Control and Resistance
Control and Resistance is the second and final studio album by American progressive metal band Watchtower, released on November 6, 1989, by Noise Records.[1] This was the band's last album before their initial disbandment in 1993, and it marked the debut of vocalist Alan Tecchio (ex-Hades) and guitarist Ron Jarzombek (later of Spastic Ink and Blotted Science), replacing original members Jason McMaster and Billy White.[2] The album blends elements of thrash metal, progressive metal, and jazz fusion, featuring complex song structures, intricate guitar work, and rapid tempos that pushed the boundaries of the genre.[3] Tracks like "Instruments of Random Murder" and the title song showcase the band's technical proficiency and thematic exploration of control, technology, and human resistance. It has been widely regarded as a landmark in technical thrash metal and an influence on the emerging technical death metal scene, with bands like Atheist and Cynic citing its impact.[4]Background
Band formation and debut album
Watchtower was formed in May 1982 in Austin, Texas, by guitarist Billy White, drummer Rick Colaluca, and bassist Doug Keyser, who had previously played guitar before switching to bass.[5][6] The trio soon recruited vocalist Jason McMaster to complete the lineup, enabling the band to begin developing original material influenced by thrash metal and progressive rock.[5][7] From their inception, Watchtower focused on local performances, starting with parties and small club shows in Austin, which helped cultivate an underground following amid the burgeoning 1980s metal scene.[5] By the mid-1980s, they had progressed to larger venues like The Ritz, opening for prominent acts such as Slayer and Anthrax, and earning praise in fanzines and local outlets like the Austin Chronicle for their technically demanding style that blended aggressive thrash riffs with intricate rhythms and odd time signatures.[5][8] The band's debut album, Energetic Disassembly, was self-released on November 30, 1985, via their own Zombo Records imprint, financed through manager Fred Mitchum and recorded at Cedar Creek Studios in Austin.[9][5] Featuring the original lineup of McMaster on vocals, White on guitar, Keyser on bass, and Colaluca on drums, the album highlighted Watchtower's pioneering "techno-thrash" sound—characterized by rapid tempos, complex compositions, and progressive flourishes—and garnered worldwide underground acclaim despite limited distribution.[9][10] Following the album's release, significant lineup shifts began in late 1986, when original guitarist Billy White departed to pursue other opportunities, including later work with Don Dokken.[5][11] Ron Jarzombek, previously of San Antonio's S.A. Slayer, joined as his replacement in January 1987, bringing heightened technical prowess that marked an evolution toward more elaborate instrumentation.[5][6] In 1988, vocalist Jason McMaster temporarily exited to front Dangerous Toys, leading to a brief interim period with vocalist Mike Soliz; these later vocal changes positioned the band for the creative developments leading into their sophomore effort.[5]Conception of the album
Following the success of their 1985 debut album Energetic Disassembly, Watchtower began the songwriting process for their follow-up in 1987, focusing on expanding their technical thrash metal foundation. Guitarist Ron Jarzombek, who joined the band that year after Billy White's departure, contributed to early demos recorded with vocalist Jason McMaster, including tracks such as "Meltdown" and "The Eldritch." These sessions laid the groundwork for several songs that would appear on the album, emphasizing intricate guitar work and odd time signatures that marked a shift toward greater musical complexity.[12][13] Jarzombek's technical style profoundly influenced the album's direction, introducing complex riffs and jazz-infused progressions that pushed the band beyond their initial thrash-oriented sound. Post-debut, the group deliberately pursued a more progressive and fusion-oriented approach, aiming for conceptual depth through layered compositions and textural elements, as Jarzombek co-wrote roughly half the material alongside bassist Doug Keyser. This evolution was seen as a natural progression, blending thrash aggression with fusion's harmonic sophistication to create a uniquely demanding listening experience.[13][14] Vocalist Alan Tecchio's integration presented notable challenges, as he joined shortly before recording after McMaster's exit to front Dangerous Toys, requiring adjustments to accommodate his mid-range style over the demos' higher-pitched melodies originally tailored for McMaster. The band also considered relocating to Europe for production, ultimately recording vocals in Berlin to align with their Noise Records deal, though this introduced logistical tensions amid ongoing lineup solidification. During these writing sessions, conceptual themes of technology's double-edged role, societal control, and human resistance began to emerge, drawing from lyrics that critiqued innovation's perils and conformity's grip.[13][15][14]Recording and production
Studio sessions
The recording sessions for Watchtower's Control and Resistance took place in August 1989 at SkyTrak Studio in Berlin, Germany, spanning approximately one month.[1] The band's signing with the German label Noise Records facilitated this European location, aligning with the company's distribution network and allowing for efficient production oversight.[4][16] Hailing from Austin, Texas, the band members—vocalist Alan Tecchio, guitarist Ron Jarzombek, bassist Doug Keyser, and drummer Rick Colaluca—traveled internationally for the first time to reach Berlin, arriving just months before the fall of the Berlin Wall.[14] Noise Records arranged their flights and accommodations, housing the group on the fifth floor of the studio building, which included bedrooms, a recreation area, kitchen, and laundry, with the recording facilities on the floor below.[17] This setup enabled a focused environment, where the band adapted to the international locale by integrating downtime activities such as photo sessions and visits to nearby landmarks like the Berlin Wall alongside their work.[17] The daily workflow centered on tracking the album's complex arrangements, building on songwriting demos developed since 1987, with the band rehearsing extensively prior to entering the studio.[14] Sessions involved progressive layering of instrumentation, emphasizing the progressive metal style's intricate textures, though specific sequences like initial drum and bass foundations followed by guitars and vocals reflected standard practices for the genre.[3] Challenges arose from the material's increased complexity compared to their debut, including disputes over balancing guitar and drum volumes during tracking, as well as internal studio staff issues that led to personnel changes mid-session.[17] Additionally, Tecchio's recent addition to the lineup meant limited rehearsal time, requiring quick adaptation to the songs' demanding vocal lines under tight deadlines.[14] Despite these hurdles, the band described the overall experience as immersive and enjoyable, with Colaluca noting it as "a blast" amid the novel European setting.[14]Technical production
The band Watchtower self-produced Control and Resistance, handling the creative and oversight aspects of the recording process internally.[18] Recording engineering was managed by Tom Stokinger at SkyTrak Studio in Berlin, where the sessions occurred in August 1989, with drum engineering and drum recording handled by Alan Leeming.[1] This in-house approach at the Berlin facility allowed for close collaboration between the band and engineering team during the multi-track sessions, capturing the intricate guitar layers essential to the album's progressive and fusion-influenced structures while maintaining sonic clarity amid complex arrangements.[19] Mixing duties fell to Andreas Gerhardt, also at SkyTrak Studio, who balanced the album's thrash metal aggression with its subtler jazz elements through precise layering and separation of instruments.[1] Specific techniques included prominent drum treatments to underscore the rhythmic intensity—featuring tight, forward-placed kicks and snares that cut through the dense guitar work—and vocal effects that amplified Alan Tecchio's high-register delivery for a piercing, urgent tone without overwhelming the mix.[3] The overall mixing prioritized instrumental definition, ensuring the progressive time shifts and fusion textures remained audible and dynamic.[20] Following mixing, the album underwent mastering to provide final audio polish, enhancing overall cohesion and volume consistency for release on Noise Records.[21] Compared to the debut album Energetic Disassembly, which was self-produced and engineered by Fred Remmert at BOSS Studios in Austin with a rawer, less refined sound, Control and Resistance demonstrated marked improvements in fidelity and dynamics, resulting in a cleaner, more professional presentation that better showcased the band's technical prowess.[9][20]Musical style and composition
Genre elements
"Control and Resistance" exemplifies a core blend of progressive metal, thrash metal, and jazz fusion, characterized by intricate compositions featuring complex time signatures and polyrhythms that challenge conventional metal structures.[22] This fusion creates a dense, intellectually demanding sound where aggressive thrash riffs intersect with improvisational jazz elements, as seen in the album's layered instrumentation and rhythmic displacements. The result positions the album as a landmark in technical metal, emphasizing precision and innovation over straightforward aggression.[23] The album draws clear influences from progressive rock pioneers like King Crimson and jazz fusion ensembles such as Return to Forever, particularly evident in the extended instrumental passages that incorporate angular melodies and fusion-derived harmonies. Early Voivod's experimental thrash also informs the work, contributing to the dissonant atmospheres and unconventional phrasing in these sections.[23] These inspirations manifest through sophisticated arrangements that prioritize dynamic interplay among instruments, setting "Control and Resistance" apart from more linear metal contemporaries. Compared to Watchtower's 1985 debut "Energetic Disassembly," which leaned toward straight-ahead thrash, the sophomore album evolves into more experimental territory with odd meters, polyrhythmic grooves, and extended fusion solos that expand the band's sonic palette.[22] This shift reflects a maturation in songwriting, incorporating greater harmonic complexity and rhythmic variability while retaining thrash's intensity. Central to this evolution is guitarist Ron Jarzombek's contributions, whose virtuosic playing bridges metal's ferocity with jazz traditions through fluid, Allan Holdsworth-inspired phrasing and technical command of odd time.[22] His solos and riffs often emulate fusion aesthetics, integrating chromatic runs and modal improvisation into thrash frameworks. Jarzombek's approach not only elevates the album's complexity but also underscores its role as a precursor to technical thrash, influencing subsequent bands in the subgenre with its emphasis on musicianship and boundary-pushing structures.[23]Song structures and themes
The album Control and Resistance features intricate song structures characterized by frequent tempo shifts, complex time signatures, and fusions of thrash metal aggression with jazz and symphonic elements, creating a sense of controlled chaos that mirrors its thematic concerns. Lyrical content, penned primarily by bassist Doug Keyser, draws from real-world events and philosophical inquiries into power dynamics, often evoking dystopian scenarios of societal control and individual defiance. These elements coalesce into a loose conceptual narrative arc, progressing from random violence and hidden fears to broader struggles against systemic oppression and cycles of renewal, inspired by 1980s geopolitical tensions and technological anxieties.[24][25][26] "Instruments of Random Murder," the opener, launches with aggressive, fast-paced riffs and kaleidoscopic thematic fragments that abruptly shift into atonal interludes and a jazzy guitar solo, underscoring lyrics about unexplained deaths from cyanide-tainted products, probing corporate negligence and motiveless violence as metaphors for uncontrollable societal hazards.[24][25] "The Eldritch" begins with a drum solo leading into high-speed symphonic guitar lines evoking a cello's wail, building tension through off-kilter rhythms and instrumental breaks that heighten the sense of disorientation; thematically, it delves into subconscious terror and insanity induced by darkness, portraying an existential battle against irrational fears overpowering reason.[24][25] "Mayday in Kiev" opens with a blistering pace before transitioning to mid-tempo classic guitar arrangements reminiscent of Rush, incorporating acoustic flourishes to evoke catastrophe; the lyrics explicitly reference the 1986 Chernobyl disaster, critiquing Soviet secrecy and the far-reaching radioactive fallout as symbols of technological hubris and governmental control.[24][25] As the album's longest track, "The Fall of Reason" employs mid-tempo grooves with electric-acoustic interplay, a prominent solo-bass section, and symphonic builds that culminate in progressive expanses, aligning with lyrics that question the irrationality of war, its senseless sacrifices, and the erosion of logical thought in human conflict.[24][25] The title track "Control and Resistance" showcases bass and semi-acoustic dialogues evolving into heavy, fast sections with jazz-inflected drumming and layered solos, its structure emphasizing tension-release dynamics; lyrically, it confronts societal conformity, mental manipulation, and the urge to rebel, encapsulating the album's core dialectic between submission and defiance.[24][25] "Hidden Instincts" starts softly with semi-acoustic passages before accelerating into dazzling, theme-shifting riffs and solos, using abrupt vocal deliveries to convey urgency; the words explore crime as an innate human drive, illustrating how fear of violence curtails personal freedoms and enforces behavioral control.[24][25] "Life Cycles" adopts a ballad-like symphonic intro with soft, introspective builds that explode into fast, heavy passages and a jazzy solo, providing emotional contrast; its lyrics reflect on life's inevitable cycles of hardship and resilience, advocating for agency amid uncontrollable forces.[24][25] Closing with "Dangerous Toy," the track maintains a quieter, direct techno-thrash drive with minimal shifts but punchy instrumental accents; thematically, it scrutinizes a hypothetical mind-reading device, highlighting risks to privacy and justice in an era of invasive technology.[24][25] Early demo versions, recorded in 1987 with original vocalist Jason McMaster, differ notably from the final 1989 cuts, particularly in vocal melodies—such as the title track's demo featuring altered phrasing and phrasing that extends its raw, practice-room energy—before Alan Tecchio's high-pitched delivery refined the polished release. These demos, captured on rudimentary equipment, reveal looser structures with potential for extended improvisations, though the album versions streamline for cohesion.[27]Release and promotion
Commercial release
Control and Resistance was released on November 6, 1989, by the independent German label Noise Records in Europe and through its international arm, Noise International, in the United States.[1][28] The album's initial pressings were issued in vinyl LP, cassette, and CD formats, catering to the predominant physical media preferences of the era's metal audience.[16] As a release from a niche independent label specializing in heavy metal during the late 1980s, Control and Resistance encountered significant distribution hurdles, including limited access to major retail chains and reliance on specialty outlets, fan mail-order networks, and import channels, which constrained its broader market penetration.[29] It achieved underground acclaim and steady sales within progressive and technical metal communities but failed to register on mainstream charts like the Billboard 200, reflecting the era's challenges for avant-garde metal acts outside major label support.[3] The band's dissolution in 1990, just a year after the album's launch, curtailed opportunities for sustained promotional efforts and follow-up releases, further limiting its commercial trajectory at the time.[7]Marketing and tours
Noise Records handled promotion primarily through trade publications and targeted outreach to the thrash and progressive metal audience, including announcements of the album's release and tour dates in radio trade magazines like The Hard Report.[30] These efforts highlighted the album's technical complexity to appeal to niche listeners, though broader mainstream outreach was minimal due to the band's specialized sound. Positive reviews in major metal magazines further amplified visibility, praising the fusion of jazz influences and intricate songwriting.[31] No official singles were released from the album, limiting commercial tie-ins, but tracks like the title song "Control and Resistance" received airplay on rock radio stations, including appearances on trade charts like the Hard Report.[32] This underground exposure helped sustain interest among dedicated fans without achieving widespread commercial success. Touring was constrained by the band's niche appeal and label priorities, focusing on select club and support gigs rather than extensive headlining runs. In the US, Watchtower performed limited club shows in late 1989, including dates at L'Amour in Brooklyn, New York, on December 22 and The China Club in Hillsdale, New Jersey, on December 17, showcasing material from the new album alongside earlier tracks.[33] These appearances built grassroots momentum but did not include high-profile support slots. In Europe, Noise Records organized a short spring 1990 tour as openers for labelmates Coroner, joined by Loudblast on select dates, covering cities like Hamburg, Düsseldorf, and Zwolle; a full-scale European headline tour was not pursued due to logistical and promotional constraints.[34][35] Promotional materials, including press kits distributed to media and fans, emphasized the band's technical prowess and innovative fusion elements to differentiate them in the competitive thrash scene.[31] However, Watchtower's progressive style and lineup changes restricted wider promotion, resulting in album sales of around 40,000–50,000 copies, predominantly in Europe, without significant video or merchandising pushes.[13][31] This niche positioning, while earning critical acclaim, curtailed broader market penetration at the time.Critical reception
Contemporary reviews
Upon its release in 1989, Control and Resistance received positive coverage in the underground metal press, where critics lauded its technical prowess and innovative fusion of thrash metal with progressive and jazz elements. Publications such as Metal Forces praised the album's songwriting, musicianship, and production, positioning it as a landmark in technical thrash metal.[36] Kerrang! commended its experimental approach, highlighting the jazz-metal fusion as a bold evolution for thrash metal.[36] However, the album's intricate compositions drew mixed reactions regarding accessibility, with some reviewers in period zines noting it as "challenging" for traditional thrash fans due to its odd time signatures and dense arrangements.[4] Critics often emphasized guitarist Ron Jarzombek's virtuosic work, with outlets like Rock Hard calling the technical execution "unbelievable" and a step beyond contemporaries.[37] Reviews reflected admiration for its ambition despite the learning curve.[3] Reviewers frequently compared Control and Resistance to contemporaries like Voivod for its experimental edge and King's X for melodic undertones amid the chaos, underscoring its role in bridging thrash with progressive influences.[19] The album garnered little mainstream attention, appearing primarily in specialized underground outlets rather than broader rock publications, which contributed to its cult status among niche audiences.Retrospective views
In the 2000s, AllMusic critic Eduardo Rivadavia described Control and Resistance as a "landmark recording" in extreme metal, praising its instrumental supremacy, complex songwriting, and influence on subsequent bands like Meshuggah, while awarding it 4 out of 5 stars.[38] The album's technical prowess was further highlighted in a retrospective Guitar World feature, which included it among the "Top Ten Shred Albums of the 80's" for its virtuosic guitar work and mastery of intricate rhythms.[39] By the 2010s, publications like Decibel Magazine inducted the album into its Hall of Fame in 2010, lauding it as a "technical marvel" that blended virtuosic shredding with melodically infectious and intellectually challenging compositions, and noting its prescient role in advancing progressive and extreme metal subgenres.[4] This reassessment emphasized its foundational impact on later styles such as djent and technical death metal, where bands drew from Watchtower's rhythmic complexity and fusion elements.[4] Reviews in zines during the 2010s and 2020s, including Decibel's ongoing coverage, consistently praised these enduring innovations despite acknowledging the production's thin, raw sound as a product of its era.[4] In 2021, a reissue by High Roller Records featured remastered audio and bonus tracks, renewing interest and acclaim among fans and critics for its lasting influence.[40] Fan-driven platforms have reinforced this positive reevaluation, with Rate Your Music users assigning an average score of 3.6 out of 5 based on over 2,000 ratings (as of 2025), often citing the album's groundbreaking innovation in progressive thrash as a key strength that outweighs its dated sonic limitations.[41] These modern perspectives balance critiques of the album's occasionally harsh, underproduced mix with acclaim for its compositional depth and lasting technical influence.[42]Album content
Track listing
All tracks are written by Watchtower.| No. | Title | Duration |
|---|---|---|
| 1. | "Instruments of Random Murder" | 4:10 [28] |
| 2. | "The Eldritch" | 3:20 [28] |
| 3. | "Mayday in Kiev" | 5:45 [28] |
| 4. | "The Fall of Reason" | 8:00 [28] |
| 5. | "Control and Resistance" | 7:05 [28] |
| 6. | "Hidden Instincts" | 3:43 [28] |
| 7. | "Life Cycles" | 6:50 [28] |
| 8. | "Dangerous Toy" | 4:17 [28] |