Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Consignment

Consignment is a commercial arrangement in which a consignor, the owner of goods, delivers them to a consignee, typically a merchant or retailer, for the purpose of sale, while retaining ownership and title to the goods until they are sold to a third-party buyer.^[1] Under this agreement, the consignee acts as an agent, handling the storage, display, marketing, and sale of the goods, and receives a commission—often ranging from 25% to 60% of the sale price—for their services.^[2] The consignor bears the risk of unsold inventory, which is typically returned after a specified period, and may cover costs such as shipping or insurance.^[3] In practice, consignment operates through a formal contract that outlines key terms, including the duration of the arrangement, pricing, commission rates, payment timelines, and procedures for handling unsold or damaged goods.^[3] Upon sale, the consignee remits the consignment's share of the proceeds, minus the commission, often within 30 to 60 days, though this can vary by agreement.^[2] This model is commonly used in industries such as fashion, art, antiques, and handmade crafts, where it allows consignors—such as artists or small producers—to access retail spaces without upfront inventory costs for the seller.^[3] For instance, an artist might consign works to a gallery, which displays and sells them for a 50% commission, expanding the artist's market reach.^[2] The primary benefits of consignment include reduced financial risk for consignors, as they avoid tying up capital in unsold stock, and broader market exposure without the need for their own storefront or e-commerce setup.^[2] Consignees benefit from diversified inventory at no initial cost, potentially increasing foot traffic and sales volume, with the U.S. craft consignment market accounting for more than $3 billion annually in the early 2000s.^[3] However, drawbacks exist, such as potential delays in payments, disputes over item condition, or limited control over pricing and display by the consignor.^[2] Legally, consignment is governed by contract law and, in the United States, provisions of the Uniform Commercial Code (UCC), particularly Article 9, which provides rules for consignments meeting specific criteria—including the delivery of goods valued at $1,000 or more to a merchant operating under a different name who is not generally known by its creditors to be substantially engaged in selling the goods of others—to protect the consignor's security interest in the inventory.^[1] A written consignment agreement is essential to protect both parties, specifying responsibilities for insurance, taxes, and termination to prevent issues like commingling of goods or creditor claims against the consignee's assets.^[3] In international contexts, consignment may also involve customs regulations for cross-border shipments.^[1]

Fundamentals

Definition and Core Principles

Consignment is a mercantile transaction in which a supplier, known as the consignor, delivers goods to an agent or intermediary, called the consignee, for the purpose of sale to a third party, while the consignor retains ownership of the goods until such a sale occurs.^[1] This arrangement allows the consignee to handle the marketing, display, and sale of the goods without assuming the financial risk of upfront purchase, with payment to the consignor typically consisting of the sale proceeds minus an agreed commission.^[4] The core principles of consignment revolve around three essential conditions that distinguish it as a specific type of commercial bailment: the goods must be made available specifically for sale by the consignee; the consignee is obligated to pay the consignor only after a successful sale to a third party, rather than upon receipt; and the consignor maintains title to the goods, along with the associated risk of loss or damage, until the point of sale.^[1] In this relationship, the consignee acts in a fiduciary capacity to promote and sell the goods diligently, often under terms that include a commission rate—typically ranging from 25% to 60% of the sale price awarded to the consignee for their efforts.^[2] These principles ensure that the consignor bears the primary economic risk while leveraging the consignee's sales infrastructure. Consignment differs from related arrangements such as bailment, which involves the temporary transfer of possession for purposes like storage or repair without any intent to sell the goods, and from a general agency relationship, which encompasses broader fiduciary duties beyond mere sales facilitation and may not involve retained ownership of specific assets.^[1] For instance, in a basic freight shipping scenario, a manufacturer might consign goods to a distributor via carrier for eventual sale, retaining title during transit and storage; similarly, an individual could consign artwork to an auction house, where the house sells it on commission without purchasing it outright.^[5]

Historical Origins

The practice of consignment, involving the delivery of goods to an agent for sale with title retained by the owner until sale, has roots in ancient maritime commerce where merchants entrusted cargo to shippers or partners under conditional agreements tied to safe delivery. In Roman law, analogs appear in nauticum foenus (maritime loans), where repayment was contingent on the successful arrival of goods, allowing owners to send commodities via agents without immediate transfer of ownership or payment, as documented in contracts from ports like Puteoli and Alexandria.^[6] These arrangements, influenced by Hellenistic models like the Greek syngraphe, facilitated bulk transport of staples such as grain and oil through partnerships (societates) and trade associations (collegia), with risks borne by the carrier until delivery.^[6] During the medieval period, similar agency-based systems emerged along European trade routes, where sedentary merchants dispatched goods to distant factors or agents without upfront payment, relying on reciprocal networks to manage sales and remittances, as seen in Genoese and Maghribi trader coalitions that enforced cooperation through reputational mechanisms.^[7] The 19th century saw formalization of consignment amid the Industrial Revolution, particularly in transatlantic shipping and commodity trades. In the American South, the factorage system dominated the cotton economy pre-Civil War, with planters consigning bales to factors in ports like New Orleans or New York for sale in Europe or the North, retaining ownership to mitigate market risks without advancing funds for transport.^[8] This practice, embedded in emerging U.S. and European shipping laws, supported the explosive growth of cotton exports, which accounted for over half of U.S. exports by mid-century, while highlighting vulnerabilities like creditor claims on unsold goods under common law bailment principles.^[8] Common law treated consignments as bailments, protecting consignors' title from consignee creditors but creating "secret liens" that complicated commerce, a tension addressed in early statutory reforms.^[9] In the 20th century, consignment evolved amid technological and regulatory shifts, with traditional shipping applications declining due to containerization and standardized international rules. Post-World War II innovations, starting with Malcolm McLean's 1956 container ship voyages, streamlined global logistics by reducing handling costs and enabling faster, more secure transfers, diminishing the need for consignment's risk-sharing model in bulk ocean freight as ownership often passed via bills of lading upon loading.^[10] The 1968 Hague-Visby Rules, amending the 1924 Hague Rules, further standardized carrier liabilities for cargo from loading to discharge, making consignment rare in shipping by the 1980s as containerization and International Maritime Organization standards post-1948 promoted direct sales and financing.^[11] Meanwhile, retail consignment rose with the post-war consumer boom, as high-end shops in the 1950s catered to vintage apparel markets.^[12] Key milestones include the Uniform Commercial Code's (UCC) adoption in the U.S. during the 1950s, with Article 2's Section 2-326 (enacted 1952, effective in states by the 1960s) regulating consignments to protect creditors by deeming goods part of the consignee's inventory unless publicized, shifting from pure common law bailments.^[9] Revised UCC Article 9 (1999) further integrated consignments as security interests requiring public filing, influencing global standards.^[9] By the 2000s, e-commerce platforms briefly revived consignment models in retail by enabling low-risk inventory sharing between sellers and marketplaces.^[12]

Applications and Contexts

In Retail and Second-Hand Goods

In retail settings, particularly boutiques, antique stores, and second-hand shops, consignment serves as a low-risk model for selling goods such as clothing, furniture, art, and electronics, where the consignor supplies the items to the consignee for display and sale without transferring ownership upfront. The consignee, typically the store owner, markets and sells the merchandise, remitting payment to the consignor only after a sale occurs, deducting a commission for their services including storage, promotion, and handling. This arrangement allows retailers to diversify inventory without the financial burden of purchasing stock, thereby minimizing unsold inventory risks and appealing to small-scale sellers seeking to monetize personal collections.^[13] In second-hand goods contexts, consignment is prevalent for items like vintage clothing, jewelry, and antiques, where shops curate high-quality pre-owned pieces to attract eco-conscious consumers. Procedures typically begin with the consignor submitting items for inspection, followed by inventory tagging for tracking, mutual agreement on pricing based on condition and market value, and a defined sales period—often 60 to 90 days—after which unsold goods may face price reductions or return to the owner. Payments are split post-sale, commonly following a 50/50 or 60/40 division favoring the consignor after the store's commission, with payouts issued within 30 to 60 days of the transaction to ensure prompt settlement.^[14]^[15]^[16] This model has fueled growth in sustainable fashion resale, as consignment shops promote circular economy practices by extending product lifecycles. For instance, chains like Buffalo Exchange operate hybrid resale systems that incorporate consignment elements, buying or accepting items on approval for immediate or post-sale payouts, enabling rapid turnover of second-hand apparel and accessories. Industry data highlights the sector's expansion, with the U.S. second-hand apparel market valued at approximately $39 billion in 2022 and projected to reach $74 billion by 2029 as of 2025, driven by demand for affordable, environmentally friendly options in consignment retail.^[17]^[18]^[19]

In International Trade and Shipping

In international trade, consignment involves the shipment of goods from an exporter (consignor) to a foreign distributor (consignee) for sale in the local market, with the exporter retaining legal title and ownership until the goods are sold and payment is received. This arrangement serves as a variation of open account payment terms, allowing the distributor to manage inventory and sales while the exporter avoids the immediate transfer of ownership, thereby mitigating risks such as non-payment or distributor insolvency. It is particularly prevalent in commodities like agricultural products, where a substantial portion of produce exports from Latin America to the United States are handled on consignment to accommodate fluctuating demand and enable local marketing by the distributor. Similarly, it facilitates trade in textiles by enabling exporters to test market acceptance without upfront capital commitment from buyers.^[20]^[21]^[22] Regarding shipping, consignment goods are transported internationally via carriers, with documentation such as the bill of lading issued in the name of the consignee to authorize receipt, while contractual agreements specify the retained ownership to protect the exporter's interests during transit and storage. Historically, this method was more common for cross-border shipments of bulky or perishable items, but its use has declined in modern trade due to heightened risks and the rise of secure alternatives like letters of credit, especially following 1990s globalization that promoted direct sales and improved financing options. Regulations like Incoterms 2020, particularly FAS (Free Alongside Ship) and FOB (Free on Board), are often paired with consignment arrangements, as they define delivery points where the seller loads goods onto the vessel but retains control over title until sale.^[23]^[24]^[21] Cross-border consignment faces challenges including exposure to currency fluctuations that can erode sale proceeds when remitted to the exporter, as well as compliance with varying customs regulations and tariffs that may require the consignee to handle import formalities despite non-ownership. In the European Union single market, consignment stock arrangements benefit from VAT simplifications, allowing goods to be stored across borders without immediate taxation until withdrawal for sale, thus easing intra-regional trade flows. Although less favored in high-volume routes like U.S.-China trade due to tariff complexities and enforcement issues, consignment persists in emerging markets where relational trust between exporters and local agents supports risk-sharing for commodities.^[21]^[25]^[20]

In Inventory and Supply Chain Management

In inventory and supply chain management, consignment serves as a strategic tool for optimizing stock levels through vendor-managed inventory (VMI) arrangements, where the supplier retains ownership of goods placed at the buyer's location until consumption or sale occurs. This model shifts the inventory holding risk to the consignor, allowing the consignee—such as a manufacturer or retailer—to access products without tying up capital in unsold stock, thereby reducing carrying costs that can account for 20-30% of inventory value annually. By minimizing the consignee's exposure to obsolescence and overstock, consignment enhances cash flow efficiency and supports lean operations across the supply chain.^[26]^[27] Consignment further integrates with just-in-time (JIT) delivery principles to streamline supply chain responsiveness, enabling suppliers to replenish stock based on real-time demand signals rather than forecasts, which can lower overall inventory levels by up to 50% in collaborative setups. In the automotive sector, for example, suppliers consign critical components like brake parts or engines to assembly plants, ensuring availability exactly when needed for production lines without excess storage at the manufacturer. In retail, consignment is particularly effective for seasonal goods, such as holiday decorations or summer apparel, where stores can stock diverse items from multiple vendors without upfront purchases, avoiding post-season markdowns on unsold merchandise. These applications foster stronger supplier-buyer partnerships, reduce lead times, and improve service levels by aligning inventory with actual sales patterns.^[27]^[28]^[29] To maintain control over consigned inventory, organizations employ advanced tracking technologies such as RFID tags and barcodes, which provide automated, real-time visibility into stock movements and locations, reducing manual errors by up to 99% compared to traditional methods. RFID systems, in particular, allow bulk scanning without line-of-sight requirements, enabling suppliers to monitor usage remotely and trigger replenishments proactively. Periodic audits, conducted monthly or quarterly, verify physical counts against digital records to reconcile discrepancies and prevent commingling—where consigned goods mix with the consignee's owned inventory—through segregated storage zones or color-coded labeling. These techniques not only safeguard asset ownership but also mitigate risks like shrinkage, which can erode 1-2% of inventory value annually in unmanaged systems.^[30]^[31] A fundamental metric for evaluating consignment efficiency is the inventory turnover ratio, calculated as:

\text{Turnover} = \frac{\text{Cost of Goods Sold (COGS)}}{\text{Average Consigned Inventory}}

This ratio indicates how many times consigned inventory is sold and replaced over a period, typically a year, with higher values signaling effective utilization. To arrive at the solution, first determine COGS for the consigned goods, which is the consignor's cost of items sold during the period. Next, compute the average consigned inventory by adding the beginning and ending inventory values (as reported in the consignor's records) and dividing by 2: \text{Average} = \frac{\text{Beginning Inventory} + \text{Ending Inventory}}{2}. Divide COGS by this average to obtain the turnover; for instance, if COGS is $500,000 and average consigned inventory is $100,000, the turnover is 5, meaning the inventory turns over five times annually. This calculation helps identify bottlenecks, such as slow-moving items, and guides adjustments in replenishment strategies.^[32] In contemporary supply chains, consignment has evolved through integration with enterprise resource planning (ERP) systems, which automate real-time ownership transfers upon point-of-sale or usage events, ensuring seamless updates to both parties' ledgers without manual intervention. ERP platforms like NetSuite or SAP maintain separate ledgers for consigned stock, using transfer orders to record sales and trigger commission payments or invoice settlements instantly, which can reduce processing delays from days to minutes. This digital linkage enhances transparency, supports predictive analytics for demand forecasting, and scales consignment across global networks, ultimately boosting overall supply chain agility.^[33]^[31]

Modern Digital and E-Commerce Applications

In the digital era, consignment has evolved through e-commerce platforms that facilitate peer-to-peer and mediated sales of second-hand goods, allowing sellers to retain ownership until a transaction completes while platforms manage listings, payments, and fulfillment minus a commission fee. Platforms like Poshmark and Depop exemplify this model, where users upload photos of clothing or accessories, set prices, and the site handles secure payments and shipping labels, remitting proceeds after deducting 10-20% fees. Similarly, eBay supports consignment-style listings via its Authenticity Guarantee for high-value items, where verified sellers list goods and eBay processes sales, ensuring buyer protection through its Money Back Guarantee. ThredUp operates a more traditional online consignment service, where users ship items to the platform for inspection, photography, and listing; unsold goods are recycled or returned, with sellers earning 5-80% of sale prices based on item value.^[34]^[35]^[36]^[37] Virtual consignment extends to digital assets, particularly non-fungible tokens (NFTs) and software licenses, where ownership remains with the creator or licensor until sale. On marketplaces like OpenSea, NFT creators list unique digital art or collectibles for fixed prices or auctions, with the platform escrowing the asset during the transaction and taking a 2.5% royalty on resales to track perpetual ownership transfers via blockchain. This model ensures immutable provenance, as Ethereum smart contracts automatically enforce royalties (typically 5-10%) on secondary sales, preventing unauthorized duplication. For software licenses, platforms like G2A enable resellers to list unused keys on a consignment basis, where the marketplace verifies authenticity, handles payments, and remits funds after deducting fees, though this operates in a gray market prone to invalid keys. Blockchain integration further enhances tracking in these systems by logging every transfer in a decentralized ledger, reducing disputes over digital ownership.^[38]^[39]^[40] Post-2020, the COVID-19 pandemic accelerated sustainable e-consignment adoption, with online resale growing 27% in 2020 alone as consumers shifted to value-driven, eco-friendly shopping amid economic uncertainty. ThredUp's platform saw heightened activity, contributing to the global secondhand apparel market reaching $167 billion in 2022 and $197 billion in 2023, with projections for $367 billion by 2029 as of 2025 driven by circular fashion trends. This surge aligned with broader sustainability goals, as 62% of consumers preferred secondhand to reduce environmental impact. Integration of artificial intelligence has further innovated these platforms; ThredUp's AI-powered tools, launched in 2024, use image recognition for product recommendations and dynamic pricing based on demand trends, while Poshmark's Smart List AI automates listing generation from single photos to optimize seller efficiency and match items to buyers via algorithmic personalization.^[41]^[42]^[37]^[43]^[44]^[45]^[19] Digital consignment faces challenges like fraud prevention and logistical scalability, addressed through escrow mechanisms and hybrid fulfillment models. Escrow services, such as those integrated into eBay or third-party providers like Escrow.com, hold buyer funds until goods or digital assets are verified and delivered, mitigating risks in peer-to-peer transactions where 20-30% of disputes involve non-delivery or misrepresentation. For global reach without physical inventory, hybrid dropshipping-consignment models allow e-commerce sellers to partner with suppliers who hold goods on consignment and ship directly to international buyers, combining low upfront costs with on-demand fulfillment; platforms like Shopify support this via apps that automate vendor coordination and ownership transfers upon sale. These innovations enable borderless operations while maintaining consignment's core principle of deferred ownership transfer.^[46]^[47]^[48]^[49]

Legal and Regulatory Framework

Legal Definitions and Contractual Elements

In the United States, consignment is legally defined under the Uniform Commercial Code (UCC) § 9-102 as a transaction, regardless of its form, in which a person delivers goods to a merchant for the purpose of sale, provided that the merchant deals in goods of that kind under a name other than the deliverer's, is not an auctioneer, is not generally known by its creditors to be substantially engaged in selling others' goods, the aggregate value of the goods is $1,000 or more at delivery, the goods are not consumer goods immediately before delivery, and the transaction does not create a security interest securing an obligation.^[50] This definition treats consignment as retaining a security interest for the consignor (the deliverer) against the consignee's (the merchant's) creditors, distinguishing it from outright sales by preserving the consignor's title until the goods are sold to a third party or the consignee pays.^[9] Internationally, consignment agreements are distinguished from sales under frameworks like the United Nations Convention on Contracts for the International Sale of Goods (CISG), where retention of title by the supplier means the transaction does not qualify as a sale under Article 4(b), as it does not involve transfer of property in the goods.^[51] Key contractual elements in consignment agreements include detailed descriptions of the goods consigned, specifying type, quantity, condition, and value to avoid disputes over identification.^[52] Commission rates are typically outlined as a percentage of the sale price paid to the consignee upon sale, often ranging from 20% to 50% depending on the industry, with unsold goods returnable without payment.^[53] Duration clauses commonly set a fixed term, such as 90 days of exclusivity for display and sale efforts by the consignee, after which unsold items must be returned.^[54] Termination rights allow either party to end the agreement with notice, often 30 days, for breach or mutual consent, while specifying post-termination handling of inventory.^[55] Insurance responsibilities are allocated to the consignee to cover loss, damage, or theft during possession, with the consignor retaining risk of title until sale.^[56] Jurisdictional variations affect consignment, particularly in title transfer rules. In the European Union, the Consumer Rights Directive (2011/83/EU) imposes consumer protection requirements on retail consignment sales, mandating clear pre-contractual information on goods, pricing, and withdrawal rights, treating the consignee as a trader liable for conformity even if title remains with the consignor.^[57] Under common law systems like the U.S. and UK, title explicitly remains with the consignor until sale to a third party, perfected via UCC filing to protect against consignee creditors, emphasizing intent and delivery without ownership transfer.^[58] In civil law jurisdictions, such as France or Germany, title transfer is similarly retained by the consignor but governed by codified principles under the Civil Code, where delivery (tradition) does not imply ownership shift without explicit agreement, differing from common law's reliance on contractual intent over formal acts.^[59] Dispute resolution in consignment contracts often includes arbitration clauses to resolve conflicts efficiently, specifying binding arbitration under rules like those of the American Arbitration Association for U.S. agreements.^[60] Such clauses are common to avoid costly litigation, with provisions for venue in the consignor's jurisdiction.^[53] Notable cases from the 2010s art market illustrate consignment fraud litigation, such as the 2010 Salander O'Reilly Galleries scandal, where owner Lawrence Salander was convicted of grand larceny for misappropriating over $100 million in consigned artworks, leading to court rulings exposing consignors to creditor claims absent proper UCC perfection.^[61] In a recent New York federal case, a consignor sued a gallery for fraud under a net consignment agreement, alleging misrepresentation of sales proceeds, though the court dismissed claims for lack of specificity in alleging intent to defraud.^[62]

Tax Implications

In consignment arrangements, tax deferral is a key feature, allowing the consignor to recognize income only upon the actual sale of the goods by the consignee, rather than at the point of delivery. In the United States, the consignor recognizes income upon the sale of the goods by the consignee to a third party, as the consignee acts solely as an agent without ownership. The consignee does not report the consigned goods as inventory income. Similar deferral applies to value-added tax (VAT) and goods and services tax (GST) in other jurisdictions. In the European Union, under the VAT Directive (2006/112/EC, as amended), VAT on consignment stock is deferred until the goods are supplied to the final customer, with title transfer marking the taxable event; a simplification regime allows non-EU suppliers to avoid immediate intra-EU acquisition VAT by treating removals from stock as direct supplies. As of January 1, 2025, the EU abolished the €150 customs duty exemption for low-value imports, applying duties to consignment shipments previously exempt.^[63] In the United Kingdom, post-Brexit VAT rules mirror this approach, charging VAT at the time of sale rather than consignment, with the supply occurring when goods are removed from stock for the customer.^[64] Reporting obligations vary by role and jurisdiction but emphasize transparency in income flows. In the U.S., consignors must report net proceeds from sales as ordinary income on Schedule C (Form 1040), while consignees report commissions received as business income and may deduct related expenses; consignees are required to issue Form 1099-MISC (Box 7) to consignors for gross proceeds paid exceeding $600 annually, or Form 1099-NEC for non-employee compensation if applicable.^[65] Consignors, in turn, report these amounts but can deduct costs of goods sold. Internationally, cross-border consignments trigger withholding taxes, such as the U.S. 30% backup withholding on payments to non-resident aliens lacking a valid taxpayer identification number, applied to fixed, determinable, annual, or periodical (FDAP) income like sales proceeds; tax treaties, such as the U.S.-Canada Income Tax Convention, often reduce this rate to 0-15% for business profits or exempt them absent a permanent establishment, mitigating double taxation.^[66] Recent post-2020 developments have heightened scrutiny on digital consignment platforms. The OECD's 2019 report on digital platforms' role in VAT/GST collection recommends that platforms withhold and remit taxes on online sales, directly impacting e-consignment by treating facilitators as deemed suppliers for low-value transactions.^[67] In the EU, the 2021 VAT e-commerce reforms abolished the €22 de minimis exemption for imports, mandating VAT on all consignments via the Import One-Stop Shop (IOSS) for goods up to €150, with platforms liable for collection on cross-border online sales, including digital consignment models. These changes aim to curb VAT losses estimated at €5-7 billion annually from non-compliance in low-value e-commerce.

Financial and Accounting Treatment

Accounting Standards and Revenue Recognition

Under U.S. Generally Accepted Accounting Principles (GAAP), Accounting Standards Codification (ASC) Topic 606, Revenue from Contracts with Customers, which became effective for public entities in 2018, provides the framework for recognizing revenue in consignment arrangements.^[68] This standard requires entities to determine whether they act as a principal or an agent in the transaction, with the consignor typically classified as the principal who controls the goods before transfer to the end customer, while the consignee acts as an agent facilitating the sale.^[69] The International Financial Reporting Standard (IFRS) 15, Revenue from Contracts with Customers, issued by the International Accounting Standards Board and effective from 2018, aligns closely with ASC 606 and applies the same core principle for consignment scenarios globally.^[70] Revenue recognition in consignment arrangements occurs only when control of the goods transfers to the customer, as outlined in ASC 606-10-55-80, which identifies indicators such as the consignor's retention of control until a specified event (e.g., sale by the consignee) or the ability to require return of unsold goods.^[71] For the consignor, consigned goods remain as inventory on the balance sheet until sold, reflecting ongoing control, rather than being treated as a completed sale upon shipment to the consignee.^[72] Similarly, under IFRS 15, revenue is deferred until the consignor transfers control, ensuring that financial statements accurately depict economic substance over legal form.^[73] For the consignor, initial shipment of goods to the consignee is recorded by debiting "Consignment Inventory" (an asset account) and crediting "Inventory" for the cost of goods transferred, maintaining the items on the balance sheet without recognizing revenue.^[72] Upon notification of sale by the consignee, the consignor records the transaction as: debit "Accounts Receivable" for the full sale proceeds due from the consignee, credit "Sales Revenue" for the gross amount, debit "Cost of Goods Sold" for the cost, and credit "Consignment Inventory" for the cost; separately, the commission payable to the consignee is recorded as debit "Commission Expense" and credit "Accounts Payable."^[74] From the consignee's perspective, acting as an agent, no inventory is recorded on their balance sheet; instead, upon sale, they debit "Cash" for the customer payment, credit "Accounts Payable" to the consignor for the net amount (sale price minus commission), and recognize their commission as debit "Accounts Receivable" from consignor (if not immediate) and credit "Commission Revenue."^[72] The consignor's gross profit on a consignment sale is calculated as the net proceeds received minus the cost of the goods sold, where net proceeds equal the sale price less the commission paid to the consignee.^[74] This is derived step-by-step as follows: (1) determine the sale price (P) at which the consignee sells the goods to the end customer; (2) subtract the commission (C), typically a percentage of P (e.g., C = r × P, where r is the commission rate), to obtain net proceeds (NP = P - C); (3) subtract the consignor's original cost of the goods (COGS) from NP to yield gross profit (GP = NP - COGS = (P - C) - COGS). This adjustment ensures that only the consignor's economic benefit is recognized, aligning with ASC 606's emphasis on control transfer and principal status.^[75]

Risk Management and Liabilities

In consignment arrangements, the consignor faces significant risk from loss or damage to goods while they are in the consignee's possession, as title remains with the consignor until sale, making them potentially liable for such incidents unless contractually shifted.^[29] Contracts often allocate this liability by requiring the consignee to maintain insurance coverage for storage, handling, and transit risks, such as comprehensive property insurance or specific consignment policies, to protect against theft, negligence, or accidents.^[76] For instance, in cases of proven consignee negligence, legal recourse may include claims under tort law or breach of contract, but proving fault requires detailed documentation of the goods' condition upon delivery and return.^[77] Non-payment by the consignee represents another core risk, particularly if goods remain unsold or the consignee becomes insolvent, leaving the consignor without revenue while bearing ongoing holding costs.^[78] To mitigate this, consignors must file Uniform Commercial Code (UCC) financing statements to perfect their security interest in the goods, ensuring priority over other creditors in bankruptcy proceedings and preventing the consignee from treating inventory as its own assets.^[77] Market depreciation during the holding period exacerbates this issue, as unsold goods may lose value due to obsolescence, fashion shifts, or economic changes, with the consignor absorbing the devaluation upon repurchase or disposal.^[79] Effective risk management begins with thorough due diligence on potential consignees, including credit checks, financial audits, and references to assess solvency and operational reliability before entering agreements.^[78] Diversification across multiple consignees reduces exposure to any single entity's failure, spreading inventory and payment risks geographically or by sector.^[80] In international consignment, currency fluctuations add volatility to expected proceeds; mitigation involves hedging strategies like forward contracts to lock in exchange rates, protecting against adverse movements that could erode profits.^[81] Clear contractual terms on payment timelines, minimum sales guarantees, and return conditions further limit liabilities by enforcing accountability.^[82] The 2020s supply chain disruptions, particularly during the COVID-19 pandemic, highlighted these risks through widespread retail closures that led to consignment defaults and insolvencies. For example, numerous consignment shops, such as Leah's Lucky Finds in Pennsylvania and the VNACJ Thrift & Consignment Shop in New Jersey, permanently closed in 2020 due to lockdown mandates and revenue drops, stranding consignors' goods and delaying or preventing payments.^[83]^[84] In the diamond trade, pandemic shutdowns prompted wholesalers to reevaluate consignment practices, with many facing extended holding periods and heightened insolvency risks among retailers, underscoring the need for robust insurance and UCC protections.^[85]

Operational Procedures

Standard Procedures

The standard operational process for consignment begins with the initiation phase, where the consignor and consignee negotiate and sign a formal consignment agreement specifying key terms such as inventory quantities, pricing structures, commission rates, and duration of the arrangement.^[86] Following agreement, the consignor ships or transfers the goods to the consignee's location, accompanied by essential documentation like a consignment note, which details the shipment's contents, quantities, descriptions, and handling instructions to serve as proof of transfer and facilitate inventory control.^[87] Upon receipt, the consignee conducts quality inspections to verify the condition and accuracy of the delivered items before integrating them into their inventory.^[31] During ongoing management, the consignee maintains detailed inventory tracking to monitor stock levels, sales, and replenishment needs, often using dedicated software to ensure real-time visibility for both parties.^[28] Periodic reporting, such as monthly sales updates, is provided by the consignee to the consignor, including details on items sold, remaining stock, and any required adjustments to pricing or promotions to optimize sales performance.^[13] This phase emphasizes regular communication between the consignor and consignee to address stock discrepancies or market changes promptly.^[86] The process concludes with the sale notification, where the consignee informs the consignor of completed transactions, followed by payment remittance for sold goods, calculated net of the agreed commission (typically 20-60% depending on the agreement).^[13] Unsold goods are then returned to the consignor or disposed of according to the contract terms, often after a predefined period like 30-90 days, with documentation ensuring accurate reconciliation of inventory.^[28] Effective implementation relies on tools such as consignment inventory management software for automated tracking, reporting, and alerts, which streamline operations and reduce errors in multi-location setups.^[86]^[88] Best practices include conducting thorough quality inspections at receipt to prevent disputes and integrating consignment tracking with broader inventory systems for seamless oversight.^[31]

Advantages and Challenges

Consignment arrangements offer several advantages to both consignors and consignees in inventory and supply chain management. For consignees, such as retailers, the model minimizes financial risk by eliminating upfront inventory purchase costs, allowing them to stock products without tying up capital in unsold goods. This can lead to significant cost savings through deferred payments and reduced obsolescence risks. For consignors, like manufacturers or suppliers, consignment enables market testing of new products with lower entry barriers, as they retain ownership until sale, facilitating broader distribution without immediate revenue loss. Additionally, it expands market reach by leveraging the consignee's established customer base and sales channels. Despite these benefits, consignment presents notable challenges that can impact operational efficiency and profitability. Consignors often face delayed cash flow, as payments are received only upon sale, which can strain working capital and complicate financial forecasting; this delay is particularly acute for cash-constrained suppliers. Unsold inventory returns pose another issue, requiring consignors to manage storage, potential depreciation, or disposal costs, which can erode margins if products remain unsold for extended periods. Consignees, meanwhile, must handle increased operational demands, such as detailed tracking and reporting of consigned goods, leading to dependency on the consignee's sales performance and inventory management capabilities. In comparative terms, consignment contrasts with outright sales, where consignors receive faster payments but bear higher upfront risk from non-recoverable inventory commitments, making consignment preferable for volatile markets. Compared to dropshipping, consignment provides greater control over product quality and branding since physical inventory is held by the consignee, though it involves more logistical coordination than dropshipping's hands-off approach. Strategically, consignment is most viable for high-value or seasonal goods, such as luxury apparel or holiday merchandise, where demand uncertainty is high and testing reduces overstock risks.

References

[1]
consignment | Wex | US Law | LII / Legal Information Institute
Consignment is a type of contract in which the consignor delivers the goods to the consignee for sale. The consignee takes care of the goods and sells them.Missing: reliable sources
[2]
Consignment Explained: How It Works and Its Benefits - Investopedia
Aug 22, 2025 · Consignment is an arrangement in which goods are left in the possession of an authorized third party to sell.What Is Consignment? · How Consignment Works · Consignment Payment...Missing: reliable | Show results with:reliable
[3]
Retail, Wholesale, and Consignment Sales - Nolo
A consignment occurs when you provide work to a reseller (the "consignee"), who agrees to pay you proceeds from the sales minus a commission. If your product ...Different Sales Methods Mean... · Wholesale Marketing · Consignment SalesMissing: reliable | Show results with:reliable<|control11|><|separator|>
[4]
Consignment - Practical Law - Thomson Reuters
Consignment is a commercial relationship where goods are transferred to another for sale. The consignor receives payment when the consignee sells or uses the ...
[5]
Consignment Agreement Terms and Best Practices - UpCounsel
Rating 5.0 (4,486) May 13, 2025 · Consignment agreements specify the rate of commission, sales deadline, and the consequences in the event that a sale doesn't occur. For example, ...
[6]
https://library.oapen.org/bitstream/handle/20.500.12657/61936/external_content.pdf?sequence=1&isAllowed=y
[7]
[PDF] Roman Law and Maritime Commerce
is the Roman History which helps to understand Civil Law, the Ecclesiastical History ... consignment of goods shipped by several merchants, most likely '38 ...
[8]
[PDF] Enforcing cooperation among medieval merchants: The Maghribi ...
Feb 24, 2007 · agents who cheat will not be fired, so all agents will cheat and no agent will ever be hired. Merchant-agent trade relations cannot be sustained ...<|separator|>
[9]
Itinerant Cotton Merchants of the Antebellum South - jstor
THE ANTEBELLUM SOUTH. The factorage system dominated the antebellum cotton trade. Most pl marketed their cotton by consigning it to factors in the larger ...
[10]
[PDF] Untangling the Web of Consignment Law - Scholarship Repository
This Article examines and analyzes the law of consignments from the common law through Revised Article 9 with a goal towards identifying and analyzing the ...
[11]
History of Containerization
History of Containerization. In 1956, an entrepreneurial trucker named Malcolm McLean, seeking a cost effective alternative to move cargo between New Jersey and ...
[12]
The Hague Rules – 100 years old and still standing | Gard's Insights
Sep 2, 2024 · With the advent of container shipping, the Hague Rules were slightly revised by the Hague-Visby Rules in 1968. The relatively low package ...
[13]
History of Thrift Stores | TIME
Aug 17, 2018 · Consignment shops catering to a high-end clientele started to emerge in the 1950s, and wealthier consumers started coveting “vintage” clothes.
[14]
The Ins and Outs of Selling on Consignment - inFlow Inventory
Jan 21, 2025 · Consignment inventory can be a cost-effective way for retailers to stock their stores. And it allows suppliers to gain exposure without spending extra money.
[15]
Consignment Definition: What It Is, How It Works, and Examples
Sep 29, 2024 · What's the typical split? ... Most consignment shops take between 40% to 60% of the sale price. Keep in mind that every shop sets its own terms.
[16]
Clothing Resale Options - National - Consumers' Checkbook
Consignment stores generally offer items for sale for three months or so, sometimes marking them down over the course of time. If something doesn't sell, it's ...In-Person Options · Old Clothes, New Wardrobe... · For Online Sales, Styling...
[17]
https://www.linnworks.com/blog/how-to-start-a-consignment-shop/
[18]
How to start a consignment shop: step-by-step guide for 2025
The most popular items sold in clothing consignment shops are designer labels and vintage pieces. Examples include Buffalo Exchange and Beacon's Closet.
[19]
How To Sell - Buffalo Exchange
No need to wait for an item to sell! On the day you sell, you'll walk away with 25% of our selling price in cash or 50% in store credit for anything we're able ...Locations · The Five C’s of Cleaning Your... · Blog · Giving Back
[20]
[PDF] 2023 Resale Report - ThredUp
clothing sector in 2022. 5x. Resale grew. $39B. U.S. Secondhand Market Expected To Reach. $70 Billion by 2027. The U.S. secondhand market maintains a strong ...
[21]
Consignment | BETA - International Trade Administration
Consignment in international trade is a variation of the open-account method of paymentin which payment is sent to the exporter only after the goods have been ...
[22]
Chapter 7-Consignment - Export-U.com
An international consignment transaction is based on a contractual arrangement in which the foreign distributor receives, manages, and sells the goods for the ...
[23]
Produce Inventory Management for Consignments - Stokes Law Office
May 7, 2012 · The major part of produce shipped to the United States from Latin America is shipped on consignment. The US importer receives the produce, ...
[24]
Bill of Lading | BETA - International Trade Administration
The customer usually needs an original bill of lading as proof of ownership to take possession of the goods. Bill of lading instructions.
[25]
Methods of Payment - International Trade Administration
Clearly, exporting on consignment is very risky as the exporter is not guaranteed any payment and its goods are in a foreign country in the hands of an ...
[26]
The VAT regime for consignment stock arrangements – Simplification?
Sep 1, 2022 · The VAT Directive has introduced a VAT simplification scheme for companies that store part of their stock abroad.
[27]
Vendor Managed Inventory vs Consignment & its Affects on Supply ...
Dec 12, 2024 · Vendor Managed Inventory or VMI and Consignment Inventory (CI) models are two distinct strategies designed to improve supply chain operations.Vendor-Managed Inventory... · Benefits Of Vmi · Hybrid Model: Ci&vmi
[28]
(PDF) How inventory consignment programs can improve supply ...
Inventory Consignment (IC) has largely been viewed as a method of shifting the ownership and cost burden of inventory from buyer to supplier to benefit the ...
[29]
What is Consignment Inventory? [Best Practices & FAQs]
Mar 14, 2024 · An automotive manufacturer places a consignment inventory of robotic arm components at their client's factory. This arrangement ensures that ...
[30]
Selling products on consignment - Info entrepreneurs
Selling goods on consignment is described as a situation whereby goods are shipped to a dealer who pays you, the consignor, only for the merchandise which sells ...Missing: reliable | Show results with:reliable
[31]
RFID for Consignment Inventory Management - Terso Solutions
Optimize consignment inventory with RFID inventory management and automatically identify when inventory needs to be replenished.Missing: techniques periodic
[32]
Consignment Inventory Best Practices | A Comprehensive Guide
Sep 8, 2025 · Consignment inventory management best practices automate & track inventory, which benefits both wholesalers and retailers.Missing: RFID periodic commingling
[33]
Consignment Store KPI's: 8 Essential Metrics and How to Get Them
Mar 14, 2025 · Formula: Inventory Turnover Rate = Cost of Goods Sold / Average Inventory Value ... sales to move inventory quickly. When to Track. Weekly ...
[34]
Implementing NetSuite Consignment Inventory Flows Using Transfer ...
Sep 14, 2025 · Learn how to implement consignment inventory flows in NetSuite using transfer pricing and location-based modeling to track obligations ...
[35]
Poshmark Vs Thred Up: Which Consignment Shop Is Better?
May 11, 2023 · ThredUp is an only consignment that takes all the extra work out of selling your gentle worn clothes. You can order a clean kit or opted to ...
[36]
Which Is the Better Resale App: Poshmark vs. Depop | Lifehacker
Aug 12, 2025 · Depop only takes 10% of whatever the sale and shipping cost are combined while Poshmark takes 20% of the sale price or, if you sell something ...
[37]
Depop vs. eBay for Sellers: Which Marketplace is Better? - Reeva Blog
Aug 4, 2025 · Depop only charges fees when an item is sold successfully. The platform takes a flat 10% fee for every successful transaction made through the ...Depop Vs. Ebay: Key... · Selling Fees: A Breakdown Of... · Is Depop Better Than Ebay...
[38]
https://opensea.io/learn/nft/how-to-sell-nfts
[39]
How to Sell an NFT: Step-by-Step Guide - OpenSea
Oct 7, 2022 · To sell an NFT using OpenSea you'll need a few things: an OpenSea account, a crypto wallet, and something really awesome to sell.How Do Nfts Work? · Step 1: Choose A Method For... · Step 2: List Your Nft For...
[40]
How do I sell an NFT? - OpenSea Help Center
You can sell your item using OpenSea from three places: from your profile, from the item page, or from the item's collection page.
[41]
OpenSea Business Model and Revenue Sources Explained - SoluLab
Sep 8, 2023 · OpenSea employs a business model rooted in facilitating transactions and fostering the growth of the NFT ecosystem.
[42]
ThredUp: Pandemic Will Turbocharge a 'Shift to Thrift'
Jun 23, 2020 · Online fashion resale platform ThredUp released its 2020 Resale Report showing the resale market will grow by 27 percent in 2020 alone.Missing: surge consignment
[43]
The 'Post-Pandemic Consumer' Is Embracing Secondhand Clothes
Jun 22, 2021 · Online Resale Appears to Be Pandemic-Proof. Thredup believes the Covid-19 crisis has accelerated the consumer shift towards secondhand e- ...
[44]
ThredUp: The apparel resale industry grew 18% in 2023
Mar 27, 2024 · The apparel resale market continued to grow in 2023, accounting for $197 billion in sales globally, according to ThredUp's 2024 Resale Report.
[45]
ThredUp Launches Suite of AI Shopping Features
Aug 5, 2024 · A new suite of AI-powered shopping tools designed to revolutionize the way customers discover unique fashion finds.
[46]
Poshmark turns to generative AI to help sellers list more | Retail Dive
Feb 4, 2025 · Poshmark is adding the Smart List tool with generative AI to its suite of seller tools to help merchants create high-quality listings.Missing: consignment matching
[47]
Fraud Prevention - Escrow.com
The most effective way to protect yourself against scams and fraudulent activity is to use Escrow.com. We are a licensed and registered escrow service.Internet Escrow Scams · Overview Of Internet Escrow... · Other Signs To Watch Out For
[48]
Escrow in eCommerce: Your Shield Against Online Fraud
May 13, 2025 · Discover how escrow services protect eCommerce transactions from fraud and build trust between buyers and sellers. Learn how Castler secures ...
[49]
Consignment, wholesale and dropshipping - which one is right for ...
Dropshipping is simply a site or store selling your product to customers, and having you ship the order directly to the customer when it is ordered. Pros: You ...
[50]
The Difference Between 3PL, Drop Shipping & Consignment
In this white paper, we focus on the three business models – 3PL, dropshipping and consignment inventory – that can benefit your business with growth ambitions.
[51]
§ 9-102. DEFINITIONS AND INDEX OF DEFINITIONS. | US Law
(19) " Consignee " means a merchant to which goods are delivered in a consignment . (20) " Consignment " means a transaction, regardless of its form, in which a ...
[52]
[PDF] United Nations Convention on Contracts for the International Sale of ...
Apr 11, 1980 · Contracts of sale are distinguished from contracts for services in two respects by article 3. A contract for the supply of goods to be ...
[53]
[PDF] consignment agreement factors to consider - Ferris State University
Apr 16, 2020 · An essential element of a consignment agreement is that one party (Consignor) retains ownership of the personal property, but places the ...
[54]
Consignment Agreement: Definition, Key Terms, Considerations
In contract law, consignment agreements contain language indicating that the retailer agrees to display the provided consigned items for a specific time period ...
[55]
Consignment Agreement: The Essential Elements You Should Know
A well-structured consignment agreement should include the type of goods being sold, pricing terms, and inventory control procedures.
[56]
Consignment Clause for Sale of Consigned Goods - Practical Law
It addresses crucial aspects of the consignment relationship, including the retention of title to the consigned goods, the allocation of risk of loss, and the ...
[57]
Consumer rights directive - European Commission
The Consumer Rights Directive gives consumers the same strong rights across the EU. It aligns and harmonises national consumer rules.About the directive · Evaluation of the Consumer...Missing: consignment | Show results with:consignment
[58]
Consignment: Overview | Practical Law - Westlaw
This Practice Note examines the distinctions between consignment and other commercial transactions, such as "sale or return" and "sale on approval" under ...
[59]
The Concept of Title Transfer in a Civil Law System - SSRN
Sep 5, 2016 · This article explains the concepts of legal capacity, legal norm and contract as grounds, which give rise to obligations, financial assets (the ...Missing: consignment | Show results with:consignment
[60]
What to Do When a Consignment Deal Goes Wrong
Oct 20, 2023 · Risk of loss or damage: The agreement should clearly define who bears the risk of loss or damage while the goods are in the consignee's ...
[61]
[PDF] Consignment Catastrophes: Lessons from New York's Art Gallery ...
Oct 1, 2014 · Megan Haslach, Consignment Catastrophes: Lessons from New York's Art Gallery Fraud, 10 WASH. ... YORK ARTS AND CULTURAL AFFAIRS LAW 2 (2010), ...Missing: market | Show results with:market
[62]
Court Dismisses Lawsuit Challenging Net Consignment Agreement
Sep 3, 2025 · Recently, a New York court dismissed a lawsuit filed by a consignor alleging that a gallery committed fraud in connection with a net sale ...
[63]
8.6 Consignment arrangements - PwC Viewpoint
8.6 Consignment arrangements ... The entity is able to require the return of the product or transfer the product to a third party (such as another dealer).
[64]
Changes to VAT treatment of overseas goods sold to customers from ...
Jan 1, 2021 · Consignments of goods not exceeding £135 in value, where the goods are outside the UK at the point of sale and the supply is to a UK VAT ...
[65]
Instructions for Forms 1099-MISC and 1099-NEC (04/2025) - IRS
Report on Form 1099-MISC or Form 1099-NEC only when payments are made in the course of your trade or business. Personal payments are not reportable. You are ...
[66]
Publication 515 (2025), Withholding of Tax on Nonresident Aliens ...
Beginning on or after August 16, 2024, withholding agents are required to withhold at the statutory 30% withholding tax rate on payments of US source income.
[67]
None
Nothing is retrieved...<|control11|><|separator|>
[68]
[PDF] Revenue from Contracts with Customers ASC 606 Updated
The arrangement is a consignment arrangement in accordance with ASC 606 because. • The product is controlled by the designer until a specified event (that is ...
[69]
Consignment Arrangements - RevenueHub
Apr 17, 2016 · In a consignment arrangement, revenue cannot be recognized until control of the product has transferred, which may be when a specified event ...
[70]
[PDF] ifrs-15-revenue-from-contracts-with-customers.pdf
IFRS 15 provides a comprehensive framework for recognising revenue from contracts with customers.
[71]
Consignment Inventory Accounting: Complete Guide to Treatment ...
Aug 7, 2025 · Unlike traditional inventory models, the consignee doesn't purchase the inventory upfront—they only pay the consignor after items sell.
[72]
[PDF] Revenue: IFRS 15 handbook 2025 - KPMG agentic corporate services
Jul 31, 2025 · This handbook provides a detailed analysis of the revenue standard, including insights and examples to help entities to navigate the revenue ...
[73]
Consignment Inventory Accounting Defined [+ Journal Entries]
May 19, 2023 · Consignment inventory is merchandise that's stored by a retailing business but owned by its supplier until the items have sold.The Consignment Partnership · Inventory Transfer To... · Consignee Accounts To The...
[74]
10.2 Principal versus agent framework - PwC Viewpoint
The principal versus agent assessment is a two-step process that consists of (1) identifying the specified good or service to be provided to the end consumer.
[75]
End-of-life consignment agreements: Key considerations
Liability and reputation, Whilst we would expect credible consignment companies to have reasonable product liability and hangar keepers liability insurance ...
[76]
Consignment Agreement Terms and Legal Protections - UpCounsel
Apr 3, 2025 · Failing to Document Ownership: If a consignee goes bankrupt and no formal agreement or UCC filing exists, the consignor could lose their goods.
[77]
Consignment Arrangements: Dos & Don'ts to Avoid Getting Hurt
Nov 25, 2020 · A consignment arrangement comes with risk if your consignee becomes insolvent or files for bankruptcy. Know the right steps to take as a ...
[78]
What is consignment revenue recognition? - Stripe
Nov 28, 2024 · This method of revenue recognition reflects sales only when they happen, not before, ensuring that financial records portray completed sales ...
[79]
Issues to Consider in a Consignment Agreement - LegalVision
Oct 14, 2022 · A consignment agreement is an arrangement where you, as a supplier (the consignor) provide your goods to another business (the consignee).Missing: core | Show results with:core<|control11|><|separator|>
[80]
Foreign Exchange Risk - International Trade Administration
One of the simplest ways to avoid the risks associated with fluctuations in exchange rates is to quote prices and require payment in US dollars.
[81]
What Is A Consignment Agreement? (2025 Updated) - Sprintlaw UK
Jan 10, 2025 · Consignment Agreements not only reduce liability but also delineate the responsibilities of both your business and its partners, minimising ...
[82]
Allentown jewelry store, Walnutport consignment shop close ...
May 7, 2020 · Leah's Lucky Finds, a Walnutport consignment shop offering a variety of women's fashions, has closed permanently due to COVID-19 mitigation efforts.
[83]
VNA thrift shop closes in Manasquan, in business for 60+ years
Jul 22, 2020 · A fixture for more than 60 years, the VNACJ Thrift & Consignment Shop has been forced to close because of the coronavirus pandemic.
[84]
Consignment and Covid-19 - Rapaport
Jun 30, 2020 · The Covid-19 shutdown and its consequences have caused many diamond wholesalers and jewelry retailers to reevaluate even the most basic ...
[85]
What Is Consignment Inventory and How Does It Work? - NetSuite
May 25, 2023 · With consignment inventory, the manufacturer, wholesaler or supplier retains ownership of the goods until the retailer sells them to customers.
[86]
Consignment Note Components, Functions, Types
Dec 24, 2023 · Consignment notes play a role in inventory control, helping both the consignor and consignee track the movement of goods and manage their stock.
[87]
Best Consignment Software 2025
Capterra directory of consignment software, highlighting specialized tools for resale and consignment operations with features like automated tracking, reporting, and multi-location support.