Diapsids are a major clade of sauropsid reptiles distinguished by the presence of two pairs of temporal fenestrae—openings in the skull behind each eye that accommodate jaw muscles—originating in the late Carboniferous period around 300 million years ago. This skull configuration, which enhances cranial strength and muscle attachment for powerful bites, defines the group and includes a vast array of extant and extinct forms such as lizards, snakes, tuatara, crocodilians, birds, turtles, and numerous fossil lineages like pterosaurs and dinosaurs. Diapsids represent the dominant radiation of reptiles, achieving unparalleled diversity in terrestrial, aquatic, and aerial environments throughout the Mesozoic era and into the present.[1]The evolutionary history of diapsids traces back to early amniotes, with the earliest known member being Petrolacosaurus kansensis from the Late Carboniferous of North America, exemplifying the primitive diapsid skull with fully open fenestrae. Over time, diapsids diverged into two primary lineages during the Permian and Triassic periods: Lepidosauromorpha, which includes squamates (lizards and snakes, ~12,000 species as of 2025) and sphenodontians (tuatara); and Archosauromorpha, encompassing archosaurs such as crocodilians, extinct non-avian dinosaurs, pterosaurs, and birds (the only surviving dinosaur lineage). Turtles, long debated for their anapsid-like skulls lacking visible fenestrae, are now firmly placed within Diapsida as the sister group to Archosauria, based on molecular phylogenomic analyses of nuclear genes showing their divergence around 255 million years ago and secondary closure of the temporal openings during shell evolution.[2]Diapsids exhibit remarkable adaptive radiation, with subgroups exploiting diverse niches: lepidosaurs dominate modern terrestrial and subterranean habitats with limbless forms like snakes and specialized climbers like geckos, while archosaurs include the apex predators of the Mesozoic, such as theropod dinosaurs leading to avian flight; other diapsids include aquatic specialists like ichthyosaurs (extinct forms convergent on fish-like body plans). Their success is underscored by physiological innovations, including ectothermy in most forms (with endothermy in birds and some dinosaurs), amniotic eggs for terrestrial reproduction, and scaly integument for water retention. Today, diapsids comprise approximately 23,500 living species as of 2025, far outnumbering other reptile clades, and continue to shape ecosystems as pollinators, predators, and herbivores.[3][4][5]
Anatomy
Skull Structure
Diapsids are defined as a clade of amniotes characterized by the presence of two pairs of temporal fenestrae in the skull: the upper temporal fenestra (supratemporal fenestra) and the lower temporal fenestra (infratemporal fenestra), located behind the orbits.[6] These openings allow for the expansion and increased attachment area of the jaw adductor muscles, such as the temporalis and pterygoideus, thereby enhancing bite force while reducing overall skull weight compared to more solid crania in basal amniotes.[6][7] The infratemporal bar, formed by the jugal and quadratojugal bones, separates the upper and lower fenestrae, maintaining structural integrity while permitting muscular expansion.[6]In some derived diapsids, additional fenestrae appear, including the antorbital fenestra anterior to the orbit in archosauromorphs, which lightens the snout and may house pneumatic diverticula, and the mandibular fenestra in the lower jaw of archosaurs, accommodating the intramandibularis muscle for improved jaw mechanics.[6] These features contribute to the functional diversity of diapsid crania, adapting to varied feeding and sensory demands across the clade.Evolutionary modifications to the temporal fenestrae occur in advanced lineages; for instance, in snakes (lepidosaurs), the fenestrae are reduced or fused due to kinetic skull adaptations for swallowing large prey, with the loss of the infratemporal bar exposing the braincase.[8] In archosaurs, the fenestrae often expand, as seen in birds where modifications support lightweight construction and integrate with middle ear structures for enhanced aerial hearing via the elongated columella.[6]Primitive diapsids, such as the Permian Youngina capensis, exhibit fully open upper and lower temporal fenestrae bordered by distinct bony arches, representing the ancestral condition with minimal secondary closure.[9] In contrast, derived forms like crocodilians retain the diapsid pattern with prominent supratemporal and infratemporal fenestrae, though the orbits lack sclerotic rings unlike in many lizards and birds; these fenestrae support powerful jaw adduction suited to ambush predation.[6]
Postcranial Features
Diapsids exhibit a vertebral column characterized by distinct regionalization into cervical, dorsal (trunk), and caudal (tail) segments, with variations in centrum shape reflecting locomotor and structural adaptations across the clade. In early diapsid forms, such as those from the Permian and Early Triassic, vertebral centra are typically amphicoelous, featuring concave anterior and posterior faces that facilitate flexibility in the axial skeleton.[10] Later diapsids, including some lepidosaurs and archosauromorphs, show procoelous centra in certain regions, with a concave anterior face and convex posterior, enhancing shock absorption during movement.[11] This vertebral morphology supports diverse gaits, from the flexible undulation in squamates to the more rigid support in archosaurs.Many diapsids possess gastralia, paired dermal ossifications forming a ventral basket along the abdominal wall that provides structural support to the belly and aids in respiration by stabilizing the trunk during locomotion.[11] These belly ribs are particularly prominent in basal diapsids, crocodilians, and some dinosaurs, where they articulate with the sternum and ribs to reinforce the ventral body wall against gravitational and torsional stresses.[12] In contrast, gastralia are reduced or absent in birds and many snakes, reflecting secondary losses associated with flight or limblessness.The postcranial skeleton of diapsids includes specialized limb girdles adapted to sprawling or erect postures, with the pectoral girdle featuring a scapulocoracoid that varies markedly between major subclades. In archosauromorphs, the scapulocoracoid is robust and often fused, providing strong anchorage for forelimb muscles that support semi-erect to fully erect gaits in forms like dinosaurs and crocodilians.[13] Conversely, in lepidosaurs such as lizards and tuataras, the scapulocoracoid is reduced and more loosely articulated, accommodating the sprawling posture typical of these groups.[13] Pelvic girdles similarly reflect postural diversity, with expanded ilia and robust pubes-ischia in archosauromorphs enabling upright limb positioning, while lepidosaur pelves feature broader, more flexible acetabula for lateral limb excursion in sprawling locomotion.[14]Forelimbs in diapsids often feature elongated radius and ulna bones, which enhance pronation-supination mobility and extend reach for foraging or predation.[15] This elongation contributes to agile maneuvers in sprawling taxa like lizards, where the parallel shafts allow for effective substrate contact. Specific dermal specializations include osteoderms, polygonal bony plates embedded in the skin, present in crocodilians for armor-like protection and in some dinosaurs such as ankylosaurs and stegosaurs for defensive reinforcement along the dorsal and caudal regions.[12] Additionally, tail autotomy represents a derived postcranial trait in lizards (squamates), where fracture planes in caudal vertebrae enable voluntary tail shedding as an anti-predator escape mechanism, followed by regeneration of a cartilaginous replacement.[16] The lightweight cranial architecture enabled by temporal fenestrae complements these postcranial traits by reducing overall mass for enhanced agility.[17]
Evolutionary Origins
Fossil Record
The fossil record of diapsids begins in the Late Carboniferous to Early Permian, approximately 310–300 million years ago (Ma), marking their initial diversification among early amniotes.[10] Key early localities include the Karoo Basin in South Africa, which has yielded Permian specimens preserving characteristic diapsid skull fenestrae, and the Texas Red Beds in the United States, where Lower Permian deposits have produced early amniote remains.[9][18]Throughout the Permian, diapsid fossils appear in several major horizons, including the Tropidostoma-Dicynodon zones of the Karoo Basin, exemplified by taxa like Youngina from South Africa.[9] Diapsids remained relatively rare during this period but underwent explosive radiation in the Early Triassic following the end-Permian mass extinction, around 252 Ma, leading to their ecological dominance across Mesozoic terrestrial, marine, and aerial environments.[10] This diversification continued into the Jurassic and Cretaceous, with diapsids persisting and adapting through the Cenozoic to the present day.[19]The diapsidfossil record is exceptionally rich, encompassing thousands of extinct species across diverse clades, with major Lagerstätten providing exceptional preservation.[20] The Late JurassicSolnhofen Limestone in Germany has yielded well-preserved pterosaurs and early avialan birds, while the Morrison Formation in North America has produced abundant dinosaur skeletons, highlighting diapsid dominance in Late Jurassic ecosystems.[21][22]Recent discoveries from 2021–2025, including new stem saurian reptiles from the late Permian of South Africa, have refined timelines for early diapsid evolution by filling gaps in the Gondwanan record.[23]
Earliest Forms
The earliest known diapsids appeared in the Late Carboniferous period, approximately 305 to 300 million years ago, during the Pennsylvanian epoch.[24][10] These primitive forms were small, agile reptiles that bridged the gap between earlier reptiliomorphs and the more diverse diapsid radiation. Petrolacosaurus kansensis, from the Upper Pennsylvanian of Kansas, North America, represents a classic early example, with fossils dated to around 302 million years ago.[25][26] Araeoscelidians, such as Araeoscelis from the Early Permian of Texas (approximately 290 million years ago), have also been proposed as basal diapsids, though their exact position remains debated.[27][10]Morphologically, these early diapsids were lizard-like in build, typically measuring 20 to 60 centimeters in length, with slender bodies adapted for terrestrial life.[24][27] Their skulls exhibited the defining diapsid condition: two pairs of temporal fenestrae (upper and lower temporal openings) that were fully open and unobstructed by bony bars, facilitating jaw muscle attachments for efficient feeding.[26][27] Postcranially, they possessed a sprawling gait, with limbs positioned laterally to the body, enabling scuttling movement similar to modern lizards.[28] Dental structures, including sharp, conical teeth of varying lengths without significant crushing adaptations, indicate an insectivorous diet, consistent with their small size and predatory niche in Paleozoic ecosystems.[26][28]These taxa display transitional features linking them to earlier reptiliomorphs, such as the anapsid captorhinids, through shared primitive traits like simple, homodont dentition and lightweight skeletal construction suited to insectivory.[29][30] Protorothyridids, intermediate forms between captorhinids and diapsids, further illustrate this progression, with phylogenetic analyses placing them closer to diapsids based on cranial and postcranial similarities.[29] This morphological continuity underscores the gradual evolution of the diapsidskull from basal eureptilian ancestors.[30]Recent phylogenetic studies have challenged the inclusion of araeoscelidians within crown Diapsida, proposing instead that they represent stem sauropsids outside the true diapsid clade. For instance, Simões et al. (2022) analyzed an expanded dataset of early amniote fossils and recovered araeoscelidians as more basal, shifting the origin of crown diapsids later into the Permian and emphasizing Petrolacosaurus as a more reliable basal representative.[31][32] This debate highlights the ongoing refinement of early diapsid origins, with implications for understanding the clade's diversification amid Paleozoic environmental changes.[31]
Phylogeny and Classification
Relationships to Other Amniotes
Diapsida represents one of the two primary clades within Sauropsida, the sauropsid branch of Amniota, with the other being the reduced Anapsida, which traditionally encompassed turtles and various extinct lineages but now excludes turtles based on phylogenetic evidence.[33]Sauropsida as a whole forms the sister group to Synapsida—the lineage leading to mammals—within the broader Amniota clade, which originated from tetrapod ancestors and is defined by the synapomorphy of the amniotic egg, an adaptation enabling terrestrial reproduction through a shelled egg containing extraembryonic membranes.[34] All amniotes, including diapsids, synapsids, and anapsids, share this amniotic innovation, which protects the embryo from desiccation.[35]A defining synapomorphy of Diapsida is the presence of two temporal fenestrae in the skull, paired openings that accommodate jaw adductor muscles and enhance cranial strength, contrasting with the single fenestra in synapsids and the absence of fenestrae in anapsids.[33] This diapsid skull configuration distinguishes the clade from its amniote relatives and supports diverse feeding adaptations across its members.[35]Historically, early 20th-century classifications divided reptiles into three groups based on temporal fenestration: Anapsida (no fenestrae, including turtles), Synapsida (one fenestra, leading to mammals), and Diapsida (two fenestrae, encompassing lizards, snakes, crocodilians, birds, and dinosaurs).[36] Modern cladistic analyses, however, have revised this framework, repositioning turtles within Diapsida as the sister group to Archosauria within Archosauromorpha, supported by genomic studies in the 2010s revealing shared molecular markers with archosaurs and lepidosaurs, as well as fossil evidence of transitional forms like Pappochelys showing incipient diapsid features.Further resolving debates on early amniote relationships, a 2020 phylogenetic analysis by Ford and Benson integrated morphological and molecular data from over 200 taxa, nesting the traditionally separate Parareptilia and Varanopidae within Diapsida as the sister group to crown-group diapsids (Neodiapsida), thereby eliminating Parareptilia as a distinct clade outside Sauropsida and simplifying the amniote tree. This study also confirmed that temporal fenestration evolved fewer times than previously thought, with diapsid-like openings appearing convergently in some synapsids but ancestrally in the sauropsid lineage.[37]
Internal Phylogenetic Structure
The internal phylogenetic structure of Diapsida reflects a hierarchical branching that originated in the late Carboniferous, with the clade encompassing a diverse array of reptiles characterized by two temporal fenestrae in the skull. At its base, Diapsida comprises Araeoscelidia as a stem group sister to Neodiapsida, the latter representing the crown group that emerged around 290 million years ago (Ma) during the early Permian and excluding more primitive stem forms.[31] Neodiapsida forms the core of modern reptile diversity, splitting into two major subclades: Lepidosauromorpha, which includes lizards, snakes, and tuatara, and Archosauromorpha, encompassing crocodilians, birds, and various extinct lineages.[31]Sauria is recognized as the total group uniting lepidosaurs (crown Lepidosauromorpha) and archosaurs (crown Archosauromorpha), capturing their most recent common ancestor and all descendants, thus framing the evolutionary radiation of these dominant diapsid lineages from the Permian onward.[31] This structure is supported by cladistic analyses emphasizing shared anatomical synapomorphies, such as modifications in the temporal region and postcranial adaptations, though these are briefly noted here as they underpin the branching without defining it exclusively.[31]Recent phylogenetic revisions, particularly from a 2022 analysis incorporating stratigraphic and morphological data, and further supported by 2025 studies on late Paleozoic relatives of Neodiapsida, have refined this topology by excluding araeoscelidians from Sauropsida—the broader crown reptile assemblage—and positioning them instead as early stem diapsids outside the saurian radiation.[31][38] This study also affirms the inclusion of marine reptiles like ichthyosaurs and sauropterygians within Diapsida, nesting them proximally to Archosauromorpha and highlighting convergent aquatic adaptations within the clade.[31] Such updates underscore short internodal durations in early diapsid evolution, around 1.9 Ma, which contribute to ongoing topological instability.[31]Debates persist regarding the placement of certain taxa within this framework, notably thalattosaurs, whose semiaquatic Triassic forms show uncertain affinities within Diapsida, with analyses variably positioning them near lepidosauromorphs or as basal neodiapsids due to incomplete fossil material.[39] Similarly, parareptiles are increasingly viewed as a paraphyletic assemblage rather than a cohesive clade, scattered across the diapsid stem and challenging traditional boundaries between parareptilian and eureptilian reptiles.[31]Turtles, however, are consistently nested within Archosauromorpha in molecular and combined analyses, forming the cladeArchelosauria as sister to Archosauria (crocodilians and birds), with divergence estimated around 255 Ma.[40]
Major Clades
Lepidosauromorpha
Lepidosauromorpha is a stem-based clade of diapsid reptiles defined as the most recent common ancestor of Sphenodon (the tuatara) and squamates (lizards and snakes), and all descendants of that ancestor.[41] This clade encompasses the crown group Lepidosauria, which includes the orders Squamata and Sphenodontia (formerly Rhynchocephalia), as well as various extinct stem lineages such as the gliding kuehneosaurids from the Triassic period.[42] Lepidosauromorpha forms the sister group to Archosauromorpha within the larger saurian clade.[42]Key subgroups within Lepidosauromorpha include Squamata, which comprises approximately 11,000 extant species of lizards, snakes, and amphisbaenians, representing the most diverse reptilian order.[43] Sphenodontia is restricted to a single living genus, Sphenodon, with two species of tuatara endemic to New Zealand, though the group was more widespread in the Mesozoic.[44] Extinct forms, such as the kuehneosaurids (e.g., Kuehneosaurus and Kuehneosuchus), were small, lizard-like reptiles adapted for gliding via elongated, airfoil-like ribs, known from Late Triassic deposits in Europe and North America. These subgroups highlight the clade's range from highly speciose modern lineages to specialized fossil taxa.Synapomorphies diagnosing Lepidosauromorpha include a transversely oriented cloacal fissure, which facilitates the eversion of hemipenes in males of derived members like squamates.[42] In Squamata specifically, additional shared traits encompass flexible skull kinetics, enabling wide gape and enhanced feeding capabilities through streptostylic and mesokinetic joints.[42] Other features, such as the fusion of the atlantal and axial neural centra, further support the clade's monophyly.[42]The evolutionary trajectory of Lepidosauromorpha began with divergence from archosauromorphs in the mid-Permian, allowing survival through the end-Permian mass extinction.[45] Diversification accelerated in the Early to Middle Triassic, with fossils indicating global distribution by the Late Triassic, including early squamates and rhynchocephalians.[46] The crown group Lepidosauria originated around 242 million years ago in the Triassic, followed by Jurassic radiation of Squamata.[46] Modern endemism is exemplified by the tuatara, whose lineage has persisted with minimal morphological change since the Cretaceous, confined to offshore islands in New Zealand due to historical biogeographic isolation.[44]
Archosauromorpha
Archosauromorpha is a major clade of diapsid reptiles comprising all taxa more closely related to archosaurs than to lepidosaurs, including the crown group Archosauria (encompassing crocodilians, birds, non-avian dinosaurs, and pterosaurs) as well as various stem-archosauromorphs such as proterosuchids, which represent early archosauriforms with transitional features.[47][48] This clade originated in the middle to late Permian period, with the earliest known members including Archosaurus rossicus from the Late Changhsingian and Eorasaurus olsoni from the Capitanian–Wuchiapingian stages, marking the initial diversification of diapsids following the Carboniferous rainforests collapse.[48][49]Key subgroups within Archosauromorpha include Pseudosuchia, which comprises crocodylians and their extinct relatives such as phytosaurs, rauisuchids, and aetosaurs, and Avemetatarsalia, which includes dinosaurs, birds, and pterosaurs as ornithodirans.[48] Recent phylogenetic analyses have placed turtles (Testudines) within Archosauromorpha as the sister group to crown-group Archosauria, supported by molecular data and shared features including a modified diapsid skull pattern with secondarily closed temporal fenestrae and certain limb specializations.[2] Diagnostic synapomorphies of Archosauromorpha and its subclades include the antorbital fenestra, an opening in the skull anterior to the orbit that lightens the skull and accommodates jaw musculature, observed in basal forms like Proterosuchus and Prolacerta; thecodont dentition, where teeth are deeply socketed in the jaw bones for enhanced anchorage, seen in taxa such as Tasmaniosaurus triassicus; and, in more derived archosaurs, a four-chambered heart that improves circulatory efficiency, a trait retained in extant crocodilians and birds.[48][50]Evolutionarily, Archosauromorpha underwent significant radiation following the end-Permian mass extinction around 252 million years ago, achieving dominance in terrestrial and aerial ecosystems throughout the Mesozoic Era, with archosaurs supplanting other diapsid lineages in predatory and herbivorous niches.[51][52] Non-avian dinosaurs and many pseudosuchians went extinct at the Cretaceous–Paleogene (K-Pg) boundary approximately 66 million years ago due to the Chicxulub impact and associated environmental catastrophes, while avian dinosaurs (birds) survived and underwent a major adaptive radiation in the Cenozoic, diversifying into over 10,000 extant species today. This post-extinction avian expansion highlights the clade's resilience and ongoing evolutionary success.[53]
Diversity and Adaptations
Extant Representatives
Extant diapsids represent one of the most species-rich lineages of vertebrates, with over 23,500 known species distributed across birds and reptiles as of 2025. Approximately 11,100 species belong to Aves (birds), while reptiles comprise around 12,500 species, including approximately 12,000 squamates (lizards, snakes, and amphisbaenians), 360 turtles (Testudines), 26 crocodilians, and the single extant rhynchocephalian, the tuatara (Sphenodon punctatus).[54][55][56][57][58] This diversity underscores the evolutionary success of diapsids, which dominate modern terrestrial, aquatic, and aerial ecosystems.[59][60]Diapsids exhibit a global distribution, inhabiting virtually every biome on Earth. Birds range from polar regions, exemplified by penguins (Spheniscidae) in Antarctic waters, to equatorial rainforests and high-altitude mountains. Reptiles occupy tropical forests, arid deserts (e.g., various lizard genera like Phrynosoma in North American deserts), freshwater systems, and marine environments, with sea turtles (Cheloniidae) traversing oceans worldwide. This broad ecological occupancy reflects adaptations to extreme conditions, from the heat of Saharan dunes to the cold depths of subpolar seas.[59][60]Biologically, extant diapsids display key physiological contrasts that influence their ecology. Reptiles are predominantly ectothermic, regulating body temperature primarily through behavioral adjustments to environmental conditions, which enables efficient energy use in varied habitats but limits activity in cold climates. In contrast, birds are endothermic, generating internal heat via high metabolic rates to sustain activity across temperature extremes. Reproductive strategies are similarly diverse: oviparity predominates, with most species laying shelled eggs that develop externally, but viviparity—live birth with internal embryonic nourishment—has arisen independently over 100 times in squamates, facilitating reproduction in unstable or cold environments.[61][62]Conservation challenges threaten this diversity, with habitat loss from agriculture, logging, and urbanization identified as the primary driver of decline across diapsid groups. According to IUCN assessments, at least 21% of reptile species are threatened with extinction, a figure rising to 30% for forest-dwellers. The tuatara, confined to offshore islands in New Zealand, holds Least Concern status overall but faces risks from invasive predators and habitat fragmentation, necessitating protected reserves and predator control. Among crocodilians, seven of the 26 species are Critically Endangered, largely due to historical overhunting and ongoing wetland degradation.[59][63][64]
Extinct Lineages and Ecological Roles
Diapsids encompass several major extinct lineages that dominated Mesozoic ecosystems before their ultimate demise. Pterosaurs, flying relatives of dinosaurs within the archosaur group, represent one such lineage, with over 200 known species that thrived from the Late Triassic to the end of the Cretaceous.[65] These aerial reptiles went extinct during the Cretaceous-Paleogene (K-Pg) boundary event approximately 66 million years ago.[66] Non-avian dinosaurs, another prominent archosaurian group, included roughly 1,000 described genera that radiated across terrestrial environments from the Late Triassic to the Late Cretaceous.[67] Marine reptiles such as ichthyosaurs, dolphin-like diapsids adapted to fully aquatic life, persisted from the Early Triassic to the mid-Cretaceous, filling oceanic predatory niches.[68]These extinct diapsids occupied diverse ecological roles, shaping Mesozoic food webs. Large theropod dinosaurs like Tyrannosaurus rex served as apex predators in Late Cretaceous North American floodplains, preying on other vertebrates with powerful jaws and keen senses. Giant sauropods such as Brachiosaurus functioned as primary herbivores, consuming vast quantities of vegetation and influencing plant community structure through their browsing habits. Pterosaurs may have contributed to seed dispersal and potentially pollination of early angiosperms via frugivory, aiding the diversification of Cretaceous flowering plants as endozoochorous agents.[69] In the Late Permian, gliding weigeltisaurids like Weigeltisaurus filled arboreal niches in forested environments, using dermal sails for aerial locomotion among high canopy trees, representing early diapsid experimentation with gliding.[70]Extinction events profoundly impacted diapsid diversity. The Permian-Triassic mass extinction around 252 million years ago created a bottleneck for early diapsids, drastically reducing their abundance and limiting them to rare, low-diversity forms in the immediate aftermath, which delayed their full radiation until the Early Triassic.[10] The K-Pg extinction event eradicated non-avian archosaurs, including all pterosaurs and non-avian dinosaurs, due to the combined effects of an asteroid impact, volcanism, and environmental collapse, thereby opening ecological opportunities for surviving lepidosaurs like lizards and snakes, as well as avian dinosaurs (birds).[71]Notable adaptations in these lineages facilitated their ecological success. Mosasaurs, late-diving lepidosaurs of the Late Cretaceous, evolved paddle-like flippers from their limbs and a flattened, bilobed tail for efficient undulatory swimming in open marine habitats, enabling them to pursue fast prey like fish and ammonites.[72] Pterosaurs achieved aerial prowess with wingspans reaching up to 12 meters in species like Quetzalcoatlus, supported by elongated finger bones bearing leathery membranes for powered flight and gliding over vast distances.[73] Recent analyses of thalattosaurs, enigmatic Triassicmarine diapsids, reveal transitional adaptations to fully aquatic lifestyles, including elongated snouts for piscivory and limb modifications for paddling, as evidenced by bone histology indicating rapid growth and marine specialization during the post-Permian recovery.[74]