Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Bed rest

![Patients undergoing bed rest in a sanatorium]float-right Bed rest is a clinical intervention characterized by confining individuals to bed to restrict physical activity, historically prescribed for recovery from acute illnesses, injuries, surgical procedures, and obstetric complications.^[1] Traced to Hippocratic medicine, the practice gained prominence in the 19th and 20th centuries for conditions like tuberculosis and myocardial infarction, under the assumption that immobilization facilitates healing by conserving energy and reducing physiological stress.^[1] Systematic evaluations, however, demonstrate that bed rest confers no measurable benefits across 15 diverse conditions studied in randomized trials, while exacerbating outcomes in nine instances, including worsened pain and function in low back pain.^[2] Prolonged immobilization induces rapid deconditioning, with muscle strength declining nonuniformly—up to 20-30% within weeks—alongside atrophy, cardiovascular adaptations leading to orthostatic intolerance, and elevated risks of deep vein thrombosis and osteoporosis.^[3]^[4]^[5] In pregnancy, where bed rest was once standard for threatened preterm labor or hypertension, meta-analyses confirm its ineffectiveness in prolonging gestation or improving neonatal outcomes, instead associating it with maternal harms like inflammation and physical decline.^[6] These findings underscore a paradigm shift toward early ambulation and targeted rehabilitation, recognizing disuse as a primary driver of iatrogenic harm rather than therapeutic repose.^[7]

Definition and Physiological Basis

Definition and Scope

Bed rest constitutes a deliberate medical directive restricting patients to recumbent positions in bed, typically aimed at mitigating symptoms, promoting tissue repair, or averting complications in conditions such as acute pain, postpartum recovery, or threatened preterm labor. This intervention differs from involuntary immobility imposed by severe illness or injury, as it involves prescriptive limitations on ambulation and upright activity to ostensibly conserve energy or reduce physiological stress. Definitions emphasize temporary curtailment of physical exertion, often confined to durations of 1 to 2 days for severe acute episodes, though extensions to weeks occur in specialized protocols.^[8]^[9] Variations in bed rest protocols delineate its scope, ranging from strict or absolute bed rest—prohibiting any departure from the supine or semi-recumbent posture except for hygiene—to modified or partial bed rest, which accommodates intermittent sitting, bathroom privileges, or brief standing while curtailing strenuous tasks. Hospital-based implementations may incorporate monitoring equipment and nursing oversight, whereas outpatient variants rely on patient compliance at home. Prescriptions span diverse etiologies, including musculoskeletal strains, cardiovascular events post-procedure, and obstetric risks, with adherence levels influencing outcomes; non-compliance rates can exceed 50% in prolonged regimens due to practical burdens.^[10]^[11] Empirical scrutiny underscores bed rest's expansive yet contested application, as meta-analyses of randomized trials reveal no consistent superiority over early mobilization across 15 primary treatment scenarios, alongside documented risks of iatrogenic harm from disuse. This breadth reflects entrenched clinical inertia rather than unequivocal evidence, prompting guidelines from bodies like the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists to de-emphasize routine use since the early 2010s.^[12]^[9]^[13]

Mechanisms of Disuse and Deconditioning

Prolonged bed rest, as a model of experimental disuse, triggers systemic deconditioning through the absence of mechanical loading against gravity, reduced neuromuscular activation, and altered hormonal signaling, leading to atrophy in multiple tissues within days to weeks.^[14] Muscle mass declines by 1-2% per day initially, with antigravity muscles like the soleus experiencing up to 20-30% loss after 2-3 weeks, driven by upregulated proteolysis via the ubiquitin-proteasome system (e.g., MuRF1 and MAFbx E3 ligases) and suppressed protein synthesis through impaired IGF-1/Akt/mTOR pathways.^[15] Myostatin-Smad signaling further promotes catabolism, while NF-κB activation links inflammation to fiber-type shifts favoring fast-twitch dominance and selective type I fiber atrophy.^[16] ^[17] Skeletal deconditioning manifests as bone mineral density loss of 0.5-1.5% per month, accelerating in weight-bearing sites due to diminished osteoblast activity and enhanced osteoclast resorption from reduced piezoelectric signals and fluid shear stress on osteocytes.^[14] Parathyroid hormone and RANKL upregulation exacerbate resorption, with trabecular bone affected more rapidly than cortical, mirroring unloading models like hindlimb suspension.^[5] Cardiovascular mechanisms involve rapid plasma volume contraction (10-20% within 24-48 hours) from diuresis and venous pooling shifts, reducing central venous pressure, stroke volume, and cardiac output by 15-25%, which impairs orthostatic tolerance and maximal oxygen uptake (VO2 max) by up to 25%.^[18] ^[19] Baroreflex desensitization and sympathetic withdrawal contribute to hypotension upon upright posture, alongside mild cardiac atrophy (5-10% ventricular mass loss after 2 weeks) via myocyte remodeling and downregulated sarcomeric proteins.^[20] Metabolic disruptions include intramuscular lipid accumulation and glycogen supercompensation, fostering insulin resistance via impaired GLUT4 translocation and mitochondrial dysfunction, compounded by inflammatory cytokine elevation (e.g., IL-6, TNF-α).^[21] Neuromuscular junctions degrade with denervation-like changes, reducing motor unit firing rates and excitability, while overall disuse integrates these via shared pathways like FoxO transcription factors amplifying proteostasis imbalance across systems.^[22] These processes are nonlinear, with early fluid shifts amplifying later structural losses, underscoring bed rest's role as a potent atrophy inducer even in healthy adults.^[23]

Historical Context

Ancient Origins and Early Prescriptions

In ancient Egyptian medicine, as documented in the Edwin Smith Papyrus (circa 1600 BCE, transcribing earlier texts from around 2500 BCE), bed rest was prescribed for traumatic injuries such as fractures or wounds to the head and body, with instructions to monitor the patient closely during initial recovery while restricting movement to prevent exacerbation.^[24] This approach reflected an empirical observation of rest facilitating natural healing processes, often combined with bandaging and herbal applications, though magical incantations were also invoked for conditions like the common cold alongside rest.^[25] Such prescriptions prioritized immobilization to stabilize injuries, marking one of the earliest recorded uses of enforced repose in clinical contexts.^[24] The Greek physician Hippocrates (c. 460–370 BCE), often credited as the father of Western medicine, formalized bed rest as a core therapeutic intervention across the Hippocratic Corpus, recommending it for a wide array of ailments including fevers, pains, and surgical recoveries to promote the body's innate restorative capacities.^[1] In works like Aphorisms, he asserted that "in every movement of the body, whenever one begins to endure pain, it will be relieved by rest," emphasizing immobilization as "of capital importance" to avoid aggravating humoral imbalances or tissue damage.^[26]^[1] This principle extended to regimen advice, where rest was balanced against diet and environment, predicated on the belief that excessive activity depleted vital forces while repose conserved them for recovery.^[27] Roman physician Galen (129–216 CE) built upon Hippocratic foundations in his humoral pathology, prescribing bed rest for acute fevers and inflammations to reduce metabolic demands and allow purging of morbid humors, though he cautioned against prolonged immobility due to risks like atrophy or secondary complications.^[28] In treatises such as Method of Medicine, Galen detailed rest protocols tailored to disease stages, integrating it with nourishment and sometimes exercise resumption, reflecting a nuanced view informed by anatomical dissections and clinical observations rather than unchecked prolongation.^[28] These early Greco-Roman prescriptions, grounded in observational causality rather than experimental validation, influenced medical practice for centuries by prioritizing rest as a passive aid to the body's self-regulating mechanisms.^[1]

19th-Century Rest Cure and Institutionalization

The rest cure, a regimen emphasizing prolonged bed rest, isolation, and overfeeding, was pioneered by American neurologist Silas Weir Mitchell in the 1860s and 1870s as a treatment for nervous exhaustion and related conditions. Initially applied to injured soldiers during the American Civil War at Turner's Lane Military Hospital in Philadelphia, it was first formally described in 1873 for locomotor ataxia and gained wider prominence through Mitchell's 1877 book Fat and Blood: And How to Make Them.^[29] The approach targeted neurasthenia—a diagnosis encompassing symptoms like fatigue, anxiety, and weakness, often attributed to depleted "nerve force"—and hysteria, predominantly in female patients described as thin and anemic.^[29]^[30] Central to the rest cure were enforced bed rest lasting six weeks to two months, during which patients remained supine for nearly 24 hours daily under constant nurse supervision, with prohibitions on reading, writing, or social interaction to prevent mental exertion.^[29] Complementary elements included force-feeding regimens—such as three to four pints of milk and one pound of beef daily—to promote weight gain, alongside massage and electrical stimulation to mitigate muscle atrophy from immobility.^[29]^[31] Mitchell reported high success rates, with many patients achieving substantial recovery, including weight increases of 20 to 40 pounds, which he linked to restoration of vital forces through passive rebuilding rather than active exertion.^[29] The treatment reflected 19th-century physiological views prioritizing caloric surplus and rest to counteract perceived nervous depletion, diverging from earlier active therapies.^[32] Institutionalization of the rest cure occurred primarily in specialized medical facilities, including military hospitals like Turner's Lane, private sanatoriums operated by Mitchell near Philadelphia, and nervous disease infirmaries that expanded in the late 19th century to accommodate growing demand.^[29] Upper-middle-class patients, especially women, received care in these controlled environments where physicians enforced isolation from family and daily routines, often with nurses residing in the patient's room to maintain compliance.^[30] The practice spread internationally, reaching Britain by 1881 via physician William Playfair, who adapted it for private clinics treating similar "nervous" disorders.^[29] For lower socioeconomic groups unable to afford private care, analogous rest-based protocols appeared in public asylums and hospitals, though less systematically documented, contributing to broader institutional confinement for mental and neurological complaints under the guise of therapeutic repose.^[33] This institutional framework underscored the era's paternalistic medicine, where bed rest served as both curative intervention and means of total patient subjugation to medical authority.^[29]

20th-Century Evidence and Paradigm Shift

In the early 20th century, prolonged bed rest remained a cornerstone of treatment for conditions such as pulmonary tuberculosis, myocardial infarction, and various pregnancy complications, predicated on the belief that immobilization promoted healing by reducing metabolic demands and strain on affected organs. Sanatorium regimens for tuberculosis, emphasizing strict recumbency and fresh air, persisted into the 1940s despite emerging doubts about their efficacy, with patients often confined for months or years until the advent of streptomycin in 1944 began eroding reliance on rest alone.^[34]^[35] Similarly, post-myocardial infarction protocols mandated weeks of bed rest to prevent reinfarction, a practice rooted in pre-antibiotic era caution but increasingly questioned as observational data linked immobility to complications like pneumonia and thrombosis. Pivotal challenges arose mid-century, exemplified by World War II observations where early mobilization of injured soldiers yielded faster recovery than prolonged recumbency, prompting initial shifts toward activity in trauma care. In cardiology, Samuel A. Levine and Bernard Lown's 1952 study advocated "armchair" treatment for acute coronary thrombosis, seating patients upright within days rather than enforcing strict bed rest; among 81 cases, this approach correlated with lower mortality (8.6% versus historical 30%) and fewer pulmonary issues, challenging orthodoxy and accelerating adoption of graduated ambulation.^[36] Concurrently, space medicine research in the 1960s utilized bed rest as a microgravity analog, revealing rapid physiological deconditioning: Bengt Saltin et al.'s 1968 experiment on five young men demonstrated a 25% drop in maximal oxygen uptake after 20 days of recumbency, attributed to diminished cardiac output and plasma volume, underscoring inactivity's causal role in cardiovascular detraining.^[37] By the late 20th century, accumulating empirical evidence from randomized trials exposed bed rest's net harms across indications. A 1999 systematic review of 24 trials post-procedure found no significant benefits and trends toward worse outcomes like thromboembolism, while pregnancy-focused meta-analyses confirmed no prolongation of gestation in preterm labor threats and heightened risks of musculoskeletal atrophy and venous stasis.^[7] These findings, coupled with documentation of 15% muscle loss within one week and up to 50% after three to five weeks, catalyzed a paradigm shift toward early mobilization, particularly in critical care, where protocols emphasizing awakening and activity supplanted rest-centric models by the 1990s to mitigate deconditioning and enhance functional recovery.^[38] This transition reflected causal recognition that disuse, rather than disease alone, drives many iatrogenic declines, prioritizing evidence over tradition.^[5]

Purported Clinical Applications

In Pregnancy and Preterm Labor

Bed rest has been a longstanding intervention for managing threatened preterm labor, typically involving partial or strict limitation of physical activity, either at home or in hospital, with the aim of reducing uterine irritability, preserving cervical integrity, and prolonging gestation.^[39] Proponents historically posited that decreased maternal activity might enhance placental perfusion and minimize contractions, though this rationale lacks empirical validation from physiological studies.^[40] Systematic reviews, including a 2015 Cochrane analysis of four randomized controlled trials involving 294 women with singleton pregnancies at risk of preterm birth, found no significant reduction in preterm delivery rates with bed rest compared to normal activity (odds ratio 0.64, 95% CI 0.31 to 1.30).^[39] Similarly, the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists (ACOG) states there is no scientific evidence supporting bed rest to prevent preterm labor or mitigate associated risks like preeclampsia.^[41] Evidence from observational and trial data indicates bed rest does not delay delivery or improve neonatal outcomes, such as birth weight or perinatal mortality.^[42] Despite these findings, bed rest remains prescribed in up to 20% of high-risk pregnancies in some practices, often due to tradition rather than data.^[43] However, it carries documented harms, including increased risk of venous thromboembolism from immobility (up to 10-fold higher incidence in prolonged cases), maternal muscle atrophy and deconditioning, bone mineral density loss (comparable to 1-2% per month of immobilization), and gestational weight gain deficits leading to potential fetal growth restriction.^[42]^[13] Psychological effects are also prevalent, with studies reporting elevated rates of anxiety, depression (affecting 10-30% of adherent women), and social isolation, exacerbating overall morbidity without offsetting benefits.^[44] Current guidelines from ACOG and the Society for Maternal-Fetal Medicine recommend against routine bed rest for preterm labor threat, favoring evidence-based alternatives like progesterone supplementation or cerclage where indicated, as activity restriction shows no perinatal advantage and may paradoxically heighten preterm birth risk through inflammatory pathways or non-compliance stress.^[41]^[6] In multiple gestations, a separate Cochrane review echoes this, finding insufficient data to endorse bed rest for preventing preterm birth.^[45]

For Musculoskeletal Injuries and Back Pain

Bed rest has been conventionally recommended for acute musculoskeletal injuries, such as sprains, strains, and fractures, as well as nonspecific low back pain, with the aim of minimizing movement to alleviate pain, reduce inflammation, and promote tissue healing.^[46] This approach posits that immobilization prevents aggravation of damaged structures, though it often extends beyond 1-2 days, leading to unintended physiological consequences.^[14] Randomized controlled trials and systematic reviews, however, demonstrate that bed rest provides no significant benefit over advice to remain active for acute low back pain, and may prolong recovery by fostering deconditioning. A landmark multicenter trial involving 183 patients with acute low back pain found that those advised to maintain ordinary activities returned to work a mean of 8.1 days earlier than the bed rest group (95% CI 4.8-11.5 days), with no increase in pain during activity.^[46] The Cochrane review of nine trials (n=647) on bed rest for acute low back pain and sciatica concluded that it yields at worst slightly harmful effects compared to staying active, with no important difference in pain relief but delayed functional recovery.^[47] An updated analysis reinforced that for acute low back pain, bed rest is less effective than activity, while for sciatica, evidence of benefit remains scant.^[48] In musculoskeletal injuries beyond back pain, such as ankle sprains or limb fractures, evidence similarly cautions against prolonged bed rest due to accelerated muscle atrophy and strength loss disproportionate to injury healing timelines. During the initial two weeks of bed rest, muscle strength declines more rapidly than atrophy—up to 20-30% in weight-bearing muscles like the quadriceps—exacerbating weakness and increasing reinjury risk upon mobilization.^[3] For vertebral compression fractures treated conservatively, short-term (2-week) bed rest may aid alignment in select cases, but lacks standardized guidelines and risks secondary complications like thromboembolism without counteractive measures.^[49] Contemporary protocols emphasize early supervised mobilization over immobilization, as bed rest beyond 48 hours correlates with poorer outcomes in soft tissue injuries, including delayed return to function.^[50] Professional guidelines reflect this evidence shift: the American College of Physicians advises against bed rest for acute or subacute low back pain, favoring staying active alongside nonpharmacologic therapies, based on moderate-quality evidence from trials showing reduced short-term pain with activity (up to 3 months).^[51] For fractures post-fixation, such as ankle repairs, postoperative bed rest lacks empirical support for superior healing and may hinder rehabilitation.^[52] Overall, while brief relative rest (hours to 1 day) may mitigate acute pain in severe cases, empirical data prioritize graduated activity to preserve muscle integrity and expedite recovery across these indications.^[53]

Post-Surgical Recovery and Critical Illness

Bed rest has been traditionally prescribed following surgical procedures to facilitate wound healing, minimize disruption to the surgical site, and reduce the risk of immediate postoperative complications such as bleeding or dehiscence. For instance, in procedures involving free flap reconstruction of the lower limb, extended bed rest is deemed essential to maintain microsurgical flap viability by limiting movement that could compromise vascular pedicles. Similarly, after total knee arthroplasty, a period of bed rest during the first 7 postoperative days has been advocated to enhance range of motion and leg control without elevating risks of common complications like deep vein thrombosis, when combined with appropriate antithrombotic measures. Historically, durations varied by procedure; four weeks of bed rest followed myocardial infarction, while three weeks were standard after hernia repair, reflecting a belief that immobilization conserved bodily resources for tissue repair.^[54]^[55]^[33] In critical illness, particularly within intensive care units (ICUs), bed rest is routinely imposed on patients, often mechanically ventilated or hemodynamically unstable, under the rationale that it prevents complications from exertion, conserves metabolic energy during acute recovery phases, and avoids risks like falls or dislodgement of invasive lines and tubes. This practice assumes that immobility supports stabilization by reducing physiological stress, allowing the body to prioritize resolution of underlying pathology such as sepsis or organ failure over physical activity. For critically ill adults, bed rest is viewed as a foundational intervention to mitigate immediate threats, with purported benefits including lowered oxygen demand and preservation of limited reserves in catabolic states. However, these assumptions stem from longstanding clinical tradition rather than unequivocal empirical support, as scrutiny has intensified regarding its net effects.^[56]^[57]^[58]

Empirical Evidence on Efficacy

Systematic Reviews and Randomized Trials

Systematic reviews of bed rest for preventing preterm birth in singleton pregnancies, including multiple Cochrane analyses, have found no evidence supporting its use, either at home or in hospital, with outcomes showing no reduction in preterm delivery rates compared to usual activity.^[59] ^[45] A 2019 meta-analysis of prenatal bed rest across developed and developing regions similarly concluded it does not improve maternal or fetal health outcomes, with no decrease in preterm birth incidence despite prescription to up to 20% of at-risk pregnancies.^[6] Randomized trials in twin pregnancies prescribed partial bed rest in hospital reported low-quality evidence of reduced hypertensive disorders but no overall perinatal benefits, highlighting potential harms like increased thromboembolic risks without efficacy.^[45] In acute low back pain, randomized controlled trials consistently demonstrate that bed rest delays recovery and worsens functional outcomes compared to advice to remain active within pain tolerance. A 1995 multicenter RCT assigning patients to two days of bed rest, exercises, or usual activity found the bed rest group had slower return to work and poorer recovery at three and 12 weeks than the usual activity group.^[46] Another RCT comparing four days of bed rest to normal activity in 197 patients with acute low back pain showed no differences in pain relief but increased disability and longer sick leave in the bed rest arm.^[60] Systematic reviews of such trials affirm bed rest is ineffective and may prolong symptoms, with active management preferred.^[61] Post-surgical contexts reveal similar inefficacy, with meta-analyses favoring early mobilization over prolonged bed rest to mitigate deconditioning. A 2023 meta-analysis of RCTs on early ambulation after incidental durotomy in spine surgery found it associated with fewer pulmonary complications than bed rest, without increased reoperation risks.^[62] Systematic reviews of postoperative protocols, including after cardiac surgery, indicate early mobilization reduces hospital length of stay and complications like pneumonia or venous thromboembolism, contrasting bed rest's promotion of muscle atrophy and functional decline observed in bed rest durations exceeding 24-48 hours.^[63] ^[64] In orthopedic repairs, such as ankle fractures, RCTs show early mobilization shortens hospitalization without elevating complication rates.^[52] Broader experimental bed rest studies, often simulating spaceflight or critical illness, include RCTs and meta-regressions documenting rapid declines in cardiorespiratory fitness, with VO2max dropping up to 20-30% after 10-14 days, independent of countermeasures in some protocols.^[65] Lean body mass reductions averaging 1.5 kg occur across durations, underscoring disuse atrophy as a consistent adverse effect without therapeutic gains in non-sleep contexts.^[64] These findings from high-quality reviews prioritize empirical outcomes over traditional prescriptions, revealing bed rest's lack of causal benefit in common indications.

Lack of Benefits in Common Indications

In singleton pregnancies at risk of preterm birth, randomized controlled trials and systematic reviews have found no reduction in preterm delivery rates with bed rest compared to ambulatory management.^[66] A 2015 Cochrane review of five trials involving 415 women concluded there is insufficient evidence to support or refute bed rest, with no differences in perinatal mortality, neonatal morbidity, or maternal outcomes.^[66] Similarly, a 2023 analysis of activity restriction for arrested preterm labor reported no scientific evidence that it prevents preterm birth, despite its common prescription.^[43] For acute low back pain, high-quality evidence from Cochrane reviews indicates bed rest provides no benefit and may worsen outcomes relative to advice to remain active.^[48] An updated 2005 review of nine trials showed patients advised to rest in bed experienced slightly more pain at three weeks and delayed recovery in function compared to those encouraged to stay active.^[48] For sciatica, bed rest similarly yielded little to no difference in pain relief or functional improvement versus activity, with potential for minor harm in acute cases.^[48] Post-surgical recovery protocols prescribing prolonged bed rest lack empirical support for improved outcomes in multiple contexts. A meta-analysis of trials following ankle fracture repair found early active exercises accelerated return to work and daily activities compared to immobilization and rest, without increased complications.^[52] In cardiac surgery, systematic reviews of early mobilization versus extended bed rest demonstrate faster recovery times and reduced hospital stays with ambulation, as bed rest correlates with worse functional and physiological results.^[63] For medical conditions like pulmonary embolism or deep vein thrombosis, meta-analyses favor early ambulation over bed rest, showing equivalent or superior resolution of symptoms with fewer adverse events.^[67]

Contexts Where Limited Rest May Apply

In cases of acute nonspecific low back pain without red flags such as neurological deficits or infection, guidelines recommend limiting bed rest to less than 48 hours solely for patients experiencing intolerable pain that precludes basic activity, allowing time for analgesic effects to take hold before initiating mobilization.^[68] This approach stems from randomized trials showing that even brief bed rest beyond this duration delays recovery compared to advice to remain active as tolerated, yet very short periods may provide symptomatic relief in severe initial presentations without significantly worsening outcomes.^[69] The American Academy of Family Physicians emphasizes avoiding bed rest when possible, as patient-directed activity promotes faster return to function, but acknowledges its transient use for pain control in the hyperacute phase.^[70] For uncomplicated acute myocardial infarction, early 20th-century protocols evolved to short bed rest periods of 1-3 days prior to graded mobilization, with meta-analyses of trials finding no increased risk of adverse events like reinfarction or death compared to prolonged rest, suggesting limited rest suffices for initial hemodynamic stabilization in stable patients.^[71] Modern cardiology guidelines, however, prioritize rapid ambulation within 24-48 hours post-percutaneous intervention to mitigate deconditioning, reserving even brief bed rest for those with ongoing instability or arrhythmias.^[72] No high-quality evidence demonstrates net benefits from this limited rest beyond facilitating acute monitoring, underscoring its role as a transitional measure rather than therapeutic intervention.^[73] Limited bed rest, defined as 1-2 days of supine positioning with minimal ambulation, may also apply immediately following certain invasive procedures, such as lumbar puncture or minor spinal interventions, to reduce risks of cerebrospinal fluid leakage or hematoma expansion, though systematic reviews indicate no significant improvement in complication rates versus early activity.^[7] In these scenarios, rest serves precautionary purposes during observation rather than promoting healing, with prompt resumption of movement encouraged to counteract immobility-related harms like thromboembolism. Overall, such applications remain narrowly circumscribed, guided by individual symptom severity and outweighed by evidence favoring early rehabilitation in most conditions.^[12]

Risks and Adverse Effects

Musculoskeletal Atrophy and Weakness

Prolonged bed rest induces disuse atrophy in skeletal muscle, characterized by a rapid decline in muscle mass and fiber cross-sectional area, primarily due to reduced mechanical loading and altered protein synthesis-degradation balance.^[74] This atrophy is nonuniform, with antigravity muscles such as the soleus, quadriceps, and back extensors experiencing preferential losses compared to upper body or non-weight-bearing muscles.^[5] In healthy adults, even short-term bed rest of 3-5 days can initiate measurable atrophy, with leg lean mass decreasing by approximately 3% after 5 days.^[64] Muscle strength declines disproportionately to mass loss, often exceeding atrophy rates by 2-3 times, as evidenced by isometric strength reductions in lower limb muscles during controlled bed rest protocols.^[74] For instance, up to 40% of muscle strength can be lost within the first week of immobilization, driven by neural adaptations, selective fast-twitch fiber atrophy, and impaired neuromuscular activation alongside structural changes.^[5] In older adults or hospitalized patients, this effect accelerates, with immobility leading to 10% muscle mass loss over 7 days, exacerbating sarcopenia and increasing fall risk upon remobilization.^[75] Recovery from bed rest-induced weakness is protracted, often requiring weeks to months of rehabilitation to restore pre-rest function, as muscle protein synthesis remains suppressed post-immobility without targeted interventions like resistance training.^[76] Studies simulating disuse, such as those in healthy volunteers, confirm that strength deficits persist longer in lower extremities, with full reversal demanding progressive loading to counteract residual atrophy and fibrosis.^[77] These findings underscore the causal role of mechanical disuse in atrophy, independent of underlying illness in experimental models.^[78]

Cardiovascular, Metabolic, and Thromboembolic Complications

Prolonged bed rest induces cardiovascular deconditioning characterized by orthostatic intolerance, where upright posture leads to excessive drops in stroke volume and blood pressure due to reduced plasma volume, baroreflex impairment, and cardiac atrophy.^[79] Studies of head-down bed rest simulating microgravity demonstrate that even 5-10 days of immobility alter baroreceptor function, exacerbating syncope risk upon reambulation.^[80] Systematic reviews confirm a decline in cardiorespiratory fitness, with maximal oxygen uptake (VO2max) decreasing by up to 20-30% after 1-2 weeks, inversely related to baseline fitness levels, and persisting without countermeasures like exercise.^[81] This deconditioning mimics accelerated aging, with parallels in vascular stiffness and reduced left ventricular mass observed after 60 days.^[82] Metabolically, bed rest rapidly promotes insulin resistance, primarily in skeletal muscle, even after short durations of 5-7 days, leading to elevated fasting insulin, impaired glucose tolerance, and shifts toward glucose oxidation with glycogen accumulation that further hampers storage capacity.^[83] One week of strict bed rest causes substantial muscle atrophy alongside a 20-30% drop in whole-body insulin sensitivity, independent of fat-induced mechanisms, and elevates hepatic insulin resistance in predisposed individuals.^[77] Prolonged inactivity, such as 60 days, mirrors metabolic syndrome features including visceral fat gain, low-grade inflammation, and persistent hyperglycemia despite caloric adjustment, underscoring immobility's causal role in disrupting glucose homeostasis.^[84]^[85] Thromboembolic risks escalate with bed rest due to venous stasis, with autopsy data indicating venous thrombosis in 15% of patients bedridden under one week and rising to 80% beyond one week, highlighting immobility as a potent Virchow's triad factor.^[86] While anticoagulation mitigates progression in acute deep vein thrombosis (DVT), unnecessary bed rest in otherwise healthy individuals fosters deep vein thrombosis and pulmonary embolism through reduced fibrinolysis and endothelial dysfunction, with evidence favoring early mobilization over rest to avert these outcomes without heightened recurrence.^[87]^[88] Short-term bed rest post-procedure does not independently drive venous thromboembolism in low-risk contexts, but cumulative immobility duration amplifies hazard across populations.^[89]

Psychological and Systemic Impacts

Prolonged bed rest induces psychological distress, including elevated levels of anxiety and depression, as evidenced by self-reported increases in negative emotions among subjects during simulated microgravity studies involving 15 days of head-down tilt.^[90] Women on antepartum bed rest exhibit the highest anxiety and depression scores compared to non-bed rest groups, correlating with reduced spiritual well-being.^[91] Cognitive impairments arise, with declines in executive functions and positive affect observed after 15-30 days of head-down bed rest, potentially linked to autonomic nervous system alterations affecting emotion and cognition.^[92] Deconditioning syndrome encompasses psychological decline alongside physical effects, manifesting as functional deterioration from immobility.^[93] Systemically, bed rest disrupts endocrine function, leading to hypercortisolemia and insulin resistance after 28 days, which exacerbate muscle catabolism and metabolic dysregulation independent of exercise countermeasures.^[94] Cortisol levels rise continuously during prolonged immobilization, contributing to stress responses and appetite suppression via hormonal shifts.^[95] Immune competence diminishes, with weakened responses increasing infection risk, as prolonged bed rest impairs overall immunocompetence through reduced activity and associated physiological stress.^[96] Circadian phase delays in core body temperature occur after long-term bed rest, amplifying psychological stress markers within one week and disrupting broader homeostatic regulation.^[97]

Modern Guidelines and Alternatives

Shift to Early Mobilization Protocols

In the mid-2010s, critical care medicine began transitioning from prolonged bed rest and heavy sedation toward early mobilization protocols, driven by evidence that immobility exacerbates complications like ICU-acquired weakness and delirium while mobilization improves functional outcomes.^[98] This shift emphasizes initiating physical activity within 24–72 hours of ICU admission or as soon as hemodynamically stable, progressing from passive range-of-motion exercises to active ambulation, even in intubated patients where endotracheal tubes are no longer deemed contraindications.^[99]^[100] Randomized trials and meta-analyses have substantiated these protocols' efficacy, showing reduced ICU and hospital lengths of stay, lower rates of ventilator dependence, and decreased incidence of complications such as thromboembolism and muscle atrophy compared to traditional bed rest.^[101] For instance, in post-surgical settings like chronic subdural hematoma evacuation, early mobilization within hours reduced medical complications from 34.6% under 48-hour bed rest to 19.2%, without increasing recurrence rates.^[102] Nurse-driven protocols, incorporating tools like progressive mobility ladders (e.g., supine to sitting, then standing and walking), have demonstrated feasibility in up to 80–90% of eligible patients, enhancing ambulation rates and weaning from mechanical ventilation.^[103]^[104] Professional guidelines, such as the 2024 European Society of Intensive Care Medicine (ESICM) recommendations, endorse early mobilization for critically ill adults, advocating multidisciplinary teams to assess safety via tools like the Perme ICU Mobility Score and contraindications limited to unstable fractures or active hemorrhage.^[105] In enhanced recovery after surgery (ERAS) pathways, protocols mandate at least 2 hours of mobilization on postoperative day zero, correlating with accelerated functional recovery and reduced postoperative ileus or pneumonia risks.^[106] Despite barriers like staff workload and perceived risks, implementation studies report sustained adoption when bundled with sedation minimization, yielding net reductions in healthcare costs through fewer adverse events.^[107]^[108]

Evidence-Based Rehabilitation Strategies

Evidence-based rehabilitation strategies prioritize active interventions to reverse deconditioning from bed rest, focusing on progressive exercise protocols that target musculoskeletal, cardiovascular, and metabolic impairments. Systematic reviews of bed rest analogs, such as head-down tilt studies, demonstrate that combined aerobic and resistance training effectively mitigates muscle atrophy and strength loss, with programs typically initiating low-intensity exercises within 24-48 hours post-immobility and advancing to higher loads over 2-4 weeks.^[109] ^[19] For instance, resistive vibration exercise (RVE) and flywheel resistive training have preserved lower body muscle mass and power output in controlled trials, outperforming passive countermeasures like negative pressure garments, which show negligible effects on 159 physiological outcomes.^[110] ^[111] In hospitalized and ICU settings, early mobilization protocols—entailing supervised progression from passive range-of-motion to upright ambulation—reduce ventilator days, ICU length of stay, and incidence of delirium, with meta-analyses confirming safety across 20+ trials involving over 2,000 patients.^[101] These protocols often incorporate multidisciplinary teams, starting with bedside cycling or tilt table training to address orthostatic intolerance, followed by treadmill walking with body weight support to restore cardiovascular baroreflex function impaired by even short-term bed rest.^[112] ^[113] Evidence indicates that for every week of bed rest, 2.5 weeks of intensive rehabilitation are required to regain baseline function in seniors, emphasizing individualized progression based on functional assessments like the Early Mobility Index.^[114] Resistance Training Components: High-intensity isotonic or isokinetic exercises, performed 3-5 days per week, counteract quadriceps and trunk muscle volume losses of up to 20% after 10-14 days of immobility, as shown in randomized bed rest trials. Plyometric and eccentric loading phases enhance neuromuscular recovery, with post-protocol gains in peak torque matching pre-bed rest levels after 11-21 days.^[76] ^[115] Aerobic and Endurance Strategies: Running or cycling countermeasures preserve VO2 max declines limited to 5-10% versus 15-25% without intervention, per comparative studies; integration with nutritional support (e.g., protein supplementation) augments lean mass retention, though standalone nutrition yields minimal benefits.^[109] ^[116] Multimodal programs for deconditioned patients include psychosocial screening and risk factor modification, aligning with cardiac rehabilitation guidelines that report 20-30% improvements in ejection fraction and exercise tolerance post-myocardial infarction when initiated early.^[117] Limitations persist in severe cases, where 2 weeks of reconditioning may not fully restore lumbopelvic volumes after 60 days of bed rest, underscoring the need for sustained, monitored adherence.^[118]

Patient Education and Prevention of Over-Reliance

Effective patient education on bed rest focuses on conveying the rapid onset of deconditioning effects, such as a 12% weekly loss of muscle strength and significant atrophy in lower limbs unaccustomed to gravity resistance.^[119] ^[110] Providers should explain that immobility promotes complications including deep vein thrombosis, pressure ulcers, constipation, bone density loss, and psychological distress like depression, often outweighing short-term symptomatic relief in conditions like acute low back pain or post-surgical recovery.^[120] ^[121] This information counters historical overprescription by highlighting randomized trial evidence showing no superior outcomes from rest compared to active rehabilitation.^[122] To prevent over-reliance, education emphasizes early mobilization as a core strategy, with patients instructed to incorporate range-of-motion exercises, ankle movements, and gradual upright positioning even during prescribed rest periods.^[110] ^[123] For hospitalized or post-illness individuals, as little as 25 minutes of daily slow walking has been shown to counteract physical declines in older adults, reducing risks of functional loss and prolonged recovery.^[124] Preoperative or post-surgical programs using teach-back methods—where patients repeat instructions to confirm understanding—enhance adherence to mobilization, accelerating walking capacity restoration and lowering complication rates like pneumonia or delirium.^[125] ^[106] Shared decision-making tools aid prevention by encouraging patients to query the necessity and duration of bed rest, advocating for evidence-based alternatives such as structured physical therapy over indefinite immobility.^[126] In contexts like pregnancy or minor injuries, materials stress monitoring symptoms for safe activity resumption, as routine bed rest lacks endorsement from major guidelines due to absent benefits and heightened risks.^[10] Patients are advised to track progress with simple metrics, like daily step counts or pain levels during movement, to self-limit rest and avoid dependency cycles where initial avoidance of activity perpetuates weakness.^[127] This approach fosters autonomy, with follow-up reassessments every 48 hours to taper rest as tolerated.^[128]

Controversies and Societal Implications

Persistent Overprescription Despite Data

Despite extensive evidence accumulated since the 1980s documenting the physiological harms of bed rest—including rapid muscle atrophy, cardiovascular deconditioning, and thromboembolic risks—its routine prescription endures in clinical practice for conditions such as acute low back pain, pregnancy complications, and postoperative recovery.^[129]^[77] In obstetrics, bed rest remains the most common intervention for threatened preterm labor and other high-risk scenarios, with surveys indicating that 89% to 95% of obstetricians prescribe it despite randomized trials and meta-analyses showing no benefits in preventing preterm birth, fetal growth restriction, or prolonging gestation.^[130]^[131]^[42] For acute nonspecific low back pain, major guidelines, including those from the American Academy of Family Physicians, contraindicate bed rest beyond 48 hours, as prolonged immobility fails to accelerate recovery and exacerbates functional decline compared to early activity.^[68]^[132] Nevertheless, adherence lags; clinician surveys and observational data reveal persistent recommendations rooted in historical norms, with patients often receiving 1–2 days or more of prescribed rest, correlating with slower return to work and heightened chronicity risks.^[133]^[134] This discrepancy arises from entrenched therapeutic inertia, where interventions like bed rest—once standard since the early 20th century—persist amid uneven guideline dissemination, physician risk aversion (e.g., fear of litigation for perceived inadequate action), and patient demands for passive reassurance over active rehabilitation.^[135] In hospitalized elderly populations, overprescription manifests as profound inactivity, with studies documenting 71%–83% of hospital time spent lying down, amplifying deconditioning cascades despite protocols advocating mobilization within 24 hours of admission.^[136] Such patterns highlight systemic delays in translating empirical data into practice, prioritizing tradition over causal evidence of harm.^[27]

Historical Biases and Gender Disparities

In the late 19th century, American neurologist Silas Weir Mitchell developed the "rest cure" as a treatment for neurasthenia, a condition characterized by fatigue, anxiety, and nervous exhaustion, which was disproportionately diagnosed in women.^[29] The regimen, pioneered in the 1860s and 1870s, mandated six to eight weeks of enforced bed rest, isolation from family and intellectual stimulation, overfeeding with milk and fattening foods, and passive treatments like massage and electricity, aiming to rebuild physical strength through immobility.^[32] Mitchell explicitly targeted women, whom he viewed as more susceptible due to their reproductive physiology and societal roles, prescribing it for conditions ranging from postpartum depression to hysteria, often dismissing underlying psychological or social factors in favor of physical repose.^[33] This approach reflected paternalistic biases in Victorian medicine, where women's complaints were frequently pathologized as uterine or nervous disorders warranting confinement rather than active intervention or autonomy.^[137] The rest cure's gender specificity is evident in its application: while Mitchell occasionally used modified versions for men, such as soldiers with trauma, the full protocol was almost exclusively imposed on female patients, reinforcing stereotypes of women as inherently fragile and in need of male-directed control.^[32] Criticisms emerged contemporaneously; writer Charlotte Perkins Gilman, a patient in 1887, documented its psychologically devastating effects in her 1892 story "The Yellow Wallpaper," portraying it as exacerbating madness through sensory deprivation and enforced passivity.^[138] Empirical outcomes supported these accounts, with reports of weight gain masking deepened depression and dependency, and the treatment persisting into the early 20th century despite such evidence.^[139] Gender disparities extended into obstetrics, where bed rest became a default for pregnancy complications like threatened miscarriage or preterm labor, conditions exclusive to women. By the mid-20th century, it was routinely prescribed without robust trials, affecting up to 20% of pregnancies in the U.S., yet randomized studies from the 1980s onward, such as those reviewing outcomes in high-risk cases, found no fetal benefits and increased maternal risks including thromboembolism and bone density loss.^[140]^[6] This overprescription persisted due to anecdotal traditions and risk-averse practices, disproportionately burdening women with physical deconditioning and psychological strain, such as isolation and financial dependency, while men faced no analogous routine immobilization for comparable health issues.^[141] Historical patterns thus reveal a bias toward immobilizing women under the guise of protection, often prioritizing perceived uterine rest over evidence-based mobility, with legacies in modern guidelines that continue to recommend it selectively despite meta-analyses showing inefficacy.^[6]

Broader Critiques of Medical Paternalism

The persistent prescription of bed rest, despite accumulating evidence of its inefficacy and harms, exemplifies medical paternalism wherein physicians prioritize their clinical judgment over empirical data and patient autonomy.^[142] In obstetrics, for instance, bed rest has been routinely ordered for conditions like threatened preterm labor since the mid-20th century, often without randomized controlled trials supporting its benefits, leading to unintended consequences such as muscle atrophy, venous thromboembolism, and psychological distress.^[42] This practice reflects a paternalistic model where doctors assume directive authority, framing rest as a benign intervention while downplaying risks, thereby limiting informed consent and shared decision-making.^[141] Critics argue that such overreliance violates core ethical principles, including autonomy—by restricting patients' daily activities without compelling evidence of net benefit—and beneficence, as meta-analyses of 24 trials on post-procedural bed rest found no significant improvements in outcomes and worsening in eight cases, including increased deep vein thrombosis risk.^[9]^[142] Justice is also implicated, as bed rest disproportionately burdens lower-income patients through lost wages and caregiving demands, yet persists due to ingrained professional norms rather than patient-centered evaluation.^[42] This paternalism extends beyond pregnancy; in general medicine, bed rest for low back pain or post-surgical recovery has similarly endured, with guidelines from bodies like the American College of Physicians recommending against it since 2017 based on evidence favoring early mobilization.^[143] Broader critiques highlight how bed rest's entrenchment reveals systemic flaws in medical culture, including resistance to evidence-based shifts and overprotection that infantilizes patients, akin to "kindergarten-like" behaviors in care settings that erode trust and self-efficacy.^[144] Historical analysis traces this to 19th-century sanatorium traditions, where prolonged immobility was idealized as therapeutic despite early observations of deconditioning, perpetuating a top-down paradigm that delays adoption of alternatives like tailored rehabilitation.^[145] Proponents of autonomy-focused reforms, such as those in bioethics literature, contend that paternalistic prescribing fosters dependency and iatrogenic harm, urging transparency about uncertainties to empower patients—yet surveys indicate up to 20% of U.S. obstetricians still recommend it routinely as of 2018, underscoring incomplete paradigm shifts.^[141]^[142] This pattern informs calls for regulatory scrutiny of non-evidence-based interventions, prioritizing causal mechanisms like disuse atrophy over ritualistic rest.

References

[1]
The evolution of bed rest as a clinical intervention - PubMed
Bed rest as a therapy can be traced back to Hippocrates and has been used for many types of illnesses since then. It is still commonly used as an intervention ...
[2]
Bed rest: a potentially harmful treatment needing more careful ...
Oct 9, 1999 · In 15 trials investigating bed rest as a primary treatment, no outcomes improved significantly and nine worsened significantly for some ...
[3]
Nonuniform loss of muscle strength and atrophy during bed rest
Bed rest results in nonuniform loss of isometric muscle strength and atrophy over time, where the magnitude of change was greater for muscle strength than for ...
[4]
Cardiac Atrophy After Bed-Rest Deconditioning | Circulation
The cardiovascular adaptation to bed rest leads to orthostatic intolerance, characterized by an excessive fall in stroke volume (SV) in the upright position.
[5]
The impact of extended bed rest on the musculoskeletal system in ...
Oct 9, 2015 · Prolonged immobility is harmful with rapid reductions in muscle mass, bone mineral density and impairment in other body systems evident within the first week ...
[6]
Prenatal bed rest in developed and developing regions - NIH
Jul 5, 2019 · Bed rest is likely to drive inflammation, which may increase the risk of preterm birth, necessitating further research on the levels of ...
[7]
Bed rest: a potentially harmful treatment needing more ... - NCBI - NIH
The authors state that overall there was no evidence that bed rest has any significant beneficial effect when used as a treatment or when used after surgery.
[8]
Bed Rest - an overview | ScienceDirect Topics
Bed rest is defined as a temporary state of limited physical activity, typically recommended for 1 to 2 days in cases of severe pain, with the understanding ...
[9]
Bed rest: a potentially harmful treatment needing more ... - PubMed
Background: Bed rest is not only used in the management of patients who are not able to mobilise, but is also prescribed as a treatment for a large number ...
[10]
Bed Rest During Pregnancy: Types, Reasons & Positions
Jan 14, 2025 · Bed rest is limiting your activity during pregnancy to improve your chances of a healthy birth. It's typically not a routine treatment ...
[11]
Making the most of Bed Rest - Miracle Babies
Definition: Bed rest is when your medical practitioner recommends you limit your activities, and spend time confined in bed. · Full bed rest · Partial bed rest ...
[12]
Bed rest: a potentially harmful treatment needing more careful ...
In 24 trials investigating bed rest following a medical procedure, no outcomes improved significantly and eight worsened significantly in some procedures ( ...
[13]
Bed rest during pregnancy: Get the facts - Mayo Clinic
Bed rest used to be tried on a regular basis to delay labor that had started early, called preterm labor, or to prevent a baby from being born too soon, called ...Missing: scope | Show results with:scope
[14]
The impact of extended bed rest on the musculoskeletal system in ...
Oct 9, 2015 · Prolonged immobility is harmful with rapid reductions in muscle mass, bone mineral density and impairment in other body systems evident within the first week ...
[15]
Skeletal muscle wasting with disuse atrophy is multi-dimensional
Mar 17, 2014 · Molecular signals such as myostatin/SMAD pathway, MAFbx, and MuRF1 E3 ligases of the ubiquitin proteasome pathway and IGF1-AKT-mTOR pathway are ...
[16]
Signaling mechanisms involved in disuse muscle atrophy - PubMed
NF-kappaB seems to be a key intracellular signal transducer in disuse atrophy. Factors such as myostatin, p38 and calcineurin can induce muscle protein loss ...
[17]
Disuse-induced muscle wasting - PubMed - NIH
This review will examine the current understanding of the molecular and cellular mechanisms regulating muscle loss under disuse conditions.
[18]
physiological effects of bed rest and restricted physical activity
Underlying physiological mechanisms include dramatic reductions in maximal stroke volume, cardiac output, and oxygen uptake. However, bed rest by itself does ...
[19]
Effects of Bed Rest on Physical Performance in Athletes
Jul 26, 2023 · Bed rest rapidly (within 3 days) decreases upright endurance exercise performance, likely due to a rapid loss in plasma volume.
[20]
Cardiac atrophy after bed rest and spaceflight
Thus bed rest deconditioning led to a remodeling (i.e., changes in cardiac morphology) of the heart first by changes in volume and secondarily via changes in ...
[21]
The impact of bed rest on human skeletal muscle metabolism
Jan 16, 2024 · Muscle glycogen build-up in bed rest reduces insulin sensitivity and further storage. Muscle lipid overload, lipotoxicity, and inflammation develop during bed ...
[22]
Muscle Atrophy Induced by Mechanical Unloading - PubMed
Mar 20, 2018 · This review aims to update the current state of knowledge and the underlying cellular mechanisms related to skeletal muscle loss during a variety of unloading ...
[23]
Cardiac, skeletal muscle and neuromuscular plasticity in disuse and ...
Jul 20, 2025 · Many of the deleterious muscle-level physiological responses attributed to ageing can be manifested by subjecting young, healthy adults to ...
[24]
The Edwin Smith Papyrus Sheds Light on Ancient Egyptian Medicine
Feb 4, 2025 · The care provider is instructed to put the injured person on bed rest and monitor them, particularly at the beginning when the patient is in ...
[25]
Egyptian Medical Treatments - World History Encyclopedia
Feb 20, 2017 · The common cold, for example, was prevalent, but one's symptoms would not have been treated with medicine and bed rest, or not these alone, but ...
[26]
Aphorisms by Hippocrates - The Internet Classics Archive
48. In every movement of the body, whenever one begins to endure pain, it will be relieved by rest. 49. Those who are accustomed to endure habitual labors, ...Missing: prescriptions | Show results with:prescriptions
[27]
The Evolution of Bed Rest as a Clinical Intervention - ScienceDirect
This article explores the history of bed rest as a clinical intervention and discusses the use of bed rest for pregnancy complications.
[28]
GALEN, Method of Medicine, Volume II | Loeb Classical Library
danger of inappropriate fasting and bed rest. That fevers change in kind due to inappropriate treatment, particularly excessive fasting, is recognized.
[29]
Anne Stiles, “The Rest Cure, 1873-1925”
This essay discusses the rest cure, a popular treatment for nervous illness pioneered by Philadelphia neurologist Silas Weir Mitchell in the 1860s and '70s.Missing: ancient | Show results with:ancient
[30]
The Rest Cure Revisited | American Journal of Psychiatry
May 1, 2007 · The patient was instructed to lie in bed for 24 hours each day, sometimes for months at a time, with a special nurse who would sleep on a cot in ...Missing: institutionalization | Show results with:institutionalization
[31]
'Rest or Go West'- The Forgotten Legacy of Silas Weir Mitchell (P6 ...
Apr 6, 2015 · Rest cure had three components: isolation, rest, and feeding, with electrotherapy and massage added to prevent muscle atrophy.
[32]
Go rest, young man - American Psychological Association
Jan 1, 2012 · This oppressive “cure” involved electrotherapy and massage, in addition to a meat-rich diet and weeks or months of bed rest. Historians now view ...Missing: institutionalization | Show results with:institutionalization
[33]
Bed rest: a sexist treatment that killed more than it cured
Jul 5, 2016 · Bed rest was mostly prescribed for women and became a popular treatment for hysteria, writes Muiris Houston.
[34]
Tuberculosis sanatorium treatment at the advent of the ...
Nov 11, 2020 · The discovery of antibiotics in the mid-twentieth century marked a major transition in tuberculosis (TB) treatment and control.<|separator|>
[35]
Tuberculosis sanatorium regimen in the 1940s: a patient's personal ...
The second part narrates the strict routine of sanatorium treatment for pulmonary tuberculosis in the 1940s before the introduction of streptomycin therapy.
[36]
ARMCHAIR TREATMENT OF ACUTE CORONARY THROMBOSIS
Levine SA, Lown B. "ARMCHAIR" TREATMENT OF ACUTE CORONARY THROMBOSIS. JAMA. 1952;148(16):1365–1369. doi:10.1001/jama.1952.02930160001001. Manage citations ...
[37]
Response to exercise after bed rest and after training - PubMed
Response to exercise after bed rest and after training. Circulation. 1968 Nov;38(5 Suppl):VII1-78. Authors. B Saltin, G Blomqvist, J H Mitchell, R L Johnson ...Missing: deconditioning | Show results with:deconditioning
[38]
The Physiology Associated With “Bed Rest” and Inactivity and ... - NIH
Mar 12, 2021 · With time, the negative impact of bed rest was recognized as a source of slow and even reduced patient healing. As treatment paradigms shifted, ...
[39]
Bed rest in singleton pregnancies for preventing preterm birth
Mar 30, 2015 · Authors' conclusions: There is no evidence, either supporting or refuting the use of bed rest at home or in hospital, to prevent preterm birth.
[40]
Bed rest in singleton pregnancies for preventing preterm birth
Mar 30, 2015 · Bed rest in hospital or at home is widely recommended for the prevention of preterm birth. This advice is based on the observation that hard ...Missing: labor efficacy
[41]
Will I need bed rest near the end of pregnancy? - ACOG
For most women, bed rest is not recommended. There is no scientific evidence that bed rest prevents preterm labor or reduces preeclampsia risk.
[42]
Lack of evidence for prescription of antepartum bed rest - PMC
The use of bed rest as a treatment in healthcare dates to the early 1900s [2]. However, during World War II, the value of bed rest began to be questioned as ...
[43]
Activity restriction for women with arrested preterm labor
However, there is no scientific evidence that bed rest reduces preterm birth.
[44]
Bed Rest During Pregnancy: Implications For Nursing - ScienceDirect
Evidence shows that bed rest affects pregnant women in the same manner. ... Muscle atrophy and weight loss are major side effects of bed rest during pregnancy.
[45]
Bed rest with and without hospitalisation in multiple pregnancy for ...
Mar 6, 2017 · Partial bed rest in hospital reduced the number of pregnant women developing high blood pressure (one trial, 141 women, low‐quality evidence) ...Missing: efficacy harms
[46]
The Treatment of Acute Low Back Pain — Bed Rest, Exercises, or ...
Feb 9, 1995 · Our controlled study of workers with acute low back pain suggests that avoiding bed rest and maintaining ordinary activity as tolerated lead to ...
[47]
The Cochrane review of bed rest for acute low back pain and sciatica
Conclusion: Bed rest compared with advice to stay active at best has no effect, and at worst may have slightly harmful effects on LBP. There is not an important ...
[48]
The updated cochrane review of bed rest for low back pain and ...
Conclusion: For people with acute low back pain, advice to rest in bed is less effective than advice to stay active. For patients with sciatica, there is little ...
[49]
Comparative Study on the Period of Absolute Bed Rest of Vertebral ...
In particular, bed rest can reduce the risk of bone resorption and secondary fracture25). It has been widely advised, but there are still no guidelines on its ...
[50]
Current Concepts in Rehabilitation Protocols to Optimize Patient ...
Traditional methods of rehabilitation following MSK trauma, including bed rest and prolonged immobilization, were detrimental to our patients' ability to return ...
[51]
What are the likely benefits and harms of non-medicine ... - Cochrane
Mar 27, 2025 · For people with acute/subacute low back pain, we found that advice to stay active probably reduces pain in the short term (i.e. up to 3 months) ...
[52]
Rest easy? Is bed rest really necessary after surgical repair of an ...
Bed rest with elevation of the affected limb is commonly prescribed postoperatively following ankle fracture fixation although there is no evidence that this is ...Missing: efficacy | Show results with:efficacy
[53]
Bed Rest Is Bad for Back Pain, Ineffective for Sciatica - AAFP
Jul 15, 2005 · Six trials consistently demonstrated that for patients with uncomplicated low back pain, bed rest was slightly worse than staying active for ...
[54]
Physical and Psychological Burden of Bed Rest on Patients ...
Jan 22, 2025 · Postoperative bed rest is considered essential after free flap reconstruction of the lower limb to ensure microsurgical success.
[55]
Bedrest After TKA Improves Recovery
Our study showed that bedrest during days 1–7 post-op, when done the right way, facilitates improved range of motion and leg control without increasing common ...
[56]
Consequences of bed rest - PubMed
Bed rest can cause several complications that may delay or prevent recovery from critical illnesses including disuse muscle atrophy, joint contractures.
[57]
Bed rest in health and critical illness: a body systems approach
Bed rest is a common intervention for critically ill adults. Associated with both benefits and adverse effects, bed rest is undergoing increasing scrutiny.
[58]
Consequences of bed rest - Critical Care Medicine
Bed rest can cause several complications that may delay or prevent recovery from critical illnesses including disuse muscle atrophy, joint contractures, ...
[59]
Bed rest in singleton pregnancies for preventing preterm birth - PMC
There is no evidence, either supporting or refuting the use of bed rest at home or in hospital, to prevent preterm birth.
[60]
Bed rest or normal activity for patients with acute low back pain
They were randomized into two treatment groups: one instructed to continue normal activity (insofar as the pain allowed), and the other prescribed 4 days of bed ...
[61]
Systematic reviews of bed rest and advice to stay active for acute ...
Consistent findings showed that bed rest is not an effective treatment for acute low back pain but may delay recovery.
[62]
Early ambulation versus prolonged bed rest for incidental ... - PubMed
Nov 22, 2023 · Early mobilization was associated with a lower incidence of pulmonary complications as compared with prolonged bed rest.Missing: post | Show results with:post
[63]
A systematic review and meta-analysis of the effects of... - Medicine
This systematic review and meta-analysis aims to assess the effects of early mobilization therapy for non-emergency cardiac surgery patients in the intensive ...
[64]
The Aging Muscle in Experimental Bed Rest: A Systematic Review ...
Overall, total lean body mass was decreased by 1.5 kg, while there was no relationship between bed rest duration and outcomes (Z = 0.423, p = 672). The meta- ...
[65]
Effects of strict prolonged bed rest on cardiorespiratory fitness
Although this is the first systematic review on the effects of prolonged bed rest on V̇o2max, the study is not without limitations. Metaregression analyses are ...
[66]
Bed rest in singleton pregnancies for preventing preterm birth
Mar 30, 2015 · This updated review finds no evidence to support or refute bed rest in preventing preterm birth. The current practice has been based on observational studies.
[67]
A meta-analysis of bed rest versus early ambulation in the ...
Aug 6, 2025 · Bed rest is often recommended as part of the management of deep vein thrombosis (DVT) and pulmonary embolism (PE), ...
[68]
Don't prescribe bed rest for acute localized back pain without ... - AAFP
Bed rest prescriptions should be limited to less than 48 hours in patients with non-traumatic acute localized low back pain in the absence of traditional red ...
[69]
Bed rest for acute low-back pain and sciatica - PubMed
Oct 18, 2004 · For people with acute LBP, advice to rest in bed is less effective than advice to stay active. For patients with sciatica, there is little or no difference.
[70]
Diagnosis and Treatment of Acute Low Back Pain - AAFP
Feb 15, 2012 · Bed rest should be avoided if possible. Exercises directed by a physical therapist, such as the McKenzie method and spine stabilization ...
[71]
Short versus prolonged bed rest after uncomplicated acute ...
A systematic review on brief vs prolonged bed rest after acute myocardial infarction without complications concluded that there is no evidence to support ...
[72]
When is the best time to mobilize patients after myocardial infarction ...
Although the benefits of bed rest in the acute phase ... Herkner H, Arrich J, Havel C, Mullner M. Bed rest for acute uncomplicated myocardial infarction.
[73]
Bed rest for acute uncomplicated myocardial infarction - PMC
1 Coronary thromboses (Thesaurus) 2 Myocardial infarctions (Thesaurus) 3 AMI 4 MI 5 Post‐infarction 6 Myocardial infarct* 7 Acute heart infarction* 8 Coronary ...
[74]
Nonuniform loss of muscle strength and atrophy during bed rest
Jul 1, 2021 · Bed rest results in nonuniform loss of isometric muscle strength and atrophy over time, where the magnitude of change was greater for muscle strength than for ...
[75]
Movement is muscle in hospitalized adults - ScienceDirect.com
Older adults lose muscle mass as they age, but immobile older adults lose up to 10 % of their muscle mass over the course of 7 days.6 Reduced muscle mass, ...
[76]
Disuse-Induced Muscle Loss and Rehabilitation - LWW
Conclusions: Bed rest results in upper and lower leg muscle atrophy in a linear pattern, and an 11-day rehabilitation program was safe and effective in ...Missing: musculoskeletal | Show results with:musculoskeletal
[77]
One Week of Bed Rest Leads to Substantial Muscle Atrophy and ...
Jun 29, 2016 · In this study, we demonstrate that short-term bed rest leads to skeletal muscle atrophy, pronounced whole-body insulin resistance, and a decline ...
[78]
Human Skeletal Muscle Disuse Atrophy: Effects on Muscle Protein ...
Aug 24, 2016 · Immobilization also induces muscle insulin resistance (IR). Moreover, the trajectory of muscle atrophy appears to be accelerated in persistent ...
[79]
https://www.ahajournals.org/doi/full/10.1161/01.cir.96.2.517
[80]
Effects of Prolonged Head-Down Bed Rest on Cardiac and Vascular ...
Aug 23, 2019 · We hypothesized that prolonged bed rest deconditioning alters overall baroreceptor functioning, thereby reducing orthostatic tolerance in healthy volunteers.
[81]
https://journals.physiology.org/doi/full/10.1152/japplphysiol.00415.2017
[82]
The Detrimental Effects of Bedrest: Premature Cardiovascular Aging ...
Bedrest as an experimental paradigm or as an in-patient stay for medical reasons has negative consequences for cardiovascular health.
[83]
Bed-rest-induced insulin resistance occurs primarily in muscle
Six to seven days of strict bed rest resulted in moderate deterioration in oral glucose tolerance and increased both fasting plasma insulin concentration and ...Missing: syndrome | Show results with:syndrome
[84]
60-day bed rest study shows dangers of long-term inactivity for ...
Feb 20, 2023 · A new study from the University of Bath, published today, shows that long-term inactivity significantly increases blood sugar levels even if you reduce your ...<|separator|>
[85]
The effect of 8 days of strict bed rest on the incretin effect in healthy ...
Physical inactivity and bed rest induce changes resembling metabolic syndrome, including increased amounts of visceral fat, insulin resistance, and low-grade ...
[86]
Risk Factors for Venous Thromboembolism | Circulation
Gibbs found that 15% of patients on bed rest for <1 week before death had venous thrombosis at autopsy, whereas the incidence rose to 80% in patients in bed for ...
[87]
Bed Rest versus Early Ambulation with Standard Anticoagulation in ...
Compared to bed rest, early ambulation of acute DVT patients with anticoagulation was not associated with a higher incidence of new PE, progression of DVT, and ...Missing: thromboembolism | Show results with:thromboembolism
[88]
A meta-analysis of bed rest versus early ambulation in the ...
Compared with bed rest, early ambulation of patients with DVT, PE or both, was not associated with a higher risk of progression of DVT, new PE or death.
[89]
Original Article Short-Term Bed Rest is not a Risk Factor for Venous ...
Short-term bed rest after EEA is not a risk factor for development of VTE in the immediate postoperative period.
[90]
Effects of 15-Days −6° Head-Down Bed Rest on the Attention Bias ...
Jun 26, 2022 · The results of previous studies have found that the subjects' self-reported negative emotions such as anxiety and depression increase during bed ...
[91]
SPIRITUAL WELL-BEING, ANXIETY, AND DEPRESSION IN ...
Jul 9, 2009 · The researchers expected and found that women on bedrest had the highest levels of anxiety and depression and had the lowest level of SWB. ...Missing: evidence | Show results with:evidence<|separator|>
[92]
Effects of Head-Down Bed Rest on the Executive Functions and ...
Our results provide some evidence for a detrimental effect of prolonged bed rest on executive functioning and positive affect.
[93]
Prevalence, severity, and nature of preventable patient harm across ...
Jul 17, 2019 · We define 'deconditioning syndrome' as the syndrome of physical, psychological and functional decline that occurs as a result of prolonged bed ...
[94]
28 day bed-rest with hypercortisolemia induces peripheral insulin ...
Among these hormonal alterations, hypercortisolemia and insulin insensitivity are thought to negatively affect muscle mass and function with spaceflight. As ...
[95]
Effects of bedrest 3: gastrointestinal, endocrine and nervous systems
Jan 21, 2019 · It remains unclear whether bedrest alone is responsible for increased cortisol levels; some studies report a continuous increase in cortisol ...
[96]
[PDF] Effects of bedrest 4: renal, reproductive and immune systems
Prolonged bedrest may reduce libido and, in women, disrupt the menstrual cycle. It is also likely to weaken the immune response, increasing the risk of ...
[97]
Long-Term Bed Rest Delays the Circadian Phase of Core Body ...
May 9, 2021 · Psychological stress markers are significantly increased after one week of HDBR compared to before bed rest (Rai and Kaur, 2011).
[98]
Let's change our behaviors: From bed rest and heavy sedation to ...
Several trials suggest that early mobilization is feasible and result in shorter ICU and hospital length of stay.[3,4] What are the barriers to implementing ...
[99]
Early Mobilization for Critically Ill Patients - PMC - NIH
Some authors believe that mobilization should be implemented as soon as possible in critically ill patients (within 24–72 h of ICU admission) to prevent muscle ...
[100]
Early Mobilization and Rehabilitation in the ICU: Moving Back to the ...
In modern day critical care, bed rest is common practice, especially for mechanically ventilated patients, with increasingly recognized short- and long-term ...
[101]
Mobilizing Progress: A Comprehensive Review of the Efficacy ... - NIH
Apr 4, 2024 · During the 1990s, a significant paradigm shift unfolded in ICU ... ICU early mobilization: movement, not rest, may be key to recovery.
[102]
Impact of an early mobilization protocol on the reduction of medical ...
Mar 17, 2023 · Early mobilization after cSDH surgery reduced medical complications (19.2%) compared to 48-hour bed rest (34.6%), without increasing recurrence.
[103]
Move to Improve: The Feasibility of Using an Early Mobility Protocol ...
The purpose of this study was to determine the effectiveness of a nurse-driven mobility protocol to increase the percentage of patients ambulating during the ...
[104]
Nurse-Driven Early Mobility Protocols: Facilitator Guide - AHRQ
The use of an early mobility protocol should minimize complications of bed rest, improve patients' overall functions, promote ventilator weaning in a timely ...<|separator|>
[105]
Guideline on positioning and early mobilisation in the critically ill by ...
Jul 29, 2024 · A guideline to support healthcare providers in implementing positioning and early mobilisation for critically ill adult patients in the ICU.
[106]
Early mobilization in enhanced recovery after surgery pathways
Early mobilization reduces the risk of postoperative complications, accelerates the recovery of functional walking capacity, positively impacts several patient ...
[107]
Early Mobilization in the ICU - ScienceDirect.com
Early mobilization (EM) has emerged as an intervention to help prevent or to mitigate ICU-AW, or both, and to improve functional outcomes for patients.
[108]
Effect of a generalized early mobilization and rehabilitation protocol ...
Jul 30, 2025 · This result suggests that recovery of physical function may increase the proportion of home discharge in trauma patients admitted to the ICU.
[109]
Running vs. resistance exercise to counteract deconditioning ...
This study aimed to compare the effectiveness of two exercise countermeasure programs, running and resistance training, applied separately, for counteracting ...
[110]
Bed Rest And Skeletal Muscle - Physiopedia
Muscle atrophy (sarcopenia) and muscle strength losses occur very quickly with prolonged bed rest. Hospitalization of ≤5 days, referring to disuse/ ...
[111]
Systematic review of the effectiveness of standalone passive ...
Apr 25, 2024 · Overall, standalone passive countermeasures showed no significant effect in maintaining 159 unique outcome measures close to their pre-bed rest ...
[112]
The effects of bed rest on cardiac and muscle-pump baroreflexes
Feb 8, 2024 · Orthostatic intolerance is often observed in individuals after prolonged inactivity that occurs during bed rest or spaceflight.
[113]
Introduction and Evidence for Early Mobility: A Protocol To Get ...
This module provides an introduction to and the evidence behind early mobility. We will also discuss establishing a protocol for getting the patients out of bed ...
[114]
Early Mobility Index and Patient Outcomes: A Retrospective Study in ...
May 1, 2024 · Early mobility interventions in intensive care units (ICUs) are safe and improve outcomes in subsets of critically ill adults.
[115]
The effects of rehabilitation on the muscles of the trunk following ...
The aim of this study was to determine the effectiveness of two commonly adopted rehabilitation programs on recovery of size of the trunk muscles and changes ...
[116]
Effectiveness of nutritional countermeasures in microgravity and its ...
Jun 9, 2020 · A systematic review was performed to evaluate the effectiveness of nutrition as a standalone countermeasure to ameliorate the physiological ...<|separator|>
[117]
Core Components of Cardiac Rehabilitation Programs: 2024 Update
Sep 24, 2024 · Programs must include physician prescribed exercise, cardiac risk factor modification, psychosocial assessment, and outcomes assessment. Each ...
[118]
The Effects of Reconditioning Exercises Following Prolonged Bed ...
This study showed that both 2 weeks of reconditioning programs following 60 days of HDT bed rest were insufficient to restore all volumes of lumbopelvic muscles ...
[119]
Bedrest: Implications for the Aging Population - Pharmacy Times
13 Jan 2011 · In the late 1800s, alienists (psychiatrists) began to prescribe bedrest frequently. The thought was that making “asylums” look more like regular ...
[120]
Problems Due to Bed Rest - Special Subjects - Merck Manuals
Problems Due to Bed Rest · Blood clots · Constipation · Depression · Pressure sores · Weak bones · Weak muscles and stiff joints · Prevention of Problems Due to Bed ...<|separator|>
[121]
Prolonged Bed Rest Care Plans: 8 Nursing Diagnosis - Nurseslabs
Oct 27, 2024 · However, prolonged bed rest may have deleterious effects on the cardiovascular, respiratory, musculoskeletal, integumentary, and cognitive ...
[122]
Limit Bed Rest For Back Pain | Summit Orthopedics
Dec 21, 2015 · Limit bed rest to short periods of time. Use rest for a few hours when you need a break from severe pain. When you are in bed, ease the ...
[123]
[PDF] Bed Rest Guidelines | UW Medicine
Use the toilet as usual. Emptying your bladder often can help decrease uterine irritability. Spend only short times on the toilet.Missing: scope | Show results with:scope<|separator|>
[124]
Walking 25 mins enough to counter impact of bedrest on older ...
Aug 3, 2023 · As little as 25 minutes a day of slow walking seems to be enough to counter the detrimental physical effects of bedrest on older hospital patients.
[125]
Effects of Preoperative Mobilization Education Using the Teach ...
May 29, 2025 · This study aimed to determine the effects of preoperative mobilization education enhanced with the Teach‐Back method on postoperative mobilization, recovery, ...
[126]
Learning About Getting Moving After Surgery - MyHealth Alberta
Using your muscles as soon as you can after surgery can help you recover. It may help prevent problems that you can have from staying in the hospital too long.
[127]
Bed Rest Complications: How to Prevent and Why - HealthXchange.sg
Prolonged bed rest can lead to a depressed mood, anxiety and loss of appetite for the patient. However, loved ones can help to lift the patient's spirits.
[128]
[PDF] Top 10 tips for bed rest
plan an individualised, 24 hour pressure management plan to avoid prolonged bedrest. •. Review the need for bed rest with your team every. 2 weeks. •. Talk to ...
[129]
Age‐dependent effects of bed rest in human skeletal muscle
However, overwhelming evidence from clinical trials proved the contrary by showing that even short periods of bed rest can lead to serious complications ...
[130]
Prescription of activity restriction to treat high-risk pregnancies
Results reveal that bed rest was prescribed extensively (89%-93%), but few any physical and psychologic side effects.Missing: rates | Show results with:rates
[131]
Bed Rest in Pregnancy - Bigelow - 2011 - Wiley Online Library
Mar 21, 2011 · The use of bed rest in medicine dates back to Hippocrates, who first recommended bed rest as a restorative measure for pain.
[132]
Does 48 hours' bed rest influence the outcome of acute low back pain?
Background: Bed rest is a traditional treatment for back pain, yet only in recent years has the therapeutic benefit of this been questioned.Missing: doctors | Show results with:doctors
[133]
Bed rest for back pain? A little bit will do you. - Harvard Health
Jan 24, 2017 · Bed rest, once a key part of treating back pain, has a limited role in healing sore backs. In very small doses, bed rest can give you a break.
[134]
How many days of bed rest for acute low back pain? Objective ...
However, the optimal duration of bed rest is still being discussed. The recommended periods vary from 2 days to 2 weeks.
[135]
Why Bed Rest May Not Be the Best Prescription - Lamaze International
Mar 12, 2012 · Yet, our statistics show that bed rest is not improving outcomes nor making any dent whatsoever in maternal or infant mortality. Everyday I read ...Missing: surveys rates
[136]
Perceived acceptability and preferences for low-intensity early ...
Feb 20, 2018 · Studies have found older patients to spend between 71% and 83% of their time in hospital lying down [3,4,5], with up to 40% remaining in bed for ...<|separator|>
[137]
Female hysteria: The history of a controversial 'condition'
13 Oct 2020 · Rest cure involved lots of bed rest and strict avoidance of all physical and intellectual activity. Mitchell prescribed this treatment ...
[138]
The Literature of Prescription: The Woman Question
Mar 25, 2024 · Charlotte Perkins Gilman consulted nervous diseases specialist Dr. Silas Weir Mitchell for treatment during her unhappy marriage. As one of many ...
[139]
The 'Father of American Neurology' Prescribed Women Months of ...
Sep 28, 2018 · But according to Dr. Silas Weir Mitchell, his strict “rest cure” regimen had her on the mend. By the end of the month, she'd gained 40 pounds ...
[140]
Bedrest Is Bunk - The Atlantic
Aug 6, 2018 · There's little to no evidence to show that restricting pregnant women's activity has any benefits—so why do doctors still prescribe it?<|separator|>
[141]
Rethinking Bed Rest For Pregnancy - NPR
Nov 26, 2018 · Research indicates bed rest does not improve birth outcomes and can be risky for the mom. So why is it still prescribed by many doctors and ...
[142]
"Therapeutic" bed rest in pregnancy: unethical and unsupported by ...
Prescribing bed rest is inconsistent with the ethical principles of autonomy, beneficence, and justice. Hence, if bed rest is to be used, it should be only ...
[143]
Bed Rest, When Used for Anything Other Than Sleep Has no...
Jan 27, 2012 · The bed rest cure was initially indicated for those suffering 'nervous injuries and maladies' as a result of fighting in the Civil War. Later, ...Missing: origins | Show results with:origins
[144]
Back to Kindergarten? Paternalistic Care Behavior in Healthcare ...
Paternalism in healthcare, characterized by overprotection and limited communication, undermines shared decision-making and patient autonomy, which are crucial ...
[145]
The Evolution of Bed Rest as a Clinical Intervention - ResearchGate
Aug 10, 2025 · Bed rest as a therapy can be traced back to Hippocrates and has been used for many types of illnesses since then. It is still commonly used ...