Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Call to Action

Call to Action (CTA) is an American organization advocating progressive reforms within the Roman Catholic Church, founded in Chicago in 1978 as a response to the U.S. Catholic bishops' 1976 Call to Action conference in Detroit, which had gathered delegates to address social issues like racism and sexism alongside ecclesiastical changes inspired by the Second Vatican Council.^[1]^[2] The group promotes structural alterations to Church governance and doctrine, such as the ordination of women and married men to the priesthood, elimination of mandatory clerical celibacy, approval of artificial contraception and remarriage after divorce, and expanded lay participation in decision-making, stances that diverge from longstanding magisterial teachings and have prompted canonical sanctions including excommunications.^[2]^[3]^[4] Emerging from post-Vatican II ferment, CTA initially organized locally before expanding nationally, issuing a 1990 "Call for Reform of the Catholic Church" document signed by over 4,500 individuals that publicized its agenda through media like a New York Times advertisement, drawing both support from reform-minded Catholics and opposition from orthodox sectors.^[1] Key activities have included annual conferences featuring speakers like theologian Hans Küng, promotion of alternative liturgies and intentional Eucharistic communities outside official parish structures, and listings of services led by women priests, reflecting a shift toward decentralized, inclusive worship models amid declining traditional attendance.^[5]^[1] By the 2010s, the organization adapted to regional gatherings and emphasized social justice issues like anti-racism, while reaffirming its mission against perceived right-wing influences within Catholicism.^[1]^[6] CTA's advocacy has sparked significant controversies, notably a 1996 decree by Bishop Fabian Bruskewitz of Lincoln, Nebraska, imposing latae sententiae excommunication on all members of its Nebraska chapter for promoting positions deemed incompatible with Catholic faith, a penalty that persists despite individual appeals and offers for case-by-case revocation.^[4]^[7] Critics, including conservative Catholic outlets, portray the group as fostering dissent and subversive activities linked to broader networks challenging hierarchical authority, while supporters view it as a vital voice for democratization and justice in a post-Vatican II context.^[3]^[8] These tensions underscore ongoing debates over fidelity to tradition versus adaptation to modern societal shifts, with CTA maintaining a niche but persistent role in progressive Catholic circles.^[9]^[2]

Origins and Historical Development

Founding at the 1976 Detroit Conference

The U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops (USCCB) initiated the Call to Action program in 1975 as part of the Catholic Church's observance of the American Bicentennial, soliciting input through diocesan hearings that drew responses from over 800,000 participants on issues ranging from social justice to ecclesial governance.^[10] This process culminated in the Call to Action Conference held October 21–23, 1976, at Cobo Hall in Detroit, Michigan, attended by 1,340 voting delegates—including more than 100 bishops—and approximately 1,500 observers selected from 152 dioceses.^[11]^[12] The conference aimed to synthesize lay input into actionable recommendations for the Church, focusing on themes of "liberty and justice for all," though proceedings were criticized for disproportionate representation of progressive clergy, religious sisters, and lay activists, with delegates often chosen by local committees rather than direct episcopal appointment.^[13] Delegates deliberated in workshops across 47 issue areas, ultimately approving 281 recommendations by majority vote, many of which challenged core Catholic doctrines and disciplines.^[11] Prominent proposals included calls for optional clerical celibacy, ordination of women to the priesthood, reevaluation of teachings on contraception and homosexuality, greater lay involvement in decision-making, and structural reforms toward a more democratic ecclesial model.^[14]^[1] For instance, resolutions urged repeal of "right-to-work" laws, opposition to militarism, and affirmative actions against racism and sexism, alongside doctrinal shifts like accepting married clergy and altering male-only ordination norms.^[15] Critics, including participant Rev. Vincent P. Miceli, observed that debates were marked by procedural manipulations favoring radical voices, anti-intellectual rhetoric, and an underlying push for Marxist-influenced egalitarianism over hierarchical tradition.^[13] In response, the USCCB issued "A Call to Action: An Agenda for the Catholic Community" in 1977, endorsing about 30 percent of the recommendations—primarily those on social issues like poverty and education—while rejecting doctrinal alterations as incompatible with magisterial teaching, prompting accusations from progressives of episcopal dismissal.^[16] This perceived inaction galvanized conference participants; in October 1978, over 400 individuals convened in Chicago to formally establish Call to Action as a national organization dedicated to advancing the unheeded Detroit agenda through advocacy for structural and doctrinal reforms.^[1] The group's founding charter drew directly from the conference's "Call for Reform in the Catholic Church," positioning it as a persistent voice for internal renewal amid ongoing tensions with Church authorities.^[1]

Expansion and Key Milestones (1978–1990s)

Following the 1976 U.S. Catholic bishops' Call to Action Conference in Detroit, Call to Action (CTA) was formally established as an independent organization in 1978, initially as a Chicago-based group responding to local ecclesiastical concerns, such as criticizing Cardinal John Cody's financial accountability and advocating for stronger parish councils.^[1]^[10] Its inaugural national conference in October 1978 drew over 400 participants, launching Chicago Call to Action as a local entity focused on church reform and social justice initiatives.^[8] This marked the beginning of grassroots expansion, with early efforts emphasizing lay involvement in diocesan structures and accountability for clerical leadership.^[1] Throughout the 1980s, CTA experienced organizational growth, transitioning from localized actions to broader national engagement on issues including nuclear disarmament and aid to Nicaragua through affiliations like the Quixote Center.^[1] A pivotal milestone was the 1981 national conference at Chicago's McCormick Place, which attracted 1,800 attendees and featured theologian Hans Küng, highlighting CTA's increasing visibility and appeal among dissenting Catholics.^[1] Membership expanded as chapters formed across regions, supported by initiatives such as the Performing Arts Ministry, which received a Vatican World Communications Day Award, demonstrating selective alignment with certain church recognitions amid reform advocacy.^[1] These developments solidified CTA's role in fostering networks for ecclesial critique and social activism. By 1990, CTA achieved a defining milestone with the release of its "Call for Reform in the Catholic Church," a pastoral letter outlining demands for structural changes, which garnered over 4,500 signatures and was publicized via a full-page advertisement in The New York Times on Ash Wednesday.^[1] This document catalyzed CTA's evolution into a fully national organization, with subsequent conferences reinforcing its platform for challenging doctrines on celibacy, ordination, and authority.^[10] The period's expansion reflected growing tensions with the Catholic hierarchy, as CTA's milestones underscored persistent lay-driven pushes for democratization despite ecclesiastical resistance.^[1]

Contemporary Activities and Challenges (2000s–Present)

In the 2000s, Call to Action maintained its tradition of annual national conferences, drawing participants to discuss church reforms such as optional clerical celibacy, women's ordination, and inclusive policies on sexuality. The 2009 conference in Chicago attracted over 2,000 attendees, featuring addresses by executive director Jim Fitzgerald on sustaining reform efforts amid opposition. Subsequent gatherings, including the 2010 event with keynote speaker Joan Chittister emphasizing persistence in dissent, and the 2011 conference themed around ministering to marginalized groups, continued to platform progressive Catholic voices through workshops and resolutions. These events often aligned with broader advocacy, such as the 2010 statement from the Equally Blessed coalition—including Call to Action—condemning Catholic bishops' silence on gay youth suicides amid a wave of reported cases.^[17]^[18]^[19]^[20] The organization also engaged with ecclesial developments under Pope Francis, viewing the Synod on Synodality (2021–2024) as an opportunity to amplify calls for structural change. Call to Action submitted perspectives from its constituencies, urging "reimagining" the church through greater lay involvement and democratic processes, as reported in their 2022 synodality summaries. Initiatives like the People's History of Vatican II project sought to document lay memories of conciliar reforms, fostering intergenerational dialogue on unfinished agendas such as clerical reforms and social justice. Publications, including the newsletter Call to Action News and Church Watch reports, tracked Vatican actions and mobilized grassroots responses, while chapters supported dissenting clergy, as in the 2011 endorsement of excommunicated priest Roy Bourgeois by 157 priests.^[21]^[22]^[23] Challenges intensified due to institutional opposition from the Vatican and U.S. bishops, who deemed Call to Action's positions incompatible with Catholic doctrine. In 2006, the Holy See affirmed Lincoln Bishop Fabian Bruskewitz's 1996 excommunication of the Nebraska chapter and affiliates, citing activities "in contrast with the Catholic faith" including advocacy for women's ordination and liturgical innovations. This decree remained in effect, with Bruskewitz's successor offering individual lifts in 2018 only upon public renunciation of the group, a condition the chapter rejected while continuing reform lobbying. Orthodox Catholic outlets critiqued Call to Action's alliances with secular networks like the Industrial Areas Foundation as undermining traditional authority.^[24]^[7]^[8] Internally, demographic and financial strains emerged by the 2010s, with an aging membership base—predominantly over 60—and declining numbers leading to shortfalls that prompted reorganization in 2019. Efforts to attract younger progressives via programs like Re/Generation aimed to reverse this, but participation lagged amid broader Catholic disaffiliation trends. These pressures, compounded by Vatican scrutiny under Popes Benedict XVI and Francis, limited expansion, though chapters persisted in local actions like supporting inclusive parishes and critiquing hierarchical responses to clergy abuse scandals.^[25]^[26]^[5]

Core Ideology and Advocacy Positions

Proposed Reforms to Clerical Celibacy and Ordination

Call to Action advocates for the elimination of mandatory celibacy in the Latin Rite Catholic priesthood, proposing instead an optional discipline that would permit priests to marry while allowing those who prefer celibacy to maintain it. This reform, articulated in their organizational statements and liturgical guidelines, draws on historical precedents from the early Church where married clergy were common, arguing that compulsory celibacy exacerbates the ongoing priest shortage—estimated at over 3,000 fewer priests in the U.S. since 1965—and contributes to issues like clerical isolation and abuse scandals.^[27]^[1] The group contends that optional celibacy would foster healthier ministries and align with biblical examples of married apostles, such as Peter, without diminishing spiritual efficacy.^[27] Regarding ordination, Call to Action calls for the full sacramental ordination of women to the priesthood and diaconate, rejecting the Church's reservation of holy orders to men as a barrier to gender justice and inclusive leadership. Their "We Are Church" platform explicitly includes support for ordaining women alongside trans and non-binary individuals, positioning this as essential for addressing clerical shortages and democratizing ecclesial authority.^[28]^[1] Proponents within the organization, including chapter events featuring advocates like Fr. Roy Bourgeois, frame women's ordination as a restoration of egalitarian practices from early Christianity, citing figures like Phoebe in Romans 16:1 as deaconesses.^[29] These proposals extend to reinstating married men as priests, integrating optional celibacy with expanded eligibility to sustain parish viability amid declining vocations, which dropped 80% in the U.S. from 1965 to 2020.^[27]^[1]

Stances on Sexuality, Gender, and Family

Call to Action advocates for a reimagining of Catholic teachings on sexuality and gender, emphasizing "sexuality and LGBTQ+ justice" as core principles, which includes support for same-sex relationships and the full inclusion of LGBTQ+ individuals in church life.^[28] The organization celebrated the Vatican's 2023 declaration permitting priests to offer blessings to same-gender couples, describing it as a "significant victory for LGBTQIA+ Catholics" and a step toward greater acceptance.^[30] This position aligns with CTA's broader push against traditional prohibitions on homosexual acts, favoring pastoral accommodations that affirm such unions rather than doctrinal condemnation. On gender, CTA promotes "gender justice" within the church, explicitly calling for the ordination of women, transgender, and non-binary individuals to foster inclusivity and challenge hierarchical male dominance.^[28] The group has criticized U.S. bishops' directives restricting Catholic healthcare providers from offering gender-transition procedures, such as surgeries or hormone therapies, for transgender, nonbinary, and intersex patients, positioning these restrictions as contrary to compassionate care.^[31] CTA's advocacy extends to intersections of gender identity and reproductive issues, with members arguing for theological frameworks that integrate transgender experiences with access to abortion services.^[32] Regarding family structures, CTA supports expansive definitions that encompass LGBT families, interracial households, multi-generational units, and those affected by divorce, urging synodal processes to address "issues surrounding marriage equality, fertility, and divorce."^[33] The organization prays for inclusion of diverse family forms in church prayer and policy, including families with varying abilities and those led by same-sex couples, while decrying evictions of LGBT Catholic families from parishes as unjust.^[34]^[35] These stances reflect CTA's dissent from magisterial teachings on indissoluble sacramental marriage and procreation within heterosexual unions, prioritizing lived experiences and equity over doctrinal norms on remarriage and fertility regulation. Call to Action (CTA) interprets Catholic social teaching to encompass a range of broader justice issues, including a preferential option for the poor, criminal justice reform, abolition of the death penalty, workers' dignity, environmental stewardship through "care for creation," and global solidarity.^[28] These positions align with traditional Catholic emphases on the common good but extend to advocacy for systemic changes, such as opposing capital punishment as incompatible with human dignity and promoting labor rights amid economic inequalities.^[28] Organizationally, CTA has formed working groups dedicated to racial justice, alongside gender and LGBTQ justice, to address intersections of oppression, including anti-racism efforts rooted in Gospel imperatives.^[36] Historical records indicate CTA's dual commitment since its origins to societal justice alongside internal church renewal, viewing external advocacy as inseparable from faith practice.^[1] In ecclesial democracy, CTA promotes a vision of the church as "the people of God" accountable mutually rather than solely through hierarchical authority, emphasizing lay empowerment and inclusive decision-making processes.^[28] This includes calls for reforms to foster equality and conscience formation within communities, challenging autocratic elements in favor of participatory governance models.^[37] Practical initiatives feature support for intentional Eucharistic communities and alternative liturgies led by diverse participants, including women, as alternatives to conventional parish structures, aiming to democratize worship and leadership.^[5] Critics from orthodox Catholic perspectives, such as those documented in conservative media, argue this push supplants magisterial hierarchy with secular democratic ideals, potentially undermining doctrinal unity, though CTA frames it as renewal faithful to Vatican II's communal ethos.^[38] Empirical assessments of such reforms remain limited, with CTA's conferences and statements serving as primary vehicles for mobilization rather than quantifiable policy impacts within the institutional church.^[1]

Organizational Framework

Leadership, Membership, and Internal Governance

Call to Action's national leadership is headed by an executive director, with Black Moses Rankins serving in the role as of 2025, following his involvement with the organization since joining the inaugural Re/Generation cohort in 2018.^[39] Rankins assumed interim executive director duties after Jim FitzGerald's resignation effective April 1, 2025, amid an organizational reinvention process aimed at adapting to evolving challenges in the Catholic landscape.^[40] The national office employs a small staff of organizers and advocates, including Christopher Ortiz as an organizer focused on youth and Latino communities, Jason as a faith-based advocate with experience in conflict resolution, and Tamar, a former board member active in local initiatives.^[39] In place of a traditional board of directors, Call to Action established a Vision Council in 2015 to guide strategic direction, with council members functioning as organizational ambassadors who collaborate on core beliefs and mission alignment alongside broader membership input.^[41]^[28] This shift emphasized decentralized representation over centralized oversight, reflecting the group's emphasis on prophetic witness and adaptability.^[41] Membership consists of Catholics who affiliate with Call to Action's goals of justice and Church reform, sustained through dues and donations as a member-supported entity without fixed enrollment quotas.^[28] Local chapters operate autonomously, forming communities for prayer, advocacy, and action tailored to regional contexts, while national coordination supports programs like the Re/Generation initiative for Catholics in their 20s and 30s.^[42]^[28] Internal decision-making prioritizes member-led processes, with working groups and chapters initiating grassroots efforts that inform national priorities, though the organization has faced membership decline and financial strains in recent years.^[25]

Conferences, Publications, and Grassroots Activities

Call to Action has organized national and regional conferences since its inception, evolving from the 1978 founding assembly in Chicago, which drew over 400 participants to formalize the group as a network of local reform advocates.^[1] Subsequent events included the 1981 Chicago conference at McCormick Place, attended by 1,800 people and featuring theologian Hans Küng as a speaker.^[1] Annual national conferences commenced around 1990, continuing until 2016, with notable gatherings such as the 1995 Chicago event that attracted approximately 3,000 participants focused on church renewal initiatives like FutureChurch.^[1]^[43] By the late 2010s, the organization shifted to regional formats amid declining attendance, including the 2019 West Coast Conference in Sacramento, a Border Experience in McAllen, Texas, and a young adult-focused event in New York City.^[1] The group's publications include periodic newsletters such as Call to Action News, which disseminated updates on reform proposals and member activities, as referenced in analyses of its advocacy strategies during the 1970s and 1980s.^[44] A key document was the 1990 pastoral letter "Call for Reform in the Catholic Church," published as a full-page advertisement in The New York Times on Ash Wednesday and initially signed by 4,500 Catholics, advocating changes to doctrines on sexuality, ordination, and governance.^[1]^[45] More recent outputs encompass online news statements and seasonal newsletters, such as the Fall 2025 edition addressing contemporary justice issues.^[46] Grassroots efforts center on affiliated local chapters, which function as autonomous communities engaging in justice-oriented actions, including advocacy for parish councils and critiques of clerical financial practices, as seen in the Chicago chapter's 1978–1979 campaigns against Cardinal John Cody's administration and for improved teacher benefits in Catholic schools.^[1]^[42] In the 1980s, chapters pursued anti-nuclear disarmament initiatives and humanitarian aid to Nicaragua through the Quest for Peace program in collaboration with the Quixote Center.^[1] Additional activities involved the Performing Arts Ministry, which produced and toured musicals promoting peace and economic justice themes nationwide during that decade.^[1] Chapters continue to emphasize on-the-ground activism, such as alternative liturgies and community-building outside traditional parishes, with a directory listing intentional Eucharistic communities and women-led services across the United States.^[42]^[47]

Reception and Controversies

Endorsements from Progressive and Dissenting Catholics

Bishop Thomas J. Gumbleton, retired auxiliary bishop of Detroit known for his advocacy of peace, nuclear disarmament, and church reforms including optional celibacy and women's ordination, publicly supported Call to Action through repeated appearances at its national conferences. In November 2011, he addressed the organization's gathering in Milwaukee, critiquing hierarchical responses to clerical sexual abuse and calling for greater accountability and inclusivity in the Church.^[48] Gumbleton's involvement extended to earlier events, positioning him as the most visible U.S. bishop aligned with CTA's agenda amid broader ecclesiastical opposition.^[49] Swiss theologian Hans Küng, whose licentiate to teach Catholic theology was revoked by the Vatican in 1979 for dissenting views on doctrines like papal infallibility, endorsed CTA's platform as early as 1981 via keynote speeches and later through explicit support for its 1990 "Call for Reform in the Catholic Church." This document, advocating changes to celibacy, ordination practices, and lay governance, garnered signatures from over 4,500 Catholics and was advertised in The New York Times, amplifying CTA's reformist voice with Küng's international stature.^[1] Moral theologian Rev. Charles E. Curran, disciplined by the Vatican in 1986 for positions challenging official teachings on contraception, divorce, and homosexuality, has engaged with CTA through speaking engagements, including a recent event hosted by its Colorado chapter alongside activist Sr. Jeannine Gramick, focusing on ethical reforms and marginalized voices in the Church.^[50] Curran's participation underscores alignment with CTA's emphasis on contextual moral theology over strict doctrinal adherence. In the mid-1990s, reports indicated at least three U.S. Catholic bishops held membership in CTA, reflecting pockets of episcopal sympathy for its justice-oriented critiques, though public endorsements remained limited due to canonical pressures.^[51] These figures represent a dissenting cadre privileging post-Vatican II emphases on collegiality and social engagement over traditional authority structures, viewing CTA as a vehicle for prophetic renewal despite risks of marginalization.

Theological and Doctrinal Critiques from Orthodox Perspectives

Traditional Catholic theologians and canon lawyers have characterized Call to Action (CTA)'s positions as constituting formal heresy, defined as the obstinate post-baptismal denial of some truth which must be believed with divine and Catholic faith.^[52] CTA's advocacy for ordaining women to the priesthood directly contradicts the infallible teaching of the Church that the sacrament of holy orders is reserved exclusively to baptized males, as articulated in Ordinatio Sacerdotalis (1994) by Pope John Paul II, which CTA leaders have publicly rejected.^[38] Similarly, CTA's push to abolish clerical celibacy and reinstate married priests undermines the disciplinary norm rooted in apostolic tradition and reaffirmed in councils such as Trent (Session 23, Canon 10), viewing celibacy not as a charism but as an oppressive structure causing ecclesial dysfunction, as argued by figures like sociologist Richard Schoenherr in CTA forums.^[38] ^[8] On sexuality and gender, orthodox critiques highlight CTA's endorsement of homosexual acts and gender self-identification as intrinsically disordered and contrary to natural law and Scripture (e.g., Romans 1:26-27), positions the Catechism of the Catholic Church (CCC 2357) deems gravely sinful. CTA workshops and affiliates, such as DignityUSA, have promoted interpretations dismissing biblical condemnations (e.g., Sodom and Gomorrah) as "problematic texts" irrelevant to modern ethics, effectively seeking to normalize what the magisterium teaches as objective moral evil.^[38] ^[8] This stance aligns with CTA's broader rejection of the Church's anthropological doctrine, including the binary nature of sex as determined by biology, favoring instead a constructivist view of gender that echoes modernist errors condemned in Pascendi Dominici Gregis (1907) by Pope Pius X. Ecclesiologically, CTA's call for a "democratic" Church with decentralized authority, small faith communities overriding hierarchical oversight, and a pope reduced to symbolic role negates the divine constitution of the Church as a monarchical episcopate under Petrine primacy, as defined at Vatican I (Pastor Aeternus, 1870).^[38] Critics, including Bishop Fabian Bruskewitz of Lincoln, Nebraska, who in 1996 declared automatic excommunication (latae sententiae) for CTA members in his diocese due to promotion of heresy and schism, argue this fosters schismatic tendencies akin to Protestant congregationalism.^[8] Such views embed "internal heresies" into catechesis and parish life, subverting fidelity to the magisterium and prioritizing subjective experience over objective revelation, as noted in analyses of CTA's infiltration of diocesan structures.^[8] These critiques emphasize that CTA's reforms, while framed as inclusive justice, causal realign the Church toward secular ideologies, eroding sacramental ontology and moral absolutes essential to Catholic identity. Orthodox apologists contend that true reform adheres to doctrinal continuity, not dissent, warning that CTA's trajectory risks formal schism by persistently challenging irreformable teachings.^[38]

Canonical Responses: Excommunications and Disciplinary Actions

In March 1996, Bishop Fabian Bruskewitz of the Diocese of Lincoln, Nebraska, issued a decree declaring that Catholics who joined or actively participated in Call to Action (CTA), along with several other organizations deemed incompatible with Church teaching, incurred automatic (latae sententiae) excommunication under Canon 1364 of the Code of Canon Law for promoting heresy or schism.^[53]^[4] The decree followed prior warnings issued in September 1995, giving members 30 days to disassociate, and targeted CTA's advocacy for positions such as women's ordination and optional clerical celibacy, which Bruskewitz described as contrary to defined Catholic doctrine.^[54] Approximately 150 individuals in the Lincoln CTA chapter were affected, though the group continued activities outside Church properties, and some members disputed the decree's validity without formal trial processes.^[4] CTA Nebraska appealed the decree to the Vatican, but on November 24, 2006, Cardinal Giovanni Battista Re, prefect of the Congregation for Bishops, informed Bruskewitz that the Holy See upheld the excommunication, stating that "formal adhesion to this group, which is against the non-negotiable nature of the Catholic faith, carries with it the penalty of excommunication."^[24]^[55] The Vatican's affirmation emphasized that CTA's activities caused "serious damage to the faith and to the life of the Church," rendering membership irreconcilable with coherent Catholic practice, though it did not extend the penalty universally beyond the diocese.^[24] This response marked a rare instance of Vatican-backed episcopal excommunication of a lay reform group, distinguishing it from mere doctrinal censures.^[55] Beyond Lincoln, canonical disciplinary actions against CTA affiliates have been sporadic and localized, often involving suppression of chapters or restrictions on clergy participation rather than widespread excommunications. For example, various U.S. bishops have denied CTA use of diocesan facilities, withdrawn faculties from participating priests, or issued public rebukes, citing violations of canons on obedience and scandal (e.g., Canons 1371 and 1373).^[2] No evidence exists of Vatican-initiated laicizations or universal excommunications targeting CTA leadership as of 2025, though individual priests associated with the group, such as those publicly dissenting on ordination, have faced investigations or removal from ministry under norms for promoting error.^[53] These measures reflect the Church's preference for episcopal discretion in enforcing orthodoxy, prioritizing persuasion over penalty where possible, amid critiques that inconsistent application has allowed CTA persistence.^[4]

Long-Term Impact and Evaluation

Influence on Catholic Reform Movements

Call to Action (CTA) originated from the 1976 National Call to Action Conference convened by the U.S. Catholic bishops in Detroit, Michigan, which gathered 1,340 voting delegates and 1,500 observers to recommend implementations of Vatican II (1962–1965) principles, including greater lay involvement and social justice priorities.^[1] This event, intended to energize post-conciliar renewal, instead catalyzed CTA's formation as an independent entity in Chicago in 1978, amid local tensions with Cardinal John Cody, shifting focus toward structural critiques of clerical authority and doctrinal rigidity.^[1] ^[8] By channeling Vatican II's emphasis on the "people of God" into demands for ecclesial democracy, CTA influenced early post-conciliar lay activism, drawing from precedents like the hierarchical Catholic Action movements of the mid-20th century, which promoted social engagement but within orthodoxy.^[44] Through its advocacy, CTA shaped progressive reform agendas by prioritizing reevaluations of mandatory priestly celibacy, admission of women to ordination, and enhanced lay governance, as articulated in its 1990 "Call for Reform in the Catholic Church," a pastoral letter signed by over 20,000 Catholics and advertised in The New York Times.^[1] ^[2] This document, emphasizing responsiveness to contemporary justice issues like sexism and poverty, resonated in activist circles, fostering networks that extended Catholic social teaching into calls for institutional accountability and inclusivity in sacraments and decision-making.^[1] Annual conferences since the late 1970s served as platforms for disseminating these ideas, influencing affiliated groups and individuals in grassroots efforts to challenge hierarchical centralization, though often diverging from magisterial interpretations of Vatican II.^[56] CTA's organizational model—combining publications, regional assemblies, and youth-oriented initiatives like the 2010s Re/Generation program—has sustained influence among reform advocates, particularly in amplifying lay voices on gender equality and liturgical participation amid declining institutional deference.^[56] ^[1] By preserving archives at DePaul University and documenting "people's histories" of Vatican II, it has provided resources for subsequent generations to reinterpret conciliar texts toward greater egalitarianism, indirectly contributing to broader synodality discussions under Pope Francis, though without achieving doctrinal alterations.^[1] Orthodox critiques, however, contend that CTA's impact remains confined to dissenting subcultures, provoking rather than advancing reforms by endorsing positions incompatible with defined teachings, as evidenced by its marginalization through episcopal prohibitions since the 1980s.^[8] ^[57] Empirical indicators, such as persistent doctrinal continuity on ordination and family matters, underscore limited structural penetration despite four decades of agitation.^[2]

Measurable Outcomes and Empirical Assessment

Call to Action's membership peaked in the late 20th century but has since declined steadily. In 1996, the organization reported approximately 16,000 members, including over 5,000 priests and nuns.^[51] By the period spanning roughly 2008 to 2018, it had lost about 5,000 members, reflecting broader challenges in sustaining engagement amid internal Church disciplinary actions and external critiques.^[2] Conference attendance provides another quantifiable metric of organizational vitality, showing a marked downward trajectory. The 1995 national conference in Chicago drew 3,500 participants.^[38] Attendance at the 2008 event reached 2,500, but by 2015 it had fallen to around 1,200, and the 2018 conference attracted only 300 attendees.^[2]^[58] This decline correlates with reduced financial contributions detailed in the group's available annual reports from 2009 to 2016, which list donor levels but indicate no reversal of membership erosion.^[2] Empirical assessment of Call to Action's influence on Catholic doctrine or policy reveals negligible outcomes relative to its stated aims of structural reform, such as ordaining women or revising teachings on sexuality. No Vatican doctrinal shifts have aligned with these positions since the organization's founding in 1976, as evidenced by unchanged canon law and papal encyclicals upholding traditional norms on priesthood and marriage.^[1] Instead, measurable effects appear confined to fostering localized dissent networks, with chapters like the Madison Area group maintaining small-scale activities involving around 350 participants as of recent listings, but without broader institutional adoption.^[59] Quantitative indicators thus suggest limited efficacy in achieving transformative goals, with organizational contraction outpacing any documented growth in reform-aligned parishes or clergy defections attributable to the group. Progressive Catholic media note parallel trends in overall U.S. Catholic disaffiliation, rising from under 10% in 1990 to nearly 25% today, but attribute this more to generational shifts than direct causation by advocacy efforts like Call to Action's.^[56] Absent peer-reviewed longitudinal studies isolating the group's causal impact, these metrics—declining membership and events—serve as primary proxies for assessing its empirical footprint, pointing to marginalization rather than mainstream integration within the Church.

Ongoing Debates and Future Prospects

Ongoing debates surrounding Call to Action (CTA) center on the compatibility of its advocacy for doctrinal and structural reforms—such as ordaining women and eliminating mandatory priestly celibacy—with longstanding Catholic teachings reaffirmed in recent synodal processes. CTA members contributed reflections to the Synod on Synodality, emphasizing themes like incarceration justice and inclusive participation, yet the synod's final report in October 2024 called for enhanced lay involvement without endorsing alterations to core doctrines on ordination or sexuality.^[60]^[61] Orthodox Catholic commentators argue that such reforms risk diluting sacramental theology rooted in apostolic tradition, viewing CTA's positions as persistent dissent amid the Church's emphasis on synodality as a method for communal discernment rather than revision of immutable truths.^[38] These tensions persist in discussions over the Synod's implementation, where progressive groups like CTA interpret calls for "co-responsibility" as openings for governance changes, while critics from traditionalist perspectives highlight the absence of explicit support for CTA's agenda and warn against conflating synodal listening with doctrinal evolution. Empirical indicators, including stable global Catholic population growth to 1.406 billion by 2023 alongside regional declines in U.S. attendance, underscore debates on whether progressive advocacy sustains vitality or exacerbates disaffiliation, particularly as peer-reviewed analyses and Church statistics reveal no measurable uptake of CTA-proposed reforms in official policy.^[62]^[2] Future prospects for CTA hinge on its ability to engage younger generations amid countervailing trends toward traditional Catholicism, evidenced by increased conversions among Gen Z and rising attendance at Latin Mass communities. The organization's Re/Generation Program, targeting Catholics aged 21-39 for a 2025-2026 cohort of 10-12 participants, aims to foster leadership through retreats, mentorship, and justice-focused projects like anti-racism advocacy, positioning CTA to develop alternative models outside mainstream parishes.^[63] However, surveys and reports indicate young Catholics are disproportionately drawn to reverent, orthodox expressions—such as the Traditional Latin Mass—seeking stability and doctrinal clarity over progressive experimentation, potentially marginalizing CTA's influence as traditional parishes report growth while progressive initiatives face demographic stagnation.^[64]^[65]^[66]

References

[1]
History — Call To Action - cta-usa.org
The "Call for Reform in the Catholic Church," a document proclaimed by more than 20,000 signers, articulates the goals of our Church. The 1976 conference and ...
[2]
Call To Action (CTA) - InfluenceWatch
In 1990, CTA issued a “Call for Reform of the Catholic Church” urging the religion to reevaluate its positions on priestly celibacy, birth control ...
[3]
Finally, Someone Does Something | EWTN
Also named are two organizations whose inclusion is sure to cause the most controversy: Call to Action (CTA) and its Nebraska chapter, Call to Action Nebraska.<|separator|>
[4]
16 years after excommunication, Call to Action group still at crossroads
Nov 10, 2012 · In 1996, Fabian Bruskewitz, then Lincoln's bishop, issued a blanket decree excommunicating anyone part of Call To Action Nebraska.
[5]
Call To Action
Our mission is to be the leader in challenging Catholics to act for justice and build inclusive communities. Who We Are · Our History. Alternative Liturgies.Who We Are · Staff · Chapters · Re/Generation Program
[6]
Call to Action places emphasis on anti-racism work, action
Sep 11, 2020 · When Jacob Blake was shot by police Aug. 23 in Kenosha, Wisconsin, Call to Action, the 40-year-old Catholic Church reform organization, was ...
[7]
Lincoln bishop offers way to lift excommunication of Call to Action ...
Jan 17, 2018 · Lincoln Bishop James Conley extended an offer to lift the excommunication of its members on an individual basis while leaving the decree in place against ...
[8]
Library : The Underground Call to Action | Catholic Culture
Stephanie Block describes the subversive activities of the Industrial Areas Foundation (IAF) and explains how they are connected to Call to Action initiatives.
[9]
Correct, don't complicate excommunication of Lincoln's Call to ...
Feb 20, 2018 · Does an Omaha member of Call to Action somehow become excommunicated as soon as they travel to the Lincoln Diocese only to regain their standing ...
[10]
Collection: Call To Action records - DePaul University Libraries
Call To Action (CTA), established in 1978, is a group of Catholics organized in response to the Second Vatican Council's challenge for all Roman Catholics ...
[11]
A Catholic Call: Will It Be Heard? - Christianity Today
The sponsoring National Conference of Catholic Bishops (NCCB) charged the 1,340 Detroit ... The bishops had designed the Call to Action conference as the ...
[12]
Call to Action Conference | Encyclopedia.com
This fledging group adopted the name Call to Action (CTA) and met for the first time in 1978 in Chicago. Notwithstanding its name, Call to Action is an ...
[13]
Library : Detroit: A Call To Revolution In The Church | Catholic Culture
The following are the observations of Reverend Vincent P. Miceli, who participated, as a delegate, in the 1976 "Call to Action" conference held in Detroit. It ...
[14]
Conference of Catholics Supports Resolution on Ordaining Women ...
The “Call to Action” conference was a result of an unparalleled effort by the nation's bishops to create dialogue on concerns of church membership ...
[15]
Meet asks major changes — The Clarion Herald 28 October 1976
Oct 28, 1976 · The 1,340 delegates at the “Call to Action” conference urged repeal of the “right to work” laws still existing in 20 states. They asked ...
[16]
A call to action :an agenda for the Catholic community - Curate ND
National Conference of Catholic Bishops. <br> Response of the NCCB to the work of the Call to Action conference held Oct. 21-23, 1976.<|separator|>
[17]
'Were it not for Call To Action....\" | National Catholic Reporter
Nov 7, 2009 · Jim Fitzgerald, the new executive director of Call to Action for the first time in his new role stood before more than 2000 gathered ...Missing: activities present
[18]
Chittister: One of a kind at Call to Action gathering
Nov 9, 2010 · So this is Call to Action, an organization, a movement, a dream: real Catholics who won't give up and are passing their dreams to the next ...
[19]
Ministering to, ministering as 'the marginalized' theme of conference
Nov 7, 2011 · Call To Action, a Catholic church reform group based in Chicago, hosted a series of sessions, keynote addresses, and workshops ranging from the ...
[20]
Catholic Bishops Silent on Gay Suicides, 2,000 ... - Dignity/New York
November 8, 2010 Catholic Bishops Silent on Gay Suicides, 2,000 Catholics ... -Statement of Equally Blessed Coalition and Call To Action Conference Participants.
[21]
CTA Constituencies Speak Out in the Synod on Synodality
Oct 5, 2022 · The Archdiocese has called us to 'reimagine' the Catholic Church in St. Louis. They have asked, 'Are we ready for change?' Call To Action wants ...
[22]
People's History of Vatican II — Call To Action
The People's History project documents the memory of Vatican II reforms, co-creating an archive through conversations and reflections, and inviting community ...
[23]
Call to Action rallies support for excommunicated priest
Jul 25, 2011 · Call to Action, the Chicago-based dissident Catholic group, has released a statement signed by 157 priests in support of Father Roy ...
[24]
Vatican supports excommunication of Call to Action group
Dec 7, 2006 · ... Call to Action is “irreconcilable with a coherent living of the Catholic Faith,” due to some of their anti-Catholic activities and stances.Missing: challenges | Show results with:challenges
[25]
Call to Action — the 'loyal left opposition' - National Catholic Reporter
May 6, 2019 · The group's origins stretch back to a 1976 U.S. bishops' conference meeting in Detroit (part of the country's bicentennial celebration), in ...<|separator|>
[26]
Younger progressive Catholics ready to 'regenerate' Call to Action
May 8, 2019 · Our first story took a look at the challenges facing Call to Action, including an aging and declining membership and financial shortfalls.
[27]
Alternative Liturgies Directory — Call To Action - cta-usa.org
... Call To Action chapter liturgies, and more. Alternative liturgies were ... We support women's ordination, optional celibacy for all priests, and a ...<|separator|>
[28]
Who We Are — Call To Action - cta-usa.org
Since 1976, Call To Action has been a leader in the progressive Catholic movement in challenging Catholics to act for justice and build inclusive communities.
[29]
Where Do We Go From Here? — Call To Action - cta-usa.org
Jun 9, 2025 · The West Suburban chapter of Call To Action ... They have already offered a talk by Father Roy Bourgeois, listened to a panel of married priests ...
[30]
LGBTQ — News & Statements — Call To Action - cta-usa.org
On December 18, the Vatican announced that priests may bless same-gender couples. Call To Action celebrates this significant victory for LGBTQIA+ Catholics ...
[31]
U.S. Bishops Condemn Healthcare for Trans, Nonbinary & Intersex ...
Mar 23, 2023 · The bishops' committee mandates that Catholic health providers cannot perform gender-affirming procedures, including surgeries or chemical ...<|separator|>
[32]
I feel a lot safer when I'm in charge of what happens to me
Aug 2, 2025 · CTA member Tess Thompson explores the intersection of abortion and gender identity in both Catholic theology and the broader national
[33]
Rosary Vigils hope Synod will pray with LGBT families - cta-usa.org
Oct 9, 2025 · "We PRAY our Bishops listen to the voices of US Catholics around issues surrounding marriage equality, fertility, and divorce. ... LGBTQ · Call To ...
[34]
PRESS RELEASE: LGBT Catholic Families Evicted from St. John the ...
Aug 17, 2025 · Equally Blessed coalition releases the following statement: LGBT Catholic Families Evicted from St. John the Evangelist Catholic Church.
[35]
Synod Family Prayer Card — Call To Action - cta-usa.org
We pray, God, with our siblings in faith, for all families… For LGBT families. Families of various abilities. Interracial families. Multi-generational families.
[36]
CTA 2018 Opening Address — Call To Action - Cta-usa.org
Nov 30, 2023 · We're forming Working Groups based on each of CTA's five focus areas: Women's Justice, Racial Justice, LGBTQ Justice, Church Worker Justice, ...Missing: positions | Show results with:positions<|separator|>
[37]
https://www.natcath.org/NCR_Online/archives/111502/111502d.htm
[38]
Inside Call to Action | EWTN
Call to Action members refuse all calls to repentance, demanding instead the Church grant an imprimatur to clearly sinful behaviors. The final plenary session ...<|separator|>
[39]
Staff — Call To Action - cta-usa.org
Black Moses Rankins, Executive Director. blackmoses@cta-usa.org. Black Moses, a native of New Orleans, is ...Missing: internal structure
[40]
Changes to Call To Action Executive Leadership - cta-usa.org
Feb 1, 2025 · The Holy Spirit is calling Call To Action to reinvent itself in order to continue to be a prophetic presence in our church and world. There can ...Missing: governance | Show results with:governance
[41]
Call to Action creates new Vision Council | National Catholic Reporter
Oct 22, 2015 · In the end, it concluded that the board of directors should be replaced by a Vision Council, in which members would serve as ambassadors for ...
[42]
Chapters — Call To Action - cta-usa.org
A chapter is a group of Catholics who have affiliated with Call To Action and who come together to be a Catholic community and work for justice.
[43]
Call to Action, Call to Insanity - EWTN
An estimated 3000 persons gathered at the Hyatt Regency O'Hare Hotel in Chicago this past 4-6 November for the annual Call to Action (CTA) Conference. The cool, ...
[44]
The Relationship between Catholic Action and Call to Action - jstor
Feb 20, 2011 · Keywords:Catholicism; conflict; social movements/collective behavior. This article offers an alternative interpretation of two social movement.Missing: milestones | Show results with:milestones
[45]
http://static1.squarespace.com/static/5e3e0a8394d5fa3ebbaa9df2/5e3e108ac51ae36d29b2d31d/5e3e1078c51ae36d29b2c7a7/1581125752495/Call-for-Church-Reform-Pastoral-Letter.pdf
[46]
News & Statements — Call To Action - cta-usa.org
On December 18, the Vatican announced that priests may bless same-gender couples. Call To Action celebrates this significant victory for LGBTQIA+ Catholics ...
[47]
https://www.cta-usa.org/alternative-liturgies
[48]
Retired bishop asked to leave Detroit parish for testimony
Nov 4, 2011 · Gumbleton spoke Nov. 4 at a session given by the Survivors Network for those Abused by Priests at the Call to Action national conference in ...
[49]
Bishop Gumbleton: Remembering a Prophet Pioneer of Catholic ...
Apr 5, 2024 · From the moment I first heard him at a Call To Action conference in Detroit in1997 I was inspired. He spoke the truth with humble conviction.
[50]
Colorado Chapter to Host Fr. Charles Curran & Sr ... - Cta-usa.org
Charles Curran & Sr. Jeannine Gramick. chapters. Aug 18. Written By Call To Action. A rare opportunity to hear two leading Catholic Theologians and ...
[51]
TOP STORY: DISSENT AND THE CATHOLIC CHURCH
Mar 30, 1996 · Three US Catholic bishops are among the members of Call to Action, a liberal Catholic organization targeted in a sweeping excommunication threat.
[52]
Heresy, Schism & Apostasy - EWTN
The person who holds something contrary to the Catholic faith is materially a heretic. They possess the matter of heresy, theological error.<|separator|>
[53]
Library : Letter Concerning 'Call to Action' | Catholic Culture
In March of 1996, Bishop Bruskewitz excommunicated those Catholics in his diocese who were members of Call to Action, Catholics for a Free Choice, Planned ...Missing: actions | Show results with:actions
[54]
Bishop Bruskewitz & Call to Action | Commonweal Magazine
Dec 8, 2006 · One of the groups, Call to Action, appealed to the Vatican. Bishop Bruskewitz recently received the response: In a Nov. 24 letter to the Lincoln ...Missing: actions | Show results with:actions
[55]
News Features | Catholic Culture
The Vatican has confirmed an American bishop's decision to excommunicate members of the dissident group Call to Action. Call to Action is “causing damage to the ...Missing: actions | Show results with:actions
[56]
At Call to Action, younger leaders are reimagining church reform
May 10, 2019 · A group of new, younger leaders are connecting with CTA through an innovative new program called Re/Generation, as our second story describes.
[57]
(PDF) Movement to Movement Transmission and the Role of Place
Aug 6, 2025 · evaluated over a ﬁve-year span. Ninety-two percent of the 182 resolutions passed by the delegates at the. 1976 conference in Detroit were consis ...
[58]
CTA calls for solidarity to support church worker justice
Nov 16, 2015 · 8, before all 1,200 conference attendees, the statement was read aloud by former church workers who had lost their jobs. The declaration reads, ...Missing: attendance statistics
[59]
Catholic Church Organizations and Reform Groups
Membership 25,000. Contact: Call to Action. Call to Action – Madison Area, Inc.: 350 Catholic laity and religious committed to participate in the renewal and ...<|separator|>
[60]
Incarceration a key issue in synod report — Call To Action
Aug 3, 2025 · Incarcerated and formerly incarcerated Catholics speak out in Metro New York synod report.
[61]
Synod's final report calls for all baptized Catholics to shape future ...
Oct 26, 2024 · Synod's final report calls for all baptized Catholics to shape future church ... Pope Francis gives his blessing to members of the Synod of ...
[62]
New Church statistics reveal growing Catholic population, fewer ...
Mar 20, 2025 · The global Catholic population increased by 1.15% between 2022 and 2023, rising from approximately 1.39 billion to 1.406 billion.
[63]
Re/Generation Program — Call To Action - cta-usa.org
Call To Action's Re/Generation Program calls young leaders animated by liberatory, life-giving faith to reckon with the injustices of the Catholic institution.
[64]
America's Catholic Church sees an immense shift toward the old ways
Apr 30, 2024 · The shift, molded by plummeting church attendance, increasingly traditional priests and growing numbers of young Catholics searching for more orthodoxy, has ...
[65]
Why young people are converting to Catholicism en masse - NY Post
Apr 17, 2025 · A growing number of young people are turning to the Catholic Church from other denominations, religions, and even no faith at all.Missing: traditionalism | Show results with:traditionalism
[66]
How the Latin Mass is Bringing Gen Z to Christ - Catholic Exchange
Aug 22, 2025 · Lately, the headlines from mainstream media read more like, “Catholicism sees major resurgence among Gen Z” (Fox News) and “Young people are ...