Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Spitball

A spitball, also known as a spitter, is an illegal pitch in Major League Baseball (MLB) in which the pitcher applies a foreign substance—such as saliva, petroleum jelly, or sweat—to the baseball, altering its aerodynamic properties to create unpredictable movement, typically a sharp downward break as it approaches the plate.^[1] The pitch is thrown with a stiff wrist motion similar to a fastball, but the moistened surface reduces friction, causing the ball to "dive" or tail late in its flight path.^[2] The spitball gained prominence during the dead-ball era of baseball (approximately 1900–1919), when pitchers commonly used it and other doctored pitches to compensate for the less lively baseballs of the time, which were often softened, scuffed, or—after 1910—featured a cork center for better grip and control.^[3] Its origins are attributed to several early pitchers, including Ed Walsh and Frank Corridon in the 1900s, though variations like saliva applied via chewing tobacco or slippery elm bark were widespread by the 1910s.^[4] MLB banned the spitball and similar foreign-substance pitches effective February 1920, following a vote by team owners amid concerns over safety and game integrity after the 1919 Black Sox scandal, though 17 active pitchers were grandfathered in and allowed to continue using it until their retirements—the last being Burleigh Grimes in 1934.^[5] Notable spitball specialists from this era included Hall of Famers like Walsh (career 1.82 ERA), Red Faber, Stan Coveleski, and Grimes (270 wins), who relied on the pitch for much of their success in an age when such trickery was a hallmark of pitching dominance.^[6] Despite the ban, the spitball's influence persisted, with later pitchers like Gaylord Perry (314 wins, 1962–1983) gaining fame for suspected use of substances to mimic its movement, leading to ejections and fines but also highlighting ongoing enforcement challenges in MLB.^[7] The pitch's legacy endures as a symbol of baseball's evolution toward cleaner play, with modern rules under MLB Rule 6.02(c) strictly prohibiting any foreign substances on the ball, punishable by immediate ejection and suspension.^[1]

Definition and Characteristics

Overview of the Pitch

The spitball is an illegal baseball pitch in which the pitcher moistens one side of the baseball's surface using saliva, Vaseline, petroleum jelly, or other foreign substances to alter its flight path and create unpredictable movement.^[8] This alteration reduces the friction between the ball and the air, allowing for erratic breaks that make the pitch difficult for batters to predict or hit effectively.^[2] In its basic mechanics, the applied moisture causes the ball to slip more easily off the pitcher's fingers upon release, resulting in reduced backspin or overall rotation compared to a dry pitch.^[8] This slippage leads to sharper, more sudden deviations in trajectory, often manifesting as a pronounced drop or lateral break that occurs late in the ball's path.^[2] Unlike legal breaking pitches such as the curveball or slider, which generate movement primarily through deliberate spin imparted by the fingers to exploit aerodynamic forces on a clean ball, the spitball's effectiveness stems from the slick surface disrupting uniform airflow and minimizing spin efficiency.^[9] This produces a more deceptive, non-spin-dependent motion that can mimic a fastball before diving sharply, setting it apart from the predictable arcs of dry pitches.^[8]

Physical Effects and Movement

The spitball's movement is primarily driven by the application of moisture, such as saliva, to one side of the baseball, which smooths that portion of the surface and creates asymmetric drag.^[5] This asymmetry disrupts the airflow around the ball, leading to uneven boundary layer separation where the air detaches from the ball's surface at different points on each side.^[9] As a result, the pitch experiences irregular lateral or downward deviations, distinguishing it from conventionally spinning pitches that follow more predictable paths. The key physical principle underlying this effect is the alteration of aerodynamic forces, particularly drag and lift. The drag force acting on the baseball is described by the equation F_d = \frac{1}{2} \rho v^2 C_d A, where \rho is air density, v is velocity, C_d is the drag coefficient, and A is the ball's cross-sectional area.^[10] Moisture reduces friction on the treated side, lowering C_d asymmetrically by delaying flow separation on that side while allowing earlier separation on the untreated side, which amplifies turbulence and break.^[11] Seam orientation plays a critical role, as the raised stitching interacts differently with the airflow depending on the moisture's position, further contributing to unpredictable deflections. Additionally, the lubrication typically reduces the pitcher's grip, resulting in lower spin rates compared to standard fastballs (often below 1,000 rpm versus 2,000+ rpm), which diminishes the stabilizing gyroscopic effect and enhances erratic motion.^[9] Common movement variations include the "fadeaway," where the ball breaks sharply from right to left for a right-handed pitcher, creating an away trajectory to right-handed batters with a late, diving action.^[12] This break can exceed 12 inches laterally over the 60-foot distance to home plate, far more sudden than a typical curveball due to the lack of consistent topspin. The pitch's overall trajectory often features an initial straight path that gives way to a pronounced drop—up to 2 feet more than a standard fastball—owing to minimized backspin and heightened drag asymmetry near the plate.^[9] In comparison to modern pitches like the slider, the spitball prefigures lateral movement through sidespin elements but introduces greater unpredictability, as its low and inconsistent spin prevents reliable Magnus force application, resulting in breaks that can shift direction mid-flight rather than following a fixed arc.^[11] This erratic quality, driven by the interplay of moisture-induced asymmetry and seam effects, made the pitch particularly challenging for batters to track.

Historical Development

Origins in Early Baseball

The spitball, a pitch involving the application of saliva or other moisture to the baseball to alter its trajectory, first appeared in organized baseball during the late 1890s in minor league circuits. Anecdotal accounts credit minor league pitcher Frank Corridon with its accidental invention around 1902 while playing for the Providence Grays in the Eastern League; he reportedly discovered that throwing with wet fingertips and a dry ball grip produced erratic movement after spilling water on his hand during a game.^[13] Similarly, umpire and former player George Hildebrand is said to have collaborated with Corridon in refining the technique, using it sparingly in minor league games to deceive hitters on uneven fields.^[3] These early experiments in the minors laid the groundwork for the pitch's transition to major league play, though exact origins remain debated among contemporaries. Pitchers adopted the spitball primarily as a response to the dead-ball era's conditions, where baseballs featured low seams, were made of softer materials, and often became scuffed or dirtied after limited use, reducing their natural flight predictability.^[14] On rough, poorly maintained fields common in the early 1900s, the moisture-induced grip enhanced control and imparted sharp, unpredictable breaks, allowing pitchers to counter aggressive hitters more effectively.^[15] Chewing tobacco juice became a favored moistening agent due to its availability and sticky residue, aligning with the era's casual player habits.^[3] The pitch spread to the major leagues around 1905–1910, with Elmer Stricklett, dubbed the "father of the spitball," popularizing it after using it successfully with the Brooklyn Superbas in 1904 and teaching it to others during spring training.^[16] Ed Walsh debuted its effective major league use in 1906 for the Chicago White Sox, crediting Stricklett for instruction and posting a 1.88 ERA while leading the American League with 10 shutouts that season.^[15] Jack Chesbro's adoption in 1904, resulting in a record 41 wins for the New York Highlanders, accelerated its acceptance, as leagues initially permitted such alterations alongside other doctored pitches like the shine ball.^[17] This era's lax regulations reflected a broader tolerance for innovation in pitching, prioritizing competitive balance over uniformity until mounting concerns about fairness prompted scrutiny.^[3]

Peak Usage in the Dead-Ball Era

During the Dead-Ball Era from 1910 to 1920, the spitball reached its zenith as a cornerstone of major league pitching, contributing to the era's characteristically low offensive output with its unpredictable movement and difficulty for batters to track. Pitchers who mastered the pitch dominated league statistics, often posting sub-2.00 earned run averages (ERAs) in seasons where league-wide ERAs hovered around 2.50 to 3.00. Ed Walsh, a premier spitballer for the Chicago White Sox, exemplified this dominance; in 1910, he recorded an MLB-low 1.27 ERA despite an 18-20 win-loss record, while averaging over 20 wins per season from 1906 to 1910 with multiple sub-2.00 ERAs, including a 1.60 mark in 1907 alongside 24 victories and a 2.22 ERA in 1911 with 27 wins.^[15] Similarly, Eddie Cicotte, another White Sox spitball specialist using a variant known as the shine ball, led the American League in winning percentage in 1916 and posted a 1.53 ERA with 28 wins in 1917, helping secure the team's pennant.^[18]^[3] These performances underscored the spitball's statistical edge, as its moistened surface caused sharp breaks that reduced batting averages against users to below .200 in key outings.^[3] Team strategies in this period heavily integrated spitball pitchers into rotations to exploit the era's emphasis on pitching control and defensive play, particularly for contenders like the Chicago White Sox and New York Giants. The White Sox built a formidable staff around spitballers such as Walsh, Cicotte, and Red Faber, who combined for over 150 wins in the 1910s and anchored the rotation through high-inning workloads, often exceeding 300 innings per season to maintain low team ERAs under 2.50.^[3] The Giants, while less reliant on the pitch, adapted their strategy to the dead-ball environment by prioritizing spitball-adjacent trick pitches in low-scoring matchups, with a staff ERA of 2.42 in 1913 en route to a World Series title, reflecting broader league trends where doctored balls stifled offense.^[3] This approach not only prolonged games' focus on strategy over power but also elevated team success, as spitball rotations minimized home runs—fewer than 500 league-wide annually—and kept total runs under 4.5 per game.^[3] The spitball's influence shone in pivotal postseason moments, such as the 1917 World Series between the White Sox and Giants, where its use fostered low scoring across the six games, totaling 38 runs as pitchers like Cicotte and Faber limited the Giants to a .224 batting average.^[19]^[3] Cicotte's shine ball was prominent in Game 3, a 2-0 shutout loss for the White Sox, while the series' tight contests—three decided by two runs or fewer—highlighted how the pitch's deceptive drop and fade contributed to the White Sox's 4-2 victory and the era's defensive ethos.^[19] By 1919, however, mounting concerns over the spitball's safety and fairness began signaling its decline; critics argued it endangered hitters by obscuring the ball's visibility and perpetuated an uneven playing field amid low salaries and corruption, indirectly amplified by the Black Sox scandal involving Cicotte and teammates, which exposed broader integrity issues in the sport.^[3]^[20]

Throwing Techniques

Ball Preparation Methods

Pitchers prepared the spitball by applying a foreign substance to one side of the baseball, creating an uneven surface that altered its aerodynamic properties during flight. The most common substance was saliva, which pitchers discreetly applied by licking their fingers or bringing the ball and glove to their mouth in a ritualistic motion before nearly every pitch, often under the guise of routine adjustments.^[3] Other lubricants included tobacco juice, petroleum jelly (such as Vaseline), sweat, licorice, and slippery elm bark, which were chosen for their ability to moisten and slick the ball's surface without immediate detection.^[5]^[21]^[22] The process typically occurred between pitches or during brief pauses on the mound, where the pitcher would rub the substance onto a specific seam or area of the ball using their fingers or glove, ensuring only one side was affected to induce lateral movement. To maintain secrecy, some pitchers concealed aids like a damp sponge hidden within their glove or small containers of lubricant tucked behind the knee, under the cap's bill, or in uniform pockets, allowing quick access without drawing attention from fielders or umpires.^[23]^[24] Other doctored pitches, such as the mudball (smearing mud on one side to dull the leather and reduce spin), the shine ball (vigorously rubbing and polishing one hemisphere against the uniform or dirt for a glossy finish), and the emery ball (subtle roughening of the surface with hidden emery paper or a file-like tool to create drag irregularities), shared the goal of asymmetrical alteration with the spitball and were often prepared in similar covert manners. The resulting uneven friction on the ball's surface could cause sharp, unpredictable breaks, similar to the classic spitball's dive or tail.^[3] Preparation carried inherent risks, as umpires retained the authority to inspect the baseball at any time for irregularities, potentially leading to ejection if a foreign substance was discovered during routine checks or complaints from opposing teams. Pitchers thus relied on sleight-of-hand and consistent rituals to avoid scrutiny, though overt "loading up" motions sometimes invited suspicion from vigilant officials.^[3]

Grip, Release, and Delivery

The spitball grip typically involves holding the ball with the index and middle fingers across the seams in a two-seam fastball orientation, positioning the moistened side against the palm or fingertips to create an asymmetrical friction surface. This setup allows the pitcher to apply normal finger pressure along the seams on the dry side while the wet portion slips more easily during the throw, enhancing the pitch's unpredictable movement. The grip was generally the same as a fastball, with the moistened side positioned to control the direction of the break.^[25]^[21] Upon release, the moisture induces a "slippery" effect that minimizes spin on the lubricated side, causing the ball to accelerate unevenly and break downward with reduced visible rotation compared to standard pitches. The direction of the break—in toward a right-handed batter or away—is controlled by orienting the wet spot relative to the pitcher's grip and wrist action, often incorporating a subtle snap or twist for added deflection.^[26] Delivery styles for the spitball varied between overhand and sidearm motions to suit the pitcher's arm slot, avoiding underhand throws that would diminish the break. This overhand or three-quarters approach ensured the ball's trajectory mimicked a conventional fastball until late movement occurred.^[26]^[3] To apply moisture discreetly, pitchers incorporated practice routines such as feints, routinely bringing the ball and glove to their mouth before nearly every pitch—a motion known as "loading up"—even when not throwing a spitball, to mask the technique and avoid detection by umpires. This habitual gesture helped maintain rhythm while occasionally scuffing the mound for subtle surface alteration during preparation.^[3]

Regulatory History

The 1920 Ban

The prohibition of the spitball in Major League Baseball (MLB) was enacted as part of broader efforts to reform the game following the 1919 Black Sox scandal, which eroded public trust and prompted structural changes including the appointment of a commissioner. In December 1919, National League president John Heydler proposed banning the spitball for all new pitchers starting in 1920, a measure led by Pittsburgh Pirates owner Barney Dreyfuss to promote fairness and cleaner play. This initiative culminated in February 1920 when the Joint Rules Committee, during meetings in Chicago, adopted Rule 30, Section 2, which outlawed the use of moisture, foreign substances, or any defacement on the baseball to alter its flight, effectively targeting the spitball and similar "freak" pitches like the shine ball and emery ball.^[27]^[3] The primary rationale for the ban centered on player safety and the integrity of the sport. Spitballs and other doctored pitches often resulted in discolored, scuffed balls that were difficult for batters to see, increasing the risk of injury from errant pitches. These visibility issues with dirty balls were highlighted by the tragic death of Cleveland Indians shortstop Ray Chapman on August 16, 1920—after the ban's announcement—when he was struck in the head by a pitch from New York Yankees submarine pitcher Carl Mays; the ball was described as dirty and nearly invisible, a common problem during the Dead-Ball Era. In response, MLB also mandated that umpires replace soiled balls more frequently to improve visibility, further underscoring the safety imperative behind prohibiting moisture and defacement. Additionally, the ban aimed to enhance offensive play and fan interest by reducing the dominance of trick pitches, which had contributed to low-scoring games and perceptions of unfair advantages for pitchers.^[3]^[28] The ban was implemented in stages to allow a smooth transition. Announced on February 9, 1920, it permitted each team to designate up to two pitchers to continue using the spitball during the 1920 season, resulting in 17 "grandfathered" veterans—such as Burleigh Grimes, Stan Coveleski, and Red Faber—who were allowed to employ the pitch for the remainder of their careers. The full prohibition took effect after the 1920 season, barring all new practitioners starting in 1921, with violations punishable by immediate ejection, removal from the game, and a 10-day suspension. Kenesaw Mountain Landis, appointed as MLB's first commissioner on November 12, 1920, in the scandal's aftermath, endorsed these reforms as part of his mandate to restore the game's credibility, though the rule itself predated his tenure.^[28]^[3]^[27] Initial reactions from pitchers were marked by protests, with many spitball specialists arguing that the pitch was essential to their success and that the ban unfairly targeted established hurlers without addressing other forms of doctoring. Despite lobbying efforts, the Joint Rules Committee's decision stood, reflecting a consensus among owners and league officials to modernize baseball amid declining attendance and ethical concerns.^[3]

Enforcement Challenges and Loopholes

Enforcing the 1920 spitball ban proved challenging for umpires, who were required to conduct routine inspections of baseballs and pitchers' hands to detect moisture or foreign substances, but detection relied heavily on visual observation and was often inconsistent due to pitchers' deceptive techniques.^[3] Umpires could eject violators under the new rules, which imposed penalties like immediate removal and 10-day suspensions for first offenses, yet controversies arose in the 1920s when pitchers like Jack Quinn publicly protested the ban as discriminatory, claiming it unfairly targeted their established skills without adequate transition support.^[3] Early enforcement sparked debates over subjective judgment calls that divided fans and players.^[29] Pitchers frequently evaded the ban by employing "legal" substitutes that mimicked the spitball's movement, such as the cut fastball, which achieved similar lateral break without explicit doctoring, or concealing substances like Vaseline in caps or belts to subtly alter the ball's surface.^[30] The grandfather clause allowed 17 established spitball specialists, including Burleigh Grimes, to continue throwing the pitch legally until retirement, with Grimes as the last permitted user in 1934, creating a loophole that blurred enforcement lines as opponents complained of unfair advantages from the wet ball's handling difficulties.^[31] Rule amendments in the 1930s sought to clarify prohibitions on "doctored" pitches by expanding definitions to include any foreign substance beyond the original spitball focus, aiming to close gaps exploited by subtle evasions, though implementation remained uneven.^[3] Minor leagues exhibited variances, often permitting continued spitball use for career pitchers reliant on it, as seen in the Texas League where individuals like Snipe Conley threw it legally into the 1920s without MLB-level scrutiny, highlighting decentralized enforcement.^[32] Detection methods evolved minimally before the 1950s, starting with basic visual checks of pitchers' motions and ball examinations for shine or residue, but lacked advanced tools like radar, relying instead on managerial complaints to prompt inspections, which umpires found burdensome amid fast-paced games.^[30]

Notable Practitioners

Pre-Ban Spitball Specialists

Ed Walsh emerged as one of the premier spitball pitchers in the early 1900s, anchoring the Chicago White Sox rotation during their dominant years. He learned the pitch from Elmer Stricklett in 1904 and refined it into a devastating weapon by 1906, disguising it by touching his mouth before nearly every delivery to maintain unpredictability. Walsh's mastery culminated in his legendary 1908 season, where he recorded 40 wins against 15 losses, a 1.42 ERA over 464 innings pitched, and 269 strikeouts, leading the White Sox to a strong contention push despite falling short of the pennant.^[15]^[33] His career totals included 195 wins and a 1.82 ERA, earning him induction into the Baseball Hall of Fame in 1946 for his spitball-driven dominance.^[33]^[34] Eddie Cicotte also relied heavily on the spitball early in his career with the Chicago White Sox, integrating it into his arsenal to enhance movement and deception before shifting emphasis toward his knuckleball. From 1917 to 1919, he showcased exceptional control and effectiveness, posting records of 28-12 with a 1.53 ERA in 1917, 12-19 with a 2.77 ERA in the war-shortened 1918 season, and 29-7 with a 1.82 ERA in 1919, leading the American League in wins and ERA those years.^[18]^[35] Despite his involvement in the 1919 Black Sox scandal, Cicotte's pre-ban spitball work established him as a tactical innovator, using the pitch to complement his overall command and contribute to the White Sox's 1917 World Series title.^[12] Stan Coveleski, another Hall of Famer, developed his spitball in the minor leagues and used it to anchor the Cleveland Indians' rotation pre-ban, winning 24 games with a 1.81 ERA in 1917 and 22 games with a 2.20 ERA in 1918 while leading the AL in ERA both years. His sharp-breaking spitter helped secure the 1920 World Series championship, though he continued using it legally post-ban for much of his 215-win career.^[36]^[37] Among other notable pre-ban spitball specialists, Doc White and Jack Quinn exemplified the pitch's role in sustaining long-term success. White, a left-handed mainstay for the White Sox from 1904 to 1913, incorporated an excellent spitball alongside his sinker and fastball, finishing his career with 189 wins, 156 losses, and a 2.39 ERA while helping secure the 1906 pennant.^[38]^[39] Quinn, who debuted in 1909, built his enduring career around the spitball, amassing 247 wins and 218 losses with a 3.29 ERA over 23 major league seasons; though he collected two World Series rings and matched the win totals of several Hall of Famers, he was never inducted into Cooperstown.^[40]^[41] Pre-ban spitball pitchers like Walsh, Cicotte, White, and Quinn strategically centered their repertoires on the pitch to achieve superior control and induce weak contact in the dead-ball era. By moistening a specific spot on the ball and manipulating its break—often darting sharply downward or outward—they created unpredictable movement that baffled hitters, allowing for precise location and reduced hard contact when mixed with fastballs and curves.^[15]^[3] This tactical emphasis on deception, including ritualistic "loading" motions to obscure intent, enabled them to dominate lineups and pitch deep into games, often exceeding 300 innings annually while maintaining low ERAs.^[3]

Post-Ban Legal Users and Exceptions

Following the 1920 ban on the spitball, Major League Baseball implemented a grandfather clause that permitted 17 established pitchers to continue using the pitch for the remainder of their careers, recognizing their reliance on it for success.^[5] These pitchers included Burleigh Grimes, Clarence Mitchell, Red Faber, Stan Coveleski, Bill Doak, Dick Rudolph, Phil Douglas, Jack Quinn, Dana Fillingim, Ray Fisher, Marv Goodwin, Doc Ayers, Ray Caldwell, Dutch Leonard, Allan Russell, Urban Shocker, and Allen Sothoron.^[6] Among them, Urban Shocker achieved 136 wins from 1921 to 1928 before his death in 1928, while Red Faber compiled 254 career victories, including 149 after 1920, en route to Hall of Fame induction. Burleigh Grimes, the most prolific of the group, amassed 270 total wins, with 231 coming after the ban, leveraging the spitball to lead the National League in victories twice.^[42]^[43]^[44] One notable case among the exempted pitchers was Phil Douglas, whose career ended abruptly amid scandal in 1922. Douglas, a skilled spitballer with a league-leading 2.63 ERA that year for the New York Giants, was suspended indefinitely after a heated dispute with manager John McGraw and fined $100 for poor performance.^[45] Shortly thereafter, he sent a letter to a former teammate offering to quit mid-season and aid the St. Louis Cardinals in defeating the Giants, explicitly referencing his spitball as a tool to "fix" games if traded or released.^[46] Commissioner Kenesaw Mountain Landis banned Douglas for life on August 19, 1922, ending his major league tenure despite 11 wins that season.^[45]^[47] The grandfathered pitchers gradually phased out the spitball as they aged and retired through the 1920s and early 1930s, adapting by relying more on other pitches like fastballs and curves amid evolving game conditions.^[48] By 1930, only a handful remained active with the pitch, including Grimes, Faber, and Quinn, as younger hurlers developed without it and offensive output rose league-wide.^[48] Grimes threw the last legal major league spitball in a September 20, 1934, game for the Pittsburgh Pirates before retiring, marking the definitive end of the exception.^[49] Beyond the majors, rare revivals of the spitball persisted in minor leagues and international play into the 1940s, where enforcement was laxer and some circuits allowed it under local rules. Frank Shellenback, a prominent minor leaguer never grandfathered in the majors, legally threw the spitball in the Pacific Coast League through 1937, winning 295 games there from 1920 onward and influencing prospects like Bob Feller.^[50] Isolated uses continued in lower minors and outlaw leagues into the early 1940s, though the pitch faded as umpires cracked down and cleaner styles dominated.^[51]

Legacy and Modern Relevance

Influence on Pitching Evolution

The spitball ban in 1920 marked a pivotal shift in pitching strategies, transitioning Major League Baseball from an era dominated by trick pitches and deception to one emphasizing power and velocity. Prior to the ban, pitchers relied heavily on altered balls like the spitball for unpredictable movement, allowing finesse-oriented hurlers to control games with low-scoring outcomes characteristic of the deadball era. Post-ban, with the prohibition of such deliveries for new pitchers, teams increasingly favored hard-throwing arms capable of overpowering hitters, fostering the development of high-velocity fastballs as the cornerstone of arsenals. This evolution was accelerated by the simultaneous introduction of a livelier ball, which favored offense and compelled pitchers to adapt by prioritizing speed over subtlety. Concurrently, the slider emerged in the mid-1920s as a legal breaking pitch, offering sharper, late movement akin to the spitball's dive but achieved through grip and arm action rather than foreign substances; pioneers like George Blaeholder of the St. Louis Browns popularized it, helping bridge the gap from banned tricks to modern repertoires.^[14]^[52] Statistically, the ban contributed to a significant inflation in earned run averages (ERAs) and a surge in offensive production, underscoring the hitters' newfound advantages. In 1919, the combined MLB ERA stood at 2.80, reflecting the effectiveness of doctored pitches in suppressing runs. By 1920, following the ban and rule changes like more frequent ball replacements, the ERA jumped to 3.35, and it climbed further to 3.93 in 1921, as pitchers struggled without their signature movement tools. This ERA escalation aligned with a ~28% increase in runs scored league-wide from 1919 to 1921, from an average of 3.85 runs per game to 4.92, highlighting how the removal of the spitball tilted the balance toward batters and hastened the live-ball era's high-scoring dynamics.^[53]^[54]^[55] The spitball's techniques profoundly influenced pitching coaching, particularly in the instruction of grips for legal breaking balls. Grandfathered spitballers, such as Burleigh Grimes—the last active legal user until 1934—shared their knowledge of ball handling and release points with younger pitchers, adapting the "slippery" spitball grip to curveballs and early sliders for enhanced spin and drop without foreign aids. This cross-pollination helped standardize teaching methods for movement pitches, emphasizing wrist snap and seam orientation to mimic the spitball's erratic path legally; Grimes, in his post-playing career as a scout and manager, exemplified this by mentoring hurlers on velocity-integrated breaking balls that became staples in 1930s arsenals. Such adaptations ensured that the core principles of unpredictable movement endured in coaching curricula, evolving into the diverse pitch mixes of mid-20th-century baseball.^[3]^[56] Culturally, the spitball's legacy endures through persistent nicknames and lore that evoke its cunning mystique in baseball narratives. Terms like "spitter" remain synonymous with any suspected doctored pitch, as seen in the enduring reputation of Hall of Famer Gaylord Perry, dubbed the "Spitball Master" for his 1960s-1970s mastery of illusory movement despite the ban. This nomenclature, rooted in the pitch's saliva-based origins, continues to color discussions of pitching ethics and innovation, symbolizing the tension between tradition and regulation in the sport's history.^[57]^[8]

Current Rules and Substitute Pitches

Major League Baseball's Official Rule 6.02(c)(7) explicitly prohibits pitchers from having on their person or in their possession any foreign substance, including saliva, petroleum jelly, or other materials that could alter the ball's movement.^[58] This rule aims to maintain fairness by preventing artificial enhancements to pitch grip or trajectory. Violations result in immediate ejection from the game and an automatic 10-game suspension, with no pay during the suspension period.^[59] In June 2021, MLB launched a heightened enforcement initiative to address widespread use of "sticky stuff" substances, such as Spider Tack, that boosted spin rates and movement.^[60] The policy mandated umpire inspections of pitchers' hands, gloves, belts, and caps, particularly after the first, third, fifth, and seventh innings for starters, and upon entering games for relievers.^[61] This crackdown led to the first disciplinary action when Seattle Mariners pitcher Héctor Santiago received a 10-game suspension on June 29, 2021, after umpires discovered a foreign substance during a post-inning check.^[62] The initiative significantly reduced league-wide spin rates, demonstrating its immediate impact on pitching dynamics.^[63] Current enforcement remains rigorous, with umpires conducting random and routine checks to detect violations, often focusing on residue from rosin mixed with sweat or other illicit additives.^[64] Pitchers found in violation face the same ejection and 10-game suspension penalties, while teams risk fines for repeated infractions.^[59] Umpire crews use visual and tactile inspections, sometimes confiscating items for further review, to uphold the rule's integrity amid ongoing technological advancements in pitch tracking. To replicate the spitball's signature sharp drop and reduced spin without foreign substances, modern pitchers rely on legal grips that manipulate aerodynamics. The split-finger fastball, gripped with index and middle fingers spread wide around the seams, induces a late dive by minimizing backspin, offering a close approximation to the spitball's tailing action.^[65] Similarly, the knuckleball achieves erratic, unpredictable movement through near-zero spin, fluttering and dipping in ways reminiscent of a moistened ball's path.^[66] Sliders, when thrown with pronation to reduce spin efficiency, can also produce lateral break with subtle vertical drop, filling the deceptive void left by banned pitches.^[67] Recent incidents underscore continued umpire vigilance. In 2023, New York Mets pitcher Max Scherzer was ejected and suspended 10 games after umpires detected a sticky substance on his pitching hand during a game against the Los Angeles Dodgers.^[68] San Diego Padres reliever Robert Suárez and New York Mets reliever Drew Smith each served 10-game suspensions for similar violations.^[69]^[70] In 2024, Houston Astros starter Ronel Blanco was ejected mid-game and suspended 10 games following a glove inspection revealing residue, while New York Mets closer Edwin Díaz faced the same penalty after a failed hand check.^[71]^[72] As of November 2025, no major ejections have been reported this season, but routine inspections persist to deter attempts at "spit-like" alterations through sweat or rosin manipulation.^[64]

References

[1]
Doctoring the Baseball | Glossary - MLB.com
Pitches utilizing foreign substances, such as the spitball, were outlawed in 1920, but teams were allowed to designate up to two pitchers who could legally ...<|control11|><|separator|>
[2]
Spitball Baseball Dictionary
A late-breaking pitch made with a ball that has been spat upon. It is thrown like a fastball but with a stiff wrist, squirting the ball out of the fingers like ...
[3]
The Spitball and the End of the Deadball Era
Back in the 1890s Clark Griffith created the scuff ball by using his spikes to roughen its surface. As the decade of the teens moved forward, pitchers began to ...
[4]
SteveSteinberg.net Features : Origins of the Spitball 20th Century
The spitball (or 'spitter') was the most famous and well-known of the 'trick pitches' that pitchers threw in the first two decades of the 20th century.
[5]
#Shortstops: Slippery elm and the spitball | Baseball Hall of Fame
Originally, 22 spitballers were exempted for only 1920, but a compromise later resulted in 17 being allowed to continue throwing it for the rest of their ...
[6]
MLB Spitball Pitchers - Baseball Almanac
Stan Coveleski, RHP, Cleveland Indians ; Red Faber, RHP, Chicago White Sox ; Dutch Leonard, LHP, Detroit Tigers ; Jack Quinn, RHP, New York Yankees ; Allan Russell ...
[7]
Remembering Gaylord Perry, a great spitballer and legendary MLB ...
Dec 1, 2022 · That was Gaylord Perry, who did so much more than throw a spitball. He had great stuff, he was a big, strong, rough, gruff farmer from North ...
[8]
Spitball - BR Bullpen - Baseball-Reference.com
Nov 28, 2015 · A spitball (aka spitter, wet one, or unsanitary pitch) is a pitch in which the pitcher applies saliva to the baseball, either to change its aerodynamic ...
[9]
Putting Something On The Ball - Science of Baseball
The way a ball curves is determined by the direction and amount of spin placed on the ball, as well as the speed of the pitch. Fastballs usually curve slightly ...
[10]
History 101 - The Spitball - Paul Danesi - Twins Daily
Feb 5, 2024 · With a spit ball the pitcher applies either saliva to the ball or another slippery substance. The actions of saliva or a slippery substance on ...Missing: definition | Show results with:definition
[11]
Aerodynamics of Baseball | Glenn Research Center - NASA
Aug 6, 2025 · What makes a curveball curve? What determines how far a batted ball will travel? How do weather conditions change the flight of a baseball?
[12]
Explaining the notorious and mysterious spitball
backspin creates lift; topspin causes the ball to sink; sidespin pushes ...
[13]
Eddie Cicotte - Society for American Baseball Research
Jan 4, 2012 · The rest of the time the right-hander relied on a fadeaway, slider, screwball, spitter, emery ball, shine ball, and a pitch he called the ...
[14]
Frank Corridon - Society for American Baseball Research
May 21, 2014 · ... inventor of the spitball. Minor league ... Elmer Stricklett, and Corridon himself, each credited Corridon with developing the spitball.
[15]
The Rise and Fall of the Deadball Era
1908 was also the offensive nadir of what is now popularly called the Deadball Era, a two-decade period of depressed run-scoring between 1901.Missing: origins | Show results with:origins
[16]
Big Ed Walsh - Society for American Baseball Research
Jan 4, 2012 · As a spot starter and reliever for the White Sox in 1904 and 1905, Walsh went 14-6 with a solid 2.37 ERA. It was not until the 1906 campaign, ...Missing: debut | Show results with:debut
[17]
Elmer Stricklett - Society for American Baseball Research
Feb 2, 2015 · Although Stricklett did not invent the spitball, he has been called “the father” of the spitball because his early use of the pitch sparked ...Missing: inventor | Show results with:inventor
[18]
Jack Chesbro - Society for American Baseball Research
After beginning 1904 at 4-3 through May 7, McGuire agreed to catch the spitter, and Chesbro was given permission to use the wet one as his primary weapon. He ...<|control11|><|separator|>
[19]
Eddie Cicotte Stats, Height, Weight, Position, Rookie Status & More
Eddie Cicotte ; WAR. 59.0. W. 209. L. 148. ERA. 2.38 ; G. 502. GS. 361. SV. 24 ; IP. 3226.0. SO. 1374. WHIP. 1.154.
[20]
1917 World Series - Baseball Almanac
The 1917 World Series by Baseball Almanac with a detailed description, complete rosters, cumulative statistics and box scores.
[21]
The Black Sox Scandal - Society for American Baseball Research
Talented members of that White Sox club conspired with professional gamblers to rig the outcome of the 1919 World Series.
[22]
From the spitball to Spider Tack: A brief history of foreign substance ...
Jun 17, 2021 · "Meanwhile, pitcher Frank Corridon of the Providence Grays made an accidental discovery: If you throw a baseball with wet fingertips and a dry ...
[23]
5 Ways to Cheat in Baseball (that Aren't Steroids) | HowStuffWorks
Banned from professional baseball after 1920 (with exceptions for a few pitchers at the time), the spitball relied on saliva, tobacco spit, petroleum jelly or ...
[24]
The Spitball Has Been Contraband for a Century
Feb 12, 2020 · The inventor of the spitball, pitcher Frank Corridon, or perhaps ... hidden in his glove). It also wasn't a secret. One of Stricklett's ...
[25]
Baseball's Sticky Situation With Ball Doctoring - The New York Times
sometimes actual saliva — to balls to make them jump and turn unpredictably, which contributed to an ...Missing: preparation | Show results with:preparation
[26]
THE INFAMOUS SPITTER - Sports Illustrated Vault | SI.com
John Wyatt of theRed Sox, Jack Hamilton of the Angels, Ron Kline and Dean Chance of the Twinsand Orlando Pena of the Tigers are reputed to have the finest ...Missing: MLB | Show results with:MLB
[27]
Babe Ruth's Own Book of Baseball - Project Gutenberg
BABE RUTH'S OWN BOOK OF BASEBALL. 3. BABE RUTH'S OWN BOOK OF BASEBALL. CHAPTER ... Poor old Whitey is out of baseball now and raising tomatoes down on his farm in ...
[28]
Dreyfuss led spitballer ban - Baseball Hall of Fame
Pittsburgh Pirates owner Barney Dreyfuss spearheaded an effort to ban the spitball in the National League starting with the 1920 season.Missing: vote MLB 12-5
[29]
Baseball History in 1920: Saviors of the Game - This Great Game
On February 9, baseball's rules committee bans pitchers from using all foreign substances upon the ball, effectively abolishing the spitball, shineball, emery ...
[30]
Spitball Pitchers and the 1920 Rule - The Baseball Umpire
The Spitball Pitchers in baseball caused MLB to put the spitball rule into effect in 1920. Baseball Rule Eight, The Pitcher (refer to MLB Rule Book 8.02(a)1-6.
[31]
MLB's Pitch Doctoring Epidemic Is Nothing New - Sports Illustrated
Jun 8, 2021 · Since the spitball was outlawed in 1920, umpires have been trying to figure out how to check pitchers, managers have been trying to figure out ...
[32]
Burleigh Grimes - Society for American Baseball Research
Jan 4, 2012 · He pitched for the last time in the major leagues on September 20, 1934, in relief of Waite Hoyt in a 2-1 loss to the Dodgers at Ebbets Field. ...Missing: enforcement | Show results with:enforcement
[33]
Texas League Spitballin' | Seamheads.com
Nov 21, 2023 · And so the spitball was banned, starting with the 1920 season. It more or less ended with the Deadball era, and there is some evidence that ...Missing: rules variances
[34]
Ed Walsh Stats, Height, Weight, Position, Rookie Status & More | Baseball-Reference.com
### Ed Walsh 1908 Season Stats
[35]
Ed Walsh - Baseball Hall of Fame
Walsh won 195 times in a 14-year career. Among modern era pitchers, 1901 to present, only contemporary Addie Joss at 1.89 registered a career ERA below the 2.00 ...
[36]
Former Baseball Star Eddie Cicotte's Secret For Dominating Hitters ...
Jul 3, 2022 · Much like other pitchers, Cicotte did throw a spitball earlier in his career: “I first used it after I joined the White Sox. I had used the ...
[37]
Doc White - BR Bullpen - Baseball-Reference.com
Dec 18, 2019 · Doc White went 17-13, 1.76 in 1905, then won 18 games for the pennant-winning 1906 team otherwise known as the "Hitless Wonders". He also had ...
[38]
Doc White Stats, Height, Weight, Position, Rookie Status & More
Doc White ; Positions: Pitcher and Outfielder ; Bats: Left • Throws: Left ; Born: April 9, 1879 in Washington, DC us ; Died: February 19, 1969 in Silver Spring, MD.Missing: spitball | Show results with:spitball
[39]
Jack Quinn Stats, Height, Weight, Position, Rookie Status & More | Baseball-Reference.com
**Jack Quinn Career Summary:**
[40]
Jack Quinn - Society for American Baseball Research
Jan 4, 2012 · The spitball is a nasty delivery and was voted out of organized ball ... Babe Ruth's Own Book of Baseball, Bison Book Edition. Lincoln ...
[41]
https://sabr.org/bioproj/person/jack-quinn/
[42]
https://sabr.org/bioproj/person/burleigh-grimes
[43]
Phil Douglas' battle with baseball in 1922 derailed a stellar career
Feb 4, 2022 · In 1922, the Tennessee-raised Douglas, a savvy hurler with speed and a sharp-breaking spitball, was coming off a stellar 15-win season with the National League ...
[44]
https://www.baseball-reference.com/players/f/faberre01.shtml
[45]
Burleigh Grimes - Baseball Hall of Fame
Burleigh Grimes, baseball's last legal spitballer, recorded five 20-win seasons. ... A noted spitballer, Grimes' career began in 1916 with the Pittsburgh Pirates.
[46]
Let's Recall The Last Legal Spitballer, Frank Shellenback!
Oct 8, 2025 · Frank Shellenback won more Pacific Coast League games than anyone else, an amazing 295 from 1920-1937. Adding wins attained in the ...
[47]
Spitball Outlawed but 17 pitchers were "Grandfathered" in
Notable pitchers who admitted throwing the spitter include Preacher Roe, Don Drysdale, and Gaylord Perry. A number of other pitchers, most notoriously Joe ...
[48]
The New Breaking Ball on the Block: The early history of the slider
Aug 23, 2022 · The slider is a newcomer on the block. Unlike the curveball, there's no evidence that the pitch was thrown in the 19th century.
[49]
Eras of ERA - The Sport Journal
Dec 18, 2020 · Average ERA increased from 3.07 in 1919 to 4.05 in 1921 ushering in what is often referred to as the live-ball era and what Bill James calls ...
[50]
Major League Pitching Year-by-Year Averages
Major League Pitching Year-by-Year Averages, Pitching Totals and more on Baseball-Reference.com.
[51]
Burleigh Grimes - The Last Spitballer Legend in Baseball
Jan 16, 2025 · Grimes' impact is felt even today, as his approach to pitching and his strategic insights continue to influence players and coaches. His ...<|separator|>
[52]
Late MLB Legend Gaylord Perry Once Embraced His 'Spitter ...
Dec 2, 2022 · The Late Gaylord Perry earned the nickname of 'Spitball Master', due to his unique pitching technique.
[53]
6.02 Pitcher Illegal Action - Baseball Rules Academy
The pitcher is allowed to rub the ball between his bare hands. (7) Have on his person, or in his possession, any foreign substance. Rule 6.02 (c)(7) Comment: ...
[54]
MLB announces new guidance to deter use of foreign substances
Jun 15, 2021 · Under the new guidelines, any pitcher who possesses or applies foreign substances in violation of the rules will be ejected from the game and ...
[55]
Sticky stuff 101: Everything you need to know as MLB's foreign ...
Jun 21, 2021 · How will umpires enforce MLB's foreign-substance crackdown during games? Rogers: Pitchers will be inspected after innings and/or when they come ...Missing: 6.02 | Show results with:6.02
[56]
FAQ: Sticky stuff and new rule enforcement - MLB.com
Jun 21, 2021 · That changed in 1920, the first year the spitball and other defaced balls were more formally banned with the implementation of the 10-game ...
[57]
First MLB player disciplined in substance crackdown, suspended 10 ...
Jun 29, 2021 · Seattle Mariners pitcher Héctor Santiago became the first player disciplined under MLB's crackdown on foreign substance, given a 10-game ...Missing: examples | Show results with:examples
[58]
MLB's Reaction to a Sticky Situation Is Making the Game Fairer
May 12, 2023 · The league announced a crackdown effective June 1 on pitchers using sticky substances as a performance enhancer to generate more spin.Missing: 6.02 foreign
[59]
MLB players view rate of ejections from sticky substances as sign ...
aided by the use of sticky substances like Spider Tack, various types of glues, and ...Missing: examples | Show results with:examples<|control11|><|separator|>
[60]
Splitter - BR Bullpen - Baseball-Reference.com
Feb 1, 2006 · The splitter (aka Split-Fingered-Fastball) is a pitch thrown with the same motion as a fastball, but with the index and middle fingers split wide.
[61]
Identifying Pitch Types: A Fan's Guide - MLB.com
Jun 1, 2019 · Here's how it works: A four-seamer is thrown with straight backspin. When the ball is spinning that way, it will resist the pull of gravity ...Missing: spitball mechanics
[62]
Max Scherzer suspended 10 games for having foreign substance on ...
Apr 20, 2023 · Mets pitcher Max Scherzer will not appeal a suspension he received after being ejected from a game against the Dodgers on Wednesday.
[63]
Mets closer Edwin Díaz suspended 10 games for foreign substance
Jun 24, 2024 · Pitchers suspended for foreign substance ; 2024, Ronel Blanco ; 2023, Robert Suarez ; 2023, Drew Smith<< ; 2023, Domingo Germán.
[64]
Astros pitcher Ronel Blanco suspended for 10 games after being ...
May 16, 2024 · Astros pitcher Ronel Blanco suspended for 10 games after being ejected over foreign-substance check vs. A's. R.J. Anderson. By R.J. Anderson. & ...