Double play
In baseball, a double play is a defensive play in which two offensive players are put out as a result of continuous action, provided no error occurs between the putouts.[1] This efficient maneuver, often called a pitcher's best friend due to its ability to quickly retire two batters and limit scoring opportunities, typically arises with runners on base and fewer than two outs already recorded.[2] Double plays most commonly occur on ground balls hit with a runner on first base, enabling force outs at second and then first, though they can also result from fly balls, line drives, or tag plays in various situations.[3] Under Major League Baseball rules, the play must involve uninterrupted defensive action, and violations of the slide rule—such as a runner failing to execute a bona fide slide at second base to break up the play—can result in both the runner and batter-runner being declared out.[1] There are numerous types of double plays, denoted by numerical sequences indicating the fielders involved (e.g., 6 for shortstop, 4 for second baseman, 3 for first baseman), with 17 routine variations recognized in professional play.[4] The most frequent is the 6-4-3 double play[3], where the shortstop fields the ball, throws to the second baseman for the force out at second, and the second baseman relays to the first baseman for the out at first; other forms include the 4-6-3 (second baseman to shortstop to first) and rare plays like the 1-2-3 (pitcher to catcher to first).[4][3] Scoring credits putouts and assists to the participating fielders, and runs scored prior to the second out generally count unless the final out is a force or appeal play.[1]Fundamentals
Definition
In baseball, a double play is a defensive play in which two offensive players are put out during the same continuous action, without an intervening error by the defense.[2] This typically involves the batter hitting a ground ball to an infielder, who then throws to another fielder to record the first out before relaying the ball to complete the second out.[1] Double plays are most commonly executed with a runner on first base and fewer than two outs already recorded, forcing the runner to advance and allowing the defense to retire both the runner and the batter-runner efficiently.[2] The basic mechanics of a double play retire two baserunners in one sequence, often the batter and a baserunner, effectively advancing the defensive team toward the three outs required to end an inning with a single play.[1] This contrasts with standard single outs, where only one player is retired per action, and underscores the efficiency of the play in controlling the game's pace. In terms of baserunning rules, a double play relies on force situations, where a runner must vacate their base upon the batter becoming a runner, enabling the defense to tag the base for an out; the force is removed once the first out is made, shifting subsequent outs to tags of runners off the base.[1] Double plays serve as a critical defensive tool to escape base-running jams, quickly reducing threats from multiple runners on base and limiting scoring opportunities for the offense.[2] They are particularly valuable for ground-ball-inducing pitchers and infield units skilled in quick transfers, often referred to as a "pitcher's best friend" due to their dual impact on run prevention.[2] In Major League Baseball, teams average approximately 0.7 double plays per game (as of 2023), highlighting their frequency in gameplay.[5][6] To contextualize double plays within baseball's structure, an out occurs when a batter or runner is retired through means such as a strikeout, flyout, or tag, with each team's offensive half-inning ending after three such outs.[1] Baserunners advance counterclockwise around the bases on hits, walks, or errors, but must adhere to rules like not passing preceding runners or retouching bases on caught flies, creating opportunities for defensive plays like the double.[1]Types of Double Plays
In baseball, double plays are categorized using a numbering system that identifies the sequence of fielders involved, based on standard defensive positions: 1 for pitcher, 2 for catcher, 3 for first baseman, 4 for second baseman, 5 for third baseman, 6 for shortstop, 7 for left fielder, 8 for center fielder, and 9 for right fielder.[4] This system allows for precise notation of plays, such as a ground ball fielded by the shortstop (6) and relayed to second base (4) before a throw to first base (3), denoted as 6-4-3. The most common double plays occur on ground balls with runners on first and possibly second base, enabling force outs at multiple bases. The 6-4-3 double play, where the shortstop fields the ball and throws to the second baseman covering second for the force out before the relay to first, is the standard and most frequent infield combination, accounting for the majority of ground ball double plays due to the shortstop's central positioning and the typical trajectory of batted balls.[7] The 4-6-3 variation, involving the second baseman fielding and throwing to the shortstop at second before the throw to first, is the next most common, often occurring on balls hit more directly toward second base.[4] Other infield variations arise depending on runner positions and the location of the ground ball. The 5-4-3 double play, known as "around the horn," happens when the third baseman fields a ball—typically with runners on first and second—and throws to the second baseman at second for the force out, followed by a relay to first; it is employed when the ball is hit sharply to the left side, creating a shorter pivot for the infielders.[4] The 3-6-1 double play is less routine, occurring when the first baseman fields a grounder with a runner on first and throws to the shortstop covering second, then to the pitcher covering first base after the first baseman vacates the bag; this setup is used specifically when the pitcher must back up first to complete the play, though it carries a higher error risk due to the pitcher's involvement.[4] Rarer double plays include line drive double plays, such as a 6-4-3 where the shortstop catches a liner and quickly throws to second to double off the runner from first who left early, exploiting the immediate nature of the catch to limit baserunner awareness.[4] Outfield-assisted double plays, like the 8-6-3 (center fielder to shortstop to first), involve a fly ball caught in the outfield with a relay throw to catch a tagging runner, often seen with runners on first and third or in situations requiring long-distance precision.[8] Force plays at multiple bases can also produce unique sequences, such as a grounder forcing a runner at third before a secondary force at second, though these remain infrequent compared to standard infield grounders. These descriptions align with fielder positions in diagrams, where the diamond's layout emphasizes the shortstop's (6) and second baseman's (4) pivotal roles in routine turns.[4]History and Cultural Impact
Origins in Baseball
The double play, as a defensive maneuver resulting in two outs during continuous action, emerged in the mid-19th century amid baseball's evolving rules that permitted multiple force outs on a single play. Early codified rules, such as the Knickerbocker Rules of 1845, emphasized force plays at bases but did not explicitly define multi-out sequences; however, the term "double play" first appeared in print in 1858, reflecting its recognition in amateur games where runners could be retired en masse on grounders or flies. The first credited instance occurred in 1866, when shortstop George Wright of the Cincinnati Red Stockings executed a double play using the hidden-ball trick to deceive a runner, followed by tagging another who strayed from base. By the 1870s, during the National Association era (1871–1875), such plays became documented in professional contests, though barehanded fielding limited their frequency to roughly 0.6 per game league-wide in 1880.[9][10][11] Rule changes in the late 19th century enhanced double play opportunities by refining force play mechanics and addressing exploitative tactics. In 1895, the National League adopted the infield fly rule, declaring the batter out on a catchable fly ball with runners on first and second (or bases loaded) and fewer than two outs, to prevent infielders from intentionally dropping the ball for an easy double or triple play. This addressed a loophole in prior rules where such drops allowed force outs at multiple bases without a catch. The transition from barehanded play to padded gloves, which became standard by the 1890s, further enabled quicker transfers and pivots at second base, boosting execution speed. League-wide double play totals rose accordingly, reflecting improved defensive capabilities.[12][13] In the 1920s, clarifications to the Official Baseball Rules formalized the double play as "any two continuous put-outs... between the time the ball leaves the pitcher's hand and the time the next batter enters the batter's box," distinguishing it from interrupted action and aligning it with the era's emphasis on precise scoring. This coincided with the dead-ball period (roughly 1900–1919), where low-scoring "small ball" strategies—featuring bunts, steals, and ground-ball hitting—made double plays a cornerstone of infield defense, as teams prioritized manufacturing runs over power hitting. By the end of the 1910s, double plays averaged over 1.5 per game, underscoring their tactical importance before the live-ball era shifted focus to offense. Notably, the Chicago Cubs' infield trio of Joe Tinker, Johnny Evers, and Frank Chance exemplified this defensive prowess in the dead-ball years.[14][15]Tinker to Evers to Chance
The phrase "Tinker to Evers to Chance" evokes the iconic 6-4-3 double play executed by the Chicago Cubs' infield trio of shortstop Joe Tinker, second baseman Johnny Evers, and first baseman Frank Chance, whose seamless coordination defined early 20th-century baseball defense from 1902 to 1912.[16] This combination not only anchored the Cubs during their most dominant era but also became a cultural touchstone for precision and inevitability in the sport.[17] Joe Tinker, born Joseph Bert Tinker in Muscotah, Kansas, in 1880, debuted with the Cubs in September 1902 and served as their primary shortstop through 1912, continuing his career until 1916 with stints in Cincinnati and Brooklyn; renowned for his strong arm and error-free play, he posted a career .262 batting average over 1,647 games.[18] Johnny Evers, born John Joseph Evers in Troy, New York, in 1883, joined the Cubs the same year and played second base until 1914, later returning briefly in 1917; a cerebral player known for his base-running savvy and vocal intensity, he finished with a .270 average in 1,786 games across multiple teams.[19] Frank Chance, born Francis Leroy Chance in Fresno, California, in 1877, transitioned from college football to baseball, becoming the Cubs' regular first baseman from 1903 and player-manager starting in 1906 until 1912; a tough, strategic leader who batted .296 over 1,273 games, he managed the Cubs to a 522-255 record during their peak.[20] Together, their intuitive rapport—honed through relentless practice—allowed for rapid pivots and throws that neutralized baserunners with mechanical efficiency. The trio's historical performance peaked during the Cubs' dynasty years, as they participated in turning 491 double plays from 1906 to 1910, a figure that underscored their role in the team's league-leading defense and propelled Chicago to National League pennants in 1906, 1907, 1908, and 1910, along with World Series victories in 1907 and 1908.[21] In their standout 1906 season, when the Cubs set a major league record with 116 wins, Tinker contributed to 55 double plays, Evers to 51, and Chance to 71, helping the infield excel in converting ground balls into twin killings amid 1,305 total team chances.[22] Although the exact sequence of Tinker flipping to Evers relaying to Chance occurred only 54 times across 770 games in that span, their overall synergy elevated the Cubs' fielding percentage to .971, the highest in the National League.[23] Their legacy transcended statistics through cultural resonance, most notably in Franklin P. Adams' 1910 poem "Baseball's Sad Lexicon," written as a Giants fan's wry lament after witnessing a Cubs double play; published in the New York Evening Mail on July 18, the verse captured the trio's rhythmic dominance with lines like "These are the saddest of possible words: / 'Tinker to Evers to Chance.' / Trio of bear cubs, and fleeter than birds, / Tinker and Evers and Chance."[24] The poem, inspired by a July 11, 1910, game where the Cubs defeated New York 4-0 behind such a play, permeated baseball literature, inspiring references in works from novels to broadcasts and embedding the phrase in American idiom as a metaphor for flawless execution.[16] The combination dissolved in 1912 amid internal strife, including a bitter feud between Tinker and Evers that erupted in 1905 over a misplayed grounder—leading to a field altercation and 33 years of silence between them—compounded by Chance's firing as manager after a third-place finish, though Tinker and Evers remained teammates briefly.[25] Undimmed by the discord, their enduring symbol of defensive artistry was affirmed when all three entered the Baseball Hall of Fame in 1946, Tinker and Chance posthumously, cementing "Tinker to Evers to Chance" as baseball's gold standard for infield harmony.Execution and Tactics
Turning a Double Play
In a standard 6-4-3 double play, the shortstop fields the ground ball and delivers a quick underhand flip or throw to the second baseman covering second base to record the force out on the runner from first, after which the second baseman executes a pivot and throws to the first baseman to retire the batter.[26][27] The shortstop's role begins with proper glove work to field the ball cleanly, positioning the body low with knees bent and the glove pocket open toward the incoming ball to ensure a secure catch.[28] Upon securing the ball, the shortstop separates it from the glove into the throwing hand while stepping toward second base, using a quick release via an underhand flip—typically with a stiff wrist and chest-high trajectory—to minimize time and accuracy loss over short distance.[27] The second baseman, meanwhile, plants the left foot on the back of the base while facing the shortstop squarely to present a clear target, then steps the right foot toward the incoming ball for a central catch in the middle of the body, facilitating a rapid transfer.[29] Pivot mechanics at second base emphasize balance and momentum: after catching the feed, the second baseman shifts weight to the right leg for the pivot, bringing the left foot forward to align the body toward first base while keeping the knee pointed in that direction for stability, then releases the throw with a low, athletic motion driven by the legs.[29][26] To avoid collisions with the sliding runner, the second baseman jumps immediately after the throw, either spreading the legs wide, spinning toward the infield grass, or using the base as a shield while staying outside the baseline.[28] The shortstop, upon reaching second, clips the bag's outer quadrant with the right foot for the force out, pivots the upper body to square shoulders toward first, and jumps to evade the runner post-throw.[28] Common errors include botched throws from the shortstop due to poor separation or wrist action, leading to drops at second and only one out, or late pivots by the second baseman from improper foot planting, which delays the throw to first and allows the batter to reach safely.[29][26] Another frequent issue is the second baseman facing the knee toward third base during the pivot, weakening stability and increasing injury risk like ACL strains.[29] Training drills focus on repetition to build timing and muscle memory, such as lining up players at shortstop, second, and first with a coach hitting fungo grounders to simulate the sequence, emphasizing relay throws between positions to practice quick releases and pivots.[26][30] Modern infield gloves, typically 11.5 to 12 inches with shallow pockets, enable faster ball transfers by reducing snagging and allowing quicker glove-to-hand exchanges, contributing to pop times—the interval from catch at second to arrival at first—of around 1.4 to 1.5 seconds in elite play.[31][32] Artificial turf provides firmer footing for explosive movements compared to natural grass.[33]Defensive Strategies
Defensive teams optimize infield positioning to facilitate quick double plays, particularly by adjusting the second baseman and shortstop to "double play depth," where they position approximately three steps closer to the batter and toward second base when there is a runner on first with fewer than two outs. This setup enhances the ability to pivot and throw to first after recording the force out at second, trading some range for faster execution on ground balls hit to the pitcher, shortstop, or third base. Since the 2023 season, Major League Baseball has restricted infield shifts with rules requiring all four infielders to be on the infield dirt or grass and at least two on each side of second base prior to the pitch, limiting extreme alignments based on batter tendencies.[34] Teams still use spray charts to anticipate ground ball directions within these constraints; for example, against pull-hitters, defenses may position infielders to cover the pull side more effectively without violating the rules, increasing the chances of turning two.[35][36] Situational tactics emphasize prioritizing the double play in favorable scenarios, such as runners on first and second with one out, where the defense plays at double play depth to exploit the force opportunities at multiple bases and escape the inning with minimal damage. However, in high-leverage situations like late innings with runners in scoring position, teams may opt for safer alignments, such as playing the infield in to prevent sacrifice bunts or immediate runs from crossing the plate, even if it reduces double play efficiency. These decisions balance the risk of allowing a single out against the reward of two, adapting to runner speed and game score.[35] Pitchers play a crucial role by holding runners at first to discourage steals, maintaining a quick delivery to keep the double play in reach, and focusing on pitches that induce ground balls, such as sinkers targeted low in the zone to promote contact with the ball's lower half. Effective communication, often through subtle signals or calls like "double play ball" from the catcher or infielders, cues the pitcher to prioritize ground-ball outcomes over strikeouts in these spots. While league-wide data shows no significant overall increase in ground-ball rates during double play opportunities—suggesting hitters adjust their approach—certain pitchers with high ground-ball profiles, like Mariano Rivera, demonstrated modest strategic elevations in such situations.[37] Since the 2010s, analytics have transformed these strategies through tools like spray charts, which map batter ground-ball directions to inform precise shifts within rule limits, and defensive metrics such as Ultimate Zone Rating (UZR), which quantifies a fielder's contribution to double plays via its Double Play Runs (DPR) component, measuring runs saved or allowed in turning two. Teams leverage UZR alongside batted-ball data to evaluate infield alignment efficiency, prioritizing setups that maximize outs in double-play scenarios based on probabilistic outcomes rather than intuition alone.[38][39]Notable Instances
Famous Double Plays
In Game 3 of the 1970 World Series, Baltimore Orioles third baseman Brooks Robinson snared a sharp line drive down the third-base line by Cincinnati Reds' Tony Perez in the first inning, spun, and started a 5-4-3 double play that quashed an early scoring threat with runners on first and second.[40] This play helped the Orioles maintain control, contributing to their 9-3 victory and bolstering their 3-0 series lead en route to a 4-1 championship win, for which Robinson earned World Series MVP honors.[40] During the Chicago Cubs' historic 8-7 victory in Game 7 of the 2016 World Series against the Cleveland Indians, a 17-minute rain delay before the 10th inning—tied at 6-6—allowed for a pivotal players-only meeting that refocused the team, leading to two runs in the top half on hits by Ben Zobrist and a sacrifice fly by Miguel Montero.[41] This refocusing contributed to the Cubs ending their 108-year title drought. In the 2004 ALCS, as the Boston Red Sox mounted their improbable comeback from a 3-0 deficit against the New York Yankees, second baseman Mark Bellhorn grounded into a bases-loaded double play in the second inning of Game 6, ending a scoring opportunity but shifting momentum toward the pitchers' duel won by Curt Schilling's "bloody sock" performance in a 4-2 Red Sox victory.[42] This set up Boston's series-clinching 10-3 win in Game 7, advancing them to the World Series where they swept the St. Louis Cardinals for their first title in 86 years.[42] The 1964 Philadelphia Phillies' infamous late-season collapse, marked by a 10-game losing streak that cost them the National League pennant despite a 6½-game lead with 12 games remaining, featured multiple instances where double plays stifled rallies, such as in their September 25 extra-inning loss to the Milwaukee Braves where defensive turns limited comeback chances in a 7-5 defeat.[43] These plays, amid errors and missed opportunities, dropped the Phillies to a tie for second place, finishing one game behind the champion St. Louis Cardinals.[44]Unusual and Record-Setting Plays
One notable variation in double play execution involves the catcher relaying the ball to the center fielder, scored as a 3-2-8 double play, which requires precise coordination to retire runners at multiple bases. The St. Louis Cardinals turned the first such play in the expansion era on August 28, 2020, when catcher Yadier Molina fielded a bunt attempt, tagged a runner at home, and threw to center fielder Harrison Bader to double off another runner.[45] This rarity stems from the unconventional path, as center fielders rarely participate in infield double plays.[46] Unassisted double plays, where a single fielder records both outs without aid, represent an extreme rarity, often occurring when an infielder catches a line drive and tags a baserunner before they return to the bag. Outfielder Tris Speaker holds the career record with six unassisted double plays, achieved by playing shallow center field and exploiting runners' advances on hits.[47] In modern examples, Oakland Athletics pitcher Kendall Graveman executed one on April 27, 2017, by fielding a comebacker, stepping on the pitcher's plate to retire the runner from third, and tagging the batter-runner.[48] Such plays by pitchers are exceptionally uncommon, with Graveman's being the first for the Athletics since Blue Moon Odom in 1971.[8] Certain double plays arise from chaotic circumstances, such as errors or rundowns that inadvertently create out opportunities. For instance, on June 23, 2025, the Los Angeles Angels turned a bizarre double play during a rundown, where Christian Moore tagged Jarren Duran before throwing to second to catch Abraham Toro off base.[49] Around-the-horn double plays (5-4-3), starting at third base and relaying through second to first, are a standard mechanic but can become unusual when executed under pressure with runners in scoring position.[50] Record-setting double plays highlight defensive efficiency extremes, including the most turned in a single game. The Chicago Cubs tied the major league record with seven double plays on August 18, 2018, against the Pittsburgh Pirates, five induced by pitcher Cole Hamels.[51] Statcast data has captured exceptionally quick executions, such as DJ LeMahieu's unassisted double play on September 13, 2019, completed in under two seconds after catching a 109 mph line drive and tagging the base.[52] While precise sub-1.5-second times are not universally tracked, such plays demonstrate the sub-three-second window typical for elite infield turns.[53] In Game 1 of the 2025 NLCS on October 14, the Milwaukee Brewers turned a rare double play when center fielder Sal Frelick caught a line drive by Max Muncy of the Los Angeles Dodgers, which bounced off the wall, forcing out Teoscar Hernández at home and doubling up a runner at third, preserving a key escape.[54] In the 2020s, defensive shifts contributed to quirky outcomes before their 2023 ban, such as grounders deflecting off overshifted infielders into double-play balls, though specific instances like the 2020 Cardinals' 3-2-8 were not shift-related but exemplified era-specific anomalies.[8]Statistics and Records
Defensive Double Play Leaders
Defensive double play statistics measure the number of double plays in which a fielder participates while playing a specific position, with credits assigned for assists or putouts in the play. These records highlight the defensive prowess of infielders, particularly those involved in common combinations like the 6-4-3 (shortstop to second base to first base). Official Major League Baseball tracking of double plays turned began in the National League in 1933 and in the American League in 1939, though some earlier data exists from unofficial sources.[55] Career leaders vary by position, reflecting the roles each fielder plays in double play executions. First basemen often lead overall due to their frequent putouts on the throw to first base in routine grounder double plays. For example, Mickey Vernon holds the all-time record with 2,044 double plays turned at first base during his 20-year career.[56] At second base, Bill Mazeroski ranks first with 1,706, renowned for his pivot skills in the 1960s.[57] Shortstops follow closely, led by Omar Vizquel's 1,734.[58] Third basemen participate less frequently, with Brooks Robinson topping the list at 618.[59]| Position | Player | Double Plays Turned | Years Active |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1B | Mickey Vernon | 2,044 | 1939–1960 |
| 2B | Bill Mazeroski | 1,706 | 1956–1972 |
| SS | Omar Vizquel | 1,734 | 1989–2012 |
| 3B | Brooks Robinson | 618 | 1956–1977 |
| Position | Player | Double Plays Turned | Year | Team |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1B | Ferris Fain | 194 | 1949 | Philadelphia Athletics |
| 2B | Bill Mazeroski | 161 | 1966 | Pittsburgh Pirates |
| SS | Rick Burleson | 147 | 1980 | Boston Red Sox |
| 3B | Graig Nettles | 54 | 1971 | New York Yankees |
Grounded Into Double Play (GIDP) Leaders
A grounded into double play (GIDP) occurs when a batter hits a ground ball that results in two outs, most commonly with a runner on first base and fewer than two outs already recorded.[65] This statistic has been officially tracked in Major League Baseball since 1933 in the National League and 1939 in the American League, reflecting its role as a measure of offensive inefficiency in situations ripe for defensive exploitation.[66] Among career leaders, power hitters often rank highly due to their tendency to produce hard contact on the ground with runners on base, increasing double play opportunities compared to contact-oriented or speed-focused players.[67] Albert Pujols holds the all-time record with 426 GIDP over his 22-season career, followed closely by Miguel Cabrera with 364.[68] Other prominent names include Cal Ripken Jr. (350) and Hank Aaron (328), underscoring how longevity and slugging prowess correlate with elevated totals.[68] For single-season marks, Jim Rice set the record with 36 GIDP in 1984 while playing for the Boston Red Sox, a figure that highlights the vulnerability of pull-hitting left-handed batters in that era.[69] Rice also holds the next-highest total with 35 in 1985.[69] At the team level, the 1990 Boston Red Sox grounded into a record 174 GIDP, a dubious achievement amid a lineup heavy with ground-ball prone sluggers.[70] Hitters adept at avoiding GIDP typically emphasize line drives or fly balls over grounders, often through high contact rates and base-running savvy; Ichiro Suzuki exemplifies this with just 92 career GIDP across 19 MLB seasons, one of the lowest rates for a high-volume hitter.[71] In modern baseball, league-wide GIDP rates have declined notably since the mid-2010s, dropping from about 0.70 per game in 2015 to 0.63 in 2025, largely attributable to the "launch angle revolution" that encourages uppercut swings to produce more airborne contact and fewer ground balls.[72]| Category | Leader | Total | Year/Span | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Career GIDP | Albert Pujols | 426 | 2001–2022 | Baseball-Reference |
| Single-Season GIDP | Jim Rice | 36 | 1984 | Baseball-Reference |
| Team Single-Season GIDP | Boston Red Sox | 174 | 1990 | Baseball Almanac |