Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Azolla event

The Azolla event was a major paleoclimatic episode during the early to middle Eocene epoch, around 49 million years ago (Ma), in which enormous quantities of the free-floating freshwater fern Azolla proliferated across the isolated Arctic Basin, leading to the formation of organic-rich, microlaminated sediments through its rapid growth, reproduction, and eventual burial.^[1] This event, spanning approximately 800,000 years from about 49.3 to 48.1 Ma, is hypothesized to have covered up to several million square kilometers of the Arctic Ocean's surface under a stratified freshwater layer, fostering ideal conditions for Azolla's symbiotic nitrogen-fixing capabilities and high biomass production.^[1]^[2] The proliferation of Azolla is attributed to a combination of factors, including the Arctic Ocean's semi-isolated state due to tectonic configurations, elevated atmospheric CO₂ levels (around 800–2,000 ppm) that enhanced fern growth, increased hydrological cycling from orbital forcing (such as obliquity and precession cycles), and nutrient influx from enhanced precipitation and riverine runoff during warmer Eocene summers.^[1]^[2] Evidence for the event comes primarily from sediment cores, such as those from the Integrated Ocean Drilling Program (IODP) Expedition 302 on the Lomonosov Ridge, which reveal thousands of Azolla-bearing laminae with high concentrations of fern megaspores, microspores, and biomarkers like ω-(o-alkyl) diols, alongside reduced marine microfossils indicating low salinity.^[1]^[3] A key aspect of the Azolla event's significance lies in its potential role in global climate regulation through carbon sequestration: the burial of Azolla biomass is estimated to have locked away 0.9–3.5 × 10¹⁸ grams (900–3,500 petagrams) of organic carbon, accounting for up to 40% of the total Eocene carbon drawdown and contributing to a decline in atmospheric CO₂ from over 1,500 ppm to around 900 ppm, which facilitated the planet's transition from a greenhouse to an icehouse state.^[1] However, more recent analyses of Arctic sediment records, including lower Azolla abundances in peripheral basins like the Beaufort-Mackenzie, propose that the bloom was more localized and terrestrially influenced rather than a basin-wide oceanic event, potentially limiting its overall climatic impact to a modest fraction of the observed CO₂ reduction.^[3] The event's termination around 48.1 Ma is linked to tectonic reopening of connections to the global ocean, increased marine influence, reduced freshwater input, and possible sea-level rise, which disrupted the stratified conditions necessary for Azolla's dominance.^[2]

Background

Definition and Timeline

The Azolla event refers to a hypothesized paleoclimatic phenomenon in the middle Eocene epoch, marked by extensive blooms of the free-floating, nitrogen-fixing aquatic fern Azolla that proliferated across the surface of the Arctic Ocean, leading to substantial burial of organic carbon in underlying sediments and a hypothesized drawdown of atmospheric CO₂.^[4] This event is inferred from microlaminated, organic-rich sediments recovered from the Lomonosov Ridge during Integrated Ocean Drilling Program Expedition 302, where Azolla remains dominate the palynological record, indicating sustained surface freshwater conditions conducive to its growth.^[4] The blooms are estimated to have covered up to several million square kilometers, forming dense mats that sank episodically, contributing to anoxic bottom waters and enhanced carbon preservation. Stratigraphic dating places the Azolla event at approximately 49 million years ago, spanning the interval from about 49.0 to 48.2 Ma in the late Ypresian to early Lutetian stages of the Eocene, with a total duration of roughly 800,000 years based on integrated biostratigraphy, magnetostratigraphy, and orbital tuning of sediment cores.^[4] The event's onset aligns with a phase of heightened hydrological cycling in the Arctic Basin, while its termination coincides with a modest sea surface temperature increase from around 10°C to 13°C, signaling renewed marine influence.^[4] Occurring roughly 7 million years after the Paleocene-Eocene Thermal Maximum (PETM) at ~56 Ma—a period of extreme global warming—the Azolla event is positioned within the broader Eocene climatic framework of declining atmospheric CO₂ and polar cooling.^[4] It marks an early phase in the long-term shift from a warm greenhouse world, characterized by ice-free poles and elevated tropical temperatures, toward the cooler icehouse conditions that culminated in Antarctic glaciation by the late Eocene.^[5] Quantitative estimates suggest the event sequestered 0.9–3.5 × 10¹⁸ grams of carbon, potentially reducing Eocene pCO₂ by 55–470 ppm and amplifying this climatic transition.^[1] The event unfolded in distinct phases: an initial bloom onset around 49 Ma driven by freshwater stratification, a peak proliferation phase with recurrent Azolla mat formation and sinking over hundreds of thousands of years, and a subsidence phase where accumulated biomass was preserved in stratified, low-oxygen sediments, locking away carbon on geological timescales.^[4]

The Genus Azolla

Azolla is a genus of small, floating aquatic ferns belonging to the family Salviniaceae, characterized by their delicate, branching fronds that typically measure 1–3 cm in length and form floating mats on freshwater surfaces. These ferns maintain a unique symbiotic relationship with the cyanobacterium Nostoc azollae, which resides within specialized leaf cavities called sporocarps and cavities, enabling efficient atmospheric nitrogen fixation. This symbiosis allows Azolla to thrive in nutrient-poor environments by converting dinitrogen gas into bioavailable forms, with fixation rates reaching up to 1.1 tonnes of nitrogen per hectare per year, far exceeding that of many leguminous plants at approximately 0.4 tonnes per hectare per year.^[6]^[7]^[8] The growth characteristics of Azolla are remarkable for their rapidity and adaptability, with biomass doubling every 3–10 days under optimal conditions, depending on temperature, light, and nutrient availability. This fast proliferation supports high biomass production, potentially sequestering up to 6 tonnes of carbon per acre per year through photosynthesis and growth in suitable aquatic settings. Azolla exhibits tolerance to low salinity levels (up to 2–3 ppt) and can flourish in phosphorus-limited or otherwise nutrient-deficient waters, owing to its nitrogen-fixing capability and efficient nutrient recycling within the symbiotic system. These traits make it resilient in fluctuating freshwater ecosystems, such as ponds, ditches, and slow-moving rivers.^[9]^[10]^[11] Evolutionarily, the genus Azolla has a fossil record extending back to the Late Cretaceous period, around 80 million years ago, with early representatives appearing in North American and Patagonian deposits. During the Eocene epoch, species such as A. prisca demonstrated adaptations to high-latitude, cooler conditions in the Arctic region, forming extensive blooms that highlight the genus's historical ecological versatility. Today, seven extant species persist worldwide, including A. filiculoides, A. pinnata, and A. caroliniana, serving as modern analogs for studying ancient populations due to their conserved symbiotic and growth mechanisms.^[12]^[13]^[14] A key ecological trait of Azolla is its ability to form dense surface mats that provide shading, effectively suppressing algal and weed growth by limiting light penetration to underlying waters. These mats can also induce anoxic conditions in the water column below through oxygen depletion from decomposition and reduced mixing, altering local aquatic habitats. Reproduction occurs primarily vegetatively through fragmentation, but sexually via the production of sporocarps containing megaspores and microspores, which facilitate dispersal and genetic diversity in stable populations.^[15]^[16]^[7]

Geological Evidence

Fossil Records

The primary paleontological evidence for the Azolla event comes from sediment cores drilled during Integrated Ocean Drilling Program (IODP) Expedition 302 on the Lomonosov Ridge in the central Arctic Ocean, where thick layers of sediment, up to 15 meters in thickness, are dominated by Azolla remains. These layers, spanning an interval of approximately 1.2 million years from about 49.3 to 48.1 Ma, contain abundant Azolla biomass fossils comprising over 90% of the preserved organic material in the cores. Similar Azolla-rich sediments have been identified in other Arctic and peri-Arctic sites, confirming the event's occurrence, though recent analyses suggest it may have been more localized with terrestrial influences rather than uniformly basin-wide.^[17]^[3] The fossils consist of well-preserved megaspores, microspores (in massulae), and vegetative fragments, attributable to multiple species including Azolla arctica, a taxon described from these high-latitude marine deposits, along with at least two others. These remains indicate in situ growth and reproduction of the fern in the surface waters, though intact floating mats are absent, likely due to partial decomposition before burial under low-oxygen conditions. The high abundance of these fossils, reaching up to 10^9 specimens per gram of sediment in peak intervals, underscores the scale of the blooms.^[18]^[4]^[17] Stratigraphically, the Azolla event is precisely bounded by paleomagnetic reversals within chron C22r and biostratigraphic markers, including the last occurrences of certain dinoflagellate cysts such as Achomosphaera alcicornu. This correlation places the event firmly in the basal middle Eocene.^[4]^[19] The spatial distribution of these fossil layers suggests that Azolla blooms covered up to approximately 4 million km² across the central Arctic basin, as evidenced by records from multiple drill sites including IODP Site M0004 on the Lomonosov Ridge and Ocean Drilling Program Site 913 in the Norwegian-Greenland Sea; however, lower abundances in peripheral basins like the Beaufort-Mackenzie indicate potential localization and fluvial transport. This extent reflects the semi-enclosed paleogeography of the Eocene Arctic Ocean, facilitating the fern's proliferation.^[17]^[20]^[3]

Geochemical Indicators

Geochemical evidence from sediment cores, particularly those recovered from the Lomonosov Ridge during the Integrated Ocean Drilling Program's Arctic Coring Expedition (ACEX), reveals distinct signatures of the Azolla event, highlighting the scale of the bloom and its role in carbon and nutrient cycling. These indicators include isotopic compositions of carbon and nitrogen in organic matter, elevated total organic carbon (TOC) contents, and specific lipid biomarkers derived from Azolla, all pointing to an episode of exceptional primary productivity under stratified, low-salinity surface waters in the Eocene Arctic Ocean.^[4] A prominent negative δ¹³C excursion in bulk organic matter, averaging around –27.7‰ during the Azolla phase, signifies massive photosynthetic fixation of ¹²C-enriched CO₂ by the fern, far exceeding typical background productivity levels. This isotopic shift, observed in cores spanning the event interval (~49–48 Ma), reflects the dominance of C3 photosynthesis in a high-pCO₂ environment, where reduced carbon isotope fractionation occurred due to abundant dissolved inorganic carbon. The resulting organic matter burial is estimated to have sequestered 0.9–3.5 × 10¹⁸ g of carbon, contributing to an inferred atmospheric CO₂ drawdown from ~1,500–2,000 ppm around the early-middle Eocene transition to ~650–1,000 ppm by the late middle Eocene, facilitating global cooling.^[1]^[21] Nitrogen isotope ratios (δ¹⁵N) in the sediments are characteristically low, ranging from –2.4‰ to –0.7‰, which is diagnostic of N₂ fixation by symbiotic cyanobacteria hosted within Azolla fronds. These values contrast with higher δ¹⁵N typically associated with nitrate assimilation or denitrification in marine settings, confirming that the bloom was sustained by diazotrophic nitrogen inputs in a nutrient-limited, freshwater-influenced surface layer. Fossilized heterocyst glycolipids (e.g., C₂₆ HG diols) further corroborate this symbiosis, linking the isotopic signal directly to cyanobacterial activity during the event.^[1] The Azolla layers exhibit TOC concentrations of 3–6 wt% (reaching up to 10% in some intervals), markedly higher than adjacent sediments, with organic matter dominated by Azolla-specific biomarkers such as C₃₀–C₃₆ 1,ω-20 diols, C₂₉ triols, and β-sitosterol. These compounds, comprising up to 4.5 µg/g sediment, indicate that Azolla contributed ~40% of the preserved TOC, underscoring rapid biomass production and minimal degradation under anoxic bottom waters.^[1] Natural gamma ray logs from ACEX cores display anomalous spikes in the Azolla interval, linked to elevated thorium/potassium (Th/K) ratios arising from clay mineral alterations and organic enrichment, providing a reliable stratigraphic marker for event correlation across Arctic sites. These geophysical anomalies, combined with the chemical proxies, enable precise chronostratigraphic placement of the bloom within the early middle Eocene.

Causes and Conditions

Paleogeographic Setting

During the early to middle Eocene, approximately 50 million years ago (Ma), the Arctic basin formed as a semi-enclosed epicontinental sea through ongoing tectonic rifting that isolated it from the global ocean. This configuration resulted from the separation of the Lomonosov Ridge from the Eurasian continental margin around 57 Ma, following the Paleocene-Eocene Thermal Maximum (PETM), combined with rifting in surrounding regions and subduction zones along the Pacific margins that influenced regional hydrology. The basin connected to the broader ocean primarily via shallow sills in the proto-Fram Strait to the North Atlantic and the proto-Bering Strait to the Pacific, with the Nordic Seas gateway only intermittently open due to incomplete seafloor spreading in the Norwegian-Greenland Sea until around 50 Ma. These restrictions limited deep-water exchange while allowing surface freshwater inputs from adjacent landmasses, including proto-Europe and Greenland, via riverine discharge.^[22]^[1] The Arctic basin spanned approximately 10 million km², extending as a broad, shallow feature with paleodepths ranging from 50 to 200 m, which promoted low circulation and stratification. This shallow epicontinental setting, bordered by continental fragments and highlands, facilitated the accumulation of organic-rich sediments during the Azolla event (49–48 Ma), as restricted gateways hindered oceanic inflow and enhanced the influence of terrestrial runoff. Paleogeographic reconstructions indicate the basin lay at latitudes of 70–80°N, where prolonged summer daylight—up to 24 hours—supported extended photosynthesis in surface waters.^[1]^[4]^[22]^[23] This tectonic isolation created conditions conducive to low-salinity surface waters, to which Azolla was well-adapted, enabling its proliferation across the basin. The post-PETM tectonic stability, marked by continued rifting without major volcanic disruptions in the immediate vicinity, maintained this semi-closed system for roughly 800,000 years, until increased connectivity via the gateways introduced saltier waters around 48 Ma.^[4]^[1]

Environmental Factors

The proliferation of Azolla in the Eocene Arctic Ocean was strongly influenced by hydrological conditions that established a stable, low-salinity surface environment conducive to its growth. Increased precipitation during the Eocene climatic optimum, driven by orbital forcing such as obliquity and precession cycles, drove high river discharge into the basin, supplying substantial freshwater that formed a thin, oligohaline to mesohaline surface layer (salinity ~1–6 psu) overlying denser, more saline marine waters below, thereby creating a pronounced halocline. This stratification, enhanced by Azolla's own mat formation which trapped rainwater and further stabilized the gradient, minimized vertical mixing and wave disturbance, allowing the fern to dominate the surface without being displaced.^[24]^[2] The paleogeographic isolation of the Arctic basin amplified these effects by limiting oceanic exchange and promoting the persistence of this freshwater cap. Nutrient dynamics played a pivotal role in sustaining Azolla's biomass accumulation under these stratified conditions. Phosphorus, the primary limiting nutrient for Azolla, was delivered via enhanced chemical weathering of surrounding landmasses—intensified by the warm, humid Eocene climate—and transported through riverine inputs, while initial upwelling from marginal shelves may have contributed before full stratification suppressed deeper nutrient flux.^[1] Nitrogen was abundantly fixed in situ by symbiotic cyanobacteria within Azolla, enabling self-sustaining growth without reliance on external sources, and the resulting eutrophic surface waters were further supported by the recycling of phosphorus within the micro-halocline layer, where it accumulated and remained bioavailable.^[1] These conditions prevailed amid Eocene warmth, with Arctic sea surface temperatures averaging around 10–14°C, fostering high primary productivity. Optimal light and temperature regimes further favored Azolla's phototrophic expansion. The high-latitude setting provided extended polar day illumination—up to 24 hours of continuous summer sunlight for several months—maximizing photosynthetic efficiency for the surface-floating fern.^[1] Coupled with the mild Eocene temperatures (mean annual ~13°C), which aligned with Azolla's thermal tolerance, these factors enabled rapid vegetative reproduction and mat formation across vast expanses.^[1] The development of anoxic bottom waters enhanced the event's longevity by preventing the oxidative degradation of sinking organic material. Persistent stratification inhibited oxygen replenishment from the surface, leading to oxygen depletion (euxinic conditions in places) and the accumulation of sulfides, as evidenced by pyrite concentrations and laminated sediments lacking benthic fauna.^[1] This oxygen-poor hypolimnion not only preserved Azolla remains but also facilitated phosphorus regeneration from decomposing biomass, recycling it upward to support ongoing surface blooms.^[24]

Mechanisms of the Event

Bloom Dynamics

The Azolla event commenced with the initial colonization of the Eocene Arctic Ocean's brackish surface waters by the freshwater fern Azolla, primarily through dispersal of its resilient spores or vegetative fragments from adjacent continental margins. This colonization, dated to approximately 49 million years ago, enabled rapid vegetative propagation under nutrient-enriched conditions, leading to exponential population growth. Within a short period, Azolla formed dense, floating mats that expanded across the basin, reaching thicknesses of 5–7 cm and covering vast areas of the estimated 4 × 10^6 km² Arctic surface.^[24]^[1] These mats established a self-sustaining feedback loop that reinforced Azolla dominance. By drastically reducing light penetration into the water column, the thick biomass inhibited the growth of competing primary producers, such as diatoms and algae, which rely on photosynthesis. Concurrently, Azolla's symbiotic association with the nitrogen-fixing cyanobacterium Anabaena azollae allowed it to enrich the surrounding waters with bioavailable nitrogen, further fueling its own proliferation while limiting resources for non-nitrogen-fixing competitors. This ecological advantage enabled sustained biomass accumulation, with peak standing crops estimated at around 8 kg fresh weight per m².^[1]^[24] The bloom persisted for less than 800,000 years, characterized by cyclical phases tied to orbital forcings like obliquity cycles of approximately 80,000 years. Annual dynamics likely featured peak growth during warmer summer months, when temperatures exceeded 10°C and supported high photosynthetic rates, followed by die-off in cooler winters; however, dormant spores overwintered in the sediments, facilitating recolonization each spring. Overall turnover rates, with primary productivity reaching about 120 g C m⁻² year⁻¹, supported a total primary production of approximately 3.8 × 10^{17} kg of organic carbon across the basin over the event's duration.^[1]^[25]

Carbon Sequestration Process

During the Azolla event, the freshwater fern Azolla fixed atmospheric CO₂ through C3 photosynthesis, a process enhanced by its symbiotic relationship with nitrogen-fixing cyanobacteria, which provided bioavailable nitrogen to support rapid biomass accumulation without nutrient limitation.^[1] Cultivation experiments under Eocene-like conditions (elevated pCO₂ of ~1900 ppm) demonstrated that Azolla biomass doubled compared to modern levels, achieving growth rates sufficient to cover the Arctic Basin's surface area repeatedly over the event's duration.^[1] Stable isotope analyses (δ¹³C ~ –30‰) confirm the C3 fixation pathway, while low δ¹⁵N values (–0.7 to –2.4‰) verify the role of symbiotic N₂ fixation in boosting photosynthetic efficiency.^[1] As Azolla mats senesced, they detached and sank rapidly through the stratified, brackish water column of the Eocene Arctic Ocean, reaching the anoxic seafloor and largely bypassing aerobic remineralization that would otherwise return fixed carbon to the atmosphere.^[1] This sinking was facilitated by the formation of a stable freshwater lens over denser marine waters, creating a low-oxygen environment that preserved organic matter integrity during descent.^[26] Sedimentation rates during the event averaged 12.7 m per million years (equivalent to ~1.3 cm/kyr), with higher rates up to ~2.4 cm/kyr in peak bloom intervals, allowing for the accumulation of thick Azolla-derived layers.^[1] Burial efficiency overall was low (~1.2% net burial relative to primary production), as most organic matter was remineralized despite anoxic conditions, resulting in kerogen-rich shales with total organic carbon (TOC) contents exceeding 5% in sediment cores from the Lomonosov Ridge.^[26] Although net burial relative to primary production was low (~1.2%), the scale of blooms across ~4 million km² ensured substantial carbon drawdown, estimated at 0.9–3.5 × 10¹⁸ g C (900–3,500 Gt C) over the ~800,000-year event, equivalent to a pCO₂ reduction of 55–470 ppm under Eocene conditions.^[1] Net burial rates reached ~1.4 g C m⁻² year⁻¹, underscoring the event's role in long-term CO₂ removal.^[1] Over geological timescales, the buried Azolla biomass compacted into hydrocarbon source rocks, locking carbon away for millions of years and contributing to the formation of organic-rich sediments that persist in the Arctic Basin today.^[26] This process transformed transient biological productivity into enduring geological storage, with Azolla remains identifiable in Eocene strata as a marker of the event's extent.^[1]

Global Impacts

Climatic Effects

The massive proliferation of Azolla during the event is hypothesized to have contributed to atmospheric CO₂ drawdown of 55–470 ppm, part of the broader middle Eocene decline from ~1,500–2,000 ppm to ~900 ppm. This CO₂ sequestration lowered radiative forcing by diminishing the greenhouse effect, contributing to global cooling trends over the middle Eocene. The process involved the burial of vast quantities of organic carbon in anoxic Arctic sediments, preventing its return to the atmosphere and ocean, with total sequestered carbon estimated at 0.9–3.5 × 10¹⁸ g (detailed in Carbon Sequestration Process).^[1] In the Arctic region, the event involved a minor decline in surface water temperatures from ~13–14°C prior to the bloom to ~10°C during the event, as evidenced by biomarker proxies like TEX₈₆. This reflects freshwater stratification rather than extreme cooling. The Arctic's transformation from a warm, ice-free basin to one with enhanced stratification marked a step toward polar amplification of cooling, ultimately facilitating the onset of Antarctic glaciation around 34 Ma during the Eocene-Oligocene Transition.^[27] The diminished CO₂ levels from the Azolla event amplified the influence of orbital forcing via Milankovitch cycles, particularly eccentricity and obliquity variations, by lowering the threshold for ice sheet initiation. This interaction promoted ice-albedo feedback loops, wherein expanding ice cover reflected more solar radiation, further reducing temperatures and sustaining the shift from greenhouse to icehouse conditions.^[28]^[29] The Azolla event coincides with early middle Eocene cooling trends, but major icehouse transition occurred later at ~34 Ma, with benthic foraminiferal δ¹⁸O values rising by ~1‰ then, indicative of cooler deep waters and continental ice.^[28]

Oceanographic and Biospheric Changes

The Azolla event, occurring approximately 49 million years ago in the middle Eocene, induced significant ocean stratification in the Arctic Basin through the influx of massive freshwater from surrounding landmasses, creating a persistent halocline that separated low-salinity surface waters from denser saline deep waters. This stratification inhibited vertical mixing and deep-water formation, fostering euxinic conditions with oxygen-depleted bottom waters, as evidenced by laminated sediments, high pyrite concentrations (47–72 mg g⁻¹), and low C/S ratios (1–2) in Arctic Ocean cores. The resulting anoxia episodes promoted the deposition of organic-rich black shales, with total organic carbon contents reaching 3.1–6.0 wt% in the Lomonosov Ridge sediments, reflecting enhanced preservation of labile organic matter under reduced oxygenation. The dominance of Azolla mats disrupted nutrient cycling by establishing a micro-halocline (5–7 cm thick) beneath the floating biomass, which trapped phosphorus and other nutrients in the surface layer through efficient internal recycling, limiting their availability to deeper or adjacent marine ecosystems.^[24] This Azolla monopoly on surface nutrients, supported by its symbiotic nitrogen fixation and dense coverage, depleted resources for other phytoplankton, leading to an "Azolla world" characterized by suppressed marine primary productivity outside the Arctic Basin, as indicated by low C/N ratios and minimal non-Azolla organic matter in event strata.^[24] However, recent analyses indicate a more localized bloom, potentially limiting its global biospheric impacts.^[3] Biospheric shifts during the event included a marked decline in calcareous plankton, such as benthic and planktonic foraminifera, attributable to the low-salinity freshwater cap and associated ocean acidification from decaying organic matter, which reduced carbonate saturation in surface waters. Post-event recovery saw a rise in siliceous organisms, including diatoms, as cooling and renewed ocean circulation favored silica-based primary producers over calcareous ones in the transitioning Arctic ecosystem. Long-term effects of the event extended to the Eocene-Oligocene boundary around 34 million years ago, where the massive carbon burial (~0.9–3.5 × 10¹⁵ kg C) enhanced the efficiency of the ocean's biological pump, amplifying global cooling and contributing to faunal turnovers, including shifts in deep-sea benthic communities and the onset of Antarctic glaciation.

Controversies and Alternative Hypotheses

Debates on Scale and Duration

Scientific debates surrounding the scale of the Azolla event center on the extent of basin coverage by the fern blooms, with estimates varying from localized marginal zones to up to 10 million km² or more for the entire Arctic Basin based on paleogeographic reconstructions of the Eocene Arctic Ocean. Initial hypotheses posited near-complete enclosure of the Arctic Basin under a persistent freshwater cap, facilitating widespread Azolla proliferation. However, a 2019 study analyzing sediment cores and isotopic data challenged this view, proposing that the freshwater layer was limited in extent and intermittent, preventing full basin enclosure and suggesting smaller-scale blooms confined to marginal or coastal zones.^[3] Controversies over the event's duration arise from discrepancies between core-based chronostratigraphy and climate modeling. Sedimentary records from Arctic cores indicate an approximately 800,000-year phase, with some estimates suggesting a minimum of ~160,000 years based on cyclostratigraphy, marked by repeated Azolla layers reflecting seasonal or annual deposition cycles. In contrast, some modeling approaches link the blooms to shorter, pulsed episodes driven by Milankovitch orbital cycles, particularly eccentricity variations that could have modulated freshwater input and nutrient availability on timescales of tens of thousands of years.^[2] These debates are compounded by inherent limitations in the paleontological evidence, primarily derived from a small number of Integrated Ocean Drilling Program (IODP) cores, such as those from Expedition 302 on the Lomonosov Ridge. Sampling biases from these sites, which may not represent the full basin variability, raise concerns about extrapolating local bloom records to regional scales, as core recovery gaps and diagenetic alterations could obscure the true spatial and temporal patterns.^[30] Recent research on micro-halocline dynamics has offered critiques that refine understandings of bloom sustainability, suggesting that small-scale salinity gradients formed by Azolla mats enabled efficient nutrient recycling from underlying waters, potentially extending bloom durations beyond initial freshwater influx estimates.^[31] This mechanism implies that nutrient limitations were less constraining than previously thought, allowing recurrent Azolla growth over multiple cycles despite variable hydrological conditions. The fossil Azolla layers, reaching thicknesses of several meters in some cores, further support prolonged deposition but are interpreted variably in light of these findings.

Competing Explanations

One alternative hypothesis to the in situ growth of Azolla in the Arctic Ocean posits that the fern primarily proliferated in freshwater river systems and marginal lakes surrounding the paleocean, with biomass subsequently transported to marine environments via estuarine outflows and increased fluvial discharge. This river transport model suggests that an intensified hydrologic cycle during the middle Eocene, driven by high-latitude warmth and precipitation, facilitated the export of terrestrially sourced Azolla and associated organic matter into the Arctic Basin, where it contributed to carbon burial without requiring a persistent freshwater cap over the entire ocean. Proposed in the 2010s, this scenario challenges the traditional view of large-scale, sustained blooms within the Arctic itself by emphasizing episodic delivery from continental margins, potentially explaining the observed Azolla fossils in sedimentary records while reducing the need for improbable long-term stratification in a deep basin.^[3] Another competing explanation attributes the Eocene carbon drawdown and associated cooling primarily to enhanced silicate weathering triggered by tectonic uplift, particularly the initial rise of the Tibetan Plateau around 50 million years ago, which increased erosion rates and exposed fresh rock surfaces to atmospheric CO₂. Under this hypothesis, the uplift intensified chemical weathering of silicate minerals on land, accelerating the conversion of CO₂ into bicarbonate ions that were ultimately buried in marine sediments, thereby operating independently of biological blooms like Azolla and providing a tectonic driver for the long-term decline in atmospheric CO₂ from ~1,500 ppm to ~900 ppm. More recent 2021 analyses further challenge this as the primary driver for Eocene cooling, emphasizing its greater relevance to Neogene trends.^[32] This mechanism is supported by geochemical proxies indicating elevated weathering fluxes coinciding with Himalayan orogeny, suggesting it as a dominant control on global cooling trends rather than localized organic carbon sequestration in the Arctic. Orbital forcings via Milankovitch cycles and variations in volcanic activity have also been invoked as primary drivers of Eocene cooling, with Azolla blooms playing at most a secondary or amplifying role. Changes in Earth's orbital parameters, such as eccentricity and obliquity, modulated insolation patterns and may have initiated cooling phases by altering seasonal contrasts and ice-albedo feedbacks, as evidenced by cyclostratigraphic records showing orbital pacing in Eocene sedimentary sequences. Similarly, a potential reduction in mid-ocean ridge volcanism or arc activity during the middle Eocene could have diminished CO₂ outgassing, contributing to net atmospheric drawdown over millions of years, though direct evidence for such a decline remains debated and is often linked more broadly to Cenozoic subduction dynamics. Recent 2024 studies suggest Eocene intraplate volcanism in the Arctic may have influenced local carbon cycles.^[33] These abiotic forcings highlight how astronomical and geodynamic processes might explain the observed climatic shift without relying heavily on the Azolla event.^[34]^[35] Critiques of the Azolla event's primacy further question its capacity for global-scale CO₂ impact, arguing that the estimated biomass production—potentially sequestering 0.9 to 3.5 × 10¹⁸ grams of carbon—was insufficient to drive the full extent of observed cooling, implying more regional effects confined to the Arctic rather than a planet-wide phenomenon. Studies from around 2008, including analyses of sediment cores and carbon isotope excursions, suggest that while Azolla contributed to local anoxia and burial, the overall CO₂ decline aligns better with broader geochemical cycles, such as ocean circulation changes or diffuse organic matter inputs, rather than a singular bloom event dominating global budgets. This perspective underscores the event's role as one factor among multiple, with uncertainties in bloom duration and extent limiting claims of primacy.

Modern Implications

Potential for Climate Mitigation

The Azolla event has inspired modern efforts to cultivate the fern for carbon sequestration, particularly in rice paddies and controlled ponds where it serves as both a biofertilizer and a carbon sink. In rice systems, Azolla fixes atmospheric nitrogen at rates of 0.4–1.2 kg N/ha/day and, when incorporated as green manure, supplies 20–40 kg N/ha while reducing methane emissions by 30–60% compared to conventional practices. This dual role enhances rice yields by 14–40% and sequesters carbon through rapid biomass accumulation, with observed rates of up to 1.8 tons CO₂/ha/year in integrated cropping systems. Globally scaled cultivation across suitable aquatic areas could mimic the event's drawdown potential without displacing food production, as Azolla thrives in non-arable wetlands, potentially offsetting current anthropogenic CO₂ emissions equivalent to ~11.5 Gt C/year (as of 2025).^[36]^[37]^[38] Geoengineering proposals draw on the ancient event by advocating large-scale floating Azolla farms in oceans, lakes, or marginal waters to accelerate carbon burial, potentially sequestering 32.5–60 tons CO₂/ha/year under optimized conditions. These systems would involve periodic harvesting and sinking of biomass to the seabed, similar to the Eocene Arctic bloom, to lock away carbon for millennia. However, implementation faces significant hurdles, including the need for sustained nutrient inputs like phosphorus and nitrogen to sustain growth, which could exacerbate eutrophication and deplete oxygen in surrounding waters. Ecological risks are pronounced, as uncontrolled Azolla proliferation—already classified as an invasive weed in North America and Europe—could smother aquatic habitats and disrupt biodiversity.^[39]^[40] Economically, Azolla cultivation offers versatility as a biofuel and animal feed crop, leveraging its high biomass productivity and low input requirements. As a biodiesel feedstock, it yields viable oil content grown in wastewater ponds, reducing production costs relative to traditional oilseeds and cutting greenhouse gas emissions from fossil fuels through sustainable harvesting. In livestock feed, incorporating 50% Azolla reduces overall emissions by 28.5% per 1,000 birds in poultry systems and boosts productivity in dairy and small ruminants, enhancing farm profitability in tropical regions. The ancient Arctic Azolla deposits, rich in organic matter, represent potential oil shale resources, but extraction poses risks of methane release from permafrost disturbance, potentially offsetting sequestration gains.^[41]^[36] Despite these prospects, Azolla-based mitigation is limited by slower sequestration rates compared to industrial carbon capture and storage, which can achieve gigaton-scale drawdown more rapidly without biological constraints. Scalability remains unproven, constrained by factors such as the fern's short shelf life due to high water content, sensitivity to temperatures above 30°C, and potential for pest infestations or invasiveness. In 2025, the National Science Foundation awarded a grant to Stony Brook University researchers to test Azolla as a soil amendment for carbon offsets, focusing on automated harvesting and modeling to cover areas like 20% of Long Island for U.S.-scale impact, though broader deployment requires further validation of long-term efficacy and minimal phosphorus needs. The November 2025 Global Carbon Budget report confirms ongoing rises in emissions, underscoring the urgency for such biological solutions.^[36]^[42]^[38]

Recent Research Developments

In 2021, researchers at Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory (CSHL) explored the Azolla event as a model for modern carbon burial strategies, highlighting the fern's rapid growth and symbiotic nitrogen fixation as key factors enabling massive biomass accumulation during the Eocene.^[43] Subsequent genomic studies from 2021 to 2025 have advanced understanding of Azolla's genetic underpinnings for such explosive proliferation. For instance, a 2024 study sequenced the genome of Azolla caroliniana, revealing structural variations and gene duplications that likely facilitated its adaptation to nutrient-poor, freshwater environments, including enhancements in photosynthetic efficiency and cyanobiont symbiosis critical for the Eocene bloom.^[44] Analyses of the Azolla-Nostoc symbiosis have shown extensive gene loss in the cyanobiont Nostoc azollae, underscoring evolutionary adaptations that optimized nitrogen fixation and growth rates under low-light, stratified conditions akin to the Arctic Ocean during the event.^[45] A 2024 investigation by Penn State University confirmed the safety of Azolla for potential applications, identifying non-toxic strains of the symbiotic cyanobacteria Nostoc azollae that lack genes for cyanotoxin production, addressing prior concerns about toxicity in bloom biomass.^[46] This finding, published in Plants, supports Azolla's viability beyond paleoclimate contexts, with implications for scalable cultivation.^[47] In 2025, Stony Brook University received a National Science Foundation grant to evaluate Azolla as a carbon offset mechanism in controlled environments, simulating Eocene-like conditions to quantify sequestration rates and biomass viability for contemporary mitigation.^[42] Preliminary models from the project suggest that deploying Azolla on 20% of Long Island's surface could offset annual U.S. emissions, informing integration with global climate simulations.^[48] Mechanistic research has refined explanations for the bloom's persistence, with renewed analyses of micro-halocline dynamics showing how Azolla mats created salinity gradients in brackish waters, enabling efficient nutrient recycling and preventing nutrient limitation over millennia. Genome sequencing efforts continue to illuminate Eocene-specific adaptations, such as whole-genome duplications around 80 million years ago that enhanced the fern's ability to maintain cyanobacterial partnerships under warming climates.^[49] Looking ahead, ongoing projects emphasize incorporating Azolla dynamics into Earth system models to predict bloom-scale cooling effects, while exploratory genetic engineering approaches, including CRISPR, are proposed to amplify sequestration traits like growth rate and carbon storage in modern strains.^[50]

References

[1]
https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1472-4669.2009.00195.x
[2]
Orbitally forced Azolla blooms and Middle Eocene Arctic hydrology
May 1, 2011 · This strong correlation suggests periods of enhanced rainfall and runoff during Azolla blooms, presumably linked to increased local summer ...
[3]
Limited freshwater cap in the Eocene Arctic Ocean | Scientific Reports
Mar 12, 2019 · We propose that Azolla events are related to an increased hydrologic cycle washing terrestrially sourced Azolla, and other organics, into the Arctic Ocean.
[4]
Episodic fresh surface waters in the Eocene Arctic Ocean - Nature
Jun 1, 2006 · The termination of the Azolla phase in the Arctic coincides with a local sea surface temperature rise from ∼10 °C to 13 °C, pointing to ...Missing: event | Show results with:event
[5]
[PDF] The Eocene Arctic Azolla bloom - Bujak Research
Enormous quantities of the free-floating freshwater fern Azolla grew and reproduced in situ in the Arctic Ocean during the middle Eocene, ...
[6]
Azolla - an overview | ScienceDirect Topics
As a result, Azolla can fix nitrogen with a rate of up to 1.1 tons/ha/year, which is remarkably greater than the nitrogen fixation rate of legumes i.e. 0.4 tons ...
[7]
Origin and Evolution of the Azolla Superorganism - PubMed Central
The Campanian Stage extends from 83.7 to 72.2 million years (Ma) based on Gradstein et al.'s (2020) Geological Time Scale [52], with the succeeding ...Missing: timeline | Show results with:timeline
[8]
THE AZOLLA-ANABAENA SYMBIOSIS: BASIC BIOLOGY
All Azolla species normally contain, as a symbiont, an heterocyst-forming,. Nz-fixing cyanobacterium known as Anabaena azollae Strasburger. Strasbur ger (105), ...
[9]
Azolla Plant Production and Their Potential Applications - Korsa - 2024
Jan 17, 2024 · Azolla can grow quickly, doubling in 2–5 days, and form very dense ... Biomass growth and composition of Azolla (Azolla Pinnata R. BR ...
[10]
Azolla - Climate Foundation
If properly managed, i.e. excess biomass sunk to become peat or sequestered in the deep ocean, Azolla could be promoted as a carbon negative feed supplement.Missing: sources | Show results with:sources<|control11|><|separator|>
[11]
The oxidative stress caused by NaCl in Azolla caroliniana is ...
Growth characterized by biomass, doubling time (DT) and relative growth rate (RGR) of Azolla plants treated by different concentrations of NaCl (0, 50, 100 ...
[12]
Azolla Sporophytes and Spores from the Late Cretaceous and ...
Jul 19, 2019 · In this contribution, we describe two fossil Azolla species based on both sporophytes and spores from Chubut Province, Patagonia, Argentina.
[13]
The freshwater fern Azolla (Azollaceae) from Eocene Arctic and ...
Jul 15, 2013 · We describe 3 new Azolla species from Eocene marine deposits. · In total 5 Azolla species occurred in the Arctic and Nordic Seas during the ...
[14]
Azolla - an overview | ScienceDirect Topics
Traditionally, seven species are recognized and they are divided into three series, with A. filiculoides, A. rubra, A. caroliniana, A. microphylla, and A.
[15]
Azolla: A Review of Its Biology and Utilization - jstor
... Azolla mat reduces the volatilization of ammonia that normally occurs. 11. A thick Azolla mat in a rice field has the side-benefit of suppressing weeds. C ...Missing: traits anoxic
[16]
(PDF) Azolla: Botany, physiology, and use as a green manure
Weed suppression.-The ability of a thick, light-proof Azolla mat to suppress weed development has long been observed (Braemer, 1927a, b; Nguyen, 1930 ...<|control11|><|separator|>
[17]
(PDF) The Eocene Arctic Azolla phenomenon: species composition ...
Two species of this plant have been shown to have bloomed and reproduced in enormous numbers in the latest Early to earliest Middle Eocene of the Arctic Ocean ...
[18]
A new species of the freshwater fern Azolla (Azollaceae) from the ...
A new fossil species of the freshwater fern Azolla (Azollaceae, Salviniales) is described from an unusual setting of high palaeolatitude in the Arctic Ocean ...
[19]
Paleogene biomarker records from the central Arctic Ocean ...
Mar 28, 2008 · During Integrated Ocean Drilling Program Expedition 302 (Arctic Coring Expedition (ACEX)) a more than 200 m thick sequence of Paleogene ...
[20]
Proc. IODP, 302, Sites M0001–M0004
During Expedition 302, cores ranging in age from the Campanian (basement) to the Holocene were recovered. Major hiatuses occur between the Campanian and the ...<|control11|><|separator|>
[21]
Early to middle Eocene history of the Arctic Ocean from Nd‐Sr ...
Jun 5, 2009 · The Arctic Azolla event (49.0–48.3 Ma), registered in IODP Hole 302-4A (unit 2 of Moran et al. [2006]), was a massive event that correlates with ...
[22]
https://agupubs.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1029/2008PA001685
[23]
The Eocene Arctic Azolla bloom: Environmental conditions ...
Carbon dioxide is sequestered by most of the plants, including Azolla. Azolla bloom, often referred to as the Azolla event, occurred in the Arctic Ocean about 8 ...
[24]
(PDF) The Azolla Story: Climate change and Arctic hydrocarbons.
Feb 2, 2016 · The Azolla event was so profound that it fundamentally changed the global climate from the Paleo-Eocene thermal maximum to the much cooler world ...
[25]
Trends, Rhythms, and Aberrations in Global Climate 65 Ma to Present
### Summary of Global Temperature Trends (Early to Middle Eocene)
[26]
The Eocene Arctic Azolla bloom: environmental conditions ...
Mar 27, 2009 · Flux calculations were used to quantitatively reconstruct the potential storage of carbon (0.9–3.5 1018 gC) in the Arctic during the Azolla ...Missing: sequestration | Show results with:sequestration
[27]
Descent into the Icehouse | Geology - GeoScienceWorld
Feb 1, 2008 · The cooling in the late Eocene and early Oligocene was truly a global event, affecting organisms from high to low latitudes, thus supporting ...
[28]
Paleogene record of elemental concentrations in sediments from the ...
Mar 22, 2008 · The most pronounced affect of this control was the Azolla event at the culmination of several flooding events [Brinkhuis et al., 2006].
[29]
[PDF] IODP Expedition 302, Arctic Coring Expedition (ACEX)
One growing legacy of scientific ocean drilling is the realization that sediment sequences represent deep biosphere systems where solids, fluids, and microbes.
[30]
Micro-Halocline Enabled Nutrient Recycling May Explain Extreme ...
Here we show that Azolla is able to create a windproof, small-scale salinity gradient in brackish waters, which allows for efficient recycling of nutrients.Missing: thorium ratio ACEX<|separator|>
[31]
Change in dominant orbital cycles led to warm excursions during the ...
Jan 9, 2025 · The middle–late Eocene Epoch is generally considered to be marked by a warmhouse climate that was characterized by gradual cooling bridging the ...Introduction · Geologic Background · Results
[32]
Reconstructing Eocene Eastern Indian Ocean Dynamics Using ...
Jan 26, 2021 · The astronomical Milankovitch cycles induce oscillations in the insolation distribution across latitudes and seasons on 104–106 year timescales.3 Results · 3.1 Odp Hole 762c · 3.2 Iodp Site U1514
[33]
https://www.nature.com/articles/s43247-024-01843-4
[34]
https://pubs.geoscienceworld.org/gsa/gsabulletin/article/137/5-6/2619/651340/Change-in-dominant-orbital-cycles-led-to-warm
[35]
Can the Fern That Cooled the Planet Do It Again? - Scientific American
Jul 15, 2014 · Researchers hope to use the fernlike Azolla to reverse the global warming effects of burning fossil fuels. By Jennifer Huizen & ClimateWire.
[36]
CO2 sequestration | The Azolla Foundation
With a doubling time of one to two days azolla would sequester 55 to 60 tonnes of CO2/ha/yr (listed above as the 'Maximum Theoretical Azolla Productivity').Missing: per acre
[37]
https://doi.org/10.1007/s11356-021-16986-6
[38]
SBU Researchers Test Ancient Fern as Carbon Offset Solution
Oct 23, 2025 · Over approximately 8,000 years, this “Azolla Event” helped reduce atmospheric carbon dioxide to 400 parts per million. Azolla 2. The NSF ...Missing: drop 3500 650
[39]
How to bury carbon? Let plants do the dirty work.
Feb 5, 2021 · The Azolla Event was an environmental catastrophe for life in the Eocene era 49 million years ago. Today, though, it is a source of inspiration— ...Missing: review | Show results with:review
[40]
The genome assembly of the duckweed fern, Azolla caroliniana
Azolla is a genus of freshwater ferns that is economically important as a nitrogen-fixing biofertilizer, biofuel, bioremediator, and for potential carbon ...
[41]
Adaptive pangenomic remodeling in the Azolla cyanobiont amid a ...
Pangenomic analyses of T. azollae indicate extreme pseudogenization and gene loss compared to free-living relatives—especially in defensive, stress-tolerance, ...
[42]
Water fern gains more evidence as safe potential global food ...
Oct 23, 2024 · International research points to promise and safety of azolla, a plant that can double its biomass in two days and capture nitrogen from the air.
[43]
Azolla as a Safe Food: Suppression of Cyanotoxin-Related Genes ...
Sep 27, 2024 · Azolla is the only plant that retains an endocyanobiont, Nostoc azollae (aka Anabaena azollae), during its sexual and asexual reproduction.
[44]
Stony Brook Researchers Receive NSF Grant to Study Ancient Fern ...
Oct 24, 2025 · The project aims to transform harvested Azolla into soil amendments, addressing both atmospheric carbon reduction and soil degradation — ...
[45]
Origin and Evolution of the Azolla Superorganism - MDPI
The presence of 2-methylhopane lipids characterises modern cyanobacteria and has been used to infer their oldest occurrence in sediments deposited close to the ...1. Introduction · 1.2. Azolla's Suprageneric... · 1.4. Azolla's Transmission...<|control11|><|separator|>
[46]
Role of Azolla in sustainable agriculture and climate resilience
In flooded rice systems, fixation rates of 2–4 kg N per hectare per day have been reported, substantially reducing the need for synthetic fertilizers and ...