Barbara Boxer
Barbara Boxer (née Levy; born November 11, 1940) is a retired American politician who represented California in the United States Congress for 34 years as a Democrat, including service in the House of Representatives from 1983 to 1993 and the Senate from 1993 to 2017.[1] Born in Brooklyn, New York, to Jewish parents, she earned a bachelor's degree from Brooklyn College in 1962 and relocated to California with her husband, where she briefly worked as a stockbroker before entering public service on the Marin County Board of Supervisors from 1977 to 1982.[1] Her congressional career emphasized environmental protection, women's rights, and opposition to certain military engagements, such as the Iraq War.[2][3] As chair of the Senate Committee on Environment and Public Works, Boxer advanced legislation to strengthen clean water standards, combat climate change, and designate over one million acres of California wilderness for preservation.[4][2] She co-sponsored bills to enhance child care funding, restrict the criminal use of personal data from vehicle records—a measure affirmed by the Supreme Court—and promote infrastructure improvements through bipartisan efforts.[4][1] Alongside Senator Dianne Feinstein, Boxer formed the first all-female Senate delegation from a single state, marking a milestone in congressional representation.[5] Boxer's tenure drew criticism for her partisan intensity and rhetorical style, exemplified by a 2007 Senate hearing exchange with Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice, in which Boxer implied Rice lacked personal stakes in foreign policy due to not having children serving in the military.[6] After retiring, she registered as a lobbyist and faced scrutiny from environmental advocates for undisclosed compensation related to promoting a controversial desalination project opposed by taxpayer and coastal protection groups, raising questions about consistency with her prior advocacy.[7]Early life and education
Upbringing and family influences
Barbara Boxer was born Barbara Sue Levy on November 11, 1940, in Brooklyn, Kings County, New York, to Ira Levy, a lawyer, and Sophie Silvershein Levy, a homemaker whose parents had immigrated from Eastern Europe.[3][1] The Levys were a Jewish family, and Boxer's early exposure to Jewish history included reading The Diary of Anne Frank as a child, an experience that instilled a lasting awareness of the Holocaust's impact on her psyche.[8] Her mother had worked outside the home from ages 16 to 21 before marrying, but thereafter focused on homemaking, reflecting a traditional family structure common in mid-20th-century Jewish immigrant households.[9] Boxer grew up in the Flatbush and Crown Heights neighborhoods of Brooklyn, areas characterized by secure, close-knit communities of Jewish and Italian residents during the 1940s and 1950s.[10] She attended local public schools, where her education emphasized civic engagement, though she later recalled no initial aspiration for public office in her youth.[11][12] Family life centered on stability, with her parents providing a supportive environment amid the post-World War II urban Jewish milieu, which valued education and community ties over early professional ambitions for daughters.[3] Key family influences included her father's keen interest in politics, which exposed her to discussions of current events and governance from an early age, potentially shaping her later trajectory despite the era's limited opportunities for women in such fields.[10] This paternal engagement contrasted with her mother's domestic role, highlighting gendered divisions in the household that Boxer would later challenge through her career, though her upbringing remained rooted in conventional expectations for Jewish American girls of the time.[9] Her Jewish heritage fostered a sense of identity tied to resilience and ethical responsibility, influenced by immigrant parental narratives of perseverance.[3]Academic and early professional experiences
Boxer earned a Bachelor of Arts degree in economics from Brooklyn College in 1962.[13][14] After graduation, she worked as a stockbroker on Wall Street, applying her economics training to financial markets while supporting her husband through law school.[3][15] In 1965, Boxer moved with her husband to Marin County, California, concluding her early career in finance.[15][16]Entry into politics
Local activism and initial campaigns
Boxer entered politics through anti-war activism in Marin County, California, beginning with volunteer work for Senator Eugene McCarthy's 1968 presidential campaign.[1] In 1970, she co-founded the Marin Alternative, an organization focused on protesting the Vietnam War, advocating for equal rights, and promoting women's rights.[1] That same year, she managed publicity for a successful local ballot initiative to advance peace efforts, which passed despite expectations.[17] She also co-founded the Education Corps in Marin City to assist young women, particularly high school dropouts, in securing employment, and participated in candlelight vigils against the Vietnam War.[18] Her initial electoral campaigns targeted the Marin County Board of Supervisors. In 1972, Boxer ran as a Democrat against incumbent Republican Peter Arrigoni but lost the election.[19] Following the defeat, she served as a congressional aide to Representative John Burton, gaining experience in legislative operations.[19] She launched a successful bid in 1976, winning a seat on the Board of Supervisors by campaigning on "the new politics of the mid-70s," emphasizing community responsiveness and progressive reforms.[20] During her tenure from 1977 to 1982, she prioritized issues such as transportation improvements and air quality enhancements in the county.[21]1982 House election
Barbara Boxer, serving as a Marin County supervisor since 1976, entered the 1982 U.S. House race for California's 6th congressional district, an open seat reconfigured by Democratic-led redistricting after the 1980 census to favor the party while incorporating her North Bay base alongside parts of San Francisco.[1][22] The redistricting, orchestrated by Assemblyman Phillip Burton, drew criticism for entrenching Democratic advantages through irregular boundaries, though the 6th district remained marginally competitive.[22] Boxer secured the Democratic nomination in the June 8, 1982, primary, advancing against a field of local contenders to face Republican Dennis McQuaid, a businessman, in the general election.[23]| Candidate | Party | Votes | Percentage |
|---|---|---|---|
| Barbara Boxer | Democratic | 98,379 | 52.38% |
| Dennis McQuaid | Republican | 82,128 | 44.62% |
| Howard C. Creighton | Libertarian | 3,191 | 1.73% |
| Timothy-Allen Albertson | Peace & Freedom | 2,366 | 1.29% |
Congressional career in the House (1983–1993)
Representing California's 6th district
Barbara Boxer was elected to represent California's 6th congressional district in the U.S. House of Representatives in 1982, defeating Republican Dennis McQuaid with 52 percent of the vote.[1] The district encompassed Marin County, a liberal-leaning region in northern California characterized by affluent suburban communities and environmental advocacy.[1] Her campaign slogan, "Barbara Boxer Gives a Damn," emphasized her commitment to constituent issues, reflecting her prior experience on the Marin County Board of Supervisors.[25] Boxer served five terms from January 3, 1983, to January 3, 1993, facing no serious re-election challenges after her initial victory, with subsequent wins by widening margins such as 68 percent in 1984.[1] [26] During her tenure, she focused on issues pertinent to her district's priorities, including environmental protection, child welfare, and government oversight. She secured committee assignments on Government Operations, Budget, Armed Services, and the Select Committee on Children, Youth, and Families, allowing her to influence policies on federal spending and family support programs.[1] Among her legislative achievements, Boxer authored the Small Business and Federal Procurement Competition Enhancement Act of 1984 (Public Law 98-577), which promoted competition in government contracting to benefit smaller enterprises.[1] She also gained attention for critiquing military procurement excesses, highlighting wasteful expenditures like overpriced toilet seats to argue against inflated defense budgets.[11] In foreign policy, Boxer voted against authorizing U.S. military involvement in the 1991 Gulf War, aligning with her district's dovish leanings. Additionally, in 1991, she joined a protest march to the Senate demanding fuller hearings on Anita Hill's allegations against Supreme Court nominee Clarence Thomas, underscoring her advocacy for women's issues.[1]Legislative priorities and votes
During her tenure in the House representing California's 6th congressional district, Barbara Boxer prioritized reducing government waste and enhancing accountability, often highlighting examples of inefficient federal spending such as the Pentagon's purchase of a $7,622 coffee maker in 1984.[1] She advocated for small business interests, sponsoring the Small Business and Federal Procurement Competition Enhancement Act of 1984, which became law as Public Law 98-577 and aimed to improve small businesses' access to federal contracts by promoting competition.[1] Boxer also focused on environmental protection, including efforts to address consumer information on sustainable fishing practices, and served on the Government Operations Committee, where she chaired the Subcommittee on Government Activities and Transportation in the 102nd Congress (1991–1993).[11] Boxer's legislative agenda extended to issues affecting families, children, and women, building on her local activism to push for protections against domestic violence and greater gender equity in congressional facilities, such as integrating the House gym.[11] She addressed public health concerns like the AIDS epidemic impacting her district's proximity to San Francisco.[11] In environmental legislation, she sponsored the Dolphin Protection Consumer Information Act of 1990 (H.R. 3742), which established "dolphin-safe" labeling for tuna products to reduce harm to marine mammals during fishing operations.[11] On foreign policy, Boxer opposed U.S. military authorization for the Persian Gulf War, voting against the January 12, 1991, resolution (H.J.Res. 77) that empowered President George H.W. Bush to use force against Iraq.[1] She joined a bipartisan group of House members in a 1991 march to the Senate in support of Anita Hill's testimony during Clarence Thomas's Supreme Court confirmation hearings, emphasizing procedural fairness in addressing sexual harassment allegations.[1] Her voting record aligned with liberal Democratic positions on social issues, including support for consumer protections and family-oriented policies, though specific roll-call data from the era reflects consistent opposition to defense spending increases amid her fiscal scrutiny efforts.[1]Senate tenure (1993–2017)
Gubernatorial appointment and initial election
Barbara Boxer, having served five terms in the U.S. House of Representatives, sought the Democratic nomination for the U.S. Senate seat in California being vacated by retiring incumbent Alan Cranston, whose term expired in 1993.[1] She announced her candidacy in early 1991 and secured the nomination in the June 2, 1992, Democratic primary, defeating several challengers including state Controller Gray Davis and Los Angeles Mayor Tom Bradley.[27] In the November 3, 1992, general election, Boxer faced Republican nominee Bruce Herschensohn, a conservative radio talk show host and former aide to Ronald Reagan.[28] The race was competitive, with Herschensohn initially leading in polls amid national Republican gains under President George H. W. Bush. However, a late October report by Gentleman's Quarterly revealed Herschensohn's attendance at a San Francisco strip club featuring nude dancers in 1990, which he acknowledged but described as a one-time event during a fundraiser; the disclosure, aired days before the election, contributed to a shift in momentum.[28] Boxer prevailed with 5,173,467 votes (47.90%), to Herschensohn's 4,644,182 (43.00%), while American Independent Party candidate Jerome McCready received 373,051 (3.45%).[29] Voter turnout exceeded 10 million, reflecting high engagement in California's concurrent special election for the other Senate seat.[29] Boxer's victory, alongside Democrat Dianne Feinstein's win in the special election, made California the first state to send two women to the Senate simultaneously and contributed to the election of four new female senators overall, dubbed the "Year of the Woman" amid public response to events like the Anita Hill hearings.[30] She was sworn in on January 5, 1993, beginning her tenure representing California's Class 3 Senate seat.[2]Subsequent reelection campaigns
In the 1998 election, Boxer faced Republican challenger Matt Fong, California's state treasurer and son of former U.S. Secretary of State Hiram Fong, in a contest marked by competitive fundraising and attacks on each other's records.[31] Boxer secured a second term on November 3, 1998, with 53 percent of the vote to Fong's 43 percent, a margin of approximately 10 percentage points amid a national Republican midterm gain.[1] Boxer's 2004 reelection bid pitted her against Republican Bill Jones, the former California Secretary of State, in a race where she emphasized her legislative achievements on environment and women's issues while Jones criticized her support for federal spending.[32] On November 2, 2004, coinciding with President George W. Bush's reelection, Boxer won decisively with about 58 percent of the vote to Jones's 38 percent, achieving a margin of roughly 20 percentage points in a state leaning Democratic.[32] Facing a national Republican resurgence in 2010, Boxer campaigned against Carly Fiorina, the former Hewlett-Packard CEO who self-funded much of her challenge and highlighted Boxer's long tenure and perceived liberal extremism.[33] Despite the GOP wave that flipped the House, Boxer prevailed on November 2, 2010, capturing 52 percent of the vote to Fiorina's 42 percent, a margin of about 10 percentage points, bolstered by strong Democratic turnout in urban areas.[34][35]Committee roles and influence
Boxer joined the Senate Committee on Environment and Public Works in 1995, serving continuously until 2017, and used her position to prioritize environmental regulations and infrastructure investments.[1] From 2007 to 2015, amid Democratic majorities in the 110th through 113th Congresses, she chaired the committee as the first woman in that role, directing hearings and markup sessions on clean air standards, water quality protections, and transportation reauthorizations such as the 2012 Moving Ahead for Progress in the 21st Century Act, which allocated $127 billion for highway and transit projects over six years.[2] [36] Her leadership emphasized reducing greenhouse gas emissions, evidenced by her advocacy for the 2007 energy bill that mandated fuel efficiency standards rising to 35 miles per gallon by 2020 for passenger vehicles. Concurrently, Boxer chaired the Senate Select Committee on Ethics from 2007 to 2015, the first woman to lead it, where she presided over investigations into member conduct, including probes into lobbying violations and financial disclosures that resulted in public admonishments and referrals to law enforcement in several cases during her tenure.[2] This role amplified her influence on Senate institutional integrity, as she enforced rules under the Ethics in Government Act of 1978, contributing to bipartisan enforcement actions that upheld disclosure requirements for over 100 members annually.[2] Boxer's assignments also included the Committee on Foreign Relations from 2001 to 2013, where she influenced nominations and oversight on international aid and sanctions, such as supporting the 2010 Russia sanctions legislation amid concerns over human rights; the Committee on Commerce, Science, and Transportation from 2001 to 2017, focusing on telecommunications and consumer protection; and later the Judiciary Committee from 2013 to 2017, participating in confirmation hearings for judicial nominees.[1] As ranking member on Environment and Public Works after 2015 Republican gains, she blocked several rollbacks of Obama-era regulations, maintaining opposition to measures easing permitting for fossil fuel projects.[37] Her committee seniority enabled cross-aisle negotiations, though critics noted her environmental priorities sometimes delayed infrastructure approvals, extending project timelines by an average of 18 months in contested cases during her chairmanship.[36] Overall, these roles positioned her as a pivotal figure in shaping federal policy on sustainability and ethics, with over 500 bills marked up under her committees advancing to the floor.[38]Key legislative initiatives
Boxer chaired the Senate Committee on Environment and Public Works from 2007 to 2015, advancing initiatives to address climate change and environmental degradation. In 2009, her committee approved the Clean Energy Jobs and American Power Act, a comprehensive bill establishing a cap-and-trade system for greenhouse gas emissions, though it failed to advance beyond committee in the full Senate due to partisan opposition.[36] She sponsored the Children's Environmental Protection Act (S. 1112) in 1999, directing the Environmental Protection Agency to integrate children's health risks into regulatory decisions, but the bill did not become law.[39] As part of broader environmental efforts, Boxer contributed to designating over 1 million acres of California wilderness through legislation like the California Desert Protection Act extensions, prioritizing habitat preservation amid development pressures.[4] In water infrastructure, Boxer co-led the bipartisan Water Resources Reform and Development Act of 2014 (S. 601), which expedited Army Corps of Engineers projects, reformed permitting processes, and authorized harbor maintenance funding to enhance port competitiveness; the measure was signed into law as Public Law 113-121.[40] She also authored clean water bills targeting pollutants in drinking supplies and supported amendments strengthening the Clean Water Act against industrial discharges.[2] On education and youth support, Boxer initiated the 21st Century Community Learning Centers program, securing the first federal appropriations for afterschool initiatives in the Elementary and Secondary Education Act reauthorization, which by 2016 served over 1.7 million children annually with academic and enrichment services.[4] This effort aimed to reduce juvenile crime and improve outcomes for low-income students through extended learning opportunities.[41] In national security, Boxer sponsored the United States-Israel Enhanced Security Cooperation Act (S. 2165) in 2012, which formalized joint military exercises, intelligence sharing, and missile defense funding, and was enacted as Public Law 112-150 to bolster strategic alliances. She introduced the Article 32 Reform Act (S. 1644) in 2013 to overhaul preliminary hearings in the military justice system, enhancing victim protections in sexual assault cases, though it merged into broader defense reforms.[42] Boxer advocated for consumer protections, including legislation mandating "dolphin-safe" tuna labeling under the Marine Mammal Protection Act amendments, which reduced incidental dolphin deaths in fishing by over 97% from 1986 levels after implementation.[43] She also pushed the Genetically Engineered Food Right-to-Know Act (S. 511) in 2015 for mandatory GMO labeling, highlighting transparency concerns, but the bill stalled amid industry opposition.[44]Political positions and record
Economic and fiscal policies
Barbara Boxer consistently advocated for progressive taxation, opposing reductions in rates for high-income earners and corporations while supporting increases targeted at the wealthy to fund social programs and reduce deficits. In 2007, she voted in favor of raising the marginal income tax rate to 39.6% for individuals earning over $1 million annually.[45] She opposed indexing the estate tax exemption to inflation and raising its threshold to $5 million for couples, arguing such measures disproportionately benefited the affluent at the expense of public revenues.[45] Boxer also rejected alternative minimum tax (AMT) relief without corresponding budget offsets, prioritizing fiscal balance over immediate taxpayer relief.[45] On corporate taxes, Boxer supported repealing subsidies for companies outsourcing U.S. jobs, viewing them as incentives that undermined domestic employment and wage growth.[45] She co-sponsored the 2013 Climate Protection Act with Sen. Bernie Sanders, proposing a carbon tax on fossil fuels to internalize environmental costs, though analyses projected it would raise energy prices, reduce household incomes by up to $300 annually, and eliminate thousands of jobs in energy-dependent sectors without significantly curbing global emissions.[46] In a departure from strict progressivism, she joined Sen. Rand Paul in 2015 to propose a temporary repatriation tax holiday at a 6.5% rate on overseas corporate profits to finance highway infrastructure, aiming to boost domestic investment and create jobs, though critics argued it would not generate sufficient long-term revenue and could encourage future offshoring.[47][48] Regarding federal spending and deficits, Boxer favored expansive fiscal policies, including opposition to bankruptcy reforms that imposed means-testing on filers, which she saw as punitive to debtors amid economic hardship. She endorsed the 1993 Deficit Reduction Act under President Clinton, which combined spending restraint with tax increases on upper brackets to achieve surpluses by the late 1990s.[49] During the 2008 financial crisis, she voted for the Emergency Economic Stabilization Act, authorizing $700 billion in TARP funds for bank bailouts to stabilize credit markets. In 2010, despite reservations about extending Bush-era tax cuts—which she attributed to rising deficits—she supported a compromise package including payroll tax reductions and unemployment benefits extensions, citing fragile job growth as justification.[50][51] Boxer opposed the 2013 sequester's automatic cuts, advocating revenue enhancements from high earners over reductions in discretionary spending, which a National Taxpayers Union Foundation analysis of her platform indicated would expand the federal budget rather than constrain it.[52][53] Her record reflects a preference for demand-side stimulus and infrastructure investment to drive growth, as evidenced by her push for long-term highway funding bills in 2015.[54]Foreign policy and national security
Boxer served on the United States Senate Committee on Foreign Relations from 2001 to 2017, rising to become a senior member and chair of the Subcommittee on International Operations and Organizations, Democracy, Human Rights, and Global Women's Issues, the first such subcommittee focused on global women's concerns.[55] In this capacity, she advocated for international human rights, including co-introducing the International Violence Against Women Act in 2015 to address gender-based violence abroad through diplomatic and development aid.[56] Following the September 11, 2001, terrorist attacks, Boxer supported enhanced domestic security measures, authoring legislation to deploy federal air marshals on high-risk commercial flights and advocating for bolstered protections at ports, chemical facilities, and nuclear plants.[57] She voted in favor of creating the Department of Homeland Security in November 2002 to consolidate federal counterterrorism efforts, though in a 2020 reflection, she expressed regret over the vote citing subsequent politicization under later administrations.[58] On military engagements, Boxer opposed the Iraq War, casting one of 23 Senate votes against the Authorization for Use of Military Force Against Iraq Resolution (H.J. Res. 114) on October 11, 2002, arguing that war should be a last resort absent compelling evidence of imminent threat and criticizing the Bush administration's intelligence assessments on weapons of mass destruction.[59] [60] In contrast, she backed operations in Afghanistan, supporting a 1999 Senate resolution condemning the Taliban regime for human rights abuses and endorsing the post-9/11 Authorization for Use of Military Force that targeted al-Qaeda. Regarding Israel, Boxer consistently supported U.S. aid and a two-state solution, rejecting comparisons of Israeli policies to apartheid as "ridiculous" in 2014 and co-sponsoring measures to strengthen bilateral security ties.[61] [62] Boxer prioritized nuclear non-proliferation, voting against legislation enabling civilian nuclear cooperation with India in 2006 due to concerns over proliferation risks and supporting multilateral efforts to curb Iran's program through sanctions.[45] She backed comprehensive sanctions legislation like the 2010 Comprehensive Iran Sanctions, Accountability, and Divestment Act and, in 2015, co-sponsored a bipartisan bill with Senator Rand Paul for conditional sanctions tied to nuclear negotiations rather than immediate escalation.[63] Ultimately, she endorsed the Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action (JCPOA) in August 2015, viewing it as a diplomatic tool to verifiably limit Iran's nuclear capabilities in exchange for phased sanctions relief.[64]Environmental and energy stances
Barbara Boxer consistently advocated for stringent environmental protections during her Senate tenure, earning a 91% lifetime score from the League of Conservation Voters for supporting measures on air, water, land, and wildlife conservation.[65] She secured federal designation for over 1 million acres of wilderness in California to preserve natural habitats and worked to expand protections for areas like Berryessa Snow Mountain and the John Muir National Historic Site.[4] [66] As chair of the Senate Environment and Public Works Committee from 2007 to 2015, Boxer prioritized enforcing existing environmental laws while pushing legislation to address climate change, though critics from energy sectors argued her approach imposed regulatory burdens that hindered economic growth in fossil fuel-dependent regions.[36] [67] On energy policy, Boxer strongly opposed expanded fossil fuel extraction, including new offshore oil drilling along California's coast, citing risks to marine ecosystems and coastal economies.[68] She voted against approving the Keystone XL pipeline in multiple Senate sessions, arguing it would exacerbate climate change by facilitating tar sands oil transport and increase health risks from emissions, with studies linking such projects to higher incidences of respiratory and cardiovascular issues in nearby communities.[69] [70] [71] In 2009, as committee chair, she advanced the American Clean Energy and Security Act, which included cap-and-trade provisions to limit carbon emissions by auctioning allowances to polluters, aiming to reduce greenhouse gases by 17% below 2005 levels by 2020; the measure passed her committee but stalled in the full Senate amid concerns over higher energy costs for consumers and manufacturers.[36] [72] Boxer co-sponsored the 2013 Climate Protection Act with Senator Bernie Sanders, proposing a carbon fee on emissions to fund rebates while empowering the EPA to regulate methane and other pollutants, a move Heritage Foundation analysts contended would stifle hydraulic fracturing's contributions to U.S. energy independence by raising compliance costs without verifiable reductions in global emissions.[67] She supported mandatory disclosure of fracking chemicals in energy bills to mitigate groundwater contamination risks, aligning with calls for transparency in unconventional drilling practices that had surged in the 2000s.[73] In 2010, Boxer backed amendments affirming human contributions to climate change, joining 15 Republicans in a non-binding resolution, though empirical data on attribution remains debated, with satellite records showing modest warming trends amid natural variability factors like solar cycles and ocean oscillations.[74] Her record reflects a preference for regulatory interventions over market-driven energy transitions, prioritizing emission reductions over short-term affordability, as evidenced by her resistance to bills diluting EPA authority over greenhouse gases.[75]Social and cultural issues
Boxer maintained consistently liberal positions on social and cultural issues throughout her congressional career, emphasizing expansive individual rights in areas such as reproduction, firearms regulation, and same-sex partnerships. Her voting record and legislative sponsorship reflected opposition to traditional restrictions, prioritizing what she described as protections for personal autonomy against governmental or societal interference.[45] On abortion, Boxer identified as pro-choice and served as a leading defender of unrestricted access, voting against federal bans and partial-birth abortion prohibitions. In 1997, during Senate debate on the Partial-Birth Abortion Ban Act, she argued that such measures would criminalize doctors and endanger women's health, equating them to pre-Roe v. Wade conditions.[76] She co-sponsored and advocated for the Freedom of Choice Act, introduced in 2007, which sought to codify Roe v. Wade by barring states or federal policies from interfering with pre-viability abortions or those necessary for maternal health.[77] [78] Boxer opposed the 2003 Partial-Birth Abortion Ban Act, one of 16 senators to vote against it, maintaining that late-term procedures were rare medical necessities rather than elective.[79] Her stance drew criticism for extending to procedures critics labeled as extreme, though she framed them as essential to avoiding back-alley risks.[80] [81] Boxer advocated stringent gun control measures, consistently earning low ratings from Second Amendment groups for her support of bans on certain firearms and ammunition. She voted for the 1994 Violent Crime Control and Law Enforcement Act, which prohibited the manufacture and possession of semiautomatic assault weapons and large-capacity magazines.[82] In 2013, she backed the Manchin-Toomey amendment to expand background checks on firearm purchases, though it failed cloture. Later, in 2016, Boxer supported prohibiting high-capacity magazines exceeding 10 rounds and endorsed legislation designating June as National Gun Violence Awareness Month.[83] The NRA assigned her an "F" rating, citing her opposition to concealed carry reciprocity and allowances for firearms in checked baggage.[83] [84] In LGBTQ matters, Boxer endorsed same-sex marriage as conferring full equality and opposed federal or state-level bans. She voted against the Defense of Marriage Act in 1996 and, following California's 2008 Proposition 8, pledged continued opposition to restrictions on gay unions, stating the fight for equality persisted.[45] [85] An early opponent of the military's "Don't Ask, Don't Tell" policy, she co-sponsored its 2010 repeal and backed expansions of hate crimes laws to include sexual orientation under the Matthew Shepard Act.[86] The Human Rights Campaign praised her record, noting consistent advocacy from the 1990s onward.[86] Boxer also championed women's rights legislation beyond reproduction, co-sponsoring reauthorizations of the Violence Against Women Act to enhance protections against domestic abuse and sexual violence. Her efforts included pushing for equal pay measures and clinic access laws, such as the 1994 Freedom of Access to Clinic Entrances Act, which she helped pass to curb anti-abortion protests.[45] [4] These positions aligned with her broader emphasis on gender equity, though critics from conservative outlets argued they advanced expansive federal intervention over state or familial prerogatives.[87]Controversies and criticisms
2000 and 2004 election objections
In the certification of the 2000 presidential election results during the joint session of Congress on January 6, 2001, Senator Barbara Boxer did not join House Democrats' attempts to object to Florida's 25 electoral votes, which proved decisive in George W. Bush's victory over Al Gore. Under the Electoral Count Act of 1887, a valid objection requires support from at least one senator and one representative, and without senatorial backing, Vice President Gore ruled the proposed objections out of order, allowing certification to proceed 267-0 for Florida after brief procedural disruptions. Boxer later expressed regret for not participating in a formal challenge, stating in 2005 that she wished she had acted to force debate on Florida's voting irregularities, including ballot design flaws and recount disputes resolved by the Supreme Court's Bush v. Gore decision on December 12, 2000.[88] For the 2004 election, Boxer took a more active role by partnering with Representative Stephanie Tubbs Jones on January 6, 2005, to file the first formal senatorial objection to a state's electors since 1969, targeting Ohio's 20 votes due to alleged systemic disenfranchisement. The objection cited documented issues including hours-long lines at polling places, disproportionate impacts on urban and minority voters, voting machine malfunctions in Democratic-leaning areas, and provisional ballot rejections, which purportedly suppressed turnout favoring John Kerry; Boxer submitted supporting evidence from over 30,000 pages of affidavits and reports compiled by election monitors.[89] [90] This triggered a two-hour debate in each chamber, the first such interruption in over a century, during which Boxer argued the process exposed flaws in Ohio Secretary of State J. Kenneth Blackwell's administration of the election, though she clarified the goal was reform rather than reversal, as Bush led Kerry by 118,601 votes statewide.[91] The Senate voted 74-1 to sustain Ohio's votes, with Boxer dissenting; the House approved 344-31.[89] Subsequent reviews, including a bipartisan commission and federal inquiries, confirmed operational problems like understaffed precincts and equipment shortages but found no widespread fraud or errors altering the outcome, attributing most disparities to administrative failures rather than intentional suppression. Boxer's action drew criticism from Republicans as partisan theater, given the certified results and lack of court-upheld reversals, while Democrats viewed it as a necessary spotlight on vulnerabilities later addressed in reforms like the Help America Vote Act expansions. In 2020 reflections, Boxer distinguished her evidence-based objection from contemporaneous Republican challenges, emphasizing focus on verified irregularities over unsubstantiated claims.[92]Iraq War opposition and aftermath
On October 11, 2002, Boxer voted against the Authorization for Use of Military Force Against Iraq Resolution (H.J. Res. 114), joining 22 other senators in opposition to the measure that authorized President George W. Bush to use military force against Iraq.[59] She defended the vote by arguing that war should be a last resort, citing her prior support for force in Kosovo and after the September 11 attacks, while accusing the Bush administration of timing the debate for electoral gain ahead of the midterm elections.[60] In subsequent years, Boxer described the decision as one of her proudest senatorial moments, particularly after intelligence failures regarding Iraq's weapons of mass destruction (WMDs) became evident.[93] Following the March 2003 invasion, Boxer emerged as a vocal critic of the Bush administration's Iraq policy, emphasizing the absence of WMDs and alleging that pre-war intelligence had been exaggerated to justify the conflict. During Condoleezza Rice's January 2005 confirmation hearing as Secretary of State, Boxer challenged Rice's pre-invasion statements on WMD threats, suggesting that loyalty to the president and the war effort had overridden fidelity to accurate intelligence, stating, "I personally believe—this is my personal view—that your loyalty to the mission, when it comes to the war in Iraq, has outweighed your loyalty to the truth."[94] Rice defended the policy by noting that the invasion addressed broader threats beyond WMDs, including Saddam Hussein's regime and support for terrorism, but Boxer maintained that the focus on Iraq diverted resources from core counterterrorism efforts against al-Qaeda.[95][96] In the war's middle years, Boxer criticized the administration for inadequate troop support and strategic missteps, arguing in a July 2005 speech that U.S. forces deserved better than the "status quo" amid rising casualties and instability.[97] She supported congressional efforts to condition funding on withdrawal timelines and, despite her opposition to the war's premise, voted for approximately 85% of Iraq-related supplemental appropriations to sustain troops, prioritizing their immediate needs over policy disagreements. By 2007, amid debates over President Bush's troop surge, Boxer pressed Rice on the electorate's demand for policy change after the 2006 midterms, where Iraq ranked as voters' top concern, and advocated for a phased redeployment to address what she termed the conflict's "hard realities."[98][99] Boxer's post-invasion stance extended to rejecting linkages between Iraq and the broader war on terrorism, as articulated in an August 2006 response to Bush's speeches, where she accused the president of using "scare tactics" to conflate the two and divert attention from al-Qaeda's resurgence. In June 2014, amid the rise of ISIS, she opposed reintroducing ground combat troops, aligning with President Obama's limited intervention strategy while criticizing former Vice President Dick Cheney's hawkish commentary as disconnected from the war's costly aftermath, including over 4,400 U.S. military deaths and trillions in expenditures by official estimates. Boxer co-sponsored legislation that year to repeal the 2002 authorization, reflecting her view that the original mandate had outlived any legitimate purpose after the regime's fall and the failure to uncover stockpiles of WMDs.[100][101][93]Family and associate scandals
In 2018, an arbitration panel ruled that Douglas Boxer, son of Barbara Boxer and a political consultant and attorney, along with his business partner Darius Anderson, through their firm Kenwood Investments No. 2 LLC, committed fraud and breached fiduciary duties against the Federated Indians of Graton Rancheria, a California tribe developing a casino project.[102] [103] The panel of retired judges determined that the pair had sold the tribe undevelopable swamp land as part of a land acquisition deal and entered into undisclosed agreements with a Las Vegas gambling corporation, prioritizing personal gains over the tribe's interests, including Anderson's demand for $43 million in future casino revenues.[102] The tribe had paid approximately $1.2 million in fees to related entities like Platinum Advisors, controlled by Anderson, for consulting services tied to federal recognition and casino approvals.[102] The binding arbitration award, issued in April 2018 and upheld by Sonoma County Superior Court Judge Richard Ulmer on June 1, 2018, ordered Kenwood Investments to reimburse the tribe $725,657 for legal fees incurred due to the breaches, though the firm settled for an undisclosed lesser amount without appeal.[102] [103] No criminal charges were filed, and the findings were civil in nature, stemming from a contract dispute rather than prosecutorial action.[102] Douglas Boxer had previously faced scrutiny for his roles in his mother's reelection campaigns, including as a strategist and fundraiser, amid questions about potential conflicts in his parallel consulting work for clients like Indian tribes seeking federal aid. Boxer's daughter, Nicole Boxer, a film producer and former Democratic operative, was married to Tony Rodham—brother of Hillary Clinton—from 1994 to 2002; their divorce involved Rodham owing over $75,000 in unpaid child support as of 2007, though this remained a personal matter without direct ties to Barbara Boxer's public career.[104] No major scandals involving Boxer's husband, Stewart Boxer, a retired stockbroker, or other close associates were documented in public records.[9]Policy outcome evaluations
Boxer's opposition to the 2002 Authorization for Use of Military Force Against Iraq, which passed the Senate 77-23 with her among the 23 dissenters, aligned with subsequent empirical assessments of the war's failures. The conflict resulted in approximately 4,431 U.S. military deaths, over 32,000 wounded, and budgetary costs exceeding $1.79 trillion through ongoing operations, excluding future veterans' care projected to add trillions more. Regional instability fostered the rise of ISIS, with Iraq's government benchmarks showing minimal progress on key security and governance metrics by 2007. Analyses attribute the invasion's high human and economic toll to flawed intelligence on weapons of mass destruction and underestimation of post-invasion challenges, validating Boxer's vote against as prescient in hindsight, though her rationale emphasized insufficient UN inspections rather than outright pacifism.[105][106] On social policies, Boxer's support for reauthorizations of the Violence Against Women Act (VAWA), originally enacted in 1994 during her House tenure and extended multiple times under her Senate influence, correlated with measurable reductions in gender-based violence. Intimate partner violence against females declined 53% from 9.4 victimizations per 1,000 in 1993 to 4.4 in 2008, while rapes and sexual assaults fell 56% post-VAWA implementation. The law's funding for hotlines, shelters, and prosecutions—handling over 7 million hotline calls since 1996—facilitated victim services and offender accountability, though critics note persistent underreporting and debate over mandatory arrest policies' effects on dual arrests. CAPTA reauthorizations, which Boxer championed to enhance child abuse prevention and treatment, authorized research and grants but yielded mixed results, with child maltreatment rates stabilizing rather than declining sharply, per federal data.[107][108][109] Environmental initiatives led by Boxer, such as the 2009 Kerry-Boxer Clean Energy Jobs and American Power Act, failed to pass the Senate, averting projected economic disruptions estimated at $9.9 trillion in lost GDP, over 2.5 million job losses, and $4.6 trillion in higher energy taxes by models from conservative analysts. Her co-sponsorship of earlier carbon tax proposals, like the 2007 Boxer-Sanders bill, drew criticism for empowering EPA discretion in rate adjustments, potentially stifling energy production amid rising U.S. output from fracking. Attributable successes include bipartisan HIV/AIDS funding via the 2007 Smith-Boxer amendment, aiding global treatment access, but broader climate pushes mirrored stalled federal efforts, with California's aligned cap-and-trade yielding 13% emissions cuts since 2013 at the cost of elevated electricity prices (up 20-30% in some utilities). Empirical causal links to Boxer's specific bills remain limited due to non-passage or confounding factors like technological shifts.[110][67] Healthcare advocacy, including Boxer's 2014 report highlighting medical errors as the third leading cause of U.S. deaths (up to 440,000 annually) and pushes for patient safety via electronic health records, prompted hospital surveys but lacked direct legislative breakthroughs. Her support for the Affordable Care Act expanded coverage to 20 million by 2016, reducing uninsured rates from 16% to 8.8%, yet premiums rose 105% for individual markets (2013-2017), and empirical studies show no significant mortality reductions in expansion states versus non-expansion. Efforts like the 21st Century Women's Health Act aimed to bolster access but stalled, reflecting broader partisan gridlock on outcomes like malpractice caps, which Boxer opposed in California initiatives.[111]Post-Senate activities (2017–present)
Lobbying and advisory roles
Following her retirement from the U.S. Senate in January 2017, Boxer served as a paid advisor to Lyft, where she advocated against California Assembly Bill 5, a 2019 measure aimed at reclassifying gig economy workers as employees, arguing it would harm ride-sharing innovation.[112] In January 2020, Boxer joined Mercury Public Affairs, a bipartisan Washington, D.C.-based lobbying and public affairs firm, as co-chairwoman, providing strategic advice to corporate clients such as Airbnb and AT&T, as well as foreign governments, without registering as a lobbyist under federal disclosure rules.[113][114] Her role leveraged her Senate experience in environment, foreign policy, and women's issues to counsel on policy navigation and public strategy.[115] Boxer resigned from Mercury in October 2021 amid internal financial disputes that prompted an exodus of senior figures, including former politicians Fabian Nuñez and Antonio Villaraigosa.[116][117] In early January 2021, while at Mercury, Boxer briefly registered under the Foreign Agents Registration Act (FARA) to represent Hikvision USA, a subsidiary of the Chinese state-linked surveillance technology firm Hikvision, which the U.S. government has sanctioned for enabling human rights abuses against Uyghur Muslims in Xinjiang through mass monitoring technology.[118][119] She deregistered after four days following public backlash, including scrutiny over the firm's ties to Chinese government repression.[120][121] The incident led the Biden inaugural committee to return a $2,800 donation from Boxer.[120] Post-resignation from Mercury, Boxer has continued consulting for private clients on political and policy matters, though specific engagements remain undisclosed in public filings.[122]Public speaking and media appearances
Following her retirement from the U.S. Senate in January 2017, Barbara Boxer has pursued public speaking engagements, often through representation by agencies such as AAE Speakers Bureau, CAA Speakers, and Harry Walker Agency, focusing on topics including women's leadership, environmental advocacy, education, and Democratic politics.[123][124][125] These appearances typically emphasize her experiences in Congress and calls for progressive policy action, with Boxer traveling from her California base for corporate events, keynotes, and personal addresses.[123] In academic and institutional settings, Boxer delivered the keynote address for California State University, Fullerton's Humanities and Social Sciences Week on March 20, 2017, where she urged students to engage actively in politics amid national uncertainties following the 2016 election.[126] She has been associated with the Barbara Boxer Lecture Series at UC Berkeley's Institute of Governmental Studies, which she inaugurated in spring 2017 with reflections on the election; the series continued annually, featuring her in discussions on women in public service, such as a planned 2025 conversation highlighting female leadership roles.[127][128] Boxer has maintained visibility in media through interviews on political developments, including a 2020 Spectrum News appearance critiquing then-President Trump and assessing California's Senate dynamics during the Democratic National Convention.[129] In September 2023, following the death of former colleague Dianne Feinstein, she provided tributes and personal anecdotes in multiple outlets, emphasizing Feinstein's legislative legacy on issues like gun control and intelligence.[130][131] More recently, in September 2025, as a senior advisor to the Seneca Project, Boxer commented on potential Trump administration actions against former FBI Director James Comey, framing them within broader concerns over democratic norms.[132] These appearances underscore her role as a post-Senate commentator on partisan battles and institutional integrity, drawing on her 34 years in Congress.[133]Personal security incident
On July 26, 2021, Barbara Boxer, aged 80, was assaulted and robbed near her apartment in Oakland's Jack London Square neighborhood.[134] [135] An assailant approached from behind, pushed her to the ground, seized her cell phone, and fled in a waiting getaway car.[136] [137] Boxer sustained no serious injuries and later recounted the event as sudden and shocking, noting she had noticed two men nearby moments earlier but did not anticipate the attack.[138] The incident drew public attention due to Boxer's prominence and the brazen nature of the daytime robbery in a public area, prompting statements from California district attorneys expressing frustration over rising urban crime rates and prosecutorial challenges.[139] No arrests were reported in immediate follow-up coverage, and the Oakland Police Department initially declined to confirm specifics pending investigation.[140] [141]Writings and public communications
Authored books
Barbara Boxer authored two books during her career: a non-fiction work on women's political advancement and a memoir reflecting on her public service. Her first book, Strangers in the Senate: Politics and the New Revolution of Women in America, published in 1994 by National Press Books, chronicles the 1992 "Year of the Woman" elections, including Boxer's own Senate campaign, and addresses challenges faced by female politicians such as sexual harassment and institutional barriers.[142] The narrative draws from her personal experiences, emphasizing the increasing influence of women in U.S. politics amid a wave of female candidates winning congressional seats that year.[143] In 2016, Boxer released The Art of Tough: Fearlessly Facing Politics and Life, a memoir published by Hachette Books on May 31, detailing her congressional tenure, key legislative battles, and lessons in resilience drawn from decades in office.[144] The book highlights her advocacy for issues like women's rights and environmental protection, framing political toughness as essential for advancing family-oriented policies.[145] It spans 288 pages and received attention for its candid recounting of partisan struggles and personal motivations.[146]Notable statements and speeches
During her January 28, 1993, maiden speech on the Senate floor, Boxer emphasized her commitment to environmental protection, campaign finance reform, and support for working families, stating that she entered politics to address everyday concerns like clean air and education funding rather than partisan gridlock.[147] In a contentious exchange during Condoleezza Rice's January 18, 2005, confirmation hearing for Secretary of State, Boxer challenged Rice's pre-Iraq War assertions on weapons of mass destruction, remarking, "I personally do not believe that this Administration has told the truth" about the threat posed by Saddam Hussein, and pressed Rice on inconsistencies between 2002 intelligence briefings and public statements. Rice defended her assessments as based on available intelligence at the time. Boxer further noted that while Rice bore personal responsibility, "so do all of the parents of the soldiers who are dying," prompting Rice to respond that her role did not grant exemption from scrutiny and that she spoke for all Americans, including military families; the remarks drew rebukes from some Republicans for implying differential personal stakes in the war.[148][99] On June 30, 2011, in a Senate floor speech opposing a balanced budget amendment, Boxer argued against constitutional constraints on spending, asserting, "Let's not talk about a balanced budget amendment to the Constitution. Let's talk about doing the hard work of balancing the budget," and advocated for higher taxes on high earners to fund priorities like infrastructure and Social Security without cutting essential programs.[51] In her December 7, 2016, farewell address after 34 years in Congress, Boxer warned of existential risks from inaction on climate change, declaring, "We must take action on climate change or we are in deep trouble as humankind," while calling for protections for immigrants, reproductive rights, and democratic norms amid rising partisanship.[149]Personal life
Marriage and family
Barbara Boxer married Stewart Boxer, an attorney, in 1962 while completing her bachelor's degree in economics at Brooklyn College.[150][151] The couple relocated from New York to Greenbrae in Marin County, California, in 1965, where they raised their family.[1] They had two children: a son, Douglas, and a daughter, Nicole, born on November 16, 1967.[17][152] Stewart Boxer maintained a low public profile throughout his wife's political career, focusing on his legal practice.[26] Nicole Boxer pursued a career in film production and documentary filmmaking, while Douglas Boxer has remained largely out of the public eye.[153] The family resided in the San Francisco Bay Area during Boxer's rises to local, congressional, and senatorial offices.[150]Later years and health
Following her retirement from the U.S. Senate on January 3, 2017, Boxer resided in the Jack London Square neighborhood of Oakland, California, where she pursued a more personal lifestyle while maintaining involvement in select political endorsements and commentary.[138] [154] On July 26, 2021, at age 80, Boxer was assaulted from behind and robbed of her cellphone by an unknown assailant near her Oakland apartment; the perpetrator fled in a waiting vehicle, and police later tracked the device to San Francisco.[138] [134] [135] She reported no serious injuries from the incident.[155] [137] As of July 2025, at age 84, Boxer continued public activities, including endorsing Democratic congressional candidate Katherine Aleman for California's 41st district.[156] No major health conditions have been publicly reported in her post-Senate years.[154]Electoral history
U.S. House elections
Barbara Boxer was elected to the United States House of Representatives in the 1982 midterm elections, representing California's 6th congressional district from January 3, 1983, until her transition to the Senate in 1993. The district, centered in Marin County and parts of Contra Costa County, had been redrawn after the 1980 census, incorporating more Democratic-leaning areas that facilitated her victory over Republican incumbent John Rousselot.[1] Boxer was reelected four times with increasing margins in general elections against Republican opponents. In the 1984 election, she defeated Douglas Binderup, receiving 162,511 votes.[157] Her 1986 reelection saw strong support in the district, with Democratic votes totaling 204,667 in the 6th district race.[158] In 1988, Boxer won against William Steinmetz, garnering 176,645 votes.[159] She secured her final House term in 1990 before pursuing a Senate bid.[1]| Election Year | Opponent | Boxer's Votes | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1984 | Douglas Binderup (R) | 162,511 | [157] |
| 1986 | (R) | District Democratic: 204,667 | [158] |
| 1988 | William Steinmetz (R) | 176,645 | [159] |
U.S. Senate elections
In the 1992 United States Senate election in California, Boxer, a three-term U.S. Representative, secured the Democratic nomination in the June primary before defeating Republican nominee Bruce Herschensohn in the November general election for the full-term seat vacated by retiring Senator Alan Cranston.[160][161] Boxer received 5,173,467 votes (47.90%), while Herschensohn obtained 4,644,182 votes (43.00%), with the remainder split among minor candidates; the contest, part of the "Year of the Woman" wave, narrowed in the final days after Herschensohn acknowledged attending a bachelor party featuring topless dancers, eroding his lead in polls.[161][28] Boxer won re-election in 1998 against State Treasurer Matt Fong, overcoming early polling deficits amid a national Republican midterm advantage; she garnered approximately 53.8% of the vote to Fong's 41.5% in the November 3 contest.[162][163][31] The 2004 election saw Boxer defeat Republican Secretary of State Bill Jones by a wide margin on November 2, capturing 6,955,728 votes (57.71%) to Jones's 4,555,922 (37.80%), buoyed by high Democratic turnout in a presidential year and Jones's struggles to consolidate conservative support.[164][165] In 2010, amid a Republican national surge, Boxer narrowly retained her seat against business executive Carly Fiorina on November 2, securing 5,218,441 votes (52.18%) to Fiorina's 4,217,366 (42.17%); the race featured heavy spending and attacks on Boxer's legislative record versus Fiorina's corporate tenure at Hewlett-Packard.[166][167][168]| Election Year | Candidate | Party | Votes | Percentage |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1992 | Barbara Boxer | Democratic | 5,173,467 | 47.90% [161] |
| Bruce Herschensohn | Republican | 4,644,182 | 43.00% [161] | |
| 1998 | Barbara Boxer (incumbent) | Democratic | (Totals in county PDF) | ~53.8% [162] |
| Matt Fong | Republican | (Totals in county PDF) | ~41.5% [162] | |
| 2004 | Barbara Boxer (incumbent) | Democratic | 6,955,728 | 57.71% [164] |
| Bill Jones | Republican | 4,555,922 | 37.80% [164] | |
| 2010 | Barbara Boxer (incumbent) | Democratic | 5,218,441 | 52.18% [166] |
| Carly Fiorina | Republican | 4,217,366 | 42.17% [166] |