Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Comprehensive high school

A comprehensive high school is a non-selective secondary institution in the United States that serves all students within a designated geographic district, offering an integrated curriculum encompassing academic subjects for college preparation alongside vocational and practical training to accommodate diverse student abilities and career aspirations.^[1]^[2] Emerging in the early 20th century, the model gained prominence through the 1918 Commission on the Reorganization of Secondary Education's Cardinal Principles of Secondary Education, which advocated for schools fostering citizenship, health, vocation, and efficient social integration over narrow elitism.^[3]^[4] This approach democratized access to education, dramatically expanding enrollment from under 10% of youth in 1900 to nearly universal by mid-century, while emphasizing adaptability to industrial society's demands for both skilled laborers and informed citizens.^[1]^[5] The system's defining characteristics include heterogeneous grouping, with curriculum differentiation via electives and tracking rather than segregation by ability, aiming to balance equity and excellence in a pluralistic democracy.^[6] Proponents credit it with enabling broad socioeconomic mobility and workforce preparation during periods of rapid industrialization, as evidenced by high school completion correlating with economic productivity gains in the mid-20th century.^[5] However, controversies persist regarding its efficacy; empirical analyses indicate potential trade-offs, such as diluted academic rigor for high-achievers in mixed-ability settings, contributing to debates over stagnant achievement gaps and calls for alternatives like specialized academies or selective admissions.^[7]^[8] Despite these critiques, the comprehensive high school remains the dominant form of public secondary education in the U.S., shaping policy discussions on reform amid persistent challenges in outcomes like graduation rates and post-secondary readiness.^[2]

Definition and Core Features

Definition and Principles

A comprehensive high school is a type of public secondary school serving students typically aged 14 to 18 (grades 9 through 12 in the United States), characterized by non-selective enrollment that admits all local residents regardless of academic ability, aptitude, or socioeconomic status, with the aim of providing universal access to secondary education.^[1] This model integrates a broad curriculum under unified administration, encompassing academic preparation for higher education, vocational training for workforce entry, and general education for civic and personal development, thereby serving diverse student needs without external segregation into specialized institutions.^[1] The foundational principles derive from early 20th-century progressive education reforms, which envisioned the comprehensive high school as an embodiment of democratic ideals by extending secondary schooling to the masses and promoting equal opportunity through heterogeneous grouping.^[6] Egalitarianism forms a core tenet, rejecting ability-based streaming or selective admissions in favor of mixed-ability classrooms to cultivate social cohesion and shared democratic values among students from varied backgrounds.^[3] This approach ties to first-principles reasoning on equal access as a means to societal equity, yet causal realism highlights inherent challenges from innate differences in cognitive abilities and motivation, which limit uniform academic outcomes despite egalitarian structures.^[6] In practice, these principles emphasize administrative flexibility to accommodate individual variation through internal program differentiation rather than institutional separation, fostering a "common school" environment that prioritizes broad exposure over early specialization.^[1] The rejection of rigid tracking aims to mitigate social divisions but acknowledges the need for tailored instruction to address disparate student capacities, aligning with empirical observations of heterogeneous learner profiles.

Organizational Characteristics

Comprehensive high schools in the United States generally serve large student bodies, with average enrollments around 979 students in regular secondary schools as of the 2015–16 school year, though many urban examples range from 1,000 to over 3,000 to accommodate heterogeneous populations from assigned districts.^[9] Classrooms are organized heterogeneously by grade level (typically 9–12), mixing students of diverse academic abilities, socioeconomic backgrounds, and needs without formal ability-based tracking, enabling a single institution to address broad educational demands.^[10]^[11] Administratively, these schools employ departmentalized structures where teachers specialize in specific subjects and instruct multiple sections, contrasting with self-contained elementary models.^[12] Elective systems allow students to select courses beyond required subjects, supporting individualized pathways within the comprehensive framework. Special education is organizationally integrated into mainstream classrooms via inclusion practices, with services delivered in general settings to promote the least restrictive environment as mandated by federal law.^[13]^[14] Operational variations arise by locale, with urban comprehensive high schools averaging larger enrollments and facing overcrowding alongside constrained resources, such as fewer materials per student, compared to suburban schools that often have smaller sizes and enhanced facilities.^[15] This disparity reflects funding tied to local property taxes and demographic densities, impacting administrative capacity for diverse needs.^[15]

Historical Development

Early Origins and Progressive Era

The comprehensive high school emerged in the United States during the early 20th century amid the "high school movement" of 1910 to 1940, which expanded secondary enrollment from elite, selective institutions to broadly accessible ones serving diverse socioeconomic groups.^[16] This transition reflected practical adaptations to industrialization and immigration, rather than solely ideological commitments, with schools evolving to offer integrated academic, vocational, and general curricula to prepare youth for varied roles in a democratic society.^[17] Progressive educators, drawing on figures like John Dewey, advocated for experiential, socially oriented learning to foster civic engagement, though empirical evidence attributes the model's adoption more to rising community wealth, ethnic homogeneity, and reduced child labor opportunities than to pure philosophical drivers.^[18] Early implementations built on reorganizational experiments, including the establishment of junior high schools starting in 1909 in places like Columbus, Ohio, which aimed to bridge elementary and high school by addressing adolescent developmental needs and curricular differentiation.^[1] By the 1910s and 1920s, urban districts increasingly consolidated these into comprehensive four-year high schools, shifting from classical academies focused on college preparation to multipurpose entities accommodating non-college-bound students, including immigrants seeking assimilation into industrial workforces. This model gained traction as states enacted compulsory attendance laws raising the minimum age to 14 or 16—such as Massachusetts in 1909 and others following suit by the 1920s—which demonstrably increased secondary enrollment by retaining potential dropouts, particularly from lower-income families.^[19] High school enrollment rates for ages 14-17 surged from about 7% in 1910 (519,000 students in grades 9-12) to roughly 73% by 1940 (6.6 million students), reflecting not only legal mandates but also economic factors like income stability that enabled broader access.^[20] These laws narrowed attendance gaps between rich and poor youth by up to 25% in adopting states, though graduation rates lagged behind at around 50% by 1940, underscoring the model's challenges in uniform academic outcomes across heterogeneous populations.^[21] While proponents framed the comprehensive approach as embodying industrial democracy, causal analyses highlight structural enablers like public funding and social capital over egalitarian rhetoric alone.^[22]

Post-World War II Expansion

Following the Soviet Union's launch of Sputnik in 1957, which intensified national concerns about American competitiveness in science and mathematics education, James Bryant Conant advocated for the expansion of large comprehensive high schools in his 1959 report The American High School Today. Conant argued that schools enrolling at least 2,000 students could effectively identify and cultivate talent across diverse ability levels through differentiated programs within a single institution, countering the limitations of smaller, less resourced rural and suburban high schools.^[23]^[24] This vision aligned with post-World War II demographic pressures, including the baby boom, which drove secondary enrollment from approximately 6.6 million students in 1950 to over 13 million by 1965, necessitating school consolidation and modernization to accommodate rapid growth.^[25] Federal policies in the 1960s further propelled the model's adoption. The Elementary and Secondary Education Act (ESEA) of 1965, enacted under President Lyndon B. Johnson, allocated over $1 billion annually in grants to states for improving elementary and secondary education, with emphasis on aiding low-income districts and facilitating desegregation efforts that comprehensive high schools were positioned to support by enrolling students from varied socioeconomic and racial backgrounds.^[26] These incentives, combined with state-level consolidations, resulted in comprehensive high schools becoming the dominant form by the early 1970s, serving roughly 90% of U.S. secondary students in unified institutions offering both academic and vocational tracks.^[2] From the 1960s, however, early critiques highlighted structural flaws in the comprehensive approach, particularly its emphasis on uniformity that often overlooked merit-based differentiation. Observers noted that mixed-ability classrooms frequently led to curricula adjusted to the lowest common denominator, diluting academic rigor for higher-achieving students and failing to sustain motivation or achievement across ability levels, as evidenced in analyses of urban school outcomes during decentralization experiments.^[27] These concerns, raised amid broader evaluations of federal aid's implementation, questioned whether the model's egalitarian structure inherently compromised instructional quality without robust tracking or selective grouping.^[28]

International Adoption and Variations

The Labour government in the United Kingdom issued Circular 10/65 on July 12, 1965, directing local education authorities to submit plans for phasing out selection at age 11 and transitioning from the tripartite system—comprising grammar, technical, and secondary modern schools—to comprehensive secondary schools, motivated by egalitarian aims to reduce social segregation in education.^[29]^[30] This policy faced opposition from Conservative-led authorities and parents favoring selective grammar schools for high-achieving students, yet by the late 1970s, over 80% of secondary pupils attended comprehensives, rising to near 90% coverage in England by the early 1980s amid centralized pressure and local reorganizations.^[31] Empirical analyses indicate that while the reform expanded access, it did not consistently narrow educational inequalities, as de facto streaming within comprehensives and residual grammar schools preserved advantages for higher socioeconomic groups, reflecting causal challenges in mixing disparate ability levels without tailored instruction.^[32] In Sweden, the comprehensive model achieved fuller adoption through reforms culminating in the 1962 parliamentary decision for a unified nine-year grundskola for ages 7-16, implemented progressively from the 1950s to the 1970s, establishing a non-selective system intended to promote equity in a relatively homogeneous society.^[33] This politically driven shift, emphasizing anti-elitist uniformity, eliminated early tracking and extended compulsory education, but longitudinal data reveal subsequent declines in overall achievement and rising segregation via parental school choice post-1990s deregulation, underscoring limitations in sustaining mixed-ability environments amid growing immigration-related inequality.^[34]^[35] Continental European nations like Germany and France retained selective elements despite partial comprehensive influences, with Germany's early tracking at ages 10-12 into stratified tracks (e.g., Gymnasium for academic elites) persisting due to entrenched vocational-cultural norms and evidence that comprehensive alternatives exacerbate mismatches in high-inequality contexts.^[36]^[37] France's system, featuring general and vocational streams post-collège, similarly resisted full non-selection, as reforms toward comprehensives in the 1960s-1970s yielded hybrids where selectivity at later stages mitigated disruptions from ability heterogeneity.^[38] Studies comparing these to comprehensive models find selective systems often yield higher average outcomes for top performers without proportionally widening gaps when inequality stems from pre-existing socioeconomic divides rather than institutional design alone.^[39]^[40] Australia adopted mixed models post-1970s, building on 1960s reforms like New South Wales' Wyndham Scheme, which expanded comprehensive high schools for ages 12-17 while preserving selective institutions for gifted students, resulting in majority comprehensive enrollment by the 1970s but ongoing debates over equity in stratified urban areas.^[41]^[42] This hybrid approach, politically justified as balancing access with excellence, highlights adaptation challenges: in diverse, high-inequality settings, comprehensives faced internal stratification via streaming or zoning, limiting their divergence from U.S.-style uniformity and yielding persistent performance gaps tied to family background.^[43]^[44]

Curriculum and Internal Structure

Academic and Vocational Offerings

Comprehensive high schools provide a broad curriculum encompassing core academic subjects required for graduation, typically including four years of English language arts, three to four years of mathematics (such as algebra, geometry, and pre-calculus), three years of laboratory sciences (biology, chemistry, and physics), and three to four years of social studies (U.S. history, world history, government, and economics).^[45]^[46] These subjects form the foundation, occupying the bulk of instructional time to ensure baseline preparation for postsecondary options or workforce entry.^[46] To promote versatility, the model incorporates electives that extend beyond academics, including fine arts (visual arts, music, theater), foreign languages, physical education, and vocational courses in areas like automotive mechanics, building construction, computer-aided drafting, business management, and cosmetology.^[47]^[48] Vocational offerings aim to impart practical skills for trades, reflecting the comprehensive design's intent to accommodate diverse student aptitudes and career paths within a single institution.^[49] Graduation hinges on accumulating credits—generally 22 to 26 total—earned through course completion, with state-specific minima in core areas rather than uniform emphasis on content mastery or standardized assessments.^[50]^[51] Advanced options like Advanced Placement (AP) or International Baccalaureate (IB) courses exist in many comprehensive high schools to offer depth for capable students, yet their implementation faces constraints from heterogeneous class compositions, potentially moderating pace and challenge to suit broader enrollment.^[52] This breadth-oriented structure trades specialized rigor for inclusivity, as evidenced by post-1980s shifts where heightened academic requirements crowded out vocational depth; for instance, states mandated more core credits, reducing vocational coursetaking from about 30% of high school schedules in the early 1980s to under 20% by the 1990s, often resulting in shallower skill acquisition when vocational programs compete with academic priorities.^[53]^[54]

Role of Tracking and Grouping

In comprehensive high schools, formal ability tracking—grouping students into rigid academic, general, or vocational streams—is largely rejected in favor of heterogeneous classrooms to promote educational equity and avoid stigmatizing lower-achieving students. This approach emerged prominently in U.S. policy debates during the 1970s and 1980s, amid civil rights-era concerns over racial and socioeconomic segregation within schools, leading to detracking reforms that dismantled overt tracks in many districts.^[55]^[56] However, de facto differentiation persists through mechanisms such as honors, Advanced Placement (AP), and International Baccalaureate (IB) courses, elective choices, and informal teacher recommendations, often described as "hidden tracking" since the late 1970s. These practices effectively stratify students by prior achievement, with data from the National Assessment of Educational Progress (NAEP) showing resurgence in within-class ability grouping by the 2010s, particularly in fourth and eighth grades, as a workaround to mixed-ability challenges.^[57]^[58] Critics of untracked systems argue that avoiding explicit grouping overlooks innate cognitive variances, where students progress through developmental stages at differing paces, necessitating tailored pacing to maintain engagement and mastery. Piaget's framework of cognitive stages—sensorimotor, preoperational, concrete operational, and formal operational—implies that uniform instruction in mixed settings mismatches readiness levels, potentially stunting advanced thinkers while frustrating slower developers through inadequate challenge or remediation.^[59] While heterogeneous classes aim to reduce labeling stigma, empirical observations indicate heightened disengagement: high-ability students report boredom and reduced motivation in mixed environments, and low-ability students experience diminished self-concept due to repeated comparative failure, as evidenced in longitudinal studies of detracking effects.^[60]^[61] U.S. studies from the 1990s and 2000s reveal that tracked or grouped classes often yield superior outcomes for both high- and low-achievers relative to fully mixed formats, despite null or small average effects across all students. For instance, analyses of National Education Longitudinal Study (NELS) data by Betts and Shkolnik (2000) found that ability grouping reallocates instructional resources effectively, boosting mathematics gains for top-quartile students by up to 0.15 standard deviations and providing neutral-to-positive effects for bottom-quartile performers through focused remediation, contrasting with diluted pacing in heterogeneous settings. Similarly, Hoffer (1992) reported that high-track placements correlate with accelerated achievement trajectories for gifted students, while low tracks prevent further alienation compared to mixed classes where low performers lag without targeted support.^[62] These findings challenge the causal assumption of untracking as uniformly beneficial, highlighting how variance in aptitude demands differentiation to maximize individual progress rather than enforcing a one-size-fits-all model.^[63]

Extracurricular and Support Programs

Comprehensive high schools incorporate a wide array of extracurricular activities, including interscholastic sports, debate clubs, music ensembles, and vocational interest groups, to accommodate the diverse abilities and motivations of their non-selective student bodies. These offerings aim to cultivate school identity and interpersonal connections in large enrollments often exceeding 1,000 students, where academic heterogeneity can otherwise erode cohesion.^[64] Participation rates vary, but national surveys from the early 1990s documented that about 70% of public high school sophomores engaged in at least one activity, with sports and arts being predominant.^[64] Empirical analyses link extracurricular involvement to improved retention metrics, such as reduced absenteeism and higher on-time graduation probabilities; for example, a 2017 study using propensity score matching estimated that at-risk students participating in activities were 10-15% less likely to drop out compared to non-participants.^[65] Longitudinal data from the 1990s further showed correlations between activity participation and sustained engagement, with involved students exhibiting 20-30% higher attendance rates.^[64] Nonetheless, these associations may reflect selection bias rather than direct causation, as higher-achieving or more disciplined students disproportionately join such programs, confounding observational interpretations.^[66] Support programs complement extracurriculars by providing targeted interventions for vulnerable subgroups, including counseling services for academic advising and mental health, which address barriers like family instability or low motivation in heterogeneous cohorts. Dropout prevention efforts gained traction in the 1980s amid rising national concerns, with federal initiatives like New York City's 1985-1986 attendance improvement programs targeting middle and high schools to curb truancy through incentives and monitoring.^[67] By the late 1980s, the School Dropout Demonstration Assistance Program (1988-1996) allocated grants to districts for localized strategies, such as mentoring and credit recovery, yielding modest reductions in dropout rates from 13.1% in 1980-82 to 7.0% in 1990-92 among 16-24-year-olds.^[68]^[69] In comprehensive settings, these programs often integrate with compulsory attendance enforcement, where states mandate enrollment until age 16-18, supplemented by truancy interventions to sustain participation amid varied student preparedness.^[67]

Comparisons to Alternative Models

Versus Selective Academic Schools

Selective academic schools, such as grammar schools in the United Kingdom or magnet schools in the United States, typically admit students based on entrance examinations, standardized test scores, or demonstrated academic aptitude, concentrating resources on college-preparatory curricula for high-achieving pupils.^[70] In contrast, comprehensive high schools enroll students from all ability levels within a geographic catchment, aiming for broad accessibility but often resulting in curricula that must accommodate diverse needs, which can reduce overall academic rigor and depth for advanced learners.^[71] This structural difference leads to selective schools maintaining a sharper focus on rigorous subjects like advanced mathematics and sciences, while comprehensives may prioritize inclusivity over specialized acceleration.^[72] Empirical studies indicate that students in selective schools achieve superior academic outcomes compared to similar-ability peers in comprehensive systems, particularly at higher ability levels. In the UK, grammar school attendees score approximately 5.5 GCSE grade points higher on average than matched comprehensive school students, with gains most pronounced among top performers who benefit from accelerated pacing and specialized instruction.^[71] Similarly, selective school pupils select subjects averaging about one-tenth of a GCSE grade more challenging, contributing to 20-30% higher attainment in key qualifications like A-levels.^[72] These disparities persist after controlling for prior achievement and socioeconomic factors, suggesting institutional effects beyond selection bias.^[70] In the US, magnet high schools show modest positive impacts on mathematics achievement for admitted students, though effects diminish with demographic adjustments, underscoring advantages for motivated high achievers in targeted environments.^[73] Causal mechanisms include peer effects, where high-ability classmates in selective settings elevate motivation and study norms, fostering upward assimilation in performance.^[70] Comprehensive schools, by mixing abilities, expose talented students to lower average peer achievement, which can demotivate via relative comparison.^[74] This aligns with the big-fish-little-pond effect, wherein high-ability individuals in mixed-ability environments experience diminished academic self-concept due to unfavorable peer contrasts, potentially reducing persistence in challenging courses.^[75] Selective environments reverse this by placing high achievers among equals or superiors, enhancing self-efficacy and long-term outcomes without the dilution observed in comprehensives.^[76] Such dynamics highlight merit-based sorting's role in optimizing high-end performance, though comprehensives may better serve average or lower-ability pupils through tailored support unavailable in purely selective models.^[77]

Versus Specialized or Vocational Institutions

Specialized vocational institutions prioritize intensive, field-specific training, often integrating apprenticeships with theoretical instruction, as exemplified by Germany's dual education system established in the 19th century and refined post-World War II. In this model, approximately 500,000 youths annually participate in programs combining company-based work with vocational schooling, yielding a youth unemployment rate of about 6% in 2018, compared to over 20% in countries like France with less emphasis on such specialization.^[78] ^[79] This system fosters direct pathways to skilled employment, with studies attributing a 5 percentage point reduction in youth unemployment to its structure relative to purely academic tracks.^[80] Comprehensive high schools, by contrast, integrate vocational elements into a generalized curriculum serving all students, resulting in shallower exposure to trades that critics in the 1980s argued produced "jack-of-all-trades" graduates ill-equipped for specialized labor markets. The 1983 report A Nation at Risk, commissioned by the U.S. Department of Education, highlighted this dilution, noting declining student achievement amid broadened but less rigorous offerings, including vocational courses that failed to match the depth of dedicated programs.^[81] Such critiques, echoed in analyses of U.S. secondary education, pointed to comprehensive models' tendency to subordinate vocational rigor to egalitarian breadth, yielding graduates with fragmented skills rather than mastery.^[2] Empirical evidence from 2000s studies on U.S. Career and Technical Education (CTE) underscores the employment advantages of concentrated vocational paths over the dispersed offerings in comprehensive schools. Participants in high school CTE programs, particularly those with multiple courses in a single field, exhibited higher post-graduation earnings and field-specific employment rates, with non-experimental data linking CTE exposure to increased labor market entry success in the subsequent decade.^[53] ^[82] For undecided students, comprehensives may facilitate exploration without early commitment, but this comes at the expense of proficiency, as CTE concentrators outperform general-track peers in targeted outcomes like attendance and skill acquisition.^[83] This egalitarian orientation in comprehensive institutions often disregards students' comparative advantages—such as aptitude for manual trades over abstract academics—leading to persistent skill mismatches and underutilization of talent. Vocational specialization aligns training with individual strengths and market demands, minimizing opportunity costs, whereas the comprehensive approach's uniformity can perpetuate inefficiency, as evidenced by higher transition frictions in systems lacking dedicated tracks.^[84] While comprehensive schools aim for versatility, data indicate that for career-bound youth, specialized models deliver superior causal pathways to occupational fit and economic productivity.^[85]

Purported Advantages

Comprehensive high schools were designed to foster social integration by enrolling students from varied socioeconomic backgrounds in non-selective environments, aiming to diminish class-based snobbery and promote mutual understanding among youth. In the United Kingdom, the expansion of comprehensive schools during the 1960s and 1970s was explicitly motivated by egalitarian principles, with policymakers arguing that mixing pupils across ability and class lines would erode social divisions inherited from the selective grammar school system.^[86] Early implementation data indicated short-term increases in socioeconomic diversity within individual schools, as catchment areas drew from broader residential mixes compared to prior selective models, though this varied by local authority adoption rates.^[87] Despite these intentions, empirical observations reveal persistent self-segregation that undermines claims of substantial integration gains. Studies of U.S. comprehensive high schools, which represent the dominant non-selective model, document pronounced divides in informal settings; for instance, a 2014 analysis of cafeteria seating patterns in ethnically diverse middle schools (analogous to high school dynamics) found significant racial segregation, with students clustering by background even in integrated physical spaces, suggesting socioeconomic parallels where class proxies like attire or speech patterns reinforce divides.^[88] Similarly, no rigorous causal evidence links comprehensive structures to long-term reductions in class divides or enhanced intergenerational mobility; evaluations of England's transition to comprehensives show negligible impacts on overall social mobility rates, with outcomes comparable to selective systems and no attributable boost from mixing alone.^[89] ^[90] From a causal standpoint, assumptions underlying social mixing overlook innate trait variations that influence social and academic trajectories. Twin studies consistently estimate IQ heritability at 50-80% in adulthood, indicating genetic factors substantially shape cognitive potential independent of environmental mixing, which challenges the premise that mere proximity equalizes opportunities or erodes entrenched divides without addressing underlying differentials.^[91] ^[92] Overstated equity narratives thus lack substantiation, as integration efforts yield observable diversity in enrollment but fail to demonstrably alter persistent behavioral segregation or mobility pathways.^[93]

Accessibility and Broad Preparation

Comprehensive high schools operate without selective entry requirements, admitting all students residing within designated catchment areas, which facilitates near-universal secondary enrollment in systems like the United States public education framework.^[94] This open-access model has contributed to sustained high participation rates, with U.S. public high schools enrolling approximately 90% of secondary students as of recent data. Post-1990s policy emphases on accountability and completion, including measures like the No Child Left Behind Act of 2001, aligned with rising graduation rates; the averaged freshman graduation rate climbed from 71% in 1995–96 to 75% by 2004–05, while adjusted cohort graduation rates reached 86.2% by 2018–19.^[95]^[96] The curriculum structure emphasizes broad preparation through core subjects supplemented by elective courses, enabling students to tailor education toward diverse postsecondary paths such as college, vocational training, or workforce entry.^[97] This flexibility supports youth uncertain about future directions by exposing them to varied disciplines, fostering initial exploration of interests without premature specialization.^[98] Empirical observations from educational analyses indicate that such breadth aids in decision-making for undecided adolescents, as elective options allow sampling of fields like arts, technology, or trades alongside academics.^[99] However, this accessible breadth incurs opportunity costs relative to more focused models, as time allocated across multiple subjects inherently limits depth in any one area. Studies on high school science coursework reveal that students achieving greater depth—covering fewer topics intensively—earn higher grades in corresponding college classes compared to those with broader but shallower exposure.^[100]^[101] Causal analysis of learning constraints underscores this trade-off: fixed instructional hours force allocation choices between extensive coverage and mastery, potentially suboptimal for human capital development in specialized domains.^[102] While verifiable via enrollment metrics, the model's emphasis on inclusivity raises questions about efficiency in cultivating expertise for high-skill trajectories.

Criticisms and Empirical Shortcomings

Dilution of Academic Standards

In comprehensive high schools, the integration of students across a wide range of academic abilities into heterogeneous classrooms often results in instructional practices adjusted downward to meet the needs of the average or lower-performing students, thereby reducing overall rigor. Teachers, facing diverse readiness levels, tend to simplify curricula and lower expectations to ensure broader comprehension, which disadvantages higher-ability students who receive insufficient challenge.^[55]^[103] This dynamic has been critiqued as a form of diluted standards, where the lowest common denominator dictates pacing rather than differentiated instruction or grouping by ability. A notable manifestation occurred during the 1960s and 1970s, as U.S. education shifted toward more progressive, inclusive models aligned with comprehensive schooling principles, coinciding with a sharp decline in standardized test performance. Average SAT verbal scores fell from 478 in 1963 to 429 by 1978, while math scores dropped from 502 to 468 over the same period, prompting concerns over eroding curriculum demands and instructional quality.^[104]^[105] This downturn was partly attributed to experimental pedagogies and reduced emphasis on foundational skills, which prioritized equity over excellence in mixed-ability environments.^[106] In response, the "back to basics" movement emerged in the mid-1970s as a direct counter to perceived laxity in academic expectations within comprehensive systems. Advocates demanded a return to rigorous focus on core subjects like reading, writing, and arithmetic, criticizing prior decades' innovations for fostering undisciplined, watered-down instruction that failed to prepare students adequately.^[107]^[108] This push reflected empirical evidence of falling achievement, including stagnant or declining scores amid expanding enrollment in non-selective schools. Long-term data from the National Assessment of Educational Progress (NAEP) further underscores this erosion, with reading and math scores for 17-year-olds remaining largely flat from the 1970s through the 2000s despite real per-pupil spending rising over 245% in constant dollars.^[109]^[110] Analysts have linked this disconnect to anti-tracking policies prevalent in comprehensive high schools, which discourage ability-based grouping and promote uniform curricula ill-suited to the bell-shaped distribution of cognitive abilities documented in psychometric research.^[111] Such policies, by design, ignore innate variance in student aptitude—where abilities cluster around a mean with significant tails—leading to mismatched instruction that neither elevates low performers nor sustains high ones, as argued in analyses of intelligence stratification.^[112] Detracking experiments have yielded mixed results, often showing no gains for lower-ability students and setbacks for advanced ones due to reduced curricular depth.^[113]^[55]

Peer Effects and Discipline Challenges

In mixed-ability classrooms typical of comprehensive high schools, exposure to lower-achieving or unmotivated peers has been shown to exert negative influences on the engagement and performance of higher-achieving students through behavioral disruptions and reduced classroom focus.^[114] Empirical analyses from the early 2000s indicate that high-ability students experience substantial declines in math achievement gains when paired with more low-ability peers, with effects large enough to offset potential benefits from average peers.^[114] These dynamics arise causally from the tendency of disruptive or disengaged students to interrupt instructional time, fostering an environment where motivated learners divert energy to coping with distractions rather than advancing academically.^[115] Discipline challenges intensify in such heterogeneous settings, as the presence of unmotivated or behaviorally challenging students correlates with elevated rates of classroom disorder and formal sanctions. U.S. Department of Education data from the 2010s reveal suspension rates exceeding 7% for secondary students in non-selective public schools, with disruptions from low-engagement peers contributing to chronic absenteeism and teacher burnout that perpetuate cycles of indiscipline.^[116] Critiques attribute part of this to policy shifts toward leniency since the 1960s, which, in the absence of ability-based sorting, amplify conflicts arising from mismatched motivation levels and fail to contain spillover effects on compliant students.^[115] From an evolutionary perspective, human tendencies toward status-seeking within peer groups exacerbate these mismatches, as integrating disparate ability levels disrupts natural hierarchies where high-status individuals (often high-achievers) model prosocial behaviors, leading instead to victimization and conformity pressures toward lower norms.^[117] Studies in developmental psychology highlight how rigid social hierarchies in classrooms heighten peer aggression and disengagement when high- and low-status students are forcibly intermixed, undermining cooperative learning without structured separation.^[118] This aligns with causal mechanisms where deviant peer behaviors propagate through social contagion, reducing overall group productivity in unsorted environments.^[119]

Evidence from Research and Outcomes

Short-Term Academic Performance Studies

Studies comparing short-term academic performance in comprehensive high schools to selective alternatives primarily rely on standardized test scores and national exams as metrics, with raw differences often exceeding 0.5 standard deviations in favor of selective schools. However, causal estimates from admission lotteries and regression discontinuity designs, which control for prior achievement, typically range from 0.1 to 0.3 standard deviations for selective attendance. A 2018 analysis of Australian selective high schools using entry exam cutoffs found that admitted students gained about 0.2 standard deviations in university entrance scores relative to high-achieving applicants rejected to comprehensive or non-selective schools, attributing gains partly to peer effects but diminishing over time.^[120] Similarly, UK studies on grammar schools versus comprehensives report comparable small causal boosts in GCSE exam results for selective attendees, after adjusting for baseline ability. In the U.S., where comprehensive high schools predominate, the 1983 "A Nation at Risk" report documented declining average SAT scores (from 978 in 1963 to 897 in 1977 for college-bound seniors) and international underperformance, linking these to diluted standards and uneven rigor in mixed-ability classrooms that characterize comprehensive models.^[81] Evaluations of selective exam schools, such as those in Chicago, show initial test score advantages of 0.2-0.4 standard deviations, but these largely vanish when controlling for applicant selection and prior test scores, suggesting minimal added value from the school environment itself.^[121]^[122] Recent 2020s research reinforces that comprehensive systems yield no overall short-term edge in test scores, with subgroup benefits—such as for mid-tier students—remaining marginal (under 0.1 standard deviations) even under competitive pressures from choice policies.^[123] High-ability students in comprehensives often experience relative downward equalization, achieving 0.1-0.2 standard deviations less in exams than peers of similar priors in selective settings, due to diluted pacing and peer influences.^[122] Methodologically, studies prioritizing prior controls over simple correlations highlight that selection effects explain most variance, with school composition exerting limited causal influence on immediate outcomes beyond student sorting.^[121]^[122]

Long-Term Socioeconomic Impacts

Graduates of selective secondary schools demonstrate higher rates of university degree attainment and long-term earnings compared to those from comprehensive high schools, with differences persisting into adulthood. A 2020 analysis of UK birth cohorts in BMC Medicine reported that selective school attendees had a 1.5 times higher likelihood of obtaining a university degree and exhibited elevated occupational status, though multivariate adjustments revealed these outcomes were predominantly associated with pre-existing higher IQ scores (average 10-point advantage) and advantaged family socioeconomic status rather than causal effects of the school system itself.^[124] Longitudinal evidence from the 2010s and 2020s indicates no causal enhancement of social mobility under comprehensive systems, challenging claims of equalization through non-selective mixing. A 2023 London School of Economics study, exploiting England's staggered shift from selective grammar schools to comprehensives between 1960 and 1979, found that the transition did not increase intergenerational income mobility; instead, selective schooling boosted absolute mobility for high-ability children from low-income families by 5-10 percentile points in adult earnings, as peer concentration preserved motivational and network advantages that carried over into career trajectories.^[89] This aligns with quasi-experimental findings from grammar school expansions, where access to selective places raised human capital accumulation—measured via lifetime earnings—by approximately 7% for marginal entrants, underscoring selection's role in amplifying innate potential over environmental averaging in comprehensives.^[125] Twin and adoption studies reinforce that genetic and cognitive selection mechanisms, rather than comprehensive schooling's environmental interventions, predominantly drive divergent adult socioeconomic paths. Heritability estimates from twin designs attribute 50-70% of variance in educational and earnings outcomes to genetic factors, with shared school environments explaining less than 10%, implying that comprehensive integration induces regression to the population mean for both gifted and lower-ability students without altering underlying causal trajectories.^[126] These designs isolate selection effects by comparing monozygotic twins discordant for school type, revealing persistent peer-driven divergences in professional attainment that favor selective sorting over egalitarian mixing.^[127]

Global Implementation and Policy Debates

United States Context

In the United States, comprehensive high schools emerged as the predominant public secondary education model following the 1918 Cardinal Principles of Secondary Education, which advocated for schools serving diverse student needs under one roof, and solidified their near-monopoly by the 1970s as enrollment in specialized or vocational alternatives waned amid expanding compulsory attendance laws and suburbanization.^[6] By the late 20th century, over 90% of public high school students attended these institutions, which aimed to integrate academic, vocational, and general tracks but often faced criticism for diluting rigor in heterogeneous settings.^[128] This dominance persisted into the 2020s, with approximately 20,000 public high schools—vastly outnumbering charter or magnet alternatives—enrolling the majority of the roughly 15 million secondary students.^[129]^[130] The rise of charter schools, beginning with Minnesota's 1991 legislation authorizing independently operated public schools exempt from certain regulations, and voucher programs, such as Wisconsin's 1990 initiative for low-income Milwaukee families, signaled growing dissatisfaction with the comprehensive model's one-size-fits-all approach, particularly in underperforming urban districts.^[131]^[132] By 2023, charter enrollment reached about 3.7 million students across 7,800 schools, representing roughly 7% of public school pupils, while voucher expansions in states like Florida and Arizona further eroded the traditional monopoly by enabling parental choice and competition.^[133] The Every Student Succeeds Act (ESSA) of 2015 reinforced this shift by devolving accountability from federal to state levels, permitting greater flexibility for intradistrict choice, weighted lotteries favoring disadvantaged students, and portable Title I funds to follow pupils to preferred schools, though comprehensive high schools remained the default in most districts due to entrenched union and bureaucratic resistance.^[134]^[135] Empirical data underscores policy debates, with National Assessment of Educational Progress (NAEP) results revealing persistent achievement gaps in urban comprehensive high schools, where Black and Hispanic students scored 20-30 points below white peers in 2022 reading and math assessments for grades 8 and 12, gaps that widened post-2020 amid disruptions in these settings.^[136] Trial Urban District Assessments (TUDA) highlight failures in cities like Detroit and Baltimore, where proficiency rates hover below 10% in core subjects, contrasting with modest gains in selective charter alternatives and fueling arguments for expanded choice to address causal factors like peer heterogeneity and administrative inefficiencies rather than perpetuating a state-assigned model.^[137]^[138] Proponents of reform cite these outcomes as evidence that comprehensive structures exacerbate disparities in diverse environments, prompting legislative pushes in over 20 states since 2015 to prioritize parental empowerment over centralized uniformity.^[139]

United Kingdom and European Models

In the United Kingdom, the comprehensive secondary school model was widely implemented from the 1960s onward, with the 1965 policy directive encouraging local education authorities to abolish selective grammar schools in favor of non-selective institutions serving all ability levels. By 1980, approximately 85% of secondary pupils attended comprehensives, driven by aims to promote social equality.^[140] Critiques of this system, including evidence of stagnant social mobility and lower average attainment in non-selective areas compared to selective legacies, have fueled calls for selective revivals. In the 2020s, under Conservative leadership, expansions of existing grammar schools—163 of which remain operational, admitting about 5% of pupils via the 11+ exam—were permitted through bulge classes and satellite sites, though new standalone grammars faced legal bans lifted only partially in policy proposals like those from Rishi Sunak in 2023.^[140] ^[141] Sweden's comprehensive upper secondary system, consolidated in the 1970s by merging academic and vocational tracks, encountered significant challenges following PISA score declines from 590 in 2000 to 497 in mathematics by 2012, attributed partly to reduced differentiation and teacher autonomy erosion. Reforms post-2010, including expanded free schools (friskolor) comprising 15% of upper secondary enrollment by 2020, introduced quasi-selective elements via parental choice and performance-based funding, aiming to rectify uniformity-induced disengagement without reinstating formal early selection.^[142] ^[143] These adjustments yielded modest PISA recoveries, with mathematics rising to 509 by 2018, though equity gaps persisted.^[144] European variance highlights hybrid approaches; France's system features comprehensive collèges for ages 11-15, followed by partial selectivity in lycées where students are streamed into general (20% enrollment), technological, or professional tracks based on middle school performance and orientation counseling, with elite classes préparatoires aux grandes écoles selecting top performers for higher education pipelines.^[145] Empirical analyses across Europe, including quasi-experimental studies of grammar school attendance, indicate that selective mechanisms boost high-end academic outcomes—such as higher university progression rates for top decile pupils—without depressing system-wide averages, as variance increases but peak performance rises.^[146] ^[40] Debates in these models pit equity, which comprehensive uniformity seeks via reduced early sorting, against excellence, where selection preserves incentives for cognitive elites driving innovation; causal evidence from tracking reforms favors the latter, as compressed achievement distributions in non-selective settings correlate with diminished elite formation, per longitudinal European cohort data.^[147] ^[148] Pro-equity advocates, often from equity-focused NGOs, emphasize widened access but overlook how selection sustains overall productivity via specialized pathways, as seen in persistent gaps where comprehensives underperform grammars on value-added metrics by 0.1-0.2 standard deviations.^[40] ^[146]

Challenges in Developing Nations

In developing nations, the adoption of comprehensive high school models—non-selective secondary institutions intended to integrate students of varying abilities—has frequently encountered profound obstacles due to entrenched infrastructure deficits and socioeconomic disparities. During the 2000s, India's expansion of secondary education under initiatives like the Rashtriya Madhyamik Shiksha Abhiyan aimed to universalize access through non-selective public schools, yet persistent gaps in basic facilities undermined these efforts; for example, a 2011 analysis documented widespread lacks in school infrastructure, including electricity in only about 50% of secondary institutions and functional toilets in under 60%, particularly in rural areas. ^[149] ^[150] Similarly, Brazil's push for universal secondary enrollment by the mid-2000s achieved near-complete primary coverage but faltered at the secondary level, where public non-selective schools grappled with overcrowded classrooms and inadequate materials, contributing to stagnant learning outcomes amid rapid enrollment growth from 72% in 2000 to over 90% by 2007. ^[151] These infrastructural shortfalls have precipitated de facto segregation within ostensibly comprehensive systems, as affluent families increasingly turn to fee-based private alternatives, concentrating high-ability and motivated students away from public institutions. In India, this dynamic has resulted in public secondary schools predominantly enrolling lower-income cohorts, with private unaided schools capturing over 30% of secondary enrollment by the early 2010s, thereby diluting the integrative intent of comprehensives and perpetuating resource drain from public funding. ^[150] In Brazil, non-selective policies have not prevented pronounced classroom-level segregation; studies from the 2010s reveal black-white segregation indices in public high schools exceeding those in comparable U.S. contexts without tracking, driven by residential sorting and parental choice, which widens proficiency gaps—e.g., segregated schools show a 0.2-0.3 standard deviation larger racial achievement disparity. ^[152] ^[153] UNESCO's Global Education Monitoring Reports underscore how such comprehensive frameworks, absent robust selection mechanisms or quality safeguards, amplify inequalities in resource-constrained settings by failing to buffer against preexisting hierarchies of wealth and ability. ^[154] World Bank evaluations of secondary education structures in developing countries similarly caution that uniform non-selective models overlook local causal realities, such as acute teacher shortages (e.g., vacancy rates exceeding 20% in many systems) and uneven resource distribution, which hinder effective peer mixing and instead reinforce low-quality equilibria for the majority. ^[155] This mismatch has sustained lower completion rates—around 60-70% for secondary in India and Brazil during the 2010s—and diminished socioeconomic mobility, as comprehensives without foundational supports devolve into stratified venues rather than equalizers. ^[151]

Recent Reforms and Future Directions

Adaptations Post-2020

The shift to hybrid learning models in comprehensive high schools during the COVID-19 pandemic from 2020 to 2022 highlighted inherent challenges in accommodating diverse student abilities within mixed classrooms, as remote components exacerbated disparities in engagement and achievement without addressing underlying structural issues.^[156]^[157] Public school enrollment, predominantly in comprehensive systems, dropped sharply from 50.8 million students in fall 2019 to 49.4 million in fall 2020 and 2021, reflecting parental dissatisfaction with hybrid efficacy and a pivot toward alternatives like homeschooling.^[158] By 2023, as in-person instruction resumed, these models persisted with incremental tweaks, such as asynchronous modules, but failed to resolve core dilution effects from ability mixing, with studies noting sustained learning losses averaging 0.2-0.5 standard deviations in math and reading.^[159]^[160] Emerging AI-driven tools from 2023 onward have offered partial personalization within comprehensive frameworks, functioning as supplements rather than catalysts for paradigm shifts away from non-selective enrollment. Teacher adoption of AI for tasks like adaptive tutoring reached 60% in the 2024-2025 school year, enabling differentiated instruction in mixed-ability classes without necessitating streaming or selective tracking.^[161] Reports indicate AI platforms improved student agency and engagement by tailoring content to individual paces, yet implementation remained uneven, with only 31% of schools establishing formal AI policies by mid-2025, underscoring reliance on tech as a band-aid for persistent heterogeneity challenges.^[162]^[161] In the United States, adaptations have included expanded career pathways programs within comprehensive high schools, driven by post-pandemic recognition of mismatched postsecondary preparation, though these have not supplanted the comprehensive model. A 2025 analysis projected U.S. high school graduates peaking at 3.9 million in 2025 before declining to 3.4 million by 2041, prompting states to integrate vocational tracks earlier, with 72% of 2025 graduates reporting inadequate career readiness and just 35% pursuing traditional college paths.^[163]^[164] Enrollment in such pathways rose amid broader trends, as 45% of grades 7-12 students in 2025 surveys favored alternatives to four-year colleges, yet comprehensive schools retained mixed cohorts, using AI and pathways for superficial customization rather than systemic reform.^[165] Overall, these post-2020 measures have mitigated symptoms of ability dilution but evidenced no widespread abandonment of the comprehensive paradigm, with projected enrollment stabilization masking unresolved causal tensions in causal student interactions.^[166]

Ongoing Policy Controversies

In the United States, expansions of school voucher and charter programs during the 2020s have intensified debates over the efficacy of comprehensive high schools, which emphasize non-selective enrollment for all students. Proponents argue that these choice mechanisms enable tailored educational environments, with randomized controlled trials demonstrating improved long-term outcomes such as higher college enrollment rates among participants compared to those in assigned public schools.^[167] ^[168] However, critics of vouchers contend that they divert funds from comprehensive public systems without proportional academic gains, citing analyses showing participating students often underperform on standardized tests relative to public school peers.^[169] ^[170] Fiscal impact studies present conflicting evidence, with one estimating taxpayer savings of $19.4 to $45.6 billion through fiscal year 2022 due to reduced public school enrollment costs, while others highlight budget strains on remaining comprehensive institutions.^[171] ^[172] In the United Kingdom, recent analyses of selective grammar schools versus comprehensive models have questioned traditional claims of widespread harm from academic selection. A 2024 study found that attendance at selective schools correlates with post-18 educational and employment advantages for students who complete their studies there, challenging narratives of inherent inequality exacerbation.^[173] Complementary research indicates that grammar school attendees outperform statistically matched peers in non-selective settings, suggesting potential benefits from ability-grouped instruction without the predicted systemic drawbacks for lower-achievers.^[71] Defenders of comprehensives counter that selective systems may depress overall attainment in surrounding areas, though causal evidence from comparative regions shows minimal aggregate grade improvements from grammar dominance.^[174] Diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) initiatives in comprehensive high schools have sparked controversy over their effects on academic rigor, with empirical data revealing correlations between such policies and declining standards. Implementation of DEI-driven admissions, as in certain elite public high schools, has led to measurable drops in test scores and enrollment of high-performing demographics, such as Asian students, from 73% to 54% in one case.^[175] Broader proficiency trends link DEI emphasis to worsened outcomes, particularly in reading and math for non-white students, undermining merit-based progression central to comprehensive ideals.^[176] Advocates for merit restoration prioritize causal evaluations, including randomized trials favoring flexible, performance-aligned structures over ideologically driven equity measures that dilute incentives for excellence.^[177]^[178]

References

[1]
[PDF] Pease, Virginia H. TITLE The Comprehensive High School - ERIC
ABSTRACT. This report charts a brief history of the comprehensive high school in the United States designed particularly to highlight those key decisions ...
[2]
Is the Comprehensive High School Doomed? - Education Week
Sep 21, 2004 · The comprehensive high school was a uniquely American phenomenon. It sought to gather all youths into a single institution that would prepare ...Missing: origins | Show results with:origins
[3]
[PDF] The Cardinal Principles Report Revisited - Purdue e-Pubs
The Cardinal Principles report promoted a comprehensive high school model for social efficiency, aiming to equip citizens for an orderly, efficient society.
[4]
The History of the American High School - Sutori
1918 Commission on the Reorganization of Secondary Education This commission was made up of leaders of education schools who favored a comprehensive high school ...
[5]
When High Schools Shaped America's Destiny - City Journal
Aug 1, 2017 · As a result, the comprehensive high school took on the shape familiar to us today. In its early incarnation, it was highly effective at its ...<|separator|>
[6]
[PDF] The Comprehensive High School in American Education - ASCD
Whereas the comprehensive high school was conceived early in this century as the prototype of American democracy, it was now being viewed as an impedi ment to ...Missing: origins | Show results with:origins
[7]
The Traditional High School - Education Next
Jun 22, 2006 · And the questions today are whether and how much this “comprehensive high school” has contributed to the declining quality of secondary ...
[8]
[PDF] U.S. High School Curriculum: Three Phases of Contemporary ...
They begin by tracing the historical development of the U.S. comprehensive high school and then examine the curricular reforms of the past three decades. During ...
[9]
What is the population of the average American high school? - Quora
Mar 28, 2016 · According to the most recent data, as of 2015–16, the average enrollment in regular secondary schools was 979 students. Source: Digest of ...Missing: comprehensive | Show results with:comprehensive
[10]
Heterogeneous Grouping in Education: Benefits & Best Practices
Sep 9, 2024 · Heterogeneous grouping is an educational practice where students with diverse abilities, skills, and backgrounds are placed in the same learning group.Introduction · Research Supports... · The Dangers of Ability Grouping
[11]
How Can Heterogeneous Grouping Help? | Coalition of Essential ...
Heterogeneous grouping–mixing students of different ability levels in academic classes, instead of streaming them with like peers in tracks toward class-born ...Missing: comprehensive | Show results with:comprehensive
[12]
Departmentalized Classrooms
A departmentalized classroom is where an instructor teaches a specific subject to a group, often in middle, junior, or high school settings.Missing: administrative features
[13]
Continuum of Special Education Services | New York State ...
The continuum of special education services for school-age students with disabilities is an array of services to meet an individual student's needs.
[14]
Special Education: Making Classrooms Inclusive
Jul 13, 2023 · What is an Inclusive Classroom? Special education teachers play a big role in facilitating inclusive classroom environments in schools.<|control11|><|separator|>
[15]
Urban Schools: Executive Summary
Urban schools had larger enrollments, on average, than suburban or rural schools at both the elementary and secondary levels. Urban teachers had fewer resources ...Missing: comprehensive | Show results with:comprehensive
[16]
[PDF] the rise of secondary schooling in america, 1910 to 1940
The US led in secondary school growth from 1910-1940, driven by factors like income homogeneity, community stability, and social capital, with high pecuniary ...
[17]
[PDF] Lessons from Secondary School Expansion, 1910 to 1940 | Harvard ...
Jun 28, 2008 · The US led in education due to the "high school movement" with higher wealth, income, social stability, and public college funding. Areas with ...
[18]
The Rise of Secondary Schooling in America, 1910 to 1940 | NBER
Mar 1, 1998 · The high school movement was driven by income homogeneity, higher wealth, community stability, ethnic/religious homogeneity, and high pecuniary ...
[19]
[PDF] Does compulsory school attendance affect schooling and earnings?
Our estimates suggest that as many as 25 percent of potential dropouts remain in school because of compulsory schooling laws. We estimate the impact of ...
[20]
Enrollment in grades 9 through 12 in public and private schools ...
This table compares enrollment in grades 9-12 with the population aged 14-17, from 1889-90 through fall 2017, including ratios.
[21]
Study finds early U.S. compulsory schooling laws benefited minorities
Apr 25, 2014 · A University of Kansas researcher has found early US compulsory schooling laws produced hidden gains in school attendance and educational attainment among ...
[22]
[PDF] Lessons from Secondary School Expansion, 1910 to 1940
The group forms an "educational belt" across America. Enrollment and graduation rates in California, Oregon,. Washington, Nebraska, Kansas, Iowa, Indiana, a ...
[23]
ERIC - EJ283832 - The American High School Today
Conant's "The American High School Today" (1959) conveyed his confidence in consolidation of smaller schools into comprehensive high schools.
[24]
The American High School Today: A First Report to Interested Citizens
The American High School Today: A First Report to Interested Citizens. Front Cover. James Bryant Conant. McGraw-Hill, 1959 - Education, Secondary - 140 pages ...
[25]
Total undergraduate fall enrollment in degree-granting ...
The primary purpose of the Digest of Education Statistics is to provide a compilation of statistical information covering the broad field of American ...
[26]
Elementary and Secondary Education Act of 1965
This law brought education into the forefront of the national assault on poverty and represented a landmark commitment to equal access to quality education.<|separator|>
[27]
How the School System is Rigged for Failure
Jun 18, 1970 · Mario Fantini and Gerald Weinstein, who have had much to do with shaping the Ford Foundation's broad program of educational support, cite ...Missing: comprehensive | Show results with:comprehensive
[28]
If Schools Had Heeded Their 1960's Critics... - Education Week
Jun 1, 1983 · The critics of the 1960's-John Holt, Jonathan Kozol, Herbert Kohl, Nat Hentoff, Peter Schrag, Edgar Z. Friedenberg, George Dennison, Mario Fantini, Neil ...Missing: comprehensive | Show results with:comprehensive
[29]
DES Circular 10/65 (1965) - Education in the UK
Jun 21, 2009 · It is the Government's declared objective to end selection at eleven plus and to eliminate separatism in secondary education.Missing: rate | Show results with:rate
[30]
[PDF] From Learning to Live to Circular 10/65 Gary McCulloch UCL
Fifty years after its initial circulation, the current article seeks to trace the idea of comprehensive education from the 1940s to the 1960s, to understand the ...
[31]
[PDF] A (short) history of comprehensive education in England
Nov 12, 2016 · Labour introduced the School Standards and Framework Act in 1999. Grammar schools were designated as such under section 104 of the Act. Under ...Missing: adoption rate
[32]
Educational achievement in selective and comprehensive local ...
There are a number of possible explanations why inequality is relatively lower in Sweden, among them a school system which facilitates transitions at any point, ...
[33]
https://oxfordre.com/education/display/10.1093/acrefore/9780190264093.001.0001/acrefore-9780190264093-e-1679
[34]
Three Decades of School Failure in Swedish Compulsory School
Nov 10, 2020 · The introduction of comprehensive, nine-year compulsory schooling in the 1960s turned the Swedish school system into one of the most progressive ...
[35]
[PDF] School choice and segregation: Evidence from Sweden - EconStor
May 4, 2015 · The Swedish voucher system is based upon the idea to give equal opportunities to all pupils: the voucher follows the pupil to his/her school of ...
[36]
School tracking, educational mobility and inequality in German ...
Jan 1, 2017 · Secondary education is associated with a comparatively high level of inequality in Germany. This has often been attributed to the early ...
[37]
The effect of tracking in secondary education on educational inequality
For instance, evidence from Great Britain, France and Germany suggests that the shift from a selective to a comprehensive secondary school system did not ...
[38]
Educational attainment: a French-German comparison - ResearchGate
This documentation analyses the structure of educational attainment in France and Germany. While France and Germany share in many respects similar ...
[39]
[PDF] Academic Evidence on Selective Secondary Education
Available evidence from England and international comparisons using PISA data suggests that selective education systems widen educational inequality. Selective ...
[40]
[PDF] Evidence on the effects of selective education systems
Most studies show no clear advantage overall, but grammar school pupils tend to perform better than equally able pupils in comprehensives.
[41]
Reform movement - NSW Department of Education
Mar 6, 2023 · The introduction of the Wyndham Scheme from 1962 confirmed the trend towards comprehensive, co-educational high school system in NSW. At the ...
[42]
Comprehensive government high school - DEHANZ
Feb 22, 2014 · By the 1970s such comprehensive schools educated a majority of Australian 12-17 year-old youth, but the size of the majority has been in a ...
[43]
Selective schools' long and tangled history with race and class
Mar 28, 2017 · During the 1960s and 1970s, selective schools fell out of favour with policymakers and many parents. They were mostly replaced by comprehensive ...
[44]
Tracking and educational inequality: a longitudinal analysis of two ...
Apr 22, 2023 · This paper examines the effects of different forms of tracking on learning inequalities in compulsory education. In contrast to comprehensive ...<|control11|><|separator|>
[45]
High School Graduation Requirements: Core Classes & Credits ...
High school core classes typically include four years of English language arts, three years of math and science, and two years of social sciences.
[46]
Table 2.13. State course credit requirements for high school ...
This table shows 2018 state course credit requirements for high school graduation, including total credits, English, Math, Science, Arts, and Social Studies. ...
[47]
Complete List of High School Electives - PrepScholar Blog
Vocational Education · Auto body repair · Auto mechanics · Building construction · Computer-aided drafting · Cosmetology · Criminal justice · Driver Education ...Missing: comprehensive | Show results with:comprehensive
[48]
Complete List of High School Electives - College Transitions
Jan 29, 2024 · You'll find below a complete list of high school electives and know exactly what to expect in this important chapter of your high school career.Missing: comprehensive | Show results with:comprehensive
[49]
The troubled history of vocational education | APM Reports
Sep 9, 2014 · Vocational education was once used to track low-income students off to work while wealthier kids went to college.
[50]
How Many Credits Do You Need to Graduate High School?
Dec 13, 2024 · On average, high schools require students to earn between 22 and 26 total credits to graduate. At Obridge Academy, we require students to earn ...<|separator|>
[51]
50-State Comparison: High School Graduation Requirements
May 23, 2023 · This resource provides a national comparison of state policies addressing graduation requirements, including pathways, diploma types and endorsements.
[52]
Closing Advanced Coursework Equity Gaps for All Students
Jun 30, 2021 · This report examines the patterns of which high school students are enrolling and succeeding in AP classes based on the availability of AP courses offered at ...
[53]
What we know about Career and Technical Education in high school
Oct 5, 2017 · However, CTE has been on the decline for several decades. Starting in the 1980s, states increased the number of courses required for high school ...Missing: dilution | Show results with:dilution
[54]
[PDF] Trends in High School Vocational/Technical Coursetaking: 1982–1998
Based on. SST classifications, occupational education in this report consists of the 10 broad and 18 narrow pro- gram areas shown in figure A. General labor ...Missing: dilution | Show results with:dilution
[55]
The Detracking Movement - Education Next
Jun 30, 2006 · Critics argued that tracking, especially in practice, created greater learning opportunities for high-performing students at the expense of ...
[56]
Newfangled 'Grouping' in Schools Looks Like Oldfangled 'Tracking'
Jun 22, 1997 · Grouping of students by intellectual ability, or tracking, has been taboo since the 1970's, the victim of concerns about racial pigeonholing ...Missing: comprehensive hidden<|separator|>
[57]
The Resurgence of Ability Grouping and Persistence of Tracking
Mar 18, 2013 · This study examines the use of ability grouping and tracking in America's schools. Recent NAEP data reveal a resurgence of ability grouping in fourth grade.
[58]
Tracking and Ability Grouping in Middle Level and High Schools
Tracking refers to a method used by many secondary schools to group students according to their perceived ability, IQ, or achievement levels.
[59]
https://www.simplypsychology.org/piaget.html
[60]
The dark side of detracking: Mixed-ability classrooms negatively ...
Our study provides important insights into how detracking affects students' academic self-concept and contributes to the debate between the labeling hypothesis ...
[61]
Learning-related behaviors, cognitive skills, and ability grouping ...
We use ECLS-K data from a national sample of students to estimate the determinants and consequences of reading ability group placement in kindergarten and ...Missing: variance Piaget
[62]
How should we measure the effect of ability grouping on student ...
Work by Argys, Rees and Brewer (1996)and Hoffer (1992), suggests that tracking creates winners and losers. Students placed in upper-track classes benefit in ...
[63]
Full article: Ability grouping and student performance: A longitudinal ...
The results indicate that students from high-ability groups enjoyed greater levels of teacher support, which partly explains their higher levels of achievement.
[64]
Extracurricular Participation And Student Engagement
This issue brief examines the relationship between extracurricular participation and student engagement in school using data from 1992 public high school ...
[65]
Extracurricular Participation, “At-Risk” Status, and the High School ...
Apr 1, 2017 · I estimate the effect of extracurricular participation on the high school dropout decision with a particular focus on at-risk students.
[66]
The Relationship between Participation in Extracurricular Arts and ...
Jun 27, 2024 · Neely and Vaquera found that participation in extracurricular sports and arts activities significantly reduced dropout rates in high school ...
[67]
ED354450 - Dropout Prevention Initiatives FY 1986 to 1990 ... - ERIC
In 1985-86 two major attendance improvement/dropout prevention programs were initiated in selected New York City middle and high schools with attendance ...
[68]
The Impacts of Dropout Prevention Programs - Mathematica
From 1988-1996, SDDAP provided federal support for local efforts to reduce the dropout rate, awarding grants to school districts, nonprofit community-based ...
[69]
[PDF] A Comparison of High School Dropout Rates in 1982 and 1992
High school dropout rates decreased by almost 50 percent between 1980-82 and 1990-92, though some groups of students did not improve.
[70]
Differences in exam performance between pupils attending selective ...
Mar 23, 2018 · On average, students attending selective schools outperform their non-selective counterparts in national exams. These differences are often ...
[71]
Consequences of academic selection for post‐primary education in ...
Jun 9, 2025 · Multi-level regression analysis, Grammar students obtained 5.5 GCSE grade points more than comparable students who attended comprehensive ...
[72]
[PDF] Social selectivity of state schools and the impact of grammars
The research suggests that grammar school students take subjects that are on average about a tenth of a GCSE grade harder than pupils in other schools. Page 5 ...
[73]
[PDF] Magnet Schools and Student Achievement
Magnet schools show a positive effect on math achievement, but this is reduced when controlling for student demographics and prior achievement.
[74]
https://oxfordre.com/economics/display/10.1093/acrefore/9780190625979.001.0001/acrefore-9780190625979-e-894
[75]
Stanford education study provides new evidence of “big-fish-little ...
Nov 30, 2018 · Conversely, when equally talented students (little fish) are in high-achieving environments (big pond), they compare themselves to their peers ...Missing: comprehensive | Show results with:comprehensive
[76]
The Big-Fish-Little-Pond Effect on the Four Facets of Academic Self ...
Jul 20, 2018 · How an early transition to high-ability secondary schools affects students' academic self-concept: contrast effects, assimilation effects, and ...
[77]
The Good, the Bad, and the Average: Evidence on Ability Peer ...
We study ability peer effects in English secondary schools using data on four cohorts of students taking age-14 national tests and measuring peers' ability ...
[78]
[PDF] Europe between youth unemployment and skilled labour shortages
In Germany, the dual vocational training system is one of the reasons for the country's low youth unemployment rate. Each year some 500,000 youths – nearly ...
[79]
The story of the vocational education system in Germany - GIS Reports
Dec 11, 2018 · Germany is a model of the vocational education system, with youth unemployment of just over 6 percent. France, where 22 percent of young people don't have jobs,
[80]
Vocational training reduces youth unemployment, IW study finds
Aug 23, 2004 · According to the study, the dual vocational training system reduces youth unemployment on average by 5 percentage points in a comparison of ...
[81]
[PDF] A Nation at Risk: The Imperative for Educational Reform
* The amount of homework for high school seniors has decreased (two-thirds report less than 1 hour a night) and grades have risen as average student achievement ...
[82]
Putting evidence on CTE to work - Kappan Online
Feb 27, 2023 · Data from previous decades provided evidence that high school CTE programs appear to increase earnings in the decade after high school, ...
[83]
The impacts of career-technical education on high school labor ...
CTE increases school attendance and completion rates. Students earn extra, especially with computer courses. Advanced non-computer CTE courses have positive ...
[84]
[PDF] U.S. and German youths: unemployment and the transition from ...
In Germany, a social consensus on the value of apprenticeship training results in low youth unemployment and a relatively easy transition from school to work;.
[85]
[PDF] CAREER AND TECHNICAL EDUCATION IN HIGH SCHOOL: - ERIC
Greater exposure to CTE is associated with better outcomes for students. The average student takes 4.9 CTE courses during his or her high school career. In ...
[86]
a history - Chapter 12 - Education in the UK
In November 1964, a survey conducted by The Sunday Times showed that 120 of the 149 authorities in England were either undertaking some form of reorganisation ...
[87]
Education and Social Integration. Comprehensive Schooling in ...
This chapter uses WVS data to test the four perspectives on value diversity that are outlined below. ... During the 1960s and 1970s, the Social Democrats ...
[88]
https://psycnet.apa.org/fulltext/2014-32900-001.html
[89]
Selective schooling and social mobility in England - ScienceDirect
We assess whether changing from an academically selective to a comprehensive schooling system promotes social mobility, using England as a case study.Missing: integration | Show results with:integration
[90]
The shift from grammar schools to comprehensives had little effect ...
Jun 19, 2023 · We found little evidence to support the idea that either selective or comprehensive schooling improved overall social mobility outcomes.
[91]
The new genetics of intelligence - PMC - PubMed Central
One of the most interesting developmental findings about intelligence is that its heritability as estimated in twin studies increases dramatically from infancy ...
[92]
Genetics and intelligence differences: five special findings - Nature
Sep 16, 2014 · A recent study of 11000 twin pairs found that the top 15% of the intelligence distribution was just as heritable (0.50) as the rest of the ...<|control11|><|separator|>
[93]
Do comprehensive schools reduce social mobility?1 - Boliver - 2011
Mar 1, 2011 · This paper investigates the claim that the shift from a selective to a comprehensive school system had a deleterious effect on social mobility in Great Britain.<|separator|>
[94]
K-12 Education: Transforming Public Education for a Changing World
Nov 4, 2024 · Globally, the K-12 education system in the United States stands out because of its universal access and affordability.
[95]
Averaged Freshman Graduation Rate
The AFGR decreased from 74 percent in 1990–91 to 71 percent in 1995–96, and then rose from 71 percent in 1998–99 to 75 percent in 2004–05 (figure 5.1). After a ...Missing: post- | Show results with:post-
[96]
public high school 4-year adjusted cohort graduation rate (ACGR)
Number of high school graduates is projected by NCES unless otherwise noted. NOTE: Data in this table represent the 50 states and the District of Columbia.Missing: post- | Show results with:post-
[97]
A Well-Rounded Education - Center for American Progress
Aug 16, 2018 · America's high school students need a rich and varied curriculum in order to be successful in high school, college, and beyond.Missing: undecided | Show results with:undecided
[98]
5 Reasons Why Student Choice is Important in Middle & High School
Dec 21, 2023 · Student choice gives agency, boosts engagement, empowers students, increases motivation, and fosters autonomy in learning.
[99]
Spotlight Story - The Harvey School
the ability to adapt to ...
[100]
Study Finds That Students Benefit From Depth, Rather Than Breadth ...
Mar 4, 2009 · A recent study reports that high school students who study fewer science topics, but study them in greater depth, have an advantage in college science classes.Missing: empirical trade- offs comprehensive selective
[101]
Depth Versus Breadth: How Content Coverage in High School ...
Aug 10, 2025 · Students who reported covering at least 1 major topic in depth, for a month or longer, in high school were found to earn higher grades in college science.
[102]
Optimal Learning Under Time Constraints: Empirical and Simulated ...
Apr 18, 2022 · Learners are often constrained by their available study time, typically having to make a trade-off between depth and breadth of learning.Missing: comprehensive schools
[103]
Accountability, Rigor, and Detracking: Achievement Effects of ...
The authors conclude that if a detracking reform includes high expectations for all students, sufficient resources and a commitment to the belief that students ...Missing: comprehensive | Show results with:comprehensive
[104]
Education: Why Those Falling Test Scores? | TIME
Sep 5, 1977 · The mean score for verbal ability, measured on the SAT'S 200 to 800 scale, dropped gradually from 478 in the 1962-63 academic year into the 430s.
[105]
The Achievement Decline of the 1970s - jstor
3 The SAT verbal average declined from a high of 478 in 1963 to 460 in 1970 and 429 in 1978, while math SAT scores averaged 502, 488, and 468 in those years.
[106]
The Use and Misuse of Test Scores in Reform Debate - RAND
They saw the decline as an indictment of educational standards and practices during the 1960s and 1970s. Some even claimed that reforms begun in the Reagan era ...
[107]
Schools' Back-to-Basics Drive Found to Be Working in Math
Jun 8, 1988 · This movement reflected widespread public reaction against the relaxation of academic standards by many schools in the turbulence of the ...
[108]
High Schools Under Fire - Time Magazine
Nov 14, 1977 · Conservative back to basics” forces rail that '60s innovations have left schools flaccid. They demand a return to a three-Rs curriculum and call ...<|separator|>
[109]
Test scores have barely risen since 1970 despite 245% spending ...
Jun 22, 2023 · Test scores have barely risen since 1970 despite 245% spending increase ... The NAEP graphs track test scores from the 1970s until today.Missing: 2000s | Show results with:2000s
[110]
The Impact of Federal Involvement in America's Classrooms
Feb 10, 2011 · Despite that massive real spending increase, overall achievement has stagnated or declined, depending on the subject. But what of the ...
[111]
Ticket to Nowhere - Education Next
Jul 14, 2006 · The downward shift occurred during the 1970s, when scores fell by as much as 50 percent of a standard deviation. Though they gained some ground ...
[112]
'The Bell Curve', Explained: Part II, Cognitive Classes and Social ...
May 15, 2017 · This chapter examines the contribution of cognitive ability to the capacity for civility and citizenship.
[113]
What the Research Tells Us About Detracking - M-A Chronicle
Dec 7, 2022 · It said, “The findings suggest that the detracking reform had appreciable effects on low-ability student achievement and no effects on average ...
[114]
[PDF] Classroom Peer Effects and Student Achievement - Urban Institute
although at the high school level we observe a relatively large negative impact on math achievement gains as high ability students get more low-ability peers.
[115]
The High Costs of Classroom Disorder - City Journal
Aug 21, 2025 · Research shows that exposure to disruptive peers can harm students' long-term outcomes, and disordered classrooms contribute to teacher burnout ...
[116]
Pushed Out: Trends and Disparities in Out-of-School Suspension
Sep 30, 2022 · In 2017–18, nearly 1 in 14 secondary school students (7%) were suspended—more than three times the rate of elementary school students (2%). In ...Missing: mixed | Show results with:mixed
[117]
Classroom social hierarchy and associations between children's ...
Higher classroom social hierarchy was associated with higher peer victimization across all three operationalizations.
[118]
Exploring the peer status prototypes: A large‐scale latent profile ...
Aug 8, 2022 · The peer status describes the relationship between an individual and the group, qualifying the consideration received from other members along ...
[119]
Learning from bad peers? Influences of peer deviant behaviour on ...
This study finds that peer deviant behaviour mainly reduces adolescent academic performance by increasing their own deviant behaviours and reducing their ...Missing: comprehensive | Show results with:comprehensive
[120]
[PDF] Achievement Gains from Attendance at Selective High Schools
Jun 18, 2018 · The mean NAPLAN score for the non-selective exam sample is 0.8 standard deviations below that of the selective sample (0.94 compared with 1.76),.
[121]
[PDF] Assessing Mismatch at Chicago Exam Schools
We evaluate mismatch in Chicago's selective public exam schools, which admit students using neighborhood- based diversity criteria as well as test scores.
[122]
[PDF] The Educational Benefits of Attending Higher Performing Schools
In contrast to studies on selective schools, several studies have generally found positive effects from attending higher performing schools when examining ...
[123]
The Competitive Effects of School Choice on Student Achievement
Overall, we found small positive effects of competition on student achievement. We also found some evidence that the type of school-choice policy and student ...
[124]
The long-term health effects of attending a selective school
Apr 3, 2020 · We found that people who attended selective secondary school had more advantaged economic backgrounds, higher IQs, higher likelihood of getting a university ...
[125]
Human capital consequences of missing out on a grammar school ...
This paper investigates the impact of selective schooling on human capital. It identifies the impact of an expansion in grammar school places in England.
[126]
Raising the Floor? Genetic Influences on Educational Attainment ...
Mar 15, 2025 · Twin studies have indicated that a substantial part of the variation in educational attainment can be attributed to genetic differences ...
[127]
The genetic lottery goes to school - PNAS
In this paper, we investigate whether better schools can compensate for the effects of children's genetic differences. To this end, we combine data from the ...
[128]
ED352520 - The Comprehensive High School: An Historical ... - ERIC
This report charts a brief history of the comprehensive high school in the United States designed particularly to highlight those key decisions that make them ...Missing: origins | Show results with:origins
[129]
Fast Facts: Educational institutions (84)
There were a total of 23,499 public secondary and high schools in 2009–10 and a total of 23,519 public secondary and high schools in 2020–21. ... 2021, Digest of ...
[130]
High School Statistics in the United States
Oct 7, 2022 · High School Students Demographics · In the United States, 15.1 million pupils attended high school between 2019 and 2020. · With somewhat fewer ...
[131]
National Charter Schools Timeline
Since 1991 when Minnesota enacted the first state law permitting charter schools, the idea of chartering has meant educational choice and opportunity.
[132]
School Choice Movement: How We Got Here
Mar 1, 2023 · The first modern private school voucher program and the longest-running in the country began in 1990 for Wisconsin's Milwaukee County schools ...
[133]
The Federal Charter Schools Program: 30 Years of Impact
May 1, 2025 · 2025 marks the 30th anniversary of the first Charter Schools Program grant award to support the growth and promise of charter schools.
[134]
https://www.ed.gov/laws-and-policy/laws-preschool-grade-12-education/every-student-succeeds-act-essa
[135]
ESSA and What it Means for School Choice - EdChoice
Feb 16, 2016 · By reforming Title I to give states the option to make dollars portable, policymakers would create much-needed flexibility for education ...
[136]
Achievement Gap Dashboard - The Nation's Report Card
The charts on this page show achievement gaps, which are significant differences in assessment scores between two groups of students.Missing: comprehensive | Show results with:comprehensive
[137]
NAEP State and District Snapshots
Sep 18, 2025 · See one-page Snapshot reports of how your state/jurisdiction or Trial Urban District Assessment (TUDA) district have performed in NAEP since 2002.Missing: comprehensive | Show results with:comprehensive
[138]
The “Nation's Report Card” Is Out: Here's What the Results Tell Us ...
May 15, 2025 · The recently released 2024 results confirm a long-term crisis in education, with student performance stagnating or declining despite decades of federal ...
[139]
https://www.brookings.edu/articles/three-waves-of-school-vouchers-a-history-of-expansion-and-exclusion/
[140]
[PDF] Grammar schools in England - UK Parliament
Mar 13, 2023 · Grammar schools select pupils based on academic ability, usually at age 11. Existing schools can expand, but new ones are generally prohibited.Missing: 2020s critiques
[141]
What do voters think of grammar schools? | Onward
Aug 1, 2022 · Public opinion on grammar school expansion is mixed · More voters want grammar expansion than for selection to be abolished, but public opinion ...Missing: critiques | Show results with:critiques<|separator|>
[142]
[PDF] Improving-Schools-in-Sweden.pdf - Education GPS
Mar 11, 2021 · This report is the result of an analysis of Sweden's context and policies and of relevant international best practices to support school ...
[143]
Sweden's schools: lessons from history to build a better future
Mar 29, 2019 · The latest vintage of PISA points to a brighter future for Sweden's schools. Average results improved, reflecting at least partly recent ...
[144]
PISA 2022 Results (Volume I and II) - Country Notes: Sweden | OECD
Dec 5, 2023 · In mathematics and reading, the drop in average scores between 2018 and 2022 reversed most of the gains observed between 2012 and 2018: results ...
[145]
[PDF] The Long term Outcomes of Early Educational Differentiation in France
Mar 27, 2025 · Moreover, informal tracking in secondary education has an effect on the probability of accessing the most selective path in higher education.
[146]
Comprehensive Versus Selective Schooling in England in Wales
Aug 7, 2025 · Both studies find significant positive effects on attainment of grammar education compared to comprehensives although Manning and Pischke (2006) ...
[147]
Inequity and Excellence in Academic Performance: Evidence From ...
Apr 3, 2018 · Underlying the excellence/equity tradeoff position is the belief that policymakers need to balance the competing demands of promoting excellence ...<|control11|><|separator|>
[148]
Do selective schooling systems increase inequality? | Oxford
We investigate the impact on earnings inequality of a selective education system in which school assignment is based on initial test scores.
[149]
[PDF] The Challenges for India's Education System - Chatham House
inadequate school infrastructure, poorly functioning schools, high teacher absenteeism, the large number of teacher vacancies, poor quality of education and.
[150]
Challenges in access to secondary education in India
Nov 9, 2022 · The secondary schools also suffer from inadequate infrastructure facilities or its poor quality. Although the situation has improved with ...Missing: non- selective
[151]
Educational Inequality by Race in Brazil, 1982–2007 - NIH
By the mid-2000s, primary school enrollment was nearly universal for children ages 7 to 14 of all racial categories.
[152]
[PDF] Classroom Segregation Without Tracking: Chance, Legitimacy, And ...
Though schools do not track in Brazil, I find that black/white classroom segregation in Brazil is greater than recent estimates from North Carolina high ...
[153]
Effect of racial segregation on proficiency of Brazilian elementary ...
The results indicate that racial segregation has a direct effect on the black–white proficiency gap, that is to say, the more segregated the school, the worse ...Missing: universal secondary
[154]
New UNESCO Report shows extent of global inequalities in ...
Paris, June 23, 2020 –A new report published today by UNESCO shows the extent of exclusion in education now further exacerbated by Covid-19.
[155]
[PDF] Secondary Education in Developing Countries
Myriad issues are being addressed-for example, whether governments should moderate their response to the rising demand for secondary schooling when the labor.Missing: comprehensive | Show results with:comprehensive
[156]
Hybrid teaching after COVID-19: advantages, challenges and ...
Jul 12, 2024 · There were obvious changes in students from 2020 to 2022 about the disadvantages of hybrid teaching, the improvement of students' learning ...
[157]
How Hybrid Learning Is (and Is Not) Working During COVID-19
Nov 11, 2020 · The mix of hybrid learning approaches is dizzying, but schools are learning valuable lessons about what is worth replicating.Missing: comprehensive adaptations
[158]
COE - Public School Enrollment
During the coronavirus pandemic, public school enrollment first fell from 50.8 million students in fall 2019 to 49.4 million students in fall 2020 and 2021 ...
[159]
The Pandemic's Effects on Children's Education | Richmond Fed
School closures and switches to hybrid/virtual learning due to the pandemic adversely affected student achievement through several channels.
[160]
K-12 Public School Enrollment Declines, Explained - FutureEd
Aug 5, 2025 · Between fall 2019 and fall 2023, enrollment fell from 50.8 million to 49.5 million, a loss of more than 1.2 million students, or 2.5 percent, in ...
[161]
[PDF] AI in High School Education Report
Aug 15, 2025 · Introduction. Artificial intelligence (AI) is reshaping how teachers and students engage with learning and instructional processes.
[162]
[PDF] 2025 AI in Education: A Microsoft Special Report
Jun 24, 2025 · Across the globe, educators are using AI to increase student agency, giving them a greater sense of ownership over how they learn. Education ...
[163]
Report: U.S. high school graduates will peak next year ... - WICHE
U.S. high school graduates will peak at 3.9 million in 2025, then decline to 3.4 million by 2041, with most states seeing losses.
[164]
2025 Post-Graduation Readiness Report: 72% of ... - YouScience
May 20, 2025 · YouScience report finds 72% of grads feel unprepared and just 35% pursue college, signaling urgent need for earlier career guidance and ...
[165]
More teens lean toward alternative postsecondary options - K-12 Dive
Jun 4, 2025 · Teens' postsecondary plans are shifting, with just 45% of students in grades 7-12 seeing a two- or four-year college as their most likely next ...
[166]
School Enrollment Shifts Five Years After the Pandemic
Jul 22, 2025 · By fall 2020, early research found that K–12 public school enrollment had dropped by 3 percent nationwide, as growing numbers of families opted ...
[167]
[PDF] COMPARING ED REFORMS Assessing the Experimental Research ...
Four RCT studies examined private school choice program participants' educational attainment: two have found positive outcomes for either the full sample or at ...
[168]
[PDF] School Choice and School Performance in the New York City Public ...
There is strong evidence from randomized trials that some components of the choice environment in NYC, particularly charter schools and the new smaller high ...
[169]
How vouchers harm public schools: Calculating the cost of voucher ...
Dec 19, 2024 · Many vouchers end up going to students who have never been in public schools, so funding these students' private school expenses introduces new ...Missing: 2020s | Show results with:2020s
[170]
Research - Public Funds Public Schools
Independent research has shown students participating in school voucher programs perform lower academically than those in public schools.Missing: 2020s | Show results with:2020s
[171]
NEW RESEARCH: The Fiscal Effects of School Choice - EdChoice
Oct 15, 2024 · A new EdChoice report estimates that U.S. private school choice programs saved taxpayers $19.4 to $45.6 billion through FY 2022.Missing: 2020s | Show results with:2020s<|separator|>
[172]
Rapidly expanding school voucher programs pinch state budgets
a figure that could balloon to ...Missing: 2020s outcomes
[173]
Full article: Do academically selective school systems strengthen the ...
The results show that attending selective schools is associated with some post-18 advantages for pupils who stayed until the end of Key Stage 5.
[174]
English regions dominated by grammar schools do not improve ...
Aug 28, 2023 · Grammar schools have long been criticised for creating a two-tier education system, and for being inaccessible to children from disadvantaged ...Missing: 2020s critiques
[175]
Top high school's standards slip following DEI policy - UnHerd
Sep 29, 2024 · After the implementation of new admissions metrics, the admission of Asian students declined from 73% to 54%. Critics, including parents of ...
[176]
The DEI era harmed non-white students most, yet some states won't ...
May 15, 2025 · DEI programs have worsened student outcomes, especially for non-white students, with declining proficiency in reading and math. Black and ...Missing: impact high
[177]
Does the amount of school choice matter for student engagement?
For example, in some cities magnet schools are choice schools where families must apply and be admitted via a lottery or by meeting certain admissions ...
[178]
[PDF] The Theory and Practice of School Choice - Dallas Fed
The research from randomized field trials summarized in this paper is reported in full in this monograph. 2. David Myers, Paul E. Peterson, Daniel Mayer ...