Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Extrasensory perception

Extrasensory perception (ESP), also referred to as the sixth sense, is the alleged acquisition of information about an external event, object, or individual through means other than the known physical senses.^[1] This purported ability encompasses several distinct phenomena, including telepathy (the direct transmission of thoughts or information between minds), clairvoyance (perception of remote or hidden objects and events without sensory cues), and precognition (foreknowledge of future occurrences).^[1] While ESP has fascinated cultures and individuals for centuries, it remains a topic of intense debate, with proponents claiming it represents an untapped human potential and skeptics attributing reported instances to coincidence, fraud, or cognitive biases.^[2] The modern study of ESP emerged from 19th-century spiritualism and psychical research societies, which investigated paranormal claims through early experimental methods. In 1930, psychologist J. B. Rhine and his wife Louisa established the Parapsychology Laboratory at Duke University, marking the beginning of rigorous, university-affiliated ESP research in the United States.^[3] Rhine popularized the term "extrasensory perception" in his 1934 book Extra-Sensory Perception, where he detailed experiments using Zener cards—decks featuring five simple symbols—to test subjects' ability to guess cards beyond chance levels, often under controlled conditions to rule out sensory leakage. These efforts, supported by figures like William McDougall, aimed to integrate ESP into mainstream psychology, though the lab operated at Duke until 1965 before relocating as the Rhine Research Center.^[3] Despite decades of investigation, scientific consensus holds that ESP lacks empirical validation and is classified as a pseudoscience.^[4] Rhine's initial positive results could not be consistently replicated in subsequent studies, and methodological flaws—such as sensory cues, statistical errors, and selective reporting—have undermined claims of success. A comprehensive meta-analysis by Milton and Wiseman (1999) reviewed 30 ganzfeld experiments (a technique isolating subjects to enhance ESP detection) across multiple labs and found effect sizes indistinguishable from chance, with no evidence of anomalous information transfer.^[5] Similarly, analyses of mass-media ESP tests involving thousands of participants yielded results no better than random guessing.^[6] Mainstream organizations, including the American Psychological Association, emphasize that while belief in ESP persists—often linked to intuitive thinking styles and existential anxieties—no mechanism or replicable proof has been established.^[2]

Definition and Overview

Core Definition

Extrasensory perception (ESP) refers to the alleged acquisition of information about the external world through means other than the known physical senses, such as sight, hearing, touch, taste, and smell.^[1] This purported ability challenges conventional understandings of perception by suggesting direct mental access to knowledge without sensory mediation, as exemplified in claims of mind-to-mind communication (telepathy) or awareness of remote events (clairvoyance).^[1] The term "extrasensory perception" was coined in 1934 by parapsychologist J.B. Rhine in his seminal monograph summarizing early experimental work at Duke University. In the field of parapsychology, ESP phenomena fall under the broader category of "psi," a neutral term introduced in 1948 by psychologists Robert H. Thouless and B.P. Wiesner to describe anomalous mental processes, derived from the Greek psyche (mind or soul). Psi encompasses both receptive processes like ESP and other purported abilities, but emphasizes empirical investigation of these claims.^[7] ESP is distinct from psychokinesis (PK), the claimed mental influence over physical objects or events without physical interaction, as ESP focuses solely on information acquisition rather than causation or manipulation in the material world.^[8] This separation highlights ESP's emphasis on perceptual anomalies within parapsychological frameworks. Parapsychological claims of ESP pose philosophical challenges to strict materialism, which holds that perception and cognition arise exclusively from physical brain processes and sensory inputs, by implying non-physical mechanisms of knowledge that resonate with dualist views positing an independent mind.^[9]

Distinction from Other Phenomena

Extrasensory perception (ESP) fundamentally differs from normal sensory perception in that it purportedly involves the acquisition of information through mechanisms independent of the five recognized physical senses—sight, hearing, touch, taste, and smell—which operate via detectable physical stimuli such as light waves, sound vibrations, or chemical interactions. For instance, visual perception relies on electromagnetic radiation entering the eye and stimulating retinal cells, whereas ESP is claimed to bypass such channels entirely, allowing direct apprehension of distant or hidden information without physical mediation.^[10] ESP is also distinguished from certain related paranormal claims that incorporate anomalous but still sensory-like modalities. Dermo-optical perception, for example, refers to the alleged ability to identify colors or objects through direct skin contact; while sometimes investigated as a potential psi phenomenon, it is often distinguished from core ESP due to possible involvement of tactile or physical inputs rather than fully transcending sensory apparatus.^[11] Similarly, aura reading involves perceiving supposed energy fields surrounding individuals, often described as an enhanced form of visual or synesthetic experience rather than a non-sensory process, setting it apart from the core definition of ESP as devoid of any physical sensory involvement.^[10] Non-paranormal psychological explanations offer alternative accounts for experiences resembling ESP, such as cold reading techniques employed by mentalists, where vague statements and observations of subtle behavioral cues create the illusion of insightful knowledge. Confirmation bias further contributes, as individuals tend to recall instances where perceived intuitions align with outcomes while disregarding discrepancies, mimicking extrasensory accuracy without invoking paranormal means. These mechanisms highlight how everyday cognitive processes can simulate ESP-like phenomena.^[10] Within parapsychology, ESP is categorized as a core component of psi phenomena—encompassing anomalous cognition and action—that involves the anomalous acquisition of information, which can include purported interactions with discarnate entities in survival-related abilities like mediumship (though this raises debates between super-ESP from living sources and direct post-mortem communication).^[12]

Types of Extrasensory Perception

Telepathy

Telepathy refers to the purported direct transfer of thoughts, feelings, or information from one mind to another without the use of known sensory channels or physical interaction.^[13] It is classified as a primary form of extrasensory perception (ESP), involving interpersonal communication distinct from perceiving external objects or events.^[13] Within parapsychology, telepathy is divided into subtypes based on intentionality and timing. Active telepathy involves deliberate transmission or reception of information, often in controlled settings where one individual (the agent) consciously sends a thought or image to another (the percipient).^[14] In contrast, latent telepathy, also known as unconscious or deferred telepathy, occurs without conscious effort and may involve a time lag between the event and its perception, such as receiving impressions of past or future thoughts.^[15] These distinctions highlight telepathy's proposed variability, from spontaneous emotional exchanges to structured attempts at mind-to-mind linkage.^[14] Early historical claims of telepathy emerged through organized investigations in the late 19th century. In 1882, the Society for Psychical Research (SPR) formed a committee to study "thought-transference," conducting initial experiments with the Creery sisters in England, where percipients reportedly identified hidden cards and objects at rates exceeding chance expectations.^[16] These trials, led by researchers including William Barrett, Edmund Gurney, and Frederic W.H. Myers, involved 382 attempts over several days, yielding successes such as five consecutive correct guesses of playing cards with odds against chance estimated at over 1 in a billion. However, in 1888, two of the sisters confessed to using secret signals such as eye movements and foot tapping in some trials, leading to the discrediting of the overall findings, though the method could not fully explain all reported isolated successes.^[16] The SPR's work established thought-transference as a foundational concept in parapsychological inquiry, influencing subsequent claims of non-sensory mental communication.^[17] Purported mechanisms for telepathy have drawn analogies from physics in modern parapsychology, though these remain speculative. Some researchers propose models likening telepathic links to quantum entanglement, where distant particles exhibit correlated states instantaneously, suggesting a non-local transfer of mental information without signal propagation.^[18] For instance, a 2010 quantum model posits that entangled quantum states in neural processes could enable such mind-to-mind correlations, framing telepathy as an extension of subatomic interconnectedness.^[18] Examples of this include crisis telepathy reported among identical twins, where one twin senses the other's distress during emergencies, such as injury or illness, often interpreted as an unconscious emotional transmission amplified by genetic similarity.^[19] Accounts describe twins experiencing shared physical sensations, like pain or anxiety, during life-threatening events separated by distance.^[19] A notable example of claimed telepathic ability is documented in Upton Sinclair's 1930 book Mental Radio, which details informal experiments conducted with his wife, Mary Craig Sinclair, over three years. In these trials, Upton created drawings in a separate room or at distances up to 40 miles, while Mary attempted to replicate them mentally, achieving 65 exact matches and 155 partial successes out of 290 attempts, far surpassing chance levels. The experiments focused on artistic imagery, such as objects and scenes, and were later analyzed by parapsychologists Walter Franklin Prince and William McDougall, who affirmed the results as evidence of telepathic transmission. Sinclair's work emphasized the role of emotional bonds in facilitating such "mental radio" exchanges.

Clairvoyance and Precognition

Clairvoyance, often described as "clear seeing," refers to the purported extrasensory perception of information about distant or hidden objects, events, or locations that cannot be obtained through normal sensory channels.^[20] This ability is distinguished from telepathy, which involves mind-to-mind communication, as clairvoyance focuses on direct perception of physical or environmental targets independent of other individuals' thoughts. Examples include claims of locating lost items or describing concealed scenes, such as in early experimental setups where subjects attempted to identify hidden cards or objects.^[17] Precognition, in contrast, involves the anticipation of future events or outcomes without any logical inference or prior knowledge, allowing individuals to acquire non-inferential information arising from events that have not yet occurred.^[21] This form of extrasensory perception emphasizes forward-looking foresight, often reported through dreams, visions, or sudden intuitions about impending incidents. A related subtype, retrocognition, pertains to the perception of past events after they have transpired, though it receives less emphasis in parapsychological literature compared to precognition's prospective nature. In the 1920s, the Society for Psychical Research conducted pioneering clairvoyance tests using free-response and quantitative methods, where participants described hidden targets like drawings or objects screened from view, aiming to quantify hits beyond chance levels.^[17] These experiments, led by researchers such as George Tyrrell, explored the reliability of such perceptions through controlled trials.^[22] Precognitive dreams gained attention through J.W. Dunne's 1927 book An Experiment with Time, in which he documented personal experiences of dreams that accurately foreshadowed future personal events, such as disasters or daily occurrences, and proposed a method for readers to track similar instances.^[23] During the 1970s, the U.S. government explored remote viewing—a claimed application of clairvoyance—as part of the Stargate Project, a classified program investigating psychic methods for intelligence gathering, such as visualizing distant sites or hidden facilities.^[24] The project, involving trained viewers attempting to describe remote targets, was declassified in 1995, revealing operational trials spanning over two decades.^[25]

Historical Context

Ancient and Pre-Modern Beliefs

In ancient civilizations, concepts akin to extrasensory perception (ESP) manifested through prophetic visions and oracles, interpreted as divine communications beyond ordinary senses. In the Hebrew Bible, dreams and visions served as channels for foreknowledge and guidance, such as Abraham's vision foretelling future events (Genesis 17) or Isaiah's encounter with divine seraphs (Isaiah 6), viewed as direct revelations from God that transcended human perception.^[26] Similarly, the Delphic Oracle in ancient Greece, established around the 8th century BCE as Apollo's sanctuary, functioned as a primary site for divination where the Pythia priestess entered trance-like states to deliver ambiguous prophecies, consulted by civic leaders for insights into the gods' will and future outcomes.^[27] These practices underscored a widespread belief in mediated extrasensory access to hidden knowledge, central to religious and communal decision-making. Indigenous cultures worldwide incorporated shamanic trance states as mechanisms for ESP-like interactions with the spirit world, enabling healing, prophecy, and divination. Shamans across societies, from Siberian Evenki to Mesoamerican groups, achieved altered states of consciousness through drumming, chanting, psychedelics like balche in Yucatec rituals, or dreams among Huastec practitioners, allowing them to perceive and communicate with spirits for communal guidance.^[28] In ancient Greece and Rome, oracles were broadly accepted as valid conduits for supernatural insight, influencing state affairs, though philosophical skepticism emerged; Cicero's De Divinatione (44 BCE), a dialogue between his brother Quintus (defending divination) and himself, critiqued oracles and prophecies as superstitious, arguing they lacked rational evidence and often relied on coincidence or fraud.^[29] During the medieval and Renaissance periods in Europe, ESP-related beliefs intertwined with fears of witchcraft, often framed as demonic rather than divine gifts. The Malleus Maleficarum (1487), authored by Heinrich Kramer (with attributed co-author Jacob Sprenger), portrayed witches as women empowered by pacts with demons to perform supernatural feats, including causing impotence or storms through spells, shape-shifting, and nocturnal flights to sabbaths, justifying inquisitorial trials across Europe.^[30] These abilities were seen as inverted extrasensory powers, enabling harm and deception under satanic influence, fueling witch hunts until the 17th century. Non-Western traditions also embedded ESP concepts in spiritual frameworks. In ancient Hindu texts like Patanjali's Yoga Sutras (c. 2nd–4th century CE), siddhis represented yogic accomplishments granting extrasensory perceptions, such as telepathy (knowledge of others' thoughts), clairvoyance of distant objects, and the eight mahasiddhis including levitation (laghima) and atomization (animā), attained through meditation or austerity but warned against as distractions from enlightenment.^[31] In Chinese cosmology, qi—the vital energy constituting all existence—was believed perceivable through divination practices like the I Ching (c. 1000 BCE), where interpreting hexagrams revealed patterns of cosmic change, akin to extrasensory attunement to yin-yang flows for foresight and harmony.^[32]

Modern Emergence in the 19th-20th Centuries

The modern emergence of extrasensory perception (ESP) as a formalized concept began in the mid-19th century amid the rise of spiritualism, a movement that popularized claims of communication with spirits and psychic phenomena. In 1848, sisters Margaret and Kate Fox in Hydesville, New York, reported mysterious rapping sounds in their home, which they interpreted as messages from the deceased using a code similar to the Morse alphabet.^[33] This event, promoted by their older sister Leah, sparked widespread interest and led to public séances where mediums claimed to demonstrate telepathic and clairvoyant abilities, framing ESP as a bridge between the living and the spirit world.^[34] Spiritualism rapidly spread across Europe and North America, attracting figures from literature and science who viewed these manifestations as potential evidence of non-physical perception, though the Fox sisters later confessed to producing the sounds via toe-cracking before retracting the admission.^[35] By the late 19th century, efforts to study ESP shifted toward systematic investigation through psychical research. In 1882, the Society for Psychical Research (SPR) was established in London by a group of scholars including philosopher Henry Sidgwick, physicist William Fletcher Barrett, and classics scholar Frederic W. H. Myers, aiming to apply scientific methods to phenomena like telepathy and apparitions of the dead.^[17] Sidgwick, as the first president, emphasized rigorous inquiry to distinguish genuine ESP from fraud or hallucination, leading to early reports on thought-transference experiments and ghostly sightings that influenced public discourse on psychic abilities.^[36] The SPR's work, including the 1886 publication of Phantasms of the Living by Myers, Gurney, and Podmore, documented cases suggesting extrasensory communication, establishing psychical research as a precursor to modern parapsychology.^[17] The early 20th century saw parapsychology institutionalize as a distinct field, particularly through J.B. Rhine's efforts at Duke University. In 1930, Rhine, a botanist turned researcher, founded the Parapsychology Laboratory at Duke with his wife Louisa, focusing on empirical tests of ESP under controlled conditions.^[37] Collaborating with perceptual psychologist Karl Zener, Rhine introduced Zener cards in the early 1930s—decks featuring five symbols (circle, cross, waves, square, star)—to quantify telepathy and clairvoyance through guessing tasks, as detailed in Rhine's 1934 book Extra-Sensory Perception.^[38] These experiments aimed to measure psi abilities statistically, positioning parapsychology as a legitimate scientific endeavor despite ongoing debates.^[39] Mid-20th-century developments further solidified the field's structure with the founding of professional organizations. In 1957, the Parapsychological Association (PA) was established at the initiative of J.B. Rhine and other researchers, serving as an international body for scientists studying psi phenomena, including ESP.^[40] The PA's formation facilitated annual conventions and peer-reviewed publications, promoting standardized methodologies and interdisciplinary collaboration in parapsychology.^[41] This era marked ESP's transition from fringe spiritualism to an organized area of inquiry, influencing subsequent research into perceptual anomalies.

Scientific Research and Evidence

Early Experimental Approaches

The Society for Psychical Research (SPR), established in 1882, pioneered laboratory-based investigations into extrasensory perception through its Thought-Transference Committee, focusing on telepathic phenomena in the 1880s and 1890s.^[17] Key figures including Edmund Gurney, Frederic W.H. Myers, and Henry Sidgwick designed protocols where an "agent" concentrated on a simple target—such as a playing card, number, or drawn object—while a screened "percipient" in an adjacent or distant room attempted to identify it verbally or in writing. These experiments emphasized repetition for statistical evaluation, with early trials involving household objects or standard card decks to test thought transference under controlled conditions, often conducted in private homes or SPR facilities to minimize external interference.^[42] In the 1930s, parapsychologist J.B. Rhine advanced these methods at Duke University's Parapsychology Laboratory by introducing a standardized quantitative framework using Zener cards, a 25-card deck featuring five suits of symbols: a circle, cross, square, star, and three wavy lines.^[43] Rhine's protocols tested clairvoyance (guessing hidden cards) and telepathy (guessing cards viewed by a sender), with subjects providing guesses for entire decks or runs of 25 cards, recorded on separate sheets to prevent immediate feedback.^[43] The baseline chance hit rate was 20% due to the five-symbol design, allowing for clear deviation analysis; for instance, in the 1933–1934 Pearce-Pratt distance series, subject Hubert Pearce, separated by up to 250 yards from the cards, recorded 558 correct guesses out of 1,850 trials, exceeding chance expectations.^[44] Rhine incorporated mechanical shufflers and sealed envelopes to enhance reliability across thousands of trials.^[43] Field-based approaches emerged in the 1960s with Montague Ullman's dream telepathy studies at Maimonides Medical Center in Brooklyn, New York, blending sleep laboratory techniques with ESP testing from 1964 onward.^[45] Participants, selected for creative or psychic interests, underwent EEG and eye-movement monitoring to detect REM sleep phases; upon awakening, they recounted dreams, which were transcribed verbatim.^[46] Simultaneously, an agent in an isolated room concentrated on transmitting details from one of 12 emotionally evocative art prints, selected randomly before the session.^[45] Independent judges, blind to the target, ranked dream content against all prints for thematic matches, with hits determined by high correspondence scores.^[47] Throughout these early efforts, experimenters identified methodological challenges, including sensory leakage—unintended visual or auditory cues, such as glimpses of cards through screens or experimenters' subtle reactions—and cueing from inadequate randomization, like predictable shuffling patterns.^[38] In SPR setups, initial trials revealed risks of deliberate signaling or inadvertent hints between participants in close proximity, prompting stricter isolation and verification procedures.^[42] Rhine's team countered these by relocating subjects to separate buildings, employing automated devices for card handling, and withholding result confirmations until sessions ended, aiming to isolate extrasensory elements from ordinary perceptual influences.^[38]

Contemporary Studies and Meta-Analyses

Contemporary research on extrasensory perception (ESP) since the 1970s has emphasized refined experimental protocols and quantitative syntheses to evaluate claims of psi phenomena. The ganzfeld procedure, involving sensory deprivation to facilitate telepathic transmission, emerged as a prominent method during this period. In a meta-analysis of 28 ganzfeld studies conducted between 1974 and 1981, Charles Honorton reported an overall hit rate of 35%, significantly exceeding the 25% expected by chance, with a combined z-score indicating a small but statistically significant effect size of approximately 0.20.^[48] Subsequent refinements, including automated judging and double-blind protocols, have been applied in over 100 experiments, maintaining similar effect sizes in proponent-led reviews.^[49] Remote viewing experiments, which test clairvoyance by having participants describe distant or hidden targets, were systematically investigated through government-sponsored programs at SRI International from 1972 to 1995. Physicists Russell Targ and Harold Puthoff led early efforts, reporting successful trials where viewers accurately sketched remote sites, such as a Soviet facility, with judges matching descriptions to targets at rates better than chance (e.g., rankings of 1-2 out of 10 possibilities).^[50] The program, part of the broader Star Gate initiative, involved over 100 sessions and influenced later protocols, though operational applications yielded mixed outcomes.^[51] In the realm of precognition, psychologist Daryl Bem's 2011 study in the Journal of Personality and Social Psychology presented nine experiments suggesting retroactive influences, where participants performed better on tasks after stimuli that had not yet occurred, with effect sizes ranging from 0.22 to 0.36 (p < 0.05 across conditions).^[52] A 2015 meta-analysis by Bem and colleagues of 90 replication attempts from 33 laboratories reported an overall effect greater than 6 sigma (Hedges' g = 0.09), supporting anomalous anticipation in randomized future events.^[53] However, independent large-scale replications in the 2010s and 2020s, such as a 2022 study with over 2,000 participants, failed to detect significant effects, highlighting persistent replication challenges.^[54] Integration with neuroscience has explored physiological correlates of ESP tasks, particularly through electroencephalography (EEG). In 2004 experiments, Dean Radin examined event-related potentials in isolated subject pairs during telepathy-like tasks, finding correlated EEG responses (e.g., P300 components) in 3 of 13 pairs at distances up to 15 miles, with odds against chance of 1 in 1,000.^[55] Meta-analyses of EEG studies on anomalous perception from 2001 to 2019 have confirmed small effect sizes suggestive of potential brain-based markers for psi, though mechanisms remain debated.^[56] Broader meta-analyses post-2000 have synthesized ESP data across protocols. A 2023 review of 36 years of forced-choice ESP experiments (1987-2022) across 59 studies found a modest overall effect (z = 6.12, p < 10^{-9}), consistent with earlier syntheses but emphasizing the need for preregistered designs.^[57] Similarly, a 2021 meta-analysis of telepathy-focused ESP trials from the prior two decades reported a significant but small effect size (g = 0.15), underscoring ongoing quantitative support amid methodological refinements.^[58] As of 2025, recent pre-registered studies continue to explore forced-choice designs, though large-scale replications remain inconsistent.^[59] These analyses reflect a field grappling with reproducibility while advancing toward more rigorous, technology-integrated investigations.

Skepticism and Criticisms

Methodological and Scientific Critiques

Critics of extrasensory perception (ESP) research have highlighted numerous methodological flaws that undermine the validity of experimental findings. Common issues include inadequate controls against fraud and sensory leakage, where participants or experimenters might unconsciously or deliberately convey information through non-extrasensory channels. For instance, in many studies, insufficient safeguards allow for subtle cues, such as experimenter bias in judging responses or participant cheating via unmonitored actions. Randomization errors further compromise results, as early ESP experiments often relied on manual shuffling or pseudorandom methods prone to patterns detectable by participants, leading to inflated hit rates that mimic ESP but stem from statistical artifacts. The file-drawer effect exacerbates these problems, with negative or null results disproportionately unpublished, skewing meta-analyses toward apparent positive effects; estimates suggest that dozens of unreported studies would be needed to nullify some reported significances in parapsychology.^[60]^[61]^[62] A persistent lack of replication across independent laboratories has also drawn sharp scrutiny. The 1988 National Research Council report, after reviewing decades of parapsychological experiments including those on telepathy and precognition, concluded that no scientific justification exists for ESP claims due to inconsistent and non-replicable outcomes, with methodological defects present in the majority of studies examined. For example, only a fraction of remote viewing trials succeeded under rigorous peer review, and even prominent protocols like the ganzfeld procedure have been criticized for vulnerability to bias despite attempts at standardization. This failure to achieve reliable replication violates core scientific standards, rendering ESP phenomena unsubstantiated despite occasional positive results in proponent-led research.^[63] Theoretically, ESP poses profound incompatibilities with established physics, particularly in forms like precognition that appear to violate causality by allowing future events to influence the present. No known mechanism accommodates non-local information transfer required for telepathy or clairvoyance, as such processes would exceed the speed of light and contravene relativity and quantum field theory principles. Information theory further limits ESP plausibility, as acquiring knowledge without sensory input defies entropy and channel capacity constraints in known physical systems. Bayesian analyses reinforce this skepticism, assigning ESP an extremely low prior probability given its contradiction with well-corroborated physical laws; even strong evidential support from experiments would require extraordinary replication to overcome such priors, a threshold unmet in parapsychology.^[63]^[64]^[60]

Specific Case Debunkings

One prominent claim of extrasensory perception involved dermo-optical perception, or the alleged ability to perceive colors and read text using the skin, particularly the fingertips, without visual input. In the 1960s, Soviet researchers, including neurologist I.M. Goldberg, reported that Rosa Kuleshova, a 22-year-old woman from Nizhny Tagil, could accurately identify colors and read printed material while blindfolded by running her fingers over surfaces.^[65] These demonstrations gained widespread attention in the Soviet Union, with Kuleshova appearing on national television in 1963, reaching over 40 million viewers. However, subsequent investigations revealed that her blindfolds were inadequately secured, allowing her to peek through gaps or around the edges, thus relying on normal vision rather than skin-based perception.^[65] Skeptics, including Martin Gardner, highlighted how the setup enabled subtle cheating, such as tilting her head to view the material, debunking the claims as fraudulent.^[66] Similar vulnerabilities appeared in related demonstrations, such as those by other Soviet claimants in the 1960s and 1970s. For instance, skeptic James Randi tested a claimant of seeing without sight in 2001 using swimmer's goggles sealed with aluminum foil and duct tape to prevent peeking; the participant initially succeeded but failed after enhancements to the blindfold.^[67] This exposure underscored how methodological laxity, including inconsistent blindfolding, had propped up the illusion of skin vision across multiple cases. In the realm of mediumship, Italian medium Eusapia Palladino (1854–1918) was a central figure in late-19th-century spiritualism, renowned for producing physical phenomena like table levitations, spirit hands, and apportations during séances attended by scientists such as Cesare Lombroso and Pierre and Marie Curie.^[68] Investigations in the 1890s, including controlled sittings in Milan and Cambridge, exposed her use of accomplices, hidden threads, and her own limbs to manipulate objects; for example, she was caught freeing her hands from restraints to move tables and produce "ectoplasmic" effects with cheesecloth or gauze concealed in her clothing.^[69] Harry Houdini, in his 1924 book A Magician Among the Spirits, analyzed Palladino's methods based on eyewitness reports and replicated her tricks using identical fraudulent techniques, such as foot-based manipulations and pre-arranged signals with assistants, confirming her phenomena as stage illusions rather than supernatural. Palladino's exposures were part of a broader pattern in mediumship frauds, where mediums employed cheesecloth soaked in chemicals to simulate ectoplasm or used confederates for auditory cues, as documented in multiple scientific critiques of the era.^[68] The U.S. government's Stargate Project (1978–1995), a classified program exploring remote viewing as a form of clairvoyance for intelligence gathering, represented a high-profile ESP initiative funded by the CIA and DIA. Remote viewers, including participants like Joseph McMoneagle, claimed to describe distant or hidden targets, such as Soviet facilities, based on psychic impressions. In 1995, the American Institutes for Research conducted an independent evaluation at the CIA's request, reviewing over 20 years of experiments and operational records; the panel, led by statistician Jessica Utts and skeptic Ray Hyman, concluded that while some laboratory results showed statistical anomalies, remote viewing produced no actionable intelligence of value and was unreliable for practical applications.^[70] The review highlighted vague descriptions that could fit multiple targets and a lack of consistent hits in real-world scenarios, leading to the program's termination in September 1995.^[70] Contemporary claims of precognition faced similar scrutiny in the replication crisis. In 2011, psychologist Daryl Bem published "Feeling the Future" in the Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, reporting nine experiments suggesting participants could anticipate random events, such as erotic images appearing on screens, with effect sizes indicating statistical significance (p < 0.05 across studies). However, a 2012 pre-registered replication by Stuart Ritchie, Richard Wiseman, and Christopher French, involving three independent attempts with 150 participants, failed to reproduce the retroactive facilitation of recall effect, yielding non-significant results (combined p = 0.84).^[71] The replicators attributed Bem's original findings to questionable research practices, such as selective reporting and p-hacking—analyzing data in multiple ways until significance emerged—rather than genuine precognition, a conclusion supported by subsequent meta-analyses showing diminished effects upon preregistration.^[71]

Cultural and Societal Impact

In Media and Popular Culture

Extrasensory perception (ESP) has been a recurring motif in literature, often intertwined with themes of the supernatural and the human mind's hidden potentials. Edgar Allan Poe's short story "The Facts in the Case of M. Valdemar" (1845) depicts a mesmerizing experiment on a dying man, involving hypnosis that blurs the boundaries between life, death, and altered states of consciousness. In film, ESP frequently drives narrative tension and moral dilemmas. M. Night Shyamalan's The Sixth Sense (1999) centers on a child psychologist aiding a boy who communicates with the dead, presenting clairvoyance as a burdensome gift that reveals hidden truths about the living world. Steven Spielberg's Minority Report (2002), adapted from Philip K. Dick's story, features "pre-cogs" with precognitive visions used to preempt crimes, raising ethical questions about determinism and surveillance in a dystopian society. Television and comics have amplified ESP through ensemble casts and serialized adventures. The Marvel Comics X-Men series, starting in 1963, showcases Professor X's telepathic prowess to read and influence minds, positioning mutants with ESP-like abilities as both heroes and societal outcasts. Netflix's Stranger Things (2016–present) draws on sensory deprivation experiments to depict Eleven's extrasensory powers, including remote viewing and telekinesis, as tools for battling otherworldly threats.^[72] These portrayals have solidified enduring tropes in media, such as the "psychic detective" archetype, where individuals with ESP assist law enforcement in solving mysteries through intuition or visions, as seen in various science fiction narratives from the mid-20th century onward.

Public Beliefs and Surveys

Public belief in extrasensory perception (ESP) remains notable in contemporary societies, though levels vary by region and have shown fluctuations over time. In the United States, a 2005 Gallup poll found that 41% of Americans believed in ESP, making it the most commonly endorsed paranormal phenomenon among those surveyed.^[73] By 2025, this figure had declined to 24%, reflecting broader skepticism toward paranormal claims, with belief in ESP ranking as the most accepted among eight tested phenomena but still met with majority doubt.^[74] Demographic patterns indicate higher openness to paranormal beliefs, including ESP, among women (40%) compared to men (28%), and among those who infrequently attend religious services (40%) versus weekly churchgoers (78% skeptical).^[74] Globally, surveys reveal comparable yet regionally divergent patterns. A 2005 Gallup poll showed similar levels of paranormal belief, including ESP, across the United States, Canada, and the United Kingdom, with ESP being the top endorsement in each.^[75] In Europe, belief tends to be lower in Scandinavia; for instance, a 2024 study in Sweden reported that 41% of adults affirm belief in paranormal phenomena, but rates for specific claims like ESP are generally subdued compared to more religious regions.^[76] A study on Sweden highlighted lower endorsement of paranormal beliefs in Scandinavia, attributing this to higher secularization.^[77] Societal factors significantly influence acceptance of ESP. Studies from the 2010s consistently demonstrate an inverse correlation between analytical cognitive style and belief in ESP, with greater analytical thinking associated with reduced endorsement of paranormal claims.^[78] Conversely, exposure to media portrayals of paranormal events has been linked to increased belief; a 2023 analysis found that heavier consumption of television, social media, and podcasts featuring supernatural themes predicts stronger convictions in paranormal phenomena such as UFOs.^[79] Recent trends suggest a resurgence in interest in ESP amid broader discussions of spirituality and mental health following 2020. A 2023 Pew Research Center survey indicated that 70% of U.S. adults identify as spiritual in some form, with 22% describing themselves as spiritual but not religious, potentially fueling openness to phenomena like ESP as tools for personal insight.^[80] Similarly, 2024 data from the American Psychiatric Association showed that 60% of adults view faith or spirituality as important to their mental health, correlating with heightened exploration of non-traditional beliefs such as ESP in wellness contexts.^[81]

References

[1]
extrasensory perception (ESP) - APA Dictionary of Psychology
alleged awareness of external events by other means than the known sensory channels. It includes telepathy, clairvoyance, and precognition.
[2]
Who Believes in ESP: Cognitive and Motivational Determinants of ...
Feb 28, 2019 · Many people believe in extra-sensory perception, e.g. the ability to communicate with thoughts, to sense future events or locate radiation ...
[3]
About the Exhibit · Early Studies in Parapsychology at Duke
The early work of The Parapsychology Laboratory began at Duke in 1930 after Dr. William McDougall invited Drs. J.B. and Louisa Rhine to Durham.
[4]
ESP: What can science say?
mind reading, sensing when a far-off friend is in ...
[5]
https://psycnet.apa.org/doiLanding?doi=10.1037%2F0033-2909.125.4.387
[6]
A meta-analysis of mass-media tests of extrasensory perception.
Citation. Milton, J., & Wiseman, R. (1999). A meta-analysis of mass-media ... The authors conducted a meta-analysis of eight ESP studies conducted via ...
[7]
The psi processes in normal and paranormal psychology - PubMed
The psi processes in normal and paranormal psychology. J Parapsychol. 1948 Sep;12(3):192-212. Authors. R H THOULESS, B P WIESNER. PMID: 18885711.Missing: term | Show results with:term
[8]
APA Dictionary of Psychology
### Summary of Psychokinesis Definition
[9]
[PDF] Philosophical Dimensions of Parapsychology - Journals@KU
philosophical psychology, takes the findings of psych- ical research to be "a small black cloud on the horizon of a Materialist theory of mind." This caution is ...
[10]
Extra-sensory perception - a controversial debate | BPS
Jul 6, 2009 · Extra-sensory perception (ESP) is a term often scoffed at in psychology and wider science: an alleged 'paranormal' or supernatural phenomenon.
[11]
Dermo-Optical Perception | Psi Encyclopedia
Mar 5, 2018 · Dermo-optical perception (DOP) refers to the apparent ability to discern the colour of a stimulus object purely on the basis of touch.
[12]
[PDF] RESEARCH INTO PS I PHENOMENA - CIA
Mediumship (communication with the departed) ... Currently, experimental studies of PK and ESP are receiving primary attention in the psi community because of the.
[13]
Relevance of para-psychology in psychiatric practice - PMC - NIH
TELEPATHY. The apparent communication between two minds without the use of known sensory channels was initially called 'thought transference' and later came to ...
[14]
[PDF] Aspects of Parapsychology relevant to Spirituality and Psychiatry
Telepathy is thought transference and clairvoyance is extra-sensory awareness of objects or objective events. (Schizophrenic thought transference is an active ...
[15]
Latent Telepathy - The Parapsychological Association
Nov 17, 2015 · An instance of telepathy in which there seems to be a time lag between the agent's attempt to transmit the target, and the percipient's awareness of that ...Missing: active | Show results with:active
[16]
Creery Telepathy Experiments | Psi Encyclopedia
Jun 16, 2018 · Successful early experiments in telepathy (1882-1888) carried out by SPR researchers with a family of five girls in the north of England, ...
[17]
Our History | spr.ac.uk - Society for Psychical Research
Much experimental work was also done in Britain at this time, with the use of statistically assessable material or other targets for thought-transference, ...
[18]
(PDF) A Primary Quantum Model of Telepathy - ResearchGate
Aug 7, 2025 · Quantum being has it possible entanglement with experimentation and scientific explanation for telepathy phenomena. The principle of quantum ...
[19]
[PDF] identical twins and telepathy
CRISIS TELEPATHY. I have become more and more inclined to the belief that it is the highly emotional or exciting thoughts that are most apt to get through ...
[20]
Clairvoyance - The Parapsychological Association
Nov 17, 2015 · Paranormal acquisition of information concerning an object or contemporary physical event; in contrast to telepathy, the information is ...Missing: definition | Show results with:definition
[21]
Rethinking Extrasensory Perception: Toward a Multiphasic Model of ...
Mar 24, 2015 · Extrasensory perception (ESP) is a panhuman experience observed since ... However, a crucial distinction between synesthesia and PC ...
[22]
Proceedings of the Society for Psychical Research.
... clairvoyance : Do we need the hypothesis of clairvoyance to account for the results of clairvoyance tests? Can we not suppose that telepathy jxplains the ...
[23]
An Experiment with Time - Faded Page
The book deals with precognitive dreams and suggests a theory of time. [Suggest a different description.] Downloads: 4,380. Pages: 282 Info. Available Formats ...<|separator|>
[24]
[PDF] STAR GATE PROJECT: AN OVERVIEW - CIA
The STAR GATE program focuses on anomalous phenomena, including parapsychological interactions, with foreign assessment, research, and in-house investigations.
[25]
STARGATE | CIA FOIA (foia.cia.gov)
STARGATE is a collection of CIA documents, including one with a mission statement and a computer-based test of face precognition.
[26]
Prophetic Dreams and Visions in the Hebrew Bible - Bible Odyssey
Jun 20, 2017 · Dreams and visions in the ancient Near East offered insights into everyday realities or provided opportunities to transcend them.
[27]
Chapter 7: Oracles and Prophecy – HIS 337: Greek Gods, Heroes ...
Unlike most other Greek oracles, the Delphic oracle appears to have been used mostly for civic consultation, as opposed to private, and was open both to ...Missing: beliefs | Show results with:beliefs
[28]
Cross-Culturally Exploring the Concept of Shamanism
Mar 27, 2019 · First, all three shamans performed rituals and practices to achieve trance states—specialized altered states of consciousness. For all three, ...
[29]
LacusCurtius • Cicero — de Divinatione
### Summary of Cicero's Arguments in *De Divinatione*
[30]
Malleus Maleficarum: The Hammer of Witches | The New York ...
Oct 19, 2020 · Malleus is written in three parts: Part I examines the concept of witchcraft ... Witch trials did decline after 1650, but it is important to ...
[31]
[PDF] Siddhis and Psi Research: An Interdisciplinary Analysis
Abstract. Psi experiences, or siddhis, are one among many varieties of human experiences reported from ancient times across cultural and geogra-.
[32]
The Chinese Cosmos: Basic Concepts
Everything that ever existed, at all times, is made of qi, including inanimate matter, humans and animals, the sky, ideas and emotions, demons and ghosts.
[33]
[PDF] Spiritualism in the 19th Century - AustinTexas.gov
The Fox Sisters' raps and knocks were similar to the Morse alphabet, which had been invented just a few years before, leading the promoters of Spiritualism to.
[34]
Spiritualism in 19th century Lowell - The Town & the City - LibGuides
March 31, 1848 is often set as the beginning of the Spiritualist movement. This is the date that the Fox sisters first claimed that mysterious rapping sounds ...
[35]
[PDF] The rise of spiritualism in nineteenth-century America
Sep 12, 2019 · In 1848 in Rochester, New York, spiritualism materialized as Kate and Margaret Fox, also known as the infamous Fox sisters, communicated with ...
[36]
Henry Sidgwick | Psi Encyclopedia
Oct 14, 2020 · He was a co-founder of the Society for Psychical Research in 1882 and was its first president, contributing largely to its organization and also ...Interest In Psi · Statements About Aims And... · Practical Work
[37]
Extrasensory Perception (ESP) Cards - Duke University
With these ESP/Zener cards, you can find out if they're clairvoyant! Duke's Parapsychology Laboratory was founded in 1930 when Drs. J. B. and Louisa Rhine came ...
[38]
ESPecially intriguing - American Psychological Association
Apr 1, 2008 · Although Rhine did much of the research, he had Zener design the cards since Zener was a perceptual psychologist. In his experiments, Rhine ...
[39]
Early Studies in Parapsychology at Duke
J.B. himself was primarily concerned with ESP and many tests of ability were developed, including the famous Zener card test. Even though the laboratory is no ...
[40]
Historical Figures of the Parapsychological Association
Aug 10, 2025 · ... psychic') experiences, and a resource for those interested in the ... The Parapsychological Association (PA) was founded in 1957 with ...
[41]
Parapsychological Association - Psi Encyclopedia
Jul 29, 2017 · ... founded in 1957 and based in Columbus, Ohio ... The Parapsychological Association (PA) is an international, professional society ...Missing: 1950s | Show results with:1950s
[42]
Society for Psychical Research | Psi Encyclopedia
### Summary of Early Experimental Approaches by SPR (1880s-1900s)
[43]
Extra Sensory Perception : Rhine J. B. - Internet Archive
Oct 22, 2020 · Extra Sensory Perception. by: Rhine J. B.. Publication date: 1935. Topics: Philosophical Systems, Allama Iqbal Library, University of Kashmir, ...
[44]
JB Rhine - Psi Encyclopedia - Society for Psychical Research
Feb 23, 2018 · In April 1934, Rhine published a monograph entitled Extra-Sensory Perception summarizing the first six years of the Duke research – a landmark ...
[45]
Maimonides Dream Telepathy Research | Psi Encyclopedia
Jul 4, 2023 · Successful ESP dreaming experiments were carried out in a sleep laboratory at the Maimonides Medical Center in Brooklyn, New York, between 1964 and 1978.Missing: primary | Show results with:primary
[46]
An Experimental Approach to Dreams and Telepathy - JAMA Network
MONTAGUE ULLMAN, MD ... ESP—Creativity Project: Dream Studies and Telepathy—Preliminary Report of Findings , Department of Psychiatry, Maimonides Hospital of ...Missing: 1960s | Show results with:1960s
[47]
[PDF] Dream Studies and Telepathy - Parapsychology Foundation
"An. Experimental Approach to Dreams and Telepathy," by Montague. Ullman. Biological Psychiatry (Vol. 1, 1969, pp. 259-270). "A Laboratory. Approach to the ...Missing: sources | Show results with:sources<|control11|><|separator|>
[48]
Stage 1 Registered Report: Anomalous perception in a Ganzfeld ...
This meta-analysis is an investigation into anomalous perception (i.e., conscious identification of information without any conventional sensorial means).
[49]
(PDF) What Do We Know About Psi? The First Decade of Remote ...
Aug 7, 2025 · Beginning 1972, three physicists at Stanford Research Institute (now known as SRI International)––Harold Puthoff, Edwin May, and Russell ...
[50]
The Star Gate Archives: Reports of the United States Government ...
The Star Gate Archives provide an extensive overview of the U.S. government-sponsored psi program from 1972 to 1995, particularly focusing on the phenomenon ...<|separator|>
[51]
Feeling the future: Experimental evidence for anomalous retroactive ...
Feeling the future: Experimental evidence for anomalous retroactive influences on cognition and affect. Citation. Bem, D. J. (2011). Feeling the future: ...
[52]
Feeling the future: A meta-analysis of 90 experiments on the ...
Oct 30, 2015 · We here report a meta-analysis of 90 experiments from 33 laboratories in 14 countries which yielded an overall effect greater than 6 sigma.
[53]
The future failed: No evidence for precognition in a large scale ...
(2011). Precognition or pathological science? An analysis of Daryl Bem's controversial “Feeling the Future” paper. Skeptic, 16(4), 28-32.
[54]
Event-Related Electroencephalographic Correlations Between ...
May 17, 2025 · Under certain conditions, the EEG of a sensorially isolated human subject can become correlated with event-related potentials in a distant person's EEG.
[55]
Unveiling the EEG signatures of extrasensory perception during ...
We explored a mediumistic experience called “channeling” where the individual connects with a non-corporeal intelligence (NCI) source.
[56]
(PDF) Assessing 36 Years of the Forced Choice Design in Extra ...
We sampled the recent meta-analyses on ESP studies that used the four most prominent experimental protocols: namely, Forced-Choice (Storm & Tressoldi, 2023) ...
[57]
A Meta-analysis for Extrasensory Perception Experiments in Last 20 ...
Oct 12, 2021 · The meta-analysis aims to detect telepathy's effect in the extrasensory perception (ESP) experiments in the last 20 years.
[58]
Statistical Problems in ESP Research - Science
Some common problems are multiple end points, subject cheating, and unconscious sensory cueing. Unfortunately, such problems are hard to recognize from ...Missing: randomization | Show results with:randomization
[59]
Methodological Criticisms of Parapsychology - ResearchGate
However, few researchers in the field seem willing to argue that such problems prove that the experimental method is flawed or that it should ...
[60]
Meta-Analysis and the Filedrawer Effect | Skeptical Inquirer
Dec 1, 2002 · Radin is aware of the file-drawer effect, in which only positive results tend to get reported and negative ones are left in the filing cabinet.
[61]
9 Paranormal Phenomena | Enhancing Human Performance
Suggested Citation:"9 Paranormal Phenomena." National Research Council. 1988. Enhancing Human Performance: Issues, Theories, and Techniques.<|control11|><|separator|>
[62]
A Bayes factor meta-analysis of Bem's ESP claim
May 15, 2011 · ESP seems contradicted by well-substantiated theories in physics and biology. Consequently, it is reasonable to have low prior odds on ESP.
[63]
[PDF] Testing 'The Girl with X-Ray Eyes' - Skeptical Inquirer
reported that Rosa Kuleshova, a twenty- two-year-old patient, could read with her middle finger and accurately describe magazine pictures. Before long ...
[64]
Dermo-optical Perception: A Peek Down the Nose - jstor
After the publicity about Rosa, Rus- sian women of all sorts turned up, performing even more sensational feats of eyeless vision. The most publicized of these ...Missing: debunked | Show results with:debunked
[65]
Debunking Seeing Without Sight - Time Magazine
Feb 6, 2002 · Randi's explanation of Natalia's earlier success was simple. He had noticed an unusual concavity in the bridge of her nose and discerned, from ...Missing: dermo- | Show results with:dermo-
[66]
Becoming Eusapia: The rise of the “Diva of Scientists”
Jan 28, 2022 · Eusapia Palladino was a fraud. Moreover, she had already been accused of fraud many times in her long career. She was, therefore, a ...
[67]
[PDF] 'I Am Houdini! And You Are a Fraud!' - Skeptical Inquirer
There are also a number of slides detailing how to produce fraudulent spirit phenomena, including the production of spirit mes- sages on slates, the ...
[68]
[PDF] AN EVALUATION OF THE REMOTE VIEWING PROGRAM - CIA
The part of the program review conducted by the American Institutes for Research ... These operations continued until the Spring of 1995, when the program ...
[69]
Failing the Future: Three Unsuccessful Attempts to Replicate Bem's ...
Mar 14, 2012 · Failing the Future: Three Unsuccessful Attempts to Replicate Bem's ... failed to produce significant effects (combined n = 150; combined p = .
[70]
SFE: Psychology - SF Encyclopedia
Aug 26, 2024 · Thus a story like Edgar Allan Poe's "The Facts in the Case of M. Valdemar" (December 1845 American Whig Review) invites classification as sf ...
[71]
10 Coolest Movie Depictions of Psychic Powers - MovieWeb
Aug 24, 2023 · Psychic powers, or extrasensory perception (ESP), are paranormal abilities that allow individuals to perceive or interact with information ...
[72]
SFE: ESP - SF Encyclopedia
Mar 10, 2025 · An acronym for extra-sensory perception which was popularized by the pioneering exercise in parapsychology, Extra-Sensory Perception (1934) by JB Rhine.
[73]
Real ESP Experiments Inspired 'Stranger Things' - Inverse
Aug 11, 2016 · The closest thing our body has to ESP, Shams muses, is when someone experiences phantom limb phenomenon, which occurs when a person has a limb ...
[74]
Three in Four Americans Believe in Paranormal - Gallup News
Jun 16, 2005 · About three in four Americans profess at least one paranormal belief, according to a recent Gallup survey. The most popular is extrasensory perception (ESP), ...
[75]
Paranormal Phenomena Met With Skepticism in U.S. - Gallup News
Americans are broadly skeptical about each of eight paranormal phenomena tested in a recent Gallup poll.
[76]
Prevalence, patterns and predictors of paranormal beliefs in The ...
A Gallup poll from 2005 showed comparable levels of paranormal belief in the USA, Canada and the UK, with the most popular phenomenon in all three countries ...
[77]
Four out of ten Swedes believe in supernatural phenomena
Mar 7, 2024 · The study shows that around 41 per cent of adult Swedes confirm that they believe in paranormal phenomena, i.e. things that cannot be explained.
[78]
(PDF) Paranormal Sweden? Paranormal beliefs and practices in ...
Jan 31, 2024 · This dissertation aims to study the contemporary occurrence of paranormal beliefs, activities and experiences in Sweden as well as a ...
[79]
Analytic cognitive style predicts religious and paranormal belief
An analytic cognitive style negatively predicted both religious and paranormal beliefs when controlling for cognitive ability as well as religious engagement.
[80]
Cultivating paranormal beliefs: how television viewing, social media ...
Mar 8, 2023 · This study builds on cultivation theory to consider how use of different media – including television, social media, and podcasts – may predict belief in ...Missing: influence | Show results with:influence
[81]
Spirituality Among Americans | Pew Research Center
Dec 7, 2023 · Overall, 70% of U.S. adults describe themselves as spiritual in some way, including 22% who are spiritual but not religious.
[82]
New Polling Data Shows Most People of Faith Would Seek Mental ...
Sep 16, 2024 · A survey released today by the American Psychiatric Association (APA) found that six in 10 adults (60%) agree that their faith or spirituality is an important ...