A pilot light is a small, continuously burning flame, typically fueled by natural gas or propane, that provides a constant ignition source for the main burner in gas-powered appliances such as furnaces, water heaters, ovens, and fireplaces.[1][2] This flame remains lit at all times, ensuring immediate and safe ignition without the need for manual lighting each time the main burner activates.[3][4]Pilot lights originated in the early 20th century as a safety feature for gas appliances, with a key development being a U.S. patent filed on May 13, 1922, for a safety gas-control system. They addressed the risks of gas accumulation and explosion from manual ignition methods using matches or open flames on early stoves and heaters. By the mid-20th century, they had become widespread in residential and commercial gas equipment, offering convenience and reliability, particularly in environments without electricity for ignition. Standing pilot lights consume a notable amount of fuel, with estimates indicating up to 1-2% of a household's annual gas usage for affected appliances—equating to several hundred cubic feet of gas wasted per year based on average U.S. householdconsumption of approximately 61,000 cubic feet annually.[5]Although reliable, standing pilots have been largely phased out in new appliances due to energy efficiency standards, such as the U.S. Department of Energy's 2012 prohibition on them in gas cooking products.[6] Modern systems often use electronic ignition instead, which activates only when needed and reduces energy waste significantly.
Overview
Definition and Purpose
A pilot light is a small, continuously burning gas flame, typically fueled by natural gas or propane, that serves as a reliable ignition source for the larger main burners in various gas appliances such as furnaces, water heaters, and stoves.[2] This persistent flame remains lit at all times when the appliance is connected to a gas supply, ready to ignite the primary fuel flow upon activation.[7]The primary purpose of a pilot light is to provide immediate and safe ignition of the main burner when heat is demanded by the user or thermostat, thereby preventing the need for manual lighting methods like matches and reducing potential delays or risks associated with unignited gas release.[8] By maintaining a constant ignition source, it enhances operational efficiency and user convenience in appliances that require frequent on-off cycling.[1]The term "pilot light" originated in the mid-19th century, with the earliest recorded use dating to 1846, and derives from "pilot" in the sense of a guide or leader, analogous to the small flame's role in directing or initiating the larger combustion process.[9] This etymology underscores its function as a preliminary or guiding element in gas ignition systems.At its core, a pilot light operates on the basic physics of controlled low-flow combustion, where a minimal volume of fuel gas is precisely metered and mixed with ambient air before ignition, sustaining a stable blue flame that signifies efficient, complete oxidation without soot production or extinction due to insufficient fuel or oxygen.[7] This blue coloration results from the high-temperature reaction producing excited molecular species that emit light in the visible spectrum.[3] In many designs, the flame's heat continuously powers safety features like a thermocouple, which generates a small electric current to hold open the gas valve and confirm ongoing combustion.[2]
Historical Development
The concept of the pilot light originated in 19th-century gas lighting systems, where small, continuous flames were employed in gas lamps to facilitate quick ignition and relighting, drawing from the basic principles of manufactured gas use that began in the 1820s.[10][11] These early implementations were rudimentary, often consisting of a low-burning flame maintained near the main burner in lamps to ensure reliable operation in public and domestic settings.[11]The modern standing pilot light emerged in the 1920s as a key innovation in gas appliance safety, providing a constant small flame to ignite the main burner while incorporating automatic shutoff mechanisms to prevent gas leaks if the flame extinguished.[12][13] This development addressed the hazards of manual lighting in earlier gas stoves and heaters, marking a significant advancement in reliable and safer gas utilization.[14][15]The design of pilot lights was influenced by the principles established in Robert Bunsen's 1855 invention of the Bunsen burner, which utilized premixed air and gas for a stable, hot blue flame that became foundational for efficient combustion in later gas appliances.[16] Following World War II, pilot lights saw widespread adoption in the mid-20th century as natural gas infrastructure expanded across the United States, becoming integral to household furnaces, water heaters, and stoves by the 1950s.[17] This era's boom in natural gas appliances standardized the technology, with safety features like thermocouples—devices that detect pilot flame presence and shut off gas flow—integrated to enhance reliability.[18]By the 1980s, however, the continuous energy consumption of pilot lights led to their decline, driven by federal and state energy regulations aimed at reducing waste, such as New York's 1977 law banning standing pilots in new gas appliances sold after 1980.[19][12] These policies promoted more efficient electronic ignition alternatives, phasing out pilots in favor of intermittent lighting systems that only activate when needed.[20]
Mechanism of Operation
Key Components
The pilot light assembly in gas appliances consists of several essential physical and functional components that work together to maintain a stable ignition source. These include the pilot burner, thermocouple, gas supply line, and flame shield or aerator, each designed to ensure reliable operation in domestic and commercial settings.[2]The pilot burner is a small nozzle or tube that facilitates the mixing of a low volume of gas with air to sustain a continuous, small flame. This component typically features a precisely sized orifice, typically 0.018 to 0.026 inches for natural gas and 0.006 to 0.013 inches for propane, which controls the gas flow to produce a steady blue flame rather than a sooty yellow one. The burner's design, including its tip style (such as batwing or single port), directs the flame for optimal ignition of the main burner when needed.[2][21]A thermocouple serves as a safety sensor within the assembly, comprising two dissimilar metals, such as chromel and alumel (Type K) or iron and constantan (Type J), that generate a thermoelectric voltage when heated. Positioned so its tip is enveloped by the pilot flame, it produces approximately 20-30 millivolts to signal the gas valve to remain open, confirming the flame's presence. In some systems, a thermopile—a series of thermocouples—generates higher voltage (typically 250-750 millivolts) to power the gas control valve. This bimetallic device is essential for the assembly's basic functionality, with the voltage output directly tied to the flame's heat.[22][23][24][25]The gas supply line provides a dedicated, low-pressure feed of fuel specifically to the pilot burner, distinct from the higher-volume line serving the main burner. This separate tubing, usually made of copper or flexible material, delivers a minimal gas flow—typically around 0.5-1.2 cubic feet per hour for natural gas—to sustain the pilot without excess consumption. It connects upstream to the appliance's gas valve and includes fittings for secure, leak-proof attachment.[2][26][27]Flame shields or aerators are protective and mixing elements integrated into or around the pilot assembly to safeguard the flame and optimize combustion. The flame shield, often a metal or ceramic enclosure, prevents drafts, wind, or debris from extinguishing the pilot while allowing heat to reach the thermocouple. Meanwhile, the aerator—typically a hooded or ported section of the burner—introduces primary air into the gas stream via adjustable vents, ensuring a proper air-to-gas ratio (around 10:1 for natural gas) for efficient, clean burning without carbon buildup. These components enhance the assembly's stability in varying environmental conditions.[26][28]
Ignition and Control Process
The ignition and control process of a pilot light begins with manual startup. The user turns the gas control knob to the "pilot" position, which allows a small amount of gas to flow to the pilot burner assembly. The pilot flame is then ignited using a long match, barbecue lighter, or built-in piezo igniter that produces a spark near the pilot opening. While holding the control knob or reset button depressed to maintain gas flow, the user waits approximately 30 seconds for the pilot flame to stabilize and heat the thermocouple sufficiently to generate the required voltage for holding the gas valve open.[2][29]Once established, the steady-state operation involves the pilot flame burning continuously at a low rate. This flame constantly heats the thermocouple, which produces a small thermoelectric voltage—typically 20 to 30 millivolts—through the Seebeck effect, energizing an electromagnet to keep the pilot gas valve open and prevent shutdown. During this phase, the main gas valve remains closed, ensuring no fuel flows to the primary burner until a demand for heat is signaled by the thermostat, at which point the pilot serves as a reliable, always-ready ignition source.[2]The ignition sequence for the main burner activates upon receiving a signal from the thermostat or control system. The main gas valve opens, releasing fuel into the burner tube or manifold, where the steady pilot flame immediately ignites it, producing the larger combustion needed for heating. The process reverses during shutdown: when the thermostat reaches the set temperature, the main gas valve closes, extinguishing the primary flame while the pilot continues to burn uninterrupted to maintain system readiness.[2]Central to the control logic is the thermocouple's role in flame supervision. As long as the pilot flame envelops the thermocouple tip, the generated voltage sustains the electromagnetic holding coil in the gas valve, allowing continuous pilot operation. If the pilot flame extinguishes for any reason, the thermocouple cools quickly—typically within seconds—causing the voltage to drop and the electromagnet to de-energize, which closes the valve and stops all gas flow to both pilot and main burner.[2]
Applications
Domestic Appliances
In domestic settings, pilot lights serve as a continuous ignition source in various gas-powered appliances, particularly in older models designed for reliability and simplicity. Tank-style gas water heaters commonly feature standing pilot lights to ignite the main burner, enabling the production of hot water on demand. These pilots maintain a small, steady flame that ensures immediate response when hot water is needed, avoiding delays associated with electronic systems. The pilot flame should be steady and blue, typically around 0.5 inches tall to properly heat the thermocouple.[30][31] As of 2025, standard-efficiency models of new gas water heaters may still incorporate standing pilot lights, while high-efficiency models use electronic ignition to meet U.S. Department of Energy Uniform Energy Factor (UEF) standards.[32][33]Central heating systems, including gas furnaces and boilers, frequently incorporate pilot lights in pre-1990s installations to facilitate reliable ignition during cold weather. In these setups, the standing pilot remains lit year-round, ready to fire the main burners when the thermostat signals a need for heat, which is especially valuable in older homes lacking advanced controls. This design was prevalent in U.S. residential construction before the widespread adoption of electronic ignition in the 1980s and 1990s, contributing to consistent performance in traditional forced-air or hydronic systems.[13][34]Gas fireplaces and stoves also utilize pilot lights to deliver instant flames for heating, ambiance, or cooking purposes. In vented or unvented gas fireplaces, the pilot provides a constant low-level burn that ignites the primary logs or burners, enhancing user convenience by eliminating manual lighting. For gas stoves and ovens, pilots ignite the top burners, broilers, and bake elements, supporting everyday meal preparation in homes without spark ignition. These implementations prioritize ease of use in residential environments, where quick activation is essential.[35][7]Despite regulatory efforts by the U.S. Department of Energy to phase out standing pilots in new gas appliances since the 1980s—driven by energy efficiency standards—pilot lights remain common in pre-1990s U.S. homes, with many existing gas appliances continuing to rely on them as of 2025. This persistence reflects the slow replacement rate of legacy equipment in the residential sector, where upgrades often lag behind manufacturing shifts toward intermittent or electronic ignition.[36][37]
Commercial and Industrial Uses
In commercial settings such as restaurants and laundromats, pilot lights are integral to gas-fired boilers and heaters, providing continuous ignition for high-demand hot water systems and space heating. These larger-scale appliances often feature standing pilot lights sized for high-BTU burners to ensure reliable startup during peak usage, such as meal preparation or laundry cycles, where interruptions could disrupt operations. For instance, in restaurant boilers, the pilot maintains readiness for instant hot water supply to dishwashers and sinks.[38]In commercial kitchens, pilot lights remain a standard feature in gas ranges, ovens, fryers, and broilers, offering immediate ignition for multiple burners and enhancing operational efficiency in fast-paced environments. Unlike residential units, these pilots are designed for frequent, heavy use and are typically left burning continuously to minimize downtime, with one pilot often serving each burner for precise control. This setup supports backup ignition for torches or auxiliary burners in high-volume cooking scenarios.[7][39][40]For industrial applications, pilot lights, often in the form of robust pilot burners, are employed in furnaces for process heating in sectors like metalworking and food processing. These pilots ignite the main gas flames in high-temperature environments, such as annealing metals or sterilizing equipment, and are engineered with durable materials to withstand harsh conditions including vibration, dust, and extreme heat. Manufacturers prioritize stoichiometric combustion in these pilots to optimize ignition reliability while minimizing gas consumption.[41]In laboratory settings, pilot lights facilitate safe ignition in gas torches and burners used for experiments requiring precise flame control, such as in analytical chemistry or material testing. These compact pilots, integrated into Bunsen-style or specialized burners, provide a stable ignition source and are adjusted for consistent flame output.[42]Regulatory standards, such as those in NFPA 54 (National Fuel Gas Code), mandate the use of pilot lights or equivalent ignition sources in commercial and industrial gas appliances to ensure safety and reliability, particularly in high-stakes environments where failure could lead to operational hazards. As of 2025, these codes emphasize proper installation and maintenance of pilots in systems operating at pressures up to 10 psi, applying to a wide range of non-residential installations including boilers and furnaces.[43][44]
Safety Considerations
Protective Mechanisms
Pilot lights incorporate several protective mechanisms to prevent gas leaks and ensure safe operation by automatically detecting flame presence and controlling gas flow. One primary safety feature is the thermocouple, a thermoelectric device typically consisting of two dissimilar metals joined at a junction placed in the pilot flame. When heated by the flame, the thermocouple generates a small millivolt electrical current, typically 20-30 mV, which energizes an electromagnet to hold open the gas valve, allowing continuous fuel supply to the pilot.[45] If the pilot flame extinguishes, the thermocouple cools rapidly—within approximately 30 seconds—and the voltage drops, causing the electromagnet to de-energize and the safety valve to close, shutting off the gas supply to prevent unburned gas accumulation.[2] This mechanism is standard in standing pilot systems and provides a reliable, fail-safe response without requiring external power.[46]In more advanced pilot light configurations, particularly those integrated with intermittent ignition systems, flame rectification serves as an alternative or complementary safety detection method. This process exploits the conductive properties of the ionized flame: an AC voltage is applied across a flame rod (or sensor) positioned in the flame and grounded through the burner. The flame rectifies the AC signal into a DC microamp current (typically 1-4 μA), which the control module detects to confirm flame presence and maintain solenoid valve operation for gas flow.[47] If the flame is absent, the rectification signal ceases within seconds, triggering the module to close the gas valve and halt fuel delivery, thereby averting potential leaks or ignition hazards.[48]Flame rectification is valued for its sensitivity and ability to distinguish true flame from false signals, enhancing reliability in commercial and modern residential applications.The standing pilot design itself contributes to safety by maintaining a constant, low-intensity flame that acts as an inherent ignition source for the main burner. Unlike manual or spark-ignition systems, this continuous flame ensures immediate lighting upon demand, minimizing the risk of unlit gas buildup in the combustion chamber that could lead to delayed ignition or explosions.[49] Integrated with thermocouple or similar sensors, the standing pilot reduces accumulation of unburned gas compared to non-pilot systems, as any gas release to the main burner encounters the ready flame.[1] This design's simplicity promotes consistent safety performance in domestic appliances like water heaters and furnaces.[50]Compliance with established certification standards further reinforces these protective features. Pilot light systems in gas appliances must adhere to ANSI Z21 series codes, such as ANSI Z21.1 for household cooking appliances and ANSI Z21.88 for vented gas fireplaces, which mandate automatic shutoff mechanisms to prevent gas flow in the absence of proven ignition.[51] These standards require rigorous testing for flame detection reliability, valve closure response times, and resistance to gas buildup, ensuring that protective devices like thermocouples and flame rectification systems activate to avert explosions from accumulated gas.[52] Certified appliances demonstrate compliance through independent verification, promoting uniform safety across installations.[53]
Associated Hazards
Pilot lights in gas appliances can experience flame outages due to external drafts that blow out the small flame, accumulation of dirt or soot blocking the gas flow, or fluctuations in low gas pressure during high-demand periods.[54][55] If the flame extinguishes and the appliance's safety valve fails to close properly, unburned natural gas may continue to flow undetected, leading to potential leaks that pose asphyxiation or fire risks within enclosed spaces.[56]Incomplete combustion in pilot lights, often indicated by a yellow flame rather than a proper blue one, results from soot buildup or insufficient oxygen supply, producing carbon monoxide (CO) as a byproduct. This colorless, odorless gas can accumulate indoors, especially in poorly ventilated areas, leading to CO poisoning symptoms such as headaches, dizziness, and in severe cases, death; pilot lights contribute to indoor air pollution through these unvented combustion byproducts.[57][58] A yellow flame signals inefficient burning and elevated CO release, necessitating professional inspection to prevent health hazards.[59]Relighting a pilot light after an outage without adequate ventilation carries an explosion risk if gas has accumulated in the area, as an ignition source can trigger a flash fire or blast; U.S. authorities warn against attempting relights if gas odor is present to avoid this danger. Based on 2018 NFPA data, natural gas leaks from appliances contributed to approximately 4,200 home fires annually, some involving explosions from ignited leaks.[60] More recent NFPA data (2018–2022 average) estimates 15,941 structure fires annually where flammable gases were the first material ignited.[61] As of 2024, catastrophic natural gas explosions in homes continue to rise, with 2023 marking the deadliest year in nearly 20 years according to investigative reports.[62]Maintenance neglect exacerbates outage frequency through clogging of the pilot assembly by spider webs, which insects build in dormant tubes, or corrosion from moisture exposure that narrows orifices and disrupts gas flow. These issues increase the likelihood of repeated flame failures and associated risks like leaks or inefficient combustion if not addressed periodically by qualified technicians.[63][64]
Energy and Environmental Impact
Consumption and Waste
A typical standing pilot light in gas appliances consumes between 400 and 1,000 British thermal units (BTU) per hour, depending on the appliance and adjustment.[65][66] This continuous burning equates to roughly 35 to 88 therms of natural gas annually, representing 5-15% of a typical U.S. household's total yearly gas consumption (average ~585 therms per gas-using household as of 2020) and adding $56-142 to the average annual gas bill based on 2025 national residential prices of approximately $1.61 per therm.[67]The 24/7 operation of pilot lights results in significant unused energy expenditure, as the flame provides no heating benefit during periods without main burner activation. For gas water heaters, this standby consumption accounts for 10-20% of the appliance's overall annual gas usage, given that a standard unit requires about 180-250 therms per year for hot water production.[68][65]Several factors influence pilot light gas usage, including the size of the flame (which can be manually adjusted via the gas valve), the type of fuel (natural gas versus propane, with propane requiring less volume for equivalent BTU output due to its higher energy density), and ambient conditions such as temperature and wind, which may necessitate larger flames or more frequent adjustments in colder climates to maintain stable ignition.[69][70]In 1975, a study found that pilot lights in New York State alone wasted enough natural gas annually to heat approximately 220,000 average homes.[71] As of 2025, with over 90% of new gas appliances using electronic ignition per DOE standards, standing pilots persist mainly in legacy systems affecting 20-30% of older U.S. homes.
Efficiency and Mitigation
Pilot lights in gas appliances contribute to household greenhouse gas emissions through continuous combustion of natural gas, producing an estimated 0.4-1.0 metric tons of CO2 equivalent annually for households with multiple appliances such as water heaters and furnaces.[72] Additionally, incomplete combustion in these small flames generates nitrogen oxides (NOx), which degrade local air quality and contribute to smog formation and respiratory health issues.[73]Regulatory measures have addressed these inefficiencies by promoting higher energy standards that discourage standing pilot lights. In the United States, the Energy Policy Act of 1992 established a minimum 78% annual fuel utilization efficiency (AFUE) for residential furnaces, rendering standing pilots impractical in new models due to their constant energy draw and effectively phasing them out.[74] In the European Union, Commission Regulation (EU) No 813/2013 imposed seasonal space heating energy efficiency requirements for boilers and space heaters, incorporating ignition burner power consumption into efficiency calculations and incentivizing designs without continuous pilots.[75] Many utilities and governments provide rebates and incentives for retrofitting older appliances to electronic ignition systems, reducing ongoing emissions and operational costs.[76]To mitigate inefficiencies in existing pilot light systems, techniques such as pilot proving switches—devices that detect and confirm the presence of a stable flame before allowing main burner operation—help prevent gas waste from unlit or erratic pilots.[77] Adjustable orifices allow technicians to fine-tune the pilot flame size, minimizing gas flow to the lowest level necessary for reliable ignition while maintaining safety.[78]The reduced adoption of standing pilot lights has contributed to broader efficiency gains, correlating with a 20-30% decline in natural gas use per residential customer in the U.S. since 2000, driven by appliance upgrades and regulatory standards.[79]
Modern Alternatives
Electronic Ignition Systems
Electronic ignition systems represent a class of technologies designed to ignite gas in appliances without relying on a continuously burning pilot flame, activating only during heating cycles to enhance efficiency. These systems typically employ electrical components such as spark generators or heating elements to initiate combustion, integrated with control modules that monitor flame presence and manage gas flow.[38]The intermittent pilot system operates by igniting a small pilot flame solely when heat is demanded, using either a spark electrode or a hot surface element to light the pilot gas stream. Once the pilot is established and verified through flame rectification sensing—where the flame conducts electricity to complete a circuit—the main burner valve opens to sustain combustion; the pilot then extinguishes when the heating cycle ends, cycling on and off with thermostat calls. This setup is commonly applied in furnaces, boilers, and water heaters, providing reliable ignition while minimizing constant gas use.[80]Direct spark ignition employs a high-voltage arc, typically around 10,000 volts generated by a transformer, directed near the main burner ports to directly ignite the gas-air mixture without an intermediary pilot. The system features two electrodes: one for sparking and another for flame sensing via rectification, ensuring safe operation by confirming ignition within seconds before allowing sustained gas flow; if no flame is detected, the control module shuts off the valve to prevent unburned gas accumulation. This method is favored in space heaters, ovens, and some furnaces for its simplicity and lack of pilot components.[81]Hot surface ignition utilizes a durable heating element made from silicon carbide or silicon nitride that rapidly glows to approximately 1,800°F (980°C) when powered, radiating heat to ignite the main burner gas directly. The element, often shaped as a flat or coiled rod, reaches ignition temperature in 15-45 seconds depending on voltage (typically 120V AC), after which the control verifies flame presence via a nearby sensor before maintaining operation; it deactivates post-cycle to avoid wear. This technology is prevalent in modern residential gas furnaces and boilers due to its robustness and integration with high-efficiency designs.[82]Other variants include retrofit conversion kits that transform existing standing pilot systems into intermittent pilot configurations, incorporating electronic modules, spark igniters, and gas valves to enable on-demand operation without full appliance replacement. These kits, available from manufacturers like Honeywell, are adaptable to atmospheric gas-fired equipment such as older furnaces and unit heaters, facilitating upgrades for improved performance.
Adoption and Benefits
Electronic ignition systems have seen widespread adoption in new gas appliances across the United States, with nearly all modern gas furnaces and water heaters incorporating them as standard since the early 2000s to comply with federal energy efficiency standards. By 2025, over 90% of newly manufactured gas appliances, including furnaces and water heaters, utilize electronic ignition rather than standing pilot lights, driven by requirements under the Energy Policy and Conservation Act and updates from the Department of Energy. Additionally, DOE's 2024 amended standards for consumer gas-fired water heaters, effective starting 2025, further promote electronic ignition by tightening uniform energy factor (UEF) requirements, accelerating the phase-out of standing pilot models.[83] This shift is particularly pronounced in residential heating equipment, where high-efficiency models (90%+ AFUE) with electronic ignition dominate the market, replacing older pilot-light systems that are now rare in new installations. Retrofits to electronic ignition in existing appliances can yield significant energy bill reductions, often saving 30-50% on the portion of gas usage attributable to constant pilot burning, particularly in regions with high heating demands.The primary benefits of electronic ignition include the elimination of continuous gas waste from standing pilots, which typically consume 30-60 therms per year per appliance when not in active use, translating to annual savings of $50-150 depending on local gas prices and appliance type. This efficiency also reduces carbon monoxide (CO) and carbon dioxide (CO₂) emissions by minimizing unnecessary combustion; for instance, converting a gas furnace pilot eliminates the constant low-level CO production from incomplete pilot burning, while overall CO₂ output drops by up to 1.5 tons annually in cold climates due to lower fuel consumption. Additionally, electronic systems offer longer operational life for key components compared to pilot assemblies, with igniters lasting 7-10 years under normal conditions versus 5 years or less for pilots prone to extinguishing and requiring frequent manual relighting.[37][84][85]Despite these advantages, challenges persist in adopting electronic ignition. The upfront cost for retrofitting an existing gas appliance ranges from $200-500, including the ignition kit and professional installation, which can deter homeowners with older systems. These systems require a reliable electricity supply, posing risks during power outages where ignition fails without a backup generator, unlike self-sustaining pilot lights. Reliability can also be compromised in humid environments, where moisture accelerates corrosion and failure in electronic components, potentially shortening lifespan by 20-30% without proper enclosure or dehumidification.[86][87]Market trends reflect a global push toward electronic ignition, accelerated by net-zero emissions goals and stringent efficiency regulations. California's Title 20 appliance standards, effective around 2003, set standby loss limits that effectively required intermittent or electronic ignition for many new gas water heaters to comply and curb energy waste.[88] This aligns with comparisons to pilot light waste detailed in energy consumption analyses, underscoring the role of electronic alternatives in overall efficiency gains. As countries pursue net-zero targets by 2050, adoption is projected to grow at a 6% CAGR through 2032, prioritizing reduced emissions and fuel efficiency in residential and commercial applications.[89][90]