Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Royal Rainmaking Project

The Royal Rainmaking Project is a Thai weather modification program initiated by King Bhumibol Adulyadej in November 1955 to mitigate droughts impacting agriculture, employing cloud seeding methods that achieved initial success on 20 July 1969.^[1]^[2] Operated under the Department of Royal Rainmaking and Agricultural Aviation within the Ministry of Agriculture and Cooperatives, the initiative uses fleets of specialized aircraft to release hygroscopic agents like calcium chloride or glaciogenic substances such as silver iodide into convective clouds, aiming to enhance precipitation over targeted areas.^[3]^[4] By 1977, operations had scaled to multiple teams conducting regular missions across drought-prone regions, contributing to reported benefits including stabilized crop yields for rain-fed farmers—who constitute a significant portion of Thailand's agricultural sector—and replenishment of hydroelectric reservoirs.^[3]^[5] Peer-reviewed experiments, such as those involving warm-cloud hygroscopic seeding, have demonstrated increased rainfall from seeded versus unseeded clouds, though overall program efficacy in substantially alleviating large-scale droughts remains debated due to challenges in isolating causal effects amid natural variability.^[4]^[6]^[7] The project received a patent in 2001 for its rainmaking innovations and has influenced international weather modification efforts, underscoring its role in Thailand's applied scientific development despite persistent questions about long-term environmental impacts and cost-effectiveness.^[8]^[9]

Origins and Historical Development

Initiation and Early Conceptualization

On November 14, 1955, King Bhumibol Adulyadej traveled through the drought-afflicted Isan region of northeastern Thailand, observing vast expanses of parched farmland and distressed rural communities dependent on erratic rainfall for agriculture.^[10]^[8] Despite noticing clouds overhead with apparent humidity and temperature conducive to precipitation, no rain fell, which led the king to question why natural processes could not be augmented to induce rainfall reliably.^[10] This firsthand encounter with water scarcity, affecting over 82 percent of Thailand's rain-fed agricultural lands at the time, marked the genesis of the Royal Rainmaking Project as a royal initiative aimed at addressing chronic droughts through deliberate atmospheric intervention rather than passive reliance on seasonal patterns.^[1] The king's conceptualization emphasized manipulating identifiable physical conditions—such as cloud formation and condensation nuclei—to replicate the causal chain of natural rainfall, drawing on observable meteorological principles without presupposing advanced foreign technologies.^[8] He personally directed initial studies into cloud modification techniques, recognizing that seeding clouds with suitable agents could lower the threshold for droplet coalescence and precipitation in humid but unproductive skies.^[11] This approach prioritized domestic empirical investigation over imported models, as the king allocated private funds and existing national aviation resources for preliminary theoretical modeling and desktop analyses of atmospheric dynamics.^[3] Early proposals outlined a trial-and-error framework to test hypotheses on rain induction, focusing on scalable methods to enhance water availability for farmers while avoiding dependency on unpredictable monsoons.^[12] Between 1955 and the late 1960s, these efforts involved the king's oversight of small-scale simulations and data collection on cloud physics, laying the intellectual foundation for engineered precipitation without external aid, as Thailand's agricultural economy demanded self-reliant solutions to recurrent dry spells.^[3]^[12] This phase underscored a commitment to verifiable causation in weather patterns, setting the project apart from folklore-based rituals by grounding it in replicable scientific inquiry.^[8]

First Experiments and Expansion

The inaugural experiment of the Royal Rainmaking Project occurred on July 20, 1969, when dry ice flakes were dispersed from light aircraft into cloud clusters over Khao Yai National Park, marking the first operational cloud seeding flight directed by King Bhumibol Adulyadej.^[8]^[13] This trial targeted convective clouds to stimulate precipitation amid recurring droughts affecting Thai agriculture, with the seeding aimed at enhancing ice crystal formation in supercooled water droplets.^[1] Initial observations noted rainfall following the operation, prompting continued trials to refine targeting and dispersal methods.^[14] Subsequent experiments from 1969 to 1972 expanded operations across drought-prone regions, driven by petitions from farmers unable to transplant rice seedlings due to water shortages.^[8] In 1973, King Bhumibol evaluated these efforts, identifying three procedural steps for rainmaking: cloud selection, seeding agent delivery, and post-operation monitoring, which informed iterative improvements in aircraft coordination and dosage rates.^[8] By the mid-1970s, operations scaled to multiple provinces, incorporating hygroscopic materials like sodium chloride for seeding warm, low-altitude clouds prevalent in Thailand's tropical climate, complementing dry ice for colder cumulonimbus formations.^[15] Governmental response to escalating demand culminated on September 21, 1975, with a royal decree establishing the Royal Rainmaking Research and Development Institute to systematize operations and address widespread agricultural shortfalls.^[3] This formalization enabled broader deployment of seeding fleets during dry seasons, linking early successes in localized rainfall induction to reduced drought impacts in petitioned areas without yet institutionalizing nationwide protocols.^[3]

Evolution into a National Program

Following the initial trials in 1969, empirical successes in drought mitigation prompted formal institutionalization. In 1972, rainmaking operations increased water levels in Bhumibol Dam by 620 million cubic meters, demonstrating potential for reservoir replenishment amid variable monsoon patterns.^[8] By 1974, operations across 16 drought-affected provinces facilitated a 55% rise in rice transplanting over 17 million rai of farmland, correlating with reduced crop losses verifiable through agricultural output records.^[8] These outcomes, tied to targeted cloud seeding rather than coincidental weather, justified expanded resource commitment, as initial ad-hoc efforts transitioned to structured response mechanisms driven by observed yield protections. Rising farmer petitions for interventions—reflecting growing reliance on the project amid recurrent dry spells—led to the government's establishment of the Royal Rainmaking Research and Development Institute (RRRDI) in 1975 under the Ministry of Agriculture and Cooperatives.^[3] This marked the shift from experimental phases to a national framework, with annual petition volumes escalating due to proven efficacy in water augmentation, enabling systematic allocation of aircraft and personnel. Response protocols prioritized empirical indicators like soil moisture deficits and dam levels, integrating rainmaking into broader agricultural resilience strategies without supplanting natural rainfall dependencies. By the 1990s, adaptations incorporated agricultural aviation capabilities, extending operations to aerial pesticide dispersal for pest outbreaks alongside rain enhancement, thereby addressing compounded threats to harvests.^[3] The 1992 formation of the Bureau of Royal Rainmaking and Agricultural Aviation formalized this dual mandate, with subsequent upgrades to departmental status in 2013 enhancing operational scale through regional bases. Such evolution stemmed from causal links between early verifiable gains—such as dam refills supporting irrigation for staple crops—and policy prioritization, fostering sustained funding independent of short-term political cycles.^[8]

Organizational Structure

Establishment of the Department of Royal Rainmaking and Agricultural Aviation

The Department of Royal Rainmaking and Agricultural Aviation was formally established on September 21, 1975, via a Royal Decree under the Ministry of Agriculture and Cooperatives, centralizing previously fragmented rainmaking efforts into a dedicated institute focused on research, development, and operational coordination.^[3] This institutionalization responded to escalating drought impacts on Thai agriculture and increasing petitions for rain induction, prioritizing self-sufficiency in aviation assets and technical expertise to sustain nationwide cloud seeding without reliance on foreign procurement.^[3] The department's governance model, rooted in the royal initiative of King Bhumibol Adulyadej, emphasized streamlined, monarchy-overseen administration to avoid inefficient state expansion, enabling rapid scaling of operations through in-house aircraft modification and personnel training programs for pilots and ground technicians.^[3] By fostering domestic capabilities, it reduced dependency on external support, aligning with broader goals of agricultural resilience in a monsoon-dependent economy. In coordinating fleets, the department managed a growing inventory, reaching 24 dedicated aircraft by 2024 supplemented by six from the Royal Thai Air Force for peak operations, facilitating missions across Thailand's 77 provinces.^[16] Operational metrics underscore this scale: annual flights typically number in the thousands, with 1,673 missions executed in 2019 alone, targeting coverage in drought-prone areas without unsubstantiated claims of precipitation enhancement.^[17] This framework supported empirical monitoring of flight hours and seeding deployments, prioritizing verifiable logistics over unproven efficacy metrics.

Operational Framework and Resources

The Department of Royal Rainmaking and Agricultural Aviation coordinates operations through five primary centers located in Chiang Mai, Nakhon Sawan, Khon Kaen, Rayong, and Surat Thani, supplemented by additional units to cover Thailand's 77 provinces during peak seasons.^[18]^[16] These centers integrate ground-based monitoring, including weather radar and generator sites for alternative seeding, to support aerial missions dependent on the presence of seedable clouds.^[19] Operations typically commence when meteorological forecasts indicate convective cloud formations suitable for enhancement, with missions prioritizing drought-affected agricultural zones identified through local provincial requests and hydrological assessments.^[8]^[20] The fleet comprises approximately 24 department-owned aircraft, including 11 Cessna 208 Caravan turboprops, seven CASA models, two Beechcraft Super King Air, and two CN-235 transports, often augmented by six Royal Thai Air Force jets such as BT-67s for nationwide coverage.^[21]^[22] These fixed-wing platforms handle seeding flights, with ground crews managing logistics like fuel, flares, and post-mission data collection, though activities remain constrained by seasonal cloud scarcity, limiting flights to viable windows between March and May or during monsoons.^[21] Human resources include around 71 specialized pilots trained for low-level cloud penetration, alongside technicians and meteorologists, underscoring the program's reliance on skilled personnel amid operational risks.^[18] A notable hazard materialized on September 24, 2019, when a Cessna Caravan crashed in Kanchanaburi province due to adverse weather, killing the pilot and trainee and highlighting vulnerabilities in flight safety during turbulent seeding conditions.^[23] Budgetary allocations for the department totaled 2,173.5 million baht in fiscal year 2023, funding aircraft maintenance, seeding materials, and expanded operations, with supplemental requests like 4 billion baht in 2023 for El Niño contingencies reflecting adaptive resource strains.^[24]^[25] These finances prioritize pragmatic deployment, yet persistent weather dependencies often reduce mission efficacy, as unsuitable atmospheric conditions can ground fleets for extended periods.^[18]

Technical Methods

Cloud Seeding Techniques Employed

The Royal Rainmaking Project utilizes two principal cloud seeding methodologies: glaciogenic seeding for colder clouds and hygroscopic seeding tailored to Thailand's prevalent warm, convective cloud systems in tropical conditions. Glaciogenic seeding introduces ice-nucleating agents such as silver iodide (AgI) or dry ice (solid CO₂) into supercooled clouds, where temperatures range from 0°C to -20°C, to facilitate heterogeneous ice crystal formation through epitaxial growth on the nucleating particles, thereby accelerating the Bergeron-Findeisen process of vapor diffusion from liquid droplets to ice crystals and subsequent precipitation. Hygroscopic seeding, more commonly applied in the project's operations due to the region's maritime tropical climate, disperses soluble salts like calcium chloride (CaCl₂) or sodium chloride (NaCl) into warm clouds above 0°C; these agents absorb ambient water vapor, promoting the coalescence of cloud droplets via enhanced collision efficiency and gravitational settling, which fosters larger raindrop formation without relying on ice-phase processes.^[6]^[4]^[26] Operational procedures commence with cloud identification and selection using ground-based radar, satellite imagery, and real-time meteorological observations to target developing cumulus or stratiform clouds exhibiting sufficient vertical extent, updraft velocities exceeding 3-5 m/s, and moisture profiles conducive to nucleation. Seeding aircraft, typically modified crop-dusters or specialized platforms, then ascend to optimal release altitudes—often 1,000-3,000 meters for warm clouds—and dispense agents directly into cloud bases or updrafts at rates such as 21 kg/km per pass for CaCl₂ flares or pyrotechnic burners for AgI, ensuring dispersion into regions of high supersaturation for maximal particle activation. The process incorporates sequential phases: initial "agitation" via hygroscopic flares to stimulate convective uplift and droplet formation; "fattening" through additional glaciogenic or hygroscopic dosing to enlarge cloud mass and prolong precipitation; and, where feasible, "cloud moving" by repeated seeding to influence wind patterns or direct enhanced outflows toward target areas.^[26]^[4]^[27] Post-seeding monitoring involves continuous radar tracking of echo evolution, rain gauge networks for fallout patterns, and atmospheric soundings to assess changes in cloud microphysics, such as increased radar reflectivity indicating droplet growth, though these observations serve diagnostic rather than evaluative purposes in technique execution. Adaptations for Thailand's seasonal monsoons and agricultural demands include integrating seeding sorties with fertilizer dispersal flights for operational efficiency, leveraging the same aircraft fleet to minimize logistical overhead while targeting rain-deficient rice paddies or reservoirs. Ground-based generators occasionally supplement aerial methods by releasing AgI smoke plumes into inflow layers for broader coverage in stratified conditions.^[15]^[28]

Materials, Equipment, and Procedures

The Royal Rainmaking Project employs hygroscopic and glaciogenic agents tailored to warm and cold cloud types prevalent in Thailand's tropical climate. For warm cloud seeding, primary materials include sodium chloride (NaCl) for initial nucleation, calcium chloride (CaCl₂) for cloud growth enhancement, and urea for precipitation initiation, often dispensed as fine powders in quantities scaled to cloud volume, such as approximately 21 kg of CaCl₂ per kilometer of seeding pass.^[4]^[8] Cold cloud seeding utilizes silver iodide (AgI) flares to promote ice crystal formation at temperatures between -8°C and -12°C, supplemented by dry ice (solid CO₂ at -78°C) for cooling and nucleation in mixed-phase clouds.^[8]^[12] Additional endothermic agents like calcium oxide and exothermic ones such as ammonium nitrate may be selected based on real-time atmospheric conditions to optimize droplet coalescence or evaporation suppression.^[8] Equipment consists primarily of modified fixed-wing aircraft adapted from agricultural spraying models for precise agent dispersal. Key types include single-engine Porter PC-6/B2-H2 (payload 500-550 kg), Cessna Caravan (700-800 kg), twin-engine Casa C-212 (1,200 kg), CN235-220 (2,000-2,500 kg), and research-oriented Super King Air 350B, alongside helicopters such as Bell 206B, 412 EP, and 407 series for lower-altitude operations.^[8] Modifications feature underwing flares for AgI release, powder dispensers for hygroscopic salts, and dry ice hoppers with regulated ejection mechanisms to ensure even dispersion patterns, typically conducted at altitudes from 1,000 ft above cloud base to 21,500 ft, with safety protocols including pilot training for turbulent updrafts and coordination via ground radar.^[8]^[12] Operational procedures follow a structured six-step sequence to target cumulus cloud development, beginning with atmospheric assessment via humidity (≥60% relative humidity) and wind patterns. Step 1 (triggering) disperses NaCl at 7,000-8,000 ft to initiate cloud formation; Step 2 (fattening) applies CaCl₂ at 8,000 ft to vertically expand clouds to 15,000-20,000 ft; Step 3 (attacking warm clouds) uses a "sandwich technique" releasing NaCl near cloud tops and urea 1,000 ft above the base for droplet collision enhancement.^[8]^[12] Step 4 (enhancing) introduces dry ice 1,000 ft below the base to cool air and reduce evaporation; Step 5 (attacking cold clouds) ignites AgI flares at 21,500 ft for ice nucleation; and Step 6 (super sandwich) integrates warm and cold methods simultaneously for intensified precipitation over target areas.^[8]^[12] Post-seeding verification involves deploying rain gauges in fixed target zones to measure accumulation and correlate with intervention timing, augmented by field observations from regional stations.^[8]^[29]

Scientific Principles and Evaluation

Underlying Meteorological Mechanisms

Cloud precipitation arises from the microphysical processes within clouds, where water vapor condenses onto aerosol particles serving as cloud condensation nuclei (CCN) to form liquid droplets, or deposits directly onto ice nuclei (IN) to form ice crystals in colder conditions.^[30] In natural clouds, the scarcity of effective nuclei can result in fewer, larger droplets that grow slowly via collision-coalescence in warm clouds (>0°C) or through the Bergeron-Findeisen process in mixed-phase clouds, where ice crystals grow at the expense of surrounding supercooled droplets before falling as precipitation.^[31] Cloud seeding targets these processes by introducing artificial nuclei to increase particle concentration, thereby accelerating droplet or crystal formation and enhancing the efficiency of precipitation release from existing atmospheric moisture.^[32] At the core of seeding efficacy lies heterogeneous nucleation theory, which posits that seeding agents lower the free energy barrier required for water vapor to condense or freeze onto particles, compared to homogeneous nucleation that demands extreme supersaturation levels.^[33] In glaciogenic seeding for supercooled clouds (typically -5°C to -20°C), materials like silver iodide (AgI) are used due to their crystallographic similarity to ice, facilitating ice embryo formation via deposition or immersion freezing modes, which then propagate through the cloud via secondary ice production mechanisms.^[34] Hygroscopic seeding, employed in warmer clouds, utilizes salts such as sodium chloride to attract water vapor, promoting the formation of larger droplets that more readily collide and coalesce into rain-sized particles.^[32] These interventions do not alter the thermodynamic state of the atmosphere but exploit kinetic limitations in natural nucleation rates, leading to more numerous but smaller initial particles that optimize fallout pathways.^[31] Seeding provides probabilistic enhancements to precipitation rather than deterministic control, amplifying the natural efficiency of moisture conversion in clouds that already possess sufficient vapor and updrafts, without generating water from absent sources.^[35] In dry or clear-sky conditions, where clouds lack the requisite supersaturation or liquid water content, seeding yields negligible effects, as the process cannot conjure moisture or force phase changes absent favorable meteorology.^[30] This underscores the causal dependency on preexisting atmospheric conditions, with seeding acting as a catalyst for microphysical pathways rather than a mechanism for wholesale weather manipulation.^[33]

Empirical Studies and Effectiveness Assessments

A randomized warm-cloud hygroscopic seeding experiment conducted in Thailand from 1995 to 1998 in the Bhumibol catchment area utilized a floating single-target design to assess rainfall enhancement, seeding semi-isolated convective clouds with calcium chloride particles near cloud base or top.^[4] Statistical analysis of seed versus no-seed cases revealed significant increases in rain mass, with seeding near cloud base yielding higher seed-no-seed ratios (up to 1.5-2.0 in precipitation efficiency metrics) compared to top seeding, attributed to enhanced droplet coalescence and raindrop formation rates.^[4] Physical evidence from radar and in-situ measurements corroborated these findings, showing prolonged cloud lifetimes and greater precipitation volumes in seeded clouds, with an estimated mean annual rainfall increase of approximately 23% in targeted areas.^[36] Parallel cold-cloud glaciogenic seeding trials in the same region from 1991 to 1998 employed randomized designs targeting supercooled clouds with silver iodide, measuring outcomes via radar-derived rainfall volumes and ground gauges while controlling for natural variability through crossover statistical models.^[37] These experiments demonstrated modest but detectable enhancements in precipitation, particularly in dynamic seeding modes that aimed to invigorate updrafts, though results varied with cloud type and atmospheric conditions, with seeding effects most pronounced in clouds exceeding 4 km in height.^[37] Evaluation metrics emphasized distribution accuracy, such as alignment of seeded rain with target zones (within 10-20 km radii), and accounted for seasonal monsoon influences via historical baselines, yielding seeding effects of 10-15% in favorable cases. Broader assessments of the Royal Rainmaking Project integrate these randomized data with operational monitoring, reporting targeted rainfall enhancements of 10-20% in agricultural zones during drought periods, though efficacy diminishes in cloud-scarce environments where natural convective activity is insufficient for seeding initiation.^[36] Global meta-analyses of cloud seeding, including hygroscopic and glaciogenic methods, present mixed results, with some reviews indicating statistical significance at the 5-10% level for precipitation augmentation under specific conditions, while others highlight challenges in isolating seeding signals from natural variability due to high spatiotemporal heterogeneity. Thai-specific evaluations prioritize rigorous randomization and physical process tracing over purely statistical targets, yet acknowledge that overall program success rates (e.g., 70-90% in operational flights) blend empirical gains with qualitative judgments on cloud availability.^[28]

Achievements and Impacts

Agricultural and Hydrological Benefits

The Royal Rainmaking Project has provided drought relief in rural Thailand since its inception in 1969, enabling farmers to maintain rice production and reduce crop losses during dry periods. Operations have targeted arid regions to induce rainfall for crop irrigation, particularly for water-intensive rice cultivation, which constitutes a major portion of Thailand's agricultural output. For instance, in 1974, rainmaking efforts across 16 northeastern provinces covered 17 million rai (approximately 2.72 million hectares), boosting rice transplanting rates by 55% of the total planting area and salvaging dry seedbeds to facilitate near-complete crop establishment.^[8] Such interventions have been credited with preventing widespread harvest disruptions in drought-prone areas, where natural rainfall deficits historically led to significant yield reductions.^[38] Hydrological benefits include augmented water storage in reservoirs and dams, supporting sustained irrigation and ancillary uses like hydropower. A notable example occurred in late 1972, when targeted seeding over the Bhumibol Dam catchment area increased its water volume by 620 million cubic meters and raised the reservoir level by 150 centimeters, thereby enhancing downstream water availability for agriculture.^[8] Similar outcomes were reported at the Ubonrat Dam in Khon Kaen province during 1971 operations, contributing to regional water reserves amid scarcity.^[8] In 1999–2000, the application of advanced "Super Sandwich" techniques mitigated drought impacts in the Chao Phraya and northern basins, averting shortages that could have curtailed irrigation supplies.^[8] These enhancements have been attributed to the project's ability to stimulate precipitation in upstream watersheds, directly bolstering reservoir inflows during critical low-water periods.^[39]

Economic and Broader Societal Effects

The Royal Rainmaking Project mitigates economic losses from droughts, which have inflicted damages reaching tens of billions of baht in severe cases; for instance, 2019 projections estimated up to 37 billion baht in agricultural impacts if dry conditions extended into September.^[40] By targeting rain induction during critical dry spells, the initiative stabilizes crop yields and rural incomes in Thailand's agriculture-heavy economy, where water scarcity disrupts harvests across millions of hectares.^[8] Empirical assessments of hygroscopic seeding experiments indicate rainfall enhancements of up to 46% in targeted warm-cloud systems, suggesting high potential economic returns through preserved productivity despite operational costs.^[9] Beyond agriculture, recent expansions include urban cloud seeding for pollution control, as in 2024 deployments over Bangkok to wash out PM2.5 particulates amid haze episodes that have generated over $139 million in public health expenses since late 2023.^[7]^[22] These efforts address externalities like reduced worker productivity and medical burdens in densely populated areas, though quantifiable mitigation gains remain tied to variable seeding efficacy.^[41] The project also bolsters energy security by replenishing reservoirs for hydroelectric generation, countering shortfalls in water storage that threaten power supply during prolonged dry seasons.^[10] Societally, it enhances rural resilience by sustaining farming viability in arid northeastern provinces, curbing income volatility and supporting community stability without reliance on ad-hoc relief.^[42] This fosters adaptive capacity against recurrent climate stressors, prioritizing causal interventions over reactive measures amid opportunity costs like aircraft maintenance and fuel expenditures.

Criticisms, Challenges, and Controversies

Debates on Efficacy and Statistical Evidence

Scientific evaluations of cloud seeding, including Thailand's Royal Rainmaking Project, face significant challenges in distinguishing anthropogenic effects from natural precipitation variability, as weather systems exhibit high inherent fluctuations that confound causal attribution without large-scale randomized controlled trials (RCTs). Critics argue that non-randomized historical data from the project's early phases (1955–1990s) lacked rigorous controls, leading to overclaims of efficacy based on correlative observations rather than probabilistic evidence. Even subsequent RCTs, such as the 1991–1993 exploratory cold-cloud experiments and the 1995–1998 warm-rain hygroscopic seeding trials in the Bhumibol catchment, reported potential precipitation enhancements of 10–20% in targeted storms, but these findings suffered from limited replication (fewer than 100 experimental units) and insufficient statistical power to rule out Type I errors amid regional variability.^[6]^[4]^[43] A 2003 National Academy of Sciences review underscored broader evidentiary gaps in cloud seeding literature, concluding that operational claims of reliable rainfall augmentation lack robust statistical support due to difficulties in achieving experimental isolation and replication under real-world conditions. In Thailand, while some analyses of Bhumibol trials indicated statistically significant increases in convective cloud rainfall (e.g., via dynamic seeding concepts), skeptics highlight persistent issues like seeding-target drift and unaccounted microphysical feedbacks, rendering effect sizes context-dependent and marginal (typically under 15%) rather than transformative. Analogous programs elsewhere reinforce scalability doubts; Australia's CSIRO ceased cloud seeding research in 1984 after trials failed to demonstrate consistent winter rainfall enhancements in plains regions, and Snowy Hydro permanently ended its Snowy Mountains operations in 2024 following a review that deemed costs (including silver iodide deployment) to outweigh uncertain benefits amid variable snowfall outcomes.^[44]^[45]^[46] Global assessments, including U.S. Government Accountability Office analyses, align on cloud seeding's potential for modest, opportunistic gains (5–15% in supercooled orographic clouds) but emphasize that efficacy hinges on precise meteorological windows, with natural variability often overwhelming seeded signals in statistical models. For the Royal Rainmaking Project, proponent-cited yield studies (e.g., maize increases post-seeding) provide indirect support but falter under scrutiny for omitting counterfactual baselines and yield confounders like soil moisture. Overall, while Thai RCTs offer suggestive evidence of localized enhancements under convective regimes, the scientific consensus views cloud seeding as yielding marginal, non-generalizable results, prompting calls for advanced radar integration and Bayesian modeling to bolster future verifiability rather than endorsing widespread operational expansion.^[47]^[48]

Environmental, Safety, and Operational Risks

The primary environmental concern associated with the Royal Rainmaking Project involves the use of silver iodide (AgI) as a seeding agent, which could theoretically accumulate in soil and water bodies over repeated applications, potentially affecting ecosystems. However, laboratory assessments of AgI exposure at concentrations expected from cloud seeding operations indicate low risk of acute toxicity to soil and plants, with no significant adverse effects observed under controlled conditions mimicking operational levels.^[49] Animal toxicity tests, including feeding sheep forage laced with AgI at 1,300 μg/kg for three months, have similarly shown no evidence of harm, underscoring that the insoluble nature of AgI limits bioavailability compared to more soluble silver compounds.^[50] Geochemical analyses further suggest that prior studies may overestimate risks by focusing on total silver rather than the bioavailable free silver ion, which remains negligible in seeded precipitation.^[51] Safety risks to personnel are evident in aviation incidents during seeding flights, as the project relies on low-level aircraft operations in variable weather. On September 24, 2019, a Cessna Caravan turboprop used for rainmaking crashed in Kanchanaburi province, killing instructor pilot Captain Trin Amranand, aged 58, and trainee pilot Suksan Sathientham, aged 28, with their bodies trapped in the wreckage during a training mission.^[52]^[53] Such accidents highlight hazards from engine failures or turbulent conditions inherent to dispersing agents into convective clouds. Additionally, unintended precipitation from seeding can exacerbate flooding in downstream or urban areas if operations coincide with saturated conditions, prompting protocols to suspend flights when reservoirs are full or severe thunderstorms are forecast.^[54] Operationally, the project's efficacy is constrained by meteorological prerequisites, rendering it ineffective during prolonged arid periods lacking seedable clouds, as seen in 2019 drought efforts in northern Thailand where insufficient cloud cover hampered deployments despite urgent needs.^[14] This dependency on existing convective activity limits reliability in extreme dry spells, while the resource-intensive nature— involving specialized aircraft, fuel, and chemical logistics—imposes ongoing financial burdens amid variable outcomes, though precise cost-benefit ratios remain project-specific and under-evaluated in public records.^[55]

Recognition and International Context

Domestic and Global Acknowledgments

The Thai Cabinet formally acknowledged King Bhumibol Adulyadej's role in developing the Royal Rainmaking Project by proclaiming him the Father of Royal Rainmaking in 2002 and designating November 14 as Father of Royal Rainmaking Day, commemorating the initiation of successful operations on that date in 1969.^[56]^[57] This recognition highlighted the project's empirical contributions to drought mitigation through verifiable cloud-seeding techniques adapted for tropical conditions.^[8] On the international stage, the EUREKA organization awarded King Bhumibol a gold medal in 2001 for the project's innovative rain induction methods, citing their global utility in enhancing precipitation for agriculture and water management.^[58] The World Meteorological Organization further validated Thailand's advancements by selecting the country to host its 7th Scientific Conference on Weather Modification in Chiang Mai in February 1999, an event that facilitated peer-reviewed discussions on seeding efficacy data from the project.^[8] These merits have prompted technology transfers to ASEAN neighbors, with Singapore adopting Thai hygroscopic seeding protocols in the early 2000s to combat urban water scarcity, demonstrating the project's adaptability and practical validation beyond symbolic praise.^[59] Such exports underscore endorsements rooted in operational success metrics, including increased rainfall yields documented in joint assessments, rather than unsubstantiated acclaim.^[8]

Influence on Other Weather Modification Efforts

The Royal Rainmaking Project served as a technical model for weather modification initiatives in other drought-prone Asian nations, particularly through direct advisory roles and technology transfer. In 2019, Thai experts from the project assessed cloud seeding feasibility in Sri Lanka, recommending operations under specific convective conditions suitable for warm-cloud seeding with hygroscopic agents like sodium chloride, akin to Thailand's methodology; however, Sri Lankan trials yielded limited success due to insufficient cloud bases and inadequate moisture, highlighting the challenges of direct emulation without adapting to local meteorology.^[60] Similarly, Thailand formalized a three-year expertise-sharing agreement with Indonesia in March 2021, focusing on operational protocols for precipitation enhancement in tropical environments, which emphasized scalable aircraft-based seeding over resource-intensive alternatives.^[61] The project's empirical outcomes, including randomized warm-cloud experiments demonstrating seed-to-no-seed precipitation ratios exceeding 1.5 when seeding near cloud base with calcium chloride, informed global adoption of targeted, low-altitude interventions rather than broad-scale geoengineering.^[4] These results, achieved at operational costs around USD 91 per square kilometer, underscored the viability of cost-effective techniques using domestically sourced flares and aircraft, influencing programs in Southeast Asia to prioritize warm-cloud physics over silver iodide for cold clouds, where efficacy remains debated in humid tropics.^[62] Through participation in international forums, the project contributed data and demonstrations to the World Meteorological Organization (WMO), with Thai specialists invited to lecture on hygroscopic seeding techniques across multiple countries, fostering discourse on verifiable enhancements limited to 10-20% under optimal conditions rather than transformative drought reversal.^[8] This exchange via WMO panels promoted evidence-based refinements, such as integrating radar verification, but also exposed overhyped expectations in emulations where baseline atmospheric data was lacking, as seen in variable Asian trials.^[63]

Recent Developments and Future Outlook

Contemporary Applications and Adaptations

In response to escalating droughts and urban air pollution exacerbated by climate variability, Thailand's Royal Rainmaking Project deployed 30 aircraft nationwide starting in February 2024 for cloud-seeding operations aimed at inducing rainfall to alleviate dry conditions and reduce PM2.5 levels in areas like Bangkok.^[22]^[64] These missions targeted intensified dry seasons, with longer periods of low relative humidity noted as a consequence of shifting weather patterns.^[65] To enhance targeting amid variable conditions, the project has incorporated prospects for artificial intelligence in weather forecasting and decision-making for seeding timing, improving operational precision over traditional methods.^[66] In 2025, operations responded to persistent drought risks with 2,065 flights conducted from February 23 to August 26 across 161 days, yielding rainfall in over 95% of missions and supporting agricultural resilience in drought-prone regions.^[67]^[68] These adaptations underscore the program's expansion to address immediate hydrological deficits and pollution, with Thailand leading global weather modification efforts by volume.^[69]

Ongoing Research and Potential Enhancements

In recent years, the Royal Rainmaking Project has incorporated experimental applications of cloud seeding techniques to address emerging challenges beyond traditional drought alleviation, such as urban air pollution. In January 2025, Thai authorities initiated trials in Bangkok deploying aircraft to spray cold water or dry ice into atmospheric inversion layers, aiming to cool warm air masses and induce localized precipitation to disperse PM2.5 particles. These operations represent an adaptation of core seeding methods—typically using silver iodide or hygroscopic salts—to target pollution inversions, with twice-daily flights conducted to evaluate precipitation's role in improving air quality. Critics, including atmospheric scientists, contend that such interventions may yield negligible long-term pollution reductions due to the transient nature of induced rainfall and underlying emission sources, underscoring the need for complementary pollution control measures.^[7] To strengthen empirical foundations, project affiliates are pursuing enhanced statistical rigor through international knowledge-sharing initiatives. Thailand hosted the ASEAN Regional Seminar on Weather Modification in 2024, facilitating discussions on advanced experimental designs, including randomized seeding protocols informed by prior Thai trials from the 1990s that tested hygroscopic particle effects in warm clouds. These past randomized experiments in the Bhumibol catchment demonstrated potential rainfall increases but highlighted variability requiring modern validation with improved radar and modeling integration. Ongoing collaborations aim to adapt such crossover designs—alternating seeded and control areas—to contemporary operations, potentially quantifying enhancements amid climate variability, though implementation details remain operational rather than purely experimental.^[70]^[4] Potential enhancements emphasize cost-effective and ecologically mindful innovations, such as transitioning to drone-delivered seeding agents to supplant manned aircraft, which currently dominate the program's 2,000+ annual flights. While specific drone trials within the project are not documented, global weather modification research indicates drones could enable precise, lower-emission dispersal of alternatives like refined calcium chloride flares, reducing silver iodide dependency and minimizing aerial fuel use. Nanoparticle-based nucleants, explored elsewhere for enhanced ice formation efficiency, offer theoretical promise for warm-cloud seeding but face unproven scalability and regulatory hurdles in Thailand's context.^[68]^[71] Prospectively, advancements prioritize hybrid strategies integrating seeding with natural hydrological engineering, acknowledging inherent limits in modifying chaotic atmospheric dynamics. Rather than over-reliance on chemical interventions, which statistical analyses suggest augment rainfall by at most 10-20% under optimal conditions, future protocols advocate coupling operations with watershed restoration, efficient irrigation, and predictive AI-driven forecasting to amplify drought resilience. This balanced approach aligns with causal understandings of precipitation as influenced by broader climatic forcings, tempering expectations of transformative yields from seeding alone.^[4]

References

[1]
Rain Making Project - a weapon against aridity : ฝนหลวง
May 30, 2024 · This project was initiated in November 1955 by H.M. King Bhumibol Adulyadej because over 82 percent of Thai agricultural land relied on rainfall ...
[2]
Royal Rainmaking Project - Witoon Chen - Prezi
The royal rainmaking project debuted on 20 July 1969 at his behest, when the first rainmaking attempt was made at Khao Yai National Park.
[3]
History of the Department - กรมฝนหลวงและการบินเกษตร
In 1977, the Royal Rainmaking operation was composed of four teams. Each team had three - four small aircrafts, and each aircraft consisted of three pilots and ...
[4]
Results of the Thailand Warm-Cloud Hygroscopic Particle Seeding ...
The seeding of warm convective clouds with calcium chloride particles produced more rain than was produced by their unseeded counterparts.
[5]
https://fukuoka.thaiembassy.org/en/content/the-king-and-the-cloud-the-story-behind-the-royal
[6]
Results of On-Top Glaciogenic Cloud Seeding in Thailand. Part I
Exploratory experimentation in 1991 and 1993 suggested increases in rainfall from seeding. A demonstration experiment followed in which the design was specified ...
[7]
Thailand trials unconventional 'cloud seeding' as air pollution ...
Jan 24, 2025 · But its effectiveness is open to question and scientists say it has been shown to only be marginally useful in creating rain and absorbing ...
[8]
[PDF] The Royal Rainmaking Story
In 2001, the Royal Rainmaking Project was granted a patent by the Department of Intellectual Property, Ministry of Commerce of Thailand and other organizations ...
[9]
Evaluating cloud seeding initiatives for sustainable water supply in ...
Thailand and Indonesia have also been using cloud seeding to increase rainfall for decades. In Thailand, cloud seeding has been successful in increasing ...
[10]
[PDF] The Royal Rainmaking Project
The project enables. Thai farmers to harvest without disruption, and to fill hydroelectric dams to help fulfill the increasing demand for electricity. In 2013, ...
[11]
The Royal Rain Maker - The BigChilli
Apr 15, 2020 · “I am very proud of working in the Royal Rainmaking Project because it is beneficial to all Thai people, no matter rich or poor.” Comments ...
[12]
[PDF] Update on Royal Rainmaking Project, Thai Embassy, 2017
History of His Majesty the King's initiative project Royal Rainmaking. Background of "the Royal Rainmaking Project". ".. At that time, I looked up at the sky ...<|separator|>
[13]
Father of Royal Rainmaking Day - Hua Hin Today
Dec 1, 2018 · The Royal Rainmaking Project was initiated in November 1955 by King Bhumibol Adulyadej. Thai farmers repeatedly suffered the effects of drought.<|separator|>
[14]
Royal rainmaking efforts hindered by lack of clouds - Facebook
Jul 17, 2019 · On July 20, 1969 Thai history was made with the first attempt at artificial rainmaking involving seeding a cluster of clouds with dry ice.
[15]
EP1491088B1 - Weather modification by royal rainmaking technology
The method involves dispersing condensation nuclei of hygroscopic chemicals into a volume of air to activate cloud formation and enrich newborn cloud.
[16]
Thailand deploys 30 rain-making jets to battle drought, pollution
Feb 29, 2024 · The operations in 2024 will rely on 24 aircraft from the Royal Rain-making Department and six jets from the Royal Thai Air Force, the government ...
[17]
The King and the Cloud – the story behind the Royal Rainmaking ...
Dec 3, 2020 · The project later manifested into the establishment of the Bureau of Royal Rainmaking and Agricultural Aviation in 1992 under the supervision ...Missing: evolution program
[18]
The gift that keeps on giving - Bangkok Post
Oct 13, 2019 · Artificial rainmaking remains a solution that Thailand can depend on to tackle the problem of air pollution and climate change-induced drought.
[19]
AGRICULTURAL COOPERATION PROJECT ON RAINMAKING ...
They learned about the Ground-based Generator (GBG technology) and observed its operation as an alternative method to the use of aircraft for rainmaking in ...
[20]
Thailand deploys rainmaking planes to battle drought, pollution
Mar 1, 2024 · The annual royal rainmaking program began on February 29, with seven centers set up across the country to coordinate efforts in all the 77 ...
[21]
24 planes of Royal Rainmaking Department, Air Force deployed to ...
Jul 21, 2019 · The department uses 11 Caravan planes, 7 Casa planes, two Super King Air planes and two CN-235 planes and the Air Force is deploying BT-67 ...
[22]
Thailand Deploys 30 Rainmaking Jets to Battle Drought, Pollution
Feb 29, 2024 · This year's operations will rely on 24 aircraft from the Royal Rainmaking Department and six jets from the Royal Thai Air Force, it said.
[23]
Aircraft for artificial rain-making operations crashes - Nation Thailand
Sep 24, 2019 · The Department of Royal Rainmaking and Agricultural Aviation reported that a Caravan aircraft crashed in Kanchanaburi at 10.10am during ...Missing: Project | Show results with:Project
[24]
[PDF] thailand's budget - in brief fiscal year 2023 - SIPRI
This document summarizes Thailand's FY 2023 budget, including estimated receipts, budget expenditures, and government finance, with four parts.
[25]
Royal Rain Dept seeks additional 4 bn baht to tackle El Nino
Aug 21, 2023 · Royal Rain Dept seeks additional 4 bn baht to tackle El Nino · The Department of Royal Rainmaking and Agricultural Aviation has proposed a plan ...
[26]
US20050056705A1 - Weather modification by royal rainmaking ...
The technology is developed to help people in Thailand and particularly those farmers who repeatedly face drought disasters due to variation and deviation of ...
[27]
Evaluation of Cloud Seeding in Thailand during 2018 to 2020 - ADS
The cloud seeding operation in Thailand are performed mainly for the purpose of rain enhancement and rain redistribution at the target areas.
[28]
[PDF] SCIENTIFIC BASIS OF WEATHER MODIFICATION
Jul 22, 2019 · Environmental effect of glaciogenic and hygroscopic seeding. 12. Cost/Benefit ratio of dry-ice pellet seeding to secure water resources for ...
[29]
[PDF] ( A Country Report)
They were trained on the proper use of the 8-inch rain gauge and on rainfall measurements. Daily observations are taken and collected from each of these ...
[30]
What is Cloud Seeding? - DRI - Desert Research Institute
Cloud seeding is a weather modification technique that improves a cloud's ability to produce rain or snow by introducing tiny ice nuclei into certain types of ...
[31]
Wintertime Orographic Cloud Seeding—A Review in - AMS Journals
The fundamental hypothesis underlying cloud seeding as a method to enhance precipitation from wintertime orographic cloud systems is that a cloud's natural ...
[32]
WMO Statement on Weather Modification
Hygroscopic seeding adds particles to the cloud with the intent to modify the number and size of liquid drops while glaciogenic seeding targets the number and ...
[33]
Precipitation formation from orographic cloud seeding - PNAS
Jan 22, 2018 · The intent of glaciogenic seeding of orographic clouds is to introduce aerosol into a cloud to alter the natural development of cloud particles ...
[34]
Cloud Seeding - an overview | ScienceDirect Topics
Glaciogenic cloud seeding is usually done by dispersing efficient ice nuclei, such as silver iodide particles or dry ice (solid carbon dioxide) into the cloud, ...
[35]
Planned Weather Modification through Cloud Seeding
There remain limits to the certainty with which desired changes in cloud behavior can be brought about using current cloud seeding techniques. Continued effort ...
[36]
Results of the Thailand Warm-Cloud Hygroscopic Particle Seeding ...
Aug 5, 2025 · The seeding was done by dispensing the calcium chloride particles at an average rate of 21 kg km1 per seeding pass into the updrafts of growing ...
[37]
Results of On-Top Glaciogenic Cloud Seeding in Thailand. Part I - jstor
ABSTRACT. Randomized, cold-cloud, rain-enhancement experiments were carried out during 1991–98 in the Bhumibol catchment area in northwestern Thailand.
[38]
[PDF] Royal Rainmaking Water scarcity
Since its birth in 1969, the Royal Rainmaking project continues to alleviate drought problem in Thailand's rural area enabling farmers to harvest without ...
[39]
The Royal Rainmaking - สถานเอกอัครราชทูต ณ กรุงพริทอเรีย
The Royal Rainmaking project continues to alleviate drought problem in Thailand's rural area enabling farmers to harvest without disruption.
[40]
Drought disaster initial damage estimated 10bn baht - Thailand
Aug 4, 2019 · The overall damage is expected to escalate to 37 billion baht should the drought extends to September, as the wet season rice cultivation cycle ...Missing: Royal savings
[41]
Ice in the sky: Thailand's fight against air pollution - Phys.org
Jan 24, 2025 · Critics argue there is little to no evidence that Thailand's attempts to reduce pollution by releasing icy water from the sky works. PTT did not ...
[42]
The Royal Rainmaking - Royal Thai Embassy, Doha
The Royal Rainmaking project continues to alleviate drought problem in Thailand's rural area enabling farmers to harvest without disruption.Missing: studies | Show results with:studies
[43]
Advances in the Evaluation of Cloud Seeding: Statistical Evidence ...
Sep 2, 2018 · In cloud seeding experiments in Thailand and Texas (the Unites States), it was reported that the precipitation increased within 3–12 hr ...
[44]
Dodging silver bullets: how cloud seeding could go wrong
Aug 11, 2022 · These limits are meant to ensure that cloud seeding doesn't cause flooding. However, broader governance systems designed to address potential ...Missing: probabilistic deterministic
[45]
A Critical Review of the Australian Experience in Cloud Seeding in
The static cloud-seeding hypothesis is not effective in enhancing winter rainfall in the plains area of Australia.<|control11|><|separator|>
[46]
Cloud Seeding - Snowy Hydro
2025 CLOUD SEEDING UPDATE: Following a comprehensive review, Snowy Hydro is permanently ceasing its cloud seeding program. This decision follows a review that ...
[47]
Cloud Seeding Technology: Assessing Effectiveness and Other ...
Dec 19, 2024 · Cloud seeding operations can only enhance precipitation when the right kind of clouds are present, which limits opportunities for success.Missing: probabilistic deterministic
[48]
[PDF] The Effect of Rainmaking Service on Maize, Cassava and ...
Since 1971, the Royal Rainmaking Project created by King Bhumiphol, the King of Thailand, has endeavored to alleviate these drought problems throughout the ...
[49]
Potential risk of acute toxicity induced by AgI cloud seeding on soil ...
Aug 9, 2016 · The aim of this study is to assess the risk of acute toxicity caused by AgI exposure under laboratory conditions at the concentration expected in the ...
[50]
[PDF] The toxicology of silver iodide in relation to its use as a cloud ... - DWS
Direct toxicity tests with silver iodide have been done on animals : Sheep fed with forage containing 1 300 ~g.kg-1. Agl for 3 months showed no evidence of ...
[51]
[PDF] Geochemistry and Impacts of Silver Iodide Use in Cloud Seeding
May 2, 2011 · Since the free silver ion is the toxic form of silver, these studies overestimate the actual toxicity of the measured silver concentration.
[52]
Thai rain-making aircraft crashes, 2 deaths - Xinhua | English.news.cn
Sep 24, 2019 · 24 (Xinhua) -- A rain-making single-engined turboprop crashed, killing the pilot and trainee pilot in western Thailand on Tuesday. Both were ...
[53]
Inquiry into fatal crash of rainmaking plane - Bangkok Post
Sep 25, 2019 · A full investigation is under way into the crash of a small plane owned by the Department of Royal Rainmaking and Agricultural Aviation whileMissing: Project | Show results with:Project
[54]
Royal rainmaking flights raising dam levels amid drought. As ...
Apr 26, 2016 · Their missions achieved a 76.9 percent success rate, increasing water in the dams ... “While Thailand's royal rainmaking was rooted in science, it ...Missing: refilling improvements
[55]
What will it take for people to stop believing in Cloud Seeding?
May 1, 2024 · Cloud seeding does work, it just takes longer than just a month sometimes especially when Thailand is less humid compared to it's neighbour. It ...Cloud seeding in Thailand to contain the smog and heavy pollutionWhy isn't cloud seeding used to fight the droughts currently ... - RedditMore results from www.reddit.comMissing: efficacy | Show results with:efficacy
[56]
KING BHUMIBOL'S PROJECTS, POLICIES, IDEAS AND AWARDS
Projects under royal patronage are ones operated by the private sector using its own financial, technical and human resources and based on His Majesty's advice ...Missing: budget | Show results with:budget
[57]
"The King and the Cloud – the story behind the Royal Rainmaking ...
The project enables Thai farmers to harvest without disruption, and to fill hydroelectric dams to help fulfill the increasing demand for electricity.
[58]
Making it rain - Bangkok Post
Feb 21, 2018 · In 2001, the project earned King Bhumibol a gold-medal award from the Eureka Organization, for inventing something of great benefit to the ...
[59]
A world leader in rainmaking - Nation Thailand
Oct 17, 2016 · Singapore was the first Asean nation interested in the Thai rainmaking technology due to a water shortage in the city-state. In fact, the ...
[60]
Cloud seeding bears no rain in Sri Lanka - Mongabay
Apr 12, 2019 · The previous month, a team had been sent to study artificial rainmaking at Thailand's Department of Royal Rainmaking and Agricultural ...<|separator|>
[61]
Artificial rain eases Asia's droughts but heats up tensions
Jul 27, 2021 · Thailand in March announced a three-year agreement with Indonesia to share weather modification expertise and promote further research. The ...
[62]
Viability of Artificial Rain for Air Pollution Control - MDPI
Our work shows that artificial rain appears to be a promising management strategy for air pollution control.
[63]
WMO data sharing through WIS 2.0
Apr 17, 2024 · Real-time data sharing is crucial for the World Meteorological Organization. It not only underpins the accuracy of weather forecasts and enhances global ...
[64]
30 rainmaking planes to battle drought, pollution - Bangkok Post
Feb 29, 2024 · This year's operations will rely on 24 aircraft from the Department of Royal Rainmaking and Agricultural Aviation and six jets from the Royal ...<|separator|>
[65]
[PDF] The Usage of Alternative Rainmaking Substances for Rain ...
Climate change affects the weather, causing some years to have a longer dry season. The. RH statistic in Thailand shows that there are few days when ...
[66]
[PDF] COUNTRY REPORT:
Oct 13, 2024 · The prospect of AI for supporting weather modification operation: - Better weather forecasting. - Enhance decision-making on cloud seeding time ...
[67]
Thailand ranked first worldwide in weather modification
Sep 11, 2025 · Thailand, now ranked first in the world for weather modification, continues to expand its royal rainmaking programme to combat drought and ...
[68]
Thailand expands weather modification programme to combat drought
Thailand is expanding its weather modification programme, commonly known as royal rainmaking, to address drought and support agricultural activities ...
[69]
Thailand ranked first worldwide in weather modification
Sep 14, 2025 · Thailand, ranked first in the world for weather modification, continues to expand its royal rainmaking program to combat drought and support ...<|control11|><|separator|>
[70]
ASEAN Regional Seminar on Weather Modification 2024
Thailand would offer to host of ASEAN Regional Seminar on weather modification 2024 with an aim to build up a cumulative knowledge on weather modification ...
[71]
The New Gods of Weather Can Make Rain on Demand—or ... - WIRED
Jul 30, 2024 · Other projects have been looking at “terrain modification”—whether planting trees or building earthen barriers in certain locations could ...