Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Ashmore and Cartier Islands

![Australia in its region (Ashmore and Cartier Islands special)](./assets/Australia_in_its_region_Ashmore_and_Cartier_Islands_special The Ashmore and Cartier Islands Territory is an uninhabited external territory of Australia, encompassing Ashmore Reef—with its West, Middle, and East Islands—and the isolated Cartier Island, positioned in the Indian Ocean along the northwest continental shelf margin, roughly 300 kilometres offshore from the Kimberley region of Western Australia and 200 kilometres south of Indonesia's Roti Island.^[1]^[2] The landforms consist primarily of low-lying coral outcrops, sand cays, and sparse grass cover surrounding a large lagoon at Ashmore Reef, while Cartier Island features similar sandy elevations rising to about five metres above sea level, with no permanent human presence or infrastructure.^[2] Originally sighted by European explorers in the early 19th century, Ashmore Reef was formally annexed by the United Kingdom in 1878 and Cartier Island in 1909 to secure maritime interests, before sovereignty was transferred to Australia via an Order in Council on 23 July 1931, effective from 10 May 1934.^[2] Administered by the Australian Department of Infrastructure, Transport, Regional Development, Communications and the Arts from Canberra, the territory delineates a 12-nautical-mile territorial sea and contributes to Australia's exclusive economic zone, underpinning resource and jurisdictional claims in the region.^[2] Ecologically, the area stands out as a biodiversity hotspot, with Ashmore Reef designated a Ramsar Wetland of International Importance for its unique oceanic reef system supporting diverse marine species, including an estimated 11,000 turtles, seabirds, and coral assemblages; both Ashmore Reef National Nature Reserve and Cartier Island Marine Reserve are classified as strict nature reserves (IUCN Category Ia) prohibiting extractive activities to preserve these values.^[3]^[4] Limited access permits traditional Indonesian trepang fishing under a bilateral memorandum of understanding, reflecting pragmatic management of cross-border resource use amid the territory's remote, protected status.^[1]

Geography

Physical Composition and Features

The Territory of Ashmore and Cartier Islands comprises two distinct reef systems on the shallow upper slope of the Sahul Shelf in the Indian Ocean. Ashmore Reef forms an atoll-like structure enclosing a central lagoon, featuring three low-lying coral islets—West Island, Middle Island, and East Island—that collectively span approximately 5 hectares. These islets consist primarily of coral sand, rubble, and beach rock, with elevations rarely exceeding a few meters above sea level, rendering them vulnerable to tidal inundation and storm surges. Sparse vegetation, mainly grasses and herbs, covers parts of the islets, while the surrounding reef includes diverse hard substrates such as pavement and consolidated rubble, supporting intertidal sand flats and subtidal algal beds.^[5]^[6]^[7] Cartier Island, located approximately 95 kilometers east-southeast of Ashmore Reef, is a small, unvegetated sand cay covering about 0.4 hectares within its own encircling reef. Composed almost entirely of wind- and wave-deposited sand without significant coral outcrops or rocky features on the surface, the island lacks the vegetated or structural complexity of Ashmore's islets. Its low elevation and sandy composition contribute to dynamic shoreline changes influenced by seasonal monsoons and currents. Both reef systems exhibit typical tropical carbonate platforms, with no exposed bedrock or volcanic elements, emphasizing their origin from biogenic accumulation on the continental margin.^[2]^[8]

Location and Maritime Extent

The Ashmore and Cartier Islands territory is situated in the Indian Ocean, approximately 320 kilometers northwest of the Australian mainland coast.^[2] Ashmore Reef lies at 12°14′ S, 123°05′ E, roughly 840 kilometers west of Darwin in the Northern Territory and 610 kilometers north of Broome in Western Australia, while Cartier Island is positioned 70 kilometers east of Ashmore Reef at 12°32′ S, 123°32′ E.^[9]^[10] The islands rest on the edge of Australia's continental shelf, consisting primarily of low-lying coral and sand formations with no permanent human habitation.^[2] The maritime extent of the territory includes the land areas of Ashmore Reef's West, Middle, and East Islands, Cartier Island, and a surrounding territorial sea extending 12 nautical miles (22 kilometers) from the baselines.^[2] Australia asserts sovereign rights over an exclusive economic zone (EEZ) of 200 nautical miles (370 kilometers) around the islands for resource exploration and exploitation, alongside a contiguous zone up to 24 nautical miles for customs, fiscal, immigration, and sanitary enforcement.^[11]^[10] The continental shelf claim extends to the 200-meter depth or beyond to the depth of exploitation where natural prolongation allows, subject to international agreements such as the 1974 memorandum with Indonesia delineating overlapping maritime boundaries.^[12]^[13] These claims underpin Australia's management of marine resources and biodiversity in the region, with Ashmore Reef and Cartier Island designated as commonwealth marine reserves covering about 750 square kilometers.^[4]

History

European Discovery and British Annexation

The first recorded European sighting of Cartier Island occurred in 1800, when British Captain Nash, commanding the ship Cartier, approached the island and named it after his vessel.^[14] This discovery was soon verified in 1801 by Captain James Heywood of HMS Vulcan, who confirmed its position during surveys in the region.^[14] Ashmore Reef was discovered on 11 June 1811 by British Captain Samuel Ashmore, commander of the brig Hibernia, en route between Fiji and India; he named the feature after himself and an adjacent shoal after his ship.^[2] Following these sightings, American whaling vessels began exploiting the reefs' waters in the mid-19th century, prompting territorial disputes between the United States and the United Kingdom over access rights.^[15] Britain formally annexed Ashmore Reef in 1878 to resolve claims by U.S. whalers, establishing sovereignty amid competing interests in the guano-rich area.^[14]^[15] Cartier Island followed with British annexation in 1909, accompanied by an official proclamation of sovereignty on 17 May of that year.^[2] These actions secured British control over the isolated territories prior to their later administrative transfer.

Transfer to Australia and Early Administration

In 1931, the United Kingdom issued an Order in Council on 23 July placing the Ashmore and Cartier Islands under the authority of the Commonwealth of Australia upon formal acceptance.^[16] Australia enacted the Ashmore and Cartier Islands Acceptance Act on 15 December 1933, which provided for the acceptance of the territory and its incorporation as an external territory, effective from 1934.^[17] Initially, the islands were administered as part of Western Australia following acceptance.^[16] Administrative control shifted to the Northern Territory in 1938, where it remained until 1978, reflecting the islands' remote location and minimal human presence, with no permanent settlements established.^[16] Early governance focused on sovereignty assertion rather than development, as the uninhabited territory supported sporadic activities like guano extraction under British leases prior to transfer, though these ceased shortly after.^[2] The first official visit by an Australian government minister, Herbert Victor Johnson, occurred in 1947, highlighting the territory's low priority in immediate post-transfer administration.^[2]

Indonesian Interactions and Boundary Agreements

In the early 20th century, Indonesian fishermen from regions such as Rote Island and eastern Indonesia had established traditional seasonal voyages to the Ashmore Reef area for fishing, trepang collection, and resupplying with fresh water from the lagoon, a practice dating back centuries based on oral histories and archaeological evidence of campsites.^[18] These interactions prompted diplomatic concerns after Australia's 1934 annexation of the islands, leading to the 1974 Memorandum of Understanding (MoU) between Australia and Indonesia, which formally recognized and permitted continued traditional Indonesian fishing in designated northern Australian waters, including zones proximate to Ashmore Reef, using non-mechanized vessels under 30 gross tons and methods like handlines and spears, excluding trawling or explosives.^[2]^[19] The MoU was amended in 1989 to define the "MoU Box," a 50,615 square kilometer area north of Australia where such fishing was confined, explicitly excluding Ashmore Reef following its 1983 declaration as a national nature reserve and the 1988 prohibition on all fishing there to protect biodiversity; this adjustment aimed to balance historical access with Australia's conservation priorities, while allowing limited Indonesian access to the reef's lagoon for shelter and water during storms.^[20]^[21] Enforcement challenges persisted, with Australian authorities detaining hundreds of Indonesian vessels annually in the 1990s and 2000s for illegal fishing or unauthorized entry, often involving motorized boats exceeding MoU limits, resulting in fines, vessel seizures, and diplomatic protests from Indonesia over perceived overreach.^[19] Indonesia's challenges to Australia's sovereignty over the islands in the 1990s, amid overlapping continental shelf claims, were resolved by the Treaty between Australia and the Republic of Indonesia on the Delimitation of a Maritime Boundary, signed on December 14, 1997, in Perth (ratified by Australia in 1999). This agreement established an exclusive economic zone (EEZ) boundary and certain seabed boundaries, extending Australia's territorial sea around Ashmore and Cartier Islands to 12 nautical miles and the EEZ to 200 nautical miles where possible, while confirming Australian jurisdiction over the islands themselves and incorporating provisions for traditional fishing rights under the prior MoU framework.^[1]^[22] The treaty's boundary around Ashmore was adjusted outward to a 24-nautical-mile arc to accommodate resource management, promoting cooperative surveillance against illegal activities and sustainable resource use, though occasional disputes over enforcement and potential renegotiation have arisen, as noted in Australian policy analyses.^[23]^[12]

Governance

Federal Oversight and Legal Status

The Territory of Ashmore and Cartier Islands was formally accepted by the Commonwealth of Australia under the Ashmore and Cartier Islands Acceptance Act 1933, which declared the islands a territory under federal authority effective from 16 August 1934.^[24] This legislation placed the islands directly under the governance of the Australian federal government, without delegation to any state or self-governing body, reflecting their status as an external territory administered from Canberra.^[2] In 1978, administrative responsibility was centralized under federal control, transferring oversight from prior arrangements to the Commonwealth executive.^[15] Federal oversight is exercised by the Department of Infrastructure, Transport, Regional Development, Communications and the Arts, which manages the territory's affairs, including access permits, environmental protection, and maritime enforcement, given the absence of permanent inhabitants or local institutions.^[2] The Governor-General, acting on behalf of the Commonwealth, holds power to enact ordinances specific to the territory, which may amend or repeal applicable laws as needed for administration.^[24] Judicial matters fall under federal jurisdiction, with Commonwealth courts applying Australian law, supplemented by Northern Territory legislation where extended by ordinance.^[2] The legal framework integrates the territory into Australia's constitutional structure as a non-self-governing possession, subject to full Commonwealth legislative power under section 122 of the Constitution, without the autonomy granted to internal territories like the Northern Territory.^[25] This status ensures direct federal control over sovereignty, resource management, and security, including patrols by the Australian Border Force to enforce entry restrictions and prevent unauthorized activities.^[2] No provisions exist for local representation or devolved powers, underscoring the territory's role primarily as a marine and strategic asset under undivided national authority.^[26]

Administrative and Judicial Framework

The Ashmore and Cartier Islands are administered as an external territory of the Commonwealth of Australia under federal oversight, with primary management responsibilities held by agencies such as the Australian Border Force for sovereignty enforcement, border protection, and regulation of access, alongside the Department of Infrastructure, Transport, Regional Development, Communications and the Arts for broader territorial coordination.^[2] The Australian Fisheries Management Authority addresses illegal fishing, while the Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade handles diplomatic aspects related to maritime boundaries and interactions.^[2] Absent a permanent population or local government, administration operates remotely from Canberra, with no resident officials or infrastructure for on-site governance; access requires permits issued by federal authorities, primarily restricted to scientific, conservation, or enforcement purposes.^[2] The foundational legal instrument is the Ashmore and Cartier Islands Acceptance Act 1933 (Cth), which formalized Australia's acceptance of the islands from British cession via proclamation on 16 August 1934, initially attaching them administratively to the Northern Territory for law application before their effective transfer to direct Commonwealth control in 1978.^[24] This Act empowers the Governor-General to promulgate ordinances that may amend or repeal applicable laws, subject to parliamentary tabling and disallowance provisions, though such ordinances are infrequent given the territory's uninhabited status.^[24] Applicable laws encompass Commonwealth statutes, Northern Territory legislation extended under section 6 of the Act, and any relevant ordinances, ensuring alignment with the Australian Constitution while permitting federal override.^[24] Notably, section 6A excludes the federal Criminal Code Act 1995 (Cth), thereby preserving Northern Territory criminal laws for offenses within the territory.^[24] Judicial authority resides with the courts of the Northern Territory, as stipulated in section 12 of the Act, which grants them jurisdiction over matters arising in the islands without provision for local tribunals.^[24] Proceedings for violations, such as unauthorized entry or illegal fishing, occur in mainland Australian courts—typically Northern Territory or federal—following arrests by patrolling vessels of the Royal Australian Navy or Australian Border Force, with penalties including prosecutions, fines, and vessel impoundment enforced under Commonwealth or territorial law.^[2] This framework underscores the territory's integration into Australia's federal judicial system, prioritizing enforcement of sovereignty and environmental protections over autonomous local adjudication.^[24]

Environment

Biodiversity and Ecological Significance

The Ashmore and Cartier Islands host exceptional marine biodiversity, functioning as isolated oceanic reefs in the northwest Indian Ocean that support diverse coral, fish, and invertebrate communities. Ashmore Reef, encompassing three small islets within a large atoll, features over 255 species of hard and soft corals, alongside extensive sea fans and sponges that form complex habitats. These ecosystems sustain high densities of reef-associated fish, with surveys identifying substantial schools of pelagic species, and molluscan diversity reaching 433 recorded species. The presence of 14 sea snake species, including several endemics to the region, underscores the area's significance for reptilian biodiversity in remote coral environments.^[27]^[1] Cartier Island, a smaller sand cay atop a submerged reef, similarly qualifies as a biodiversity hotspot, attracting aggregations of marine megafauna such as turtles, dugongs, dolphins, and whales due to its position as a biological stepping stone between continental shelves and deeper oceanic waters. Fish diversity around Cartier exceeds 540 species, contributing to gene flow and larval dispersal across the Indo-Pacific. Both reserves protect vulnerable habitats that harbor endangered marine species, including green and hawksbill turtles, which utilize the reefs for nesting and foraging. Terrestrial biodiversity is limited, with Ashmore's islets supporting seasonal seabird colonies numbering approximately 100,000 breeding pairs annually, primarily terns and noddies, alongside sparse insect and arthropod communities adapted to guano-rich soils.^[28]^[29] Ecologically, these islands represent bioregionally unique systems as the only true oceanic reefs in northwest Australia, facilitating connectivity in the Timor Sea's marine biota and serving as refugia for species sensitive to coastal pressures. Their remoteness preserves pristine conditions, with low human impact enabling natural processes like coral recruitment and predator-prey dynamics to dominate. Recognition as a Ramsar Wetland of International Importance for Ashmore Reef highlights its role in maintaining regional biodiversity amid broader Indo-West Pacific reef declines. These features position the territory as a critical node for conservation, informing strategies to sustain ecosystem resilience against environmental stressors.^[3]^[30]^[4]

Conservation Policies and Reserves

The Ashmore Reef National Nature Reserve, encompassing 583 square kilometers, was established in 1983 under the National Parks and Wildlife Conservation Act 1975 to safeguard its coral reef systems, seagrass meadows, and associated biodiversity.^[2] The Cartier Island Marine Reserve, covering 172 square kilometers, was proclaimed in 2000.^[31] Both are administered as Commonwealth marine reserves under the Environment Protection and Biodiversity Conservation Act 1999, with management focused on preserving ecological integrity through strict zoning and activity restrictions.^[4] Oversight includes patrols by the Royal Australian Navy and Australian Fisheries Management Authority to deter illegal fishing and enforce compliance.^[2] Ashmore Reef operates primarily as a Sanctuary Zone, classified under IUCN Category Ia, where only approved scientific research is permitted to avoid disturbance to breeding seabirds, turtles, and coral habitats; a limited Recreational Use Zone allows anchoring at designated moorings and recreational fishing under Western Australian rules, excluding protected species.^[29] Traditional Indonesian fishers retain access rights within a specified "MoU Box" for harvesting sedentary species, collecting freshwater, and visiting gravesites, as per bilateral agreements.^[29] The reserve's wetlands hold Ramsar Convention status, underscoring their international significance for migratory shorebirds and marine species.^[29] Access to key seabird islands requires permits, with moorings mandated to prevent reef damage from anchoring.^[2] Cartier Island Marine Park is entirely a Sanctuary Zone, prohibiting all human activities except Director of National Parks-approved scientific research to protect deep-water corals, sea snakes, whale sharks, and other pelagic species.^[31] No recreational access or anchoring is allowed without prior written approval, primarily due to risks from unexploded ordnance within a 10-kilometer radius, alongside conservation imperatives.^[31] Emergency anchoring on sand bottoms is conditionally permitted with precautions.^[31] Management principles for both reserves, outlined in plans effective since 2002, emphasize preventing introductions of non-native species, monitoring biodiversity threats, and maintaining ecosystem processes through minimal intervention.^[14] These policies prioritize habitat protection over extractive uses, with enforcement supported by federal agencies to sustain the reserves' role as refugia for vulnerable tropical marine life.^[32]

Threats from Climate and Human Activity

![Satellite image of Ashmore reef on 26 August 2021.](./assets/Coral_reefs_of_the_Kimberley_region_in_Australia_threatened_by_climate_change_Copernicus The Ashmore Reef has experienced severe coral bleaching events due to elevated sea surface temperatures, with more than 60% of coral cover affected in the Scott and Ashmore reef systems during past marine heatwaves, leading to widespread mortality.^[33] In 2024, minor bleaching and recent mortality were observed at select sites on Ashmore Reef, though mass bleaching was averted by cooling storms that reduced heat stress.^[34] These events underscore the vulnerability of the reef's coral ecosystems to ocean warming, a primary climate-driven threat exacerbated by global temperature rises.^[4] Cartier Island, lacking extensive coral formations, faces risks from sea-level rise and intensified storm activity, which could accelerate coastal erosion on its low-lying sandy shores.^[31] Broader climate impacts, including ocean acidification, further threaten the marine biodiversity surrounding both territories by impairing calcification in reef-building organisms.^[3] Human activities pose additional pressures, including illegal fishing and poaching of protected species by traditional Indonesian fishers, which disrupt local ecosystems despite the territories' status as highly protected marine reserves.^[9] Cartier Island harbors unexploded ordnance from its prior use as a bombing range until 1993, presenting ongoing safety hazards and potential contamination risks to marine habitats.^[31] Vessel groundings and ballast water discharge introduce pollution and invasive species, amplifying biosecurity threats in these remote areas.^[32] Increased maritime traffic has been linked to declines in sea snake populations at Ashmore Reef, possibly through pollution and habitat disturbance.^[35] Conservation measures, such as sanctuary zones prohibiting extractive activities, mitigate these impacts but cannot fully counteract cumulative stressors from both climate and anthropogenic sources.^[36]

Economy and Resources

Hydrocarbon Exploration and Potential

The offshore areas adjacent to the Ashmore and Cartier Islands form part of the Bonaparte Basin, a hydrocarbon-bearing sedimentary basin spanning approximately 270,000 km² with established petroleum systems involving Jurassic, Permian, and Carboniferous reservoirs.^[37]^[38] Source rocks such as the Oxfordian to Valanginian Flamingo Group exhibit moderate to good oil generative potential, with total organic carbon content ranging from 1-2.4 wt%.^[39] Exploration in the Territory of Ashmore and Cartier Islands adjacent area has yielded several discoveries, including the Laminaria and Corallina oil fields in production licence AC/L5, which produce light crude oil via the Northern Endeavour floating production, storage, and offloading (FPSO) facility operational since 1999 and located within the territory's scheduled area.^[40] Additional oil discoveries include the Puffin field (e.g., Puffin-8 and Puffin-10 ST2 wells), while gas has been found in the Crux field (e.g., Crux-2, Crux-2 ST1, and Crux-3 wells).^[41] These findings confirm hydrocarbon charge to structures like the Ashmore Platform, supported by evidence of natural seeps, though only one proven accumulation has been established to date.^[42] The Australian government periodically releases acreage for exploration, such as areas AC04-1 and AC04-2 in the Vulcan Sub-basin, highlighting undeveloped discoveries alongside producing fields.^[43] In 2023, Melbana Energy was awarded permit AC/P70 in the Bonaparte Basin for a six-year term, encompassing plans for 3D seismic reprocessing, geological studies, and drilling one exploration well, with company assessments identifying leads and prospects holding an estimated 500 million barrels of oil equivalent in recoverable resources.^[44] Seismic features like gas chimneys and diapirs in the Vulcan Sub-basin further suggest residual hydrocarbon potential in Paleogene sandstones and carbonates within structural traps near the Cartier Trough.^[45] Despite these indicators, commercial development remains limited, constrained by factors including reservoir complexity and proximity to marine reserves.

Fisheries and Traditional Harvesting Rights

The waters surrounding the Ashmore and Cartier Islands form part of Australia's exclusive economic zone, where fisheries are managed primarily for conservation under the Environment Protection and Biodiversity Conservation Act 1999, prohibiting Australian commercial fishing operations within the Ashmore Reef National Nature Reserve and Cartier Island Marine Reserve to preserve marine biodiversity and ecosystem integrity.^[46] Recreational fishing by Australians is permitted only in designated zones of the Ashmore Reef Marine Park, subject to Western Australian recreational rules and prohibitions on protected species, while the reserves as a whole emphasize no-take policies in sanctuary zones to mitigate overexploitation risks.^[29] Traditional harvesting rights in the region stem from a 1974 Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) between Australia and Indonesia, which recognizes centuries-old Indonesian fishing practices by communities from Rote and Kupang using non-motorized perahu vessels and methods such as handlining and free-diving for species including finfish, sharks, trepang (sea cucumbers), trochus shells, and sponges; the MOU was reviewed and amended in 1989 to confine activities to the approximately 50,000 km² "MoU Box" encompassing Ashmore Reef and Cartier Island.^[20]^[46] These rights permit subsistence-level harvesting for immediate consumption but exclude motorized vessels, air compressors, engine-assisted gear, and the taking of turtles, birds, or eggs, with fishers allowed limited landing on West Island (Ashmore) for freshwater access or grave site visits in recreational zones.^[20] Restrictions intensified in the late 1980s due to evidence of stock depletion from historical overharvesting of sedentary species like trepang and trochus; at Ashmore Reef, traditional fishing is now confined to finfish caught for immediate needs or one day's sailing supply within [West Island](/page/West Island) Lagoon, with all other harvesting requiring permits, while Cartier Island Marine Reserve remains fully closed to Indonesian traditional fishing to protect its biodiversity and address unexploded ordnance hazards.^[46] Enforcement is conducted by the Australian Fisheries Management Authority (AFMA) and Australian Border Force, with non-compliance leading to vessel seizures, fines, or prosecutions, amid ongoing challenges from illegal activities that prompted increased patrols following rises in unauthorized incursions.^[2]^[20] No equivalent traditional harvesting rights exist for Australian Indigenous groups, as the islands lack permanent habitation or documented pre-colonial use in official management frameworks.^[46]

Territorial Claims and Sovereignty

Historical Basis of Australian Control

The United Kingdom established sovereignty over Cartier Island through annexation in 1909, following earlier European discoveries in the region.^[2] Ashmore Reef, comprising the three main islands of the group, had been sighted by Captain Samuel Ashmore of the ship Hibernia on 11 June 1811, with British possession formalized subsequently.^[1] These acts placed the islands under British imperial authority as unincorporated territories, without settled populations or competing territorial claims at the time.^[16] On 23 July 1931, King George V issued an Order-in-Council transferring administrative authority over both Ashmore and Cartier Islands to the Commonwealth of Australia, at the request of Western Australia to extend its jurisdiction over nearby waters.^[12] This executive action reflected Britain's policy of delegating control of remote oceanic possessions to dominions, aligning with the Statute of Westminster 1931 that granted legislative independence to Australia. Australia formalized acceptance through the Ashmore and Cartier Islands Acceptance Act 1933, assented to on 15 December 1933 and proclaimed operative on 10 May 1934, thereby incorporating the islands as an external territory under federal oversight.^[2] ^[24] The Act authorized the Governor of Western Australia to promulgate ordinances for governance, emphasizing resource regulation and maritime boundaries rather than habitation. In July 1938, administration was reassigned to the Northern Territory for logistical efficiency, solidifying continuous Australian sovereignty without interruption.^[16] This legal framework provided the enduring basis for control, predicated on effective occupation and international recognition under prevailing colonial norms.

Indonesian Objections and Treaty Resolutions

Indonesia has not formally contested Australian sovereignty over the Ashmore and Cartier Islands, which were annexed by the United Kingdom on 23 August 1931 and transferred to Australia on 16 August 1933, with effective occupation maintained since.^[15] Instead, Indonesian concerns have centered on maritime boundaries, exclusive economic zones (EEZs), and traditional fishing access, stemming from historical visits by Indonesian fishermen dating to approximately 1700.^[15] These activities, primarily by ethnic groups like the Bajau and Rotenese from Rote Island, involved seasonal trepang (sea cucumber) harvesting and later fishing, but did not establish territorial title under international law, as no effective Indonesian administration or claim predated Australia's.^[47] To accommodate traditional Indonesian fishing while asserting control, Australia and Indonesia signed a Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) on 11 December 1974, designating a "MOU Box" of approximately 50,000 square kilometers adjacent to the islands, including Ashmore Reef and Cartier Island, where Indonesian fishers could continue non-commercial, traditional methods using specified vessels and gear.^[20] The MOU explicitly recognized Australian sovereignty and prohibited destructive practices, with amendments in 1989 further restricting access to preserve marine parks declared around Ashmore in 1983 and Cartier in 2000.^[19] This arrangement resolved immediate access disputes but highlighted tensions over resource exploitation, as Australia's establishment of protected areas limited Indonesian harvests, prompting complaints from fishers but no official sovereignty challenge.^[21] In the 1990s, broader negotiations under the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS) framework brought maritime delimitation issues to the fore, with Indonesia questioning the weight given to the uninhabited Ashmore and Cartier Islands in calculating EEZ and continental shelf boundaries, arguing for equitable principles that might reduce Australia's claims in overlapping zones.^[15] These discussions, influenced by post-Cold War resource interests like potential hydrocarbons, did not extend to territorial sovereignty but focused on boundary lines; Australia maintained the islands' full effect as base points per UNCLOS Article 121.^[48] The dispute was resolved through the Australia-Indonesia Maritime Boundary Treaty signed on 14 March 1997 in Perth, which delineated stable EEZ and continental shelf lines in the Indian Ocean and Timor Sea sectors, incorporating the islands' positions while granting Australia seabed rights subjacent to some Indonesian waters.^[22] Ratified by both parties, the treaty entered force on 8 February 1999 after parliamentary approval, effectively affirming Australian title by excluding the islands from any Indonesian maritime entitlements and providing mechanisms for future cooperation on resources.^[23] Contemporary echoes of objection surfaced in Indonesian media in November 2022, fueled by nationalist sentiments amid discussions of maritime maps and resource potential, with some outlets and a Rote Island community group announcing plans to sue Australia over perceived historical rights to "Pulau Pasir" (Ashmore Reef).^[49] However, Indonesia's government reaffirmed Australian sovereignty, citing the 1974 MOU and 1997 Treaty as binding, and noted no legal basis for revision under international law; no diplomatic protest followed Australia's 2004 continental shelf submission to the UN Commission, underscoring the lack of substantive claim.^[48] These episodes reflect domestic political rhetoric rather than policy shifts, with treaties ensuring stability despite occasional enforcement frictions over illegal fishing incursions.^[12]

Contemporary Disputes and Indigenous Assertions

![Australia in its region, highlighting Ashmore and Cartier Islands' proximity to Indonesia](./assets/Australia_in_its_region_Ashmore_and_Cartier_Islands_special In 2022, a group of indigenous Indonesians from Rote Island announced plans to sue Australia in international courts over sovereignty of the Ashmore and Cartier Islands, asserting historical rights based on ancestral fishing and navigation in the area known locally as Pulau Pasir.^[50] These claims emphasize long-standing traditional use by communities in East Nusa Tenggara, predating formal Australian annexation in 1933, though Australian legal title derives from British transfer and subsequent international recognition.^[48] The assertions lack support in established territorial law, which prioritizes effective control and treaties over customary access, but highlight resource interests including potential hydrocarbons.^[12] Ongoing disputes center on traditional fishing rights, with Australia restricting Indonesian access since designating Ashmore Reef a national nature reserve in 1983 and closing it to non-Australian fishing in 1999 to protect biodiversity.^[15] Indonesian artisanal fishers, primarily from the Bajo and Rotinese ethnic groups, continue incursions, leading to regular Australian Border Force interceptions; for instance, in 2021-2022, multiple vessels were detained for illegal fishing within the exclusive economic zone.^[51] The 1997 Australia-Indonesia Maritime Delimitation Treaty delineated boundaries while permitting limited traditional fishing in zoned areas, but enforcement gaps and conservation priorities have fueled tensions, with Indonesian groups viewing restrictions as infringing ancestral entitlements.^[52] Australian policy frames these as biosecurity and sustainability measures, rejecting sovereignty challenges as resolved by prior agreements.^[47] Indigenous assertions by these Indonesian communities invoke customary law under Indonesia's 2007 Fisheries Act, which recognizes traditional rights for communities with historical practices, though such claims do not extend to territorial sovereignty under international norms.^[53] No equivalent assertions from Australian Indigenous groups have gained prominence, as the islands' remote oceanic location limits pre-colonial ties to mainland Aboriginal or Torres Strait Islander custodianship.^[54] Disputes persist amid broader Indo-Pacific maritime frictions, with Australia maintaining patrols to deter unauthorized entry, underscoring the tension between ecological preservation and historical resource access.^[55]

Access and Security

Regulated Visitation and Permits

Access to the Ashmore and Cartier Islands is governed by the Environment Protection and Biodiversity Conservation Act 1999 and associated regulations, which establish the territory as a network of Commonwealth Marine Reserves to safeguard biodiversity, coral ecosystems, and seabird habitats from human disturbance.^[4] Visitation is confined to designated zones, with public entry prohibited in most areas classified as IUCN Category Ia Sanctuary Zones, where only approved scientific research is permitted.^[18] Permits are mandatory for landing on islands, conducting commercial activities, or entering restricted zones, enforced through on-site management by Parks Australia and coordination with the Australian Border Force to address biosecurity risks and unauthorized incursions.^[29] In the Ashmore Reef Marine Reserve, recreational visitation is allowed solely within the Recreational Use Zone, encompassing West Island Lagoon, the eastern beach, and a central corridor on West Island, to enable low-impact activities such as snorkeling, scuba diving, and limited finfish fishing using rod, line, or hand spear for immediate consumption or one day's travel provisions.^[4] Vessels must utilize the 13 installed moorings in West Island Lagoon—established in 2003—to prevent anchor damage to coral reefs, with anchoring permitted only on sand substrates if moorings are occupied.^[29] Access to Middle and East Islands, primary seabird breeding sites, requires specific permits for research or monitoring, while prohibited actions include camping, collecting specimens like coral or shells, lighting fires, feeding wildlife, or using spear guns and scuba gear for fishing.^[2] Organized tours or commercial operations demand prior authorization from the Director of National Parks to ensure compliance with environmental safeguards.^[18] The Cartier Island Marine Reserve imposes a total ban on public visitation, including entry, landing, or anchoring, due to hazards from unexploded ordnance remnants of historical military activities, with exceptions limited to maritime emergencies requiring immediate reporting to authorities.^[4] This closure aligns with the reserve's IUCN Category Ia status, prioritizing undisturbed marine and island ecosystems over any recreational or extractive uses.^[18] Permits for allowable visitation are obtained by application to the Commonwealth Marine Reserves Branch of the Department of Climate Change, Energy, the Environment and Water, demonstrating negligible environmental impact, biosecurity protocols, and adherence to zoning rules; approvals are not granted for general tourism but for vetted purposes like research or compliant recreation.^[4] Violations, such as unauthorized access or prohibited activities, incur penalties under the EPBC Regulations 2000, including fines exceeding AUD 500,000 for corporations and potential imprisonment, underscoring the priority of ecological integrity over public access.^[18] Traditional access rights for Indonesian fishers, governed by a 1974 Memorandum of Understanding, permit limited island use for shelter and freshwater but exclude broader visitation frameworks.^[2]

Implications for Migration and Border Control

The Ashmore and Cartier Islands' remote location in the Indian Ocean, approximately 320 kilometers west of Darwin and within Australia's exclusive economic zone, positions them as a potential transit point for irregular maritime migration from Indonesia and Southeast Asia toward the Australian mainland.^[2] Their excision from Australia's migration zone in September 2001 under amendments to the Migration Act enabled the classification of arrivals as "unauthorized maritime arrivals," facilitating offshore detention and processing rather than onshore resettlement rights.^[2] This policy shift was part of broader efforts to deter people smuggling by removing incentives for boat voyages, allowing interdiction, turn-backs, or transfer to regional processing centers without automatic access to refugee determination on the mainland.^[56] Australian Border Force (ABF) and Royal Australian Navy operations maintain a near-permanent presence, including the patrol vessel ABFC Thaiyak stationed at Ashmore Reef to monitor and intercept unauthorized vessels within the surrounding maritime domain.^[57] These patrols, coordinated through the Maritime Border Command, extend to the islands' reserves and reefs, enforcing biosecurity, fisheries, and migration laws amid occasional incursions by fishing or migrant boats.^[58] Between 2002 and 2013, multiple asylum seeker vessels landed at or near Ashmore Reef, with arrivals processed under excised status provisions; for instance, a 2009 incident involved a boat explosion at the reef carrying over 40 people, resulting in five deaths and injuries, highlighting the hazards and enforcement challenges.^[59] Legal designations have reinforced border control efficacy, though not without contention: a 2018 Federal Court ruling invalidated the government's 2001 appointment of Ashmore Reef as a "port," potentially affecting up to 1,600 historical claims by reclassifying some arrivals as onshore, prompting retrospective validation legislation.^[60] In practice, such measures underscore the islands' role in Australia's "push-back" strategy, where vessels are sometimes towed through Ashmore Reef waters to affirm offshore status, deterring further attempts amid high-risk sea routes.^[61] This framework has contributed to a decline in successful boat arrivals post-2013 under Operation Sovereign Borders, integrating the islands into a layered defense prioritizing interdiction over accommodation.^[62]

References

[1]
Ashmore and Cartier Islands | Geoscience Australia
Jul 10, 2025 · Indonesian fishermen visit Ashmore Reef each year under a Memorandum of Understanding signed by the Australian and Indonesian Governments, which ...
[2]
Ashmore and Cartier Islands
On the 23 July 1931 an order-in-council placed Ashmore and Cartier Islands under the authority of the Commonwealth. It was not until 10 May 1934 that the ...
[3]
Ashmore Reef Commonwealth Marine Reserve Ramsar site ...
Oct 10, 2021 · It was listed as a Wetland of International Importance because it is a biodiversity hotspot and bioregionally unique as the only oceanic reef in ...
[4]
[PDF] Ashmore Reef and Cartier Island Commonwealth Marine Reserves
It is thought that Ashmore and Cartier support approximately 11,000 marine turtles. Significant populations of feeding Green, Loggerhead and Hawksbill turtles ...
[5]
[PDF] Ashmore Reef Commonwealth Marine Reserve - DCCEEW
The Reserve is located in Australia's External Territory of Ashmore and Cartier Islands and is under the jurisdiction of the Australian Government.
[6]
[DOC] Commonwealth marine environment report card Supporting the ...
Ashmore Reef and Cartier Island are situated on the shallow upper slope of the Sahul Shelf, north of Scott and Seringapatam reefs. They form part of a series of ...
[7]
[PDF] survey and stock size estimates of the shallow reef (0-15 m - DCCEEW
Ashmore Reef, Cartier Island and Browse Island had high cover of hard substrate such as pavement (18%–33% cover) or consolidated rubble 27% - 32% cover). For ...
[8]
https://www.cia.gov/the-world-factbook/about/archives/2022/countries/ashmore-and-cartier-islands/
[9]
Ashmore and Cartier Islands - 2022 World Factbook Archive - CIA
Dec 21, 2022 · Geography ; Location. Southeastern Asia, islands in the Indian Ocean, midway between northwestern Australia and Timor island; Ashmore Reef is 840 ...
[10]
Ashmore and Cartier Islands Geography Profile - IndexMundi
Geographic coordinates, 12 25 S, 123 20 E · note - Ashmore Reef - 12 14 S, 123 05 E; Cartier Islet - 12 32 S, 123 32 E ; Map references, Southeast Asia ; Area ...
[11]
The Law of the Sea - Geoscience Australia
Jun 27, 2014 · Australia has an Exclusive Economic Zone (EEZ) that extends beyond the 12 nautical mile territorial sea to a distance of 200 nautical miles (one ...
[12]
Ashmore Reef resurfaces as a maritime headache - Lowy Institute
Nov 3, 2022 · This resulted in islands having an entitlement to a 200 nautical mile exclusive economic zone (EEZ), and a minimum 200 nautical mile continental ...
[13]
[PDF] Indonesia Territorial Sea and Continental Shelf Boundaries
The median line and the deep water line eventually converge and cross as the boundary approaches the Australian. Ashmore and Cartier Islands. The two lines ...<|separator|>
[14]
[PDF] Ashmore Reef National Nature Reserve and Cartier Island Marine ...
2.3.2 European discovery and activities. Europeans discovered the two reef systems in the early 19thCentury. Cartier Island was found first (by Captain Nash ...
[15]
Ashmore and Cartier Islands - The World Factbook - CIA
Dec 1, 2023 · The UK disputed US access to Ashmore Reef and formally annexed it in 1878. Cartier Island was annexed in 1909. In 1931, the UK transferred the ...
[16]
Ashmore and Cartier Islands - The World Factbook - CIA
Sep 25, 2025 · Government. Country name · Dependency status · Legal system · Citizenship · Diplomatic representation in the US · Diplomatic representation from ...Missing: governance | Show results with:governance
[17]
https://oxcon.ouplaw.com/abstract/10.1093/law:ocw/law-ocw-cd75-H1933.regGroup.1/law-ocw-cd75-H1933
[18]
[PDF] Ashmore Reef and Cartier Island Reserves - DCCEEW
An agreement between Australia and Indonesia allows traditional. Indonesian fishers to continue to access certain parts of Ashmore. Reserve to replenish fresh.<|separator|>
[19]
Indonesia - Australia Fisheries Cooperation - DAFF
Oct 16, 2020 · Guidelines under the MoU were agreed in 1989 in order to clarify access boundaries for traditional fishers and take into account the declaration ...
[20]
Traditional Indonesian fishing in the MoU Box
Feb 14, 2023 · Indonesian traditional fishers, using traditional fishing methods only, are permitted to operate in an area of about 50,000km2 of Australian ...
[21]
[PDF] Implications of the Memoradum of Understanding on Bajo fishing ...
The banning of fishing at Ashmore Reef in 1988 and the 1989 amendments to the 1974 Memorandum of Understanding which confined “traditional fishing” to a box ...
[22]
[PDF] AUSTRALIA-INDONESIA MARITIME DELIMITATION TREATY
The treaty establishes an Exclusive Economic Zone Boundary and certain seabed boundaries between Australia and Indonesia, including details of boundaries and ...
[23]
[PDF] The Australian and Indonesian Maritime Boundary Delimitation Treaty
The March 1997 Treaty established an Exclusive Economic Zone and seabed boundaries, aiming to promote sustainable development and give Australia jurisdiction ...
[24]
ASHMORE AND CARTIER ISLANDS ACCEPTANCE ACT 1933
Acceptance of Ashmore Islands and Cartier Island 6. Application of Northern Territory laws 6A. Criminal Code does not apply 7. Ordinance may amend or repeal ...
[25]
10. External territories - Australian Law Reform Commission
Jul 15, 2010 · Australia's external territories include Ashmore and Cartier Islands, Christmas Island, Cocos (Keeling) Islands, Coral Sea Islands, Australian ...
[26]
[PDF] CHAPTER TWO: THE LEGAL FRAMEWORK
Legal status of External Territories 2.3 Norfolk, Christmas, Cocos, Ashmore, Cartier and the Coral Sea Islands are all administered by the Department of ...Missing: governance | Show results with:governance
[27]
Exploring Ashmore Reef Marine Park - CSIRO
Ashmore Reef Marine Park is a remote, biodiversity-rich area with diverse marine life, 255 coral species, and 100,000 breeding birds, but faces threats from ...Missing: Reserve | Show results with:Reserve
[28]
North-west > Cartier Island – Seamap Australia
Much like Ashmore Reef Marine Park, this biodiversity hotspot attracts huge schools of pelagic fish, whales, dolphins, turtles and dugongs, as well as an ...
[29]
Ashmore Reef Marine Park
It was declared because the islands and surrounding waters are important for the seabirds, shorebirds and other marine life they support. It is one of 65 Ramsar ...Missing: EEZ | Show results with:EEZ
[30]
Values of the North-west Marine Parks Network
Like the islands of Ashmore Reef, Cartier Island is a biodiversity hotspot and an important biological stepping stone, facilitating the transport of biological ...
[31]
Cartier Island Marine Park
Cartier Island Marine Park, a Sanctuary Zone, protects diverse marine life in the Timor Sea, 45km from Ashmore Reef, and is 600km north of Broome. It covers ...Missing: conservation policies
[32]
[PDF] Ashmore Reef National Nature Reserve and Cartier Island Marine ...
The ecological impact of this species has yet to be determined. However, it is widely distributed on many islands throughout the Indo-West Pacific region and at ...
[33]
Coral bleaching events | AIMS
Bleaching was severe (more than 60% of coral cover) at the Scott and Ashmore reef systems, causing widespread mortality. A film about coral bleaching in ...
[34]
Scientists confirm that WA oceanic reefs avoid mass bleaching | AIMS
May 28, 2024 · “We did see some minor bleaching and evidence of recent mortality, at a few sites at Ashmore and the Scott Reefs, but not nearly as much as ...
[35]
Pinpointing Drivers of Extirpation in Sea Snakes - Frontiers
Hypothesis: Increased acute maritime activity and subsequent upsurge in pollution at Ashmore significantly impacted sea snake populations and drove declines.<|separator|>
[36]
Ashmore Reef – History and Recovery - Schmidt Ocean Institute
May 3, 2021 · It became a marine reserve in 1983 and has the highest level of protection from human activities – with most of the Marine Park a Sanctuary Zone ...
[37]
Bonaparte Basin | Geoscience Australia
Aug 29, 2023 · The Cambrian to Recent Bonaparte Basin is a fan-shaped hydrocarbon-bearing basin extending over 270 000km 2 in the northwestern offshore and onshore Australia.
[38]
(PDF) The petroleum systems of the Bonaparte Basin. - ResearchGate
There are four petroleum systems in the Southern Bonaparte Basin with Jurassic, Permian, and Carboniferous reservoirs (Earl, 2004) .
[39]
[PDF] total petroleum systems of the bonaparte gulf basin area, australia ...
The Oxfordian to Valanginian Flamingo Group (Upper Petrel Formation) has good oil source-rock potential in the Bonaparte Basin; TOC ranges from 1-2.4 wt% and ...
[40]
Northern Endeavour FPSO Subscribe - Industry environment plans
The NE FPSO is situated within the Scheduled Area for the Australian Commonwealth Territory of Ashmore and Cartier Islands. It produces oil from the Laminaria- ...Missing: reserves | Show results with:reserves
[41]
Table 1.6: Territory of Ashmore and Cartier Wells Drilled for ...
Geoscience Australia is the national public sector geoscience organisation. Its mission is to be the trusted source of information on Australia's geology ...
[42]
Establishing hydrocarbon charge to the Ashmore Platform ...
Aug 9, 2025 · To date there is one proven hydrocarbon accumulation on the Ashmore Platform, Bonaparte Basin, Australia, with hydrocarbon charge remaining ...<|separator|>
[43]
[PDF] Areas AC04-1 & AC04-2 Vulcan Sub-basin, Bonaparte Basin ...
Mar 31, 2020 · The Ashmore Cartier region contains producing and decommissioned oil fields as well as oil and gas discoveries that are presently undeveloped.
[44]
Melbana Energy Limited Annual Report 2023
... petroleum exploration permit AC/P70, located in the Territory of Ashmore and Cartier Islands, for an initial period of six years. Melbana made an ...
[45]
Implications of gas chimneys and linear diapirs for hydrocarbon ...
Seismic attributes reveal residual hydrocarbon potential in Paleogene sandstones and carbonates, particularly within structural traps in the Cartier Trough and ...
[46]
[PDF] Ashmore Reef National Nature Reserve and Cartier Island Marine ...
Located in Australia's External Territory of Ashmore and Cartier Islands, the Reserves are under the jurisdiction of the Commonwealth of Australia.
[47]
[PDF] A Study of Socio-Economic Issues Facing Traditional Indonesian ...
protect the wildlife on Ashmore and Cartier Islands. Indonesia indicated its willingness to prevent breaches of the MOU and both sides agreed to cooperate ...
[48]
A New Maritime Boundary Dispute: Is Ashmore Reef Part of Australia?
Nov 6, 2022 · The three Ashmore Islands and adjoining reef have formally been a part of Australia since the Ashmore and Cartier Islands Acceptance Act 1933 ...
[49]
Indonesian nationalism and the Ashmore Reef debate - Policy Forum
Nov 21, 2022 · A recent debate in Indonesian media about Australia's sovereignty over Ashmore Reef shows why it's important for politicians to listen to policy experts.Missing: Cartier | Show results with:Cartier
[50]
Indonesian tribe to sue Australia over oil-rich islands as it draws line ...
Nov 1, 2022 · A group of indigenous people in Indonesia plans to sue Australia over its ownership of the Territory of Ashmore and Cartier Islands.
[51]
[PDF] Ashmore Reef National Nature Reserve and Cartier Island Marine ...
Flotsam and jetsam are common on the shorelines of the islands at Ashmore Reef. The fruits and seeds from 83 different species, mostly of Indonesian origin were ...
[52]
[PDF] INDIGENOUS USE AND LEGAL PROTECTION OF PULAU PASIR ...
Pasir Island, also known as Ashmore and Cartier, is an area geographically located close to East. Nusa Tenggara (NTT). Indigenous communities in NTT have a long ...
[53]
[PDF] TRADITIONAL FISHING RIGHTS BEYOND NATIONAL JURISDICTION
May 19, 2011 · Access to the MoU Box would continue to be limited to Indonesian traditional fishermen using traditional methods and traditional vessels.
[54]
Indigenous Underwater Cultural Heritage Legislation in Australia
The article examines possible amendments to the Australian legislative regime regulating and protecting Indigenous cultural heritage in an offshore, ...
[55]
Indonesia's efforts to reclaim its right over Sand Island Cluster
Oct 14, 2022 · Indonesia must do something to regain its rights to the Sand Island cluster. This case can be settled through court or arbitration.
[56]
Immigration Control beyond Australia's Border
Dec 15, 2014 · Under the legislative changes, the 1958 Migration Act was revised to exclude Ashmore Reef, Cartier Island, Christmas Island, Cocos (Keeling) ...
[57]
[PDF] Australian Border Force Operational Fleet Composition
The Australian Border Force Cutter Thaiyak is stationed on a near- permanent basis at the Ashmore Reef National Nature Reserve and Cartier Island Marine ...
[58]
MARITIME BORDER COMMAND - Australian Border Force
Sep 22, 2024 · A variety of vessels make up the ABF Fleet. These vessels respond to Civil Maritime Security Threats in a diverse range of maritime environments.
[59]
Boats intercepted near Darwin, Ashmore Reef - ABC News
Apr 29, 2009 · Earlier this month, a boat carrying more than 40 asylum seekers exploded at Ashmore Reef, killing five people and injuring dozens. The Federal ...
[60]
1,600 asylum claims could be reopened due to poorly drafted ...
Jul 20, 2018 · A court judgment has ruled the government's attempt to excise Ashmore Reef from Australia's migration zone 16 years ago was invalid.Missing: oversight | Show results with:oversight<|separator|>
[61]
Australia sailed asylum seekers to remote reef to prevent them ...
Jul 23, 2018 · By sending asylum seekers to Ashmore Reef, government wanted to ensure boat arrivals could be legally detained offshore.
[62]
MARITIME BORDER COMMAND - Australian Border Force
Sep 22, 2024 · PROTECTING THE AUSTRALIAN MARITIME DOMAIN · Heard Island and McDonald Islands · Cocos (keeling) Islands · Christmas Island · Ashmore and Cartier ...