Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Igneous differentiation

Igneous differentiation refers to the geochemical and mineralogical evolution of a parent magma, resulting in the formation of compositionally diverse igneous rocks from a single source through physical and chemical processes that separate melt from crystals or incorporate external materials.^[1] This process is fundamental to understanding the diversity of igneous rock suites observed in volcanic and plutonic settings worldwide.^[2] The primary mechanism of igneous differentiation is fractional crystallization, where minerals crystallize sequentially from cooling magma according to their melting points, as outlined in Bowen's reaction series, with early-formed mafic minerals like olivine and pyroxene separating from the residual melt to enrich it in silica and incompatible elements.^[2] This separation can occur via gravity settling, where denser crystals sink to the chamber floor, or through other methods like filter pressing and convective currents, leading to layered intrusions such as those in the Bushveld Complex.^[3] For instance, the removal of plagioclase and mafic phases from a basaltic magma can produce andesitic or rhyolitic compositions over time.^[1] Other key processes include assimilation, where magma incorporates and partially melts surrounding crustal rocks, altering its trace element and isotopic signatures—evidenced by xenoliths and shifts in ratios like ⁸⁷Sr/⁸⁶Sr from 0.702 in mantle-derived magmas to 0.720 in contaminated ones.^[1] Magma mixing occurs when compositionally distinct magmas converge, often in subduction zones or hotspots, yielding hybrid rocks with disequilibrium textures such as reverse-zoned phenocrysts.^[2] These mechanisms are identified through variation diagrams plotting major oxides (e.g., SiO₂ vs. MgO), which reveal smooth evolutionary trends, and trace element patterns showing enrichment in incompatibles like Zr and Nb.^[1] Igneous differentiation plays a crucial role in crustal evolution, influencing everything from volcanic hazard assessment to the formation of ore deposits associated with evolved magmas.^[2]

Definitions and Key Terms

Primary Melts

Primary melts are basaltic compositions generated directly by partial melting of the mantle or lower crust, representing liquids that remain in equilibrium with their peridotitic source without significant prior modification by processes such as fractionation or assimilation.^[4] These melts are considered the starting point for igneous differentiation sequences, capturing the chemical signature of the mantle source at the conditions of generation. Key characteristics of primary melts include near-primitive compositions, typically featuring high MgO contents (often 12-18 wt%), elevated Ni (>300 ppm), and Cr (>1000 ppm), which reflect minimal loss of compatible elements during ascent. Experimental petrology demonstrates that these compositions achieve equilibrium with mantle-derived olivines, as evidenced by phase relations in high-pressure experiments on peridotite compositions. Such melts are distinguished from evolved ones by the forsterite content (Fo) of their olivines, where primitive assemblages show Fo >89 mol%, indicating negligible olivine fractionation.^[5] Formation of primary melts occurs primarily through decompression melting beneath mid-ocean ridges, where upwelling mantle crosses the solidus due to reduced pressure, producing tholeiitic basalts like mid-ocean ridge basalts (MORB).^[6] In subduction zones, flux melting dominates, as hydrous fluids from the dehydrating slab lower the mantle wedge solidus, generating primary basaltic melts enriched in incompatible elements. These processes yield melts that serve as parental magmas for subsequent differentiation, though primary melts themselves experience minimal alteration en route to the surface.

Parental Melts

Parental melts represent the initial magma compositions from which a specific suite of igneous rocks evolves through differentiation processes, typically exhibiting only minor modifications from primary melts, such as limited olivine fractionation that slightly increases silica content without substantially altering the overall chemical signature.^[1] These melts serve as the starting point for rock series formation, where their bulk composition dictates the trajectory of subsequent crystallization and the resulting diversity in mineralogy and geochemistry.^[7] Identification of parental melts relies on compositional criteria that allow forward modeling of fractional crystallization to reproduce the observed range of rock types within a suite, such as the tholeiitic series characterized by iron enrichment trends or the calc-alkaline series marked by early iron depletion.^[8] Whole-rock major element modeling, often using software like Petrolog, reconstructs these starting compositions by reversing crystallization paths from erupted or plutonic samples, ensuring the modeled parent aligns with trace element patterns and phase equilibria.^[7] For instance, in tholeiitic suites, parental melts are typically basaltic with moderate silica (around 50 wt% SiO₂), while calc-alkaline parents may start as basaltic andesites with higher initial water content influencing mineral stability.^[8] Representative examples include Archean komatiites, which act as parental melts for ultramafic suites in greenstone belts, derived from high-degree partial melting of hot mantle and exhibiting high MgO contents (up to 30 wt%) that evolve into associated basalts via olivine-dominated fractionation.^[9] In modern arc settings, andesitic compositions often serve as parental melts for calc-alkaline series, as evidenced in the Altiplano-Puna volcanic complex, where hydrous basaltic andesites (52-56 wt% SiO₂) undergo differentiation to produce dacites and rhyolites, reflecting subduction-related fluxing.^[10] Cumulate rocks, such as olivine-rich layers, may form as residues during this initial crystallization from parental melts.^[11] The concept of parental melts gained foundational prominence through Norman L. Bowen's reaction series, outlined in his 1928 work, which framed differentiation as a sequential crystallization process from a basaltic parent, linking mafic to felsic rock evolution and emphasizing crystal-liquid separation as the key mechanism.^[12] This framework highlighted how slight initial variations in parental melt composition, such as oxidation state or volatile content, steer divergent paths in series like tholeiitic versus calc-alkaline, influencing global igneous diversity.^[13]

Cumulate Rocks

Cumulate rocks are igneous rocks formed by the accumulation of crystals that settle or float within a cooling magma, with the remaining interstices filled by late-stage liquid or subsequent crystallization products. This process results in a texture dominated by cumulus grains—early-formed crystals that make up the bulk of the rock—distinguishing them from non-cumulate igneous rocks where crystals are suspended in a fully crystallized matrix. The term "cumulate" was introduced to describe such rocks, emphasizing their origin from crystal precipitation and accumulation rather than direct solidification of the melt. Cumulate rocks are classified based on the proportion of cumulus crystals versus trapped liquid or intercumulus material. Adcumulates contain over 95% cumulus crystals with minimal trapped liquid, exhibiting highly equilibrated textures due to extensive in situ crystallization. Mesocumulates have 85–95% cumulus crystals, showing moderate post-accumulation growth, while orthocumulates possess less than 85% cumulus crystals and retain more original trapped liquid, often displaying coarser, less equilibrated textures. These rocks commonly feature modal layering, where mineral proportions vary rhythmically across layers, and cryptic variation, involving subtle but systematic changes in mineral compositions through the stratigraphy, such as decreasing magnesium content in pyroxenes upward.^[14] They typically form at the floors or roofs of magma chambers, where gravitational settling or buoyancy drives crystal accumulation, as seen in layered intrusions. For instance, ultramafic cumulates like dunites and pyroxenites in the Lower Zone of South Africa's Bushveld Complex represent early-stage accumulations of olivine and pyroxene from primitive magmas, often with trapped liquid fractions around 5–18%. These settings highlight cumulates as the solid residues of fractional crystallization, preserving a record of the differentiating magma.^[15] Compositional trends in cumulate rocks reflect enrichment in compatible elements within cumulus phases, contrasting with the evolving melt depleted in those elements. For example, early cumulates often contain plagioclase with higher anorthite (An) content (e.g., An >80), indicating crystallization from more primitive, mafic melts, while later layers show more sodic plagioclase. Such trends, including elevated levels of elements like Cr and Mg in ultramafic varieties, allow reconstruction of parental melt compositions by modeling the reverse fractionation process.

Core Mechanisms of Differentiation

Fractional Crystallization

Fractional crystallization is a fundamental closed-system process in igneous petrology whereby crystals nucleate and grow from a cooling magma, subsequently separating from the residual melt, which leads to progressive compositional changes in the liquid.^[16] This separation enriches the remaining melt in incompatible elements—those that are not readily incorporated into the crystal lattice—while depleting it in compatible elements that partition preferentially into the solids.^[17] The process assumes no exchange with external materials, focusing solely on internal redistribution driven by thermodynamic equilibria during cooling.^[18] The quantitative framework for trace element evolution during fractional crystallization is described by the Rayleigh fractionation law, derived from the principles of fractional distillation and adapted to magmatic systems:

\frac{C_L}{C_0} = F^{D-1}

where C_L is the concentration of an element in the residual liquid, C_0 is the initial concentration in the parental melt, F is the fraction of melt remaining (0 < F ≤ 1), and D is the bulk distribution coefficient (D = C_solid / C_liquid) for that element.^[17] For incompatible elements (D < 1), concentrations increase exponentially as F decreases, whereas compatible elements (D > 1) diminish in the melt.^[19] This equation underpins modeling of magmatic differentiation and has been validated through trace element patterns in natural suites.^[20] The process unfolds in distinct stages: nucleation, where supersaturation triggers initial crystal formation; growth, during which crystals expand via diffusion-limited attachment of ions from the surrounding melt; and separation, primarily through gravitational settling of denser crystals to form layered cumulates at the chamber base or filter pressing, where tectonic stresses expel interstitial melt.^[18] Crystal-melt equilibria are governed by Bowen's reaction series, which delineates two branches: the discontinuous series, involving sequential replacement of mafic minerals (olivine → pyroxene → amphibole → biotite) as temperature drops, and the continuous series, where plagioclase feldspar evolves from calcium-rich to sodium-rich compositions without phase change.^[16] These reactions ensure that early-formed crystals react partially with the evolving melt, but incomplete reaction in fractional settings amplifies differentiation.^[18] A classic example is the differentiation of basaltic magmas into rhyolitic compositions, as observed in layered intrusions like the Skaergaard complex, where ~90% crystallization of mafic minerals (olivine, pyroxene, plagioclase) yields silica-rich residual melts.^[21] Evidence for this process includes zoned phenocrysts, such as plagioclase displaying core-to-rim shifts from anorthite-rich (early, mafic conditions) to albite-rich (late, felsic conditions), recording the progressive enrichment of the melt in incompatible components like potassium and silica.^[22] Cumulate rocks, formed as byproducts of this separation, accumulate at the base of magma chambers and preserve the extracted crystal cargo.^[18]

Assimilation

Assimilation refers to the process by which magma incorporates and dissolves surrounding host rock (country rock), leading to changes in the magma's chemical and isotopic composition without the addition of new melt from depth. This open-system process contrasts with closed-system differentiation by introducing external material, often resulting in contamination that shifts the magma toward the composition of the assimilated rock. Two primary types are recognized: bulk assimilation, involving the complete or partial melting of wall rock xenoliths or fragments due to heat transfer from the magma, and reactive assimilation, characterized by diffusion-driven chemical exchange at the magma-country rock interface without wholesale melting. Bulk assimilation typically occurs when small crustal fragments are engulfed and melted, while reactive assimilation involves selective ion exchange, such as silica diffusion into the country rock in exchange for other components. A key quantitative framework for assimilation combined with fractional crystallization is the assimilation-fractional crystallization (AFC) model, which describes how trace element concentrations evolve under simultaneous wall rock addition and crystal removal. In DePaolo's model, the concentration of a trace element in the liquid relative to that in the initial magma (C_L / C_0) is given by:

\frac{C_L}{C_0} = F^{-z} + \frac{r}{r-1} \cdot \frac{C_A}{z C_0} (1 - F^{-z})

where C_0 is the initial concentration in the parental magma, C_A is the concentration in the assimilant, F is the fraction of liquid remaining, r is the ratio of the mass of assimilant added to the mass of crystals removed, z = \frac{r + D - 1}{r - 1}, and D is the bulk distribution coefficient for the element.^[23] This equation illustrates how assimilation can amplify or dampen trace element enrichment depending on r and D; for instance, when r > 1, more assimilant is added than crystallized, leading to greater contamination. The model often integrates with fractional crystallization to form hybrid AFC processes, where assimilation provides the heat for melting via latent heat release during crystallization.^[23] Driving factors for assimilation include thermal erosion at magma chamber margins, where convective heat transfer melts the adjacent wall rock, particularly if the country rock has a lower melting temperature than the magma. Solubility of the country rock in the magma plays a crucial role; for example, carbonates readily dissolve in hot mafic magmas, releasing CO₂ and CaO, which can produce calcic skarn minerals like wollastonite and diopside at the contact zone. This process is enhanced in hydrous systems where reactions promote further dissolution.^[24] Examples of assimilation are evident in granitic plutons intruding metasedimentary country rocks, where incorporation of aluminous sediments leads to peraluminous compositions characterized by excess aluminum (e.g., high ASI > 1.1) and minerals like muscovite or tourmaline. Isotopic evidence, such as shifts in ⁸⁷Sr/⁸⁶Sr ratios toward higher values matching the country rock, confirms contamination; for instance, initial ⁸⁷Sr/⁸⁶Sr values increasing from ~0.703 in mantle-derived magmas to >0.710 in crustal-influenced granites. These signatures are commonly traced in arc settings where thickened crust facilitates greater interaction.^[23]

Open-System Processes

Magma Replenishment

Magma replenishment refers to the periodic injection of fresh, primitive magma—typically hotter and more mafic—into an existing magma chamber that is partially crystallized or undergoing differentiation, leading to remelting of cumulates and hybridization of the resident melt.^[25] This open-system process disrupts the ongoing fractional crystallization by introducing thermal and compositional contrasts, often resulting in the erosion of floor cumulates and the rejuvenation of stalled magmatic systems.^[26] The influx of hot recharge magma induces vigorous convection and overturn within the chamber, eroding and remobilizing earlier-formed cumulates while resetting differentiation trajectories.^[27] Geochemical evidence for such events includes reversals or inflections in differentiation trends on Harker diagrams, such as abrupt spikes in FeO* content that deviate from expected fractional crystallization paths, indicating the input of less evolved material.^[28] These disruptions can prolong chamber activity and influence eruption styles by altering melt viscosity and volatile content. Magma replenishment commonly occurs in polybaric settings, such as crustal magma chambers in volcanic arcs or continental rifts, where tectonic extension facilitates repeated injections from deeper mantle sources.^[29] A well-documented example is the 1959 Kīlauea Iki eruption in Hawaii, where multiple pulses of primitive basalt replenished the shallow lava lake system over 36 days, causing observed convective overturn and partial remelting of early-formed olivine-rich cumulates.^[30] Such events highlight how replenishment sustains long-lived magmatic systems in rift environments. Quantitative assessments of replenishment involve heat balance calculations to estimate remelting rates of cumulates, considering the latent heat of fusion for typical gabbroic material at approximately 500 kJ/kg.^[31] Models show that the thermal energy from a single influx of hot ultramafic magma (e.g., 100–200°C hotter than the resident basalt) can remelt significant volumes of cumulates—up to 20–30% of the recharge volume—over timescales of days to weeks, depending on chamber size and influx rate.^[25] This process may lead to magma mixing upon contact with the resident melt.^[27]

Magma Mixing

Magma mixing refers to the physical and chemical blending of compositionally distinct magmas within a magmatic system, resulting in hybrid compositions that contribute to igneous diversity.^[32] This process is particularly common in convergent margin settings where mafic magmas from the mantle interact with more evolved, silicic magmas in crustal reservoirs. Mechanically, mixing initiates at the interface between end-members, driven by diffusion across thermal and compositional boundaries, followed by convective stirring that promotes homogenization.^[32] Efficient blending requires low viscosity contrasts (less than 0.3 log units) between the magmas, high shear rates exceeding 10⁻³ s⁻¹, and the presence of bubbles, which can reduce effective viscosity by up to four orders of magnitude.^[32] Contrasts between end-members, such as mafic basalts (low SiO₂, high MgO) and silicic rhyolites (high SiO₂, low MgO), generate density and temperature gradients that facilitate initial mingling before full mixing.^[33] Such interactions are often triggered by replenishment events where hotter mafic magmas intrude cooler reservoirs.^[32] Textural evidence of magma mixing manifests as mingling features preserved in the rock record, reflecting incomplete homogenization. Mafic enclaves—fine-grained, rounded inclusions of basaltic material within host andesites or dacites—form through quenching of intruding mafic magma against cooler silicic walls, with enclave sizes ranging from centimeters to decimeters.^[33] Sieve textures in plagioclase phenocrysts arise from partial resorption due to reheating by the mafic influx, creating a spongy appearance from dissolved material.^[33] Reverse zoning in minerals like clinopyroxene or hornblende, where rims are more mafic than cores, indicates rapid crystallization from hybrid melts following mixing.^[33] These textures are widespread in volcanic and plutonic rocks, highlighting the role of mechanical disequilibrium during the process. Chemically, magma mixing produces hybrid signatures that can be traced through element variations. Major elements typically plot along linear trends in binary diagrams (e.g., SiO₂ vs. MgO), reflecting simple volumetric blending between end-members, as seen in suites spanning 58–71 wt% SiO₂.^[34] Trace elements, however, often show curved trajectories due to differing partition coefficients between the magmas; incompatible elements like La may enrich nonlinearly, while compatible ones like Ni deplete in a bowed pattern influenced by crystal-melt interactions at the interface.^[35] Isotopic disequilibria provide further evidence, such as mismatched ⁸⁷Sr/⁸⁶Sr ratios between coexisting minerals in hybrid rocks, indicating incomplete exchange during rapid mixing. A prominent example of magma mixing is the production of andesites in volcanic arcs, where basaltic magmas (∼50 wt% SiO₂) mix with resident rhyolitic melts (∼70 wt% SiO₂) to yield intermediate compositions (55–65 wt% SiO₂).^[32] At Mount Pinatubo (Philippines, 1991 eruption), approximately 36% basaltic and 64% dacitic contributions formed homogeneous andesitic hybrids, evidenced by isotopic homogeneity and enclave textures.^[32] Similarly, in the Taupo Volcanic Zone (New Zealand), mixing between andesite-dacite hosts and mafic enclaves has generated diverse intermediate lavas, with isotopic variations confirming multi-stage blending. These cases underscore mixing's role in crustal growth and eruption triggering at arcs.

Partial Melt Extraction

Partial melt extraction refers to the mechanical or reactive segregation of melt from a partially molten source region, typically occurring in the mantle or lower crust during igneous processes. This mechanism involves the physical separation of low-density melt from the surrounding solid matrix, driven by buoyancy or applied stresses, and is distinct from later-stage differentiation within established magma chambers. Key processes facilitating partial melt extraction include porous flow, where interconnected melt networks allow migration through the deforming solid matrix at rates of approximately 30 meters per year; filter pressing, which compacts the matrix to squeeze out melt under differential stress; and deformation-induced extraction, such as shear-enhanced flow that channels melt along high-strain zones. These processes operate in either batch melting modes, where the entire melt fraction equilibrates with the residue before extraction, or fractional melting modes, where small melt increments are removed incrementally, leading to progressive source depletion.^[36] The implications of partial melt extraction for igneous differentiation are profound, as it generates variably depleted solid residues with reduced incompatible element contents and enriched melts that carry concentrated incompatible elements and heat-producing isotopes. For instance, in mantle diapirs associated with hotspot plumes, melt extraction produces basaltic magmas that form ocean island basalts (OIB), such as those in Hawaii, where upwelling depleted mantle undergoes progressive melting to yield compositions reflecting prior extraction events.^[37] Evidence for partial melt extraction is provided by Lu-Hf isotope systematics, which reveal decoupling between melt and residue due to the incompatible behavior of Hf relative to Lu during melting, resulting in elevated ¹⁷⁶Hf/¹⁷⁷Hf ratios in extracted melts compared to their sources. This isotopic signature in residual peridotites and OIB indicates multiple stages of depletion from ancient melt removal events.^[38]^[39]

Additional Differentiation Processes

Interface Entrapment

Interface entrapment involves the accumulation of late-stage, incompatible element-enriched melts or fluids at grain boundaries within crystallized cumulates, governed by interfacial surface tension and dihedral angles between solid phases and the melt. The dihedral angle (θ) represents the equilibrium angle formed at the junction of two solid-liquid interfaces, determined by the balance of grain boundary energy (γ_gb) and solid-melt interfacial energy (γ_sl) according to the relation cos(θ/2) = γ_gb / (2 γ_sl). When θ exceeds 60°, melt pockets form isolated pores at triple junctions; however, θ < 60° promotes wetting, where the melt spreads along grain boundaries, facilitating entrapment of residual liquids during solidification.^[40]^[41] Mechanisms of interface entrapment arise from wettability contrasts among mineral phases in the cumulate pile, where late-stage melts preferentially adhere to certain crystal interfaces due to lower interfacial energies. For instance, incompatible-rich melts, depleted in compatible elements like Mg and Fe but enriched in rare earth elements (REE) and volatiles, migrate through the porous crystal mush but become trapped where dihedral angles favor wetting, preventing full expulsion. This process contributes to the development of localized features such as pegmatitic veins, formed by crystallization of these trapped liquids, or apatite-rich pockets, as apatite—a late-crystallizing phosphate—concentrates in the evolved melt residues. Experimental studies confirm that in basaltic systems, θ values below 60° enable such wetting and interconnected melt networks at porosities as low as 1-5 vol.%, enhancing entrapment efficiency during cooling.^[40]^[42]^[43] In layered intrusions, interface entrapment can lead to localized enrichment of incompatible elements, including REE, in residual melts trapped at mineral boundaries, influencing the bulk geochemistry by retaining fractionated components.

Volatile Exsolution

Volatile exsolution is the process by which dissolved volatiles, primarily H₂O, CO₂, and sulfur species, separate from silicate magma to form a distinct gas phase, driven by decreasing pressure during ascent or by progressive crystallization under relatively constant pressure conditions.^[44] This degassing mechanism plays a key role in igneous differentiation by altering melt composition, rheology, and phase relationships as volatiles concentrate in the interstitial liquid.^[45] The primary processes include decompression-induced degassing, often termed first boiling, and crystallization-induced degassing, known as second boiling or isobaric degassing. In second boiling, as crystals form during cooling, incompatible volatiles become enriched in the residual melt until it reaches volatile saturation, prompting bubble nucleation and growth even without significant pressure change.^[44] Volatile solubility in melts generally obeys Henry's law, stating that the concentration of a dissolved gas is directly proportional to its partial pressure (or fugacity) in the equilibrating vapor phase, with partitioning coefficients varying by melt composition and temperature.^[46] Empirical models describe volatile solubility; for H₂O in natural silicate melts, solubility decreases with falling pressure or rising temperature, accelerating exsolution.^[47] These models highlight how such changes affect degassing behavior. Volatile exsolution promotes differentiation by enriching residual melts with volatiles, which lowers viscosity and enhances melt mobility relative to crystals. This facilitates processes like filter pressing, where expanding gas bubbles create overpressures that squeeze volatile-rich interstitial melt through the crystal framework, segregating it from cumulates and generating compositionally evolved liquids.^[48] A notable example occurs in plinian eruptions of rhyolitic magmas, such as those at large calderas, where rapid second boiling produces high vesicularity and overpressure, driving explosive ascent and widespread ash dispersal.^[49]

Magma Chamber Dynamics

Chamber Stratification

Chamber stratification in magma chambers manifests as vertical zonation in composition and density, resulting from the interplay of crystal settling and double-diffusive convection. Denser mafic cumulates, rich in olivine and pyroxene, accumulate at the chamber floor due to gravitational settling of early-formed crystals, while the overlying melt evolves toward more silica-rich, less dense compositions through progressive fractionation. This creates a stable, layered architecture where the lower zones host primitive, ultramafic to gabbroic assemblages, grading upward into felsic residual liquids. Double-diffusive convection further enhances this layering by exploiting differences in diffusivity between heat and chemical components, fostering localized mixing at interfaces without fully homogenizing the chamber.^[50] The dynamics of stratification formation involve gravitational instabilities that drive crystal suspension and settling, coupled with intermittent convection cells that redistribute material episodically. As magma cools from the walls and roof, crystals nucleate and sink, but convective overturns—triggered by density perturbations—can resuspend them, leading to periodic layering. A classic example is the Skaergaard Intrusion in Greenland, where rhythmic layering appears as modally graded sequences (typically 5-50 cm thick) with iron-titanium oxides concentrated at layer bases, overlain by plagioclase and pyroxenes, reflecting gravity sorting during convective episodes. Macrorhythmic layers (0.5-5 m thick) in the same intrusion arise from shifts in cumulus mineral assemblages, illustrating how intermittent convection interrupts settling to produce repetitive, density-controlled banding. These processes highlight the chamber's response to cooling-induced instabilities, maintaining dynamic yet stratified evolution.^[50]^[51]^[52] Layer stability hinges on density contrasts arising from magmatic differentiation, particularly Fe-enrichment trends that modulate buoyancy. In tholeiitic magmas, early fractionation of mafic silicates increases FeO content in the residual melt, elevating its density and reinforcing gravitational separation of crystals from the buoyant upper liquid. This trend peaks before Fe-Ti oxide saturation, after which iron content stabilizes or declines, allowing silica enrichment to further lighten the melt and sustain the density gradient. Such contrasts prevent wholesale convection, preserving stratification against disruptive forces, as evidenced in the Skaergaard liquid line of descent where FeO rises from ~10 wt% in early stages to over 15 wt% mid-sequence.^[53]^[54] Seismic imaging of contemporary magma systems offers direct evidence of chamber stratification. Under Yellowstone Caldera, deployments of over 600 seismometers in 2020 imaged a upper reservoir at ~5 km depth as horizontally elongated sills with up to 28% melt fraction, exhibiting seismic anisotropy consistent with compositional layering between viscous rhyolite and underlying basaltic components. This structure implies ongoing zonation akin to ancient intrusions, with density-driven segregation visible in wave propagation patterns that differentiate melt-rich from crystal-mush zones. Magma replenishment occasionally disrupts these layers, promoting localized mixing.^[55]^[56]^[57]

Dissolved Gases and Degassing

Dissolved gases, primarily water (H₂O) and carbon dioxide (CO₂), play a critical role in igneous differentiation by influencing the physical properties of magma. These volatiles dissolve in silicate melts under high pressure, reducing viscosity and density while promoting bubble nucleation upon exsolution. For instance, increased dissolved H₂O content can lower melt viscosity by orders of magnitude, facilitating convection and crystal settling within magma chambers.^[58] Similarly, CO₂ enhances magma buoyancy, aiding ascent and contributing to differentiation through volatile-driven segregation.^[59] In silicate melts, H₂O exists in two primary speciation forms: hydroxyl groups (OH⁻) and molecular H₂O, with their relative proportions depending on factors such as pressure, temperature, and melt composition. At higher pressures, molecular H₂O predominates, while lower pressures favor OH⁻ formation via the dissociation reaction H₂O + O (melt) ⇌ 2OH⁻. This speciation affects solubility limits and diffusion rates, influencing how volatiles partition during magma evolution. CO₂, in contrast, primarily speciates as CO₂ᵐ (dissolved molecular) and minor carbonate (CO₃²⁻) in more alkaline melts.^[60]^[61] The dynamics of dissolved gases in magma chambers involve accumulation and degassing processes that drive differentiation. Bubbles formed by volatile exsolution rise and accumulate at the chamber roof, potentially forming low-density pumice caps that enhance convection and promote recharge events. In crystal-rich mushes, gas accumulation can also drive filter pressing, where buoyant bubbles expel interstitial melt, concentrating incompatible elements in the residual liquid. Degassing occurs via closed-system paths, where volatiles exsolve internally without external loss, or open-system paths, involving permeable escape through fractures, which alters magma composition and eruption style.^[62]^[63] Monitoring SO₂ emissions provides insights into degassing dynamics, as seen at Mount Etna, where ground-based and satellite observations track volatile release from summit craters. During the 2020–2021 paroxysms, SO₂ fluxes reached up to approximately 20,000 tons per day, indicating open-system degassing and magma replenishment. Such emissions correlate with eruption transitions: rapid closed-system degassing leads to overpressurization and explosive eruptions, while gradual open-system loss favors effusive styles by reducing bubble volume and fragmentation potential.^[64]^[58] Quantitative assessment of volatile behavior relies on models like MagmaSat, which calculates saturation pressures for H₂O-CO₂ in diverse melt compositions using thermodynamic databases. For example, at 200 MPa, a rhyolitic melt with 4 wt% H₂O and 0.1 wt% CO₂ reaches saturation, predicting bubble onset depths crucial for differentiation modeling. This tool integrates oxide inputs to estimate phase equilibria, aiding interpretations of magma chamber processes without direct sampling.^[65]

Quantifying Differentiation

Geochemical Modeling

Geochemical modeling in igneous differentiation employs computational tools to simulate the evolution of magma compositions through processes such as crystallization and assimilation. Forward modeling predicts phase equilibria and compositional changes from initial conditions, using thermodynamic databases to calculate stable mineral assemblages and melt compositions under specified pressure, temperature, and oxygen fugacity. A prominent example is the MELTS software package, which facilitates simulations of equilibrium or fractional crystallization in mafic to intermediate systems up to 2 GPa. Inverse modeling, conversely, reconstructs differentiation histories by fitting observed geochemical trends to theoretical paths, often employing least-squares optimization to determine parameters like assimilation rates or crystallization extents.^[66] Central to these models are mass balance equations that conserve elements during phase changes. For fractional crystallization, the Rayleigh fractionation equation describes the concentration of a major element C_L in the evolving liquid as C_L = C_0 F^{D-1}, where C_0 is the initial concentration, F is the fraction of liquid remaining, and D is the bulk distribution coefficient.^[67] These equations are solved iteratively for major elements like SiO₂, MgO, and FeO to trace bulk compositional shifts. To address uncertainties in parameters such as assimilation-to-crystallization ratios in AFC processes, Monte Carlo simulations generate probabilistic distributions by randomly sampling input variables, enabling quantification of likely differentiation scenarios.^[68] Despite their utility, early models like MELTS faced limitations in handling diffusion kinetics, which control local disequilibria and reaction rates during rapid cooling or deformation, often requiring ad hoc adjustments for non-equilibrium conditions. Recent advances incorporate these kinetics through coupled diffusion-reaction frameworks, improving accuracy for dynamic magma chambers. In the 2020s, updates to rhyolite-MELTS have enhanced simulations of hydrous, silica-rich systems by refining thermodynamic calibrations for volatile-bearing melts, better capturing phase relations in subduction-related settings.^[69]^[70] A classic application involves modeling the Skaergaard intrusion in Greenland, where forward simulations test fractional versus bulk crystallization by comparing predicted liquid lines of descent against observed whole-rock trends in FeO and TiO₂ enrichment. These efforts reveal that near-perfect fractional crystallization dominated early stages, transitioning to more equilibrium-like behavior in later cumulates due to compaction. Such models can be validated briefly using isotopic indicators to confirm closed-system assumptions.^[71]^[72]

Isotopic and Trace Element Indicators

Isotopic and trace element indicators provide key evidence for igneous differentiation processes, revealing patterns of fractional crystallization, assimilation, and magma mixing through variations in element concentrations and ratios that are preserved in rocks. These tracers are particularly valuable because incompatible trace elements and certain isotopes fractionate predictably during magma evolution, allowing petrologists to reconstruct the history of magma chambers without relying solely on major element compositions. Incompatible trace elements, such as zirconium (Zr) and niobium (Nb), become enriched in residual melts during fractional crystallization because they are not readily incorporated into common crystallizing minerals like olivine or pyroxene. This enrichment follows Rayleigh fractionation laws, where concentrations increase exponentially with the degree of crystallization, providing quantitative estimates of differentiation extent—for instance, Zr concentrations can rise from ~100 ppm in primitive basalts to over 500 ppm in evolved andesites. Spider diagrams, which plot these elements normalized to primitive mantle compositions, highlight subduction-related signatures through characteristic depletions in Nb and Ta relative to neighboring elements like La and Hf, reflecting the addition of slab-derived fluids to arc magmas. These patterns are widely used to distinguish arc settings from intraplate volcanism, as demonstrated in discrimination diagrams that separate volcanic arc fields based on ratios like Th/Yb versus Ta/Yb.^[73]^[74] Radiogenic isotopes like ⁸⁷Sr/⁸⁶Sr shift toward higher values during crustal assimilation, as continental crust typically has elevated ratios (0.708–0.720) compared to mantle-derived magmas (0.702–0.704), enabling detection of contamination even in small amounts. For example, increases in ⁸⁷Sr/⁸⁶Sr from 0.704 to 0.706 in andesitic suites often correlate with trace element trends indicating interaction with older crustal rocks. Stable isotopes, such as δ¹⁸O, serve as indicators of crustal contamination through elevated values (δ¹⁸O > +7‰) from assimilation of supracrustal materials hydrothermally altered by meteoric water, contrasting with mantle values around +5.3‰. U-Pb dating of zircons records crystallization ages directly, as zircons incorporate U and exclude initial Pb, yielding concordant ages that pinpoint the timing of magma differentiation events, such as the formation of late-stage granitic melts at 100–200 Ma in arc plutons.^[75]^[76]^[77] Interpretation of these indicators often involves rare earth element (REE) patterns, where negative Eu anomalies (Eu/Eu* < 1) arise from plagioclase fractionation, as plagioclase preferentially incorporates Eu²⁺ over other trivalent REEs like Sm and Gd, depleting the melt in Eu. These anomalies are evident in chondrite-normalized plots, with Eu/Eu* ratios dropping to 0.6–0.8 in evolved rocks after 20–30% crystallization. Quantitative assessment uses N-MORB-normalized multi-element plots, which accentuate incompatible element enrichments and help validate differentiation models by comparing observed patterns to predicted fractionation trajectories.^[73] In the Parícutin volcano products, isotopic evidence from Sr-Nd-Pb-Os systems indicates magma evolution driven primarily by fractional crystallization and melting of a heterogeneous mantle, with ⁸⁷Sr/⁸⁶Sr ratios around 0.7038 showing limited variations consistent with minor open-system influences rather than significant crustal assimilation.^[78] Recent applications in lunar petrology use trace elements and isotopes to trace differentiation in the lunar magma ocean, where incompatible element enrichments in mare basalts (e.g., Zr up to 200 ppm) and stable isotope variations (δ²⁵Mg ~ -0.3‰) support cumulate overturn and partial melting of a stratified mantle following initial crystallization. These indicators align with geochemical models when observational data match simulated fractionation paths, confirming process interpretations.^[79] Emerging stable isotope systems, such as Zr, Sr, and Mg isotopes, have advanced as tracers for magmatic differentiation as of 2025. For instance, stable Zr isotopes fractionate during crystallization, revealing kinetic to equilibrium transitions in arc magmas, while stable Sr isotopes trace magma-fluid interactions in granitic systems.^[80]^[81]^[82]

References

[1]
Magmatic Differentiation - Tulane University
Jan 30, 2012 · Magmatic differentiation is any process that causes magma composition to change, such as distinct melting events, partial melting, crystal ...
[2]
Igneous Processes and Volcanoes – Introduction to Earth Science
Igneous rocks form when liquid rock (magma/lava) freezes. Magma forms near the surface, and lava cools quickly on the surface, forming fine-grained rocks.
[3]
[PDF] Differentiation of Magmas By Fractional Crystallization
Magmatic differentiation is the process by which diverse rock types are generated from a single magma through crystal-melt fractionation.
[4]
Olivine-enriched melt inclusions in chromites from low-Ca boninites ...
Primary melt has been defined as a silicate liquid fully equilibrated with the mantle peridotite at the conditions of its generation (e.g., Green et al., 1979).Olivine-Enriched Melt... · Abstract · Introduction
[5]
The origin of medium-K ankaramitic arc magmas from Lombok ...
This suggests that, in the case of these magmas, the melt inclusions in forsterite-rich olivine crystals (Fo89–91) represent melt batches whose mixing is ...
[6]
Primary magmas of mid‐ocean ridge basalts 2. Applications - Kinzler
May 10, 1992 · The total extents of depletion achieved by the decompression melting process to yield the observed variation in major elements of MORB range ...
[7]
Petrolog3: Integrated software for modeling crystallization processes
Jul 29, 2011 · Modeling of reverse fractional crystallization can be used to restore the compositions of less fractionated parental melts from the ...
[8]
The importance of parental magma composition to calc‐alkaline and ...
Jan 10, 1992 · Modelling based on the rare earth elements suggests approximately 7% melting for the calc-alkaline parent and 20% for the tholeiitic parent.
[9]
Komatiitic parental magmas of the Archean Ujaragssuit Nunât ...
Feb 21, 2025 · Komatiites are thought to form through high degrees of partial melting, with most originating from fertile or slightly depleted mantle ...
[10]
Constraining the sub-arc, parental magma composition for the giant ...
Apr 22, 2020 · The Andean continental arc is built upon the thickest crust on Earth, whose eruption products reflect varying degrees of crustal ...
[11]
[PDF] Lecture 37 - SOEST Hawaii
crystals are in instantaneous chemical equilibrium with the melt as they form, but are immediately removed from contact with the melt.Missing: petrology | Show results with:petrology
[12]
The evolution of the igneous rocks : Bowen, Norman Levi, 1887-1956
Oct 7, 2009 · The evolution of the igneous rocks based on a brief course of lectures given to advanced students in the Department of geology at Princeton in the spring of ...
[13]
Norman Levi Bowen (1887–1956) and igneous rock diversity
He reasoned that rocks of the subalkaline igneous rock series, including granite, have been derived from parental basalt by crystal separation, e.g. settling, ...
[14]
Cumulates rocks - ALEX STREKEISEN
Cumulates are igneous rocks formed by sedimentation, displaying cumulate textures, and are classified by the proportion of cumulate crystals.
[15]
https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-020-20778-w
[16]
https://press.princeton.edu/books/paperback/9780691601953/evolution-of-the-igneous-rocks
[17]
Effect of melt composition on crustal carbonate assimilation ...
Sep 20, 2016 · Mafic magmatic intrusions are also capable of releasing excess CO2 due to carbonate assimilation. However, the effect of mafic to silicic melt ...
[18]
The fluid dynamics of a basaltic magma chamber replenished by ...
This paper describes a fluid dynamical investigation of the influx of hot, dense ultrabasic magma into a reservoir containing lighter, fractionated basalti.Missing: balance | Show results with:balance
[19]
Magmatic karst reveals dynamics of crystallization and differentiation ...
Apr 1, 2021 · Evidence for igneous differentiation in ... magma replenishment via sill intrusion in the Rum Western Layered Intrusion NW Scotland.
[20]
Some effects of viscosity on the dynamics of replenished magma ...
Aug 10, 1984 · Some aspects of the dynamical behavior of magma chambers, replenished from below with hotter but denser magma, have been modeled in a series ...Missing: balance | Show results with:balance
[21]
Magmatic differentiation - Geological Society, London, Memoirs Home
Magmatic differentiation is the process by which magmas differentiate, mainly through crystal-liquid fractionation, causing diversity in igneous rocks.Missing: reversals | Show results with:reversals
[22]
Rapid crustal transit of magmas beneath the Main Ethiopian Rift
Aug 15, 2025 · We find that magmas move rapidly through the crust, replenishing mid-crustal reservoirs only weeks to months before intrusive-eruptive events.
[23]
Magma mixing and high fountaining during the 1959 Kīlauea Iki ...
Aug 15, 2014 · The 1959 Kīlauea Iki eruption provides a unique opportunity to investigate the process of shallow magma mixing, its impact on the magmatic ...
[24]
[PDF] Thermodynamic and Transport Properties of Silicate Melts and Magma
The heat needed to completely fuse (melt) gabbro, the plutonic (crystalline) equivalent of basaltic magma, is about 500 kJ/kg.
[25]
https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/BF01166768
[26]
Textural and compositional evidence for magma mixing and its ...
Magma mixing at Abu volcano group involves liquid-liquid mixing in mafic mixtures and liquid-solid mixing in silicic mixtures, with basalt and dacite magmas ...Missing: signatures | Show results with:signatures
[27]
https://agupubs.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1029/JB089iB08p06857
[28]
Trace element mobility during magma mixing - ResearchGate
Aug 8, 2025 · During the magma mixing process, elements with similar diffusivity values generally display linear patterns while elements with contrasting ...<|separator|>
[29]
Mantle Melting and Basalt Extraction by Equilibrium Porous Flow
... mantle during porous flow. Model ... Lithosphere thickness controls the extent of mantle melting, depth of melt extraction ...
[30]
Progressive Melt Extraction from Upwelling Mantle Constrained by ...
OIB are good targets for studying mantle melting processes because they often exhume mantle-derived xenoliths (indicating rapid ascent from mantle depths) ...
[31]
Earth Mantle's Isotopic Record of Progressive Chemical Depletion
Mar 7, 2023 · Calculating the Sm/Nd and Lu/Hf ratios of such residual peridotites, that is, peridotites that have only been affected by melt extraction, shows ...
[32]
The combined Hf and Nd isotope evolution of the depleted mantle ...
Mar 24, 2023 · We present a theoretical analysis of published Hf and Nd isotopic data representing the depleted mantle and demonstrate that continental growth must have ...
[33]
[PDF] Decoding dihedral angles in melt-bearing and solidified rocks
A comparatively neglected microstructural parameter is the dihedral angle, that angle subtended between two grain boundaries or interfaces. (Smith, 1948; 1964).
[34]
https://doi.org/10.3390/geosciences3030585
[35]
Well-wetted olivine grain boundaries in partially molten peridotite in ...
The dihedral angles of olivine–silicate melt in partially molten peridotite were determined at pressures of 1 to 7 GPa and temperatures between 1473 and 1993 K.Missing: trapping cumulates
[36]
On the Use of Changes in Dihedral Angle to Decode Late-stage ...
Abstract. The melt-filled pore structure in the final stages of solidification of cumulates must lie somewhere between the two end-members of impingement (
[37]
Differentiation and Compaction in the Skaergaard Intrusion
Variations in the textural maturity of the basal cumulates, expressed by the plagioclase–plagioclase–augite dihedral angle, demonstrate that the chamber filled ...
[38]
How do volatiles escape their shallow magmatic hearth? - PMC
Jan 7, 2019 · They come out of solution (exsolve) as magmas decompress while they ascend to shallower depths (first boiling) or crystallize while they cool ...
[39]
[PDF] Chapter 16 - Augustine Volcano—The Influence of Volatile ...
The manner of fluid exsolution exerts a strong control on styles of volcanic eruption and on the compositions and textures of eruptive materials. Thus, it is ...
[40]
Solubility and solution mechanism of H2O in alkali silicate melts and ...
Aug 6, 2025 · The solubility behavior of H2O in melts in the system Na2O-SiO2-H2O was determined by locating the univariant phase boundary, melt = melt + ...
[41]
[PDF] An empirical model for the solubility of H2O in magmas to 3 kilobars
ABSTRACT. We present 16 new manometric determinations of H2O solubility for a range of natural silicate liquid compositions equilibrated up to 3 kbar of H2O ...
[42]
Segregation Vesicles, Gas Filter-Pressing, and Igneous Differentiation
As crystallization proceeds H₂O is concentrated in the residual liquid and gas. This produces a higher pressure in the gas-poor matrix than in the vesicles and ...
[43]
The effect of pre-eruptive fluid exsolution on the volatile budgets of ...
Oct 4, 2025 · The amounts of volatiles emitted from large Plinian eruptions are typically estimated using the difference between their concentration in ...
[44]
The Layered Series - the virtual Skaergaard intrusion
The LS forms a stratigraphic cumulate succession of around 2500 metres developed on the magma chamber floor. It evolves systematically from high-temperature ...
[45]
[PDF] The origin of rhythmic layering - RRuff
SUMMARY. Rhythmic layering in the Skaergaard intru- sion shows variation in crystal size and in modal propor- tions of primocrysts with structural height.
[46]
Skaergaard Layered Series. Part II. Magmatic flow and Dynamic ...
Magmatic flow results in contrasting layers and strong foliation accompanied by a linear orientation of elongated minerals.
[47]
Experimental constraints on the Skaergaard liquid line of descent
The forward modeling illustrates that only for unrealistic small amounts of Fe–Ti oxide minerals will iron enrichment accompany silica depletion into UZ.
[48]
The differentiation of the Skaergaard Intrusion - NASA ADS
We propose that the Skaergaard magma evolved on a trend of pronounced silica-enrichment after cumulus magnetite appeared at the top of the Lower Zone. At that ...
[49]
New views of how magma is stored beneath Yellowstone provided ...
Jul 31, 2023 · Data from a major deployment of seismometers in 2020 is revealing new insights into the characteristics of the magma chamber beneath Yellowstone caldera.
[50]
Extreme seismic anisotropy indicates shallow accumulation of ...
Aug 15, 2023 · Images of Yellowstone's crustal magmatic system are predominantly shaped by seismic P-wave travel-time tomography studies using local ...
[51]
Convection and mixing in the oceans and the Earth
Convection in magma chambers is almost always highly time dependent or ... development of a stratified hybrid layer in a magma chamber. repIenished from ...
[52]
Controls on explosive-effusive volcanic eruption styles - Nature
Jul 19, 2018 · This is because volatiles lower the melt viscosity and also lead to greater exsolution and production of exsolved volatiles, thereby increasing ...
[53]
Role of volatiles in highly explosive basaltic eruptions - Nature
Jul 6, 2022 · Water and carbon dioxide are the most abundant volatile components in terrestrial magmas. As they exsolve into magmatic vapour, they promote magma buoyancy.
[54]
Bulk solubility and speciation of H2O in silicate melts - ScienceDirect
Feb 20, 2018 · The bulk solubility and speciation of H2O in silicate melts of virtually any composition is predicted from first principles with a ...
[55]
Silicate melt properties and volcanic eruptions - AGU Journals - Wiley
Dec 5, 2007 · Even though both H2O and CO2 are present in silicate melts as at least two species, the complexity in the solubility and diffusion behavior of H ...
[56]
Gas-driven filter pressing in magmas - USGS.gov
For gas-driven filter pressing to be effective, the region of crystallization must inflate slowly relative to buildup of pressure and expulsion of melt These ...
[57]
Exsolved volatiles in magma reservoirs - ScienceDirect.com
We review the role and importance of exsolved volatiles in magma reservoirs. We examine the influence of magma compressibility on eruption duration and ...
[58]
A SO2 flux study of the Etna volcano 2020–2021 ... - Frontiers
May 31, 2023 · Because all the summit craters can degas simultaneously, SO2 sensing tools able to resolve emissions from distinct vents/craters are very useful ...
[59]
Spatially resolved SO2 flux emissions from Mt Etna - AGU Journals
Jul 14, 2016 · We find that the fissure eruption contributed ~50,000 t of SO2 or ~30% of the SO2 emitted by the volcano during the 5 July to 10 August eruptive ...
[60]
VESIcal: 2. A Critical Approach to Volatile Solubility Modeling Using ...
Jan 12, 2022 · For example, to calculate a saturation pressure in MagmaSat (Ghiorso & Gualda, 2015), users must hand-type 9–14 oxide concentrations in addition ...
[61]
PetroGram: An excel-based petrology program for modeling of ...
PetroGram is an Excel© based magmatic petrology program that generates numerical and graphical models. PetroGram can model the magmatic processes.
[62]
fractional crystallization in the alkali basalt series of Chaîne des ...
The mass balance equations, D i = ∑ ; x j D j ii where Di and Dji are the bulk and mineral/liquid distribution coefficients respectively, and xj the weight ...
[63]
Crustal assimilation in arc magmas controlled by overriding plate ...
Nov 5, 2025 · ... Sr isotopes, which are the tracers of assimilation, change systematically in magmatic rocks with the crustal thickness of the arc. These ...
[64]
a Modified Calibration of MELTS Optimized for Silica-rich, Fluid ...
We create a modified calibration of MELTS optimized for silicic systems, dubbed rhyolite-MELTS, using early erupted Bishop pumice as a reference.
[65]
Understanding rhyolite-MELTS versions - OFM Research
This version is the rhyolite-MELTS model with CO2 melt properties and mixed-fluid energetic terms from Ghiorso and Gualda (2015), utilizing H2O melt properties ...
[66]
On the Skaergaard intrusion and forward modeling of its liquid line ...
High or increasing fO2 favors earlier crystallization of Fe–Ti oxide minerals, restricting iron enrichment and enhancing silica enrichment (calc-alkalic ...
[67]
Trace Element Constraints on the Differentiation and Crystal Mush ...
Apr 2, 2018 · However, incompatible elements, and especially REE, show a degree of enrichment in plagioclase rims (> 20 ppm Ce) that strongly exceeds the ...
[68]
[PDF] Chemical and isotopic systematics of oceanic basalts
We need to do the following. (1) Undertake complete chemical and isotopic characterization of the Earth's primitive mantle (the silicate sphere of the Earth).
[69]
(PDF) Trace Element Discrimination Diagrams for the Tectonic ...
Aug 9, 2025 · The application of trace elements to petrogenesis of igneous rocks of granitic compositions ... elements indicative of subduction. ...
[70]
Petrographic, geochemical and isotopic evidence of crustal ...
Coupled petrography and 87Sr/86Sr mineral analyses are used to evaluate assimilation. •. The crust contamination process is related to initial stages of ...
[71]
Low-δ 18 O silicic magmas on Earth: a review - ScienceDirect.com
Silicic magmas with low δ18O values represent an unusual case of intracrustal recycling, as they record assimilation of rocks that were hydrothermally ...
[72]
What's in an age? Calculation and interpretation ... - GeoScienceWorld
Apr 26, 2023 · In this article, we examine each of these variables as they relate to interpretation of the record of zircon crystallization in igneous rocks.
[73]
A re-interpretation of the petrogenesis of Paricutin volcano
Jan 20, 2019 · We have conducted new major and trace element and isotopic studies (whole rock Sr-Nd-Pb-Os) of the Paricutin lavas and tephras spanning the ...
[74]
Trace element partitioning in the lunar magma ocean
Apr 13, 2024 · Here we report new experimental trace element partition coefficients (D) between clinopyroxene (cpx), pigeonite, orthopyroxene, plagioclase, olivine (ol), and ...