Break Every Rule
Break Every Rule is the sixth solo studio album by American singer Tina Turner, released in September 1986 by Capitol Records.[1] Serving as the follow-up to her critically acclaimed 1984 album Private Dancer, it features a mix of rock, pop, and soul tracks produced by a team including Terry Britten and Graham Lyle, with songwriting contributions from notable artists such as David Bowie, Mark Knopfler, and Bryan Adams.[2] The album includes eleven tracks, among them the hit singles "Typical Male", which reached number two on the US Billboard Hot 100, and "What You Get Is What You See", peaking at number thirteen.[3] Other notable songs feature guest appearances and collaborations, such as Steve Winwood on keyboards for "Back Where You Started", which earned Turner a Grammy Award for Best Female Rock Vocal Performance in 1987.[2] Commercially, Break Every Rule was a major success, debuting at number four on the US Billboard 200 chart and certified platinum by the RIAA for sales exceeding one million copies in the United States.[4] In the United Kingdom, it peaked at number two on the Official Albums Chart, spending 49 weeks in the top 100 and earning platinum certification for 300,000 units sold.[5] Globally, the album topped charts in Germany and Switzerland, achieving over three million sales worldwide and solidifying Turner's status as a pop-rock icon during the 1980s.[4] It also supported Turner's Break Every Rule World Tour, one of the highest-grossing tours of 1987–1988.[2]Background and development
Conception
Following the monumental success of her 1984 album Private Dancer, which sold over 12 million copies worldwide and established Turner as a global superstar, Tina Turner sought to capitalize on this momentum by crafting a follow-up that delved deeper into rock-oriented sounds while preserving broad pop accessibility.[6] This direction reflected her desire to honor her rock 'n' roll roots from her earlier career while ensuring the material appealed to a mainstream audience, avoiding a strict repetition of Private Dancer's blueprint.[7] The conception of Break Every Rule began in early 1985, shortly after Turner's triumphant world tour for Private Dancer, as she collaborated closely with songwriters and producers to shape a bold vision. Key influences included producers Terry Britten and Rupert Hine, who emphasized an experimental "break every rule" ethos in song selection, prioritizing tracks that showcased Turner's vocal power and allowed for creative reinterpretation over conventional structures. Britten, reuniting with songwriter Graham Lyle—the team behind Private Dancer's hit "What's Love Got to Do with It"—co-wrote and produced five tracks, insisting that every song must stand as a potential single to match Turner's elevated status.[7] Hine, handling three songs including the title track, encouraged Turner to personalize demos by singing along at home until she "owned" them, fostering a process of bold experimentation that captured her live performance energy in one-take recordings.[8] Turner actively rejected several demo tracks that failed to align with this ambitious scope, such as those lacking the necessary drive or innovation, ensuring the album's cohesive yet daring profile.[7] Central to the album's conceptual foundation was Turner's insistence on themes of empowerment and resilience, drawn directly from her experiences escaping her abusive relationship with Ike Turner in 1976. Having rebuilt her career on narratives of independence in Private Dancer and her 1986 autobiography I, Tina, she infused Break Every Rule with a defiant spirit, selecting and shaping material that symbolized breaking free from past constraints and asserting personal agency.[9][10] This focus not only guided lyrical choices but also influenced production decisions, with Britten and Hine tailoring arrangements to amplify Turner's commanding presence and narrative of triumph.[7]Recording sessions
The recording sessions for Tina Turner's sixth solo album, Break Every Rule, spanned from 1985 to 1986, reflecting a collaborative effort across multiple locations and production teams to capture her evolving pop-rock sound following the success of Private Dancer. Primary tracking for the album's first six tracks occurred at Mayfair Studios in London, where engineer John Hudson worked closely with producers to layer live instrumentation and Turner's vocals, emphasizing a balance between organic energy and polished arrangements. The remaining tracks were recorded at Studio Grand Armée in Paris, allowing Turner to complete her vocal performances in a focused environment away from the main rhythm section sessions.[11] Terry Britten, returning from his work on Private Dancer, handled production duties for six tracks, including the lead single "Typical Male" and the David Bowie-written song "Girls." Britten's approach prioritized minimalistic production to spotlight Turner's vocal delivery, incorporating electric guitars and drum machines during initial demos before enhancing with live elements for rhythmic drive. He guided Turner through her vocal takes, which she completed in approximately two hours per song, focusing on intimate phrasing to convey emotional depth without excessive overdubs. This efficiency stemmed from Britten's pre-recorded guide vocals and demos, which Turner used to interpret the material, though she initially expressed reservations about some songs' pop leanings before committing to the sessions.[7] Rupert Hine contributed to the album's second half, producing "Back Where You Started" and co-writing and producing the title track "Break Every Rule," where he handled most instrumentation and backing vocals to create atmospheric arrangements blending synthesizers with rock edges. Hine's involvement was facilitated by Turner's admiration for his production on The Fixx's albums, leading to a seamless integration of his style into her project; he aimed for dynamic builds that complemented her powerful range, using layered percussion and guitars to evoke a sense of urgency. The sessions faced logistical hurdles, including coordinating guest musicians like Steve Winwood, who provided keyboards for "Afterglow" amid his busy schedule, but these contributions added distinctive solos that enhanced the track's danceable groove without derailing the overall timeline.[12][13] Overall, the production emphasized live band interplay over heavy reliance on synthesizers, with Britten and Hine opting for raw, energetic recordings—such as real drum kits and guitar riffs—to maintain momentum during extended sessions that wrapped by mid-1986 for the September release. This hands-on process, involving multiple producers like Mark Knopfler and Neil Dorfsman for "Overnight Sensation," ensured variety while adhering to Capitol Records' vision for a rule-breaking follow-up.[7]Musical content
Composition and style
Break Every Rule blends pop rock, synth-pop, and soul elements, drawing on 1980s new wave and R&B influences to create a dynamic sound that emphasizes Turner's vocal prowess. The album features prominent synthesizers and keyboards, providing a sleek, electronic texture, alongside guitar-driven rhythms that add rock edge and funk accents. Turner's powerhouse vocals dominate, often layered with harmonies for depth and intensity, while the production incorporates live band energy to balance studio polish with raw performance feel.[13][14][15] Key tracks showcase varied tempos and keys, highlighting the album's experimental arrangements. For instance, the title track "Break Every Rule" is an upbeat pop song at 124 BPM in E♭ major, featuring driving guitar riffs and synth swells that propel its danceable rhythm. Similarly, "Afterglow" employs synth-driven melodies for a soulful, atmospheric vibe, while "Overnight Sensation" leans into guitar-led rockabilly with contributions from Mark Knopfler on guitar. These elements reflect a deliberate mix of formats, from ballads to hard rock, tailored for broad radio appeal.[16][14][17] Compared to the rock-leaning introspection of Private Dancer, Break Every Rule evolves toward more danceable, rule-breaking experimentation, incorporating broader collaborations with artists like Phil Collins on drums and Bryan Adams on guitar and piano. This shift amplifies the album's AOR and pop accessibility, prioritizing confident, mature delivery over narrative legend-building, while retaining gospel-charged soul roots in Turner's raspy, emotive singing. The result is a potent fusion of rock energy and synth-infused grooves that underscores Turner's artistic autonomy.[14][18][19]Lyrics and themes
The lyrics of Break Every Rule revolve around themes of empowerment, independence, and sensuality, reflecting Tina Turner's ongoing personal reinvention as a resilient artist post-abuse and career resurgence. The album portrays a "tough girl" archetype, as Turner described it, emphasizing self-reliance and defiance in navigating love and societal norms.[20][21] Co-writers significantly shaped these messages, often through narratives challenging relational dynamics. In "Typical Male," penned by Terry Britten and [Graham Lyle](/page/Graham Lyle), Turner embodies a woman employing her allure to sway a detached lawyer, critiquing gender stereotypes with lines like "All I want is a little reaction, just enough to tip the scales / I'm just using my female attraction on a typical male." This highlights female agency and the predictability of male behavior, blending humor with pointed social commentary.[22][23] Tonal shifts range from bold, anthemic declarations to reflective introspection, employing straightforward rhyme schemes and vivid metaphors to convey emotional depth. The rock-driven "Back Where You Started," co-written by Bryan Adams and Jim Vallance, uses cyclical imagery of emotional resets—such as "You'll never get another chance again, you'll be back where you started / I know you won't admit it but you're broken-hearted"—to assert independence after heartbreak, with an AABB rhyme structure amplifying its confrontational edge. In contrast, the sensual ballad "Afterglow," also by Britten and Lyle, evokes intimacy through metaphors of light and guidance, as in "I need you here beside me to chase the night away / I need your love to guide me safe through another day," revealing vulnerability beneath the empowerment.[24][25][26][27] These elements culminate in the album's title track, co-written by Rupert Hine and Jeannette Obstoj, where lyrics of distant longing—"Every road that I walk, every single flight I ever take / Though I'm thousands of miles away, in my mind every journey leads me closer to you"—symbolize breaking relational and personal rules, fostering rebellion against constraints for authentic self-expression.[28][20]Release and promotion
Singles
The lead single from Break Every Rule, "Typical Male", was released in August 1986 to launch the album's promotion, featuring bold, empowering lyrics about gender stereotypes set to a synth-driven rock beat. The single's artwork depicted Tina Turner in a confident pose against a stark background, emphasizing her commanding presence, while the B-side was the non-album track "Don't Turn Around", a soulful ballad later popularized by other artists. It peaked at No. 2 on the Billboard Hot 100, establishing the album's commercial momentum through its radio airplay and music video directed by Brian Grant, which showcased Turner in dynamic office dance sequences blending performance art with high-energy choreography.[29][30][31] Subsequent singles built on this foundation with varied release strategies to target international markets. "Two People", issued in October 1986, paired the album track with "Don't Turn Around" as its B-side in several regions, including a limited edition double 12-inch pack with live recordings for enhanced collectibility; its music video highlighted intimate duet-style visuals, promoting the song's theme of connection. "What You Get Is What You See", released in January 1987 in the US and February in Europe, featured a live version of itself as the B-side on some pressings and an extended rock mix on others, with artwork mirroring the album's vibrant aesthetic; the accompanying video, directed with a focus on Turner's guitar-driven performance alongside Eric Clapton, underscored the track's country-rock fusion and drove targeted TV promotions like the American Music Awards appearance.[32][33][34] The title track "Break Every Rule" followed in April 1987 as the fifth single, with a B-side cover of Al Green's "Take Me to the River" that added a gospel-infused edge, and its artwork incorporated tour footage elements for cross-promotional synergy. The music video, directed by David Mallet, intercut studio performance with live clips from the emerging world tour, capturing Turner's rule-breaking energy and amplifying the single's role in sustaining album visibility. "Girls", released in February 1987 primarily in Europe, used "Take Me to the River" (extended version) and remixes as B-sides, with regional variations including bundled live tracks; its video portrayed female solidarity through playful, ensemble scenes, targeting markets like the UK where it received heavy radio push. These releases, often with unique remixes or non-album B-sides, highlighted the album's diverse styles and contributed to its global reach without overlapping broader marketing efforts.[35][36][37][38]Marketing and packaging
Break Every Rule was released on September 8, 1986, by Capitol Records in the United States, with a slightly earlier rollout in Europe on September 5 in select markets. The album debuted in standard formats including 12-inch vinyl LP, audio cassette, and compact disc, reflecting the transitional era of music consumption in the mid-1980s. Some international variants, such as certain European pressings on EMI labels, featured gatefold sleeves or club-exclusive editions with additional liner notes.[13][39] The album's packaging emphasized bold visual aesthetics, with cover art designed by the London-based creative agency Stylorouge. The front artwork prominently displays Tina Turner posed confidently in a striking red dress against a minimalist background, capturing her empowered stage persona. Inner sleeves in vinyl editions typically included full lyrics, production credits, and black-and-white photography, while CD jewel cases followed similar design elements for consistency across formats. Certain regional releases, particularly in the UK and Australia, incorporated promotional inserts like printed lyric booklets or artist interviews to enhance collector appeal.[40][41] Capitol's marketing strategy focused on leveraging Turner's post-Private Dancer momentum through targeted media exposure, prioritizing television and radio to reach pop and adult contemporary listeners. Turner made key promotional appearances on flagship music programs, including performances of the lead single "Typical Male" on the BBC's Top of the Pops, which helped build pre-release buzz across Europe. Radio campaigns emphasized airplay on adult contemporary stations, where "Typical Male" quickly gained traction, positioning the album as a continuation of Turner's crossover success. International efforts varied, with European promotions featuring earlier single releases and localized advertising in music magazines, while U.S. strategies integrated tie-ins with broader pop media outlets.[42]Break Every Rule World Tour
The Break Every Rule World Tour served as the primary live promotion for Tina Turner's sixth solo studio album, spanning from March 4, 1987, to March 30, 1988, and encompassing over 200 concerts across Europe, North America, Asia, South America, and Australia.[43] The itinerary featured five legs, with 91 performances in Europe, 78 in North America, 6 in South America, 22 in Australia, and 12 in Asia, drawing massive crowds and breaking attendance records in multiple countries.[44] Sponsored by Pepsi, the tour showcased Turner's high-energy performances and established her as one of the era's top live acts, grossing approximately $60 million worldwide.[43] The production emphasized theatricality, with elaborate stage setups, frequent costume changes, and dynamic lighting to highlight Turner's commanding stage presence and the album's themes of empowerment and resilience. The touring band consisted of James Ralston on guitars and vocals, Jack Bruno on drums, Bob Feit on bass and vocals, Laurie Wisefield on guitar, Don Snow on keyboards, saxophone, and vocals, Steve Scales on percussion, and backing vocalists including Tessa Niles.[45] Although specific stage designer credits for this outing are not widely documented, the tour built on the innovative designs from Turner's prior productions, incorporating elements like tiered platforms and visual effects to enhance the rock-soul spectacle.[46] Setlists varied slightly by region but typically opened strongly with album tracks to set an upbeat tone, beginning with "What You Get Is What You See" followed immediately by the title song "Break Every Rule." Highlights included medleys blending new material like "Typical Male" and "Two People" with older hits such as "What's Love Got to Do with It," "Private Dancer," and "Proud Mary," often extending into high-octane covers like "I Can't Stand the Rain" and "The Acid Queen." These arrangements allowed for seamless transitions and audience engagement, with Turner incorporating improvisational flair and dance routines to maintain momentum over two-hour shows. Notable events underscored the tour's success, including seven consecutive sold-out performances at London's Wembley Arena from June 11 to 18, 1987, which captivated over 90,000 fans and reinforced Turner's popularity in the UK. The trek also achieved financial benchmarks, exceeding $50 million in gross revenue and ranking as the highest-earning female-led tour of the 1980s, while setting a Guinness World Record for the largest paying audience at a solo concert with 180,000 attendees at Rio de Janeiro's Maracanã Stadium on January 16, 1988.[43]Commercial performance
Chart performance
Break Every Rule performed strongly on international music charts upon its release, reaching the top ten in multiple countries and demonstrating Tina Turner's continued global appeal following Private Dancer. The album's chart success was driven by the popularity of its lead singles, particularly "Typical Male," which propelled it up the rankings in key markets.| Chart (1986) | Peak Position | Weeks on Chart |
|---|---|---|
| Australian Albums (Kent Music Report) | 11 | — |
| Canada Top Albums/CDs (RPM) | 4 | — |
| German Albums (Offizielle Top 100) | 1 | 61 |
| UK Albums (OCC) | 2 | 49 |
| US Billboard 200 | 4 | 52 |
Sales and certifications
Break Every Rule achieved significant commercial success, selling over 5 million copies worldwide within its first year of release and exceeding 6 million copies by 1988. In the United States, the album surpassed 1 million in sales and was certified platinum by the RIAA for shipments of 1 million units.[52][53][54] The album received various certifications across regions, reflecting its strong performance. In the United Kingdom, it was certified platinum by the BPI, equivalent to 300,000 units shipped. Canada awarded 2× platinum certification for 200,000 units, while Germany certified it 2× platinum for 1,000,000 units, and Australia certified it gold for approximately 70,000 units sold. These figures were drawn from official reports by the RIAA, BPI, Music Canada, BVMI, and ARIA.[4][2][55] A regional breakdown highlights the album's global reach: North America accounted for over 1.2 million certified units (primarily US at 1 million and Canada at 200,000), Europe exceeded 1.5 million (led by Germany at 1 million and the UK at 600,000), and other markets like Australia contributed additional gold-level sales. Estimates from BPI and RIAA reports indicate steady accumulation, with Europe representing the largest share due to Turner's popularity there.[4][52] Long-term sales trends showed sustained interest, with additional certifications in the 1990s stemming from catalog reissues and compilations boosting visibility. For instance, Austria upgraded to 2× platinum in 1993 for 100,000 units, and similar updates occurred in several European countries as streaming and remasters revived demand in the digital era, including a 2022 deluxe edition release. This enduring appeal contributed to total worldwide sales estimates reaching over 6 million copies.[4][52][1]Critical reception
Initial reviews
Upon its release in September 1986, Break Every Rule received generally positive reviews from critics, who praised Tina Turner's commanding vocal presence and the album's high production values, though some noted its reliance on a familiar pop-rock formula that prioritized commercial appeal over bold artistic innovation.[56] In a review for Rolling Stone, Dave Marsh highlighted Turner's vocal energy and rock edge, writing that she "sounds as if she had the time, guidance and confidence to really master these songs," delivering a potent performance across the record, but contrasted this with critiques of its overproduced, formulaic nature, observing that it "obeys every rule set by Private Dancer, and slavishly," without deeper creative risks.[56] Billboard's coverage in its September 27, 1986, issue echoed this balance, with the Album Spotlights section describing the material as "so-so" yet the production as "class A," positioning the album as a solid follow-up to Private Dancer and spotlighting "Typical Male" as a standout track already in the top 20. In the magazine's Rhythm & Blues review, Nelson George commended Turner's "husky, controlled sensuality" on midtempo pop-R&B cuts like "Typical Male," which he noted for its sass and urban appeal, while praising her supple delivery on "Paradise Is Here," backed by Branford Marsalis's soprano sax, and predicting the soulful tracks would drive the biggest hits despite her stated shift toward rock.[57] Contemporary publications such as NME and Cash Box provided additional coverage of the album's immediate impact in 1986-1987, focusing on its polished sound and Turner's enduring charisma.[13]Retrospective commentary
In the decades following its release, Break Every Rule has garnered renewed appreciation for its bold fusion of rock and soul, highlighting Tina Turner's resilience and artistic evolution. Critics in the 21st century have praised the album's production, which captures the glossy yet energetic 1980s sound while underscoring themes of female empowerment through tracks like "Typical Male" and "Girls." For instance, a 2023 review of the deluxe reissue in Classic Pop Magazine praised the high-energy performances and collaborations with artists like Phil Collins, Steve Winwood, Mark Knopfler, and Bryan Adams, highlighting tracks such as "Girls" and "Two People" for their quality despite the album not matching the commercial success of Private Dancer.[14] The album's legacy extends to its influence on subsequent generations of performers, particularly in crafting empowerment anthems that blend vulnerability with strength. Beyoncé has frequently credited Turner as a pivotal inspiration, describing her as "the ultimate" embodiment of resilience in a 2008 Grammy performance context and later paying tribute to her as a "beloved queen" whose work shaped modern expressions of female power.[58] The 2022 deluxe reissue, featuring remastered tracks, bonus material, and live recordings from the era, revitalized interest in the album's role in Turner's career trajectory. Publications like Liverpool Sound and Vision acclaimed it with an 8.5/10 rating, emphasizing how it pushed boundaries by solidifying Turner's transition from R&B roots to global rock stardom while showcasing her unyielding stage presence.[18] Following Turner's death on May 24, 2023, the album continued to be highlighted in posthumous releases, such as the 2023 compilation Queen of Rock 'n' Roll, which includes tracks from Break Every Rule and underscores its place in her enduring legacy. A 2024 review of the reissue further noted the strong audio quality of the live recordings, appreciating how they capture Turner's dynamic stage energy.[59][60] Academic analyses further illuminate the album's cultural significance, positioning it as a cornerstone in the rock-soul fusion pioneered by African American women artists. In Maureen Mahon's 2020 book Black Diamond Queens: African American Women and Rock and Roll, a dedicated chapter explores Turner's "turn to rock" in the 1980s, including Break Every Rule, as a revolutionary act that challenged racial and gender barriers in music, blending soul's emotional intensity with rock's rebellious edge to broaden the genre's inclusivity.[61] This fusion not only amplified Turner's voice but also paved the way for diverse artists to claim space in rock traditions historically dominated by white male performers.Track listing and credits
Standard track listing
The standard edition of Break Every Rule, released in 1986 by Capitol Records, consists of eleven tracks across two sides of the vinyl LP (or equivalent on CD/cassette formats). The track listing is as follows, with songwriters and primary producers credited per track.[39]| No. | Title | Writer(s) | Producer(s) | Duration |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Typical Male | Terry Britten, Graham Lyle | Terry Britten | 4:18 |
| 2 | What You Get Is What You See | Terry Britten, Graham Lyle | Terry Britten | 4:31 |
| 3 | Two People | Terry Britten, Graham Lyle | Terry Britten | 4:11 |
| 4 | Till the Right Man Comes Along | Terry Britten, Graham Lyle | Terry Britten | 4:11 |
| 5 | Afterglow | Terry Britten, Graham Lyle | Terry Britten | 4:30 |
| 6 | Girls | David Bowie, Erdal Kızılçay | Terry Britten | 4:56 |
| 7 | Back Where You Started | Bryan Adams, Jim Vallance | Bryan Adams, Bob Clearmountain | 4:25 |
| 8 | Break Every Rule | Rupert Hine, Jeannette Obstoj | Rupert Hine | 3:59 |
| 9 | Overnight Sensation | Mark Knopfler | Mark Knopfler, Neil Dorfsman | 4:35 |
| 10 | Paradise Is Here | Paul Brady | Mark Knopfler, Neil Dorfsman | 5:37 |
| 11 | I'll Be Thunder | Rupert Hine, Jeannette Obstoj | Rupert Hine | 5:21 |
Vocals
Tina Turner provided lead vocals on all tracks, as well as backing vocals on tracks 8 and 11.[40]Backing vocals were contributed by Tessa Niles on tracks 1, 4, and 5; Terry Britten on tracks 1, 3, 4, and 5; Rupert Hine on tracks 8 and 11; Bryan Adams on track 7; and Samantha Brown, Margot Buchanan, Jimmy Chambers, and George Chambers on tracks 9 and 10.[53]
Instrumentation
The album featured guitars by Terry Britten on tracks 1–6, Bryan Adams and Keith Scott on track 7, Jamie West-Oram on tracks 8 and 11, and Mark Knopfler on tracks 9 and 10.[40]Drums were played by Phil Collins on tracks 1 and 6, Jack Bruno on tracks 3 and 5, Micky Curry on track 7, and Jamie Lane on tracks 9 and 10.[53]
Bass guitar was handled by Terry Britten on tracks 1–6, Dave Taylor on track 7, and Micky Feat on tracks 9 and 10.[40]
Keyboards were performed by Nick Glennie-Smith on tracks 1, 2, 4, 5, and 6; Tommy Mandel on track 7; Guy Fletcher on tracks 9 and 10; and Steve Winwood, who provided a synthesizer solo on track 5 ("Afterglow").[53]
Additional instrumentation included saxophone solos by Tim Cappello on track 1 and Branford Marsalis (soprano) on track 10; mandolin by Graham Lyle on track 2; piano by Bryan Adams on track 7; organ by Tommy Mandel on track 7; and percussion by Garry Katell on track 6, Jim Vallance on track 7, and Frank Ricotti on tracks 9 and 10.[40]
Production
Tracks 1–6 were arranged and produced by Terry Britten, with John Hudson handling recording and mixing.[53]Track 7 ("Back Where You Started") was arranged and produced by Bryan Adams and Bob Clearmountain, who also recorded and mixed it.[41]
Tracks 8 and 11 were arranged and produced by Rupert Hine, who also played all other instruments on those tracks.[53]
Tracks 9 and 10 were produced by Mark Knopfler and Neil Dorfsman, who engineered and mixed them, with programming by Albert Boekholt.[40]
String arrangements on track 4 were by Nick Glennie-Smith, and drum programming on tracks 2 and 4 was by Terry Britten.[53]
Engineering assistance included Mike Ging on track 6, and additional recording by Steve Rinkoff, Paul Hamilton, Mark McKenna, and Richard Moakes on track 7.[53]
The album was mastered by Stephen Marcussen at Precision Lacquers in Los Angeles.[62]
Additional Credits
Design was by Stylorouge, make-up by Phyllis Cohen, and photography by Herb Ritts.[41]Management was provided by Roger Davies Management Inc.[63]