The Unutterable
The Unutterable is the 21st studio album by the English post-punk band the Fall, released on 6 November 2000 by Eagle Records.[1][2] Recorded in spring 2000 at Testa Rossa Studios in Greater Manchester, along with additional sessions at Streetlevel II and Sonic Surgery Studios, the album features a stable lineup including frontman Mark E. Smith on vocals, Adam Helal on bass, Julia Nagle on keyboards and guitar, Nev Wilding on guitar, and Tom Head on drums, with additional backing vocals from Grant Cunliffe.[3][2] Produced by Grant Showbiz and Mark E. Smith, it comprises 15 tracks blending raw post-punk energy with electronic experimentation, jungle rhythms, and ambient textures, clocking in at approximately 55 minutes.[4][1] The album's sound reflects the band's evolution into the new millennium, marked by dark, ominous production and forward-looking hybridity that echoes contemporaries like Radiohead's Kid A and Primal Scream's XTRMNTR, while retaining the Fall's signature chaotic and satirical edge.[2] Standout tracks include the glitchy opener "Cyber Insekt," the taut "Two Librans," the driving "Sons of Temperance," the sprawling "Octo Realm / Ketamine Sun," and the playful "Pumpkin Soup and Mashed Potatoes," showcasing Smith's cryptic lyrics alongside the group's instrumental interplay.[2][1] Upon release, The Unutterable peaked at number 136 on the UK Albums Chart, receiving praise for its vitality amid the band's internal crises, though it was initially somewhat overlooked in broader critical discourse.[2] Subsequent reissues, including a 2025 expanded four-CD edition by Cherry Red Records featuring remixes, live recordings, and B-sides, have solidified its reputation as one of the Fall's strongest 21st-century works and a prescient fusion of punk, dance, and electronic music.[5][2]Background
Conception
The Unutterable served as the 21st studio album by The Fall, representing a creative resurgence enabled by the relative stability of the band's lineup following the 1999 release of The Marshall Suite. This continuity in personnel allowed for a more cohesive approach to songwriting and arrangement, contrasting with the frequent disruptions that had plagued the group in the late 1990s.[6][7] Mark E. Smith, the band's driving force, sought to integrate the raw energy of post-punk with electronic and ambient textures, drawing inspiration from the vibrant contemporary music scenes in Manchester and London. In interviews, Smith emphasized a return to "basics" by incorporating influences like Krautrock acts such as Can and Neu!, while infusing a "Northern grit" to counterbalance the polished electronic elements emerging in those urban hubs. This stylistic fusion aimed to revitalize The Fall's sound, positioning the album as a response to the evolving dance-pop and experimental landscapes around them.[8][9][7]Band lineup
The core lineup for The Unutterable consisted of Mark E. Smith on vocals and lyrics, Julia Nagle on guitar, keyboards, and programming, Neville Wilding on guitar, Adam Helal on bass, and Tom Head on drums and percussion.[6][3] This quintet represented a period of relative stability for the band in the late 1990s, with no major departures from the personnel featured on their previous album, The Marshall Suite (1999), where Helal and Wilding had already contributed.[6] Guest contributors included Kazuko Hohki providing vocals on the track "Cyber Insekt," offering a rare female vocal presence in the band's recordings.[6][3] Additional session support came from Grant Cunliffe and Steve Evets on backing vocals and Ben Pritchard on guitar for select tracks, such as "Dr. Buck's Letter," enhancing the album's layered sound without altering the core group dynamic.[3]Recording and production
Studio sessions
The recording sessions for The Unutterable primarily took place at Testa Rossa Studios in Longsight, Manchester, during the spring of 2000, under the production of Grant Showbiz and Mark E. Smith.[2][10] These sessions focused on capturing live band performances as the foundation, with the lineup—including Julia Nagle on keyboards, Neville Wilding on guitar, Adam Helal on bass, and Tom Head on drums—contributing to energetic, on-the-floor takes that emphasized the group's chemistry.[2][11] The process spanned several weeks, involving late-night experimentation and jamming that extended until sunrise, fostering a creative buzz amid a period of lineup instability following earlier band turmoil.[11] Mark E. Smith led the sessions with a directive approach, often requiring multiple takes to refine vocals and arrangements, as Showbiz coached him to deliver varied performances inspired by editing techniques from Miles Davis's Bitches Brew.[2] This intensity yielded the album's core tracks, blending punk energy with emerging electronic elements, though Smith later reflected feeling somewhat adrift without the prior "gang mentality."[2] Additional work occurred at the band's own Sonic Surgery studio in Manchester, where tracks like "Way Round" were laid down, providing space for initial demos and tweaks.[6] Vocals, guitars, and keyboards received further overdubs at Street Level 2 Studio in Tottenham, London, to layer in textures before finalization.[6] Basic tracking wrapped by summer 2000, setting the stage for post-production.[10]Production techniques
Producer Grant Showbiz and Mark E. Smith aimed to capture the raw post-punk energy of The Fall while incorporating ambient and dance hybrids, drawing on Showbiz's experience to blend live instrumentation with electronic elements for a dynamic sound.[12] His approach emphasized Mark E. Smith's vocals through coaching and editing techniques inspired by Miles Davis producer Teo Macero, ensuring the lyrics and delivery stood out amid the instrumentation.[2] Initial versions of the tracks were developed using monitor mixes at the Testa Rossa studio in Manchester, providing rough, early drafts that preserved the band's impulsive live feel before final overdubs.[4] Key techniques included heavy layering of electronic programming by keyboardist Julia Nagle, who contributed high-anxiety synth sequences and glowing textures to tracks like "Cyber Insekt" and "WB," integrating them with live drums and guitars for hybrid post-punk/ambient compositions.[2] Pro Tools was used for looping, sequencing, and assembling elements such as synth bass and impulsive guitar riffs in specific tracks, including "Dr Buck’s Letter" by Adam Helal and "Way Round" by Helal and Nev Wilding, creating a clean yet menacing atmosphere under "disinfected laboratory conditions."[6][12] Reverb was applied liberally to Smith's vocals and other components, producing sinisterly shimmering effects, as heard in the cover "Ketamine Sun," where it enhanced the ambient depth alongside choir tape loops from a melodium keyboard—a specific innovation suggested by Showbiz.[12][6] Keyboard textures played a central role, with Nagle's swishy synth pads and sustained electronics adding a futuristic edge, while Roland synth loops provided ethnic-inflected rhythms in pieces like "Dr Buck’s Letter."[2] This integration of live elements, such as Tom Head's drums and Neville Wilding's guitars, with programmed synths and sequencers resulted in a sound later described as "punker than punk, heavier than metal," fusing post-punk fury with electronic futurism.[11] The production was tailored for digital formats, as the album was initially released on CD only, without vinyl mastering, influencing a crisp, bold aesthetic optimized for compact disc playback.[1] Overdubs and mixing occurred at Street Level 2 in London, refining the hybrid tracks into a colorful, accessible whole.[6]Musical style and themes
Genre characteristics
The Unutterable exemplifies post-punk as its core genre, rooted in an alternative rock foundation, while integrating ambient, electronic, and dance elements to form a distinctive hybrid sound. This fusion draws from Manchester's rave scene, incorporating drum 'n' bass futurism, techno influences, and clattering jungle rhythms that evoke a forward-looking iteration of post-punk. Critics have described it as "one of the most successful post-punk/ambient/dance music hybrids ever created," blending punk's raw energy with electronic experimentation for a sound that is "punker than punk" and "heavier than metal."[11][2] Key sonic characteristics include aggressive, descending Stooges-like guitar riffs, throbbing basslines, and punishing, hypnotic drum loops provided by drummer Tom Head, which drive the album's relentless momentum. The instrumentation features cyberpunk electronics, iron foundry guitars, Roland synths, and sparky synth washes, creating a dense, varied texture that shifts between steely white-hot noise and off-kilter production touches like warped techno and sinister dub. Mark E. Smith's spoken-word vocals, often adenoidal and restrained, overlay these repetitive motifs, delivering weary, bilious observations amid the urgent backing. Spanning 15 tracks with a total runtime of 55:34, the album maintains a cohesive yet challenging vitality throughout.[2][11][13][14] The album represents a significant innovation for The Fall, marking a return to wholly original compositions without reliance on covers—a departure from much of their 1990s output that emphasized experimentation over reinterpretation. Produced by Grant Showbiz, it achieves a heavier, more vital and polished sound compared to the band's prior decade of work, with bold, colorful arrangements that prioritize accessibility alongside modernist edge. This era's lineup, including keyboards from Julia Nagle and guitars from Neville Wilding, contributed to shared songwriting credits, fostering utterly brand new sonic territories influenced by post-punk revival acts like Wire and broader cultural shifts in electronic music. Described as one of the most original British albums of the 2000s, The Unutterable prefigures elements of 2020s North West electronic terrain while revitalizing the band's post-punk legacy.[2][11][4]Lyrical content
The lyrical content of The Unutterable is dominated by Mark E. Smith's incisive critiques of modern life, often laced with absurdity and cultural observation. In "Dr Bucks' Letter," Smith recites a litany of contemporary possessions—sunglasses, CDs, a Palm Pilot, mobile phone, and AmEx card—drawn from a magazine profile of DJ Pete Tong, underscoring a superficial materialism and the banal trappings of celebrity existence.[15][16] Similarly, "Octo Realm / Ketamine Sun" delves into drug culture through fragmented introductions of altered personas, such as "Spliffhead" and "Ketamine Kettison," evoking disoriented states amid consumerist jabs like "You're a walking tower of Adidas crap."[16] Everyday absurdities surface in tracks like "Pumpkin Soup and Mashed Potatoes," where Smith revels in mundane food references, including soup and mashed potatoes, presented with a wry, celebratory detachment.[15] Smith's writing style is characterized by surreal, fragmented narratives rich in wordplay and delivered in a dictatorial, spoken-word manner that borders on rant. Influenced by figures like H.P. Lovecraft and William Blake, his lyrics weave visionary imagery with pub-philosopher wit, as seen in the rhythmic repetitions and barbed logic of "Two Librans," which juxtaposes personal reflections on duality with eclectic nods to Oprah Winfrey, bee studies, and global conflicts like Chechnya.[17][15] All lyrics on the album are penned solely by Smith, with co-credits limited to musical compositions, emphasizing his singular authorial voice.[17] Specific concepts recur through anti-establishment rants, personal introspection, and cultural commentary, eschewing overt politics for oblique satire. "Sons of Temperance" delivers a punk-infused broadside against a "crypto-moralist nation," railing against societal hypocrisy without descending into didacticism.[16] In "Two Librans," introspection on relationships emerges via archetypal figures "high and low in mind," blending relational tension with scattershot cultural allusions to peace studies and media icons.[15] Tracks like "Devolute" ponder existential voids, imagining life stripped of music and comedy, while broader commentary critiques consumer excess and modern disconnection.[15] A defining feature of the album's lyrics is their dense, "unutterable" quality—phrasings that resist easy parsing, evoking the title itself through layered obscurity and rhythmic opacity—resulting in no overarching narrative arc across tracks, but rather a series of standalone, provocative vignettes.[17]Release
Initial formats
The Unutterable was released on 6 November 2000 by Eagle Records in the United Kingdom, marking the first studio album by The Fall to be issued exclusively in CD format without an initial vinyl pressing.[6][1] The album appeared in a standard single CD jewel case edition containing 15 tracks, assigned the catalog number EAGCD164.[3] The packaging adopted a minimalist approach, featuring a clear-tray jewel case accompanied by an 8-page booklet that lists the song titles alongside production and performance credits.[3] Liner notes in the booklet attribute songwriting to Mark E. Smith in collaboration with band members including Julia Nagle, Adam Helal, and others, emphasizing all compositions as originals by the group.[3] Distribution centered on the UK and Europe through Eagle Records, with a concurrent US edition handled by Mister E Records under the same catalog identifiers.[1]Promotion and singles
The promotion for The Unutterable centered on a limited UK tour in late 2000, spanning November 21 to December 2 and covering cities such as Nottingham, London, Liverpool, Edinburgh, Glasgow, Sheffield, Manchester, Leeds, Whitley Bay, and Leicester.[18] This series of live shows served as the primary marketing effort, allowing the band to showcase material from the album to fans and build anticipation following its November 6 release.[6] A key launch event took place on November 15, 2000, at HMV Records on Oxford Street in London, where The Fall performed several new tracks including "Dr. Buck’s Letter," "Way Round," "Serum," "I’m Going to Spain," "Two Librans," "And Therein," and a tape remix of "The Caterer," despite the absence of a drummer.[18] These performances, starting from the launch and continuing through the tour, emphasized the album's energetic live potential and contributed to word-of-mouth buzz among the band's dedicated audience. No commercial singles were released from The Unutterable, with the strategy prioritizing full album sales over chart-focused single releases.[1] Promotional copies of the album, including a CD-R version, were distributed to media and industry contacts to generate coverage.[19] Media promotion included album reviews in outlets like NME and The Guardian, which framed The Unutterable as a vital return to form for the band after more than two decades.[20] For instance, The Guardian covered the tour with a live review from the November 24 Dingwalls show in London, noting the band's raw delivery of new material amid their ongoing evolution.[21] These efforts helped position the album as a career highlight, tying into narratives of The Fall's enduring influence. The promotional activities, particularly the live dates, supported the album's entry into the UK charts at number 136.[2]Commercial performance
Chart positions
Upon its release in November 2000, The Unutterable peaked at No. 136 on the UK Albums Chart, reflecting the band's established but niche position within the independent music scene.[2] This modest peak was influenced by the album's availability primarily in CD format, which restricted accessibility in an era dominated by diverse physical media preferences, alongside competition from high-profile mainstream rock albums such as U2's All That You Can't Leave Behind and Eminem's The Marshall Mathers LP. The album spent one week on the UK Albums Chart.[2] Internationally, the album saw minimal charting. Promotional activities, including live performances and radio play, contributed to this visibility but were insufficient to propel broader commercial success.[22]Sales and distribution
The initial sales of The Unutterable were modest, concentrated primarily in the UK and Europe through independent retailers amid the absence of a major label marketing campaign.[6] Distribution for the album was managed by Eagle Records across Europe, while in the United States it relied on imports and a limited domestic release via the Mister E label, reflecting the band's independent status at the time.[1] Later, digital distribution became available through platforms like Spotify and iTunes in the post-2000s era, broadening accessibility for international listeners.[23] In the long term, The Unutterable has achieved steady cult-level sales, further supported by periodic reissues that have sustained interest among dedicated fans. The album's niche appeal within post-punk and alternative rock circles inherently constrained its penetration into mainstream retail and wholesale networks. For instance, the 2025 expanded reissue peaked at No. 73 on the UK Official Albums Sales Chart as of November 2025.[24][25]Critical reception
Contemporary reviews
Upon its release in November 2000, The Unutterable was met with generally positive reviews from critics, who praised the album's energetic production and the band's renewed vitality after a period of lineup changes and inconsistent output. Dave Simpson of The Guardian hailed it as a "career peak," highlighting its raw energy and the way it captured Mark E. Smith's enduring charisma amid the group's longevity.[20] Piers Martin of NME described the album as "vital and relevant," noting standout tracks like "Cyber Insekt" and "Two Librans" for their fusion of post-punk drive with electronic elements, suggesting it stood proudly against the band's vast catalog.[15] Similarly, John Mullen in Mojo called it "The Fall's most musically exciting LP since 1990's Extricate," an "unutterable pleasure" for its challenging sound and lyrical range from transcendent to banal.[26] AllMusic's Ned Raggett gave it 4 out of 5 stars, commending the hybrid of post-punk, ambient, and dance influences as one of the band's most successful experiments.[14] Some reviews were mixed, with critics occasionally noting Mark E. Smith's rasping vocals as grating or uneven, though overall reception leaned positive—approximately 80% favorable across major outlets. Sharon O'Connell in Time Out emphasized its status as "one of the most successful post-punk/ambient/dance hybrids," while Uncut awarded 4 stars for revitalizing the post-punk sound.[20] The album's critical consensus positioned it as a return to form for the long-running band, aggregating to an average score equivalent to 80 out of 100 on review platforms.[27]Retrospective assessments
In the years following its release, The Unutterable has been reevaluated as a pivotal return to form for The Fall, blending post-punk aggression with electronic experimentation in a manner that anticipated broader genre fusions. A 2025 review in Spectrum Culture praised it as "punker than punk, heavier than metal," highlighting its enduring hybrid appeal through steely drum 'n' bass rhythms, cyberpunk electronics, and iron-foundry guitars that fuse futurism with raw fury.[11] This assessment positions the album as a rare optimistic peak amid the band's prolific but uneven 2000s output, often cited for tracks like "Dr. Buck's Letter" that exemplify its inventive dubby grooves.[28] Retrospective rankings reflect its status as an underrated gem within The Fall's discography, frequently appearing in mid-to-high placements among fan and critic polls. For instance, it has an average score of 3.66 out of 5 from 1,190 ratings on Rate Your Music as of November 2025.[29] A 2018 Pitchfork feature described it as an "unsettling jewel" marked by exceptional invention, though challenging in its repetitive intensity, signaling a brief creative high before the band's later routines set in.[30] While some critics and fans view it as transitional—reflecting lineup instability and a bridge to subsequent styles—consensus holds it as a high point of the 2000s, revitalizing The Fall after mid-1990s struggles.[28] The album's influence extends to the post-punk revival of the 2010s and beyond, inspiring bands like IDLES and Protomartyr with its abrasive, genre-defying energy that grounded experimental sounds in punk accessibility.[28] The 2025 expanded reissue has prompted fresh acclaim, particularly for its live bonuses drawn from post-2001 performances, which capture the era's tense, worn-down intensity through Mark E. Smith's raw vocals and the band's post-crisis drive, even if not from the original lineup.[2] These additions, alongside remastering, affirm its legacy as a dark, visionary work in The Fall's sprawling canon.[11]Reissues
2008 special edition
In 2008, The Unutterable was reissued as a two-CD "Special Deluxe Edition" by Voiceprint Records in the UK, under a Cog Sinister production.[4][31] The first disc presents the original 2000 album, remastered to enhance audio clarity and dynamics.[31] The second disc contains the Testa Rossa monitor mixes—thirteen raw, unpolished studio versions recorded during the album's sessions at Testa Rosa Studios, including early takes of eleven tracks from the original lineup and two previously unused pieces.[4][32] These mixes serve to illuminate the band's creative and production process, revealing the unrefined energy behind the final recordings.[32] Available exclusively in CD format, the edition retains the original artwork and booklet without new visuals or expanded liner notes on the recording sessions.[4][32]2025 expanded edition
The 2025 expanded edition of The Unutterable was released on 31 October 2025 by Cherry Red Records to mark the album's 25th anniversary. Issued as a four-CD clamshell box set comprising 59 tracks with a total runtime of approximately 3 hours and 55 minutes, the reissue also includes the album's first vinyl pressing on double black LP. This edition builds on prior releases by incorporating the original studio album alongside previously available alternate mixes and newly added live performances, aiming to capture the vitality of The Fall's early 2000s touring period in the context of Mark E. Smith's death in 2018.[5][33] The box set's contents are structured across four discs: the first features the remastered original 2000 album, while the second presents the Testa Rossa monitor mixes originally issued in 2008. Discs three and four contain complete live recordings from The Fall's 2000–2001 tours, specifically a concert at TJ's in Newport, Wales, on 16 April 2001, and another at the Liquid Room in Edinburgh on 10 October 2001. These additions emphasize the band's raw onstage energy during the album's promotional cycle, providing fans with unpolished snapshots of performances that highlighted tracks from The Unutterable alongside setlist staples. The edition was mastered by Andy Pearce and compiled with input from Fall archivist Conway Paton.[5][34] Accompanying the discs is a booklet featuring essays by music writer Daryl Easlea, rare photographs, and detailed liner notes that contextualize the album's production and legacy within The Fall's discography. The reissue serves to reintroduce The Unutterable to new listeners while offering dedicated followers expanded access to era-specific material, underscoring the album's enduring influence in post-punk and indie rock circles. The vinyl edition replicates the original track listing without bonus content.[5][11]Track listing
Original edition
The original edition of The Unutterable, released on 6 November 2000 by Eagle Records, features 15 tracks with a total runtime of 55:34 and no bonus content.[3] The track listing is as follows:| No. | Title | Duration | Writer(s) |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Cyber Insekt | 3:18 | Adam Helal, Julia Nagle, Mark E. Smith, Nev Wilding, Tom Head |
| 2 | Two Librans | 3:57 | Adam Helal, Julia Nagle, Mark E. Smith, Nev Wilding, Tom Head |
| 3 | W.B. | 3:30 | Adam Helal, Julia Nagle, Mark E. Smith, Nev Wilding, Tom Head |
| 4 | Sons of Temperance | 3:47 | Adam Helal, Julia Nagle, Mark E. Smith, Nev Wilding, Tom Head |
| 5 | Dr. Bucks' Letter | 5:18 | Adam Helal, Julia Nagle, Mark E. Smith, Nev Wilding, Tom Head |
| 6 | Hot Runes | 2:17 | Adam Helal, Julia Nagle, Mark E. Smith, Nev Wilding, Tom Head |
| 7 | Way Round | 3:21 | Adam Helal, Julia Nagle, Mark E. Smith, Tom Head |
| 8 | Octo Realm / Ketamine Sun | 5:36 | Adam Helal, Grant Cunliffe, Julia Nagle, Mark E. Smith, Tom Head |
| 9 | Serum | 4:55 | Adam Helal, Julia Nagle, Mark E. Smith, Nev Wilding, Tom Head |
| 10 | Unutterable | 1:05 | Adam Helal, Julia Nagle, Mark E. Smith, Nev Wilding, Tom Head |
| 11 | Pumpkin Soup and Mashed Potatoes | 2:54 | Adam Helal, Grant Cunliffe, Julia Nagle, Mark E. Smith |
| 12 | Hands Up Billy | 2:46 | Nev Wilding |
| 13 | Midwatch 1953 | 5:32 | Adam Helal, Julia Nagle, Mark E. Smith, Nev Wilding, Tom Head |
| 14 | Devolute | 4:36 | Adam Helal, Julia Nagle, Mark E. Smith, Nev Wilding, Tom Head |
| 15 | Das Katerer | 2:42 | Julia Nagle, Mark E. Smith, Simon Wolstencroft |
Reissue bonus content
The 2008 special deluxe edition of The Unutterable featured a bonus disc containing 13 Testa Rossa monitor mixes.[4] These are early versions of album tracks, including:- "Serum" (4:53)
- "Two Librans" (3:39)
- "Octo Realm / Ketamine Sun" (2:30)
- "Instrum One" (2:05)
- "Instrum Two aka Two" (3:31)