Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Nirodha

Nirodha, in , refers to the cessation or extinction of (dukkha), constituting the third of the as articulated by in the . It is defined as the "remainderless fading away and cessation" of (), involving the complete renunciation, relinquishment, release, and letting go of this without any residue. This truth asserts that , which arises from attachment, , and , can be entirely extinguished in this life through insight and practice. Within the framework of the , nirodha follows the truth of the origin of (samudaya), which identifies as the root cause, and precedes the truth of the path (magga), the that leads to this cessation. The realization of nirodha reverses the chain of dependent origination by eliminating (avijjā), thereby halting the cycle of rebirth () and the perpetuation of . It is not mere suppression but a profound uprooting of the , , and —achieved through ethical conduct (sīla), concentration (samādhi), and (paññā). Nirodha is synonymous with nibbāna (nirvana), the unconditioned state of ultimate peace and liberation, free from all clinging and the dualities of existence and non-existence. In this state, all mental and physical fabrications still, and the mind is released from the intoxication of sensuality, becoming, and views. The Buddha emphasized that nirodha is attainable , as verified through direct knowledge, offering a practical assurance of freedom from dukkha for practitioners.

Etymology and Terminology

Origins in Pali and Sanskrit

The term nirodha in derives from the ni- (indicating downward motion, intensification, or privation, meaning "down," "into," or "without") combined with the rudh (to obstruct, , or confine), resulting in a that fundamentally conveys confinement, repression, or complete suppression. This etymological composition implies not merely temporary hindrance but a thorough extinguishing or ing of flow, as seen in its classical definitions encompassing , , , and destruction. In Pali, the equivalent term nirodha retains this core structure and semantic range, appearing prominently in early Buddhist canonical texts such as the Nikayas of the Sutta Pitaka. For instance, in the (SN 56.11), it denotes the cessation within the framework of the , described as the "complete fading away and cessation" (virāga, nirodha) of craving. Buddhist commentaries, such as the , provide etymological analyses, deriving nirodha from 'ni-' (without) and 'rodha' (prison or obstacle), signifying the complete confinement and cessation of craving and defilements. The form aligns closely with phonetically and morphologically, reflecting the shared Indo-Aryan heritage, though adapted to the vernacular style of the Tipitaka. The root rudh (to obstruct) appears in Vedic literature, and while the emphasize control over the senses for inner stillness, the term nirodha as a compound gains specific soteriological connotations in later Indian traditions, including early . In , this was repurposed to highlight mental cessation, particularly the obstruction of defilements like craving, marking a doctrinal shift from general restraint to soteriological extinction in early . Phonetic and orthographic variations of nirodha occur in dialects, such as ṇirodhaṇa or ṇiroha in Maharashtri and other Middle Indo-Aryan forms, where the intervocalic r may simplify and the initial n shifts to the cerebral typical of vernacular evolution. These adaptations reflect regional linguistic divergences while preserving the obstructive central to the term.

Modern Translations and Interpretations

In modern English translations of Pali Buddhist texts, nirodha is most commonly rendered as "cessation," particularly in reference to the third Noble Truth concerning the end of suffering (dukkha-nirodha). This choice reflects the term's root in the verb nirujjhati, implying a stopping or quelling of conditioned processes. T. W. Rhys Davids, in the Pali-English Dictionary (1921-1925), defines nirodha primarily as "cessation" or "destruction," emphasizing its role in halting the cycle of rebirth and affliction. Similarly, Maurice Walshe, in his translation of the Dīgha Nikāya (1995), consistently uses "cessation" for nirodha, as in the phrase "the cessation of suffering," aligning with a pragmatic understanding of liberation as the absence of craving's fuel. Alternative renderings include "extinction," which conveys the complete dying out of defilements akin to a flame's extinguishing, and "suppression," often applied in meditative contexts to denote the temporary restraint of perceptions and feelings. These variations highlight ongoing efforts to balance literal fidelity with interpretive clarity in conveying nirodha's dynamic cessation rather than mere negation. In European languages beyond English, translations of nirodha similarly prioritize connotations of ending or dissolution, adapting to linguistic nuances while drawing from Pali roots. In German scholarship, the term is frequently translated as Erlöschen or Erlöschung, underscoring the annihilation of causal conditions underlying suffering. Richard Gombrich, in his analysis of early Buddhist doctrine (2009), employs Erlöschen to describe nirodha as the extinguishing of reactive processes, emphasizing its non-annihilistic implications for the self's conditioned nature. French and other Romance language interpretations often mirror this with cessation or extinction, as seen in Étienne Lamotte's comprehensive works on Buddhist philosophy (1981), where nirodha is framed as the "arrêt" or stopping of dependent origination. These renderings, informed by comparative philology, shift focus from colonial-era pejorative tones toward a more neutral, process-oriented view. Twentieth- and twenty-first-century scholarly debates have refined nirodha's interpretation, particularly through textual comparisons and commentarial analysis, often favoring "stopping" to capture its active, provisional quality. Anālayo, in his A Comparative Study of the (2011), examines nirodha in the Madhyama Āgama parallels, interpreting it as a "stopping" of perceptual and volitional formations rather than absolute annihilation, based on contextual usages in discourses like 49. This approach counters earlier essentialist readings by highlighting nirodha's role as a meditative and doctrinal pivot, achievable through insight into impermanence. Such analyses, building on post-World War II philological advances, underscore nirodha's etymological ties to niruddha (restrained or ceased), promoting translations that avoid implying . Colonial-era translations, such as those overseen by Max Müller in the Sacred Books of the East series (1879-1910), often rendered Buddhist terms like nirodha with loaded English equivalents such as "annihilation" or "destruction," reflecting Orientalist biases that portrayed Buddhism as pessimistic or world-denying. Müller's editions of texts like the Dhammapada (1870) contributed to these interpretations, prioritizing literal Sanskrit-Pali etymologies over doctrinal intent. Post-1950s Buddhist studies, amid decolonization and renewed access to Asian commentaries, introduced corrections emphasizing contextual accuracy; for instance, scholars like I. B. Horner and the Pali Text Society revisions (1950s onward) advocated "cessation" to restore nirodha's optimistic soteriological function, influencing subsequent works like those of the Buddhist Publication Society. These shifts, driven by interdisciplinary methods including linguistics and anthropology, have standardized more nuanced translations across global academia.

Role in Buddhist Doctrine

Position Within the Four Noble Truths

In the foundational framework of Buddhist doctrine, the are enumerated as dukkha (the truth of ), samudaya (the truth of the origin of ), nirodha (the truth of the cessation of ), and magga (the truth of the to the cessation of ). Nirodha occupies the third position, articulating the potential for the complete termination of dukkha once its causes are eradicated. The first systematically presented these truths in his inaugural discourse, the ( 56.11), addressed to his five former ascetic companions at in Isipatana (modern ). In this sutta, nirodha is explicitly defined as "the fading away and cessation of that very same [samudaya] with nothing left over; giving it away, letting it go, releasing it, and not clinging to it," emphasizing its role as the direct to the craving identified in the second truth. This declaration underscores nirodha's function as an attainable reality, realized through insight into the truths. Structurally, nirodha contrasts with the preceding truths by shifting from problem identification—dukkha as the pervasive condition of and samudaya as its causal mechanism—to affirmative resolution, establishing the cessation as the ultimate diagnostic objective of the Buddhist . This logical progression diagnoses as impermanent and resolvable, countering any notion of it as an eternal fate. Early textual formulations of the appear with minor variations in the , notably in the Mahāvagga's narration of the Buddha's enlightenment under the (Mahāvagga 1.6). Here, nirodha is portrayed as "the complete cessation of that , giving it up, renouncing it, the , the destruction of that very ," highlighting the abandonment of desire for in a more concise manner than the sutta's elaboration, though preserving the emphasis on eradication.

Relation to Dukkha and Samudaya

In the framework of dependent origination (paṭiccasamuppāda), nirodha serves as the antidote to dukkha () and samudaya (its origin) by reversing the causal chain that begins with (avijjā) and culminates in . This model illustrates how the cessation of each conditioning factor leads to the non-arising of subsequent links, thereby dismantling the process of conditioned existence that perpetuates dukkha. A key mechanism in this reversal is the cessation of (taṇhā), identified as the core of samudaya, which directly precipitates the nirodha of dukkha. As detailed in the Vibhaṅga Sutta (SN 12.2), the Buddha explains: "With the cessation of comes cessation of grasping; with the cessation of grasping, cessation of continued existence; with the cessation of continued existence, cessation of rebirth; with the cessation of rebirth, cessation of and death, sorrow, lamentation, pain, displeasure, and despair cease. Such is the cessation of this whole mass of ." This sequence underscores how interrupting taṇhā at the point of samudaya halts the proliferation of dukkha. Nirodha functions diagnostically as the unbinding from the cycle of rebirth (), which is inextricably tied to the origins outlined in samudaya. By negating the influxes of defilements that fuel this cycle, nirodha severs the bonds of conditioned arising, providing a precise understanding of how 's perpetuation can be terminated. Buddhaghosa, in his commentary, further elaborates on nirodha as the complete negation of conditioned arising through the reverse order of dependent origination. In Chapter XVII of the , he describes this process as systematically eliminating each link from dukkha backward to avijjā, emphasizing nirodha's role in uprooting the foundational conditions of samudaya to achieve the non-arising of .

Conceptual Meaning and Implications

Cessation of Suffering

Nirodha, as articulated in the third noble truth, denotes the complete cessation of (dukkha), achieved through the fading away and relinquishment of , the originating cause of . This state represents the extinguishing of the afflictive processes that perpetuate cyclic , resulting in freedom from all forms of unsatisfactoriness. In the Abhidhamma framework, nirodha entails the termination of the three principal categories of dukkha: dukkha-dukkhata, the direct experience of physical and mental pain or anguish; viparinama-dukkhata, the inherent arising from the inevitable change and loss of pleasant sensations; and sankhara-dukkhata, the subtle embedded in all conditioned phenomena due to their impermanence, fragility, and inability to provide lasting . These cessations occur as the underlying conditions of grasping and becoming are eradicated, with nirodha manifesting temporarily during stages of insight practice—where phenomena dissolve momentarily, offering direct of extinction—and permanently upon , where the roots of affliction are irrevocably severed. For instance, in the Brahma-nimantanika Sutta, the Buddha illustrates permanent nirodha by declaring that defilements have been "cut off at the root, made like a stump, obliterated so that they are unable to arise in the future." Psychologically, nirodha involves the complete eradication of the (raga), (dosa), and (moha)—which fuel the by distorting perception and motivating unwholesome actions. explains that a mind rid of , free from ill will, and unconfused achieves from these toxins, fostering clarity and non-attachment. This extinguishing aligns with the cessation of samudaya, as the removal of craving eliminates the generative force behind dukkha. Suttas describe nirodha experientially as a profound, peaceful state transcending sensory engagement, where physical, verbal, and mental processes cease and become stilled, beyond the reach of ordinary and feeling. This unperturbed tranquility arises from a purified released from the five senses, embodying the ultimate quietude free from the flux of conditioned inputs.

Connection to Nibbana

In , nirodha serves as the direct entry point to nibbana, representing the complete and irreversible cessation of the afflictions— (rāga), (dosa), and (moha)—that fuel the . This is explicitly articulated in the , where nibbana is defined as "the remainderless fading away & cessation of , , & ," marking the transition from conditioned existence to the deathless state () beyond rebirth. The realization of nirodha through the thus extinguishes the roots of , allowing the practitioner to abide in nibbana, the unconditioned peace free from all fabrications. Theravada exegesis distinguishes nirodha as the dynamic event or process of cessation—specifically, the momentary or progressive ending of craving and —while nibbana constitutes the ground or that this cessation reveals. Nirodha is the extinguishing of the fires of defilement, akin to the flame going out, whereas nibbana is the cool, signless state (animitta) that remains, unarisen and unceasing. This differentiation underscores that nirodha is realizable within the path of , culminating in the full of nibbana as the ultimate . Sutta passages further illuminate this connection, portraying nibbana as the "total cessation" (parinibbāna) of all conditioned phenomena, where there is neither arising nor passing away. In the Udāna, nibbana is described as a dimension beyond the elements of , , , and , transcending even the highest meditative spheres, with no coming, no going, no standing still—simply the end of . This realization through nirodha embodies nibbana's core attributes of timelessness, as it lies outside temporal processes, and non-duality, dissolving all distinctions between self and other in the unborn, unconditioned reality.

Meditative Attainments

Nirodha-Samāpatti

Nirodha-samāpatti, translated as the "attainment of extinction," represents an advanced meditative absorption in , characterized as a ninth jhāna-like state extending beyond the eight conventional jhānas. This profound cessation is attainable exclusively by non-returners (anāgāmins) and arahants, those who have eradicated the five lower fetters and, in the case of arahants, all defilements. The canonical foundation for nirodha-samāpatti appears in the (AN 10.72), where enumerates ten "thorns" obstructing spiritual progress, identifying perception and feeling as barriers to this attainment of their own cessation. It receives further elaboration in the Paṭisambhidāmagga, a text, which analyzes it within the framework of discriminative knowledges (paṭisambhidā), portraying it as the ultimate temporary suspension in meditative practice. In nirodha-samāpatti, all mental formations cease, resulting in the complete suspension of (viññāṇa), (saññā), and feeling (vedayita), often termed saññā-vedayita-nirodha. The vitality faculties (āyusaṅkhāra) and associated bodily processes, including in-and-out breathing as a bodily formation (kāya-saṅkhāra), also halt, though the essential life force persists to enable revival; this state renders the practitioner unresponsive to external stimuli while maintaining physical integrity. The duration of nirodha-samāpatti is limited to up to seven days, predetermined by the meditator's before entry, after which occurs spontaneously. Upon revival, the practitioner regains full instantaneously, akin to awakening from but without any preceding subconscious interval; for non-returners, this leads directly into the fruition attainment of non-returning (anāgāmī-phala), while arahants experience the fruition of arahantship (arahatta-phala).

Attainment Process and Prerequisites

The attainment of nirodha-samāpatti requires rigorous prerequisites rooted in advanced meditative and ethical development within the tradition. Practitioners must first achieve mastery over all eight jhānas, the progressive absorptions culminating in the eighth jhāna, known as the base of neither nor non-, which serves as the foundational platform for entry. Additionally, deep insight into the three characteristics—impermanence (anicca), suffering (dukkha), and non-self ()—is essential, enabling the meditator to contemplate the transient nature of phenomena and transcend ordinary . Finally, the practitioner must hold ariya status at the level of non-returner (anāgāmī) or arahant, as lower noble stages like stream-entry lack the necessary elimination of sensual desire and aversion to sustain this profound cessation. The process unfolds sequentially from the eighth jhāna, emphasizing deliberate intention and refined mental faculties. After emerging from the eighth jhāna, the meditator cultivates toward all formations and resolves firmly to enter cessation, often after preparatory reflections to ensure no harm to body, property, or dependents. This resolve propels a transition into a state of non-perception, where and feeling temporarily suspend, resulting in the complete cessation of for a predetermined duration, typically up to seven days. , in his commentary, outlines this as a supramundane attainment accessible only after such preparation, with the meditator tracking time precisely to emerge without disruption. Buddhaghosa structures the broader path to this attainment across foundational stages in the Visuddhimagga's Chapter XXIII, beginning with sīla (ethical purity) to establish moral integrity free from defilements. This progresses to samādhi (concentration), developed through sustained jhāna practice to achieve mental unification and tranquility. These elements integrate with paññā (wisdom) via practices, ensuring the meditator's readiness for the cessation itself. While nirodha-samāpatti yields benefits such as profound mental purification and heightened post-emergence clarity that deepens into , it carries risks including physical vulnerability during the "death-like" suspension of vital functions and difficulties upon improper emergence. Consequently, it is deemed unsuitable for beginners, reserved exclusively for those with the outlined advanced qualifications to mitigate adverse effects.

Interpretations Across Traditions

Theravada Perspectives

In Theravada Buddhism, nirodha constitutes the third Noble Truth, denoting the complete cessation of suffering (dukkha) through the elimination of its origin, craving (taṇhā). This truth is realized via vipassana, the practice of insight meditation that discerns the impermanent, unsatisfactory, and selfless nature of all phenomena, thereby uprooting the mental defilements and leading to arahantship—the state of perfect where rebirth and suffering are utterly terminated. The Abhidhamma Pitaka provides a detailed analytical framework for nirodha, classifying it as the asankhata dhamma, or unconditioned element, which transcends all formed (sankhata) phenomena and remains eternally peaceful and unchanging. Unlike conditioned dhammas subject to arising, persistence, and dissolution, nirodha embodies the ultimate quiescence free from fabrication, serving as the object of supramundane consciousness in the path to . Key commentaries elucidate nirodha's integration into the process. The Atthasalini, Buddhaghosa's exposition on the Dhammasangani, explains nirodha's pivotal role in the path moments (magga-phala), where the path consciousness (magga-citta) directly penetrates the truth of cessation, eradicating fetters, followed immediately by the fruition consciousness (phala-citta) that savors the unconditioned state. This momentary realization marks the irreversible stages of awakening, from stream-entry to arahantship. Contemporary interpretations, such as those by Walpola Rahula, underscore nirodha as a profound psychological , achievable in this life through the mind's detachment from ego-centric attachments and the cessation of conditioned mental proliferations. Rahula portrays it not as an abstract metaphysical realm but as the immediate ending of suffering's mental roots, fostering and freedom from existential distress.

Mahayana and Views

In Mahayana Buddhism, nirodha is reinterpreted as the realization of (emptiness), transcending conventional notions of dualistic cessation by recognizing the lack of inherent existence in all phenomena. , in his (Chapter 25), argues that nirvāṇa—synonymous with nirodha—is neither arising nor ceasing, neither permanent nor annihilated, but the very that dissolves distinctions between and liberation, as "nirvāṇa is not arisen, not ceased, not annihilated, and not permanent." This view positions nirodha not as an event of stopping something existent, but as the non-dual suchness free from conceptual elaborations, where samsara and nirvana are indistinguishable due to their shared empty nature. The Prajñāpāramitā sūtras further equate nirodha with non-abiding nirvāṇa (apratiṣṭhita-nirvāṇa), a state beyond attachment to either cyclic existence or personal extinction, realized through the perfection of that perceives all dharmas as . In these texts, cessation is described as the "non-production, no-birth, non-existence, dispassion, cessation, nirvāṇa," synonymous with , signlessness, and wishlessness, allowing bodhisattvas to remain active in the world without abiding in extremes. This integration emphasizes nirodha as an inexhaustible, space-like reality where dharmas neither come nor go, embodying the third noble truth within the framework of ultimate rather than mere termination of . In Vajrayana traditions, nirodha manifests in deity yoga as the momentary cessation of the ordinary, dualistic mind, transforming perception through visualization and identification with enlightened deities to reveal innate luminosity and emptiness. This practice facilitates a direct glimpse of the mind's natural state, where ordinary conceptual activity dissolves, paving the way for mahāmudrā—the "great seal"—as the non-dual realization of mind's empty, blissful essence beyond subject-object dichotomy. Here, nirodha is not a static end but a dynamic integration of cessation with tantric methods, leading to the union of bliss and emptiness that characterizes buddhahood. Tsongkhapa, in his Lamrim Chenmo, integrates nirodha into the Gelugpa path by defining it as the complete cessation of afflictive obscurations—rooted in , attachment, and aversion—that bind beings to , achieved through the gradual path of ethical discipline, concentration, and wisdom. He describes this cessation as liberating the mind from defilements, akin to curing a chronic disease, resulting in the ultimate peace of nirvāṇa where "the conception of self" and its attendant sufferings fully subside. This view aligns nirodha with both sūtra-based and practices, emphasizing its role in eliminating faults to actualize true cessations and good qualities.

References

  1. [1]
    SN 56.11: Dhammacakkappavattanasutta—Bhikkhu Sujato
    Now this is the noble truth of suffering. Rebirth is suffering; old age is suffering; illness is suffering; death is suffering; being coupled with the disliked ...
  2. [2]
    The Noble Truth of the Cessation of dukkha - Access to Insight
    The noble truth of the cessation of dukkha: the remainderless fading & cessation, renunciation, relinquishment, release, & letting go of that very craving.Missing: Nirodha | Show results with:Nirodha
  3. [3]
    Buddha philosophy and western psychology - PMC - PubMed Central
    Buddha was a unique psychotherapist. His therapeutic methods helped millions of people throughout the centuries. Today the Western world has realized the ...
  4. [4]
    The meaning of existence (bhava) in the Pāli discourses of the Buddha
    Sep 9, 2022 · This paper seeks to reconstruct the meaning of existence in the Pāli discourses of the Buddha by considering how the notion is used in the most systematic ...<|control11|><|separator|>
  5. [5]
    None
    ### Definitions and Explanations of Nirodha from the Four Noble Truths Perspective
  6. [6]
    Monier-Williams Sanskrit-English Dictionary --न
    MBh. निरोध [ nirodha ] [ ni-rodha ] m. confinement , locking up , imprisonment ( [ -tas ] Lit. Mn. viii , 375). investment , siege Lit. Cat. enclosing ...
  7. [7]
    [PDF] The Vedic and Buddhist Concept of "Dharma" - Mandala Collections
    Such information to be gathered from the Vedic literature is not quite as ... For to stop is to put an end (nirodha) to pain. When mind, itself a Product ...
  8. [8]
    Nirodha: 41 definitions - Wisdom Library
    Oct 22, 2025 · Nirodha (निरोध, “restraint”) refers to “forgetting the material world entirely (and becoming exclusively attached to the Lord/Bhagavān)”, ...
  9. [9]
    SN 56.11: Dhammacakkappavattanasutta—Bhikkhu Bodhi
    ... four noble truths and analyzes them in twelve aspects. It ends with Venerable Kondañña becoming the first person apart from the Buddha to realize the Dhamma.
  10. [10]
  11. [11]
    Vibhaṅgasutta—Bhikkhu Sujato - SN 12.2 - SuttaCentral
    The Buddha gives definitions for each of the twelve links. These are general definitions that apply wherever the twelve links are mentioned.
  12. [12]
    Chapter XVII - Dependent Origination (paññā-bhūmi-niddesa)
    Dec 7, 2021 · This page describes Dependent Origination (panna-bhumi-niddesa) of the section Understanding (Paññā) of the English translation of the Visuddhimagga ('the path ...Missing: nirodha | Show results with:nirodha
  13. [13]
    Dukkhata Sutta: Suffering - Access to Insight
    Dukkha-dukkhataa, the actual feeling of physical or mental pain or anguish. 3. Sankhaara-dukkhataa, the suffering produced by all "conditioned phenomena" (i.e., ...<|separator|>
  14. [14]
    Brahmanimantanikasutta—Bhikkhu Sujato - MN 49 - SuttaCentral
    This is permanent, this is everlasting, this is eternal, this is whole, this is not liable to pass away. For this is where there's no being born, growing old, ...Missing: nirodha temporary<|separator|>
  15. [15]
  16. [16]
  17. [17]
    SN 38.1: Nibbānapañhāsutta—Bhikkhu Sujato - SuttaCentral
    “It is simply this noble eightfold path, that is: right view, right thought, right speech, right action, right livelihood, right effort, right mindfulness, and ...
  18. [18]
  19. [19]
  20. [20]
    [PDF] Path of Purification (Visuddhimagga) - Access to Insight
    The Buddhist Publication Society is an approved charity dedicated to making known the Teaching of the Buddha, which has a vital message for people of.Missing: nirodha- samāpatti
  21. [21]
    [PDF] Cessations of consciousness in meditation
    overview of the state of cessation in its two documented forms, nirodha and nirodha sam¯apatti. We have reviewed historical descriptions and accounts from ...Missing: peaceful | Show results with:peaceful<|control11|><|separator|>
  22. [22]
  23. [23]
    Nibbana: nibbana
    ### Theravada View on Nirodha and Its Relation to Nibbana in Abhidhamma
  24. [24]
    Wh126 — The Way of the Noble - Buddhist Publication Society
    He gets a vision of Nibbāna in its Fruition consciousness (magga-phala). He attenuates or weakens the fourth and fifth fetters, namely, sense-desires (kāma ...
  25. [25]
    Investigation of Nirvana [Chapter 25]
    May 22, 2014 · The Mulamadhyamakakarika is not only a grand commentary on the Buddha's discourse to Kaccayana, the only discourse cited by name, but also a ...Missing: nirodha translation
  26. [26]
    [PDF] THE PERFECTION OF WISDOM IN 8,000 LINES - Maitripa College
    Aug 12, 2018 · In order to understand this, it is helpful to read the sutras, such as The Perfection of Wisdom in Eight Thousand Lines, in which the buddhas ...
  27. [27]
    Commentary on “Root Text for Mahamudra” – Geshe Ngawang ...
    According to this set of teachings, mahamudra is like a lion and its practice without the oral tradition of possessing five is like a lion robbed of its sight.<|separator|>
  28. [28]
    [PDF] Tsongkhapa's Coordination of Sūtra and Tantra - CORE
    Deity Yoga: Divine Pride and Vivid Appearance. Tsongkhapa identifies deity yoga as the unique feature of the vajrayāna, as deity yoga uniquely captures the ...
  29. [29]
    None
    Below is a merged summary of Tsongkhapa's description of *nirodha* (cessation) within the Four Noble Truths, based on the provided segments from *The Great Treatise on the Stages of the Path to Enlightenment, Volume 1*. To retain all information in a dense and organized manner, I will use a table in CSV format, followed by a concise narrative summary that integrates the key points. The table captures detailed references, quotes, and context, while the narrative provides an overarching synthesis.