The Smart Forfour (stylized as "smart forfour") is a subcompact, four-seat city car produced by Smart Automobile, a joint venture between Mercedes-Benz Group and Geely, across two generations from 2004 to 2006 and 2014 to 2021. Designed for agile navigation in congested urban environments, it emphasizes compact dimensions, efficient powertrains, and innovative space utilization while accommodating four passengers. The model evolved from Smart's original focus on two-seater microcars, expanding the brand's lineup to appeal to small families and city dwellers seeking low-emission, easy-to-park vehicles.[1][2]The first generation, internally designated W454, was introduced in 2004 as a five-door hatchback sharing its front-wheel-drive platform and components with the Mitsubishi Colt supermini, including a range of Mitsubishi-sourced petrol engines from 1.1-liter three-cylinder (75 PS / 74 hp) to 1.5-liter turbocharged four-cylinder (177 PS / 175 hp in Brabus variant). Produced at Mitsubishi's NedCar facility in Born, Netherlands, it measured approximately 3.75 meters in length with a wheelbase of 2.50 meters, offering up to 750 liters of cargo space with rear seats folded. Despite its practical interior and optional automated manual transmission, sales fell short of expectations due to higher pricing and competition, leading to production ending in 2006 after around 140,000 units.[3][4][5][6]The second generation, W453, relaunched in 2014 after an eight-year hiatus, shifted to a rear-engine, rear-wheel-drive layout on a dedicated platform co-developed with Renault, sharing about 70% of parts with the third-generation Renault Twingo for cost efficiency. Built primarily at Smart's Hambach plant in France and later in Novo Mesto, Slovenia for electric models, it featured a shorter 3.49-meter length and 2.49-meter wheelbase, enabling an exceptionally tight turning circle of 8.65 meters. Power came from Renault-derived 0.9-liter turbocharged three-cylinder petrol engines (71 hp or 90 hp) paired with five- or six-speed manual/dual-clutch transmissions, with a facelifted electric EQ variant introduced in 2017 offering 81 hp from a 17.6 kWh battery for up to 160 km range. Notable for advanced safety features like Crosswind Assist and optional autonomous emergency braking, production ceased in December 2021 to refocus on larger electric SUVs like the smart #1, with over 300,000 units sold globally. In September 2025, Smart announced plans to revive the Forfour nameplate with a new electric four-seater model expected in late 2026 or later.[1][7][2][8]
Background and development
Origins and concept
The Smart Forfour emerged as an extension of the Smart brand's dedication to compact urban vehicles, envisioned as a four-seater counterpart to the two-seater fortwo to broaden appeal for city dwellers needing more passenger capacity without sacrificing maneuverability or efficiency. The brand's foundational concept originated in 1994 with the creation of Micro Compact Car AG (MCC), a joint venture between the Swatch Group (SMH) and Mercedes-Benz, focused on developing innovative, low-emission city cars tailored for congested urban environments and limited parking spaces. This partnership introduced early prototypes like the Eco Sprinter and Eco Speedster at a 1994 press event, emphasizing rear-wheel-drive layouts and modular designs for affordability and environmental sustainability.[9][10]By 1998, following Mercedes-Benz's full acquisition of MCC and the rebranding to Smart, the fortwo debuted as the brand's flagship, validating the urban mobility vision with its sub-3-meter length and Tridion safety cell. The Forfour concept built directly on this success, proposed in the early 2000s as a practical larger variant to accommodate families or groups while prioritizing short turning radii and fuel efficiency for daily city use. Development emphasized the brand's core principles of lightweight construction and agile handling, targeting markets where parking constraints demanded vehicles under 4 meters long; the resulting 3.75-meter design struck a balance between compactness and interior space for four occupants.[11][12]Early Forfour prototypes incorporated an adapted Tridion safety cell, the brand's hallmark high-strength steel skeleton, extended to protect four passengers while allowing flexible body panels for customization and crash energy absorption. Design influences drew from the fortwo's space-efficient packaging, exploring rear-engine configurations in initial studies to maximize cabin room and minimize overhangs, though the final first-generation model shifted to a front-engine layout for broader engineering compatibility. This conceptual evolution underscored Smart's goal of versatile, eco-friendly transport solutions amid growing urban density.[13][14]
Partnerships and platforms
The development of the first-generation Smart Forfour (W454) stemmed from a strategic alliance between DaimlerChrysler and Mitsubishi Motors, formalized in March 2000 when DaimlerChrysler acquired a 34% stake in Mitsubishi for approximately $2 billion, enabling joint projects in vehicle development and production.[15][16] This partnership facilitated the co-engineering of a shared platform with the Mitsubishi Colt (Z30), a front-engine, front-wheel-drive architecture designed for compact urban vehicles.[17] The collaboration emphasized cost efficiencies through common components while allowing Smart to incorporate its distinctive Tridion safety cell for enhanced crash protection.[18]Assembly of the Forfour occurred at the NedCar facility in Born, Netherlands, from 2004 to 2006, under a production arrangement tied to the DaimlerChrysler-Mitsubishijoint venture, where Mitsubishi managed operations but integrated DaimlerChrysler's quality standards.[19][20] This setup leveraged NedCar's existing lines for the Colt, producing the Forfour alongside it until low sales prompted discontinuation.[21]For the second generation (W453), Smart shifted partnerships to the Renault-Nissan-Mitsubishi Alliance via a 2010 memorandum of understanding between Daimler and Renault-Nissan, focusing on shared small-car platforms to reduce development costs.[22] The Forfour utilized a dedicated rear-engine, rear-wheel-drive platform co-developed with Renault for the third-generation Twingo, adapted for rear-engine, rear-wheel-drive configuration in Smart variants, with approximately 70% parts commonality including chassis and powertrain elements.[7][23] Despite the shared base, Smart customized the design with its signature Tridion cell and unique styling cues to maintain brand identity.[24] The electric EQ Forfour variant further adapted this platform with battery integration, drawing from Renault's electrification expertise.[25]Smart's ownership evolved significantly, beginning with the 1998 dissolution of its joint venture with Swatch Group, when Daimler-Benz acquired full control effective October 31, making Micro Compact Car a wholly owned subsidiary.[26] By 2020, Daimler formed a 50-50 joint venture with Geely Holding to oversee the Smart brand, emphasizing electric vehicles for future models, though this did not affect Forfour production, which concluded in 2021.[27][28][2]
First generation (W454; 2004–2006)
Production and manufacturing
The first-generation Smart Forfour (W454) was assembled exclusively at the NedCar facility in Born, Netherlands, a plant operated as a joint venture between DaimlerChrysler and Mitsubishi Motors. Production commenced in 2003 under a contract manufacturing agreement with Mitsubishi, leveraging shared assembly lines originally designed for the Mitsubishi Colt to achieve cost efficiencies while incorporating Smart-specific quality assurance protocols.[29][30]The vehicle entered the market in late 2004 with an initial production capacity targeted at up to 140,000 units annually, contributing to the NedCar plant's overall output potential of 250,000 vehicles per year alongside Colt models. However, actual output averaged around 35,000 Forfour units per year due to persistently low demand, resulting in total production of approximately 106,000 units across all variants by the program's end. The manufacturing process emphasized automated welding and stamping of steel body panels, adapted from Colt production lines to meet Smart's standards for compact urban vehicles.[31][32]Production was abruptly terminated on June 30, 2006, less than three years after launch, primarily due to insufficient sales volumes and escalating production costs that failed to achieve economies of scale. This early shutdown contributed to broader Smart brand impairments exceeding €3.9 billion from 2003 to 2006. The decision also impacted the NedCar workforce, leading to reduced shifts and layoffs as the plant shifted focus to Colt production alone.[21][33][34]Initial production runs encountered quality challenges, which were resolved through mid-production modifications and supplier adjustments. These measures helped stabilize output in the final months, though they underscored the challenges of integrating Smart branding with Mitsubishi's platform.[35]
Design and equipment
The first-generation Smart Forfour (W454) was designed as a compact supermini measuring 3.75 meters in length, 1.68 meters in width, and 1.45 meters in height, with a 2.50-meter wheelbase that enabled seating for four passengers in a city-friendly footprint.[36] This configuration prioritized maneuverability in urban environments while providing adequate space for everyday use.[37]The exterior featured the brand's signature Tridion safety cell, a visible steel structure available in black, silver, or titanium finishes, which formed the rigid core of the vehicle and allowed for modular body panels made of scratch-resistant plastic.[37] These interchangeable panels, offered in ten color options (four solid and six metallic), could be easily replaced to customize or repair the car without affecting the underlying chassis, emphasizing the model's innovative, customizable aesthetic.[37] The design drew from the Mitsubishi Colt platform but retained Smart's distinctive two-tone styling, with conventional four-door access rather than unconventional door mechanisms.[38]Inside, the Forfour offered a practical interior with modular seating, including a rear bench that split 50:50 and could slide forward up to 15 cm for adjustable legroom or cargo flexibility, folding flat to expand storage from 268–330 liters (seats up) to 910 liters.[37] Materials were primarily basic plastics for cost efficiency, though higher trims included optional leather upholstery; visibility was enhanced for city driving through large windows and an optional panoramic glass roof.[39] The cabin layout supported four occupants comfortably in short trips, with the front passenger seat folding to accommodate longer items.[40]Equipment was structured around three main levels: the base Pulse trim, focused on sporty essentials with black Tridion cell, steel wheels, and cloth seats in brick red or grey; the comfort-oriented Passion, featuring a silver Tridion, alloy wheels, air conditioning, and leather-trimmed steering wheel; and the Sport package, adding performance-oriented styling like body kits and upgraded suspension on select models.[41] Standard features across trims included anti-lock brakes (ABS), electronic stability program (ESP) from 2005 models onward, twin front airbags, and electric power steering, while options encompassed a satellite navigation system, xenon headlights, and a panoramic roof.[37] Earlier 2004 variants included basic ABS and airbags, with ESP becoming standard later in production.[38]In safety testing, the Forfour earned a four-star overall rating from Euro NCAP in 2005 (applicable to 2004 models), with four stars for adult occupant protection, two stars for child occupant protection, and one star for pedestrian protection.[42] The reinforced Tridion cell provided strong structural integrity in frontal and side impacts, complemented by pretensioners, load limiters, and side airbags, though it faced criticism for poor child restraint performance, high chest loading in side tests, and inadequate pedestrian-friendly front-end design.[42] Rear impact protection was noted as a weak area, with suboptimal whiplash mitigation due to seat structures.[39]
Powertrain
The first-generation Smart Forfour utilized front-mounted internal combustion engines paired with front-wheel drive, offering a selection of petrol and diesel options derived from partner manufacturers Mitsubishi and Mercedes-Benz, respectively. Petrol engines included a base 1.1-litre three-cylinder unit delivering 47 kW (64 PS), a mid-range 1.3-litre four-cylinder producing 70 kW (95 PS), and a 1.5-litre turbocharged four-cylinder rated at 80 kW (109 PS) in standard configuration or 130 kW (177 PS) for the high-performance Brabus model.[38][43] These engines emphasized efficient urban driving with lightweight construction and multi-point fuel injection for the petrol variants.[37]The diesel lineup featured a single 1.5-litre three-cylinder common-rail turbocharged engine, also from Mercedes-Benz, available in 50 kW (68 PS) or 70 kW (95 PS) tunes.[44] This unit incorporated advanced CDI (Common-rail Direct Injection) technology for improved torque delivery and reduced emissions, achieving a highway fuel economy of 3.9 L/100 km in the higher-output version.[45][46]Transmission choices comprised a standard five-speed manual gearbox for all engines, providing direct control suited to the car's agile handling.[37] An optional Softouch automated manual transmission offered six speeds with semi-automatic shifting via paddle selectors and included features like kickdown for overtaking and a crawl function for low-speed maneuvers.[38]Performance across the range varied by engine, with 0-100 km/h times spanning 8.4 to 16.8 seconds and top speeds from 145 to 195 km/h.[47] Combined fuel consumption for petrol models typically fell between 5.9 and 7.0 L/100 km, while diesels were more efficient at around 4.6 L/100 km. All powertrains met Euro 4 emissions standards, focusing on low CO2 output without hybrid or electric alternatives.[48]
The first-generation Smart Forfour was available in four main trim levels: Pure (also known as Purestyle), which offered basic equipment for entry-level buyers; Pulse, a mid-range option with enhanced features like air conditioning and alloy wheels; Passion, positioned as a sportier variant with upgraded interior materials and styling accents; and the top-tier Brabus, which emphasized performance modifications.[49][50]The Brabus variant, launched in 2005, represented the high-performance edition of the Forfour, featuring a turbocharged 1.5-liter inline-four engine tuned by Brabus to deliver 130 kW (177 PS) and 230 Nm of torque. This powertrain enabled acceleration from 0 to 100 km/h in 6.9 seconds and a top speed of 221 km/h, supported by a five-speed manual transmission and front-wheel drive. The model included a lowered suspension for improved handling, 17-inch alloy wheels, and distinctive Brabus badging and interior trim, distinguishing it from standard trims.[51][52]Diesel variants were offered exclusively in CDI form, utilizing a Mercedes-Benz-sourced 1.5-liter three-cylinder common-rail engine in two states of tune: 50 kW (68 PS) for efficiency-focused models and 70 kW (95 PS) for better performance, both paired with a five-speed manual gearbox and achieving strong low-end torque for urban driving.[53][3]A cabriolet version was planned during development but ultimately canceled due to high production costs, though soft-top concepts were displayed at the 2004 Geneva Motor Show to gauge interest in an open-air variant. Cosmetic special editions, such as the blue and silver packages, provided unique two-tone paint schemes and minor styling upgrades without mechanical changes. Regional adaptations included specifications tailored for markets like Australia, with adjusted suspension for local conditions, while the Japanese market received later second-generation models with localized emissions compliance.[54]
Second generation (W453; 2014–2024)
Concepts and development
The development of the second-generation Smart Forfour stemmed from the 2010 strategic partnership between Daimler AG and the Renault-Nissan Alliance, which sought to pool resources for small-car projects and mitigate the high development and production costs that had plagued the first-generation model, leading to its discontinuation after just two years of sales.[22] This collaboration focused on creating a shared rear-engine, rear-wheel-drive platform with the third-generation Renault Twingo, enabling up to 70% parts commonality to reduce expenses while preserving Smart's distinctive urban mobility ethos.[55]Early prototypes emerged in 2012, disguised under existing Smart bodywork to test the new architecture, marking a shift from the front-wheel-drive layout of the prior Forfour to improve weight distribution and handling in tight city environments.[56] The public preview arrived with the Smart Fourjoy concept, unveiled at the 2013 Frankfurt Motor Show as a doorless, roofless four-seater that emphasized playful urban design through its open-air structure, futuristic lounge-style seats, and vibrant composite plastic body panels attached to the iconic Tridion safety cell.[57] Measuring 3.49 meters in length, the Fourjoy featured a rear-mounted 55 kW electric motor and 17.7 kWh lithium-ion battery, delivering agile performance with a fixed-ratio gearbox and a sub-9.1-meter turning circle, while hinting at the production model's electric-ready architecture designed for future electrification.[57][58]Engineering efforts prioritized compatibility between Smart's premium branding—rooted in the rigid Tridion cell for enhanced crash protection—and Renault's volume-oriented manufacturing, requiring adaptations to integrate the steel safety structure with the shared chassis without compromising the Forfour's compact footprint or nimble dynamics. The vehicles entered production in 2014, with the Forfour launching later that year alongside its Twingo sibling, fulfilling the alliance's goal of cost-efficient innovation for city driving.[59]
Production and assembly
The second-generation Smart Forfour was assembled primarily at the Revoz plant in Novo Mesto, Slovenia, a subsidiary of Renault Group, from 2014 to 2021.[60][2]Production of petrol-powered models began in September 2014, while the electric EQ Forfour variant started in 2016 and became the sole offering after internal combustion engine (ICE) production phased out in 2019.[60][61] Overall, Revoz manufactured approximately 248,000 units across both powertrains during this period, with 216,530 petrol models and 32,326 electric ones.[62]Manufacturing occurred on a shared production line with the Renault Twingo at the Revoz facility, leveraging the common rear-engine platform developed in partnership with Renault.[63] The process incorporated extensive robotic automation, with over 650 robots handling tasks such as bodywork assembly, enabling an output of around 45 vehicles per hour across the plant's models.[64] For the EQ Forfour, additional steps included battery pack integration into the rear structure, marking Revoz's entry into electric vehicle production.[60] The distinctive Tridion safety cell—a high-strength steel structure—was painted separately using an environmentally friendly powder coating method before integration with the colorful body panels, ensuring durability and aesthetic contrast.[1]The Revoz plant's total annual capacity stood at 220,000 vehicles, but Forfour output was scaled back after 2019 amid declining demand, contributing to a 31% reduction in overall plant production to 95,797 units in 2021.[65] Minor assembly adjustments accompanied the 2019 model year facelift, which focused on efficiency tweaks without major line changes.[61] By 2020, the shift to electric-only production streamlined operations, but low sales volumes—exacerbated by market shifts toward larger EVs—prompted the end of Forfour assembly in December 2021.[2]Production cessation was announced as part of Smart's strategic pivot under its 2020 joint venture with Geely, redirecting focus to crossover SUVs like the Smart #1 and allowing Revoz to reallocate resources toward new Renault electric models such as the Twingo E-Tech.[2][66] This transition involved workforce adjustments at Revoz, including a reduction of about 350 employees in late 2021 to align with lower volumes, though the plant later ramped up for other EVs to sustain around 1,400 jobs.[67][66]
Design features
The second-generation Smart Forfour (W453) measures 3.495 meters in length, 1.665 meters in width, and 1.554 meters in height, with a wheelbase of 2.494 meters that contributes to its agile handling in urban environments.[68] This makes it notably shorter than the first-generation model, which spanned approximately 3.75 meters, emphasizing a more compact footprint suited for city driving.[68]The exterior design highlights the brand's signature Tridion safety cell, a high-strength steel structure often finished in a contrasting color to the surrounding body panels, which are constructed from lightweight, scratch-resistant plastic for enhanced durability and ease of replacement.[1] The front features round headlights integrated into a hexagonal grille, giving the Forfour a playful yet modern appearance, while the rear doors open to 85 degrees for improved accessibility in tight spaces.[69]Inside, the Forfour adopts a 2+2 seating configuration optimized for four occupants, with a boot capacity ranging from 185 liters with seats up to 975 liters when folded flat, providing versatile cargo space for a city car.[70] Materials represent an upgrade over the first generation, incorporating higher-quality fabrics and plastics, though the overall fit remains budget-focused to align with its entry-level positioning.[71]Standard equipment includes Bluetooth connectivity and USB ports for media integration, while optional upgrades feature a Harman Kardon premium audio system with an eight-channel DSP amplifier and additional speakers for immersive sound.[72] Further options encompass wireless charging pads and a 360-degree camera for parking assistance, available on upper trims. Safety features include autonomous emergency braking with pedestrian detection and lane-keeping assist, standard or optional depending on the model year and variant.[73]The Forfour earned a four-star rating from Euro NCAP in 2014, with 78% for adult occupant protection, supported by the robust Tridion cell that absorbs crash energy while protecting the passenger compartment.[74] Pedestrian protection scored 65%, aided by the front-end design and detection systems that mitigate impacts.[74]
Powertrain options
The second-generation Smart Forfour offered a range of petrol powertrains derived from the Renault Twingo platform, emphasizing efficiency and urban agility with all engines mounted at the rear driving the rear wheels (RWD).[75] The lineup included two naturally aspirated 1.0-liter three-cylinder units and a turbocharged 0.9-liter three-cylinder option, all compliant with Euro 6 emissions standards and featuring no diesel variants.[76] These engines were designed for low-end torque suitable for city driving, with fuel injection systems optimized for reduced consumption under the NEDC cycle.[77]
Transmission choices comprised a standard five-speed manual gearbox for direct control and an optional six-speed dual-clutch automatic (Twinamic) that provided quicker shifts and smoother operation in traffic, enhancing the car's responsive handling integrated with its short wheelbase design.[75][80] Performance varied by engine and transmission, with acceleration from 0-100 km/h ranging from 10.8 seconds for the turbocharged manual to 16.8 seconds for the base model, and top speeds between 151 km/h and 165 km/h.[79][78] Combined fuel economy under NEDC testing fell between 4.5 and 5.2 L/100 km, supporting CO2 emissions as low as 98 g/km.[76][77]Higher trims like Prime and Premium featured mild ECU remapping on the 1.0-liter engine to achieve the 52 kW output from the same hardware as the base version, delivering improved throttle response without hardware changes.[80] Production of these internal combustion options ceased in 2019 as Smart shifted focus entirely to electric vehicles.[81]
Electric version
The Smart EQ forfour, introduced in summer 2017, represented Smart's commitment to urban electric mobility as the battery-electric version of the second-generation Forfour. It featured a rear-mounted synchronous electric motor producing 60 kW (82 PS) and 160 Nm of torque, paired with a single-speed transmission driving the rear wheels. The claimed NEDC range stood at 160 km, though real-world estimates averaged around 120 km depending on conditions. From 2020 onward, the EQ forfour became the exclusive powertrain variant available, aligning with Smart's shift to an all-electric lineup amid broader industry electrification trends.[82][83][84]The powertrain was supported by a 17.6 kWh lithium-ion battery pack, also positioned at the rear for balanced weight distribution and enhanced handling. Standard charging via a 7.4 kW onboard ACcharger took about 2.5 hours for a full charge from a wallbox, but an optional 22 kW three-phase AC unit reduced this to under 40 minutes. An optional CCS Combo port enabled DC fast charging at up to 22 kW, suitable for the compact battery's needs. Performance included 0-100 km/h acceleration in 12.7 seconds and a governed top speed of 130 km/h, prioritizing efficiency over outright speed for city use.[83][85][86]A 2019 facelift brought subtle efficiency enhancements, including aerodynamic tweaks and software optimizations, boosting the WLTP-rated range to up to 130 km while maintaining the core specifications. New drive modes—such as eco for maximized range and sport for sharper response—were complemented by adaptive regenerative braking, which used radar sensors to adjust deceleration intensity, approximating one-pedal driving by slowing the vehicle significantly upon accelerator release without brake input. 32,326 units were produced over its run, reflecting modest uptake in the niche urban EV market.[87][88]Key technologies included radar-assisted recuperation to recapture energy during coasting and braking, alongside eco and sport modes to tailor performance and consumption. The EQ forfour benefited from the Renault-Nissan-Mitsubishi Alliance, integrating shared electric drivetrain elements originally developed for the Renault Zoe, such as the motor and battery architecture, adapted for the Forfour's rear-engine layout.[88][89]As the final Forfour iteration, the EQ model served exclusively from 2020 through 2024, with production ceasing in late 2021 due to sluggish demand for small electric city cars amid slower-than-expected EV adoption in that segment. Remaining inventory was sold until mid-2024, marking the end of the Forfour nameplate before Smart's pivot to larger SUV models like the #1.[2][87]
Sales and reception
Sales performance
The first generation of the Smart Forfour, produced from 2004 to 2006, recorded total European sales of 123,809 units, significantly below the manufacturer's target of 200,000 units annually. Sales peaked at 49,729 units in 2005, with strong uptake in key markets such as Germany and the United Kingdom, while availability was limited outside Europe, contributing to weaker global performance. A sharp drop to 34,789 units in 2006 prompted the model's early discontinuation after less than three years.[90][11]The second generation, spanning 2014 to 2021, achieved approximately 210,000 units in sales across Europe through 2022, representing about 80% of global volume, with minor contributions from China. Initial success saw 39,543 units sold in 2015 following its late-2014 launch, peaking at 37,133 units in 2016 due to its compact size appealing to urban buyers facing parking constraints. Sales then trended downward, averaging around 35,000 units annually through 2019 before plummeting to 7,640 units in 2020 amid the shift to electric powertrains, where the EQ variant suffered from range limitations and competition from rivals like the Volkswagen up!. Sales further declined to 8,823 units in 2021, the final production year, with approximately 3,600 units sold in Europe in 2022 from remaining stock. Including an estimated 35,000 electric EQ Forfour units globally, the two generations combined for about 335,000 units worldwide, underscoring the Forfour's niche role in city car segments priced from €20,000. In September 2025, Smart announced plans for a potential Forfour revival as part of its expanded lineup with Geely.[90][91][92][8]
Marketing and critical reviews
The marketing of the first-generation Smart Forfour (2004–2006) emphasized its role as a practical four-seater extension of the compact Smart brand, highlighting the "double the fun" aspect of accommodating four passengers in the brand's signature stylish, urban-focused design. Print advertisements spotlighted the vehicle's compact dimensions and innovative Tridion safety cell alongside traditional four-door rivals to attract attention to its blend of efficiency and versatility. The Brabus variant was promoted as a sporty hot hatch, featuring tuned engines and suspension for enhanced performance, appealing to enthusiasts seeking a nimble alternative to larger performance cars.[93][94][95]Critical reviews of the first generation praised its maneuverability and city-friendly handling, with What Car? awarding it 4 out of 5 stars for its practical four-seat layout that made it the most versatile Smart model, ideal for urban driving despite its small size. However, outlets like Autocar criticized the ride quality as harsh over bumps and the interior space as compromised for taller passengers or longer trips, often describing the overall package as gimmicky due to reliability issues, including frequent breakdowns reported in long-term tests. Fleet News noted good front and rear space but a necessary compromise between legroom and boot capacity via the sliding rear bench.[96][97][98]For the second generation (2014–2021), marketing campaigns positioned the Forfour as "smarter together" with the Fortwo, through urban adventure-themed ads that showcased its agility in city environments and shared platform with the Renault Twingo for refined engineering. The 2014 launch featured high-profile events in Berlin with celebrity appearances to underscore its modern, fun-loving appeal, while the EQ electric version was marketed as a zero-emission city car emphasizing sustainable urban mobility. By 2019, efforts shifted to digital marketing with social media activations and partnerships promoting city use, including collaborations aligned with ride-sharing services like Uber for efficient fleet integration. Post-2020, sustainability campaigns highlighted the EQ's role in carbon-neutral goals, with Smart committing to all-electric models and decarbonization by 2045 through reports detailing environmental progress.[99][100][101]Critical reception for the second generation improved on handling and refinement, with Top Gear lauding its tight turning circle and Benz-like quality as "funny and flickable" in urban settings, though noting a lack of outright vim compared to rivals. Edmunds gave it a 7 out of 10, appreciating the clever design but critiquing the tight rear seating for adults on anything beyond short trips. The EQ variant earned praise for efficiency and instant torque in city driving from Auto Express, which awarded 3 out of 5 stars, but faulted its short 81-mile range as limiting for non-urban use and the ride as firmer than competitors like the VW e-up!. Overall, the Forfour's legacy is viewed as iconic for pioneering compact, innovative urban cars, yet a commercial failure due to its niche appeal in premium-priced small-car segments, leading to discontinuation amid low global sales.[102][103][104]