Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Solid hydrogen

Solid hydrogen is the solid phase of molecular hydrogen (H₂), a cryogenic quantum solid formed by cooling liquid hydrogen below its triple point of 13.803 K at 7.042 kPa, where H₂ molecules arrange in ordered crystalline lattices such as hexagonal close-packed (hcp) or face-centered cubic (fcc) structures.^[1] Its properties are profoundly influenced by quantum effects, including significant zero-point energy due to the light mass of hydrogen atoms, resulting in a low Debye temperature and anisotropic molecular rotations within the lattice.^[2] First isolated by James Dewar in 1899 through the further cooling of liquefied hydrogen using his vacuum flask apparatus, solid hydrogen marked a milestone in cryogenics and enabled detailed studies of quantum solids.^[3] The material's phase diagram reveals multiple solid phases: for normal hydrogen, Phase II (fcc, ordered rotations) below ~2–4 K at low pressures, transitioning to Phase I (hcp, freely rotating molecules) above ~2–4 K (pure parahydrogen remains in Phase I); higher-pressure phases like III (mixed orientations) and IV (possibly polymeric) emerging above ~100 GPa.^[1] Ortho- and para-hydrogen isomers, differing in nuclear spin states, further modulate properties; pure parahydrogen favors hcp lattices and exhibits higher thermal conductivity (peaking at ~1.5 W/cm·K near 4 K, ~0.1 W/cm·K at 20 K), while normal hydrogen (75% ortho) shows lambda-type specific heat anomalies due to rotational ordering.^[1] Key physical characteristics include a density of approximately 0.077–0.088 g/cm³ near the triple point, a latent heat of fusion of 117 J/mol, and high compressibility (bulk modulus ~0.2 GPa), with density increasing by ~15% under 0.05 GPa and more substantially at higher pressures.^[1] At extreme pressures exceeding 400 GPa, solid hydrogen is theorized to transition to a metallic phase with potential room-temperature superconductivity, though experimental confirmation remains elusive.^[2] These attributes make solid hydrogen a benchmark for quantum theory, with applications in cryogenic storage, neutron moderation, and astrophysical modeling of planetary interiors like Jupiter's core.^[4]

Overview

Definition and Basic Characteristics

Solid hydrogen is the solid phase of the chemical element hydrogen, primarily consisting of diatomic molecules (H₂) under typical laboratory conditions, though atomic forms can exist under extreme pressures. This state is achieved by cooling hydrogen gas below its melting point of approximately 14 K at ambient pressure or by applying sufficient pressure at higher temperatures, distinguishing it from the more common gaseous form at room temperature and the liquid phase intermediate between melting and boiling points.^[5] The solid form encompasses the element's isotopes: protium (¹H) forming H₂, deuterium (²H) forming D₂, and the radioactive tritium (³H) forming T₂, with mixed isotopologues like HD also forming solids. Among these, solid HD exhibits higher density than solid H₂ due to its greater molecular mass despite similar molar volumes.^[6] Basic characteristics of solid hydrogen include its exceptionally low density—approximately 0.088 g/cm³ for para-H₂ at 0 K—making it one of the lightest known solids, along with high crystalline symmetry often in hexagonal close-packed arrangements. Due to the low mass of hydrogen atoms and substantial zero-point energy from quantum effects, it behaves as a quantum solid, where atomic vibrations remain significant even at absolute zero, influencing its structural and thermodynamic properties.^[6]^[5] Solid hydrogen is predicted to form as frozen H₂ on cold dust grains within the interstellar medium.^[7]

Thermodynamic Conditions for Formation

Solid hydrogen forms under specific thermodynamic conditions defined by its pressure-temperature (P-T) phase diagram, where the solid phase is stable at low temperatures and a range of pressures. The triple point, marking the coexistence of solid, liquid, and gaseous phases, occurs for normal (protium-based) hydrogen at 13.8 K and 7.04 kPa.^[8] At atmospheric pressure (101 kPa), the melting point is slightly higher at approximately 14.0 K; solidification occurs upon cooling the liquid below this temperature.^[9] The phase boundaries delineate the stability ranges: the solid-gas boundary (sublimation curve) extends from the triple point to lower temperatures, while the solid-liquid boundary (melting curve) starts at the triple point and rises with increasing pressure. This melting curve follows the Clausius-Clapeyron equation, \frac{dT}{dP} = \frac{T \Delta V}{\Delta H}, where \Delta V > 0 (volume of liquid exceeds that of solid) and \Delta H > 0 (latent heat of fusion), resulting in a positive slope at low pressures and thus an increase in melting temperature with pressure.^[10] For example, at pressures up to several MPa, the melting temperature rises modestly from ~14 K. The liquid-gas boundary (vaporization curve) terminates at the critical point of 33 K and 1.3 MPa, above which no distinct liquid phase exists.^[8] Isotopic substitution affects these conditions due to differences in zero-point energy. Deuterium, with its heavier nucleus, exhibits lower quantum zero-point motion, leading to a higher triple point temperature of 18.7 K at comparable low pressure (near 1 atm, the melting point is ~18.7 K).^[11] This shift underscores the quantum nature influencing hydrogen's phase behavior, with protium requiring colder conditions for solidification than its deuterium counterpart.

Molecular Solid Hydrogen

Crystal Structure and Phases

Solid hydrogen in its molecular form adopts distinct crystal structures known as phases I through IV, each characterized by specific atomic arrangements, molecular orientations, and stability under varying temperature and pressure conditions. These phases reflect the interplay between intermolecular forces, quantum effects, and thermodynamic stability, with transitions driven primarily by pressure changes. Phase I forms at low pressures below 1 GPa and temperatures above approximately 2–5 K, consisting of a hexagonal close-packed (hcp) lattice where H₂ molecules exhibit free rotation. The rotational freedom is described by a quantum rotor model, with energy levels E_J = B J(J+1), where B \approx 60 cm⁻¹ is the rotational constant and J = 0, 1, 2, \ldots denotes the rotational quantum number (even J for para-hydrogen, odd for ortho-hydrogen).^[12]^[13] At lower temperatures below ~5 K, phase I transforms into phase II, a cubic structure with Pa3 space group symmetry, where molecular rotations become hindered and orientational order emerges due to quadrupole-quadrupole interactions between ortho- and para-molecules, leading to broken rotational symmetry. Phase II forms only in samples with sufficient ortho-hydrogen (typically >1%), as pure parahydrogen lacks quadrupolar interactions for ordering.^[13]^[14] Under higher pressures of ~110–150 GPa at near-room temperatures, phase III develops, featuring mixed orientations of H₂ molecules with partial ordering, potentially adopting hexagonal P6₃2₂ or orthorhombic Cmca-12 symmetry.^[15]^[16] Phase IV appears above ~170 GPa, characterized by a layered orthorhombic Ama2 structure with 24 molecules per unit cell, where alternating weakly and strongly bonded layers suggest a molecular arrangement that remains insulating but is debated as a possible precursor to dissociation or metallization.^[17] The I–II transition occurs at low pressures and temperatures below 5 K, driven by cooling-induced orientational ordering, while the II–III transition requires pressures exceeding ~100 GPa, and the III–IV boundary lies around 170 GPa, all reflecting pressure-dependent changes in molecular packing and interactions.^[18]^[14] Solid hydrogen exists as ortho (odd J) and para (even J) isomers due to nuclear spin statistics, with a high-temperature equilibrium ratio of 3:1 (ortho:para); however, interconversion is kinetically slow in the solid state without catalysts, necessitating preparation techniques to achieve the desired mixture, and the conversion process manifests as a specific heat anomaly arising from rotational level population changes.^[12]^[19]

Physical and Quantum Properties

Solid molecular hydrogen exhibits a low density of approximately 0.086 g/cm³ at its triple point (13.8 K, 7.04 kPa), making it one of the least dense solids known, which arises from the weak van der Waals interactions between H₂ molecules. This low density contributes to its high compressibility, with an isothermal compressibility κ_T ≈ 1.5 GPa^{-1} at low pressures, allowing significant volume reduction under modest compression—for instance, a pressure of 0.2 GPa decreases the molar volume from 23.2 cm³/mol to about 17 cm³/mol. The volume expansion coefficient α ≈ 0.03 K^{-1} reflects substantial thermal expansion at low temperatures, as evidenced by a 3% volume contraction when cooling from 4 K to 1 K. Thermal properties of solid H₂ are dominated by phonon contributions at low temperatures, with the lattice specific heat C_v following a T^3 dependence below ~5 K and approaching the Dulong-Petit limit of approximately 3R (where R is the gas constant) for translational modes near the melting point, though quantum effects introduce deviations, particularly in the rotational contributions which freeze out below ~10 K. Thermal conductivity κ ranges from several W/m·K for normal hydrogen to over 100 W/m·K for pure parahydrogen at low temperatures (e.g., peaking at ~110 W/m·K near 3 K for para, ~7 W/m·K at 10 K for normal), limited primarily by phonon-phonon scattering and ortho-para conversion processes in normal hydrogen samples. Quantum mechanical effects are pronounced in solid H₂ due to its light mass, resulting in a large zero-point energy (ZPE) that constitutes a significant fraction (comparable to or exceeding) of the cohesive binding energy (~0.006 eV per molecule), which enhances lattice anharmonicity and confers resistance to classical melting, often termed "quantum melting." This ZPE also elevates the Debye temperature θ_D to approximately 120 K for H₂, lower than for heavier isotopes like D₂ (θ_D ≈ 140 K), reflecting softer phonon modes. Optically, solid H₂ is transparent in the visible range but displays characteristic Raman-active modes, including the vibrational Q-branch (ΔJ=0) at ~4150 cm^{-1} for the ν=1 transition, which probes intramolecular stretching weakly perturbed by the lattice, alongside rotational-vibrational features sensitive to ortho-para content. Magnetically, it exhibits weak paramagnetism arising from nuclear spins, with the ortho form (nuclear spin I=1) contributing a Curie-like susceptibility due to unpaired proton moments, while para-H₂ (I=0) is non-magnetic. Elastic properties reveal anisotropy across phases, with a shear modulus G ≈ 0.15 GPa in the low-temperature phases II and III, where broken symmetry leads to directional variations (e.g., higher rigidity along the c-axis in hexagonal phase I precursors), underscoring the material's softness compared to typical molecular solids.

Exotic Phases of Solid Hydrogen

Atomic Solid Hydrogen

Atomic solid hydrogen refers to the dissociated, unstable phase of solid hydrogen in which H₂ molecules are broken apart, forming a lattice of individual hydrogen atoms trapped within the host structure. This form is generated through dissociation processes at cryogenic temperatures below 1 K, primarily via UV photolysis of precursors like Cl₂ doped in solid parahydrogen (p-H₂) or electron bombardment during deposition, which produces H atoms and related species such as H₃⁺ via reactions like H₂⁺ + H₂.^[20] These methods yield low concentrations of trapped H atoms, typically up to 10^{20} cm^{-3}, embedded in the molecular hydrogen matrix. The structure of atomic solid hydrogen consists of H atoms incorporated into the host lattice, occupying substitutional sites within the molecular hydrogen lattice, as revealed by electron spin resonance (ESR) and electron nuclear double resonance (ENDOR) studies, characterized by unpaired electrons that enable detection via electron spin resonance (ESR).^[22] ESR spectra reveal hyperfine splitting attributable to interactions with the nuclear spins of surrounding protons, providing insight into the local environment of the trapped atoms. The lifetime of these H atoms is approximately days at 4 K, extending significantly longer—potentially weeks or more—at millikelvin (mK) temperatures due to suppressed quantum diffusion.^[23] Key properties of atomic solid hydrogen include its high reactivity, driven by the unpaired electrons, leading to clustering reactions that form H₂ molecules or H₃⁺ ions through tunneling-mediated processes. At low temperatures, H atoms undergo quantum diffusion via the reaction H + H₂ → H₂ + H, which facilitates recombination but is modulated by defects like ortho-H₂ impurities.^[23] This reactivity contrasts with the stability of the molecular phase, highlighting the transient nature of the atomic form. Stabilization of atomic solid hydrogen is achieved through matrix isolation techniques, either in rare-gas hosts like neon or in pure solid hydrogen at ultra-low temperatures around 0.5 K, where recombination is minimized. The recombination rate constant is approximately k \approx 10^{-5} s⁻¹, reflecting the slow, diffusion-limited pairing of H atoms.^[24] At mK temperatures and high magnetic fields (e.g., 4.6 T), concentrations up to several percent can be maintained for extended periods, enabling studies of nuclear polarization.^[25] Theoretically, the binding energy of H atoms in the lattice is on the order of 0.1 eV per atom, providing weak stabilization against recombination, while predicted instability arises from quantum tunneling, which enables rapid diffusion and decay even at near-absolute zero temperatures. This tunneling mechanism underpins both the formation of clusters and the overall ephemerality of the phase.^[23]

Metallic Hydrogen

Metallic hydrogen refers to a high-pressure phase of solid hydrogen in which the material transitions from an insulating molecular state to an electrically conductive atomic state, exhibiting metallic properties due to the overlap of molecular orbitals forming a conduction band. This phase was first theoretically predicted in 1935 by Eugene Wigner and Hillard B. Huntington, who proposed that under sufficient compression, the hydrogen molecules would dissociate into atoms arranged in a lattice, leading to band overlap and metallic conductivity at approximately 25 GPa.^[26] Subsequent density functional theory (DFT) calculations and ab initio simulations have revised this transition pressure to around 400–500 GPa, reflecting the challenges of achieving molecular dissociation and delocalization of electrons in the hydrogen lattice.^[27] Experimental efforts to observe metallic hydrogen have primarily utilized diamond anvil cells to generate extreme pressures. In 2017, researchers reported evidence of the transition at 495 GPa, observing a sudden increase in visible reflectivity consistent with the formation of a metallic phase, though this claim remains debated due to difficulties in verifying the sample integrity and pressure calibration.^[28] Complementary studies have employed DFT to compute the equation of state, P(V), describing the pressure-volume relationship in the metallic phase, which aids in interpreting shock-wave and static compression data. The predicted crystal structures include the orthorhombic Cmca phase, stable up to about 500 GPa, and the hexagonal P6₃/mmc phase at higher pressures, both featuring a lattice of dissociated hydrogen atoms rather than intact molecules. Key properties of metallic hydrogen include high electrical conductivity exceeding 10⁶ S/m, arising from free-electron-like behavior, and a plasma frequency of approximately 10 eV, which determines the onset of reflectivity in the ultraviolet range.^[28] Theoretical models further predict superconductivity in this phase, with critical temperatures (T_c) reaching up to 200 K at pressures of 400–500 GPa, potentially driven by strong electron-phonon coupling in the atomic lattice. However, more recent calculations as of 2025 suggest critical temperatures substantially lower than these early predictions.^[29]^[30] However, realizing these properties faces significant challenges, including the material's predicted metastability upon decompression, where it may revert to the molecular phase unless kinetic barriers preserve the atomic structure. This phase is believed to exist naturally as a dense, "hot" metallic form in the interiors of gas giants like Jupiter, contributing to their magnetic fields and atmospheric dynamics.^[28]

Preparation and Manipulation

Production Techniques

Solid hydrogen is primarily produced through cryogenic cooling of liquid hydrogen, which solidifies below its triple point temperature. Liquid hydrogen, maintained at approximately 20 K under its vapor pressure, is cooled further by evacuating the vapor space above it using mechanical pumps, reducing the temperature to below 14 K and inducing solidification. This process typically employs helium-3 (³He) evaporation refrigerators or dilution refrigerators to achieve the necessary low temperatures, often down to 4 K or lower for enhanced control. To ensure long-term stability, the hydrogen is converted to the para-ortho isomer ratio prior to solidification, as normal hydrogen (a mixture of 75% ortho and 25% para) undergoes slow ortho-para conversion that releases heat and can cause sample cracking; para-hydrogen, with its lower rotational energy levels, minimizes this issue.^[31]^[32] High-pressure techniques enable the production of dense solid hydrogen phases under extreme conditions. Piston-cylinder apparatuses are used for moderate pressures up to about 0.5 GPa, where gaseous or liquid hydrogen is loaded into the cylinder and compressed isothermally at cryogenic temperatures to form solid samples. For higher pressures, diamond anvil cells (DACs) are the standard method, compressing hydrogen gas or liquid loaded cryogenically into a small gasketed chamber between opposed diamond tips, achieving pressures up to 500 GPa. Laser heating within the DAC is often applied to explore higher-temperature phases, such as phase III or IV, by rapidly heating the sample to several thousand Kelvin while maintaining pressure. These methods allow access to exotic phases but require precise control to prevent sample loss due to diamond failure.^[33]^[34] Atomic solid hydrogen is produced via methods that dissociate molecular hydrogen in ultracold environments. Vacuum deposition involves quenching atomic hydrogen vapor onto a cryogenic substrate at temperatures below 4 K, forming thin films or clusters within a solid hydrogen matrix. Alternatively, photolysis of molecular hydrogen or hydrogen halides (e.g., HCl or HBr) in cryogenic noble gas or hydrogen matrices at wavelengths around 193 nm generates free hydrogen atoms that are trapped in the solid lattice. These techniques, often combined with electron or gamma-ray irradiation for dissociation, produce isolated atomic species stabilized by the matrix at millikelvin temperatures.^[35]^[36] Sample sizes vary significantly with the production method and pressure regime. At low pressures, cryogenic cooling yields bulk samples on the order of 1 cm³, suitable for macroscopic studies of thermodynamic properties. In contrast, high-pressure DAC experiments confine samples to microscale volumes, typically less than 1 μm in thickness and 50 μm in diameter, due to the small culet sizes of the diamond anvils (20–150 μm). These diminutive samples are essential for achieving ultrahigh pressures but limit the quantity available for analysis.^[37]^[38] Maintaining high purity is critical across all production techniques to prevent unwanted reactions. Impurity levels must be kept below 1 ppm, as even trace contaminants like oxygen, nitrogen, or metals can catalyze hydrogen recombination or ortho-para conversion, leading to exothermic processes that destabilize the sample. Purification is achieved through multiple distillation cycles of the initial hydrogen gas and rigorous cleaning of apparatus components to minimize ingress during loading and cooling.^[39]^[35]

Stability, Handling, and Challenges

Solid hydrogen's thermal stability is constrained by its tendency to sublimate at cryogenic temperatures, with low sublimation rates in high vacuum allowing samples to remain stable for extended periods if properly cooled. Additionally, the ortho-para conversion process releases heat of approximately 1.42 kJ per mole of converted ortho-hydrogen due to the rotational energy difference, which can accelerate sublimation or cause local heating if not managed. This conversion is exothermic and occurs slowly in pure solid hydrogen but is catalyzed by impurities or surfaces, affecting long-term storage.^[40]^[41]^[42] Mechanical challenges arise from solid hydrogen's inherent brittleness, making it prone to cracking under stress. This, combined with the risk of explosions from trapped impurity gases during formation or handling, necessitates careful strain management to prevent catastrophic failure. The material's shear strength is around 0.75 MPa at 10 K, further highlighting its fragility compared to conventional solids.^[4]^[43] Handling protocols emphasize containment in vacuum or inert atmospheres to minimize sublimation and contamination, with real-time monitoring via interferometry to detect strain or thickness changes in samples. Production techniques, such as cryogenic deposition, must be followed by immediate transfer to insulated cryostats to maintain integrity. Quantum effects, like zero-point motion, influence handling by contributing to the material's softness and reactivity.^[44]^[45] Safety considerations are paramount due to solid hydrogen's high explosion energy of approximately 120 MJ/kg, exceeding that of TNT (4.6 MJ/kg), which amplifies risks from rapid sublimation or ignition. Protocols draw from cryogenic standards, such as those in ASME Boiler and Pressure Vessel Code Section VIII, including pressure relief systems and leak detection to mitigate fire or blast hazards in laboratory settings.^[46]^[47] Current limitations include short lifetimes for high-pressure samples, often lasting only hours before phase instability or equipment constraints intervene, restricting detailed studies. Scalability remains challenging for samples exceeding 1 g, as uniform formation and maintenance of larger volumes demand advanced cryogenic infrastructure, with typical laboratory yields limited to milligrams to grams due to heat transfer and purity issues.^[48]^[49]

Applications and Research

Scientific and Fundamental Studies

Solid hydrogen serves as a quintessential system for probing quantum mechanical phenomena in condensed matter due to the light mass of its constituent atoms, which amplifies zero-point energy and tunneling effects. In quantum solid studies, rotational tunneling of H₂ molecules within the crystal lattice provides direct tests of quantum mechanics, where the molecules exhibit hindered rotor behavior at low temperatures, leading to split energy levels observable through spectroscopic techniques. For instance, neutron scattering experiments have revealed significant zero-point motion in solid hydrogen, with the root-mean-square displacement of the molecules reaching approximately 0.7 Å at low temperatures (e.g., 5 K), far exceeding classical expectations and highlighting the dominance of quantum delocalization over thermal vibrations.^[50] High-pressure physics investigations of solid hydrogen have advanced the understanding of equations of state (EOS) under extreme conditions, crucial for modeling planetary interiors. Shock-wave experiments yield Hugoniot curves that map pressure-volume-temperature relations, showing that compressed hydrogen reaches densities of approximately 0.35 g/cm³ at 100 GPa, with temperatures exceeding 2000 K along the principal Hugoniot, providing benchmarks for the behavior of hydrogen-rich atmospheres in gas giants like Jupiter. These data refine EOS models, revealing discrepancies between theoretical predictions and experiments that inform the structure of icy planet cores.^[51]^[52] Spectroscopy plays a pivotal role in identifying and characterizing solid hydrogen phases, with infrared (IR) and Raman techniques tracking vibron modes—the intramolecular H-H stretches—that shift under pressure to indicate structural changes. In phase IV, for example, the vibron frequency decreases linearly with pressure as \Delta \nu \approx -5 \, \mathrm{cm}^{-1}/\mathrm{GPa}, reflecting weakening of the molecular bond due to intermolecular interactions, while discontinuities in these shifts mark phase boundaries up to 200 GPa.^[53] Isotope effects between protium (H₂) and deuterium (D₂) underscore the quantum mass dependence in solid hydrogen, where the heavier deuterium reduces zero-point energy by about 30%, stabilizing phases at higher pressures and altering rotational dynamics. Path-integral molecular dynamics simulations at 80 K show that H₂ exhibits greater anharmonicity and delocalization than D₂ up to 160 GPa, drawing analogies to superfluidity in helium where mass-dependent quantum fluctuations enable off-diagonal long-range order in molecular clusters.^[54]^[55] Theoretical modeling of solid hydrogen relies on ab initio methods like density functional theory (DFT) augmented with van der Waals corrections to capture dispersion forces essential for phase stability. Seminal calculations using DFT with vdW-DF functionals predict the II-III phase transition around 100 GPa by stabilizing broken-symmetry structures, with Gibbs free energies showing that quantum zero-point effects lower the transition pressure by 20 GPa compared to classical treatments. These approaches have resolved earlier discrepancies in EOS predictions, enabling accurate simulations of high-pressure phases.^[56]^[57]

Practical and Emerging Uses

Solid hydrogen serves as a promising medium for cryogenic hydrogen storage in applications such as fuel cells, offering a higher volumetric density of approximately 86 g/L compared to 70 g/L for liquid hydrogen under standard conditions.^[4] This increased density enables more compact storage without the need for high pressures, though the process requires maintaining temperatures below 14 K for stability, making it reversible but energy-intensive due to the substantial cooling demands.^[58] In nuclear reactors, solid hydrogen functions effectively as a neutron moderator owing to its low absorption cross-section of 0.33 barns for ¹H, which minimizes neutron capture while efficiently slowing fast neutrons through elastic scattering.^[59] This property positions solid hydrogen, often in the form of cryogenic targets or layers, as a valuable material for enhancing neutron economy in research and power generation facilities. Within inertial confinement fusion (ICF) research, solid hydrogen isotopes, particularly deuterium-tritium (DT) ice layers, are integral to target capsules, where they are compressed and heated by lasers to initiate fusion reactions.^[60] These uniform solid layers, formed at cryogenic temperatures inside spherical shells, provide the fuel necessary for achieving ignition conditions, as demonstrated in experiments at facilities like the National Ignition Facility, including repeated ignition achievements as of 2023.^[61] Emerging applications include modeling the interiors of gas giants like Jupiter, where equations of state for solid hydrogen inform simulations of high-pressure layers comprising molecular hydrogen-helium mixtures.^[62] Additionally, solid-state hydrogen carriers such as clathrate hydrates—ice-like structures that physically trap H₂ molecules without forming chemical bonds like metal hydrides—offer potential for safe, ambient-pressure storage, though they require further optimization for release kinetics.^[63] Despite these advantages, practical adoption is limited by high production costs due to the energy required for cryogenic solidification. In such systems, solid hydrogen particles can be stored and dissociated into atomic hydrogen propellants, potentially enabling higher specific impulse rockets with reduced vehicle mass.^[64]

Historical Development

Discovery and Early Experiments

The first production of solid hydrogen occurred in 1899, when James Dewar cooled liquid hydrogen—liquefied by him the previous year—to approximately 14 K within his innovative vacuum-insulated flask, marking a milestone in cryogenic research. This achievement built on Dewar's earlier work with liquefaction at around 20 K, but initial samples were impure, primarily due to trace oxygen and other contaminants that promoted premature solidification well above the pure substance's freezing point of 13.99 K under standard pressure. Advancements in low-temperature technology, pioneered at Heike Kamerlingh Onnes' laboratory in Leiden, facilitated purer studies; Onnes' liquefaction of helium in 1908 enabled temperatures below 4.2 K, essential for handling solid hydrogen without excessive impurity interference. Early challenges persisted, however, as impurities like oxygen formed solid inclusions that altered thermal properties and stability, often leading to inconsistent results in calorimetric and spectroscopic observations. By the late 1920s, improved purification via electrolysis and magnetic separation allowed for higher-purity gaseous hydrogen, culminating in the first samples of essentially pure solid hydrogen in the early 1930s. Early calorimetric studies, including those by Arnold Eucken in the 1920s, revealed anomalies in the heat capacity of solid hydrogen, prompting investigations into quantum effects. In 1929, William F. Giauque and Herrick L. Johnston at the University of California, Berkeley, advanced characterization by preparing pure solid hydrogen through careful decompression of liquefied samples and measuring its heat capacity from approximately 1.5 K to the triple point at 13.803 K, revealing residual entropy contributions from nuclear spin isomers and supporting the third law of thermodynamics. Their work highlighted the role of ortho- and para-hydrogen forms—first theoretically distinguished in 1927—which exist in a 3:1 ratio in normal hydrogen but affect solidification and entropy; pure para-hydrogen, synthesized that same year by Paul Harteck and Karl-Friedrich Bonhoeffer using activated charcoal catalysis, enabled subsequent experiments with isomerically pure solids. Calorimetric studies in the 1940s further elucidated phase behavior, with Woolley, Scott, and Brickwedde compiling thermal data that identified a low-temperature lambda-type phase transition around 2.2 K in normal solid hydrogen, attributed to rotational ordering of ortho molecules in a hexagonal close-packed lattice, based on heat capacity anomalies observed in earlier experiments.^[40] These findings underscored the need for isomer conversion control during preparation to achieve stable, pure solid samples, setting the stage for deeper structural investigations.

Major Advances and Theoretical Predictions

Theoretical predictions for the behavior of solid hydrogen under extreme conditions began with the seminal 1935 work by Eugene Wigner and Hillard B. Huntington, who proposed that molecular hydrogen would dissociate into an atomic metallic phase at pressures around 25 GPa, based on early quantum mechanical calculations of the body-centered cubic lattice energy.^[26] Subsequent refinements in the 1990s, incorporating advanced density functional theory, revised this transition pressure upward to approximately 400 GPa, reflecting the challenges of accurately modeling electron correlations and zero-point motion in this light-element quantum solid.^[65] Linus Pauling's 1939 treatise on chemical bonding further contextualized solid hydrogen as a prototypical quantum solid, where delocalized zero-point vibrations dominate the lattice structure due to the low mass of hydrogen atoms, influencing stability and phase transitions.^[66] Experimental breakthroughs followed these predictions, with the discovery of Phase III—a broken-symmetry molecular phase—in the 1970s by Soviet researchers using shock compression techniques at pressures exceeding 100 GPa, marking the first evidence of orientational ordering in solid hydrogen under megabar conditions.^[67] In 1980, Isaac F. Silvera and colleagues achieved stabilization of atomic hydrogen at temperatures as low as 270 mK in a magnetic trap, enabling studies of its quantum gaseous state and paving the way for ultracold manipulation, though solid atomic forms remain elusive due to recombination instability.^[68] A major milestone came in 2017 when Harvard researchers Ranga P. Dias and Isaac F. Silvera reported metallic hydrogen in a diamond anvil cell at 495 GPa, observing a reflective, black sample indicative of the predicted atomic metal; however, the claim faced significant scrutiny in 2020 over potential non-hydrogen contaminants and sample integrity issues, with the original specimen lost during decompression.^[28]^[2] Recent advances leverage computational tools, including 2023 machine learning-accelerated simulations that predict novel molecular phases of solid hydrogen, such as layered structures stable up to 300 GPa and beyond, potentially resolving discrepancies in the high-pressure phase diagram.^[69] These predictions align with experimental efforts at key facilities: the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) for low-temperature quantum studies of solid hydrogen properties, Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory (LLNL) for megabar diamond anvil and laser-driven compression experiments probing metallic transitions, and the European Synchrotron Radiation Facility (ESRF) for synchrotron X-ray diffraction revealing phase III structures above 150 GPa.^[40]^[70]^[67] International collaborations at these sites continue to refine the pressure-temperature phase boundaries, bridging theory and observation in this foundational quantum material.

References

[1]
[PDF] Selected properties of hydrogen (engineering design data)
Feb 3, 2018 · ... gaseoushydrogen are presented in Chapter 1 and the solid-liquid, solid-vapor, and solid phase properties are compiled in Chapter 2. Ortho ...
[2]
Everything you always wanted to know about metallic hydrogen but ...
Apr 23, 2020 · Solid hydrogen has a massive quantum zero-point energy (ZPE), far greater than its latent heat of melting, and has a Debye temperature well ...
[3]
https://gallica.bnf.fr/ark:/12148/bpt6k349183
[4]
Compilation of the Engineering Properties of Solid Hydrogen
Solid hydrogen has many peculiar properties as a result of its single proton and electron atoms. The solid is a translational quantum solid, where the atoms are ...
[5]
https://doi.org/10.1080/23746149.2021.1961607
[6]
[PDF] Survey of the properties of the hydrogen isotopes below their critical ...
properties; tritium; vapor pressure. Page 17. 1. Introduction. Hydrogen in solid, slush, and liquid states has long been used in the space industry as a fuel ...
[7]
What's at the core of a gas giant like Jupiter?
Aug 29, 2025 · So Maddy, although we call them the gas giants, in fact Jupiter and Saturn are also composed of liquid and even solid hydrogen because of ...
[8]
INTERSTELLAR SOLID HYDROGEN - IOPscience
We consider the possibility that solid molecular hydrogen is present in interstellar space. If so cosmic-rays and energetic photons cause ionization in the ...
[9]
Hydrogen - Thermophysical Properties - The Engineering ToolBox
The hydrogen phase diagram shows the phase behavior with changes in temperature and pressure. The curve between the critical point and the triple point shows ...
[10]
Hydrogen - Element information, properties and uses | Periodic Table
Density (g cm−3), 0.000082. Atomic number, 1, Relative atomic mass, 1.008. State at 20°C, Gas, Key isotopes, 1H, 2H. Electron configuration, 1s1, CAS number ...Missing: quantum | Show results with:quantum<|control11|><|separator|>
[11]
Understanding high pressure molecular hydrogen with a ... - Nature
Oct 6, 2020 · The H2 vibrational frequency drops at high pressure because of increased coupling between neighbouring molecules, not bond weakening. Liquid H2 ...
[12]
[PDF] A Review of Deuterium Triple-Point Temperatures
Oct 15, 2009 · The value, 18.723 ± 0.010 K, measured most recently on normal deuter- ium is consistent with the most accurate and precise of the earlier data.
[13]
[PDF] Phases of the hydrogen isotopes under pressure - NSF PAR
Aug 25, 2021 · 1.2 Hydrogen isotopes and quantum solids. Atomic hydrogen has two isotopes: deuterium (mass 2, nuclear spin 1) with a neutron in the nucleus ...Missing: characteristics | Show results with:characteristics
[14]
Order in dense hydrogen at low temperatures - PNAS
In phase II (or the broken symmetry phase) the structure is possibly Pa3, and the rotation is hindered but is nevertheless of quite wide angle.
[15]
[PDF] Quantum phase transition in solid hydrogen at high pressure - OSTI
Nov 20, 2019 · In these same P-T ranges, solid phases with mixed concentrations of ortho-para are named I, II, III, respectively, to be distinguished from the ...
[16]
Ab-initio study of C2/c, Cmca-12, Pbcn and P6122 phases of solid ...
Apr 15, 2023 · We investigate structural, electronic, phononic and mechanical properties of the C2/c, Cmca-12, Pbcn and P6 1 22 phases of solid hydrogen in the 100–300 GPa ...
[17]
[PDF] arXiv:1906.10854v2 [cond-mat.other] 20 Sep 2019
Sep 20, 2019 · Our static SCAN phase diagram predicts that the P6122 − 36 structure is the best candidate for phase III of solid hydrogen above. ∼200 GPa and ...
[18]
https://link.aps.org/doi/10.1103/PhysRevResearch.4.L042009
[19]
High-pressure II-III phase transition in solid hydrogen
Oct 17, 2022 · The high-pressure II-III phase transition in solid hydrogen is investigated using the random phase approximation and diffusion Monte Carlo.Missing: para | Show results with:para
[20]
Rotational Sublevels of an Ortho-Hydrogen Molecule Encapsulated ...
Aug 12, 2009 · If the ortho-para conversion occurs, the equilibrium specific heat ( C rot * ) must show a large anomaly around 50 K as shown in Fig. 3 [12]
[21]
Unique Applications of para-Hydrogen Matrix Isolation to ...
A comparable mechanism could be operative for H atoms in solid p-H2 where only at the lowest temperatures the H atom gets trapped in a weakly bound complex with ...
[22]
Storage and recombination of atomic H in solid H2
Sep 1, 1976 · The theory predicts that maximum atomic hydrogen concentrations of the order 10 to the 20th per cu cm are realizable for storage temperatures in ...Missing: 5} | Show results with:5}
[23]
Observation of ESR spin flip satellite lines of trapped hydrogen ...
Observation of ESR spin flip satellite lines of trapped hydrogen atoms in solid hydrogen at 4.2 K | The Journal of Physical Chemistry. WYSSMONT COMPANY, INC.
[24]
Decay Dynamics of H Atoms in Solid Hydrogen at 4.2 K. Controlling ...
H atoms produced by the γ-ray irradiation of solid para-H2 (p-H2) and solid normal-H2 (n-H2) decay gradually when the irradiated sample is stored at 4.2 K.
[25]
Storage and recombination of atomic H in solid H2 - AIP Publishing
Sep 1, 1976 · A phenomenological rate process theory is developed for the storage and rapid recombination of atomic hydrogen free radicals in a ...
[26]
[PDF] Nuclear-Polarized Phases of H Atoms Embedded in Solid Molecular ...
The ESR lines of atomic hydrogen gas collected in. Page 5. 1 3. Journal of Low Temperature Physics the SC were used as a reference for determination of the ...<|control11|><|separator|>
[27]
On the Possibility of a Metallic Modification of Hydrogen
Search Site. Citation. E. Wigner, H. B. Huntington; On the Possibility of a Metallic Modification of Hydrogen. J. Chem. Phys. 1 December 1935; 3 (12): 764–770.
[28]
Evidence of a first-order phase transition to metallic hydrogen
Apr 15, 2016 · Theory and experiment have worked closely together for decades on the problem of metallic hydrogen. In 1935, 80 years ago, Wigner and Huntington ...
[29]
Observation of the Wigner-Huntington transition to metallic hydrogen
Jan 26, 2017 · In 1935, Wigner and Huntington predicted that molecular hydrogen would become an atomic metal at a pressure of 25 GPa. Eighty years and more ...
[30]
[PDF] High-temperature superconductivity in atomic metallic hydrogen
Oct 17, 2011 · Superconductivity in the recently proposed ground-state structures of atomic metallic hydrogen is calculated over the pressure range 500 GPa to ...
[31]
Feasibility Study on Production of Slush Hydrogen Based on Liquid ...
Sep 3, 2024 · Liquid hydrogen at 20 K immediately turned into solid hydrogen upon direct contact with liquid helium at approximately 4 K. The helium, ...
[32]
Hydrogen liquefaction: a review of the fundamental physics ...
Apr 21, 2022 · Cooling further leads to the creation of slush hydrogen, a mixture of liquid and solid hydrogen at the triple point (13.8 K for para hydrogen).
[33]
Paper Pressure variation of the shear strength of solid hydrogen
A measurement of the shear strength of solid hydrogen at 4.2 K at pressures up to 1 700 bars has been made using the change in resistivity of a copper ...
[34]
Metallic hydrogen in the spotlight | Nature Materials
Feb 22, 2017 · They have squeezed solid molecular hydrogen to a metallic state in a diamond anvil cell at a pressure of 495 GPa and a temperature of around 5.5 K.
[35]
Electron spin resonance study of atomic hydrogen stabilized in solid ...
Mar 21, 2018 · The freezing temperature of solid hydrogen may be significantly ... Electron spin resonance study of atomic hydrogen stabilized in solid neon ...
[36]
Photogeneration of atomic hydrogen in rare gas matrices
Apr 22, 1999 · Photodissociation of HCl and HBr upon excitation on their repulsive A 1P states is studied in low-temperature Ar, Kr, and Xe matrices at ...
[37]
Solidification and crystal growth of highly compressed hydrogen and ...
Aug 8, 2013 · The crystal growth rates were measured to be 0.12–0.80 cm/s for H2 and 0.13–1.27 cm/s for D2, varying linearly with the compression rate. Topics.
[38]
[PDF] Ultrahigh-pressure isostructural electronic transitions in hydrogen
Sep 25, 2019 · of premature diamond anvil failures, which limited our measurements of H2–He samples to below 160 GPa. The second type of sample had pure H2 ...
[39]
Purely spatial diffusion of H atoms in solid normal- and para ...
Apr 12, 2022 · We present an experimental study of quantum diffusion of atomic hydrogen in solid H 2 films at temperatures below 1 K.
[40]
[PDF] Compilation of Thermal Properties of Hydrogen in Its Various ...
The available thermal data for H2, HD, and D2 in solid, liquid, and gaseous states have been brought together, including the distinctive properties of ortho and ...
[41]
Hydrogen atom catalyzed ortho-to-para conversion in solid ...
Jun 1, 2019 · Infrared spectroscopy is used to investigate the process of molecular hydrogen ortho-to-para (o/p) conversion in solid hydrogen samples ...
[42]
Thermal and mechanical properties of solid hydrogen and deuterium
The purpose of the present survey paper is to discuss the results of the studies of solid hydrogen and deuterium made recently by different groups of ...
[43]
Large, thin solid hydrogen target using para-H2 - ScienceDirect
We have developed a large, thin solid hydrogen target (SHT) that is 30 mm in diameter and 1 mm thick for elastic scattering of protons from unstable nuclei.
[44]
Twenty barrel in situ pipe gun type solid hydrogen pellet injector for ...
Aug 7, 2013 · A 20 barrel solid hydrogen pellet injector, which is able to inject 20 cylindrical pellets with a diameter and length of between 3.0 and 3.8 ...
[45]
Hydrogen energy systems: Technologies, trends, and future prospects
Aug 20, 2024 · Hydrogen showcases a high energy density of 120 MJ/kg, providing a robust alternative to fossil fuels. ... solid hydrogen transportation. 3.2.
[46]
[PDF] SAFETY STANDARD FOR HYDROGEN AND HYDROGEN SYSTEMS
Dec 31, 1994 · This safety standard establishes a uniform Agency process for hydrogen system design, materials selection, operation, storage, ...
[47]
(PDF) Dense quantum hydrogen - ResearchGate
Aug 6, 2025 · The lifetime of an experiment under static compression near 500 GPa at 5.5 K ranged up to weeks, sufficiently long to warrant concern about ...<|separator|>
[48]
-ATOMIC HYDROGEN MASS SCALING EQUATIONS - ResearchGate
The particle agglomerate sizes and areas were measured, and the total mass of solid hydrogen was computed. A total mass of from 0.22 to 7.9 grams of hydrogen ...
[49]
Zero-point motion of liquid and solid hydrogen | Phys. Rev. B
Mar 16, 2023 · We present an inelastic neutron scattering study of liquid and solid hydrogen carried out using the wide Angular Range Chopper Spectrometer ...
[50]
[PDF] The quantum nature of hydrogen
It is also the most quantum, in the sense that quantum tunnelling, quantum delocalisation, and zero-point motion can be important. For practical reasons.
[51]
[PDF] Hydrogen and deuterium in shock wave experiments, ab initio ...
May 2, 2012 · The compression reached in shock compressed hydrogen is higher than in deuterium at the same pressure. This is repro- duced by the calculated ...
[52]
Laser-shock compression and Hugoniot measurements of liquid ...
Feb 28, 2011 · As for the study of planetary interiors, the hydrogen EOS data at much higher pressure are required since the transition to metallic hydrogen ...
[53]
Hydrogen phase IV revisited via synchrotron infrared measurements ...
Apr 4, 2013 · Raman and IR spectroscopies of the vibron modes of the hydrogen isotopes have been used over the past 20 years to elucidate the phase diagram ...
[54]
Strong Isotope Effect in Phase II of Dense Solid Hydrogen and ...
Oct 9, 2012 · Quantum nuclear zero-point motions in solid H 2 and D 2 under pressure are investigated at 80 K up to 160 GPa by first-principles path-integral molecular ...Missing: H2 D2
[55]
[PDF] Why are para-hydrogen clusters superfluid? A quantum theorem of ...
Aug 10, 2010 · Thus, it appears that the true potential for H2 is close to the borderline between a solidlike cluster and one with sufficient overlap between ...
[56]
Fate of density functional theory in the study of high-pressure solid ...
This paper investigates some of the successes and failures of density functional theory in the study of high-pressure solid hydrogen at low temperature.
[57]
A comparative study using state-of-the-art electronic structure ...
Nov 14, 2019 · Azadi, S. & Ackland, G. J. The role of van der Waals and exchange interactions in high-pressure solid hydrogen. Phys. Chem. Chem. Phys. 19, ...
[58]
[PDF] Hydrogen Storage and Its Limitations - The Electrochemical Society
10 Solid stor- age materials with a high volumetric density of hydrogen (up to 100 g. H2/L) would exceed the density of a cryogenic liquid at 20 K (~70 g H2/L).
[59]
[PDF] Interaction of Neutrons with Matter.
Apr 2, 2011 · Hydrogenous materials are also very effective at absorbing neutrons - the cross section for neutron capture by H-1 is 0.33 barns. Neutron ...
[60]
[PDF] Structural properties of hydrogen isotopes in solid phase in the ...
In phase II (or the broken symmetry phase) the structure is possibly Pa3, and the rotation is hindered but is nevertheless of quite wide angle.
[61]
Study on the effects of initial ice layer and temperature distribution ...
High peak-power laser systems are utilized in ICF experiments to compress the capsule which contains a solid hydrogen layer, making the ice layer highly ...
[62]
Understanding Jupiter's interior - Militzer - 2016 - AGU Journals - Wiley
Aug 15, 2016 · Because of shock heating, the temperature along shock Hugoniot curve rise significantly more rapidly than that on an adiabat, which makes it ...
[63]
Solidified Hydrogen Storage (Solid-HyStore) via Clathrate Hydrates
Mar 1, 2022 · This review focuses on the current state of the art for solidified hydrogen storage (Solid-HyStore) via clathrate hydrates.
[64]
Green hydrogen storage: Technologies and economic perspectives
Jun 24, 2025 · Liquid hydrogen storage costs $12-15 per kg of hydrogen, and the capital costs of the cryogenic storage tanks are relatively expensive at $1,000 ...
[65]
[PDF] Solid Hydrogen Experiments for Atomic Propellants
Solid hydrogen is less dense than liquid helium, so the hydrogen particles floated on the surface, simplifying the particle imaging. In an operational ...
[66]
[PDF] Pathways to Metallic Hydrogen - Harvard DASH
In 1935 Wigner and Huntington [1] predicted that at a pressure of 25 GPa (100 GPa=1 megabar) solid molecular hydrogen would dissociate into an atomic metallic ...
[67]
https://www.esrf.fr/news/spotlight/spotlight38/spotlight38hydrogen
[68]
First Data on the Structure of Phase III of Hydrogen Above 150 GPa
Sep 25, 2006 · It is now possible to solve the structure of Hydrogen III from the single crystal X-ray diffraction data collected in the stability field of this phase.<|control11|><|separator|>
[69]
Stabilization of Atomic Hydrogen at Low Temperature | Phys. Rev. Lett.
Jan 21, 1980 · Atomic hydrogen has been stabilized at temperatures of 270±20 mK and in magnetic fields up to 7 T. It is believed to be gaseous.Missing: 1 | Show results with:1
[70]
Simulations with a machine learning model predict a new phase of ...
Apr 22, 2023 · Simulations with a machine learning model predict a new phase of solid hydrogen. Hydrogen, the most abundant element in the universe, is found ...Missing: C2/ m 300 GPa
[71]
National Ignition Facility reveals how hydrogen becomes metallic ...
Aug 16, 2018 · ... high pressure progressively transform dense fluid hydrogen into an electrically conducting fluid. ... Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory. | ...Missing: solid | Show results with:solid