Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Fenian

The Fenians, encompassing the Fenian Brotherhood founded in the United States in 1858 by John O'Mahony and the closely allied Irish Republican Brotherhood established the same year in Ireland by James Stephens, constituted a secret revolutionary organization dedicated to achieving Irish independence from British rule through physical force and establishing a republic.^[1]^[2]^[3]
The movement drew its name from the ancient Fianna, legendary Irish warriors, and sought to harness the energies of the Irish diaspora, particularly battle-hardened veterans of the American Civil War, to wage guerrilla warfare and invasions aimed at compelling Britain to relinquish control over Ireland.^[4]^[1]
Prominent actions included the 1866 Fenian raids into Canada, highlighted by the Battle of Ridgeway where approximately 600-800 Fenians under John O'Neill achieved a tactical victory against Canadian militia before retreating amid U.S. enforcement of neutrality, and the 1867 Irish uprising, which, despite widespread plotting, collapsed due to inadequate arms, informant betrayals, and swift British suppression, resulting in mass arrests and executions such as those of the Manchester Martyrs.^[1]^[4]
Internal schisms between factions favoring direct action in Ireland versus extraterritorial campaigns, coupled with leadership disputes—such as O'Mahony's ousting—contributed to the organization's fragmentation and decline by the 1880s, though its emphasis on militant separatism influenced subsequent nationalist efforts without delivering immediate sovereignty.^[1]^[2]

Origins and Ideology

Founding and Early Development

The Fenian movement emerged in 1858 as a clandestine effort to achieve Irish independence from British rule through physical force, drawing on the legacy of earlier failed rebellions like that of 1848. James Stephens, a veteran of the Young Ireland uprising, established the Irish Republican Brotherhood (IRB) on March 17, 1858—St. Patrick's Day—in Peter Lanigan's timber yard on Lombard Street, Dublin.^[5] This secret society aimed to organize a democratic republic via coordinated insurrection, recruiting initially among disillusioned nationalists who viewed parliamentary agitation as ineffective.^[2] In parallel, John O'Mahony, an Irish scholar and exile who had fled after participating in the 1848 rebellion, founded the Fenian Brotherhood in the United States the same year as a transatlantic support network for the IRB.^[6] O'Mahony, based in New York, emphasized the organization's ancient Irish nomenclature, deriving "Fenian" from the Fianna, mythical warrior bands led by Fionn mac Cumhaill, to evoke martial heritage and cultural revival.^[3] The American branch leveraged the large Irish diaspora, swelled by the Great Famine (1845–1852), for funding and potential military expertise, particularly from Civil War veterans emerging after 1865. Early development centered on secretive expansion and ideological alignment between the branches. Stephens visited America later in 1858 to forge operational ties with O'Mahony, securing financial pledges and outlining mutual strategies, though tensions arose over leadership and priorities.^[2] By the early 1860s, the IRB had grown to several thousand members in Ireland through a cell-based "circle" structure, while the U.S. Fenians amassed resources amid rising anti-British sentiment fueled by events like the Trent Affair.^[7] These foundations positioned the movement for escalated activities, prioritizing empirical preparation over rhetorical nationalism.

Core Principles and Oath

The Fenian movement, comprising the Irish Republican Brotherhood in Ireland and its counterpart the Fenian Brotherhood in the United States, centered on the goal of Irish separation from British rule to form an independent democratic republic governed by universal male suffrage.^[7] This republican ideal rejected monarchical governance and emphasized self-determination through revolutionary action, drawing inspiration from the United Irishmen of 1798 and Young Irelanders of 1848, while prioritizing physical force over parliamentary reform.^[7] The organizations advocated non-sectarian unity among Irish people, though membership was predominantly Catholic, and they sought to harness the Irish diaspora, particularly in America, for financial and military support to enable uprisings.^[8] Membership required swearing a binding oath of allegiance to the prospective Irish Republic, with variations between the Irish and American branches reflecting leadership differences but unified in commitment to independence. James Stephens, founder of the IRB in 1858, instituted an oath pledging members to exert utmost effort "at every risk" to achieve a democratic republic, sever ties with Britain, abstain from British offices or loyalist bodies, take up arms when ordered, and obey superiors.^[9] The full text read: "I, A.B., do solemnly swear, in the presence of Almighty God, that I will do my utmost, at every risk, while life lasts, to make Ireland an independent democratic Republic; that I will sever the connection with the British Empire, and that I will not hold office in the British Empire, or knowingly remain a member of any political body that upholds its rule and government; that I will, when called upon, take up arms to fight for a free Ireland, and that I will obey and comply with all orders issued to me by my superior officers. So help me God."^[9] John O'Mahony's Fenian Brotherhood oath, established in 1858, similarly affirmed allegiance to the "Irish Republic, now virtually established," vowing utmost defense of its independence and implicit obedience to officers, though it omitted explicit mention of arms to align with American legal sensitivities.^[10] These oaths enforced secrecy and loyalty, binding members under penalty of expulsion or worse for betrayal, and underscored the movement's conspiratorial structure amid British suppression.^[10] Despite factional tensions over strategy—such as O'Mahony's caution versus Roberts' advocacy for invading Canada—the oaths symbolized shared dedication to republican separatism.^[11]

Organizational Structure and Internal Dynamics

Irish Republican Brotherhood

The Irish Republican Brotherhood (IRB) was established on March 17, 1858, in Dublin by James Stephens, a veteran of the 1848 Young Irelander rebellion, with the explicit goal of achieving Irish independence through revolutionary means.^[5] Stephens, born in Kilkenny in 1825 and trained as a civil engineer, initiated the organization in Peter Lanigan's timber yard on Lombard Street East, drawing on disillusionment with constitutional nationalism following the failed 1848 uprising and the Great Famine's demographic catastrophe.^[2] The IRB operated as a clandestine, oath-bound fraternity, mirroring the contemporaneous Fenian Brotherhood founded by John O'Mahony in the United States, with both groups coordinating to amass resources for an armed insurrection against British rule.^[12] Membership required swearing a binding oath of allegiance to the principle of an independent democratic republic, pledging utmost efforts to subvert British authority in Ireland "by force of arms" if necessary, while maintaining absolute secrecy under penalty of expulsion or worse.^[9] The oath, formalized around 1859, invoked Almighty God and committed initiates to labor unceasingly for the republic's establishment, eschewing loyalty to any foreign government.^[9] This ritual underscored the IRB's absolutist commitment to physical-force separatism, rejecting parliamentary paths as futile given Britain's entrenched dominance.^[13] Organizationally, the IRB adopted a cellular structure to evade detection, comprising local "circles" led by centers reporting to higher provincial councils, culminating in a Supreme Council functioning as the provisional government of a virtually extant Irish Republic.^[14] Stephens served as the inaugural "Head Centre," wielding dictatorial powers initially to build the network, which expanded rapidly among urban artisans, rural laborers, and returning emigrants radicalized by American Fenianism, reaching an estimated 1,500 members by late 1858.^[2] Internal discipline was enforced through military-style commissions, with Stephens emphasizing recruitment from the Irish Confederate and Tenant League circles, though tensions arose over his autocratic style and delays in launching the anticipated rising.^[5] By 1863, the IRB had formalized its governance with a constitution vesting supreme authority in an elected Supreme Council of 23 members, including a president, secretary, and treasurer, while prohibiting dual membership in non-republican bodies to prevent dilution of revolutionary zeal.^[15] Stephens' leadership faltered amid scandals, including his 1866 arrest and escape, leading to factional challenges from figures like John O'Leary and Thomas Luby, who criticized the organization's over-reliance on American funding without commensurate action.^[2] Despite these dynamics, the IRB's rigid hierarchy and oath-enforced loyalty sustained its role as the ideological core of Fenianism, infiltrating later groups like the Irish Volunteers and influencing the 1916 Easter Rising through persistent IRB veterans.^[16]

Fenian Brotherhood in America

The Fenian Brotherhood in America, also known as the American Fenians, was founded on March 17, 1858, in New York City by John O'Mahony, an Irish exile and former Young Irelander, as the counterpart to James Stephens' Irish Republican Brotherhood in Ireland.^[17] O'Mahony, who had arrived in the United States in 1856, modeled the organization on secret societies like the French Carbonari and aimed to unite Irish immigrants toward establishing an Irish republic through revolutionary means.^[6] The Brotherhood's oath committed members to bear arms against England and its allies, fostering a militant Irish republican ideology among the diaspora.^[3] By the end of the American Civil War in 1865, the Brotherhood had grown significantly, drawing on Irish-American veterans who gained military experience in Union and Confederate armies; estimates of active membership ranged from 50,000 to over 250,000, though Fenian leaders often inflated figures for propaganda purposes.^[18]^[19] The organization established "circles" in major cities like New York, Chicago, and Philadelphia, raising funds through picnics, lectures, and subscriptions to support arms procurement and potential invasions.^[1] Under O'Mahony's leadership as "Head Centre," the group initially prioritized aiding an uprising in Ireland, shipping weapons and funds across the Atlantic while deferring direct action in North America.^[20] A strategic shift emerged in 1865, with some leaders advocating raids into British Canada to seize territory as leverage for Irish independence, exploiting post-Civil War demobilization and U.S. sympathy for Irish nationalism.^[21] In April 1866, O'Mahony authorized a small raid on Campobello Island near Eastport, Maine, involving about 100 Fenians who briefly raised the Irish flag before U.S. authorities intervened and arrested O'Mahony himself.^[22] The most notable incursion occurred in June 1866 under the rival faction led by William R. Roberts, who had split from O'Mahony's conservative wing to form the "Senate" group favoring immediate Canadian attacks.^[20] On June 1, approximately 1,500 Fenians under Colonel John O'Neill crossed the Niagara River from Buffalo, New York, landing near Fort Erie, Ontario; they defeated a Canadian militia force of similar size at the Battle of Ridgeway on June 2, marking the only Fenian victory against British colonial troops.^[23]^[24] O'Neill's force looted the area before withdrawing due to lack of supplies and U.S. naval blockade, with many participants arrested upon return.^[21] Internal divisions deepened the Brotherhood's fractures: O'Mahony's faction emphasized coordination with Ireland, while Roberts' aggressive approach prioritized Canada, leading to competing treasuries and raids that diluted resources.^[22]^[25] By 1867, U.S. government crackdowns under neutrality laws, combined with British countermeasures, curtailed major activities, though splinter efforts persisted into the 1870s. O'Mahony's death in 1877 further fragmented the group, reducing its influence despite initial momentum from Irish-American grievances over famine-era emigration and British rule.^[6]^[3]

Factional Splits

The Fenian Brotherhood in the United States, established in 1858 by John O'Mahony under the guidance of James Stephens of the Irish Republican Brotherhood (IRB), initially operated as a supportive arm for Irish independence efforts, but strategic differences soon emerged.^[3] O'Mahony regarded the American organization as an equal partner to the IRB, focused on fundraising and arms procurement for a coordinated uprising in Ireland, whereas Stephens viewed it primarily as a subsidiary to finance and supply the IRB's Irish operations.^[3] These tensions intensified after the American Civil War, as U.S. Fenians, buoyed by returning Irish-American veterans, pressed for autonomous military action against British interests, particularly invasions of Canada to coerce concessions on Ireland.^[20] By late 1865, internal divisions led to the formation of a Fenian Senate by Midwestern leaders, challenging O'Mahony's authority during a congress in Philadelphia on November 4.^[20] William R. Roberts, a New York businessman, was elected president, splitting the Brotherhood into two factions: O'Mahony's group, loyal to Stephens and emphasizing coordination with Ireland, and Roberts' more aggressive wing, prioritizing immediate Canadian raids without awaiting an Irish rising.^[20] The schism reflected broader acrimony over leadership and tactics, with Roberts' faction commanding greater resources and membership support.^[7] The factions pursued divergent actions in 1866, underscoring the split's disruptive impact. O'Mahony's supporters launched a failed incursion from Eastport, Maine, on April 15, targeting Campobello Island but withdrawing without significant engagement due to U.S. naval intervention.^[26] In contrast, Roberts' group executed the Battle of Ridgeway in Canada West (Ontario) on June 1–2, where approximately 1,000 Fenians under Colonel John O'Neill defeated Canadian militia before retreating amid British reinforcements.^[20] These uncoordinated efforts diluted Fenian strength and invited harsher British and American suppression. The 1867 IRB rising's failure in Ireland deepened rifts, as arrests of leaders like Stephens fragmented unity and sparked debates between militants advocating continued violence and others favoring political mobilization for broader support.^[7] By then, the IRB had recruited up to 50,000 members but mobilized only about 10,000 for the abortive rebellion, highlighting organizational weaknesses exacerbated by transatlantic divisions.^[7] Roberts' faction dominated American Fenianism thereafter, evolving into groups like Clan na Gael, while O'Mahony's influence waned until his death in 1877.^[3]

Key Military and Revolutionary Activities

1867 Rising in Ireland

The 1867 Rising, organized by the Irish Republican Brotherhood (IRB), aimed to establish an Irish republic through armed insurrection against British rule.^[27] Led by figures such as Thomas J. Kelly, the IRB's deputy central organizer and a veteran of the American Civil War, the rebellion followed the arrest of IRB founder James Stephens in December 1865 and internal efforts to coordinate with American Fenian support.^[28] Planning included a provisional government proclaimed in London, with an initial scheme to seize arms from Chester arsenal on February 11 aborted due to informers, shifting the focus to Ireland on March 5.^[27] A proclamation issued on March 4 declared the formation of a republic based on universal suffrage and called for mass mobilization, estimating 200,000 sworn IRB members in Ireland, of whom about 40,000 were adequately armed.^[27] Execution began prematurely in some areas, with up to 10,000 Fenians mobilizing nationwide, though coordination faltered amid British infiltration and poor communication. In the Dublin region, particularly Tallaght, approximately 7,000 rebels assembled as a diversionary force, capturing police barracks at Dundrum, Stepaside, and Glencullen before clashing with a small police detachment led by Sub-Inspector Dominic Burke; this "Battle of Tallaght" resulted in two Fenian deaths and six injuries, with most insurgents dispersing into the hills.^[29] Skirmishes occurred elsewhere, including 1,000 gathering in Drogheda, the seizure of Ballyknockane barracks and Knockadoon coastguard station in Cork, and attacks on police in Killmallock, Limerick, where two rebels died; efforts to disrupt rail and telegraph lines also failed to materialize broadly.^[27] The rising collapsed within 24 hours due to arrests of key leaders like General Massey in Cork on March 4, whose capture yielded plans, compounded by snowstorms, lack of unified command, and informers such as JJ Corydon.^[29]^[27] British forces, forewarned, suppressed outbreaks rapidly, resulting in about 200 arrests and a total of 12 deaths nationwide on March 5, eight of them Fenians. No major battles ensued, and while American Fenians dispatched the ship Erin's Hope with arms on April 13, it arrived too late and failed to land effectively.^[27] The IRB avoided executions of rising participants in Ireland, opting instead for imprisonment, though the event prompted suspension of habeas corpus and heightened British countermeasures.^[29]

Raids on Canada

The Fenian raids on Canada consisted of cross-border incursions launched by the Fenian Brotherhood's American branch from 1866 to 1871, with the explicit goal of capturing and holding Canadian territory to compel Britain to grant independence to Ireland. These operations drew on Irish-American Civil War veterans, leveraging their military experience and the unguarded U.S.-Canada border to stage invasions from New York and Vermont into Ontario and Quebec. Leaders like John O'Neill, a former Union cavalry officer, directed the efforts, viewing Canada as Britain's "Achilles heel" due to its colonial status and sparse defenses. Despite initial tactical successes, the raids ultimately failed due to British reinforcements, Canadian militia resistance, and U.S. enforcement of neutrality laws under Presidents Andrew Johnson and Ulysses S. Grant.^[30]^[31] The principal raid occurred along the Niagara frontier in June 1866. On June 1, approximately 800 Fenians under O'Neill's command crossed the Niagara River from Buffalo, New York, landing near Fort Erie, Ontario, after commandeering vessels and evading initial U.S. patrols. They fortified positions and marched inland, proclaiming an Irish republic on Canadian soil. The next day, June 2, O'Neill's force of about 750 engaged roughly 850 Canadian volunteers, mainly from the Queen's Own Rifles and other Toronto militia units, at the Battle of Ridgeway. Employing superior tactics learned from the U.S. Civil War, the Fenians outmaneuvered and routed the less experienced Canadians, who suffered 9 killed and 37 wounded, while Fenian losses totaled around 9 dead and 14 wounded. Later that day, Fenians repelled a Canadian counterattack at Fort Erie, inflicting additional casualties without significant losses of their own.^[24]^[31]^[30] However, the incursion collapsed rapidly thereafter. U.S. authorities, responding to British diplomatic pressure, dispatched gunboats to block Fenian supply lines and arrested over 700 participants upon their retreat across the border on June 3. British regular troops from Toronto arrived too late for Ridgeway but reinforced the area, preventing further advances. A concurrent minor raid in April 1866 on Campobello Island, New Brunswick, involved about 40-50 Fenians who briefly landed but withdrew after encountering local resistance and British naval forces, with no significant combat. These events exposed defensive weaknesses in British North America, contributing to momentum for Canadian Confederation in 1867 as provinces sought unified military capabilities.^[24]^[31] In 1870, O'Neill, elected president of the Fenian Brotherhood, attempted a resurgence with a raid from St. Albans, Vermont, into Quebec. On May 25, roughly 300 Fenians advanced toward Eccles Hill near Frelighsburg, aiming to link with sympathizers and establish a base. They encountered immediate opposition from local Canadian militia, including the Missisquoi North Division Volunteers and hastily mobilized farmers, who used terrain advantages and rifle fire to halt the advance. In the ensuing skirmish, Fenians suffered several killed and wounded, including O'Neill himself, who was shot in the leg; the raid disintegrated within hours, with most invaders captured or fleeing back to the U.S. This final major effort underscored the Fenians' logistical shortcomings and declining support, as U.S. troops under Grant's orders intercepted reinforcements and supplies. Canadian forces reported minimal losses, primarily wounded, affirming the effectiveness of local defenses bolstered by post-1866 reforms.^[32]^[33]^[30]

Dynamite Campaign in England

The Dynamite Campaign in England, spanning from January 1881 to January 1885, marked a tactical evolution for elements within the Irish Republican Brotherhood (IRB) and Fenian Brotherhood, shifting from open insurrection to covert dynamite bombings aimed at eroding British resolve through urban disruption and fear. Primarily directed by Irish-American Fenians, including figures such as Jeremiah O'Donovan Rossa, John Devoy, and Patrick J. Tynan, the operations were funded via the "Skirmishing Fund" raised in the United States and involved operatives trained in explosive handling at a dynamite school in Brooklyn, New York. These attacks targeted symbolic sites of British power and infrastructure, such as public buildings and transport hubs, with timers and detonators used to enable timed detonations, often placed during off-peak hours to limit immediate fatalities while amplifying propaganda value.^[34]^[35] Early phases in 1881 and early 1883 focused on northern English targets before escalating to London, reflecting a strategy to extend the "Irish question" into British civilian life without the scale of prior incidents like the 1867 Clerkenwell bombing, which had killed 12 and injured over 100. The campaign's 1884-1885 intensification included coordinated strikes, culminating on 24 January 1885—known as "Dynamite Saturday"—with near-simultaneous explosions at the Tower of London, Westminster Crypt, and the House of Commons chamber, causing property damage but no reported deaths in these specific blasts. Overall, the bombings resulted in minimal verified casualties, aligning with perpetrators' stated intent to avoid mass slaughter, though they inflicted widespread alarm, property destruction, and economic strain on British cities.^[34]^[35] British authorities responded with intensified surveillance and arrests, leading to the capture of approximately 20 suspects by early 1885; one, Denis Deasy, died in custody under disputed circumstances, while others endured severe penal conditions, including reports of induced insanity from solitary confinement. The campaign fractured Fenian unity, as American backers debated its efficacy against diplomatic alternatives, ultimately ceasing after these setbacks and contributing to a temporary "new departure" in IRB strategy toward political agitation. Despite limited material success, it established a precedent for dynamite as a tool in Irish republicanism, influencing perceptions of Fenianism as synonymous with indiscriminate urban violence in British discourse.^[34]^[35]

Activities in Australia

Fenian activities in Australia primarily involved Irish immigrants and transported political prisoners from the 1867 rising, with secret societies forming in eastern colonies like New South Wales and Victoria amid growing Irish nationalist sentiment. These groups, extensions of the Irish Republican Brotherhood, focused on fundraising and propaganda for the Irish cause rather than large-scale insurrections, though colonial authorities monitored them closely due to fears of subversion. A notable incident occurred on March 12, 1868, when Henry James O'Farrell, an Irish-born Fenian sympathizer in Sydney, attempted to assassinate Prince Alfred, Duke of Edinburgh, during a public picnic at Clontarf Beach, shooting him in the back with a revolver. O'Farrell claimed the act was motivated by republican principles and orders from Fenian leaders, though evidence of direct IRB involvement remains contested; he was convicted of attempted murder and hanged on April 21, 1868, sparking anti-Irish riots and heightened suppression of suspected Fenians across the colonies.^[36]^[37] In Western Australia, 62 Fenian prisoners arrived aboard the Hougoumont on January 9, 1868, marking the last convict transport to the colony; most were military men sentenced to penal servitude for treason-felony related to the IRB. Subjected to forced labor in areas like the Swan River valley, they endured harsh conditions, with civilian Fenians granted early releases by 1869 while military prisoners remained confined in Fremantle Prison. Escape efforts defined their resistance: John Boyle O'Reilly fled in February 1869 via an American whaler arranged by local sympathizers, later becoming a prominent Irish-American journalist. The most celebrated action was the Catalpa rescue on April 17–19, 1876, when six prisoners—Thomas Darragh, James Darragh, Martin Hogan, Michael Haggerty, Peter Lyons, and Robert Cranston—absconded from work parties using horses and wagons, rowed to the U.S. whaler Catalpa off Rockingham, and evaded British pursuit to reach New York in August, funded and planned by Clan na Gael leaders John Devoy and John Breslin.^[38]^[39] These events highlighted limited but audacious Fenian operations in Australia, constrained by isolation and colonial policing, ultimately aiding global awareness of the Irish republican struggle without sparking local revolts. Post-release, some ex-prisoners integrated into Australian society, contributing to labor and cultural movements, while others emigrated to continue activism abroad.^[38]^[39]

Suppression and Decline

British Countermeasures

In anticipation of Fenian uprisings, the British Parliament passed the Habeas Corpus Suspension (Ireland) Act 1866 on February 15, 1866, empowering authorities to arrest and detain suspects without charge or trial to preempt revolutionary activities.^[40] This measure facilitated the apprehension of over 1,000 individuals suspected of Fenian affiliations between February 1866 and early 1867, significantly disrupting organizational structures.^[41] The Act's implementation involved widespread raids coordinated by the Royal Irish Constabulary and military intelligence, leveraging informants to identify key figures such as IRB leaders.^[42] Following the outbreak of the 1867 rising on March 5, British forces, numbering around 8,000 troops, rapidly mobilized to quell scattered engagements, resulting in the capture or dispersal of Fenian units within days.^[43] Martial law was selectively enforced in hotspots like Tallaght and Stepaside, where confrontations led to Fenian casualties and arrests exceeding 100 participants.^[44] Judicial responses included special commissions for treason-felony trials, with over 100 convictions in Dublin during 1867, many resulting in penal servitude or transportation to Australia.^[45] High-profile executions served as deterrents, notably the hanging of William Allen, Michael O'Brien, and Michael Larkin—the Manchester Martyrs—on November 23, 1867, for their role in the September 18 rescue of Fenian prisoners in Manchester, which killed a police sergeant.^[46] Similarly, Michael Barrett was executed on May 26, 1868, for the Clerkenwell bombing that December, which claimed 12 civilian lives.^[47] To counter Fenian operations in Britain, particularly the dynamite campaign from 1881, the Metropolitan Police established the Special Irish Branch in March 1883, a dedicated unit for surveillance and infiltration of Irish republican networks.^[48] This precursor to modern counter-terrorism employed undercover agents and expanded arrest powers under the Prevention of Crimes Act 1882, leading to the dismantling of bombing cells and the conviction of figures like Thomas Clarke. British strategy emphasized intelligence over brute force, incorporating coastal watches and port controls to curb arms smuggling from America.^[49]

Factors Contributing to Failure

The Fenian movement encountered significant organizational deficiencies that precipitated its operational failures, particularly evident in the disjointed execution of the 1867 rising in Ireland. Leaders proclaimed the rebellion prematurely on February 28, 1867, after British authorities arrested key figures like Thomas Clarke Luby and others in late 1866, disrupting coordinated mobilization across counties such as Dublin, Cork, and Tipperary.^[49] Only scattered groups totaling around 1,500 to 2,000 poorly armed insurgents mobilized, lacking sufficient weaponry—many relied on pikes or improvised arms—and facing harsh weather that exacerbated logistical breakdowns.^[50] ^[51] Internal factionalism further eroded effectiveness, as divisions between the Irish Republican Brotherhood in Ireland and the American Fenian Brotherhood intensified after 1865. In the United States, rivalry between John O'Mahony's conservative faction, favoring support for Ireland over direct action, and William Roberts' militant group, which pursued unauthorized raids into Canada, fragmented fundraising and strategy; by 1866, these splits had led to competing conventions and diluted transatlantic unity.^[52] The IRB's refusal to endorse either American faction post-1867 rising deepened isolation, channeling resources into futile debates rather than sustained operations.^[1] Broader societal resistance compounded these issues, with limited grassroots enthusiasm in Ireland despite initial recruitment of up to 40,000 members in the mid-1860s. Rural tenantry, burdened by post-Famine economic precarity, prioritized land reform over revolution, while urban Catholic clergy, led by figures like Archbishop Paul Cullen, denounced Fenianism as a mortal sin, excommunicating participants and withholding moral sanction that might have broadened participation.^[7] This ecclesiastical opposition, rooted in the Church's alignment with constitutional nationalism, alienated potential allies and reinforced perceptions of the movement as a fringe conspiracy rather than a mass uprising.^[53] Strategic miscalculations, including overreliance on American funding that proved unreliable after failed incursions like the 1866 Battle of Ridgeway—where 700 Fenians retreated due to supply shortages—prevented scaling up efforts.^[54] By the 1870s, these cumulative weaknesses shifted Fenian remnants toward controversial tactics like the dynamite campaign, which alienated moderate supporters and accelerated decline without achieving independence.^[52]

Controversies and Criticisms

Accusations of Terrorism and Civilian Harm

The Fenians, particularly elements of the Irish Republican Brotherhood, were accused of terrorism by British authorities and the press for employing explosives against civilian-adjacent targets in urban Britain, with the intent to coerce political concessions on Irish independence through fear and disruption. These accusations centered on incidents where bombings endangered or directly harmed non-combatants, contrasting with the group's self-framing as legitimate revolutionaries targeting imperial symbols. Historical analyses describe such tactics as early examples of urban terrorism, involving indiscriminate explosives in populated areas to amplify psychological impact beyond military objectives.^[34]^[55] A pivotal case was the Clerkenwell Outrage on December 13, 1867, when Fenians detonated approximately 4 barrels of gunpowder—equivalent to 500 pounds—against the wall of Clerkenwell Prison in London to facilitate the escape of prisoner Michael Burke, a convicted Fenian. The blast demolished 60 feet of the prison wall and collapsed nearby tenements housing civilians, killing 12 people including women and children, and injuring at least 120 others with flying debris and structural failures.^[56]^[57] Contemporary reports from The Times and other outlets condemned the act as a "diabolical outrage," attributing it to Fenian operatives who miscalculated the charge's power or disregarded bystander risks during exercise hour when prisoners and locals were proximate. Michael Barrett, identified as a participant, was tried, convicted based on witness testimony, and hanged publicly on May 26, 1868—the last such execution in Britain—intensifying public outrage and anti-Fenian sentiment.^[56]^[58] The later dynamite campaign, launched by Irish-American Fenian factions like Clan na Gael from 1881 to 1885, escalated these accusations through over 20 timed bombings in English cities, targeting landmarks such as the London Underground, Tower Bridge, and Scotland Yard to symbolize vulnerability of British power. While Fenian leaders like Thomas Clarke claimed warnings were issued to evacuate areas and casualties avoided—citing no direct deaths in most blasts—the operations inherently risked civilian lives due to dynamite's volatility and placement in public infrastructure, injuring several bystanders and police in incidents like the January 1881 Salford explosion and the October 1883 Whitehall attempt.^[34]^[35] British parliamentary records and press, including The Times, labeled the campaign "dynamite terror," arguing it prioritized spectacle over precision, fostering widespread panic equivalent to modern terrorism definitions involving civilian intimidation for political ends.^[59] Fenian apologists countered that targets were governmental, not personal, but evidentiary trial records of convicted bombers like the "dynamiters" group under Henry Dalton reveal premeditated urban disruption without foolproof safeguards against collateral harm.^[60] These events fueled broader condemnations, with British Prime Minister William Gladstone's administration enacting the 1883 Explosive Substances Act in response, framing Fenian methods as morally equivalent to assassination plots despite the group's ideological claims of anti-colonial warfare. Accusations persisted in historical scholarship, noting how civilian proximity in dense Victorian cities amplified harm, undermining Fenian narratives of restraint and contributing to their isolation from moderate Irish nationalists.^[61]^[55]

Strategic and Ideological Shortcomings

The Fenian strategy relied heavily on external support from Irish-American expatriates, whose enthusiasm for invasion contrasted with the limited mobilization capacity in Ireland, resulting in factional splits such as the 1865 schism between John O'Mahony's conservative wing and the more aggressive Roberts faction, which undermined unified action.^[49] The raids into Canada, commencing with the 1866 incursion at Ridgeway where approximately 800 Fenians briefly defeated Canadian militia on June 2, ultimately faltered due to U.S. enforcement of neutrality under the Foreign Enlistment Act, leading to arrests and dispersal without provoking Anglo-American war as anticipated.^[31] ^[62] Subsequent raids in 1870 and 1871 similarly collapsed, holding no territory long-term and exposing logistical vulnerabilities like inadequate supply lines.^[63] In Ireland, the 1867 rising exemplified tactical disarray, with uncoordinated skirmishes—such as the attack on Tallaght on March 21 involving fewer than 200 poorly armed men—failing to ignite broader revolt amid informant penetration and absence of popular backing, allowing British troops to suppress operations within days.^[64] The later dynamite campaign in Britain (1881–1885), launching over 20 bombings including the January 24, 1885, House of Commons attempt, prioritized disruption over precision, causing minimal strategic damage while inviting backlash through civilian risks and operational blunders like premature detonations.^[34] ^[35] Ideologically, Fenian republicanism's insistence on physical-force separatism as the sole path to a democratic republic neglected integration with agrarian reforms, alienating the post-Famine peasantry whose priorities centered on land rights rather than abstract sovereignty.^[7] The secretive, oath-bound structure, requiring vows of absolute obedience, fostered paranoia and limited mass recruitment, contrasting with open constitutional nationalism under figures like Isaac Butt.^[49] Condemnation by the Catholic Church, including Pius IX's 1865 encyclical viewing Fenianism as incompatible with papal loyalty, eroded clerical and conservative Irish support, framing the movement as godless radicalism.^[65] This isolation persisted, as the ideology's disdain for compromise precluded alliances during the Land War (1879–1882), rendering Fenianism a fringe force despite inspirational rhetoric.^[66]

Relations with Irish and Broader Communities

The Fenian Brotherhood encountered significant opposition from the Catholic Church hierarchy in Ireland, which condemned the organization in pastoral letters and excommunications starting in the mid-1860s, primarily due to its secret oaths perceived as incompatible with religious loyalty and its advocacy for armed revolution against British rule.^[67]^[68] Church leaders, including Archbishop Paul Cullen of Dublin, viewed Fenianism as a moral and social threat, arguing it promoted atheism and disorder among the faithful, leading to widespread clerical influence against recruitment in rural parishes where priests held sway over congregants.^[67] This ecclesiastical hostility limited grassroots support in Ireland to urban centers and working-class enclaves, with estimates of active Fenian membership never exceeding 5,000-10,000 despite broader sympathy for independence, as many Irish nationalists favored constitutional paths under figures like Isaac Butt.^[7]^[49] In contrast, the Irish diaspora, particularly in the United States, provided crucial financial and organizational backing, with the American Fenian Brotherhood—founded in 1858 by John O'Mahony—raising tens of thousands of dollars through subscriptions and picnics to fund the 1867 rising and Canadian raids.^[1]^[69] This transatlantic solidarity stemmed from famine-era grievances and Civil War veterans' military experience, yet internal rifts, such as the 1865 schism between factions favoring immediate action versus coordinated efforts with Ireland, eroded unity and diaspora enthusiasm post-failures.^[70] American Irish communities faced repercussions, including U.S. government crackdowns under neutrality laws after the 1866 Ridgeway raid, which strained relations with host society institutions wary of foreign entanglements.^[49] Relations with British and colonial communities were predominantly adversarial, as Fenian dynamite campaigns in England from 1881 onward targeted infrastructure like the 1883 London Underground explosion, fostering widespread fear and anti-Irish sentiment that reinforced stereotypes of disloyalty among the Irish immigrant underclass in industrial cities.^[49] In Canada, the 1866-1871 raids provoked defensive mobilizations and lingering resentment, with Fenian incursions like the Battle of Ridgeway on June 2, 1866, briefly victorious but ultimately alienating potential sympathizers by associating Irish nationalism with invasion.^[68] Broader European and Australian Irish networks offered limited support, hampered by distance and local authorities' suppression, though prisoner amnesties in the 1870s garnered some cross-community petitions from labor groups wary of Fenian extremism.^[7] Overall, Fenian militancy isolated the movement from moderate reformers, contributing to its marginalization within Irish and expatriate circles favoring parliamentary agitation.^[49]

Legacy and Contemporary Perceptions

Influence on Irish Nationalism

The Fenian Brotherhood and its Irish counterpart, the Irish Republican Brotherhood (IRB), established a tradition of revolutionary republicanism that emphasized armed insurrection against British rule, influencing subsequent nationalist strategies toward physical force over parliamentary reform. Founded in 1858, these organizations pledged members to an oath supporting the creation of an independent Irish republic based on democratic principles and universal male suffrage, rejecting monarchical governance as incompatible with Irish sovereignty.^[7] This ideological framework persisted despite the failure of the 1867 uprising, which, though suppressed, elevated executed leaders to martyr status and sustained underground networks committed to separatism.^[71] The IRB's covert structure enabled it to infiltrate and direct later formations, notably the Irish Volunteers established in 1913 to counter the Ulster Volunteers' unionist mobilization. By 1916, IRB leaders such as Thomas Clarke and Seán Mac Diarmada dominated the military council, orchestrating the Easter Rising on April 24, which proclaimed an Irish Republic and directly invoked Fenian precedents in its call for national self-determination.^[72] ^[73] Although the Rising resulted in over 450 deaths and the execution of 15 leaders, it radicalized public opinion, eroding support for Home Rule and propelling Sinn Féin from obscurity to victory in the 1918 general election, where it secured 73 seats on a republican abstentionist platform.^[74] This Fenian-derived militancy shaped the Irish Republican Army (IRA), formed in 1919 from the Volunteers as the military wing of the First Dáil, engaging in guerrilla warfare during the War of Independence (1919–1921) that compelled the Anglo-Irish Treaty and partition.^[73] The IRB's emphasis on disciplined conspiracy and rejection of compromise influenced the anti-Treaty IRA faction in the Civil War (1922–1923) and later iterations, embedding a separatist ethos that prioritized territorial unity over negotiated autonomy.^[75] Fenian tactics, including diaspora fundraising and transnational raids, also modeled sustained external support, as seen in Irish-American backing for 20th-century campaigns.^[76]

Modern Political and Cultural Usage

In Northern Ireland, the term "Fenian" has evolved into a sectarian slur primarily used by Protestants and unionists to derogatorily refer to Catholics, Irish nationalists, or republicans, detached from its original historical context of the 19th-century Fenian Brotherhood. This pejorative application, which connotes association with revolutionary violence and separatism, appears in verbal abuse, graffiti, and online rhetoric, exacerbating communal divisions rooted in the Troubles and earlier conflicts. For instance, in 2024, a Merseyside police officer faced scrutiny for using the term without recognizing its offensive connotations toward Irish Catholics in a sectarian context.^[77] Similarly, during sectarian incidents, such as a 1999 killing involving taunts of "Fenian Nigger," the word has been linked to violence against perceived Catholic targets.^[78] In Scotland, "Fenian" functions analogously as an ethnic and religious epithet, especially in football culture surrounding the Celtic-Rangers rivalry, where it targets Celtic fans perceived as aligned with Irish Catholic heritage and nationalism. This usage reinforces anti-Irish sentiment among some Protestant communities, appearing in chants and supporter banter that echo historical animosities toward Fenian-style republicanism.^[79] Academic analyses of sacralized politics in Northern Ireland note its casual deployment as a marker of "otherness" against those favoring Irish unity, highlighting how the term perpetuates identity-based antagonism without reference to the original movement's ideology.^[80] Politically, "Fenian" lacks endorsement by contemporary groups, with modern Irish republicanism—such as Sinn Féin—eschewing the label in favor of broader constitutional strategies, though rhetorical invocations persist in unionist critiques of unification efforts. Culturally, it surfaces in literature, media depictions of sectarianism, and public discourse on legacy issues, serving more as a symbol of entrenched tribalism than active ideology, with no verifiable adoption by political parties or cultural movements post-1922 Irish independence.

Usage in Northern Ireland and Scotland

In Northern Ireland, the term "Fenian" functions as a sectarian slur predominantly used by Protestant unionists to derogatorily refer to Catholics, Irish nationalists, or republicans, evoking historical associations with the 19th-century Fenian Brotherhood's revolutionary activities against British rule.^[77] This usage persists in everyday discourse, political tensions, and public incidents, such as a 2024 case where a Merseyside Police officer was sanctioned for misconduct after directing the term at a Northern Irish colleague, highlighting its perceived offensiveness in professional and legal contexts.^[77] Despite its origins in Irish republicanism, contemporary application often strips away historical nuance, serving instead to signal tribal loyalties amid the region's divided ethno-religious landscape, where such language can escalate community frictions without reference to the original Fenian movement's ideological goals.^[81] In Scotland, "Fenian" similarly operates as a pejorative, most prominently in the polarized atmosphere of Old Firm football derbies between Celtic F.C. (with its Irish Catholic heritage and fanbase) and Rangers F.C. (linked to Protestant unionism), where it is hurled as abuse implying disloyalty to British institutions or sympathy for Irish separatism.^[82] Scottish courts have equated its sectarian impact to the reciprocal slur "Hun" directed at Rangers supporters, as affirmed in a 2023 ruling that classified such terms as aggravating factors in hate crime prosecutions due to their role in fostering division based on perceived religious or national affiliations.^[82] Incidents include a 2021 Ross County match where fans were investigated for chanting "dirty Fenian bastards" at Celtic players, underscoring enforcement efforts by football authorities to curb its normalization in stadiums.^[83] This linguistic persistence reflects broader Scottish-Irish diasporic tensions, though usage remains confined largely to working-class, football-centric subcultures rather than mainstream political rhetoric.^[84] Cross-regional patterns show the term's adaptability as a marker of "otherness" in Protestant-majority enclaves, with little evidence of reclamation by targeted groups in these areas, unlike sporadic ironic adoptions elsewhere; instead, it reinforces binary oppositions inherited from 19th-century conflicts, including Fenian raids and risings that fueled British propaganda portraying the movement as treasonous.^[81] Legal and institutional responses in both jurisdictions treat it as hate speech when contextually abusive, prioritizing de-escalation over historical rehabilitation, though debates persist on whether censoring such terms stifles free expression or merely polices symptoms of unresolved sectarian undercurrents.^[82]^[84]

References

[1]
Celebrating Irish Americans: The Fenian Brotherhood
Mar 25, 2021 · One of the earliest American-born organizations was the Fenian Brotherhood, founded in 1858 by Irish immigrants John O'Mahony and Michael Doheny.Missing: activities | Show results with:activities
[2]
Stephens, James - Dictionary of Irish Biography
Stephens, James (1825–1901), nationalist and co-founder of the Fenian movement, was, according to local tradition and baptismal records, born in July 1825 ...
[3]
O'Mahony, John | Dictionary of Irish Biography
O'Mahony, John (1815–77), founder of the Fenian Brotherhood and Gaelic scholar, was born probably on 12 January 1815 at Clonkilla, near Mitchelstown, Co. Cork.
[4]
Rebels on the Niagara | State University of New York Press
The group behind the invasion-the Fenian Brotherhood-was formed in 1858 by Irish nationalists in New York City in order to fight for Irish independence from ...Missing: activities | Show results with:activities
[5]
The Irish Republican Brotherhood - History Ireland
On St Patrick's Day 1858, in Peter Lanigan's timber yard, Lombard Street, Dublin, James Stephens formally established the Irish Republican Brotherhood.
[6]
John O'Mahony | Revolutionary, Fenian Brotherhood, Irish Republic
John O'Mahony was the founder of the American branch of the Fenian Brotherhood, an Irish nationalist secret society active in Britain and the United States ...
[7]
The Fenians: An Overview - The Irish Story
Mar 7, 2017 · On the 150th anniversary of the Fenian Rebellion of 1867, John Dorney gives an overview of the Fenian movement. The word 'Fenian' conjures ...Missing: primary | Show results with:primary
[8]
Reconstructing Liberty, Right Principles, and the Fenian Brotherhood
Dec 22, 2017 · They fiercely criticized the Democratic Party; promoted black suffrage and equal rights; supported the temperance movement; openly disparaged ...Missing: core | Show results with:core
[9]
[PDF] 1859 OATH OF THE IRISH REPUBLICAN BROTHERHOOD - Cartlann
I, A.B, do solemnly swear, in the presence of Almighty God, that I will do my utmost, at every risk, while life lasts, to make Ireland an independent ...Missing: text | Show results with:text
[10]
Two Fenian Oaths | Encyclopedia.com
I, A.B., in the presence of Almighty God, do solemnly swear allegiance to the Irish Republic, now virtually established; and that I will do my very utmost, at ...
[11]
Reconstructing Liberty, Right Principles, and the Fenian Brotherhood
This essay is an attempt to rescue from relative obscurity a pro-Fenian newspaper, the Irish Republic , published in Chicago from May 1867 until April 1868.Missing: core | Show results with:core
[12]
James Stephens - Kilkenny Archaeological Society
Aug 20, 2024 · James Stephens, a Kilkenny man, founded it on 17th of March 1858. Around the same time John O'Mahoney founded the Fenians in New York.
[13]
Irish Republican Brotherhood
The Irish Republican Brotherhood (IRB) was a secret organization founded in Dublin in 1858 by James Stephens (1824–1901) to secure the creation of an ...
[14]
The Irish Republican Brotherhood
The IRB, a secret, oath-bound organisation, was hierarchical, with a Supreme Council, the government of the Irish Republic, now 'virtually established'.Missing: organization | Show results with:organization
[15]
Irish Republican Brotherhood Constitution: As Revised to Date 1920
Two copies of constitution of the Irish Republican Brotherhood, titled 'Constitution as revised to date 1920', issued "By order of the Supreme Council", with ...
[16]
Irish War of Independence | National Army Museum
... oath-bound organisations. The most significant to emerge in the 19th century was the Irish Republican Brotherhood (IRB). Founded in 1858, the IRB was ...
[17]
The Fenian Brotherhood Records and O'Donovan Rossa Personal ...
This includes proceedings of Fenian Conventions, versions of the Fenian Constitution, versions of the Fenian By-Laws, and speeches made to the organization.Missing: primary | Show results with:primary
[18]
Fenian Brotherhood Collection on JSTOR
The Fenian Brotherhood, formed in 1858, aimed to overthrow British rule in Ireland. The collection includes letters, ledgers, and other documents.
[19]
The Irish-American Social Club Whose Exploits in Their Homeland ...
Mar 21, 2019 · Warren was one of perhaps 250,000 Irish-Americans who joined the Fenian Brotherhood, organized in 1858 to “perpetuate our undying hatred of ...Missing: activities | Show results with:activities
[20]
American Fenians | The Fenian Brotherhood in America 1860s-1880s
May 31, 2025 · The Fenian Brotherhood evolved from the Emmet Monument Association in the United States in 1858. Founded by Young Irelander exiles John O'Mahony and Michael ...
[21]
The Fenian Raids - Canadian War Museum
During the largest raid, in June 1866 along the Niagara frontier, the Fenians defeated a small Canadian force at Ridgeway. The Fenians returned to the United ...
[22]
A Brief History of the - RootsWeb
A split occurred in the Brotherhood as William Randall Roberts led a splinter group called the "Senate Wing" in opposition to O'Mahony and Stephens. Roberts ...
[23]
Battle of Ridgeway | The Canadian Encyclopedia
May 30, 2016 · Fenian raids were armed incursions into Canadian territory between 1866 and 1871. The Fenians intended to seize and hold Canadian territory in ...
[24]
The Fenian Raid 1866
On 1 June 1866, the Fenians invaded Canada. With 1,500 men they crossed the Niagara River just north of Fort Erie. Upon landing they established a defensive ...
[25]
The Fenians - Dictionary of Canadian Biography
One wing, led by O'Mahony, believed that Irish American republicans should send men, money, and materiel across the Atlantic to support a revolution in Ireland.
[26]
https://americanfenians.wordpress.com/2021/04/19/the-april-1866-fenian-fizzle/
[27]
Fenian Rebellion of 1867 - History of Ireland - YourIrish.com
Aug 20, 2024 · The Provisional Government next set March 5th as a new date for the Fenian Rebellion. On March 4th, 1867 The Times received a proclamation ...
[28]
Kelly, Thomas J. - Dictionary of Irish Biography
In early 1865, Kelly's prior army experience as a communications and tactical advisor led the American Fenian Brotherhood to appoint him one of an American team ...
[29]
'In every generation' – An Irishman's Diary on the Fenian rising of ...
Feb 28, 2017 · The death toll across the country was 12. Wisely, the British refused to make martyrs of the ringleaders, a lesson forgotten almost a half ...
[30]
John O'Neill & the Fenian Raids into Canada
Aug 5, 2019 · Official Report of Gen. John O'Neill, President of the Fenian Brotherhood: On the Attempt to Invade Canada, May 25th, 1870.
[31]
The Fenian Raids in Canada West - Ontario Heritage Trust
In the two hours of fighting, the Canadian militia suffered nine deaths and 33 casualties (four of whom later died). The Fenians are estimated to have suffered ...<|separator|>
[32]
The Fenian Raids | QAHN
Another raid occurred in 1870 at Eccles Hill (not far from Pigeon Hill), when 400 Fenians under the command of "General" John O'Neill, President of the Fenian ...<|control11|><|separator|>
[33]
Last Fenian Raid-Vermont-Quebec Border: 25 May-7 June 1870
Colonel John O'Neill, the former US cavalry officer who had led the first Fenian raid into Canada in 1866, launched what would prove to be the final Fenian ...
[34]
The Fenian Dynamite campaign 1881-85 - The Irish Story
Feb 13, 2012 · Irish-American Fenianism undertook a sustained terrorist campaign incorporating a series of explosions in British urban centres.
[35]
The Fenian Dynamite Campaign and the Irish American Impetus for ...
Irish-American Fenians undertook a sustained terrorist campaign executing a series of explosions in British urban centres.
[36]
Lone Wolf Republican | The life of Henry James O'Farrell - HeadStuff
Aug 7, 2018 · ... Henry O'Farrell's failed assassination is the Royal Prince Alfred Hospital in Sydney. After the attempt on his life, Prince Alfred decided ...<|control11|><|separator|>
[37]
150 Years on – The Story of Australia's First Attempted Political ...
Convicted of attempted murder, and hanged soon after on 21 April at Darlinghurst Gaol, clemency had been refused to O'Farrell, despite evidence of mental ...
[38]
The Fenians I Fremantle Prison Characters
The Fenian movement, or Irish Republican Brotherhood, was a secret society that flourished during the 1860s. Its activities included an armed rebellion against ...
[39]
[PDF] The Fenians in Australia - Cork Historical and Archaeological Society
Feb 20, 2017 · The transportation of the 62 to Western. Australia took place in the wake of the Fenian rising of 5 March 1867, and the events in Man chester ...
[40]
Habeas Corpus Suspension (Ireland) Bill - Hansard - UK Parliament
Hansard record of the item : 'Habeas Corpus Suspension (Ireland) Bill' on Saturday 17 February 1866.
[41]
Union Rebels: Civil War Veterans & the Fenian Campaign in Britain ...
Feb 23, 2016 · ... Fenian Campaign in Britain & Ireland, 1866 ... Habeas Corpus Suspension Act released from Imprisonment, and Number arrested, February 1866-67.
[42]
Coercion in Nineteenth Century Ireland - The Irish Story
Apr 26, 2019 · The suspension of Habeas Corpus acts was aimed at both nationalist and agrarian crime. The Quarterly review listed 17 murders of landlords, ...<|separator|>
[43]
Ireland's Wars: The 1867 Rebellion | Never Felt Better
Nov 2, 2016 · ... British response. The 8'000 or so Fenians couldn't help but be noticed when they gathered and marched, and local police moved to block their ...<|separator|>
[44]
The Lasting Impact Of The Fenian Rising of 1867 - Éirígí
Mar 14, 2019 · Larkin, Allen and O'Brien – “The Manchester Martyrs” – were hanged for a daring rescue of Fenian leaders in which a police constable died.
[45]
The Fenian Conspiracy - Hansard - UK Parliament
The Government has taken Steps to obtain correct Reports of the Evidence given upon the Trials for Treason and Participation in the Fenian Conspiracy.
[46]
The tale of the Manchester Martyrs - People's History Museum
Nov 22, 2019 · William Allen, Michael Larkin, and Michael O'Brien were executed on 23 November 1867 for the murder of Sergeant Charles Brett and hanged outside the New Bailey ...
[47]
Executed men remembered in London | An Phoblacht
Jun 3, 2021 · Republicans in London assembled in late May to lay wreaths and remember two executed patriots; the falsely accused Fenian Michael Barrett - executed in 1868.
[48]
The Metropolitan Police Force - GCSE History by Clever Lili
❖ In 1883 a 'Special Irish Branch' was set up to monitor the activity of Irish terrorists called Fenians. This later became known simply as Special Branch.
[49]
What Happened to the Fenians After 1866? - TeachingHistory.org
In 1866, the Fenian Brotherhood conducted three military incursions into Canada after plans for an insurrection in Ireland had fallen apart due to British raids ...
[50]
Today in Irish History –The Fenian Rebellion, March 5, 1867
Mar 5, 2011 · The Rising, which had never properly started, was over. A total of 12 people were killed on March 5, of whom eight were Fenians.
[51]
Exploring the 1867 Fenian Rising in Cork
Mar 6, 2017 · In addition, the American Fenians dispatched the vessel Erin's Hope to Ireland on 13 April 1867 with a supply of arms to support the effort (1) ...
[52]
Francis B. Gallagher collection of Fenian Brotherhood records
The papers document the Brotherhood's activities, including its failed invasion of Canada, as well as the internal divisions that led to the organization's ...
[53]
Patriotism as Pastime: The Appeal of Fenianism in the Mid-1860s
Young Ireland days gave virtually no support. More striking still, the ... cipline partly explains their lack of support for fenianism in the 1860s. By ...
[54]
[PDF] Irish Revolutionaries and the Invasion of Canada (1848-1871)
Doheny placed much of the blame for their failure on their lack of preparation and military training, and he immediately set out to address the problem. The ...
[55]
Fenianism and the Martyrdom-Terrorism Nexus in Ireland before ...
Irish Republicanism came to be associated with both martyrdom and terrorism in the nineteenth century with the growth of the “Fenian” movement.<|separator|>
[56]
From the archive, 14 December 1867: Many killed as Fenians try to ...
Dec 14, 2010 · An attempt was made to blow up the House of Detention, Clerkenwell Green. It is said that some men were observed to place a barrel against a newly-built ...
[57]
Fenian explosion at Clerkenwell Prison | London Museum
This aquatint shows the explosion at Clerkenwell Prison caused by a bomb planted by the Irish Republican Brotherhood.
[58]
The Clerkenwell explosion, and why the Fenians mattered
Dec 2, 2017 · Twelve people were killed and another 50 injured. The Irish Times condemned the attack as a “diabolical Fenian outrage”. The explosion had a ...
[59]
Weinger Essay: The Fenian Dynamite Campaign in the British Press
Jun 20, 2022 · Between 1881 and 1885, extreme Irish nationalists waged a campaign of urban terrorism—dubbed the 'Fenian dynamite campaign'—against targets ...
[60]
How the British Press Reported the Fenian Dynamite Campaign ...
Jan 24, 2022 · On a winter evening thick with fog in January 1881, the campaign began. A group of men, under the cover of darkness, placed a time-delayed ...
[61]
[PDF] The Disreputable Legacies of Fenian Violence in Nineteenth-Century
In short the symbolic logic of the bombings indicates their importance as an archetype for much subsequent urban terrorism. The attacks were part of the ' ...
[62]
Fenian Raids - The War That Never Happened - Military History Online
The war to free Ireland was an audacious strategy that failed. Who Were the Fenians? ... Sweeny's strategy was to make a three-pronged attack: Brigadier Charles ...
[63]
Why Did the Fenians Attack Canada? - About Canadian History
Jun 21, 2017 · Despite the fact that the Fenian Raids (1866-1871) all ended in failure, their history is tied up with that of Canadian Confederation.
[64]
135 years ago: the Fenian uprising suppressed - Archive - Irish Echo
Feb 16, 2011 · Although the Fenian rising of 1867 failed to spark a mass revolt to overthrow British rule, it did succeed in stimulating nationalist ...
[65]
The Catholic Church and the Fenian Brotherhood of New York City
At first, the Fenians failed to believe the condemnation, attributing initial reports to British troublemakers. 51 When they recognized that the statement ...
[66]
The Fenians: Rise and Decline | Workers' Liberty
Mar 18, 2012 · But our criticism of the elements of this to be found already in the early Fenians is very relative and highly qualified. They were more or less ...
[67]
The Catholic Church and Fenianism - History Ireland
The struggle between the Catholic Church and the Fenians, as this evolved in the mid-nineteenth century, had its origins in the wider context of the church's ...
[68]
Fenian Risings for Irish Independence | Research Starters - EBSCO
The Fenian Risings were a series of attempts by Irish nationalists in the mid-to-late 19th century to end British rule in Ireland.
[69]
Irish-America: A Journey from the Fenian Raids to NORAID
Sep 28, 2025 · The Irish diaspora in America had maintained its Irish identity for over 70 years since the Famine by actively supporting the fight for Irish ...
[70]
The Fenian Movement: A reflection on threat to Church and State in ...
Nov 6, 2020 · [64] Moody writes that the mass body of Fenians in Ireland “rendered indispensable help” in its ultimately success. ... lack of definition to ...
[71]
What Was The Fenian Brotherhood? And Was Ellen Cochrane Real?
Sep 25, 2025 · The Fenian Brotherhood was a revolutionary nationalist movement founded in the late-1850s among Irish emigrants in the United States, and its ...Missing: core | Show results with:core
[72]
Easter Rising | National Army Museum
But the militant Irish Republican Brotherhood, along with sections of the Irish Volunteers and Irish Citizen Army, opted for a violent response.
[73]
Implications Of The 1916 Easter Rising: An Analysis Of Irish ...
Jan 10, 2023 · The Fenians worked as a covert governing order of their desired Irish Republic and provided the framework and leadership for the failed 1916 ...
[74]
The Easter Rising - Never Such Innocence
A number of the volunteers had come under the inﬂuence of the Irish Republican Brotherhood (IRB), a secret revolutionary society that saw the world war as an ...
[75]
[PDF] The Resurrection of Ireland: The Sinn Féin Party, 1916–1923
It was the successor of the Fenians, the more flexible of whom had engaged in electoral politics and had co-operated briefly with. Parnell in the 'new departure ...
[76]
[PDF] IRISH AMERICAN TRANSNATIONAL ... - ScholarSpace
leaders…the Fenian brotherhood in Ireland fell to pieces. –Yet, notwithstanding all this, the Fenian conspiracy was by no means subdued; for the defeat which ...
[77]
Merseyside PC 'misunderstood' anti-Irish term 'Fenian' - BBC
Oct 22, 2024 · However it has since evolved into an offensive term for Irish Catholics and is often used in a sectarian context.
[78]
[PDF] Sectarianism: The Key Facts - Equality Coalition
Feb 17, 2020 · He was killed by a car after taunts of 'Fenian Nigger' led to him confronting a group of loyalist youths (McKittrick et al.1999: 1400).
[79]
Fenian - Wiktionary, the free dictionary
Antonyms: (slang, sometimes derogatory) Orangey, (slang, sometimes derogatory) Prod. (chiefly Northern Ireland, Scotland, derogatory, offensive). Synonyms ...
[80]
Northern Ireland (Part VII) - When Politics are Sacralized
Jun 10, 2021 · Let me pause here to unfold the terminology that my schoolmate so casually deployed. “Fenian” (from the nineteenth-century Republican ...Missing: credible | Show results with:credible
[81]
How to spot and call out sectarianism | Metro News
May 19, 2021 · Fenian: A derogatory term used to describe Catholics or Irish republicans. Tarrier: A derogatory term used to describe Irish people or Catholics ...
[82]
Judges rule using word 'Hun' for Rangers fans IS a sectarian slur
Oct 9, 2023 · “It is, in that respect, no different to the use of the term 'fenian' as a form of sectarian abuse to describe Celtic supporters who are ...
[83]
Ross County working to identify fans who aimed sectarian abuse at ...
Dec 17, 2021 · Sectarian slurs can be heard in the sickening 45-second clip at the Scottish Premiership match, including 'dirty fenian b*******'. Article ...
[84]
Swearing and calling police “hun” was aggravated breach
Oct 9, 2023 · ... slur for an individual of the Protestant faith. The term had been directed at the police, whom the accused did not know; Rangers had not ...