarted potential attacks, with CST's proactive monitoring credited for averting incidents amid heightened post-2023 tensions, though sustained government partnership remains essential for scalability.

Controversies

Debates on Incident Definitions and Reporting

The Community Security Trust (CST) defines an antisemitic incident as "any malicious act aimed at Jewish people, organisations or property, where there is that the incident" targets the victim due to their perceived or actual or connection to Jewish institutions. This encompasses a range of acts, from extreme violence and threats to lower-level occurrences such as , , or online harassment, provided links the motivation to rather than unrelated factors. CST records incidents based primarily on reports from victims, witnesses, or sources, without requiring involvement or criminal prosecution, which allows capture of events that may not meet legal thresholds for hate crimes. Critics contend that this methodology results in overcounting by including incidents with ambiguous motivations, particularly those involving or , thereby blurring the distinction between political dissent and genuine . For example, in its 2023 report, CST documented over 4,000 incidents, with more than half referencing or amid the attacks and subsequent conflict, prompting accusations that the trust equates anti- activism—such as protests or calls—with antisemitic targeting of . Organizations like have argued that CST's reliance on subjective victim perceptions, without independent verification of intent, inflates figures to advance a pro- narrative, as evidenced by the trust's historical emphasis on as a form of . CST's alignment with the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance (IHRA) working definition of antisemitism, adopted by the government in 2016, has intensified these debates, as the IHRA includes examples where denying Jewish self-determination or applying double standards to may constitute antisemitism. Detractors, including some academics and advocacy groups, claim this framework risks suppressing legitimate criticism of Israeli policies by categorizing it under antisemitic incidents when reported in Jewish community contexts, though CST insists classification requires specific evidence of malice toward , not abstract political views. Comparisons with official statistics highlight further contention: while CST reported 1,037 incidents in the first half of 2024, police-recorded antisemitic hate crimes in for full-year 2023 totaled around 1,500, suggesting CST captures unreported or non-criminalized events but also raising questions about consistency in evidentiary standards. does not publicly detail its full verification processes beyond basic evidence requirements, which some observers attribute to protecting reporter but others view as lacking , potentially undermining the data's reliability for policy or academic use. In response, emphasizes that its figures reflect lived community threats—often underreported to authorities due to fear or perceived inefficacy—rather than prosecutable offenses, providing a more comprehensive gauge of antisemitic prevalence than data alone.

Political and Ideological Criticisms

Critics, particularly from pro-Palestinian advocacy groups and left-wing Jewish organizations, have accused the Community Security Trust (CST) of exhibiting a pro-Israel ideological that conflates opposition to Israeli policies with . For instance, in August 2014, CST's then communications director Mark Gardner stated that the (BDS) movement posed a greater danger to than a recent attack on a , a comparison decried by analyst Antony Lerman as an unjustified conflation of political advocacy with violent . Such critiques often center on CST's incident recording methodology, which relies on a incorporating elements of the (IHRA) examples, including certain forms of or denial of Jewish . In its 2023 Antisemitic Incidents Report, CST classified 427 instances of "Free Palestine" expressions and 1,299 incidents with references to or as antisemitic, prompting accusations from Joseph Finlay of that this approach politicizes data by treating context-dependent political speech—such as chants at protests—as inherently hateful, thereby inflating totals and fostering a "" rather than addressing unambiguous threats. Further ideological objections portray as advancing Zionist interests over broader community security, with involvement in pro-Israel initiatives like the Fair Play Campaign Group in 2012 and internal documents from 2011 denouncing anti-Zionist to government bodies cited as evidence of mandate overreach. The , in a analysis, labeled a "Zionist" entity aligned with state efforts to criminalize , arguing its post-October 7, 2023, reporting—documenting a 147% rise in incidents to 4,103—serves to shield 's operations from scrutiny by framing dissent as Jew-hatred. These sources, often from outlets critical of , maintain that 's framework stifles legitimate debate on policy while underemphasizing intra-community or non-Zionist perspectives on Jewish safety.

Intra-Community Disputes

Certain factions within the Jewish community, notably left-leaning groups such as (JVL), have contested the Community Security Trust's (CST) approach to defining and tallying antisemitic incidents, particularly its categorization of anti-Zionist expressions as potentially antisemitic when directed at Jewish individuals or sites. JVL has argued that the CST's methodology, which recorded 1,299 incidents with anti-Zionist motivations in 2023 (up from 149 in 2022), conflates legitimate political criticism of with hatred against , thereby inflating overall figures and marginalizing dissenting Jewish voices on the Israel-Palestine conflict. In a March 2024 analysis, JVL's Joseph highlighted that while the CST rejected 2,185 of 6,288 reported incidents in 2023 as non-antisemitic, its retained criteria still encompass online rhetoric or protests invoking alongside traditional antisemitic tropes, which JVL views as an overreach that prioritizes advocacy for over nuanced threat assessment. These critiques intensified amid the 2015-2020 Labour Party antisemitism controversy, where CST data—showing spikes like 1,005 incidents in 2019—were cited by mainstream Jewish organizations to highlight perceived institutional failures, prompting JVL to accuse the CST of selective reporting that aligned with efforts to discredit left-wing politics rather than solely safeguarding community security. JVL has further contended that the CST's emphasis on Israel-related incidents, comprising over 60% of 2023 totals, serves broader lobbying interests and discourages intra-community dialogue, as evidenced by their rejection of the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance (IHRA) working definition of antisemitism, which the CST employs in its assessments. In response, CST officials, including policy director Dave Rich, have defended the classifications by noting empirical patterns where anti-Zionist rhetoric explicitly targets —such as vandalism of synagogues with slogans like "Zionist scum"—distinguishing these from abstract policy critiques, and arguing that excluding such data would understate real security risks amid surges like the 600% rise post-October 7, 2023. Independent Jewish commentator Antony Lerman has echoed some concerns, writing in 2011 that CST reporting amplifies perceptions of perpetual threat, potentially fostering unnecessary alarmism within the community, though he acknowledged the organization's objective verification processes. Such disagreements reflect broader fractures in British Jewish life, with mainstream bodies like the Board of Deputies of endorsing 's work as vital for evidence-based advocacy, while fringe progressive elements decry it as ideologically driven; no unified intra-community has emerged, and disputes have not led to formal schisms in operations or funding.

References

  1. [1]
    About CST – CST – Protecting Our Jewish Community
    Community Security Trust (CST) is the charity that protects British Jews from terrorism and antisemitism. We ensure that Jewish people across the UK can ...CST’s Mission · SAFE: Security Advice for... · Police Partnership · CST's Leadership
  2. [2]
    COMMUNITY SECURITY TRUST - 1042391 - Charity Commission
    CST seeks to protect Britain's diverse and vibrant Jewish community from the external threats of bigotry, antisemitism and terrorism.
  3. [3]
    CST (Community Security Trust) | JVN - Jewish Volunteering Network
    CST gained charitable status in 1994, though its origins lie in many decades of Jewish self-defence – both before and after World War Two. Across the UK, 2,000 ...Missing: history | Show results with:history<|separator|>
  4. [4]
    CST's Mission – CST – Protecting Our Jewish Community
    Promote good relations between British Jews and the rest of British society by working towards the elimination of racism, and antisemitism in particular.
  5. [5]
    [PDF] DED0045 Written evidence submitted by the Antisemitism Policy Trust
    Mar 28, 2024 · The Community Security Trust recorded over 4,000 antisemitic incidents in 2023, 1,662 incidents in 2022 and 2,261 incidents in 2021.
  6. [6]
    Home Secretary speech at the Community Security Trust - GOV.UK
    Mar 26, 2025 · Home Secretary, Yvette Cooper gave a speech at the Community Security Trust where she announced new measures to protect places of worship from intimidation.
  7. [7]
    [PDF] The Antisemitism Policy Trust (APT), a charity fo
    Data from the Community Security Trust (CST) highlights a rise in antisemitic incidents at schools and universities. This submission addresses exposure to.
  8. [8]
    [PDF] Letter from the Community Security Trust - GOV.UK
    Jun 1, 2025 · CST is widely acknowledged as. Britain's leading non-state authority on antisemitism, anti-Jewish terrorism and. Jewish communal security issues ...
  9. [9]
    Antisemitism on university campuses - House of Lords Library
    May 1, 2025 · Reported rise in antisemitic incidents on university campuses. The Community Security Trust (CST) is a UK charity that works to protect Jews ...
  10. [10]
    Thirty years of protecting the community: the CST marks a milestone
    Dec 2, 2024 · The CST's story began in 1994 when it evolved from the Community Security Organisation into its current charitable structure, guided by three ...Missing: founding origins
  11. [11]
    [PDF] Community Security Trust - Charity Commission
    Dec 31, 2020 · The charity was established by a charitable trust deed on 21 November 1994 as amended by deeds of variation on 12 November 1996, 31 December ...
  12. [12]
    [PDF] Terrorist Incidents 1968-2010 - CST
    When the first edition of this report was published in 2003, it was the first time that the history of post-1967 anti-Jewish terrorism had been collated.
  13. [13]
    Government Grant – CST – Protecting Our Jewish Community
    CST distributes an £18m government grant that funds commercial security guards (as distinct from CST staff and volunteer security personnel) at Jewish communal ...Missing: milestones expansion
  14. [14]
    [PDF] ANNUAL REVIEW - CST
    CST works closely with the police and shares hate crime information with police forces across the UK. CST manages a £14 millon government grant for security ...Missing: milestones | Show results with:milestones
  15. [15]
    Record funding will protect Jewish communities from harm - GOV.UK
    Feb 29, 2024 · The government provided an additional £3 million for the Community Security Trust to provide additional security in October 2023, raising the ...Missing: expansion | Show results with:expansion
  16. [16]
    UK government increases security funding for Jewish community
    Feb 28, 2024 · British Prime Minister Rishi Sunak on Wednesday announced 54 million pounds ($68 million) of new funding to protect Jewish communities against antisemitism ...Missing: expansion | Show results with:expansion
  17. [17]
    Record funding to protect Jewish communities - GOV.UK
    Oct 16, 2025 · Jewish communities will receive up to £10 million in an emergency cash injection to scale up security at synagogues and schools, ...Missing: expansion | Show results with:expansion
  18. [18]
    What is Antisemitism? – CST – Protecting Our Jewish Community
    For more detailed information about how CST defines and categorises antisemitic incidents, see our leaflet, Categories of antisemitic incidents. CST – ...Missing: criteria | Show results with:criteria
  19. [19]
    Definitions of antisemitism: a quick guide – Blog - CST
    Oct 6, 2016 · Antisemitism is a certain perception of Jews, which may be expressed as hatred toward Jews. Rhetorical and physical manifestations of ...
  20. [20]
    None
    ### Full Definition of Antisemitic Incidents by CST
  21. [21]
    Antisemitic Incidents 2024 – CST Publications
    CST recorded 3,528 antisemitic incidents in the UK in 2024, the second-highest total ever reported to CST in a single calendar year. This is a decrease of ...Missing: evolution | Show results with:evolution
  22. [22]
    Community Security Trust (CST)(COM0024) - Committee ...
    CST is recognised by government and police as a best practice model of a minority-community security organisation. CST administers the UK government's Jewish ...
  23. [23]
    CST – Protecting Our Jewish Community
    Community Security Trust is a registered charity in England and Wales (1042391) and Scotland (SC043612). Fundraising Regulator JVN. Back to Top.About CSTContactDonate Online NowAntisemitismReport Antisemitism
  24. [24]
    An open letter from CST Chairman, Gerald M Ronson CBE
    Sep 6, 2018 · For all of my adult life, I have fought against antisemitism. In the 1950s and 1960s, the fascists had to be physically forced off our ...
  25. [25]
    Arise Sir Gerald! Philanthropist Ronson knighted in New Year's ...
    Dec 30, 2023 · V One of the Jewish community's most influential philanthropists, Gerald Ronson, has been knighted and one of its most prominent rabbis, ...
  26. [26]
    CST's Leadership – CST – Protecting Our Jewish Community
    CST's Leadership · Mark Gardner, CST Chief Executive · Amanda Bomsztyk, CST Northern Regional Director · Dr Dave Rich, CST Director of Policy.Missing: governance | Show results with:governance
  27. [27]
    Mark Gardner is new chief executive of the Community Security Trust
    Jun 16, 2020 · Mark Gardner is to become the new chief executive of the Community Security Trust, replacing David Delew, who has announced he would stand down ...
  28. [28]
    CST Chief Executive David Delew to step down – Blog
    Jun 17, 2020 · CST's Chief Executive, David Delew has decided to step down after successfully leading the organisation for the past 7 years.
  29. [29]
    [PDF] ANNUAL REVIEW - CST
    Mar 4, 2025 · SECURITY. We provide security advice and equipment to. Jewish schools, organisations, synagogues etc. across the UK. CST also donates money ...Missing: milestones | Show results with:milestones
  30. [30]
    [PDF] ANNUAL REVIEW - CST
    May 21, 2024 · Across the UK, 2,000 dedicated volunteers and over 100 members of staff power CST's mission. CONTENTS. INTRODUCTION. COMMUNITY SECURITY TRUST.
  31. [31]
    [PDF] 1 CST ANNUAL REVIEW 2022
    Apr 20, 2023 · The. King was introduced to dozens of CST guests, including senior volunteers, CST's board of trustees and police ... www.cst.org.uk Community ...
  32. [32]
    [PDF] ANTISEMITIC INCIDENTS - CST
    Community Security Trust (CST) is a UK charity that advises and represents the Jewish community on matters of antisemitism, terrorism, policing and security.Missing: size | Show results with:size
  33. [33]
    Safe, sound and secure with the CST - Jewish News
    Jul 10, 2017 · More than 80 staff and 3,000 communal security volunteers work in partnership with synagogues, schools, and community centres to help keep the ...
  34. [34]
    None
    ### Summary of CST's Security Services and Training from 2023 Annual Review
  35. [35]
    CST and the Police working together to enact armed patrols
    Aug 24, 2016 · CST and the Police have worked very closely together to plan and enact armed foot patrols in various areas of London with large Jewish ...
  36. [36]
    Training Courses – CST – Protecting Our Jewish Community
    CST offers a range of security training for individuals and organisations throughout the Jewish community.Missing: services | Show results with:services
  37. [37]
    [PDF] Written evidence from the Community Security Trust [CCI0042]
    model of a minority-community security organisation. CST administers the. Government's 'Jewish Community Protective Security Grant' that significantly.
  38. [38]
    Antisemitic Incidents Report January-June 2025 - CST
    CST recorded 1,521 antisemitic incidents across the UK in the first half of 2025, the second-highest total ever reported to CST in the first six months of ...Missing: evolution | Show results with:evolution
  39. [39]
    Report Antisemitism – CST – Protecting Our Jewish Community
    CST publishes statistics and analysis of antisemitic incidents in the annual Antisemitic Incidents Report.Missing: recording response
  40. [40]
    CST Publications – CST – Protecting Our Jewish Community
    CST publications include our annual reports on antisemitic incidents and antisemitic discourse, and other publications to help increase understanding of ...Missing: recording response
  41. [41]
    Pathway to Terror – Blog - CST
    Oct 21, 2024 · CST's latest research briefing published today, titled Pathway to Terror, reveals the full story of Robert Taylor who was sentenced on Friday 18 October 2024 ...
  42. [42]
    Research & Analysis – CST – Protecting Our Jewish Community
    CST is an expert on antisemitism in the UK. We monitor, research and analyse antisemitic activity to advise the Government, police, politicians, media and the ...
  43. [43]
    Jewish Community Protective Security Grant - GOV.UK
    Feb 13, 2025 · The Jewish Community Protective Security Grant is managed on behalf of the Home Office by the Community Security Trust (CST) to protect synagogues.
  44. [44]
    PM announces £72 million to fund security for Jewish communities
    Feb 29, 2024 · The Government provided an additional £3 million to the CST to provide additional security in October 2023, raising the funding to £18 million a ...Missing: amounts | Show results with:amounts
  45. [45]
    COMMUNITY SECURITY TRUST - 1042391 - Charity Commission
    Charity overview · What, who, how, where · Governance · Trustees · Financial history · Assets and liabilities · Accounts and annual returns · Governing document ...
  46. [46]
    GB-CHC-1042391 | Community Security Trust - Find that Charity
    Community Security Trust. A Registered Charity based in England. Active ... Employees Volunteers. Data on employees is only available for financial years ...
  47. [47]
    Donate Online Now – CST – Protecting Our Jewish Community
    Almost all of our costs have to be covered by charitable donations so please give generously. You will be helping us to enable our community to live safe and ...
  48. [48]
    Leave a Legacy – CST – Protecting Our Jewish Community
    A legacy is often the biggest gift a supporter can make, and at the same time is the easiest. There are different ways you can help CST via a legacy.
  49. [49]
    None
    ### Summary of CST Achievements in 2024
  50. [50]
    Rabbi and security staff who blocked synagogue attacker 'true ... - BBC
    Oct 2, 2025 · Burnham confirmed that volunteers from the Community Security Trust, a charity that monitors antisemitism in the UK, were at the scene during ...
  51. [51]
    Latest Security Advice – CST – Protecting Our Jewish Community
    Oct 2, 2025 · ... prevented further casualties and we pay tribute to their courage. ... Community Security Trust is a registered charity in England and Wales ...
  52. [52]
    Community Security Trust (CST) - Facebook
    Dec 18, 2024 · For decades, our volunteers and police officers have partnered on joint patrols and security operations to protect the Jewish community. CST ...Missing: achievements | Show results with:achievements
  53. [53]
    From Music Festivals to Street Attacks: The Spread of Antisemitism ...
    Aug 8, 2025 · Cooper also announced the creation of a new Antisemitism Working Group and reaffirmed a £54 million funding package for CST's protective work ...
  54. [54]
    SAFE: Security Advice for Everyone - CST
    SAFE shares CST's security knowledge with groups outside the Jewish community that are vulnerable to violence, extremism or hate crime.
  55. [55]
    [PDF] Definitions of Antisemitic Incidents.pdf - CST
    CST assists and supports individual members of the Jewish Community who have been affected by antisemitism and antisemitic incidents. CST also represents the ...Missing: definitional framework
  56. [56]
    More than a question of numbers – the CST and antisemitism
    Mar 26, 2024 · Joseph Finlay takes an in-depth look at the new Community Security Trust report on antisemitism in Britain in 2023 to assess how useful its approaches are and ...<|control11|><|separator|>
  57. [57]
    [PDF] ANTISEMITIC INCIDENTS - CST
    Community Security Trust (CST) is a. UK charity that advises and represents the Jewish community on matters of antisemitism, terrorism, policing and security.Missing: definitional framework
  58. [58]
    UK Zionist Community Security Trust group equates opposition to ...
    Feb 26, 2024 · The CST's “Antisemitic Incidents Report 2023” reinforces the campaign by the Conservative government, backed by the Labour opposition, ...
  59. [59]
    Clare Short, the IHRA definition and a case study in being wrong - CST
    May 30, 2019 · What is Antisemitism? Antisemitic Discourse · Educational Resources · Security · Volunteer · Training Courses · Building Security · Security ...
  60. [60]
    Is there a 'rising tide' of anti-Semitism in the West? - BBC News
    Aug 21, 2014 · ... anti-Semitic graffiti and online expressions of anti-Semitism. The CST says it received around 240 reports of anti-Semitic incidents in July ...
  61. [61]
    What Is Wrong with the International Holocaust Remembrance ...
    May 11, 2022 · The IHRA's four-line definition of antisemitism correctly states that hate towards Jews may be antisemitic but is worded vaguely and ...<|control11|><|separator|>
  62. [62]
    Anti-Semitism watchdog CST "abusing" mandate to defend Israel
    Aug 12, 2014 · The Community Security Trust, a UK charity which records and combats anti-Semitism, claims that the boycott of Israel is worse than a recent ...Missing: methodology | Show results with:methodology
  63. [63]
    Will the latest CST report do more to protect British Jews or Israel
    May 2, 2024 · He suggests the claims that the CST report findings reflect an unprecedented increase of “anti-Jewish hate threatening British Jews everywhere” ...
  64. [64]
    Protecting British Jews In a Time of Crisis
    Jul 9, 2025 · Dave Rich is Director of Policy at the Community Security Trust (CST), a British charity dedicated to protecting the UK's Jewish community from ...
  65. [65]
    How Feelings of Jewish Insecurity are Aggravated ... - Antony Lerman
    Jun 13, 2011 · CST, however, ultimately defines incidents against Jews as being antisemitic only where it can be objectively shown to be the case, and this may ...Missing: Orthodox | Show results with:Orthodox
  66. [66]