Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

NeoGAF

NeoGAF is an centered on discussions, analysis, sales data, reviews, and news across platforms and genres. Originating in 1999 as a message board extension of the Gaming-Age website, it transitioned to independent operation in 2004 under Tyler Malka following a near-collapse due to technical issues and community fundraising efforts, before rebranding as NeoGAF in 2006 to sever ties amid publisher pressures. The site emphasizes structured, substantive debate through rigorous , eschewing free-for-all chaos in favor of enforced civility and focus on topics, which has cultivated a reputation for depth in enthusiast conversations and occasional via leaks and trend-setting threads. A defining 2017 controversy arose from allegations of leveled by an ex-partner against Malka, which he categorically denied as baseless and from an unreliable source, prompting moderator resignations, user mass-exoduses via intentional ban-seeking posts, a temporary shutdown, and subsequent rules banning social issues and to refocus on core content.

Overview

Founding and Purpose

NeoGAF originated as the Gaming-Age Forums (GAF), established in 2000 as a community discussion board adjunct to Gaming-Age, a video game news and review website founded by Jim Cordeira. The forums served primarily as a platform for gamers to engage in conversations about video games, share news, and interact with industry developments, initially hosted under the Gaming-Age umbrella to support its content ecosystem. In , following a database crash that threatened the forums' survival, teenager Tyler Malka, known online as EviLore, stepped in to revive the community. Using approximately $2,000 raised through member donations, Malka migrated the forums to independent software, assuming administrative control and marking the shift toward self-sustained operations detached from Gaming-Age's hosting dependencies, which had previously included stints with and other platforms post-dot-com bust. This revival solidified the site's purpose as a dedicated, user-driven for in-depth , emphasizing community moderation and rapid information exchange. On April 4, 2006, the forums rebranded to NeoGAF—"New GAF"—to formally sever ties with Gaming-Age amid increasing harassment from publishers over leaked content posted by users. The rebranding underscored NeoGAF's evolving role as an independent entity committed to fostering unfiltered discussions, breaking industry news ahead of official channels, and serving as a neutral ground for gamers, developers, and journalists, while prioritizing integrity over commercial publisher influences. By this point, the forum had grown into a influential hub, attracting over 100,000 members and generating around 50,000 daily posts centered on analysis, sales data, and cultural impacts.

Core Features and Operations

NeoGAF functions as a traditional , or , centered on user-generated discussions about video games and related topics. It requires user registration for participation, supporting the creation of threads and replies in a hierarchical structure that has accumulated 963,481 threads and 129,379,249 messages as of October 2025. The platform emphasizes community-driven content, with active moderation to enforce rules such as restricting political discourse in designated off-topic areas. The core subforums include Gaming Discussion, which covers video game news, industry analysis, sales data, promotional deals, user impressions, reviews, and broad conversations spanning all platforms (e.g., consoles, PC) and genres. This section alone hosts over 460,000 threads and 60 million messages, serving as the primary hub for timely gaming discourse. Supporting areas encompass Communities for ongoing "OT" (off-topic within gaming) threads and matchmaking, Off-Topic Discussion for non-gaming, non-political exchanges (365,200 threads, 38.8 million messages), Marketplace for user buy/sell/trade listings, and Forum Archive preserving select historical content (7,400 threads, 29.3 million messages). Operational features include a premium tier known as NeoGAF Gold, launched on December 14, 2018, which grants subscribers ad-free browsing, access to instant updates, custom profile covers, gilded usernames with exclusive member titles and badges, and additional perks like special achievements. The maintains a membership base exceeding 169,000 registered users, with daily activity involving hundreds online alongside thousands of guests. Content moderation relies on staff-enforced policies to sustain focused, rule-compliant interactions, though specifics beyond category restrictions (e.g., no in ) are not publicly detailed on the main site.

Historical Development

Early Growth (1999–2010)

NeoGAF originated as the Gaming-Age Forums (GAF), launched in 1999 as a discussion board adjunct to the Gaming-Age video game news and review website. Initially focused on fostering community discourse around gaming news, releases, and industry developments, the forums quickly attracted enthusiasts amid the late-1990s surge in online gaming communities. By 2000, amid the burst, Gaming-Age's founder Jim Cordeira shifted priorities to the main site due to escalating server costs and financial pressures, leading to GAF's relocation to IGN's hosting infrastructure while maintaining loose ties to the parent site but without direct oversight. Throughout the early , GAF experienced instability from frequent hosting migrations, including stints on EZBoard and GameSquad Network platforms plagued by inadequate servers, excessive advertisements, and performance issues. A critical juncture occurred in when a database incident rendered the site inoperable, with no accessible backups exacerbating the crisis; administrator Tyler Malka, then 19 years old and known online as EviLore, spearheaded its revival by securing approximately $2,000 in community donations via to fund an independent vBulletin-based setup on dedicated servers. This transition enforced stricter moderation policies against disruptive behavior and low-quality ads, emphasizing substantive, civil discussions that distinguished GAF from contemporaneous forums. On April 4, 2006, the forums rebranded to NeoGAF to fully detach from Gaming-Age and mitigate pressures from publishers wary of unfiltered criticism, solidifying its status as an autonomous entity under Malka's ownership. This period marked accelerated growth, with membership reaching 100,000 users and daily post volumes hitting 50,000 by mid-2006, driven by a minimalist interface, reputation for insightful analysis, and appeal to dedicated gamers seeking alternatives to mainstream sites dominated by advertising or superficial content. Through 2010, NeoGAF expanded its influence by hosting influential threads on major releases and industry events, attracting traffic that positioned it as a key referral source for gaming journalism, though it remained volunteer-moderated with Malka handling core operations.

Peak Influence and Community Expansion (2011–2016)

During the period from 2011 to 2016, NeoGAF solidified its position as the pre-eminent online forum for enthusiasts, developers, and journalists, experiencing marked expansion in community size and traffic amid the gaming industry's transition to next-generation consoles. By , the site drew 2.6 million unique monthly visitors and 70 million page views per month, metrics that underscored its growing centrality in gaming discourse. The membership base reached approximately 100,000 users, who generated around 50,000 posts daily, enabling in-depth threads on releases, hardware announcements, and market trends. This surge aligned with heightened industry activity, including major events like , where NeoGAF threads often overloaded servers due to intense real-time engagement. NeoGAF's influence peaked as a news aggregator and opinion-shaper, with users frequently breaking leaks and providing impressions deemed more reliable than those from traditional outlets by some participants. Notable incidents, such as the 2011 leak of the beta footage—which prompted legal threats from —highlighted the forum's role in disseminating sensitive information ahead of official reveals. Industry insiders, including developers like and , actively posted, drawn by the site's reputation for substantive debate unmarred by anonymity-driven trolling, thanks to its closed-registration policy requiring verification. During E3 2013's and unveilings, NeoGAF hosted sprawling discussion threads that influenced public perception and media coverage of console features like and always-online requirements. Financial viability further evidenced this expansion, as ad from high volumes enabled profitability after years of losses, prompting owner Tyler Malka to reject a $5 million acquisition offer in amid a subsequent 50% uptick. The forum's minimalist design and strict moderation against bigotry sustained a dedicated core, fostering off-topic communities alongside gaming-specific ones, though growth strained server infrastructure during peak events. By 2016, as mobile and indie gaming proliferated, NeoGAF remained a for enthusiast-level analysis, with its user-driven content often cited in broader analyses despite lacking formal oversight.

2017 Controversy

In October , NeoGAF faced a major crisis triggered by resurfaced allegations of against its owner, Tyler "Evilore" Malka. The claims originated from a 2015 post by filmmaker Ima Leupp, who described an incident of unwanted advances and harassment by an unnamed individual, later identified as Malka through contextual clues like "Google Evilore." These allegations gained renewed attention amid the , with discussions surfacing on platforms like around October 18, 2017. Malka denied the accusations, stating they were "baseless," that the accuser lacked credibility, and that he possessed supporting evidence and witnesses. The fallout escalated rapidly on October 20–21, as numerous moderators and longtime users publicly resigned, citing discomfort with Malka's alleged behavior and the site's handling of the matter. Many community members posted intentional "suicide threads"—provocative messages designed to provoke bans—as a form of , leading to widespread disruption. By , the site went offline for "scheduled maintenance," halting all activity amid the resignations and user exodus. Upon reopening on at approximately 10 p.m. ET, threads criticizing Malka dominated, outnumbering gaming discussions, prompting temporary closure of off-topic sections and a shift to anonymous moderation without a public mod list. The controversy resulted in a significant community fracture, with thousands of users departing NeoGAF to join or form alternatives, most notably ResetEra, launched on , 2017, by former moderators and members seeking stricter conduct policies. While NeoGAF eventually stabilized with a smaller, more polarized user base, the events highlighted tensions over accountability, moderation, and the site's direction under Malka's ownership. No legal resolutions to the allegations were publicly reported.

Post-2017 Recovery and Evolution

Following the 2017 sexual misconduct allegations against owner Malka, NeoGAF was taken offline on October 21, 2017, for review of its , reopening four days later with Malka issuing a emphasizing a return to focused gaming discussions and stricter enforcement against off-topic or inflammatory content. The relaunch retained a core of loyal users but saw a significant exodus, as most moderators resigned and thousands of members migrated to the newly formed ResetEra forum, launched on the same day by former NeoGAF staff. Despite predictions of its demise, the site persisted, with remaining and returning users prioritizing unmoderated debate on topics, sales data, and hardware performance over broader social commentary. In the years after, NeoGAF's community evolved into a more contrarian space, attracting participants disillusioned with ResetEra's stricter content policies, which emphasized progressive social norms and rapid thread closures for perceived toxicity. Discussions shifted toward empirical analysis of trends, such as NPD figures and console shipment estimates, often featuring detailed breakdowns of and software attach rates. By , user metrics indicated resilience, with NeoGAF reporting approximately 8,500 concurrent visitors—surpassing ResetEra's roughly 7,000—reflecting a stabilized, niche audience engaged in long-form threads on topics like subscription service growth and platform exclusives. As of September 2025, NeoGAF maintains a global ranking of #32,105 in , placing #365 within the video games consoles and accessories category, supported by active subforums for ongoing threads (), community , and specialized interests like titles and games. The forum's evolution has emphasized durability over expansion, fostering a user base that values archival sales data and skepticism, with recent activity including debates on 2024 U.S. console sales (e.g., under 3 million units) and bot-driven trends. This contrasts with broader declines in standalone forums, positioning NeoGAF as a holdout for substantive, data-oriented amid platform fragmentation.

Controversies and Internal Dynamics

Moderation Practices and Policies

NeoGAF's operates under a centralized model where decisions on thread closures, post removals, and user bans are made exclusively by site administration and are described as non-democratic and final, with no formal process outlined in official terms. Users are encouraged to objectionable via for manual review, as real-time moderation is not provided, and administration reserves the right to edit, delete posts, or disclose user identities in response to legal complaints. Core content guidelines prohibit abusive, vulgar, hateful, obscene, or threatening language, including sexual, racial, or ethnic slurs, which result in immediate bans on ; is to be minimized, discussion must occur in English unless specified otherwise, and images of a sexual or profane —such as exposed genitalia or nipples—are discouraged and subject to removal. Additional restrictions include bans on multiple usernames, self-promotion or (though incidental participation in discussions is allowed), full transcriptions of articles without attribution, and links or instructions promoting software , while general discussions are permitted. In threads and select high-profile topics, moderation emphasizes strict on-topic enforcement, with users derailing discussions or posting complaints facing thread locks or personal bans to maintain focus. Prior to 2017, moderation drew criticism for perceived biases favoring progressive political views and products, with users alleging selective enforcement that banned conservative or dissenting opinions while tolerating aligned rhetoric; site owner Tyler Malka acknowledged this imbalance in June 2017, confirming prior biased moderation by at least one staff member and pledging efforts toward greater opinion diversity. In January 2018, Malka further attributed community decline to , authoritarian left-leaning hostility, and unfair moderation practices that stifled discourse. Following the October 2017 scandal involving allegations against Malka, NeoGAF implemented a policy banning all political and discourse, including in sections, to mitigate and heated exchanges that had exacerbated internal conflicts; this change aimed to refocus on gaming but was implemented amid moderator resignations and user exodus. Subsequent measures included public ban histories listing reasons such as calls for (despite the discourse ban) and a 2018 ban review project addressing pre-scandal overzealous enforcement, particularly around politically charged events like the 2016 U.S. election primaries. These policies remain subject to unilateral changes by administration without prior notification.

Key Disputes and User Conflicts

In October 2017, NeoGAF faced its most prominent internal crisis when multiple women accused owner Tyler Malka of , including non-consensual advances and dating back several years. These allegations, first detailed publicly on October 17, prompted over a dozen moderators and administrators to resign in protest, citing a lack of from , which led to the site's complete outage from October 22 to 23 as volunteer staff withdrew support. Malka's response included mass bans of users discussing the claims, enforced under expanded rules prohibiting "social issues" and , which users criticized as an attempt to suppress scrutiny rather than address root concerns. This triggered widespread user revolts, with thousands departing the forum—many high-profile posters among them—and forming ResetEra as an alternative on , fracturing the community along lines of loyalty to Malka versus demands for transparency. Reflecting on the fallout in early 2018, Malka acknowledged that uneven moderation, driven by and "authoritarian left" influences among staff, had eroded trust and amplified conflicts, as favored users received leniency while others faced punitive actions for off-topic or dissenting posts. Broader user disputes often stemmed from such practices, including accusations of favoritism toward posters and suppression of debates on , as seen in earlier Gamergate-era threads where appeared selective based on ideological rather than site rules. These tensions persisted post-2017, with periodic ban waves and appeals highlighting ongoing friction over perceived arbitrariness in .

Reception and Cultural Impact

Industry Engagement

NeoGAF has historically drawn participation from gaming industry professionals, including developers such as , creator of the series, and , designer of , who were active members of the forum. These figures engaged in discussions alongside users, contributing to the site's reputation as a hub for insider perspectives on and development challenges. Community managers and gaming journalists also frequented the platform, often monitoring threads for public sentiment on upcoming titles and industry trends. The forum's live threads during major events like the Electronic Entertainment Expo (E3) generated significant traffic spikes, frequently overwhelming servers due to real-time commentary on press conferences and announcements. This engagement extended to leaks, with NeoGAF users breaking early details on games, financial reports, and hardware, prompting reactions from publishers; for instance, Square Enix's disclosure of fiscal data was accelerated following forum discussions. Such incidents led to prior of the site's originating entity, Gaming-Age, by publishers over unauthorized disclosures, influencing the rebranding to NeoGAF. Direct interactions occasionally turned contentious, as seen in the 2008 public feud between NeoGAF users and CEO , who defended his studio's on the amid criticism of its development and exclusivity. later explained his posting as an attempt to counter what he viewed as the site's particularly harsh environment. In , despite its influence in disseminating industry news, NeoGAF's application for an official media pass was rejected by the , which classified it as a discussion rather than a journalistic outlet. Following the 2017 controversy, industry engagement diminished, with professionals shifting to alternatives like ResetEra, though NeoGAF continued to host discussions on sales data and development insights that occasionally informed broader market analysis. The site's role in amplifying user-driven hype, dubbed the "NeoGAF effect" by participants, was credited anecdotally with influencing day-one sales for titles like through concentrated buzz. However, this impact relied on the forum's pre-2017 prominence as a for enthusiast opinions.

Community and Media Perspectives

The NeoGAF community experienced significant fragmentation following the October 2017 allegations against owner Tyler "Evilore" Malka, which prompted mass moderator resignations and of thousands of users who formed the rival ResetEra. Remaining users expressed mixed sentiments, with some viewing the site as a resilient space for dedicated gaming discussions stripped of off-topic drama, while others criticized it as a diminished echo of its former self, plagued by overzealous moderation and internal conflicts. For instance, post-reopening statements from the administration emphasized a refocus on to rebuild trust, yet user feedback on platforms like highlighted perceptions of toxicity, immaturity, and low-quality discourse, rating the site at 2.5 out of 5 based on reviews citing inconsistent rules enforcement. Earlier community critiques, predating the scandal, often pointed to perceived biases in moderation favoring certain console ecosystems like , with accusations of suppressing dissenting views on topics such as sales figures or industry favoritism. Loyalists defended NeoGAF as a of in-depth analysis and sales data tracking, contrasting it with broader fragmentation, though post-2017 analyses noted a shift toward niche, less influential engagement compared to its peak era. This internal dynamic reflected broader gaming forum trends, where drama and power struggles led to repeated community splits, as observed in discussions of declining activity relative to competitors. Media coverage of NeoGAF has predominantly focused on its controversies, portraying the forum as a high-stakes hub of gaming discourse marred by scandals and uneven moderation practices. Outlets like documented early issues such as legal disputes and control battles in , framing the site as stable yet volatile, while reports emphasized the fallout from Malka's allegations, often amplifying user revolts and the site's temporary shutdown. Gaming press, which frequently critiqued NeoGAF's progressive-leaning moderation biases, acknowledged its historical influence on industry conversations but highlighted risks of echo chambers and , though such narratives may reflect media incentives to sensationalize internal forum drama over substantive discussion.

Comparisons with Competitors like ResetEra

ResetEra emerged as NeoGAF's primary competitor following a mass exodus of users and moderators on October 24, 2017, triggered by allegations of against NeoGAF owner Tyler Malka, which prompted the site's administrators to resign en masse and establish the new forum as an alternative with reformed moderation practices. Unlike NeoGAF's historical tolerance for unmoderated debates spanning , , and off-topic threads, ResetEra positioned itself with explicit rules emphasizing inclusivity, prohibiting harassment, and enforcing progressive standards on topics like and social issues, attracting former NeoGAF members seeking a "better" environment free from the original site's perceived toxicities. In terms of moderation, ResetEra adopted a stricter, more proactive approach compared to NeoGAF's post-2017 recovery, where the latter relaxed some policies to foster freer expression amid user backlash against the split's origins; ResetEra's administrators implemented zero-tolerance for infractions like "dogwhistling" or views deemed exclusionary, leading critics to describe it as totalitarian or , while proponents credit it with reducing overt . NeoGAF, by contrast, permits broader , including politically charged threads that ResetEra would likely curtail, resulting in accusations from ResetEra users that NeoGAF has devolved into a haven for controversial ideologies, though this reflects subjective ideological divides rather than empirical metrics. Community dynamics diverge sharply: ResetEra quickly became a hub for gaming industry professionals and journalists, aggregating news and zeitgeist discussions with higher activity levels—evidenced by its superior , outpacing NeoGAF by thousands of monthly visits as of September 2025—while fostering a more unified, left-leaning on cultural matters. NeoGAF, retaining a core of long-term users from its 1999 founding, maintains wider topical breadth but struggles with lower engagement and perceptions of irrelevance, though some observers note its discussions as more substantive on amid ResetEra's occasional drift into . This split underscores a broader schism, where ResetEra's model prioritizes curated over NeoGAF's enduring, if diminished, emphasis on unfiltered exchange.

Current Status and Legacy

NeoGAF remains operational as of 2025, hosting active discussions on news, sales figures, industry analysis, and off-topic topics. The underwent a site update in April 2025, introducing new features to enhance user experience. Recent threads cover current events such as anticipated 2026 games, Pro patches for titles like , and Pokémon updates, indicating ongoing community engagement despite a post-2017 decline in prominence. The site's user base has significantly contracted from its peak, with estimates placing concurrent or daily visitors around 8,500 in mid-2024, a fraction of the 2.6 million unique monthly users reported in 2013. This reduction stems from the 2017 ownership controversy, which prompted a mass exodus of users to alternatives like ResetEra, fracturing the original community. NeoGAF has since repositioned itself with looser moderation, attracting users previously banned from other platforms for dissenting views on gaming culture and , evolving into a more contrarian space relative to mainstream forums. NeoGAF's legacy lies in its role as a pioneering hub for detailed discourse during the and early , where it facilitated early aggregation of sales data, discussions, and critical that shaped broader conversations. It highlighted tensions in , including the risks of centralized leading to chambers or abrupt shifts, influencing the decentralization of communities across platforms like and . While diminished, its endurance underscores the demand for unfiltered debate in an industry often critiqued for ideological conformity in and circles, serving as a cautionary example of how personal scandals can realign ecosystems.

References

  1. [1]
    NeoGAF
    Gaming Discussion. Video game news, industry analysis, sales figures, deals, impressions, reviews, and discussions of everything in the medium, covering all ...Gaming Discussion · Off-Topic Discussion · NeoGAF Gold · Ban History
  2. [2]
    The story of NeoGAF part one: humble beginnings - VG247
    May 15, 2013 · Alex Donaldson sat down with owner Tyler Malka to discuss the site's birth, influence and growth over the years.
  3. [3]
    NeoGAF goes offline in wake of sexual assault allegations
    Oct 23, 2017 · "An allegation of sexual misconduct has been made against me by an ex," said Malka in a post on the site. "It's not true, the individual making ...
  4. [4]
    Inside the Sexual Misconduct Allegations Rocking NeoGAF's ... - VICE
    Oct 23, 2017 · “It's been a perfect storm of misanthropy and opportunism,” said Malka, who described the accusations as “totally ridiculous and baseless.” As ...
  5. [5]
    The story of NeoGAF part two: scandal and control - VG247
    May 16, 2013 · Malka and NeoGAF's most infamous public feud was with Denis Dyack, the founder and CEO of Too Human developer Silicon Knights. The clash between ...
  6. [6]
    https://www.neogaf.com/forums/off-topic-discussion.22/
  7. [7]
    Gaming Discussion - NeoGAF
    Video game news, industry analysis, sales figures, deals, impressions, reviews, and discussions of everything in the medium, covering all platforms, genres.Gaming Discussion | Page 2 · Ban History · Page 61
  8. [8]
    NeoGAF Gold
    NeoGAF Gold Features · Ad-Free Browsing · Instant Updates (beta) · Custom Profile Cover · Gold Username and Gold Member Title · Special Achievement · More Features ...
  9. [9]
    Staff - Introducing: NeoGAF Gold
    Dec 14, 2018 · * Luxuriate in your gilded username, Gold Member status, and exclusive NeoGAF Gold header logo (on both Classic and Modern themes). * Still get ...NeoGAF Gold GiftingHey everyone | Page 10 - NeoGAFMore results from www.neogaf.com
  10. [10]
    NeoGAF - Archiveteam
    Apr 28, 2023 · ... gaming industry, previously known as the Gaming-Age Forums from its inception in 1999 until April 2006. It's amongst one of the largest ...
  11. [11]
    The story of NeoGAF part three: money, money, money - VG247
    May 17, 2013 · Alex Donaldson concludes his discussion with NeoGAF owner Tyler Malka, and discusses the issue of money and how you keep something so big ...
  12. [12]
    Let's Stop Calling Games "IP" - BuzzFeed News
    May 7, 2013 · The popular discussions on NeoGAF, the most influential fan forum in gaming, are largely what you would expect: speculation about the new ...<|separator|>
  13. [13]
    One of the internet's oldest gaming forums is imploding over sexual ...
    Oct 17, 2017 · It started last week when the site's owner, Tyler Malka, was publicly accused of sexual harassment. In the hours and days that followed, a ...
  14. [14]
    NeoGAF Reopens, Users Revolt - Kotaku
    Oct 23, 2017 · Following a weekend of strife that led to mass mod resignations and the forums going offline for days, popular gaming community NeoGAF has ...
  15. [15]
    NeoGAF goes silent following allegations against owner - Polygon
    Oct 22, 2017 · After the post yesterday afternoon numerous commentators offered “suicide posts,” which were deliberately written in hopes of being banned.
  16. [16]
    NeoGAF is back online, but it's turned into an undead Nazi version ...
    Oct 24, 2017 · The uproar of NeoGAF's progressive community was a direct response to that, not an object example of a situation that needs to be "fixed."
  17. [17]
    https://www.polygon.com/2017/10/24/16536652/neogaf-resetera-forum-scandal-malka
  18. [18]
    Anybody else surprised how different ResetEra and NeoGAF became?
    Oct 29, 2024 · It is hard to believe that we were all a unified voice once. Could ResetEra and NeoGAF ever reconcile and become one forum again?Resetera reflects: This place sucks. We want GAF back. - NeoGAFResetEra Discussion -- Stay civil. Don't get personal. Keep it in here.More results from www.neogaf.comMissing: evolution | Show results with:evolution
  19. [19]
    Sales-Age - November NPD 2017 | NeoGAF
    Dec 15, 2017 · Accessories also experienced an uptick last month, growing 11 percent year-over-year to $344 million. This is thanks mostly due to gamepads, ...Sony Q4 2017 and FY17 results. - NeoGAFNPD Sales Results for August 2017 [Up: Video From NPD] - NeoGAFMore results from www.neogaf.com
  20. [20]
    Has Neogaf overtaken Resetera in terms of online traffic ... - Reddit
    Jul 1, 2024 · Neogaf seems to currently have just over 8500 visitors, whereas Resetera is trailing by roughly 1500...Missing: 2017 | Show results with:2017
  21. [21]
    neogaf.com Traffic Analytics, Ranking & Audience [September 2025]
    neogaf.com's audience is 80.62% male and 19.38% female. The largest age group of visitors are 25 - 34 year olds.Missing: statistics 2010s
  22. [22]
    What Happened To Gaming Forums? - YouTube
    Aug 30, 2024 · There used to be numerous gaming forums but they've all died out over time.<|separator|>
  23. [23]
    Terms and rules - NeoGAF
    Moderation Policy. A. Moderation of NeoGAF is not by democracy. All decisions with regards to thread closure and movement, permanent and temporary bans ...
  24. [24]
    So it begins, the great console battle of our time (moderation policy ...
    Mar 20, 2020 · In these select topics, moderation policy will be a bit more focused on removing members who are not on topic and instead derailing or trying ...Terms of Service | NeoGAFModerators: the new ban on social and political discourse - NeoGAFMore results from www.neogaf.com
  25. [25]
    NeoGAF Owner Confirms Previously Biased Moderation, Pushes for ...
    Jun 5, 2017 · Despite this prestige, NeoGAF's moderation team has long held a reputation for being biased, particularly in favor of progressive ideology ...
  26. [26]
    NeoGAF Owner Admits Identity Politics, Authoritarian Left Hostility ...
    Jan 25, 2018 · NeoGAF Owner Admits Identity Politics, Authoritarian Left Hostility, and Unfair Moderation Ruined its Community. by Brandon Orselli on ...
  27. [27]
    NeoGAF bans all talk of 'social issues' after founder is accused of ...
    Oct 24, 2017 · Banning all politics and social issues seems like an utterly misguided way to deal with being accused of sexual harassment.
  28. [28]
    Ban History - NeoGAF
    Ban History. Here you can see the latest site bans. User, Post, Given, Expires ... Calls for political violence. Minari, Oct 21, 2025, Nov 21, 2025, Yes, gaming ...Missing: issues 2017
  29. [29]
    Staff - NeoGAF Ban Review/Justice Project
    Jun 29, 2018 · In 2016 US election primaries season, it appears some bias entered the picture on the moderation team regarding pro-Hillary sentiment and anti- ...Role of moderation in gaming forums | Page 2 | NeoGAFStaff - New Moderation Transparency - Ban History Page - NeoGAFMore results from www.neogaf.comMissing: practices controversies
  30. [30]
    NeoGAF Has Gone Down After Mods Boycott The Popular Gaming ...
    Oct 22, 2017 · This was due to the fact that the owner of the forum (who we won't name) has allegedly sexually harassed a female some months ago (among other ...
  31. [31]
    Dyack: I posted on NeoGAF because it's “the worst forum” | VG247
    Aug 19, 2008 · Speaking to VG247, Silicon Knights boss Denis Dyack has spoken out about his public feud with NeoGAF, saying that he wanted to make an example ...
  32. [32]
    Influential gaming forum NeoGAF rejected from E3 - The Daily Dot
    May 21, 2014 · NeoGAF, the forum famous for breaking the latest information in the video game industry, has been rejected from attending E3 this year.
  33. [33]
    Ubisoft: Watch Dogs Day 1 Sales higher than any other Ubisoft title ...
    ... hick town so it was a little unexpected. I · imtehman. Banned. May 28, 2014 · #70. lol, dat neogaf effect. I · IdreamofHIME. Member. May 28, 2014 · #71.
  34. [34]
    Read Customer Service Reviews of www.neogaf.com - Trustpilot
    Rating 2.5 (10) NeoGAF has a 2.5 rating. Reviews describe it as terrible, with immature users, toxic moderators, and low discussion quality.
  35. [35]
    Community Article- NeoGAF & it's Bias, by Tim Dog | Rectify Gaming
    Sep 10, 2015 · It's a sad fact that the great forum formerly known as Gaming Age Forum (GAF) is forever overshadowed by NeoGaf. GAF was back in the wild ...Missing: origin | Show results with:origin
  36. [36]
    Are gaming forums less popular now than 10 years ago? (AKA why ...
    Jul 17, 2025 · But NeoGAF (and later Resetera) was always the exception. In the early-to-mid 2010s, as all the smaller forums died, GAF was one of the last ...
  37. [37]
    NeoGAF vs ResetEra: A Tale of Two Gaming Forums | JoyFreak
    May 14, 2023 · NeoGAF and ResetEra represent two distinct eras in the evolution of gaming forums. While NeoGAF has a longer history and a wider range of ...
  38. [38]
    Which one is better Neogaf or Resetera
    Apr 21, 2020 · Member. Resetera is more active and has a Steam thread. There are no reaction emojis but I still enjoy browsing it. Just stay out of anything ...Anybody else surprised how different ResetEra and NeoGAF became?Resetera reflects: This place sucks. We want GAF back. - NeoGAFMore results from www.neogaf.comMissing: comparison | Show results with:comparison
  39. [39]
    What was the issue that caused a massive exodus at ResetEra over ...
    Feb 10, 2022 · I've been a lurker, and occasional poster at ResetEra ever since the sit was founded in 2017 itself a product of a massive exodus fom NeoGAF.Missing: shutdown | Show results with:shutdown
  40. [40]
    I'm just gonna say it... ResetERA is a really good gaming forum
    Feb 21, 2023 · I joined NeoGAF back in 2012, and I enjoyed it there immensely. Era is nice, but I think GAF was better at its peak. It could be rose-tinted ...
  41. [41]
    That Time People Switched From One Social Media Site to Another
    Nov 5, 2022 · Another parallel: much like Twitter is on its way to becoming, NeoGAF quickly became a safe space for white supremacists and transphobes.
  42. [42]
    resetera.com vs neogaf.com Traffic Comparison - Similarweb
    resetera.com had more total visits compared to neogaf.com in September 2025. Total visits last 3 months.<|separator|>
  43. [43]
    Schreier/Bloomberg: That Time People Switched From One Social ...
    Nov 4, 2022 · Since then, ResetEra has replaced NeoGAF as the video game industry's go-to news aggregator and the place to capture the zeitgeist of the gaming ...<|separator|>
  44. [44]
    Can someone please explain as to how/why Neogaf and Resetera ...
    Jul 10, 2023 · The important thing to remember with Era is that at the end of the day it's just more NeoGAF. Most of the people are people who left NeoGAF, but ...Alternatives to Resetera : r/ResetEraInAction - RedditWhy did Resetera find it so easy to take so many of Neogaf's users ...More results from www.reddit.com
  45. [45]
    Welcome to the NeoGAF 2025 "OT" Update
    Apr 13, 2025 · Welcome to the NeoGAF 2025 "OT" Update We're happy you're here! There are a TON of new site features that we've been working on, ...[Dring] Newzoo 2025 Growth Report: Consoles 2.5%, Mobile 4.5 ...What do you think will happen next in the rest of 2025, in gaming?More results from www.neogaf.com
  46. [46]
    What's new | NeoGAF
    Latest threads ; Your top 10 most anticipated games of 2026? · 5 minutes ago ; Helldivers 2 PS5 Pro patch is coming soon · Today at 4:59 AM · News ; New Pokemon ...
  47. [47]
    NeoGAF, the Right-Wing's Gaming Forum, has killed it's Politics ...
    Apr 22, 2021 · Neogaf was a progressive gaming site (especially the off topic section) but when the site owner Evilore got Me-Too-ed, they were forced to unban all their ...How The Fuck Did NeoGAF Get So Brainwashed? : r/KotakuInActionThe state of Neogaf : r/Games - RedditMore results from www.reddit.com