Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Springer Science+Business Media


Springer Science+Business Media was a multinational academic publishing company specializing in scientific, technical, and medical (STM) books, e-books, and peer-reviewed journals, formed in 2003 through the merger of the German publisher Springer-Verlag and the Dutch firm Kluwer Academic Publishers. The entity traced its origins to the Berlin-based publishing house founded by Julius Springer on May 10, 1842, which initially focused on legal and humanities texts before expanding into scientific journals in the late 19th century. By the mid-2000s, Springer Science+Business Media had grown to encompass 70 publishing houses, employ around 5,000 staff, and produce approximately 1,450 journals and 5,000 book titles annually, establishing itself as the world's second-largest academic publisher. Its portfolio emphasized empirical research dissemination, with digital platforms like SpringerLink enabling broad access to content that constituted over 70% of STM revenue by the early 2010s. In May 2015, the company merged with the majority of Holtzbrinck Publishing Group's Macmillan Science and Education division to create Springer Nature, combining operations to enhance scale in research publishing amid rising demands for open access and data-driven scholarship. While renowned for advancing scientific communication through high-volume peer-reviewed output—reaching 2,400 journals and over 9,000 new books by 2014—the publisher faced scrutiny over issues like retractions of fraudulent papers and the economics of subscription models that prioritized revenue from institutional access over unrestricted dissemination.

History

Founding and Early Years (1842–World War II)

Julius Springer founded the publishing house in on May 10, 1842, on his 25th birthday, beginning operations as a bookstore that soon incorporated publishing activities focused initially on political caricatures and philosophical treatises. Born in 1817 to a prominent family, Julius built the enterprise amid the era's constraints, which prompted an early pivot toward specialized content. Upon his death in 1877, his sons, including Ferdinand Springer, assumed leadership, expanding the firm from a small operation with four employees into a prominent player in German scientific literature. By the 1880s, the company shifted decisively to natural sciences and engineering, publishing seminal works by inventors such as and , and acquiring the Zeitschrift des Vereins Deutscher Ingenieure (VDI journal) in 1882. The adoption of the knight-in-chess signet in 1881, designed by architect Martin Gropius, marked a visual consolidation of its identity. Expansion into medicine commenced around 1904, including a German translation of Marie Curie's research, while the launch of Die Naturwissenschaften in 1913 and acquisition of the prestigious Mathematische Annalen established Springer as a leader in and multidisciplinary sciences, with a catalog encompassing over 10,000 book titles and 286 journals by 1945. World War I spurred growth in technical publications, such as Ferdinand Sauerbruch's 1916 surgical manual on war injuries, reflecting demand for applied scientific knowledge. The interwar years reinforced its international reputation in . However, the Nazi regime's ascent in 1933 imposed existential challenges: over 50 Jewish editors and contributors were forcibly removed to comply with policies, eroding the firm's intellectual core. To avert outright , the Springer family transferred operational control to trustee Tönjes Lange, a maneuver that preserved the business under duress but at the cost of autonomy. Personal tragedies compounded institutional strain, with family member Ernst Springer dying in the Theresienstadt concentration camp and Fritz Springer taking his own life in 1944 to escape impending deportation. Operations persisted under Nazi oversight through 1945, navigating wartime shortages and ideological impositions on content.

Post-War Reconstruction and Expansion (1945–1990s)

Following , Springer-Verlag faced significant challenges due to the destruction of its facilities and the division of , but the company was restored to the Springer family after manager Tönjes Lange, who had held it in trust during the Nazi era, returned control and shares to Ferdinand Springer. Reconstruction began in 1946 with the establishment of a new office in focused on medical and natural sciences publishing, where the first post-war book, Die Idee der Universität by , was issued amid ongoing restrictions in the Soviet-occupied sector. Operations initially restarted from a temporary site at Reichpietschufer 20 in , with production volumes recovering to pre-war 1932 levels by 1960 through gradual rebuilding of printing capabilities and editorial staff. Management transitioned in the late 1950s under Dr. Heinz Götze, who became managing director in 1957 and oversaw consolidation, followed by Dr. Konrad F. in 1963 and Claus Michaletz in 1978, emphasizing scientific journal growth and international outreach. Headquarters relocated to Heidelberger Platz in in 1958, and new facilities were constructed in in 1982, supporting expanded operations that employed over 1,000 staff across Berlin and sites by 1988. This period marked a shift from domestic recovery to strategic acquisitions, including J.F. Lehmann Verlag for medical texts, Dr. Dietrich Steinkopff Verlag in 1980, and Physica Verlag in 1983, which bolstered portfolios in specialized fields like physics and . International expansion accelerated in the 1960s, with the founding of Springer-Verlag , Inc. in 1964 to facilitate English-language publications and connections with North American academics, followed by offices in (1973), (1983), (1985), (1986), and and (1990). Efforts also included translating select Chinese scientific works into English starting in 1978, reflecting growing global scientific collaboration amid dynamics. By the early 1990s, new offices near the original site symbolized reunification-era optimism, positioning Springer-Verlag as a leading European scientific publisher with diversified revenue from journals, monographs, and regional imprints.

Mergers Leading to Springer Science+Business Media (1990s–2000s)

In the late 1990s, , a longstanding academic publisher founded in , underwent significant ownership changes amid industry consolidation. acquired a majority stake in Springer-Verlag in , leading to the formation of BertelsmannSpringer, which integrated additional imprints such as Gabler, Teubner, and Vieweg to expand its portfolio in scientific, technical, and medical () publishing. This move positioned BertelsmannSpringer as a key player with revenues exceeding €500 million annually by the early . Meanwhile, Kluwer Academic Publishers (KAP), a Dutch STM specialist originally part of , faced its own restructuring. In November 2002, Wolters Kluwer divested KAP to firms Candover and for €600 million, allowing KAP to operate independently with a focus on journals, books, and databases in fields like , , and sciences. Candover and Cinven viewed the acquisition as a platform for growth in , leveraging KAP's established electronic platforms. The pivotal consolidation occurred in 2003 when Candover and acquired from for €1.05 billion in May, enabling a strategic merger with KAP. Regulatory approvals from the and U.S. authorities followed, clearing the joint control and subsequent integration despite concerns over in STM sectors. The merger was completed in early 2004, officially creating Springer Science+Business as the world's second-largest academic publisher, combining over 1,700 journals, approximately 5,000 annual book titles, and combined revenues of about €880 million. This entity retained headquarters in the and , emphasizing synergies in digital distribution and global reach while operating under oversight.

Merger with Macmillan and Transition to Springer Nature (2010s–Present)

On January 15, 2015, and funds advised by announced an agreement to merge —fully owned by —with the majority of Macmillan Science and Education, which included Publishing Group, , and , all primarily held by . The transaction valued the combined entity at approximately €4.4 billion, creating the world's largest group by revenue and output, with over 13,000 employees and annual sales exceeding €1.5 billion at the time. Regulatory approvals followed, including from the , leading to the merger's completion on May 6, 2015, and the official formation of . The new structure positioned Springer Nature as a hybrid organization integrating Springer's strengths in (science, technology, medicine) journals and books with Macmillan's prestige titles like and , alongside educational imprints. Ownership was divided with Holtzbrinck holding a majority stake of 53% and retaining 47%, reflecting Holtzbrinck's in the Macmillan assets contributed to the deal. This arrangement preserved operational continuity while enabling synergies in digital platforms, such as shared content management systems and expanded offerings, which grew from around 550 fully open access journals in 2015 to approximately 700 by 2025. Post-merger, Springer Nature focused on digital transformation and global expansion, increasing its journal portfolio from about 2,000 to over 3,000 titles by 2025, driven by acquisitions and in high-impact publishing. The company navigated challenges like evolving mandates from funders, implementing hybrid models alongside full options, and reporting steady revenue growth—such as 6% underlying revenue increase in the first half of 2025. In September 2024, Springer Nature announced plans for an (IPO) on the , involving a €200 million capital increase and share sales, which proceeded successfully by October 2024, marking a shift toward public markets while maintaining and family ownership influences. This transition enhanced liquidity for shareholders and supported further investment in infrastructure amid competitive pressures in .

Corporate Structure and Operations

Ownership and Governance

Springer Science+Business Media was owned by firms throughout much of its existence as an independent entity. In 2009, acquired an 82% stake and the Investment Corporation (GIC) an 18% stake from previous owners and Candover. In June 2013, purchased the company for €3.3 billion, with EQT and GIC retaining minority interests to ensure operational continuity. Following the May 2015 merger with Macmillan Science and Education—a unit of —Springer Science+Business Media integrated into . Ownership of is split between , which holds a majority 50.6% stake as a family-controlled entity based in , , and funds advised by , controlling the remaining approximately 49.4%. Holtzbrinck's majority position provides strategic influence, while BC Partners' involvement reflects focus on value creation and potential exits, including a planned in 2024. Governance prior to the merger centered on a management structure led by CEO Derk Haank, appointed in 2004 and overseeing operations under oversight emphasizing efficiency and growth. Post-merger, adopted a dual-board system typical of KGaA structures: a appoints and supervises the Management Board, with shareholder representatives from Holtzbrinck and alongside three independent members; Dr. Stefan von Holtzbrinck serves as Chair. The Management Board, responsible for executing strategy, is headed by CEO Frank Vrancken Peeters, who assumed the role in 2019 after prior leadership transitions including Daniel Ropers. Committees on , nominations, and support oversight, ensuring alignment with shareholder interests and . operates as a key division within this framework, retaining its branding for certain publications.

Global Reach and Organizational Scale

Springer Science+Business Media maintained a multinational operational footprint with offices in 25 countries, centered in —particularly and the —while extending to key locations in the , , and other regions to support its academic publishing activities. Publishing houses operated in major cities including , , , and , facilitating coordination across global markets for production, distribution, and author relations. This decentralized structure enabled localized editorial and sales efforts, with headquarters activities split between for corporate functions and for core publishing operations. As the world's second-largest science, technical, and medical publisher prior to its 2015 merger, the company achieved annual revenues of approximately €981 million in 2013, reflecting its scale in producing peer-reviewed content amid a competitive landscape dominated by subscription-based models. Its portfolio encompassed thousands of journals and books annually, supported by subsidiaries like for open-access initiatives, underscoring an organizational capacity to handle high-volume scholarly output across disciplines. This scale positioned Springer Science+Business Media as a pivotal player in disseminating globally, with revenues driven primarily by institutional subscriptions and licensing agreements rather than direct consumer sales.

Business Model Fundamentals

Springer Science+Business Media's business model revolved around the aggregation, peer-reviewed validation, and monetized distribution of scholarly content in science, technology, medicine, and related fields, leveraging economies of scale from its extensive portfolio of journals and books. The company acquired content primarily from academic authors who submitted work voluntarily, with peer review conducted by unpaid experts, minimizing production costs while relying on the prestige of its imprints to attract high-quality submissions. Core revenue derived from institutional subscriptions and site licenses granting access to bundled collections of electronic journals via platforms like SpringerLink, which by the mid-2000s hosted over 1,000 titles and facilitated "big deal" agreements with and libraries worldwide. Book sales, including monographs, textbooks, and works in and formats, formed another pillar, often sold directly to researchers, educators, and institutions. By the 2010s, the model incorporated open access options in subscription journals, allowing authors to pay article processing charges (typically €2,000–€3,000) for immediate free dissemination, alongside fully journals funded by such fees, reflecting a gradual shift toward author-pays mechanisms amid institutional pressures for broader . This approach enabled to maintain subscription income while capturing growth in funded research outputs.

Products and Services

Core Offerings: Journals, Books, and Databases

Springer Science+Business Media specialized in publishing peer-reviewed journals, scholarly books, and digital databases focused on , , (STM), , and social sciences (HSS). These offerings formed the backbone of its operations, serving academic researchers, professionals, and institutions through both print and electronic formats. By the mid-2010s, the company's portfolio emphasized high-volume output in English-language content to support global . The journals division produced over 2,400 English-language titles annually by 2014, spanning disciplines such as , , and , with a strong emphasis on peer-reviewed articles advancing in STM fields. These journals were distributed via subscription models, often indexed in major abstracting services to enhance , and included options allowing authors to pay for publication of individual articles. Key examples encompassed flagship titles in physics, chemistry, and life sciences, contributing to the company's reputation for rigorous editorial standards in technical publishing. Books represented another pillar, with more than 9,000 new titles released in alone, including monographs, edited volumes, textbooks, and reference handbooks tailored for university-level and professional reference. The catalog prioritized specialized content, such as advanced treatises in and clinical , often developed through collaborations with academic authors and societies, and increasingly offered as e-books to facilitate access. This output supported ongoing dissemination, with series organized under imprints like Series in for targeted disciplinary depth. Databases and digital platforms, notably SpringerLink, provided centralized online access to the company's journal articles, book chapters, and supplementary materials, hosting millions of full-text documents by the 2010s for search, retrieval, and citation tracking. SpringerLink integrated metadata from journals and books, enabling keyword-based discovery across STM and HSS content, and incorporated tools like usage analytics for institutional subscribers. Additional specialized databases, such as Springer Protocols for laboratory methods and SpringerMaterials for material properties data, extended offerings into practical, data-driven resources for researchers.

Digital Infrastructure and Tools

Springer Science+Business Media developed its primary digital platform, SpringerLink, in 1996 to facilitate the transition from print to electronic publishing, initially hosting 100 journals. By 2016, the platform had expanded to encompass over 10 million documents, including peer-reviewed journals, books, and reference works across science, technology, medicine, and other disciplines. SpringerLink features advanced search capabilities, such as Google-style querying with auto-suggest functionality, full-text access, and tools for browsing tables of contents, abstracts, and downloads in PDF format, enabling researchers to access content via web browsers or mobile devices. The platform served as the core infrastructure for digital content delivery, supporting subscription-based access to electronic journals and e-books while integrating alerting services for new publications. Springer Science+Business Media complemented SpringerLink with specialized databases, such as those aggregating material properties and experimental data for scientific research, which provided structured, searchable repositories beyond standard journal content. These tools enhanced through indexing and cross-referencing, allowing users to query interdisciplinary datasets efficiently. For publishing workflows, the company implemented submission and peer-review systems, including Editorial Manager, which automated manuscript handling, reviewer assignments, and tracking to reduce processing times compared to paper-based methods. This infrastructure supported high-volume operations, with features for status monitoring and integration with author profiles, contributing to the of 's output of thousands of annual publications. Overall, these tools underpinned the firm's shift toward data-driven , prioritizing and in academic dissemination during the 2000s.

Open Access Evolution and Implementation

Springer Science+Business Media initiated its (OA) efforts in 2004 by pioneering the model, enabling authors to opt for immediate OA in subscription-based journals upon payment of an (APC). This approach balanced revenue from subscriptions with author-funded accessibility, reflecting early adaptation to demands for broader research dissemination amid rising subscription costs for libraries. The acquisition of (BMC) in October 2008 marked a significant expansion, incorporating BMC's established full model—initiated in 2000—which relied on APCs to cover and production without subscription barriers. BMC's integration provided Springer with expertise in gold (immediate, unrestricted access) and a growing portfolio of fully journals, accelerating internal capabilities for implementation. In June 2010, Springer launched SpringerOpen, comprising over 200 peer-reviewed fully journals across , , , and other fields, funded primarily through averaging several thousand euros per article. This initiative formalized Springer's commitment to gold , complementing options and emphasizing rigorous standards equivalent to subscription titles. Implementation encompasses journals—where over 2,100 titles allow optional —and fully venues, with policies supporting waivers or discounts for authors from low- and middle-income countries to mitigate access inequities. Transformative agreements with institutions and consortia, such as those covering unlimited in journals without direct author fees, have since facilitated read-and-publish models, shifting costs from subscriptions to upfront funding while tracking uptake via metrics like article downloads and citations. These mechanisms ensure , though critics note that dependency can favor well-funded researchers, potentially skewing publication toward resource-rich institutions.

Key Imprints and Publications

Major Imprints

Springer Science+Business Media's primary imprint, , originated from Springer-Verlag, founded in , and specialized in scientific, technical, and medical () publications, encompassing thousands of journals and books across disciplines such as physics, chemistry, , and . This imprint formed the core of the company's output following the merger, with annual production exceeding 5,000 book titles and 1,450 journals by 2006. The Kluwer Academic Publishers imprint, retained after the integration of the publisher Kluwer Academic Publishers (itself a successor to entities like D. Reidel and Plenum Publishing), emphasized social sciences, , , , and select areas, contributing to a diverse portfolio that strengthened Springer's position in non-STM academic markets. BioMed Central emerged as a key open access imprint following its acquisition by Springer Science+Business Media in October 2008, focusing on peer-reviewed journals in , life sciences, and related fields, with over 180 titles at the time of purchase that expanded the company's digital and OA capabilities. Adis International served as a specialized imprint for drug-focused content, including journals and databases on , therapeutics, and clinical data, supporting professionals in pharmaceuticals and healthcare with in-depth reviews and original research. These imprints collectively underpinned Springer Science+Business Media's operations until the 2015 formation of , enabling broad coverage from traditional monographs to emerging digital formats.

Selected High-Impact Journals and Books

Springer Science+Business Media publishes a portfolio of high-impact journals that span science, technology, medicine, and social sciences, with influence measured through metrics like Journal Impact Factors (JIF) from Clarivate Analytics. These journals prioritize rigorous peer review and dissemination of empirical findings, contributing to advancements in fields such as epidemiology and high-energy physics. For instance, the European Journal of Epidemiology, established in 1985, reports a JIF of around 11, emphasizing causal analyses of population health patterns based on longitudinal data. Similarly, Journal of High Energy Physics, launched in 2004 as an open-access venue, maintains a JIF near 6, hosting theoretical and experimental papers on particle physics validated against accelerator data from CERN. In , Clinical Reviews in Allergy and Immunology achieves a JIF of 9.1 (as of recent assessments), featuring synthesis of clinical trials and mechanistic studies on immune responses, often drawing from randomized controlled . These selections exemplify Springer's role in amplifying verifiable, data-driven , though JIFs can fluctuate annually and are critiqued for incentivizing citation-maximizing behaviors over foundational insights. Regarding books, Springer Science+Business Media excels in series that provide enduring references grounded in first-principles derivations and empirical validations. The Graduate Texts in Mathematics series, initiated in 1968, includes over 300 volumes on topics from to , with seminal works like Serge Lang's cited over 10,000 times for its axiomatic rigor. In , the Lecture Notes in Computer Science (LNCS) series, started in 1973, exceeds 14,000 volumes and underpins algorithmic advancements, such as proceedings from foundational conferences on , amassing millions of citations across disciplines. These outputs reflect Springer's emphasis on archival quality, though book impact is gauged via citations rather than standardized factors, prioritizing depth over rapid publication.

Financial Performance and Market Position

Revenue Growth and Profitability Metrics

, encompassing the operations of Springer Science+Business Media following its merger with Nature Publishing Group, reported revenue of €1,853 million in 2023, reflecting underlying growth driven by publications and transitions. In 2024, reported revenue dipped slightly to €1,847 million, a 0.3% decline year-over-year, though underlying revenue increased by 5%, primarily from a 6% rise in the Research segment to €1.41 billion, fueled by article processing charges and subscription renewals. Historical trends show steady expansion prior to 2024: revenue grew 7.1% to €1,822 million in 2022 and 4.6% to €1,701 million in 2021, supported by platform and global academic demand. Profitability metrics highlight , with adjusted operating profit (AOP) reaching €511 million in 2023, equating to a margin of approximately 27.6%. For 2024, net income surged 341% to €68.3 million, bolstered by cost controls and revenue mix shifts toward higher-margin revenues, despite flat reported top-line figures. EBITDA stood at €625 million with a 33.8% margin in recent assessments, underscoring robust cash generation from core publishing activities, though net margins remain pressured by investments in .
YearReported Revenue (€ million)Underlying Growth (%)Adjusted Operating Profit (€ million)AOP Margin (%)
20211,701N/AN/AN/A
20221,822N/AN/AN/A
20231,853N/A51127.6
20241,8475N/AN/A
These metrics position Springer as a leader in scientific , with profitability sustained by scale advantages in peer-reviewed content, though growth has moderated amid mandates and competition from predatory journals.

Economic Impact on Academia and

Springer's traditional subscription model has imposed substantial financial burdens on academic institutions, exacerbating the where journal prices have outpaced inflation and budgets for decades. Universities and research collectively spend billions annually on access to publisher bundles, with Springer Nature's "big deals" requiring commitments to thousands of titles regardless of usage, leading to cancellations of smaller journals and reduced diversity in collections. Transformative agreements, such as those negotiated by the in 2023 for unlimited in Springer hybrid journals, aim to offset article processing charges (APCs) but often maintain or increase overall institutional expenditures, as evidenced by cost-neutral or escalating hybrid models adopted by institutions like the from 2024 to 2026. The transition to under Springer's framework has shifted costs upstream to authors and funders via APCs, which range from €2,000 to over €10,000 per in many journals, potentially straining grant allocations and disadvantaging researchers in resource-limited settings. Springer's reported adjusted operating of approximately 28% in 2024, yielding €512 million on €1.847 billion in , reflects the sector's high profitability, derived largely from content generated by unpaid academic labor and . This model extracts significant economic value from publicly funded research outputs, diverting resources that could otherwise support direct scientific advancement or . For , 's dissemination of peer-reviewed research facilitates essential for R&D, enabling corporations to integrate academic findings into pipelines and achieve economic returns through enhanced . Studies on university- collaborations, frequently published in journals, demonstrate positive effects on firm-level and broader economic indicators, such as and new product revenues, by bridging theoretical insights with practical applications. However, corporate access costs via site licenses or can burden smaller enterprises, while larger firms benefit disproportionately, reinforcing concentration in sectors reliant on proprietary knowledge.

Controversies and Criticisms

Nazi-Era Compliance and Ethical Lapses

During the , Springer-Verlag, led by Ferdinand Springer, complied with the Third Reich's racial policies to ensure the company's survival amid widespread of Jewish-owned enterprises and professional organizations. In , following the Nazi seizure of power and the enactment of the Law for the Restoration of the Professional Civil Service, which barred from roles including academic editorships, Springer-Verlag began aligning its operations with regime demands, including the removal of Jewish personnel from editorial positions. This compliance extended to scientific journals, where non-Aryan editors were dismissed to avoid state intervention, reflecting a pragmatic prioritization of business continuity over opposition to discriminatory laws. A prominent example occurred in 1935 with the journal Die Naturwissenschaften, a flagship publication of Springer-Verlag founded and edited by Arnold Berliner, a Jewish . Berliner was forcibly dismissed on August 13, 1935, as part of the regime's non-Aryan policies targeting Jewish influence in science and publishing, despite his foundational contributions to the journal since 1912. Similarly, in 1938, under pressure from Nazi authorities, Springer-Verlag enforced racial criteria on Zentralblatt für Mathematik, removing mathematician , a Jewish member, from his role; this action followed broader demands to purge "non-Aryan" elements from mathematical reviewing and editorial boards, as documented in the journal's own historical account. These decisions facilitated the exclusion of Jewish scholars from German scientific discourse, contributing to the emigration or marginalization of key figures in mathematics and physics. Springer-Verlag's cooperation also involved collaboration with Nazi-aligned academics, such as Wilhelm Süss, who influenced the Deutsche Mathematiker-Vereinigung to promote regime-approved policies; the publisher supported these efforts by continuing to produce journals under such oversight, avoiding outright resistance that could lead to , as occurred with publishers like Ullstein. While Ferdinand Springer did not publicly affiliate with the , the firm's adaptations— including selective publication alignments and avoidance of politically sensitive content—enabled operations through , but at the cost of ethical integrity in upholding scientific universality against ideological mandates. Post-war, these actions drew scrutiny in processes, though the company was classified as minimally implicated, allowing resumption of activities. Such mirrored patterns across German industry, where economic imperatives often superseded moral opposition to the regime's antisemitic framework.

Peer Review Failures and Retraction Incidents

In 2015, retracted 64 articles from 10 subscription journals following investigations that uncovered evidence of manipulated s, where authors provided fake email addresses for suggested reviewers, allowing self-review or compromised assessments. This incident contributed to a broader involving over 100 retractions across multiple publishers, highlighting vulnerabilities in systems that permit authors to nominate reviewers without sufficient verification. A subsequent in led and to retract 58 articles from seven journals after confirming instances of manipulation, including the use of fabricated reviewer identities and endorsements. identified an additional 30 articles for retraction and flagged nine more for further scrutiny, notifying the (COPE) of systemic lapses in editorial oversight. These cases underscored failures in verifying reviewer authenticity, particularly in high-volume submission environments. More recently, in October 2024, retracted 75 conference papers linked to Juan Manuel Corchado, rector of the , due to fraudulent practices such as duplicate publications and authorship irregularities identified through third-party audits. The publisher's investigation revealed patterns of misconduct that evaded initial , prompting broader scrutiny of under Springer's umbrella. The journal Optical and Quantum Electronics, published by , issued over 200 retractions since September 2024, primarily for issues including , , and inadequate , reflecting ongoing challenges with paper mill submissions and editorial capacity in specialized fields. In 2024 alone, retracted 2,923 papers across its portfolio, with 61.5% involving pre-2023 publications, indicating delayed detection of shortcomings such as insufficient scrutiny of methodological claims or conflicts of interest. These incidents demonstrate recurrent weaknesses in Springer's peer review protocols, including over-reliance on author-suggested reviewers and delays in post- verification, despite publisher commitments to COPE guidelines and enhanced fraud detection tools. While retractions serve as a corrective , their volume—exceeding thousands annually—signals underlying pressures from publication incentives and resource constraints in scaling rigorous evaluation.

Allegations of Ideological Bias and Content Suppression

In 2017, , which includes Springer Science+Business Media imprints, blocked access to approximately 1,000 articles within on topics deemed sensitive by the , including references to , , the , the , and the 1989 Tiananmen Square events. This action, affecting journals such as the Journal of and International Politics, was implemented to comply with censorship demands for continued , prompting from scholars who argued it represented a form of content suppression prioritizing commercial interests over . The practice extended to book publishing, where in 2018, editors of several series terminated partnerships with , citing the publisher's acquiescence to Chinese demands as incompatible with scholarly and leading to the suppression of politically inconvenient . Critics, including academic librarians and researchers, highlighted this as evidence of systemic content suppression driven by geopolitical and economic pressures rather than editorial merit. More recently, in June 2025, the U.S. Trump administration terminated federal contracts worth millions with Springer Nature, alleging political bias in its operations, including favoritism toward China and suppression of dissenting scientific viewpoints. This decision followed accusations of politicized retractions and content moderation, with U.S. officials pointing to instances where taxpayer-funded research was influenced by ideological alignments. In November 2024, New York state senators called for an investigation into a no-bid contract between the State University of New York and Springer Nature, citing similar concerns over censorship and ideological bias in academic publishing. Allegations of ideological have also surfaced in Springer Nature's editorial policies, particularly in journals under its umbrella. In 2022, Nature Human Behaviour introduced guidelines discouraging publication of research that could be perceived as offensive or harmful to certain societal groups, even if empirically robust, drawing criticism for elevating ideological considerations over scientific inquiry. processes have been accused of incorporating quotas—such as mandates to consider , racial, and ethnic in reviewer selection—which proponents of bias claims argue introduces non-merit-based criteria, potentially suppressing heterodox views in fields like social sciences and . These practices, embedded in broader norms, reflect systemic pressures from institutional biases favoring progressive ideologies, as evidenced by retractions of papers challenging mainstream narratives on topics like predatory journals or dynamics.

Challenges to Traditional Publishing Practices

The subscription-based model long dominant in academic publishing, including Springer's operations, has been criticized for imposing unsustainable costs on libraries and institutions, exacerbating the "serials crisis" where journal prices outpace inflation and budget growth. Major publishers like have seen annual subscription revenue increases of 3-5% compounded over decades, contributing to total university expenditures exceeding £1 billion on subscriptions and related fees from 2010 to 2019, with over 90% directed to a handful of commercial entities. This pricing structure, justified by publishers as covering editorial, production, and distribution expenses, has prompted widespread cancellations and negotiations, such as those by European consortia demanding transparency and caps on escalations. In parallel, 's pivot toward and (OA) models—where authors or funders pay article processing charges (APCs) for immediate public access atop ongoing subscriptions—has intensified debates over "double dipping," as institutions effectively subsidize both reader access and selective OA without proportional fee reductions. APCs in Springer hybrid journals typically range from $2,000 to $4,000, escalating to over $11,000 for high-impact titles like those in portfolios under , figures defended as reflecting premium editorial oversight but condemned for perpetuating high barriers in a system shifting from paywalls to pay-to-publish. These practices challenge core tenets of traditional publishing, such as impartial and equitable dissemination, by allegedly aligning incentives toward higher output volumes to maximize revenue, potentially diluting selectivity in an era of expanded submission rates. Empirical analyses indicate that -funded can amplify publication biases, favoring well-resourced researchers and institutions capable of absorbing fees, while smaller or underfunded entities face exclusion, thus straining the meritocratic foundations of . Instances of consortia-wide subscription terminations, including reported cuts to U.S. government-funded access in 2025 totaling around $20 million for titles, underscore how unresolved cost pressures erode trust in the model's sustainability.

References

  1. [1]
  2. [2]
    Global Publishing Leaders 2015: Springer Science+Business Media
    Jun 26, 2015 · Springer Science+Business Media merged with the majority of Macmillan Science and Education in May 2015. The new company is called Springer Nature.Missing: history | Show results with:history
  3. [3]
  4. [4]
    Response to recent investigation into predatory journals and fake ...
    That 5,000 scientists in Germany and 400,000 worldwide have been affected by the cynical activity of rogue publishers presents a real risk to the scientific ...<|control11|><|separator|>
  5. [5]
    [PDF] Springer-Verlag 1842 - 1999: A Review Essay - CORE
    Springer-Verlag was founded in Berlin by Julius Springer (1817-1877) on his 25th birthday on May 10 in 1842. Julius Springer was the son of a prominent Berlin.
  6. [6]
    180 years in the making: a publishing evolution | For Librarians
    Nov 17, 2022 · ... 1842 when 25-year-old Julius Springer founded 'Springer-Verlag'. His son Ferdinand Springer then grew it from a small firm of just four ...
  7. [7]
  8. [8]
    [PDF] Mathematical Publishing in the Third Reich: Springer-Verlag and the ...
    Springer was amongst the leading scientific publishers in Germany, and their mathematics branch enjoyed a worldwide repu- tation. After World War I Springer had ...
  9. [9]
    Springer Timeline - University Libraries
    1842, Julius Springer opens a bookshop in Berlin on his 25th birthday. He publishes political and philosophical works and soon was in trouble with the ...Missing: 1842-1945 history
  10. [10]
    The beginnings of Acta Neurochirurgica and the work of Fritz Loew ...
    Aug 10, 2025 · ... Springer 1939 became partner, together with F. Springer. After the war T. Lange returned his shares in. the Verlag to Ferdinand Springer, as ...<|separator|>
  11. [11]
    Bertelsmann pockets £750m from publishing sale - The Guardian
    May 13, 2003 · Cinven and Candover are paying 1.05bn euros (£751m) for BertelsmannSpringer, which had revenues of £520m last year and has 70 science and ...
  12. [12]
    Kluwer Academic Publishers Sold to Venture Capitalists - NewsBreaks
    Nov 4, 2002 · Dutch publisher Wolters Kluwer has announced the sale of Kluwer Academic Publishers (KAP) to London-based private equity funds Candover and ...Missing: Springer- | Show results with:Springer-<|separator|>
  13. [13]
    Cinven to acquire BertelsmannSpringer for €1.05 billion
    May 13, 2003 · KAP was acquired by Candover and Cinven in January 2003 in a transaction worth €600 million. KAP, like BertelsmannSpringer, is a global ...
  14. [14]
    [PDF] Case No COMP/M.3197 - CANDOVER / CINVEN / BERTELSMANN
    Dec 18, 2002 · Effective Date: the date on which Candover and Cinven acquire joint control of BS under the terms of the. Share Purchase Agreement concluded ...
  15. [15]
    Press Release re. Kluwer/Springer merger - LIBLICENSE
    Sep 16, 2003 · KLUWER AND SPRINGER JOINT RELEASE PRESS RELEASE Merger of Springer Science+Business Media and Kluwer Academic Publishers to begin spring 2004 ...Missing: formation | Show results with:formation
  16. [16]
    Holtzbrinck Publishing Group and BC Partners announce ...
    Holtzbrinck Publishing Group and BC Partners announce agreement to merge majority of Macmillan Science and Education with Springer Science+Business Media.
  17. [17]
    Nature owner merges with publishing giant
    Jan 15, 2015 · Macmillan Science and Education, the London-based publisher of Nature and Scientific American, will merge with Berlin-based Springer Science+Business Media.
  18. [18]
    Macmillan Science and Education agrees merger with Springer
    Jan 16, 2015 · Details of the agreement. The merger comprises Springer Science+Business Media (owned by funds advised by BCP) with the majority of ...Missing: formation | Show results with:formation
  19. [19]
  20. [20]
    About Us - Springer Nature
    Nearly two centuries of progress and advancement in science and education have helped shape the business we are today.Missing: facts | Show results with:facts
  21. [21]
    Springer Nature - ESAC Initiative
    Oct 14, 2018 · Holtzbrinck Publishing Group holds 53% of the company, 47% is owned by the private equity firm BC Partners. Market position. Share of global ...
  22. [22]
    Celebrating 10 years of Springer Nature | Advancing Discovery
    May 5, 2025 · 10 years ago, a heritage of trusted brands including Springer, Macmillan, Nature and Palgrave came together to form Springer Nature.Missing: history 2010s
  23. [23]
    Springer Nature reports strong growth in the first half of 2025 and ...
    Aug 13, 2025 · Springer Nature reports strong growth in the first half of 2025 and raises full-year guidance · Strong performance with 6% underlying1 revenue ...
  24. [24]
    Springer Nature plans Frankfurt IPO in latest test of market
    Sep 13, 2024 · The German academic research publisher said its planned IPO will consist of a 200 million euro ($220 million) capital increase and a sale of ...
  25. [25]
    Springer Nature holds first Annual General Meeting since its IPO
    Jun 5, 2025 · The dividend is scheduled to be paid to eligible shareholders on 11 June 2025. The AGM also confirmed changes to the Supervisory Boards of both ...Missing: structure | Show results with:structure<|separator|>
  26. [26]
    BC Partners seeks to sell $7bn Springer Nature stake to itself
    Later on, in May 2015, Springer Science + Business Media was merged with Holtzbrinck-owned Nature Publishing Group, Palgrave Macmillan, and the global ...Missing: formation | Show results with:formation
  27. [27]
    BC Partners to buy Springer Science for 3.3 bln euros | Reuters
    Jun 19, 2013 · In December 2009, EQT and GIC bought 82 percent and 18 percent of the company, respectively, from Candover and Cinven.<|separator|>
  28. [28]
    BC Partners to acquire Springer Science + Business Media
    Jun 19, 2013 · BC Partners agreed to acquire Springer for approximately EUR 3.3 billion, with EQT Partners and GICIC as minority shareholders. BC Partners ...
  29. [29]
    Shareholder Structure - Springer Nature Group - Investor Relations
    Jun 30, 2025 · Shareholder Structure1) A majority owned and controlled indirect subsidiary of funds that are advised by BC Partners LLP>
  30. [30]
    BC Partners revives plans for $9.7 bln Springer Nature sale, sources ...
    Feb 29, 2024 · BC Partners is in the early stages of exploring options for its 47% stake in Springer Nature, including a potential IPO as soon as the ...<|control11|><|separator|>
  31. [31]
    Macmillan Science and Education, Springer Science+Business to ...
    Jan 15, 2015 · Holtzbrinck Publishing Group and BC Partners have reached an agreement to merge Springer Science+Business Media (owned by funds advised by ...Missing: 2004 | Show results with:2004<|separator|>
  32. [32]
    Corporate Governance - Springer Nature Group
    Springer Nature has a dual board structure made up of a Supervisory Board and a Management Board.
  33. [33]
    Supervisory Board - Springer Nature Group
    The Supervisory Board oversees Springer Nature's management, with three independent members. Dr. Stefan von Holtzbrinck is the Chair, and Nikos Stathopoulos is ...
  34. [34]
    Executive Team - Springer Nature Group
    Frank Vrancken Peeters joined Springer Nature in 2017 as Chief Commercial Officer and became CEO in September 2019. He has spent more than 25 years in the ...
  35. [35]
    Corporate Governance | Springer Nature | Springer Nature Group | Springer Nature
    ### Summary of Corporate Governance at Springer Nature
  36. [36]
    [PDF] Corporate Governance - Springer Nature Annual Report 2024
    Mar 27, 2025 · It includes an overview of the structure and procedures of our management and supervisory bodies, as well as our compliance with the ...
  37. [37]
    Springer Science+Business - New York - MapQuest
    Under the brand 'Springer,' worldwide publishing houses in Berlin, London, Paris, New York, Tokyo and Milan, Italy, produce more than 3,500 new books each year, ...
  38. [38]
    Springer Science+Business Media - CB Insights
    The company is headquartered in Luxembourg with extensive activities in Germany and the Netherlands amongst others. Springer SBM publishes academic and ...
  39. [39]
    Nature publisher to merge with the world's second biggest science ...
    Springer's portfolio will include all of their medical and technical books and journals, including those published by open-access subsidiaries BioMed Central, ...
  40. [40]
    Global Publishing Leaders 2014: Springer
    Jun 27, 2014 · Springer's turnover fell from 976m€ in 2012 to 943m€ in 2013. Springer corrected its last year result to 981m€. Ownership, mergers & acquisition ...
  41. [41]
    Global Publishing Leaders 2013: Springer Science+Business Media
    Jul 19, 2013 · Springer has offices in 25 countries worldwide, and was first founded as a bookstore in 1842. A publishing company quickly followed, started by ...
  42. [42]
  43. [43]
  44. [44]
    How to choose a publishing model (Open access or subscription)
    Jul 15, 2025 · One of these steps will be to select a publishing model for your article. You will be asked to do so after confirming your country and affiliation.
  45. [45]
    SpringerLink: Home
    Providing access to millions of research articles and chapters from Science, Technology and Medicine, and Humanities and Social Sciences.Journals A-Z · Books A-Z · Journal finder · International Journal on Digital...
  46. [46]
    Springer Protocols and Wiley Current Protocols - PMC - NIH
    Current Protocols, by Wiley, has 17 titles, 15,000 procedures, and tools. Springer Protocols, by Springer, has 15 titles, 18,000 protocols, and mobile access.
  47. [47]
  48. [48]
    your go-to intelligence resource for the scholarly publishing industry
    Sep 23, 2016 · Founded in 1996, SpringerLink paved the way for the publisher's transition from traditional print media to electronic publishing. SpringerLink ...
  49. [49]
    [PDF] eBookshelf SpringerLink Platform Review - Vanderbilt University
    SpringerLink allows for both basic and advanced searching. The main search bar allows for 'Google style' searching which includes an auto-suggest feature. ...
  50. [50]
    SpringerLink Home - Main
    SpringerLink is one of the world's leading interactive databases for high-quality STM journals, book series, books, reference works and the Online Archives ...<|separator|>
  51. [51]
    Databases & Solutions | Springer Nature | For Librarians
    Springer Nature offers databases like AdisInsight, SpringerMaterials, protocols.io, SpringerProtocols, and Springer Nature Experiments, plus Springer Nature ...Missing: Business core offerings
  52. [52]
    Find submission status of your article / manuscript - Springer Support
    Feb 3, 2025 · Track your article status online via "Your research" (login required) or through your Springer Nature Profile under "Your research" section.
  53. [53]
    About open research | Open science | Springer Nature
    For over twenty years, since BMC first pioneered an open access publishing model, openness and innovation have been at the heart of our business. Today, we ...
  54. [54]
    About SpringerOpen
    SpringerOpen, launched in June 2010, includes Springer's portfolio of 200+ peer-reviewed fully open access journals across all areas of science.Open access · Publication costs and funding · Who we are · About
  55. [55]
    Open access policies for journals - Springer Nature
    Find out about Springer Nature's open access (OA) policies for journal articles published via the immediate (gold) OA and subscription routes.
  56. [56]
    Open access agreements | Open science - Springer Nature
    Publishing your article open access (OA) can bring you several benefits, including increased downloads and citations—and make your research more accessible ...Open data · United States of America · Egypt · United KingdomMissing: implementation | Show results with:implementation
  57. [57]
    Big Ten Academic Alliance and Springer Nature Announce First ...
    May 29, 2025 · CHAMPAIGN, IL, May 29, 2025 – The Big Ten Academic Alliance has signed a two-year Open Publishing Agreement with Springer Nature, making it the ...Missing: ownership | Show results with:ownership
  58. [58]
    The International Development of Open Access Publishing
    May 25, 2021 · This paper offers a cross-country and cross-disciplinary analysis of the development of open access publishing from 2000 to 2019.
  59. [59]
    BioMed Central acquired by Springer Science+Business Media
    Oct 21, 2008 · BioMed Central was acquired by Springer Science+Business Media, the world's second largest publisher of Scientific, Technical and Medical journals.
  60. [60]
  61. [61]
    Top 10 Journals in Springer - SciSpace
    Jul 7, 2021 · Let's look at the top 10 journals published by Springer publication, including their impact factor, H-index, citation count, article submission template, and ...<|separator|>
  62. [62]
    Springer Journals List with Impact Factor 2025 - JournalsInsights
    This document lists Springer journals with their impact factors. For example, Clinical Reviews in Allergy and Immunology has an impact factor of 9.1.
  63. [63]
    Impact Factors for Journals - Springer Nature Support
    Jun 16, 2025 · A number of Springer journals have impact factors and some journals are being tracked by Clarivate Analytics and will receive their impact factor in due course.
  64. [64]
    Books | Products - Springer Nature
    Springer Nature offers 300000+ books—an essential resource for students and researchers across STM, humanities, and social sciences.
  65. [65]
    Springer Nature achieves revenue and profit targets and projects ...
    Mar 18, 2025 · Research saw a 6% underlying3 revenue growth to €1,414 million, primarily due to the excellent performance of the OA Journals portfolio.Missing: sources | Show results with:sources
  66. [66]
    Springer Nature Sales Rose 5% in 2024, Topping $2 Billion
    Mar 18, 2025 · Underlying revenue (which excludes the impact of companies sold in the year) increased 5% in 2024 over 2023, rising to €1.85 billion ($2.02 billon) while ...Missing: breakdown | Show results with:breakdown<|separator|>
  67. [67]
    Springer Nature AG & Co KgaA (DB:SPG) Revenue - Investing.com
    Springer Nature AG & Co KgaA's revenue decreased in 2024 (1.847 billion, -0.3%) and increased in 2021 (1.701 billion, +4.6%), 2022 (1.822 billion, +7.1%), and ...
  68. [68]
    Springer Nature KGaA Full Year 2024 Earnings - Yahoo Finance
    Apr 5, 2025 · Springer Nature KGaA (ETR:SPG) Full Year 2024 Results. Key Financial Results. Revenue: €1.85b (flat on FY 2023). Net income: €68.3m (up 341% ...Missing: metrics | Show results with:metrics
  69. [69]
    Springer Nature AG & KGaA Profit Metrics - MLQ.ai | Stocks
    Springer Nature AG & KGaA (SPG.F) Profit Metrics ; Gross Profit. $785.10M ; Gross Profit Margin (2023). 42.50% ; EBITDA. $625.10M ; EBITDA Margin. 33.84% ; Operating ...
  70. [70]
    Springer Nature Annual Report 2024
    We delivered another year of solid results in 2024, extending our track record of continuous improvement in revenues and operating profits.Open Access · Tech and AI · Download Centre · People and PlanetMissing: growth metrics
  71. [71]
    BTAA, Springer Nature announce first unlimited open access ...
    Jun 6, 2025 · This OPA deal offers all authors across participating institutions unlimited open access publishing in Springer's hybrid journals portfolio — ...<|control11|><|separator|>
  72. [72]
    Springer - Penn Libraries Open Access Agreements for Penn Authors
    Oct 2, 2025 · The Penn Libraries has a 3-year agreement (2024-2026) with Springer Journals for Penn authors to publish articles open access with no article processing fees ( ...Missing: costs | Show results with:costs
  73. [73]
    Costs of publishing in Springer Nature journal
    Jul 21, 2025 · If you wish to publish in one of our subscription based journals then in the majority of cases there is no charge. Charges may apply for colour ...
  74. [74]
    The oligopoly's shift to open access: How the big five academic ...
    Nov 1, 2023 · Among the five publishers, Springer Nature made the most revenue from OA ($589.7 million), followed by Elsevier ($221.4 million), Wiley ($114.3 ...
  75. [75]
    The Effect of University-industry R&D Collaboration On Economic ...
    Aug 16, 2023 · The result suggests that the university-industry R&D collaboration significantly and positively affects economic growth through capital formation.Missing: partnerships | Show results with:partnerships
  76. [76]
    The contribution of collaboration to the development of sustainable ...
    Nov 28, 2022 · The results show that investments in R&D, and moreover, the existence of collaborations clearly increase company revenue from new products and ...
  77. [77]
    Open access agreements in the USA | Open science - Springer Nature
    Springer Nature partners with institutions globally to provide flexible agreements that help cover OA publication costs (known as article processing charges, ...
  78. [78]
    Dr Arnold Berliner (1862–1942), physicist and founding editor of ...
    Dec 5, 2013 · On 13th August 1935, Arnold Berliner was dismissed from the journal as part of the non-Aryan policies implemented by the NAZI government.
  79. [79]
    80 Years of Zentralblatt MATH
    umes appearing between 1931 and 1938. The years 1933–1945. In 1933, shortly after the Nazis assumed power, Zentralblatt experienced a critical change. On ...
  80. [80]
    64 more papers retracted for fake reviews, this time from Springer ...
    Aug 17, 2015 · Springer is pulling another 64 articles from 10 journals after finding evidence of faked peer reviews, bringing the total number of retractions from the ...
  81. [81]
    Springer Nature retracts 75 papers connected to Spanish university ...
    Oct 21, 2024 · The scientific publisher Springer Nature has retracted 75 conference papers connected to computer scientist Juan Manuel Corchado, rector of the University of ...
  82. [82]
    Springer Nature retracts 75 studies by Spanish rector and his ...
    Oct 17, 2024 · The publisher's decision to withdraw the articles by Juan Manuel Corchado is the biggest scandal to hit Spanish scientists.
  83. [83]
    Springer Nature journal has retracted over 200 papers since ...
    Oct 15, 2024 · Optical and Quantum Electronics, a Springer Nature journal, has retracted more than 200 papers since the start of September, and continues issuing retraction ...
  84. [84]
    Springer Nature retracted 2923 papers last year
    Feb 17, 2025 · Springer Nature retracted 2,923 papers last year · 61.5% (1797 articles) of the retractions were of papers published before January 2023. · 38.5% ...
  85. [85]
  86. [86]
    springer retractions - Retraction Watch
    A journal has retracted 16 papers after a whistleblower flagged it for “irregularities” in peer review, among other concerns.
  87. [87]
    Leading Western Publisher Bows to Chinese Censorship
    Nov 1, 2017 · One of the world's largest academic publishers was criticized on Wednesday for bowing to pressure from the Chinese government to block access to hundreds of ...Missing: suppression | Show results with:suppression<|separator|>
  88. [88]
    Springer Nature blocks access to certain articles in China - Reuters
    Nov 1, 2017 · The Financial Times said at least 1,000 Springer Nature articles had been blocked in China, containing sensitive key words like Taiwan, Tibet ...
  89. [89]
    Springer Nature, academic publishing, and the battle against ...
    Oct 8, 2024 · Springer Nature had removed over 1,000 articles from the websites of two of its journals, Journal of Chinese Political Science and International ...
  90. [90]
    Springer, Censorship and the Need for Open Access
    Jan 18, 2018 · Censorship is the suppression of ideas, and is directly opposed to Springer Nature's stated policy: “Our publishing and editorial policies ...Missing: Business | Show results with:Business
  91. [91]
    Book publishers part ways with Springer Nature over concerns ...
    Oct 2, 2018 · Editors of book series stop publishing with Springer Nature to protest its acquiescence to Chinese government censorship demands.
  92. [92]
    Protest against Springer bowing to censorship - U.OSU
    Oct 4, 2018 · The Springer argument that “only 1 %” of Springer Nature articles offered were affected disregards the fact that once this door of accepting ...
  93. [93]
    Trump admin ends Springer Nature contracts over political bias ...
    Jun 26, 2025 · The publishing giant has also been accused of significantly downplaying the COVID lab-leak theory and censoring content to appease the Chinese ...
  94. [94]
    Scoop: Trump admin cuts contracts with scientific publishing giant
    Jun 25, 2025 · The Trump administration has terminated millions worth of funding for Springer Nature, a German-owned scientific publishing giant.
  95. [95]
    SUNY urged to probe no-bid contract with publishing giant accused ...
    Nov 11, 2024 · Three New York state senators are urging SUNY to probe a contract with Springer Nature after the publishing company was accused of censorship.
  96. [96]
    "Science shouldn't offend". So says Nature Magazine, which used to ...
    Aug 29, 2022 · The new editorial policy of Nature Human Behavior basically trashes free and open inquiry and scientific merit.
  97. [97]
    Authors object after Springer Nature journal cedes to publisher ...
    Sep 7, 2021 · The authors of a paper taking a major database to task for including papers from allegedly predatory journals are objecting to the retraction of the article.
  98. [98]
    Academic journals are a lucrative scam – and we're determined to ...
    Jul 16, 2024 · Between 2010 and 2019, UK universities paid more than £1bn in journal subscriptions and other publishing charges. More than 90% of these fees ...
  99. [99]
    Who should pay for open-access publishing? APC alternatives ...
    Nov 14, 2023 · Critics have a range of complaints about APCs, with some arguing that journals demand exorbitant fees that go well beyond covering their costs ...
  100. [100]
    A Big Science Publisher Is Going Open Access. But at What Cost?
    Jan 14, 2021 · By levying a fee in excess of $11,000, Springer Nature promises to do irreparable harm to the already crippled scientific publishing system.
  101. [101]
    Nature's OA fee seems outrageously high – but many will pay it
    Dec 1, 2020 · Nature Springer argue that the costs for Nature journals are far higher than this because they employ in-house editors and press officers ...
  102. [102]
    Is the pay-to-publish model for open access pricing scientists out?
    Aug 1, 2024 · Some critics of APCs argue the model incentivizes journals to favor quantity over quality, because publishing more papers generates more revenue ...
  103. [103]
    Publishing scientific research in open access, hybrid, or paywall ...
    Aug 31, 2019 · Caps on library subscription costs and fees. Communities can organize and refuse to publish in journals with exorbitant profits and fees.
  104. [104]
    Trump Admin. Cuts NIH's Springer Nature Subscriptions
    Jun 27, 2025 · Citing an unnamed source, Axios reported this week that the Trump administration has cut “about $20 million in grants covering ...Missing: controversies | Show results with:controversies