Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Economic and Political Weekly

The Economic and Political Weekly (EPW) is an Indian academic journal founded in 1949 as the Economic Weekly by editor Sachin Chaudhuri and renamed in 1966 under the Sameeksha Trust, a charitable entity registered to publish multidisciplinary analyses on economics, politics, sociology, culture, and related social sciences through weekly issues featuring peer-reviewed special articles and current affairs commentary. EPW has carved a distinctive niche in India's intellectual ecosystem by prioritizing empirical scrutiny and interdisciplinary discourse, often catalysing policy debates on development, inequality, and governance that challenge prevailing orthodoxies and fill gaps left by commercial media. Its editorial policy emphasizes a "social conscience," enabling bold stances on contentious issues, though this has occasionally led to internal tensions over autonomy and content selection. Among its notable achievements, EPW has hosted seminal contributions from economists, sociologists, and policymakers, fostering original research on India's post-independence trajectory and earning a global reputation for independent scholarship amid a landscape dominated by ideologically aligned outlets. However, the journal has faced controversies, including criticisms of an ideological slant favoring left-of-center perspectives in article selection, deviating from strict neutrality expected in peer-reviewed venues, as seen in the 2017 editorial crisis where disputes over an article on Hindu nationalism prompted the editor's resignation and accusations of external pressures compromising its independence. These episodes underscore ongoing challenges in balancing rigorous analysis with governance under the Sameeksha Trust, whose board oversees operations while aiming to preserve editorial freedom.

History

Founding and Early Years (1949–1965)

The Economic Weekly was founded in by Sachin Chaudhuri in Bombay, immediately after India's from British rule. Chaudhuri, an intellectual with a background in and , launched the weekly to deliver timely, data-informed insights into the country's economic conditions, targeting policymakers, academics, and public intellectuals amid the challenges of post-colonial reconstruction. From its inception through 1965, the publication emphasized rigorous economic and social analysis, publishing articles on topics such as India's nascent industrial expansion, fiscal policies, and resource allocation under the framework. Contributions came predominantly from Bombay-based economists, journalists, and business leaders, fostering a localized yet influential that critiqued and informed government initiatives. While aligning broadly with Jawaharlal Nehru's socialist development model—such as state-led industrialization—the journal maintained editorial autonomy, occasionally diverging on specific policy implementations to prioritize empirical assessment over ideological conformity. Sustained by subscriber support rather than commercial advertising or official patronage, Economic Weekly positioned itself as an independent forum for critical inquiry in the social sciences, contributing to intellectual debates during India's First and Second Five-Year Plans (1951–1960). Under Chaudhuri's editorship until 1965, it avoided becoming an organ of any political faction, emphasizing verifiable data and causal analysis of economic trends over partisan advocacy.

Expansion into Broader Scope (1966–1980s)

In 1966, the journal transitioned from its original title, Economic Weekly, to the Economic and Political Weekly (EPW), signaling an intentional broadening of its editorial mandate to include , , and alongside economic analysis. This reorientation, initiated by founder-editor Sachin Chaudhuri, aimed to address the interplay of economic structures with political developments in India's nascent democratic framework, incorporating sections on and interdisciplinary critiques. The first issue under the new name appeared in August 1966, marking the start of regular coverage of topics such as sectoral imbalances, agrarian challenges, and state interventions, which had previously been confined to economic commentary. Chaudhuri's sudden death in December 1966 disrupted this momentum, prompting a search for stable leadership amid financial and editorial uncertainties. Dr. R.K. served as interim editor until November 1969, when , a long-time associate who had contributed to the predecessor publication, took over. Raj's tenure, extending through the 1980s, solidified EPW's expansion by emphasizing peer-reviewed special articles, notes on policy debates, and reviews that integrated empirical data with theoretical insights, drawing submissions from academics across , , and . Circulation grew steadily, supported by subscriptions from universities and research institutions, as the journal positioned itself as a to official narratives through data-driven examinations of issues like industrial licensing and . By the 1970s and into the 1980s, EPW's scope encompassed critical analyses of pivotal events, including the 1975–1977 Emergency, where it published articles questioning executive overreach and erosion based on contemporaneous reports and economic indicators. Contributions increasingly featured quantitative assessments of alleviation programs, regional disparities, and labor unrest, often challenging Nehruvian planning models with evidence from field surveys and statistical critiques. Under , editorial standards prioritized methodological rigor, including referee consultations for complex submissions, fostering a reputation for hosting debates that privileged verifiable data over ideological assertions, though the journal's platform attracted progressive scholars whose works sometimes reflected institutional biases toward state-centric reforms. This period saw EPW evolve into a weekly staple for policymakers and intellectuals, with annual indices from onward aiding archival access to its growing corpus.

Contemporary Developments (1990s–2025)

During the 1990s, under the long-serving editorship of Krishna Raj, Economic and Political Weekly (EPW) intensified its scrutiny of India's post-1991 , publishing analyses that highlighted rising inequalities, fiscal austerity's impacts on social welfare, and the retreat of the state from public provisioning, often drawing on empirical data from and surveys. The journal's circulation expanded steadily, reaching thousands of subscribers among academics, policymakers, and activists, bolstered by its role as a to mainstream pro-reform narratives in outlets like . Krishna Raj's death on August 25, 2004, marked a pivotal transition; the Sameeksha Trust appointed C. Rammanohar Reddy, a former editor at , as editor later that year. Reddy's 12-year tenure emphasized policy critiques and interdisciplinary pieces on globalization's domestic effects, such as trade liberalization's toll on agriculture—evidenced by studies showing farmer distress metrics like indebted households rising from 26% in 1991 to 49% by 2003 per National Sample Survey data—but also faced internal critiques for prioritizing accessible prose over Raj's denser, theory-driven style, potentially broadening readership at the cost of scholarly depth. Circulation stabilized around 10,000 print copies annually, supplemented by emerging digital dissemination. Reddy's resignation in January 2016, ahead of his 's scheduled end in March, stemmed from disagreements with the over editorial autonomy and limits, igniting backlash: over 100 academics petitioned for his reinstatement, citing risks to institutional independence, while board member resigned in protest, decrying opaque governance. An interim editorial committee, including Partha Chatterjee, managed operations until January 2018, when political scientist Gopal Guru assumed editorship for a five-year , introducing greater on subaltern epistemologies amid ongoing debates on and marginality. Guru departed in July 2023, replaced by economist S. Mahendra Dev, whose leadership has prioritized evidence-based reviews of post-2014 policy shifts like demonetization's GDP drag (estimated at 1-2% in analyses) and implementation challenges. Parallel to editorial flux, EPW digitized its archives starting in the mid-2000s, enabling online access to issues from 1966 onward by the , with full-text searchability aiding researchers tracking longitudinal trends like employment elasticities declining from 0.4 in the 1980s to near-zero post- per data. Subscription models evolved: print-dominant in the 1990s gave way to hybrid digital-print by , but financial strains—exacerbated by print media's global ad revenue drop of 20-30% in the —prompted stricter paywalls from January 2021, limiting free previews to abstracts and reserving full articles for paid users to ensure viability amid rising production costs. By 2025, EPW sustains weekly output of 50 issues yearly, with enhanced for special articles, though critiques persist on over-reliance on institutional subscribers (e.g., universities funding 70% of revenue) potentially insulating it from broader audience accountability.

Organizational Framework

Publisher and Governance Structure

The Economic and Political Weekly (EPW) is published by the Sameeksha Trust, a registered under the Bombay Public Trusts Act, 1950. Established in 1966, the Trust's primary purpose is the publication of EPW and related books, operating as a non-profit entity independent of commercial ownership or shareholders. Donations to the Trust qualify for tax exemptions under Section 80G of the Income Tax Act, supporting its financial sustainability through contributions rather than profit-driven revenue models. Governance of the Sameeksha Trust is vested in a Board of Trustees, composed of distinguished individuals from , , , and sectors. The Board is chaired by Deepak Nayyar, an economist and former professor at , with Shyam Menon serving as Managing Trustee. Other members include sociologist André Béteille, financier , historian , sociologist Dipankar Gupta, social scientist N. Jayaram, economist Sudipto Mundle, and journalist . This structure ensures oversight by experts in relevant fields, though the Board maintains separation from editorial content by limiting its role to appointing the editor without intervening in daily operations or article decisions. The Trust's framework emphasizes institutional autonomy, with the Managing Trustee handling administrative duties under the Board's direction, aligning with standard practices for charitable trusts focused on intellectual publications. No indicate changes to this governance model since its inception, reflecting stability in leadership composition over decades.

Key Editors and Leadership Transitions

The Economic and Political Weekly (EPW) was founded in 1949 as the Economic Weekly by Sachin Chaudhuri, who served as its editor until 1965, establishing its initial focus on economic analysis amid India's post-independence planning era. In 1966, following Chaudhuri's death, the publication was renamed EPW and came under the editorship of Krishna Raj, a alumnus who had joined as assistant editor in 1960; Raj led the journal for 35 years until his sudden death on February 2, 2004, during which time he expanded its scope to include political, social, and interdisciplinary scholarship while maintaining rigorous standards. Raj's passing marked the beginning of frequent leadership changes, overseen by the Sameeksha Trust, the journal's governing body. C. Rammanohar , formerly economics editor at , succeeded Raj in 2004 and edited EPW until his resignation in January 2016, a tenure characterized by efforts to sustain the journal's reputation amid digital transitions but ending in disputes with the trust over editorial autonomy and governance. The departure prompted protests from over 100 academics and contributors, who urged the trust to address underlying issues of transparency and editorial independence, highlighting concerns about the trust's influence on content decisions. Subsequent transitions reflected ongoing tensions. , a journalist and author, was appointed editor in early 2017 but resigned in July of that year after clashes with the trust, including over the retraction of an article critical of the , which raised questions about external pressures on editorial integrity. , a political scientist, then served as editor from January 2018 to July 2023, focusing on sustaining scholarly output during a period of institutional challenges. In August 2023, S. Mahendra Dev, an economist and former director of the Indira Gandhi Institute of Development Research, assumed the editorship, emphasizing continuity in EPW's tradition of independent analysis. As of 2025, Pyaralal Raghavan holds the operational editor role, supporting the leadership structure under the Sameeksha Trust. These shifts underscore EPW's evolution from a stable, long-term editorial anchor under Raj to a more contested model, with multiple resignations tied to trust-editor relations.

Publishing Practices

Format, Frequency, and Production

The Economic and Political Weekly (EPW) is issued weekly, with new editions typically released every , maintaining a consistent schedule since its expansion in 1966. Each weekly issue compiles approximately 70,000 to 80,000 words of content, structured around special articles (in-depth research pieces), shorter commentaries on , discussion notes, and book reviews, reflecting its multidisciplinary focus on , , , and related fields. EPW employs dual print and digital formats to disseminate content. The print edition, assigned ISSN 0012-9976, adheres to a compact layout optimized for readability and archival purposes, often spanning 60–80 pages per issue depending on content volume. The digital counterpart, ISSN 2349-8846, mirrors this structure online, incorporating searchable full-text access, hyperlinked references, and supplementary data where applicable, with archives dating back to available via subscription. Production is overseen by the Sameeksha Trust in , where editorial offices handle content curation, including selective peer review for special articles and expedited internal vetting for timely commentaries to meet the weekly cadence. Printing occurs locally in , enabling efficient distribution to subscribers across and abroad, though the process from acceptance to publication can extend up to 12 months for research pieces due to rigorous selection and backlog management. This framework supports EPW's high output—over 50 issues annually—while prioritizing substantive analysis over rapid turnaround.

Indexing, Abstracting, and Open Access Policies

The Economic and Political Weekly (EPW) is indexed in , a comprehensive abstract and citation database maintained by that covers peer-reviewed literature across s, including economics and political studies. It is also archived and accessible via , which provides and search functionality for its historical issues dating back to the journal's early volumes. Additional indexing occurs through services such as the Index Copernicus International (ICI) Journals Master List, which evaluates journals based on criteria like publication ethics and international collaboration, and MIAR (Information Matrix for the Analysis of Journals), a registry aggregating visibility data from various bibliographic sources. These indexing efforts enhance EPW's discoverability, though its coverage in broader impact metrics like remains limited, reflecting its niche focus on interdisciplinary commentary rather than high-volume quantitative research. Regarding abstracting, serves as the primary service, extracting abstracts, keywords, and citation metadata from EPW articles to facilitate scholarly searches and bibliometric analysis. complements this by offering full-text indexing with embedded abstracts for older content, supporting retrospective research. Abstracting practices prioritize EPW's core outputs, such as special articles and reviews, but exclude non-peer-reviewed sections like editorials, aligning with standard protocols for academic journals. EPW maintains a subscription-based access model, restricting full-text articles to paid subscribers or institutional licensees since January 2, 2021, a policy shift aimed at sustaining operations amid declining print circulation. Abstracts and limited previews remain freely available to non-subscribers, but complete content requires payment or affiliation-based access. In a hybrid approach, EPW introduced an author-funded open access option, allowing contributors to pay a fee to make their published articles freely downloadable on the journal's website, with such pieces listed separately on a dedicated open access page. This opt-in mechanism, detailed in contributor guidelines, does not apply retroactively to pre-existing content and is positioned as a voluntary enhancement rather than a default policy, reflecting EPW's emphasis on financial viability over universal open access. No mandatory embargo period exists for non-OA articles, reinforcing the paywall structure.

Editorial Content and Standards

Core Topics and Interdisciplinary Approach

The Economic and Political Weekly (EPW) primarily focuses on economic, political, and social issues pertinent to and , with articles analyzing policy reforms, development trajectories, and institutional dynamics. Core topics include patterns, fiscal policies, labor markets, agrarian structures, and trade relations, often grounded in empirical data such as statistics or household surveys. Political coverage addresses electoral processes, , challenges, and constitutional interpretations, exemplified by examinations of union-state fiscal transfers and legislative changes like the Bharatiya Nyay Sanhita of 2023. Social dimensions encompass dynamics, disparities, , and environmental impacts on livelihoods, with recent issues highlighting spending trends since 2014 and property rights among communities. EPW's interdisciplinary approach integrates with , , and to dissect causal linkages in multifaceted problems, such as the interplay between adoption, , and small enterprise growth in sectors. This method employs quantitative tools like alongside qualitative narratives from fieldwork, enabling critiques of how economic policies intersect with social inequalities or political power structures. For example, discussions on climate crises or incorporate historical context, , and ethnographic evidence to challenge unidirectional explanations. The journal's review issues and special articles further exemplify this synthesis, dedicating space to thematic clusters like rural affairs, , and environment-development linkages, where contributors from diverse fields collaborate on evidence-based assessments. This framework prioritizes analytical depth over ideological conformity, though selections reflect editorial preferences for data-driven arguments over speculative commentary.

Peer Review Process and Methodological Rigor

The Economic and Political Weekly (EPW) applies selectively, primarily to its Special Articles, which are extended contributions limited to 7,000 words and focused on original analyses in the or sciences. These pieces require novel data or methodologies and undergo external , with authors submitting point-by-point "Action Taken" reports on reviewer feedback alongside tracked revisions; the process remains ongoing, potentially extending into , where further changes may be demanded, and inadequate responses can result in rejection. Acceptance decisions for such articles may take up to six months, with publication delays extending to 12 months. Shorter formats, including Commentaries (2,000–3,000 words), Notes or Perspectives (4,000–5,000 words), and Letters (500–800 words), typically receive editorial review by in-house staff rather than full peer scrutiny, enabling faster turnaround for time-sensitive topics. All submissions, regardless of type, must include an abstract (150–200 words), six to eight keywords, and verifiable author details; figures, tables, and data are restricted to editable formats like MS Word or Excel, used sparingly to maintain focus. The editorial board retains discretion over slotting, titling, and prioritizing policy-relevant content, ensuring alignment with EPW's interdisciplinary scope on economics, politics, and society. Methodological standards emphasize originality and empirical substantiation, particularly for Special Articles, which prohibit , prior publication, or undue self-referencing. Calls for themed sections, such as the Review of Urban Affairs, explicitly evaluate submissions on criteria including methodological rigor, technical quality, and presentation clarity, alongside substantive contribution. This framework supports EPW's reputation for influencing academic and policy discourse, though the hybrid model—peer review for research alongside editorial gatekeeping for commentary—has faced occasional critiques for variability in scrutiny depth, as seen in reports of prolonged review timelines without guaranteed external validation. Overall, prioritizes substantive insight over uniform double-blind protocols common in specialized journals, reflecting EPW's weekly format and broad commentary role.

Ideological Stance and Critiques

Evolving Editorial Positions

The Economic and Political Weekly (EPW) originated under founder-editor Sachin Chaudhuri as the Economic Weekly in 1949, emphasizing rigorous economic commentary aligned with India's post-independence socialist planning paradigm, while critiquing inefficiencies in state-led development without rejecting its core premises. Upon its rebranding to EPW in 1966 and under Krishna Raj's editorship from 1969 to 2004, the journal solidified a scholarly tone, publishing diverse viewpoints on but consistently favoring analytical frameworks skeptical of unregulated markets and communal politics, as evidenced by its coverage of agrarian crises and secular challenges during the and post-Emergency eras. Raj's tenure prioritized intellectual depth over overt activism, fostering contributions from Marxist economists and social scientists who interrogated power structures, yet maintained space for empirical dissent against prevailing orthodoxies. Post-1991 marked a pivotal phase, with EPW's editorials and special issues framing reforms as structurally flawed, prioritizing corporate interests over equitable growth and widening inequalities, as articulated in retrospective analyses marking 25 years of . Under C. Rammanohar Reddy (2004–2016), the journal intensified critiques of neoliberal policies, highlighting empirical shortfalls in alleviation and generation, while upholding a commitment to data-driven scrutiny of fiscal and . This period saw no fundamental ideological pivot but an adaptation to globalization's causal impacts, with positions evolving to incorporate interdisciplinary lenses on , , and environmental costs of market-oriented shifts, often attributing failures to weakened capacities. In the post-2014 era under editors like Paranjoy Guha Thakurta (2016–2017) and Gopal Guru (2018–2023), EPW's commentary sharpened against perceived cronyism in the Modi administration, exemplified by exposés on corporate favoritism that prompted internal trust interventions for factual verification, underscoring tensions between bold positioning and editorial accountability. Editorials critiqued Hindutva-inflected governance for undermining secular pluralism and economic data transparency, yet the Sameeksha Trust's oversight—evident in article retractions or amendments—signaled an evolving restraint against unsubstantiated claims, aiming to preserve credibility amid polarized discourse. This reflects a continuity in left-leaning skepticism toward right-wing populism and market fundamentalism, tempered by institutional mechanisms to mitigate activist overreach, as circulation pressures and digital transitions necessitated broader appeal without diluting core analytical rigor.

Allegations of Left-Leaning Bias and Empirical Shortcomings

Critics, including economist T C A Srinivasa-Raghavan, have alleged that the Economic and Political Weekly (EPW) developed a pronounced left-leaning starting in the , transforming from an independent forum into a platform dominated by Marxist and perspectives that marginalized liberal economic viewpoints. This shift aligned with the political legitimacy of Nehruvian under , enabling EPW to certify academics adhering to leftist ideologies while sidelining alternatives, as evidenced by the backlash against Dharma Kumar's 1991 call to dismantle Marxist hegemony in Indian economics, which EPW affiliates labeled as Western imperialism. Scholarly accounts corroborate EPW's early editorial teams' subscription to a socialist pattern of society, with many contributors of Marxist persuasion influencing its discourse on planned economies and state intervention. A key manifestation of this alleged bias was EPW's consistent opposition to India's efforts. In the 1980s, the journal critiqued imports of milk powder from the not on empirical grounds of cost or supply efficiency, but through an ideological lens prioritizing domestic over global trade integration. Similarly, EPW resisted India's entry into the while tacitly accepting Soviet-led trade blocs, reflecting a selective aversion to market-driven reforms. This stance extended to broader policy influence, with EPW's intellectual framework reportedly shaping entities like the National Advisory Council (2004–2014), contributing to anti-reform policies that critics argue delayed India's growth. Allegations of empirical shortcomings center on EPW's purported prioritization of ideological activism over rigorous data analysis. For instance, leftist economists linked to the journal have been accused of denying verifiable historical facts, such as the massive starvation deaths during China's (1958–1962), estimated at 30–45 million by demographic studies, in favor of theoretical defenses of Maoist policies. Critics contend this reflects a broader pattern where EPW endorses subjective interpretations and advocacy over falsifiable evidence, compounded by funding from government bodies like the University Grants Commission, , and Indian Council of Social Science Research, which may incentivize alignment with state-favored narratives rather than independent scrutiny. Such practices, per detractors, undermine methodological standards by favoring "ignorance and activism" in debates on , , and .

Major Controversies

Internal Editorial Disputes (2016–2017)

In April 2016, assumed the editorship of Economic and Political Weekly (EPW), succeeding C. Rammanohar Reddy after a selection process that had drawn prior contention among stakeholders, though specific internal frictions during the transition remained limited to procedural debates over candidates. Tensions escalated in mid-2017 when EPW published articles by Thakurta and colleagues critiquing Limited's practices, prompting a legal notice from the alleging factual inaccuracies and defamation. The Sameeksha Trust, EPW's governing body—including trustees Deepak Nayyar, D.N. Ghosh, , Dipankar Gupta, Shyam Menon, and —unanimously directed the removal of the two disputed articles from EPW's website on July 17, 2017, citing concerns over unverified claims, though Thakurta maintained the content was fact-based and peer-reviewed. Thakurta responded by hiring a without prior trustee consultation to defend the , a procedural lapse that trustees viewed as a breach of protocol, further eroding their confidence in his leadership. Internal disagreements also surfaced over Thakurta's initiatives, including plans to appoint a co-editor and formalize guidelines, which trustees argued altered EPW's longstanding of collegial . On July 18, 2017, Thakurta resigned with immediate effect, stating that trustees had imposed "unacceptable conditions," including barring him from authoring under his , amid broader complaints from some editorial staff about his . Trustees countered that the decision stemmed not from external pressure but from Thakurta's failure to uphold institutional norms during his 15-month tenure, emphasizing their role in safeguarding EPW's against potential litigation risks. The episode highlighted fault lines between editorial autonomy and trustee oversight, with Thakurta attributing the outcome to capitulation before corporate influence, while trustees prioritized procedural fidelity and risk mitigation. No formal reconciliation occurred, and EPW proceeded under interim arrangements, underscoring the internal power dynamics that had simmered since Thakurta's appointment.

External Criticisms and Publishing Conflicts

In 2017, the Economic and Political Weekly encountered significant external pressure over an article critical of the Adani Group's tax arrangements, highlighting tensions between editorial independence and legal threats from corporate entities. On June 14, 2017, then-editor Paranjoy Guha Thakurta published "Did Adani Group Evade ₹1,000 Crore Taxes?", which alleged that amendments to Special Economic Zone rules in 2012–2013 allowed the Adani Group to claim undue tax refunds exceeding ₹1,000 crore through creative accounting in Mundra SEZ operations. The Adani Group responded swiftly with a legal notice on June 28, 2017, demanding retraction and threatening defamation suits, claiming factual inaccuracies and reputational harm. The Sameeksha Trust, EPW's governing body, intervened under this pressure, instructing Guha Thakurta to substantially edit or withdraw the piece to mitigate litigation risks, a decision that precipitated his on , 2017. An edited version of the article was republished online with excisions, including removal of direct references to figures and caveats added disputing the original claims, while the print edition carried a . External observers, including journalists and press freedom advocates, criticized EPW for yielding to corporate influence, arguing it undermined the journal's historical role as a platform resistant to power structures, with some labeling the episode as driven by fear of costly lawsuits. The controversy extended beyond immediate publication, as Adani pursued proceedings against Guha Thakurta personally, culminating in a Gujarat court issuing an against him on January 20, 2021, for non-appearance in the case, which stemmed partly from the EPW article's republication on other platforms. Critics externally faulted EPW's management for prioritizing institutional survival over journalistic integrity, noting that the Trust's actions contrasted with the journal's prior critiques of , potentially eroding trust among contributors wary of similar vulnerabilities. This incident fueled broader discourse on how legal intimidation—often termed SLAPP suits—can coerce academic and analytical outlets into altering content, with EPW cited as a case where external economic interests prevailed over discourse. Beyond the Adani episode, EPW has faced sporadic external accusations of selective practices favoring certain ideological viewpoints, though documented conflicts remain fewer. For instance, conservative commentators have alleged that EPW rejects or delays articles challenging orthodoxies on topics like agrarian reforms or minority policies, attributing this to an entrenched preference for empirically contested narratives aligned with state-critical leftism, but such claims often lack specific rejected evidence and stem from outlets skeptical of EPW's sourcing rigor. No major additional legal or corporate interventions akin to the case have been publicly litigated against EPW, underscoring its general insulation from such pressures relative to , yet the Adani fallout persists as a for critiques of compromised in India's intellectual landscape.

Impact and Legacy

Academic and Policy Influence

The Economic and Political Weekly (EPW) has exerted considerable influence within Indian academic circles, particularly in social sciences, by serving as a key platform for disseminating heterodox economic analyses, empirical studies on , and critiques of development policies since its in 1966. It has catalyzed debates on topics such as land reforms, , and labor markets, with contributions from prominent scholars like and shaping subsequent research agendas in Indian universities and think tanks. Bibliometric analyses indicate steady citation patterns in regional scholarship, though its global academic footprint remains limited, as evidenced by an (SJR) of 0.241 and an of 0.24 for recent years, prioritizing depth in policy-oriented over high-volume international citations. In policy domains, EPW's role has been more indirect, fostering intellectual groundwork for reforms through weekly commentaries that engaged policymakers and bureaucrats during pivotal periods, such as the 1991 liberalization debates and post-2000s analyses of strategies. Articles in the journal have informed discussions on public expenditure priorities and social welfare schemes, with former contributors including Planning Commission officials influencing incremental policy adjustments, as seen in critiques of the National Rural Employment Guarantee Act's implementation. However, empirical assessments of direct causal impact on enacted policies are sparse, with influence often confined to advisory circles skeptical of market-driven approaches, reflecting the journal's emphasis on state interventionist paradigms over neoliberal prescriptions. EPW's archival role extends its legacy, providing a longitudinal for policy evaluations; for instance, its coverage of the 1970s era and 1980s fiscal experiments has been referenced in government white papers and RBI reports on evolution. Despite this, critiques highlight that its predominantly critical stance toward has resonated more in oppositional policy advocacy—such as NGO-led campaigns on environmental regulations—than in mainstream executive adoption, underscoring a tension between academic provocation and practical implementation. Overall, while EPW lacks the quantitative heft of global journals, its qualitative imprint on India's policy persists through sustained engagement with empirical anomalies in official narratives.

Reception Among Diverse Ideological Groups

Among left-wing and progressive intellectuals in India, the Economic and Political Weekly (EPW) is frequently praised for offering a platform for critical analyses of neoliberal policies, caste dynamics, and state power, aligning with socialist and Marxist frameworks that emphasize structural inequalities. Its editorial stance, which often critiques market-driven reforms and right-wing nationalism, resonates with academics and activists who view it as a bulwark against dominant economic orthodoxies, as evidenced by its extensive publication of articles engaging Marxist theory since the 1960s. This reception stems from EPW's role in fostering debates on issues like agrarian distress and labor rights, where it prioritizes empirical critiques over policy endorsements favoring liberalization. Conservatives and right-wing commentators, conversely, regard EPW with skepticism, frequently accusing it of systemic left-leaning bias that manifests in selective scrutiny of BJP-led governments and ideologies while downplaying similar flaws in opposition narratives. Outlets aligned with market-oriented , such as Swarajya, have highlighted instances where EPW articles perpetuate unsubstantiated claims of inequality exacerbation under reforms, framing them as ideological opposition to pro-growth measures rather than neutral scholarship. A 2016 analysis in Rediff attributed India's delayed partly to the influence of "EPW types"—intellectuals wedded to statist models—who resisted in the , costing potential GDP growth estimated at 1-2% annually during that period. Centrist and liberal economists appreciate EPW's contributions to original on topics like metrics and service delivery, acknowledging its methodological depth despite ideological tilts; for example, its data-driven state rankings have informed discussions across spectra. However, this group often qualifies praise by noting empirical shortcomings in politically charged pieces, such as those critiquing demonetization or without fully accounting for macroeconomic stabilization effects post-2016. Right-leaning sources like have amplified perceptions of EPW's vulnerability to external pressures in controversies, such as the 2017 withdrawal of an Adani-critical amid legal notices, interpreting it as evidence of inconsistent application of its purported . Overall, while EPW commands respect in academia for its archival rigor, its reception fractures along ideological lines, with left-leaning circles treating it as indispensable and right-leaning ones as a for anti-establishment narratives post-2014.

References

  1. [1]
    About Us | Economic and Political Weekly
    First published in 1949 as the Economic Weekly and since 1966 as the Economic and Political Weekly, EPW, as the journal is popularly known, occupies a special ...
  2. [2]
    Sachin Chaudhuri - Azim Premji University
    a weekly publication that was neither an ...
  3. [3]
    Sachin Chaudhuri | Economic and Political Weekly
    Sachin Chaudhuri was the founder–editor of EPW. Below, we reproduce a tribute that was published after his death in the 24 December 1966 issue.
  4. [4]
    Why Economic and Political Weekly matters - The Hindu
    Aug 19, 2016 · EPW's pages hosted some of the most important debates, about economic strategies, change in village societies, foreign policy, political ...<|separator|>
  5. [5]
    Economic and Political Weekly - jstor
    The Economic and Political Weekly, published from Mumbai, is an Indian institution which enjoys a global reputation for excellence in independent scholarship ...Missing: Sameeksha Trust
  6. [6]
    The EPW episode: Don't jump to saffron conclusions so readily
    Jul 24, 2017 · It is not an academic journal for two solid reasons. It is not ideology-neutral with regard to research articles it publishes. Secondly, it does ...
  7. [7]
    The impossible journal | The Indian Express
    Aug 30, 2017 · Institutional innovations are urgently needed to sustain EPW without eroding editorial autonomy or erasing uniqueness.
  8. [8]
    Sachin Chaudhuri and the EW: The Early Years
    Sachin established the Economic Weekly after independence both to inform India's new policymakers and intellectuals as to what was occurring in the economy and ...Missing: founding history
  9. [9]
    Krishna Raj and the Economic and Political Weekly | The Caravan
    Nov 30, 2012 · THE EPW BEGAN LIFE IN 1949 as the Economic Weekly. Its founder was Sachin Chaudhuri, a Bengali grandee from a talented family. One brother was ...
  10. [10]
    Call for Papers by The Economic & Political Weekly - Lawctopus
    Dec 20, 2024 · First published in 1949 as the Economic Weekly and since 1966 as the Economic and Political Weekly, EPW, as the journal is popularly known ...
  11. [11]
    50 Years of EPW: Sachin Chaudhuri (1904-1966)
    Dec 24, 2016 · Economic and Political Weekly ... From the 24 December 1966 issue,a tribute to the founder-editor of EPW, Sachin Chaudhuri on his passing away.
  12. [12]
    Vol. 1, Issue No. 11, 29 Oct, 1966 | Economic and Political Weekly
    Special Articles · Expansion In Spite of Excess Capacity · The Agricultural Situation in the Coming Year · On Contradictions in a Developing Society · Sectoral ...Missing: broader scope
  13. [13]
    CC January 2004 -- Obituary - Sabrang
    Krishna Raj became the editor of EPW in November 1969, succeeding Dr. RK Hazari when the latter moved over to the Reserve Bank of India as deputy governor.
  14. [14]
    Krishna Raj | India - The Guardian
    Feb 17, 2004 · For more than 30 years, he edited the Economic And Political Weekly (EPW), a unique institution providing an unrivalled commentary on the ...
  15. [15]
    EPW Archive from 1966 - 2024 | Economic and Political Weekly
    EPW consults referees from a database of 200+ academicians in different fields of the social sciences on papers that are published in the Special Article ...Missing: history | Show results with:history
  16. [16]
    [PDF] ISID Index Series: Volume One - IGM Library
    Dec 16, 1996 · The present volume has three parts. Part One contains chronological listing of the main contributions in the EPW since its launch in August 1966 ...
  17. [17]
    The Economic And Political Weekly Is Dying | Countercurrents
    Sep 19, 2017 · Readers may recall Dharma Kumar's stinging criticism of what she termed 'the editorial policy of EPW' followed by Krishna Raj's brief, mild ...Missing: bias | Show results with:bias
  18. [18]
    Glimpses from the Past | Economic and Political Weekly
    As editor for 35 years (1969-2004), Krishna Raj gave EPW the reputation it now enjoys. On his 13th death anniversary, we reproduce the tribute published in ...
  19. [19]
    692 C. Rammanohar Reddy, EPW: the little magazine that grew up
    The Economic and Political Weekly began publication in August 1966 but Sachin Chaudhuri passed away in less than four months. But this was not the end of the ...
  20. [20]
    The legend of EPW: How a weekly magazine became an institution
    Jan 24, 2016 · While recommending KR to Economic Weekly founder and editor Sachin Chaudhuri, the economist KN Raj (no relation) said that KR asked especially “ ...<|separator|>
  21. [21]
    EPW editor's exit: 101 academics write, Dreze quits board | India News
    Jan 16, 2016 · One, Reddy, who has been the editor since 2004, be allowed to complete his term (his tenure was supposed to end on March 31 this year). Two, ...
  22. [22]
    The Challenge of Editing the EPW-I - The Hoot
    Aug 10, 2017 · Both Sachin Chaudhuri and Krishna Raj came from economics (so did R.K. Hazari who was editor for a brief two years in the late 1960s). Chaudhuri ...
  23. [23]
    https://www.openthemagazine.com/features/india/economic-political-weekly-a-little-liberal-storm
  24. [24]
    Changes to our Online Access Policy | Economic and Political Weekly
    We have made some changes to our online access policy. Starting 2 January 2021 the full text of the content published in the Economic & Political Weekly is ...
  25. [25]
    Journey of a journal | Beyond Business Features
    Jan 23, 2016 · His tenure lasted three years before he joined the Reserve Bank of India. It was then that Krishna Raj, an assistant editor, took over as editor ...
  26. [26]
    Change at helm in Economic & Political Weekly - Business Standard
    Jan 16, 2016 · Reddy was economics editor at The Hindu when selected by the trust to succeed Krishna Raj, its second editor and the person credited for the ...<|separator|>
  27. [27]
    Letter by 101 Contributors to EPW Trustees Following Ram Reddy's ...
    Jul 21, 2017 · 101 EPW contributors, academics and readers wrote to the trustees of the journal about the resignation of its then editor, C. Rammanohar Reddy.
  28. [28]
    Paranjoy Guha Thakurta quits as EPW editor - The Hindu
    Jul 18, 2017 · Guha Thakurta, a senior journalist, author and political commentator, took over as Editor of EPW from C. Rammanohar Reddy. Updated - December 04 ...
  29. [29]
    Economic and Political Weekly on edge: Reflections of former editor ...
    Jul 23, 2017 · After EPW editor Paranjoy Guha Thakurta resigned last week after disagreements with the trust that publishes the journal, a previous editor ...Missing: Ram | Show results with:Ram
  30. [30]
    The Team | Economic and Political Weekly
    Editor Pyaralal Raghavan. Senior Assistant Editors Indu K Nachiket Kulkarni. Assistant Editors Sahba Fatima Shweta Shetty. Editorial Assistants Saket Moon
  31. [31]
    My editorial after Joining EPW as the Editor | S.Mahendra Dev
    Aug 4, 2023 · Attaching my editorial after joining as editor of Economic and Political weekly (EPW). It discusses the importance of EPW in the last 57 years.
  32. [32]
    Letter from the Not so Distance Past: Former Editor Ram Reddy's ...
    Jul 22, 2017 · The controversy over the resignation of Paranjoy Guha Thakurta as Editor of EPW is only 15 months after C. Rammanohar Reddy left the journal as Editor in less ...Missing: Political Weekly
  33. [33]
    EPW, Vol.60, Issue No.01, 04 Jan, 2025 | PDF | Agriculture - Scribd
    Jan 4, 2025 · LETTERS. Issn 0012-9976. Ever since the first issue in 1966, EPW has been India's premier journal for Free Electricity for since 2023, ...
  34. [34]
    Notes For Contributors | Economic and Political Weekly
    Economic and Political Weekly · Open Access · Submissions · Notes for contributors · Style Sheet · Track Your Submission · engage · Distilled · Resource Kits ...Style Sheet · Frequently Asked Questions... · EPW EngageMissing: frequency | Show results with:frequency
  35. [35]
    Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) - Economic and Political Weekly
    Articles accepted for publication can take up to twelve months from the date of acceptance to appear in the EPW. 2. I want to re-publish my article that was ...Missing: production | Show results with:production
  36. [36]
    Economic and Political Weekly: Home
    Jayant Lele brought an interdisciplinary and critical thrust to theorising. His work marked a break from dogmatic readings of Indian society and politics. From ...About Us · EPW Archive from 1966 · Economic Weekly (1949–1965) · Subscribe
  37. [37]
    Journal Rank of EPW | Economic and Political Weekly
    Economic and Political Weekly is indexed on Scopus, “the largest abstract and citation database of peer-reviewed literature,” which is prepared by Elsevier N V.Missing: services | Show results with:services
  38. [38]
    Economic and Political Weekly | ICI Journals Master List
    The Economic and Political Weekly, published from Mumbai, is an Indian institution which enjoys a global reputation for excellence in independent scholarship ...<|separator|>
  39. [39]
    ECONOMIC AND POLITICAL WEEKLY - 0012-9976 - MIAR - UB
    Title: ECONOMIC AND POLITICAL WEEKLY · related ISSN: 2349-8846 · Country: India · URL: http://www.epw.in · Subject: ECONOMICS; POLITICAL SCIENCE AND PUBLIC ...Missing: abstracting | Show results with:abstracting
  40. [40]
    Economic and Political Weekly - Impact Factor (IF), Overall Ranking ...
    Economic and Political Weekly is a journal covering the technologies/fields/categories related to Economics, Econometrics and Finance (miscellaneous) (Q3)
  41. [41]
    About Open Access | Economic and Political Weekly
    Under EPW Open Access, authors will have the opportunity to make their published article available at no cost to readers on the EPW website.
  42. [42]
    Open Access | Economic and Political Weekly
    Articles that have been made available under Open Access will be listed here. To know more about Open Access at EPW, please visit our About Open Access page.
  43. [43]
    Economic and Political Weekly - Impact Factor & Score 2025
    The top authors publishing in Economic and Political Weekly (based on the number of publications) are: Romesh Thapar (54 papers) absent at the last edition ...Missing: founder | Show results with:founder
  44. [44]
    Gist of EPW Magazine - Shankar IAS Parliament
    It covers a wide range of social science disciplines including economics, Political Science, human science, and public policy.Missing: core | Show results with:core
  45. [45]
    Interdisciplinary research | Economic and Political Weekly
    EPW consults referees from a database of 200+ academicians in different fields of the social sciences on papers that are published in the Special Article and ...
  46. [46]
    Economic and Political Weekly - Research Guides
    The EPW journal provides comprehensive coverage of economic, social, and political issues in India and globally. High-quality Articles: The EPW journal ...Missing: production process
  47. [47]
    [PDF] EPW-Brochure-2025.pdf
    In addition, we also bring out thematic issues, popularly known as EPW Special. Issues, covering a range of topics such as money, banking and finance, budget ...
  48. [48]
    Call for Papers- Review of Urban Affairs | Economic and Political ...
    Economic and Political Weekly · Open Access · Submissions ... of contribution (b) methodological rigor &amp; technical quality and (c) clarity of presentation
  49. [49]
    Broken Review Process of EPW? - RAIOT
    Oct 1, 2018 · EPW informed us that our draft would take up to 12–15 weeks from the date of acceptance for its publication. We were then hopeful that this ...Missing: production | Show results with:production
  50. [50]
    25 Years Of Economic Liberalisation
    The state in a "liberalised regime" acts almost exclusively in the interests of globalised capital and the domestic corporate-financial oligarchy that gets ...
  51. [51]
    Liberalisation | Economic and Political Weekly
    India's economic order is far from neo-liberal. The state, and thus politicians, have retained very substantial powers over market forces. Expectations that the ...
  52. [52]
    EPW Trustees Say They Were Denied Evidence on Adani Article
    Aug 3, 2017 · ... Economic and Political Weekly ... Its reputation as an independent credible voice, based on rigorous non-partisan editorial review, is what makes ...
  53. [53]
    Reinventing EPW | The Indian Express
    Aug 3, 2017 · From 1969 till his death in 2004, Krishna Raj edited the Economic and Political Weekly (EPW) out of a tiny office at Hitkari House in the ...
  54. [54]
    How India paid the price for 'EPW types' - Rediff.com
    Sep 30, 2016 · It was born in 1966 from the Economic Weekly, which had been founded in 1949 by Sachin Chaudhuri. 1966 was important not only because it ...<|separator|>
  55. [55]
    EPW: A Unique Journal - jstor
    Bombay Talkies, but clearly his heart lay elsewhere. With some help from Hiten,. Sachin took the step of founding a brand new journal, the ew, in 1949, ...
  56. [56]
    Paranjoy Guha Thakurta appointed EPW Editor - Business Standard
    Jan 23, 2016 · Thakurta, 60, will take over from April 1, in succession to C Rammanohar Reddy, who ran the journal for 11 years before he decided to step down ...
  57. [57]
    EPW Controversy Comes to Rest With Appointment of Thakurta as ...
    Jan 24, 2016 · NEW DELHI: ”Look ahead” is how the new editor designate of the Economic and Political Weekly Paranjoy Guha Thakurta is looking at his new ...
  58. [58]
    EPW editor Guha Thakurta quits over differences with board
    Jul 19, 2017 · Paranjoy Guha Thakurta resigned as editor of the Economic and Political Weekly (EPW) with immediate effect on Tuesday, after differences ...
  59. [59]
    EPW toes Adani line, Paranjoy Thakurta quits as editor - Newslaundry
    Jul 18, 2017 · Speaking to Newslaundry, Thakurta confirmed his resignation and said that he looked forward to spending more time in Delhi with his family.
  60. [60]
    Trustees lost confidence in me, says former EPW editor - The Hindu
    Jul 19, 2017 · ... Sameeksha Trust chairman Deepak Nayyar, the managing trustee D.N. Ghosh, and four trustees present, which included historian Romila Thapar ...Missing: board | Show results with:board
  61. [61]
    Paranjoy Guha Thakurta quits as EPW editor: Adani Pressure
    Jul 19, 2017 · EPW editor Paranjoy Guha Thakurta stepped down after the celebrated and well-regarded Economic and Political weekly (EPW) refused to back him for his story.
  62. [62]
    Paranjoy Guha Thakurta on His Resignation From the EPW, the ...
    Jul 25, 2017 · Guha Thakurta is the second editor to resign from the EPW in two years. His predecessor, C Rammanohar Reddy, held the position for over a decade ...
  63. [63]
    Q&A: 'Chilling': Journalist sued by Adani, cited by Hindenburg
    Apr 21, 2023 · That same year, Guha Thakurta resigned as editor of the Economic and Political Weekly after an article he wrote about Adani was pulled. US ...
  64. [64]
    Controversial article by former EPW editor on Adani Group stays on ...
    Dec 18, 2017 · The article, authored by former Economic and Political Weekly editor Paranjoy Guha Thakurta, claimed the Centre had amended Special Economic ...
  65. [65]
    Arrest warrant issued for Indian journalist Paranjoy Guha Thakurta in ...
    Jan 22, 2021 · The Adani Group initiated criminal and civil defamation suits in 2017 against Guha Thakurta ... Economic and Political Weekly, a peer-reviewed ...
  66. [66]
    Adani defamation case: Gujarat court issues arrest warrant against ...
    Jan 19, 2021 · The Adani Group had filed a defamation case against Thakurta in 2017 over an article in the Economic and Political Weekly. WrittenBy:NL Team.
  67. [67]
    Adani SLAPP Costs EPW Editor His Job – Communist Party of India ...
    ... Economic And Political Weekly, led to the journal's trustees pushing its editor Paranjoy Guha Thakurta to quit. Thakurta is a highly respected senior ...
  68. [68]
    India: Indian court issues warrant for journalist Paranjoy Thakurta - IFJ
    Jan 22, 2021 · After receiving a warning from the Adani Group, EPW management removed the articles, leading to Thakurta's resignation, while The Wire remained ...<|separator|>
  69. [69]
    Gender Discourse: Engineering a Conflict - Swarajya
    Feb 16, 2013 · ... Economic And Political Weekly (EPW). EPW is known for it's far-left and feminist sympathies. Any reader reading those papers would be well ...Missing: criticism | Show results with:criticism
  70. [70]
    About Us - Economic and Political Weekly Research Foundation.
    First published in 1949 as the Economic Weekly and since 1966 as the Economic and Political Weekly, EPW, as the journal is popularly known, occupies a special ...
  71. [71]
    Economic And Political Weekly impact factor, indexing, ranking (2025)
    The Economic And Political Weekly is a research journal that publishes research related to Economics, Econometrics and Finance; Social Sciences.Missing: abstracting services
  72. [72]
    Sachin Chaudhuri and the EW: The Early Years - jstor
    know on issues of India's political economy and was a steady contributor to the ew and later to Economic & Political Weekly (epw), when he left government ...<|separator|>
  73. [73]
    Indian Economy | Economic and Political Weekly
    The employment rate in India is falling. Profit inflation is rising. A solution is shown to lie in public investment and public works.
  74. [74]
    [PDF] Politics of Economic Growth in India, 1980-2005, Part II
    Apr 8, 2006 · The “big bang” rhetoric of a dramatic policy shift aside, India's economic policies during the 1990s altered only incrementally, responding to ...
  75. [75]
    The Political Economy of Industrial Growth in India | World Politics
    Chakravarty, , “Aspects of India's Development Strategy for the 1980s,” Economic and Political Weekly ... influenced industrial policy under Prime Ministers Nehru ...
  76. [76]
    Marxism | Economic and Political Weekly
    Economic and Political Weekly · Open Access · Submissions · Notes for ... Marxist caste studies, is a mystification. The Marxist view of caste as a ...
  77. [77]
    Vol. 31, No. 2/3, Jan. 13-20, 1996 - jstor
    The Economic and Political Weekly, published from Mumbai, is an Indian ... Marxist Method (p. 62). R. Paranthaman. https://www.jstor.org/stable/4403655.<|separator|>
  78. [78]
    Reforms, Inequality And Poverty – Saga Of Myths Over Facts
    Apr 30, 2012 · The best part is that this paper has been published by the Economic And Political Weekly ( EPW ) – no advocates of free markets or economic ...
  79. [79]
    State Rankings: Five Of The Six Best-Performing States Of 2001 ...
    Sep 5, 2016 · ... Economic and Political Weekly (EPW). The trio has used the quality of service delivery as an important measure for assessing the quality of ...
  80. [80]
    List of Indian media houses and their political leanings : r/IndiaSpeaks
    Apr 17, 2019 · EPW (Economic and Political Weekly): Far Left. Probably only mainstream magazine to publish original research on economics. Political ...
  81. [81]
    Leftist media outlet target Centre for implementing court order asking ...
    Sep 17, 2025 · After EPW's owners took down the article it was published on The Wire. 22 January, 2021. The Wire passes off the obvious about Adani-Israel ...