Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Knowledge Navigator

The Knowledge Navigator is a visionary concept for a personal information appliance developed by Apple Inc. in 1987, portrayed in a six-minute promotional video as a foldable, tablet-like device featuring an intelligent digital assistant named Phil that facilitates voice-activated interactions, video conferencing, document management, and access to networked information resources. Commissioned by then-CEO John Sculley for his keynote address at the EDUCOM conference, the video depicted a scenario set in the year 2011 where a university professor uses the device to coordinate schedules, retrieve and summarize research articles, update visual charts, and conduct seamless video calls with colleagues. The project was led by designer Hugh Dubberly in collaboration with Apple's research team, including key contributions from futurist Mike Liebhold on technical concepts and product designer Gavin Ivester on the device's , and was completed in just six weeks on a $60,000 budget. Conceptual influences drew from MIT's Architecture Machine Group and such as William Gibson's , emphasizing networked collaboration, hypertext navigation, and anticipatory AI agents integrated with multimedia interfaces, with advice from Apple Fellow . The video's production involved with sketches, mockups, and a single day of live-action shooting directed by Randy Field, without a full , to evoke a tangible yet aspirational future for personal computing. Key features showcased in the video included a with a large, high-resolution display, for videoconferencing, wireless connectivity for sharing, and an embodied assistant that proactively suggests actions, scans printed text by holding the device against it, and maintains context across conversations—elements that anticipated modern hardware like the and software capabilities such as . The assistant's allowed for fluid queries, such as requesting article summaries or calendar integrations, highlighting a human-centered approach to in an era of emerging digital libraries and global networks. Though never realized as a product due to technological and market constraints at the time, the Knowledge Navigator has endured as a seminal artifact in computing history, inspiring Apple's later innovations in mobile devices and , and influencing industry visions for intelligent personal assistants that bridge physical and digital worlds. Its legacy persists in contemporary developments like Apple Intelligence, which as of 2024 enhances on-device for tasks echoing the video's demonstrations, underscoring how the concept presciently outlined the trajectory toward ubiquitous, proactive computing.

Development

Origins

The term "Knowledge Navigator" was coined by Apple CEO in his 1987 book Odyssey: Pepsi to Apple... A Journey of Adventure, Ideas, and the Future, co-authored with John A. Byrne, where it appeared in the epilogue as a visionary concept for future personal computing. Sculley's vision portrayed the Knowledge Navigator as a portable device functioning as an intelligent intermediary, enabling users to access and navigate expansive information networks through natural interaction, drawing inspiration from contemporaneous advancements in , networking, and compact portable . This concept emphasized the device as a proactive assistant that would anticipate user needs, integrate voice and visual interfaces, and connect to distributed bases, reflecting Sculley's broader optimism about democratizing information access. The idea emerged within Apple's strategic pivot following the 1984 Macintosh launch, as the company grappled with intensifying competition from IBM's PC dominance in markets and sought to reinforce its leadership in and productivity tools. Under Sculley's leadership, Apple aimed to differentiate through innovative, user-centric visions that positioned computing as an empowering tool for learning and knowledge work, countering the enterprise focus of rivals. In 1987, initial internal discussions at Apple refined this concept in preparation for Sculley's keynote at the EDUCOM conference, a key forum for , where themes of integrating computing into aligned closely with the Knowledge Navigator's emphasis on networked learning environments. These deliberations, involving Apple's advanced group, adapted the book's abstract ideas into a more tangible demonstration to showcase the company's forward-thinking direction amid industry challenges. The resulting 1987 promotional video served as the primary public embodiment of this evolving vision.

Video Production

The Knowledge Navigator video was commissioned by Apple for John Sculley's keynote speech at the EDUCOM conference in October 1987, with Bud Colligan, Apple's director of marketing, serving as the primary sponsor. The project operated under a tight six-week timeline and a $60,000 budget drawn from Apple's marketing funds, necessitating rapid execution from concept to final edit. This promotional piece visualized concepts inspired by Sculley's 1987 book Odyssey: Pepsi to Apple: A Journey of Adventure, Ideas, and the Future, aiming to illustrate future computing paradigms for an academic audience. The production was led by the Dubberly Design Office, with Hugh Dubberly as and , collaborating closely with a multidisciplinary team that included scriptwriter Doris Mitsch, technical advisor Mike Liebhold from Apple's Advanced Technology Group, device designer Gavin Ivester from the Product Design Group, and director Randy Field. An external , The Kenwood Group, handled filming and as contractors to Apple, while Apple Fellow provided advisory input on the conceptual elements. Without a traditional full , the team relied on snapshots, sketches, and iterative discussions to guide the process, allowing flexibility amid the compressed schedule. Filming techniques combined live action with practical effects and early digital animations to depict the envisioned . A live portraying a professor-like figure interacted with the device in a simulated setting, while the "talking head" agent was realized through to serve as a guide. The clamshell device mockup was constructed as a functional wooden over the course of a week, enabling on-camera manipulation without relying on complex , which was limited by 1987 technology. Interface animations and screen were prototyped using a video paint box system, incorporating Macintosh-era visual styles to evoke a near-future aesthetic, with all computer-display elements developed in just a few days prior to the shoot. The entire shoot was completed in a single 12-hour day to adhere to the budget constraints, capturing key scenes in sequence to minimize setup changes. Major challenges included the absence of extensive time, which forced quick adaptations during filming, and the need to synchronize the video's content precisely with Sculley's speech on emerging trends in educational computing. These hurdles were mitigated through focused team collaboration and the addition of the animated agent midway through development to clarify the human-computer interaction dynamics.

Design and Features

Hardware Design

The Knowledge Navigator was envisioned as a clamshell-style resembling a large , featuring a foldable display that opens like a to reveal an interactive interface. Notebook-sized and resembling a large tablet or book, its design emphasized portability, allowing users to carry and deploy it in various settings such as an office desk. The physical model, crafted by Apple's Product Design Group, incorporated a sturdy hinge mechanism to facilitate smooth opening and closing, enabling the screen to pivot upward from a base unit for ergonomic viewing angles. Key hardware components included a prominent touchscreen display for direct finger-based interaction, such as swiping and tapping to navigate content, surrounded by substantial bezels typical of conceptual aesthetics. A built-in front-facing camera supported video calling capabilities, while integrated and speakers handled voice input and audio output, facilitating hands-free communication. The device also featured a scanning capability to capture printed text by holding documents against the screen. The device was implied to be battery-powered, underscoring its and nature without reliance on external power sources during use. Although no dedicated was shown, the touchscreen allowed for drawing and precise pointing gestures directly with the user's finger. Ergonomically, the Knowledge Navigator prioritized user comfort through its lightweight construction—estimated to be manageable for one-handed carrying—and a prop-up stand integrated into the base for stable tabletop positioning during extended sessions. The hinge design balanced durability with ease of use, preventing strain during repeated folding, and the overall reduced desk clutter compared to bulkier peripherals of the era. These elements reflected thoughtful integration of peripherals, making the device suitable for professional environments. In contrast to 1987's hardware landscape, dominated by the stationary Macintosh with its fixed monitor and separate keyboard, the Knowledge Navigator represented a departure toward compact, all-in-one portability. While the offered color graphics and expansion slots, it lacked the integrated , video hardware, and foldable mobility conceptualized here, highlighting Apple's forward-thinking push beyond desktop constraints.

User Interface and Software

The Knowledge Navigator featured a touch-based graphical user interface (GUI) that utilized windows, icons, and hyperlinked information nodes to enable intuitive navigation through vast databases of knowledge. This design extended the principles of Apple's software, introduced in , which allowed users to interact with "stacks" of digital cards containing text, graphics, and links, but adapted them to a fully networked environment where data could be dynamically pulled from remote sources. The interface supported gesture-based interactions on a high-resolution color , permitting users to point, drag, and manipulate visual elements without keyboards or typing, predating modern tablet computing paradigms. Voice-activated controls formed a core component of the software, enabling queries for tasks such as scheduling appointments or retrieving information, with the system's assistant responding through both verbal and on-screen visuals. For instance, the assistant, depicted as an animated , could verbally notify users of incoming calls or events, like a member's reminder, and facilitate video conferencing by connecting parties seamlessly. This multimodal approach combined touch inputs for precise selections—such as zooming into interactive maps showing rainfall trends over regions like the or —with voice commands for broader directives, ensuring an intuitive that emphasized conversational interaction over rigid menus. Key software features included integrated calendar management, where the AI proactively handled reminders and rescheduling; email-like message handling for personal communications, such as voice or video notes from contacts; and dynamic data visualization tools that generated charts, maps, and simulations from external networked sources to support research or presentations. Users could, for example, compile environmental data on and share it via video links during collaborative sessions, with the interface hyperlinking related nodes to deepen exploration. These elements highlighted the system's emphasis on personalized, agent-mediated assistance, where the software learned user preferences to curate and present information efficiently.

Core Technologies

Artificial Intelligence Elements

The Knowledge Navigator featured a personified AI assistant named , depicted as a advisor with a human-like appearance, including a bowtie, designed to engage users through natural conversation. This assistant utilized to interpret informal and ambiguous user requests, such as locating an article "from about five years ago" by "Dr. Flemson or something," and to respond contextually without requiring explicit prompts like "Okay, ." In the conceptual video, maintained conversational threads, advancing interactions by summarizing information and confirming actions, thereby simulating a trusted personal companion. Proactive capabilities were central to Phil's design, allowing the assistant to anticipate user needs and initiate actions independently. For instance, Phil alerted the user to incoming messages, noted a colleague's delay due to , and autonomously managed tasks like initiating video calls. Over time, the system was envisioned to learn from user preferences by tracking history, relationships, and behaviors, enabling personalized recommendations such as prioritizing certain types of news or calendar integrations. These features positioned Phil as an that not only responded to commands but also enhanced productivity through foresight, briefly integrating fetched via networking for timely suggestions. The AI's knowledge representation relied on linked databases that interconnected disparate sources, facilitating synthesis of information into coherent outputs. Phil could pull from calendars, , feeds, and encyclopedic libraries to generate summaries, such as compiling rainforest simulation data up to 2010 or cross-referencing academic papers with user notes. This hypertext-like structure, influenced by existing technologies, allowed the assistant to navigate vast information worlds, displaying results like maps or visualizations on the device's . Envisioned in , the Knowledge Navigator's was constrained by the era's technological landscape, primarily relying on rule-based systems for rather than the approaches that would later enable more adaptive . Conceptual limitations included challenges in achieving seamless context awareness and in constant monitoring, reflecting the conceptual nature of the demo produced under tight constraints without novel algorithmic inventions.

Networking and Data Access

The Knowledge Navigator concept envisioned a networked computing environment that connected users to remote databases through either wireless or wired links, forming the backbone for accessing a "global knowledge network" of interconnected information resources. This system predated the widespread adoption of the internet, drawing inspiration from emerging hypertext and database technologies to enable seamless retrieval from centralized servers housing vast libraries of data. In the demonstration video, the device interfaces with a "University Research Network," allowing users to query and visualize geographic data, such as deforestation rates across regions, by pulling from distributed academic repositories. Central to data access were hypertext linking mechanisms, which permitted browsing through multimedia content in a non-linear fashion, akin to early visions of the . Users could navigate linked articles, journal entries, and directories via voice commands, with examples including the retrieval of recent publications on environmental topics or lecture notes from previous semesters stored in networked databases. The AI assistant briefly interprets these queries to fetch and organize results, such as displaying predictive models for ecological trends from interconnected sources. This approach emphasized conceptual navigation over rigid search structures, prioritizing integrated access to maps, directories, and simulations from university libraries. Video conferencing features integrated real-time audio-video transmission, enabling over the network for collaborative purposes. In the video scenarios, the user initiates a call to a colleague in , where the system handles connection setup and displays the participant on a large screen, facilitating discussions on shared research data. This capability extended to lectures or meetings, with the network supporting low-latency transmission to simulate global connectivity without the infrastructure limitations of the . The design highlighted the fusion of communication and , allowing mid-call access to supplementary information like geographic visualizations during conversations.

Demonstration

Key Scenarios

The 1987 Knowledge Navigator demonstration video illustrates practical applications through a narrative depicting of a named , showcasing the device's seamless integration into daily workflows. In the morning routine scenario, the user opens the clamshell-style device on his desk, prompting the AI agent, , to inform him of three messages: a check-in from the , a student's request for an extension, and a reminder from his mother about his father's birthday party. reviews his , highlighting key appointments such as a faculty lunch at 12:00, taking Kathy to the airport by 2:00, and a at 4:15 on Amazon deforestation, enabling efficient planning without manual input. The research and collaboration scenario emphasizes professional interactions, where the professor queries the device for lecture notes and recent journal articles on Amazon deforestation. Phil retrieves resources such as Jill Gilbert’s article on deforestation effects, displaying interactive maps and simulations of topics like the spread of the Sahara desert and Amazon changes over 20 years; this transitions into a video call with colleague Jill Gilbert, where shared documents are reviewed in , allowing discussion of correlations between global environmental patterns, including challenges to CO2 projections from John Fleming’s 2006 article, while the AI facilitates data exchange. The professor and Jill integrate maps to simulate logging at 100,000 acres per year, with Phil printing the article and arranging a follow-up meeting. Information synthesis is highlighted as the device pulls and links disparate sources to address complex queries, such as combining journal articles with geographic maps and simulations to form a cohesive overview of global environmental trends like . autonomously correlates from various sources, presenting synthesized visuals and insights that the user can manipulate via gestures, underscoring the system's ability to navigate and interconnect across domains without user intervention.

Production Credits

The production of the 1987 Knowledge Navigator video was led by Hugh Dubberly, who served as and at Apple Creative Services, overseeing the conceptualization and execution to align with Apple's vision for future computing. John , Apple's CEO at the time, originated the core concept—drawing from his book : Pepsi to Apple—and presented the video during his at the Educom conference, while Bud Colligan, director of marketing, acted as , securing the $60,000 and ensuring the project met Apple's marketing objectives within a tight six-week timeline. The creative team included writer Doris Mitsch, who co-authored the script with Dubberly to depict everyday scenarios of knowledge navigation, and interface designers such as Gavin Ivester and Adam Grosser from Apple's Product Design Group, who prototyped the device's visuals, including a wooden model for reference. Animators and specialists from The Kenwood Group, the contracted , handled the futuristic animations using early video paintbox tools, under the direction of Randy Field and with cinematography by Bill Zarchy. Technical input came from Mike Liebhold of Apple's Advanced Technology Group, who provided expertise on networking and elements, supplemented by research consultations with Paul Saffo, Bob Johansen, and Aaron Marcus. Performers in the video included an portraying the university professor interacting with the AI assistant "Phil" in the primary scenario, voice talents providing dialogues for the assistant and other characters, and a in the family usage vignette, though specific names for these roles remain uncredited in production records. Supporting roles encompassed producers Jane Hernandez and executive producer Christina Crowley from The Kenwood Group, who managed logistics, timeline adherence, and budget allocation to keep the project on track for its Educom premiere. Special acknowledgments went to contributors like Audrey Crane, , Chris Hoover, and for additional production support.

Reception and Legacy

Contemporary Reception

The Knowledge Navigator concept, unveiled through a video during John Sculley's keynote at the EDUCOM 1987 conference, received positive feedback from the higher education community, who praised its visionary depiction of technology's role in education and its potential to inspire innovative AI applications for learning. Attendees appreciated the portrayal of an intelligent personal assistant that could facilitate interactive knowledge exploration, sparking discussions on integrating advanced computing into academic environments. Media coverage in the late 1980s highlighted the concept's ambition while acknowledging the technological limitations of the era. In a November 1987 Macworld interview, Sculley described the Knowledge Navigator as a 21st-century capable of navigating vast information resources through voice interaction, support, and user-adaptive learning, positioning it as a transformative tool for productivity and creativity. Similarly, a December 1987 Compute! magazine feature quoted Sculley envisioning the device as an entertaining educational interface akin to Star Wars or , feasible by the early with advancing technology. The video's public debut at the 1988 Macworld Expo further amplified its acclaim, with tech publications and mainstream outlets like hailing it as Apple's bold new vision for personal computing. Internally at Apple, the video boosted employee morale during a period of product development challenges and resource strains, serving as a motivational tool in meetings and fostering a sense of forward-thinking . It inspired subsequent projects, such as Project 2000, though it did not lead to immediate product development due to the company's focus on incremental Macintosh enhancements rather than radical pursuits. Critics viewed the concept as overly optimistic, questioning its near-term practicality given the 1980s' rudimentary voice recognition and networking capabilities. Analysts in early 1989 described it as more inspirational than achievable roadmap, reflecting broader skepticism about Apple's ability to bridge visionary ideas with feasible hardware amid competitive pressures.

Long-term Influence

The Knowledge Navigator concept video, released by Apple in 1987, anticipated many features of later portable computing devices, most notably the 2010 , which featured a interface, integrated video calling via , and an app ecosystem for tasks such as calendar management and document access—elements reminiscent of the video's depiction. In the realm of , the Knowledge Navigator foreshadowed key advancements in voice-activated personal assistants, directly inspiring Apple's , introduced in 2011. The video's portrayal of a contextual, proactive —capable of scheduling, retrieving , and engaging in natural —aligned with 's core traits as a voice-driven helper integrated into devices. This lineage extended further with the 2024 rollout of Apple Intelligence, which incorporates on-device generative for enhanced contextual awareness, such as summarizing notifications and personalizing responses, echoing the video's vision of an intelligent companion that anticipates user needs. As of September 2025, Apple Intelligence received updates including enhanced Visual Intelligence for searching and taking action on visual content, and additional features for more natural interactions, continuing to realize elements of the video's anticipatory . Co-creator Tom Gruber has explicitly referenced the Knowledge Navigator as a foundational influence on 's humanistic design principles. Beyond Apple, the concept popularized hyperlinked knowledge navigation and intelligent interfaces across the industry, reminiscent of tablet prototypes like Microsoft's in 2009, which featured dual-touchscreen and gesture-based paradigms for productivity tasks similar to the Navigator's multifunctional design. The concept anticipated smart assistants such as , with their emphasis on seamless, voice-mediated contributing to the broader ecosystem of where devices act as extensions of human cognition. The enduring cultural legacy of the Knowledge Navigator is evident in retrospectives that highlight its prescience, such as analyses drawing direct parallels to the iPad's debut and discussions linking it to contemporary challenges. These examinations often tie the concept to ethical considerations in deployment, including in proactive assistants and the societal implications of , underscoring its role in prompting ongoing debates about human- interaction.

References

  1. [1]
    The Making of Knowledge Navigator - Dubberly Design Office
    Mar 30, 2007 · Most of the technical and conceptual input came from Mike Liebhold. We collaborated with Gavin Ivester in Apple's Product Design Group who ...
  2. [2]
    Apple Intelligence inches closer to Apple's 1987 Knowledge Navigator
    Jun 12, 2024 · Knowledge Navigator is a famous six-minute video created for John Sculley in 1987, and depicting life in what was meant to be the far future of around 2011.
  3. [3]
    Apple's 1987 Knowledge Navigator video - Fast Company
    Jul 25, 2023 · Apple's 1987 'Knowledge Navigator' video depicted a future that's still a work in progress. From its folding screen to full-motion ...
  4. [4]
    How Apple Invented The Future (and the iPad) in 1986 - Forbes
    Oct 24, 2011 · The Knowledge Navigator vision was captured in the epilogue to Sculley's 1987 autobiography, “Odyssey: Pepsi to Apple,” coauthored with John A.Missing: origins | Show results with:origins
  5. [5]
    How the Knowledge Navigator video came about
    Nov 20, 2011 · It's important to note that the Knowledge Navigator vision first articulated in Odyssey morphed quite a bit based on Hugh and Doris's ...Missing: origins | Show results with:origins
  6. [6]
    Growing Apple with the Macintosh: The Sculley Years - Low End Mac
    Feb 22, 2006 · Sculley made up for his uncharismatic appearance during his speech on how Apple would have to change to compete with IBM. He said that Apple ...
  7. [7]
    How Did Apple Get So Big? - Investopedia
    Dec 7, 2024 · The 1984 release of the Macintosh was a leap forward for Apple but IBM caught up in the intervening years between the Apple II and the Macintosh ...
  8. [8]
    Yesterday's Tomorrows: The Origins of The Tablet - CHM
    Dec 17, 2014 · A video released in 1987 by Apple showcased the “Knowledge Navigator.” It was a fold-out, tablet-like device first envisioned by Apple CEO John ...
  9. [9]
    Sculley Charts 21st Century Fantasy - Los Angeles Times
    Although Knowledge Navigator is years away, Apple already offers a programming language for the Macintosh demonstrating some of its concepts. HyperCard ...
  10. [10]
    Knowledge Navigator Deconstructed: Building an Envisionment
    Jun 19, 2007 · The Knowledge Navigator is a notebook-sized computer with video, sound, and high-resolution display, designed to show Apple's vision of ...<|control11|><|separator|>
  11. [11]
    Knowledge Navigator (1987/88) - Mac History
    Aug 2, 2011 · The Knowledge Navigator is a concept described by former Apple Computer CEO John Sculley in his 1987 book, Odyssey.
  12. [12]
    Apple's Knowledge Navigator: Why Doesn't that Conversational ...
    May 11, 2024 · Apple's 1987 Knowledge Navigator video contains a vision of a sophisticated digital personal assistant, but the natural human-agent conversational dialog shown ...
  13. [13]
    Apple's 1987 Knowledge Navigator, Only One Month Late - Waxy.org
    Oct 4, 2011 · It was created for John Sculley's 1987 keynote at EDUCOM. I replaced it with a version that's lower-quality but won't confuse people, and some ...
  14. [14]
    None
    ### Summary of Knowledge Navigator Video Production
  15. [15]
    Apple's 1987 Knowledge Navigator Video - YouTube
    Apr 8, 2007 · ... interface which is just now, 20 years later, really becoming a reality (iPhone). Same with easy point-to-point video conferencing (iChat ...Missing: user | Show results with:user<|control11|><|separator|>
  16. [16]
    Apple Knowledge Navigator Video (1987) - YouTube
    Mar 4, 2012 · The Knowledge Navigator Video was made for Apple-CEO John Sculley's EDUCOM 1987 keynote in six weeks on a $60000 budget.
  17. [17]
    [PDF] Making Knowledge Navigator - Presentations - Dubberly Design Office
    Mar 29, 2024 · Doris Mitsch wrote the first script and created graphics. Hugh Dubberly was creative director and PM. Bud Colligan was our sponsor and executive ...Missing: actors | Show results with:actors
  18. [18]
    The Knowledge Navigator (Short 1987) - Full cast & crew - IMDb
    The Knowledge Navigator (Short 1987) - Cast and crew credits, including actors, actresses, directors, writers and more.Missing: video child scenario
  19. [19]
    Full text of "MacWorld 8711 November 1987" - Internet Archive
    Nov 2, 1987 · ... Knowledge Navigator will drive us through them. By the 21st century, we will have the installed base to make the computer a mass ...
  20. [20]
    Full text of "Compute! Magazine Issue 091" - Internet Archive
    ... 1987 COMPUTEI 19 Knowledge Navigator. Can schools teach innovative thinking, or is inno- vation up to the individual? Sculley: I think schools can do a ...
  21. [21]
    APPLE : HAS IT LOST ITS BITE? : Critics Contend the Firm Needs to ...
    Feb 19, 1989 · Sculley's “Knowledge Navigator” video, he claims, was designed more to inspire engineers within Apple than outside audiences. One result, he ...Missing: Byte Magazine
  22. [22]
  23. [23]
    Is this 1987 video the origins of Apple Intelligence? - Business Insider
    Jun 11, 2024 · A 1987 version of an Apple AI assistant, called Knowledge Navigator, is wildly similar to its newest Apple Intelligence.Missing: transcript | Show results with:transcript
  24. [24]
    25 years before Siri, Apple had 'Knowledge Navigator' - NBC News
    Oct 5, 2011 · The most impressive aspect of the envisionment is how it guided Apple's design direction for the subsequent twenty years. In 1991, 4 years after ...
  25. [25]
    Exclusive: Siri creator Tom Gruber on the future of humanistic AI
    Mar 28, 2023 · It was called the Knowledge Navigator video, it was a vision video that Apple put out, showing a virtual assistant on what looked like a little ...
  26. [26]
    Screw Microsoft's Courier: Apple Had Better Ideas 22 Years Ago
    Sep 24, 2009 · The Knowledge Navigator is a fully interactive PDA–in smartness way beyond what Microsoft's envisaging, and capable of many of the tasks a ...Missing: influence | Show results with:influence
  27. [27]
    Apple Made a Controversial Prediction About the Future of Computers
    and people were furious.Missing: trends | Show results with:trends
  28. [28]
    Privacy, Trust, and Technological Hurdles in Human-Agent Interaction
    In 1987, Apple introduced the Knowledge Navigator, a visionary concept of a digital personal assistant capable of sophisticated human-agent interactions.<|separator|>