Zach Gilford
Zachary Michael Gilford (born January 14, 1982) is an American actor best known for portraying quarterback Matt Saracen on the NBC sports drama series Friday Night Lights from 2006 to 2011.[1][2] Born in Evanston, Illinois, to parents Anne and Steve Gilford—his mother of Lutheran background and his father Jewish—Gilford graduated from Evanston Township High School and later earned a Bachelor of Arts in education and theater from Northwestern University.[1][3] His early career included stage work and small television roles before landing the breakout part of Saracen, which earned him recognition for depicting the challenges of adolescence, family, and small-town life in a Texas high school football context.[4][5] Following Friday Night Lights, Gilford expanded into film with roles such as in the horror thriller The Purge: Anarchy (2014), where he played a supporting character amid a chaotic night of violence.[6] He also took on leading television parts, including Dr. Ben Keeton in the short-lived ABC medical drama Off the Map (2011) and Gregg in the NBC comedy-drama Good Girls (2018–2021).[7][8] In recent years, Gilford has embraced genre work, starring as Father Paul Hill in the Netflix horror miniseries Midnight Mass (2021), for which he received a Critics' Choice Television Award nomination for Best Supporting Actor in a Limited Series or Movie Made for Television.[9] He followed this with appearances in Mike Flanagan's Netflix horror projects, including The Midnight Club (2022) and a role in The Fall of the House of Usher (2023).[6] He portrays serial killer Elias Voit in the Paramount+ series Criminal Minds: Evolution (2022–present), with the series renewed through at least its 19th season as of 2025.[10][11] Gilford's diverse portfolio also includes the action spinoff L.A.'s Finest (2019–2020) as special agent Ben Walker and a guest spot in Taylor Swift's music video for "Ours" (2011).[2] In 2025, he starred in the film After All and continues to reflect on his Friday Night Lights legacy through reunions and interviews with co-stars like Scott Porter.[12][13]Early life and education
Family background
Zachary Michael Gilford was born on January 14, 1982, in Evanston, Illinois, a suburb of Chicago.[4] He is the son of Anne Gilford and Steve Gilford.[4] His mother, of Swedish ancestry, was raised Lutheran, while his father has Jewish heritage.[14] Gilford's family background reflects a blend of cultural and religious influences from his mixed-faith parents, with his father's Jewish roots specifically of Russian Jewish, Austrian Jewish, and Hungarian Jewish descent.[14] Raised in the close-knit suburban community of Evanston, Gilford experienced a stable childhood amid the area's progressive and multicultural atmosphere, which fostered a sense of openness in his pre-teen years.[4] One notable early memory from around age seven involved listening to Michael Jackson's Thriller on a Walkman, where the spoken intro by Vincent Price instilled a lasting fear, highlighting the imaginative influences of his youth in this Midwestern setting.[15]Schooling and early interests
Zach Gilford attended Evanston Township High School in Evanston, Illinois, where he developed an early interest in the performing arts through participation in school theater productions.[16] He graduated from the school in 2000.[17] During his high school years, Gilford was involved in ETHS's theater program, notably contributing to YAMO, the school's annual student-written musical sketch comedy revue that has been a tradition since the mid-20th century.[16][18] This involvement ignited his passion for acting and stage performance, laying the foundation for his later pursuit of theater studies.[16] Gilford's exposure to high school athletics came through the local sports scene, as ETHS football games were held on Saturday mornings due to the stadium lacking lights until 2008.[19][20] His family supported these emerging interests, encouraging his creative and extracurricular pursuits during his teenage years.[21]University and pre-acting work
Gilford enrolled at Northwestern University in 2000, following his graduation from Evanston Township High School, and majored in education and theater.[22] He graduated with a Bachelor of Arts degree in 2004.[4] During his time at Northwestern, Gilford actively participated in the university's theater program, performing in student productions that honed his acting skills. Notable roles included appearances in Equus and The Laramie Project, which provided him with experience in intense dramatic scenes and ensemble work.[23] These campus performances built his confidence and prepared him for professional opportunities.[24] After graduation, Gilford took on roles outside of acting to support himself while pursuing his career. He worked as a trip leader for Adventures Cross-Country, an organization that organizes wilderness and adventure programs for teenagers across locations such as Alaska, British Columbia, and California.[2] These positions involved leading groups through challenging outdoor activities, fostering leadership, teamwork, and communication abilities that later proved valuable in his interpersonal demands as an actor.Career
Early roles and debut
Gilford's entry into professional acting followed his time at Northwestern University. Relocating to New York City immediately after, he navigated the competitive landscape of early career auditions, often attending multiple callbacks for minor roles while supplementing income through commercials and off-Broadway performances. This period highlighted the challenges of breaking in as a newcomer, including the uncertainty of sporadic bookings and the risk of typecasting in youthful, everyday roles typical for recent theater graduates transitioning to television.[25] His professional debut arrived in 2005 with a guest-starring role on Law & Order: Special Victims Unit, appearing as Kevin Wilcox in the season 6 episode "Contagious," which aired on January 11, 2005. In the episode, Gilford portrayed a high school lacrosse player suspected in a sexual assault investigation tied to a young girl's medical emergency following a car accident, demonstrating his ability to convey emotional intensity in a procedural drama format.[26][27] Between 2005 and 2006, Gilford continued auditioning for television pilots and guest spots, though opportunities remained limited as he built visibility in the industry; these early efforts underscored his versatility in dramatic scenarios, setting the stage for more substantial roles amid the grind of New York-based casting calls.[24]Breakthrough with Friday Night Lights
Gilford's breakthrough came with his casting as Matt Saracen, the reserved second-string quarterback for the Dillon Panthers, in the NBC series Friday Night Lights, which aired from 2006 to 2011. Initially auditioning for the role of the rebellious Tim Riggins (ultimately played by Taylor Kitsch), Gilford was reassigned to Matt after the originally cast actor became unavailable due to a conflicting Disney TV movie commitment, just days before filming began. This last-minute pivot thrust the then-24-year-old into a lead role, marking his transition from minor guest spots to series stardom.[12] Throughout production, Gilford frequently improvised alongside co-star Jesse Plemons, who portrayed Landry Clarke, Matt's awkward best friend. Their unscripted moments, particularly surrounding the controversial Season 2 murder subplot involving Landry, injected humor and realism into the dialogue; Gilford recalled ad-libbing lines like, “Oh, hey. Hey. Wait. Remember when you murdered that guy? That was crazy. Anyway, I’m glad you got away with it. Who are we playing this week?” These improvisations not only lightened the ensemble's intense dramatic scenes but also enhanced the authentic, documentary-style feel of the show, directed by creator Peter Berg.[12] Matt Saracen's character arc traced the protagonist's evolution from an introverted sophomore unexpectedly elevated to starting quarterback following Jason Street's paralyzing injury, to a young adult grappling with profound responsibilities. Living with his dementia-afflicted grandmother while his father served in Iraq, Matt balanced the pressures of high school football, a budding romance with Julie Taylor, and eventual tragedy—his father's death in combat—forcing him to confront grief, ambition, and independence, culminating in choices about college and leaving Dillon. This journey of reluctant maturity and quiet resilience resonated broadly with audiences, mirroring the burdens many young people face, though Gilford emphasized its universal relatability rather than personal parallels in interviews.[28][29][30] Friday Night Lights earned widespread critical acclaim for its nuanced depiction of small-town American life, community obsession with high school football, and exploration of themes like race, class, and family dynamics, achieving a 95% approval rating on Rotten Tomatoes across its five seasons. Gilford's portrayal contributed significantly to the ensemble's strength, embodying the "everyman" hero whose vulnerability anchored the group's interpersonal tensions and triumphs. The series' cultural legacy endures as a generational touchstone, praised for treating viewers as thoughtful participants rather than passive observers. In a 2025 reunion interview with co-star Scott Porter, Gilford reflected on its lasting impact, stating, "It feels authentic. It rings true. You feel like you’re watching real people, and it was so grounded," while Porter noted how it "gets handed down generationally," with even teenagers in 2025 discovering its relevance nearly two decades later.[31][32][33][34] Following Friday Night Lights, Gilford took on leading roles in other television series. He starred as Dr. Ben Keeton, an idealistic ER doctor, in the short-lived ABC medical drama Off the Map (2011), which was set in a remote South American clinic and explored themes of healing and personal redemption amid exotic locales.[35] Later, from 2018 to 2021, he portrayed the charismatic criminal mastermind Rio in the NBC comedy-drama Good Girls, a role that showcased his ability to blend menace with charm in a story of suburban mothers turning to crime. The series ran for four seasons and earned praise for its witty take on heists and family dynamics.[36] He also appeared as special agent Ben Walker in the action spinoff L.A.'s Finest (2019–2020), partnering with Gabrielle Union and Jessica Alba in a high-stakes police procedural derived from the Bad Boys universe.[37]Expansion into film
Gilford began transitioning to feature films with supporting parts that showcased his versatility across genres, concurrent with and following his Friday Night Lights tenure. Gilford's first major film appearance came in the 2006 independent horror-thriller The Last Winter, directed by Larry Fessenden and produced by Glass Eye Entertainment. He portrayed Maxwell McKinder, the young son of a colleague who joins an oil drilling crew in the Alaskan wilderness, where environmental disturbances unleash supernatural forces. The ensemble cast included Ron Perlman as the lead engineer, James LeGros, Connie Britton, and Kevin Corrigan, with the film exploring themes of ecological revenge through a "revenge of nature" narrative. It premiered at the Toronto International Film Festival and received praise for its atmospheric tension, though it achieved modest commercial release.[38][39] In 2014, Gilford took on a more prominent supporting role as Shane, a cab driver navigating the chaotic annual Purge with his girlfriend (played by Kiele Sanchez), in the action-horror sequel The Purge: Anarchy, directed by James DeMonaco. The film expanded the franchise's dystopian premise, focusing on class warfare and survival in the streets during the government-sanctioned night of violence, with Gilford's character providing grounded emotional stakes amid high-octane sequences. It grossed $71.6 million domestically and $111.9 million worldwide against a $9 million budget, marking a significant box office success and critical improvement over the original.[40] Gilford continued exploring diverse film roles in the ensuing years, including the comedic drama Boy Genius (2019), where he played Gordon, a quirky teacher who aids a 12-year-old prodigy (Miles Brown) in solving a family crisis and a local mystery, alongside Rita Wilson and Tracie Thoms. The film highlighted his ability to blend humor with heartfelt mentorship dynamics in an indie family-oriented story. More recently, in the 2023 Blumhouse horror film There's Something Wrong with the Children, directed by Roxanne Benjamin, Gilford starred as Ben Winslow, a husband on a glamping trip whose weekend with friends turns nightmarish when their children exhibit disturbing, seemingly possessed behavior in the woods. His performance emphasized paternal paranoia and relational strain, contributing to the film's psychological tension in a runtime focused on isolation and doubt.[41] In 2025, Gilford starred in the drama After All, directed by Kerstin Karlhuber, which explores three generations of women confronting trauma and family reconnection when a grandmother suffers a stroke. The film received positive reviews for its emotional depth and was released in theaters on October 17, 2025.[42] Looking ahead, Gilford is set to appear in the upcoming techno-thriller A.I. Heart U, written and directed by Jason Cook, with principal photography completed in Portland, Oregon, in early 2025. He plays Hayden in this indie ensemble piece about a startup's rise and fall amid artificial intelligence innovations, intertwined with themes of sex, murder, and corporate ambition, co-starring T.J. Miller as Marco and Heather Morris. The project was announced in March 2025, positioning Gilford in a narrative examining AI's disruptive impact on human connections.[43][44]Horror genre and recent television
Gilford's entry into the horror genre was marked by his collaborations with director Mike Flanagan, beginning with the 2021 Netflix miniseries Midnight Mass, where he portrayed Riley Flynn, a troubled protagonist grappling with guilt and redemption after a fatal drunk-driving accident. The series explores profound themes of faith, grief, and the perils of religious fanaticism, as Riley returns to his isolated island hometown amid supernatural occurrences that test his skepticism toward organized religion.[45][46][47] This partnership continued in Flanagan's 2022 Netflix series The Midnight Club, in which Gilford played Mark, a compassionate nurse at a hospice for terminally ill teenagers who form a secret group to share frightening stories. The narrative delves into themes of mortality, friendship, and the cathartic power of storytelling, blending emotional depth with supernatural horror elements.[48][49][50] Gilford reprised his recurring presence in Flanagan's oeuvre in the 2023 Netflix miniseries The Fall of the House of Usher, embodying a younger Roderick Usher, the ambitious CEO of a corrupt pharmaceutical empire whose family's downfall unfolds through Poe-inspired tales of vengeance. Here, the story examines family dysfunction, inherited trauma, and the horrors of unchecked greed and grief.[51][52] Transitioning from atmospheric horror to procedural thriller, Gilford took on the role of Elias Voit, a cunning serial killer and leader of the "Sicarius" network, in Criminal Minds: Evolution starting in season 16 (2022) as a recurring antagonist. Promoted to a main role in seasons 17 and 18, Voit's character evolves from a manipulative psychopath to a more conflicted figure dealing with amnesia and reluctant alliances with the BAU team, allowing Gilford to explore the unsub's internal turmoil, including regret over his monstrous actions and protective instincts toward his family.[53] Season 18 premiered on May 8, 2025, on Paramount+, comprising 10 episodes that deepen Voit's psychology through his uneasy partnership with the team against his own network, culminating in a twisty narrative arc; Paramount+ subsequently ordered season 19, with Gilford confirmed to return.[54][55] Behind the scenes, Gilford has highlighted the challenges of balancing Voit's past depravities with his present vulnerability, noting that portraying the character's amnesia required treating him as a "new" persona while subtly revealing lingering traits like dark humor, which left him emotionally drained and reflective on human flaws.[56] Gilford's dynamic with co-star Joe Mantegna, who plays SSA David Rossi, mirrors their characters' tense mentor-antagonist relationship, evolving from initial on-set nervousness—stemming from Gilford's childhood admiration for Mantegna—to a supportive off-screen friendship that facilitates intense scenes involving pity, disbelief, and psychological manipulation.[57] In 2025 interviews, Gilford reflected on how these horror and thriller roles have showcased his versatility, building on his earlier dramatic work in shows like Friday Night Lights to avoid typecasting while embracing complex antagonists that demand emotional range beyond genre stereotypes.[58][5]Personal life
Marriage to Kiele Sanchez
Zach Gilford met actress Kiele Sanchez in early 2010 while co-starring on the ABC pilot The Matadors, which was not picked up as a series.[59] The pair began dating shortly after, bonding over their shared experiences in the entertainment industry during the early stages of their relationship.[60] Gilford later described Sanchez as "the most amazing woman in the world," highlighting the personal support they provided each other amid career transitions following his breakout role on Friday Night Lights.[61] The couple got engaged in late November 2011 after dating for about a year and a half.[62] They opted for a private ceremony, reflecting their preference for keeping personal life out of the public eye despite their professions.[63] Gilford and Sanchez married on December 29, 2012, in an intimate wedding in Napa Valley, California.[64] The low-key event, attended by close family and friends, underscored their desire for a simple celebration away from Hollywood's spotlight.[59] Throughout their early years together, they continued to offer mutual encouragement during professional highs, such as Sanchez's starring role on The Glades and Gilford's ventures into film.[62]Family and children
Gilford and his wife, actress Kiele Sanchez, welcomed their first child, daughter Zeppelin Adele Gilford, on November 29, 2017, via surrogate in Los Angeles.[65] Kiele Sanchez suggested the name Zeppelin Adele to Gilford spontaneously after their first ultrasound with the surrogate, while Adele honors Gilford's grandmother.[66] In interviews following the birth, Gilford described himself as a hands-on and present father, emphasizing his desire to support his daughter's confidence and individuality while guiding her growth.[66] He also praised Sanchez as a fiercely protective "mama lion," noting her instinctive devotion to their newborn.[66] The couple expanded their family with the birth of their son, Revel Gilford, in 2021.[67] Gilford has shared that raising their children in Los Angeles involves navigating the demands of their entertainment careers, with both parents drawing from their acting backgrounds to foster a supportive home environment.[68] However, the challenges of balancing parenthood with professional commitments became evident when Gilford missed Revel's birth due to filming Netflix's Midnight Mass during the COVID-19 pandemic; he later reflected on the experience as emotionally taxing, stating it left him in a headspace of self-doubt and reluctance on set.[67] Gilford's experiences as a father have highlighted the priorities of family life amid his career, with the couple's shared foundation in the industry enabling them to prioritize presence and guidance for Zeppelin and Revel in their Los Angeles home.[69]Divorce proceedings
On April 18, 2025, actor Zach Gilford filed for divorce from his wife, actress Kiele Sanchez, in Los Angeles County Superior Court after 12 years of marriage.[70] The filing cited irreconcilable differences as the grounds for the dissolution, with no specific date of separation provided in the documents.[71] The couple, who share two children—daughter Zeppelin Adele, aged 7, and son Revel, aged 4—requested joint legal and physical custody arrangements to prioritize co-parenting.[70] Gilford also indicated in the court papers a request for spousal support to be awarded to Sanchez, though details on asset division were not disclosed in the initial filing.[70] As of the filing date, no further information on property settlement or other financial matters had been made public.[72] Public response to the divorce has been limited, with representatives for both Gilford and Sanchez declining to comment immediately following the announcement.[70] Media coverage highlighted the couple's history as co-stars on shows like Friday Night Lights and Criminal Minds: Evolution, noting the amicable tone suggested by the joint custody request amid Gilford's ongoing professional commitments in 2025, including his role in the latter series.[73] No additional statements from Gilford regarding the proceedings have been reported as of November 2025.[74]Filmography
Film
- The Last Winter (2006) – Maxwell McKinder[38]
- Whisper (2007) – David
- The Last House on the Left (2009) – Justin
- Post Grad (2009) – Adam
- Dare (2009) – Johnny Drake[75]
- In My Sleep (2010) – Marcus
- The River Why (2010) – Gus
- Answer This! (2011) – Paul Tarson
- Answers to Nothing (2011) – Evan
- In Our Nature (2012) – Seth
- Crazy Kind of Love (2012) – Matthew
- The Last Stand (2013) – Jerry Bailey
- Devil's Due (2014) – Zach McCall
- The Purge: Anarchy (2014) – Shane[40]
- The Stanford Prison Experiment (2015) – John Lovett
- LBJ (2017) – Gerald Ford
- The Wind (2018) – Isaac
- Boy Genius (2019) – Gordon
- Classmates (2023) – Professor Walsmith[76]
- There's Something Wrong with the Children (2023) – Ben
- After All (2025) – Bobby[77]
- A.I. Heart U (TBA) – TBA (filming completed, no release date as of November 2025)[44]
Television
Gilford made his television debut with a guest appearance on the NBC series Law & Order: Special Victims Unit, portraying Kevin Wilcox in the episode "Mean" during the sixth season. He achieved his breakthrough role as the lead character Matt Saracen, the quarterback of the Dillon Panthers, in the NBC drama Friday Night Lights, appearing as a main cast member from 2006 to 2011 across five seasons and 62 episodes.[78] In 2009, Gilford guest-starred as Charlie Lowell, a patient seeking amputation for idiopathic leg pain, in a single episode of ABC's Grey's Anatomy titled "Here's to Future Days." From 2011, he starred as Dr. Tommy Fuller, a young physician in a South American medical outpost, in the ABC series Off the Map, serving as a main cast member for the full 13-episode first and only season. Gilford took the lead role of Dr. Brett Robinson, a surgical resident entangled in organized crime, in Fox's medical drama The Mob Doctor, appearing as a main cast member in all 15 episodes of its single season from 2012 to 2013. He made guest appearances in two episodes of Comedy Central's anthology series Drunk History between 2013 and 2015, portraying historical figures Roger Sharpe in "Philadelphia" (2013) and Jim Abbott in "Sports" (2015). In the Audience Network MMA drama Kingdom, Gilford played Nate Kulina, the troubled younger brother of the protagonist, as a recurring cast member from 2014 to 2017, accumulating 40 episodes over three seasons. Gilford starred as Danny Warren, the missing son returned after a decade, in ABC's political thriller The Family, serving as a main cast member for all 12 episodes of its 2016 single season. He led the Crackle sci-fi web series Lifeline as Conner Hooks, a man navigating alternate realities, appearing in all 8 episodes of its 2017 first season. In 2017, Gilford guest-starred as Kyle, a suspect in a bank heist, in one episode of NBC's Blindspot. From 2018 to 2021, he had a recurring role as Greg, the husband of a main character, in NBC's crime comedy Good Girls, appearing in 16 episodes across four seasons. Gilford appeared as Danny in two episodes of SundanceTV's drama This Close in 2018, marking a guest role in the deaf-centered series. In 2018, he guest-starred as Andrew Ford, a victim of a serial killer, in one episode of CBS's Criminal Minds. He portrayed Ben Walker, an undercover DEA agent, as a main cast member in the Spectrum Originals action series L.A.'s Finest from 2019 to 2020, appearing in all 26 episodes over two seasons. In 2019, he guest-starred on Law & Order: Special Victims Unit as James Miller in the episode "The Burden of Our Choices" during the 21st season. In the 2021 Netflix miniseries Midnight Mass, Gilford starred as Riley Flynn, a former resident returning to his island hometown amid supernatural events, in all 7 episodes.[79] He played Mark, a terminally ill teen sharing ghost stories, as a main cast member in Netflix's horror mystery The Midnight Club in 2022, appearing in all 10 episodes of its single season. Beginning in 2022, Gilford has portrayed the serial killer Elias Voit in the Paramount+ revival Criminal Minds: Evolution, initially recurring in season 16 before becoming a main cast member in season 17; as of November 2025, he has appeared in 30 episodes, including the season 18 premiere on May 8, 2025. In the 2023 Netflix miniseries The Fall of the House of Usher, Gilford starred as the younger version of Roderick Usher in 8 episodes, framing the narrative through flashbacks.| Year(s) | Title | Role | Episodes | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2005 | Law & Order: Special Victims Unit | Kevin Wilcox | 1 | Guest star |
| 2006–2011 | Friday Night Lights | Matt Saracen | 62 | Main cast |
| 2009 | Grey's Anatomy | Charlie Lowell | 1 | Guest star |
| 2011 | Off the Map | Dr. Tommy Fuller | 13 | Main cast |
| 2012–2013 | The Mob Doctor | Dr. Brett Robinson | 15 | Main cast |
| 2013–2015 | Drunk History | Roger Sharpe / Jim Abbott | 2 | Guest star |
| 2014–2017 | Kingdom | Nate Kulina | 40 | Recurring / Main cast |
| 2016 | The Family | Danny Warren | 12 | Main cast |
| 2017 | Lifeline | Conner Hooks | 8 | Main cast |
| 2017 | Blindspot | Kyle | 1 | Guest star |
| 2018 | This Close | Danny | 2 | Guest star |
| 2018–2021 | Good Girls | Greg | 16 | Recurring |
| 2018 | Criminal Minds | Andrew Ford | 1 | Guest star |
| 2019–2020 | L.A.'s Finest | Ben Walker | 26 | Main cast |
| 2019 | Law & Order: Special Victims Unit | James Miller | 1 | Guest star |
| 2021 | Midnight Mass | Riley Flynn | 7 | Main cast (miniseries) |
| 2022 | The Midnight Club | Mark | 10 | Main cast |
| 2022–present | Criminal Minds: Evolution | Elias Voit | 30 | Recurring (S16), Main (S17+) |
| 2023 | The Fall of the House of Usher | Young Roderick Usher | 8 | Main cast (miniseries) |
Music videos
Gilford made a notable appearance in the music video for Taylor Swift's single "Ours," released on December 2, 2011, where he portrayed the singer's long-distance love interest, a soldier facing family opposition before reuniting with her at an airport.[80] The video, directed by Declan Whitebloom, depicts a narrative of enduring romance amid challenges, with Gilford's character returning from deployment.[81] This role came during Gilford's mid-career transition following the end of Friday Night Lights. The accompanying single from Swift's album Speak Now topped the Billboard Country Songs chart in March 2012 and peaked at number 13 on the Billboard Hot 100.[82] As of 2025, this remains Gilford's only documented music video appearance.Accolades
Awards
Zach Gilford has won three awards recognizing his performances in film and television. In 2009, he received the Breakthrough Performer award in the Rising Stars category at the Hamptons International Film Festival for his role as Johnny Drake in the film Dare.<grok:render type="render_inline_citation">Nominations
Throughout his career, Zach Gilford has accumulated 13 award nominations across various genres, with early recognition for his dramatic work on Friday Night Lights and later acclaim in horror projects. These nominations highlight his versatility, particularly in supporting roles during the late 2000s and lead performances in horror series from 2021 onward. Gilford's initial nominations came from his portrayal of Matt Saracen on Friday Night Lights (2006–2011) and early film work. He received multiple nods from Gold Derby TV Awards, including for Drama Supporting Actor in 2007, Ensemble of the Year in 2007 and 2010, and Drama Supporting Actor of the Decade and Drama Guest Actor in 2010. He also earned Entertainment Weekly's EWwy Awards nominations for Best Supporting Actor in a Drama in both 2010 and 2011, as well as a 2011 INOCA nomination for Best Guest Actor in a Drama or Comedy Series. Additionally, for the ensemble in The Last Winter (2006), he was nominated for a 2007 Gotham Independent Film Award for Best Ensemble Performance. In film, Gilford was nominated for an MTV Movie Award in 2015 for Best Scared-As-Shit Performance for his role as Shane in The Purge: Anarchy (2014). Post-2020, Gilford's horror roles garnered specialized recognition. For his performance as Riley Flynn in the Netflix limited series Midnight Mass (2021), he received nominations including the Critics Choice Super Awards for Best Actor in a Horror Series, the Critics' Choice Television Award for Best Supporting Actor in a Limited Series or Movie Made for Television, and the Gold Derby TV Award for Limited/Movie Supporting Actor, all in 2022. He followed this with a nomination in the Best Actor in a Horror Series, Limited Series or Made-for-TV Movie category at the 2024 Critics Choice Super Awards for portraying young Roderick Usher in The Fall of the House of Usher (2023). As of November 2025, no new nominations have emerged for his ongoing role as Elias Voit in Criminal Minds: Evolution (2022–present).| Year | Awarding Body | Category | Work |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2007 | Gold Derby TV Awards | Drama Supporting Actor | Friday Night Lights |
| 2007 | Gold Derby TV Awards | Ensemble of the Year | Friday Night Lights |
| 2007 | Gotham Independent Film Award | Best Ensemble Performance | The Last Winter |
| 2010 | Gold Derby TV Awards | Ensemble of the Year | Friday Night Lights |
| 2010 | Gold Derby TV Awards | Drama Supporting Actor of the Decade | Friday Night Lights |
| 2010 | Gold Derby TV Awards | Drama Guest Actor | Friday Night Lights |
| 2010 | EWwy Awards | Best Supporting Actor in a Drama | Friday Night Lights |
| 2011 | EWwy Awards | Best Supporting Actor in a Drama | Friday Night Lights |
| 2011 | INOCA TV Awards | Best Guest Actor in a Drama or Comedy Series | Friday Night Lights |
| 2015 | MTV Movie Awards | Best Scared-As-Shit Performance | The Purge: Anarchy |
| 2022 | Critics Choice Super Awards | Best Actor in a Horror Series | Midnight Mass |
| 2022 | Critics' Choice Television Awards | Best Supporting Actor in a Limited Series or Movie Made for Television | Midnight Mass |
| 2022 | Gold Derby TV Awards | Limited/Movie Supporting Actor | Midnight Mass |
| 2024 | Critics Choice Super Awards | Best Actor in a Horror Series, Limited Series or Made-for-TV Movie | The Fall of the House of Usher |