Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

BAMN

The Coalition to Defend Affirmative Action, Integration and Immigrant Rights and Fight for Equality By Any Means Necessary (BAMN) is a militant, Trotskyist-influenced activist organization founded in 1995 in Berkeley, California, to oppose the University of California Regents' decision to ban affirmative action and advocate for racial quotas, integration, and immigrant rights through direct action and legal challenges.^[1]^[2] BAMN emerged from efforts by attorney Shanta Driver and associates linked to the Revolutionary Internationalist League, a small Trotskyist group, positioning itself as a vanguard for a "new civil rights movement" that prioritizes revolutionary tactics over incremental reform.^[2]^[3] BAMN's ideology emphasizes "fighting for equality by any means necessary," drawing from Malcolm X's phrase but adapted to Trotskyist principles of permanent revolution, opposing what it terms fascist threats like immigration restrictions and supporting causes such as Palestinian activism and anti-Trump mobilization.^[4]^[5] The group has pursued legal interventions, including a Supreme Court case challenging Michigan's Proposition 2 ban on affirmative action preferences, though its broader strategy relies on mass mobilizations and campus disruptions to enforce its vision of enforced integration and opposition to perceived racism.^[6]^[3] While BAMN claims to build democratic, youth-led structures for civil rights, its tactics have drawn criticism for authoritarian internal dynamics and endorsement of confrontational protests that prioritize ideological purity over broad coalitions, often alienating potential allies in affirmative action debates.^[2]^[7] The organization's small size belies its outsized role in catalyzing radical responses to policy shifts, yet empirical assessments of its impact reveal limited success in reversing affirmative action rollbacks, attributable to causal factors like judicial precedents favoring color-blind approaches over quota systems.^[1]^[6]

Origins and Early History

Founding in 1995

By Any Means Necessary (BAMN) was established in Berkeley, California, in 1995 by civil rights attorney Shanta Driver and activist Luke Massie as a militant response to the University of California Regents' decision on July 20, 1995, to phase out affirmative action in admissions and hiring across the UC system.^[1]^[8] This vote, which affected policies at institutions like UC Berkeley, prompted Driver—who was affiliated with the Trotskyist Revolutionary Workers League—to organize student and youth activists into a coalition emphasizing direct confrontation and legal challenges to preserve race-based preferences.^[8]^[2] The founding aligned with broader opposition to California's Proposition 209, a 1996 ballot measure that sought to constitutionally prohibit such programs statewide, framing BAMN's inception as a defense against what its founders viewed as institutional rollback of civil rights gains.^[1]^[9] Initially structured as the Coalition to Defend Affirmative Action By Any Means Necessary, the group prioritized mobilizing protests on university campuses, including physical disruptions of Regents meetings, while offering legal support for participants facing trespassing or disorderly conduct charges.^[8] Driver's role was central, drawing on her experience in radical labor and anti-discrimination litigation to blend street-level activism with courtroom strategies, a tactic rooted in the group's adoption of Malcolm X's "by any means necessary" slogan to justify aggressive tactics.^[2]^[9] BAMN quickly positioned itself as a national formation, recruiting from diverse student populations at UC Berkeley and beyond, with an emphasis on interracial unity under proletarian leadership principles influenced by Driver's Trotskyist background.^[8] The organization's early framework rejected reformist approaches, advocating instead for mass action capable of overriding institutional barriers, as evidenced by its charter commitment to building a "new civil rights movement" through integrated, democratic structures that prioritized youth and workers over established civil rights bureaucracies.^[9] This founding ethos, while effective in galvanizing small-scale defenses of affirmative action, drew from sectarian leftist traditions, with Driver's RWL ties providing ideological continuity from earlier Trotskyist efforts to intervene in social justice struggles.^[8] By late 1995, BAMN had begun coordinating actions against the impending Proposition 209 campaign, setting the stage for its expansion into litigation and protests that defined its first decade.^[1]^[2]

Initial Ties to Trotskyist Groups

BAMN originated in 1995 in Berkeley, California, as the Coalition to Defend Affirmative Action By Any Means Necessary, formed in opposition to Proposition 209, a state ballot measure that banned race-based affirmative action in public institutions.^[1] The group's early leadership included activists like Luke Massie and attorney Shanta Driver, who served as national spokeswoman.^[1] From its inception, BAMN maintained close connections to the Revolutionary Workers League (RWL), a small Trotskyist organization headquartered in Detroit that advocated for the construction of a revolutionary vanguard party based on Leon Trotsky's theory of permanent revolution and opposition to bureaucratic Stalinism within the workers' movement.^[1] Luke Massie, an RWL member and BAMN participant, explicitly acknowledged this link in a 2001 interview, stating, "BAMN was partially initiated by the RWL" and affirming, "The Revolutionary Workers League is a Trotskyist organization of which I’m a member […] We [RWL] are proud to be part of a whole lot of struggles and to have played a role in the founding of BAMN."^[10] These ties positioned BAMN as an extraparliamentary front for RWL's broader goal of mobilizing mass actions to advance socialist objectives under the guise of civil rights defense.^[1] ^[11] Critics, including former associates, have described BAMN as a sectarian front group controlled by RWL cadre, who used it to recruit and radicalize participants toward Trotskyist ends rather than purely reformist affirmative action advocacy.^[12] The RWL's influence manifested in BAMN's emphasis on "militant" tactics and rejection of liberal coalitions, aligning with Trotskyist critiques of reformism as insufficient for systemic change.^[1] Over time, these origins contributed to perceptions of BAMN as ideologically driven by entryism—Trotskyist strategy of infiltrating broader movements to steer them toward revolution—rather than independent grassroots activism.^[13]

Ideology and Organizational Principles

Core Political Beliefs

BAMN holds that structural racism and sexism necessitate affirmative action policies, including race- and gender-based preferences in education and employment, as the primary means to realize America's founding principle that "all men are created equal." The organization argues these measures are indispensable for integration and equality, asserting that race-neutral alternatives perpetuate segregation and undermine democratic ideals.^[14]^[2]^[1] Central to BAMN's ideology is the construction of a mass, integrated civil rights movement drawing from abolitionist and historical struggles, aimed at uprooting oppression through independent action outside the Democratic and Republican parties. It views U.S. democracy as illusory without affirmative action to address poverty, racism, and sexism, committing to mass organizing and "by any means necessary" methods to enforce egalitarian outcomes.^[14]^[1] With roots in Trotskyism via the Revolutionary Workers League, BAMN extends its platform to immigrant rights, demanding full citizenship for undocumented individuals, open borders, and inclusion in unions to frame immigration enforcement as racist oppression. The group opposes educational privatization, standardized testing, charter schools, and tuition increases, advocating public job creation and militant unionism as vehicles for broader social equality.^[1]^[2]

Advocacy for Militant Tactics

BAMN explicitly promotes the integration of militant direct actions with legal strategies as indispensable for overcoming institutional barriers to civil rights goals, arguing that reliance on courts or non-confrontational methods alone permits opponents to entrench power unchallenged.^[1] The organization's name, derived from Malcolm X's declaration of self-defense "by any means necessary," underscores a philosophy that justifies aggressive tactics, including physical disruptions and counter-protests, to defend affirmative action, immigrant rights, and integration against perceived fascist or reactionary threats.^[9] BAMN leaders, such as organizer Clarence Thomas, have articulated this approach: "When we say 'by any means necessary,' we mean everything from doing legal cases to organizing more militant actions," emphasizing a spectrum of methods calibrated to the intensity of opposition.^[9] In practice, BAMN's advocacy manifests in calls for mass militant protests designed to physically halt events or policies it opposes, framing such interventions as proactive defenses rather than initiations of violence. For instance, in 2017, BAMN distributed flyers urging supporters to "shut down" conservative speaker Milo Yiannopoulos at the University of California, Berkeley, through "mass militant protest action," which resulted in the event's cancellation amid clashes that caused property damage estimated at $100,000.^[15] Similarly, during the 2020 protests against Donald Trump, BAMN materials declared "TRUMP MUST GO BY ANY MEANS NECESSARY! NO BUSINESS AS USUAL UNTIL TRUMP IS DEFEATED," advocating sustained disruptions to public institutions like universities until political demands were met.^[16] These statements reflect BAMN's rejection of passive advocacy, positing that militant tactics mobilize the masses and expose adversaries' vulnerabilities more effectively than petitions or dialogue. BAMN distinguishes its militancy from indiscriminate violence by tying it to organized, goal-oriented actions aimed at protecting marginalized groups, yet critics from law enforcement and security analyses contend that this framework often escalates confrontations, as evidenced by federal scrutiny of BAMN's role in events leading to injuries and arrests.^[17] The group maintains that such tactics are historically validated by successes like the defense of affirmative action campaigns, where direct actions complemented litigation to sway public and judicial opinion, though empirical outcomes show mixed results, with legal victories rare without broader mobilizations.^[1] BAMN's official principles further codify this dual-track method, committing to a "mass civil rights movement" that employs "aggressive legal strategy" alongside street-level enforcement to enforce equality.^[4]

Key Campaigns and Activities

Defense of Affirmative Action (1990s–2000s)

BAMN, formally the Coalition to Defend Affirmative Action, Integration and Immigrant Rights, and Fight for Equality By Any Means Necessary, originated in 1995 in Berkeley, California, explicitly to oppose efforts to dismantle affirmative action programs, particularly in response to the impending California Proposition 209 ballot initiative.^[1] The group framed affirmative action as essential for combating systemic racial and class inequalities in education and employment, organizing initial rallies and student mobilizations at University of California campuses to rally opposition before the November 1996 vote, which passed with 54.6% approval and banned state consideration of race, sex, or ethnicity in public admissions and hiring.^[18] Following Proposition 209's enactment, BAMN pursued legal challenges, including class-action lawsuits alleging the measure discriminated against low-income minority students by restricting pathways to inflate academic credentials through affirmative action.^[19] In November 1996, BAMN members encouraged high school students to walk out of classes in protest, leading to disruptions at Berkeley High School where participants chanted against the ban and clashed with authorities attempting to maintain order.^[18] These actions underscored BAMN's advocacy for "militant" direct action, drawing from Malcolm X's phrase "by any means necessary" to justify confrontational tactics aimed at overturning the policy through courts and street protests.^[20] By the early 2000s, BAMN shifted significant resources to Michigan amid challenges to the University of Michigan's race-conscious admissions policies in Gratz v. Bollinger and Grutter v. Bollinger. On April 1, 2003, the group coordinated a protest march to the U.S. Supreme Court in Washington, D.C., where demonstrators demanded upholding affirmative action as a civil rights imperative, coinciding with oral arguments in the cases that ultimately affirmed limited use of race in law school admissions while striking down undergraduate point systems.^[21] BAMN positioned itself as a vanguard for integrated education, filing amicus briefs and mobilizing student coalitions at UMich to argue that bans perpetuated segregation under a meritocracy myth favoring privileged applicants.^[22] The passage of Michigan's Proposal 2 on November 7, 2006, which amended the state constitution to prohibit racial preferences in public university admissions by a 58% majority, prompted BAMN to lead the Coalition to Defend Affirmative Action the following day by filing Coalition to Defend Affirmative Action v. Granholm in federal court.^[23] The lawsuit contended that Proposal 2 unconstitutionally burdened minorities' political participation by requiring amendments to the state constitution for policy reversals, a claim that advanced through appeals, including a 2012 Sixth Circuit ruling in BAMN's favor declaring the ban violated equal protection.^[24] Throughout the decade, BAMN orchestrated campus rallies, regents disruptions, and "super marches" at UMich, emphasizing class-based arguments that affirmative action benefited working-class students of all races against elite gatekeeping.^[25] These efforts, while sustaining litigation into the 2010s, highlighted BAMN's fusion of legal strategy with disruptive activism to preserve race-conscious policies amid declining public support.^[1]

Immigrant Rights and Anti-Racism Protests

BAMN, formally the Coalition to Defend Affirmative Action, Integration, and Immigrant Rights and Fight for Equality By Any Means Necessary, has organized and participated in protests advocating for expanded immigrant protections, including opposition to deportation policies and efforts to end what the group describes as second-class treatment of immigrants.^[5]^[26] The organization adopted a formal declaration on immigrant rights at its Ninth National Conference on May 26, 2006, emphasizing mass action to secure legal status for undocumented immigrants and linking immigrant struggles to broader civil rights goals.^[27] In response to immigration enforcement under the Trump administration, BAMN led a march in Oakland, California, on February 3, 2025, protesting executive actions on border security and deportations; participants marched along International Boulevard and 35th Avenue to highlight economic impacts of immigrant labor.^[28] The following day, February 4, 2025, BAMN-affiliated attorney Ronald Cruz participated in Bay Area "A Day Without Immigrants" demonstrations, arguing that such actions demonstrated the essential role of immigrants in the economy amid heightened enforcement.^[29] BAMN has also filed amicus briefs in federal cases, such as one submitted to the U.S. Supreme Court on April 29, 2025, supporting respondents in challenges to immigration restrictions, positioning itself as a youth-led advocate for undocumented rights.^[30] On anti-racism, BAMN has mobilized against events perceived as promoting white supremacist or fascist ideologies, often through counter-protests employing direct confrontation. In Berkeley, California, BAMN organizers, including Yvette Felarca, coordinated counter-demonstrations against right-wing speakers and rallies in 2017, such as efforts to shut down Milo Yiannopoulos appearances and clashes during a March 4 pro-Trump event, framing these as defenses against rising racism.^[31]^[32] On September 26, 2017, BAMN members engaged in physical confrontations near Sproul Plaza with groups like Patriot Prayer during protests tied to Free Speech Week activities.^[33] Following the August 12, 2017, Charlottesville rally, BAMN joined solidarity actions on August 13, 2017, in Detroit and Ann Arbor, Michigan, aligning with counter-protests against white nationalism and calling for mass mobilization to combat perceived fascist threats.^[34] In 2020, amid nationwide unrest over police conduct, BAMN co-organized social justice rallies on August 29 in San Jose and Oakland, California, emphasizing opposition to systemic racism and police violence while urging sustained street action over reliance on electoral politics.^[35] The group's June 8, 2020, program outlined demands for a new civil rights movement, including public disclosure of police records and removal of officers with histories of racial bias, tying these to broader anti-racism efforts.^[36] BAMN's approach consistently advocates "mass action" over institutional reform, viewing protests as essential to dismantling racial hierarchies.^[5]

Litigation and Legal Strategies

BAMN has employed litigation as a complementary strategy to its direct-action tactics, primarily targeting laws and ballot initiatives that eliminate race-based preferences in public institutions. The group's most prominent legal effort centered on challenging Michigan's Proposal 2, a 2006 voter-approved constitutional amendment prohibiting affirmative action in state university admissions, public employment, and contracting. Immediately after its passage on November 7, 2006, BAMN, as the Coalition to Defend Affirmative Action, Integration and Immigrant Rights and Fight for Equality By Any Means Necessary, filed suit in the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Michigan against Governor Jennifer Granholm and other officials, arguing that the amendment violated the Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment by restructuring the political process to disadvantage racial minorities seeking affirmative action through university boards rather than statewide votes.^[37]^[23] The district court dismissed the case in 2008, with Judge David Lawson rejecting BAMN's claims that Proposal 2 imposed a racial classification or burdened minority political participation unequally, emphasizing that the amendment applied neutrally to all groups and that equal protection does not mandate favorable political outcomes for specific policies.^[38] The Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals reversed in 2012, finding a plausible equal protection violation under the political restructuring doctrine derived from cases like Hunter v. Erickson (1969), which scrutinized laws making it harder for minorities to enact race-conscious measures via local processes.^[39] However, the U.S. Supreme Court granted certiorari and, in Schuette v. Coalition to Defend Affirmative Action (572 U.S. 291, 2014), reversed the Sixth Circuit in a plurality opinion, holding that Proposal 2 did not deny equal protection because it neither classified individuals by race nor improperly interfered with judicial review of university admissions; Justice Kennedy's opinion stressed that the political process must remain open to all without judicial imposition of racial preferences.^[40]^[23] BAMN's legal approach in this and related affirmative action defenses typically invokes the political process theory, positing that bans on race-conscious policies erect barriers akin to those struck down in precedents involving housing discrimination, though courts have consistently distinguished such measures as neutral prohibitions on government use of race rather than targeted discrimination. The organization often litigates pro se or with minimal external counsel, integrating court filings with street protests to amplify pressure on defendants like universities, which BAMN has noted are frequent targets in its suits despite occasional alliances.^[41] Beyond affirmative action, BAMN has pursued narrower claims tied to integration and immigrant rights, such as challenging school segregation policies, but these have yielded limited documented successes and remain secondary to its core anti-ban campaigns.^[1] Overall, BAMN's litigation record reflects an aggressive use of federal courts to contest democratic enactments, yet it has faced repeated defeats, underscoring the judiciary's reluctance to override voter-approved restrictions on racial classifications in public decision-making.

Incidents of Violence and Confrontations

Sacramento Riot of 2016

On June 26, 2016, a permitted rally by the white nationalist Traditionalist Worker Party and affiliated neo-Nazi activists at the California State Capitol in Sacramento was met with violent opposition from counter-protesters, including members of By Any Means Necessary (BAMN). Approximately 25 to 30 rally participants arrived intending to demonstrate, but hundreds of counter-protesters, organized by groups such as Antifa Sacramento and BAMN, outnumbered and physically assaulted them upon arrival, using fists, feet, and improvised weapons like flagpoles wielded as clubs.^[42]^[43]^[44] BAMN played a prominent role in mobilizing and advocating for the disruption, issuing pre-event statements declaring that the fascist rally "must be stopped by any means necessary" through a "mass, militant demonstration" to deny them a platform and publicity.^[44]^[45] Videos from the scene captured BAMN national organizer Yvette Felarca punching a rally participant in the head and body during the melee, consistent with the group's endorsement of direct physical confrontation to suppress opposing views.^[46]^[47] The assaults prevented the rally from proceeding beyond its initial stages, as counter-protesters swarmed the group before they could assemble fully.^[48] In response to the attacks, several rally participants drew knives, resulting in stabbings primarily among the counter-protesters. Ten individuals were hospitalized with injuries including stab wounds, lacerations, and blunt trauma; reports specified seven to ten stabbings, with nine men and one woman treated for such wounds alongside cuts and bruises, and at least one initially in critical condition.^[42]^[43]^[49] California Highway Patrol officers present made no arrests during the incident and faced subsequent criticism for a delayed response, allowing the violence to escalate unchecked for several minutes.^[50] Legal consequences focused heavily on counter-protester actions, with Sacramento District Attorney Anne Marie Schubert charging BAMN figures including Felarca, Mike Williams, and Porfirio Paz with felonies such as assault with a deadly weapon, participating in a riot, and inciting a riot based on video evidence of their involvement in the assaults.^[46]^[51]^[52] In 2019, the three BAMN members entered no-contest pleas to reduced misdemeanor charges of unlawful assembly, avoiding felony convictions, while one charged white nationalist, William Planer, was sentenced to time served on assault charges.^[53]^[54] The incident drew federal scrutiny, contributing to an FBI assessment of BAMN as a domestic terrorism threat due to its promotion of violence against perceived fascists.^[55]

Other Physical Clashes and Disruptions

In 2017, BAMN organized and participated in counter-protests against pro-Trump and right-wing rallies in Berkeley, California, which frequently escalated into physical confrontations between opposing groups. On March 4, 2017, BAMN members confronted attendees at a "March 4 Trump" demonstration in Berkeley's Civic Center Park, contributing to clashes that involved mutual assaults amid heightened tensions.^[33]^[56] A more significant incident occurred on April 15, 2017, during another pro-Trump rally in the same location, where BAMN organizer Yvette Felarca directly engaged with protesters, leading to her arrest on felony charges of inciting a riot after video evidence showed her encouraging a physical altercation with a pro-Trump demonstrator. The event devolved into violence, including assaults and stabbings among participants from both sides, resulting in multiple injuries and arrests.^[56]^[57]^[58] During UC Berkeley's Free Speech Week on September 24, 2017, BAMN joined other anti-fascist groups in protesting the event's conservative speakers, heightening the risk of disruption amid prior violent precedents at the university. Although the main events were canceled due to security concerns, the gatherings contributed to ongoing physical tensions and property damage in the area, with BAMN advocating for militant resistance against perceived fascist threats.^[59]^[60] BAMN's tactics in these clashes often involved direct physical intervention to disrupt events, justified by the group as necessary defense against extremism, though critics highlighted the resulting chaos and legal repercussions, including felony riot charges against members that were later contested in court.^[57]^[61]

Law Enforcement Scrutiny

FBI Investigations and Terrorism Labels

The Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) first documented concerns regarding By Any Means Necessary (BAMN) in a 2005 internal report, which classified the group alongside anti-war organizations as involved in "terrorist activities" during monitoring of Michigan-based activism focused on affirmative action and peace protests.^[62] This assessment stemmed from BAMN's disruptive tactics, including street protests and legal challenges, though no charges resulted and the labeling drew criticism from civil liberties advocates for conflating advocacy with violence.^[63] FBI scrutiny intensified in 2016 following BAMN's role in counter-protests against a white nationalist rally in Sacramento, California, on June 26, where clashes injured at least 10 people and led to multiple arrests.^[55] In response, the FBI initiated a domestic terrorism investigation into BAMN, conducting surveillance on its members' movements, communications, and activities under guidelines for assessing threats of politically motivated violence.^[64] Documents obtained via Freedom of Information Act requests revealed that the probe treated BAMN as a potential "black identity extremist" or anarchist threat, prioritizing physical security risks over protected speech, amid broader post-Charlottesville concerns about left-wing extremism.^[55]^[65] No formal designation of BAMN as a terrorist organization has occurred under U.S. law, which reserves such labels for groups like foreign state sponsors or those meeting strict criteria for systematic violence against civilians.^[66] However, the investigations aligned BAMN with domestic terrorism predicates, enabling tools like undercover operations and data analysis, as outlined in FBI domestic terrorism reference guides that emphasize preventing ideologically driven attacks.^[67] Congressional testimony in 2019 highlighted how such probes into BAMN exemplified expansive FBI use of terrorism standards, potentially risking First Amendment overreach when applied to groups employing confrontational but non-lethal tactics.^[64] BAMN contested these efforts as politically motivated suppression, arguing in public statements that the surveillance targeted legitimate anti-racist organizing rather than credible threats.^[68] Subsequent FBI monitoring extended to BAMN-linked disruptions, such as the 2017 UC Berkeley riots against a planned conservative speaker event, where the group claimed organizing involvement and federal agents probed participant identities for potential extremism ties.^[69] These actions reflected causal links between BAMN's advocacy of "militant action" and real-world confrontations, justifying scrutiny under empirical threat assessments, though outcomes remained limited to intelligence gathering without designations or widespread prosecutions.^[70]

Prosecutions of Members

In June 2016, during counter-protests against a planned neo-Nazi rally at the California State Capitol in Sacramento, violence erupted involving participants from the group By Any Means Necessary (BAMN), resulting in multiple injuries including stab wounds.^[53] Yvette Felarca, a national organizer for BAMN and Berkeley Unified School District teacher, was identified as actively participating in the clashes.^[71] Felarca faced felony charges of assault by means likely to produce great bodily injury, along with misdemeanor charges of inciting a riot and participating in a riot, filed by the Sacramento County District Attorney's office in July 2017.^[46] Two associates, Michael Williams and Porfirio Paz—whom BAMN defended alongside Felarca—were similarly charged with assault with a deadly weapon and riot participation.^[72] Prosecutors alleged the defendants contributed to the melee that hospitalized at least nine people, but defense arguments included claims of selective prosecution favoring right-wing participants.^[73] In November 2019, Felarca, Williams, and Paz entered pleas to reduced misdemeanor charges of unlawful assembly, agreeing to community service and other conditions; the original felony and riot charges were subsequently dismissed by the Sacramento DA upon completion of terms.^[74]^[53] No convictions resulted from these cases, with the DA describing the resolution as "fair and just" given evidentiary challenges.^[73] Other instances of legal action against BAMN members have been limited and typically resolved without felony convictions. For example, in 2015, a BAMN staffer was arrested at the University of Michigan for violating a no-trespass order during protests, but details on outcomes remain minor and non-violent in nature.^[75] Federal scrutiny, including FBI designations of BAMN as a domestic terrorism threat in some contexts, has not yielded public prosecutions of members for violent acts as of 2025.^[67]

Criticisms, Impact, and Effectiveness

Allegations of Incitement and Extremism

BAMN's core slogan, "Fight for equality by any means necessary," derives from Malcolm X's advocacy of self-defense against oppression, but critics interpret it as endorsing violence and extremism to achieve political goals.^[1] The group's full name, Coalition to Defend Affirmative Action, Integration and Immigrant Rights and Fight for Equality By Any Means Necessary, explicitly incorporates this phrase, signaling a rejection of non-violent restraint in confrontations with perceived opponents.^[1] Law enforcement in California has attributed incitement of violence to BAMN during counter-protests against conservative rallies, citing their organized disruptions that escalated into physical altercations.^[76] In 2017 Berkeley protests against speakers like Milo Yiannopoulos, BAMN mobilized participants, including public school students recruited by affiliated teachers, leading to riots involving vandalism, assaults, and property damage estimated at over $100,000.^[77] BAMN organizer Yvette Felarca described these events as a "resounding success," defending the use of force to shut down events deemed fascist.^[77] Critics, including congressional figures, have labeled BAMN's tactics as domestic extremism, linking them to broader Antifa-aligned violence that prioritizes ideological enforcement over democratic discourse.^[78] BAMN's alignment with Antifa and participation in counter-demonstrations, such as the 2017 San Francisco Patriot Prayer rally, have drawn accusations of premeditated incitement, with the group vowing to confront "white supremacists" aggressively.^[76] Following events like the 2017 shooting of Rep. Steve Scalise, commentators highlighted BAMN's "by any means necessary" ethos as emblematic of left-wing extremism that justifies violence against conservatives.^[78] Despite BAMN's claims of defensive action against fascism, federal scrutiny has treated their methods as indicative of organized political violence rather than mere protest.^[1]

Failures in Policy Goals and Backlash

BAMN's campaign to preserve affirmative action in Michigan failed decisively when voters approved Proposal 2 on November 7, 2006, with 58% support, amending the state constitution to ban the consideration of race, sex, color, ethnicity, or national origin in public university admissions, government hiring, and public contracting.^[2] Despite BAMN's organization of mass protests and disruptions, including a 2006 incursion at the Michigan Board of Canvassers meeting where activists shouted obscenities and halted proceedings, the initiative was certified and implemented, reducing minority enrollment at institutions like the University of Michigan.^[1] The U.S. Supreme Court affirmed the ban's constitutionality in Schuette v. Coalition to Defend Affirmative Action (April 22, 2014), ruling 6-2 against BAMN's claim that the political restructuring process violated equal protection, thereby entrenching the policy loss despite years of litigation.^[40] Similar setbacks occurred in California, where BAMN's legal challenges to Proposition 209—a 1996 voter-approved measure prohibiting racial preferences in public education, employment, and contracting—were rejected by the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals, upholding the ban and limiting avenues for race-based remedies.^[2] These defeats highlighted the inefficacy of BAMN's confrontational strategies in swaying electoral or judicial outcomes, as aggressive tactics like courtroom disruptions and street mobilizations failed to counter broader public opposition to quotas, evidenced by repeated voter mandates.^[1] BAMN's militant approach provoked significant backlash, alienating potential allies and reinforcing perceptions of extremism. Teacher unions, segments of the left-wing activist community, and even partner organizations like campus NAACP chapters criticized the group's "rough-and-ready" methods for perpetuating negative stereotypes of minority youth and prioritizing disruption over persuasion.^[2] ^[1] Incidents such as the 2020 Detroit school protests, where BAMN blockades prevented hundreds of low-income students from attending in-person summer classes amid COVID-19 restrictions, drew condemnation for undermining educational access in communities the group purported to champion, resulting in attendance drops from 2,000 to fewer than 1,500 students.^[1] Federal scrutiny intensified, with a 2002 FBI assessment labeling BAMN a potential domestic terrorism threat due to patterns of violence and incitement, further eroding credibility and inviting prosecutions that diverted resources from policy advocacy.^[2] This backlash contributed to policy entrenchment, as public and institutional aversion to BAMN's tactics bolstered support for race-neutral alternatives, hampering broader goals like immigrant rights and anti-racism integration.^[1]

Alternative Viewpoints on Achievements

In specific instances, participants and observers have credited BAMN's direct-action tactics with tangible policy concessions. During the 2023 occupation of UC Berkeley's Anthropology Library, BAMN joined student protesters in sustaining an 85-day demonstration against proposed closures and mergers, which pressured administrators to retain dedicated staff and operations for the facility, albeit in a restructured format rather than full independence.^[79] This outcome contrasted with administrative plans for consolidation, illustrating how militant occupations could extract compromises in resource preservation disputes.^[80] Proponents of BAMN's approach, including group organizers, contend that confrontational protests against perceived fascist gatherings have disrupted recruitment and platforming of extremists. For example, following counter-demonstrations during UC Berkeley events involving far-right figures, BAMN representatives asserted that such actions effectively repelled neo-Nazi participants and curtailed their organizing efforts on campus. These viewpoints frame disruptions not as mere backlash generators but as causal interventions that limited the spread of ideologies deemed threats to integration and equality, drawing on historical precedents like Malcolm X's advocacy for uncompromising resistance.^[20] ![Berkeley Free Speech Week protest][float-right] In litigation, alternative analyses suggest BAMN's challenges to affirmative action bans, such as the 2012 Sixth Circuit ruling in their favor on procedural grounds in Schuette v. BAMN, temporarily advanced civil rights framing by linking ballot initiatives to discriminatory barriers, even if ultimately overturned by the Supreme Court in 2014.^[37] Supporters argue this reframed the debate from meritocracy critiques to equal protection imperatives, fostering broader mobilization among youth and minorities despite the net policy losses.^[20] Such perspectives emphasize long-term ideological gains over immediate electoral defeats, positing that sustained militancy builds organizational capacity for future egalitarian struggles.

References

[1]
By Any Means Necessary (BAMN) - InfluenceWatch
Nov 25, 2018 · By Any Means Necessary (BAMN) ; Formation: 1995 in Berkeley, California ; Full Name: Coalition to Defend Affirmative Action, Integration and ...
[2]
BAMN: By Any Means Necessary - Capital Research Center
Aug 7, 2010 · The radical group called By Any Means Necessary, or BAMN, believes racial profiling is wrong but racial quotas in hiring and college admissions are right.
[3]
About BAMN - BAMN
BAMN is committed to defeating Donald Trump and his fascist movement by any means necessary. This moment in history calls for bold leaders who are prepared ...
[4]
BAMN Principles
Principles of The Coalition to Defend Affirmative Action, Integration and Immigrant Rights and Fight for Equality By Any Means Necessary (BAMN) ... history.
[5]
BAMN: The Coalition to Defend Affirmative Action, Integration, and ...
BAMN is committed to defeating Donald Trump and his fascist movement by any means necessary. This moment in history calls for bold leaders who are prepared ...Join BAMN · MFJ BAMN · EON/BAMN Caucus · Clients
[6]
The Parade of Horribles Lives: Schuette v. Coalition to Defend ...
Jan 6, 2014 · Coalition to Defend Affirmative Action, Integration and Immigrant Rights and Fight for Equality By Any Means Necessary. It seems unlikely that ...<|separator|>
[7]
Group out to destroy BAMN - The Michigan Daily
Jan 23, 2006 · Students who both advocate and oppose affirmative action have formed a new group known as The Coalition to Stop BAMN, By Any Legal Means.Missing: origins | Show results with:origins
[8]
By Any Means Necessary (BAMN) - Discover the Networks
Attorney (and Revolutionary Workers League member) Shanta Driver founded BAMN in 1995 in Berkeley, California. BAMN's initial purpose was to act as a ...
[9]
BAMN - KeyWiki
Jun 8, 2024 · "BAMN formed in 1995 to fight California's rollback of affirmative action. ... “When we say 'by any means necessary,' we mean everything from ...
[10]
Revolutionary Workers League (U.S.) - Wikipedia
The Revolutionary Workers League (RWL) is a Trotskyist political party in the United States. RWL formed in the late 1970s.History · International affiliation · Subsequent history · Publications
[11]
September 28, 2001 (vol. 111, iss. 154) - Image 12
BAMN member. Hist oy. BAMN originated in Berkeley, Calif., in 1995 as the Coalition to Defend Affirmative Action By Any Means Necessary in response to Propo-Missing: origins | Show results with:origins
[12]
BAM-N UpdateA former member of… - Goodspeed Update
Jan 27, 2004 · “Revolutionary Workers League: Formed in 1976 as a split from the Spartacist League, the RWL is a dogmatic and intensely militant Trotskyist ...
[13]
Letters to the Editor - The Michigan Daily
Mar 19, 2002 · ... BAMN is a front group for the Revolutionary Workers League, a Detroit-based, sectarian, Trotskyite organization. This awakening began in ...
[14]
WHY I LEFT ORTHODOX TROTSKYISM - Socialist Currents
Feb 22, 2025 · Yours would have been an interesting interaction. The Revolutionary Workers League had a strong presence in Detroit when I lived there. I ...Missing: origins | Show results with:origins
[15]
Principles of BAMN
### Summary of BAMN Principles
[16]
[PDF] SHUT DOWN MILO YIANNOPOULOS - BAMN
Mass militant protest action shut down him and his heinous plans. ... By Any Means Necessary (BAMN) bamn.com california ... whether the nation's principles of ...
[17]
[PDF] MOVEMENT TO DEFEAT TRUMP - BAMN
○ TRUMP MUST GO BY ANY MEANS NECESSARY! NO BUSINESS AS USUAL UNTIL TRUMP IS. DEFEATED! ○ Free Mass Testing of COVID-19 at UC'S for everyone! Open UC ...Missing: tactics | Show results with:tactics
[18]
Behind the Black Bloc - FDD
Jun 14, 2021 · BAMN is an anti-racist group founded in 1995 in Southern California that focuses on racism, immigration, and youth issues. The group is opposed ...
[19]
Students Incited to Leave Campus in Prop. 209 Protest
Nov 5, 1996 · Police said the BAMN group, shouting encouragement from outside the school fence, urged the students to leave campus to protest Proposition 209.
[20]
Class Challenges Affirmative-Action Ban - Courthouse News Service
... by Any Means Necessary (BAMN), claims Prop. 209 discriminates against poor minority students who are unable to inflate their grade point averages because ...
[21]
MAKING A CIVIL RIGHTS CLAIM FOR AFFIRMATIVE ACTION
The organization's very name suggested a connection to various political struggles: “By any means necessary” is a phrase coined by Malcolm X, the Black Muslim ...
[22]
Defending Affirmative Action - BAMN
Defend free speech and academic freedom for supporters of the Palestinian struggle! •Support the pro-Palestine student-defendant intervention to defeat the pro- ...
[23]
Coalition To Defend Affirmative Action, Integration and Immigrant ...
Coalition To Defend Affirmative Action, Integration and Immigrant Rights and Fight For Equality By Any Means Necessary (BAMN) et al v. Granholm et al, No.<|separator|>
[24]
SCHUETTE v. BAMN | Supreme Court - Law.Cornell.Edu
COALITION TO DEFEND AF- FIRMATIVE ACTION, INTEGRATION AND IMMI- GRANT RIGHTS AND FIGHT FOR EQUALITY BY ANY MEANS NECESSARY (BAMN), et al. on writ of ...
[25]
COALITION TO DEFEND AFFIRMATIVE ACTION BAMN 08 1387 v ...
... Defend Affirmation Action, Integration and Immigrant Rights and Fight for Equality by any Means Necessary (BAMN), et al., Plaintiffs, Chase Cantrell, et al ...
[26]
Coalition to Defend Affirmative Action By Any Means Necessary ...
The Coalition to Defend Affirmative Action By Any Means Necessary (University of Michigan) (BAMN) records consist of materials distributed by BAMN to members at ...
[27]
Campaigns - BAMN
BAMN is building the movement to end Jim Crow, second-class treatment against immigrants, documented and undocumented. We are building a united mass, ...<|separator|>
[28]
Yearning to Breathe Free: BAMN Declaration on Immigrant Rights
This is BAMN's perspective on immigrant rights and its central role in the fight for equality, democracy, and freedom in America.
[29]
People rally in Oakland in protest of Trump's immigration actions
Feb 3, 2025 · Activists from the group By Any Means Necessary (BAMN) led a march down International and 35th Avenue in Oakland protesting the nationwide ...
[30]
Across Bay Area, 'A Day Without Immigrants' Meets Trump ... - KQED
Feb 4, 2025 · Ronald Cruz, an attorney at the civil rights group By Any Means Necessary, or BAMN, said he hoped the demonstrations would show the economic ...
[31]
[PDF] Brief AMICUS CURIAE OF BAMN IN SUPPORT OF RESPONDENTS ...
Apr 29, 2025 · Immigrant Rights and Fight for Equality By Any Means Necessary (BAMN) is an integrated, youth-led civil rights and immigrant rights organization.Missing: protests | Show results with:protests
[32]
Confront and Defeat the Trump Movement: COUNTER-PROTEST ...
Mar 1, 2017 · Confront and Defeat the Trump Movement: COUNTER-PROTEST the Pro-Trump Berkeley Rally ... by any means necessary. All out on March 4th! Confront ...
[33]
Trump's America: Where activists face felony charges - Al Jazeera
Aug 14, 2017 · Felarca is an organiser with By Any Means Necessary (BAMN), a militant left-wing civil rights group that called for that counterprotest ...
[34]
Drop the Charges Against the Anti-Trump Berkeley 5! - BAMN
Coalition to Defend Affirmative Action, Integration and Immigrant Rights and Fight for Equality By Any Means Necessary (BAMN). Hotline: 510-817-2617 BAMN.com ...
[35]
Groups rally in Detroit, Ann Arbor after deadly Virginia protest
Aug 13, 2017 · Rallies across southeastern Michigan Sunday pledged solidarity with anti-racism counter-protests ... (By Any Means Necessary), was aimed at ...
[36]
Social justice rallies Friday night in San Jose, Oakland | KTVU FOX 2
Aug 29, 2020 · Organizers with By Any Means Necessary (BAMN) said they are one of several groups behind Friday's demonstrations. "Our movements cannot rely ...Missing: anti- | Show results with:anti-
[37]
Program of Action for the New Civil Rights Movement - BAMN
Jun 8, 2020 · Attempts to co-opt and shut down our movement with threats of violent repression or polite deception and distraction have utterly failed and ...
[38]
Michigan Civil Rights Initiative Litigation: BAMN v. Russell et al.
Dec 18, 2006 · ... By Any Means Necessary (BAMN) filed a suit in federal court alleging that the new amendment violated the Fourteenth Amendment of the U.S. ...Missing: strategies | Show results with:strategies
[39]
By No Means: Michigan Judge Turns Tables On Advocacy Groups ...
... by Any Means Necessary” or, more simply, “BAMN.” In a sweeping opinion, Lawson rejected every one of the legal arguments that BAMN and other opponents were ...
[40]
COALITION TO DEFEND AFFIRMATIVE ACTION INTEGRATION ...
Case opinion for US 6th Circuit COALITION TO DEFEND AFFIRMATIVE ACTION INTEGRATION AND IMMIGRANT RIGHTS AND FIGHT FOR EQUALITY BY ANY MEANS NECESSARY BAMN 08
[41]
Schuette v. Coalition to Defend Affirmative Action | 572 U.S. 291 ...
The Supreme Court decided that the University of Michigan's undergraduate admissions plan's use of race-based preferences violated the Equal Protection Clause.
[42]
Appeals court rejects suit seeking to end ban on affirmative action
Apr 2, 2012 · ... by Any Means Necessary, an organization known as BAMN (the acronym ... BAMN legal strategy, and in fact are typically sued in most BAMN litigation ...
[43]
10 Injured During White Nationalist Rally in California Capital
Jun 26, 2016 · Five to seven people were stabbed during a white supremacy protest and counter-protest in California on Sunday, authorities said.Missing: BAMN | Show results with:BAMN
[44]
7 stabbed at neo-Nazi event outside Capitol in Sacramento
Jun 26, 2016 · Seven people were stabbed, with some injured critically, during clashes between rallying neo-Nazis and counter-protesters at the Capitol in ...Missing: BAMN | Show results with:BAMN
[45]
Police defend response to violent rally at California Capitol
Jun 27, 2016 · “Their rally must be stopped by any means necessary,” declared a statement issued by the group By Any Means Necessary, or BAMN.
[46]
NO “FREE SPEECH” FOR FASCISTS! Mass, militant demonstration ...
Jun 26, 2016 · By having a massive anti-racist, anti-fascist protest at the State Capitol on June 26, we will make sure that any publicity or news coverage of ...
[47]
Berkeley Teacher Charged In Connection With Riot At 2016 ...
Jul 20, 2017 · Veteran activist and Berkeley school teacher Yvette Felarca has been charged with assault, participating in a riot and inciting a riot for her actions in a ...
[48]
Anti-Fascist Leader Arrested After California Capitol Brawl ...
... riot. Yvette Felarca is the name used by a leader of the group By Any Means Necessary, but public records show her given name is Yvonne Capistrano Felarca.<|control11|><|separator|>
[49]
Multiple people stabbed at Sacramento white nationalist rally
Jun 26, 2016 · Multiple people were stabbed and beaten in a brutal clash between white nationalists and counter-protesters just outside the California capitol ...
[50]
Clashes at white-supremacist rally in Sacramento leave 10 injured
Jun 27, 2016 · Nine men and one woman were treated for stab wounds, cuts and bruises, officials said. No arrests have been reported so far. Video posted on ...
[51]
Cops face criticism after Sacramento rally fight
Jun 27, 2016 · Police in California are facing criticisms for slow response times during an altercation at a nationalist rally in Sacramento Sunday.<|separator|>
[52]
Three anti-Nazi activists face felony charges in ... - Sacramento Bee
May 4, 2018 · Three anti-Nazi activists face felony charges in 2016 melee. One white supremacist still jailed. By Darrell Smith. Updated May 5, 2018 8:49 AM.Missing: BAMN | Show results with:BAMN
[53]
2 arrested in connection with violent 2016 riot outside California ...
Jul 18, 2017 · William Planer and Porfirio Paz were arrested on charges of assault with a deadly weapon and participating in a riot, the DA's office said.
[54]
State Capitol Melee Protesters Agree To Lesser Charges - CBS News
Nov 14, 2019 · Three protesters have entered no contest pleas to lesser charges stemming from a wild 2016 ... by any means necessary. MORE: 10 Stabbed, Beaten At ...
[55]
White nationalist Planer sentenced in violent 2016 Capitol riot
Jul 3, 2019 · William Scott Planer was sentenced in Sacramento Superior Court to time served on felony assault charges connected to the bloody June 2016 riot.
[56]
Revealed: FBI investigated civil rights group as 'terrorism' threat and ...
Feb 1, 2019 · The FBI launched its terrorism investigation and surveillance of Bamn after white supremacists armed with knives faced off with hundreds of ...
[57]
Berkeley teacher Yvette Felarca arrested on charges of inciting a riot
Jul 19, 2017 · 1 and directly confronted pro-Trump protesters on March 4 and April 15 in rallies in Civic Center Park that turned violent. Felarca gained even ...
[58]
Judge says no proof of 'witch hunt' against Berkeley teacher facing ...
May 8, 2018 · The case against King teacher Yvette Felarca and her co-defendants, stemming from a violent neo-Nazi rally and counter-protest, will be heard in ...Missing: physical | Show results with:physical
[59]
BAMN activist draws supportive picketers outside courthouse during ...
Feb 12, 2018 · “In the hours that followed, violent clashes occurred between the two groups resulting in a number of assaults and several stabbings.” A video ...Missing: physical | Show results with:physical
[60]
UC Berkeley prepares for possibly violent 'Free Speech Week'
Sep 22, 2017 · UC Berkeley prepares for possibly violent 'Free Speech Week'. Byby ... BAMN member Yvette Felarka. Cal says "Free Speech Week" will cost ...
[61]
The Alt-Right's Worst Nightmare Is An Antifa Middle School Teacher
Sep 25, 2017 · Felarca claims she's received more violent threats "than she can count." The vitriol is sometimes directed at the school where she teaches young ...
[62]
"No Regrets" Organizer calls for more militant protests - YouTube
Feb 3, 2017 · Yvette Felarca with the group "By Any Means Necessary" defends violence at UC Berkeley protest - says it should be the model for how the ...<|separator|>
[63]
FBI Document Labels Michigan Affirmative Action and Peace ...
Aug 29, 2005 · The American Civil Liberties Union today released an FBI document that designates a Michigan-based peace group and an affirmative action advocacy group as ...
[64]
FBI Labeling Peaceful Michigan Organizations as Terrorists, New ...
Aug 29, 2005 · DETROIT -- The American Civil Liberties Union today released an FBI document that designates a Michigan-based peace group and an affirmative ...<|separator|>
[65]
[PDF] Weaponization Sub Committee Testimony.docx - Congress.gov
Oct 29, 2019 · The FBI began to monitor the civil rights group By Any Means Necessary (BAMN) in 2016, after ... The FBI responded by opening up an investigation ...
[66]
Intelligence report appeared to endorse view leftwing protesters ...
Apr 1, 2019 · At that time, groups including By Any Means Necessary (Bamn) organized a counter-protest against a white supremacist rally which included ...<|control11|><|separator|>
[67]
State Sponsors of Terrorism - United States Department of State
Currently there are four countries designated under these authorities: Cuba, the Democratic People's Republic of Korea (North Korea), Iran, and Syria. Country ...Missing: BAMN | Show results with:BAMN
[68]
[PDF] Fighting Far-Right Violence and Hate Crimes
Jul 1, 2019 · 42 FBI, BAMN – By Any Means Necessary, 9. 43 See FBI, Abortion Extremism Reference Guide for Law. Enforcement, 2017, 1, available at “FBI ' ...
[69]
BAMN's response to released FBI investigation report on BAMN ...
BAMN · About BAMN · Struggles ... BAMN's response to released FBI investigation report on BAMN ... By Any Means Necessary (BAMN). facebook Share on ...
[70]
FBI investigating identities of black-clad UC Berkeley rioters
Feb 7, 2017 · The group, By Any Means Necessary (BAMN), a left-wing group that is often confrontational, has claimed that it was one of the “organizers of ...
[71]
Ahead of Hearing, Defending Rights & Dissent Urges Homeland ...
Recently, the FBI conducted a counterterrorism investigation into the civil rights group, By Any Means Necessary (Bamn), after its supporters protested ...
[72]
'I won't stop': Jailed activist blasts US crackdown on anti-Trump ...
Jul 25, 2017 · Felarca, a Berkeley teacher and longtime leader with the organization By Any Means Necessary ... Sacramento, California, on 26 June 2016 to ...
[73]
Defend Anti-Racist and Anti-Fascist Protesters Felarca, Williams ...
Dec 7, 2018 · Drop the charges on Yvette Felarca, Mike Williams, and Porfirio Paz! Build the Resistance Movement to Force Trump to Resign or Be Removed!
[74]
3 in melee with white supremacists plead to lesser charges - AP News
Nov 14, 2019 · Sacramento County prosecutors said the charges are “a fair and just resolution under the circumstances of this case.” Felarca called the reduced ...Missing: outcome | Show results with:outcome
[75]
Berkeley teacher Felarca gets community service in Sacramento ...
Nov 14, 2019 · The Sacramento District Attorney is set to dismiss a case against Berkeley teacher Yvette Felarca and two co-defendants related to a neo-Nazi rally and counter ...Missing: BAMN | Show results with:BAMN
[76]
BAMN protests - U-M Public Affairs - University of Michigan
Nov 20, 2015 · And then this week, on Nov. 17, one of the BAMN staff members was arrested for violating the no trespass order while handing out fliers on ...
[77]
San Fran park braces for 'Patriot Prayer' rally amid fears ... - Fox News
Aug 23, 2017 · “She's telling white supremacists to come into town.” A left-wing group aligned with Antifa called By Any Means Necessary said it would be on ...
[78]
Public School Teachers Behind Violent Antifa Group | The Daily Caller
Sep 1, 2017 · House Minority Leader Nancy Pelosi condemned the Antifa violence in Berkeley, while Felarca called BAMN's actions a “resounding success.” Yvette ...
[79]
After Scalise shooting, 'alt-left' violence becoming harder to ignore ...
... violence against conservatives and the defense of liberal ideology – by any means necessary. One group actually calls itself “By Any Means Necessary,” or BAMN.
[80]
After protests, UC Berkeley will keep anthropology library — kind of
Jul 20, 2023 · In addition to students from the anthropology department, the protest was sustained by outside groups like By Any Means Necessary (BAMN).
[81]
Victory for the UC Berkeley Anthropology Library Occupation! July ...
Jul 29, 2023 · BAMN intervened from the beginning, expanding the library struggle beyond the campus. BAMN had been invited to join the occupation in part as a ...
[82]
BAMN - Wikipedia
Origins. BAMN was formed in 1995 to oppose the July 20, 1995, decision by Regents of the University of California to ban affirmative action as The Coalition to ...