Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

A Separation

A Separation (Persian: جدایی نادر از سیمین, Jodāyi-e Nāder az Simin) is a 2011 Iranian drama film written and directed by Asghar Farhadi.^[1] The story centers on Nader and Simin, a middle-class Tehran couple seeking divorce after Simin insists on emigrating for their daughter's future while Nader refuses to abandon his elderly father with Alzheimer's, leading to a custody dispute and an accusation of assault against Nader by the devout caregiver hired to assist his father.^[1] The film eschews clear moral judgments, instead highlighting tensions in Iranian family dynamics, class differences, and the pursuit of truth under legal and cultural pressures.^[2] Released amid political unrest in Iran, A Separation was produced independently without government funding and faced temporary production bans due to Farhadi's support for detained filmmakers and his criticism of censorship, yet it became a critical and commercial success domestically and internationally.^[3] It premiered at the 61st Berlin International Film Festival, where it won the Golden Bear for Best Film, and later secured the Academy Award for Best Foreign Language Feature in 2012—the first for an Iranian film—along with a Golden Globe in the same category.^[4]^[5] These achievements underscored Farhadi's skill in crafting universally resonant narratives from specific cultural contexts, though the film drew scrutiny in Iran for its portrayal of societal fault lines, including desires to emigrate and gender roles, without overt political messaging.^[6]

Production

Development and Writing

Asghar Farhadi conceived A Separation from a single vivid image: a young man bathing his elderly father afflicted with Alzheimer's disease, an idea drawn from his brother's memory of caring for their ailing grandfather, which evoked profound isolation and familial duty.^[7]^[8] This "magnet," as Farhadi described it, attracted related personal and observed experiences, prompting interrogations such as the absence of spousal support or external caregivers, which expanded into explorations of marital strain and caregiving burdens within Iranian households.^[7]^[9] The script development began around 2009, with Farhadi building a narrative framework akin to a "domino effect," where mundane daily actions cascade into irreconcilable conflicts, grounded in authentic Persian dialogues reflective of real Iranian family dynamics.^[8] He drew on empirical observations from divorce proceedings and interpersonal disputes, emphasizing tensions between socioeconomic classes—such as differing priorities in middle-class stability versus working-class survival—without assigning moral superiority to any side.^[9]^[8] Farhadi's process involved treating the screenplay like a courthouse, granting each perspective an equitable voice to mirror causal chains in ethical decision-making.^[9] Farhadi intentionally eschewed didactic political commentary, prioritizing universal quandaries of truth, justice, and parental obligation amid Iran's legal and cultural constraints, such as guardianship laws and religious oaths, to foster audience-driven ambiguity rather than imposed resolutions.^[7]^[8] This approach stemmed from his commitment to impartiality, informed by theater traditions that trust viewers' interpretive capacities over explicit judgments.^[9]

Casting and Filming

The principal roles in A Separation were filled by experienced Iranian performers, including Peyman Moaadi as Nader, Leila Hatami as Simin, Shahab Hosseini as Hodjat, and Sareh Bayat as Razieh, complemented by non-professional actors such as Sarina Farhadi, the director's daughter, in her acting debut as Termeh.^[10] Director Asghar Farhadi prioritized authenticity in casting, deliberately incorporating non-professionals alongside seasoned talent to transcend scripted realism and capture unfiltered social and class dynamics reflective of contemporary Iran.^[7]^[11] Filming took place entirely in Tehran during 2010, completed over three months using a single handheld camera that followed characters closely, fostering a raw, documentary-style immediacy and tension through shaky, immersive shots in real-time settings.^[12] Key sequences unfolded in unadorned actual locations, such as modest apartments, operational courtrooms, and urban streets, to ground the narrative in verifiable everyday Iranian environments without constructed sets.^[13] The low-budget production, estimated at $700,000 to $800,000, emphasized narrative economy by relying on available natural light and sparse resources, prioritizing character-driven conflict over elaborate visual effects.^[12]

Censorship and Challenges in Iran

The production of A Separation required submission of a 15- to 20-page outline to Iran's Ministry of Culture and Islamic Guidance at the end of 2009, which received approval approximately one month later, enabling initial preparations while adhering to guidelines that prohibit explicit depictions of sexuality, violence, or direct regime critique.^[12] This process reflects the ministry's standard oversight, where scripts or outlines must navigate restrictions on content that could be interpreted as undermining Islamic values or state authority, including portrayals of family law influenced by Sharia principles such as guardianship and oaths on religious texts.^[14] In September 2010, shortly before principal photography, the ministry revoked Farhadi's filming permit following his acceptance speech at the House of Cinema awards, in which he advocated for the return of exiled filmmakers including Mohsen Makhmalbaf, labeled by authorities as counter-revolutionary.^[15] ^[16] The ban was temporarily lifted after Farhadi issued a statement renouncing his remarks and, under pressure, wrote a letter of apology to Supreme Leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei, demonstrating how public statements by filmmakers can directly trigger regulatory retaliation in Iran's media environment.^[17] ^[18] Filmmakers faced additional hurdles in authentically rendering religious devotion and gender dynamics without Western modifications or violations of censorship codes, such as mandatory hijab observance and avoidance of unchaperoned interactions between unrelated men and women, which aligned the film's depictions— including courtroom reliance on Quranic oaths and familial hierarchies—with prevailing empirical social and legal norms in Iran.^[19] These constraints necessitated self-censorship to secure approvals, ensuring that explorations of class tensions and marital disputes remained grounded in observable Iranian realities rather than abstracted or altered for external sensibilities.^[3]

Cast and Characters

Principal Actors

Leila Hatami portrayed Simin, the educated wife contemplating emigration, drawing on her upbringing in a prominent Iranian cinematic family as the daughter of director Ali Hatami and actress Zari Khoshkam to deliver a poised, introspective performance.^[20] Born in Tehran on October 1, 1972, Hatami's prior roles in Iranian films informed her subtle depiction of familial tension, contributing to the film's grounded realism without reliance on external stylistic influences.^[21] Peyman Moadi played Nader, the devoted husband and son, leveraging his experience as an Iranian-American performer who had collaborated with director Asghar Farhadi in earlier works like About Elly (2009) to embody quiet resolve amid conflict.^[22] Moadi, born in 1972 in New York City to Iranian parents, shared the Silver Bear for Best Actor at the 2011 Berlin International Film Festival with co-stars Shahab Hosseini, Babak Karimi, and Ali-Asghar Shahbazi for their collective contributions.^[22] Sareh Bayat enacted Razieh, the devout caregiver, bringing authenticity from her theater origins, having begun performing on stage in 2001 and majored in theater at university, where she earned a Diploma of Honor for Best Actress at Tehran's Police Theatre Festival in 2006.^[23] Bayat's training enabled nuanced physical and emotional expressiveness suited to the role's cultural constraints. Shahab Hosseini depicted Hodjat, the volatile husband, informed by his formal acting studies at the University of Tehran and early immersion in literature and theater, which honed his ability to convey raw intensity.^[24] Born February 3, 1974, in Tehran, Hosseini's theater and television background facilitated dynamic portrayals in Iranian cinema, enhancing the ensemble's interpersonal authenticity.^[25] The cast's chemistry stemmed from Farhadi's rigorous rehearsal process, rooted in his playwright experience, which incorporated improvisational elements to mirror real-life conflicts and foster naturalistic interactions devoid of Hollywood conventions.^[26]^[27] This approach, emphasizing Iranian theatrical traditions among several performers, amplified the film's credible depiction of domestic strife.^[11]

Character Analysis

Nader, portrayed by Peyman Moaadi, is driven by a profound sense of filial responsibility toward his father, who suffers from advanced Alzheimer's disease and requires constant care, including assistance with basic functions like urination and preventing wandering.^[28] This obligation anchors Nader's refusal to emigrate from Iran, prioritizing immediate familial duty over long-term prospects abroad, as he views abandoning his father as morally untenable.^[29] In contrast, his wife Simin, played by Leila Hatami, embodies a forward-looking individualism, seeking divorce to pursue emigration visas for the sake of their 11-year-old daughter Termeh's future education and opportunities outside Iran's constraints.^[30] Her motivation stems from a belief that remaining equates to condemning Termeh to diminished potential, creating an irreconcilable tension where Nader's static caregiving clashes with Simin's dynamic aspirations for mobility and improvement.^[31] Razieh, enacted by Sareh Bayat, navigates acute economic desperation as a working-class woman supporting her unemployed husband Hodjat and young children, compelling her to accept the caregiving role despite its incompatibility with her strict religious observance.^[28] Her poverty manifests in practical strains, such as affording bus fares or medical needs, forcing choices like chaining her daughter to a bed for safety during work hours.^[30] Adhering to Islamic tenets, Razieh consults a cleric before employment—questioning the permissibility of tending to a male stranger—and wears gloves to avoid physical contact, illustrating how doctrinal norms intersect with survival imperatives to limit her agency.^[28] The film's protagonists evade simplistic villainy, as their decisions arise from verifiable pressures: Nader's from paternal bonds, Simin's from parental foresight, and Razieh's from material and faith-based exigencies, each precipitating unintended escalations without inherent malice.^[29] Director Asghar Farhadi constructs these motivations to reveal how individual rationales, grounded in personal circumstances, generate interlocking dilemmas rather than deliberate antagonism.^[31] This approach underscores causal chains where initial choices, defensible in isolation, compound into ethical binds, reflecting realistic human fallibility over archetypal moral binaries.^[15]

Plot Summary

Overview

A Separation is a 2011 Iranian drama film written and directed by Asghar Farhadi, centering on the marital discord of a middle-class Tehran couple, Nader and Simin. The pair, parents to an 11-year-old daughter named Termeh, apply for divorce amid irreconcilable differences over emigration: Simin seeks to relocate abroad for enhanced opportunities for their child, while Nader declines, bound by his duty to care for his father afflicted with Alzheimer's disease.^[32]^[33] To manage his caregiving responsibilities while working, Nader employs Razieh, a devout woman from a lower socioeconomic background facing her own familial hardships, including an unemployed husband and pregnancy concerns. This arrangement precipitates interpersonal frictions exacerbated by Iran's stringent legal system and cultural norms, which prioritize familial obligations and religious piety. The central dilemma revolves around reconciling personal ambitions with duties to family and child welfare in a society where individual choices are constrained by broader institutional frameworks.^[32]^[34] The film's narrative structure depicts a progressively intensifying domestic dispute, portrayed through intimate, real-time interactions that eschew melodrama in favor of authentic emotional realism. This single-threaded conflict serves as a microcosm of wider Iranian societal tensions, including class disparities and the interplay of tradition with modernity, without delving into overt political commentary.^[35]^[36]

Key Events and Turning Points

Simin petitions for divorce from Nader, citing irreconcilable differences over emigrating from Iran with their daughter Termeh, but the court denies the request on grounds that Nader is the primary caregiver for his elderly father with Alzheimer's disease.^[22] Simin subsequently moves out to her mother's home, leaving Nader to hire Razieh, a devout and pregnant woman from a lower socioeconomic background, as a live-in caregiver for his father.^[22] ^[37] A pivotal incident occurs when Nader returns home to find his father unattended, incontinent, and in distress, prompting him to accuse Razieh of neglect and theft after discovering missing money; in the ensuing confrontation, Nader physically pushes Razieh toward the door, causing her to fall down the apartment stairs and suffer a miscarriage.^[22] Razieh's husband, Hodjat—an unemployed and volatile man—files charges against Nader for intentional harm leading to the fetal death, escalating the dispute into a criminal court case involving accusations of murder.^[22] ^[38] Court proceedings intensify with mutual allegations: Hodjat's aggressive behavior prompts a judicial order for lie detector tests, which Nader passes while Hodjat's results highlight his instability; Razieh admits under questioning to leaving the father alone, violating her own religious fatwa, and Termeh becomes entangled as a witness in the custody battle intertwined with the criminal trial.^[37] ^[33] The narrative culminates in Termeh's private courtroom deliberation, where she must choose between her parents amid unresolved tensions, leaving the family's fractures open-ended without resolution.^[37] ^[38]

Themes and Motifs

In A Separation, the central conflict arises from the socioeconomic chasm between Nader's middle-class family and Razieh's working-class household, manifesting in divergent living standards, educational attainment, and cultural norms. Nader, employed as a bank clerk in Tehran, resides in a modest but stable urban apartment equipped with modern amenities, reflecting the relative security of Iran's urban middle class, which comprised about 30-40% of the population in the early 2010s and benefited from salaried professions and access to education.^[39] In contrast, Razieh, veiled in a chador and commuting from Tehran's peripheral districts, embodies the precarious existence of the urban working poor, compelled to domestic work due to her husband Hodjat's unemployment as an itinerant laborer burdened by debts. This disparity underscores Iran's Gini coefficient of approximately 38.8 around 2011-2014, indicating moderate but persistent income inequality exacerbated by urban concentration, where Tehran's population of over 8 million in 2011 amplified divides between salaried professionals and informal laborers.^[40]^[41] The film's social realism derives from its depiction of how economic imperatives shape interpersonal trust and behavioral expectations across classes. Razieh's decision to accept the caregiving role for Nader's Alzheimer-afflicted father, despite religious qualms about physical contact with a non-mahram male, stems directly from household financial strain, as evidenced by her furtive phone consultations with a cleric and her persistence post-incident to secure wages. Such choices mirror empirical patterns in Iran, where urban poverty affected roughly 13% of households pre-fiscal transfers in 2011, driving women into informal employment amid male underemployment rates exceeding 20% in lower strata.^[42] Class-inflected frictions emerge in disputes over hygiene protocols—Razieh's hesitation to handle the father's incontinence alone clashes with Nader's expectation of unhesitating care—revealing not mere cultural variance but causal linkages to resource scarcity, where working-class families prioritize survival over the middle-class norm of professional detachment in service roles.^[2] Tehran's north-south axis amplifies these tensions, with affluent northern districts hosting educated elites and southern peripheries concentrating migrants and low-wage workers, a spatial inequality rooted in post-1979 urban planning that funneled state resources unevenly.^[43] Farhadi's narrative eschews romanticized poverty or villainizing the affluent, instead tracing conflicts to material realities: Hodjat's volatility arises from joblessness in a labor market distorted by state subsidies and cronyism, which preserved middle-class buffers while inflating costs for the vulnerable, rather than external attributions like sanctions alone. This portrayal critiques how Iranian policy frameworks, including targeted cash transfers introduced in 2011 that mitigated but did not erase a 0.05 Gini point in inequality, perpetuated class immobility by favoring connected elites over broad productivity gains. Empirical data affirm the film's verisimilitude, as urban working-class households faced vulnerability indices 2-3 times higher than middle-class counterparts in Tehran circa 2011, fostering mistrust in cross-class interactions.^[44]

Family Obligations and Gender Dynamics

In A Separation, Nader's commitment to caring for his father, who suffers from Alzheimer's disease and requires constant supervision, prevents the family from emigrating, positioning filial duty as a core obligation that supersedes Simin's desire for relocation to secure better opportunities for their daughter, Termeh. This choice reflects cultural expectations of adult children supporting aging parents in Iran, where such responsibilities often fall to sons, creating intergenerational dependencies that bind individuals beyond spousal relations. Analyses note that Nader's stance arises from practical necessity—leaving the father unattended risks his immediate harm—rather than arbitrary dominance, illustrating how family structures enforce reciprocal care to maintain household stability.^[45]^[46] Simin exhibits considerable autonomy by petitioning for divorce to emigrate alone with Termeh, leveraging Iran's family courts where women can initiate separation on grounds of irreconcilable differences, though approval depends on judicial discretion. This contrasts sharply with Razieh's circumstances, where her decision to work as the father's caregiver requires covert negotiation with her unemployed husband, Hodjat, whose financial control and religious conservatism limit her independence, as she seeks his permission to address family debts while adhering to norms restricting women's employment without male oversight. Such depictions reveal class-influenced variations in female agency: middle-class Simin navigates legal options more fluidly, while working-class Razieh contends with spousal authority amplified by economic vulnerability, underscoring that gender constraints in Iranian families stem from intersecting socioeconomic factors rather than uniform patriarchal imposition.^[47]^[48] The ensuing marital breakdown imposes evident strains on Termeh, who faces divided loyalties and heightened anxiety, mirroring broader empirical findings that divorce disrupts child stability by elevating risks of internalizing disorders, externalizing behaviors, and reduced educational outcomes, with longitudinal studies showing children of divorced parents averaging lower academic attainment and well-being compared to those in intact families. These effects arise causally from diminished parental resources, inconsistent caregiving, and exposure to conflict, prioritizing family cohesion for child development over unilateral adult choices that fragment support networks.^[49]^[50]^[51]

Religious Piety and Legal Constraints in Iran

In the film, Razieh exemplifies religious piety through her adherence to Shia Islamic norms, frequently seeking guidance from clerical authorities on matters of ritual purity and ethical conduct. Early in her employment as Nader's elderly father's caregiver, she telephones a religious scholar to inquire whether it is permissible under Islamic law for a woman to change the diaper of an unrelated male patient, citing concerns over ritual impurity (najis) associated with urine and excrement.^[52] This consultation underscores the practical constraints piety imposes on daily labor, as Razieh's devotion leads her to prioritize religious rulings over professional duties, ultimately contributing to the neglect that sparks the central conflict. Her donning of the chador and visible discomfort in secular environments further illustrate how such piety shapes interpersonal boundaries in Iranian society.^[35] The film's depiction of Iran's legal system highlights the integration of Sharia principles, particularly in family and criminal courts, where evidentiary standards emphasize witness testimony, oaths, and moral credibility over forensic evidence. In the divorce proceedings, the judge mediates based on familial obligations derived from Islamic jurisprudence, denying Simin's request to emigrate without Nader's consent due to the duty to care for his incapacitated father, reflecting Sharia's prioritization of parental piety.^[53] The subsequent assault case against Nader for allegedly causing Razieh's miscarriage invokes qisas (retaliatory justice) and diya (blood money) provisions, with the court relying on sworn statements rather than medical proof; Hodjat, Razieh's husband, offers to take a Quranic oath attesting to Nader's intentional harm, while Nader faces pressure to swear his innocence, creating an impasse rooted in the system's trust in divine accountability through oaths.^[53]^[35] This portrayal reveals how theocratic mechanisms enforce communal responsibility—such as oaths deterring false claims through fear of divine retribution—but also facilitate deception when personal stakes override scruple, as seen in the characters' selective truths during interrogations. The judge's rulings incorporate religious and cultural norms, weighing piety and gender roles in assessing credibility, yet the lack of impartial verification exposes vulnerabilities where unverifiable intent determines outcomes.^[54] Such elements depict Sharia not as abstract ideology but as a causal framework influencing real-time decisions, where piety both stabilizes social order and exacerbates conflicts absent empirical resolution.^[55]

Moral Ambiguity and Personal Agency

In A Separation, the narrative eschews binary moral categorizations, presenting characters whose decisions arise from competing personal imperatives rather than malice, yet precipitate cascading ethical complications. Nader's choice to briefly leave his Alzheimer-afflicted father unattended stems from familial duty and employment demands, while Razieh's acceptance of the caregiving role, despite religious qualms about physical contact with an unrelated man, reflects economic desperation; each act, justifiable on its face, contributes to the miscarriage incident whose causation remains disputed, underscoring how individual agency within constrained circumstances generates unintended harm without absolving responsibility.^[56] Farhadi structures these dilemmas to reveal layers of moral complexity, where self-preservation—evident in Nader's denial of knowing Razieh's pregnancy and her subsequent omissions—erodes relational trust, demonstrating causally that deceptions, even defensively motivated, amplify conflicts rather than mitigate them.^[56] The film's portrayal counters deterministic views by emphasizing how personal choices, not inexorable external forces, dictate trajectories; Hodjat's escalatory aggression during confrontations, for instance, stems from his interpretation of honor and poverty, yet his refusal to de-escalate—choosing threats over restraint—exacerbates legal entanglements for all involved, illustrating that agency persists amid socioeconomic pressures, with outcomes hinging on exercised judgment.^[15] Simin and Nader's initial separation petition, rooted in divergent priorities for their daughter's future, sets the chain of events, yet their persistent omissions—such as Nader's uncommunicated hardships—prolong familial fracture, affirming that rational self-interest, unchecked by transparency, yields relational dissolution irrespective of broader contextual excuses.^[31] Termeh's culminating indecision encapsulates the inheritance of moral agency: confronted with her parents' irreconcilable narratives and the weight of potential perjury to sway custody, the 11-year-old grapples silently, her withheld choice symbolizing the transmission of unresolved ethical burdens across generations.^[56] This open resolution highlights individual accountability, as Termeh must navigate truth amid loyalty conflicts without systemic palliatives, reinforcing that personal volition, even under duress, bears the causal freight of consequences over attributions of victimhood.^[15] Farhadi's intent, as articulated, is to provoke viewer deliberation on such impasses, where no character's arc resolves neatly, affirming ethical realism over reductive blame.^[57]

Release

Premiere and Distribution

A Separation had its world premiere in the main competition section of the 61st Berlin International Film Festival on February 17, 2011, where it competed alongside 20 other films.^[58] The film won the Golden Bear for Best Film on February 19, 2011, marking the first time an Iranian production received the festival's top prize.^[59] In Iran, the film faced initial scrutiny from the Ministry of Culture and Islamic Guidance, which had banned Farhadi from production in September 2010 over a prior speech, but permissions were ultimately granted following revisions. Domestic release occurred on March 16, 2011, through distributor Filmiran.^[60] Internationally, distribution rights were acquired by Sony Pictures Classics for North America, with a limited U.S. theatrical rollout beginning December 30, 2011, in select markets to align with Academy Awards eligibility.^[60] Other territories included Memento Films for France and Artificial Eye for the United Kingdom, facilitating screenings across Europe and beyond starting in early 2011 post-Berlin.^[60]

Box Office Performance

A Separation was produced on a budget of approximately $800,000.^[12] The film grossed $22,926,076 worldwide, yielding a return exceeding 28 times its production costs, which marked an exceptional outcome for an Iranian production with limited marketing resources.^[61] In Iran, where cinema operates under strict censorship by the Ministry of Culture and Islamic Guidance, the film achieved record-breaking domestic earnings upon its March 2011 release, reflecting widespread public engagement despite regulatory hurdles that typically constrain distribution and screening durations.^[62] Internationally, it earned $15,827,021, with significant contributions from European markets following its Berlin Film Festival premiere.^[61] In the United States, A Separation generated $7,099,055 after a limited December 2011 release, primarily through arthouse theaters rather than wide commercial circuits, a figure that positioned it among the higher-grossing foreign-language films of its release year in that market.^[61] This performance underscored the film's appeal to niche audiences interested in dramatic narratives from non-Western contexts, without reliance on blockbuster promotion.^[63] Relative to Iranian cinema standards, where most films recoup domestically through modest ticket sales and face barriers to global export, A Separation's totals represented a benchmark for profitability and reach.^[64]

Reception and Interpretation

Critical Reviews

A Separation received widespread critical acclaim upon its release, earning a 99% approval rating on Rotten Tomatoes based on 177 reviews, with an average score of 8.90/10.^[65] Critics praised the film's tight scripting and nuanced performances, particularly from leads Leila Hatami and Peyman Moadi, which convey the emotional weight of familial and ethical dilemmas with restraint and authenticity.^[33] Roger Ebert awarded it four out of four stars, highlighting its suspenseful structure and ability to immerse viewers in the characters' moral quandaries without overt didacticism.^[37] The film's exploration of moral complexity drew comparisons to classical tragedy, with reviewers noting how ordinary decisions spiral into irreversible conflicts, underscoring human fallibility and the clash of personal principles.^[66] The New York Times described it as a "rigorously honest movie about the difficulties of being honest," emphasizing director Asghar Farhadi's skill in depicting the slipperiness of truth through layered interpersonal dynamics.^[38] This focus on ambiguity—where no character emerges as wholly right or wrong—earned commendations for elevating the narrative beyond melodrama into profound ethical inquiry.^[67] In retrospective polls, A Separation ranked highly among 21st-century cinema, placing tenth in BBC Culture's 2016 survey of the greatest films since 2000, as selected by 177 international critics.^[68] It also secured the 72nd position (tied) in Sight & Sound's 2022 directors' poll of all-time greatest films, reflecting sustained admiration for its craftsmanship and thematic depth among filmmakers.^[69] Some critiques pointed to perceived coyness in key plot revelations, arguing that Farhadi occasionally withholds information to heighten tension, which could border on manipulation rather than organic revelation.^[2] Others noted an underemphasis on broader structural inequalities, such as class barriers, suggesting the film's domestic focus sometimes glosses over systemic pressures shaping the characters' choices.^[70] Despite these reservations, such analyses remained outliers amid the consensus on the film's technical precision and emotional resonance.^[71]

Iranian Domestic Response

The film A Separation encountered initial resistance from Iranian authorities, with production briefly halted in September 2010 by the Ministry of Culture and Islamic Guidance due to Farhadi's public support for detained filmmakers like Jafar Panahi, though it received approval for domestic release on March 17, 2011, following assurances that it did not undermine national values.^[72]^[3] Upon release, it garnered significant attendance in theaters, reflecting its resonance with Iranian audiences amid everyday social tensions, though exact domestic box office figures remain unreported in available data.^[73] Domestic reactions were mixed, with praise from reformist and cultural circles for authentically portraying middle-class family struggles, religious piety, and class divides without exoticizing Iran, thereby humanizing ordinary citizens in contrast to state-sanctioned narratives of uniformity.^[74] Conservative critics, however, condemned the depiction of divorce proceedings and the protagonist Simin's aspiration to emigrate as glamorizing familial breakdown and disloyalty to the homeland, arguing it amplified negative stereotypes of Iranian society under Islamic law.^[75] These debates often unfolded in semi-underground forums and intellectual discussions, highlighting frictions over exposing socioeconomic disparities like those between the educated urban middle class and devout working-class caregivers.^[76] Following its February 26, 2012, Academy Award win for Best Foreign Language Film—the first for Iran—state media outlets like Fars News Agency framed the success as a cultural victory over the "Zionist regime," airing Farhadi's acceptance speech on television despite initial reluctance to broadcast the Oscars live.^[77]^[74] This endorsement contrasted with private hardliner reservations about the film's mild critique of emigration desires, yet public celebrations erupted nationwide, with many viewing it via satellite dishes and online platforms, underscoring its role in soft power projection while sparking ongoing scrutiny of its portrayal of sharia-influenced moral ambiguities.^[73]^[73]

Western Acclaim and Political Readings

A Separation received widespread acclaim in Western markets following its international premiere, culminating in the Academy Award for Best Foreign Language Film on February 26, 2012, marking the first such win for an Iranian production.^[78] Critics and audiences praised its nuanced portrayal of familial and ethical conflicts, often highlighting its universal appeal amid Iran's restrictive cinematic environment, though the film itself eschews explicit political advocacy in favor of individual moral quandaries.^[79] This recognition was interpreted by some as a subtle victory against censorship, yet director Asghar Farhadi emphasized in post-win statements that the narrative probes personal integrity rather than systemic indictment.^[75] Western political readings frequently overlaid the story with interpretations of Iranian societal constraints, portraying the protagonists' tensions—such as the wife's push for emigration—as allegories for broader oppression under theocratic rule.^[78] Left-leaning outlets and commentators, including discussions in The Atlantic, framed elements like the female characters' dilemmas as emblematic of gender inequities and religious piety's stifling effects, aligning with preconceived narratives of women's subjugation in Islamist contexts.^[80] However, such views overlook the film's depiction of religious devotion—exemplified by the caregiver Razieh's faith-driven actions—as a source of ethical resilience and social cohesion amid class divides and modern disruptions, rather than mere repression; empirical analysis of the plot reveals piety constraining impulsive secular individualism, not dictating oppression.^[6] Causally, the film's Oscar success enhanced Iran's soft power projection, humanizing its cultural output and drawing global empathy to everyday ethical struggles, contrary to subversive intent ascribed by regime critics or Western orientalist lenses.^[81] Iranian hardliners decried the acclaim as Western propaganda amplifying anti-regime undertones, yet box office data from Europe and North America—grossing over $20 million internationally—demonstrated audience engagement with the film's apolitical humanism, boosting diplomatic perceptions without endorsing regime change.^[30] Mainstream media's emphasis on oppression narratives reflects institutional biases favoring secular-liberal frameworks, undervaluing the stabilizing causal role of traditional piety in navigating familial and socioeconomic pressures evident in the story.^[82]

Controversies and Criticisms

Production of A Separation faced temporary censorship in Iran in 2010, when authorities revoked Farhadi's filming permit following his public remarks supporting detained filmmakers like Jafar Panahi and hoping they could attend the Fajr International Film Festival, which was interpreted as political dissent.^[15]^[17] The ban was lifted shortly after Farhadi clarified his comments and expressed regret for any misperception, allowing completion and domestic release on March 17, 2011.^[72] This incident highlighted tensions between Iranian artists and state oversight, with Farhadi's film ultimately screened without government funding but under scrutiny for its portrayal of societal frictions.^[3] In Iran, conservative critics argued that the film undermines traditional family structures by depicting divorce as a viable response to personal and ethical conflicts, potentially normalizing marital dissolution in a society where Islamic law prioritizes reconciliation and family unity.^[83] Some religious authorities and commentators viewed its sympathetic treatment of the protagonists' separation—amid caregiving duties and class tensions—as promoting secular individualism over communal piety, with the narrative's ambiguity on moral culpability seen as eroding clear ethical boundaries rooted in sharia principles.^[84] These critiques often framed the story's class dynamics, pitting educated urbanites against devout rural migrants, as subtly fomenting division rather than resolving it through traditional values, though such readings were not universally held among Iranian viewers.^[76] Western interpretations have been accused by some analysts of overlooking these class warfare undertones, instead universalizing the film as a neutral study of human ambiguity while downplaying its embedded critique of Iran's legal and religious constraints on personal agency.^[6] Farhadi maintained that the work exposes hypocrisies across ideological lines—secular rationalism versus religious absolutism—without relativizing truth, grounding conflicts in observable causal realities like economic pressures and institutional inflexibility rather than abstract moral equivalence.^[85] Later plagiarism allegations against Farhadi, raised in 2022 by former student Azadeh Masihzadeh over his 2021 film A Hero (initially ruled against him but appealed and ultimately cleared in 2024), have retrospectively questioned his creative originality, casting indirect scrutiny on the authenticity of scenarios in A Separation derived from real-life inspirations.^[86]^[87] These claims, while unresolved in public perception for some, underscore ongoing debates about attribution in Iranian cinema amid tight creative controls.^[88]

Awards and Recognition

Academy Awards and International Honors

A Separation premiered at the 61st Berlin International Film Festival on February 18, 2011, where it won the Golden Bear for Best Film, the festival's highest honor, along with Silver Bear awards for Best Actor (Peyman Maadi) and Best Actress (Leila Hatami).^[89]^[90] These achievements marked a breakthrough for Iranian cinema on the European festival circuit, achieved through a modest independent production rather than state-sponsored efforts.^[89] In January 2012, the film secured the Golden Globe Award for Best Motion Picture – Non-English Language at the 69th ceremony, presented by the Hollywood Foreign Press Association.^[91] This victory preceded its crowning accomplishment at the 84th Academy Awards on February 26, 2012, when it won Best Foreign Language Film—the first Iranian production to receive an Oscar in any category.^[5] Director Asghar Farhadi accepted the award in person, dedicating it to the Iranian people amid geopolitical tensions.^[92] Further accolades included the César Award for Best Foreign Film at the 37th ceremony on February 24, 2012, affirming its appeal in France.^[93] The film was nominated for Best Film Not in the English Language at the 65th British Academy Film Awards but did not win.^[94] These honors collectively boosted the film's profile, demonstrating the viability of nuanced, non-propagandistic Iranian storytelling on the world stage.^[5]^[91]

Impact on Iranian Cinema

A Separation exemplified how Iranian filmmakers could leverage narrative ambiguity to critique social and familial tensions under censorship, initially facing a production ban in 2011 for director Asghar Farhadi's advocacy for imprisoned colleagues before gaining approval and domestic release. This success validated subtle, ethics-driven storytelling that evades explicit political content, enabling portrayals of class divides, gender roles, and moral dilemmas without violating regulatory taboos on direct institutional criticism.^[17] The film established a paradigm for post-2009 apartment dramas, a subgenre using confined urban settings to explore interpersonal conflicts as proxies for broader societal strains, including those amplified by the Green Movement's aftermath. Subsequent works adopted this model, prioritizing restrained examinations of everyday ethical quandaries over sensationalism, thereby advancing a domestic tradition of introspective social realism that sustains artistic output amid oversight.^[95] Its 2012 Academy Award win as Iran's first, announced on February 26, sparked national celebration and reinforced the commercial viability of such restrained dramas locally, though the process underscored censorship's trade-offs: fostering ingenuity in implication while limiting overt realism. This duality propelled a cautious evolution in Iranian filmmaking, where success hinged on inferential depth rather than confrontation, influencing a cohort of directors to emulate Farhadi's balance of universality and cultural specificity.^[73]

Legacy

The film A Separation prompted international discourse on the intricacies of Iranian familial structures, portraying tensions between parental obligations, spousal conflicts, and intergenerational care within a middle-class Tehran household. By depicting a husband's refusal to abandon his Alzheimer's-afflicted father for emigration, alongside disputes over child custody and caregiving ethics, it highlighted empirical realities of duty-bound family roles amid socioeconomic pressures, challenging Western preconceptions of monolithic Iranian society as solely oppressive or uniform.^[96]^[97] This realism drew from observable class divides, where urban professionals grapple with traditional expectations versus modern aspirations, fostering viewer empathy through unadorned portrayals of moral ambiguity rather than didactic narratives.^[76] Among Iranian diaspora communities and domestic audiences, the narrative resonated with debates over emigration's trade-offs, illustrating how leaving one's homeland severs ties to aging parents and cultural roots, often at the expense of personal advancement. Director Asghar Farhadi noted the film's reflection of Iranians' "conflicted love" for their country, where economic and political stagnation prompts departure desires yet underscores emotional and ethical costs, as seen in the protagonist's dilemma.^[98]^[99] This portrayal influenced perceptions by emphasizing causal links between familial piety and societal stability, with surveys of expatriates citing the story's authenticity in evoking regrets over disrupted kin networks.^[97] The film's enduring cultural footprint is evidenced by its high placement in global polls, such as BBC Culture's 2016 ranking of 21st-century films where it secured second place among critics, a status reaffirmed in 2025 assessments ranking it above titles like Amélie and Inception.^[100]^[101] In non-Western contexts, it implicitly bolsters conservative emphases on collective duty—evident in the son's unwavering care for his dependent father despite personal hardship—over unchecked individualism, aligning with data on lower divorce persistence in duty-oriented societies where family cohesion prioritizes endurance over dissolution.^[97] Such elements prompted reflections on how religious and cultural norms shape realistic choices, without idealizing or condemning them.^[96]

Influence on Asghar Farhadi's Career

A Separation (2011) represented a career-defining breakthrough for Asghar Farhadi, solidifying his approach to narratives centered on intricate moral dilemmas within familial and social conflicts, a stylistic hallmark evident in his subsequent films such as The Salesman (2016), which earned him a second Academy Award for Best International Feature Film in 2017.^[102]^[103] The film's critical and commercial success, including Iran's first Oscar win in 2012, elevated Farhadi's global profile, enabling him to explore thematic evolutions while preserving authenticity rooted in Iranian cultural nuances, as seen in his continued emphasis on ethical ambiguities without overt resolution.^[7]^[104] This international recognition facilitated expanded collaborations, including the French-set The Past (2013), co-written with Iranian sensibilities, and later projects like Everybody Knows (2018), which incorporated Western actors while maintaining Farhadi's focus on relational betrayals and societal pressures.^[105]^[106] Yet, the heightened visibility from A Separation also amplified professional challenges, including plagiarism allegations leveled against Farhadi for A Hero (2021) by former student Azadeh Masihzadeh, who claimed similarities to her 2018 documentary short; Farhadi denied the charges, asserting independent development, and was fully cleared by an Iranian court in March 2024.^[107]^[108]^[7] Post-A Separation prominence intensified scrutiny amid Iran's 2022 protests following Mahsa Amini's death, with Farhadi publicly calling for global solidarity with demonstrators in September 2022, navigating regime pressures that contributed to his departure from Iran in 2024 and a refusal to film domestically under enforced hijab rules.^[109]^[110]^[111] These events underscored the dual-edged impact of his elevated status, fostering artistic independence abroad while exposing him to domestic exile-like constraints.^[112]^[113]

References

[1]
A Separation (2011) - IMDb
Rating 8.3/10 (273,507) A married couple are faced with a difficult decision - to improve the life of their child by moving to another country or to stay in Iran.Full cast & crew · Plot · User reviews · Asghar Farhadi
[2]
A SEPARATION: The Unspoken Subject in Iranian (and American ...
Sep 5, 2023 · Why was it named the best foreign language film of 2011 by the Golden Globes, the National Board of Review, and the New York Critics Circle, and ...
[3]
A Separation as a Tool of Iranian Cultural Diplomacy
Indeed, A Separation was made without government financial backing, and production was for a time banned due to Farhadi's outspoken support for other filmmakers ...
[4]
A Separation (2011) | MUBI
Asghar Farhadi won the top prize in Berlin—and earned an Oscar® nomination—for this deeply involving marital drama. In its refusal to apportion blame for the ...Missing: plot | Show results with:plot<|separator|>
[5]
Iran wins first Oscar with "A Separation" - Reuters
Feb 26, 2012 · "A Separation" won the Oscar for best foreign language film on Sunday, becoming the first Iranian movie to win the honor.
[6]
Burning Questions: What's Controversial About "A Separation"? - Blog
Mar 13, 2012 · A Separation is blatant about the desire of many Iranians to leave the country, and looks unflinchingly at gender and class inequality.
[7]
Did the Oscar-Winning Director Asghar Farhadi Steal Ideas?
Oct 31, 2022 · Farhadi has described writing a script as “finding a suit for a button.” The starting point is often a single image. “A Separation” began with ...
[8]
Interview: Asghar Farhadi on Bringing Audiences Into "A Separation"
Dec 28, 2011 · The writer/director of what we consider to be the year's finest film discusses the single image that inspired it, when audiences became a part of his creative ...Missing: development | Show results with:development
[9]
A Masterclass with A Separation's Asghar Farhadi
May 27, 2014 · The Iranian auteur conducted a lengthy and lively masterclass, talking about his writing process, why a script is like a clothes hanger and how he approaches ...
[10]
A Separation (2011) - Full cast & crew - IMDb
Cast · Leila Hatami and Sareh Bayat in A Separation (2011). Leila Hatami · Payman Maadi at an event for Tales (2014). Payman Maadi · Shahab Hosseini · Sareh Bayat.
[11]
Asghar Farhadi, A Separation - Filmmaker Magazine
Dec 28, 2011 · A tense, character-driven drama about three well-to-do Persian families whose holiday in a Caspian Sea coastal town turns disastrous.Missing: process inspiration
[12]
The Making of Iran's Oscar Hopeful, 'A Separation'
Dec 31, 2011 · 30 release of Asghar Farhadi's A Separation, the gripping courtroom drama of a divorce and attempted murder case that doubles as a ...
[13]
A Separation (2011) summary & plot - Spoiler Town
Sep 20, 2025 · Nader and Simin's crumbling marriage sparks a tense custody battle, revealing deep truths in this gripping Iranian drama.Detailed Summary · Film Music and Composer · Book Adaptations and...
[14]
Iranian Cinema: Acclaimed Abroad, Under Siege at Home - HuffPost
Feb 29, 2012 · The Ministry of Culture, a government entity, must approve scripts before films can be made in Iran, a long process that is often used to ...
[15]
A Separation's Asghar Farhadi: 'We need the audience to think'
Jul 15, 2011 · The director of award-winning Iranian drama A Separation talks about his film-making choices and living in Iran
[16]
'A Separation' that almost didn't happen - Times of India
Mar 4, 2012 · The culture ministry accused Farhadi of advocating on behalf of the 'counter-revolutionary' Makhmalbaf and the ban was not lifted until Farhadi ...
[17]
Secrets, Lies, and Censorship - Boston Review
Aug 14, 2024 · ... Iran became increasingly charged. His next film, A Separation (2011), was initially banned after Farhadi told an interviewer that he hoped ...<|separator|>
[18]
Iran Lifts Ban on Director, Saying He Issued an Apology
Oct 3, 2010 · During the speech, Mr. Farhadi called for the return of the filmmaker Mohsen Makhmalbaf to Iran. He is in a self-imposed exile and has been one ...
[19]
How Iranian filmmakers work under strict censorship rules and a ...
Nov 24, 2023 · For decades Iran's artistic community have carefully navigated the country's strict censorship rules that ban certain portrayals of women and Islam.
[20]
Leila Hatami - Biography - IMDb
Award-winning actress, Leila Hatami, was born on October 1, 1972 in Tehran, Iran, to legendary Iranian Director, Ali Hatami, and actress mother, Zari Khoshkam ...
[21]
Leila HATAMI - Festival de Cannes
Born in Tehran, Leila Hatrami grew up in a cinematic family, her mother, Zari Khoshkam, was a movie star before the revolution and her father, Ali Hatami is ...
[22]
[PDF] A Separation | Sony Pictures Classics
Set in contemporary Iran, A Separation is a compelling drama about the dissolution of a marriage. Simin wants to leave Iran with her husband Nader and ...<|separator|>
[23]
Sareh Bayat - IMDb
She majored in Theater at university and received a Diploma of Honor for Best Actress from Tehran's Police Theatre Festival in 2006. She furthered her acting ...
[24]
Shahab Hosseini: The Rising Star Of Iranian Cinema- - Smart Picks
Rating 8.1/10 (145) 6 days ago · Shahab Hosseini's early education was marked by a deep interest in literature and theater. He studied acting at the University of Tehran ...Missing: roots | Show results with:roots
[25]
Payman Maadi - IMDb
Payman Maadi. Actor: A Separation. Peyman Maadi was born in 1972 in New York City to an Iranian couple. His father was a lawyer.Viper of Tehran · Leila's Brothers · Biography · Contact InfoMissing: background | Show results with:background<|separator|>
[26]
Interview with Leila Hatami, star of A Separation - Expats.cz
Jan 11, 2012 · Asghar Farhadi often talks about the importance of rehearsing before the shooting is started and you to be able to improvise during the shooting ...
[27]
Iran's Best Foreign Film Nominee: Asghar Farhadi's A Separation
Dec 22, 2012 · Farhadi's desire for thorough rehearsals is partly the result of his background as a playwright. He graduated Tehran University and got his ...
[28]
A Separation - International Cinephile Society
Sep 20, 2011 · Having a full-time job, Nader hires a young woman, Razieh, to take care of his father. The deeply religious Razieh has taken the job for ...
[29]
No Way Out: Asghar Farhadi on A Separation - Tribeca Film Festival
Dec 25, 2011 · In a recent interview, however, Farhadi was quick to dismantle assumptions: his is a story with universal themes—caring for aging parents ...
[30]
Backlash as Iran hardliners label Oscar favourite a 'dirty picture'
Feb 4, 2012 · A Separation, Farhadi's fifth major film, follows the story of two Iranian families – one secular and middle-class, the other religious and ...
[31]
Separation, A: Interview with Iranian Director Asghar Farhadi
Nov 30, 2011 · The film's first question is whether an Iranian child has a better future in his or her own country or abroad. There is no set answer.Missing: 2009 | Show results with:2009
[32]
A Separation (2011) - Plot - IMDb
Nader and Simin, a middle class Iranian couple with an eleven year old daughter named Termeh, are on the verge of divorce. They love each other.
[33]
A Separation – review - The Guardian
Jun 30, 2011 · The film shows a middle-class household under siege from an angry outsider; there are semi-unsolved mysteries, angry confrontations and family ...
[34]
Movie Review - 'A Separation' - In Tehran, Houses And Hearts Divided
Dec 29, 2011 · A Separation is a beautifully crafted, fascinating film, both as a portrait of modern Iranian society and as a drama involving intensely controlling men.
[35]
Never So Free - Boston Review
Asghar Farhadi's A Separation portrays an Iranian divorce under sharia law with sensitivity and pathos. Alan A. Stone · Children and Family ...
[36]
The Genius of “A Separation” - The Diplomat
Jan 27, 2012 · They have an 11-year-old daughter Termeh (played by the director's daughter) who doesn't want her parents to leave each other, and so chooses to ...
[37]
No rules can account for human feelings movie review (2012)
Rating 4/4 · Review by Roger EbertJan 25, 2012 · Nader and Simin (Peyman Moadi and Leila Hatami), a happily married middle-class couple in Tehran, have a sweet 11-year-old daughter, Termeh ...Missing: non- | Show results with:non-
[38]
'A Separation,' Directed by Asghar Farhadi - Review
Dec 29, 2011 · A tightly structured, emotionally astute new film from Iran, begins with a couple, at odds and in distress, arguing in front of a judge.Missing: casting process<|separator|>
[39]
(PDF) Middle-Class Squeeze The Process of emerging New Urban ...
Mar 1, 2023 · This study probes the middle-class squeeze and the emergence of new urban poor in Tehran after Iran's economic crisis.
[40]
Gini index - Iran, Islamic Rep. - World Bank Open Data
Gini index - Iran, Islamic Rep. · Poverty headcount ratio at national poverty lines (% of population) · Poverty gap at $4.20 a day (2021 PPP) (%) · Poverty ...
[41]
Iran IR: Gini Coefficient (GINI Index): World Bank Estimate - CEIC
Iran IR: Gini Coefficient (GINI Index): World Bank Estimate data is updated yearly, averaging 43.600 % from Dec 1986 (Median) to 2014, with 9 observations.
[42]
Fiscal Policy, Inequality and Poverty in Iran: Assessing the Impact ...
Using the Iranian Household Expenditure and Income Survey (HEIS) for 2011 ... Gini coefficient by 0.0644 points and the headcount ratio by 61 percent.
[43]
Full article: Spatial inequality in Tehran, a structural explanation
Dec 19, 2019 · This study investigates economic structures behind spatial inequality in Tehran focusing on four sectors of social reproduction.Part I. Spatial Inequality... · Part Ii. Explanations · Explaining Spatial...<|separator|>
[44]
(PDF) Tehran: Old and Emerging Spatial Divides - ResearchGate
One of the most visible characteristics of Tehran is its North-South spatial inequality and polarisation created by modernisation and its elements such as cars ...
[45]
Family, duty and dilemma - The Kathmandu Post
Dec 19, 2023 · 'A Separation' subtly delves into social issues and gender dynamics prevalent in Iranian society. The challenges Simin faces as she seeks ...Missing: analysis | Show results with:analysis
[46]
'Prescriptive' Masculinity?: Deception and Restraint in the Films of ...
Referring to A Separation, Ali Akbar Raefipoor, for instance, calls it a film that privileges a feminist viewpoint which depicts and decries “absolute ...Missing: obligations analysis
[47]
Representation of women in Asghar Farhadi Films - Reflections
Nov 6, 2019 · Abstract. This is a study of how women are represented in three Asghar Farhadi films: A Separation, About Elly and The Salesman.
[48]
[PDF] Color, Class, And Gender: The Social Construction of Women and ...
Jan 18, 2023 · A Separation (2011) and The Salesman (2016) are other well-known films of. Asghar Farhadi. A Separation is the story of Nader and Simin, a ...<|separator|>
[49]
The impact of family structure on the health of children: Effects ... - NIH
The majority of divorces affect younger children since 72 percent of divorces occur during the first 14 years of marriage. Because a high percentage of divorced ...
[50]
Parental divorce is not uniformly disruptive to children's educational ...
Mar 26, 2019 · We find that parental divorce lowers the educational attainment of children who have a low likelihood of their parents' divorcing.
[51]
[PDF] Parental Divorce and Children's Adjustment
To summarize, research suggests that children whose parents have divorced have higher levels of externalizing behaviors and internalizing problems, lower ...
[52]
Movie Review: The Separation of Nader va Simin (Iran)
Mar 7, 2012 · ... A Separation (Jodaeiye Nader az Simin). The film, which talks about ... divorce and moved into her parents' home. It also showed a more ...Missing: duty | Show results with:duty
[53]
Blood Money: Crime and Punishment in “A Separation”
Feb 24, 2012 · The Iranian film “A Separation,” written and directed by Asghar Farhadi, has been nominated for two Oscars: Best Foreign Language Film and ...
[54]
The Impact of Religion on Realistic Choices: A Separation
Jul 9, 2020 · In Iran, laws are based on religious precepts, both of them supplement each other, they established the standards of right and wrong of Iran.Missing: piety | Show results with:piety
[55]
(PDF) The Impact of Religion on Realistic Choices: A Separation
"Gender, Nation, and Belonging: Representing Mothers and the Maternal in Asghar. Farhadi's A Separation." Atlantis: Critical Studies in. Gender, Culture ...Missing: Sharia | Show results with:Sharia
[56]
[PDF] Relative Truth and Morality in Asghar Farhadi's Films
Apr 12, 2019 · For instance, Joseph Burke maintains that, in A Separation, Farhadi proposes different layers of moral complexity to emphasize the difficulty of ...<|separator|>
[57]
'A Separation' Helmer Asghar Farhadi Talks Screenwriting ... - Variety
Nov 15, 2022 · Iranian director Asghar Farhadi talks and fielded questions on screenwriting at an Atlas Workshops panel.Missing: inspiration | Show results with:inspiration
[58]
Nader And Simin, A Separation - | Berlinale |
Jodaeiye Nader az Simin | Nader And Simin, A Separation · Competition · Golden Bear · Feb 19, 2011. Film team. Not yet they knew of the prizes they would win ...
[59]
Berlin's Golden Bear goes to Farhadi's A Separation - Screen Daily
Feb 19, 2011 · The Golden Bear goes for the first time in the Berlinale's history to Iran with the International Jury's choice of Asghar Farhadi's family drama ...
[60]
A Separation - Wikipedia
A Separation is a 2011 Iranian drama film written and directed by Asghar Farhadi, starring Leila Hatami, Peyman Moaadi, Shahab Hosseini, Sareh Bayat, ...Missing: cases | Show results with:cases
[61]
Company credits - A Separation (2011) - IMDb
Distributors · Filmiran. (Iran, 2011)(theatrical) · Sony Pictures Classics. (United States, 2011)(subtitled, theatrical) · Memento Films. (France, 2011)(theatrical).
[62]
A Separation (2011) - Box Office Mojo
All Releases ; Domestic DistributorSony Pictures Classics See full company information ; Domestic Opening$59,481 ; Earliest Release DateJune 8, 2011 (EMEA) ; MPAAPG ...
[63]
Asghar Farhadi's 'Separation' to Open Dec. 30 - The New York Times
Dec 21, 2011 · “A Separation,” which opens on Dec. 30, begins as a domestic drama, with a middle-class couple in Tehran unable to resolve their disagreement over where and ...Missing: cases | Show results with:cases
[64]
https://www.nytimes.com/2019/01/31/magazine/asghar-farhadis-iran-film.html
[65]
How Iran's Greatest Director Makes Art of Moral Ambiguity
Jan 31, 2019 · When “A Separation” opened in Iran in the spring of 2011, it electrified the public. People lined up overnight to see the premiere at the Fajr ...
[66]
A Separation (2011) | Rotten Tomatoes
Rating 99% (177) Cast & Crew ; Asghar Farhadi thumbnail image. Asghar Farhadi. Director ; Peyman Moaadi thumbnail image. Peyman Moaadi. Nader ; Leila Hatami thumbnail image. Leila ...
[67]
A Separation: Film Review - The Hollywood Reporter
Feb 15, 2011 · As in all the director's work, the cast is given top consideration and their realistic acting results in unusual depth of characterization. All ...
[68]
A Separation (2011) - Deep Focus Review
Rating 4/4 · Review by Brian EggertMar 21, 2020 · Asghar Farhadi's A Separation could be mistaken as a drama about conditions specific to Iran that inhibit and prescribe.
[69]
Asghar Farhadi's 'A Separation' Among 21st Century's Top 10
The BBC Culture's recent poll of film critics around the world puts 'A Separation', the Oscar-winning Iranian film by Asghar Farhadi, among the top 10 films ...
[70]
Directors' 100 Greatest Films of All Time | BFI
A Separation. =72. 2011 Iran. Directed by Asghar Farhadi. Salò, or the 120 ... The film that topped Sight and Sound's inaugural Greatest Films of All Time poll ...
[71]
A Separation - Reviews - Reverse Shot
Jan 5, 2012 · The film is superbly written, but it's also smartly directed, insofar as there's a continuity between its writer-director's ideas and the visual ...
[72]
"A Separation" Review - The Independent Critic
Nader (Peyman Moaadi) is a man whose entire life seems to be disintegrating around him. His wife, Simin (Leila Hatami), wants to leave his native Iran and take ...
[73]
The butterfly effect in Asghar Farhadi's "A Separation" (2011). - Reddit
Jul 5, 2017 · "In September 2010, Farhadi was banned from making the film by the Iranian Ministry of Culture and Islamic Guidance, because of an acceptance ...Iranian filmmaker Asghar Farhadi will not produce any films in Iran ...A Separation: A discussion : r/TrueFilm - RedditMore results from www.reddit.comMissing: controversies | Show results with:controversies
[74]
Oscar success of A Separation celebrated back home in Iran
Feb 27, 2012 · A Separation has become the first movie ever to take an Academy Award to Iran after winning the best foreign language Oscar, prompting national celebration.
[75]
"A Separation" Buried Under the Dust of Politics - Jadaliyya
On Sunday, 26 February, Asghar Farhadi began his acceptance speech by greeting “the good people of my homeland” and saying: “Many Iranians all over the world ...Missing: Panahi | Show results with:Panahi
[76]
Hardliners Criticize Iranian Director and Oscar Winner Asghar Farhadi
Mar 13, 2017 · The film opened with Nader and Simin talking to a judge about their reasons for wanting to divorce. “I want a divorce so I can move from Iran ...
[77]
Visual Politics of Iranian Cinema: Social Class in Asghar Farhadi's 'A ...
Jan 8, 2019 · Farhadi depicts the deep divide or 'a separation' that exists between the modern middle class and conservative working class in Iran. The film ...
[78]
Iran Calls Oscar Win A Success Over Israel - NPR
Feb 27, 2012 · On Monday night, the Iranian film A Separation won the Oscar for Best Foreign Language Film. It marks the Islamic Republic's first Academy ...
[79]
Oscars 2012: 'A Separation' lauded as first Iranian Oscar film
Feb 27, 2012 · Though the film is a drama about a couple on the verge of splitting up, “A Separation” also resonated with audiences who saw it as an allegory ...
[80]
Israeli audiences flock to Iran's Oscar-winning A Separation
Feb 28, 2012 · A Separation draws large audiences in Israel as director Asghar Farhadi's Oscars acceptance speech airs on Iranian state TV.
[81]
Azar Nafisi and Robin Wright Discuss 'A Separation' - The Atlantic
Feb 21, 2012 · An Iranian-American author and a foreign correspondent on the lessons of Iran's Oscar-nominated family drama a separation followup child.
[82]
The Public Diplomacy Aspect of the Iranian Oscar Win
Mar 6, 2012 · The success of Farhadi's, A Separation, for example, is interpreted from similar perspectives by its friends and foes. Calling it a black ...
[83]
A Separation. Hollywood recognizes Iran's “glorious culture”
Feb 29, 2012 · A Separation, an intense family drama that has captivated audiences in Iran and around the world. Asghar Farhadi's film has the distinction of being the first ...
[84]
A Separation: Marriage and Divorce – Iranian Style - Critics At Large
Jan 20, 2012 · A Separation, Iran's submission for Academy Award recognition, will be competing against Israel's Oscar entry, Joseph Cedar's religiously themed Footnote.
[85]
https://www.theguardian.com/film/filmblog/2011/jul/05/a-separation-iranian-politics
[86]
A Separation can't be divorced from Iranian politics - The Guardian
Jul 5, 2011 · In Asghar Farhadi's film a middle-class family is being thrown into tumult. Nadar and Simin are evidently still in love, but they argue bitterly ...
[87]
Asghar Farhadi: Top Iranian director accused of plagiarism - BBC
Apr 5, 2022 · The Oscar-winning Iranian film-maker Asghar Farhadi has been summoned to appear in court in Iran over accusations of plagiarism.
[88]
Agent: Iranian Director Farhadi Cleared of Plagiarism - VOA
Mar 13, 2024 · Iranian director Asghar Farhadi has been cleared of charges of plagiarism over his film "A Hero" brought by one of his students.
[89]
Asghar Farhadi: New Plagiarism Accusations Emerge ... - IndieWire
Nov 3, 2022 · Published November 1: Asghar Farhadi is currently awaiting a final decision in the plagiarism lawsuit filed against him by his former student ...
[90]
Iran web abuzz at Oscar winning film - BBC News
Feb 27, 2012 · A Separation, made with a budget of just $500,000, had already won the Golden Bear for best film at the 2011 Berlin International Film Festival, ...
[91]
All the awards and nominations of A Separation - Filmaffinity
All the awards and nominations of A Separation · winner. Golden Bear - Best Picture · winner. Silver Bear - Best Actor (Peyman Maadi) · winner. Silver Bear - Best ...Missing: Oscar | Show results with:Oscar
[92]
A Separation - Golden Globes
A married couple are faced with a difficult decision – to improve the life of their child by moving to another country or to stay in Iran.Missing: 2011 Academy Bear César BAFTA
[93]
"A Separation" Wins Foreign Language Film: 2012 Oscars - YouTube
Mar 1, 2012 · Sandra Bullock presents director Asghar Farhadi with the Oscar for Foreign Language Film for Iran's A Separation at the 84th Academy Awards.
[94]
'The Artist' Wins 6 Cesar Awards, Including Best French Film of the ...
Feb 24, 2012 · Voters came together to award Asghar Farhadi's Iranian film A Separation the Cesar for best foreign film. It is nominated for best foreign ...
[95]
Nominations Announced for the Orange British Academy Film Award ...
Jan 16, 2012 · Incendies, Pina, Potiche, A Separation and The Skin I Live In are all nominated in the Film Not in the English Language category. The Short ...
[96]
Apartment Dramas in Iranian Cinema (2009-present)
The film A Separation held great significance during that period as it established a paradigm for Iranian filmmakers in depicting such challenges. It is ...
[97]
[PDF] The Impact of Religion on Realistic Choices: A Separation
A Separation is an Iranian film, depicting a real life that highlights lots of problems in religion, culture, values and law. It was awarded the Oscar in 2012 ...
[98]
[PDF] Manifestations and Implications of Social Values in Iranian Cinema
Aug 15, 2024 · Importantly, the social values depicted in "A Separation" serve as a lens through which the identity and cultural ethos of the Iranian society ...
[99]
'A Separation' probes Iranians' conflicted love for their country, says ...
Jan 20, 2012 · Using a failing marriage as a metaphor, the acclaimed film 'A Separation' juxtaposes Iranians' great love for their country with growing despair ...
[100]
Iran web abuzz at Oscar winning film - BBC News
Feb 27, 2012 · The story resonates with many young and educated Iranians, both at home and among the extensive Iranian diaspora. A Separation, made with a ...
[101]
The 21st Century's 100 greatest films - BBC
Aug 22, 2016 · The best that cinema has had to offer since 2000 as picked by 177 film critics from around the world.
[102]
Farhadi's “A Separation” ranked among best movies of 21st century
Jul 1, 2025 · It currently holds a 99 percent “fresh” rating on Rotten Tomatoes, based on 176 reviews with an average rating of 8.90/10. The website's ...
[103]
Asghar Farhadi's 'A Separation' Won Iran's First Oscar in 2012
Dec 11, 2021 · In 2012, Farhadi's A Separation earned the international prize, then called best foreign language film, before the category's name change in 2020.Missing: career influence
[104]
Oscar-winning Iranian director Asghar Farhadi - The Guardian
Jan 10, 2022 · He has already won two international feature Oscars – for A Separation in 2012 and The Salesman in 2017 – and many more awards besides (A Hero ...
[105]
Asghar Farhadi: A Master of Moral and Aesthetic Ambiguity
Starting with A Separation, Farhādī increasingly turned the camera into his voyeur character encountering the hidden actions, thoughts, and feelings of his cast ...
[106]
Asghar Farhadi on The Past, A Separation, and Crafting Earth ...
Dec 20, 2013 · In A Separation, the man wanted to keep his father, and keep his past, and stay in that house. In The Past, Ahmad also returns to his past and ...
[107]
'The Past' Director Asghar Farhadi on Finding Art in Life's Dilemmas
Dec 27, 2013 · The Oscar-winning filmmaker behind "A Separation" discusses his latest critically acclaimed feature.
[108]
A Separation director Asghar Farhadi cleared of plagiarism claims ...
Mar 13, 2024 · Iranian director Asghar Farhadi has been cleared of charges of plagiarism over his film A Hero brought by one of his students, the agency representing him said ...
[109]
Asghar Farhadi Cleared by Iranian Court of Plagiarism Allegations
Mar 13, 2024 · Two-time Oscar-winning director Asghar Farhadi has been fully cleared by an Iranian court of allegations of plagiarism pertaining to his film “A Hero”
[110]
Asghar Farhadi Urges Artists Around The World to Join Protests ...
Sep 25, 2022 · Two-time Oscar-winning Iranian director Asghar Farhadi (“A Separation”), who is currently presiding over the Zurich Film Festival jury, has ...Missing: cast influences
[111]
Asghar Farhadi Urges "Solidarity" With Protesters After Amini Death
Sep 25, 2022 · Iranian director Asghar Farhadi is imploring everyone worldwide to unite "in solidarity" with protesters following the death of Mahsa Amini.
[112]
The high price of dissident art in Iran: Silence or exile - Atlantic Council
Jun 10, 2024 · Oscar-winning filmmaker Farhadi's refusal to make a movie in Iran under mandatory hijab in cinema indicates this decisive shift. He revealed the ...
[113]
Golshifteh Farahani Talks Exile; Asghar Farhadi; Alpha, Extraction 3
Sep 9, 2025 · He denied suggestions that he was silent and since leaving Iran in 2024 has publicly voiced support for the protests on a number of occasions, ...
[114]
Asghar Farhadi's Rule: 'Always Focus on Ordinary People'
Feb 25, 2022 · Farhadi is pressured to take sides. He is mindful that navigating Iran's political landscape requires a balancing act. If he keeps silent, he is ...