Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Electronic toll collection


Electronic toll collection () is an automated method for charging s to vehicles without requiring drivers to stop or slow from highway speeds, typically by debiting linked accounts via () s mounted on vehicles or through automatic license plate systems.
Roadside antennas communicate with s to identify vehicles and apply variable rates based on factors such as time of day or vehicle type, enabling seamless passage through points and reducing manual intervention.
By minimizing delays at , systems enhance throughput, lower operating costs through reduced needs, and support for , with spanning highways in the United States, , and .
Despite these efficiencies, implementations have encountered challenges including erroneous billing leading to unexpected fees for users without s and privacy risks from persistent vehicle location tracking, prompting debates over and enforcement penalties.
The global market, valued at approximately USD 8-11 billion in recent years, continues to expand with technological advancements like satellite-based systems, underscoring its role in modernizing infrastructure amid rising road usage.

History

Early Developments and Pioneering Systems

The pioneering efforts in electronic toll collection (ETC) emerged in during the mid-1980s, driven by the need to fund urban infrastructure projects through automated, efficient charging mechanisms that minimized traffic disruptions. The Toll Ring, operationalized in January 1986, represented the world's first deployment of ETC, integrating electronic identification with traditional tollbooths at six fixed control points on key arterials entering the city; vehicles equipped with battery-free transponders were detected via roadside antennas, allowing pre-registered users to pass without stopping while manual payment options remained for others. This hybrid system collected fees to finance road improvements and demonstrated ETC's feasibility for cordon-style urban tolling, processing transactions via inductive loops and simple for vehicle authorization. Building on Bergen's foundation, the Tunnel toll station, activated on October 27, 1987, introduced the first fully automated electronic tollbooth globally, employing the PREMID system—a rudimentary inductive tag that communicated with roadside readers to debit pre-authorized accounts without requiring vehicles to halt. Located between two 4-kilometer subsea tunnels, this single-plaza setup targeted high-volume fjord-crossing traffic and relied on battery-assisted passive transponders for reliable detection in a controlled environment, achieving near-100% compliance among registered users by eliminating cash handling. The system's success validated ETC's operational reliability, paving the way for barrier-free applications and influencing subsequent designs worldwide. These Norwegian innovations spurred early adoption elsewhere, with the implementing its inaugural ETC via the Dallas Area TollTag system in 1989 on the , which used active microwave s mounted on windshields to enable high-speed, dedicated lanes separate from manual collection points. By the early 1990s, Trondheim's toll ring extended these principles with the world's first free-flow ETC in 1991, deploying gantry-based readers for non-stop charging across multiple lanes using advanced synchronization. These systems collectively established core ETC paradigms, including -based identification and centralized account debiting, which reduced congestion by 20-30% at toll points compared to manual methods.

Widespread Adoption and Standardization

The widespread adoption of electronic toll collection () systems accelerated in the late and , following pioneering implementations in . installed the world's first electronic tollbooth in in 1987, utilizing battery-powered transponders for automatic vehicle identification at ferry terminals and toll plazas, which laid groundwork for national expansion through the AutoPASS system. In , the system commenced operations in 1990 after three years of field trials, employing dedicated short-range communication (DSRC) at 5.8 GHz to enable dynamic toll payments across motorways managed by multiple operators, achieving early among 24 entities. These early systems demonstrated ETC's potential to reduce and operational costs, prompting broader deployment; by the mid-1990s, ETC lanes were widely installed at toll facilities in the United States and , transitioning from manual collections. In the United States, the Interagency Group formed in 1990 among toll authorities in , , and to standardize technology, leading to the system's launch in 1993 with initial deployment on the and subsequent expansion to 19 states by the 2010s, covering over 700 toll facilities. This regional standardization effort addressed fragmentation from proprietary systems, facilitating seamless travel and increasing usage to over 90% at participating plazas by the early 2000s. Similarly, California's 1990 legislation mandated statewide technical specifications for , promoting uniformity amid growing networks. Standardization gained momentum through international bodies to ensure cross-border compatibility. In , the (CEN) Technical Committee 278 developed electronic fee collection (EFC) standards, including frameworks for interoperable systems, with the CEN/ISO collaboration culminating in standards like ISO 12855 for system published in its current form by 2025. Japan's Association of Radio Industries and Businesses (ARIB) issued STD-T55 in 1997 for DSRC interfaces in , supporting nationwide rollout. These efforts, alongside ISO/TC 204 working group specifications, enabled global interoperability, such as the European Electronic Toll Service (EETS) directive, reducing barriers to adoption and fostering ETC's proliferation to over 100 countries by the 2020s, with market penetration exceeding 80% in mature systems like and .

Recent Advancements and Global Expansion

In recent years, advancements in electronic toll collection () have centered on GNSS-based systems, which enable distance-based charging without physical gantries by leveraging satellite positioning for precise vehicle tracking. For instance, implemented a GNSS tolling solution in France's region in 2025, marking a significant deployment for regional road user charging. Similarly, rolled out a nationwide satellite-based across its entire tolled motorway network, representing one of the largest such initiatives to date. These systems improve accuracy through multi-constellation GNSS receivers, reducing evasion and enabling based on actual usage. Parallel developments in AI-enhanced video tolling have eliminated the need for transponders in many setups, using automated license plate recognition (ALPR) combined with machine learning for real-time vehicle identification and violation detection. Deployments of AI-powered ALPR cameras, as seen in various global toll plazas, allow cashless processing without vehicle stops, cutting congestion by up to 30% in tested scenarios and lowering operational costs through edge computing. In India, for example, GNSS-ETC procurement began in 2024 for national highways, though implementation faced delays into 2025 due to infrastructure and policy hurdles. These technologies integrate with existing RFID for hybrid models, boosting interoperability. Globally, ETC adoption has accelerated, with the market expanding from USD 9.41 billion in 2024 to a projected USD 15.20 billion by 2030, driven by modernizations in emerging economies. leads this growth, exemplified by Vietnam's full ETC transition on highways, which reduced collection times and increased revenue efficiency. maintains strong standards, supporting cross-border tolling, while advances video-based "pay-by-plate" systems. By 2025, over 60 countries operated ETC networks, with new entrants in and adopting GNSS for rural tolling.

Technical Principles

Core Mechanisms of Operation

Electronic toll collection (ETC) systems automate toll payment through wireless identification, primarily using s equipped with (RFID) or dedicated short-range communication (DSRC) . These s, typically affixed to the 's , contain a linked to a user account. As a approaches a toll point, roadside readers—consisting of antennas and transceivers—emit radio signals within a detection zone, often spanning several meters, to interrogate the . The , usually passive and powered by the incoming signal, responds by transmitting its identifier and any associated data, such as class, enabling the system to verify account status and compute the applicable toll without requiring the to stop. Upon successful identification, the roadside equipment forwards the transaction details—including tag ID, , toll plaza location, and calculated amount—to a central backend for processing. The is then deducted from the linked prepaid account or added to a post-paid billing profile, with settlement occurring between the toll operator (away agency) and the user's home agency via protocols or regional hubs. Vehicle classification, determined by data or additional sensors measuring axles or height, influences the rate, which may vary by or in mileage-based systems. DSRC operates at frequencies like 915 MHz or 5.9 GHz for higher-speed, secure communications, while RFID protocols such as TDM or ISO 18000-6C support read ranges up to speeds with read accuracies exceeding 99% under optimal conditions. For unequipped vehicles lacking transponders, ETC systems integrate automatic license plate recognition (ALPR) cameras to capture images of the rear license plate as the vehicle passes. These images undergo optical character recognition to extract plate details, which are matched against vehicle registration databases for invoicing via mail, often with added surcharges of 50-100% over transponder rates, or escalated to violation enforcement if unpaid. ALPR handles up to 90% of readable plates but faces challenges with obstructions or poor lighting, leading to higher uncollectible rates for out-of-state vehicles.

Key Technologies for Identification and Processing

Electronic toll collection systems primarily rely on (RFID) s for vehicle identification, where battery-powered tags mounted on windshields communicate with roadside readers using electromagnetic signals in the 900 MHz band, such as 915 MHz, to transmit unique identifiers at speeds. These active RFID systems employ protocols like Title 23 Time Domain (TDM) in networks across 18 U.S. states, supporting over 42 million s, or ISO 18000-6C for cost-effective sticker tags adopted in eight states with 7.7 million units. involves roadside antennas interrogating the , which backscatters encrypted data including account details; readers demodulate and validate this via multiprotocol equipment capable of handling TDM, Super eGo (SeGo), and 6C simultaneously for . Dedicated Short-Range Communications (DSRC) serves as an alternative or complementary technology, operating at 5.8 GHz in systems like Japan's ETC or 5.9 GHz in U.S. Intelligent Transportation Systems allocations, enabling bidirectional data exchange for precise toll deduction without full stops. transponders process transactions through short bursts of signals, with onboard units (OBUs) handling and roadside beacons confirming passage, though adoption lags behind RFID in due to higher infrastructure costs. Automatic Number Plate Recognition (ANPR) provides identification via on license plates captured by high-resolution cameras, achieving 90% readability in all-electronic tolling setups and up to 99.9% accuracy in optimized conditions like Denmark's automated systems. Processing entails or visible light imaging, for plate localization, and algorithmic segmentation followed by neural network-based character matching against databases, often integrated with RFID for verification exceeding 99.5% reliability. Global Navigation Satellite Systems (GNSS), including GPS, enable gantry-free identification for distance-based tolling, as in Germany's LKW-Maut system launched in 2005 covering 12,000 km of highways for trucks over 3.5 tons. Onboard units log position, speed, and time data via satellite signals, which are transmitted periodically via cellular networks for backend processing to calculate charges based on traversed distance and vehicle class, with tamper detection ensuring . These technologies collectively process identifications in , linking to central clearinghouses for account debits while maintaining through standardized protocols like those from the International Bridge, Tunnel and Turnpike Association.

Violation Detection and Enforcement

Violation detection in electronic toll collection (ETC) systems occurs when a vehicle's transponder fails to register a valid payment or is absent, prompting automated capture of the license plate via overhead cameras mounted on toll gantries. These systems employ automated license plate recognition (ALPR) or automatic number plate recognition (ANPR) technology, which uses optical character recognition (OCR) software to process high-resolution images and extract vehicle identification details. The primary goal of such Violation Enforcement Systems (VES) is to deter and address toll evasion by integrating image capture, digital processing, and backend database matching to identify non-paying vehicles. Once a plate is read, the data is cross-referenced against toll authority databases and, where necessary, state department of motor vehicles (DMV) records to locate the registered owner. If no linked ETC account exists or payment is not processed, a notice is mailed including the toll due, administrative fees, and potential civil penalties. For instance, in New York, unpaid "Tolls by Mail" invoices incur a $5 late fee after 30 days, escalating to a $50 violation processing fee per instance if unresolved. Similarly, Virginia imposes a $1.50 missed toll fee within five days, rising to $12.50 on the first invoice and up to $100 civil penalties for persistent non-payment. Enforcement escalates through graduated penalties, including additional fines, vehicle booting, license or registration suspension, and referral to collections or . Interstate reciprocity agreements enable cross-state pursuit of violators; for example, reported nearly $11 million in unpaid tolls, fees, and fines from out-of-state drivers in 2020, facilitated by among toll agencies. VES implementations, often featuring multiple camera angles and video analytics, reduce evasion attempts such as plate obscuration by detecting anomalies in real-time. These systems have proven effective in minimizing revenue leakage, with ALPR integration allowing for high-volume processing and recovery of unpaid amounts, though accuracy can be affected by factors like or , necessitating periodic audits and appeals processes.

Applications

Traditional Highway and Bridge Tolling

Electronic toll collection (ETC) on traditional highways and bridges primarily employs (RFID) transponders mounted on vehicles that interact with overhead gantries equipped with antennas and readers to enable barrier-free or dedicated-lane tolling without requiring vehicles to stop. These systems replaced manual cash booths, which processed around 350 vehicles per hour, with ETC lanes handling up to 1,200 vehicles per hour, significantly enhancing throughput on high-volume corridors. In the United States, exemplifies widespread application across interstate highways, turnpikes, and bridges, interoperable in 19 states from to as of 2023, covering facilities like the (operational since 2002 for full ) and the . Usage rates exceed 80% on many networks; for instance, on of and bridges and tunnels, transactions reached 87-88% monthly averages in 2021-2024, reducing cash handling and enabling open-road tolling (ORT) conversions that eliminate physical plazas. ORT, implemented on routes like Florida's highways since the 1990s, uses gantries with readers and automatic license plate recognition (ALPR) for non-equipped vehicles, billing by mail or video tolls. Globally, ETC on highways and bridges follows similar RFID or dedicated short-range communication (DSRC) models, with early adoption in Norway's system in 1987—initially urban but expanded to highway rings—and widespread European deployment via systems like Germany's LKW-Maut for trucks on autobahns since 2005, using onboard units for distance-based charging. In Asia, Japan's , introduced on metropolitan expressways in 2001 and by 2010, achieves over 90% penetration, integrating with bridges like the . These applications prioritize high-speed identification to maintain traffic flow, often combining transponders with ALPR for enforcement on bridges spanning waterways or elevated highways.

Urban Congestion Management and Pricing

Electronic toll collection (ETC) facilitates urban management through cordon or zone-based pricing schemes, where vehicles are charged variably based on time, location, and traffic conditions using gantries equipped with transponders, dedicated short-range communication (DSRC), or global navigation satellite systems (GNSS). These systems allow seamless tolling at highway speeds, enabling dynamic adjustments to discourage peak-hour entries into high-density areas and internalize the externalities of , such as time delays and emissions. Pioneered in 's (ERP) system, implemented in 1998, ETC-based urban pricing has expanded to cities seeking to optimize without physical barriers. Singapore's ERP employs in-vehicle units (IUs) that deduct charges via smart cards when passing gantries in the and expressways, with rates adjusted in —e.g., S$3 to S$6 during peaks—to maintain target speeds of 45-65 km/h. Empirical data from the indicate that ERP has reduced downtown vehicle kilometers traveled by 20-30%, contributing to smoother and lower emissions, though real estate prices in charged zones declined by up to 19% following a S$1 hike due to reduced accessibility. The system's evolution to ERP 2.0, incorporating GNSS for satellite-based charging, further enhances flexibility by eliminating some gantries and enabling distance-based fees, operational since trials in the early . In , , a congestion tax introduced permanently in 2007 after a 2006 trial uses electronic gantries with license plate scanners linked to transponder-like debit systems, charging up to 60 (about $6) for multiple entries during peaks. Evaluations showed a 20% drop in cordon traffic volumes and 30-50% reduction in congestion delays, with sustained effects five years post-implementation and no adverse impact on retail sales. Similar cordon systems in (2013) and (2012) leverage ETC for area licensing, achieving 15-25% traffic reductions in inner zones, though reliant on public acceptance via referenda. New York City's Central Business District Tolling Program, launched January 5, 2025, applies via transponders at gantries below 60th Street, imposing a $9 peak toll (5 a.m.-9 p.m. weekdays) to curb . Initial reports indicate on-target revenue of $500 million annually for upgrades, with observed street-level easing, though the program faced revocation in February 2025 amid legal challenges, yet continued operations per city assessments. Non-transponder vehicles pay higher video tolls ($22.50 peak by 2031), incentivizing adoption. Across implementations, ETC-enabled demonstrates causal efficacy in mitigating urban —e.g., Stockholm's trial reversed post-removal increases—but outcomes depend on complementary measures like transit capacity, with studies confirming net reductions of 10-30% where and align with demand elasticity. Chile's Costanera Norte urban freeway integrates ETC for free-flow tolling through Santiago's core, supporting similar density management.

Integration with Non-Toll Systems

Electronic toll collection () systems have expanded beyond roadways to interface with parking facilities and mechanisms, leveraging the same for seamless, cashless transactions. In such integrations, RFID-equipped transponders communicate with readers at entry/exit points to deduct fees directly from linked accounts, eliminating manual payment processes. This approach mirrors tolling operations but applies to non-roadway , enhancing efficiency in environments where and time constraints amplify the value of . A prominent example is the network in the , where the E-ZPass Plus variant permits use for payments at designated airports and garages. Facilities in and , including those at and , support this functionality, with fees under $20 debited automatically from the user's prepaid account upon vehicle exit. As of 2024, expansions through partnerships like E-ZPass Group with PayByCar have broadened non-toll applications to include mobile payments for and fuel services across nearly 55 million registered vehicles, enabling low-touch deductions via license plate or linkage without additional hardware. integrated this capability in July 2024, allowing users quick, no-touch payments at select and fueling stations. These integrations extend to restricted access zones, such as gated communities or event venues, where ETC transponders grant automatic entry and bill usage accordingly, reducing staffing needs and congestion at barriers. Federal reports note that over a dozen U.S. toll agencies have enabled such ancillary uses, with airport parking as a common initial application due to high transaction volumes and traveler familiarity with transponders. However, adoption remains limited by interoperability challenges between regional ETC consortia and private parking operators, as well as the need for compatible reader infrastructure, which can require upfront investments exceeding $100,000 per site for full RFID compatibility.

Benefits

Operational Efficiency and Cost Savings

Electronic toll collection (ETC) systems enhance by automating toll transactions, enabling vehicles to pass through gantries at speeds without stopping, which reduces average transaction times from 5-10 seconds in manual booths to under 0.5 seconds per vehicle. This increases throughput by up to 300-500 vehicles per hour per , compared to 200-300 for cash-based systems, minimizing queues and idling. High accuracy rates, often exceeding 99.98%, further support reliable processing without manual intervention. Staff reductions form a core efficiency gain, as ETC eliminates the need for toll booth attendants, shifting personnel to remote and roles; for instance, full implementation can cut on-site labor by 80-90% at toll plazas. Reduced physical , such as fewer or no booths, lowers demands and vulnerability to weather-related disruptions. Cost savings accrue primarily from labor and operational reductions; averaged data from five U.S. toll facilities indicate ETC yields over $40,000 in per-lane equipment and operations savings through . In , all-electronic tolling on southern turnpikes has saved $10 million annually in operational costs by phasing out manual collection. Broader analyses project benefit-cost ratios exceeding 2:1, driven by these efficiencies alongside indirect gains like lower fuel use from reduced stops, though initial deployment costs for transponders and readers can reach $50,000-100,000 per lane before amortization.

Traffic Flow and Environmental Improvements

Electronic toll collection () enhances traffic flow by enabling vehicles to traverse toll plazas at full highway speeds, eliminating the need to stop for cash transactions and thereby minimizing queues and bottlenecks. This operational shift increases overall roadway capacity and throughput, as demonstrated by the system in the , where implementation led to higher traffic volumes during peak hours and reduced congestion at toll facilities. By facilitating continuous vehicle movement, ETC reduces average travel times and variability in speeds, contributing to more predictable and efficient highway operations. The resultant smoother traffic patterns yield environmental improvements primarily through decreased idling, frequent acceleration, and deceleration, which are major contributors to elevated consumption and emissions. Empirical measurements near ETC-equipped highways show reductions in (UFP) number concentrations and PM2.5 mass levels in downwind areas following full system adoption. Vehicle emission tests indicate that ETC usage can lower NOx emissions by 16.4%, hydrocarbons by 71.2%, by 71.3%, and CO2 by 48.9% compared to traditional tolling methods. Further quantification from modeling studies supports these outcomes; for instance, complete deployment in a studied projected annual savings of 4.1 million liters alongside a 730.89-ton decrease in total emissions. Another analysis estimated 42% less CO2, 22% less , and 64% less over a 24-hour cycle under ETC conditions versus manual collection. These reductions stem causally from minimized stop-and-go dynamics, which curb inefficient combustion processes inherent to congested, intermittent traffic flows.

Economic and Fiscal Advantages

Electronic toll collection () systems lower operational expenses for toll operators by automating transactions and reducing reliance on labor-intensive toll . of all-electronic tolling eliminates costs associated with collection and booth , with projections indicating savings of up to $472 million through 2045 for the Illinois Tollway following its transition. Agencies adopting have achieved operational cost reductions of up to 40% by phasing out manned plazas and associated overheads, including equipment upkeep and security. ETC enhances revenue capture through improved enforcement and higher transaction volumes, as vehicles no longer stop, enabling gantries to process more tolls per hour with near-100% accuracy rates reported in mature systems. Advanced ETC deployments, including , have demonstrated potential revenue uplifts of approximately 3% by optimizing collection from previously evaded or underutilized trips. This curtails revenue leakage from non-payment, which traditional methods exacerbate due to queues and . For governments, these efficiencies translate to fiscal benefits by generating stable, usage-based revenues that fund without proportional increases in general taxes. Tolls via serve as a dedicated , supporting and while minimizing administrative burdens compared to manual systems. Public-private partnerships leveraging have realized enhanced fiscal viability, as reduced costs amplify net proceeds for reinvestment in transportation networks. Overall, lifecycle analyses of confirm positive financial returns, with benefits accruing to operators and society through sustained revenue growth outweighing initial capital outlays.

Criticisms and Challenges

Privacy Risks and Surveillance Potential

Electronic toll collection (ETC) systems, which rely on radio-frequency identification (RFID) transponders or dedicated short-range communication (DSRC) devices in vehicles, inherently generate records of a driver's passage through gantries, including timestamps and locations. These records link to account information, enabling reconstruction of travel patterns that reveal routines, destinations, and associations, thereby posing risks to location privacy. RFID tags can be interrogated at distances up to several meters without the driver's active consent or knowledge, amplifying the potential for incidental surveillance as readers proliferate. In practice, ETC infrastructure often extends monitoring beyond toll plazas. For instance, in , 149 readers were deployed by 2015 across urban streets in , , and [Staten Island](/page/Staten Island) for analysis, capturing tag data unrelated to toll payment and logging movements on non-tolled roads. Similar deployments in other regions, such as California's or Florida's , use RFID to compute travel times on freeways, inadvertently tracking equipped vehicles citywide. The New York Civil Liberties Union has highlighted how such systems, without robust disclosure or safeguards, enable government agencies to infer sensitive details like political activities or personal relationships from aggregated data. Data retention exacerbates these risks, with policies varying by jurisdiction but often extending years to support billing, disputes, or audits. In , records are retained for up to 10 years, while some agencies maintain toll transaction logs for 3 to 7 years minimum. routinely accesses this data for investigations; , for example, queried the system seven times by 2017 for pursuits involving murder, kidnapping, and arson suspects. However, misuse has occurred, as in the 2013 "Bridgegate" scandal, where officials, including associates of then-Governor , accessed records to monitor political opponents' travel without judicial oversight. The potential intensifies with urban schemes, which install dense networks of readers—such as the planned 270-block expansion in City's Midtown in 2013—capable of near-real-time citywide tracking. While some operators anonymize non-toll data by scrambling IDs and deleting after brief analysis (e.g., minutes in New York's traffic studies), toll-linked records persist and can be subpoenaed, raising causal risks of or abuse absent warrant requirements. Proponents of privacy-preserving alternatives, like pseudonymous tags or cash-like anonymous accounts, argue that current systems prioritize efficiency over minimizing , underscoring the need for , access limits, and deletion mandates to mitigate inherent trade-offs.

Technical Reliability and Security Vulnerabilities

Electronic toll collection systems have demonstrated variable reliability, with hardware failures such as battery depletion leading to undetected malfunctions and consequent revenue losses if not promptly identified and replaced. Software glitches, including erroneous double deductions and processing of blacklisted or insufficiently funded tags, have caused billing inaccuracies and operational disruptions in systems like India's . Vendor-related issues have resulted in widespread incorrect billing; for instance, multiple U.S. states, including , reported thousands of erroneous charges due to software defects as of May 2023. Automatic license plate recognition components exhibit error rates that contribute to billing disputes, particularly under adverse weather or lighting conditions. Major system-wide outages underscore infrastructure fragility. In April 2025, Japan's nationwide network suffered a 38-hour affecting over 100 booths and approximately 920,000 equipped vehicles, resulting in and at least five accidents, including a multi-vehicle collision injuring five individuals. Such incidents highlight dependencies on centralized backbones prone to cascading from issues, overloads, or unpatched software. Security vulnerabilities expose to , data breaches, and denial-of-service risks. cloning, where attackers replicate RFID signals to evade charges, has been feasible due to insufficient in older systems; a 2008 breach of California's database enabled potential reprogramming of devices for unauthorized use. Account hijacking incidents, such as unauthorized EZ Pass usage across state lines reported in 2023, demonstrate how stolen credentials or cloned identifiers allow fraudulent toll evasion or charges to legitimate users. Phishing and cyber threats have escalated, with smishing campaigns impersonating toll authorities to harvest financial data; a 2025 wave targeted EZ Pass users via urgent text alerts linking to fake payment portals. In March 2025, Maine's EZ Pass system was preemptively shut down for 12 hours to mitigate a suspected , illustrating proactive measures against unauthorized . Broader risks include tampering with payment gateways and disruption of roadside units, often mitigated inadequately without segmented networks or . International actors have exploited toll payment APIs, as seen in a 2025 campaign by a China-based group abusing systems for . These flaws stem from legacy protocols lacking robust , amplifying incentives for attacks given the high volume of daily transactions.

Equity Issues and Implementation Barriers

Electronic toll collection (ETC) systems often amplify equity concerns inherent in tolling, as they facilitate all-electronic or cashless operations that can exclude or penalize low-income and individuals reliant on cash payments. Tolls function as a regressive fee, with low-income households (defined as ≤200% of the poverty line) paying a higher proportion of their compared to higher-income groups; for instance, in Washington's , low-income commuters faced toll burdens equivalent to 6.2% of for a $2 bridge toll, versus 1.3% for non-low-income commuters, yielding a regressivity ratio of 4.77. This disparity arises because low-income drivers use tolled facilities for essential commutes but lack alternatives, and ETC's shift away from cash lanes increases violation risks for those unable to obtain transponders due to deposits, requirements, or barriers. Without mitigation, such as subsidized transponders or means-tested discounts, ETC exacerbates vertical inequity, disproportionately affecting vulnerable populations who derive fewer net benefits from congestion relief. Mitigation strategies, including revenue redistribution to subsidies or income-based rebates, can reduce but not eliminate regressivity, as empirical analyses show ratios persisting at 1.88 even across all households under full-system tolling. Programs like California's Bay Area Express Lanes pilot offer means-based toll discounts, yet uptake remains low among low-income users due to awareness gaps and administrative hurdles, highlighting process inequities in adoption. equity issues also emerge, as non-users (e.g., rural or -dependent residents) fund via taxes without direct access, while ETC's efficiency gains primarily benefit frequent urban drivers. Implementation of ETC faces substantial barriers, including high capital and operational costs for gantries, RFID/DSRC , and backend processing, which deter in resource-constrained regions and necessitate public-private partnerships (PPPs) that introduce coordination delays. remains a core challenge, with incompatible protocols across agencies and states leading to fragmented systems; for example, pre-2012 U.S. federal mandates, only internal facilities achieved full compatibility, while cross-border tags like TollTags failed in . Political complexities, evident in Taiwan's 40-year transition from manual to ETC, involve public resistance to perceived , pricing opacity, and mandatory , requiring extensive marketing and alignment between governments and operators. Technical vulnerabilities, such as error-prone in video tolling or failures, compound enforcement issues and revenue leakage, while technology selection locks agencies into paths that hinder future upgrades. These barriers often prolong rollout, as seen in regional efforts like , where multi-agency agreements spanned years amid disputes over standards and revenue sharing, underscoring the need for standardized protocols to enable seamless multi-jurisdictional use. Overall, without addressing these hurdles through phased pilots and stakeholder buy-in, ETC deployment risks cost overruns and incomplete coverage, limiting scalability.

Future Outlook

Emerging Technologies and Innovations

Advancements in GNSS-based tolling systems enable distance- and location-specific charging without extensive roadside infrastructure, relying on satellite positioning for precise vehicle tracking. First implemented in Switzerland's Heavy Vehicle Charge in 2001, these systems have expanded across for tolling, with ongoing innovations improving GNSS receiver accuracy and integration with odometers to mitigate signal errors. In 2024, GNSS solutions were highlighted for reducing deployment costs by eliminating physical gantries, facilitating nationwide tolling on varied road networks. AI-enhanced video analytics and automatic license plate recognition (ALPR) are driving free-flow tolling innovations, allowing high-speed vehicle identification and classification without transponders. models for axle counting, as demonstrated in a 2024 study, achieve over 95% accuracy in multi-lane environments, supporting congestion-free operations at speeds exceeding 100 km/h. Deployments in and in 2025 utilized AI algorithms for reconstructed vehicle imaging and fraud detection, reducing manual review needs by integrating with existing cameras. Cellular Vehicle-to-Everything (C-V2X) communication emerges as a transformative protocol for interoperable tolling in connected vehicle ecosystems, enabling direct, low-latency exchanges between vehicles and infrastructure. In September 2025, North Carolina's I-485 Express Lanes became the first U.S. site to implement C-V2X tolling, optimizing payments via onboard units without gantries. Collaborative demonstrations by , , and in 2025 showcased in-vehicle toll notifications, projecting reduced infrastructure costs and enhanced safety through real-time data sharing.

Market Trends and Policy Directions

The global electronic toll collection (ETC) market is projected to expand from USD 10.19 billion in 2025 to USD 15.20 billion by 2030, reflecting a of 8.3%, driven primarily by the transition to cashless systems and infrastructure modernization efforts. Alternative estimates indicate a market value of USD 10.22 billion in 2025, growing to USD 21.50 billion by 2033 at a CAGR of 9.7%, with maintaining the largest regional share due to widespread adoption of transponder-based systems like . Asia-Pacific regions are anticipated to exhibit the fastest growth, fueled by rapid and government investments in intelligent systems in countries such as and . Key trends include the accelerating shift toward all-electronic tolling (AET), exemplified by implementations like the cashless system rollout in , in 2025, which eliminates physical booths to enhance efficiency and reduce operational costs by up to 30-50% compared to traditional methods. Interoperability standards are gaining traction, with technologies enabling seamless cross-jurisdictional payments, such as DSRC and GNSS-based systems, addressing fragmentation in multi-state or multinational corridors. Emerging integrations of for traffic prediction, for real-time vehicle detection, and for secure transaction logging are enhancing system reliability, though scalability challenges persist in high-volume environments. Policy directions emphasize interoperability mandates and smart infrastructure funding, as seen in U.S. guidelines under 23 CFR Part 950, which require compatible systems for federally supported toll facilities to facilitate nationwide usage without . Governments are increasingly prioritizing AET to minimize congestion and emissions, with directives in regions like and promoting video-based and license-plate recognition alternatives to transponders for broader accessibility. In developing markets, policies focus on phased digital transitions to boost revenue collection—often recovering 20-40% more tolls than manual systems—while addressing equity through prepaid anonymous accounts, though enforcement gaps in low-compliance areas remain a barrier. Overall, regulatory frameworks are evolving toward models integrated with congestion management, supported by public-private partnerships to offset upfront capital costs estimated at USD 1-2 million per .

References

  1. [1]
    23 CFR Part 950 -- Electronic Toll Collection - eCFR
    § 950.3 Definitions.​​ Electronic toll collection means the ability for vehicle operators to pay tolls automatically without slowing down from normal highway ...
  2. [2]
    Electronic Toll Collection Systems - Transportation Policy Research
    Electronic toll collection (ETC) systems charge a toll to users without requiring any action or stopping by the driver.Missing: history | Show results with:history
  3. [3]
    What Are Toll Transponders and How Do They Work? - Bestpass
    Toll transponders, also known as toll tags, are wireless transmitters that attach to your truck and send a radio signal to tolls. They connect toll authorities ...
  4. [4]
    How electronic tolling works | NZ Transport Agency Waka Kotahi
    Electronic toll collection uses cameras and sensors to capture an image of your vehicle's registration plate and assign the correct toll.Missing: technology | Show results with:technology
  5. [5]
    Toll Facilities in the United States - Federal Highway Administration
    Sep 8, 2017 · Electronic toll collection (ETC) leads to significant declines in the operating costs of toll facilities. Furthermore, ETC, by not requiring the ...
  6. [6]
    [PDF] DyETC: Dynamic Electronic Toll Collection for Traffic Congestion ...
    Abstract. To alleviate traffic congestion in urban areas, electronic toll collection (ETC) systems are deployed all over the world.
  7. [7]
    7 advantages and disadvantages of satellite-based toll systems
    Jun 17, 2024 · Advantages include accurate monitoring, reduced congestion, and enhanced convenience. Disadvantages include privacy concerns, high initial ...
  8. [8]
    Electronic Toll Collection Market Size, Statistics Report 2025-2034
    The global electronic toll collection (ETC) market size was estimated at USD 8.18 billion in 2024. The market is expected to grow from USD 8.91 billion in ...
  9. [9]
    Global Electronic Toll Collection Market Expected to Reach USD ...
    Dec 3, 2024 · The global electronic toll collection market size was valued at USD 11.8 Billion in 2024, and it is expected to reach USD 25.0 Billion by 2033.
  10. [10]
    [PDF] URBAN TOLLING IN NORWAY – PRACTICAL EXPERIENCES ...
    The new and innovative era of cost efficient road toll collection in Norway started when we introduced the Bergen Toll Ring in January 1986. To make the toll ...
  11. [11]
    All-electronic toll collection: the promise - and the reality
    Feb 14, 2024 · Electronic toll collection (ETC) has been around for nearly 40 years (Bergen, Norway, 1986) and - as percentages of revenue collected with ...<|separator|>
  12. [12]
    Electronic Toll, Standing Tall | Electronic Toll Collection Technology
    Mar 19, 2019 · Electronic toll collection technology was first introduced in Bergen, Norway in 1986, operating together with traditional toll booths.
  13. [13]
    Electronic Tolling History: Counting All Cars - Tedium
    Nov 8, 2018 · The Scandinavian country was an early pioneer of electronic tolling, with one early system, the Trondheim Toll Ring, being primarily ...
  14. [14]
    [PDF] Electronic Toll Collection Systems - TxDOT Research Library
    This technology will allow toll agencies to improve traffic management, to measure traffic flow and density, to identify congestion, and to communicate this.
  15. [15]
    Music, Spies And Exact Change: The Strange History Of Electronic ...
    Sep 15, 2016 · The surprising history of electronic toll collection can be traced back to the theremin and a Russian spy program. It's still in use, even ...
  16. [16]
    E-tolling is the new normal | ITS International
    Apr 29, 2020 · Bergen in Norway opened the first ETC system anywhere in 1986, and Trondheim followed with the world's first full-speed electronic system in ...
  17. [17]
    DEVELOPMENT OF TOLL COLLECTION IN ITALY - TRID Database
    In 1990, the Telepass system began operations in Italy, after three years of field trials, as the world's first dynamic method on toll payment.
  18. [18]
    Interagency Group (IAG) - E-ZPass Group - About Us
    In 1990, seven toll facilities from the states of New York, New Jersey and Pennsylvania joined to form an alliance known as the E-ZPass Interagency Group (IAG).Missing: adoption date
  19. [19]
    20 years later - E-ZPass system has made its mark
    Aug 3, 2013 · Launched in 1993 with seven toll facilities in New York, New Jersey, and Pennsylvania, the E-ZPass interagency group sought to form a regionally ...Missing: history adoption date
  20. [20]
    Standardizing Electronic Toll Collection - Reason Foundation
    Sep 1, 1992 · A 1990 state law required the California Department of Transportation to develop a statewide technical specification for electronic toll ...Missing: history | Show results with:history
  21. [21]
    CEN Standardization of the Electronic Toll Systems Architecture
    This paper describes the new version of the standard architecture for Electronic Fee Collection, or the "Road Transport and Traffic Telematics—Electronic Fee
  22. [22]
    Overview of ARIB Standards (STD-T55) - 一般社団法人 電波産業会
    11.27.1997 · This standard specifies radio communication interface for the electronic toll collection system in charge ways.
  23. [23]
    https://www.iso.org/obp/ui/en/#!iso:std:88211:en
  24. [24]
    EUROPEAN ELECTRONIC TOLL SERVICE (EETS)
    ISO/TC204/WG5 standardises Electronic Fee Collection in close co-operation with CEN/TC278/WG1. Systematic Review of ISO 12855:2015 – Information exchange ...
  25. [25]
    How Satellite-Based Tolling Systems Work - GNSS Consulting
    Indonesia has been implementing a satellite-based solution on the entire tolled motorway network. The project in Indonesia is groundbreaking since the new ...
  26. [26]
    Role of AI-Powered ALPR Cameras in Automated Toll Collection ...
    Aug 6, 2025 · AI-powered ALPR systems ensure the smooth passage of vehicles without requiring physical stops or slowdowns. They carry out critical tasks like ...
  27. [27]
    Electronic toll collection: Change is in the air | ITS International
    Nov 7, 2024 · ALPR technology is enhanced with AI capabilities and transaction data is transmitted and available in near-real time. It is a powerful tool, ...
  28. [28]
    Why GNSS Toll Collection Faces Delays in India? - Park+
    Jul 2, 2025 · The implementation of GNSS based toll collection faces obstacles because of infrastructure challenges, policy issues, and public acceptance problems.
  29. [29]
    Electronic Toll Collection Market Size, Share & Trends, 2025 To 2030
    The electronic toll collection market is likely to be valued at USD 10.19 billion in 2025 and reach USD 15.20 billion by 2030. It is expected to register a ...
  30. [30]
    Electronic toll collection (ETC) on highways: Global trends ...
    The global ETC market has grown significantly, driven by highway deployment. Vietnam's transition to ETC has yielded substantial gains, including reduced ...
  31. [31]
    Electronic Toll Collection Market Outlook 2025-2034 - GlobeNewswire
    Jul 30, 2025 · The Electronic Toll Collection (ETC) market is expected to grow from USD 11.3 billion in 2025 to USD 22.6 billion by 2034, at a CAGR of 8.0% ...
  32. [32]
    [PDF] Nationwide Electronic Toll Collection Interoperability
    Chapter 2 provides an overview of electronic tolling, including a history and the current state of tolling in the United States. Chapter 3 introduces two ...
  33. [33]
    A comprehensive review of electronic toll collection systems - Shahrier
    Mar 10, 2024 · Electronic toll collection system (ETCS) devices on vehicles communicate wirelessly with road head devices at toll stations.
  34. [34]
    How E-ZPass Works - RoadWarrior
    Aug 26, 2022 · The transponder is a two-way radio with a microprocessor, operating in the 900-MHz band. Stored in this RFID transponder is some basic account ...
  35. [35]
    What is E-ZPass? How it Works? - Upper Route Planner
    Jun 5, 2025 · It operates on the 900-MHz band with a microprocessor and is a battery-operated radio frequency identification (RFID) unit that emits radio ...
  36. [36]
    [PDF] M.1453 - dedicated short range communications at 5.8 GHz - ITU
    This Recommendation outlines the technologies and characteristics for DSRC at 5.8 GHz ... An example of a DSRC application is electronic toll collection (ETC). By ...
  37. [37]
    Dedicated Short Range Communications (DSRC) Service
    Sep 30, 2022 · In October 1999, the Commission allocated the 5.9 GHz band for DSRC-based ITS applications and adopted basic technical rules for DSRC operations ...
  38. [38]
    [PDF] The Long Term Cost of GPS/GSM vs. DSRC - IBTTA
    Outside Europe, all ORT systems require DSRC technology that conforms to CEN TC 278, except in the United States, where noninteroperable RFID (radio frequency ...
  39. [39]
    Denmark Achieves 99.9% ANPR Accuracy in Automated Tolling with ...
    The automated tolling system uses license plate registration for automatic charging, with 99.99% accurate number plate recognition and 99.83% passage detection.
  40. [40]
    Dual Identification of RFID + ANPR = High Read Rates in ETC
    Aug 15, 2018 · The APNR and RFID technologies will work together to improve the overall reading accuracy of the RFID reader to 99.5 per cent.
  41. [41]
    [PDF] Using Smartphones and In-Vehicle Telematics for RUC and Satellite ...
    Jun 10, 2024 · German Truck Tolling (“LKW Maut”) was launched in 2005, with a tolled road network of 12,000km (all the highways). In 2018, the tolled road ...
  42. [42]
    The evolution and future developments of GNSS tolling | Be-Mobile
    GNSS technology has experienced tremendous growth and has become the key technology for distance-based electronic truck toll collection across Europe.
  43. [43]
    [PDF] Technology Scan for Electronic Toll Collection - UKnowledge
    Jun 28, 2008 · The most common technology used in violation enforcement is automated license plate recognition (LPR) systems. These systems are used to ...
  44. [44]
    How to avoid toll violation fees - MTA
    Call 800-333-8655 or visit the E-ZPass website. Tolls by Mail Customers. If unpaid after 30 days of the bill date, you will owe a $5 late charge. If unpaid ...
  45. [45]
    What happens if you don't pay a toll in Virginia? | WRIC ABC 8News
    May 25, 2025 · What are the penalties for unpaid tolls? · Missed toll (within five days of trip): $1.50 fee · First invoice (6-35 days after trip): $12.50 fee ...
  46. [46]
    States work to hold out-of-state motorists accountable for tolls
    Sep 8, 2021 · Drivers from other states owed Maryland nearly $11 million in unpaid highway tolls, late fees and fines last year.
  47. [47]
    [PDF] ELECTRONIC TOLL COLLECTION SYSTEMS - Mobility Division
    The AVC technique is most commonly performed using overhead equipment (laser or infrared detectors) or intelligent detector loops embedded in the pavement, but ...
  48. [48]
    About E-ZPass
    A list of toll roads, bridges and tunnels in states that offer E-ZPass, click on a state in the map below for information on E-ZPass toll facilities in that ...
  49. [49]
    [PDF] 2024 Monthly Traffic and Percent of E-ZPass Usage
    TUNNELS AND BRIDGES. (Eastbound Traffic). Jan. Feb. Mar. Apr. May. Jun. Jul. Aug. Sep. Oct. Nov. Dec. Year-to-Date. All Crossings. Automobiles. 8,415,266.
  50. [50]
    [PDF] 2021 2020 2019 January 87.0% 85.8% 84.8% February 87.4% 85.7 ...
    2021. 2020. 2019. January. 87.0%. 85.8%. 84.8%. February. 87.4%. 85.7%. 84.8%. March. 87.5%. 86.7%. 84.5%. April. 87.6%. 100.0%. 84.6%. May. 88.0%. 93.8%.
  51. [51]
    The Essential Guide to Electronic Toll Collection (ETC) Systems
    Jun 18, 2025 · This works by having vehicles affix a tag (a device that allows charging the toll electronically and in movement) on their windshield, which ...
  52. [52]
    Experts Talk: All-Electronic Tolling for Managed Lanes and ... - HDR
    May 2, 2019 · The same or similar hardware is used in both tolling and ITS applications, including vehicle detection, vehicle classification, CCTV cameras, ...
  53. [53]
    What is Congestion Pricing? - FHWA Operations
    Feb 11, 2022 · With congestion pricing, tolls typically vary by time of day and are collected at highway speeds using electronic toll collection technology.
  54. [54]
    [PDF] Electronic Road Pricing - Urban Emissions
    Singapore's ERP System is the first of its kind meant purely for road congestion pricing, and not for toll collection. The capital cost of the ERP system, ...<|separator|>
  55. [55]
    How ERP works as a speed booster - Ministry of Transport
    Mar 21, 2022 · Data indicate that speeds have generally improved when ERP rates are increased, and vice versa. Without the ERP, traffic will not be as smooth.
  56. [56]
    Impact of electronic road pricing on real estate prices in Singapore
    Our empirical findings show that the effects of the ERP toll rate hike of S$1 per car could be translated into 19% declines in retail real estate prices in the ...
  57. [57]
    Impact of electronic road pricing (ERP) changes on transport modal ...
    Menon and Guttikunda (2010) finds that Singapore's road pricing system reduced 20–30% of the downtown passenger car traffic and Stockholm's traffic volume ...
  58. [58]
    The world's first!A Next-Generation ERP to Realize the Roads of ...
    The ERP system originated from a Road Pricing System (a sticker system), the first system of its type in the world, introduced in Singapore to reduce traffic ...
  59. [59]
    Commentary: ERP 2.0 — What is it good for and why do we need it?
    Nov 3, 2023 · The pocketbook-sized in-vehicle unit (IU) of the Electronic Road Pricing (ERP) system has been an indispensable part of Singapore's vehicle fleet since 1998.
  60. [60]
    Stockholm Congestion Pricing - Tools of Change
    Traffic decreased by about 20% across the toll cordon and congestion decreased by 30 – 50%. Traffic Changes. Traffic decreased by about 20% across the toll ...Missing: collection | Show results with:collection
  61. [61]
    The Stockholm congestion charges—5 years on. Effects ...
    ▻ We draw conclusions from the first five years of congestion charges in Stockholm. ▻ The traffic reduction caused by the charges has increased slightly over ...Missing: collection | Show results with:collection<|separator|>
  62. [62]
    Results from the Stockholm road pricing trial - ScienceDirect.com
    The results show that the Stockholm road pricing trial did not negatively affect retail revenue, neither in shopping malls nor in the sample of retail stores.
  63. [63]
    Downtown congestion pricing in practice - ScienceDirect.com
    Five major cities have implemented DCP: Singapore, London, Stockholm, Milan and Gothenburg. This paper reviews the history of DCP, reporting on each system's ...
  64. [64]
    Central Business District Tolling Program - NYC - MTA
    Since January 5, 2025, vehicles entering the Congestion Relief Zone in Manhattan—local streets and avenues at or below 60 Street—are being charged a toll.Congestion Relief Zone · Congestion Pricing mitigation · Environmental Assessment
  65. [65]
    Congestion Pricing Program in New York - MTA | Tolling
    If your E-ZPass was issued by New York State, you can check the status of your account on the E-ZPass NY website. If your E-ZPass was issued in another ...
  66. [66]
    Congestion pricing has transformed New York City streets
    Jun 16, 2025 · The congestion toll is expected to raise $500m annually – funds earmarked for long overdue upgrades. So far, revenue is on target. While it will ...
  67. [67]
    Congestion pricing costs more with no E-ZPass - NBC New York
    Jan 5, 2025 · By 2031, when the congestion pricing toll is expected to increase to $15, drivers without an E-ZPass will have to pay $22.50, 50% more than drivers with the ...
  68. [68]
    4. Effectiveness of Congestion Pricing Strategies
    Feb 10, 2022 · Some empirical studies have evaluated changes in traffic with corresponding changes in congestion. Results vary greatly, due to the existing ...
  69. [69]
    [PDF] Long-Term Effects of the Swedish Congestion Charges (EN) - OECD
    ... electronic pricing system than to manual toll collection. However, the transaction costs in the Swedish systems are small and reduced over the first five ...
  70. [70]
    Electronic toll collection - Wikipedia
    A major advantage is the driver does not have to stop, reducing traffic delays. Electronic tolling is cheaper than a staffed toll booth, reducing transaction ...History · Overview · Use for non-toll transactions · Technologies
  71. [71]
    E-ZPass Plus
    E-ZPass Plus allows you to use your E-ZPass tag at authorized parking facilities. Your NJ E-ZPass account will be debited for the parking fee less than $20.Missing: integration | Show results with:integration
  72. [72]
    What is E-ZPass Plus?| Airport Parking | DriveEzMD.com
    E-ZPass Plus offers a convenient way to pay for parking at certain facilities, including international airports and parking garages in New York and New ...Missing: integration | Show results with:integration
  73. [73]
    E-ZPass Group and PayByCar Announce Expansion of Non-Toll ...
    Jul 30, 2024 · PayByCar will provide the service to the drivers of nearly 55 million vehicles with E-ZPass tags and transponders with a low-touch mobile payment solution.
  74. [74]
    Delaware joins E-ZPass no-touch quick fuel, parking program
    Jul 31, 2024 · Delaware joins E-ZPass no-touch quick fuel, parking program · An innovative way to save time using E-ZPass is coming to the First State.
  75. [75]
    [PDF] A Model for the Benefits of Electronic Toll Collection System
    Nov 14, 2003 · The toll agency benefits include reduction in operating. Page 10. 2 cost, reduction in man labor, reduction in maintenance cost, and enhanced ...
  76. [76]
    Toll Collectors: A Disappearing Breed - Stateline.org
    Jul 24, 2015 · In Florida, for example, officials say they're saving $10 million a year in operational costs using all-electronic tolling on the southernmost ...
  77. [77]
    (PDF) Benefit-Cost Evaluation of the Electronic Toll Collection System
    Aug 6, 2025 · Time saving is a major direct benefit of ETC. Other benefits include energy saving, emission reduction, and service improvement. Toll patrons ...
  78. [78]
    [PDF] Analysis of the Operational Impact of ETC Lanes on Toll Station
    The process of stopping to pay the toll reduces the traffic flow, increases the waiting time, queue length ... of Traffic Operations at Electronic Toll Collection ...<|separator|>
  79. [79]
    [PDF] e-zpass evaluation report - ROSA P
    Table 1 below presents the Implementation History of E-ZPass on the Thruway. ... sharing technology in the adoption of a single technology for their facilities.
  80. [80]
    [PDF] EVIDENCE FROM E-ZPASS Janet Currie Reed Walker Working ...
    We exploit the introduction of electronic toll collection, (E-ZPass), which greatly reduced both traffic congestion and vehicle emissions near highway toll ...
  81. [81]
    Effect of Implementing Electronic Toll Collection in Reducing ...
    The results indicate that the full implementation of ETC can help reduce UFP number concentrations and PM 2.5 mass concentrations in the highway downwind area.
  82. [82]
    Characterizing CO2 and NOx emission of vehicles crossing toll ...
    The experiment demonstrated that ETC can effectively reduce NOx, HC, CO, and CO2 emission factors by 16.4 %, 71.2 %, 71.3 %, and 48.9 %, respectively. They also ...
  83. [83]
    Fuel Consumption and Vehicle Emission Models for Evaluating ...
    The results shows that the applications of ETC system are expected to save fuel consumption of 4.1 million liters and reduce pollution emissions by 730.89 tons ...
  84. [84]
    Estimating Environmental Benefits of Electronic Toll Collection (ETC)
    Oct 30, 2019 · It was observed that a 42, 22, and 64% reduction in CO2, CO, and NOx emissions, respectively, can be achieved during a 24-h period when the ...
  85. [85]
    Reduction of Fuel Consumption and Exhaust Pollutant Using ... - NIH
    Intelligent transport system (ITS) technologies can be implemented to lower pollutant emissions and reduction of fuel consumption. This paper investigates the ...<|separator|>
  86. [86]
    Transition to all electronic tolling leads to cost savings
    ... Tollway Authority's transition to all-electronic toll collection and potential savings of up to $472 million by 2045. By Carla Kienast, ETC Corporation.
  87. [87]
    The Future of Toll Roads: Innovations in Payment Technology
    Feb 8, 2025 · Cost Efficiency: Operating costs experienced a maximum reduction of 40% in their toll road operations. Environmental Impact: The implementation ...Missing: savings | Show results with:savings
  88. [88]
    [PDF] Facts and Myths about Tolls - IBTTA
    One-way toll collection implemented by 37 percent of a recent survey sample. One agency estimated cost savings of 40 percent. 3. Automatic coin/token machine ( ...
  89. [89]
    Envisioning the future of tolling - HNTB
    Hypothetically, after implementing all three strategies, the agency could see a 3% overall increase in total revenue (from 93% in AET 1.0 to 96% in AET 2.0).
  90. [90]
    Tolling Solutions to Stop Revenue Leakage | Deloitte US
    With new techniques for levying electronic tolls, toll authorities should seek tolling solutions to streamline integration to help stop revenue leakage.
  91. [91]
    Tolls vs. Taxes: Evaluating Funding Mechanisms for Infrastructure
    Dedicated Funding Source: Tolls provide a dedicated revenue stream for specific infrastructure projects. This can enhance financial planning and ensure that ...
  92. [92]
    Electronic Toll Collection System Market Size by 2030
    Toll collection at roads, tunnels, or expressways has proven to be an efficient solution for collecting fees and taxes, generating revenue for public-private ...
  93. [93]
    A Model for the Benefits of Electronic Toll Collection System
    It is also used to study the effect of the traffic flow on the total benefits and recommendation has been made with respect to the time for the ETC deployment.
  94. [94]
    RFID Chips | American Civil Liberties Union
    In both cases, RFID tags make it possible for governments, stores, and hackers to identify people at a distance and without their knowledge. Anywhere an RFID ...
  95. [95]
    Government Surveillance Records Show E-ZPass Readers Around ...
    Apr 21, 2015 · The NYCLU released maps indicating where the readers are located, with additional documents regarding the Stingray cell phone tracking device.Missing: retention | Show results with:retention
  96. [96]
    How RFID Tags Could Be Used to Track Unsuspecting People
    Sep 1, 2008 · A privacy activist argues that the devices pose new security risks to those who carry them, often unwittingly.
  97. [97]
    Toll payment devices used to track vehicles on toll-free roads
    Apr 28, 2015 · RFID readers track toll payment devices on toll-free roads, logging travel times. Even vehicles without toll devices are tracked via license ...
  98. [98]
    Massachusetts Officials Defend Use of Tollbooth Camera Info
    Oct 26, 2023 · MassDOT keeps the images for up to three years and E-ZPass toll data for up to 10 years, a department spokesperson said. If an emergency ...
  99. [99]
    Police have used the Mass. Pike's electronic tolling system to track ...
    Aug 10, 2017 · Authorities have attempted to track vehicles in seven cases so far. · Those cases involve at-large murder, kidnapping and arson suspects, and ...Missing: examples | Show results with:examples
  100. [100]
    Chris Christie, Port Authority Official Abused E-ZPass Data For Their ...
    Jan 21, 2015 · What data is harmless in the hands of the government? Apparently, not much. Case in point: the data collected by E-ZPass transponders.
  101. [101]
    E-ZPasses Get Read All Over New York (Not Just At Toll Booths)
    Sep 12, 2013 · The DoT was not forthcoming about what exactly was read from the passes or how long geolocation information from the passes was kept. Notably, ...
  102. [102]
    Electronic tolling: we can have new technology and privacy, too.
    Aug 29, 2016 · That means: Only collect what you need, secure the information with encryption, limit internal access, require police to get a warrant except ...Missing: risks | Show results with:risks
  103. [103]
    [PDF] A Survey on Privacy-Preserving Electronic Toll Collection Schemes ...
    The objective of ETCS is to Page 2 provide security and privacy for drivers. An adversary in ETCS could perform various attacks violating security and privacy, ...
  104. [104]
    [PDF] Electronic Tolling Turns Ugly: - Solving the Failed-Transponder ...
    Failed transponders must be identified and replaced. If they are not, toll revenues will be lost. 71. Technology. Problems with Battery Life.
  105. [105]
    [PDF] Challenges Faced by Automated E-Toll Collection System - ijrpr
    Challenges include FASTag loss, technical glitches causing double deductions, unauthorized cars in lanes, and blacklisted tags due to insufficient balance.
  106. [106]
    Toll problems not unique to Texas. How other states hold vendors ...
    May 12, 2023 · Several states, including Texas, have reported vendor software problems that have led to thousands of incorrect bills and fees. The 'problem' ...
  107. [107]
    Evaluate pros and cons of different methods for electronic toll ...
    Electronic toll collection provides a fast and efficient way for agencies to collect tolls, reducing fixed costs and increasing highway throughput. Essential to ...
  108. [108]
    https://www.giac.org/paper/gsec/3854/electronic-toll-collection-introduction-potential-vulnerabilities/106183
  109. [109]
    [PDF] Electronic Toll Collection - GIAC Certifications
    Apr 27, 2004 · There are two main types of vulnerability points for the ETC systems. The first type of vulnerability is to the backbone infrastructure, a ...Missing: breaches | Show results with:breaches
  110. [110]
    FasTrak Toll Hacked, Exposing Privacy Dangers - Dark Reading
    Jul 9, 2008 · “It amazes me there has not already been widespread fraud, cloning, and selling of 'free transponders' that” were hacked and reprogrammed, he ...
  111. [111]
    Road Tolls Hacked - ABC News - The Walt Disney Company
    Aug 25, 2008 · This means that fraudsters could clone transponders, says Lawson, by copying the ID of another driver onto their device. As a result, they could ...
  112. [112]
    EZ Pass Fraud - how did they do it? - Mr. Money Mustache Forum
    Jun 12, 2023 · EZ Pass automatically replenished my account. Went on line with EZ Pass to see that someone used our account several states away a few days ago.
  113. [113]
    E-ZPass Phishing Scam Targets E-ZPass - Security Spotlight
    Apr 7, 2025 · A massive wave of phishing texts impersonating E-ZPass is stealing personal and financial data. Scammers use urgency and encrypted messaging to bypass security ...
  114. [114]
    Maine E-ZPass System Closed to Avoid Possible Security Breach
    Apr 16, 2025 · The E-ZPass system on the Maine Turnpike was shut down for 12 hours in March to avoid a potential online security breach, turnpike officials said Tuesday.Missing: vulnerabilities | Show results with:vulnerabilities
  115. [115]
    How to Prevent Toll Hacks by Prioritizing Toll Collection Security
    Adding electronic transmissions to the collection process could result in toll hacks if cyber security is ignored or not prioritized.Missing: evasion | Show results with:evasion
  116. [116]
    Security Vulnerabilities in Toll Collection System - ResearchGate
    Aug 6, 2025 · These vulnerabilities can include unauthorized access to sensitive information, tampering with electronic payment systems, and disruption of ...
  117. [117]
    Toll Payment Services Abused by Threat Actors in Large-Scale ...
    Apr 7, 2025 · In a sophisticated and large-scale cyberattack, a China-based threat group, dubbed the "Smishing Triad," is exploiting toll payment systems.
  118. [118]
    [PDF] Analyzing the Impact of Highway Tolls on Low-Income Persons
    While not redistributing the revenues implies that tolls are likely to be regressive, it is important to recognize the financing a project with tolls will ...
  119. [119]
    [PDF] Equity Considerations for Toll Facilities
    Oct 14, 2021 · Tolls should not place a disproportionate burden on low-income households. • Toll Facility Analysis Study: Usage, Benefits, and Equity. • CAPTI.
  120. [120]
    Toll Programs and Tolling Equity in the USA: Current Best Practices
    Jul 8, 2025 · The collection of tolls, however, raises several equity concerns as these cost burdens can disproportionately affect low-income and vulnerable ...
  121. [121]
    Political and technical complexities of electronic toll collection
    This paper provides a contextual analysis of Taiwan's experience of introducing ETC and its current and ongoing development based on documentary analysis.
  122. [122]
    E-ZPass: The Effort to Design and Implement a Regional Electronic ...
    $$3.95Oct 31, 2005 · This case tells the story of the development of a regional agreement to permit the E-ZPass electronic toll collection system to be used in a ...
  123. [123]
    How could satellite-based tolling technology change India's toll roads?
    Jun 27, 2024 · GNSS-based toll collection lowers infrastructure costs as it doesn't require physical toll booths or RFID tags, it can facilitate free flow lanes.<|separator|>
  124. [124]
    A deep learning-based approach for axle counter in free-flow tolling ...
    Feb 10, 2024 · This research presents the development of an axle counter to compose a free-flow toll collection system.Proposed Method · Object Detection Analysis · Axle Counting Analysis
  125. [125]
    Tattile LPR cameras power Brazil's first free-flow tolling operation
    Thanks to its artificial intelligence-based algorithm, this LPR camera generates the reconstructed image of the vehicle for visual confirmation, together with ...
  126. [126]
    VINCI Highways leverages AI to enhance license plate reading on ...
    Mar 5, 2025 · ... . The partnership with ViaPlus delivers image review services with artificial intelligence to support HCTRA's video tolling operations.
  127. [127]
    Indra brings Connected Vehicle Tolling (C-V2X Toll) to North ...
    Sep 18, 2025 · I-485 Express Lanes will be the first in the United States to feature C-V2X tolling, a pioneering project led by Indra to optimize toll ...
  128. [128]
    Now is the time for V2X in tolling | ITS International
    Jul 9, 2025 · Next-generation toll payment using direct, low-latency cellular Vehicle to Everything (C-V2X) technology that allows vehicles to connect to roadside ...
  129. [129]
    Indra, Audi and Qualcomm Join Forces to Demonstrate the Future of ...
    May 29, 2025 · The disruptive C-V2X payment system will provide a seamless experience by displaying accurate toll notifications on in-vehicle screens, ...
  130. [130]
    Electronic Toll Collection Market Size | Industry Report, 2033
    The global electronic toll collection market size was estimated at USD 9.45 billion in 2024 and is projected to reach USD 21.50 billion by 2033, ...Missing: worldwide statistics
  131. [131]
    Electronic Toll Collection Market Report 2025, Size And Share ...
    Mar 24, 2025 · North America was the largest region in the electronic toll collection market in 2024. Asia-Pacific is expected to be the fastest-growing region ...<|separator|>
  132. [132]
    RCW 47.56.795: Tolls—Electronic toll collection and photo toll ...
    Records identifying a specific instance of travel by a specific person or vehicle must be retained only as required to ensure payment and enforcement of tolls ...Missing: periods | Show results with:periods