Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Philadelphia Eleven

The Philadelphia Eleven were eleven women deacons who were ordained as priests in the Episcopal Church on July 29, 1974, at the Church of the Advocate in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, by three retired bishops in an irregular ceremony that defied canonical prohibitions on women's ordination to the priesthood.^[1]^[2] This act of ecclesiastical civil disobedience, conducted without the authorization of the church's standing committees or bishops, immediately provoked widespread controversy, with the House of Bishops declaring the ordinations invalid and temporarily inhibiting the women from priestly functions.^[1]^[3] Despite initial opposition and the risk of schism within the denomination, the event catalyzed broader debate on gender roles in ministry, contributing directly to the Episcopal Church's General Convention authorizing women's ordination in 1976, after which the Philadelphia Eleven were formally recognized and reinstated.^[4]^[2] The ordinations highlighted tensions between tradition and reform in Anglican polity, marking a pivotal moment in the progressive inclusion of women in Episcopal leadership while underscoring the limits of unilateral action against established ecclesiastical governance.^[3]^[4]

Historical Context

Debate on Women's Ordination in the Episcopal Church

The debate over ordaining women to the priesthood in the Episcopal Church emerged prominently in the 1960s, influenced by contemporaneous movements for civil rights and gender equality that challenged traditional ecclesiastical roles. Proponents argued that women possessed equal spiritual gifts and vocational calls as men, rooted in the doctrine of the priesthood of all believers and the absence of explicit biblical mandates excluding women from ordained ministry. This view gained traction as societal norms evolved, with advocates emphasizing baptismal equality and the church's need to reflect contemporary understandings of human dignity.^[5]^[6] Opponents, drawing on scriptural interpretations, apostolic tradition, and theological symbolism, contended that the priesthood required male incumbents to represent Christ's incarnate maleness and to uphold patterns of male headship evident in texts such as 1 Corinthians 11 and the selection of male apostles. They highlighted potential disruptions to ecumenical relations with Roman Catholic and Eastern Orthodox communions, which adhered to male-only ordination, and warned of sociological and psychological strains on church unity from altering 2,000 years of precedent. These positions were reinforced by canonical restrictions explicitly limiting priesthood to men, necessitating constitutional amendments for change.^[7]^[8] Key milestones included the 1967 General Convention, which equalized women's access to the diaconate—previously a separate order for deaconesses—without addressing priesthood, thereby testing institutional barriers but exposing persistent resistance. In 1970, at the Houston convention, a resolution authorizing women's ordination to priesthood and episcopate failed to pass, prompting commissions for further study amid vocal dissent. By 1973, another constitutional amendment proposal reached the House of Deputies but stalled, reflecting entrenched divisions where traditionalists prioritized doctrinal continuity over egalitarian reforms. These repeated defeats underscored the debate's intensity, as procedural hurdles and theological stalemates delayed official authorization until after irregular actions in 1974.^[9]^[10]^[11]^[12]

Canonical and Theological Prerequisites

Prior to the 1974 ordinations, the Episcopal Church's canons outlined specific requirements for ordination to the priesthood, including completion of canonical studies, passage of examinations on theology, church history, and liturgy, endorsement by a parish vestry, and consent from the diocesan bishop and standing committee.^[13] These prerequisites applied uniformly but were interpreted to exclude women, as no bishop had authorized their ordination to the priesthood despite some women serving as deacons since 1970.^[14] Although no explicit canon prohibited women's ordination—a point later emphasized in defenses of the Philadelphia action—diocesan authorities consistently withheld consent, effectively enforcing a de facto barrier rooted in longstanding tradition rather than codified law.^[4] The 1973 General Convention's rejection of a resolution to authorize women's ordination to the priesthood further reinforced this canonical stance, signaling legislative resistance to change.^[14] Theologically, proponents of women's ordination, including the eleven deacons involved, drew on the Anglican threefold appeal to scripture, tradition, and reason to argue that no inherent doctrinal impediment existed. Scripturally, they cited Galatians 3:28—"there is neither male nor female: for ye are all one in Christ Jesus"—as affirming baptismal equality extending to ministerial orders, alongside examples of women in leadership roles such as prophetesses (Acts 21:9) and deacon Phoebe (Romans 16:1).^[5] Tradition was invoked through historical precedents like female deaconesses in the early church and the absence of explicit patristic prohibitions against women priests, attributing male-only priesthood to cultural patriarchy rather than divine mandate.^[5] Reason emphasized the full humanity of Christ shared by women, enabling sacramental representation, and the evolving nature of church orders in response to societal equality, paralleling prior reforms like the ordination of married men.^[5] Opponents countered with appeals to apostolic succession and male headship imagery from 1 Timothy 2:12 and 1 Corinthians 14:34, viewing priesthood as tied to Christ's maleness, but proponents maintained these texts addressed local contexts rather than universal theology.^[15] The eleven women met standard educational and vocational prerequisites, having completed seminary training and diaconal service, positioning themselves as fulfilling theological qualifications while challenging the canonical gatekeeping as an unjust extension of tradition over doctrine.^[2] This framework justified their irregular action, framing it as obedience to broader gospel imperatives amid institutional inertia.^[4]

The Irregular Ordination

Planning and Participants

The irregular ordination of the Philadelphia Eleven was organized primarily by Suzanne Hiatt, a deacon and canon liturgist experienced in diocesan procedures, who coordinated the effort among eleven qualified women deacons frustrated by the Episcopal Church's repeated failure to authorize women's ordination to the priesthood following unsuccessful General Convention votes in 1970 and 1973.^[2] These women, all canonically ordained as deacons and meeting theological and preparatory requirements, presented themselves as ready for priestly ordination, prompting the group to seek sympathetic retired or resigned bishops willing to act despite canonical prohibitions.^[16] Hiatt and the deacons approached Bishops Robert DeWitt (former Diocese of Northern Indiana), Daniel Corrigan (resigned suffragan of Colorado), and Edward Welles (former Diocese of West Missouri), who consented to perform the rite on July 29, 1974, at the Church of the Advocate in Philadelphia, with rector Paul Washington granting permission for the venue due to his support for civil rights and church reform.^[17]^[18] The ordinands, known collectively as the Philadelphia Eleven, included Alison Cheek, Emily Hewitt, Carter Heyward, Suzanne Hiatt, Marie Moorefield-Fleischer, Jeanette Piccard, Betty Bone Schiess, Alla Bozarth-Campbell, Merrill Bittner, Irene Paisley, and Nancy Wittig; most were postulants or candidates for priesthood blocked by diocesan bishops, with only one having formal standing committee endorsement.^[19]^[4] The ordaining bishops—DeWitt as principal consecrator, with Corrigan and Welles as co-consecrators—were selected for their progressive stances and retirement status, which insulated them from immediate hierarchical oversight.^[17] Supporting participants encompassed additional clergy, lay advocates, and a congregation of approximately 2,000 attendees, reflecting broader networks pushing for gender equality in ministry, though the core planning remained with the women and bishops to ensure liturgical validity under irregular circumstances.^[20]^[4]

The Service on July 29, 1974

The ordination service occurred on July 29, 1974, at the Church of the Advocate in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, coinciding with the feast day of Saints Mary and Martha.^[19] Eleven women, who had previously been ordained as deacons and served under the authority of eight diocesan bishops, presented themselves for ordination to the priesthood.^[21] The ceremony marked the first such ordinations of women to the priesthood in the Episcopal Church.^[21] The ordaining bishops were Daniel Corrigan, retired suffragan bishop of Colorado; Robert L. DeWitt, resigned bishop of Pennsylvania; and Edward R. Welles II, retired bishop of West Missouri.^[19] ^[22] Bishop Antonio Ramos of Costa Rica also participated by joining in the laying on of hands.^[21] Approximately 2,000 worshipers attended the service, which included a sermon by sociologist Dr. Charles V. Willie characterizing the act as "tender loving defiance."^[21] The proceedings followed the standard Episcopal ordination rite but were conducted without canonical authorization from the diocesan bishop or standing committees.^[21] During the service, protesting priests interrupted to contest the ordinations as unlawful and schismatical, reflecting immediate opposition to the irregular proceedings.^[21] The bishops proceeded with the imposition of hands and other liturgical elements, ordaining the women despite the lack of formal ecclesiastical approval at the time.^[19]

Immediate Responses

Episcopal Church Hierarchy's Reaction

The Presiding Bishop John Allin publicly opposed the planned ordinations prior to the event, sending telegrams on July 24, 1974, to the three retired bishops involved—Edward Budd, William Higley, and George Barrett—as well as to the 11 women deacons, urging them to refrain for the sake of church unity and the broader cause of women's ministry.^[23] Allin emphasized that such an action would undermine the church's deliberative processes on women's ordination, which had been debated but not yet authorized by canonical change.^[21] Following the July 29 ordination at the Church of the Advocate, the House of Bishops convened a special meeting on August 15, 1974, and unanimously declared the ordinations invalid, citing violations of the Episcopal Church's constitution and canons, which required standing bishops' consent and adherence to established ordination procedures.^[24] The resolution prohibited the women from exercising priestly functions and inhibited the ordaining bishops from further episcopal acts, framing the event as a disruptive breach of ecclesiastical order rather than a legitimate theological advancement.^[25] Allin described the ordinations as "distressing and divisive," arguing they diverted energy from developing women's roles through approved channels.^[21] Individual diocesan bishops swiftly enforced these directives; for instance, the bishops overseeing two of the women—likely those resident in their jurisdictions—issued formal suspensions within days of the service, barring them from sacramental ministry.^[25] The hierarchy's response prioritized canonical regularity over immediate recognition of the women's priestly status, reflecting a commitment to collegial decision-making amid ongoing General Convention debates, though some bishops privately acknowledged the ordinations' potential validity while deeming them procedurally irregular.^[26] This stance aimed to mitigate schism but drew criticism from women's advocates for sidelining substantive equality arguments in favor of proceduralism.

Public and Media Coverage

The ordination of the eleven women on July 29, 1974, drew extensive media coverage, with more than 200 journalists present at the Church of the Advocate, including international representatives from outlets such as the BBC.^[27] Major U.S. newspapers reported the event prominently, often framing it as a direct challenge to Episcopal canons and tradition; for instance, The New York Times published a front-page article the following day headlined "11 Women Ordained Episcopal Priests; Church Law Defied," detailing the ceremony's proceedings and the involvement of three retired bishops.^[28] Subsequent analyses in the same publication highlighted the ensuing debate over ordination validity, emphasizing canonical irregularities rather than women's eligibility per se.^[29] Public attendance at the service reflected strong support from advocates, with approximately 2,000 people gathered in the predominantly African American parish, which had agreed to host despite opposition risks.^[30] The event unfolded amid reported threats of violence from traditionalist opponents, underscoring immediate tensions.^[31] Within the Episcopal Church, reactions polarized rapidly: the House of Bishops voted 128-9 on September 17, 1974, to declare the ordinations invalid, prompting resignations by figures such as Harvard Divinity School professor William J. Wolf and sociologist Charles V. Willie in protest.^[29] Supporters, numbering around 1,500 at related gatherings, argued for the ordinations' substantive validity despite procedural flaws.^[29] Broader media portrayals varied, with some contemporary accounts describing coverage as intense and favorable toward the women's cause, aligning it with emerging movements for gender equality in religious institutions.^[32] However, the event's irregularity fueled criticism in conservative ecclesiastical circles, amplifying divisions that persisted until the 1976 General Convention.^[2]

Canonical and Legal Aftermath

Declaration of Invalidity and Inhibitions

On August 15, 1974, the House of Bishops of the Episcopal Church, convened in an emergency session in Chicago, formally declared the ordinations of the Philadelphia Eleven invalid.^[33]^[34] The bishops stated that essential canonical prerequisites had not been met, including the required consent of diocesan standing committees and the broader authorization from the General Convention, which had rejected women's ordination to the priesthood in 1973.^[35] Presiding Bishop John Allin, who had previously urged the women to refrain from the service, emphasized that the action undermined the church's legislative processes and episcopal collegiality.^[21] The House of Bishops further condemned the participation of the four ordaining bishops—retired bishops Daniel Corrigan and Robert DeWitt, resigned bishop Edward Welles II, and active bishop George Barrett—as a violation of their episcopal vows and the principle of shared governance.^[34]^[35] This declaration reaffirmed the women's status as deacons, nullifying their priestly claims in the eyes of church authority at the time. Canonical proceedings ensued against the ordaining clergy, with the bishops facing formal presentments and trials for exceeding their jurisdiction.^[36] In response to the invalidity ruling, the eleven women were placed under inhibition, a disciplinary measure prohibiting them from exercising any priestly functions such as celebrating the Eucharist or hearing confessions.^[37] Their diocesan bishops enforced these restrictions, preventing licensed ministry beyond their deaconal roles and subjecting unauthorized acts to further ecclesiastical penalties.^[38] Similarly, participating priests risked deposition, though the primary focus remained on upholding doctrinal and procedural uniformity until the General Convention's 1976 reversal. These inhibitions persisted for nearly two years, during which the women continued advocacy but were barred from formal priestly service.^[37]

Washington Four Ordination in 1975

On September 7, 1975, four women—Eleanor Lee McGee, Alison Palmer, Elizabeth Rosenberg Powell, and Diane Tickell—were ordained to the priesthood in an unauthorized ceremony at St. Stephen and the Incarnation Episcopal Church in Washington, D.C.^[39]^[40] The service, lasting two hours, was presided over by the Right Rev. George W. Barrett, retired Bishop of Rochester, New York, in defiance of canons prohibiting women's ordination to the priesthood, which remained unapproved by the Episcopal Church's General Convention.^[40] Three of the ordinands—McGee, Palmer, and Powell—hailed from the Diocese of Washington, while Tickell was from the Diocese of Newark.^[39] This event, dubbed the ordination of the "Washington Four," mirrored the irregular Philadelphia ordinations of July 1974 but occurred amid heightened ecclesiastical tension, as the church hierarchy had already declared the prior rite invalid and inhibited participating priests.^[41] The ceremony proceeded without the consent of Washington Bishop John T. Walker, violating diocesan authority and Title III, Canon 7 of the church's constitution, which reserved priestly ordination for male deacons under episcopal oversight.^[19] Participants justified the action as a necessary witness against what they viewed as discriminatory barriers, though critics within the church emphasized its breach of apostolic tradition and polity, arguing it undermined consensual governance.^[42] Presiding Bishop John Maury Allin immediately characterized the ordinations as "irregular and may be found invalid," echoing his response to the Philadelphia Eleven and signaling potential disciplinary measures against the ordaining bishop and priests.^[42] The rite drew about 300 attendees, including supporters and observers, but provoked swift backlash from conservative factions, who saw it as accelerating schismatic pressures already evident post-Philadelphia.^[40] Despite the invalidity declaration, the Washington ordinations contributed to mounting pressure on the 65th General Convention, which in September 1976 would regularize such actions through Resolution A069, effectively validating them retroactively.^[4]

Path to Official Approval in 1976

Following the irregular ordinations of the Philadelphia Eleven in 1974 and the similar ordination of four additional women in Washington, D.C., on September 7, 1975, mounting pressure within the Episcopal Church compelled the national leadership to address women's ordination at the 65th General Convention, held in Minneapolis from September 8 to 21, 1976.^[43]^[19] These events had exposed deep divisions, with proponents arguing for equality based on theological convictions and opponents citing tradition and ecumenical concerns, but the irregular actions demonstrated widespread support among clergy and laity, forcing the convention to confront the issue directly rather than defer it further.^[44] Debates at the convention were intense, spanning multiple days in both the House of Deputies and the House of Bishops, with amendments proposed to delay implementation or limit scope. On September 15, 1976, the House of Deputies passed Resolution A069 by a vote of 720-679 (lay) and 92-84 (clergy), amending Canon III.4 to state that "no one shall be denied rights, status or access to an equal place in the life, worship, and governance of this Church because of race, color, ethnic origin, national origin, marital status, sex, sexual orientation, disabilities or age, except as otherwise specified by Canons."^[45] The House of Bishops concurred the following day, September 16, 1976, by a margin of 130-74, effectively authorizing women's ordination to the priesthood and episcopate effective January 1, 1977.^[43]^[46] This canonical change did not retroactively validate the prior irregular ordinations but provided a framework for reconciliation.^[37] In response, the House of Bishops, on September 17, 1976, adopted a resolution affirming the validity of the 1974 and 1975 ordinations, requiring only a brief "act of completion"—a liturgical rite without re-ordination—for the fifteen women involved, thereby regularizing their status without further inhibition.^[19] This pragmatic step acknowledged the theological intent behind the irregular actions while upholding church polity, though it drew criticism from traditionalists who viewed it as capitulation to activism rather than principled reform.^[2] The approval marked a pivotal shift, enabling the first official ordinations of women priests in early 1977, but it also accelerated departures among conservatives opposed to the change.^[47]

The Ordained Women

Profiles and Subsequent Careers

Merrill Bittner (born 1937) served in the Diocese of Rochester from 1973 to 1976 before her ordination's validity was recognized, later working as a hospital chaplain and serving at St. Barnabas Church in Rumford, Maine, from 2001 to 2006.^[22] Alla Bozarth-Campbell (born 1938), originally Alla Bozarth, founded Wisdom House in Minneapolis and later Wisdom House West in Oregon, focusing on retreats and grief counseling; she authored books on grief in 1982 and 1990 and maintained a poetry blog.^[22] Alison Cheek (1927–2019) ministered at St. Stephen’s Church in Washington, D.C., and Trinity Memorial Church in Philadelphia following her ordination, later joining the faculty at Episcopal Divinity School; she relocated to Maine and then North Carolina by 2013, dying on September 1, 2019.^[22]^[48] Emily Hewitt (born 1935), also known as Emily C. Hewitt, served as an assistant professor at Andover Newton Theological School and later as Chief Judge of the U.S. Court of Federal Claims, retiring in 2013; she won a race walking medal at the 1987 Gay Games.^[22] Carter Heyward (born 1945) taught theology at Episcopal Divinity School from 1975 to 2005, authoring works on relational theology, and subsequently operated a therapeutic horseback riding center in North Carolina.^[22] Suzanne Hiatt (1944–2002) joined the faculty at Episcopal Divinity School from 1975 to 1999, contributing to seminary education and women's ordination advocacy through publications and papers, until her death in 2002.^[22] Marie Moorefield (born 1935), later Marie Moorefield Fleischer, initially pursued ordination in the United Methodist Church before transferring to the Episcopal priesthood; she served as Canon to the Ordinary in the Diocese of North Carolina from 2001 to 2006.^[22] Jeannette Piccard (1895–1981), a pioneering stratospheric balloonist and NASA consultant, performed unpaid ministerial duties at St. Philip’s Church in Minneapolis after her ordination, passing away on August 17, 1981.^[22] Betty Bone Schiess (1923–2017) directed the Mizpah Rural Resources Center from 1973 to 1984 and served in various New York parishes, including as executive director of counseling services, until her death in 2017.^[22] Katrina Swanson (1935–2021), also Katrina Welles Swanson, assisted at St. Stephen’s Church in St. Louis in 1975 and became the first woman rector of St. John’s Church in New Brunswick, New Jersey, from 1978 to 1995; her legacy includes the Katrina's Dream project advocating for women's inclusion in religious imagery.^[22] Nancy Wittig (born 1936), also Nancy Hatch Wittig, ministered in the Diocese of Newark and served as rector of St. Andrew’s Church in Philadelphia for 20 years, retiring to Ohio and marrying Pamela Darling in 2012.^[22]

Controversies and Criticisms

Violations of Church Polity and Tradition

The ordination of the eleven women on July 29, 1974, at the Church of the Advocate in the Diocese of Pennsylvania violated core elements of Episcopal Church polity by circumventing the canonical authority vested in the diocesan bishop and standing committee. Title III, Canon 11 of the 1973 Constitution and Canons required that no deacon be advanced to priesthood without a recommendation from the standing committee of the diocese to the bishop, followed by the bishop's examination of the candidate's qualifications and issuance of an order for ordination.^[49] In this case, the service proceeded without the consent or involvement of Bishop Allen L. Bartlett, the active diocesan bishop, or the diocesan standing committee, rendering the process irregular and unauthorized within the jurisdictional boundaries of Pennsylvania.^[50] ^[4] The participating bishops—retired suffragan Daniel Corrigan of Colorado, recently resigned diocesan Robert L. DeWitt of Pennsylvania, and retired Edward R. Welles II of West Missouri—lacked the jurisdictional authority to ordain independently in an active diocese.^[22] Episcopal polity, as outlined in the canons, reserves primary ordination powers to the diocesan bishop, coadjutor, suffragan, or missionary bishop, with retired bishops permitted to perform episcopal acts only under specific commissions, such as from the Presiding Bishop for foreign congregations or with explicit diocesan approval, neither of which applied here.^[49] This bypass undermined the hierarchical structure designed to ensure orderly governance and doctrinal uniformity, prompting the House of Bishops to declare the ordinations invalid on August 16, 1974, citing breaches of the church's constitution and canons.^[35] ^[2] Beyond procedural lapses, the event disrupted longstanding ecclesiastical tradition by introducing women into the priesthood, a role historically reserved for men across the Episcopal Church's 185-year existence and the broader Anglican Communion. While no explicit canon in 1974 prohibited female ordination—a point later leveraged by proponents—the uniform practice since the church's 1789 founding aligned with apostolic and catholic traditions limiting priesthood to males, as evidenced by consistent canonical interpretations and synodal rejections of change prior to 1976.^[4] ^[2] This departure prioritized individual conscience over communal discernment, straining the polity's emphasis on conciliar authority and risking fragmentation, as subsequent inhibitions against the ordaining bishops underscored.^[35]

Traditionalist Objections from Scriptural and Historical Standpoints

Traditionalists within the Episcopal Church and broader Anglican communion objected to the Philadelphia Eleven's ordinations on scriptural grounds, asserting that the Bible establishes male-only leadership in the priesthood through explicit prohibitions and precedents. Key passages cited include 1 Timothy 2:11-12, where Paul instructs that women should "learn in silence with all submission" and not "teach or have authority over a man," a directive interpreted as barring women from the authoritative teaching and sacramental roles central to priesthood.^[51] Similarly, 1 Corinthians 14:34-35 commands women to "keep silent in the churches" and be submissive, reinforcing a divinely ordered hierarchy incompatible with female ordination.^[52] Traditionalists argued this reflects the creation order, with man formed first (1 Timothy 2:13; Genesis 2), and noted the absence of any New Testament example of women exercising priestly functions, as Jesus selected only male apostles despite female followers like Mary Magdalene, who received honorary titles but no Holy Orders.^[52] Galatians 3:28's declaration of equality in Christ was dismissed as pertaining to salvific status, not ecclesiastical office, with 1 Corinthians 12 emphasizing distinct, non-interchangeable roles in the body of Christ.^[52] Historically, opponents emphasized an unbroken male priesthood from apostolic times through the patristic era and Reformation formularies, viewing the 1974 ordinations as a rupture with 2,000 years of practice. Church fathers such as Tertullian (c. A.D. 206) stated it was impermissible for women to speak in church or claim sacerdotal office, while Epiphanius (A.D. 377) affirmed no scriptural evidence for female priesthood, and John Chrysostom (A.D. 387) deemed the task beyond women's capacity.^[51] Early councils reinforced this: the Council of Laodicea (A.D. 360) prohibited ordaining "presbyteresses," and Nicaea I (A.D. 325) classified deaconesses as unordained laity.^[51] In Anglican tradition, the ordinal's masculine language ("him" for the ordinand) and the absence of female priests until modern innovations underscored fidelity to apostolic succession, with traditionalists like those in the Anglican Catholic Church arguing the Philadelphia action introduced feminist influences alien to historic faith.^[53] This consensus, they contended, derived from divine institution rather than cultural prejudice, as evidenced by consistent rejection across diverse contexts until 20th-century pressures.^[52]

Long-Term Impact

Achievements in Expanding Ordination

The ordinations of the Philadelphia Eleven on July 29, 1974, created a pivotal controversy within the Episcopal Church, exposing ambiguities in the canons that did not explicitly prohibit women's ordination to the priesthood.^[9] This act of defiance prompted intense debate and legal challenges, ultimately pressuring the church's leadership to address the issue at the 65th General Convention in Minneapolis.^[37] On September 16, 1976, the convention amended the canons to permit the ordination of women to both the priesthood and episcopate, applying ordination standards equally to men and women.^[43] ^[54] Following the 1976 decision, women's ordinations accelerated across most dioceses, with the church validating the Philadelphia Eleven's ordinations through a minimal "act of completion" liturgy.^[19] By 2003, the Episcopal Church had ordained 5,542 women to the priesthood and diaconate, including 12 female bishops.^[55] This expansion marked a shift from zero women priests prior to 1974 to women comprising approximately 37 percent of ordained clergy by 2020.^[56] The Philadelphia Eleven's initiative paved the way for landmark advancements, such as the 1989 consecration of Barbara Harris as the first woman bishop in the Anglican Communion.^[31] Their actions demonstrated the feasibility and demand for female clergy, fostering a pipeline of women into seminary and leadership roles, and normalizing inclusive ordination practices that influenced subsequent generations of ordinands.^[20] By challenging entrenched barriers through direct action, the group contributed to a sustained increase in female representation, with some dioceses reporting women as roughly half of active priests.^[57]

Contributions to Denominational Decline and Schisms

The irregular ordination of the Philadelphia Eleven on July 29, 1974, intensified divisions within the Episcopal Church, accelerating theological polarization that contributed to subsequent schisms among traditionalists opposed to women's priesthood on scriptural and historical grounds.^[58] This act, performed without canonical authorization, prompted the House of Bishops to declare the ordinations invalid in September 1974 and inhibit the ordaining bishops, yet it galvanized progressive advocates and forced a reckoning at the 1976 General Convention, where women's ordination was regularized.^[2] Conservatives, viewing the event as a violation of church polity and apostolic tradition, cited it as emblematic of a broader erosion of doctrinal fidelity, prompting early departures and the formation of breakaway jurisdictions.^[15] The 1976 approval, directly influenced by the Philadelphia precedent and the subsequent Washington Four ordinations in September 1975, marked a tipping point for schismatic movements. Traditionalist clergy and laity, numbering in the thousands, began exiting en masse, culminating in the 1977 Congress of St. Louis, where the Affirmation of St. Louis was adopted by continuing Anglicans rejecting women's ordination alongside revisions to the Book of Common Prayer.^[58] This document birthed entities like the Anglican Catholic Church, with initial congregations drawn from Episcopal parishes unwilling to accommodate the policy shift. Further fractures occurred in the 1990s and 2000s, as unresolved tensions over gender roles compounded by later innovations fueled the 2009 creation of the Anglican Church in North America (ACNA), which now claims over 1,000 congregations and rejects women's ordination to the priesthood in most dioceses.^[15] Conservative analyses attribute these schisms to the Philadelphia Eleven's role in prioritizing ideological change over consensus, eroding the church's catholic heritage and alienating members committed to male-only priesthood as per early church practice.^[58] Empirical data underscores the link to denominational decline: Episcopal membership peaked at approximately 3.4 million in the mid-1960s but fell to 2.3 million by the early 2000s, a 32.6% drop amid U.S. population growth, with accelerated losses post-1976 correlating to conservative exodus rather than broader secular trends alone.^[59] By 2023, baptized membership hovered around 1.6 million, with average Sunday attendance under 400,000, reflecting a failure to offset departing traditionalists with sufficient progressive influx.^[60] Critics from orthodox Anglican perspectives argue this stems from the 1974 ordinations exemplifying a pattern of unilateral innovation that prioritized cultural accommodation over evangelistic retention, as evidenced by ACNA's growth trajectory in contrast to the Episcopal Church's stagnation.^[58] While official Episcopal narratives frame the changes as adaptive renewal, the persistent numerical contraction—coupled with schismatic realignments—indicates causal contributions from the polity disruptions initiated by the Philadelphia Eleven.^[61]

Legacy and Commemorations

50th Anniversary Reflections in 2024

In 2024, The Episcopal Church commemorated the 50th anniversary of the Philadelphia Eleven's ordinations on July 29 with churchwide events, including special sermons delivered on July 28 and screenings of the documentary The Philadelphia Eleven.^[4] Various dioceses encouraged women to preside at altars, with the Diocese of New York explicitly promoting "a woman at every altar" to highlight the ordinations' legacy.^[4] The Diocese of Rhode Island released an oral history series on women's ordination, featuring interviews with figures such as Bishop Geralyn Wolf and Rev. Canon Linda Grenz, made available online on July 29.^[4] Publications marked the occasion with renewed focus on the event's historical significance. A revised and expanded 50th anniversary edition of The Story of the Philadelphia Eleven by Darlene O'Dell was published in June by Church Publishing, updating the account of the ordinations and their aftermath.^[62] The Historical Society of the Episcopal Church dedicated its June 2024 issue of Anglican and Episcopal History to the Philadelphia Eleven, featuring essays such as Carter Heyward's nine-part personal reflection on 50 years as a priest, which critiqued White Christian nationalism, and Paula D. Nesbitt's analysis arguing that the "feminization of the priesthood" may have mitigated steeper membership declines in the denomination.^[63] Reflections emphasized the ordinations' role in advancing gender inclusion, with current statistics showing 7,166 women serving as clergy (2,075 deacons, 5,039 priests, and 52 bishops) in The Episcopal Church.^[4] Rev. Carter Heyward, one of the original Eleven, preached at Philadelphia Episcopal Cathedral, stating that "many are captivated by the power of the Philadelphia ordination service."^[4] Bishop John Taylor of the Diocese of Los Angeles remarked, "The wages of misogyny are mediocrity," linking the 1974 actions to improved church leadership and justice.^[4] These commemorations largely portrayed the Eleven's defiance of canon law as a pivotal act of courage that accelerated official approval of women's ordination in 1976, though they occurred amid ongoing debates over ecclesiastical authority and tradition.^[4]

Documentary and Cultural Representations

The primary documentary representation of the Philadelphia Eleven is the 2023 feature-length film The Philadelphia Eleven, directed by Margo Guernsey and produced by Nikki Bramley through Time Travel Productions.^[64] The film chronicles the irregular ordination of the eleven women on July 29, 1974, at the Church of the Advocate in Philadelphia, framing it as an act of civil disobedience against church prohibitions on female priests, and details the subsequent ecclesiastical trials, excommunications, and eventual regularization of their ordinations in 1976.^[65] It includes interviews with surviving ordinands and bishops involved, archival footage from the event, and contextualizes the ordinations within broader 1970s movements for women's rights and church reform.^[66] The documentary premiered at film festivals in 2023, received distribution through American Public Television, and aired nationally on PBS stations starting in early 2025.^[67] Reception of The Philadelphia Eleven has emphasized its role in commemorating the 50th anniversary of the ordinations, with screenings hosted by Episcopal dioceses and organizations like the Minnesota Society of Fine Arts highlighting themes of institutional change and perseverance amid opposition.^[68] Critics and viewers, including those in Episcopal publications, have praised its archival depth and personal narratives, though it has been noted for focusing predominantly on the women's perspectives without extensive counterarguments from traditionalist opponents within the church.^[69] The film has been screened at events such as the 2024 anniversary gatherings, contributing to renewed discussions on the ordinations' legacy.^[70] In print media, the event is detailed in The Story of the Philadelphia Eleven: Revised and Expanded 50th Anniversary Edition (2024), authored by the ordinands with updates on their careers and the ordinations' aftermath, published by Church Publishing Incorporated as a historical account blending memoir and analysis.^[62] This edition expands on the original 1985 publication, incorporating reflections from the participants and serving as a primary source for subsequent cultural works like the documentary. No major feature films, theatrical plays, or novels directly centered on the Philadelphia Eleven have been produced, though the ordinations have been referenced in broader Episcopal histories and gender studies texts.^[71]

References

[1]
Exploring the Digital Archives - The Episcopal Church
Sep 6, 2024 · Finally, on July 29, 1974, an irregular ordination was held in Philadelphia. The 11 women who were ordained that day are called the Philadelphia ...
[2]
The Philadelphia Ordinations: Some Misunderstandings
Jul 29, 2024 · On July 29, 1974, eleven women were ordained to the priesthood in Philadelphia; they are commonly referred to as the Philadelphia Eleven.Missing: primary | Show results with:primary
[3]
The Journey to Women's Ordination - News - Episcopal Divinity School
Dec 27, 2023 · Douglas noted that the Philadelphia Eleven were ordained at the historically Black Church of the Advocate where Rev. Paul Washington was rector ...
[4]
Episcopal Church marks 50th anniversary of the Philadelphia 11 ...
Jul 29, 2024 · ... women priests in The Episcopal Church with special sermons, screenings of the Philadelphia Eleven documentary and even by encouraging ...Missing: primary | Show results with:primary
[5]
Episcopal Church ordination of women | Research Starters - EBSCO
The conversation around women's ordination gained momentum during the 1960s, influenced by broader societal movements for civil rights and gender equality.
[6]
The Theological Case for Women's Ordination
Many theologians favor women participating fully in the ordained ministry of the people of God who are the Church.
[7]
The Ordination of Women: Pro and Con
And Whereas, there are many reasons (psychological, sociological, ecumenical, Biblical, traditional and theological) against ordination of women to the ...Missing: pre- | Show results with:pre-<|separator|>
[8]
Incarnation, Trinity, and the Ordination of Women to the Priesthood
Arguments based on the incarnation and the Father/Son relationship within the Trinity that are thought to bar the ordination of women as priests and bishops.
[9]
Ordination of Women - The Episcopal Church
A 1967 General Convention resolution had opened the diaconate to women and recognized that women currently serving as deaconesses were members of the diaconate.Missing: debate 1960s
[10]
Background Essay: Women's Ordination in the Episcopal Church
Jul 24, 2021 · In 1970 in Houston, the General Convention of the Episcopal Church gathered, and the issue of women's ordination was put before them for the ...Missing: 1960s | Show results with:1960s
[11]
1973 Convention · Episcopal Church Women
In 1973, on the fifth day of the convention, a resolution changing the constitution to allow women's ordination was brought before the House of Deputies.
[12]
50th Anniversary, ordination of women in Episcopal Church
Jul 28, 2024 · Another resolution was proposed at the 1970 General Convention to approve women's ordination to the priesthood and episcopate. It failed to pass ...
[13]
[PDF] By Lawrence N. Crumb - Scholars' Bank
However, there are canons that reflect the polity of the church and thus its very essence. Of all the canonical requirements for ordination to the diaconate and ...
[14]
Irregular Ordination · Episcopal Church Women
The General Convention's 1973 vote rejecting women's ordination was a signal for many that the time had come to work outside the legislative system.
[15]
An Anglican Layman Looks at Women's Ordination
Apr 25, 2025 · We will attempt to answer this question: Is it faithful to scripture, tradition, and reason for women to be ordained as priests in the Anglican Church in North ...
[16]
First Ordination of Women to the Priesthood in The Episcopal Church
Jul 8, 2024 · This commemoration marks the ordination of eleven women to the priesthood in Philadelphia on 29 July 1974.
[17]
11 Women May Be Ordained as Priests - The New York Times
Episc bishops Rt Revs Robert L Dewitt, Daniel Corrigan and Edward Randolph Welles rept plans to ordain 11 women as priests in defiance of ch's laws and ...
[18]
Episcopal News Service: Press Release # 84159 - Digital Archives
... 1974 rites which defied Episcopal Church canons -- the Rev. Paul Washington, the rector who allowed his church to be used for the "irregular" ordinations ...
[19]
Philadelphia Eleven, The - The Episcopal Church
The women ordained were Merrill Bittner, Alla Bozarth-Campbell, Alison Cheek, Emily Hewitt, Carter Heyward, Suzanne Hiatt, Marie Moorefield, Jeanette Piccard, ...Missing: planning participants
[20]
The Legacy of the Philadelphia Eleven - The Diocese of West Missouri
Jul 29, 2024 · This unorthodox ordination challenged the centuries old traditions and paved the way for future inclusion of all genders in the ordination ...<|separator|>
[21]
Episcopal News Service: Press Release # 74200 - Digital Archives
July 31, 1974 [74200]. PHILADELPHIA, Pa. -- Eleven women were ordained priests in the Episcopal Church on July 29 in the Church of the Advocate in Philadelphia ...
[22]
Where are the Philadelphia 11 – and their ordaining bishops – now?
Jul 28, 2014 · The following are summaries of the lives and work of the priests known as the Philadelphia 11 since their “irregular” ordinations on July 29, 1974.
[23]
PRELATE OPPOSES ORDAINING WOMEN - The New York Times
Jul 24, 1974 · Bishop AIlin sent telegrams to the bishops, who are retired, as well as to the 11 women. “For the sake of the unity of the church and the cause ...
[24]
Authority in the Aftermath · Venture In Ministry: John Maury Allin ...
On August 15, 1974, the House of Bishops, acting at a special meeting, declared the Philadelphia ordinations “invalid.” It adopted a resolution, ...
[25]
Bishops Suspend 2 of 11 Women Ordained as Episcopal Priests
Jul 31, 1974 · John M. Allin, said yesterday that the Philadelphia ceremony was contrary to the constitution and canons of the Episcopal church” and that the ...
[26]
Sermon, August 4 | St. Dunstan's Episcopal Church
Aug 4, 2024 · Initially the Bishops were going to declare the ordinations invalid – meaning, the ordination rite was void and those women aren't really ...<|separator|>
[27]
Philadelphia Eleven's Piccard made history, first as a pilot, then as a ...
Jul 26, 2024 · ... ordained by three willing bishops (with the presence of a fourth supporting bishop). The women became known as the Philadelphia Eleven.
[28]
11 Women Ordained Episcopal Priests; Church Law Defied
Jul 30, 1974 · PHILADELPHIA, July 29—In a controversial ceremony that defied their church's laws, and tradition, 11 women were ordained as Episcopal ...<|control11|><|separator|>
[29]
Women Priests: Episcopal Ordination Controversy - The New York ...
Aug 23, 1974 · 11 women were ordained to the priesthood in the Episcopal Church in a ceremony that set off waves of controversy in the 3.1‐millionmember church.
[30]
Women's History Month: A Look Back At 'The Philadelphia Eleven'
Mar 8, 2024 · At the time when women were first ordained in the Episcopal Church, it was considered the most critical event in the denomination's history ...
[31]
Are women in the pulpit the reason mainline Christians are leaving ...
Aug 1, 2024 · The illegal ordination of 11 women as priests in the Episcopal Church in 1974 paved the way for the elevation of Barbara Harris.
[32]
Celebrating the Philadelphia 11, 40 Years Later
Jul 29, 2014 · The media coverage was intense and positive. And the women's ordination movement in the Catholic church was just gaining some steam. We were ...Missing: Eleven | Show results with:Eleven
[33]
Episcopal News Service: Press Release # 74215 - Digital Archives
Ordinations of Women to Priesthood Ruled Invalid. Diocesan Press Service. August 15, 1974 [74215]. Isabel Baumgartner. CHICAGO, Ill. -- The eleven women deacons ...
[34]
Interactive timeline of the history of women's ordination
Jul 28, 2014 · Episcopal News Service offers an annotated timeline of selected events in the journey towards women's ordination in The Episcopal Church.Missing: debate 1960s
[35]
House of Bishops Disputes Validity Of Ordination of 11 Women as ...
Aug 16, 1974 · “We believe they are wrong; we decry their acting in violaItion of the collegiality of the House of Bishops as well as the legislative process ...Missing: response | Show results with:response
[36]
July 29, 1974 - An Inch At A Time: Reflections on the Journey
Jul 29, 2009 · On August 15, 1974, the House of Bishops, called to an emergency meeting, denounced the ordinations and declared them invalid. Charges were ...
[37]
The Vote · Episcopal Church Women
The first regular ordination of a woman took place on January 1, 1977, when Jacqueline Means was ordained at the Church of All Saints in Indianapolis, Indiana.Missing: 1960s | Show results with:1960s
[38]
[PDF] The Ordination of Women and the Anglican-Episcopal Experience
The contemporary history of the issue concerning the ordination of women in the Anglican-Episcopal Church can be divided into three segments, from the 1940's to ...
[39]
Episcopal News Service: Press Release # 75313 - Digital Archives
WASHINGTON, D.C. -- Four women, three from the Diocese of Washington, were ordained to the priesthood at St. Stephen and the Incarnation, D.C., Sept. 7.
[40]
4 WOMEN BECOME EPISCOPAL PRIESTS - The New York Times
Sep 8, 1975 · WASHINGTON, Sept. 7—Four women were ordained to the Episcopal priesthood today in an unsanctioned service that appeared certain to intensify ...
[41]
Washington, DC church that was site of 'irregular' ordinations of four ...
Sep 4, 2025 · Allin said were “irregular and may be found invalid” – the ordination of the Washington 4 caused controversy across The Episcopal Church.
[42]
'I Never Felt More Danger Than When I Kneeled to Be Ordained ...
Sep 16, 2015 · John M. Allin, then presiding bishop of the Episcopal Church, referred to the ordination of the Washington Four as “distressing and divisive ...
[43]
Marking the 40th anniversary of General Convention's approval of ...
Sep 16, 2016 · Forty years ago on Sept. 16, 1976, the General Convention officially opened the Episcopal Church's ranks of priests and bishops to women.Missing: process | Show results with:process
[44]
Where do we go from here: Prospects for the 1976 Convention
... Episcopal Church were to approve the ordination of women to the priesthood and episcopate. Because the Episcopal Church is engaged in serious ecumenical ...
[45]
Celebrating 50 Years of Women's Ordination - National Cathedral
The Rev. Alison Cheek, one the Philadelphia Eleven, publicly celebrated the Eucharist in an Episcopal Church for the first time at St. Stephen and the ...Missing: primary | Show results with:primary
[46]
Acts of Convention: Resolution # 1976-B300 - Digital Archives
Since the Minnesota Convention has approved women's ordination to the priesthood, "reconciliation" will be desperately needed, a reconciliation effected ...Missing: process | Show results with:process
[47]
C023 Commemorating The Philadelphia Eleven in the Church ...
The ordinations inspired both celebration and controversy in the Episcopal Church. The House of Bishops declared them “irregular” and the Philadelphia Eleven ...Missing: planners | Show results with:planners
[48]
The Philadelphia Eleven | KPBS Public Media
Mar 7, 2025 · Individual photos of the group of Episcopal priests known as “the Philadelphia Eleven”. Pictured from left to right top row: The Rev.
[49]
[PDF] constitution & canons 1973 - Archives of the Episcopal Church
a majority of the Bishops of this Church entitled to vote in the House of Bishops shall consent to the proposed ordination and consecration under the ...
[50]
Episcopal Unit Is for Ordaining Women - The New York Times
Oct 19, 1974 · On July 29, four bishops participated in the ordination of 11 women in Philadelphia without the permission of the bishop of Pennsylvania. But ...
[51]
What the Early Church Believed: Women and the Priesthood
Can Women Be Priests? This is a question that provokes much debate in our modern world, but it is one to which the Church has always answered “No.” ...
[52]
The Anglican Error of Women's Ordination
Apr 29, 2025 · Traditional Anglicans believe women have distinct roles, not in Holy Orders, and that the Church's stance on women's ordination should not ...
[53]
Why Women's Ordination Cannot be Tolerated
Jan 27, 2023 · I believe that if we follow Scripture faithfully and assent to the Anglican Formularies, then women's ordination cannot be tolerated; it must instead be ...
[54]
Episcopal News Service: Press Release # 97-1791 - Digital Archives
(ENS) In an historic vote, the 1976 General Convention of the Episcopal Church decreed that canons on ordination should apply equally to men and women, ...
[55]
Episcopal News Service: Press Release # 030411-04
There are 5,542 ordained women in the Episcopal Church, including 12 bishops, and 12,464 male clergy. "Despite the presence of women clergy in the church for ...
[56]
Amid growth in leadership, one-fifth of U.S. clergy are female
Mar 1, 2020 · In Episcopal churches, women made up 37 percent of ordained clergy and 33 percent of pastors, nearly identical to the percentages ... Church ...
[57]
Celebrating 50 Years of Women's Ordination to the Priesthood
Jul 29, 2024 · So much has changed in those 50 years. In 1976, the Church finally gave its official approval to women's ordination. Eloise Lester became the ...
[58]
EDITOR'S NOTEBOOK: Assessing The Philadelphia 11 After 50 Years
Jul 26, 2024 · These women, dubbed The Philadelphia Eleven, created a rift in the Episcopal Church that quickly led to other policy changes, the departure of ...
[59]
Trends in Large US Church Membership from 1960 - Demographia
CHURCH MEMBERSHIP (In Millions). Church, 1960 Membership, Rank, 2002-4 ... Episcopal Church, 3,444, 7, 2,320, 11, -32.6%, 14. Evangelical Lutheran Church in ...
[60]
Episcopal Church - Groups - Religious Profiles | US Religion
Episcopal Church, Trends (1925 - 2010) ; 1960, 3,269,325, 8,938, 7,155 ; 1961, 3,317,870, 9,385, 7,096.
[61]
Beautiful Anglican Mists - Juicy Ecumenism
Sep 6, 2023 · In the 1960s The Episcopal Church's membership peaked at 3.6 million. ... Episcopal Church's current U.S. membership. There's no point in ...<|separator|>
[62]
The Story of the Philadelphia Eleven, Revised and Expanded
This expanded and revised edition serves as the definitive account of the courageous women who shattered stained glass ceilings and sparked a global movement.Missing: organizers | Show results with:organizers
[63]
Episcopal historians dedicate latest journal issue to Philadelphia 11 ...
Jun 3, 2024 · Nesbitt contends that “the Philadelphia ordinations and feminization processes may have saved the Episcopal Church from more significant ...
[64]
The Philadelphia Eleven
In this feature-length documentary film, we meet the women who challenge the very essence of patriarchy within Christendom.Watch · About · Watch the Trailer · Screening TourMissing: 2024 2025 deaths careers
[65]
The Philadelphia Eleven | PBS
In a 1974 act akin to civil disobedience, eleven women and their supporters organize their ordination as Episcopal priests in an unauthorized service.
[66]
THE PHILADELPHIA ELEVEN - American Public Television
The film chronicles how a group of women in the Episcopal Church shared a call to become priests. After two legislative votes to make it possible for women ...
[67]
The Philadelphia Eleven | PBS
Mar 1, 2025 · The Philadelphia Eleven ... In a 1974 act akin to civil disobedience, eleven women and their supporters organize their ordination as Episcopal ...Missing: primary | Show results with:primary<|control11|><|separator|>
[68]
The Philadelphia Eleven - MSP Film Society
After two legislative votes to make it possible for women to be ordained fail, they organize their own ordination as priests in defiance of church norms. The ...
[69]
Retracing the Steps of the Philadelphia 11 - The Living Church
Feb 29, 2024 · Bishops Corrigan, DeWitt, Welles and Barrett were all censured by the House of Bishops for their part in the ordination of the first 15 women.
[70]
Philadelphia 11 documentary recalls 'ruckus,' sets ordinations within ...
Oct 3, 2023 · Emily C. Hewitt, the Rev. Carter Heyward, the Rev. Marie Moorefield Fleischer and the Rev. Nancy Wittig. The sixth surviving priest, the Rev.
[71]
The Story of the Philadelphia Eleven: Revised and Expanded 50th ...
30-day returnsThe Story of the Philadelphia Eleven: Revised and Expanded 50th Anniversary Edition ... June 11, 2024. Dimensions. 5.3 x 1 x 8.4 inches. ISBN-10. 1640657193.