Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Constellation diagram

A constellation diagram is a two-dimensional graphical representation of a digitally modulated signal in the complex plane, where each possible symbol is depicted as a discrete point defined by its in-phase (I) and quadrature (Q) components, corresponding to the real and imaginary parts of the signal's complex envelope. These diagrams plot the amplitude and phase characteristics of modulation schemes such as phase-shift keying (PSK) and quadrature amplitude modulation (QAM), with the horizontal axis representing the I component and the vertical axis the Q component. In digital communications, constellation diagrams serve as a diagnostic tool to evaluate signal quality and system by comparing ideal locations against measured points, revealing impairments like , , errors, or through the clustering and spread of points. The distance between constellation points indicates the signal's resilience to errors, with closer points increasing susceptibility to bit errors, while metrics such as (EVM) quantify deviations from ideal positions in percentage or decibels, aiding in troubleshooting and optimization. Common examples include binary PSK (BPSK), which uses two antipodal points for 1 bit per symbol; quadrature PSK (QPSK), featuring four points at 90-degree intervals for 2 bits per symbol; and higher-order schemes like 16-QAM with 16 points in a square grid for 4 bits per symbol, or 64-QAM for 6 bits per symbol, balancing data rate against signal power requirements. These representations are generated by downconverting the carrier frequency to and sampling the I/Q components, enabling real-time visualization in oscilloscopes or vector signal analyzers.

Basics

Definition and Purpose

A constellation diagram is a two-dimensional in the that depicts the possible symbol states of a digitally modulated signal, where each point represents a unique combination of and . The horizontal axis corresponds to the in-phase (I) component, and the vertical axis to the (Q) component of the signal. The primary purpose of a constellation diagram is to visualize the signal's constellation points, enabling engineers to understand schemes, assess signal quality, and diagnose transmission issues such as or . It facilitates evaluation of bit-to-symbol mapping efficiency, where higher-order constellations, such as 64-QAM with 64 points, encode more bits per symbol to achieve greater data rates within limited . This visualization tool assumes familiarity with digital modulation principles but surpasses time-domain waveforms by clearly revealing both amplitude and phase characteristics, which are difficult to discern from instantaneous amplitude traces alone.

In-phase and Quadrature Components

In digital modulation schemes, the in-phase (I) component represents the real part of the complex signal, corresponding to the projection of the modulated onto the cosine at the . The quadrature (Q) component forms the imaginary part, aligned with the sine shifted by 90 degrees relative to the in-phase . Together, these components constitute the representation of the signal as s(t) = I(t) + j Q(t), where I(t) and Q(t) are the time-varying amplitudes. The modulated signal is expressed mathematically as
s(t) = I(t) \cos(\omega t) - Q(t) \sin(\omega t),
where \omega denotes the carrier . This formulation arises from the orthogonal nature of the cosine and sine carriers, allowing independent of and without between the I and Q channels.
To extract the I and Q components during demodulation, the received signal s(t) is multiplied by \cos(\omega t) to recover the in-phase part and by \sin(\omega t) to recover the quadrature part, followed by low-pass filtering to remove the high-frequency terms at $2\omega t. Specifically, the in-phase output is I(t) = \text{LPF} \left[ s(t) \cos(\omega t) \right], and the quadrature output is Q(t) = -\text{LPF} \left[ s(t) \sin(\omega t) \right], assuming perfect synchronization with the carrier. This process reconstructs the baseband I and Q signals for further processing, such as symbol detection. In constellation diagrams, the I component is plotted along the horizontal (x) , while the Q component is plotted along the vertical (y) , forming a two-dimensional . The radial distance of each point from the origin indicates the signal , and the angular position represents the ; units are often expressed in volts for analog representations or normalized to unit power for digital analysis. This I-Q plotting enables visualization of symbol positions, facilitating the interpretation of characteristics.

Generation

Mapping Bits to Symbols

In digital schemes, is grouped into sets of \log_2(M) bits to form symbols for an M-ary constellation, where each symbol corresponds to one of M possible discrete points in the . This mapping reduces the to R_b / \log_2(M), where R_b is the , thereby improving at the expense of increased susceptibility to noise due to denser constellations. For instance, in 16-QAM , groups of 4 bits map to one of 16 symbols. To minimize the impact of noise-induced symbol errors on the overall (BER), Gray coding is employed, ensuring that adjacent symbols in the constellation differ by only a single bit. This principle contrasts with natural binary coding, where adjacent symbols may differ in multiple bits, leading to higher BER for the same symbol error rate, as a single symbol misdetection can corrupt several bits. Gray coding is preferred in practical systems because it approximates the BER as roughly one-half the symbol error rate for high signal-to-noise ratios, optimizing performance in noisy channels. Symbol assignments vary by modulation type; in phase-shift keying (PSK), symbols are positioned at equal angular intervals on a , while in (QAM), they form a rectangular grid with varying amplitudes in both . For M-PSK, the symbol index k is determined by interpreting the \log_2(M) bit group as an integer from 0 to M-1, often using Gray coding to assign bits to indices. The position of the k-th symbol is then given by s_k = e^{j \cdot 2\pi k / M}, derived from the \phi_k = 2\pi k / M, which evenly spaces the points around the circle to maintain constant amplitude and exploit as the sole distinguishing feature. The following table illustrates Gray-coded bit-to-symbol mapping for 4-QAM (equivalent to ), where 2 bits map to four points at phases 45°, 135°, 225°, and 315° (shifted for standard alignment):
BitsPhase (degrees)Complex Symbol
0045\frac{1+j}{\sqrt{2}}
01135\frac{-1+j}{\sqrt{2}}
11225\frac{-1-j}{\sqrt{2}}
10315\frac{1-j}{\sqrt{2}}
For 8-PSK, 3 bits map to eight points at phases 0°, 45°, 90°, 135°, 180°, 225°, 270°, and 315°, using Gray coding as shown below:
Bits (degrees) Symbol
00001 + 0j
00145\frac{1+j}{\sqrt{2}}
011900 + 1j
010135\frac{-1+j}{\sqrt{2}}
110180-1 + 0j
111225\frac{-1-j}{\sqrt{2}}
1012700 - 1j
100315\frac{1-j}{\sqrt{2}}

Plotting in the Complex Plane

The plotting process for a constellation diagram begins with sampling the baseband signal to extract in-phase (I) and quadrature (Q) components at precise symbol times, followed by displaying these as scatter points in the complex plane where the x-axis represents the I values and the y-axis represents the Q values. To achieve accurate symbol alignment and higher resolution, the signal is typically oversampled, capturing multiple samples per symbol period to better isolate the symbol centers from inter-symbol interference. The coordinates of each point correspond to the real and imaginary parts of the k-th symbol, given by ( \operatorname{Re}[s_k], \operatorname{Im}[s_k] ), where s_k is the complex-valued symbol. Hardware tools such as digital oscilloscopes and vector signal analyzers from manufacturers like and enable real-time generation of constellation diagrams by processing I and Q channels, often requiring trigger setups synchronized to the symbol clock or data frame for stable alignment. In software environments, tools like MATLAB's Constellation Diagram block or GNU Radio's QT GUI Constellation Sink facilitate simulation and analysis by importing or generating I-Q data streams. Scaling and normalization are essential for consistent visualization; for (PSK) schemes, diagrams are typically normalized to a to reflect constant , while (QAM) constellations are scaled to average power or minimum distance to account for varying symbol energies. For received signals spanning multiple symbols, persistence modes in oscilloscopes overlay successive traces with decaying intensity to reveal point , or averaging can be applied to reduce while preserving constellation structure. Visualization parameters enhance interpretability, such as adjusting point density to reflect the accumulation of multiple captures, which highlights variations in received signals, and color-coding points by levels or status to differentiate ideal from deviated symbols.

Analysis and Interpretation

Ideal vs. Received Constellations

In an ideal constellation diagram, symbols are represented as discrete, sharp points precisely positioned in the complex plane without any overlap or spreading, reflecting the theoretical mapping of bits to symbols under perfect conditions. For quadrature phase-shift keying (QPSK), these points are typically located at coordinates corresponding to phases of 45°, 135°, 225°, and 315° on a unit circle, such as (\frac{\sqrt{2}}{2}, \frac{\sqrt{2}}{2}), (-\frac{\sqrt{2}}{2}, \frac{\sqrt{2}}{2}), (-\frac{\sqrt{2}}{2}, -\frac{\sqrt{2}}{2}), and (\frac{\sqrt{2}}{2}, -\frac{\sqrt{2}}{2}). The received constellation diagram, captured from actual transmitted signals, shows these points forming diffuse clusters or "clouds" centered around the ideal locations, arising from impairments like additive that perturb the in-phase and quadrature components. In practice, each ideal point expands into a probabilistic , with the cloud size proportional to the noise level, leading to potential symbol misinterpretation if clusters overlap decision boundaries. A side-by-side comparison highlights signal fidelity: for 16-quadrature (16-QAM), the ideal diagram displays 16 distinct points in a 4x4 square (e.g., at coordinates (±1, ±1), (±1, ±3), (±3, ±1), (±3, ±3), and their sign variants, scaled appropriately), while the received version exhibits scattered clouds around each, with greater spreading at lower signal quality. This deviation from the generated ideal points quantifies overall transmission integrity in real systems. Evaluating closeness to the ideal involves metrics like (EVM), which measures the RMS deviation of received points from ideal positions after , often integrated with eye diagrams to assess timing effects on cloud alignment. A key derived metric is the (SNR), approximated from the constellation's point spread as \mathrm{SNR} \approx \frac{ \left( \text{average distance to [decision boundary](/page/Decision_boundary)} \right)^2 }{ \text{variance} }, where variance captures the noise-induced spread in the clouds, and the distance reflects the constellation's geometry (e.g., half the minimum symbol separation). This estimation builds directly on the symbol plotting process by revealing practical distortions in received points.

Detecting Impairments

Constellation diagrams serve as a visual diagnostic tool for identifying various impairments in communication systems, where deviations from ideal point positions reveal underlying issues in the or . (AWGN), a common impairment, manifests as circular clouds of points clustered around each ideal symbol location, with the cloud radius proportional to the of the noise variance. This spreading increases the overlap between adjacent symbols, elevating the error probability; for quadrature phase-shift keying (QPSK), the (BER) is given by P_b = Q(\sqrt{2 \gamma_b}), where \gamma_b = E_b / N_0 is the per bit and Q(x) = \frac{1}{\sqrt{2\pi}} \int_x^\infty e^{-t^2/2} \, dt; at high SNR, this approximates to P_e \approx \frac{1}{2} \mathrm{erfc}\left( \sqrt{\frac{\mathrm{SNR}}{2}} \right), derived from the minimum distance between constellation points. Other distortions produce characteristic patterns that aid in pinpointing specific faults. Phase noise introduces random phase rotations, resulting in spiraling or swirling trajectories around constellation points, which can be mitigated through phase-locked loops or digital compensation algorithms. Amplitude imbalance causes elongation of symbol clusters along the in-phase (I) or (Q) axis, transforming square-like QPSK patterns into rectangles; correction involves equalization in the transmitter or . I-Q imbalance, arising from mismatches in the , tilts the constellation axes, often yielding or trapezoidal shapes instead of orthogonal grids, and can be addressed via adaptive calibration techniques that estimate and compensate for the and phase offsets. A key quantitative metric for assessing overall impairment is the (EVM), defined as the (RMS) of the error s between received symbols and their ideal positions on the constellation. It is computed as \mathrm{EVM} = \sqrt{ \frac{ \sum |e_k|^2 }{ \sum |s_k|^2 } }, where e_k is the deviation for the k-th symbol and s_k is the corresponding ideal symbol; lower EVM values indicate better signal fidelity, with typical thresholds below -20 for high-order modulations like 64-QAM. The spread or dispersion observed in constellation diagrams also correlates directly with BER, enabling predictions without exhaustive simulations. By measuring the variance of received symbols around ideal points, techniques like symbol-level replay can estimate error rates across modulation schemes; for instance, if dispersions keep symbols within decision boundaries for a given rate, the BER remains low, achieving over 95% accuracy in rate selection for wireless networks.

Applications

In Digital Modulation Schemes

Constellation diagrams are fundamental to visualizing (PSK) modulation schemes, where symbols are represented as points on a in the due to constant amplitude and varying . In binary PSK (BPSK), the diagram consists of two antipodal points on the real axis, corresponding to phase shifts of 0° and 180°, enabling transmission of 1 bit per symbol with high power efficiency in noisy environments. PSK (QPSK) expands this to four points equally spaced on the unit at phases of 45°, 135°, 225°, and 315°, allowing 2 bits per symbol while maintaining constant envelope, which is advantageous for nonlinear amplifiers. Higher-order variants like 8-PSK use eight points on the for 3 bits per symbol, but the reduced angular separation increases susceptibility to ; amplitude and (APSK), such as 16-APSK, introduces concentric rings to balance power and in satellite communications, with inner and outer rings hosting multiple phase states. Quadrature amplitude modulation (QAM) schemes employ rectangular or square grids in the I-Q plane, combining amplitude variations in both for higher data rates. For instance, 16-QAM arranges 16 points in a 4×4 grid, transmitting 4 bits per , while 256-QAM uses a 16×16 grid for 8 bits per , achieving greater at the cost of requiring higher signal-to-noise ratios (SNR) to distinguish closely spaced points. This trade-off is inherent: increasing constellation order enhances bandwidth (bits per second per Hertz) by packing more information per but reduces efficiency, as denser grids demand approximately 3-4 more SNR per additional bit for equivalent bit error rates (BER). Such schemes are prevalent in cable modems and wireless standards, where 256-QAM is common for high-throughput links. Frequency-shift keying (FSK) is less commonly depicted in standard I-Q constellation diagrams, as its symbols represent discrete frequency deviations rather than direct phase or amplitude changes; coherent FSK can be approximated in the as rotating phasors, forming circular traces rather than discrete points, though non-coherent variants are analyzed via frequency-domain plots. In (OFDM), used extensively in modern systems, each subcarrier operates independently with its own PSK or QAM constellation, allowing adaptive modulation across frequencies to optimize throughput. Constellation evolution reflects advancing standards: early systems favored low-order like 4-QAM (equivalent to QPSK), while New Radio supports up to 1024-QAM on downlink for peak spectral efficiencies exceeding 30 bits/s/Hz in low-mobility scenarios. Gray coding is applied across these schemes to minimize BER by ensuring adjacent constellation points differ by only one bit, reducing multibit errors from noise-induced misclassifications; in PSK, it sequences phases to flip a single bit between neighbors, while in rectangular QAM, it applies along rows and columns independently. Denser constellations, as in high-order QAM, imply higher efficiency by increasing bits per without proportionally expanding occupied bandwidth, though practical limits arise from peak-to-average power ratio increases and linearity requirements.

In Signal Analysis and Troubleshooting

In wireless communication systems such as and , constellation diagrams enable system-level analysis by visualizing across the entire transmission chain, allowing engineers to identify distortions like or multipath that affect overall performance. For instance, in cable networks using standards, these diagrams reveal impairments such as microreflections or group delay variations, where a tilted constellation indicates the need for adjustments to restore symbol alignment and improve downstream QAM signal quality. In satellite communications, constellation diagrams assess and propagation effects, helping to optimize settings for reliable data delivery in systems. Troubleshooting workflows typically begin with capturing the received constellation to align symbols against the ideal reference, followed by quantitative measurements of (EVM) and (SNR) to quantify impairments. Engineers then iterate fixes, such as recalibrating amplifiers or filters, and re-evaluate the diagram until EVM falls below standards thresholds, like -30 for signals. A common case study involves fixing I-Q imbalance in a transmitter: the constellation appears stretched along one axis due to gain mismatch between in-phase and paths, which is corrected by applying pre-distortion coefficients, restoring and reducing EVM by up to 10 as observed in tests. Advanced tools integrate constellation diagrams with spectrum analyzers for real-time visualization of frequency-domain issues alongside IQ-plane analysis, facilitating rapid impairment isolation in dynamic environments. When combined with bit error rate testers (BERT), they support end-to-end validation by correlating constellation scatter with pre-forward error correction (pre-FEC) BER, ensuring compliance with standards like DVB-S2, where constellations must maintain EVM below -18 dB for 16APSK modulation to meet broadcast requirements. In practice, high-order constellations (e.g., 256-QAM) become difficult to interpret at low SNR below 10 , as noise clusters points indistinguishably, limiting visual diagnostics to qualitative assessments rather than precise impairment localization. Additionally, AI-optimized modulations use to dynamically reshape constellations for adaptive SNR conditions, improving robustness in varying channels as demonstrated in neural network-based mapping schemes.

References

  1. [1]
    None
    Nothing is retrieved...<|control11|><|separator|>
  2. [2]
    [PDF] Understanding Constellation Diagrams and How They Are Used
    Constellation diagrams are an invaluable tool for evaluating a digital communication system's performance. These graphical representations of a digitally ...
  3. [3]
    [PDF] Modulation (7): Constellation Diagrams - Luiz DaSilva
    ❑ I/Q diagrams are particularly useful because they mirror the way most digital communications signals are created using an I/Q modulator. ❑ In the ...
  4. [4]
    [PDF] Software-Defined Radio for Engineers | Analog Devices
    Mar 26, 2018 · PSK presents an interesting set of trade-offs with PAM and QAM. In amplitude modulation schemes, channel equalization is an important part of.<|separator|>
  5. [5]
    [PDF] Vector Signal Analysis – 20 years on! Tim Masson – Agilent ... - Armms
    Dec 21, 1992 · From the late. 1970's High-end Spectrum Analyzers had been developed with digital control, digital displays, marker functions with state and ...
  6. [6]
    Constellation Diagram - an overview | ScienceDirect Topics
    The signal constellation diagram is very useful for providing both amplitude and phase information on signal and noise.Digital Modulation · Information Coding... · 13.2.2.3 Coded Modulation...
  7. [7]
    Understanding I/Q Signals and Quadrature Modulation
    I/Q signaling refers to the use of two sinusoids that have the same frequency and a relative phase shift of 90°. Amplitude, phase, and frequency modulation can ...
  8. [8]
    A Primer on Quadrature Amplitude Modulation (QAM)
    Sep 12, 2023 · We relate the constellation diagram to these time domain plots for QAM modulation, as well as introduce the constellation diagram for 16-QAM.
  9. [9]
    [PDF] Revision of Lecture 3
    • One bit per symbol, note the mapping from bits to symbols in constellation diagram, ... • Gray coding: adjacent constellation points only differ in a single bit ...
  10. [10]
    Symbol Mapping Examples - MATLAB & Simulink - MathWorks
    For the PSK, DPSK, FSK, QAM, and PAM modulation types, Gray constellations are obtained by setting the symbol mapping to Gray-encoding in the corresponding ...
  11. [11]
    Gray Mapping - an overview | ScienceDirect Topics
    Here, groups of coded bits are mapped to points of the signal constellation in a way that enhances the distance properties of the code.
  12. [12]
    Mapping Bits to a Constellation - TomRoelandts.com
    May 6, 2019 · An obvious way to do the mapping is to simply put the sequence 00,01,10,11 in the constellation, either clockwise or counterclockwise.
  13. [13]
    pskmod - Modulate signal using M-PSK method - MATLAB
    When the input is configured for bits, groups of log2(M) bits represent the complex symbols for the configured symbol mapping. The mapping can be binary encoded ...Missing: equation | Show results with:equation
  14. [14]
    Constellation Diagram - Display and analyze input signals in IQ-plane
    The Constellation Diagram block displays real- and complex-valued floating- and fixed-point signals in the IQ plane. Use this block to perform qualitative ...
  15. [15]
    Plotting Constellation Diagrams - Signal Processing Stack Exchange
    Apr 3, 2023 · The constellation plot is made from the baseband, matched-filtered samples. If you have a passband signal, you'll have to downcovert it and filter it -- no way ...How to do QAM modulation and plot the constellation diagram for a ...How exactly do I plot a constellation diagram?More results from dsp.stackexchange.comMissing: plane | Show results with:plane
  16. [16]
    Scatter Plots and Constellation Diagrams - MATLAB & Simulink
    A scatter plot or constellation diagram can be useful when comparing system performance and the effects of channel and RF impairments.
  17. [17]
    Normalize IQ Traces (Digital Demod) - Keysight
    For these "cross-QAM" constellations, the VSA normalizes the constellation diagram to the corner state of an ideal, square constellation diagram. In other words ...
  18. [18]
    How to use Rohde & Schwarz Instruments in MATLAB
    This application note outlines two different approaches for remote-controlling Rohde & Schwarz instruments out of MathWorks MATLAB.Missing: plotting constellation diagrams Keysight GNU
  19. [19]
    Digital oscilloscope persistence modes - Pico Technology
    Sep 17, 2024 · Persistence mode superimposes multiple waveforms on the same view, with more frequent data or newer waveforms emphasised with deeper saturation or hotter ...
  20. [20]
    [PDF] Using Constellation Diagrams to Test Wireless Devices
    Aug 16, 2012 · This method uses two amplitude modulated signals, combined into a single channel at the same carrier frequency to increase the symbol ...
  21. [21]
    comm.ConstellationDiagram - Display and analyze input signals in ...
    Description · Input and plot multiple signals on a single constellation diagram. · Select signals in the legend to toggle visibility of individual channels.
  22. [22]
    (PDF) Modulator Performance Measurement in Wireless Sensor ...
    Abstract and Figures · 1. The 2.4 GHz physical layer model · 2. Model of the 868/915 MHz physical layer · 3. Ideal constellation diagram with a transmitted value X.<|separator|>
  23. [23]
    Received QPSK constellation. (a) In an ideal receiver. (b) In a real...
    Download scientific diagram | Received QPSK constellation. (a) In an ideal receiver. (b) In a real receiver. from publication: Signal constellation ...
  24. [24]
    Signal constellation in the complex plane of 16-QAM digital...
    Signal constellation in the complex plane of 16-QAM digital communications: (a) The idea constellation; (b) The received constellation that is affected by noise ...
  25. [25]
    (PDF) EVM calculation for broadband modulated signals
    Graphs of (a) measured symbols, (b) the ideal constellation diagram, and (c) a normalized space that facilitates calculation of EVM. Normalized Constellation.
  26. [26]
    Ideal constellation diagram and actual received signal sequence...
    Ideal constellation diagram and actual received signal sequence description for 16QAM. (a) Ideal constellation diagram; (b) Actual received signal Sequence ...
  27. [27]
    [PDF] Study of Timing Synchronization in MIMO- OFDM Systems Using ...
    The ideal constellation diagram of a 4-QAM signal is also shown in Figure 7. The study was carried out by considering one distribution models namely, AWGN. In ...
  28. [28]
    [PDF] BER calculation
    Figure 1: QPSK constellation. The symbol probability of error (SER) is the probability of either branch has a bit error: Ps = 1 − [1 − Q p. 2γb. ]2. (7). Since ...
  29. [29]
    [PDF] The Effect of Phase and Amplitude Imbalance ... - IPN Progress Report
    Nov 15, 1998 · amplitude and phase imbalances can cause distortion in the signal constellation and introduce undesired interfering tone signal components ...
  30. [30]
    [PDF] Joint Compensation of IQ Imbalance and Phase Noise in OFDM ...
    In this paper, the joint effects of IQ imbalance and phase noise on OFDM systems are analyzed, and a compensation scheme is proposed to improve the system.
  31. [31]
    How Error Vector Magnitude (EVM) Measurement Improves Your ...
    Apr 1, 2021 · In general, EVM is calculated by finding the ideal constellation location for each received symbol, as shown in Figure 1b. The root means square ...
  32. [32]
    [PDF] AccuRate: Constellation Based Rate Estimation in Wireless Networks
    The. BER is an average of SoftPHY confidence values, com- puted from the dispersion of the received symbols from their nearest constellation symbols. SoftRate ...
  33. [33]
    [PDF] “Find & Fix” Guide Using DSAM - VIAVI Solutions
    − IQ Imbalance: The constellation is taller than it is wide, which is a difference between the gain of the I and Q channels. IQ imbalance is caused by baseband ...
  34. [34]
    Digital Video Broadcasting (DVB) Satellite Communication Analysis
    The following figure shows the functional block diagram of a DVB-S2 system (taken from the ETSI standard). Understanding DVB-S2 / S2X signal quality. Thanks ...
  35. [35]
    [PDF] ©Rohde & Schwarz; Understanding EVM
    When examining or describing PSK modulated signals, the states are usually represented in the form of constellation diagrams. A constellation diagram is a ...
  36. [36]
    [PDF] IQ Balancing Techniques for Broadband Receivers fred harris ...
    Figure 4 shows a 16-QAM constellation with 0.1 gain and. 0.1 radian imbalance and then the result of correcting the imbalance with an algorithm following the ...
  37. [37]
    Optimization of high-order non-uniform QAM constellations
    Non-uniform QAM constellations, up to 1024k-QAM, are proposed to approach the Shannon limit, with quadrant symmetric constellations optimized for low SNR.
  38. [38]
    [PDF] Quantum Communication 101 - NASA
    Finally, by utilizing constellations of satellites and quantum repeaters, global connectivity becomes achievable. The culmination of this development, and ...
  39. [39]
    Self-learning Constellation Mapping Method Based on Neural ...
    This paper applies the neural networks to the transmitter, which proposes a self-learning constellation mapping method.Missing: optimized | Show results with:optimized