Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Exogenesis

Exogenesis, also known as the panspermia hypothesis, posits that life on Earth did not originate solely through abiogenesis but was instead seeded from extraterrestrial sources, with microorganisms or their precursors transported across space via mechanisms such as meteorites, comets, asteroids, or interstellar dust particles.^[1] This concept suggests that the building blocks of life, including viable microbes or organic compounds, could have arrived on Earth during the planet's early bombardment phase approximately 4 billion years ago, potentially explaining the rapid emergence of life in the geological record.^[2] While exogenesis does not resolve the ultimate origin of life—merely relocating it elsewhere in the universe—it shifts the focus of astrobiology toward interstellar transfer and the ubiquity of life's precursors throughout the cosmos.^[3] The idea of exogenesis has ancient roots, traceable to Greek philosophers like Anaxagoras in the 5th century BCE, who proposed that "seeds" of life were distributed universally, and Indian texts such as the Rigveda, which alluded to cosmic dissemination of life forms.^[2] It gained scientific traction in the 19th century with figures like Lord Kelvin, who in 1871 suggested life could arrive via meteorites, and was formalized by Svante Arrhenius in 1903 through his theory of radiative pressure propelling microbes through space.^[4] The hypothesis was revitalized in the 1970s by Fred Hoyle and Chandra Wickramasinghe, who integrated astronomical observations of interstellar organic molecules with microbiological evidence, arguing that cometary impacts could deliver protected microbial payloads to Earth.^[2] Exogenesis encompasses several variants based on transfer mechanisms. Ballistic panspermia involves microbes ejected from a donor planet's surface by asteroid impacts and traveling ballistically to another world, while lithopanspermia specifies transport within rock fragments that shield organisms from radiation and vacuum.^[3] Directed panspermia, proposed by Francis Crick and Leslie Orgel in 1973, envisions intelligent civilizations intentionally launching spacecraft carrying life forms to habitable planets.^[4] Radiopanspermia, as described by Arrhenius, relies on radiation pressure to propel dust-borne microbes across interstellar distances, though survival times are limited to thousands of years without protection.^[2] Supporting evidence includes laboratory simulations showing bacterial spores, such as Bacillus subtilis, surviving space-like conditions—including vacuum, UV radiation, and extreme temperatures—for up to six years, as demonstrated in long-term space exposure experiments such as on NASA's Long Duration Exposure Facility.^[3] Meteorites like the Martian ALH84001 contain organic compounds and structures suggestive of past microbial activity, bolstering interplanetary transfer feasibility,^[5] while spectroscopic detections of complex organics in interstellar clouds indicate life's precursors are widespread.^[3] However, challenges persist, including the scarcity of direct proof for viable organism survival over interstellar timescales and the need for shielding against cosmic rays, rendering exogenesis a compelling but unproven alternative to terrestrial abiogenesis in contemporary astrobiology.^[2]

Definition and Concepts

Core Hypothesis

Exogenesis is the scientific hypothesis proposing that life on Earth did not arise solely through endogenous processes but instead originated from extraterrestrial sources, with biological material or primitive life forms delivered to the planet via mechanisms such as meteoroids, comets, or interstellar dust particles.^[1] This framework shifts the locus of life's initial emergence from terrestrial environments to cosmic scales, positing that the building blocks of life or even viable organisms were transported across space rather than forming independently on early Earth.^[6] In contrast to abiogenesis, which attributes life's origin to chemical evolution within Earth's primordial conditions, exogenesis emphasizes an external "seeding" event that initiated biological development here.^[1] Central to exogenesis are distinctions between the transport of prebiotic chemicals—such as amino acids or organic compounds—and the delivery of viable microbial life forms. The former, often termed molecular panspermia, suggests that non-living precursors arrived from space and subsequently assembled into life under Earth's conditions, while the latter involves intact organisms surviving interstellar or interplanetary journeys.^[7] Panspermia serves as a key subset mechanism within exogenesis, specifically describing the hypothesis that microscopic life is widespread in the universe and can propagate via natural cosmic vectors, thereby "seeding" habitable worlds without resolving the ultimate origin of life itself.^[8] This seeding concept underscores exogenesis's role in explaining the rapid appearance of complex biochemistry on Earth, potentially circumventing the challenges of de novo formation in a young, volatile atmosphere. The term exogenesis emerged in the early 20th century, building on ideas proposed in the late 19th century, though it gained formal traction within astrobiology as the field developed interdisciplinary approaches to life's cosmic context in the mid-20th century onward.^[9] By reframing life's origins as a panspermic or exogenous process, the hypothesis expands the temporal and spatial scales of biogenesis, suggesting that Earth's biosphere may represent a secondary development in a universe conducive to life's dissemination.^[6] Exogenesis fundamentally differs from abiogenesis, the prevailing hypothesis that life arose on Earth through natural chemical processes from non-living matter, often exemplified by the "primordial soup" model involving atmospheric gases and energy sources like lightning. By contrast, exogenesis posits that life or its precursors originated extraterrestrially and were transported to Earth, thereby sidestepping some terrestrial challenges such as the dilution of prebiotic molecules in vast oceans. However, this distinction does not eliminate the core problem of life's initial emergence, as exogenesis merely relocates abiogenesis to another cosmic site without explaining how the first self-replicating systems formed anywhere in the universe.^[10] Exogenesis is closely related to but broader than panspermia, which specifically addresses the mechanisms of life's interstellar distribution. Panspermia hypothesizes that viable microorganisms or their propagules, resilient to space conditions, are disseminated across the cosmos via natural vectors like comets, asteroids, or interstellar dust, potentially seeding habitable worlds including Earth. In this framework, exogenesis encompasses panspermia as one possible transfer mode but extends to any form of extraterrestrial importation, including directed interventions by advanced civilizations as proposed in the concept of directed panspermia.^[11] This broader scope positions exogenesis as a hypothesis about Earth's life origins rather than a universal distribution model, though both ideas rely on the survival of biological material during interstellar transit, a process challenged by cosmic radiation and vacuum exposure. A attenuated version of these ideas is pseudo-panspermia, also termed soft or molecular panspermia, which focuses on the delivery of non-living organic compounds—such as amino acids, nucleotides, or polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons—rather than intact organisms.^[12] This mechanism suggests that extraterrestrial organics, synthesized in stellar nebulae or on other planetary bodies and carried by meteorites or comets, enriched Earth's prebiotic environment and catalyzed local abiogenesis without requiring the transport of life itself. Unlike full exogenesis or panspermia, pseudo-panspermia aligns more closely with chemical evolution theories and is supported by detections of organics in carbonaceous chondrites, yet it still defers the ultimate origin of replication to terrestrial processes. In essence, exogenesis serves as a transfer hypothesis that contrasts with purely endogenous origin models like abiogenesis by invoking cosmic migration, but it inherently intersects with them by presupposing an initial abiogenic event elsewhere. This interplay highlights exogenesis's role in expanding the spatial and temporal scope of life's puzzle without providing a complete resolution, as the enigma of the first living system persists regardless of venue.

Historical Background

Ancient and Early Modern Ideas

The earliest speculations on exogenesis trace back to ancient Greek philosophy, where Anaxagoras (c. 500–428 BCE) posited that the cosmos is filled with infinite "seeds" (spermata) capable of generating all matter, including life forms, upon reaching suitable environments like Earth.^[13] These seeds were envisioned as ubiquitous particles carried through air and cosmic processes, forming the basis of a proto-panspermia theory that emphasized life's continuity across the universe rather than spontaneous local generation.^[14] Parallel notions appear in ancient Indian texts, such as the Rigveda (c. 1500–1200 BCE), which describe cosmic seeds (retaḥ) and vital forces scattered throughout the universe, implying life's origins in a distributed, eternal cosmic vitality intertwined with creation myths.^[13] In the Hellenistic and Roman periods, Epicurean atomism further developed these ideas through a materialist lens. Lucretius (c. 99–55 BCE), in his epic poem De Rerum Natura, elaborated on Epicurus's philosophy by describing an infinite universe composed of atoms or "seeds of things" (semina rerum) that eternally combine to produce life and worlds, suggesting that life's particles could traverse voids between celestial bodies.^[13] This framework portrayed life not as divinely created but as an emergent property of cosmic matter, with implications for interstellar dissemination, though framed more metaphysically than mechanistically. Seventeenth- and eighteenth-century European thinkers integrated emerging astronomical observations with these ancient concepts, often reconciling them with theological views of a purposeful universe. Bernard le Bovier de Fontenelle, in his influential 1686 dialogue Conversations on the Plurality of Worlds, speculated on inhabited planets and proposed that comets—then seen as erratic wanderers—might serve as vehicles for distributing life or vital principles across the solar system, blending Cartesian mechanics with pluralist cosmology.^[15] Such ideas reflected cultural tensions between astronomical discoveries, like those of Galileo, and religious doctrines, positioning exogenesis as a harmonious extension of divine creation rather than a challenge to it. By the nineteenth century, these philosophical notions began acquiring a proto-scientific edge amid advances in geology and microbiology. In 1871, physicist William Thomson (Lord Kelvin) delivered a presidential address to the British Association for the Advancement of Science, proposing that "germs" or microbial life could have reached Earth via meteorites from other celestial bodies, offering a naturalistic mechanism for life's introduction without invoking spontaneous generation.^[15] Kelvin's suggestion, influenced by contemporary debates on abiogenesis and fossil records, underscored meteorites' role in cosmic exchange while maintaining compatibility with theological interpretations of life's rarity and purpose.

20th-Century Developments

In the early 20th century, Swedish chemist Svante Arrhenius advanced the concept of exogenesis through his proposal of radiopanspermia, suggesting that microscopic life forms could be propelled through space by stellar radiation pressure and survive interstellar travel to seed planets like Earth. In his 1908 book Worlds in the Making, Arrhenius argued that such spores, ejected from inhabited worlds, could withstand the vacuum and cold of space due to their small size and protective coatings, providing a mechanism for life's distribution across the cosmos without addressing its ultimate origin. This idea marked a shift from philosophical speculation to a physically grounded hypothesis, influencing subsequent debates on extraterrestrial life transfer. By the mid-20th century, the Oparin-Haldane theory, independently proposed by Alexander Oparin in 1924 and J.B.S. Haldane in 1929, emphasized endogenous abiogenesis on Earth, positing that life arose gradually from inorganic precursors in a primordial soup under reducing atmospheric conditions.^[16] This framework contrasted sharply with exogenic models like panspermia, as it focused on terrestrial chemical evolution rather than external delivery, yet it spurred comparative discussions on whether life's building blocks formed locally or arrived via meteorites and comets.^[17] Concurrently, NASA's exobiology program, established in 1960 following initial grants in 1959, formalized the search for extraterrestrial life as a core objective, funding studies on cosmic organic chemistry and potential panspermia pathways.^[18] By 1960, dedicated labs at Ames Research Center and the Jet Propulsion Laboratory advanced instrumentation for detecting biosignatures, integrating exogenesis into broader astrobiological research.^[18] In the 1970s, astronomers Fred Hoyle and Chandra Wickramasinghe revitalized exogenesis by advocating cometary panspermia, proposing that microbes and organic molecules were delivered to Earth via comet impacts, supported by spectroscopic evidence of interstellar dust resembling biological materials.^[15] Their seminal works, including a 1974 paper on organic grains in space and the 1979 book Diseases from Space, extended Arrhenius's ideas to suggest ongoing cosmic seeding, linking comets to viral and bacterial dissemination.^[19] The 1977 Viking missions to Mars intensified these debates, as their labeled release experiments detected gas emissions suggestive of metabolic activity in soil samples, prompting speculation on interplanetary life transfer between Earth and Mars despite official interpretations favoring non-biological oxidants.^[20] During the 1980s, analyses of carbonaceous chondrites provided empirical support for exogenic delivery of life's precursors, with studies identifying diverse amino acids in meteorites like the Murchison and Antarctic finds, indicating abiotic synthesis in space environments.^[21] Key research, such as examinations of primitive CM chondrites, revealed amino acids formed through parent body aqueous alteration, challenging purely endogenous origins and bolstering the role of meteoritic influx in early Earth's prebiotic chemistry.^[22] These findings, building on NASA's ongoing exobiology efforts, solidified exogenesis as a testable hypothesis within astrobiology.^[18]

Proposed Mechanisms

Natural Transfer Processes

Natural transfer processes in exogenesis refer to passive mechanisms by which life forms, microorganisms, or their precursors could be transported across space without intentional intervention, relying on cosmic physical phenomena such as impacts, radiation pressure, and gravitational dynamics. These processes are central to undirected panspermia hypotheses, where viable biological material or organic building blocks are ejected from one planetary system and potentially incorporated into another. Key challenges include the survival of organisms under extreme conditions like vacuum, radiation, and thermal stresses during transit.^[23] Radiopanspermia proposes that microscopic life or organic particles, embedded in small dust grains approximately 10^{-5} cm in size, are propelled through interstellar space by stellar radiation pressure and winds. First articulated by Svante Arrhenius in 1903, this mechanism involves ejection from a host planetary system, where solar luminosity—around 4 × 10^{33} erg s^{-1} for our Sun—accelerates grains to velocities exceeding escape speeds, such as about 45 km s^{-1} at Earth's orbit.^[23]^[24] Once in the interstellar medium, these grains travel at speeds of roughly 10-20 km s^{-1}, potentially reaching nearby stars within millions of years, though deceleration upon approach to a target system is facilitated by drag from the receiving star's radiation. Stellar winds contribute secondary propulsion, but radiation pressure dominates for micron-sized carriers.^[25] Survival during transit poses significant hurdles, as ultraviolet radiation and cosmic rays can inactivate microorganisms within 10^5 to 10^6 years unless shielded by the dust grain; even then, only dormant or highly resistant forms, such as bacterial spores, might endure the interstellar void, potentially delivering necropanspermia—dead but chemically informative material.^[23]^[25] Lithopanspermia involves the ejection of rock fragments containing microorganisms from a planet's surface via hypervelocity impacts, followed by ballistic travel as meteoroids and eventual atmospheric entry on a target world. Impacts from asteroids or comets generate shock pressures of 5-50 GPa, sufficient to launch material beyond escape velocity—descriptively modeled as the speed needed to overcome gravitational binding, scaling with the square root of the planet's mass and inversely with radius—while embedding organisms within protective lithic matrices. For Mars, ejection velocities around 5 km s^{-1} suffice for interplanetary transfer, with confirmed examples including over 400 Martian meteorites that reached Earth, some with transit times as short as 700,000 years.^[26]^[27]^[28] Experiments demonstrate that hardy species like Bacillus subtilis spores and the cyanobacterium Chroococcidiopsis can survive ejection shocks up to 45 GPa and 10 GPa, respectively, with survival rates as low as 10^{-4} but non-zero, owing to their dormant states and rock shielding against initial heating below 0°C at lower pressures.^[26] During space travel, which can last from months to 15 million years, meteoroids 1-3 meters in size protect against cosmic radiation for up to 25 million years, though larger fragments (>1 m) are preferred to minimize erosion.^[27] Atmospheric entry induces secondary heating up to 550-950°C at high pressures, but slower entries for smaller, lower-velocity rocks improve survival odds, as seen in models of Mars-to-Earth transfers where ultramafic rocks like nakhlites experience reduced thermal stress.^[26] This process exemplifies interplanetary exchange, with Mars serving as a plausible donor due to its thinner atmosphere and frequent impacts facilitating ejection.^[27] Interstellar dust clouds, including molecular clouds rich in hydrogen and organics, have been hypothesized as potential carriers for panspermia, trapping and transporting microscopic life forms or precursors over galactic distances. These clouds, with temperatures of 10-20 K and densities allowing for organic molecule formation like polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons and glycolaldehyde, could shield embedded microbes from cosmic rays via ice mantles, enabling survival through energy from ionized hydrogen. However, low densities and extreme cold challenge viability, with thermodynamic models indicating marginal feasibility for processes like methanogenesis providing sufficient energy ( -60 to -370 kJ/mol ).^[29] Observations of fullerenes and other complex organics in such clouds support their role in disseminating prebiotic material.^[29] Comet impacts represent another natural vector, delivering organic compounds to planetary surfaces through hypervelocity collisions that vaporize and disperse material. Missions like Rosetta and Stardust have identified amino acids such as glycine, along with methanol and ethylene glycol, in comets 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko and 81P/Wild 2, suggesting these icy bodies aggregate interstellar organics formed in protoplanetary disks. During the early Solar System's heavy bombardment, comet deliveries could have contributed up to significant fractions of Earth's prebiotic inventory, with impacts facilitating the incorporation of these molecules into hydrothermal or atmospheric environments conducive to abiogenesis precursors.^[30] While primarily transporting chemical building blocks rather than intact life, this mechanism aligns with exogenesis by providing the raw materials for life's emergence.^[31]

Directed and Artificial Seeding

Directed panspermia refers to the intentional transmission of life forms by an advanced extraterrestrial civilization to seed habitable planets, as proposed by Francis Crick and Leslie Orgel in their 1973 paper.^[11] They suggested that microorganisms could be deliberately sent from another planetary system via spacecraft to Earth, addressing the improbability of natural panspermia mechanisms like radiation pressure or meteorite transfer achieving such specificity.^[11] In this scenario, alien probes would carry biological payloads, potentially embedding a detectable signature, such as an artificial pattern in the genetic code, to indicate intelligent origin rather than random evolution.^[11] The concept raises ethical considerations akin to interstellar gardening, where seeding distant worlds imposes a moral responsibility to preserve and propagate life without unintended ecological disruption.^[32] Proponents argue that such actions fulfill an obligation to safeguard genetic diversity across cosmic scales, but they also highlight risks of contaminating pristine environments, drawing parallels to planetary protection protocols in space exploration.^[33] Crick and Orgel emphasized that any seeding mission would require careful design to ensure viability, underscoring the ethical weight of altering planetary biospheres.^[11] Modern variants extend directed panspermia to human initiatives, such as terraforming exoplanets through microbial dispersal to foster habitable conditions.^[33] Researchers have proposed using synthetic biology to engineer resilient microbes for deployment via interstellar probes, aiming to initiate ecosystems on barren worlds and mitigate Earth's existential risks by diversifying life's cosmic footprint.^[34] These efforts connect to the Search for Extraterrestrial Intelligence (SETI), where detecting evidence of prior seeders—through anomalous biosignatures or engineered artifacts—could confirm directed origins and guide future human missions.^[35] Specific concepts for implementation include "seeding packages" containing microbes suspended in protective matrices with essential nutrients, such as organic compounds and minerals modeled after meteorite compositions to sustain growth during transit.^[11] These packages would be dispersed from spacecraft to intersect planetary paths, maximizing delivery to target zones.^[36] Probability models for detection focus on statistical assessments of non-natural patterns, like optimized genetic codes or isotopic anomalies in ancient fossils, estimating low but non-zero chances of identifying artificial intervention amid natural baselines.^[35] Such models prioritize high-impact signatures to distinguish directed seeding from undirected processes.^[33]

Supporting Evidence

Extraterrestrial Organics and Meteorites

The Murchison meteorite, a carbonaceous chondrite that fell in Australia in 1969, contains a diverse array of organic compounds, including over 70 amino acids such as glycine, alanine, and aspartic acid, as well as nucleobases like adenine, guanine, cytosine, thymine, and uracil.^[37]^[38] These molecules exhibit non-terrestrial isotopic ratios, confirming their extraterrestrial origin and suggesting synthesis in the early solar system or interstellar medium.^[39] Similarly, the Allende meteorite, another carbonaceous chondrite that fell in Mexico in 1969, is rich in complex hydrocarbons, including polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) such as coronene and benzofluoranthene, as well as fullerenes like C₆₀ and C₇₀.^[40]^[41] These aromatic compounds, concentrated in the meteorite's fine-grained matrix, indicate processing by stellar radiation or hydrothermal alteration on its parent body.^[42] Observations from space missions have extended these findings to comets. The European Space Agency's Rosetta mission (2014–2016) detected glycine, along with methylamine and ethylamine, in the coma of comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko using the ROSINA mass spectrometer, marking the first in situ identification of this amino acid in a comet. This discovery implies that comets could have delivered prebiotic organics to early Earth via impacts. Radio astronomy has revealed organic molecules in interstellar clouds, with over 100 species identified, including methanol, formaldehyde, acetaldehyde, and more complex forms like ethylene glycol.^[43] These detections, made through spectral line observations from telescopes like the Atacama Large Millimeter/submillimeter Array, demonstrate that the building blocks of life form in cold, dense regions of space long before planetary formation.^[44] Recent advancements with the James Webb Space Telescope (JWST), operational since 2022, have detected complex organic molecules such as methanol and hydrocarbons in protoplanetary disks around young stars, as observed in systems like d216-0939 and those in the Taurus molecular cloud up to 2025.^[45]^[46] These findings, using mid-infrared spectroscopy, show organics incorporated into ices and gases, linking interstellar chemistry to planet formation. Enantiomeric excesses in meteoritic amino acids provide further evidence of non-random extraterrestrial processes. In the Murchison meteorite, L-isovaline exhibits up to 15% left-handed excess, while other amino acids like alanine show smaller biases, uncorrelated with terrestrial contamination based on isotopic analysis.^[47]^[48] Such asymmetries suggest influences like circularly polarized light from neutron stars during synthesis.^[49]

Extremophile Survival Studies

Experimental studies on extremophiles have provided critical insights into the potential for microbial life to endure the harsh conditions of interplanetary transfer, such as vacuum, extreme temperatures, and ionizing radiation. These investigations simulate or directly expose organisms to space environments, demonstrating survival mechanisms that could facilitate panspermia. Key facilities like NASA's Long Duration Exposure Facility (LDEF) and the European Space Agency's (ESA) EXPOSE series on the International Space Station (ISS) have been pivotal in quantifying resilience.^[50] The LDEF, deployed in low Earth orbit from 1984 to 1990, exposed bacterial spores, including those of Bacillus subtilis, to space conditions for up to 69 months. Results showed that multilayered spores achieved survival rates of up to 80% when shielded from solar ultraviolet (UV) radiation, though unshielded samples experienced a four-order-of-magnitude reduction in viability due to UV damage. This experiment highlighted the role of physical protection in mitigating cosmic radiation and vacuum desiccation, with viable spores recoverable after rehydration.^[51] Building on LDEF, the EXPOSE-E mission (2008-2009) on the ISS directly tested bacterial endospores in the PROTECT experiment, exposing them to space vacuum, solar and cosmic radiation, and temperature fluctuations for 18 months. Endospores of Bacillus subtilis and other species demonstrated significant resistance, with survival fractions exceeding 10% under combined stressors when embedded in artificial meteorites, underscoring the protective effects of mineral matrices akin to those in meteorites.^[52] Specific extremophiles have shown remarkable tolerance in these and subsequent exposures. The bacterium Deinococcus radiodurans, known for its radiation resistance, survived nearly two years of exposure on the ISS exterior in the EXPOSE-R2 mission (2014-2016), repairing extensive DNA damage from UV and cosmic rays upon rehydration through efficient recombination and excision repair pathways. Similarly, tardigrades (Hypsibius dujardini) endured 10 days of space vacuum and radiation during the 2007 FOTON-M3 mission, with approximately 30% of active specimens reviving post-exposure via cryptobiosis, a dormant state that preserves cellular integrity.^[53] The BIOMEX experiment, part of EXPOSE-R2, further tested lichen communities, such as Circinaria gyrosa, under space and Mars-like conditions from 2014 to 2016, with post-flight analyses (published up to 2020) confirming revival of photosynthetic activity in exposed samples. Up to 48.5% of lichen thalli recovered pre-flight photosynthetic activity within hours of rehydration, despite DNA strand breaks from radiation, due to robust repair mechanisms in their symbiotic algae and fungi. These findings indicate that lichens could survive ballistic ejection and atmospheric re-entry if shielded.^[54]^[55] Underlying these survivals are adaptive strategies like spore dormancy, where extremophiles enter metabolically inactive states to resist desiccation and oxidative stress, and advanced DNA repair systems. For instance, Deinococcus species employ multiple genome copies and rapid repair enzymes to reconstruct genomes fragmented by up to 5000 Gray (Gy) of ionizing radiation—far exceeding the 3-10 Gy lethal dose for humans—enabling multi-year viability in space. However, limits exist: cumulative cosmic ray doses above 10,000 Gy typically overwhelm repair in most bacteria, though shielding extends thresholds for hardy species like endospores.^[56]^[57]

Criticisms and Limitations

Environmental Barriers to Survival

Cosmic radiation poses a primary environmental barrier to microbial survival during exogenesis, as galactic cosmic rays—comprising high-energy protons and heavy ions (HZE particles)—induce ionizing damage that fragments DNA strands, leading to lethal mutations and inactivation of cellular repair mechanisms in microorganisms. This radiation penetrates deeply but attenuates with material density, requiring substantial shielding for viable transit; studies on bacterial spores exposed to simulated cosmic radiation demonstrate that unshielded or minimally protected cells experience rapid viability loss, with heavy ions causing clustered DNA lesions that overwhelm repair pathways even in radiation-resistant species like Deinococcus radiodurans. In meteorites, survival is highly depth-dependent, with microbes embedded less than 10-20 cm from the surface facing exponential increases in exposure and corresponding reductions in survival rates—often below 10^{-6} for spores after prolonged irradiation—while deeper interiors (e.g., >1 m in large ejecta) provide adequate attenuation for potential multi-year protection against galactic cosmic rays. The vacuum of space exacerbates these challenges through extreme desiccation, stripping cellular water and inducing protein denaturation and membrane rupture, though dormant spores can endure short-term exposure (up to weeks) with minimal viability loss if pre-desiccated. Temperature fluctuations during interstellar transit, including freeze-thaw cycles from solar proximity to deep-space cold (~3 K), further stress microbes by promoting ice crystal formation that punctures cells and disrupts metabolic revival upon thawing; experiments simulating these cycles on extremophiles like Escherichia coli show up to 90% viability reduction after repeated exposures, compounding desiccation effects. Atmospheric entry upon arrival amplifies thermal hazards, with meteorite surfaces heating to peaks of 10,000 K due to frictional ablation, vaporizing shallow-embedded organisms while interior shielding limits internal temperatures to survivable levels (<100°C) only for depths exceeding several centimeters in robust lithic carriers. Interstellar travel durations for exogenic material typically span tens of thousands to millions of years—e.g., 10^4 to 10^6 years to nearby stars (a few light-years) at ejection velocities of 20-50 km/s, and longer for greater distances—greatly exceeding the active lifespans of even dormant microbial forms, which rely on metabolic stasis but accumulate irreversible damage over such timescales. Studies of unshielded microbial exposure to combined space stressors (radiation, vacuum, and thermal cycling) predict survival probabilities below 1% for transit periods beyond 10^4 years, based on dose-response models calibrated to cleanroom isolates and extremophiles, underscoring the necessity of protective encasement for any plausible exogenesis scenario.^[58]

Philosophical and Probabilistic Issues

One key philosophical critique of exogenesis, also known as panspermia, is the problem of infinite regress. This argument posits that proposing life on Earth originated from extraterrestrial sources merely displaces the fundamental question of abiogenesis—how life first arose from non-living matter—to another location in the universe, without providing a resolution to the origin problem itself. Critics contend that exogenesis fails to advance scientific understanding of life's emergence, as it requires an unexplained prior instance of abiogenesis elsewhere, potentially leading to an unending chain of dependencies.^[59] Probabilistic challenges further undermine exogenesis by highlighting the statistical improbability of life originating and surviving in sufficient density across the cosmos to enable transfer. The rarity of habitable zones, where conditions permit liquid water and stable environments, limits the number of potential sites for life's emergence; estimates suggest that only a small fraction of planetary systems possess such zones, with factors like stellar type and galactic position further constraining viability.^[60] The Drake equation, which estimates the number of communicative civilizations in the Milky Way as N = R^* f_p n_e f_l f_i f_c L—where R^* is the star formation rate, f_p the fraction of stars with planets, n_e the number of habitable planets per system, and so on—illustrates the low density of life-bearing worlds implied by conservative parameter values, making widespread exogenic seeding unlikely.^[61] Applying Occam's razor, the principle favoring the simplest explanation with the fewest assumptions, many philosophers and scientists argue that endogenous abiogenesis on Earth is preferable to exogenesis, which introduces extraneous complexities like interstellar travel and extraterrestrial life without compelling empirical necessity.^[59] This critique is compounded by connections to the Fermi paradox, which questions the apparent absence of evidence for extraterrestrial civilizations despite the universe's vastness; if exogenesis were common, one might expect detectable signs of widespread life distribution, yet none have been observed, suggesting life's rarity aligns better with localized origins.^[62]

Implications for Science and Philosophy

Role in Astrobiology Research

Exogenesis plays a pivotal role in shaping astrobiology research by informing the design and interpretation of missions that seek to identify the precursors to life and assess the potential for its interstellar transfer. NASA's OSIRIS-REx mission, which returned samples from asteroid Bennu in 2023, has enabled detailed analyses of organic compounds and potential biosignatures, such as carbon-rich materials and phosphates that could indicate early solar system chemistry conducive to life's building blocks.^[63] Similarly, Japan's Hayabusa2 mission retrieved samples from asteroid Ryugu in 2020, revealing over 20 amino acids and other organics that support hypotheses of material delivery from space to planetary surfaces.^[64] These sample-return efforts provide foundational data for evaluating exogenesis, as the preserved extraterrestrial organics mirror those found in meteorites and underscore pathways for life's dissemination across the solar system.^[65] Ongoing and future missions further integrate exogenesis concepts to probe habitability in extreme environments. The Europa Clipper spacecraft, launched in October 2024, is investigating Jupiter's icy moon Europa for subsurface ocean conditions that could harbor life, with instruments designed to detect chemical signatures potentially linked to interstellar delivery mechanisms.^[66] As of 2025, NASA's Dragonfly mission to Saturn's moon Titan has completed critical design reviews and is advancing through development and testing phases, focusing on prebiotic chemistry in its organic-rich atmosphere and surface, which may reveal processes akin to those enabling exogenic seeding of habitable worlds.^[67] Exogenesis also guides broader research impacts, such as the search for exoplanet biosignatures using the James Webb Space Telescope (JWST), operational since 2022, which observes atmospheric gases like dimethyl sulfide that could signal biological activity influenced by interstellar panspermia.^[68] Computational simulations model the interstellar spread of life, incorporating factors like radiation resistance and ejection velocities to predict viable transfer distances, thereby refining protocols for anomaly detection in astrobiology surveys, including those intersecting with SETI efforts.^[69] These interdisciplinary approaches enhance the field's ability to distinguish natural exogenic processes from indigenous origins, driving targeted inquiries into life's prevalence beyond Earth.

Broader Existential Questions

Exogenesis, by positing that life on Earth originated from extraterrestrial sources, fundamentally challenges anthropocentric views of humanity's uniqueness, suggesting that biological processes are not confined to our planet but part of a broader cosmic distribution of life. This perspective diminishes the notion of Earth as a singular cradle of existence, implying that human evolution may be one branch in a potentially vast interstellar tree of life, thereby reframing existential questions about our place in the universe. Philosophers have argued that such a hypothesis shifts focus from isolated terrestrial origins to a connected cosmic narrative, where humanity's exceptionalism is diluted by the possibility of widespread biogenesis elsewhere.^[70]^[33] The hypothesis also intersects with religious creation narratives, particularly those emphasizing divine intervention on Earth alone, by proposing mechanisms like panspermia that relocate life's inception to unknown cosmic locales. For instance, in Christian theology, exogenesis can be reconciled with Genesis through interpretations allowing extended creative periods or extraterrestrial agents, yet it poses difficulties for literalist readings that view Earth as the exclusive site of divine origination. This tension has led some theologians to integrate panspermia as a tool of providence, while others see it as a secular evasion of supernatural causation, prompting debates on whether extraterrestrial seeding undermines faith in a purposeful creation.^[71]^[72] If exogenesis involves directed seeding by advanced intelligences, it raises profound ethical questions about interstellar responsibilities, including the moral duty to propagate life versus the risks of imposing it on sterile worlds. Biocentric ethics advocate for directed panspermia to enhance cosmic biodiversity and safeguard against Earth's extinction events, such as the Permo-Triassic mass extinction that wiped out approximately 96% of marine species, yet welfarist concerns highlight potential for widespread suffering if seeded ecosystems evolve sentience in net-negative conditions. These dilemmas are codified in international frameworks like the COSPAR planetary protection guidelines, which mandate stringent bioburden controls—such as limiting spacecraft spores to 3×10⁵ for Mars landers—to prevent forward contamination that could obscure indigenous biosignatures or disrupt potential extraterrestrial life, emphasizing a precautionary approach to any seeding efforts.^[73]^[74]^[75] Culturally, exogenesis has permeated science fiction, influencing narratives that explore alien origins and human destiny, with H.G. Wells' 1937 novel Star-Begotten depicting Martians using cosmic rays to subtly evolve humanity, prefiguring directed panspermia as a theme of interstellar intervention. This work, alongside Wells' broader oeuvre, helped shape speculative fiction's engagement with evolutionary and cosmic themes, inspiring later depictions in media that question humanity's autonomy. Ongoing philosophical discussions in astrobiology, including concepts like cosmic ancestry, continue to explore how exogenesis models intersect with evolutionary biology amid advancing research.^[76]^[77]^[78]

References

[1]
Cosmic Evolution - Chemical
First, life might have originated on Earth by means of panspermia, meaning “germs everywhere.” This idea, also called exogenesis, maintains that microscopic ...Missing: definition | Show results with:definition
[2]
[PDF] VIVA PANSPERMIA! Chandra Wickramasinghe - arXiv
The arguments for panspermia as a mode of origin of life on Earth are far from dead; on the contrary they are now more robust than ever. The term panspermia is ...
[3]
Galactic Panspermia - IOP Science
With the overwhelming evidence that at least some microorganisms can survive ejection and travel in space, we ask ourselves: is intragalactic panspermia viable?
[4]
A Short History of Panspermia from Antiquity Through the Mid-1970s
Dec 6, 2022 · Panspermia is the philosophical proposition that the precursors of life are present in space and able to initiate.
[5]
High-temperature Mars-to-Earth transfer of meteorite ALH84001
Aug 15, 2007 · Martian meteorites provide crucial insights into Martian evolution and interplanetary mass transfer, including the potential for exogenesis.Missing: definition | Show results with:definition
[6]
[PDF] Session 3 - McGill University
• the science of Astrobiology is an interdisciplinary field, combining ... Exogenesis. • one hypothesis for the origin of life is that life occurred.
[7]
A Material-based Panspermia Hypothesis: The Potential of Polymer ...
Jan 19, 2022 · We introduce and review the plausibility of a polymeric material-based Panspermia seed (M-BPS) theoretical concept.Missing: exogenesis | Show results with:exogenesis
[8]
Panspermia - an overview | ScienceDirect Topics
The panspermia theory argues that life is originated in space, in spatial ices, and continuously distributed to the planets by comets and meteorites.Missing: exogenesis | Show results with:exogenesis
[9]
exogenesis, n. meanings, etymology and more | Oxford English ...
The earliest known use of the noun exogenesis is in the 1900s. OED's only evidence for exogenesis is from 1903, in Journal of Tropical Medicine.Missing: coined | Show results with:coined<|control11|><|separator|>
[10]
[PDF] Evolution: Fossils, Genes, and Mousetraps (2006) Dr. Kenneth R ...
Q&A: What about pan-spermia or exogenesis? (1:17:33). Right there, yeah. What is your view on panspermia or exogenesis? Panspermia is the notion that life on.
[11]
Directed panspermia - ScienceDirect.com
We have considered Directed Panspermia, the theory that organisms were deliberately transmitted to the earth by intelligent beings on another planet.
[12]
[PDF] Subsurface Exolife - arXiv
Apr 5, 2018 · the transfer of biomolecules by means of pseudo-panspermia (Orgel, 2004; Lingam and Loeb, 2017a). We envision a two-step process wherein a ...
[13]
The prehistory of panspermia: astrophysical or metaphysical?
Mar 30, 2007 · Turning now to ancient Greece, we find that a panspermia theory was advocated by the philosopher Anaxagoras, whose dates were 500–428 BC.
[14]
Anaxagoras - Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Aug 22, 2007 · He propounded a physical theory of “everything-in-everything,” and claimed that nous (intellect or mind) was the motive cause of the cosmos.
[15]
A Short History of Panspermia from Antiquity Through the Mid-1970s
Panspermia is the philosophical proposition that the precursors of life are present in space and able to initiate life on reaching a suitable environment.
[16]
Origins of life: a comparison of theories and application to Mars
What might be called the standard theory (the Oparin-Haldane theory) posits the production of organic molecules on the early Earth followed by chemical ...Missing: exogenous | Show results with:exogenous
[17]
Pioneers of Origin of Life Studies—Darwin, Oparin, Haldane, Miller ...
Oct 21, 2024 · The two basic approaches to elucidating how life began both date from Darwin. The first, that of the experimentalists, stems from Darwin's famous “warm little ...
[18]
Origins and development of NASA's exobiology program, 1958–1976
Following NASA's founding in 1958, the American space agency was quick to embrace exobiology as an important goal. In July 1959 NASA's first administrator, ...
[19]
Introduction—Panspermia, 2020 - PMC - PubMed Central - NIH
Jul 7, 2020 · Thus a Panspermic universe provides the scientific rationale for the actual widespread existence of Lamarckian modes of genetic evolution both ...Missing: exogenesis | Show results with:exogenesis<|control11|><|separator|>
[20]
The Case for Extant Life on Mars and Its Possible Detection by ... - NIH
The purpose of this article is to consider recent findings about martian water, methane, and organics that impact the case for extant life on Mars.Missing: debates transfer
[21]
Carbonaceous chondrites and the origin of life
The presence of amino acids on these meteorites, in particular, may imply thatthese meteorites have some relevance to the origin of life. In this paper we ...
[22]
Amino-acid synthesis in carbonaceous meteorites by aqueous ...
Feb 22, 1990 · It has been suggested that amino acids and other organic compounds found in carbonaceous meteorites formed by aqueous alteration in the meteorite parent bodies.
[23]
[PDF] PANSPERMIA, PAST AND PRESENT: - arXiv
Radiopanspermia, which involves the movement of organisms by the radiation pressure of the Sun and other stars, was discussed by Ar- rhenius in his book Worlds ...
[24]
Astrophysical and Biological Constraints on Radiopanspermia
That is the panspermia transport mechanism as we envision it. We (SLW94) have carried out a detailed set of calculations using different parameters and the ...Missing: sources | Show results with:sources
[25]
Experimental evidence for the potential impact ejection of viable ...
These results strongly confirm the possibility of a “direct transfer” scenario of “lithopanspermia” for the route from Mars to Earth or from any Mars-like ...
[26]
[PDF] Evolutionary processes transpiring in the stages of lithopanspermia
Apr 21, 2020 · Abstract Lithopanspermia is the theory that proposes the natural exchange of organisms between solar system bodies due to asteroidal or ...
[27]
None
### Summary of Interstellar Dust Clouds as Carriers for Panspermia and Survival Challenges
[28]
Organic Matter in Cometary Environments - PMC - NIH
In this review, we discuss the history and recent breakthroughs of the study of organic matter in comets, from simple organic molecules and photodissociation ...
[29]
https://arxiv.org/pdf/2502.16615
[30]
A technical and ethical evaluation of seeding nearby solar systems
Interstellar panspermia is proposed on the basis of the following ethical considerations: the moral obligation to insure the survival of the fundamental ...Missing: gardening | Show results with:gardening
[31]
The Cosmic Significance of Directed Panspermia: Should Humanity ...
Feb 2, 2022 · Directed panspermia, or planetary seeding, is the deliberate transmission of microorganisms to a lifeless planet with the aim of seeding it with life.
[32]
Directed Panspermia: A 21st Century Perspective - PMC - NIH
Applying 21st century technology to the design and development of a hypothetical extra-terrestrial colonisation programme, we reimagine 'directed panspermia' ...
[33]
Space ethics to test directed panspermia - ScienceDirect
The hypothesis that Earth was intentionally seeded with life by a preceding extraterrestrial civilization is believed to be currently untestable.
[34]
Directed Panspermia. 3. strategies and Motivation for Seeding Star ...
These objects, as modeled by meteorite materials, contain biologically available organic and mineral nutrients that are shown to sustain microbial growth. The ...
[35]
A new family of extraterrestrial amino acids in the Murchison meteorite
Apr 4, 2017 · Currently, a total of 86 amino acids have been identified in the Murchison meteorite as α, β, γ and δ amino structures with a carbon number ...
[36]
[PDF] Carbonaceous meteorites contain a wide
All terrestrial organisms depend on nucleic acids (RNA and DNA), which use pyrimidine and purine nuc1eobases to encode genetic information.
[37]
[PDF] Assessing the origins of aliphatic amines in the Murchison meteorite ...
Jul 10, 2014 · The amino acids extracted from Murchison have been extensively analyzed, including measurements of non- terrestrial stable isotopic ratios and ...
[38]
Fullerenes in Allende meteorite - Nature
many polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons. (PAHs) in the Allende meteorite, consis- tent with previous reports6. • In particular, we detected benzofluoranthene ...
[39]
Spatially resolved organic analysis of the Allende meteorite
The data suggest that the PAHs are primarily associated with the fine-grained matrix, where the organic polymer occurs. In addition, highly substituted PAH ...
[40]
Evidence that Polycyclic Aromatic Hydrocarbons in Two ...
The distribution of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) in the Allende and Murchison carbonaceous chondrites was investigated using spatially resolved ...
[41]
Extraterrestrial organic matter: a review
Oct 1, 1998 · In the interstellar medium of the Milky Way Galaxy more than 100 molecular species, the bulk of them organic, have been securely identified, ...
[42]
Recent observations of organic molecules in nearby cold, dark ...
The first detection in such regions of acetaldehyde (CH3CHO), the most complex oxygen-containing organic molecule yet found in dark clouds is reported, as well ...
[43]
Pristine ices in a planet-forming disk revealed by heavy water - Nature
Oct 15, 2025 · A JWST inventory of protoplanetary disk ices. The edge-on ... Freshly sublimated complex organic molecules in the Keplerian disk.
[44]
Webb Unveils Dark Side of Pre-stellar Ice Chemistry - NASA Science
Jan 23, 2023 · “Our identification of complex organic molecules, like methanol and ... protoplanetary disks,” concluded McClure. “This will tell us ...<|separator|>
[45]
Uncovering the chiral bias of meteoritic isovaline through ... - Nature
Jun 8, 2023 · As analogues to amino acids adsorbed on interstellar dust grains, CPL-helicity dependent enantiomeric excesses of up to 2% were generated in ...
[46]
Insights into the formation and evolution of extraterrestrial amino ...
Mar 17, 2023 · Despite isotopic and enantiomeric data indicating an extraterrestrial origin for the amino acids detected within carbonaceous chondrites, ...
[47]
Amino Acid Chiral Selection Via Weak Interactions in Stellar ... - Nature
Jun 11, 2018 · Thus, we can make a comparison to the relative production of amino acid ees in our model to those found in the Murchison and Murray meteorites.
[48]
Long-term exposure of bacterial spores to space
Jan 1, 1992 · Data shows that the chances of microorganisms surviving in free space will be greatly increased by adequate shielding against solar ultraviolet ...Missing: 1984-1990 extremophiles
[49]
Long-term survival of bacterial spores in space - PubMed
Up to 80 % of spores in multilayers survive in space. Solar UV-radiation, being the most deleterious parameter of space, reduces survival by 4 orders of ...Missing: 1984-1990 extremophiles
[50]
Resistance of Bacterial Endospores to Outer Space for Planetary ...
The space experiment PROTECT of the EXPOSE-E mission provides experimental data on the responses of the most resistant microbial representatives, for ...
[51]
Molecular repertoire of Deinococcus radiodurans after ... - Microbiome
Oct 29, 2020 · Presented results show that the non-sporulating bacterium Deinococcus radiodurans survived long-term low Earth orbit exposure if wavelength ...
[52]
Lichen Vitality After a Space Flight on Board the EXPOSE-R2 Facility ...
As part of the Biology and Mars Experiment (BIOMEX; ILSRA 2009-0834), samples of the lichen Circinaria gyrosa were placed on the exposure platform EXPOSE-R2 ...Missing: revival | Show results with:revival
[53]
Lichen Vitality After a Space Flight on Board the EXPOSE-R2 Facility ...
Aug 7, 2025 · Polymerase chain reaction analyses confirmed that there was DNA damage in lichen exposed to harsh space and Mars-like environmental conditions, ...
[54]
Molecular Mechanisms of Microbial Survivability in Outer Space
Extremophilic microorganisms in the outer space environment tolerate radiation stress and cope with radiation-induced DNA damage by means of their DNA repair ...Missing: dormancy | Show results with:dormancy
[55]
Experimental evolution of extremophile resistance to ionizing radiation
IR is not well tolerated by most organisms. The lethal dose for a human being is 3–10 Gray (Gy; 1 Gy = 100 rads) [31,32]. Despite the severe ...
[56]
[PDF] Answers to common misconceptions about biological evolution
Oct 22, 2014 · Chapter 3 Evolution does not explain the origin of life ... There are other theories among the scientific community, such as panspermia, which is.
[57]
A panspermic view of life - Frontline - The Hindu
Dec 9, 2000 · The theory maintains that life on the earth was seeded from space and that life's evolution to higher forms depends on complex genes (including ...
[58]
Panspermia in a Milky Way–like Galaxy - IOPscience
Nov 11, 2021 · We find that, unlike habitability, which only occupies a narrow dynamic range over the entire galaxy, the panspermia probability can vary by ...
[59]
The Drake Equation and the Fermi Paradox – Astrobiology
The Drake equation is a way of estimating the probability that life exists elsewhere. First written down by Frank Drake in 1961.
[60]
Reconfiguring SETI in the microbial context: Panspermia as a ...
May 12, 2021 · Reconfiguring SETI in the microbial context: Panspermia as a solution to Fermi's paradox. Biosystems. 2021 Aug:206:104441. doi: 10.1016/j ...
[61]
NASA's Asteroid Bennu Sample Reveals Mix of Life's Ingredients
Jan 29, 2025 · “Data from OSIRIS-REx adds major brushstrokes to a picture of a solar system teeming with the potential for life. Why we, so far, only see life ...Missing: biosignatures | Show results with:biosignatures
[62]
Ryugu asteroid sample return provides a natural laboratory for ... - NIH
May 30, 2023 · The samples returned from near-Earth asteroid (162173) Ryugu provide a pristine record of the 4.6 billion years since the birth of the Solar System.Missing: exogenesis | Show results with:exogenesis
[63]
Samples of Asteroid Ryugu Contain More Than 20 Amino Acids
Jun 20, 2022 · The samples obtained by Hayabusa2 have revealed that the Near Earth Asteroid Ryugu contains 20 strains of amino acids - the buildings blocks ...Missing: biosignatures exogenesis
[64]
Can Life Exist on an Icy Moon? NASA's Europa Clipper Aims to Find ...
Oct 12, 2024 · The mission will try to answer the question of whether there are ingredients suitable for life in the ocean below Europa's icy crust.
[65]
NASA's Dragonfly Mission Sets Sights on Titan's Mysteries
May 22, 2025 · The car-sized rotorcraft will be equipped to characterize the habitability of Titan's environment, investigate the progression of prebiotic ...
[66]
Prospects for Detecting Signs of Life on Exoplanets in the JWST Era
Apr 17, 2025 · The search for signs of life in the Universe has entered a new phase with the advent of the James Webb Space Telescope (JWST).Missing: 2022 onward
[67]
NASA Scientists Study Life Origins By Simulating a Cosmic Evolution
Jan 10, 2023 · If amino acids formed in our solar system, then life could be unique here. But if they came from an interstellar cloud, these precursors to life ...
[68]
Alexey Turchin, Presumptuous Philosopher Proves Panspermia
Anthropic considerations suggest that the universes in the multiverse with interstellar panspermia will have orders of magnitude more civilizations than ...
[69]
[PDF] Panspermia - Dr. Michael Heiser
1 Related terms include “exogenesis” which, like panspermia, describes the hypothesis that life on earth originated (“genesis”) outside (“exo”) earth in ...<|control11|><|separator|>
[70]
What is the theory of directed panspermia? | GotQuestions.org
Jan 4, 2022 · “Exogenesis” is a term referring to the general hypothesis that earth life originated somewhere other than Earth, such as another planet.Missing: review | Show results with:review
[71]
Estimating the ethical value of directed panspermia - ScienceDirect
Biocentric ethical theories support attempting directed panspermia to increase life's cosmic abundance and to protect it from possible extinction risks on Earth ...Missing: implications | Show results with:implications
[72]
The Ethics of Directed Panspermia - Centauri Dreams
Dec 16, 2022 · Whatever our ethical concerns may be, directed panspermia is technologically feasible for a civilization advanced enough to manipulate comets, ...Missing: implications | Show results with:implications<|control11|><|separator|>
[73]
[PDF] COSPAR Policy on Planetary Protection
Planetary protection requirements for initial human missions should be based on a conservative approach consistent with a lack of knowledge of martian.
[74]
10) HG Wells and the New World Order - Philosophy for Life
Jan 27, 2022 · For example, HG Wells wrote a sci-fi book called Starbegotten, in which Martians send cosmic rays to Earth to influence our evolution and create ...
[75]
When Will the Debate About the Origin of Life End? - ResearchGate
Sep 20, 2025 · PDF | The origin of life remains one of the most complex and persistent questions in science, philosophy and theology.Missing: ancestry | Show results with:ancestry