Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Bilge Qaghan

Bilge Qaghan (c. 683–734 CE) was the fourth khagan of the Second Turkic Khaganate, ruling the Eastern Turkic Khaganate from 716 until his death by poisoning.^[1] The son of Elteris Qaghan, he ascended to power amid a period of decline following subjugation by the Tang dynasty of China and internal fragmentation.^[2] Supported by his brother Kül Tigin, a prominent military commander, and the advisor Tonyukuk, Bilge Qaghan led extensive military campaigns—numbering up to 25, with 13 decisive battles—to subdue rebellious tribes such as the Uighurs, Khitans, and Karluks, while repelling incursions from China and its allies.^[1]^[2] These efforts culminated in a peace treaty with the Tang in 721, restoring the khaganate's sovereignty and fostering economic recovery and population growth among the Turkic peoples.^[1] His reign marked a cultural assertion of independence, resisting Chinese influence through policies that preserved nomadic traditions and Turkic identity.^[1] Bilge Qaghan's most enduring legacy lies in the Orkhon inscriptions, runic stelae erected in the Orkhon Valley of Mongolia, which chronicle his achievements, emphasize unity and wise governance, and represent the earliest substantial written records in any Turkic language.^[2]

Background

Names and Titles

Bilge Qaghan's personal name, as recorded in Tang dynasty Chinese annals, was Ashina Mojilian (阿史那默棘連).^[3] Upon ascending the throne in 716 CE, he adopted the regnal title Bilge Qaghan (Old Turkic: 𐰋𐰃𐰠𐰏𐰀:𐰴𐰍𐰣, romanized: Bilgä qaγan; Chinese: 毗伽可汗, Píjiā kěhàn), literally meaning "Wise Khagan," a designation highlighting his strategic acumen and leadership in restoring Turkic sovereignty.^[3] The Orkhon inscriptions, primary sources from his era, elaborate this title in the opening lines of his stele: "Tengri teg tengride bolmış Türk Bilge Kagan," rendered as "Heaven-like, in heaven born Turkic Wise Khagan," invoking divine origins tied to Tengrism and the Ashina clan's celestial mandate.^[4] This full epithet underscores his self-proclaimed role as a ruler ordained by Tengri (the sky god) to unify and elevate the Turkic peoples, distinguishing it from mere hereditary succession.^[1] Occasionally, variant forms like Arslan Bilgä Khağan appear in historical compilations, incorporating "Arslan" (lion) to denote martial prowess, though the core Bilge Qaghan prevailed in contemporary records.^[3]

Early Life and Family Origins

Bilge Qaghan, also known as Ashina Mojilian, was born in 683 during the initial consolidation of the Second Turkic Khaganate under his uncle Ilteriş Qaghan, who had re-established Turkic rule in 682 after decades of Tang Chinese dominance.^[5] He was the son of Qapaghan Qaghan, who succeeded Ilteriş in 692 and expanded the khaganate's territory through relentless campaigns against neighboring tribes and Chinese forces.^[6] Bilge belonged to the Ashina clan, the hereditary ruling dynasty of the Göktürks originating from the Altai Mountains region, where the clan had risen to prominence in the 6th century by uniting Turkic tribes under Bumin Qaghan.^[7] From early childhood, Bilge accompanied his father on military expeditions, gaining practical experience in steppe warfare and tribal diplomacy amid the khaganate's efforts to subdue groups like the Tardush, Oghuz, and Karluks. By his early teens, around age 14, he was appointed shad (viceroy or prince) over the Tardush tribes in the western territories, a position that involved commanding forces and administering subject peoples to prevent rebellions.^[6] His younger brother Kül Tigin (born c. 684), a skilled warrior and close advisor, shared in these formative campaigns, forging a partnership that later proved crucial to the khaganate's stability; another brother, Inel, briefly succeeded Qapaghan but was deposed in a coup led by Bilge, Kül Tigin, and the advisor Tonyukuk.^[8] These early roles honed Bilge's strategic acumen, rooted in the Ashina clan's emphasis on martial prowess and Tengrist divine mandate for rule.

Rise to Power

Service Under Predecessors

Bilge Qaghan, born in 683, began his military service under his father, Ilterish Qaghan (r. 682–692), participating in campaigns from childhood to revive Turkic independence after Tang suzerainty.^[5] These early expeditions focused on consolidating eastern Turkic tribes and resisting Chinese influence, laying the foundation for the Second Turkic Khaganate's resurgence. After Ilterish's death in 692, Bilge served his uncle Qapaghan Qaghan (r. 692–716), whose reign marked the khaganate's territorial peak through aggressive expansions. In 697, Qapaghan appointed Bilge as Tardush Shad, entrusting him with command of the western territories to counter threats from groups like the Türgesh and Karluks. Under Qapaghan, Bilge led or supported key operations, including a 700 campaign against the Tanguts that yielded victories, captives, and spoils, strengthening Turkic control over southern steppe fringes.^[1] By 701–703, Bilge and his brother Kul Tigin subdued rebellious Basmyl tribes, reintegrating them into the khaganate. He decisively defeated the Türgesh at the Battle of Bolchu, slaying their khagan Suoge, and joined forces in the 707 Battle of Ming Sha against Tang armies. From 710, amid mounting internal revolts by Uighurs, Basmyls, and others, Bilge conducted intensive campaigns—up to four major battles annually by 714—to suppress dissent and preserve Qapaghan's authority.^[1] These efforts, documented in contemporary accounts, highlighted Bilge's tactical prowess and role in staving off fragmentation until Qapaghan's fatal 716 expedition against the Toquz Oghuz.

Ascension and Consolidation

Bilge Qaghan ascended to the throne as qaghan of the Second Turkic Khaganate in 716 CE, immediately following the death of his uncle Kapagan Qaghan, whose rule had expanded the realm but left it vulnerable to internal fragmentation upon his demise.^[9] At the time, the khaganate faced severe disarray, with provincial tribes in open rebellion and Tang Chinese forces exploiting the power vacuum to incite further unrest among subject peoples.^[1] To secure his position, Bilge Qaghan, then in his early thirties, relied heavily on his younger brother Kül Tigin for military leadership and the seasoned advisor Tonyukuk for strategic counsel; together, they eliminated rival claimants, including Kapagan's sons, who posed immediate threats to the Ashina clan's dominance.^[1] This decisive action prevented a full collapse, as Bilge declared himself qaghan, drawing on his prior experience as Tardush Shad commanding the western territories since around 697 CE under Kapagan's appointment.^[10] Consolidation involved rapid campaigns against rebelling Tölös tribes and other nomadic groups in the eastern steppe, restoring unity to the khaganate's divided wings by 717–718 CE and reasserting control over key territories in Mongolia and Central Asia.^[10] These efforts, chronicled in the contemporary Orkhon inscriptions commissioned by Bilge himself, emphasized the restoration of Turkic sovereignty against external manipulations, marking the beginning of an eighteen-year period of relative stability under his rule.^[4]

Reign and Achievements

Military Campaigns

Bilge Qaghan's military campaigns during his reign (716–734) emphasized the unification of fractious Turkic tribes, defense against Tang dynasty expansion, and suppression of rival steppe confederations, thereby restoring the Second Turkic Khaganate's dominance in Mongolia and surrounding regions.^[1] His forces, often led by his brother Kul Tigin as supreme commander, numbered in the tens of thousands and employed mobile cavalry tactics suited to the steppe, achieving decisive victories through rapid strikes and exploitation of enemy divisions.^[11] These efforts are detailed in the Orkhon inscriptions, where Bilge Qaghan recounts personally directing operations from age 19 onward, though formal command began upon his ascension following Qapaghan Qaghan's death in 716.^[1] In 716–717, immediately after consolidating power by eliminating rival claimant Bogu Qaghan with Kul Tigin's aid, Bilge Qaghan launched offensives against the Karluks and Tokuz Oghuz tribes at locations including Tamag, Togu, Antargu, and Chush mountain, defeating them and incorporating survivors into his realm to bolster manpower.^[11] These victories secured the eastern flanks and prevented fragmentation amid Tang-supported revolts. By 717, campaigns extended to the Togyz Oghuz nomads, resulting in the capture of prisoners, followed by an assault on the Tatab in Katerin forest, which neutralized immediate threats from Tang allies.^[1] The period 718–719 saw further consolidation, with Kul Tigin targeting Karluk and Tataby forces to fortify borders, then conquering the Basmyl near Besbalyk and plundering Hesi corridor territories, disrupting Tang supply lines and economic interests in East Turkestan.^[11] Escalation against the Tang peaked in 720–722, when Bilge Qaghan, advised by Tonyukuk, coordinated with Tibetan allies to defeat Tang armies and their vassals—including the Khitan, Tatab, and Basmyl—in multiple engagements; Tonyukuk's forces captured Bishbalik, advanced into Gansu, seized Lanzhou, and forced a Tang peace treaty in 721 after routing 17,000 enemy troops on the first day of one clash.^[12] ^[1] These campaigns expanded Turkic control westward and extracted tribute, with Bilge Qaghan's inscription boasting of subduing "eighty tribes" under his banner by 722.^[1] Subsequent years involved punitive expeditions against holdout groups like the Türgesh remnants and Kyrgyz, building on earlier successes under Qapaghan, though specifics taper in records after Kul Tigin's death in 731, which weakened command structure and invited Uighur incursions by 734.^[11] Overall, Bilge Qaghan's forces reportedly conducted over a dozen major operations, amassing spoils equivalent to thousands of sheep and horses annually, sustaining the khaganate's revival until internal strife and poison (suspected in his death) eroded gains.^[1]

Administrative Reforms

Bilge Qaghan implemented reforms focused on socio-economic upliftment and tribal unification to consolidate the Second Turkic Khaganate after periods of fragmentation. In his Orkhon inscription, he described initiating "many changes in the lives of the poor people" upon assuming power at age 19, resulting in numerous subjects transitioning from poverty to wealth and a marked increase in population through enhanced stability and resource distribution derived from military successes.^[4] These measures addressed the khaganate's vulnerabilities, where prior reliance on Chinese promises had led to enslavement and dispersal of Turkic forces, by prioritizing self-sufficiency and internal cohesion over foreign dependencies.^[4] Central to these efforts was the reinforcement of a centralized nomadic governance structure, drawing on ancestral traditions while adapting to contemporary threats. Bilge Qaghan, aided by advisors like Tonyukuk and his brother Kül Tigin, unified disparate groups such as the Tölis tribes and core Turkic clans under a single authority, enhancing administrative control over the steppe territories and Silk Road trade routes for economic leverage.^[10] This stabilization reversed the exodus of tribes that had abandoned the khaganate during instability, fostering a unified military-administrative system that emphasized merit-based leadership and vigilance against sedentarization influences, such as proposed urban development or Buddhist adoption, which Tonyukuk deemed incompatible with Turkic mobility and independence.^[10] Such reforms underscored a pragmatic adaptation of the khaganate's patriarchal-feudal framework, where the qaghan held supreme authority but delegated military and advisory roles to kin and proven loyalists to regulate tribal allegiances through both coercion and prosperity incentives.^[1] By rejecting emulative Chinese bureaucratic models in favor of indigenous principles—like equitable rule ("Türk bilge qagan" ideals of wisdom and justice)—Bilge ensured the regime's resilience amid external pressures, though enforcement often relied on military suppression of rebellious elements rather than formalized institutions.^[4]^[13]

Foreign Relations

Bilge Qaghan's foreign policy emphasized military subjugation of steppe rivals to secure dominance while engaging in pragmatic, trade-oriented diplomacy with the Tang Dynasty to extract material benefits without full submission. Under his rule from 716 to 734, he and his brother Kul Tigin led campaigns that subdued the Uighurs, Khitans, Karluks, Basmyls, and other tribes, restoring the khaganate's authority over fragmented nomadic groups that had rebelled during periods of weakness.^[1] These victories, detailed in the Orkhon inscriptions, prevented encirclement and ensured tribute flows from vassal peoples, prioritizing Turkic unity over expansive alliances.^[14] Relations with Tang China balanced warfare and negotiation, reflecting a strategy of exploiting Chinese wealth while guarding against cultural and political erosion. Early in his reign, Bilge conducted raids and battles against Tang forces, continuing conflicts inherited from his predecessor Qapaghan Khagan, including defeats of Tang armies numbering up to 80,000 in 705–710, though these predated his ascension.^[1] By 727, he formalized tributary exchanges, delivering nominal tribute of 30 horses for 100,000 bolts of silk, a transaction that prioritized economic gain over ideological submission.^[15] The Orkhon inscriptions articulate this caution, with Bilge warning that Chinese overtures—offering silk, food, and marriage alliances—served to weaken Turkic resolve, as "the Chinese give a girl and captivate the people" through dependency, yet he advocated measured engagement to acquire goods without adopting Chinese customs.^[14] Tang records corroborate this instrumental approach, noting Bilge's rejection of deeper integration, such as proposed marital ties used by Emperor Xuanzong as leverage rather than genuine alliance.^[15] Bilge avoided entanglements with other powers, notably declining overtures from the Tibetan Empire to jointly assault Tang borders, thereby preserving autonomy amid steppe-Tang-Tibetan rivalries. This selective isolationism, coupled with internal consolidation, sustained the khaganate until internal strife and Uighur-Karluk revolts eroded it post-734.^[1]

Cultural and Religious Policies

Promotion of Tengrism

Bilge Qaghan reinforced Tengrism as the core religious ideology of the Second Turkic Khaganate, deriving his legitimacy directly from Tengri, the supreme sky deity central to Turkic shamanistic beliefs. His full regnal title, as inscribed on the Orkhon steles erected between 716 and 735 CE, proclaimed him "Tengri-like and Tengri-born Turk Bilge Qaghan," emphasizing divine descent and equivalence with the eternal blue heaven.^[16] This self-presentation underscored Tengri's mandate as the source of khaganal authority, portraying rule as a sacred trust rather than mere political inheritance. The Orkhon inscriptions, primary artifacts of his era including the Bilge Qaghan and Kül Tigin steles, abound with invocations attributing the khaganate's restoration to Tengri's will. Bilge Qaghan declared that "above, the eternal Tengri" granted strength to overcome defeats, enabled military triumphs over Tang China and neighboring tribes, and ensured the unity of Turkic subjects under his command.^[16] He warned Turks against disloyalty, framing obedience to the khagan as fulfillment of Tengri's order, thereby embedding Tengrist cosmology into state ideology to foster cohesion amid threats of fragmentation. These monuments, carved in Old Turkic runes, served as public proclamations promoting ancestral customs over foreign seductions. Bilge Qaghan's policies actively countered rival faiths, notably rejecting Buddhism despite personal inclinations toward conversion and urban temple-building around 720 CE. Advised by Tonyukuk, his vizier, he abandoned these ideas, heeding arguments that Buddhist adoption would soften nomadic warriors into sedentary weakness akin to Sogdians or Chinese subjects. Chinese annals confirm Tonyukuk's influence in opposing state patronage of Buddhism, preserving Tengrism's primacy to maintain martial vigor and cultural autonomy. This stance aligned with broader efforts to revive pre-conquest traditions, positioning Tengrism as essential to Turkic sovereignty against imperial assimilation.

Inscriptions and Literacy

Bilge Qaghan commissioned the erection of two major stelae in the Orkhon Valley: one commemorating his brother Kul Tigin, installed in 732 CE, and his own memorial inscription set up in 735 CE following his death.^[17] These monuments feature extensive texts in the Old Turkic language, inscribed using the runic Old Turkic script, which had been employed by Göktürk elites since at least the early 8th century.^[18] The script, characterized by its angular runes adapted for carving on stone, enabled the recording of poetic and prosaic narratives without reliance on Chinese or Sogdian writing systems, highlighting a deliberate assertion of cultural autonomy.^[18] The inscriptions' content, primarily dictated by Bilge Qaghan and finalized by his nephew Yollug Tigin with assistance from Chinese artisans for the carving, chronicles the khaganate's history, military exploits, and admonitions against subservience to foreign powers.^[17] As the earliest substantial corpus of Old Turkic writing—totaling over 1,000 lines across the stelae—they attest to functional literacy within the ruling class and administrative apparatus of the Second Turkic Khaganate.^[4] Professional scribes capable of composing such elaborate runic texts indicate specialized training, likely influenced by interactions with literate Central Asian cultures, yet the native script's use preserved Turkic linguistic identity. While these artifacts demonstrate elite proficiency in reading and writing for commemorative and propagandistic purposes, evidence for broader literacy among the nomadic populace remains scant. The inscriptions were probably intended for public recitation rather than individual perusal, reflecting a society where oral tradition predominated alongside selective written records for eternalizing khaganal wisdom.^[19] No policies explicitly promoting mass literacy are recorded in contemporary sources, underscoring that writing served primarily dynastic and ideological functions under Bilge Qaghan's reign.

Later Years and Succession

Challenges and Conflicts

Upon ascending to the throne in 716 following the assassination of his father Qapaghan Khagan by Basmyl tribesmen, Bilge Qaghan immediately confronted internal power struggles within the Ashina clan. His uncle Inel Khagan, who had proclaimed himself ruler, was defeated and killed by forces led by Bilge, his brother Kul Tigin, and advisor Tonyukuk, securing Bilge's position as khagan. This swift consolidation quelled potential familial disputes but highlighted the fragility of succession in the khaganate, where rival claimants often leveraged tribal loyalties.^[13] Tribal rebellions posed ongoing internal threats throughout Bilge's reign. In 716, Uyghur forces ambushed Bilge, nearly costing him his life, necessitating vigorous campaigns to reassert control over semi-autonomous groups like the Basmyls and Kyrgyz, who had previously rebelled under Qapaghan.^[1] By 720, intelligence revealed plots among subject tribes to ally with remnants of the Eastern Turkic Khaganate against the Second Khaganate, prompting preemptive military actions to prevent fragmentation.^[4] The Orkhon inscriptions, commissioned by Bilge, emphasize these struggles, portraying the Turks as a numerically inferior people—described as "seven men" at his ascension—compelled to subdue larger coalitions through relentless warfare and strategic alliances.^[4] Externally, Bilge navigated pressures from Tang China, whose economic and diplomatic influence fostered dependency among Turkic elites, as critiqued in the inscriptions for eroding sovereignty through promises of luxury goods like silk.^[4] Military confrontations arose when Tang supported dissident tribes, leading to border skirmishes in the late 710s and early 720s, though Bilge pragmatically alternated between tribute payments and raids to balance threats.^[1] Nomadic rivals, including Uyghurs and Karluks, tested the khaganate's eastern flanks, with Bilge's campaigns against the Toquz Oghuz and Otuz Tatar in the 720s aimed at securing trade routes and preventing encirclement, yet straining resources and foreshadowing the Uyghur-led coalition that toppled the khaganate a decade after his death.^[4] These conflicts underscored the khaganate's reliance on Bilge's personal leadership and the inscriptions' warnings against foreign intrigues that exacerbated internal divisions.

Death and Immediate Aftermath

Bilge Qaghan died in 734, reportedly poisoned by his retainers amid suspicions of treachery linked to succession concerns, as his sons were young.^[1]^[20] He was immediately succeeded by his eldest son, Yollıg Tigin, who assumed the title Yollıg Khagan and reigned until 739.^[20] Yollıg Khagan's rule marked the onset of decline in the Second Turkic Khaganate, characterized by ineffective governance and failure to sustain the administrative and military cohesion established by Bilge Qaghan.^[21] Internal factions and subject tribes, including the Uyghurs, Karluks, and Basmyls, began to exploit the weakened central authority, leading to mounting unrest in the years following Bilge Qaghan's death.^[20] In 739, Yollıg Khagan was succeeded by his brother Tengri Qaghan, whose brief reign until 741 intensified the instability through further leadership shortcomings.^[22] This period of rapid succession and diminishing control paved the way for large-scale rebellions by 742, culminating in the khaganate's overthrow in 744.^[21]

Legacy

Historical Impact on Turkic States

Bilge Qaghan's reign (716–734 CE) temporarily restored the centralized authority of the Second Turkic Khaganate, serving as a model for subsequent nomadic confederations by demonstrating effective integration of diverse tribes under a supreme khagan through military campaigns and administrative consolidation. His successes in subduing rebellious groups like the Tölis tribes and repelling Tang Chinese incursions reinforced the khaganate's structure as a hierarchical steppe empire reliant on cavalry mobility and tribal loyalty, principles that later Turkic polities emulated to maintain cohesion amid internal factions.^[14] Following his death in 734 CE, the khaganate's rapid fragmentation—exacerbated by succession disputes and renewed tribal revolts—highlighted the fragility of this model without a strong ruler, culminating in the Uyghur-led overthrow in 744 CE. Yet, the Uyghur Khaganate (744–840 CE) adopted similar titular conventions, as seen in rulers like Kutlug I Bilge Khagan, indicating continuity in the symbolic framework of khaganate legitimacy derived from Göktürk precedents. This adaptation allowed Uyghurs to legitimize their rule over former Turkic territories by invoking established ideals of wise (bilge) leadership and tribal supremacy.^[23] The Orkhon inscriptions, commissioned by Bilge Qaghan and his brother Kül Tigin around 732 CE, articulated a state ideology emphasizing sovereignty, vigilance against external manipulation (particularly Chinese), and unity under Tengri's mandate, which became an enduring blueprint for Turkic governance. These runic texts, preserved in the Orkhon Valley, functioned as ideological anchors, promoting a collective "Türk" identity that transcended immediate political collapse and influenced later entities like the Kyrgyz Khaganate by providing historical narratives of resilience and anti-sedentary warnings.^[14] In broader terms, Bilge Qaghan's emphasis on runic literacy and monumental propaganda fostered a tradition of written historiography among Turkic elites, enabling successor states to reference Göktürk origins for legitimacy; this is evident in the Karakhanid and Seljuk adoption of Ashina clan myths and khaganate hierarchies as foundational to their own imperial claims in the 10th–11th centuries CE. His legacy thus lay not in perpetual territorial control but in codifying causal principles of nomadic statecraft—tribal mobilization, divine sanction, and cultural autonomy—that shaped the political ethos of Central Asian Turkic polities for centuries.^[14]

Archaeological Discoveries

The most significant archaeological artifact linked to Bilge Qaghan is the Bilge Khagan inscription, a memorial stele erected in 735 CE by his youngest son, Tengri Khagan, in the Orkhon Valley of Mongolia. Carved in Old Turkic runes on its east, north, and south faces, with Chinese inscriptions on the west face, the stele chronicles Bilge Qaghan's reign, military campaigns, and administrative policies. Measuring approximately 3.45 meters in height, 1.74 meters in width, and 0.75 meters in thickness, it originally stood at the center of a monumental grave complex at Khoshoo Tsaidam.^[24]^[25] Excavations at the Khoshoo Tsaidam site in 2001 by Mongolian archaeologists uncovered the sacrificial altar associated with Bilge Qaghan's burial, revealing ritual pits and offerings consistent with Turkic funerary practices. Subsequent joint Turkish-Mongolian efforts from 2009 onward focused on excavating and conserving the surrounding complex, which spans 72 meters in length and 36 meters in width, comprising three primary sections oriented east-west: the central inscription area, auxiliary structures, and perimeter balbals (stone pillars representing defeated enemies). These findings confirmed the site's role as Bilge Qaghan's tomb, with evidence of human and animal sacrifices and Turkic-era artifacts dating to the early 8th century CE.^[25]^[26]^[27] The stele and related monuments, now partially housed in Mongolia's National Museum, were initially documented in the late 19th century but have undergone extensive restoration to preserve the runic script, providing primary epigraphic evidence of Second Turkic Khaganate governance. Additional 8th-century Turkic artifacts, including marble statues depicting khagans in period attire, have surfaced from regional excavations, though none are definitively identified as Bilge Qaghan himself.^[27]

Interpretations in Scholarship

Scholarship on Bilge Qaghan centers on the Orkhon inscriptions commissioned during his reign (716–734 CE), which serve as primary sources for reconstructing his policies and ideology, portraying him as a unifier who restored Turkic sovereignty after decades of subjugation to Tang China. These texts emphasize his military campaigns against internal rebels and external foes, such as the Otuz Tatar and Basmyls, and attribute the khaganate's revival to divine favor from Tengri, underscoring a state tradition rooted in nomadic confederation under a sacral qaghan. Historians view the inscriptions as both historical records and ideological manifestos, warning against Chinese cultural assimilation—such as adopting sedentary lifestyles or intermarrying—which Bilge deemed erosive to Turkic martial vigor and independence.^[7]^[10] Interpretations highlight Bilge's reliance on key lieutenants, including his brother Kül Tigin for military leadership and advisor Tonyukuk for strategic counsel, as foundational to centralizing power and controlling Silk Road trade routes, which bolstered economic leverage over China. Some analyses argue this structure marked the origins of enduring Turkish state principles, blending merit-based hierarchy with qaghanic authority to forge tribal unity among the Töles and other groups. However, scholars debate the inscriptions' reliability as unvarnished history versus propaganda; while they decry Chinese "generosity" (e.g., gifts of silk and titles) as a ploy for domination, evidence from Tang annals suggests Bilge pragmatically pursued diplomacy for material gains, including peace treaties in 718 and 725 CE that secured tribute without full submission.^[10]^[14] Linguistic studies of inscriptional terms, such as ïkïdmaz in the Bilge Qaghan and Kül Tigin steles, reveal ongoing debates over precise meanings, with proposals ranging from "to spare" to critiques of non-generosity, often tied to anti-Chinese rhetoric framing Tang aid as insincere. Tonyukuk's influence is interpreted variably: he dissuaded Bilge from adopting Buddhism or excessive Sinicization, prioritizing distinct Turkic identity, yet some contend this reflected elite conservatism amid pressures for administrative borrowing from China. Overall, modern historiography, drawing on epigraphic and comparative nomadic studies, positions Bilge as a pivotal figure in Eurasian steppe politics, whose legacy influenced successor states like the Uyghur Khaganate, though his assassination in 734 CE by internal intrigue underscores the fragility of such confederations.^[28]^[19]^[7]

References

[1]
BILGE-KAGAN – Institute of History and Ethnology named after Sh ...
Apr 10, 2023 · Khagan of the Eastern Turkic Khaganate from 716 to 734. Under the rule of Bilge Khan, Kyul-Tegin, and Tonyukuk, the Khaganate flourished, and ...Missing: primary | Show results with:primary
[2]
The Cradle of the Turks - Saudi Aramco World
Bilge's reign (716-734) was, according to the Orhon inscriptions, beset by economic problems: I (Bilge) did not reign over a people that was rich; I reigned ...
[3]
[PDF] Göktürks
The son of Ilteriş, Bilge, or Piqie Khan (also “Arslan Bilgä Khağan.” Chinese: 毗伽可汗, personal name “Ashina Mojilian” (阿史那默棘連); 683 or 684 - 734), was ...
[4]
Text of Bilge kagan Inscription - TURK BITIG
Achievement were made in the troubled country. The population had been increased, People in the parts of the world became friendly. Many of the people laught ...<|separator|>
[5]
毗伽可汗 - Chinese Text Project
Bilge Qaghan (; 毗伽可汗| píjiā kěhàn; 683 – 25 November 734) was the fourth Qaghan of the Second Turkic Khaganate. His accomplishments were described in ...
[6]
QAPAGHAN KHAGAN – Institute of History and Ethnology named ...
Apr 10, 2023 · Qapaghan Kagan's campaigns are described on the monument to Bilge Khagan as follows: “At fourteen, I was a Shad among the Tardush people.
[7]
https://oxfordre.com/asianhistory/display/10.1093/acrefore/9780190277727.001.0001/acrefore-9780190277727-e-52
[8]
Bilge Qaghan Facts for Kids
Born, Ashina Mojilian 阿史那默棘連 683. Died, 25 November 734(734-11-25) (aged 50–51) Otukan. Spouse, El Etmish Bilge Khatun. Issue, Yollıg TiginMissing: primary | Show results with:primary
[9]
Bilge | Mongol Ruler, Conqueror & Warrior - Britannica
Originating from the Mongol heartland in the Steppe of central Asia, by the late 13th century it spanned from the Pacific Ocean in the east to ...
[10]
(PDF) Bilge Kaghan and the Origins of Turkish State Tradition
Along with Bilge son of Kutlugh Kaghan being enthroned, the state managed to turn back to its earlier brilliant days. The roles of the biggest supporters of ...
[11]
KULTEGIN – Institute of History and Ethnology named after Sh. Sh ...
Apr 10, 2023 · On the Turkic monument the Chinese name of “On tutuk” was called Van Shen ... Bilge kagan Mojilian was called “little shad” before. He was kind by ...<|separator|>
[12]
TONYUKUK – Institute of History and Ethnology named after Sh. Sh ...
Apr 10, 2023 · Regarding this victory, the Bilge Khagan inscription says the following: “On the very first day, I defeated the seventeen-thousand-strong ...Missing: translation | Show results with:translation
[13]
Political Complexity in Nomadic Empires of Inner Asia - Social studies
... Second Turkic Khaganate. The ruler did not have enough political means to bring them under regulation and control so both Qapaghan and Bilge Khagan with Kul ...<|separator|>
[14]
Bilge Kaghan and the Origins of Turkish State Tradition
Jul 30, 2018 · the Middle and East Asia. Along with Bilge son of Kutlugh Kaghan being enthroned, the state managed to turn. back to its earlier brilliant days.
[15]
[PDF] Diplomatic Marriages Between the Tang and Uyghur Dynasties
Feb 26, 2025 · Bilge Khagan maintained a friendly relationship with China, but the Tang emperor used the promise of a Köktürk- Tang marriage as a tactic, ...
[16]
[PDF] The Orkhon Inscriptions: Being a Translation of Professor Vilhelm ...
II S 1to for 19 years I was kagan and ruled the realm. 31 (years I was tegin ?). For my Turks, for my people I have brought so much good. Having 1.Missing: Bilge ascension
[17]
(DOC) Orkhon Inscriptions - Academia.edu
The primary goal of these inscriptions is to immortalize the achievements of Kül Tigin and Bilge Khagan, instruct future generations in lessons from history, ...
[18]
[PDF] Old Turkic script - GEO Ring
Jun 6, 2020 · Turkic Orkhon script.[9] Turkic inscriptions dating from earlier than the Orkhon inscriptions used about 150 symbols, which may suggest that ...
[19]
(PDF) The Orkhon Inscriptions: Examining Turk Attitudes Towards ...
In particular, the Orkhon Inscriptions record the complex attitude of the Khagan towards Chinese influences.Missing: reforms | Show results with:reforms
[20]
Kingdoms of Central Asia - Eastern Khagans (Göktürks)
... source region for the early Turkic tribes. 716 - 734. Bilge Khagan / Bögü. Son of Kutlugh. Poisoned. 716. Bilge orders for his brother, himself, and their wise ...Missing: primary | Show results with:primary
[21]
[PDF] Khagan
This article analyzes the reinterpretation of Bilge Khagan's period in the second Ancient Turkic Khaganate, highlighting the author's post-colonial.
[22]
登利可汗
Tengri Qaghan (Old Turkic: 𐱅𐰭𐰼𐰃:𐰴𐰍𐰣, personal name: Ashina Kutluk, 阿史那骨咄) (734 or 739 or 740 – 741) was the sixth ruler of the Second Turkic Khaganate.
[23]
[PDF] TURKIC HISTORY
Unit 4: Uyghur and Khazar Khanates. Following the death of Bilge Kaghan, many Turkic tribes rebelled against the Turkish Empire during the chaotic seven year ...
[24]
Turkish Monuments in Mongolia - Travel Atelier
The Bilge Khagan Inscription was erected in 735 by Bilge Khagan's youngest son Tengri Khagan. ... Orkhon (Orhun) Inscriptions. The script used on the Orkhon ...Missing: sources | Show results with:sources
[25]
bilge khan memorial complex - Info | Mongolian Guide Tour
Bilge Khan died on November 23, 734, and a sacrificial temple and a stele ... I have made the other, which has a Kingdom and a Khagan, stand higher.
[26]
the excavation and the conservation of bilge khan monumental ...
Jan 11, 2021 · This project was removed to the covered area where a monument with Kok Turkish and Chinese Inscriptions were located is called as Bengü Taş (The ...
[27]
[PDF] Bahar-The-Excavation-and-the-Conservation-of-Bilge-Khan ...
Oct 15, 2009 · The project about Bilge Khan the determination, excavation and conservation of the Turkish monuments in its surrounding, has been supported ...
[28]
[PDF] ON ïKID- IN THE KÜL TEGIN AND BILGÄ KAGAN INSCRIPTIONS*
Many parts of the Kül Tegin and Bilgä Kagan inscriptions are almost identical with each other. Although most parts of these inscriptions are well understood ...