Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Superstition

Superstition denotes the erroneous attribution of causal influence to non-empirical factors, such as supernatural forces, omens, or rituals, in explaining natural events or outcomes.^[1] These beliefs typically emerge from cognitive processes that overdetect agency and patterns in random occurrences, reflecting an adaptive bias toward assuming causation to avoid missing genuine threats. Empirical investigations link such tendencies to mechanisms like illusory correlation and confirmation bias, which prioritize error avoidance over precision in causal inference.^[2] Despite scientific progress elucidating natural laws, superstitious convictions persist ubiquitously, with studies indicating endorsement rates exceeding 97% in general populations for at least minimal beliefs.^[3] This endurance stems from their role in mitigating anxiety and fostering perceived control amid uncertainty, as observed in domains like sports and gambling where rituals correlate with performance placebo effects.^[4] However, unchecked adherence can foster delusional reasoning devoid of evidentiary basis, potentially impeding adaptive behaviors in favor of unfounded practices.^[5] Cross-cultural analyses reveal no diminishment with education or rationality metrics alone, underscoring deep-seated evolutionary imprints over cultural eradication efforts.^[1]

Definition and Historical Context

Core Definitions and Classifications

Superstition denotes beliefs or practices attributing causal efficacy to agents, events, or actions lacking empirical validation or rational grounding, frequently invoking supernatural mechanisms such as luck, omens, or magical influence.^[1] In psychological terms, it manifests as the misattribution of cause and effect, where coincidental correlations are interpreted as deterministic links, prompting behaviors intended to manipulate uncontrollable outcomes.^[4] This definition contrasts with religious doctrines by excluding faith-based tenets supported by doctrinal authority, focusing instead on unsubstantiated claims extraneous to established scientific or theological frameworks.^[6] Classifications of superstitions often delineate them by intent and mechanism. Positive superstitions encompass proactive rituals or talismans purportedly to enhance fortune or success, such as carrying a "lucky charm" before an event, while negative superstitions involve defensive measures to avert presumed harm, like avoiding the number 13 due to anticipated misfortune.^[7] Mechanistically, they divide into magical categories—sympathetic (imitative actions mirroring desired effects, e.g., knocking on wood to deflect jinxes) and contagious (transfer of properties via contact, e.g., avoiding ladders to prevent "bad luck" transfer)—and divinatory practices interpreting signs for future prediction, such as reading tea leaves.^[1] Further distinctions arise in behavioral analyses, where superstitions appear as operant-conditioned responses reinforced by intermittent rewards, akin to experimental pigeons pecking for food at fixed intervals regardless of actual causation, as demonstrated in B.F. Skinner's 1948 studies.^[1] Philosophically and anthropologically, they are grouped as either pragmatic paranormal subsets—utilized for luck induction or calamity prevention—or broader cognitive errors rooted in pattern-seeking heuristics that overgeneralize rare events into causal rules, persisting despite disconfirming evidence due to confirmation bias.^[8] These categories underscore superstition's role in illusory control, where adherents derive psychological comfort from perceived agency over stochastic realities, though empirical scrutiny reveals no verifiable predictive power.^[9]

Etymology and Linguistic Evolution

The term "superstition" derives from the Latin superstitio, an abstract noun formed from superstitiosus, which itself stems from superstes, meaning "standing over" or "a survivor," combining super- ("over" or "beyond") with stare ("to stand").^[10] In classical Latin, particularly as used by Cicero in the 1st century BCE, superstitio often denoted excessive or irrational religious devotion, such as undue fear of the gods or worship of foreign deities, contrasting with religio, proper reverence toward the divine.^[10] ^[11] Alternative interpretations suggest it originally implied survivors "standing over" the dead, evoking ritual excess, or a state of prophetic exaltation persisting beyond normal bounds.^[12] ^[13] By late antiquity, Roman and early Christian authors like Lucretius and Augustine adapted superstitio to critique pagan practices as deviations from rational piety, emphasizing overzealous or unfounded rituals rather than core theological errors.^[11] The term entered Middle English around 1380 via Anglo-French supersticion, initially retaining connotations of "excessive religious awe" or "false worship," as seen in translations of religious texts decrying idolatrous customs.^[10] ^[14] In the 15th century, its usage broadened to encompass any belief attributing causality to supernatural forces without empirical basis, influenced by scholastic debates distinguishing orthodox faith from folk irrationalities.^[10] Linguistically, the pejorative shift intensified during the Reformation in the 16th century, when Protestant reformers applied "superstition" to Catholic rituals deemed superfluous, such as relic veneration, framing them as survivals of pre-Christian excess rather than divine mandates.^[15] By the Enlightenment era, around the 18th century, the word evolved in English to primarily signify non-religious, pseudocausal beliefs—like omens or charms—divorcing it from theological critique and aligning it with emerging scientific rationalism that prioritized observable causation over inferred supernatural agency.^[10] This modern sense, solidified by the 19th century, treats superstition as cognitive error rooted in ignorance or fear, as reflected in dictionaries defining it as "a belief or practice resulting from... trust in magic or chance, or a false conception of causation." Across Indo-European languages, cognates like French superstition and German Superstition followed parallel trajectories, retaining Latin roots while adapting to cultural contexts of rationalist critique.^[10]

Historical Conceptions Across Eras

In ancient Greece, the term deisidaimonia, often translated as superstition, emerged around the 4th century BCE to denote excessive or irrational fear of the divine or demons, contrasting with orthodox religiosity; Theophrastus, in his Characters, portrayed the superstitious individual as one plagued by compulsive rituals to avert imagined supernatural threats, such as sprinkling water to ward off demons or avoiding weasels as omens.^[17] This conception framed superstition not as mere credulity but as a deviation from rational piety, with philosophers like Plutarch later distinguishing it from true worship by its basis in terror rather than reverence.^[11] In Rome, superstitio carried a similarly pejorative sense, referring to excessive devotion or foreign cults deemed improper, as Cicero critiqued it in De Natura Deorum (45 BCE) as a servile anxiety toward the gods that undermined civic religion; Roman elites tolerated popular practices like augury and entrails-reading for state purposes but condemned private excesses, such as carrying brides over thresholds to evade underworld spirits, as marks of barbarism.^[18] During the medieval period, Christian theologians reconceived superstition as a grave sin akin to idolatry or demonic deception, rooted in Augustine's earlier warnings against pagan remnants; church councils, such as the Council of Leptines in 742 CE, condemned divination and charms as pacts with Satan, viewing them as perversions of sacramental rites that invoked false powers rather than divine grace.^[19] Thomas Aquinas, in Summa Theologica (1265–1274), classified superstitious acts—such as using herbs in rituals without faith in God—as irrational observances that bypassed providence, distinguishing them from licit religion by their reliance on created things over the Creator; this perspective fueled inquisitorial efforts to eradicate folk practices like weather magic or grave desecration, which were seen not as harmless customs but as threats to ecclesiastical authority.^[20] Empirical records from penitentials, dating to the 6th–11th centuries, document widespread clerical campaigns against such beliefs, attributing their persistence to demonic malice rather than cultural inertia.^[21] The Enlightenment era marked a secular pivot, with thinkers like Voltaire denouncing superstition as priestly manipulation fostering ignorance and tyranny; in his Philosophical Dictionary (1764), Voltaire equated it with fanaticism, arguing it enslaved minds through fear of invisible agents, as evidenced by his critiques of relics and miracles as fraudulent props for clerical power.^[22] David Hume, in The Natural History of Religion (1757), traced superstition to human terror of natural forces, positing it as a primitive error yielding to reason's light, while Kant's essay What is Enlightenment? (1784) framed emancipation from such "self-incurred immaturity" as daring to think independently, beyond dogmatic tutelage.^[23] This rationalist lens portrayed superstition as antithetical to empirical science, influencing reforms that curtailed ecclesiastical influence over education and law by the late 18th century. In the 19th century, anthropological frameworks recast superstition as a survivals of primitive mentality within civilized societies; Edward Tylor, in Primitive Culture (1871), defined it as animistic residues—beliefs in spirits animating objects—persisting amid industrial progress, supported by ethnographic data from global surveys showing parallels between tribal rites and European folk customs like knocking on wood.^[24] James Frazer's The Golden Bough (1890, expanded 1915) elaborated this evolutionist view, classifying superstitions as magical thinking stages preceding religion and science, with examples like Roman-era omens illustrating causal fallacies where correlation mimicked control; French rural studies, such as those on 19th-century peasant demonology, quantified its prevalence through parish records, revealing beliefs in apparitions and curses as adaptations to agricultural uncertainties rather than mere ignorance.^[25] These conceptions emphasized empirical classification over moral condemnation, though critics noted the era's Eurocentric bias in deeming non-Western practices inherently superstitious.^[26]

Psychological and Evolutionary Foundations

Cognitive and Behavioral Mechanisms

Superstitious beliefs frequently emerge from cognitive biases that favor the detection of causal relationships in random or uncorrelated events. A primary mechanism is the tendency toward apophenia, where individuals perceive meaningful patterns or agency in stochastic data, such as attributing personal actions to subsequent outcomes despite no causal link.^[27] This bias, rooted in adaptive pattern recognition evolved for survival, can misfire in modern contexts, fostering beliefs like knocking on wood to avert misfortune.^[28] The illusion of control further drives superstition by leading people to overestimate their influence over uncontrollable events, such as lotteries or sports outcomes. Empirical evidence shows that higher endorsement of superstitious beliefs correlates with greater perceived control in random tasks; for instance, a 2018 study found that participants scoring high on superstition scales reported stronger illusions of control in contingency judgments involving chance.^[29]^[30] Confirmation bias sustains these illusions by selectively recalling instances that align with the belief while ignoring disconfirming evidence, as demonstrated in decision-making experiments where prior superstitious commitments biased evidence interpretation.^[31] Behaviorally, superstitions manifest as rituals or avoidance actions reinforced through adventitious contingencies, akin to operant conditioning. In B.F. Skinner's 1948 experiments, pigeons exposed to fixed-time food delivery developed persistent, idiosyncratic behaviors—like spinning or head-bobbing—believing them causally linked to reinforcement, despite the schedule being response-independent.^[32] Human analogs include athletes performing pre-game routines or gamblers using "lucky" charms, where coincidental positive outcomes intermittently strengthen the association, perpetuating the behavior even absent empirical support.^[1] These mechanisms highlight how cognitive misattributions translate into habitual actions, often resistant to rational disconfirmation due to low-cost emotional reassurance.^[33]

Evolutionary Origins and Adaptive Hypotheses

Superstitious behaviors, characterized by the attribution of causality to non-causal events or actions, have been modeled as emergent properties of adaptive learning systems in evolutionary biology. In a 2008 study, Foster and Kokko demonstrated through mathematical modeling that organisms optimizing decisions under uncertainty inevitably produce superstition-like behaviors, as the fitness costs of false negatives (missing a beneficial association) outweigh those of false positives (adopting a harmless but ineffective ritual). This trade-off arises because natural selection favors mechanisms that err toward over-association in sparse reward environments, as seen in operant conditioning experiments where pigeons developed ritualistic pecking after random food deliveries, interpreting it as causal. Such patterns extend to humans, where low-cost behaviors reinforced by occasional coincidences persist, enhancing survival probabilities in unpredictable ancestral environments.^[34] One prominent hypothesis posits that superstitions stem from hyperactive agency detection, an evolved bias to infer intentional agents behind ambiguous stimuli to mitigate predation risks. This mechanism, proposed in evolutionary psychology, suggests that over-attributing rustling leaves to a predator rather than wind reduced fatal errors in hunter-gatherer contexts, with asymmetric costs favoring false positives over misses.^[35] Empirical support includes cross-cultural prevalence of animistic beliefs and laboratory tasks where participants prone to illusory pattern detection exhibit stronger superstitious tendencies.^[36] However, critiques argue that evidence for a dedicated "hyperactive agency detection device" as a heritable module is lacking, attributing such perceptions more to general Bayesian inference under uncertainty than specialized adaptations.^[37] Error management theory provides a complementary framework, extending to superstition by predicting cognitive biases that minimize high-stakes errors in causal inference. Applied to belief formation, it implies that mechanisms tuned to avoid under-detecting real correlations—such as environmental cues signaling danger—produce superstitious overgeneralizations as a side effect, particularly when verification is costly or impossible.^[38] For instance, associating a pre-hunt ritual with success, even if uncorrelated, incurs negligible cost while potentially capturing rare adaptive signals, thereby propagating through cultural transmission in populations facing variable threats.^[39] Models integrating these elements, such as those using incomplete information games, confirm that superstition evolves optimally when environmental feedback is noisy, as over-reliance on observed contingencies yields net fitness gains.^[40]

Empirical Evidence from Modern Studies

Modern experimental research has demonstrated that activating superstitious beliefs can enhance performance in cognitive and motor tasks through increased self-efficacy. In a series of studies published in 2010, participants exposed to good-luck superstitions, such as using a "lucky" charm or hearing phrases like "fingers crossed," showed improved outcomes in golf putting (with putting success rates rising from 36% in control to 65% in superstition conditions), motor dexterity tests, memory tasks, and anagram solving compared to neutral conditions.^[41] This effect was mediated by heightened self-confidence and task persistence, as participants in superstition-activated groups reported greater belief in their abilities and sustained effort longer.^[42] Subsequent replications, including high-powered experiments in 2013, partially confirmed these findings for motor tasks but highlighted variability in cognitive domains, suggesting the benefits are context-dependent rather than universally robust.^[43] Surveys indicate widespread persistence of superstitious beliefs and behaviors in contemporary populations, even among educated groups. A 2024 analysis of comprehensive measures estimated that up to 97% of individuals exhibit some form of superstitious endorsement or ritual performance, challenging underestimations from binary self-identification polls.^[3] For instance, a Gallup poll referenced in recent reviews found about 25% of Americans self-identifying as superstitious, while domain-specific beliefs—such as avoiding black cats or knocking on wood—approach 50-80% prevalence in national samples.^[44] Among athletes, pilot studies report over 90% engaging in pre-performance rituals believed to influence outcomes, correlating with perceived control in high-stakes environments.^[45] These patterns hold across cultures, with a 2024 UK survey showing only 10% extreme skepticism toward common superstitions like unlucky numbers.^[46] From an evolutionary perspective, computational models provide empirical support for superstition as a byproduct of adaptive decision-making under uncertainty. A 2009 analysis by Foster and Kokko used probabilistic simulations to show that organisms favoring false-positive associations (e.g., linking neutral actions to rare threats) achieve higher fitness than strict skeptics, as the costs of missing real causal links outweigh occasional erroneous behaviors in noisy environments.^[47] This aligns with error management theory, where over-detection of agency or patterns—evident in human neuroimaging studies linking superstition to heightened amygdala activity—reduces survival risks from overlooked dangers.^[1] Empirical validation comes from comparative behavioral data, including non-human examples like superstitious pigeons, extrapolated to humans via cross-species learning paradigms demonstrating similar operant conditioning biases.^[48] Such mechanisms explain superstition's tenacity despite rational education, as selective pressures prioritize caution over precision.

Manifestations and Prevalence

Common Categories and Examples

Superstitions are frequently classified into categories such as omens, rituals, and talismans, reflecting beliefs in signs that predict outcomes, actions to influence fate, and objects believed to possess inherent powers.^[49] Omens involve interpreting natural or chance events as portents of future good or bad fortune, often without causal evidence.^[50] A prevalent omen superstition in Western cultures holds that a black cat crossing one's path signals impending misfortune, rooted in medieval European associations of cats with witchcraft and the devil, as documented in historical folklore accounts.^[51] Similarly, walking under a ladder is avoided due to its triangular shape evoking the Holy Trinity in Christian tradition, forming an unintended pagan symbol, or practical risks from leaning ladders; this belief persists despite lack of empirical correlation with harm.^[52] Rituals encompass repetitive behaviors intended to avert evil or attract luck, typically through symbolic actions uncorrelated with outcomes. Knocking on wood, common in English-speaking societies, derives from ancient pagan reverence for tree-dwelling spirits or early Christian references to the wooden cross for protection; surveys indicate it remains practiced by a significant portion of adults despite no verifiable protective effect.^[51]^[52] Crossing fingers, another ritual, originates from Anglo-Saxon gestures invoking the Christian cross for safeguarding or from intertwined fingers symbolizing unity in wishes, observed in behavioral studies as a response to uncertainty rather than evidence-based strategy.^[51] Talismans and charms are objects carried or displayed for supposed protective or beneficial properties, classified as positive superstitions aimed at enhancing welfare. Horseshoes nailed above doors for good luck trace to folklore attributing iron's warding power against fairies and evil spirits, with the U-shape mythically capturing fortune; empirical analyses find no statistical link to improved outcomes.^[51]^[7] Numerical superstitions, such as avoiding the number 13—evident in buildings skipping the 13th floor—stem from Norse mythology's 12 gods disrupted by Loki as the 13th, leading to chaos, and persist globally with triskaidekaphobia affecting decision-making irrationally.^[52] These categories often overlap, with psychological research distinguishing positive variants (seeking benefits) from negative ones (avoiding harm), both maintained by illusory correlations rather than causal mechanisms.^[7] Prevalence data from cross-cultural surveys reveal such beliefs in up to 97% of sampled populations, underscoring their persistence absent disconfirming evidence.^[3]

Regional and Cultural Variations

Superstitions manifest distinct regional patterns, shaped by linguistic, historical, and religious contexts, though universal motifs like omens of luck or misfortune appear across cultures with varying interpretations.^[53] Empirical surveys indicate higher prevalence in post-communist Eastern European nations such as Latvia, Russia, Bulgaria, Slovakia, and the Czech Republic, where beliefs in luck and precognition exceed those in Protestant Western Europe.^[54] South Asian populations also report elevated levels, contrasting with lower endorsement in regions like the Netherlands, where only 10-20% affirm specific paranormal beliefs akin to superstitions.^[46] ^[54] In East Asia, numerical taboos dominate, with the number 4 widely avoided in China and Japan due to its phonetic resemblance to words meaning "death," leading to practices like skipping the fourth floor in buildings or forgoing gifts of four items.^[55] This contrasts with European traditions, where Friday the 13th evokes dread rooted in Christian associations with betrayal and crucifixion, prompting measurable behavioral avoidance such as reduced travel or stock market dips on that date.^[53] Black cats symbolize ill omen in much of Europe and North America, linked to medieval witchcraft accusations, whereas in parts of Asia and ancient Egyptian lore, felines historically signified protection or divinity.^[56] ^[53] African and Middle Eastern variations often intertwine with spiritual protections against envy or malevolence, such as the nazar amulet in Turkey and Iran to ward off the evil eye, a belief in unseen harm from admiration that prompts widespread use of blue glass beads.^[56] In sub-Saharan contexts, spilling salt may demand ritual gestures to avert calamity, reflecting localized fears of disrupted harmony, while South Asian customs emphasize auspicious timings, like avoiding haircuts on Tuesdays in India to prevent familial discord.^[56] ^[57] These differences persist despite globalization, as cultural transmission reinforces local adaptations over universal convergence.^[58]

Factors Influencing Individual Susceptibility

Individual susceptibility to superstition is influenced by cognitive processing styles, with analytical thinking associated with reduced endorsement of superstitious beliefs, whereas intuitive or less reflective styles correlate with higher susceptibility.^[59]^[60] Experimental interventions priming analytical thinking have demonstrated a causal reduction in reported superstitious beliefs, independent of religiosity in some cases.^[61]^[62] Higher intelligence levels negatively correlate with superstitiousness, as evidenced by studies among university students showing that greater cognitive ability predicts lower adherence to unfounded beliefs.^[63]^[64] Similarly, educational attainment exhibits a negative association, with individuals possessing advanced education displaying diminished superstitious tendencies, potentially due to enhanced exposure to empirical reasoning and scientific literacy.^[65]^[66] Personality traits play a significant role, particularly neuroticism and extroversion, which positively predict superstitious beliefs through mechanisms such as heightened emotional reactivity and social conformity pressures.^[67] Anxiety and perceived uncertainty amplify vulnerability, as superstitions often serve as psychological buffers providing an illusion of control in unpredictable environments.^[68]^[9] Individuals with external locus of control—those attributing outcomes to fate or external forces rather than personal agency—are more prone to superstitious rituals to mitigate feelings of helplessness.^[69]^[70] Developmental and experiential factors, including early exposure to cultural norms and low-confidence environments, further modulate susceptibility, though empirical data emphasize that these interact with innate cognitive dispositions rather than acting in isolation.^[4]^[5] In conditions of acute stress or threat, such as health crises, baseline susceptibility intensifies, underscoring superstition's adaptive role in short-term anxiety reduction despite lacking causal efficacy.^[71]^[72]

Intersections with Religion and Irrational Beliefs

Boundaries Between Superstition and Religion

In ancient Roman thought, Cicero distinguished religio—proper piety and dutiful observance toward the gods—from superstitio, which connoted excessive fear, particularly of omens, the dead, or divine retribution, often leading to servile rituals lacking rational basis.^[73] Lucretius, while critiquing religious fears as superstitious in De Rerum Natura (c. 55 BCE), employed religio broadly but targeted institutionalized dread of gods as a source of human misery, blurring etymological lines without a strict binary.^[74] This early demarcation emphasized mode over essence: religion as measured reverence, superstition as anxious excess. Medieval scholasticism refined the boundary normatively. Thomas Aquinas, in Summa Theologiae (1265–1274), defined superstition as a vice contrary to the virtue of religion by way of excess, not in quantity of worship but in its object or manner—such as directing divine honor (latria) to creatures (idolatry), demons (divination), or through improper observances like amulets for protection.^[75] Proper religion, by contrast, orders worship solely to God via fitting external acts, fostering justice toward the divine; superstition deviates, often invoking demonic agency or fabricating rites, as Augustine critiqued pagan practices for enslaving minds to fear rather than liberating through true faith.^[75] These views positioned the boundary as theological propriety, with superstition as corrupted religion rather than wholly alien. Philosophical critiques highlight subjectivity. Thomas Hobbes, in Leviathan (1651), attributed both to "fear of things invisible," deeming one's own system religion and rivals' superstition, a distinction "in the eye of the beholder" that sustains power dynamics.^[76] Historically, colonial Europeans labeled indigenous rites superstitious to justify dominance, despite parallels in ritual efficacy claims.^[77] Psychologically, empirical studies reveal porous borders: religiosity positively correlates with superstitious endorsement (e.g., r ≈ 0.20–0.30 in surveys of U.S. undergraduates), as both exploit cognitive heuristics like agency detection and illusory correlation, though institutional religion amplifies adherence via social norms.^[78] ^[79] Practices like saint intercession or sacramental efficacy often attribute non-empirical causation akin to talismans, underscoring that boundaries reflect cultural hegemony more than causal realism, with no verifiable criterion distinguishing irrationality levels.^[80]

Criticisms of Subjective or Ideological Definitions

Definitions of superstition frequently rely on the subjective judgment of the observer, who deems a belief irrational or supernatural based on their own cultural, philosophical, or scientific framework, rather than objective criteria such as verifiable causal mechanisms.^[81] This approach introduces bias, as the term is often applied by dominant groups to marginalize practices of others, implying superior knowledge without empirical justification for the distinction.^[82] For instance, historical Christian usage of superstitio targeted pagan rituals as excessive or improper, serving to delineate orthodox religion from heterodoxy, while similar critiques were levied by Protestant reformers against Catholic devotions like relic veneration.^[83] Such ideological applications persist, where the label enforces cultural or intellectual hierarchies; Enlightenment-era thinkers, for example, branded medieval religious practices as superstitious to promote rationalism, yet overlooked analogous unverified assumptions in emerging scientific paradigms.^[84] Critics argue this renders the term pejorative and unanalytical, as it conflates folk practices with deeper theological commitments without distinguishing between acausal magical thinking and structured metaphysical claims testable against evidence.^[85] Folklorists have largely abandoned "superstition" for this reason, favoring neutral terms like "folk belief" to avoid implying inherent irrationality, which hinders objective study.^[86] Philosophically, subjective definitions fail first-principles scrutiny by lacking universal standards; a belief's classification as superstitious often hinges on the definer's worldview, such as materialists dismissing animistic traditions as primitive while exempting secular equivalents like anthropomorphized chance in probability interpretations.^[87] This arbitrariness is evident in blurred boundaries with religion, where distinctions based on scale or organization—e.g., isolated rituals versus systematic doctrines—appear ad hoc, allowing ideological favoritism toward institutionalized faiths over indigenous or personal ones.^[88] Empirical analysis reveals no consistent metric, as both may invoke non-observable causes, underscoring the need for definitions grounded in falsifiability and causal evidence rather than normative dismissal.^[89]

Alternative Beliefs Labeled as Superstitious

Alternative beliefs labeled as superstitious encompass modern practices such as astrology, homeopathy, and crystal healing, which attribute causal effects to mechanisms lacking empirical support, paralleling traditional superstitions in positing unverified supernatural or pseudoscientific influences on events or health.^[90] These differ from religious doctrines by their individualistic, non-institutionalized nature but are critiqued similarly for relying on anecdotal correlations rather than testable hypotheses.^[91] Proponents often claim benefits through placebo mechanisms or subjective experiences, yet rigorous testing consistently reveals no effects beyond chance or expectation.^[92] Astrology, the belief that planetary positions determine personality traits or future outcomes, has been subjected to multiple controlled studies showing no predictive validity. A comprehensive review of such research concludes that astrologers perform no better than random guessing in matching birth charts to individual profiles, undermining claims of causal influence from celestial bodies.^[93] This labeling as superstition stems from its failure to falsify predictions under scientific scrutiny, despite persistent popularity driven by confirmation bias rather than evidence.^[94] Homeopathy, involving highly diluted substances to treat ailments via "like cures like," fares similarly in systematic reviews of randomized placebo-controlled trials, which find no efficacy beyond placebo for any condition. Eleven independent meta-analyses collectively indicate insufficient evidence for therapeutic effects, attributing perceived benefits to natural recovery or psychological factors.^[95] Critics classify it as superstitious due to dilutions exceeding Avogadro's limit, rendering active ingredients improbable, thus relying on implausible causal principles without biological plausibility.^[96] Crystal healing posits that gemstones channel energy to alleviate physical or emotional issues, yet no peer-reviewed studies demonstrate physiological effects attributable to crystals themselves. Scientific assessments confirm diseases arise from verifiable biological processes, not manipulable "energies" from minerals, rendering the practice akin to magical thinking unsupported by physics or medicine.^[97] Such beliefs persist in alternative wellness circles, often marketed commercially, but their superstitious designation reflects empirical null results and absence of mechanistic evidence.^[98]

Societal Impacts and Consequences

Effects on Decision-Making and Behavior

Superstitious beliefs often prompt individuals to alter decisions in ways that prioritize perceived omens or rituals over probabilistic evidence, resulting in heightened risk aversion during periods deemed unlucky. For instance, in experiments leveraging Chinese zodiac-year superstitions, participants exhibited a 50% higher rate of purchasing insurance for gambles and overestimated loss probabilities by approximately 9 percentage points, reflecting excessive pessimism that reduced stock investments by 11.9%.^[99] Similarly, Chinese firms led by chairmen in their zodiac year demonstrated reduced risk-taking, including a 10% decrease in R&D expenditures relative to within-firm standard deviation, an 11% drop in acquisition probability, and lower stock return volatility, all statistically significant at conventional levels.^[100] In non-Western contexts, Vietnamese firms curtailed fixed asset investments during directors' "calamitous ages" of 49–53, as per folk beliefs, with effects more pronounced in smaller enterprises, though employment growth remained unaffected.^[101] These patterns extend to individual behavior, where activating superstitions via lucky charms reversed standard loss aversion: participants became more risk-seeking in gain-framed scenarios (44% vs. 19% choosing risky options) and more risk-averse in loss-framed ones (14% vs. 41%), while de-emphasizing objective probabilities in favor of fatalistic outcome focus.^[102] Superstitions can also indirectly shape cognitive performance and choices through self-efficacy modulation. Inducing good-luck beliefs via symbols improved adolescent girls' accuracy on reasoning tasks involving conjunction fallacy and probabilistic errors (effect size d=0.62), mediated by heightened self-efficacy, but impaired boys' performance similarly (d=0.63), suggesting benefits accrue selectively to lower baseline performers.^[103] Overall, such influences deviate from rational utility maximization, as decisions hinge on illusory correlations rather than empirical risks, potentially yielding suboptimal resource allocation like unnecessary avoidance of benign events.^[99]^[102]

Economic and Consumer Influences

Superstitions exert measurable influence on consumer spending by prompting avoidance of perceived unlucky attributes in purchases, such as specific numbers or dates, while commanding premiums for those deemed auspicious. In China, vehicle license plates featuring the number 8—symbolizing prosperity—fetch auction prices up to seven times higher than comparable plates with neutral numbers, reflecting a market valuation of superstitious beliefs estimated in the millions annually across provinces. Similarly, real estate prices in Asian markets decline by 10-20% for properties with addresses containing the number 4, associated with death, leading to discounted sales and prolonged vacancies that distort local housing dynamics.^[104]^[105] Specific dates amplify these effects, as evidenced by Friday the 13th, when U.S. businesses incur losses of $800-900 million from reduced consumer activity in travel, dining, and retail due to paraskevidekatriaphobia. Empirical analysis of stock market data from 1950 onward reveals average returns on such days exceeding typical Fridays by over 150% in some indices, attributed to thinned trading volumes from superstitious investor caution rather than inherent market anomalies. In consumer goods, superstitions function as heuristics, increasing demand for "lucky" items like red envelopes or charms during festivals, with studies showing trait superstition correlating positively with purchases intended to invoke good fortune, such as lottery tickets featuring personal lucky numbers.^[106]^[107]^[108] Marketing strategies adapt to these patterns, incorporating cultural superstitions to boost sales; for instance, firms in East Asia avoid pricing at multiples of 4 while promoting 8, yielding measurable uplifts in conversion rates documented in cross-cultural consumer experiments. At the firm level, superstitions constrain investment, as Vietnamese executives exhibit reduced capital expenditures during zodiacally inauspicious periods, forgoing opportunities worth billions in aggregate due to heightened risk aversion. These behaviors collectively impose economic inefficiencies, including misallocated resources and forgone productivity, though they sustain niche markets for superstitious products estimated at tens of billions globally.^[109]^[101]^[99] Superstitious beliefs among voters have been empirically associated with reduced trust in political institutions and heightened support for extremist ideologies. A 2023 study of German respondents found that individuals endorsing superstitious and traditional beliefs exhibited lower confidence in democratic processes and were more likely to view Adolf Hitler positively as a statesman absent his war crimes, with such mindsets correlating to preferences for extreme-right parties.^[110] This pattern suggests that superstition fosters cynicism toward evidence-based governance, potentially amplifying populist or authoritarian appeals that promise supernatural or simplistic resolutions to complex issues.^[65] In political leadership, reliance on superstition can distort policy timing and resource allocation. Sri Lankan politicians, for instance, have historically consulted astrologers for election dates and major decisions, as documented in analyses of the country's political culture, leading to suboptimal outcomes like delayed reforms amid perceived inauspicious periods.^[111] Similarly, U.S. presidents have exhibited personal rituals—such as Abraham Lincoln avoiding travel on Fridays or Franklin D. Roosevelt shunning the number 13—which, while not directly policy-altering, reflect how such beliefs infiltrate executive behavior in high-stakes environments.^[112] These practices underscore a broader risk: when leaders prioritize omens over data, it erodes public faith in rational decision-making and invites exploitation by charlatans or rivals.^[113] Socially, superstitions exacerbate divisions and maladaptive behaviors, particularly in low-education or high-stress contexts. Empirical reviews indicate an inverse correlation between socioeconomic status and superstitious adherence, with lower-status groups more prone to beliefs that heighten anxiety and impair immune responses via chronic stress.^[114] For example, in regions with weak formal institutions, superstitions like curses on property thieves have served as informal deterrents, promoting self-governance where legal systems fail, as observed in studies of Native American communities and historical tribal societies.^[115] However, this comes at the cost of stifled progress; beliefs in omens can deter investments or travel on "unlucky" days, yielding measurable economic drags, such as avoided Friday the 13th activities costing billions annually in the U.S.^[104] On interpersonal levels, superstitions fuel stigma and exclusion, linking to broader irrational risk aversion. Research shows that superstitious individuals perceive higher threats in ambiguous situations, leading to avoidance behaviors that strain social cohesion—e.g., shunning those associated with "bad luck" symbols like black cats or broken mirrors, rooted in pre-modern folklore but persisting in modern discrimination patterns.^[99] Social exclusion itself amplifies superstitious thinking as a coping mechanism, creating feedback loops where marginalized groups turn to rituals over empirical solutions, perpetuating cycles of poverty and isolation.^[116] While some superstitions offer psychological comfort in uncertainty, their net social toll—evident in heightened prejudice or delayed aid during crises—often outweighs benefits absent robust counter-education.^[117]

Rational Critique and Opposition

Philosophical and Scientific Arguments Against

Philosophers grounded in empiricism have long contended that superstition fails the test of rational scrutiny by relying on unverified causal claims that exceed available evidence. David Hume, in his Dialogues Concerning Natural Religion (1779), distinguished superstition from true religion by arguing that the former stems from human fears and projections onto an anthropomorphic deity, leading to beliefs in arbitrary interventions without proportional testimony; he emphasized that extraordinary claims, such as miraculous events underpinning superstitions, require evidence inversely proportional to their improbability, a standard unmet by anecdotal reports alone.^[118] Bertrand Russell extended this critique in works like Why I Am Not a Christian (1927), asserting that superstitious doctrines persist due to emotional appeal rather than logical coherence, violating Occam's razor by invoking unnecessary supernatural entities when natural explanations suffice. Enlightenment rationalists further dismantled superstition as antithetical to causal realism, viewing it as a vestige of pre-scientific ignorance that impedes progress. Voltaire, in Philosophical Dictionary (1764), lambasted superstition as "the only universal enemy against which the philosopher must always declare war," exemplified by clerical exploitation of fears like omens or curses to maintain power, arguing instead for verifiable laws of nature derived from observation rather than priestly fiat.^[119] These arguments prioritize first-principles reasoning: causation must be inferred from repeatable patterns, not isolated correlations or authority, rendering superstitions philosophically untenable absent falsifiable mechanisms. From a scientific standpoint, behavioral psychology provides empirical refutation by demonstrating superstition as an artifact of operant conditioning rather than genuine causality. In a 1948 experiment, B.F. Skinner deprived pigeons of food to 75% of their normal weight, then delivered pellets at fixed intervals regardless of behavior; the birds developed repetitive "rituals"—such as turning in circles or head-bobbing—believing these actions caused reinforcement, illustrating how random contingencies foster illusory control without underlying links.^[32] This mirrors human superstitions, where intermittent coincidences (e.g., a lucky charm preceding success) reinforce unfounded rituals, as quantified in controlled studies showing no predictive power beyond chance.^[120] Cognitive neuroscience further undermines superstition by attributing it to systematic biases rather than external forces. Illusions of causality arise when the brain's pattern-detection heuristics, evolved for survival, overgeneralize temporal contiguities into false agencies, as evidenced by neuroimaging studies revealing heightened activity in agency-attribution regions during superstitious priming without corresponding environmental validation.^[121] Confirmation bias exacerbates this, with believers selectively recalling supportive instances while discounting disconfirmations; meta-analyses of paranormal claims, including astrology and precognition, consistently find null results under rigorous protocols, with effect sizes attributable to methodological flaws or expectation effects rather than veridical phenomena.^[31] Peer-reviewed surveys, such as those from the Committee for Skeptical Inquiry, document that superstitious adherence correlates inversely with scientific literacy, persisting primarily in low-evidence environments despite centuries of disconfirmation. Empirical falsificationism, as articulated by Karl Popper, seals the scientific case: superstitions evade testing by shifting goalposts (e.g., "the curse works invisibly"), rendering them non-falsifiable and thus unscientific; reproducible experiments, from randomized trials on lucky charms to longitudinal data on omens, yield no causal efficacy, affirming that natural laws—governed by probability and mechanism—obviate supernatural intermediaries. While some studies note short-term psychological boosts from rituals (e.g., reduced anxiety via placebo), these derive from self-fulfilling expectations, not objective reality, underscoring superstition's status as a cognitive shortcut supplanted by evidence-based inference.^[103]

Historical and Modern Eradication Efforts

Efforts to eradicate superstition through rational and scientific means gained prominence during the Enlightenment, when philosophers emphasized empirical evidence and critical reasoning to counter beliefs rooted in fear and unverified tradition. David Hume, in his 1742 essay "Of Superstition and Enthusiasm," argued that superstition originates from human dread of unknown evils, fostering dependency on priests and rituals rather than sound judgment, and positioned philosophy as a remedy to cure such irrationality.^[122]^[123] Enlightenment figures like Voltaire similarly decried superstition as a tool of clerical control, advocating education and skepticism to dismantle it, as seen in critiques of miracles and fanaticism that influenced broader secular reforms.^[124] In the 19th and early 20th centuries, positivist philosophy extended these campaigns by prioritizing verifiable scientific laws over speculative metaphysics. Auguste Comte's positivism, outlined in his 1830-1842 Course of Positive Philosophy, sought to replace theological and superstitious explanations with observational science, influencing educational reforms that integrated empirical methods into curricula to foster rational habits.^[125] Sigmund Freud's 1927 The Future of an Illusion further psychologized superstition as a childish projection of wishes, urging psychoanalysis and science to liberate individuals from such dependencies, though his views reflected a materialist bias against non-empirical beliefs.^[126] Modern eradication efforts crystallized in organized skeptical movements, exemplified by the 1976 founding of the Committee for the Scientific Investigation of Claims of the Paranormal (CSICOP, now the Committee for Skeptical Inquiry) by Paul Kurtz and collaborators, which promotes rigorous testing of paranormal assertions through publications like The Skeptical Inquirer and public challenges to supernatural claims.^[127]^[128] Legal measures have also targeted harmful superstitions; India's Maharashtra Prevention and Eradication of Human Sacrifice and Other Inhuman Practices and Black Magic Act of 2013 prohibits exploitative rituals like fake cures and human sacrifices, responding to documented cases of violence driven by superstitious accusations.^[129] In regions like sub-Saharan Africa, NGOs and governments have launched awareness campaigns against witch hunts, with Tanzania reporting over 500 annual attacks linked to such beliefs as of 2014, prompting community education on scientific causality.^[130] These initiatives often combine legal enforcement with science literacy programs, though persistence of beliefs underscores challenges in overcoming deeply ingrained cognitive patterns.^[126]

Potential Benefits and Limits of Rationalism

Rationalism, through its emphasis on empirical verification and logical deduction, enables the systematic rejection of unfounded beliefs, fostering advancements that superstitious practices cannot replicate. Scientific methodologies grounded in rationalism have demonstrably lowered global mortality rates and elevated living standards by replacing ritualistic approaches with evidence-based interventions, such as in medicine and public health.^[131] Analytical training further diminishes adherence to superstitions, correlating with enhanced critical evaluation and reduced vulnerability to illusory causal links.^[61] Despite these advantages, rationalism encounters inherent constraints rooted in human cognition and environmental complexity. Bounded rationality limits individuals' capacity to process complete information or compute optimal solutions under time pressures and uncertainty, often leading to reliance on heuristics that may incorporate superstitious elements for expediency.^[132] Superstitious beliefs can yield short-term performance gains by elevating self-efficacy and persistence, as evidenced in experiments where rituals like "knocking on wood" improved motor task accuracy and endurance compared to neutral conditions.^[41]^[133] Rational agents may persist with such beliefs when corrective experimentation proves costly or inconclusive, allowing superstitions to endure alongside logical frameworks.^[134] Even when aware of their irrationality, people frequently acquiesce to superstitious intuitions due to their potent psychological pull, which overrides deliberate reasoning in intuitive judgments.^[31] This acquiescence underscores rationalism's incomplete dominion over evolved cognitive biases, where over-application risks dismissing adaptive, if non-veridical, mental shortcuts in high-stakes, low-data scenarios.^[135]

References

[1]
The evolution of superstitious and superstition-like behaviour - PMC
Superstitious behaviours, which arise through the incorrect assignment of cause and effect, receive considerable attention in psychology and popular culture ...
[2]
Superstitious, magical, and paranormal beliefs: An integrative model
Historically, researchers have considered beliefs in superstition, magic, and the paranormal in some indefinite way both as distinct and interrelated phenomena.
[3]
New Research Suggests Almost Everybody Is Superstitious
Feb 19, 2024 · But their shocking conclusion was that a mere 3 percent of their sample fell into the non-superstitious category—zero belief in superstition and ...Missing: empirical | Show results with:empirical
[4]
The psychology of superstition, with Stuart Vyse, PhD
Vyse discusses the origins of some popular superstitions, the psychological purposes superstition serves, and whether or not it's possible that your lucky ...
[5]
Superstition in health beliefs: Concept exploration and development
Mar 26, 2020 · Superstition is adherence to delusions that have no intellectual or scientific explanation and lead to superstitious behaviors that are caused ...
[6]
(PDF) Understanding, defining and measuring the trait of superstition
An exploratory qualitative study allowed us to define superstition as “beliefs and/or practices that have no religious nor scientific foundations and which ...
[7]
The structure of superstitious action – A further analysis of fresh ...
Wiseman and Watt (2004) distinguished 'positive superstitions,' which seek to improve one's welfare, from 'negative superstitions,' which seek to guard against ...
[8]
The psychology of superstition - Inside UNI
Oct 29, 2024 · According to psychologist Stuart Vyse “superstitions are a subset of paranormal beliefs that are pragmatic,” meaning you can put them to use, ...Missing: scholarly | Show results with:scholarly
[9]
Superstition: Quirky Beliefs or Psychopathology? - Psychology Today
Dec 23, 2017 · In other words, a superstition is the belief that specific actions will directly influence an outcome in ways that go against scientific ...
[10]
Superstition - Etymology, Origin & Meaning
From Latin superstitionem, meaning "false religious belief or fear of the unknown," the word's origin is "standing over," combining super (above) + stare ...
[11]
The origins of superstition - Oxford Academic
The origin of the concept is found in ancient Greece in the 4th century bce, and for the next 2,000 years, superstition stood in contrast to the religious ...
[12]
Superstition
The English word derives from the Latin superstitio, the parts of which mean "standing over," as in transcending or standing outside of ordinary logic. In the ...
[13]
Superstition. - languagehat.com
May 27, 2014 · Most words as ostentatiously Latinate as superstition have transparent etymologies: election is from e(x)- 'out of' + legere 'to choose,' ...
[14]
https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/superstition
[15]
“Superstition”: an unlucky etymology? - Mashed Radish
Oct 13, 2017 · Superstitions are about “too much,” and this is thanks to its Latin root, superstare, “to stand over.”
[16]
On Ancient Superstition - jstor
I. THE Greek word for superstition is Se&uatSaovta, literally,. "fear of demons," and, as such, superstition ...
[17]
Omens and Superstitions - Roman-Empire.net
The Romans seem extremely superstitious. But then today's major religions have all throughout their past discouraged, even combatted, superstitions.
[18]
[PDF] Superstition and Sorcery
Medieval churchmen regarded superstition as rooted, ultimately, in the eternal and unwavering malice of demons, who sought always to lead faithful Christians ...<|separator|>
[19]
Introduction: The Meanings of Medieval Superstition
The origins of superstition extend deep into antiquity. Pagan Roman authors, not medieval Christian ones, coined the Latin term superstitio, while the ancient ...<|control11|><|separator|>
[20]
30 Medieval Superstitions - Medievalists.net
Sep 20, 2023 · Medieval superstitions included sacrilege at graves, swinish feasts, sacred rites of woods, and the belief that women could control the moon.
[21]
[PDF] Voltaire and the Enlightenment Response to Superstition
However, scholars uniformly agree that Voltaire was critical of religion, and further, that he was critical of superstition. Perry and Porter are a couple ...
[22]
Enlightenment and Thinking (Kant) - Time's Flow Stemmed
Oct 27, 2013 · Emancipation from superstition is called enlightenment*; for although this term applies also to emancipation from prejudices generally, still ...
[23]
[PDF] On the Resilience of Superstition
As most commonly used, there- fore, the category of belief implies the suppressed category of superstition, much like the common anthropological category 'the ...<|separator|>
[24]
Some Popular Superstitions of the Ancients : Frazer, James George ...
May 8, 2022 · Wikipedia has an entry on James George Frazer, the renowned 19th-20th-century social anthropologist and folklorist. Internet Archive has a ...
[25]
French Peasants and the Supernatural in the Nineteenth Century
This intriguing book examines popular religion, traditional medicine, witchcraft, apparitions, demonology, and magic in nineteenth-century rural France.
[26]
Apophenia as the Disposition to False Positives - NIH
Our findings suggest that apophenia may be a key cognitive process contributing to risk for psychosis. Findings also contribute to the growing body of ...
[27]
Apophenia - Psychology Today
Apophenia is a broad concept involving pattern perception in anything from the sequence of numbers in lottery wins to a pattern in statistical data.
[28]
Superstition predicts perception of illusory control - PubMed
This study found that the magnitude of this illusion was predicted by people's level of endorsement of common superstitious beliefs.
[29]
Superstition predicts perception of illusory control - Griffiths - 2019
Aug 24, 2018 · This study found that the magnitude of this illusion was predicted by people's level of endorsement of common superstitious beliefs (measured ...
[30]
[PDF] Acquiescence to Superstitious Beliefs and Other Powerful Intuitions
Feb 24, 2015 · In addition, a person's cognitive skills can affect superstitious behavior by influencing whether or not System 2 identifies a magical ...
[31]
Skinner (1948) - Classics in the History of Psychology - York University
Such a stimulus has reinforcing value and can set up superstitious behavior. A pigeon will often develop some response such as turning, twisting, pecking near ...
[32]
Superstitious beliefs and the associative mind - ScienceDirect.com
Superstition has been described as a by-product of adaptive behaviour. · This hypothesis was tested in healthy individuals using two implicit learning tasks.
[33]
Superstitions evolved to help us survive | New Scientist
Sep 10, 2008 · The tendency to falsely link cause to effect – a superstition – is occasionally beneficial, says Kevin Foster, an evolutionary biologist at Harvard University.Missing: origins | Show results with:origins
[34]
Hyperactive Agency Detection - NeuroLogica Blog
Mar 22, 2010 · Seeing natural or random events as the will of an agent is HADD. HADD also leads to superstition – thinking that there is a cause and effect ...
[35]
Paranormal believers are more prone to illusory agency detection ...
It has been hypothesized that illusory agency detection is at the basis of belief in supernatural agents and paranormal beliefs.
[36]
HADD its day: there's no evidence for an inherited hyperactive ...
Nov 13, 2024 · The hyperactive agency detection device has its roots in evolutionary psychology, quite a specific approach to evolutionary psychology in fact.
[37]
Error management theory and the ability to bias belief and doubt in
Aug 29, 2024 · Error Management Theory (EMT) suggests that cognitive adaptations evolved to minimize the cost of false negative and false positive errors in ...
[38]
Cognitive and evolutionary foundations of superstition and paranoia
Aug 3, 2022 · According to this view, superstitions inevitably result from an adaptive causal learning mechanism that reduces the risk of errors. ... ...
[39]
The evolution of superstition through optimal use of incomplete ...
The evolutionary background to (mis)understanding an uncertain world · THE ADAPTIVE FUNCTION OF SUPERSTITION FROM AN EVOLUTIONARY PSYCHOLOGY PERSPECTIVE · The ...Missing: origins | Show results with:origins
[40]
Keep your fingers crossed!: how superstition improves performance
... lucky charm improves subsequent performance in golfing, motor dexterity, memory, and anagram games. Furthermore, Experiments 3 and 4 demonstrate that these ...
[41]
Keep Your Fingers Crossed!: How Superstition Improves Performance
May 28, 2010 · Specifically, Experiments 1 through 4 show that activating good-luck-related superstitions via a common saying or action (e.g., “break a leg,” ...
[42]
Replication of the superstition and performance study by Damisch ...
Feb 18, 2013 · Here we report two high-powered, precise replications of the golf and superstition experiment (Study 1) from Damisch et al. (2010). We focused ...
[43]
Half-Belief in Superstitions | Psychology Today
Jun 19, 2024 · For instance, the authors note that one Gallup poll found that about 25 percent of Americans identified as superstitious (Daprarti et al., 2019) ...
[44]
[PDF] Superstitious Rituals Among College Athletes: A Pilot Study
Despite anecdotal information suggesting a high prevalence of superstitious practices among athletes, empirical study has been limited. Even less is known about ...
[45]
Prevalence, patterns and predictors of paranormal beliefs in The ...
Sep 4, 2024 · About a tenth of the population (10%, 95% CI [8, 11]) are extremely sceptical towards everyday superstitions, but less sceptical towards other ...
[46]
The evolution of superstitious and superstition-like behaviour
We conclude that behaviours which are, or appear, superstitious are an inevitable feature of adaptive behaviour in all organisms, including ourselves.
[47]
The evolution of superstitious and superstition-like behaviour
Sep 9, 2008 · Superstitious behavior arises from incorrect cause/effect assignment. Natural selection can favor this if occasional correct responses have a ...
[48]
Superstition | Research Starters - EBSCO
Superstition refers to the belief that unseen or supernatural forces can influence earthly events and human experiences.Missing: scholarly | Show results with:scholarly
[49]
Omens, charms, and talismans - Folklore And Visual Culture - Fiveable
Omens are signs that foretell events, while charms and talismans are objects with magical powers. The lines between them often blur. Cultural differences affect ...
[50]
[PDF] EC5594 Superstitions and their Origin - UNL Digital Commons
I. Many of our superstitious beliefs and practices originated long, long ago and it is interesting to trace back through the years to find the origin of ...
[51]
[PDF] Superstitions From Around the World
Another very common superstition in the US is to use the phrase "knock on wood", this is used to avoid bad luck. The reason behind this comes from medieval.
[52]
Ideas of luck and superstition vary among cultures around the world
Jul 12, 2018 · Even though global structures and motifs of superstitions can be very similar, cultural meanings and resonances can be very different, Thompson ...Missing: cross- variations
[53]
Level of superstition in different countries - ResearchGate
Superstitious beliefs are found to be widely prevalent among all cultures and communities across the globe. Despite the progress of science and technology, ...
[54]
Superstitions Across Cultures: Friday, 13, 4, and Green Hats
Jun 13, 2014 · Friday the 13th is unlucky in some cultures, but lucky in Chinese culture. In China, 4 is bad, 14 good, and men avoid green hats.
[55]
7 Strange Superstitions From Across the World | Psychology Today
Oct 8, 2023 · No uniform definition of superstition exists, but most conflate good or bad luck with irrational beliefs. Many superstitions revolve around ...<|separator|>
[56]
10 Superstitions From Different Countries & Cultures
Oct 10, 2025 · In India and some parts of Africa, owls are considered bad omens, often associated with death or misfortune. By contrast, in Ancient Greece, the ...
[57]
SUPERSTITIOUS BELIEFS ACROSS CULTURES: A VIEW FROM ...
Jan 6, 2022 · Superstitions vary greatly across cultures, with little similarity and cultural changes altering their concept and purpose.
[58]
Analytic cognitive style predicts religious and paranormal belief
An analytic cognitive style negatively predicted both religious and paranormal beliefs when controlling for cognitive ability as well as religious engagement.
[59]
The Effect of Analytic Cognitive Style on Credulity - PMC - NIH
Oct 15, 2020 · Analytic thinking predicts credulity and belief in the paranormal was linked with experiencing more anomalous experiences and more paranormal explanations.
[60]
Does training analytical thinking decrease superstitious beliefs ...
Analytical thinking negatively predicted superstitious beliefs. Analytic thinking could be primed through a brief session. Religiosity may moderate the link.
[61]
Does Training Analytical Thinking Decrease Superstitious Beliefs ...
Aug 7, 2025 · As expected, enhancing analytical thinking led to decreased reporting of superstitious beliefs, but contrary to our hypothesis, the moderating ...<|control11|><|separator|>
[62]
[PDF] Role of Intelligence in Superstitiousness among University Students
Research suggests a link between intelligence and superstitious beliefs, indicating that individuals with higher intelligence levels tend to exhibit lower ...
[63]
Critical Thinking, Intelligence, and Unsubstantiated Beliefs - NIH
Oct 30, 2023 · Studies have also found positive correlations between superstitious belief and intuitive cognitive style (e.g., Lindeman and Aarnio 2006 ...
[64]
Study Highlights Dangers of Superstitious Beliefs - Psychology Today
Dec 29, 2023 · In the current study, the authors found that superstitious beliefs were negatively correlated with education, which lends further evidence to ...
[65]
[PDF] Intelligence and Individual Differences in Astrological Belief - Gwern
Feb 13, 2025 · We find evidence that low intelligence and low education are associated with belief in astrology consistent with the super- ficial knowledge ...
[66]
[PDF] Relationship between superstitious beliefs, and Big Five Personality ...
Superstitious beliefs positively correlate with extroversion and neuroticism. Extroversion and neuroticism are positive predictors of superstitious beliefs. ...
[67]
The psychology of superstition - MedicalNewsToday
Sep 13, 2019 · This Friday the 13th, we take a look at the psychological mechanisms of superstitions and their effect on mental health and well-being.
[68]
[PDF] Psycho-social factors contributing to superstitious behavior - SciSpace
Psychological factors like fear, locus of control, confidence level etc. and social factors such as locale, socio-economic status etc. Keywords: superstition, ...
[69]
Superstitious beliefs, locus of control, and feeling at risk in the face ...
Superstitious beliefs are often attempts to understand and control uncertainty (Ya'akov et al., 2018). Observing superstition helps regulate tension in ...
[70]
[PDF] Differences in Prevailing Superstitious Beliefs and Health Anxiety ...
Jul 24, 2025 · Recent data show that health anxiety is becoming more common among young adults, particularly college students. A systematic review by Kocsis ( ...
[71]
Social and Psychological factors for Superstition: A Brief Literature ...
Sep 27, 2018 · The present literature review focused on social and psychological factors associated with superstition.
[72]
Cicero on religion and superstitions - IMPERIUM ROMANUM
Feb 9, 2019 · Cicero on religion and superstitions: For religion has been distinguished from superstition not only by philosophers but by our 72 ancestors.<|control11|><|separator|>
[73]
The Religio of Lucretius - jstor
Superstitio, on the other hand, appears several times in the two dialogues. I suggest that this sense of "irrational fear" is always uppermost in the mind of ...Missing: distinction | Show results with:distinction
[74]
SUMMA THEOLOGIAE: Superstition (Secunda ... - New Advent
But religion is included in the definition of superstition: for the latter is defined as being "immoderate observance of religion," according to a gloss on ...<|control11|><|separator|>
[75]
The Disenchantment of the World | Lawrence Stone
Dec 2, 1971 · Hobbes rightly pointed out that the distinction between superstition and religion is in the eye of the beholder. “This fear of things ...
[76]
Religio and Superstitio Reconsidered - jstor
differences in the beliefs and practices. Numerous religious and superstitious beliefs and practices coexisted in. Roman society. Cicero apparently.
[77]
(PDF) It Is About Believing: Superstition and Religiosity
Closeness to the churches goes in line with lower superstition. On the other hand, a generally higher perceived religiosity increases superstition.
[78]
[PDF] Religiosity, Locus of Control, and Superstitious Belief - UW-La Crosse
Religiosity has been found to correlate with the occurrence of superstitious and paranormal beliefs in many studies (Beck & Miller, 2001; MacDonald, 1995; ...
[79]
Superstitions, religiosity and secularization: an analysis of ... - Genus
Dec 1, 2016 · We investigated the influence of superstition and religious beliefs on the choice of wedding dates. We compared our results with those relative to postwar ...
[80]
Superstition and the Construction of Religious and Cultural Difference
May 12, 2013 · “Superstition” mainly refers to beliefs and practices allegedly based upon faulty understandings of nature and causality; ie beliefs not warranted by science.
[81]
Superstition | Description & Examples | Britannica
Sep 19, 2025 · Superstition, belief, half-belief, or practice for which there appears to be no rational substance. Those who use the term imply that they have certain ...
[82]
[PDF] ŸSuperstitionâ•Ž From Late Antiquity through the Carolingian Era
May 10, 2014 · Therefore, when Christians employed the term 'superstition' it was meant to insult, often directed at their pagan counterparts. 'Superstition ...
[83]
https://digitalcommons.trinity.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1020&context=infolit_usra
[84]
Superstitious Talk: Is It Time to Move On from the 'S-Word'?
Jan 23, 2017 · Philosophers, like psychologists, tend to define superstition as the human tendency to see patterns where there are none and interpret as ...
[85]
In the past, all non-scientific reasoning was considered illogical or ...
Nov 6, 2021 · Folklorists don't use the term “superstition” anymore exactly because the term is pejorative and indicates a stance of irrationality. The term * ...
[86]
The prejudice of scientific materialism towards “superstition” is racist ...
Jun 29, 2022 · The bias that exists in the monoculture's materialistic criticism of indigenous belief systems such as animism is racist at its core.
[87]
What's the difference between superstition and religion? [closed]
Nov 20, 2014 · The way he states it (and I think he gets this from others like Aquinas): superstition falls short of reason, faith (or religion, if you'd ...
[88]
The everyday magic of superstition | BPS
Oct 12, 2016 · Under the broad definition of 'superstition' he includes luck, omens or signs, occult powers or beginnings – which he describes as a belief that ...Missing: philosophy | Show results with:philosophy
[89]
How to Profit from Magical Thinking | Chicago Booth Review
May 15, 2017 · Superstition is believing, erroneously, that there is a causal connection between two things, even when it's obvious that they are not related.
[90]
Superstitiousness in obsessive-compulsive disorder - PMC - NIH
In fact, most characteristic of modern superstitious beliefs are rather abstract ideas about a paranormal causation of coincidences (telepathy, clairvoyance, ...
[91]
Crystal healing: Stone-cold facts about gemstone treatments
Jan 25, 2022 · Scientifically speaking, there is no evidence that crystal healing can be used to cure diseases, because diseases have never been found to be ...
[92]
How Astrology Escaped the Pull of Science - McGill University
Oct 9, 2020 · Astrology is a pseudoscience due to its lack of progress and refusal to deal with a large body of critical scientific studies.Missing: efficacy | Show results with:efficacy
[93]
Is Astrology Real? Here's What Science Says - Scientific American
Jun 25, 2020 · About a third of Americans believe astrology is "very" or "sort of scientific." But does being a Pisces, Virgo rising really matter in the eyes of science?
[94]
A systematic review of systematic reviews of homeopathy - PMC - NIH
Eleven independent systematic reviews were located. Collectively they failed to provide strong evidence in favour of homeopathy. In particular, there was no ...
[95]
Efficacy of homoeopathic treatment: Systematic review of meta ...
Oct 7, 2023 · The quality of evidence for positive effects of homoeopathy beyond placebo (high/moderate/low/very low) was high for I-HOM and moderate for ALL-HOM and NI-HOM.
[96]
Crystal Healing | Science-Based Medicine
Sep 18, 2019 · It is a form of energy medicine. Proponents claim that different types of crystals either contain, amplify, attract, or repel different kinds of energy.
[97]
Do Healing Crystals Work? Lore, History, Research - Healthline
There's no scientific proof that crystals have any significant effect on energy, emotions, or mental health. Don't replace medical treatment for anxiety, ...<|separator|>
[98]
The impacts of superstition on risk preferences and beliefs
This work deepens our understanding of how superstition shapes people's economic decisions, but the underlying mechanisms largely remain unexplored.
[99]
[PDF] Superstition and risk-taking: Evidence from “zodiac year” beliefs in ...
Jul 19, 2022 · In this paper, we show that superstitious beliefs impact the risk-taking of Chinese firms as a function of the birth year of their chairmen. In ...
[100]
The effects of superstition on firms' investment behavior
This study examines the impact of superstition on corporate decision-making in Vietnam, a highly irreligious country.
[101]
How superstition changes the way we make decisions
Jun 6, 2018 · Superstition and Risk-Taking. The researchers devised a few different experiments to tease out the effect of superstition on risk-taking. In ...
[102]
The Differential Effects of Good Luck Belief on Cognitive ... - NIH
Feb 28, 2019 · There is evidence that inducing a luck-related superstition leads to better performance on a variety of motor dexterity and cognitive tasks.
[103]
The value of superstitions - PMC - PubMed Central
Such superstitions can change the allocation of economic resources. For instance, those with “unlucky” plates drive their cars unnecessarily slower is an ...
[104]
The value of superstitions - ScienceDirect.com
Our main result shows that superstitions do carry a significant economic value. This finding lends further support to the fact that many business practices ...
[105]
[PDF] chicagotribune.com - The cost of superstition
Mar 16, 2008 · Researchers estimate that U.S. businesses lose between $800 and $900 million every Friday the 13th— bad luck on that day is one of the most ...
[106]
Bad Things That Have Happened on Friday the 13th - Business Insider
Jun 13, 2025 · Between $800 and $900 million are lost in business every Friday the 13th because people are afraid to shop, travel, and conduct business.<|separator|>
[107]
Friday 13th And Financial Markets - Long Finance
May 1, 2015 · In US Markets since 1950, returns on Fridays the 13th have averaged 0.88%, more than twice the 0.34% average gain of trading days in general. ' ...
[108]
(PDF) Trait Superstition and Consumer Behavior - ResearchGate
Aug 6, 2025 · The authors propose that superstitions are employed as a heuristic device and that they influence a variety of consumer behaviors.<|separator|>
[109]
beyond religion: superstition, traditional beliefs and the extreme right
Oct 9, 2023 · Superstitious voters have less trust in the political system and are more inclined to think Hitler would be a good stateman if he had not ...Missing: ramifications | Show results with:ramifications
[110]
(PDF) Superstitious Beliefs and Practices in Politics: An Aspect of ...
Oct 28, 2021 · The main objective of this paper is to examine and assess the behavior of the politicians who due to their ingrained superstitious beliefs engage in various ...Missing: ramifications | Show results with:ramifications
[111]
Surprising Details About US Presidents And Their Superstitions
Aug 19, 2025 · A lot of people have superstitions - everything from fear of black cats to throwing spilled salt over one's shoulder to ward off evil ...
[112]
Opinion: Superstition and Science in Governance and Global Health
Jan 7, 2025 · In the past, Sri Lankan leaders have used astrology to time critical decisions, including elections and policy rollouts, further eroding trust ...
[113]
[PDF] Social and Psychological factors for Superstition: A Brief Literature ...
Study conducted by James & Wells ( 2002) concluded that Superstitious beliefs can produce detrimental effects on immune system and level of stress and a greater ...Missing: consequences | Show results with:consequences
[114]
https://zenodo.org/record/1405381/files/ij11.pdf
[115]
[PDF] How social exclusion leads to superstitious thinking
This paper tests a meaning-making model of conspiratorial thinking by considering how one's search for mean- ing mediates between social exclusion and the ...
[116]
Superstitious beliefs, locus of control, and feeling at risk in the face ...
May 10, 2022 · Superstitious beliefs are related to health and individual differences regarding illnesses and epidemics. Superstition may lead to stress, ...
[117]
Hume on Religion - Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Oct 4, 2005 · David Hume's various writings concerning problems of religion are among the most important and influential contributions on this topic.
[118]
Voltaire - Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Aug 31, 2009 · Voltaire was a French writer and public activist who played a singular role in defining the eighteenth-century movement called the Enlightenment.
[119]
'Superstition' in the pigeon. - APA PsycNet
"A pigeon is brought to a stable state of hunger by reducing it to 75 percent of its weight when well fed. It is put into an experimental cage for a few ...
[120]
Illusions of causality: how they bias our everyday thinking and ... - NIH
Superstitious, magical, and pseudoscientific thinking refer to ungrounded beliefs that are not supported by current evidence (Lindeman and Svedholm, 2012). Many ...
[121]
Of Superstition and Enthusiasm - Hume Texts Online
My first reflection is, That superstition is favourable to priestly power, and enthusiasm not less or rather more contrary to it, than sound reason and ...
[122]
Hume on Curing Superstition - Project MUSE
Mar 21, 2023 · "David Hume proclaimed philosophy the supreme, indeed the only, cure for superstition." The context suggests that Hume had great "confidence ...
[123]
Enlightenment Debates over Mesmerism and Miracles
Furthermore, the miracles and convulsions at Saint-Médard figured prominently in Enlightenment criticisms of religious fanaticism and superstition. For example, ...
[124]
[PDF] Michael D. Bailey. Magic and Superstition in Europe - Journals@KU
Later, Enlightenment thinkers fought to eradicate both superstitions and institutionalized religion. Despite all attempts, magic has not been replaced by ...
[125]
Why Are We Still Superstitious? | Scientific American
May 3, 2024 · Superstitions linger into the modern era, in part, because they may be holdovers from a time when they provided a measure of protection from ...
[126]
History of CSICOP - Skeptical Inquirer
It referred to CSICOP as “the leading organization” of scientists, conjurers, and others devoted to examining the borders of science.
[127]
The History of CFI | Center for Inquiry
In 1976, humanist philosopher Paul Kurtz brought together an unprecedented assembly of some of the greatest minds of the era to promote scientific inquiry and ...
[128]
The Maharashtra Anti-Superstition Act
Nov 13, 2024 · The Maharashtra Prevention and Eradication of Human Sacrifice and other Inhuman, Evil and Aghori Practices and Black Magic Act, 2013
[129]
MP Arora moves Bill to eradicate superstition, prohibit black magic
Feb 11, 2025 · This bill seeks to prohibit black magic, human sacrifice, witch-hunting, and other exploitative rituals that continue to harm individuals.
[130]
Ritual, superstition and science in wound healing: Part 1 – the limits ...
Jul 2, 2025 · The article highlights how modern medicine, although grounded in empiricism, sometimes intersects with cultural superstitions, especially during ...
[131]
Bounded Rationality - Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Nov 30, 2018 · Bounded rationality has come to encompass models of effective behavior that weaken, or reject altogether, the idealized conditions of perfect ...
[132]
[PDF] Keep Your Fingers Crossed! How Superstition Improves Performance
A pretest identified three commonly held superstitions in our participant population, namely, the general belief in good luck, the belief that keeping one's ...
[133]
[PDF] Superstition and Rational Learning | MIT Economics
Jun 5, 2003 · Abstract: We argue that some but not all superstitions can persist when learning is rational and players are patient, and illustrate our ...
[134]
[PDF] Acquiescence to Superstitious Beliefs and Other Powerful Intuitions
First, superstitions and magical thinking focus largely on causal reasoning, whereas paranormal and su- pernatural beliefs do not. Second, paranormal and ...