Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Good Morning Good Morning

"" is a written primarily by (credited to the songwriting partnership) and recorded by the English rock band for their eighth studio album, Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band, released in 1967. The track, which runs for approximately 2:41, features Lennon's lead vocals and reflects themes of suburban boredom and daily routine, inspired by a television commercial that Lennon heard while watching TV at home. The song's recording took place at EMI Studios (now ) in , beginning with the basic rhythm track on 8 1967, followed by overdubs on 16 and further sessions in March, including brass arrangements by session musicians from Sounds Inc. and a sequence of animal sound effects sourced from the EMI tape library, ordered by increasing size to create a seamless transition to the album's of the . Produced by and engineered by , the production incorporated complex elements such as multiple time signatures and a played by on a . Despite its experimental sound and integration into one of the most acclaimed albums in rock history, "Good Morning Good Morning" has been noted for its energetic brass section and chaotic energy, though Lennon later dismissed it as filler material amid his personal dissatisfaction during the Sgt. Pepper sessions. The song's position on the album, immediately preceding the , underscores its role in the conceptual flow of Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band, which revolutionized with its innovative studio techniques and thematic cohesion.

Background and composition

Inspiration

The primary inspiration for "Good Morning Good Morning" came to from a for that he encountered in early 1967. While lounging at his home in , , Lennon was experiencing a period of creative stagnation and often left the on in the background as a passive distraction. The ad's cheerful , which repeated the phrase "Good morning, good morning," struck him amid this ennui, prompting the song's repetitive chorus as a satirical take on forced . The exact from the featured the lines "Good morning, good morning / The best to you each morning / Sunshine , Kellogg’s Corn Flakes / Crisp and full of sun," which Lennon adapted into the song's opening . This mundane source material mirrored his growing frustration with daily life, transforming a banal advertisement into a vehicle for expressing disconnection. This highlighted how such trivial intrusions fueled his lyrical spark during a bout of . In early 1967, following ' decision to stop touring, Lennon found himself isolated in suburban domesticity, feeling increasingly trapped in routine and unfulfilled in his marriage to . This sense of infused the song's with themes of and , evident in lines like "Nothing to do" and the desire to "get out of here." The track's mundane tone captured his psychological state, portraying a day structured around trivialities like meals and idle time, as a critique of the stifling normalcy he endured. Another layer of influence stemmed from the TV Meet the Wife, a popular program featuring a recurring morning greeting that echoed the commercial's cheerfulness. The lyric "Time for and meet the wife" directly nods to this show, which Lennon consumed during his idle afternoons, reinforcing the song's depiction of repetitive, unexciting domestic obligations. This reference underscored the pervasive role of in shaping his at the time, blending real-life tedium with broadcast banalities to evoke a broader sense of suburban .

Writing process

"Good Morning Good Morning" is credited to the Lennon–McCartney songwriting partnership, as was standard for Beatles compositions, but the song was primarily written by John Lennon with minimal input from Paul McCartney. Lennon composed it in late 1966 or early 1967 at his home in Kenwood, Weybridge, England, during a period of domestic boredom that influenced its theme. McCartney later described it as "largely John's song," confirming Lennon's dominant role in its creation. Lennon crafted the by expanding on a brief he heard, transforming it into a satirical commentary on the monotony of suburban life and feelings of . Key lines such as "Everybody knows there's nothing to do / Everybody goes and nobody grows" capture this sense of stagnation and routine drudgery, drawing from Lennon's own experiences of and at home. He developed a straightforward verse-chorus structure around these words, pairing them with a simple, repetitive melody that evokes an artificial cheerfulness. In initial stages, Lennon experimented with the song through home recordings, including an acoustic demo captured at Kenwood where he tested the upbeat tempo against the lyrics' downbeat sentiment. This early version featured raw vocals and basic chords, allowing Lennon to refine the contrast between the melody's energy and the theme's cynicism before bringing it to the band.

Recording and production

Studio sessions

The recording of "Good Morning Good Morning" commenced on 8 February at EMI Studios (now ) in , where the Beatles laid down the basic rhythm track using four-track tape technology. In Studio Two, under the production oversight of and engineering by , the group completed eight takes during a session running from 7 p.m. to 2:15 a.m. the following day. Take 8 was deemed the strongest and selected as the foundation for subsequent work. On 16 February 1967 in Studio Three, Lennon overdubbed his lead vocal and added bass guitar, refining the foundational band performance. Additional overdubs and arrangements followed on 13 March, 28 March, and 29 March 1967, all in Studio Two. Throughout these early sessions, guided key production choices, including establishing the song's variable tempo averaging approximately 122 beats per minute to match Lennon's rhythmic phrasing and deciding its position in the Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band track listing immediately preceding the for structural cohesion.

Overdubs and arrangement

Following the basic rhythm track laid down in February 1967, overdubs for "Good Morning Good Morning" commenced on 13 March 1967 in Studio Two, where arranged a brass section performed by the British group Sounds Incorporated to impart a raucous, orchestral energy to the song. The ensemble consisted of three saxophonists—Barrie Cameron, David Glyde, and Alan Holmes—along with two trombonists, John Lee and an unidentified player, and player Tom Richards, who collectively recorded their parts over a six-hour session starting at 7 p.m., with heavy and limiting applied to achieve a distorted, chaotic texture at John Lennon's request. On 28 March 1967, contributed the song's guitar solo in Studio Two, performing on his 1959 guitar amplified through a , with the recording double-tracked and varispeeded to raise its pitch for a brighter, more frenetic tone that complemented the track's urgent rhythm. Later that evening, McCartney and Lennon added backing vocals, and the sequence of animal sound effects was assembled from 's archival sound library tapes (Volumes 35 and 57), arranged in a conceptual "" progression by size to create a seamless transition to the . The following day, 29 March 1967, the animal sound effects—beginning with a rooster's crow followed by chirping birds, a cat's meow, barking dogs, an elephant's , a horse's neigh, foxhounds in pursuit, a seal's , and culminating in a lion's roar, with the final horse whinny edited to seamlessly transition into the opening of the subsequent , "Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band (Reprise)"—were overdubbed after 7 p.m. in Studio Two. These elements were later remixed for the Love, where the animal sounds were reincorporated into "Being for the Benefit of Mr. Kite!" for a more integrated effect. With the overdubs complete, the final mono and mixes were produced on 6 1967, the stereo version extending the fade-out of the animal sounds for greater duration (2:41 versus 2:35 in mono) and emphasizing spatial panning to enhance the arrangement's immersive, three-dimensional quality.

Musical structure and analysis

Rhythm and time signatures

"Good Morning Good Morning" is performed at a of 122 beats per minute, establishing a brisk pace that propels the track forward. The song employs mixed time signatures to create rhythmic complexity, with the intro, bridges, , and outro adhering to a standard 4/4 meter, while the verses incorporate shifts between 4/4, , and 3/4, resulting in uneven phrase lengths such as 10, 12, 9, and 14 beats. These irregular measures in the verses contribute to an off-kilter feel, mirroring the song's theme of disorientation amid mundane routine. The overall structure follows an AABAABA form across seven main parts, where A represents the sections (including the over a verse-like pattern), B denotes the bridges, and the climactic serves as a variant C section building tension toward the finale. Ringo Starr's drumming adapts fluidly to these irregular bars, featuring unique patterns in the s—such as intensified snare and hits—that contrast with the more conventional rhythm in the bridges, maintaining momentum through the metric shifts. This rhythmic framework infuses the song with an energetic yet chaotic drive, heightening the urgency of Lennon's static, repetitive about daily drudgery and amplifying the track's sense of restless awakening. The overdubs briefly accentuate these pulses, adding layered without altering the core metric foundation.

Instrumentation and solos

The core instrumentation of "Good Morning Good Morning" features John Lennon's rhythm guitar work on his 1965 ES-230TD, providing a gritty, driving foundation that cuts through the mix with its semi-hollow tone. Lennon's double-tracked lead vocals add density and urgency, layered to emphasize the 's frantic energy while harmonizing with Paul McCartney's backing vocals. McCartney contributes the bass line on his 1964 4001S, delivering punchy, rhythmic pulses that lock in with the irregular meter, and he performs the solo on a 1964 , a raucous, distorted outburst that injects raw aggression midway through the track. Ringo Starr's drumming on his 1964 Ludwig Super Classic Black Oyster Pearl kit anchors the track with emphatic fills, particularly rapid 16th-note patterns that heighten the sense of propulsion and chaos, occasionally syncing across shifts for dramatic effect. The brass ensemble, provided by —including three saxophones, two trombones, and a —overdubs create a dense, layered texture during the choruses, evoking a with blaring, punchy stabs that build a wall of sound and contrast the song's sparse verses. Animal sound effects from the tape library, such as rooster crows, bird chirps, barks, whinnies, roars, and clucks, are integrated as percussive and atmospheric elements, particularly in the , where they layer rhythmically to escalate tension and provide a surreal, non-melodic without relying on traditional harmonic resolution. These effects function biomusically to mimic natural soundscapes, enhancing the song's thematic disorientation through sequential "" arrangements where each animal sound suggests pursuit or predation.

Release and reception

Album placement

"Good Morning Good Morning" was released on 26 May 1967 as part of The Beatles' album Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band, appearing as the fourth track on side two, following "Lovely Rita" and preceding "Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band (Reprise)". The song's placement contributed to the album's conceptual flow, with engineer Geoff Emerick arranging the sequence of animal sound effects at its conclusion—a rooster, birds, cat, dog, horse, sheep, elephant, baying dogs, and final chicken cluck—under the direction of John Lennon and producer George Martin, to create a seamless transition into the guitar opening of the reprise, evoking a sense of circular return to the album's introductory theme. The track was never issued as a single but has been featured on numerous Sgt. Pepper reissues and compilations, including the 1987 compact disc edition of the album and the expanded 2017 50th anniversary editions, as well as an alternate take on the 1996 compilation Anthology 2.

Critical and fan reception

Upon its release as part of Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band in 1967, "Good Morning Good Morning" benefited from the album's overwhelming critical acclaim, which hailed the record as a groundbreaking artistic achievement in rock music. Contemporary reviewers praised the album's innovative use of satire and sound effects, with the track's frenetic energy and brass-driven arrangement contributing to the overall perception of conceptual boldness, though specific mentions of the song were sparse amid the focus on the work as a whole. However, some early assessments noted it as a comparatively lighter or less substantial entry compared to more ambitious cuts like "A Day in the Life," viewing its clipped, advertising-inspired lyrics as a playful but superficial interlude. John Lennon later expressed strong dissatisfaction with the song in a 1980 interview, describing it as "'Good Morning' is mine... It's a throwaway, a piece of garbage, I always thought," attributing its rushed and superficial quality to his personal struggles with boredom, substance use, and domestic life during the recording period. This self-critique underscored his view of the track as emblematic of uninspired output amid the pressures of Sgt. Pepper's production. Fan reception has remained mixed over the decades, with the song often ranked in the mid-to-lower tiers of ' catalog in polls and retrospectives, reflecting divided opinions on its chaotic vigor versus perceived excesses. Admirers highlight its underrated rhythmic drive and the blistering guitar solo by as bursts of raw energy that capture the era's psychedelic experimentation, while detractors frequently criticize the over-the-top brass section and animal sound effects as gimmicky and intrusive. In aggregate rankings, it typically places around the bottom third of their 200+ songs, positioning it as a solid but unremarkable mid-tier entry in fan-voted lists.

Cover versions and legacy

Notable covers

One notable cover of "Good Morning Good Morning" was recorded in 1978 by , the , and for the soundtrack of the film Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band. Produced by , this incorporates lush orchestral arrangements and the ' signature vocal harmonies, adapting the original's brass-heavy sound for a cinematic rock context. In 1988, Australian band delivered a cover on the NME tribute compilation Sgt. Pepper Knew My Father, infusing the track with a darker, edge that highlights the song's underlying cynicism in Lennon's lyrics. Other significant interpretations include Micky Dolenz's 2016 rendition, a Monkees-inspired pop take featured on his collaborative EP with and Circe Link, which emphasizes a light, groovy accessibility drawn from Dolenz's personal connection to the Beatles' sessions. contributed a grungy rock version in 2010 for the Minnesota Beatle Project Vol. 2, reworking the rhythm's challenges into a raw, alternative sound while retaining some animal effects for texture. Additionally, Dutch tribute band performed a faithful live orchestral recreation in 2017 during their Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band tour, using vintage instruments to replicate the original's brass and percussion layers onstage. These covers, among approximately 23 documented versions per the database, often vary in treatment—some preserve the iconic rooster crows and animal sounds, while others modernize the brass sections to fit genres like pop or .

Cultural impact and legacy

"Good Morning Good Morning" exemplifies the experimental sound collages integral to Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band, blending barnyard noises, brass blasts, and rhythmic shifts to create a chaotic portrait of urban routine that underscores the album's status as a milestone. The track's innovative production, overseen by , pushed boundaries in studio techniques, influencing subsequent rock experimentation by integrating everyday banalities with surreal elements to evoke the era's artistic ambition. The song's distinctive sound effects have extended its reach into multimedia productions, notably in the 2006 spectacle , where horse neighs from the track were remixed into a broader collage alongside laughter and other audio snippets to enhance the show's immersive theatricality. This adaptation highlights the song's versatility in live performance contexts, bridging the ' recorded legacy with contemporary visual storytelling. Symbolizing the ennui and escapism of 1960s counterculture, "Good Morning Good Morning" captures John Lennon's frustration with suburban monotony, offering an ironic commentary on daily drudgery that resonated with a generation seeking liberation from conformity. Its influence persists in , where it has been sampled for rhythmic and sonic texture, as in Ramirez's 1993 track "El Gallinero," demonstrating cross-genre appeal. Retrospective analyses, such as those in Rolling Stone's 2017 Sgt. Pepper anniversary coverage, praise the song's vital energy amid its thematic lethargy, affirming its enduring role in ' discography. The track's production innovations were revitalized in the 2017 stereo remixes for the album's 50th anniversary edition, which isolated and clarified the overdubbed elements like animal sounds and horn sections, allowing modern listeners to appreciate the song's layered complexity anew. This reissue underscores how "Good Morning Good Morning" continues to exemplify the .

Personnel

The Beatles members

He provided lead vocals, characterized by a raw and urgent delivery, along with backing vocals on the harmonious "good morning" refrains. Lennon also played on the track, using his 1965 ES-230TD for the basic rhythm track recorded on February 8, 1967. Paul contributed bass guitar using his 1964 4001S, laying down the foundational rhythm track alongside the other . He performed the lead guitar solo on a 1964 , adding a distinctive, biting tone during the instrumental break overdubbed later in the sessions. also supplied backing vocals. George Harrison played , providing support and fills on his during the core tracking sessions. He added backing vocals to enhance the layered harmonies in the . Ringo Starr handled the on his Ludwig Super Classic Black Oyster Pearl kit (commonly referred to as the Hollywood Maple), delivering the song's frenetic, syncopated rhythm with notable 16th-note bass drum fills that drive its energetic pulse. He also overdubbed congas during later sessions to augment the percussion texture.

Additional musicians

The brass section on "Good Morning Good Morning" was contributed by session musicians from , who recorded overdubs on 13 March 1967 at . The parts were played by Barrie Cameron, David Glyde, and Alan Holmes, while the trombones were handled by John Lee and an uncredited player; the was performed by Tom (surname unknown). , as and arranger, directed the to achieve the song's energetic and chaotic horn arrangements. Beyond these instrumental contributions, no other vocalists or live performers participated in the track's recording. The concluding animal sound effects were assembled from pre-recorded tapes in EMI's sound effects library, arranged by recording engineer on 29 March 1967 in a sequence of increasing animal size (rooster crowing, cat meowing, dogs barking, horses neighing, sheep bleating, lions roaring, elephants trumpeting, fox with dogs and hunters' horns, cow mooing, hen clucking) to create a seamless transition to the album's .

References

  1. [1]
    Good Morning Good Morning - The Beatles
    "Good Morning Good Morning" is a song written by John Lennon (credited to Lennon-McCartney) and recorded by the Beatles, featured on their 1967 album Sgt.
  2. [2]
    Good Morning Good Morning - The Beatles' songs - The Beatles Bible
    Jun 22, 2023 · 'Good Morning Good Morning' was inspired by a Kellogg's commercial he heard while working with the television playing in the background.
  3. [3]
    Beatles' 'Sgt. Pepper': Inside 'Good Morning Good Morning'
    May 30, 2017 · Read how the Beatles' "Good Morning Good Morning" grew out of John Lennon's domestic boredom and a Corn Flakes ad he heard on the "telly."
  4. [4]
    Song Facts: The Beatles — "Good Morning Good Morning"
    Jul 2, 2013 · One of the hardest-rocking songs on Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band, "Good Morning Good Morning" is also one of the album's most complex productions.<|control11|><|separator|>
  5. [5]
    John Lennon Discovers the Monotony of Suburbia in 'Good Morning ...
    May 28, 2017 · "It was about his boring life at the time. There's a reference in the lyrics to 'nothing to do' – and 'meet the wife.' There was an afternoon TV ...
  6. [6]
    The Beatles song inspired by a Corn Flakes advertisement
    Mar 6, 2025 · “It was a Corn Flakes advertisement,” Lennon shared, revealing the inspiration for the band's lyrics and composition.
  7. [7]
    Good Morning Good Morning (song) - The Paul McCartney Project
    Jan 21, 2024 · Inspiration for the song came to Lennon from a television commercial for Kellogg's Corn Flakes. Another reference to contemporary television ...<|control11|><|separator|>
  8. [8]
    John Lennon: The Last Interview - Rolling Stone
    Dec 23, 2010 · I only had about a week to write songs for Pepper. “Good Morning Good Morning” was a Kellogg's Corn Flakes ad at the time – that's how desperate ...
  9. [9]
    8 February 1967: Recording: Good Morning ... - The Beatles Bible
    Recording: Good Morning Good Morning. Wednesday 8 February 1967 | Sgt Pepper, Studio. Studio Two, EMI Studios, Abbey Road Producer: George Martin Engineer ...
  10. [10]
    16 February 1967: Recording, mixing: Good Morning Good Morning
    Recording, mixing: Good Morning Good Morning. Thursday 16 February 1967 | Sgt Pepper, Studio. Studio Three, EMI Studios, Abbey Road Producer: George Martin
  11. [11]
    13 March 1967: Recording: Good Morning Good ... - The Beatles Bible
    The Beatles had left 'Good Morning Good Morning' for almost a month before picking it up again during this session. They had begun the song on 8 February 1967.
  12. [12]
    Good Morning Good Morning, Being For The Benefit Of Mr Kite ...
    John Lennon recorded a second lead vocal for Good Morning Good Morning, following a first attempt on 16 February 1967. The Beatles also began assembling a tape
  13. [13]
    29 March 1967: The Beatles begin recording With A Little Help From ...
    Recording: Good Morning Good Morning, Being For The Benefit Of Mr Kite!, With A Little Help From My Friends. Wednesday 29 March 1967 | Sgt Pepper, Studio.
  14. [14]
    Recording "Good Morning Good Morning" (session)
    Aug 14, 2024 · On February 8, 1967, The Beatles recorded the rhythm track of John Lennon's song “Good Morning Good Morning” and added overdubs on February 16.Missing: background | Show results with:background
  15. [15]
    The Beatles' 20 greatest guitar moments, ranked
    Sep 21, 2021 · McCartney's lead part was likely performed on either an Epiphone Casino or a Fender Esquire ... Good Morning, Good Morning) with that combo, ...
  16. [16]
    Mixing "Good Morning Good Morning" (session)
    Aug 20, 2024 · On this day, from 7 pm to 1 am, John Lennon's song “Good Morning Good Morning” was mixed in mono and stereo. Also, the engineering team started ...
  17. [17]
    None
    Summary of each segment:
  18. [18]
    Alan W. Pollack's Notes on "Good Morning, Good Morning"
    Notes on "Good Morning, Good Morning" General Points of Interest Style and Form Melody and Harmony Arrangement Section-by-Section WalkthroughMissing: signatures | Show results with:signatures
  19. [19]
    "Good Morning Good Morning" by The Beatles. The in-depth story ...
    Eight days later on February 16th, 1967, The Beatles reconvened back in EMI Studios to continue sessions for John's “Good Morning Good Morning.” They moved over ...
  20. [20]
    Every guitar George Harrison used in The Beatles - Far Out Magazine
    Mar 31, 2022 · ... Good Morning Good Morning'. But as the band's lead guitarist, George ... 1957 'Lucy' Gibson Les Paul Standard. One of Harrison's most ...
  21. [21]
    (PDF) Biomusic and Popular Culture: The Use of Animal Sounds in ...
    Aug 10, 2025 · ... Good Morning Good Morning” and the reprise of “Sgt. Pepper's Lonely ... train sounding its horn, and two barking dogs. 6. The Beatles ...
  22. [22]
    Sgt Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band (album) - The Beatles Bible
    I am certain it was issued on 26th May 1967. The Beatle Monthly magazine issued on 1st June 1967 indicates that the release had already happened and the album ...
  23. [23]
    'Sgt. Pepper': Inside the making of the Beatles' masterpiece
    Jun 27, 2017 · There were also animal sound ... Good Morning” led nicely into the opening guitar line on the “Sgt. Pepper” reprise, which then segues into “A Day ...
  24. [24]
    Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band | The Beatles
    - **Track Listing Position of "Good Morning Good Morning":**
  25. [25]
    The Beatles: every song ranked in order of greatness - NME
    Nov 2, 2023 · ... level track easily stands up as The Beatles' best children's song. ... 'Good Morning Good Morning' ('Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band ...
  26. [26]
    All 214 Beatles Songs, Ranked From Worst to Best - Vulture
    Nov 2, 2023 · “Good Morning, Good Morning,” Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band (1967). A raucous song that tries to come up with a little social comment.
  27. [27]
    Original versions of Good Morning, Good Morning by Peter ...
    Good Morning, Good Morning by Peter Frampton, The Bee Gees & Paul Nicholas was written by John Lennon and Paul McCartney and was first released by The ...
  28. [28]
    Covers of Good Morning Good Morning by The Beatles - WhoSampled
    Covered in 23 songs ; Rangzen's Good Morning Good Morning · Good Morning Good Morning · Rangzen, 2007, Rock / Pop ; Soul Asylum's Good Morning Good Morning · Good ...
  29. [29]
    Review: The Beatles' 'Sgt. Pepper's' Anniversary Editions
    May 26, 2017 · You especially feel the band as a tight unit in “Getting Better,” “Good Morning Good Morning” and the blazing “Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club ...
  30. [30]
    Exclusive Track List: Preview the Beatles' Vegas Show - Rolling Stone
    Jun 1, 2006 · An insider's peek, track-by-track, in advance of the historic Cirque du Soleil show. ... Also ”Good Morning Good Morning” sound effects, laughter ...
  31. [31]
    Songs that Sampled Good Morning Good Morning by The Beatles
    Songs that Sampled Good Morning Good Morning. by The Beatles. Sampled in 4 songs. Sort: Most Popular ...
  32. [32]
    50 Years Later, Producer Remixes 'Sgt. Pepper' To 'Bring It Into The ...
    Jul 4, 2017 · ... Love," the audio restoration of Beatles concerts ... Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band." (SOUNDBITE OF SONG, "GOOD MORNING GOOD MORNING").<|control11|><|separator|>
  33. [33]
    The Guitars the Beatles used per song | Fab Forum
    May 24, 2016 · Good Morning, Good Morning. John: Rhythm Guitar (1965 Epiphone ES-230TD Casino through Vox Defiant). Paul: Lead Guitar (1964 Fender Esquire ...
  34. [34]
    Artist All Songs • The Paul McCartney Project
    Congas, Drums. Good Morning Good Morning. From album "Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band (UK Stereo)". 2:41 • Studio version • B • Stereo. Contribution: ...
  35. [35]
    Recording "Good Morning Good Morning", "Being For The Benefit of ...
    Jan 21, 2024 · Session Mar 28, 1967 • Recording "Good Morning Good Morning" and "Being For The Benefit of Mr. Kite!" Session Mar 29, 1967 • Recording "Good ...