Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Atmospheric refraction

Atmospheric refraction is the bending of light rays or other electromagnetic waves as they propagate through Earth's atmosphere, caused by gradual changes in the refractive index due to variations in air density influenced by temperature, pressure, and humidity.^[1]^[2] This phenomenon occurs because light travels slower in denser air, following Snell's law, which describes the relationship between the angles of incidence and refraction at the interface between media of different densities.^[2] The refractive index of air, typically around 1.00029 at standard temperature and pressure compared to 1 in vacuum, decreases with altitude as air becomes less dense, leading to a downward curvature of light paths toward the Earth's surface.^[1] In astronomical contexts, this bending elevates the apparent position of celestial bodies, such as making the Sun visible for several minutes after it has geometrically set below the horizon, with a maximum deviation of about 35 arcminutes under standard conditions.^[3]^[4] Temperature gradients are the primary driver, with cooler, denser air near the ground causing rays to bend concave to the surface; for instance, a standard lapse rate of -6.5 K/km in the troposphere contributes to this effect.^[3]^[5] Notable effects include the flattening of the setting Sun's disk, as lower rays bend more than upper ones, and the twinkling of stars due to turbulent air pockets causing rapid fluctuations in ray paths.^[2]^[3] Mirages arise from extreme gradients, such as inferior mirages over hot surfaces where light bends upward, creating illusory water puddles, or superior mirages in colder layers that invert distant objects like ships.^[1]^[5] Atmospheric refraction contributes to the visibility of sunlight during twilight by bending rays around the Earth's curvature, slightly extending the period of indirect illumination after sunset.^[2] In terrestrial observations, it displaces the apparent position of objects without significant magnification under uniform conditions, differing from astronomical cases where full atmospheric paths amplify distortion.^[5] Beyond optics, refraction impacts radio and radar waves similarly, bending beams to follow the Earth's curvature and enabling over-the-horizon propagation under normal conditions, though anomalous propagation can occur with unusual temperature inversions.^[6] The phenomenon's dependence on wavelength introduces dispersion, separating colors near the horizon—explaining the elusive green flash at sunset where shorter blue-green wavelengths lag behind reds.^[3] Accurate modeling, incorporating observer altitude, frequency, and local meteorology, is essential for applications in astronomy, navigation, and geodesy.^[3]

Principles of Atmospheric Refraction

Definition and Causes

Atmospheric refraction refers to the bending of electromagnetic waves, primarily visible light, as they propagate through Earth's atmosphere due to spatial variations in the refractive index.^[7] This phenomenon arises from gradients in atmospheric density, which alter the speed of light in different layers, causing rays to deviate from straight-line paths.^[7] The primary cause of atmospheric refraction is the variation of the refractive index with altitude, driven by the exponential decrease in air density from the surface upward.^[7] Air density, and thus the refractive index, is influenced by temperature, pressure, and humidity; for instance, the refractivity N = (n-1) \times 10^6 is approximated by N = 77.6 \frac{P}{T} + f(\text{humidity}), where P is pressure and T is temperature in kelvins.^[7] Temperature inversions, where warmer air overlies cooler air near the surface, can steepen these gradients locally, enhancing refraction, while increased humidity reduces the refractive index by up to about 3.6% at saturation compared to dry air.^[7]^[8] The effect was first systematically observed by ancient astronomers, including Ptolemy in the 2nd century AD, who noted the apparent elevation of the sun and other celestial bodies near the horizon, attributing it to refraction at the boundary between air and the upper ether.^[9] Ptolemy's model described the atmosphere as a sphere of uniform density, leading to a downward bend in light rays entering from rarer ether, which made the sun appear higher and slightly distorted in shape at low altitudes.^[9] In terms of ray paths, light rays entering the atmosphere on a slant follow curved trajectories concave toward the Earth's surface, as each infinitesimal layer of varying refractive index refracts the ray toward the normal in denser regions below.^[7] This gradual bending results in the observer perceiving distant objects, such as the horizon or celestial bodies, as shifted in position relative to their true geometric location.^[7]

Refractive Index and Ray Path

The refractive index of air, denoted n, quantifies the reduction in the speed of light through the medium and is defined as n = \frac{c}{v}, where c is the speed of light in vacuum and v is the phase velocity in air.^[10] In the Earth's atmosphere, n exceeds unity by a small amount due to molecular interactions, with a typical sea-level value of approximately 1.000276 under standard temperature (15°C) and pressure (1013.25 hPa) conditions for dry air in the visible spectrum (e.g., 589 nm); this value diminishes asymptotically to 1 at infinite altitude as atmospheric density approaches zero.^[11] ^[12] The vertical gradient of the refractive index, \frac{dn}{dh}, arises primarily from the exponential decrease in air density with height and is negative, reflecting the rarer medium at higher altitudes. In the International Standard Atmosphere, this gradient is derived from hydrostatic equilibrium, the ideal gas law, and a constant lapse rate of -6.5 K/km up to 11 km, yielding \frac{dn}{dh} \approx -3.9 \times 10^{-5} km^{-1} near the surface, where n - 1 \approx 2.8 \times 10^{-4} and the density scale height is about 8 km.^[13] ^[14] More precisely, for a barometric density profile \rho(h) = \rho_0 \exp\left(-\frac{h}{H}\right) with scale height H \approx 8.4 km, the refractivity follows n(h) - 1 = (n_0 - 1) \exp\left(-\frac{h}{H}\right), so \frac{dn}{dh} = -\frac{n_0 - 1}{H} \exp\left(-\frac{h}{H}\right) \approx -3.3 \times 10^{-5} km^{-1} at sea level.^[14] To model ray bending, the atmosphere is often approximated as horizontally stratified layers of constant thickness with stepwise varying n. Snell's law governs refraction at each interface: n_i \sin \theta_i = n_{i+1} \sin \theta_{i+1}, where \theta_i is the incidence angle in layer i; as layers become infinitesimally thin, this discrete application converges to the continuous eikonal equation describing curved ray paths.^[15] In the continuous limit for a gently varying n(h), the local radius of curvature R of the ray path follows from the ray equation, yielding R = -\frac{n}{\frac{dn}{dh}} for near-vertical gradients dominating over horizontal variations, indicating that rays curve concave toward the denser medium below.^[14] In astronomical contexts, where incoming rays from distant sources subtend small zenith angles (typically < 10°), the paraxial ray approximation simplifies calculations by assuming \sin \theta \approx \theta (in radians), reducing Snell's law to n_1 \theta_1 \approx n_2 \theta_2 and enabling linear ray tracing through the graded-index medium without higher-order angular terms.^[16] This approximation holds well for zenith distances up to 60°, where the error in refraction angle is less than 1% of the total effect, facilitating efficient integration of the ray path for precise positional corrections.^[17]

Astronomical Refraction

Effects on Celestial Observations

Atmospheric refraction causes celestial bodies, such as stars and the Sun, to appear higher in the sky than their true positions, with the effect increasing as the object's altitude decreases toward the horizon. This bending of light rays occurs due to the gradient in atmospheric density, which is greatest near the surface. At the zenith, where the air path is shortest, refraction is negligible (zero arcminutes), but it reaches a maximum of approximately 35 arcminutes at the horizon under standard conditions, effectively lifting objects by about half a degree.^[18]^[19] For example, a star at a true altitude of 10° might appear at approximately 10° 5', while one near the horizon could be elevated by nearly 35', significantly altering positional measurements in astronomical observations. This apparent elevation has practical implications for determining latitude, particularly using the North Star (Polaris), whose observed altitude roughly equals the observer's latitude in the Northern Hemisphere; however, uncorrected refraction introduces errors, requiring standard corrections of up to several arcminutes depending on the star's elevation.^[20]^[19] The Sun experiences additional distortion near sunrise and sunset, appearing elliptically flattened rather than circular due to differential refraction across its disk. Light rays from the lower limb of the Sun traverse denser, more refractive air layers than those from the upper limb, bending the lower part more sharply and compressing the vertical diameter by about 16-20% under typical conditions, resulting in an oblate shape with a horizontal-to-vertical extent ratio of around 1.2 at sea level.^[21]^[22] Historically, such effects contributed to errors in early celestial navigation, where inaccurate altitude measurements led to miscalculations of position; for instance, explorers relying on rudimentary instruments often overestimated latitudes by failing to fully account for refraction, as seen in voyages where uncorrected observations compounded dead reckoning inaccuracies.^[23]^[24]

Calculation Methods

The calculation of atmospheric refraction in astronomy involves determining the angular displacement of celestial objects due to the bending of light rays by the atmosphere. A fundamental approximation for small zenith distances z (the angular distance from the zenith) is given by R \approx (n - 1) \tan z, where R is the refraction angle and n is the refractive index at the observer's location.^[25] This plane-parallel model assumes a uniform atmosphere layered horizontally and is derived from Snell's law under the small-angle limit, providing reasonable accuracy near the zenith where most refraction occurs in the lower atmosphere.^[25] Historical approximations, such as Cassini's model from 1672, treat the atmosphere as a spherical shell of constant density with refraction concentrated at its upper boundary. The model yields R = \sin^{-1} \left( \frac{n r_\oplus \sin z}{r_\oplus + h} \right) - \sin^{-1} \left( \frac{r_\oplus \sin z}{r_\oplus + h} \right), where r_\oplus is Earth's radius and h is the atmospheric height scale; this is accurate to within a few arcseconds up to zenith distances of about 65°.^[25] A practical fitted form of Cassini's approximation, often used for computational efficiency, is R = 58.2'' \frac{\tan z}{15 + 0.06 \tan z} in arcseconds, which extends validity toward lower altitudes while accounting for the curvature of ray paths.^[26] For greater precision across wider zenith ranges, empirical models like Saemundsson's formula improve upon basic approximations by incorporating low-altitude effects:

R = \frac{1.02''}{\cos z} \tan \left( z + \frac{7.31^\circ}{z + 4.4^\circ} \right),

valid down to altitudes of 10° (or zenith distances up to 80°), assuming standard temperature (10°C) and pressure (1013 mbar). This formula, derived from numerical fits to ray-tracing simulations, reduces errors to under 0.1 arcminutes near the horizon compared to simpler tan z forms. More rigorous calculations employ integral methods to trace the exact ray path through a stratified atmosphere using the ray equation in spherical coordinates derived from Fermat's principle or Bouguer's invariant (n r sin i = constant, where i is the incidence angle). Numerical integration of this along the ray from space to the observer, often implemented via Runge-Kutta solvers, yields the total refraction R under a given refractive index profile n(h).^[27] Such methods are essential for non-standard conditions and provide benchmarks for empirical formulas, with errors below 0.01 arcseconds in high-fidelity models.^[25] Refraction tables offer precomputed values for standard conditions, facilitating rapid corrections in observations. Bessel's tables, published in 1830 as part of Tabulae Regiomontanae, were derived from Bradley's Greenwich observations and remain influential for their empirical adjustments to barometric pressure and temperature, achieving sub-arcsecond accuracy for zenith distances up to 85°.^[28] Modern standards, such as the Pulkovo Observatory tables (5th edition, 1985), endorsed by the International Astronomical Union (IAU), extend these with updated refractive index models based on polytropic atmospheres and spectroscopic data, providing tabulated refractions to 0.001 arcseconds for zenith distances from 0° to 90° under sea-level conditions.^[29] These tables are widely adopted in astrometric reductions and serve as the IAU reference for precise positional astronomy.^[30]

Variability Due to Atmospheric Conditions

Atmospheric turbulence introduces random variations in the refractive index of air, primarily due to temperature and density fluctuations in small-scale eddies, leading to scintillation—the twinkling of stars observed as rapid intensity changes in starlight.^[31] These eddies, formed by thermal convection and wind shear, act like numerous tiny lenses that bend and focus incoming light rays unpredictably, causing the apparent position of a star to shift by a few arcseconds multiple times per second.^[31] In astronomical observations, this effect blurs point sources, reducing the contrast and visibility of faint celestial objects.^[32] Turbulence also enlarges the seeing disk, the apparent size of a star's image in a telescope, by distorting the wavefront of incoming light through refractive index inhomogeneities along the propagation path.^[33] These fluctuations scatter and phase-shift the light, spreading the diffraction-limited Airy disk into a broader, speckled pattern with a typical full width at half maximum of around 1 arcsecond under average conditions, though it can vary significantly.^[32] The seeing disk size depends on the integrated strength of turbulence, quantified by the refractive index structure coefficient C_n^2, which measures local variations in air density.^[32] Diurnal variations in atmospheric conditions further modulate refraction, with turbulence peaking during the day due to solar heating that enhances convective eddies near the surface, while nights often exhibit more stable layers aloft.^[34] Seasonally, refraction is greater in winter because colder, denser air near the ground increases the refractive index gradient, amplifying bending of light rays from celestial objects.^[35] In summer, warmer temperatures reduce this density contrast, leading to less pronounced effects, though overall optical turbulence can intensify in unstable maritime environments due to buoyancy-driven mixing.^[35] Site-specific factors such as altitude, humidity, and temperature lapse rates profoundly influence the predictability of refraction variability. Higher-altitude observatories, like those on Mauna Kea, experience reduced turbulence by being above low-level inversion layers where ground heating creates strong eddies, resulting in seeing as low as 0.11 arcseconds.^[36] A stable temperature lapse rate—typically 6–10 °C/km—minimizes refractive index gradients, improving image stability, whereas superadiabatic rates near the ground exacerbate fluctuations.^[36] High humidity can stabilize the atmosphere by suppressing convection, potentially enhancing seeing despite reduced transparency from water vapor.^[36] Modern telescopes employ adaptive optics systems to compensate for real-time refraction variability caused by turbulence. These systems use a wavefront sensor to detect distortions in light from a guide star or artificial laser beacon, then deform a mirror in microseconds to counteract phase aberrations from refractive index changes.^[37] By continuously adjusting to evolving atmospheric conditions, adaptive optics can achieve near-diffraction-limited performance, with Strehl ratios up to 80% in the near-infrared on 8–10 meter apertures, significantly sharpening images degraded by seeing.^[37]

Terrestrial Refraction

Optical Phenomena and Illusions

Atmospheric refraction in the lower atmosphere produces striking optical illusions known as mirages, primarily driven by temperature gradients that alter the refractive index of air and bend light rays along curved paths. These phenomena occur when variations in air density, caused by uneven heating or cooling, create gradients that refract light differently at various altitudes.^[38]^[1] The inferior mirage is one of the most common examples, often observed as an apparent pool of water on hot roads or desert surfaces. It arises from a superadiabatic temperature lapse rate near the ground, where the air just above the heated surface becomes significantly warmer and less dense than the air above it, causing light rays from the sky or distant objects to bend upward away from the hot layer.^[39]^[1] This upward refraction inverts the image, creating a shimmering, displaced reflection below the actual object, which disappears when approached due to the limited extent of the bending zone.^[40] In contrast, the superior mirage elevates distant objects above their true positions, making them appear to hover over the horizon, such as ships seemingly floating in the air over cold water. This effect results from a temperature inversion, where a layer of warm air overlies cooler air near the surface, increasing air density with height and bending light rays downward toward the denser layer.^[39]^[1] The refraction creates an inverted image stacked above the erect one, often resembling a distorted reflection, and can extend visibility to objects beyond the normal horizon.^[41] A more complex variant is the Fata Morgana, which produces multiple, elongated, and vertically stretched images that can resemble towering castles or cities, historically inspiring legends in regions like the Strait of Messina. It forms under strong, layered temperature inversions that act like a multifaceted lens or mirror, trapping and repeatedly refracting light rays within atmospheric ducts to generate oscillating erect and inverted images.^[42]^[39] These conditions are prevalent in polar areas, such as the Arctic and Antarctic, where cold surfaces beneath warmer air layers enhance the effect, as documented in observations from Point Barrow, Alaska, and McMurdo Station.^[42]^[43] Looming and stooping represent subtler vertical displacements caused by gentler refraction gradients, altering the apparent height of terrestrial features without full inversion. Looming occurs when a weak temperature inversion lifts light rays, making distant objects like islands or ships appear elevated and closer, as seen in views of the Farallon Islands from San Francisco.^[44]^[41] Conversely, stooping compresses images vertically, lowering objects below their true positions due to a lapse rate transitioning from subadiabatic near the ground to more stable conditions aloft, exemplified by distorted lighthouses observed over water.^[44] Both effects stem from the curvature of light paths in response to density gradients, typically spanning a few degrees in angular displacement.^[41] In surveying, particularly in precise leveling and trigonometric heighting, atmospheric refraction causes light rays to bend downward due to the density gradient in the lower atmosphere, leading to systematic errors in measured vertical angles and distances. To mitigate this, surveyors apply corrections using the refraction coefficient k, which quantifies the curvature of the light path relative to the Earth's surface. The observed vertical angle \alpha_{\text{obs}} relates to the true angle \alpha_{\text{true}} by \alpha_{\text{obs}} = \alpha_{\text{true}} + \frac{d}{2R}(1 - k) (in radians, small angle approximation), where the term \frac{d}{2R} accounts for Earth's curvature and k \frac{d}{2R} for refraction, d is the sight distance, and R is the Earth's radius.^[45] Typical values of k range from 0.07 to 0.14 under standard conditions, with higher values indicating stronger refraction; these are determined empirically from reciprocal vertical angle measurements or meteorological data.^[46] In practice, this correction reduces height differences by up to several millimeters per kilometer in long sights, ensuring sub-centimeter accuracy in geodetic networks.^[46] In marine navigation, atmospheric refraction affects sextant observations by altering the apparent position of the horizon, creating an illusory dip that must be corrected to determine accurate latitudes. The apparent dip of the horizon increases with the observer's height of eye due to the combined effects of Earth's curvature and refraction, which bends rays concave to the surface and makes the horizon appear lower than it truly is. Correction tables in the Nautical Almanac account for this by subtracting a dip value—typically 0.97 arcminutes times the square root of eye height in feet—from the observed altitude, with refraction comprising about 14% of the total dip under standard conditions.^[47] These tables, derived from empirical models, prevent positional errors of up to 0.5 nautical miles for eye heights around 10 meters.^[48] Meteorological applications leverage refraction profiles derived from radiosonde data to diagnose atmospheric stability, particularly temperature inversions that enhance or suppress ray bending. Radiosondes measure temperature, pressure, and humidity vertically, enabling computation of refractivity N = (n-1) \times 10^6, where n is the refractive index; strong inversions (temperature increasing with height) produce super-refractive gradients (dn/dh > 0) that trap signals and indicate stable layers.^[49] By comparing these profiles to standard lapse rates, forecasters infer inversion strength and height, aiding predictions of fog or pollution trapping; for instance, surface-based inversions below 500 meters often correlate with refractivity anomalies exceeding 40 N-units.^[50] Historical geodetic surveys in the 19th century routinely adjusted for refraction in triangulation to achieve accurate continental-scale mapping. The U.S. Coast and Geodetic Survey's transcontinental triangulation (1850s–1890s) incorporated refraction corrections in vertical angle reductions, using coefficients derived from simultaneous observations to offset bending effects over baselines up to 100 km, reducing height errors from meters to centimeters.^[51] Similarly, European efforts like the Struve Geodetic Arc (1816–1855) across Northern Europe applied empirical adjustments for atmospheric refraction in angle measurements, ensuring the arc's 2,600 km length was mapped with sub-arcsecond precision despite variable weather.^[52] These corrections were pivotal in establishing foundational geodetic datums that underpin modern global positioning systems.

Advanced Topics

Modeling and Simulations

Layered atmosphere models approximate the continuous variation of refractive index in the Earth's atmosphere by dividing it into discrete horizontal layers, each with a constant refractive index derived from vertical profiles of temperature, pressure, and humidity. These models apply Snell's law iteratively at each layer boundary to compute the bending of light rays, enabling the simulation of ray paths through the atmosphere for applications such as optical surveying and celestial navigation. For instance, in a simple flat-Earth approximation with n layers, the incident and refracted angles at interfaces satisfy n_i \sin i_i = n_{i+1} \sin r_{i+1}, where n_i is the refractive index of layer i, allowing cumulative refraction to be calculated from the top of the atmosphere to the observer.^[53]^[54] More advanced layered models account for Earth's sphericity by treating layers as concentric shells, where ray tracing proceeds radially outward or inward while conserving the product of refractive index and radial distance times the sine of the incidence angle, akin to the spherical form of Snell's law. This approach is computationally efficient for vertical profiles obtained from radiosondes or numerical models, providing accurate simulations of refraction over altitudes from sea level to the stratosphere. Such models have been implemented in software libraries like Orekit for space mission analysis, where multiple layers (typically 10–50) are used to model tropospheric and stratospheric effects.^[55]^[54] Ray-tracing software simulates the curved propagation of light or electromagnetic rays through graded-index atmospheres by numerically integrating the ray equation, often incorporating Bouguer's law (n r \sin \theta = \constant, where n is the refractive index, r is the radial distance, and \theta is the angle to the radial direction) to handle spherical symmetry. In MATLAB, built-in functions like those in the Radar Toolbox enable ray tracing with atmospheric refraction models, such as exponential profiles for the refractive index gradient, to predict path deviations in radar or optical systems; for example, simulations can incorporate vertical gradients from standard atmospheres to visualize ray curvature over distances up to hundreds of kilometers.^[56] Python implementations, such as the RefractionShift module, provide tools for computing lateral shifts due to refraction via numerical integration along ray paths, supporting both dry and moist atmosphere profiles for high-precision simulations.^[57] These tools, including legacy programs like those evaluated in marine refraction studies, facilitate parametric analysis of ray bending under varying environmental conditions.^[58] Modern atmospheric models integrate ray-tracing techniques with Numerical Weather Prediction (NWP) systems to forecast refraction in real time, using gridded outputs of temperature, pressure, and water vapor to construct dynamic refractive index profiles. For example, the Weather Research and Forecasting (WRF) model has been adapted to simulate optical turbulence and refraction effects continuously from daytime to nighttime, enabling predictions of image displacement over horizons up to 20 km, with good agreement to observations. Similarly, NWP ensembles from systems like COAMPS initialize refractivity inversions, improving forecast accuracy for ducting and mirage phenomena by constraining search spaces in ray-tracing algorithms. This integration supports operational applications in astronomy and remote sensing, where forecasted refraction corrections enhance data quality.^[59]^[60]^[61] Validation of these models relies on comparisons with observational data, particularly from GPS radio occultation (RO) measurements since the early 2000s, which provide high-resolution vertical profiles of refractivity by inverting signal bending angles. For instance, GPS/MET data from 1995–1997, reprocessed in later studies, showed model biases in refractivity below 10 km altitude typically under 1%, with ray-tracing simulations using layered profiles showing good agreement to observed bending angles, typically within 1% relative error for most occultations. Post-2000 missions like COSMIC/FORMOSAT-3 have enabled global validation, confirming improved accuracy in NWP-integrated models for refraction forecasts when assimilated with RO data. More recent missions, such as COSMIC-2 launched in 2019, have further enhanced global validation, with assimilated data reducing errors in NWP models for refraction effects. These comparisons highlight the models' fidelity across scales, from local mirages to astronomical corrections, while identifying needs for improved handling of turbulence.^[62]^[63]^[64]^[65]

Refraction in Non-Visible Wavelengths

Atmospheric refraction extends beyond visible light to non-optical electromagnetic wavelengths, where principles analogous to those in optical propagation apply but are modulated by wavelength-specific interactions with atmospheric layers. In radio frequencies, particularly VHF (30-300 MHz) and UHF (300 MHz-3 GHz), signals bend due to gradients in the ionosphere and troposphere, with the refractive index decreasing with altitude leading to downward curvature that can extend communication ranges beyond line-of-sight. Super-refraction occurs in tropospheric ducts formed by temperature inversions or humidity gradients, trapping waves and enabling propagation over hundreds of kilometers, as observed in enhanced VHF/UHF signals up to 1500 km during stable atmospheric conditions.^[66]^[67]^[68] Ionospheric refraction primarily affects lower-frequency radio signals through interactions with free electrons, causing phase delays proportional to the total electron content (TEC), which represents the integrated electron density along the signal path. For GPS signals at L-band frequencies (around 1.5 GHz), this refraction induces group delays that translate to positioning errors of 10-20 meters or more during high solar activity or geomagnetic storms, when TEC can exceed 100 TEC units (1 TECU = 10^16 electrons/m²). These effects vary diurnally and with latitude, being most pronounced at low elevations and equatorial regions due to longer path lengths through the ionosphere.^[69]^[70]^[71] In microwave bands (300 MHz-300 GHz) and infrared (IR, 0.7-1000 μm), refraction similarly bends ray paths due to tropospheric density gradients, though absorption by water vapor and oxygen complicates propagation more than in radio bands. Microwave signals used in weather radar experience beam curvature from refraction, altering echo ranges by up to several kilometers at low elevations, necessitating corrections for accurate precipitation mapping. IR wavelengths face stronger wavelength-dependent absorption in atmospheric windows (e.g., 8-12 μm), but refraction still shifts apparent positions in remote sensing, with effects diminishing at shorter paths compared to microwaves due to reduced bending at higher frequencies.^[13]^[72]^[73] Since the 1990s, corrections for non-visible refraction have become essential in satellite communications and very long baseline interferometry (VLBI), where tropospheric and ionospheric delays can introduce centimeter-level errors in signal timing and positioning. In satellite links, models accounting for wet and dry tropospheric delays mitigate range errors up to 20-30 meters at low elevations, improving data rates and reliability for geostationary systems. VLBI observations, using radio frequencies from 1-100 GHz, apply ray-tracing corrections for atmospheric bending to achieve sub-millisecond synchronization across global arrays, enabling precise astrometry and geodetic measurements with accuracies better than 1 cm.^[74]^[75]^[76]^[77]

References

[1]
Mirages and other atomospheric optic phenomena - HyperPhysics
Atmospheric Refraction The phenomenon of refraction is responsible for our ability to focus images with a lens or our eye. The refraction, or bending of light, ...Missing: definition | Show results with:definition
[2]
Atmospheric Optics
Examples of refraction. Refraction causes a setting sun to look flat; Twinkling, or scintillation, if stars; Twilight caused by refraction and scattering.
[3]
[PDF] Astronomical Refraction
The real part of the atmospheric index of refraction is a function of pressure, temperature, and frequency. Many interesting low-altitude refractive effects ...
[4]
Solar Calculator Glossary - Global Monitoring Laboratory
A atmospheric refraction - as light from the sun (or another celestial body) travels from the vacuum of space into Earth's atmosphere, the path of the light is ...Missing: explanation | Show results with:explanation
[5]
Terrestrial and astronomical refractions
So one feature that makes terrestrial refraction behave differently from astronomical refraction is just the amount of bending atmosphere in the line of sight.Missing: definition | Show results with:definition
[6]
JetStream Max: Radar Beams - NOAA
Aug 10, 2023 · Refraction. Refraction under normal conditions is a little less than the curvature of Earth. In addition to beam spreading, the beam also does ...Missing: explanation | Show results with:explanation
[7]
[PDF] Atmospheric Propagation Effects Relevant to Optical Communications
Random or stochastic refraction is due to the motion of inhomogeneities in the air. It is this type of refraction that causes the light rays to wander in time ...
[8]
[PDF] Atmospheric refraction: a history - University of Manitoba
Ptolemy's experience with refraction in transparent media led him to the conclusion that refraction was occurring in the air that surrounds us.
[9]
Refractive index | Definition & Equation | Britannica
Oct 9, 2025 · Refractive index is also equal to the velocity of light c of a given wavelength in empty space divided by its velocity v in a substance, or n = ...
[10]
Refractive index of Air - Mathar-7.5 - RefractiveIndex.INFO
Air has a refractive index very close to 1 (approximately 1.0003 at sea level under standard conditions), which varies slightly with temperature, humidity, and ...
[11]
Long‐Term Evolution of The Surface Refractivity for Arctic Regions
Jul 2, 2019 · In an ITU-R Standard Atmosphere, the refractive index of air n(h) ... The index n has a mean value around 1.0003, and variations of n at ...
[12]
Radar Beam Tracing Methods Based on Atmospheric Refractive ...
With RE ≈ 6371 km, this is dN/dh = −157 km−1. If the derivative of N is smaller than that, then the curvature of the ray becomes larger than that of the earth, ...
[13]
Deriving Equations for Atmospheric Refraction
### Summary of Atmospheric Refraction Values and Formulas
[14]
[PDF] atmospheric refraction formulae from MOP6 - Purdue Engineering
If we assume that the atmosphere is composed of discrete layers and apply Snell's law for refraction between any two successive layers we obtain: (n; + dn) ...
[15]
[PDF] The paraxial approximation in optical system analysis - Doug A. Kerr
Apr 5, 2024 · In this context, refraction refers to the change in the direction of a ray of light when it crosses the boundary between two different.
[16]
[PDF] Chapter 10 Image Formation in the Ray Model
Snell's Law in the Paraxial Approximation. Recall Snell's law that relates the ray angles before and after refraction: n1 sin [θ1] = n2 sin [θ2]. In the ...
[17]
Atmospheric Extinction and Refraction - Asterism.org
... atmospheric refraction increases as we near the horizon. At altitudes of 20, 10 and 00 the respective angles of refraction, r,are 18.4', 24.75', and 35.35'.
[18]
Atmospheric Refraction - British Astronomical Association
Mar 2, 2019 · This change in speed causes the path of the light to be bent or refracted. The amount of bending is governed by the refractive indices of both ...
[19]
Latitude by Polaris - Celestial Navigation - Beyond the Horizon
Dec 8, 2018 · This section describes how to determine Latitude from the Polaris Altitude and the procedure to apply and to calculate the required adjustments.
[20]
Flattening of the setting Sun
Refraction below eye level produces flattening Now let the ray OPM be bent by refraction. If we keep O and M fixed, bending the ray moves P up, so the dip of ...Missing: sunrise | Show results with:sunrise<|separator|>
[21]
(PDF) Flatness of the setting Sun - ResearchGate
Aug 6, 2025 · Atmospheric refraction is responsible for the bending of light-rays in the atmosphere. It is a result of the continuous decrease in the ...
[22]
Refraction in Celestial Navigation–still an issue, after all these years
Feb 7, 2017 · Refraction of light as it enters the atmosphere is still one of the largest uncertainties in celestial navigation.Missing: historical Columbus
[23]
[PDF] An analysis of the development of celestial navigation
Thus, in 1492, Columbus had available for navigation purposes; a) the ... History of Air Navigation. London: George Allen and. Unwin, Ltd. ,. 1946 ...<|control11|><|separator|>
[24]
https://ufdcimages.uflib.ufl.edu/AA/00/03/71/98/00001/analysisofdevelo00mors.pdf
[25]
Fundamental Astronomy
Observations give an average value for this expression of the refraction angle. R = 58.2/1 tan ( . (2.31). Light coming from the zenith is not refracted at ...
[26]
[PDF] Ray Tracing Methods for Calculation of Atmospheric Refraction - DTIC
Jul 18, 2025 · ABSTRACT. Equations for tracing rays through an atmospheric medium of continuously variable refractive index are obtained in spherical ...Missing: credible source
[27]
Fundamental catalogues, past, present and future - NASA ADS
Of immediate importance, however, were considered Bessel's refraction tables constructed from Bradley's observations for which Bessel was awarded the Lalande ...
[28]
https://adsabs.harvard.edu/full/1985CeMec..36..207F
[29]
https://ui.adsabs.harvard.edu/abs/1985rtpo.book.....A/abstract
[30]
What Makes Stars Twinkle? | Scientific American
May 16, 2025 · The quirks of light moving through gas are the cause of stellar twinkling, which can be a bane—and sometimes a boon—for astronomers.
[31]
[PDF] Optics of the Atmosphere and Seeing - Astrophysical Sciences
Mar 23, 2011 · ▻ We define the astronomical refraction r as the angular ... ii) Fluctuations in the refractive index n depens linearly on temperature.
[32]
Effect of atmospheric turbulence on the telescope image (seeing error)
The structure function of the refractive index fluctuations is the mean square of the difference in refractive index at two separated points in space.Missing: disk | Show results with:disk
[33]
Diurnal And Seasonal Variations In The Atmospheric Structure ...
The atmospheric modulation transfer function (IMF) depends upon an integral of the index of refraction variations (Cn2) along the optical path.
[34]
Seasonal Changes in Atmospheric Optical Turbulence in a Near ...
Dec 30, 2022 · Light propagation through the atmosphere is affected by fluctuations in the refractive index along the path of propagation, called optical turbulence.
[35]
[PDF] The Atmosphere and Observing – A Guide to Astronomical Seeing
The world's finest locations for a stable atmosphere are mountain top observatories, located above frequently occurring temperature inversion layers, where the ...Missing: selection humidity lapse rate
[36]
None
### Summary of How Adaptive Optics Compensates for Atmospheric Turbulence and Refraction Variability
[37]
An Introduction to Mirages - A Green Flash Page
They are real phenomena of atmospheric optics, caused by strong ray-bending in layers with steep thermal gradients . Craig Bohren, a well-known expert on ...
[38]
Types of Mirages - A Green Flash Page
Inferior mirage Caused by the transition from a thin layer of hot air at the surface to more adiabatic lapse rates a few mm or cm higher; a smooth surface ( ...
[39]
https://aty.sdsu.edu/mirages/mirtypes.html
[40]
Atmospheric Refraction Phenomena - A Green Flash Page
Mirages and green flashes, the main topics of this website, are only some of the phenomena caused by refraction in the Earth's atmosphere.
[41]
Fata Morgana
### Summary of Fata Morgana from https://aty.sdsu.edu/mirages/FM/FM.html
[42]
The Highest Mirage in North America | Geophysical Institute
Mar 2, 1995 · A fata morgana occurs when many alternating layers of cold and warm air force light rays to take a complicated path.
[43]
Looming, Towering, Stooping, and Sinking
Looming and sinking are the simplest of all the refraction phenomena. They're simply abnormally large and small refraction, respectively.
[44]
Precise levelling in crossing river over 5 km using total station and ...
Apr 5, 2021 · where K represents the coefficient of atmospheric refraction and R denotes the mean radius of the earth in km. Substitute Eq. (7) into Eq. (6), ...
[45]
Monitoring of the refraction coefficient in the lower atmosphere using ...
Nov 2, 2010 · Atmospheric refraction is caused by variations in the refractive index along the path of light, which depend on the physical state of the ...
[46]
[PDF] CHAPTER 18 SIGHT PLANNING - The Nautical Almanac
Refraction forms part of the corrections for both dip and apparent altitude. Refraction is larger and the correction becomes more uncer- tain for bodies ...
[47]
[PDF] CHAPTER 4 CALCULATIONS AND CONVERSIONS
The dip correction is computed in the Nautical Alma- nac using the formula: where dip is in minutes of arc and h is height of eye in feet. This correction ...
[48]
[PDF] Comparing radiosonde and COSMIC atmospheric profile data to ...
Dec 3, 2010 · In this study, we examine atmospheric temperature (T), relative humidity (RH), and refractivity (N) profiles, by comparing radiosonde profiles ...
[49]
Vertical Profiling of Radio Refractivity and Associated Parameters ...
Jun 10, 2019 · The radio refractivity and its vertical gradient have been found to be strongly affected in the cases of strong temperature inversions. The ...<|separator|>
[50]
Terrestrial refraction and the trigonometrical measurement of heights
... triangulation used in the observation-equations (38). The investigations of the U.S. Coast and Geodetic Survey show (" Trans-continental Triangulation," pp.
[51]
[PDF] geodetic surveying and the adjustment of observations
principles of triangulation work as the best introduction to geodetic work in general. Nothing new of any special importance is available in the general ...
[52]
Refraction
### Layered Model for Atmospheric Refraction Using Snell's Law
[53]
[PDF] Atmospheric Refraction and Its Distortion of Aerial Photographs
Snell's Law: where n=index of refraction of the first layer of atmosphere, n' =index of refraction of the second layer of atmosphere, i = angle between the ...
[54]
MultiLayerModel.java - org.orekit.rugged.refraction
* Atmospheric refraction model based on multiple layers ... // get new los by applying Snell's law at atmosphere layers interfaces ... As we expect atmosphere ...
[55]
Simulating Radar Systems with Atmospheric Refraction - MathWorks
This example simulates radar refraction using atmospheric models, built-in functions, and an exponential approximation, showing how it impacts target parameter ...Missing: tracing software Python Bouguer's law
[56]
onera/RefractionShift: A python module for computing the ... - GitHub
This module allows you to calculate the lateral shift with four different methods. First, using numerical integration along the optical path of the light ray.Missing: Bouguer | Show results with:Bouguer
[57]
[PDF] Models of Refraction in the Marine Atmosphere Surface Layer - DTIC
Sep 30, 1993 · (Bouguer's law is the analog for rays of conservation of particle angular momentum in a spherically symmetric potential.) In principle, the ...
[58]
Continuous daytime and nighttime forecast of atmospheric optical ...
Sep 25, 2023 · This work presents a numerical approach based on the Weather Research and Forecasting software that enables continuous forecast of the ...2.1. 1 Nwp Simulations · 2.2 Weather Research And... · 4. Validation Of The...
[59]
Image shift due to atmospheric refraction: prediction by numerical ...
Mar 10, 2020 · The goal of this paper is to develop and evaluate two different methods, numerical weather prediction (NWP) and machine learning (ML), for predicting image ...Missing: integration | Show results with:integration
[60]
Fusing Numerical Weather Prediction Ensembles with Refractivity ...
This study investigates the use of numerical weather prediction (NWP) ensembles to aid refractivity inversion problems during surface ducting conditions.
[61]
Analysis and validation of GPS/MET radio occultation data - ADS
This paper describes the results of the statistical comparison of the inversions of GPS/MET radio occultation data with analysis data of the European Centre ...
[62]
Airborne GPS radio occultation refractivity profiles observed in ...
Feb 3, 2015 · Radio occultation (RO) is a remote sensing technique for measuring atmospheric properties using Global Navigation Satellite System (GNSS) ...
[63]
[PDF] An introduction to GPS radio occultation and its use in ... - ECMWF
The radio occultation technique. RO is a measurement technique for obtaining information on the vertical gradient of atmospheric refractive index, which is ...<|separator|>
[64]
Atmospheric impact on VHF Radio Propagation - VU2NSB.com
Sep 20, 2020 · Normal and Super refraction will result in downward bending of the propagating wave thus extending the communication range.
[65]
Tropospheric Enhanced Conditions: Lifts, Ducting, Tropo
Understand the way in which tropospheric radio propagation is enhanced giving VHF & UHF radio communications over distances of up to 1500km and more in lifts, ...
[66]
[PDF] ANOMALOUS MICROWAVE PROPAGATION THROUGH ...
A multidisciplinary approach that examines the effects of anomalous tropospheric refraction on electromagnetic microwaves is presented.
[67]
Ionospheric Delay - Navipedia - GSSC
Jan 17, 2016 · The ionospheric refraction depends on the geographical location of the receiver, the hour of day and the solar activity.
[68]
The Ionospheric Effect | GEOG 862: GPS and GNSS for Geospatial ...
The higher the electron density, the larger the delay of the signal, but the delay is by no means constant. The ionospheric delay changes slowly through a daily ...
[69]
Analysis of geomagnetic storm shows need for mitigation during ...
Jul 8, 2025 · In the soutwestern states, the GPS position errors were elevated 10 to 20 meters because of the enhanced plasma density. Vertical protection ...
[70]
[PDF] Earth Curvature and Atmospheric Refraction Effects on Radar Signal ...
3.2 Effective Earth's Radius Models. The radius of curvature for the refraction of a ray is given by. 11 ψ ρ cos. │. ⎠. ⎞. │. ⎝. ⎛. -. ≈ dh dn n. ,. (27) where.
[71]
Effect of atmospheric refraction on radiative transfer in visible and ...
Feb 15, 2016 · The results show that atmospheric refraction has a significant influence on both the radiance and polarization states of diffuse light.Missing: credible | Show results with:credible
[72]
[PDF] Effects of tropospheric refraction on radiowave propagation - ITU
In sharing studies it is necessary to estimate the apparent elevation angle of a space station taking account of atmospheric refraction. An appropriate ...
[73]
[PDF] TROPOSPHERIC REFRACTION EFFECTS ON SATELLITE RANGE ...
It was stated earlier, but without supporting evidence, that the tropospheric effect on satellite data for precise work is large enough to require correction.
[74]
[PDF] Atmospheric refraction and turbulence in VLBI data analysis - bonndoc
The main achievements of this thesis are the development of an atmospheric turbulence model to improve the stochastic model of VLBI observations and the ...Missing: communications | Show results with:communications
[75]
Comparison of Measurements of Atmospheric Wet Delay by ...
The best agreement of zenith wet delay (ZWD) among the collocated WVR, radiosondes, VLBI, and GPS was for minimum elevations of the GPS measurements below 10°.D. Vlbi · 4. Error Sources · E. Vlbi