Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Cuttlebone

The cuttlebone, also known as the cuttlefish bone, is a rigid, porous internal shell unique to all species in the cephalopod family Sepiidae, functioning primarily as a buoyancy control device that allows cuttlefish to adjust their density in water by regulating gas and liquid volumes within its chambers.^[1] Composed mainly of aragonite (a polymorph of calcium carbonate) at 95.5–97% by weight, with the remainder consisting of an organic matrix of β-chitin and proteins, the cuttlebone provides structural support while enabling precise hydrostatic balance, similar to a swim bladder in fish.^[1] Its lightweight, chambered architecture—featuring a dorsal shield, ventral chamber complex with horizontal septa, vertical pillars, and multiple internal membranes—exhibits high porosity (approximately 93%) and can withstand pressures up to 2.4 MPa, limiting habitat depths to around 400–700 meters depending on species morphology.^[2] The structure forms through biomineralization, where a liquid-crystal precursor of chitin-protein complex self-organizes into aragonite fibers, starting from nanometric particles and shaped by processes like viscous fingering in the pillars.^[1] Beyond its biological role in cuttlefish, the cuttlebone serves as a vital calcium supplement for captive birds and reptiles, such as parrots, tortoises, and hermit crabs, aiding bone health, eggshell formation, and beak or shell maintenance.^[3] In pet care, it also acts as a natural grinding tool for sharpening beaks in birds and turtles, promoting oral health through abrasive wear.^[3] Historically and industrially, cuttlebone has been used in jewelry casting as a heat-resistant mold material and in polishing compounds due to its fine texture, though modern applications increasingly focus on biomimicry.^[3] Recent research highlights the cuttlebone's potential in regenerative medicine and tissue engineering, where its porous aragonite structure is converted to hydroxyapatite via hydrothermal treatment for use in bone grafts, scaffolds, and dental implants, demonstrating biocompatibility and osteoconductivity in preclinical animal models.^[4] These biomimetic properties inspire lightweight, high-strength materials for engineering, leveraging the cuttlebone's efficient load distribution and fluid permeability.^[2] Environmental factors like ocean acidification threaten cuttlebone formation by disrupting calcium carbonate precipitation, potentially impacting cuttlefish populations and their ecological roles as predators.^[3]

Description and Function

Definition and Occurrence

The cuttlebone is a hard, brittle, chambered internal structure unique to all members of the family Sepiidae, the cuttlefish, and is composed primarily of aragonite, a mineral form of calcium carbonate. Unlike the external shells of nautiluses or the absent shells in squids, this internal shell lies along the dorsal side of the cuttlefish's body, providing structural support while remaining lightweight due to its porous nature. The term "cuttlebone" originates from its direct association with the cuttlefish, historically referred to as the "cuttlefish bone" to highlight its role as an internalized skeletal element in these cephalopods.^[5]^[6]^[2] Cuttlebones occur in every species of cuttlefish, which inhabit marine environments worldwide, ranging from tropical to temperate oceans. These cephalopods are typically found in shallow coastal waters over sandy or muddy substrates, with habitats extending from the intertidal zone to depths of up to 200–600 meters, limited by the point at which hydrostatic pressure causes cuttlebone implosion. This depth constraint influences the global distribution patterns of Sepiidae, concentrating populations in neritic zones rather than deeper abyssal regions.^[7]^[8]^[9]^[6]^[10] Following the death of a cuttlefish, the soft tissues rapidly decompose, leaving the durable yet lightweight cuttlebone to float or drift with ocean currents. As a result, these porous structures frequently wash ashore on beaches globally, often in large numbers after storms or seasonal die-offs, making them a common find for coastal observers. This post-mortem behavior aids in the natural dispersal and discovery of cuttlebones, which serve as indicators of local cuttlefish populations.^[11]^[12]

Buoyancy Role

The cuttlebone serves as the primary organ for buoyancy regulation in cuttlefish, enabling the animal to maintain neutral buoyancy by adjusting its overall density relative to seawater. This is achieved through a gas-filled siphuncle, a specialized tubular structure that connects the internal chambers of the cuttlebone and regulates the volumes of liquid and gas within them. By controlling the gas-to-liquid ratio, cuttlefish can fine-tune their buoyancy to hover at specific depths without expending energy on continuous swimming.^[6] The mechanism involves osmotic regulation via the siphuncular membrane, where the cuttlefish alters ion concentrations in the fluid to draw in or expel liquid from the chambers, thereby replacing it with gas or vice versa. To descend, chambers are filled with liquid, increasing density and allowing the animal to sink; to ascend, liquid is expelled and replaced with gas, decreasing density for neutral or positive buoyancy. This process provides precise depth control, particularly effective in shallow coastal waters where cuttlefish hunt and camouflage, and occurs rapidly through active physiological adjustments rather than passive diffusion. The chambered structure of the cuttlebone facilitates this compartmentalized control, preventing wholesale shifts in buoyancy.^[6]^[13] However, the cuttlebone's design imposes limitations on habitat depth due to the risk of implosion under increasing hydrostatic pressure. In most species, structural integrity is compromised beyond 200–600 meters, as the porous chambers collapse when external pressure exceeds the material's compressive strength, restricting cuttlefish to neritic and upper bathyal zones. Variations in cuttlebone morphology, such as septal thickness and pillar spacing, correlate with species-specific depth tolerances, balancing buoyancy efficiency against pressure resistance.^[9] Evolutionarily, the cuttlebone represents an internal, lightweight adaptation for buoyancy that diverged from the external, chambered shells of ancient cephalopods like nautiluses, allowing greater maneuverability while retaining a similar gas-liquid regulation system. This internalized structure reduces drag and vulnerability to predation compared to external shells, contributing to the ecological success of coleoid cephalopods in dynamic marine environments.^[6]

Formation and Development

Biological Formation

The cuttlebone is secreted by the dorsal mantle epithelium of the cuttlefish within a specialized glandular structure, with formation initiating during juvenile stages shortly after hatching. This epithelial layer produces successive organic laminae that form the foundational scaffold for mineralization.^[14] Biomineralization begins with the deposition of an organic matrix primarily composed of β-chitin and associated proteins, which self-assembles into layered cholesteric liquid crystal structures. Aragonite crystals then precipitate onto this matrix through the transport of calcium and bicarbonate ions across the epithelium, forming nanometric particles that develop into oriented needles in the chamber pillars and roof, and horizontal fibers in the floor. This process ensures the hierarchical organization essential for the cuttlebone's function.^[14] Formation is influenced by environmental factors such as seawater calcium availability, pH, temperature, and diet, which can alter ion transport rates and matrix deposition, resulting in species-specific variations in cuttlebone thickness and overall shape. For instance, reduced pH levels (e.g., from ocean acidification) enhance calcium incorporation and hypercalcification in hatchlings of Sepia officinalis, while higher temperatures (19°C vs. 16°C) decrease embryonic calcification but increase juvenile cuttlebone mass;^[15] dietary restriction during growth phases reduces cuttlebone weight relative to body size.^[14] Cuttlebone development commences immediately post-hatching, with initial chambers forming within the first weeks and continuing incrementally as the animal grows, adding up to over 100 chambers by adulthood; growth stabilizes into a mature configuration around 2 months post-hatching and ceases at sexual maturity, typically after 12-18 months. Fossil records of Miocene–Pliocene sepiids indicate the evolutionary stability of this biomineralization process over millions of years.^[16]

Growth in Cuttlefish

The cuttlebone in cuttlefish undergoes continuous posterior-anterior extension throughout the animal's life, with new chambers added at the posterior end through ventral accretion, resulting in a progressively elongating structure that maintains a slightly curved, ellipsoid shape.^[17] This growth process begins in the embryonic stage and continues into adulthood, where the cuttlebone can reach lengths of 30-40 cm in species like Sepia officinalis, accommodating up to approximately 100 thin chambers separated by septa.^[17] ^[18] Size and shape variations in the cuttlebone are species-specific, with larger species such as Sepia officinalis exhibiting thicker and longer structures compared to smaller congeners like Sepia robsoni, which may have cuttlebones under 20 mm.^[19] These traits are further influenced by age, sex, and habitat; for instance, chamber height increases modestly from about 0.27 mm in embryos to 0.33 mm in adults, while the width-to-length ratio decreases from 0.6 in early stages to 0.31 in mature individuals, indicating relatively broader proportions in juveniles.^[17] Sexual dimorphism is evident in species like Sepia bertheloti, where males show faster linear growth leading to narrower but longer cuttlebones, whereas females develop wider ones potentially linked to reproductive demands.^[20] Habitat depth also plays a role, with cuttlebones from deeper waters displaying lower width-to-length ratios (e.g., 0.31) than those from shallow areas (0.36), reflecting adaptations to environmental pressures.^[17] As cuttlefish mature, the cuttlebone's internal pillar network fully connects around the 25th chamber, typically after 1-2 months, stabilizing the structure for lifelong function.^[17] Following death, the cuttlebone decomposes, releasing calcium carbonate back into marine ecosystems. In comparative terms, the cuttlebone's development in cuttlefish represents an evolutionary internalization of the chambered shell seen in ancestral cephalopods, replacing heavier external shells with a lightweight internal structure that enhances mobility in active, predatory lifestyles—contrasting with the spiral, gas-filled shells of nautiloids (with ~30 large chambers) or the rigid pens of squid.^[17] ^[21] This adaptation allowed decapod cephalopods like cuttlefish to achieve greater agility compared to shelled forebears.

Structure and Composition

Internal Architecture

The cuttlebone exhibits a highly organized chambered internal architecture, consisting of approximately 10 to 20 superimposed chambers formed by thin, curved horizontal septa that act as partitions. These septa, typically 7 to 15 micrometers thick, divide the structure into gas-filled compartments, while vertical pillars serve as micron-thick supports connecting consecutive septa to maintain overall stability. This design creates a lightweight framework optimized for buoyancy, with the chambers displaying a gradient in size that decreases anteriorly, contributing to varying stiffness across the structure.^[6]^[2] At the microscopic level, the septa possess a double-layered "plywood" microstructure composed of aragonite nanorods, each with a diameter of 50 to 100 nanometers, arranged in orthogonal orientations between layers to enhance reinforcement and resist deformation. This hierarchical arrangement of nanorods forms planar sheets that stack to create the septa's layered appearance, providing tensile strength within the otherwise porous matrix. The vertical pillars, measuring 4 to 7 micrometers in thickness, exhibit high aspect ratios up to 100:1 (length to thickness), enabling them to withstand compressive forces by distributing loads evenly across chambers and preventing localized failure.^[6]^[13] The internal architecture achieves exceptional porosity, exceeding 90% void space (approximately 93% by volume), primarily through the open chambers and minimal solid material in septa and pillars. This high porosity is unevenly distributed, with the anterior region's smaller chambers resulting in denser packing and increased stiffness compared to the more expansive posterior sections, allowing the cuttlebone to balance lightness with structural integrity.^[6]^[2]

Chemical Composition

The cuttlebone is primarily composed of aragonite, an orthorhombic polymorph of calcium carbonate (CaCO₃), which constitutes approximately 95% of its dry weight, with trace amounts of calcite (another CaCO₃ polymorph) and amorphous calcium carbonate.^[4]^[22] The organic matrix accounts for about 5% and includes proteins such as acidic macromolecules and polysaccharides like β-chitin, which provide nucleation sites for mineral crystal formation.^[4]^[23] Elementally, cuttlebone features high levels of calcium (38-40% by weight), carbon (12%), and oxygen (48%), reflecting its dominant CaCO₃ structure, along with minor elements including magnesium, strontium, and sodium incorporated from seawater during biomineralization.^[23]^[24] Slight variations in stable isotopic ratios, such as δ¹³C and δ¹⁸O, occur within cuttlebone aragonite and are utilized in paleoceanography to reconstruct ancient seawater temperature, salinity, and chemistry from fossil specimens.^[25]^[26]

Physical and Mechanical Properties

Density and Porosity

The bulk density of cuttlebone typically ranges from 0.18 to 0.26 g/cm³, primarily attributable to its exceptionally high porosity of approximately 93 vol%, which results in an ultra-lightweight structure.^[6] This bulk density is significantly lower than that of seawater (∼1.025 g/cm³), comprising less than 20% of it, while the skeletal density of the aragonite material itself is around 2.7 g/cm³, consistent with the mineral's inherent properties.^[27]^[28] Cuttlebone exhibits a hierarchical porosity spanning multiple scales, from macro-scale chambers measuring approximately 1 mm in height to meso-scale features in the walls and pillars (∼10 µm) and nano-scale pores within the aragonite crystals. The porosity includes open-cell chambers that facilitate gas and fluid exchange through a connecting siphuncular tube, enabling buoyancy adjustments, alongside closed micropores embedded within the chamber walls and septa that contribute to the overall void volume without interconnectivity.^[6]^[27] This multiscale design optimizes the balance between lightness and structural integrity. High-resolution synchrotron micro-computed tomography (micro-CT) scanning has been instrumental in quantifying these features, revealing a structural gradient in porosity and wall thickness along the cuttlebone's length, with higher relative porosity and thinner walls in the posterior region to enhance flexibility under compressive loads.^[6]^[27] In comparison to other biological materials, cuttlebone's bulk density is notably lower than that of cortical bone (∼1.9 g/cm³) or typical coral skeletons (∼1.2–1.6 g/cm³), allowing for effective buoyancy control without imposing excessive mass on the animal.^[6]^[29]^[30]

Stiffness and Deformation

The effective Young's modulus of cuttlebone, which measures its stiffness under uniaxial stress, typically ranges from 0.5 to 1.5 GPa, reflecting variations across its hierarchical structure and loading directions.^[31] This value arises from the composite behavior of its aragonite-based components, where local moduli in walls reach up to 51 GPa and in septa around 30 GPa, but the overall porous architecture reduces the bulk response.^[6] The specific stiffness, defined as the Young's modulus divided by density, achieves up to 8.4 (MN m)/kg, making it exceptionally efficient for a lightweight material and surpassing many engineered cellular structures like octet trusses by over three times.^[6] This high specific stiffness stems from the optimized wall-septa geometry, which favors compression-dominant deformation over buckling. Despite its composition of brittle aragonite, cuttlebone exhibits notable damage tolerance through its porous design, which enables energy absorption via progressive collapse of internal chambers rather than catastrophic failure.^[6] The structure dissipates impact energy at approximately 4.4 kJ/kg, comparable to metallic foams, by localizing damage and promoting extensive densification without complete disintegration.^[27] This mitigation of brittleness allows cuttlebone to withstand underwater pressures and predatory strikes, maintaining buoyancy function even after partial deformation. Under compressive loading, cuttlebone deforms in distinct stages that enhance its resilience: first, microcracks initiate in the pillar walls due to stress concentrations at their middles; second, these cracks propagate across adjacent septa in a chamber-by-chamber manner; and third, the material undergoes densification and crushing as collapsed regions compact.^[6] The wavy morphology of the walls plays a critical role in delaying overall failure by creating tortuous crack paths and distributing stress unevenly, thereby extending the plateau phase of deformation up to strains of 0.85.^[27] The mechanical behavior of cuttlebone holds significant biomimetic potential, inspiring the design of lightweight foams and lattices for aerospace applications where high stiffness-to-weight ratios and sequential energy absorption are essential.^[32] For instance, 3D-printed cellular materials mimicking its architecture have demonstrated superior load-bearing capacity, supporting weights over 50,000 times their own while absorbing energy progressively, as highlighted in computational and experimental studies.^[32]^[33]

Uses and Applications

In Animal Care

Cuttlebone is a staple in the husbandry of captive birds, particularly species like parrots and budgerigars, where it functions as a natural calcium supplement to avert deficiencies that compromise beak integrity and eggshell formation. Typically affixed to cage interiors, it encourages pecking behavior that trims the beak while delivering essential minerals and trace elements for overall skeletal health.^[34] In the care of other captive species, cuttlebone provides targeted nutritional support. Chinchillas benefit from its use as a chewable calcium source that also promotes teeth grinding to manage continuous dental growth. Hermit crabs utilize it to bolster exoskeleton strength and facilitate shell selection and maintenance. Reptiles, including turtles, rely on it for calcium to foster robust bone development. Aquatic invertebrates such as shrimp and snails incorporate it to ensure adequate calcium availability during molting, aiding exoskeleton and shell reformation without disrupting water chemistry.^[35]^[36]^[37]^[38] With a composition dominated by 87–92% calcium carbonate in aragonite form, cuttlebone supplies highly bioavailable calcium that supports metabolic needs without excess accumulation, as the material dissolves gradually upon ingestion or exposure. For smaller animals like shrimp or young birds, grinding the cuttlebone into a fine powder enhances its digestibility and integration into diets or substrates.^[39]

Human and Industrial Uses

Historically, cuttlebone has been ground into powder for use as a polishing agent by goldsmiths, particularly during the Renaissance period in Mediterranean regions, where its fine abrasive texture aided in finishing metals without scratching. In the 19th century, powdered cuttlebone served as an abrasive in toothpaste formulations and as an antacid in medicinal preparations, valued for its calcium carbonate content that neutralized acidity. Additionally, whole cuttlebones were carved into molds for creating ornamental jewelry and small metal objects, leveraging their soft, workable structure in traditional casting techniques. In modern crafts, cuttlebone remains popular for jewelry making through direct carving and casting methods, where artisans shape the material into molds for pouring molten metals like silver, taking advantage of its carvability and heat resistance up to approximately 1000°C during the process. Calcined cuttlebone, heated to produce lime, has applications in agriculture as a soil amendment, providing calcium to neutralize acidity and enhance nutrient availability, similar to traditional limestone-based products. Industrial potential includes its use as a biomaterial for tissue scaffolds in bone regeneration and dentistry, where the high porosity (around 90-93%) supports cell growth and bioactivity in hydroxyapatite-derived structures. Its porous architecture also enables applications in filtration, such as oil absorption and pollutant removal from water, due to inherent superhydrophobic and adsorptive properties. Although historically explored as a human calcium supplement, its direct consumption has largely been replaced by safer, synthetic alternatives amid concerns over bioavailability and potential contaminants. Emerging research in the 2020s focuses on sustainable sourcing of cuttlebone from seafood processing waste to develop eco-friendly abrasives for polishing and dental products, mitigating overharvesting pressures on wild populations while promoting circular economy practices.

References

[1]
The cuttlefish Sepia officinalis (Sepiidae, Cephalopoda) constructs ...
Jun 18, 2015 · Cuttlebone, the sophisticated buoyancy device of cuttlefish, is made of extensive superposed chambers that have a complex internal arrangement of calcified ...Missing: definition | Show results with:definition
[2]
Cuttlebone: Characterisation, Application and Development of ...
Aug 10, 2025 · Commonly used as a calcium-rich dietary supplement for caged animals (birds, turtles) and as a grinding stone for the beaks of cage birds [104], ...
[3]
Cuttlefish | Museum of Natural History - University of Colorado Boulder
May 12, 2021 · Beaked animals like birds and some turtles can use cuttlebones to sharpen their beaks. These structures were also once regularly used in the ...
[4]
Cuttlefish-Bone-Derived Biomaterials in Regenerative Medicine ...
This review fills a gap in the literature by providing a comprehensive overview of the applications of CB-derived materials in the biomedical field.
[5]
Sea Wonder: Cuttlefish | National Marine Sanctuary Foundation
Nov 6, 2020 · No other animal has a cuttlebone, which is basically a hollow and porous internal shell made of aragonite, a form of calcium carbonate. Diet ...
[6]
Mechanical design of the highly porous cuttlebone - PNAS
Sep 10, 2020 · Unlike the soft swim bladders for buoyancy-regulating purposes in fishes, cuttlebone is a stiff structure composed of >90% aragonite (8), a ...
[7]
Common cuttlefish (Sepia officinalis) - MarLIN
They occur predominantly on sandy-muddy bottoms from the coastline to approximately 200 m. The most common occurrence is at 100 m.
[8]
Sepia officinalis, Common cuttlefish : fisheries - SeaLifeBase
A neritic, demersal species found in the subtidal zone to depths of 200 m, generally over sandy-muddy substrates (Ref. 1695, page 100). Presence in Portuguese ...
[9]
Cuttlebone Morphology Limits Habitat Depth in Eleven Species of ...
Aug 5, 2025 · The cuttlebone is a rigid buoyancy tank that imposes a depth limit on Sepia, the only living speciose cephalopod genus with a chambered ...<|control11|><|separator|>
[10]
https://animalfact.com/cuttlefish/
[11]
What are the cuttlefish bones found on our beaches? - Te Papa's Blog
Nov 23, 2021 · Cuttlebones are the remains of dead cuttlefish. They tend to get washed up on beaches all around the world. It is easier to find them in areas where the ...Missing: ashore | Show results with:ashore
[12]
A method for long-term electronic tagging and tracking of juvenile ...
We also found that cuttlebones with attached tags remained buoyant at the water's surface post mortem, offering the unique opportunity to recover archival tags ...<|control11|><|separator|>
[13]
The cuttlefish Sepia officinalis (Sepiidae, Cephalopoda) constructs ...
Jun 18, 2015 · The cuttlebone constitutes a highly efficient buoyancy apparatus, evolved to withstand hydrostatic pressure. Our study reveals that in Sepia the ...
[14]
https://doi.org/10.1038/srep11513
[15]
https://doi.org/10.1007/s00227-012-2059-6
[16]
Chemical composition of cuttlebone - ResearchGate
Macro mineral content (calcium, magnesium, potassium, phosphorus) is 40,18%, micro minerals (manganese, iron, zinc, sodium) 0,73%. The absorption of cuttlebone ...
[17]
[PDF] Chemical-microstructural-nanomechanical variations in the ... - bioRxiv
Jun 27, 2017 · The remarkable performance of the cuttlebone is linked to its structural architecture: cuttlebone is com- posed of calcium carbonate (CaC03) in ...
[18]
Cuttlefish Bone-Derived Calcium Phosphate Bioceramics ... - NIH
This is attributed to the faster and stronger ion dissolution behavior of the cuttlefish bone-derived bioceramics, which can promote local saturation of ...
[19]
Natural geochemical markers reveal environmental history and ...
Jul 29, 2020 · Elemental ratios in cuttlebone indicate growth rates in the Cuttlefish Sepia pharaonis. Front. Mar. Sci. 6, 796 ( 10.3389/fmars.2019.00796) ...
[20]
Elemental Ratios in Cuttlebone Indicate Growth Rates in ... - Frontiers
The growth rate of the body mantle may strongly influence the incorporation of elements into the cuttlebone; however, the process has not been well studied.Missing: epithelium | Show results with:epithelium
[21]
https://ocean.si.edu/ocean-life/invertebrates/octopuses-squids-and-relatives
[22]
[PDF] Cuttlebone: Characterization and Applications
Cuttlebone signifies a special class of ultra-lightweight, high stiffness and high permeability cellular biomaterials, providing the cuttlefish with an ...<|separator|>
[23]
Skeletal density - Coral Trait Database
99197. Skeletal density. 0.213 (g cm-3). Show · 99204. Skeletal density. 2.274 (g cm-3). Show · 99200. Skeletal density. 1.163 (g cm-3). Show · 99189. Skeletal ...
[24]
Volume to density relation in adult human bone tissue - ScienceDirect
Jan 4, 2011 · It was found that the TMD of trabecular (1.24±0.16 g/cm3) and cortical (1.19±0.06 g/cm3) bone were not statistically different (p=0.31).
[25]
[PDF] Multiscale mechanical design of the lightweight, stiff, and damage ...
The cuttlebone can withstand strong underwater pressures, prevent implosion ... Sherrard, Cuttlebone morphology limits habitat depth in eleven species of Sepia.
[26]
Mechanically Efficient Cellular Materials Inspired by Cuttlebone - Mao
Mar 6, 2021 · Cuttlebone has an overall density of around 0.2 g cm−3 and a ... Specifically, due to its high porosity, low density, and multiscale ...
[27]
[PDF] pocket-pets-manual.pdf - University of Wyoming
A calcium block or cuttlebone should be provided to keep their beaks trim and to provide a source of supple- mental calcium. As pet birds, cockatiels rank third ...
[28]
What Is a Cuttlebone? - Love My Chinchilla
A cuttlebone (also known as cuttle bone or cuttlefish bone) is a hard, brittle bone-like or shell-like structure found in cuttlefish.Missing: sources | Show results with:sources
[29]
[PDF] Basic Hermit Crab Care
Please do not offer painted or glazed shells - they are dangerous and potentially toxic to hermits. Natural and polished shells can be found online and in craft ...
[30]
What Do Snapping Turtles Eat - Housing Innovations
Mar 4, 2025 · It's also essential to provide a source of calcium, such as crushed eggshells or cuttlebone, to support strong bone growth and development.
[31]
How to Supplement Shrimp and Snails with Calcium
Although, cuttlebones, wonder shells, mineral blocks, etc. will greatly benefit your shrimp and snail. Unfortunately, it is still not enough in some cases. You ...<|separator|>
[32]
https://advanced.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/adma.202007348