Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Procedural knowledge

Procedural knowledge, often termed "knowing how," encompasses the ability to execute actions, perform skills, and apply methods to accomplish tasks or solve problems, typically acquired through practice and represented as sequences of operations or rules in cognitive models.^[1] This form of knowledge stands in contrast to declarative knowledge, which involves "knowing that"—the representation of facts, concepts, and propositions that can be explicitly stated and recalled.^[2] In cognitive science, procedural knowledge is frequently modeled as production rules—condition-action pairs that guide behavior automatically once compiled from initial declarative encodings.^[3] The distinction between procedural and declarative knowledge traces its philosophical roots to Gilbert Ryle's 1949 work The Concept of Mind, where he argued against an intellect-versus-action dichotomy, emphasizing practical abilities over mere theoretical understanding, though this distinction remains debated in contemporary philosophy between intellectualist and anti-intellectualist views; the modern psychological framework was formalized in John R. Anderson's 1983 ACT* theory of cognition.^[4] Anderson proposed that declarative knowledge serves as a precursor, which, through repeated use and tuning, transforms into efficient procedural knowledge via mechanisms like compilation, enabling faster and more automatic performance.^[5] This transition is central to understanding skill acquisition, as seen in domains like mathematics, where procedural fluency (e.g., executing algorithms for addition) emerges iteratively alongside conceptual understanding (e.g., grasping why the algorithm works).^[6] In educational contexts, procedural knowledge is vital for developing competence, particularly in procedural-heavy subjects like arithmetic or programming, where learners progress from effortful rule application to intuitive execution.^[7] Research highlights bidirectional relations: gains in procedural knowledge can enhance conceptual insights, while strong conceptual foundations facilitate more flexible procedural adaptations, countering rote learning pitfalls.^[1] Beyond education, procedural knowledge underpins expertise in cognitive architectures and artificial intelligence, informing models of human learning and intelligent tutoring systems that simulate production rule acquisition.^[8] Examples include motor skills like typing or driving, which become proceduralized over time, freeing cognitive resources for higher-level decision-making.^[9]

Core Concepts

Definition and Characteristics

Procedural knowledge, also known as "knowing how," refers to the ability to perform tasks or execute procedures effectively, typically demonstrated through practical action rather than verbal explanation.^[10] This form of knowledge encompasses the skills and routines required to accomplish specific activities, such as coordinating movements or applying step-by-step processes, and is often represented internally as production rules or sequences of actions in cognitive models.^[11] The concept traces its philosophical origins to Gilbert Ryle's 1949 work The Concept of Mind, where he distinguished "knowing how" from "knowing that," arguing that the former involves intelligent performance that cannot be fully reduced to factual propositions.^[12] Key characteristics of procedural knowledge include its non-propositional nature, meaning it is not easily articulated in declarative statements; its skill-based orientation, focusing on execution rather than description; and its implicit quality, where individuals may perform tasks competently without conscious awareness of the underlying steps.^[13] It is also context-dependent, adapting to situational demands, and generally develops through repeated practice, leading to increased automaticity over time.^[14] Subtypes of procedural knowledge include motor skills, which involve physical coordination; cognitive routines, such as mental strategies for problem-solving; and algorithms, which are formalized sequences for computational or logical tasks.^[15] Everyday examples illustrate its practical, performative essence: riding a bicycle relies on procedural knowledge of balance and pedaling without needing to explain the physics involved; tying shoelaces demonstrates fine motor sequencing acquired through habit; driving a car integrates perceptual-motor skills for navigation; playing a musical instrument requires coordinated finger movements and timing; and following a recipe entails sequential application of instructions in a kitchen setting.^[16] These instances highlight how procedural knowledge enables fluid, goal-directed behavior in real-world scenarios.^[10]

Distinction from Declarative Knowledge

Declarative knowledge, often termed "knowing that," encompasses factual and propositional information that can be explicitly stated and verbally articulated, such as knowing that Paris is the capital of France.^[4] This type of knowledge is stored in a conscious, retrievable form, allowing individuals to describe facts, definitions, or truths without necessarily demonstrating them through action.^[17] In contrast, procedural knowledge, or "knowing how," involves implicit skills and action-oriented abilities, such as riding a bicycle, which are manifested through performance rather than verbal explanation.^[4] While declarative knowledge is explicit and verbalizable, procedural knowledge is typically unconscious and resistant to forgetting once automatized, enabling fluid execution even if the underlying rules cannot be easily articulated.^[18] Declarative knowledge can be recalled but may not translate directly to application without additional procedural components, highlighting the boundary between mere awareness of facts and the capacity to act on them.^[19] Philosopher Gilbert Ryle, in his seminal work The Concept of Mind, critiqued intellectualist theories for erroneously reducing "knowing how" to a mere form of "knowing that," arguing that procedural knowledge is a primitive category irreducible to declarative propositions.^[20] Ryle contended that treating skills as disguised factual knowledge leads to a category mistake, as abilities like intelligent action cannot be fully captured by verbal descriptions alone.^[4] This distinction carries significant implications for epistemology and the philosophy of mind, challenging reductionist views that prioritize declarative forms as the foundation of all cognition.^[4] For instance, Noam Chomsky's critique of behaviorism in language acquisition underscores how innate procedural mechanisms enable creative language use beyond rote learning of factual associations, resisting explanations that conflate skills with accumulated declarative knowledge.^[21]

Acquisition and Development

In Human Ontogeny

Procedural knowledge begins to emerge in human infants during the sensorimotor stage of cognitive development, as described by Jean Piaget, where basic skills are acquired through sensory experiences and motor actions rather than verbal instruction. Around 3 to 6 months of age, infants develop initial procedural abilities, such as coordinating hand-eye movements to grasp objects, marking the transition from reflexive to intentional actions.^[22]^[23] This grasping skill, initially a palmar reflex that evolves into voluntary reaching by 4 months, exemplifies early procedural memory formation, enabling infants to manipulate their environment without conscious awareness of the underlying steps.^[24] Empirical studies from the 1990s, including longitudinal observations of sensorimotor coordination, confirm that these foundational procedures solidify through repeated trial-and-error interactions, laying the groundwork for more complex skills.^[25] In childhood and adolescence, procedural knowledge refines through everyday activities like play and formal schooling, transitioning from gross motor skills to integrated cognitive procedures. Motor milestones, such as walking, typically begin around 12 months and become automatized by age 2, allowing children to navigate varied terrains with increasing efficiency, as evidenced by Karen Adolph's longitudinal research on infant locomotion from the late 1980s to 2000s.^[26] Cognitively, basic arithmetic routines—such as counting on fingers or applying addition algorithms—emerge between ages 5 and 7, becoming fluent through practice and supporting higher mathematical reasoning.^[2] These developments highlight a shift toward procedural automaticity, where skills like handwriting or simple problem-solving sequences are executed with minimal cognitive effort by adolescence, driven by maturational changes and environmental exposure.^[27] During adulthood, procedural knowledge remains relatively stable throughout adulthood, with skills like driving or professional routines performed fluidly due to consolidated memory traces.^[28] In aging, while complex procedures may decline due to neurodegenerative processes, simpler habits often remain intact; for instance, studies on Parkinson's disease patients show preserved retention of overlearned motor sequences, such as habitual walking patterns, despite impairments in new learning.^[29] This relative preservation of procedural memory contrasts with steeper declines in declarative recall, underscoring its robustness across the lifespan.^[30] Cross-cultural variations influence procedural milestones, with universal patterns like grasping and walking emerging similarly worldwide, yet environmental factors accelerate certain skills in specific contexts. In hunter-gatherer societies, children exhibit tool-use proficiency—such as wielding sticks for play or foraging—due to greater opportunities for independent exploration.^[31] Longitudinal cross-cultural research from the 2000s, including Adolph's comparative studies, reveals that childrearing practices, like swaddling or floor time, can shift motor development timelines by months without altering core procedural foundations.^[32]

Through Practice and Instruction

Procedural knowledge is often acquired through deliberate practice, which involves structured, goal-oriented repetition combined with immediate feedback to refine skills toward expertise. According to Ericsson et al. (1993), deliberate practice differs from mere repetition by focusing on specific aspects of performance that require improvement, often under the guidance of a teacher or coach, leading to superior skill development in domains such as music and chess.^[33] For instance, in their study of violinists, elite performers had accumulated approximately 10,000 hours of deliberate practice by age 20, far exceeding that of less accomplished peers, illustrating how sustained, feedback-driven repetition builds procedural proficiency.^[33] Instructional strategies further facilitate procedural knowledge acquisition by providing structured support that aligns with learners' capabilities. Vygotsky's concept of the zone of proximal development (ZPD) posits that learners can master complex procedures with guidance from more knowledgeable others, gradually internalizing skills through scaffolding techniques such as modeling demonstrations and prompting. This approach is evident in educational settings where tasks are broken into subtasks—for example, teaching surgical procedures by first demonstrating each step, then allowing supervised practice—enabling progressive buildup of procedural competence. Complementing this, Bandura's social learning theory emphasizes observational modeling, where individuals acquire procedures by imitating observed behaviors, as demonstrated in his experiments showing that children learned aggressive actions through watching adult models. Various learning types contribute to procedural development, including trial-and-error, which allows refinement through iterative attempts and error correction, and simulation-based training that replicates real-world scenarios safely. In aviation, flight simulators enable pilots to practice emergency procedures repeatedly without risk, improving response accuracy and decision-making under pressure. However, barriers such as high cognitive load can hinder progress; Sweller's cognitive load theory highlights how excessive demands on working memory during complex procedural learning impede acquisition, recommending instructional designs that minimize extraneous load to facilitate transfer to novel contexts. Motivation serves as a key facilitator, enhancing persistence in practice, while poor transfer often arises from context-specific training without generalization strategies. In modern vocational training programs, techniques like spaced repetition—reviewing procedures at increasing intervals—have proven effective for skill enhancement. Studies from the 2010s, such as those applying spaced repetition in professional development, report improvements in skill retention and performance compared to massed practice, particularly in fields like healthcare and technical trades.^[34] More recent studies from the 2020s, including applications in medical school preparation and radiology training, continue to demonstrate the effectiveness of spaced repetition for long-term retention of procedural skills.^[35]^[36] This method counters forgetting curves by reinforcing procedural memory over time, making it a cornerstone of efficient training protocols.

Neural and Cognitive Mechanisms

Brain Structures and Processes

Procedural knowledge relies on a network of subcortical brain structures, with the basal ganglia playing a central role in habit formation and action sequencing. The basal ganglia facilitate the gradual acquisition and execution of skills through parallel loops involving the cortex, thalamus, and striatum, enabling the consolidation of repetitive behaviors into automatic routines.^[37] The cerebellum contributes to procedural learning by supporting motor coordination and error correction, particularly in fine-tuning timing and precision during skill acquisition.^[38] Within the basal ganglia, the striatum is key for reward-based procedural learning, integrating sensory inputs with motivational signals to reinforce adaptive sequences.^[39] Neuroimaging studies provide robust evidence for these structures' involvement. Functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) research from the 1990s onward demonstrates that as procedural tasks automatize with practice, activation decreases in prefrontal regions while subcortical areas like the basal ganglia and cerebellum show sustained or enhanced engagement, reflecting a shift from effortful control to implicit execution.^[40] Classic cases of amnesia, such as patient H.M., who suffered bilateral hippocampal damage, reveal preserved procedural memory despite profound declarative deficits; H.M. improved on mirror-tracing tasks over sessions without recalling prior practice, underscoring the independence of procedural systems from hippocampus-dependent fact storage.^[41]^[42] Positron emission tomography (PET) scans in similar amnesic patients confirm intact basal ganglia and cerebellar activity during skill learning, further dissociating procedural from declarative pathways.^[43] Dopamine modulates these processes by reinforcing procedural habits via midbrain projections to the striatum, where phasic signals encode prediction errors to strengthen rewarded action sequences.^[44] Synaptic plasticity in basal ganglia circuits, particularly long-term potentiation (LTP) at corticostriatal synapses, underlies the enduring changes that support habit formation, with repeated stimulation enhancing synaptic efficacy in medium spiny neurons.^[45]^[46] Pathological conditions highlight these mechanisms' specificity. In Huntington's disease, degeneration of the basal ganglia, especially the striatum, leads to profound procedural deficits, such as impaired sequence learning and motor habit formation, even in early stages when declarative memory remains relatively spared.^[47]^[48] Autism spectrum disorder often involves atypical procedural learning, with functional magnetic resonance imaging showing altered basal ganglia-cerebellar connectivity that disrupts generalization of skills and adaptation to novel contexts.^[49]^[50] Evolutionarily, procedural knowledge mechanisms are highly conserved across mammals, evident in rodents' maze navigation tasks where basal ganglia and cerebellar circuits enable implicit route learning akin to human tool use, suggesting deep phylogenetic roots for habit-based adaptation.^[39]^[51]

Activation and Automaticity

Procedural knowledge is typically activated through contextual cues and environmental stimuli that trigger well-learned sequences of actions with minimal conscious effort. For instance, an experienced driver automatically shifts gears in response to changes in road speed and engine sound, relying on situational prompts rather than deliberate planning.^[52] This activation occurs via consistent stimulus-response mappings stored in long-term memory, where relevant nodes are rapidly engaged without taxing working memory capacity.^[53] The development of automaticity in procedural knowledge progresses through stages from controlled processing, which is effortful and serially executed, to autonomous processing, which becomes habitual and parallel. According to Schneider and Shiffrin's model, controlled processing demands attention and is capacity-limited, while automatic processing emerges after extensive consistent practice, allowing involuntary activation of response sequences.^[53] This transition is often measured using dual-task paradigms, where automaticity is indicated by minimal performance decrement on the primary procedural task during concurrent cognitive demands, reflecting reduced interference as skills become effortless.^[54] Automaticity confers benefits such as enhanced efficiency in multitasking and reduced cognitive load, enabling individuals to allocate attention to higher-level goals while executing routine procedures.^[55] However, it also poses risks, including resistance to modification and the persistence of maladaptive habits, such as ingrained poor posture during prolonged sitting, which can lead to errors or inflexibility in changing environments.^[55] Measurement techniques like reaction time studies and error rate analyses further quantify this, as seen in research on expert typists where skilled performance demonstrates substantial automatic keypress activation, minimizing conscious intervention.^[56] Factors influencing the activation and maintenance of procedural knowledge include sleep consolidation, which strengthens memory traces through targeted reactivation during non-REM sleep, improving subsequent recall and execution.^[57] Acute stress, in contrast, generally exerts limited negative effects on procedural recall compared to declarative memory, though high levels may disrupt performance under novel conditions.^[58] These processes are enabled by brain regions such as the basal ganglia, which support the shift to habitual responding.^[53]

Interactions with Other Knowledge Forms

Integration with Declarative Knowledge

Procedural knowledge integrates with declarative knowledge through complementary cognitive systems, where factual information stored in declarative memory guides the selection, initiation, and refinement of action sequences managed by procedural memory. This synergy is central to Michael Ullman's declarative/procedural (DP) model, which posits that declarative memory, reliant on temporal lobe structures, provides the contextual facts necessary to activate and modulate procedural representations in frontal-subcortical circuits.^[59] For instance, in driving, declarative knowledge of traffic rules—such as yield signs or speed limits—initializes the appropriate procedural routines for maneuvering a vehicle, ensuring safe and contextually appropriate execution.^[59] Real-world examples illustrate this integration across domains. In language processing, declarative memory encodes vocabulary and exceptions (e.g., irregular verbs like "go-went"), while procedural memory applies grammatical rules to generate fluent speech or comprehension, allowing seamless combination for effective communication.^[60] Similarly, in mathematical problem-solving, declarative recall of formulas (e.g., the quadratic equation) directs the procedural steps of algebraic manipulation, enabling efficient computation beyond rote application.^[19] These interactions highlight how declarative inputs initialize procedural chains, creating hybrid cognitive processes that enhance performance in skilled tasks. Feedback loops further strengthen this integration, as outcomes from procedural execution update declarative stores, refining future interactions. For example, in learning a sport like basketball, initial declarative understanding of rules (e.g., fouls or positioning) informs procedural practice of techniques such as dribbling or shooting; repeated play then generates feedback that bolsters both rule comprehension and skill automatization.^[61] Empirical evidence from skill acquisition studies supports these hybrid traces, with 2010s fMRI research on mathematical learning revealing overlapping activations in declarative (hippocampal) and procedural (basal ganglia) regions during transition from novice to expert performance.^[62] Behavioral experiments on perceptual categorization also demonstrate mutual influences, where declarative strategies can enhance procedural learning without full independence.^[63] Despite these synergies, limitations arise from potential conflicts between systems, particularly in novel situations where declarative knowledge may override entrenched procedural habits to enable adaptation. In emergencies, such as an unexpected road hazard during driving, declarative awareness of safety protocols (e.g., evasive actions) can interrupt automatic procedural steering, preventing maladaptive responses but risking momentary inefficiency. This override mechanism, while adaptive, underscores the DP model's observation that procedural rigidity can hinder flexibility without declarative intervention.^[59]

Role in Cognitive Models

Procedural knowledge plays a central role in dual-process theories of cognition, which posit two distinct systems for information processing. System 1 is characterized as fast, intuitive, and automatic, relying heavily on procedural knowledge to enable quick, effortless responses based on learned routines, while System 2 involves slower, deliberate, and reflective thinking that draws more on declarative knowledge for analysis and reasoning. This framework, as articulated by Daniel Kahneman, highlights how procedural knowledge dominates in situations requiring expertise, where skilled individuals bypass reflective deliberation in favor of habitual, procedural actions to achieve efficiency. For instance, expert chess players or musicians exhibit System 1 dominance through procedural mastery, allowing superior performance without conscious effort. In connectionist models, procedural knowledge is represented as distributed patterns of activation across neural networks, simulating how skills emerge from interconnected nodes rather than explicit rules. The ACT-R cognitive architecture, developed by John R. Anderson starting in 1983, exemplifies this by modeling procedural knowledge through production rules that compile over time, transforming declarative facts into efficient, chunked procedures for tasks like problem-solving. This approach underscores procedural compilation, where repeated practice refines knowledge into automaticity, mirroring human learning in computational simulations. Embodied cognition theories further integrate procedural knowledge by emphasizing its grounding in sensorimotor experiences, which shape abstract thought through metaphorical mappings. George Lakoff's conceptual metaphor theory illustrates how procedural actions, such as grasping or navigating, provide the experiential basis for understanding abstract concepts like comprehension ("grasping an idea") or progress ("moving forward"), linking bodily procedures to higher cognition. This perspective argues that procedural knowledge is not isolated but embedded in physical interactions, facilitating the extension of concrete skills to symbolic reasoning. Critiques of procedural knowledge's role in cognitive models often revolve around debates between modularity and integration. Jerry Fodor's modularity hypothesis suggests cognitive processes, including procedural ones, operate in domain-specific modules isolated from central reasoning, contrasting with integrationist views that emphasize seamless interplay across knowledge types. Recent evolutions in the 2020s incorporate Bayesian inference into procedural adaptation, modeling how procedural routines update probabilistically based on environmental cues, enhancing flexibility in dynamic contexts like habit formation. Applications of these models extend to simulating real-world phenomena, such as habits in addiction, where procedural knowledge reinforces compulsive behaviors through automated loops in connectionist frameworks, or decision-making under uncertainty, where dual-process interactions predict biases in risk assessment. These simulations demonstrate procedural knowledge's explanatory power in pathological and adaptive cognition, informing interventions that target automaticity.

Applications Across Disciplines

In Artificial Intelligence

In artificial intelligence, procedural knowledge is represented through structured mechanisms that encode sequences of actions or rules for task execution. Early approaches in expert systems utilized production rules, which are conditional statements of the form "if-then" to capture heuristic decision-making processes. For instance, the MYCIN system, developed in the 1970s at Stanford University, employed over 500 production rules to diagnose bacterial infections and recommend antibiotic therapies, enabling backward chaining inference to simulate expert procedural reasoning.^[64] Similarly, scripts and schemas in knowledge bases provide templated representations of stereotyped event sequences, facilitating the modeling of dynamic interactions in domains like natural language understanding or planning. These structures allow AI systems to anticipate and execute procedural flows, such as dialogue scripts in conversational agents.^[65] In machine learning, procedural knowledge manifests implicitly through learned policies and generative algorithms. Procedural content generation in video games, exemplified by No Man's Sky released in 2016, relies on deterministic algorithms to create vast, explorable universes, including planets, flora, and fauna, by applying noise functions and parameter mappings to produce varied yet coherent procedural outcomes.^[66] In reinforcement learning, policies derived from value and policy networks encode procedural strategies as sequences of actions optimized for rewards; AlphaGo, developed by DeepMind in 2016, learned such policies through self-play, generating move sequences that defeated human champions by implicitly representing Go-playing procedures without explicit rule encoding beyond game basics.^[67] A key challenge in AI is encoding tacit procedural knowledge, which involves intuitive, context-dependent skills difficult to formalize explicitly, leading to gaps in systems reliant on symbolic or data-driven representations. Hybrid architectures address this by integrating procedural and declarative knowledge; the SOAR cognitive architecture, originating from Carnegie Mellon University in the 1980s and continually refined, uses production rules for procedural execution alongside declarative chunks for factual recall, enabling chunking mechanisms to learn new procedures from problem-solving experience.^[68] Recent advances as of 2025 leverage large language models (LLMs) to generate procedural content via chain-of-thought (CoT) prompting, where models decompose complex tasks into intermediate reasoning steps, effectively simulating procedural sequences for planning and problem-solving. The original CoT method, introduced in 2022, significantly improved LLM performance on arithmetic and commonsense reasoning benchmarks by eliciting step-by-step procedures.^[69] In 2025, researchers introduced new procedural memory frameworks to enable cheaper, more resilient AI agents capable of retaining and applying learned procedures across tasks.^[70] In robotics, imitation learning has advanced procedural acquisition through demonstration, as seen in DARPA-sponsored challenges like the Robotics Challenge (2012–2015), which spurred developments in learning manipulation sequences from human teleoperation, evolving into modern behavioral cloning techniques for tasks in unstructured environments.^[71] Despite these progresses, AI representations of procedural knowledge exhibit brittleness in novel environments, where trained policies fail to generalize due to overfitting to specific training distributions, as observed in reinforcement learning agents collapsing under distributional shifts. Ethical concerns also arise in autonomous procedural decisions, particularly in self-driving cars, where algorithms must resolve dilemmas like prioritizing passengers versus pedestrians, raising issues of accountability and fairness in real-time action selection. Frameworks for ethical AI in vehicles emphasize principles such as harm minimization and transparency to mitigate biases in procedural rule-setting.^[72]^[73]

In Education and Psychology

In educational frameworks, procedural knowledge is prominently featured in Bloom's revised taxonomy, where it forms one of the four dimensions of knowledge alongside factual, conceptual, and metacognitive types.^[74] This dimension encompasses skills, algorithms, techniques, and methods for performing tasks within a discipline, aligning particularly with the cognitive process levels of "apply" (executing procedures) and "analyze" (breaking down processes).^[75] The original taxonomy, developed in 1956, emphasized cognitive objectives but laid the groundwork for integrating procedural elements, while the 2001 revision by Anderson and Krathwohl explicitly incorporated them to guide instruction.^[74] These classifications have implications for curriculum design, promoting hands-on activities such as simulations and problem-solving exercises to foster procedural competence rather than rote memorization.^[76] Psychological research on expertise highlights how procedural knowledge manifests differently between novices and experts, often through chunked representations in memory. In a seminal study, Chi et al. (1981) examined physics problem-solving and found that experts categorize problems based on underlying principles and procedures, forming larger, integrated chunks of knowledge, whereas novices rely on surface features and smaller, fragmented units.^[77] This difference underscores procedural knowledge's role in efficient recall and application, with experts demonstrating automated procedural sequences that novices lack, enabling superior performance in domain-specific tasks. Such findings from expertise research inform psychological models of skill acquisition, emphasizing deliberate practice to build these procedural structures over time.^[78] Assessment methods for procedural knowledge prioritize performance-based evaluations to capture skill execution, contrasting with multiple-choice formats suited to declarative knowledge. Portfolios, simulations, and direct observations allow learners to demonstrate applied procedures in context, providing insights into proficiency and transferability that static tests cannot.^[79] For instance, in medical or engineering education, scenario-based assessments evaluate procedural steps like surgical techniques, revealing gaps in hands-on application.^[80] Multiple-choice questions, while effective for assessing factual recall, often fall short for procedural evaluation unless designed to simulate decision-making sequences.^[81] In psychological interventions, procedural knowledge is facilitated through structured routines, as seen in cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT) for anxiety disorders. CBT incorporates procedural elements such as exposure hierarchies and behavioral experiments, teaching patients step-by-step techniques to confront fears and reframe responses, thereby building habitual skills for symptom management.^[82] These routines enhance procedural automaticity, reducing reliance on anxious declarative thoughts over time.^[83] Regarding neurodiversity, research identifies procedural strengths in dyslexia, particularly in visuo-spatial processing, where individuals often excel at mentally rotating objects and navigating three-dimensional spaces—skills underrepresented in traditional assessments focused on verbal tasks.^[84] This highlights gaps in coverage, as dyslexia's procedural advantages in holistic pattern recognition can inform tailored therapeutic and educational supports.^[85] Current trends in the 2020s emphasize immersive technologies like virtual reality (VR) for training procedural skills in fields such as medical education. VR simulations enable repeated, risk-free practice of procedures like chest tube insertion, improving technical proficiency and confidence among learners compared to traditional methods.^[86] Studies show VR enhances procedural retention and transfer to real scenarios, with randomized trials demonstrating superior skill acquisition in procedural tasks.^[87] However, equity issues persist, as access to such practice opportunities remains uneven, disproportionately affecting low-income and underrepresented students who lack resources for hands-on or technology-enhanced learning.^[88] Addressing these disparities requires inclusive policies to ensure broad participation in procedural development activities.^[89]

In Law and Industry

In intellectual property law, trade secrets often protect procedural knowledge, encompassing methods, techniques, and processes that derive economic value from secrecy, as defined under the Uniform Trade Secrets Act (UTSA) of 1985, which includes formulas, programs, devices, and processes not generally known or readily ascertainable. For instance, the Coca-Cola Company's formula is safeguarded as a trade secret, emphasizing the procedural aspects of its production and mixing techniques rather than a mere list of ingredients, allowing indefinite protection without public disclosure. In contrast, patents protect declarative knowledge, such as detailed inventions or compositions, requiring full public revelation in exchange for a limited-term monopoly, whereas trade secrets suit ongoing procedural know-how that is difficult to reverse-engineer, like manufacturing protocols. This distinction enables firms to strategically choose trade secret protection for tacit procedural elements that could be compromised by patent disclosure requirements. In industrial settings, procedural knowledge manifests in manufacturing procedures, such as lean production techniques that optimize workflows through iterative skill-based adjustments rather than codified instructions. Toyota's Production System exemplifies this through tacit skill transfer, where experienced workers impart procedural expertise via on-the-job mentoring and problem-solving routines, fostering continuous improvement without formal documentation. Knowledge management in such firms relies on these transfers to maintain competitive edges, as procedural elements like just-in-time assembly are embedded in employee practices and protected as trade secrets to prevent replication by competitors. Disclosure of procedural knowledge in business transactions is governed by non-disclosure agreements (NDAs), which are standard in mergers and acquisitions to shield confidential processes, such as proprietary operational methods shared during due diligence. These agreements outline handling procedures, duration of secrecy, and remedies for breaches, ensuring procedural information remains protected post-transaction. Landmark case law, including Kewanee Oil Co. v. Bicron Corp. (1974), affirmed that state trade secret protections against misappropriation—such as unauthorized use of confidential processes—do not conflict with federal patent law, allowing remedies like injunctions and damages for breaches involving procedural know-how obtained through fiduciary relationships or improper means. In employee contexts, non-compete clauses restrict skilled workers from disclosing or utilizing procedural knowledge gained through training when joining competitors, addressing risks in industries where tacit skills form core value. In 2024, the U.S. Federal Trade Commission (FTC) attempted to implement a nationwide ban on non-compete agreements, but the rule was blocked by federal courts, and the FTC abandoned its appeal in September 2025, leaving enforceability to state laws.^[90] Such clauses remain enforceable under state regulations if reasonable in scope, duration, and geography, particularly for roles involving specialized processes, as they mitigate the transfer of proprietary methods that could harm former employers. Training investments in procedural skills, however, face challenges from knowledge flight, where employee turnover in tech industries leads to significant losses; studies indicate that 94% of employees would stay longer at a company that invests in their career development, underscoring the need for retention strategies to preserve procedural expertise amid high mobility.^[91] Contemporary applications highlight procedural knowledge in the gig economy, where workers like Uber drivers accumulate tacit route optimization techniques—such as timing pickups based on traffic patterns and surge pricing—through experiential learning, often unprotected by traditional IP but vulnerable to platform algorithms that standardize practices. In biotechnology, intellectual property protections increasingly emphasize trade secrets for procedural elements like cell culturing methods or purification processes, which complement patents by shielding iterative improvements that maintain secrecy in competitive R&D environments, as seen in pharmaceutical firms defending against theft in licensing disputes.

References

[1]
[PDF] Conceptual and Procedural Knowledge of Mathematics: Does One ...
We define procedural knowledge as action sequences for solving problems. These two types of knowledge lie on a continuum and cannot always be separated ...
[2]
[PDF] conceptual and procedural knowledge in learning - Dr. Robert Siegler
We define procedural knowledge as action sequences for solving problems. In ... neys in the field of developmental psychology. Demonstrating that young.
[3]
[PDF] Acquisition of Procedural skills from examples - ACT-R
In this article, we report research on the acquisition of procedural skills and their origins in declarative memory for examples. Many research efforts have ...
[4]
Knowledge How - Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Dec 4, 2012 · Better, then, to define procedural knowledge as the knowledge that is manifested in the performance of a skill. Declarative knowledge, on the ...
[5]
[PDF] Problem Solving and Learning
The ACT* theory of cognition (Anderson, 1983) makes a distinction between declarative knowledge, which en- codes our factual knowledge, and procedural knowledge ...
[6]
[PDF] Developing Conceptual Understanding and Procedural Skill in ...
Conceptual and procedural knowledge develop iteratively, with increases in one type leading to increases in the other, triggering new increases in the first.<|control11|><|separator|>
[7]
[PDF] Conceptual and Procedural Knowledge: A Framework for Analyzing ...
Procedural knowledge on the other hand, is 'knowing how' or the knowledge of the steps required to attain various goals” (p. 777). Later, Rittle-Johnson and ...
[8]
[PDF] Cognitive Tutors: Lessons Learned - John R. Anderson ... - ACT-R
What is problematical is acquiring the procedural knowledge that enables this inert knowledge to become the basis for effective action in the context of use.<|control11|><|separator|>
[9]
[PDF] Conceptual Knowledge, Procedural Knowledge, and Metacognition
We propose that when solving routine problems, students are more likely to recruit conceptual knowledge if their procedural knowledge is weak than if it is ...
[10]
Introduction - ACT-R
Procedural knowledge basically specifies how to bring declarative knowledge to bear in solving problems. Declarative knowledge in ACT-R is represented in ...
[11]
ACT: A simple theory of complex cognition. - APA PsycNet
In the Adaptive Character of Thought (ACT-R) theory, complex cognition arises from an interaction of procedural and declarative knowledge.Citation · Abstract · Copyright
[12]
The Concept of Mind, Ryle, Dennett - The University of Chicago Press
The book The Concept of Mind, Gilbert Ryle is published by University of Chicago Press ... Knowing How and Knowing That 1. Foreword 2. Intelligence and ...
[13]
Procedural Knowledge - an overview | ScienceDirect Topics
Procedural knowledge is defined as knowledge about how to perform specific tasks or procedures, represented as a series of steps or instructions that guide ...Representation and Modeling... · Procedural Knowledge in...
[14]
Unconscious knowledge: A survey - PMC - PubMed Central - NIH
More than a skill (that is, at a deeper level), procedural knowledge is a set of procedures, instructions, even algorithms, or just structures or patterns that ...
[15]
Procedural Memory - an overview | ScienceDirect Topics
Procedural memory is classified as non-declarative and is further subdivided into motor (simple) and cognitive (complex) procedural memory, depending on the ...
[16]
Procedural Memory In Psychology: Definition & Examples
Apr 19, 2025 · Procedural knowledge involves “knowing how” to do things. It included skills such as “knowing how” to play the piano, ride a bike, tie your ...<|control11|><|separator|>
[17]
Knowledge How - Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Apr 20, 2021 · One possesses this knowledge when one can be truly described as knowing how to do something: play the piano, make a pie, walk, speak, create, build, and so on.
[18]
Declarative Knowledge - Writing Commons
Declarative Knowledge involves knowing that something exists (definitional knowledge) or is true or false (propositional knowledge). Synonyms: Conceptual ...
[19]
(PDF) Declarative Versus Procedural Knowledge - ResearchGate
Mar 11, 2024 · Relatedly, declarative (or explicit) knowledge is conscious, while procedural knowledge is generally unconscious. ... Linguistic Currents in ...
[20]
Declarative & Procedural Knowledge | Definition & Examples - Lesson
Procedural knowledge is being aware of the steps needed to complete a task or a job, such as writing code. What is an example of procedural knowledge?
[21]
Procedural knowledge - Oxford Reference
The English philosopher Gilbert Ryle (1900–76) argued in The Concept of Mind (1949) that it cannot be reduced to declarative knowledge of facts. See also ...
[22]
Review of B. F. Skinner's Verbal Behavior - Chomsky.info
I had intended this review not specifically as a criticism of Skinner's speculations regarding language, but rather as a more general critique of behaviorist (I ...Missing: declarative | Show results with:declarative
[23]
Sensorimotor Stage of Cognitive Development - Simply Psychology
Jun 16, 2025 · When It Happens: Babies start showing initial signs of grasping cause and effect between 4 to 8 months. This understanding deepens and becomes ...Missing: procedural | Show results with:procedural
[24]
The Sensorimotor Stage of Cognitive Development - Verywell Mind
Piaget chose to call this stage the 'sensorimotor' stage because it is through the senses and motor abilities that infants gain a basic understanding of the ...Missing: procedural | Show results with:procedural
[25]
Infant development: Milestones from 4 to 6 months - Mayo Clinic
From ages 4 to 6 months, babies become more aware of their surroundings. Infant development milestones include rolling over, clapping hands and babbling.Missing: procedural | Show results with:procedural
[26]
Towards a developmental cognitive science. The ... - PubMed
The data show that young human infants can detect equivalences between information picked up by different sensory modalities.
[27]
[PDF] Change in action: how infants learn to walk down slopes
Adolph, K.E. (1997). Learning in the development of infant locomotion. Monographs of the Society for Research in Child. Development, 62 (3, Serial No. 251) ...Missing: procedural | Show results with:procedural
[28]
Enhancing young children's arithmetic skills through non-intensive ...
Procedural counting knowledge is defined as children's ability to perform an arithmetic task (for example, being successful in determining the number of objects ...Missing: routines | Show results with:routines
[29]
Normal Cognitive Aging - PMC - PubMed Central - NIH
Examples of procedural memory include remembering how to tie a shoe and how to ride a bicycle. Unlike declarative memory, nondeclarative memory remains ...
[30]
Intact Acquisition and Short-Term Retention of Non-Motor ...
People with Parkinson's disease (PD) have been found to acquire motor adaptation, a form of motor procedural learning, similarly to healthy older adults.
[31]
Cognitive Changes Associated with Normal Aging | Neupsy Key
Jul 14, 2016 · To summarize, aging is associated with a decline in declarative short-term and long-term memory, particularly for new episodic information. This ...
[32]
Hunter-Gatherer Children's Object Play and Tool Use
May 11, 2022 · Keywords: object play, tool use, hunter-gatherers (foragers), cross-cultural, childhood. Introduction. While many species use tools (Sanz et ...
[33]
WEIRD Walking: Cross-Cultural Research on Motor Development
Recent evidence shows that cultural differences in daily childrearing practices can explain accelerated and delayed onset ages relative to WEIRD norms.Missing: tool hunter- gatherer
[34]
The role of deliberate practice in the acquisition of expert performance.
The role of deliberate practice in the acquisition of expert performance. Citation. Ericsson, K. A., Krampe, R. T., & Tesch-Römer, C. (1993).
[35]
(PDF) Spaced Repetition Promotes Efficient and Effective Learning
Spaced review or practice enhances diverse forms of learning, including memory, problem solving, and generalization to new situations. Spaced practice is a ...
[36]
The contribution of the basal ganglia and cerebellum to motor learning
Apr 3, 2023 · We conclude that the cortex-basal ganglia loop learns via a novelty-based motor prediction error to determine concrete actions given a desired ...Fig 4. Basal Ganglia... · Central Pattern Generator · Results
[37]
A Process-Oriented View of Procedural Memory Can Help Better ...
Within non-declarative memory, the basal ganglia based system is responsible for the learning and storage of cognitive, motor and perceptual habits and skills ...
[38]
[PDF] What are the computations of the cerebellum, the basal ganglia and ...
The cerebellum is specialized for supervised learning, the basal ganglia for reinforcement learning, and the cerebral cortex for unsupervised learning.<|control11|><|separator|>
[39]
The Neural Correlates of Motor Skill Automaticity
Jun 1, 2005 · Automaticity was achieved within 2-4 h of training on both sequences. A number of regions showed decreased activation after training, including ...Materials And Methods · Results · Discussion
[40]
The Legacy of Patient H.M. for Neuroscience - PMC - NIH
HM is probably the best known single patient in the history of neuroscience. His severe memory impairment, which resulted from experimental neurosurgery to ...Missing: PET | Show results with:PET
[41]
scope of preserved procedural memory in amnesia - Oxford Academic
Abstract. The finding that patients with amnesia retain the ability to learn certain procedural skills has provided compelling evidence of multiple memory.
[42]
Neural basis of procedural memory - ResearchGate
Aug 6, 2025 · Neuroimaging studies found that motor-type procedural memory is situated in multiple brain regions, including the basal ganglia, cerebellum and ...
[43]
FROM REINFORCEMENT LEARNING MODELS OF THE BASAL ...
This approach has produced explicit models of the roles of dopamine and cortico-basal ganglia-thalamo-cortical (CBGTC) loops in learning about reinforcers ( ...
[44]
Synaptic plasticity in the basal ganglia - PubMed
Apr 12, 2009 · This review focuses on synaptic plasticity in the corticostriatal pathway. As in other systems, both long-term potentiation and long-term ...Missing: procedural | Show results with:procedural
[45]
Striatal Plasticity and Basal Ganglia Circuit Function - Cell Press
Synaptic plasticity in the striatum is thus well-suited for regulating basal ganglia circuit activity. Cell Type, Abundance, Rinput, Vrest, Axonal ...
[46]
Procedural learning is impaired in Huntington's disease
The purpose of the study was to test the hypothesis that Huntington's disease (HD) is associated with impairment of procedural learning.
[47]
Changes in striatal procedural memory coding correlate with ... - PNAS
May 16, 2011 · Changes in striatal procedural memory coding correlate with learning deficits in a mouse model of Huntington disease. Sebastien Cayzac ...
[48]
Atypical Learning in Autism Spectrum Disorders: A Functional ...
To investigate the neural mechanisms underlying impairments in generalizing learning shown by adolescents with autism spectrum disorder (ASD).
[49]
Atypical cognitive training-induced learning and brain plasticity and ...
Aug 3, 2023 · Our study uncovers atypical cognitive and neural mechanisms underlying learning in children with ASD, and informs pedagogical strategies for nurturing ...
[50]
Procedural Memory in Rodents and Humans - Maze Engineers
Mar 19, 2020 · Learn about procedural memory in rodents and humans, including how it is measured and diseases and drugs that affect it.Missing: conservation | Show results with:conservation
[51]
Studying human habit formation through motor sequence learning
May 6, 2025 · Conversely, habitual behavior, such as shifting gears while driving, is performed automatically without thinking about alternative ...
[52]
[PDF] Automatic detection, consistent mapping, and training* Originally ...
The important question is what gives rise to a controlled or an automatic process. Schneider and Shiffrin's (1977; Shiffrin & Schneider, 1977) answer to the.
[53]
Dual-task automatization: The key role of sensory–motor modality ...
Dec 28, 2017 · To probe for automaticity, we used a transfer psychological refractory period (PRP) procedure: Participants were first trained on a visual task ...Missing: techniques | Show results with:techniques
[54]
(PDF) The Perils of Automaticity - ResearchGate
Thus, developing automaticity or carrying out activities automatically has both benefits (such as efficiency, speed, and effortlessness, and hence productivity ...
[55]
Automatic Keypress Activation in Skilled Typing.
The first aim of the current research was to provide empirical evidence for the assumption that letters can automatically activate the corresponding keypresses ...Experiment 1 · Experiment 2 · Experiment 3<|separator|>
[56]
Strengthening procedural memories by reactivation in sleep - PubMed
There is robust evidence that sleep facilitates procedural memory consolidation. The exact mechanisms underlying this process are still unclear.
[57]
Does Acute Stress Impact Declarative and Procedural Learning?
Mar 25, 2020 · It is well established that acute stress can influence memory function, yet its influence may differ across memory systems.
[58]
Contributions of memory circuits to language: the declarative ...
The declarative/procedural (DP) model claims that the mental lexicon of memorized word-specific knowledge depends on the largely temporal-lobe substrates of ...
[59]
Declarative/ Procedural Model - Brain and Language Lab
The declarative/procedural (DP) model simply posits that language learning, storage, and use depend heavily on declarative and procedural memory.
[60]
Analysis of Declarative and Procedural Knowledge According to ...
Analysing declarative and procedural knowledge in sport makes it possible to evaluate the students' acquisitions in the learning process.
[61]
Phases of learning: How skill acquisition impacts cognitive processing
Aug 6, 2025 · This fMRI study examines the changes in participants' information processing as they repeatedly solve the same mathematical problem.
[62]
Interactions between Declarative and Procedural-Learning ... - NIH
Two experiments tested whether declarative and procedural memory systems operate independently or inhibit each other during perceptual categorization.
[63]
Interactions between declarative and procedural-learning ...
Two experiments tested whether declarative and procedural memory systems operate independently or inhibit each other during perceptual categorization.
[64]
The epistemology of a rule-based expert system - ScienceDirect.com
Production rules are a popular representation for encoding heuristic knowledge in programs for scientific and medical problem solving.
[65]
[PDF] Knowledge Representation
Mar 6, 2025 · A script is a structured representation describing a stereotyped sequence of events in a particular context. ○ Scripts are used to organize ...
[66]
The algorithms of No Man's Sky - Rambus
May 17, 2016 · 'No Man's Sky' is built around a procedurally generated deterministic open universe that contains a staggering 18.4 quintillion planets.
[67]
[PDF] Mastering the Game of Go without Human Knowledge
Here, we introduce an algorithm based solely on reinforcement learning, without hu- man data, guidance, or domain knowledge beyond game rules. AlphaGo becomes ...
[68]
[PDF] Introduction to the Soar Cognitive Architecture1 - arXiv
May 8, 2022 · In Soar, agent behavior is driven by the interaction between the contents of working memory, which describe the agent's current goals, situation ...
[69]
Chain-of-Thought Prompting Elicits Reasoning in Large Language ...
Jan 28, 2022 · Chain-of-thought prompting uses a series of intermediate reasoning steps to improve complex reasoning in large language models. It uses ...Missing: procedural knowledge 2023-2025
[70]
Robotic Manipulation via Imitation Learning: Taxonomy, Evolution ...
Aug 24, 2025 · Beyond cataloging, we trace the chronological evolution of imitation learning techniques within robotic manipulation policies (RMPs), ...Missing: DARPA | Show results with:DARPA<|control11|><|separator|>
[71]
Procedural Memory Is Not All You Need - arXiv
May 6, 2025 · Large language models excel at generating fluent procedural outputs but often falter when faced with dynamic, “wicked” environments that ...
[72]
Ethical frameworks for automated vehicles: a systematic analysis ...
Aug 22, 2025 · These include: (i) respect for human autonomy, (ii) prevention of harm, (iii) fairness, and (iv) explicability. Within this framework and the ...
[73]
[PDF] Anderson and Krathwohl Bloom's Taxonomy Revised | Quincy College
Procedural Knowledge refers to information or knowledge that helps students to do something specific to a discipline, subject, or area of study. It also ...
[74]
Bloom's Taxonomy of Learning | Domain Levels Explained
Mar 11, 2025 · Bloom's Taxonomy is a widely recognized hierarchical framework used by educators to classify and structure educational objectives according to their complexity ...
[75]
Bloom's Taxonomy - The University of Utah
Jun 12, 2024 · ... Procedural Knowledge of processes and methods of theories and problems, and Metacognitive Knowledge of learning strategies and processes.
[76]
[PDF] Categorization and Representation Physics Problems by Experts ...
Experts abstract physics principles, while novices base their representation on literal features. Experts and novices start with different problem categories.
[77]
2 How Experts Differ from Novices | How People Learn
... (Chi et al., 1981). Experts' problem piles are arranged on the basis of the principles that can be applied to solve the problems; novices' piles are arranged ...
[78]
[PDF] Performance-Based Assessment in the Classroom | Jay McTighe
This approach may be used for assessing declarative knowledge and procedural proficiency. In addition, constructed-responses can provide in- sight into ...
[79]
Avoiding Assessment Mistakes That Compromise Competence and ...
Dec 19, 2005 · Most of the listed (procedural) objectives mapped better to scenario-based multiple choice or performance assessments, not simple (declarative) ...Learning Assessments In The... · Serious Mistakes · The Wrong Type
[80]
Assessing declarative and procedural knowledge using multiple ...
May 22, 2013 · To exemplify, declarative knowledge MCQs typically promote surface learning, whereas procedural knowledge MCQs are capable of promoting deep ...
[81]
Cognitive-Behavioral Treatments for Anxiety and Stress-Related ...
Jun 17, 2021 · CBT uses specific techniques to target unhelpful thoughts, feelings, and behaviors shown to generate and maintain anxiety.Missing: procedural | Show results with:procedural
[82]
Elucidating the process-based emphasis in cognitive behavioral ...
CBT helps clients to identify, test, and critically evaluate negative beliefs and distortions. •. Between-session homework (BSH) promotes healthy variation, ...
[83]
Dyslexia and Visuospatial Processing Strengths: New Research ...
Children with dyslexia were faster, but no less accurate on the visuospatial task. The subjects with dyslexia also were slower and less accurate on reading ...
[84]
Dyslexia linked to talent: Global visual-spatial ability - ScienceDirect
This finding suggests that dyslexia is associated with a particular type of visual-spatial talent—enhanced ability to process visual-spatial information ...
[85]
Immersive Virtual Reality Simulation for Medical Student Procedural ...
Apr 10, 2025 · In a previous randomized controlled trial, we found immersive virtual reality (VR) simulation to be effective for teaching procedural skills to medical ...Missing: 2020s | Show results with:2020s
[86]
Virtual Reality Training Improves Procedural Skills in Mannequin ...
Apr 10, 2025 · Adding VR simulation to online learning improved technical skills and confidence in medical students learning chest tube insertion.Missing: 2020s | Show results with:2020s
[87]
Equitable Access and Opportunity - Learning Policy Institute
Research-informed policies and practices that support access and opportunity for all students include the following:Missing: procedural knowledge
[88]
Equity and Access in Math Education | EdSurge News
Apr 21, 2023 · Black and Latino students are more likely to experience mathematical learning that focuses on procedural knowledge and rote rehearsal.