Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Transfer of learning

Transfer of learning is the process by which knowledge, skills, or attitudes acquired in one context are applied to enhance (positive transfer) or hinder (negative transfer) performance in a new or varied context.^[1]^[2] This phenomenon is fundamental to human cognition and education, as it determines how prior experiences influence future behaviors and problem-solving across diverse situations.^[3]^[4] The concept traces its origins to early 20th-century psychology, particularly Edward Thorndike and Robert Woodworth's 1901 theory of identical elements, which argued that transfer depends on the similarity of stimuli and responses between the original learning environment and the new one.^[4]^[3] Over decades, this behaviorist foundation evolved into cognitive and constructivist frameworks, such as David Perkins and Gavriel Salomon's 1989 distinction between low-road transfer (automatic application in similar contexts) and high-road transfer (deliberate abstraction for dissimilar contexts).^[4]^[2] Key types include near transfer, involving closely related situations, and far transfer, requiring adaptation to novel domains, with research emphasizing the role of motivation, context, and reflection in facilitating effective transfer.^[4]^[3] In educational and training settings, transfer of learning remains a primary goal, as it enables learners to generalize abilities beyond rote memorization to real-world applications, such as using mathematical principles from classroom exercises in professional engineering tasks.^[5] Challenges like negative transfer—where prior knowledge interferes, as in language learning from native tongue habits—highlight the need for instructional strategies like problem-based learning and cognitive apprenticeship to promote mindful abstraction and situated practice.^[2]^[4] Research underscores trends toward immersive technologies and communities of practice to bridge gaps in transfer, particularly in adult education and organizational training.^[4]

Fundamentals

Definition and Scope

Transfer of learning refers to the influence that prior learning experiences exert on the acquisition and performance of new skills or knowledge in different contexts, where such influence can either facilitate (positive transfer) or impede (negative transfer) the new learning.^[6] This phenomenon is central to cognitive and educational psychology, emphasizing how previously acquired competencies are applied beyond their original setting to novel tasks or domains.^[4] The scope of transfer of learning is distinct from mere retention, which involves recalling information within the same context, or simple generalization, which applies knowledge broadly without crossing significant contextual boundaries; instead, transfer specifically highlights the adaptive reuse of knowledge across varied situations, often requiring abstraction or analogical reasoning.^[4] It encompasses applications from closely related tasks to more distant ones, underscoring the flexibility of human cognition in bridging old and new experiences. For instance, skills learned in driving a car, such as steering and spatial awareness, can positively transfer to operating a truck, accelerating mastery of the new vehicle.^[6] In contrast, negative transfer might occur when prior knowledge of French grammar confuses the learning of Spanish, leading to errors in verb conjugations or gender agreements due to superficial similarities between the languages.^[6] Transfer of learning operates on a continuum, ranging from near transfer—where the new context closely resembles the original—to far transfer, involving application to dissimilar or remote scenarios, and is inherent to all learning processes rather than an isolated event, as no knowledge acquisition occurs in complete isolation from prior experiences.^[7]^[4] This integrated view positions transfer as a fundamental aspect of cognitive development, influencing how individuals generalize skills across domains like motor abilities or linguistic structures.^[4]

Historical Development

The concept of transfer of learning traces its roots to the ancient doctrine of faculty psychology, which posited that the mind consists of discrete faculties such as memory, attention, and reasoning that could be strengthened through rigorous mental exercises, thereby enhancing general cognitive abilities.^[8] This view, originating in Aristotelian philosophy, was revived in the 19th century as the theory of formal discipline, advocating that studying classical subjects like Latin and mathematics would discipline the mind and facilitate broader intellectual transfer.^[9] In the early 20th century, Edward Thorndike challenged formal discipline with his identical elements theory, introduced in 1901, which argued that transfer occurs only to the extent that the original learning situation shares specific stimulus-response elements with the new one.^[10] Through quantitative experiments comparing performance on tasks like estimating lengths and areas, Thorndike and Robert Woodworth demonstrated minimal transfer—often near zero—when identical components were absent, emphasizing the specificity of learning over general faculty strengthening.^[10] Charles Judd advanced an alternative in 1908 with his generalization theory, highlighting the role of abstract principles in enabling transfer beyond mere identical elements.^[11] In landmark experiments with schoolchildren throwing darts at underwater targets to account for light refraction, Judd showed that groups trained with explicit explanations of the optical principle achieved substantial transfer to novel distances and setups, outperforming those relying on rote practice alone.^[11] Edwin Guthrie's contiguity theory, outlined in his 1935 work, further refined behaviorist perspectives by proposing that transfer arises from the recurrence of identical stimuli paired with responses through temporal proximity, expecting limited generalization without such overlaps.^[12] Following World War II, psychology shifted from behaviorist dominance toward cognitive approaches, incorporating mental processes like abstraction and metacognition into transfer explanations.^[13] A key milestone in this evolution came with David Perkins and Gavriel Salomon's 1988 framework of "hugging and bridging," which integrated earlier insights to promote transfer: "hugging" reinforces near transfer through contextual similarities, while "bridging" fosters far transfer via explicit connections to principles and metacognitive prompts.^[14]

Theoretical Frameworks

Relation to Learning

Transfer of learning is inseparable from the fundamental processes of learning, manifesting as a direct outcome of encoding, storage, and retrieval within memory systems. Encoding transforms sensory input from initial experiences into cognitive representations that integrate with existing knowledge, laying the groundwork for potential generalization to new contexts. Storage consolidates these representations through neural consolidation, forming interconnected networks that preserve relational structures across experiences. Retrieval accesses these stored elements to apply them adaptively, ensuring that learned content influences behavior in novel situations. Thus, all learning inherently involves the potential for transfer, as it relies on memory operations that inherently support cross-context application.^[15]^[16] Episodic and semantic memory systems underpin transfer by enabling schema activation, where organized knowledge frameworks bridge past and present experiences. Episodic memory stores context-specific events, providing vivid cues that facilitate the recall of relevant details for analogous problems, while semantic memory maintains decontextualized facts and concepts, allowing for efficient generalization. Schema activation occurs when semantic structures are primed by episodic retrieval, integrating specific memories into broader patterns that guide decision-making and skill adaptation. This interplay ensures that transfer leverages both detailed recollections and abstract principles to enhance performance in unfamiliar domains.^[17]^[18] Abstraction during initial learning further embeds transfer potential by promoting the formation of general rules and analogies from diverse examples. As learners encounter varied instances, they extract relational invariances—common structural mappings across situations—creating schemas that detach knowledge from superficial details. Analogical reasoning supports this by aligning new problems with prior ones, yielding principles applicable beyond the original context. This bootstrapping process transforms concrete experiences into flexible abstractions, making transfer a natural extension of how knowledge is initially constructed.^[19]^[20] Empirical studies from the 1970s highlight how varied practice during acquisition fosters transfer, aligning with schema-based views of learning. Richard Schmidt's schema theory argues that exposure to task variations during training builds invariant rules, enabling better adaptation to novel conditions than repetitive practice. Supporting experiments, such as those by Newell and Shapiro, demonstrated that groups trained on variable motor tasks exhibited superior transfer to untrained distances or forces, with performance gains persisting over delays. These findings illustrate that diversity in early learning strengthens abstract representations, directly enhancing transfer efficacy.^[21]

Mechanisms and Processes

The encoding specificity principle describes a core cognitive process in transfer of learning, wherein successful application of prior knowledge to a new situation depends on the overlap between contextual cues present during initial encoding and those available during retrieval. According to this principle, memory traces are formed in conjunction with specific environmental or situational details, and retrieval—and thus transfer—is optimal only when similar cues reinstate the original encoding context; mismatched cues lead to retrieval failure and hinder transfer. This process underscores why transfer often falters in novel settings lacking familiar prompts, as demonstrated in episodic memory experiments where cue-target associations directly influenced recall accuracy. Analogy and structure-mapping provide another key mechanism for enabling transfer, particularly across dissimilar surface features but shared relational structures. Structure-mapping theory posits that learners achieve transfer by aligning and mapping abstract relational patterns from a source domain (the base) onto a target domain, prioritizing higher-order connections like causal relations over object attributes. This relational abstraction allows knowledge from one area, such as solving a physics problem via a mechanical analogy, to inform problem-solving in unrelated fields like biology, provided the underlying structural correspondences are identified and applied. Metacognition facilitates transfer through self-regulatory processes that heighten awareness of one's knowledge and strategies, enabling the deliberate recognition and activation of relevant prior learning in new contexts. By engaging in self-monitoring and evaluation, learners can identify parallels between current challenges and past experiences, bridging gaps that might otherwise prevent transfer; for instance, in mathematical reasoning, metacognitive prompts encourage reflection on strategy applicability, leading to broader skill generalization. This monitoring role is essential for overcoming automatic but inflexible responses, promoting adaptive application of abstracted knowledge. Interference effects, including proactive and retroactive inhibition, represent psychological processes that can block or diminish transfer, especially in cases of negative outcomes. Proactive inhibition occurs when established prior learning competes with and suppresses the acquisition or recall of new, similar information, while retroactive inhibition arises when subsequent learning overwrites or disrupts access to earlier memories, leading to confusion or errors in application. These mechanisms explain negative transfer in skill acquisition, such as when training on one motor task impairs performance on a slightly varied one due to conflicting response patterns. Qualitative models of transfer integrate these processes by conceptualizing transfer effectiveness as a function of task similarity and the abstraction level of encoded knowledge, where transfer ≈ f(similarity × abstraction level), emphasizing that high structural similarity combined with decontextualized, relational abstractions maximizes positive outcomes across domains.

Classifications

Positive, Negative, and Zero Transfer

Positive transfer occurs when prior learning facilitates the acquisition or performance of a new skill or task, often due to shared elements between the learning contexts.^[22] For instance, knowledge of algebraic manipulation gained in mathematics courses can enhance problem-solving in introductory physics, where students apply equations to model physical phenomena more efficiently.^[23] This facilitation is evident in experimental settings where groups exposed to prior mathematical training outperform those without such exposure on physics assessments.^[24] Negative transfer, in contrast, arises when prior learning interferes with or hinders new learning, typically because of conflicting elements between tasks.^[25] A classic example is the interference from a first language (L1) in acquiring a second language (L2), where syntactic structures or phonological patterns from the L1 lead to errors in L2 production, such as incorrect word order in English sentences for speakers of verb-final languages.^[26] This phenomenon, known as negative transfer or L1 interference, slows L2 acquisition and increases error rates in early stages, as documented in cross-linguistic studies.^[27] Zero transfer refers to situations where prior learning has no discernible effect—positive or negative—on the performance of a new task, often because the domains lack overlapping components.^[28] For example, musical training may not improve spatial reasoning abilities without specific mediation, such as tasks linking notation to visual-spatial mapping; meta-analyses and vision studies show no general transfer to non-musical spatial tasks like visual search or object location memory.^[29]^[30] In unrelated domains, such as applying bowling techniques to swimming strokes, prior experience yields neutral outcomes with no facilitation or hindrance.^[25] The measurement of these transfer types relies on controlled experimental designs that compare performance across groups: one with relevant prior exposure and a control group without, isolating the net effect on learning speed, accuracy, or retention in the new task.^[22] Early work by Thorndike demonstrated this through paired-associate tasks showing variable transfer based on stimulus-response similarity.^[31] Quantitative metrics, such as reaction times or error rates, quantify positive effects as improvements above baseline, negative as declines, and zero as equivalence between groups.^[32]

Near, Far, and Vertical Transfer

Transfer of learning is often classified by the degree of contextual similarity between the original learning situation and the new application, as well as by the hierarchical progression of knowledge levels. These dimensions highlight how knowledge applies to similar or dissimilar settings and from basic to more abstract concepts, influencing educational design and cognitive development.^[14] Near transfer refers to the application of learned skills or knowledge to contexts that are highly similar to the original learning environment, requiring minimal adaptation. This type of transfer relies on shared perceptual cues or routines, making it more automatic and predictable. For instance, arithmetic skills acquired in school mathematics classes can facilitate calculations during everyday activities like shopping or budgeting, as the procedural similarities trigger direct application.^[14] Perkins and Salomon describe near transfer as involving "short steps" between closely related performances, such as shifting from driving a car to driving a truck due to overlapping motor and perceptual demands.^[14] Far transfer, in contrast, involves applying knowledge to contexts that are dissimilar or distant from the initial learning situation, often demanding greater abstraction and deliberate effort. This form is more challenging and less reliable, as it requires bridging conceptual gaps without obvious surface similarities. An example is the potential use of chess strategies, such as planning multiple moves ahead, to enhance general problem-solving abilities in unrelated domains like business decision-making; however, empirical evidence for such broad far transfer from chess remains debated, with meta-analyses showing limited or no significant effects on overall cognitive skills beyond domain-specific improvements.^[14]^[33] Perkins and Salomon characterize far transfer as a "long step," exemplified by interpreting a legal concept like a "lease" metaphorically in Shakespeare's reference to summer's brevity, where abstract connections must be actively forged.^[14] Vertical transfer describes the application of foundational or lower-level knowledge to higher-level, more complex tasks, often progressing from concrete skills to abstract principles within a hierarchical structure. This type is essential in curriculum sequencing, where prerequisite learning enables advancement. For example, mastery of basic addition and subtraction supports the understanding of algebraic equations, as initial numerical operations form the building blocks for symbolic manipulation.^[34] According to Haskell's taxonomy, vertical transfer occurs when "learning necessitates prerequisite skills," such as using alphabet letter formation to construct words and sentences, facilitating progression in linguistic complexity.^[34] A complementary taxonomy within these classifications distinguishes transfer by the level of cognitive engagement, as proposed by Salomon and Perkins: low-road transfer, which is automatic and triggered by environmental similarities without much reflection, and high-road transfer, which involves mindful abstraction and deliberate application across varied contexts. Low-road transfer aligns closely with near transfer, occurring effortlessly through well-practiced routines, such as automatically applying reading strategies to a textbook in a familiar format.^[14] High-road transfer, more aligned with far and vertical types, requires active reflection and can be forward-reaching (anticipating future uses during learning) or backward-reaching (applying past knowledge to new problems), as seen in using calculus principles derived from basic geometry to model economic trends.^[14] This mindful dimension emphasizes the role of instructional strategies in promoting deeper, more flexible transfer beyond superficial cues.^[14]

Influencing Factors

Cognitive and Individual Factors

Cognitive and individual factors play a pivotal role in modulating the transfer of learning, as they influence how learners access, apply, and generalize knowledge across contexts. These internal characteristics, including cognitive abilities, motivational states, developmental stages, and expertise levels, determine the extent to which prior experiences facilitate or hinder adaptation to new tasks. Research grounded in cognitive psychology highlights that such factors interact with task demands, often leading to variability in transfer outcomes among individuals.^[35] Higher levels of fluid intelligence, as conceptualized in the Cattell-Horn-Carroll (CHC) theory, correlate with enhanced far transfer, enabling individuals to solve novel problems by reasoning abstractly without heavy reliance on prior specific knowledge. Fluid intelligence (Gf) facilitates the identification of structural similarities between source and target tasks, supporting generalization to dissimilar contexts. For instance, individuals with superior Gf demonstrate greater adaptability in reasoning tasks that require integrating unrelated information, outperforming those with lower Gf in far transfer scenarios.^[36]^[37] Prior knowledge also significantly influences transfer efficacy, serving as a foundation for schema activation and pattern recognition during new learning. When prior knowledge aligns with target task features, it promotes positive transfer by reducing cognitive load and enabling efficient application of strategies; however, mismatched or superficial prior knowledge can induce negative transfer by triggering inappropriate analogies. Empirical studies confirm that the depth and relevance of prior knowledge predict transfer success particularly in structurally dissimilar problems, where learners must abstract principles beyond surface similarities.^[35]^[38] Motivation and metacognition further enhance transfer by empowering self-regulated learners to monitor their cognition and strategically deploy knowledge. Self-regulated individuals, who exhibit strong metacognitive awareness, more readily identify transfer opportunities through planning, monitoring, and evaluation of their learning processes. Hybrid training combining metacognitive and cognitive strategies fosters near transfer of these skills, improving strategy application across similar scenarios and boosting content knowledge acquisition. Far transfer of metacognitive skills, however, depends on sufficient prior strategy knowledge, as evidenced by improved performance in novel but related tasks among trained self-regulators.^[39] Developmental stage affects transfer patterns, with children exhibiting stronger near transfer—applying knowledge to highly similar contexts—while adults leverage abstract thinking for more robust far transfer. In young children (ages 1-6), near transfer succeeds in tasks with perceptual similarities, such as from touchscreen to physical objects, but far transfer to dissimilar modalities often fails due to limited abstraction abilities and higher cognitive demands. As development progresses, transfer breadth increases, with older children and adults showing reduced deficits in far transfer through enhanced generalization and schema formation.^[40]^[41] Individual differences, particularly expertise levels, manifest in the expertise reversal effect, where instructional approaches optimal for novices hinder experts' transfer and vice versa. Novices benefit from detailed guidance, such as worked examples, which builds foundational schemas and supports transfer to related problems by minimizing extraneous cognitive load. In contrast, experts experience reversal, as redundant support interferes with their automated knowledge structures, impeding efficient transfer; minimal guidance allows experts to draw on schemas for superior generalization. This effect, observed across domains like mathematics and science, underscores the need for expertise-tailored instruction to optimize transfer outcomes.^[42]

Contextual and Environmental Factors

The similarity of contexts between initial learning and subsequent application plays a pivotal role in facilitating transfer of learning. According to Thorndike's theory of identical elements, transfer occurs primarily when the original and new tasks share specific, identical components, such as stimuli, responses, or situational cues, which strengthens associative connections and promotes near transfer.^[10] This theory posits that the degree of transfer is directly proportional to the number of identical elements present, as demonstrated in early experiments where training on similar arithmetic operations improved performance on related but not dissimilar tasks.^[4] In contrast, for far transfer—where tasks differ significantly in surface features—principle-based similarity, involving abstract relational structures or underlying rules, is more effective; research shows that comparing examples highlighting common principles enhances generalization to novel domains by fostering relational awareness rather than rote matching.^[43] Practice variability, particularly the scheduling of practice sessions, significantly influences transfer outcomes by affecting how learners adapt skills to diverse situations. Blocked practice, where the same skill is repeated consecutively before switching, accelerates initial acquisition but often limits transfer to similar contexts due to contextual rigidity.^[44] Conversely, random or varied practice, which interleaves different skills or contexts within a session, promotes superior transfer, especially in motor skills, by encouraging cognitive flexibility and problem-solving; for instance, studies on sports training reveal that random schedules lead to better performance on novel variations of tasks compared to blocked ones.^[45] This variability enhances retention and adaptability by simulating real-world unpredictability, though it may initially slow learning progress. Cultural and social environments shape transfer through mediated interactions, as outlined in Vygotsky's socio-cultural theory, which emphasizes that learning and transfer are inherently social processes facilitated by community tools, language, and collaborative scaffolding.^[46] In this framework, transfer is mediated when individuals internalize knowledge through guided participation in cultural practices, such as apprenticeships or peer discussions, enabling the application of concepts across contexts within a shared socio-historical setting.^[47] For example, in classroom or community settings, culturally relevant dialogues help learners bridge prior experiences to new problems, promoting mediated transfer that is contextually embedded and collectively supported. The time lag between initial learning and application can lead to decay in transfer effects without ongoing reinforcement, as retention intervals erode associative strengths and contextual cues fade. Empirical studies indicate that transfer performance diminishes over extended periods, with the testing effect—where retrieval practice bolsters long-term access—partially mitigating but not eliminating this decay; for instance, spaced retrieval initially enhances transfer, yet effects wane after weeks without reinforcement. This temporal degradation underscores the need for periodic reactivation to sustain transfer, particularly for far-reaching applications where initial similarities may no longer align without maintenance.^[48]

Enhancement Strategies

Educational Teaching Methods

Problem-based learning (PBL) is a pedagogical approach where students engage with authentic, ill-structured problems to drive self-directed inquiry and collaborative problem-solving, thereby fostering the transfer of knowledge to novel contexts across subjects. Originating in medical education, PBL encourages learners to activate prior knowledge, identify learning needs, and apply concepts in interdisciplinary scenarios, which enhances near and far transfer by promoting cognitive flexibility and reflection. For instance, in STEM curricula, PBL has been shown to improve students' ability to apply mathematical principles to real-world engineering challenges, with studies demonstrating significant gains in problem-solving transfer compared to traditional lectures.^[4] Project-based learning (PjBL) extends this by involving extended, student-led projects that integrate multiple domains, facilitating vertical transfer from foundational skills to complex applications. In PjBL, learners tackle open-ended tasks, such as designing sustainable community solutions that combine science, economics, and ethics, which builds metacognitive skills for adapting knowledge to diverse situations. Research indicates that PjBL outperforms conventional methods in promoting transfer.^[49] Scaffolding supports transfer by providing temporary, structured assistance that gradually fades, enabling independent application of skills, particularly in STEM education where novices build from guided examples to autonomous problem-solving. Drawing from Vygotsky's zone of proximal development, this method involves modeling, prompting, and feedback to bridge gaps between current abilities and target transfer tasks, such as applying physics concepts to robotics design. Empirical evidence shows scaffolding leads to improved transfer outcomes.^[4] Assessment for transfer shifts focus from rote recall to evaluating application through rubrics that measure adaptability, integration, and real-world relevance, ensuring instructional methods align with transfer goals. These rubrics often include criteria for contextual adaptation and innovation, as seen in performance-based evaluations where students demonstrate skill transfer via simulations or case analyses. Such approaches have been linked to enhanced transfer.^[4] Recent studies as of 2024, including in health professions education, continue to affirm the effectiveness of these methods in hybrid and digital contexts for promoting transfer.^[50]

Cognitive and Instructional Techniques

Cognitive and instructional techniques provide targeted strategies to facilitate the transfer of learning by encouraging learners to apply prior knowledge in novel contexts. These methods focus on bridging gaps between initial learning and application, often through deliberate prompts, modeling, and relational exercises that promote abstraction and connection-making. One key approach is hugging, which involves designing instructional activities that maintain perceptual and contextual similarities between the learning environment and the target application to promote low-road transfer, where skills transfer automatically due to familiar cues.^[14] For instance, in mathematics education, practicing word problems in real-world scenarios resembling everyday decision-making—such as budgeting household expenses—helps students recognize and apply algebraic principles without explicit instruction on connections.^[14] This technique leverages environmental cues to reduce cognitive distance, making transfer more intuitive and less reliant on deliberate reflection.^[14] In contrast, bridging emphasizes high-road transfer by using explicit prompts to guide learners in abstracting principles from prior experiences and linking them to new situations.^[14] Teachers might pose questions like "How does the strategy you used in this history analysis relate to interpreting scientific data?" to foster metacognitive awareness and encourage the search for analogies across domains.^[14] Such interventions promote mindfulness about knowledge applicability, enabling learners to generalize skills deliberately rather than through superficial similarity.^[14] Cognitive apprenticeship extends these ideas by making expert thinking processes visible and scaffolded, involving stages of modeling, coaching, and fading to support transfer.^[51] In this method, instructors first demonstrate problem-solving aloud, articulating their reasoning—such as breaking down a writing task into planning, drafting, and revising—allowing learners to observe and internalize cognitive strategies.^[51] Coaching provides targeted feedback during practice, while fading gradually shifts responsibility to the learner, ensuring that skills like critical reading transfer to independent tasks in varied contexts, such as applying literary analysis to policy documents.^[51] This approach counters the invisibility of mental processes in traditional instruction, enhancing transfer by revealing how experts adapt knowledge.^[51] Analogical reasoning exercises further activate transfer through guided mapping between a source problem and a target scenario, helping learners identify relational structures rather than surface features.^[52] For example, after presenting a source analogy like a military convergence story to solve a radiation tumor problem, instructors provide hints to map elements—such as dividing forces to encircle a fortress onto dividing rays to target a tumor—promoting schema induction for broader application.^[52] These exercises improve transfer when guidance emphasizes relational alignments, as unprompted mapping often fails due to fixation on literal details, but structured practice builds flexible problem-solving across domains like physics and biology.^[52]

Modern Applications and Research

In Education and Professional Training

In educational settings, meta-analyses have demonstrated that problem-based learning (PBL) can enhance students' ability to apply knowledge to similar contexts, indicative of near transfer. For instance, analyses in John Hattie's Visible Learning database report positive, though modest, effects (d = 0.15) on academic achievement and problem-solving application.^[53] These findings suggest PBL supports near transfer outcomes compared to traditional instruction. In professional training, simulations have proven effective for promoting positive transfer from controlled environments to real-world scenarios, especially in high-stakes fields like aviation and medicine. A meta-analysis of flight simulator training studies from 1957 to 1986, encompassing jet and helicopter pilot programs, revealed a weighted mean effect size of 0.26 for transfer to actual aircraft operations, with 90% of comparisons favoring simulator-augmented training over aircraft-only methods; effects were particularly strong for tasks like landings (RPB = 0.57).^[54] In medicine, a 2014 meta-analysis of 32 studies on simulation-based medical education reported large effect sizes (d > 0.8) for transfer to clinical performance, outperforming no-intervention controls and demonstrating improved application of skills in live settings.^[55] These applications underscore simulations' value in bridging training and practice, reducing errors in complex procedures. Despite these successes, traditional curricula often exhibit low far transfer, where skills apply poorly to dissimilar contexts, limiting broader adaptability. Research indicates weaker effect sizes for far transfer (around 0.3-0.4) compared to near transfer across educational interventions, attributing distant applications to rote memorization in conventional teaching.^[56] Interventions like interleaved practice address this by mixing problem types during training, enhancing discrimination and generalization. A 2021 meta-analysis on interleaving for concept learning reported an effect size of 0.67 for transfer to novel items, showing benefits over blocked practice in promoting far transfer in mathematics and perceptual tasks.^[57] Such techniques have been integrated into curricula to mitigate transfer deficits. Post-2020 research on hybrid learning during the COVID-19 pandemic highlights its role in enhancing digital transfer skills, enabling seamless application across online and in-person contexts. A 2025 study at a Kazakh university involving 189 students and 35 teachers found that hybrid models significantly improved digital competency and academic performance (p < 0.001), with experimental groups showing higher engagement and skill transfer to real-world digital tasks compared to traditional formats.^[58] These findings, echoed in broader reviews of pandemic-era education, indicate hybrid approaches fostered adaptable digital proficiencies, such as tool integration and virtual collaboration, persisting into 2025 hybrid systems.

In Neuroscience and Artificial Intelligence

In neuroscience, transfer of learning is underpinned by interactions between the hippocampus and prefrontal cortex, which facilitate the generalization of schemas—organized knowledge structures—to novel situations. The hippocampus encodes specific episodic details, while the ventromedial prefrontal cortex integrates these into abstract schemas that support flexible application across contexts, as evidenced by functional connectivity patterns during schema formation and retrieval.^[59] Recent neuroimaging studies have further elucidated these dynamics, showing that cortico-hippocampal circuits, including the ventromedial prefrontal cortex and hippocampus, underpin schema-supported memory transfer by enabling rapid integration of new information into existing frameworks. Functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) research post-2015 has demonstrated that analogical reasoning, a key mechanism for positive transfer, activates the default mode network (DMN), which includes regions like the medial prefrontal cortex and posterior cingulate cortex involved in integrating relational knowledge. During the mapping stage of analogies—where source and target domains are aligned—DMN activations facilitate the abstraction and transfer of structural mappings, enhancing problem-solving across disparate tasks.^[60] Conversely, negative transfer in the brain manifests through amygdala-mediated interference, particularly in fear conditioning paradigms where prior aversive associations disrupt the formation of new, non-threatening links; heightened amygdala activity under anxiety sustains threat representations, impeding adaptive updating of fear responses.^[61] In artificial intelligence, transfer learning emulates biological generalization by leveraging knowledge from large-scale pre-training to adapt models to downstream tasks, with fine-tuning of pre-trained architectures like BERT (Bidirectional Encoder Representations from Transformers) serving as a cornerstone since 2018. BERT, pre-trained on vast corpora for masked language modeling, achieves state-of-the-art performance on natural language processing benchmarks through task-specific fine-tuning, reducing the need for extensive labeled data by transferring contextual embeddings. Domain adaptation techniques complement this by aligning feature distributions between source and target domains, as in Domain-Adversarial Neural Networks (DANN), which use adversarial training to learn domain-invariant representations, mitigating negative transfer from distributional shifts. Recent advances from 2020 to 2025 have advanced meta-transfer learning in AI, where models learn to optimize transfer across tasks by selecting hard examples or subsets that minimize negative transfer, as in frameworks that identify optimal pre-training data via meta-optimization.^[62] Parameter-efficient methods like LoRA (Low-Rank Adaptation) have further improved transfer in large language models by updating only a small subset of parameters, enabling efficient adaptation as of 2025.^[63] In neuroscience, studies on neural plasticity have linked synaptic mechanisms to lifelong learning and transfer, showing that experience-driven changes in connectivity—such as long-term potentiation in hippocampal circuits—enable sustained adaptability, with heterosynaptic plasticity supporting efficient knowledge generalization over the lifespan.^[64] These findings bridge biological and computational perspectives, highlighting plasticity's role in mitigating catastrophic forgetting during sequential learning.^[65]

References

[1]
None
### Definitions of Transfer of Learning
[2]
(PDF) Transfer Of Learning - ResearchGate
Transfer of learning occurs when learning in one context enhances (positive transfer) or undermines (negative transfer) a related performance in another ...
[3]
[PDF] Emerging Trends of Research on Transfer of Learning - ERIC
Transfer is a key concept in adult learning theories because most education and training aspires to transfer.
[4]
[PDF] A Review of Transfer Theories and Effective Instructional Practices
This review paper provides major theoretical perspectives and pedagogical practices to explore the most effective ways to optimize knowledge acquisition and ...
[5]
3 Learning and Transfer | How People Learn: Brain, Mind ...
Transfer is extending learning to new contexts, requiring initial mastery, understanding, and active learning, not just memorization.
[6]
[PDF] Transfer of Learning by Perkins and Salomon - Jay McTighe
Learners commonly assimilate a new language's phonetics to crude approximations in their native tongue and use word orders carried over from their native tongue ...Missing: paper | Show results with:paper
[7]
[PDF] When and Where Do We Apply What We Learn? A Taxonomy for ...
Hence, it is a presupposition of educators that a student taught to permute a set of items in school will transfer this skill to sets of items confronted.
[8]
doctrine of formal discipline - APA Dictionary of Psychology
a pedagogical theory, now discredited, that was based on the old idea that the mind is divided into general faculties (e.g., reasoning, memory, attention) that ...Missing: history | Show results with:history
[9]
Education as Mental Discipline - The Atlantic
The theory of mental discipline or formal discipline is therefore the bulwark of conventional or traditional education.
[10]
Thorndike & Woodworth (1901a)
The habit of bearing this judgment in mind or of unconsciously making an addition to our first impulse is thus an identical element of both functions. This was ...Missing: source | Show results with:source
[11]
(PDF) Transfer: Training for performance - ResearchGate
Mar 31, 2016 · ... This is captured in Identical Elements Theory (Thorndike, 1906) which emphasizes the importance of similarity of stimuli and responses ...
[12]
[PDF] The Psychology of Learning, Revised Edition - Gwern.net
In his later publications on learning Thorndike was influenced by the ... Guthrie, E. R. The Psychology of Human Conflict. New York: Harper, 1938 ...
[13]
Learning: From Speculation to Science - NCBI - NIH
... water (described in Judd, 1908; see a (more...) 3. A “metacognitive” approach to instruction can help students learn to take control of their own learning ...Missing: paper | Show results with:paper
[14]
[PDF] Teaching for Transfer - ASCD
Transfer goes beyond ordinary learning in that the skill or knowledge in question has to travel to a new context from cars to trucks, from lawyers to summer, or ...
[15]
[PDF] Transfer of Learning for 21st Century Problem Solving - ERIC
Sep 1, 2020 · Abstract: Transfer of learning, the application of learning to different contexts over time, is important to all learning for development.
[16]
(PDF) Training and Transfer of Learning. - ResearchGate
Aug 6, 2025 · Transfer is a complex process which encompasses individual abilities and motivational factors within the work environment, learning processes and situations.
[17]
Interdependence of episodic and semantic memory: Evidence ... - NIH
In our view, these results suggest that, in normal controls, episodic memory facilitates the acquisition of new semantic memory as well as the transfer and ...
[18]
Episodic memory processes modulate how schema knowledge is ...
The present study aimed to directly address the question of how schema knowledge interacts with episodic memory strength to influence behavioral performance, ...
[19]
[PDF] Learning and Transfer: A General Role for Analogical Encoding
Thus, analogical encoding may allow learners to develop knowledge using a boot- strapping process in which cases lead to the abstraction of princi- ples, which ...
[20]
Analogy and Abstraction - Gentner - 2017 - Wiley Online Library
Jun 16, 2017 · We propose that analogical generalization drives much of this early learning and allows children to generate new abstractions from experience.
[21]
Variability of practice and transfer of training: Some evidence toward ...
Variability of practice and transfer of training: Some evidence toward a schema view of motor learning. Citation. Newell, K. M., & Shapiro, D. C. (1976).Missing: 1970s | Show results with:1970s
[22]
Transfer: Training for Performance - The National Academies Press
Positive transfer refers to the facilitation, in learning or performance, of a new task based on what has been learned during a previous one.
[23]
Evidence of Transfer of Learning to Physics and Engineering - MDPI
Jan 9, 2018 · We present here research looking for evidence of transfer from university mathematics learning in semester one to second semester sciences/engineering courses.
[24]
[PDF] Transfer of Learning in Problem Solving in the Context of ...
While the Bassok and Holyoak study showed positive transfer from algebra to physics, most physics problems use more than algebra skills. Therefore, we sought to.
[25]
[PDF] Reder, LM & Klatzky, R. (1994) Transfer: Training for Performance ...
transfer, or in applied contexts, part-task training. Learning to drive a car is an example; novices are typically trained separately on shifting gears and.
[26]
The Effect of First Language Transfer on Second ... - Sage Journals
Mar 24, 2022 · The effect of first language transfer on second language acquisition and learning has been a major theoretical concept in second language ...
[27]
[PDF] Exploring the Challenges of L1 Negative Transfer among ... - ERIC
Aug 30, 2024 · The following literature review explores the theoretical framework surrounding language transfer, its implications for Vietnamese learners, and ...
[28]
[PDF] The Transfer of Cognitive Skill - Gwern
sentation was the classic refraction study by Judd (1908). In this experiment, young boys were asked to throw darts at an under- water target. During ...
[29]
Near and far transfer: Is music special? | Memory & Cognition
Aug 30, 2021 · Far transfer rarely occurs, and a recent meta-analysis suggests that music is no exception. The overall effect of musical training on cognition ...
[30]
Spatial vision is superior in musicians when memory plays a role | JOV
Musicians are not generally superior in spatial-visual tasks. They seem to have an improved working memory component, which may also be involved in visual ...
[31]
[PDF] Journal of Experimental Psychology
RELATION TO TRANSFER, OF LEARNING TO MAKE A NEW RESPONSE TO AN OLD ... Thorndike's theory also attempts to account for instances of zero transfer, for it implies ...
[32]
Specificity and Transfer of Learning - ScienceDirect.com
Positive transfer (or facilitation) would be evident when performance at test is better than the baseline level, whereas negative transfer (or. Empirical ...Missing: zero papers
[33]
Does Far Transfer Exist? Negative Evidence From Chess, Music ...
Oct 25, 2017 · We here present two meta-analyses assessing the effect of chess and music instruction on children's cognitive and academic skills.Missing: strategy | Show results with:strategy
[34]
11.3 Types and Principles of Transfer of Learning
Vertical transfer is required whenever learning necessitates prerequisite skills. For example, skills at writing letters of the alphabet are useful to ...
[35]
How does prior knowledge affect learning? A review of 16 ...
Empirical studies have shown that the amount and the characteristics of prior knowledge affect to what extent transfer occurs. For example, perceptual ...
[36]
Improving fluid intelligence with training on working memory - PNAS
May 13, 2008 · We present evidence for transfer from training on a demanding working memory task to measures of Gf. This transfer results even though the trained task is ...
[37]
The impact of working memory training on near and far transfer ...
Thus, improvements in WM and related measures, as well as the positive transfer in learning outcomes, are moderated by fluid intelligence. Keywords: ...
[38]
The Role of Initial Learning, Problem Features, Prior Knowledge ...
Aug 6, 2025 · This article draws on the knowledge and understandings of transfer of learning ... Affective as well as cognitive factors are considered.
[39]
Transfer of metacognitive skills in self-regulated learning: effects on ...
Oct 28, 2022 · Results show that hybrid metacognitive skill training supported spontaneous transfer of metacognitive skills to learning scenarios of both near and far ...
[40]
Transfer of learning in young children: Magic digital or similarity ...
Sep 13, 2022 · Furthermore, the law of similarities that governs the efficiency of transfer of learning makes necessary to distinguish near transfer from far ...
[41]
Learning to Learn: From Within-Modality to Cross-Modality Transfer ...
These studies indicate that breadth of generalization (and transfer of learning) increases in the course of development, thus suggesting that abstraction itself ...
[42]
[PDF] Expertise Reversal Effect and Its Implications for Learner-Tailored ...
Sep 13, 2007 · This paper reviews recent empirical findings associated with the expertise reversal effect, their interpretation within cognitive load theory, ...
[43]
[PDF] Comparison Promotes Learning and Transfer of Relational Categories
Feb 18, 2013 · We know that comparison supports knowledge transfer and improved, more principle-based performance in arenas such as ... The far-transfer task ...
[44]
Random and Blocked Practice Schedule Affect Search for New ...
May 23, 2025 · It has been shown that blocked practice improves performance (faster learning and more accurate performance) during acquisition, but random ...
[45]
[PDF] Practice variability promotes an external focus of attention and ...
In a series of experiments, we compared motor learning under constant versus variable (Experiment 1) or blocked versus random (Experiments 2 and 3) conditions.<|separator|>
[46]
[PDF] THE Mediational Role - American English
In this article, I explain the mediational role of teachers in sociocultural theory. Mediation. According to the Vygotskian view, it is through social mediation ...
[47]
[PDF] Vygotsky's Zone of Proximal Development: Instructional Implications ...
Sociocultural theory of mind attempts to account for the processes through which, learning and development take place. De Valenzuela (2006) rightly points out ...<|separator|>
[48]
Far transfer of retrieval-practice benefits: rule-based learning as the ...
Oct 8, 2024 · The findings further support the view that far transfer is supported by learning the underlying grammatical rules as opposed to memorizing the material.<|control11|><|separator|>
[49]
[PDF] A REVIEW OF RESEARCH ON PROJECT-BASED LEARNING
This review examines research related to a teaching and learning model popularly referred to as "Project-Based Learning" (PBL). All of the research on ...Missing: seminal | Show results with:seminal
[50]
[PDF] Cognitive apprenticeship teaching the craft of reading, writing, and ...
These techniques of scaffolding and fading slowly build students' confidence that they can master the skills required. Collins, Brown, Newman. Page 13 ...
[51]
[PDF] Schema induction and analogical transfer. - UCLA Reasoning Lab
We will discuss the. Gick and Holyoak study in more detail, since it led directly to the present investigation. We had subjects attempt to solve Duncker's (1945) ...
[52]
Problem-based learning Details - Visible Learning MetaX
Revisiting the effects of project-based learning on students' academic achievement: A meta-analysis investigating moderators. 2019, PBL, 30, 12,585, 30, 0.71.
[53]
[PDF] A Meta-Analysis of the Flight Simulator Training Research - DTIC
this meta-analysis found several that have a clear moderating effect on training transfer,. Sizable differences in the effectiveness of simulation training ...
[54]
Technology-Enhanced Simulation and Pediatric Education: A Meta ...
May 1, 2014 · The objective of this study was to describe the characteristics and evaluate the effectiveness of TES for pediatric education.
[55]
A Meta-Analysis of Ten Learning Techniques - Frontiers
Mar 30, 2021 · This article outlines a meta-analysis of the 10 learning techniques identified in Dunlosky et al. (2013a), and is based on 242 studies, ...
[56]
Interleaved practice enhances memory and problem-solving ability ...
Nov 12, 2021 · A recent meta-analysis found that the typical benefit of interleaving for perceptual category learning is Hedges' g (effect size) = 0.67, 95% ...
[57]
The impact of digital hybrid education model on teachers ... - Nature
May 22, 2025 · Contemporary research confirms that hybrid learning models contribute to increased student engagement, improved academic performance, and the ...<|control11|><|separator|>
[58]
Complementary task representations in hippocampus and prefrontal ...
Sep 28, 2022 · These data suggest that prefrontal cortex and hippocampus play complementary roles in generalization of knowledge.
[59]
The Neural Correlates of Analogy Component Processes
Mar 16, 2022 · One fMRI study investigated network activity related to analogical reasoning in ... Interestingly, activations in the default-mode network were ...<|separator|>
[60]
Extinction learning alters the neural representation of conditioned fear
Jul 27, 2020 · High state anxiety attenuated extinction-related changes to the CS+ patterning in the amygdala, which suggests an enduring threat representation.
[61]
A meta-learning framework to mitigate negative transfer in ... - Nature
Oct 9, 2025 · Therefore, we introduce a new meta-learning algorithm designed to complement transfer learning. It identifies an optimal subset of training ...
[62]
How neural systems transform synaptic plasticity into ... - PNAS
Oct 28, 2024 · Synaptic plasticity—carefully regulated changes in the strength of the synaptic connections between neurons—is the currency of learning.
[63]
(PDF) Neuroplasticity and Adult Learning - ResearchGate
Dec 14, 2022 · PDF | The malleability of the adult brain to adapt in response to experience (termed neuroplasticity) is well documented.