Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Twilight zone

The Twilight Zone is an American anthology television series created, written, narrated, and hosted by Rod Serling, which originally aired on CBS from October 2, 1959, to June 19, 1964, spanning five seasons and 156 episodes.^[1]^[2] The program features self-contained stories blending science fiction, fantasy, horror, and psychological drama, typically resolving in unexpected twist endings that underscore moral or cautionary themes about human behavior and society.^[3]^[4] Serling, drawing from his experiences as a paratrooper in World War II and frustrations with network censorship of his earlier dramas, used the series' speculative framework to allegorically critique mid-20th-century issues such as conformity, racism, nuclear anxiety, and authoritarianism, often evading direct scrutiny by disguising commentary in otherworldly scenarios.^[4] He penned or co-wrote 92 of the episodes, establishing a hallmark style of concise, dialogue-driven narratives that prioritized intellectual provocation over special effects, given the era's limited budgets.^[5] The show's innovative format and Serling's distinctive voiceover monologues popularized the phrase "twilight zone" to denote ambiguous or surreal liminal spaces, influencing subsequent genre television and earning critical acclaim, including three Emmy Awards for Serling.^[6]^[7] Despite its success—averaging high ratings and syndication longevity—the original run ended amid rising production costs, Serling's exhaustion, and network shifts toward lighter fare, though revivals in 1985, 2002, and 2019 underscore its enduring legacy as a benchmark for twist-laden storytelling.^[8] Notable episodes like "The Monsters Are Due on Maple Street" and "Eye of the Beholder" exemplify its prescient social satire, while production anecdotes, including on-set accidents and improvisational twists, highlight the resourcefulness behind its impact.^[4]

Idiomatic and metaphorical usage

Etymology and definition

The idiomatic expression "twilight zone" refers to an ambiguous or indeterminate region between two distinct states, conditions, or categories, often evoking a sense of uncertainty, ethical ambiguity, or transition akin to the dim, ill-defined light of twilight. ^[9] This metaphorical usage describes situations lacking clear boundaries, such as legal gray areas, psychological liminal spaces, or conceptual overlaps where norms blur, as in "an ethical twilight zone between right and wrong."^[10] The phrase implies a realm where reality intersects with the surreal or undefined, potentially leading to disorientation or unexpected outcomes.^[11] Etymologically, "twilight zone" first appeared in 1901 denoting a literal astronomical band in the sky illuminated by twilight, extending from the horizon during dawn or dusk.^[12] By 1909, it acquired figurative connotations for domains of unclear authority, responsibility, or distinction, predating its popularization through cultural media.^[12] Early extended uses drew from aviation contexts, where the term described a pilot's disorienting visual condition near the horizon at low light, unable to discern sky from ground, symbolizing perceptual ambiguity.^[13] This foundational sense of intermediary vagueness—rooted in observable natural phenomena—evolved into the broader idiom for abstract "in-between" states, independent of later artistic influences like the 1959 television series, though the show amplified its vernacular reach by associating it with fantasy and moral quandaries.^[14] The phrase's persistence reflects its utility in capturing causal transitions without sharp delineations, as verified in dictionary attestations from the early 20th century onward.

Historical and cultural examples

In American jurisprudence, the phrase "twilight zone" emerged in the early 20th century to describe liminal areas of legal ambiguity, particularly in jurisdictional overlaps. A seminal example appears in the U.S. Supreme Court's 1942 decision in Davis v. Department of Labor, where Justice Hugo Black characterized the indeterminate boundary between federal maritime law and state workmen's compensation statutes as a "twilight zone." This referred to cases involving workers injured on navigable waters but engaged in non-maritime activities, such as a structural steelworker falling from a barge, creating uncertainty over whether federal admiralty jurisdiction or state remedies applied. Black's opinion allowed the claimant to pursue state compensation without federal preemption, emphasizing that in such indistinct zones—estimated to affect a small but significant number of annual claims—rigid classification would undermine practical justice. This legal metaphor extended to labor relations, where the National Labor Relations Board (NLRB) invoked the "twilight zone" for borderline employee-independent contractor distinctions under the National Labor Relations Act of 1935. For instance, in pre-1950s rulings, the NLRB applied the phrase to workers like taxi drivers or newsboys whose control by employers was partial, neither fully supervisory nor wholly autonomous, complicating protections against unfair labor practices. Such usages underscored causal uncertainties in employment hierarchies, where economic dependence did not align neatly with formal contracts, affecting thousands of disputes resolved case-by-case rather than by bright-line rules. In constitutional separation of powers, Justice Robert H. Jackson's concurrence in Youngstown Sheet & Tube Co. v. Sawyer (1952) formalized a "twilight zone" category for executive actions amid congressional silence, as during President Truman's seizure of steel mills amid the Korean War on April 8, 1952. Jackson outlined three zones of presidential power: maximal when aligned with Congress, minimal when opposed, and ambiguous in between, where historical acquiescence or inertia might tacitly authorize conduct but lacked clear statutory basis. This framework, drawn from 150 years of precedent, highlighted the risks of judicial overreach in resolving such voids, influencing later analyses of executive authority in crises like the 1974 impoundment disputes.^[15] Beyond law, cultural applications appeared in early 20th-century discourse on psychological and ethical margins, with the term's first extended use dated to 1909 for realms blending reality and illusion, such as in aviation reports of disorienting dusk flights or medical descriptions of semi-conscious states post-injury. By the mid-century, it permeated political commentary, denoting transitional geopolitical states like the post-World War II "twilight zone" between Allied occupation and sovereignty in divided Germany (1945–1949), where administrative authority blurred amid denazification and economic reconstruction affecting 18 million displaced persons. These examples reflect the idiom's utility in capturing causal indeterminacy without implying supernatural elements.

Scientific contexts

Astronomical twilight zones

Astronomical twilight refers to the period immediately following nautical twilight in the evening or preceding it in the morning, when the geometric center of the Sun lies between 12° and 18° below the horizon.^[16]^[17] During this phase, the sky transitions to near-complete darkness, with only faint illumination from scattered sunlight in the upper atmosphere, allowing for the observation of all but the faintest celestial objects under clear, non-light-polluted conditions.^[18]^[19] This stage is distinguished from brighter twilights—civil (0° to 6° solar depression, sufficient for most outdoor activities without artificial light) and nautical (6° to 12°, used for horizon visibility in navigation)—by its minimal skyglow, where the horizon becomes indistinguishable to the naked eye and stars of magnitude 4 or fainter become visible.^[20]^[17] The term "astronomical" reflects its utility for professional and amateur astronomers, as zenith sky brightness drops to levels permitting spectroscopic and photometric measurements of stars, planets, and deep-sky objects without significant solar interference.^[19] In regions with high light pollution, however, urban observers may still contend with residual glow delaying effective stargazing until full night.^[17] The duration of astronomical twilight varies with latitude and season: at equatorial latitudes, it typically lasts 20–30 minutes due to the Sun's steep diurnal path, while at mid-latitudes like 40°N, it extends to about 45–60 minutes around the equinoxes.^[16] Near the poles, during summer solstices, the Sun may not descend beyond 12°–18° below the horizon, resulting in perpetual twilight and no true astronomical night; conversely, in winter, prolonged darkness eliminates twilight zones entirely for months.^[18] These variations arise from Earth's axial tilt and orbital geometry, with computational models from observatories accounting for atmospheric refraction (adding ~0.83° to apparent depression) and local topography.^[18]^[20] In practice, astronomical twilight demarcates the boundary for "dark sky" conditions essential for observatories; for instance, sites like Mauna Kea initiate full operations only after the Sun reaches 18° depression to minimize thermal noise and scattered light in instruments.^[19] Historical definitions, standardized by bodies like the U.S. Naval Observatory since the early 20th century, ensure consistency in almanacs and software for predicting these intervals worldwide.^[18]

Oceanographic twilight zone

The oceanographic twilight zone, also termed the mesopelagic zone, comprises the oceanic layer from about 200 to 1,000 meters below the sea surface, where sunlight penetration diminishes to levels insufficient for photosynthesis while still providing faint illumination.^[21]^[22] This zone transitions from the sunlit epipelagic above to the aphotic bathypelagic below, with light intensity dropping to roughly 1% of surface levels at the upper boundary.^[23] Temperatures typically range from 4°C to 12°C, decreasing with depth, while hydrostatic pressure escalates to 20–100 atmospheres.^[24] Ecological productivity in this realm relies on organic matter sinking from surface waters rather than primary production, sustaining a diverse assemblage of fishes, squids, crustaceans, and gelatinous organisms adapted to low-light conditions.^[22] Prominent adaptations include bioluminescence for predation, defense, and communication—generated via symbiotic bacteria or chemical reactions in photophores—and enlarged eyes or tubular optics for detecting scarce photons.^[21] Biodiversity is substantial, with estimates suggesting millions of species, many undescribed, though sampling challenges due to depth and migration patterns limit comprehensive inventories.^[25] A defining feature is diel vertical migration, wherein vast biomass—potentially the planet's largest synchronized animal movement—ascends nightly toward the surface to feed on plankton and descends by day to evade visual predators, covering hundreds of meters in cycles driven by light cues and predation risks.^[26]^[27] This behavior facilitates trophic linkages, channeling energy from primary producers to deeper predators like whales and tuna, while uneaten fecal pellets and carcasses enhance particulate flux.^[28] The zone's role in global biogeochemistry underscores its significance, as migrating organisms actively export carbon—via respiration, excretion, and mortality—to depths exceeding 1,000 meters, amplifying the biological carbon pump and sequestering an estimated 0.2–2 gigatons of carbon annually beyond passive sinking.^[29]^[30] Mesopelagic fishes alone contribute substantially to this flux, particularly in oligotrophic regions, influencing atmospheric CO2 drawdown and climate regulation, though overfishing risks disrupting these dynamics.^[31]^[32]

Arts and entertainment

The Twilight Zone television franchise

The Twilight Zone television franchise consists of multiple anthology series featuring self-contained stories in genres including science fiction, fantasy, horror, and psychological drama, typically resolving with ironic or cautionary twists that underscore human flaws, societal tensions, or existential dilemmas. The original iteration, created by Rod Serling, premiered on CBS on October 2, 1959, and concluded on June 19, 1964, after five seasons totaling 156 half-hour episodes filmed in black-and-white.^[2]^[33] Serling hosted each installment, providing narrative framing and closing monologues that emphasized the series' themes of moral introspection amid the uncanny, often drawing from mid-20th-century anxieties such as nuclear threats, conformity, and racial prejudice.^[34] He wrote or co-wrote 92 episodes, enabling subtle critiques of censorship-era broadcasting constraints by cloaking controversial topics in speculative fiction.^[35] Subsequent revivals adapted the format to contemporary production styles and cultural contexts while retaining the core emphasis on twist-driven parables. The 1985–1989 CBS version, produced by CBS Productions in association with MTM Enterprises, spanned three seasons with 65 hour-long episodes, narrated initially by Charles Aidman and later by Robin Ward after Serling's 1975 death; it incorporated color cinematography and updated stories addressing 1980s issues like technology and urban alienation, though it achieved moderate viewership without matching the original's acclaim.^[36] A shorter-lived iteration aired on UPN from September 18, 2002, to May 21, 2003, comprising one season of 44 episodes hosted by Forest Whitaker, with executive producer Ira Steven Behr emphasizing diverse writers to refresh the anthology amid post-9/11 reflections on fear and authority.^[37] The most recent series, executive produced and narrated by Jordan Peele via Monkeypaw Productions, debuted on CBS All Access (later Paramount+) on April 1, 2019, and ran for two seasons totaling 20 episodes until October 29, 2020; it featured Peele's voiceover in Serling's style, focusing on modern horrors like social media echo chambers and institutional distrust, but drew mixed reception for perceived heavy-handed allegory over narrative subtlety.^[38] Across iterations, the franchise maintained syndication viability, with the original series influencing television storytelling by pioneering adult-oriented speculative anthologies that prioritized intellectual engagement over visual effects, amassing awards including three Emmys for Serling's writing and anthology excellence during its 1959–1964 run.^[7] Revivals, while expanding accessibility through streaming platforms like Paramount+, often faced challenges in replicating the original's concise, Serling-authored precision, as evidenced by shorter runs and lower critical consensus scores compared to the foundational series' enduring 92% Rotten Tomatoes approval.^[34]

Music and other media adaptations

The Twilight Zone's iconic theme, derived from Marius Constant's 1963 orchestral suite "To the Unknown Regions," was edited into a shorter version for the television series' opening starting in season 2 on September 30, 1960, without Constant's knowledge or credit until later.^[39] ^[40] Scores by composers including Bernard Herrmann and Jerry Goldsmith accompanied episodes, with soundtrack compilations released, such as "The Twilight Zone Collection, Vol. 1" featuring Herrmann's contributions on April 21, 2017.^[41] For the 1985 television revival, the Grateful Dead recorded a psychedelic adaptation of the theme, used as the opening music.^[39] Radio adaptations include a syndicated drama series launched in 2002, hosted by Stacy Keach, which produced 176 audio plays adapting original television episodes and adding new stories through 2012, often featuring contemporary actors.^[42] ^[43] Comic book series began with Dell Comics' anthology issues in 1961, emulating the television format with suspenseful tales; subsequent publishers included Gold Key in the 1960s–1970s, Now Comics starting in 1988 with a Harlan Ellison-scripted debut issue, Dynamite Entertainment's "The Twilight Zone Volume 1: The Way Out" on July 1, 2014, and IDW's limited 5-issue series announced June 11, 2025, drawing directly from Rod Serling's scripts.^[44] ^[45] ^[46] Graphic novels by Mark Kneece, such as adaptations of "The After Hours" and "Death's Head Revisited," extend this medium with illustrated retellings of specific episodes. The 1983 anthology film Twilight Zone: The Movie, directed by John Landis, Steven Spielberg, Joe Dante, and George Miller, adapted two original episodes ("Kick the Can" and "It's a Good Life") alongside new segments, incorporating a soundtrack with tracks like Creedence Clearwater Revival's "The Midnight Special" and Jimi Hendrix's "Purple Haze."^[47]

References

[1]
The Twilight Zone Classic - CBS - Watch on Paramount Plus
Hosted by Rod Serling, this classic anthology series blends science fiction, drama and superstition -- with plenty of twists. Starring: Rod Serling.S1 E1: Where is Everybody? · S1 E5: Walking Distance · The Monsters are Due on...
[2]
The Twilight Zone (TV Series 1959–1964) - IMDb
Rating 9/10 (103,679) Classic American Anthology series created by Rod Serling, featuring standalone stories of science fiction, fantasy, and horror, each with a twist ending or ...Plot · Episode list · Full cast & crew · Parents guide
[3]
The Twilight Zone (TV Series 1959–1964) - Plot - IMDb
The Twilight Zone is a classic science fiction anthology series about ordinary people trapped in extraordinary situations involving futuristic societies, space ...
[4]
Everything to Know About The Twilight Zone - SYFY
Mar 21, 2025 · Here's an everything-to-know primer on The Twilight Zone, Rod Serling's classic anthology series that aired between 1959 and 1964, and airs ...Missing: facts | Show results with:facts
[5]
The Twilight Zone | Rotten Tomatoes
Rating 92% (68) "The Twilight Zone" was the brainchild of Emmy Award-winner Rod Serling, who served as host and wrote over 80 episodes of the original show's 150-plus ...
[6]
The Twilight Zone (TV Series 1959–1964) - Awards - IMDb
11 wins & 14 nominations. Academy of Science Fiction, Fantasy & Horror Films, USA. Rod Serling in The Twilight Zone (1959). 2012 Nominee Saturn Award.Missing: run | Show results with:run
[7]
The Enduring Legacy of 'The Twilight Zone' - The New Atlantis
The Twilight Zone won numerous industry awards and wide critical praise during its five-season run from 1959 to 1964 on CBS.
[8]
The Real Reason the Original 'The Twilight Zone' Got Canceled
Dec 31, 2024 · It aired once a week from September to June during 1959-1964, and was nominated for numerous awards. Creator and host Rod Serling won three ...<|control11|><|separator|>
[9]
twilight zone - American Heritage Dictionary Entry
n. An area of ambiguity between two distinct states or conditions: a twilight zone between good and evil.
[10]
TWILIGHT ZONE definition in American English - Collins Dictionary
Definition of 'twilight zone' 1. a vague or uncertain area or state. an ethical twilight zone between right and wrong. 2. infl.
[11]
https://dictionary.cambridge.org/us/dictionary/english/twilight-zone
[12]
Twilight - Etymology, Origin & Meaning
Twilight zone is from 1901 in a literal sense, a part of the sky lit by twilight; from 1909 in extended senses in references to topics or cases where authority ...
[13]
Twilight Zone - Stillpoint
Apr 29, 2020 · It's an aeronautical term used to describe the condition of a pilot trying to land a plane without being able to see the horizon.
[14]
Twilight zone - Idioms by The Free Dictionary
The phrase originated before it became the title of the popular television show. Unfortunately, his citizenship status is in the twilight zone now that the ...Missing: etymology | Show results with:etymology<|separator|>
[15]
Youngstown Sheet & Tube Co. v. Sawyer | 343 U.S. 579 (1952)
In the middle category lay situations in which Congress was silent, known as the twilight zone. ... U.S. Supreme Court. Youngstown Sheet & Tube Co. v. Sawyer, 343 ...
[16]
Astronomical Twilight – Definition and Explanation - Time and Date
Astronomical twilight is the darkest of the 3 twilight phases. It is the earliest stage of dawn in the morning and the last stage of dusk in the evening.
[17]
Twilight Types - National Weather Service
Under astronomical twilight, the horizon is not discernible and moderately faint stars or planets can be observed with the naked eye under a non light polluted ...Missing: Observatory | Show results with:Observatory
[18]
Rise, Set, and Twilight Definitions
Astronomical twilight is defined to begin in the morning, and to end in the evening when the center of the Sun is geometrically 18 degrees below the horizon.
[19]
Discover the three kinds of twilight - Astronomy Magazine
Nov 9, 2023 · Three types of twilight exist: civil, nautical, and astronomical, defined by the Sun's angle below the horizon. Atmospheric scattering of ...
[20]
The Different Types of Twilight, Dawn and Dusk - Time and Date
Astronomical twilight occurs when the Sun is between 12 degrees and 18 degrees below the horizon. Astronomical dawn is the time when the center of the Sun is at ...Astronomical Twilight · Civil Twilight · Nautical twilight · Golden Hour
[21]
Twilight Zone - Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution
The ocean twilight zone is a layer of water 200 to 1,000 meters below the surface, beyond sunlight, cold, dim, and with bioluminescence.
[22]
Mesopelagic Zone - an overview | ScienceDirect Topics
The mesopelagic zone, also called the twilight zone, is a layer of the ocean from 200 to 1000m deep, too deep for photosynthesis, but with high productivity.
[23]
Exploring the Twilight Zone - NOAA Ocean Exploration
Jul 6, 2019 · The twilight zone, or mesopelagic zone, is at 200-1000 meters, where sunlight transitions to darkness, and is a little-studied area.
[24]
Ocean Zones - Let's Talk Science
Sep 16, 2024 · The Mesopelagic Zone extends from 200 metres to 1 000 metres and has pressure of 20 to 100 atm. This zone is adjacent to the top of the ...
[25]
Advances in Environmental DNA Sampling for Observing Ocean ...
Jan 19, 2023 · Understanding the relationships between diel vertical migration, the biological carbon pump, and Earth's climate requires OTZ biodiversity ...
[26]
Migration in the Ocean Twilight Zone
This phenomenon is called the Diel Vertical Migration, and is the largest migration of animal life on earth. The migration's name comes from the latin dies, or ...Missing: ecology | Show results with:ecology
[27]
Vertical migration timing illuminates importance of predator pressure ...
Jun 21, 2021 · In the largest migration on Earth, countless fishes, squids, and crustaceans ascend from the ocean's twilight zone each night.Missing: ecology biodiversity
[28]
How the ocean's 'twilight zone' impacts climate change - NPR
Jul 27, 2025 · KWONG: This mass movement is called diel vertical migration, and these migrating organisms perform an essential service for the entire Earth.
[29]
Zooplankton vertical migrations represent a significant source of ...
Mar 15, 2019 · Huge numbers of tiny marine animals, known as zooplankton, migrate between the surface ocean and the twilight zone (200 – 1000 m below the ...Missing: biodiversity | Show results with:biodiversity
[30]
[PDF] Protecting ocean carbon through biodiversity and climate governance
Oct 4, 2022 · The mesopelagic migrant pump influences all important aspects of carbon sequestration: the total export rate, depth of peak flux, and the depth ...
[31]
[PDF] A trait-based carbon export model for mesopelagic fishes in the Gulf ...
Carbon export by mesopelagic fishes contributes significantly to the carbon transported into the mesopelagic zone, particularly in oligotrophic regions. The ...
[32]
[PDF] Mesopelagic fish traits: functions and trade‐offs
Oct 4, 2024 · the surface to the mesopelagic zone and deeper and therefore actively contribute to carbon sequestration and climate regula- tion (Anderson et ...
[33]
The Twilight Zone Archives
The original phrase "twilight zone," came from the early 1900's, used to describe a distinct condition between fantasy and reality. The phrase then evolved into ...
[34]
The Twilight Zone Classic - CBS - Watch on Paramount Plus
Full Episodes ; E1 Where is Everybody? · Oct 2, 1959 ; E2 One for the Angels · Oct 9, 1959 ; E3 Mr. Denton on Doomsday · Oct 16, 1959 ; E4 The Sixteen-Millimeter ...S1 E1: Where is Everybody? · S1 E5: Walking Distance · The Monsters are Due on...
[35]
THE TWILIGHT ZONE - WGA
Aired: CBS, 1959-1965. No show in the history of television has lingered in the imagination quite like Rod Serling's anthology series, which could function ...
[36]
The Twilight Zone (1985) - TV Series - IMDb
Rating 7.7/10 (13,018) The Twilight Zone: Created by Rod Serling. With Robin Ward, Charles Aidman, Richard Mulligan, William Atherton. Tales of science fiction, fantasy and the ...Episode list · The Twilight Zone · The Twilight · Alternate versions
[37]
Why did the UPN Twilight Zone revival fail? - SYFY
Dec 30, 2022 · During the production of UPN's short-lived 2002 revival of The Twilight Zone, Ira Behr found himself in a position similar to that of Rocky Valentine.<|separator|>
[38]
The Twilight Zone (TV Series 2019–2020) - IMDb
Rating 6/10 (20,068) An updated version of the classic anthology series featuring various tales of science fiction, mystery, and horror.Full cast & crew · Parents guide · Episode list · The Twilight Zone
[39]
A Brief History of the Theme From The Twilight Zone
Apr 8, 2019 · Twilight Zone theme: How the theme song for Jordan Peele's reboot stacks up to versions by Korn, the Grateful Dead, and the Manhattan Transfer.
[40]
Song of the Day: The Twilight Zone Theme by Marius Constant
May 11, 2025 · In 1960, when The Twilight Zone needed a theme song, an enterprising CBS employee combined two of Constant's composition to create the iconic ...<|separator|>
[41]
The Twilight Zone Collection, Vol. 1 (Original Television Soundtrack)
Listen to The Twilight Zone Collection, Vol. 1 (Original Television Soundtrack) on Spotify · album · Bernard Herrmann · 2017 · 22 songs.
[42]
The Twilight Zone Radio Dramas (Podcast Series 2002–2012) - IMDb
Rating 8.2/10 (63) The Twilight Zone Radio Dramas podcast (2002-2012) features star-studded audio adaptations of 1959-1964 episodes and nearly 20 exclusive stories.
[43]
Twilight Zone Radio Dramas : Free Download, Borrow, and Streaming
Nov 14, 2019 · All 176 episodes of the Twilight Zone Radio Dramas which were produced and aired on radio during the 2000's. Each episode is encoded at 128k.
[44]
Twilight Zone (1962 1st Series Dell/Gold Key) comic books
$$12.95 delivery 7-day returnsAnthology type comic with suspenseful, mystery, and spooky stories done in the style of the classic TV series "The Twilight Zone" which starred Rod Serling as ...
[45]
The Twilight Zone Volume 1: The Way Out (TWILIGHT ZONE TP)
30-day returnsBook details ; Part of Series. The Twilight Zone ; Print length. 104 pages ; Language. English ; Publisher. Dynamite Entertainment ; Publication date. July 1, 2014.
[46]
Twilight Zone Comic Book Announced by IDW: What to Know - SYFY
Jun 11, 2025 · The comic book publisher announced today that it will release a limited, 5-issue series directly based on Rod Serling's pioneering TV show, with ...
[47]
Soundtracks - Twilight Zone: The Movie (1983) - IMDb
Nights Are Forever. Performed by Jennifer Warnes · Anesthesia. Performed by 213 · The Midnight Special. Performed by Creedence Clearwater Revival · Purple Haze. by ...