Fast, Cheap & Out of Control is a 1997 American documentary film written and directed by Errol Morris.[1] The film interweaves the stories of four men driven by extraordinary obsessions: lion tamer Dave Hoover, who commands wild animals through discipline and respect; topiary gardener George Mendonça, who shapes shrubs into animal forms at a Massachusetts estate; naked mole-rat expert Ray Mendez, who studies the eusocial rodents' underground colonies; and MIT robotics scientist Rodney Brooks, who develops autonomous machines inspired by insect behavior.[1] Through their interviews—conducted using Morris's signature Interrotron device, which allows subjects to look directly into the camera—the film explores broader themes of human striving, the illusion of control, the interplay between nature and technology, and the blurred lines between creator and creation.[1] The title derives from a 1989 paper co-authored by Brooks and Anita M. Flynn, advocating for swarms of inexpensive, simple robots to explore the solar system rather than complex, costly single missions.[2]Morris employs a distinctive visual style, blending interviews with archival footage, reenactments, circus clips, and scientific imagery shot in multiple formats including 35mm, 16mm, Super 8, black-and-white, and color video.[1]Cinematographer Robert Richardson captures the subjects' worlds with a mix of intimacy and surrealism, while composer Caleb Sampson's score adds haunting, orchestral depth to the narrative's philosophical undertones.[1] Produced by Fourth Floor Productions in association with American Playhouse, the 80-minute film was theatrically released in the United States on October 3, 1997, and earned critical acclaim, including the National Society of Film Critics' award for Best Documentary.[1][3] It holds a 91% approval rating from critics on Rotten Tomatoes, who praise its "care and patience" in weaving disparate lives into a "fresh, cogent perspective on life," and an 84% audience score based on over 2,500 ratings.[3] Despite its modest U.S. box office gross of $878,960,[4] the documentary remains a landmark in Morris's oeuvre, celebrated for its innovative nonfiction storytelling and enduring examination of obsession and autonomy.[3]
Synopsis
Overview
Fast, Cheap & Out of Control is a 1997 American documentary film directed by Errol Morris.[1] The film interweaves interviews and archival footage of four men engaged in eccentric professions—a lion tamer, a topiary gardener, a naked mole rat expert, and a robotics scientist—all driven by an obsession to impose order on chaotic natural or technological elements.[1] Running 80 minutes, it was produced by Fourth Floor Productions in association with American Playhouse and distributed by Sony Pictures Classics.[5]The film's title derives from a 1989 paper co-authored by robotics scientist Rodney Brooks and Anita M. Flynn, titled "Fast, Cheap and Out of Control: A Robot Invasion of the Solar System," which proposed building swarms of simple, inexpensive, autonomous robots for space exploration instead of relying on a few large, complex machines.[2] This phrase encapsulates Brooks's philosophy of efficient, decentralized systems, which Morris uses to frame the broader mosaic of human attempts at mastery over unpredictability.[1]Through its non-linear structure, the documentary blends humor, melancholy, and absurdity to probe philosophical questions about control, evolution, and the boundaries between humans and the worlds they seek to shape.[1] Morris's signature style highlights the subjects' passions without overt narration, creating a tapestry that reflects on tradition, innovation, and the illusions of dominance.[5]
Dave Hoover: The Lion Tamer
Dave Hoover, a retired U.S. Air Force officer, transitioned into a career as a lion trainer after serving in the military, where he began keeping young lions as pets while stationed in Texas.[6] Following his discharge, he worked briefly as a circulation manager for a newspaper before joining family-run circuses, eventually becoming a full-time wild animal trainer with over 40 years of experience working with big cats by the time of the film's production.[6] At a Massachusetts animal park, Hoover trained lions and tigers, drawing inspiration from legendary trainer Clyde Beatty, whom he idolized from childhood viewings of adventure serials like Darkest Africa.[7][8]In his interviews, Hoover describes his approach to training as one that emphasizes respect and psychological manipulation over brute force or dominance, treating the animals as equals in their shared environment.[6] He explains using props like a chair not to physically fend off attacks but to confuse the lions' single-minded focus, pointing its four legs at them to distract and redirect their attention from aggression.[7] "Lions are very single-minded," Hoover notes, highlighting how this technique exploits their instincts to maintain safety inside the cage.[7] He stresses the importance of genuine fear as a survival tool, warning, "If you're not scared of them, you're in big trouble," while advocating affection and routine to build bonds, starting young cats on simple rewards like stew meat on a stick to teach tricks without breaking their spirit.[9][6]Hoover's philosophical outlook on animal-human relationships underscores a profound interdependence, where the cage blurs boundaries between worlds: "Outside the cage is the cage. Inside is their world."[10] He views training as a delicate balance of discipline and empathy, fostering loyalty through daily routines rather than fear, and reflects on the obsessional drive that mirrors humanity's quest for control over nature.[8] This perspective, rooted in decades of hands-on experience, portrays lions not as mere performers but as partners in a high-stakes ritual of mutual understanding.The film's visual thread on Hoover features intimate footage of him entering enclosures with multiple lions, demonstrating feeding sessions where he rewards compliance with meat, and playful interactions that reveal the animals' speed and power—capable of crossing a football field in three to four seconds.[8] These sequences emphasize the routine discipline of his work, intercut with archival clips of Beatty's acts to illustrate Hoover's lifelong emulation, culminating in live demonstrations of chair-based techniques during performances.[7] Such visuals underscore the precarious harmony Hoover achieves, paralleling broader themes of imposed order in an unpredictable world.[8]
George Mendonça: The Topiary Gardener
George Mendonça served as superintendent of the Green Animals Topiary Garden in Portsmouth, Rhode Island, from 1945 to 1985, overseeing the maintenance of over 80 sculptural evergreens shaped into animals and geometric forms.[11] He began working at the estate in 1939 alongside his father-in-law, Joseph Carreiro, the Portuguese immigrant gardener who originated many of the site's distinctive topiaries using American arborvitae, yew, and boxwood.[11] Of Portuguese descent through his family ties, Mendonça expanded the collection by introducing frame supports and new plant varieties, transforming the 3-acre formal garden into a renowned horticultural landmark overlooking Narragansett Bay.[12][13]In his interviews for the documentary, Mendonça detailed the meticulous, year-round labor required to preserve the topiaries' forms, emphasizing the physical demands of clipping overgrown privet hedges into precise figures such as elephants, lions, giraffes, and bears.[1] He described the process as an ongoing struggle, where the plants continually push toward unchecked growth, requiring daily intervention to maintain their sculpted shapes—often using monofilament lines to guide branches without rigid frames.[14] This hands-on routine, performed alongside his wife Mary Carreiro, involved seasonal tasks like heavy pruning in spring and summer to combat insects and storms that could revert decades of work to wild tangles.[14] Mendonça viewed his role not merely as maintenance but as a disciplined partnership with nature, where patience and precision yield living statues that endure for generations.[11]The segment's visual elements capture the garden's timeless allure through a blend of archival photographs and contemporary footage, showcasing Mendonça at age 82 scaling ladders to trim a giraffe's elongated neck amid falling clippings, and wide shots of the menagerie under varying light— from vibrant summer blooms to stark winter outlines.[1][14] These sequences highlight the ephemeral quality of his craft, where natural forces like hurricanes pose constant threats, underscoring topiary as a metaphor for humanity's effort to impose structure on the environment's inherent chaos.[14] Mendonça's personal history, rooted in a multigenerational commitment to the estate since his early involvement, reflects a life of quiet routine dedicated to this balance of control and coexistence.[11] This thread connects briefly to the film's exploration of order amid unpredictability.[1]
Ray Mendez: The Naked Mole Rat Expert
Raymond Mendez is a biologist and exhibit designer affiliated with institutions such as the Smithsonian Institution, where he contributed to entomology displays before extending his expertise to mammalian social structures resembling insect colonies.[15] His fascination with naked mole rats (Heterocephalus glaber) began from his background in entomology, leading him to maintain a research colony in a Boston-area lab to study their eusocial behaviors and underground dynamics.[16] Mendez's work emphasizes the rodents' colony organization, including division of labor and reproductive hierarchies, drawing parallels to ant and termite societies that challenged traditional views of mammalian behavior.[17]In the documentary, Mendez describes naked mole rats as eusocial mammals, the only known species alongside the Damaraland mole rat to exhibit such insect-like sociality, with a single breedingqueen, non-breeding workers, and soldiers maintaining lifelong roles within colonies of up to 300 individuals.[18] He highlights their queen-worker hierarchy, noting how workers can transition to queens if the reigning one dies, as observed in a case where a five-year-old worker assumed the role after the original queen's death.[18] Mendez compares their society to termites, emphasizing cooperative behaviors like communal food storage in middens and odor-based identification through feces-rolling, which allows colonies to recognize and aggressively defend against intruders.[18] He also discusses their exceptional longevity in captivity, attributing it to low predation in stable underground environments, though wild populations rarely reach advanced ages due to threats from birds and larger animals.[18]The segment features intimate close-up footage of Mendez's lab colony, showcasing the rodents' subterranean lifestyle through transparent tunnels that reveal tunneling, grooming, and social interactions without disturbing their environment.[18] Visuals include dissections and behavioral observations, such as pups consuming cecotropes for gut microbiome development and adults exhibiting rapid jaw movements for burrowing, with teeth protruding like chisels capable of gnawing concrete.[18] Mendez's hands-on experiments, like testing burrow materials for zoo exhibits, are depicted, including failures with plaster that collapsed under the mole rats' digging prowess.[18]Naked mole rats' biology, as explored by Mendez, includes adaptations to their fossorial habitat, such as hairlessness, reduced thermoregulation (lacking sweat glands and shivering ability), and a near-cold-blooded metabolism suited to constant underground temperatures.[18] Their pain insensitivity to certain stimuli, like acid, stems from lacking substance P in their skin, enabling unhindered tunneling through abrasive soils. Mendez observed breeding dynamics firsthand, including the queen's enlarged body for pup production and colony vocalizations—tweets, grunts, and whistles—for coordination, underscoring their "alien" yet familiar social complexity.[18]
Rodney Brooks: The Robotics Scientist
Rodney Brooks, a prominent researcher at MIT's Artificial Intelligence Laboratory during the 1990s, specialized in developing autonomous mobile robots inspired by insect behaviors.[19] His work emphasized creating simple, reactive systems that could navigate complex environments without relying on detailed pre-programmed instructions, marking a shift from traditional artificial intelligence paradigms.In the 1990s, Brooks led the development of insect-like robots, including the six-legged Genghis, a prototype built in 1989 as a testbed for his subsumption architecture—a layered control system where basic behaviors (such as obstacle avoidance) emerge from simple sensor-actuator connections rather than centralized planning.[20] Genghis demonstrated emergent walking and scrambling over rough terrain through distributed processing across its legs, each controlled by individual microprocessors tuned to infrared sensors mimicking insect compound eyes.[21] This approach allowed the robot to exhibit lifelike mobility, such as following heat sources or adapting to uneven surfaces, without explicit gait programming.During his interview in the film, Brooks articulated the "fast, cheap, and out of control" philosophy as a design principle for robotics, advocating for numerous inexpensive, autonomous units over singular, complex machines to enhance reliability and scalability.[18] He critiqued traditional AI for its disembodied focus on abstract reasoning, arguing that true intelligence requires physical embodiment and direct interaction with the environment, as "the world is its own best model."[18] Brooks explained that his robots succeed by starting with rudimentary reactive layers—such as stopping at obstacles or wandering randomly—which build incrementally into more sophisticated behaviors, avoiding the brittleness of top-down symbolic programming.[18]The film's visuals accompanying Brooks's thread feature dynamic footage of robot prototypes like Genghis navigating cluttered lab floors and obstacles, alongside demonstrations of multi-robot interactions and computer simulations illustrating emergent group dynamics.[18] These sequences highlight the tactile, iterative nature of his lab work, showing legged machines scrambling and adapting in real-time.Central to Brooks's concepts is a bottom-up AI methodology, where intelligence arises from layered, biology-inspired mechanisms rather than hierarchical deliberation; he drew parallels to ant colonies, noting how simple individual rules in his R-1 robots enable collective exploration without explicit communication, much like social insects foraging en masse.[18] Looking ahead, Brooks predicted swarms of such microrobots for space exploration, envisioning fleets of lightweight devices autonomously mapping planetary surfaces and performing tasks like soil analysis, as outlined in his seminal 1989 paper co-authored with Anita M. Flynn.[2] This vision, which inspired the film's title, emphasized deploying "out of control" systems that operate independently to mitigate mission failures from single-point breakdowns.[2]
Production
Development and Inspiration
Errol Morris's documentary Fast, Cheap & Out of Control originated in the early 1990s from his fascination with eccentric individuals obsessed with imposing order on chaotic subjects, a theme that echoed his earlier works such as The Thin Blue Line (1988), where he explored human attempts to control narratives through testimony and evidence.[22] This interest in eccentrics—people whose private worlds reveal broader insights into human ambition—drove Morris to profile unusual experts, blending elements of nature, animals, and technology to examine control.[23]The film's title and central inspiration came from a 1989 paper by MITrobotics scientist Rodney Brooks, titled "Fast, Cheap, and Out of Control: A Robot Invasion of the Solar System," which advocated for deploying swarms of simple, autonomous robots to explore space rather than relying on expensive, centralized systems.[24] Morris's wife first brought Brooks to his attention after reading about his work on insect-like robots, prompting Morris to contact him at MIT and secure an interview as the project's starting point.[25] From there, the concept expanded beyond robotics; Morris initially envisioned disconnected profiles of disparate obsessives but, during the research and editing phases, wove them into interconnected themes of control, evolution, and mortality to create thematic resonance.[25]Research involved personal outreach through scientific and artistic contacts, leading to the selection of the other subjects for their complementary stories and self-reflective narratives.[23]Morris met naked mole rat expert Ray Mendez, whose enthusiasm for the rodents' social structures inspired their inclusion as a counterpoint to technological control.[25] He discovered topiary gardener George Mendonça during a visit to his elaborate animal-shaped shrubbery in Portsmouth, Rhode Island, drawn to the gardener's lifelong labor of shaping nature.[25] Lion tamer Dave Hoover was a prior acquaintance, with Morris having filmed preliminary footage of his act years earlier, providing a natural fit for themes of animal domination.[25] Early development in the mid-1990s focused on securing these interviews to balance animal handlers with technological visionaries, ensuring thematic depth without a predefined linear structure.[23]As a low-budget independent production, the film was written, directed, and produced by Morris himself, relying on minimal crew and a mix of new and archival footage to keep costs down while allowing creative flexibility.[26]
Filming Process
Principal photography for Fast, Cheap & Out of Control took place primarily in 1996 over several months, capturing footage of the four subjects in their respective environments.[23] The production filmed in Massachusetts, including Rodney Brooks's robotics lab at MIT in Cambridge and Ray Mendez's naked mole rat laboratory in the Boston area, as well as George Mendonça's topiary garden at Green Animals in Portsmouth, Rhode Island.[23][10][14] For Dave Hoover's segments, the crew shot at various animal performance venues, notably the touring Clyde Beatty-Cole Bros. Circus, which presented logistical hurdles due to its mobile schedule.[27][28]The filming employed a mix of formats to achieve visual diversity, including 35mm, Super 16mm, Super 8, straight 8, 16mm, and video, alongside black-and-white, infrared color, and infrared black-and-white stocks.[27][1] Cinematographer Robert Richardson, an Oscar winner known for dynamic action sequences, orchestrated the shoots by lining up multiple cameras simultaneously to capture both high-energy moments—such as lions in performance and robots in motion—and more intimate interview setups.[27][1] His approach emphasized adaptability, switching formats mid-shoot to suit the unpredictable nature of the subjects, from animal interactions to laboratory demonstrations.[27]Challenges arose from coordinating with the subjects' demanding schedules, particularly Hoover's circus tours and the limited windows for accessing Mendez's lab or Mendonça's garden.[10][28] Safety concerns were paramount during animal segments, requiring careful management around the lions to avoid risks while filming their training and performances.[27] Errol Morris's improvisational, non-scripted style further complicated logistics, as the crew often adapted on-site to emergent opportunities, such as brief circus stops or lab experiments.[23] Additionally, Mendez initially hesitated to participate fully, citing past experiences with media exploitation, which delayed some approvals.[10] For interviews, Morris utilized the Interrotron device to facilitate direct eye contact with the camera.[1]
Editing and Post-Production
The editing of Fast, Cheap & Out of Control was handled by Shondra Merrill and Karen Schmeer, who crafted rhythmic transitions that interwove the four subjects' stories into a cohesive whole. Merrill, an experienced Avid editor who had previously worked on Morris's short-form projects, handled initial assembly, while Schmeer, promoted from assistant editor, played a pivotal role in refining the structure after taking over. Morris credited Schmeer with "saving" the film by advocating for extended interview passages to prevent the elaborate visuals from overshadowing the characters' narratives.[29][30]The editors employed a non-chronological approach, blending segments from the lion tamer, topiary gardener, mole rat expert, and robotics scientist to gradually reveal thematic parallels, such as obsessions with control and creation. This intermingled style evolved from fast-paced juxtapositions to more contemplative sequences, balancing humor—through witty cuts between absurd actions—with moments of introspection on human ambition. Archival footage was incorporated extensively, including old lion-taming clips from Hollywood serials like those featuring Clyde Beatty and test videos of Brooks's robots, to enrich the subjects' backstories and underscore historical echoes.[31][32]Post-production, completed in late 1996 ahead of the film's 1997 premiere, involved technical challenges in integrating diverse sources for a textured visual aesthetic. Cinematographer Robert Richardson shot on multiple film stocks—35mm, 16mm, Super 8, black-and-white, and color—alongside video, all transferred to digital for editing to achieve seamless blends between original footage and archives. Early digital tools facilitated these transitions, creating a collage-like effect that Morris described as essential to the film's impressionistic rhythm without relying on overt effects.[1][33]
Style and Techniques
Narrative Structure
Fast, Cheap & Out of Control employs a non-linear, mosaic narrative structure that interweaves the stories of four distinct subjects—a lion tamer, a topiary gardener, a naked mole rat expert, and a robotics scientist—without relying on a traditional plot or voice-overnarration, allowing viewers to infer connections through thematic echoes.[34] This multinarrative approach uses parallel montages to present each subject's world in isolation initially, gradually building overlaps via cross-cuts that highlight shared motifs of control, obsession, and human ingenuity.[35]Errol Morris has described this as an experimental form where the structure emerges organically during editing, rejecting preconceived linearity in favor of a fluid, associative flow that mirrors the complexity of the subjects' passions.[36]The film's 80-minute runtime is divided unevenly among the segments, with early portions dedicating substantial time to individual profiles before introducing juxtapositions of visuals—such as the raw power of lions cutting to the mechanical precision of robots—to imply deeper interconnections without explicit commentary.[37] These cross-cuts escalate toward the conclusion, particularly in the final 20 minutes, where the narratives converge more rapidly, creating a sense of thematic culmination rather than resolution and intensifying the viewer's engagement with the emergent patterns.[38] Morris's technique draws from experimental cinema traditions, emphasizing montage as a tool for discovery over conventional documentary arcs that impose a singular storyline.[39]By eschewing narration, the film compels audiences to actively construct meaning from the fragmented portraits, fostering a mosaic effect where disparate elements resonate through visual and rhythmic parallels.[34] This structure not only underscores the autonomy of each subject's expertise but also reveals broader human endeavors, as Morris intended the editing process to tease out an overarching narrative from seemingly unrelated material.[36]
Visual Style
The visual style of Fast, Cheap & Out of Control employs a diverse array of film formats to blend documentary realism with artistic experimentation, including 35mm for structured interviews, Super 8 and 16mm for dynamic action sequences, and video for supplementary material, all contributing to a textured, layered aesthetic.[40] Archival black-and-white clips from old movies, stock footage, and cartoons are integrated to add historical and cultural depth, creating a collage-like effect that juxtaposes past and present.[32]Cinematographer Robert Richardson's approach features bold contrasts in composition, with expansive wide shots capturing vast landscapes, robotic assemblies, and topiary gardens to evoke scale and ambition, set against intimate close-ups of human faces, animal subjects, and intricate details like mole rats in their burrows.[27] Slow-motion sequences emphasize dramatic tension in key moments, such as animal interactions or mechanical movements, enhancing the film's thematic exploration of control without relying on staged re-enactments.[38] Handheld camerawork and dramatic lighting, including high backlighting and infrared variations in both color and black-and-white, further amplify the observational verité style, departing from director Errol Morris's earlier use of fabricated scenes in favor of direct, unfiltered observation.[40][27]The color palette mixes vibrant and desaturated tones, with earthy hues dominating natural subjects like wildlife and foliage to ground them in organic reality, while cooler, metallic shades highlight technological elements such as robots and machinery, visually metaphorizing the tension between human dominion over nature and artificial creation—though specific palette choices were not explicitly detailed in production accounts, the overall effect arises from the interplay of color and monochrome footage.[32] This stylistic fusion, achieved through multiple cameras rolled simultaneously across formats, allows for pre-composed, high-impact frames that underscore the film's philosophical inquiries.[27] The Interrotron device, used for interviews, subtly frames subjects in a direct gaze that integrates seamlessly with these broader visual elements.[40]
Interview Technique
In Fast, Cheap & Out of Control, Errol Morris employed the Interrotron, a custom interviewing device he invented, to capture monologues from the film's four primary subjects: a lion tamer, a topiary gardener, a naked mole rat expert, and a roboticsscientist.[41] The Interrotron functions as a modified teleprompter system that projects a live video image of the interviewer—Morris himself—onto a two-way mirror positioned in front of the camera lens, enabling subjects to maintain direct eye contact with both the interviewer and the audience while speaking.[42] This setup allowed interviewees to read cues if needed without averting their gaze from the lens, resulting in unblinking, sustained delivery that conveyed immediacy and presence.[43]The device made its debut in this 1997 film, where it was used for all major interviews, marking the first time Morris applied it in production after developing it to address the limitations of traditional off-camera questioning.[42] Subjects responded positively to the Interrotron, often feeling more relaxed and engaged, which facilitated extended, intimate sessions—such as the five interviews Morris conducted, four of which appear in the final cut.[23] Technically, the system relies on a beam-splitter mirror and connected monitors to beam the interviewer's feed to the subject's prompter, ensuring the camera captures the subject's eyes looking straight ahead without interruption.[44]The Interrotron's implementation heightened the authenticity of the interactions by fostering a sense of direct address, where subjects appeared to speak vulnerability to viewers as if confiding personally.[45]Morris has described this eye contact as essential to truthful communication, arguing it restores the "true first person" in documentary filmmaking, blending intimacy with a subtle dramatic tension that underscores the speakers' convictions and quirks.[42] By eliminating the physical separation typical in interviews, the device amplified emotional exposure, aligning with Morris's philosophy that sustained gaze reveals layers of sincerity or evasion in human testimony.[23]
Themes and Interpretation
Control and Order
In Fast, Cheap & Out of Control, Errol Morris presents the four central subjects—lion trainer Dave Hoover, topiary gardener George Mendonça, naked mole-rat researcher Ray Mendez, and robotics pioneer Rodney Brooks—as microcosms of humanity's enduring drive to impose order on chaotic natural and artificial systems.[10] Each man's work reflects a quest to master unpredictable elements, from wild animals to organic growth, social hierarchies, and mechanical behaviors, underscoring a broader human impulse to project control onto the world as a means of self-understanding.[46] Morris articulates this theme as an exploration of "the control of nature" and "our ideas about control," where the subjects' endeavors reveal both the allure and the fragility of such mastery.[10]Hoover exemplifies affectionate yet firm dominance over animals, training lions through a philosophy of unyielding authority: "Never let him know that you’re weaker than him."[40] Mendonça counters the relentless chaos of plant growth by meticulously clipping topiaries into rigid shapes, creating an ordered landscape that defies nature's entropy, though his forms remain impermanent.[23] Mendez imposes laboratory hierarchies on naked mole-rats, whose eusocial structure—where individuals are "expend[ed] for the greater whole"—mirrors enforced communal order amid biological unpredictability.[40] Brooks, meanwhile, designs reactive algorithms for insect-like robots that navigate environments autonomously, aspiring to a future where "silicon replaces carbon in the evolutionary order," blending human ingenuity with simulated natural processes.[40]Philosophically, these pursuits evoke a Sisyphus-like futility, portraying control as an illusion sustained by human hubris against inevitable disorder. Morris frames the film as a meditation on whether we observe the external world or merely "project an image of ourselves on [it]," highlighting the self-deceptive nature of such efforts.[10] Through subtle juxtapositions of footage—such as archival clips of uncontrollable forces like giant insects—the director critiques the overreach in humanity's bid to order reality, suggesting that true mastery eludes even the most dedicated architects of control.[46] This lens positions the subjects not as triumphant innovators but as poignant symbols of our collective, Sisyphean struggle.[23]
Human Ambition and Mortality
The documentary Fast, Cheap & Out of Control portrays the four central subjects—lion tamer Dave Hoover, topiary gardener George Mendonça, naked mole-rat researcher Ray Mendez, and robotics engineer Rodney Brooks—as embodiments of profound human ambition, each channeling lifelong dedication into pursuits that serve as both an escape from and a confrontation with mortality.[1] Hoover's career emulates the legendary Clyde Beatty, reflecting a drive to master wild animals as a way to impose order on chaos, while Mendonça's decades-long sculpting of animal topiaries creates a tangible legacy against the inevitability of personal decline.[18] Brooks envisions robots as extensions of humanity, potentially achieving a form of immortality by outlasting biological limits and evolving independently in harsh environments like space.[18] These obsessions underscore ambition not merely as professional zeal but as a psychological bulwark against death's finality.[7]Mortality permeates the subjects' reflections, manifesting in cues of aging, impermanence, and the quest for survival. Hoover expresses fears of retirement and the physical toll of his profession, contemplating mundane ends like a heart attack over dramatic ones in the cage, highlighting the vulnerability of a life built on risk.[18] Mendonça acknowledges the ephemerality of his garden, noting that a single storm could erase years of meticulous work and lamenting that he "won’t live long enough to make another bear like that one," while committing to its care "as long as I live."[18] Mendez, studying naked mole-rats known for their exceptional longevity—up to nearly 40 years in captivity (as of 2025), far exceeding typical rodent lifespans—contrasts their eusocial stability with human transience, observing that "the whole concept of stability is a concept of death" and noting the rarity of aged specimens in the wild.[18][47] These elements evoke the film's elegiac undertones, influenced by director Errol Morris's personal losses following the deaths of his mother and stepfather.[48]The emotional tone blends melancholic humor with the subjects' obsessions, revealing human fragility beneath their eccentric genius. Hoover's tales of using chairs to outwit lions carry an absurd wit, yet betray isolation in a fading circus tradition; Mendez's fascination with mole-rats rolling feces for scent trails injects levity into discussions of evolutionary endurance.[7] This interplay humanizes their drives, portraying ambition as a poignant, often quixotic response to existential limits.[48]Ultimately, the film meditates on what propels such singular figures: a compulsion to create enduring meaning amid impermanence, whether through artistic permanence, scientific insight, or technological transcendence, inviting viewers to ponder the nobility and pathos in these quests.[7][1]
Nature Versus Technology
In Fast, Cheap & Out of Control, Errol Morris juxtaposes organic life forms—such as lions, naked mole rats, and topiaryplants—with synthetic robots to explore the binary divide between nature and technology, ultimately blurring these boundaries through bio-inspired designs. The film's natural subjects, including Dave Hoover's lion-taming sequences and Ray Mendez's studies of naked mole rats, represent untamed or collectively organized biological systems, while Rodney Brooks's autonomous robots embody artificial intelligence engineered for adaptability in unpredictable environments. Brooks's approach draws directly from biological models, advocating for swarms of simple, inexpensive robots that mimic insect behaviors rather than centralized, human-like machines, as outlined in his seminal 1989 paper where he proposes deploying numerous lightweight robots to explore space in a decentralized manner.[10][8][49]Key contrasts highlight these parallels, particularly between Mendez's naked mole rat colonies and Brooks's robot swarms, where both exhibit eusocial structures with expendable individuals sacrificing for the group, adapting without a single authority figure, and relying on a "queen" mole rat or lead robot to guide collective behavior. Morris visually intercuts footage of mole rats burrowing in underground networks with robots navigating obstacles, emphasizing their shared efficiency in harsh conditions and challenging viewers to see robotic systems as extensions of natural evolution. Similarly, George Mendonça's topiary gardens serve as a metaphor for "engineered" nature, where living shrubs are meticulously clipped into animal shapes—such as elephants and giraffes—imposing human order on organic growth, only for natural forces like storms to dismantle years of work in moments, underscoring the fragility of such artificial control.[50][8]This juxtaposition carries symbolic depth, portraying nature's chaotic, decentralized models as blueprints for technological advancement in AI, where Brooks envisions robots evolving to colonize environments independently of human oversight, potentially rendering humanity obsolete through simple feedback loops that replicate biological resilience. Morris uses these elements to question the boundaries of life itself, suggesting that the "robotic" qualities in mole rats or insects reveal technology's roots in organicchaos, while human-engineered systems like topiaries reveal the hubris of imposing control on unpredictable natural processes. Through these parallels, Morris undermines anthropocentrism by illustrating how humans project their desires for order onto both animals and machines, revealing a continuum rather than opposition between the organic and the artificial.[10][8]
Release
Premiere and Distribution
Fast, Cheap & Out of Control had its world premiere at the Telluride Film Festival in September 1997.[51] The film received further exposure shortly after at the New York Film Festival, where it screened on September 30, 1997.[37]Sony Pictures Classics then launched a limited theatrical release in the United States on October 3, 1997.[52]The distribution strategy emphasized an art-house rollout, targeting select theaters in major urban centers to reach specialized audiences.[53] International releases followed in 1998, including in the United Kingdom and France, expanding the film's reach beyond North America. Sony Pictures Classics, known for handling independent and specialty films, managed these efforts to align with the documentary's unconventional style.Marketing materials, such as theatrical posters, prominently featured the film's eccentric subjects—a lion tamer, robot builder, mole-rat specialist, and topiary artist—to underscore its quirky exploration of human endeavor.[1] Promotion also leveraged director Errol Morris's reputation from acclaimed prior works like The Thin Blue Line (1988), positioning the film as a continuation of his innovative documentary approach. This strategy aimed at cinephiles and enthusiasts of science, technology, and behavioral studies, fostering buzz through festival screenings and targeted advertising.[7]
Box Office Performance
Fast, Cheap & Out of Control had a limited theatrical release in the United States on October 3, 1997, distributed by Sony Pictures Classics. It opened in 2 theaters, earning $23,665 over its first weekend for an average of $11,832 per screen.[54]The film expanded to a maximum of 40 theaters during its run but remained confined to art house venues, ultimately grossing $861,600 domestically.[3] This performance equates to an overall average of approximately $21,500 per screen across its widest release, reflecting strong per-screen results in niche markets despite the limited distribution.Internationally, the film achieved modest earnings with no significant reported grosses. Its unconventional structure and focus on eccentric subjects limited broader commercial appeal, particularly against the backdrop of 1997's blockbuster-dominated box office, which included major releases like Men in Black and Titanic.[38]Post-theatrical, the film's visibility sustained briefly through festival screenings but diminished without substantial home video or international expansion at the time.[52]
Reception
Critical Response
Upon its release, Fast, Cheap & Out of Control received widespread critical acclaim for its innovative documentary style and profound exploration of human obsession and control. The film holds a 91% approval rating on Rotten Tomatoes, based on 32 reviews, reflecting strong consensus among critics who praised its originality.[3] It also earned a 7.1/10 average rating on IMDb from over 4,000 user votes, though professional reviews were more uniformly positive.[5] Several publications ranked it among the best films of 1997, highlighting its place in a standout year for cinema.[55]Prominent critics lauded the film's eccentric and inventive approach. Roger Ebert awarded it four out of four stars, describing it as a "magical" work that captures the quirky eccentricity of its subjects in a way that transcends conventional documentary storytelling.[7] In The New York Times, Janet Maslin commended Errol Morris's "one-of-a-kind" filmmaking for its delightfully exotic blend of whimsy, science, and philosophy, creating haunting connections between man, beast, and machine.[37] However, some reviewers noted minor drawbacks, such as a perceived aimlessness in its nonlinear structure, with one calling it an "unusual documentary [that is] pointless but engrossing."[56]Recurring themes in the reviews emphasized admiration for Morris's distinctive visual and interview techniques, which provide deep insight into the obsessive personalities profiled, revealing broader truths about human ambition and the illusion of control. Critics appreciated how the film weaves disparate stories into a cohesive meditation on order amid chaos, often citing its thematic richness as a hallmark of Morris's oeuvre. Minor critiques occasionally pointed to moments of inaccessibility for viewers unaccustomed to experimental nonfiction, though these were overshadowed by praise for its intellectual depth.In the 2020s, retrospective reevaluations have underscored the film's enduring relevance, particularly through the lens of artificial intelligence, linking Rodney Brooks's insect-inspired robotics philosophy to contemporary debates on machine intelligence and autonomy.[57] This renewed interest highlights how the documentary's portrayal of technological ambition anticipates modern AI developments.
Accolades and Recognition
Fast, Cheap & Out of Control received widespread critical acclaim upon its release, earning several prestigious awards that underscored its innovative approach to documentary filmmaking. The film won the National Board of Review's award for Best Documentary Feature in 1997, recognizing its unique blend of philosophical inquiry and visual experimentation.[58] Similarly, it secured the New York Film Critics Circle's Best Documentary Film award that same year, highlighting Errol Morris's distinctive interviewing technique and thematic depth.In addition to these honors, the film was awarded the National Society of Film Critics' Best Non-Fiction Film prize in 1997, affirming its status as a standout in nonfictioncinema for its exploration of human obsession and control.[59] At the 13th Independent Spirit Awards in 1998, it tied for the Truer Than Fiction Award with Soul in the Hole, celebrating its truthful yet inventive portrayal of eccentric subjects. The Kansas City Film Critics Circle also named it Best Documentary of 1997, further cementing its critical prestige among regional associations.[60]Beyond formal awards, Fast, Cheap & Out of Control marked a significant milestone in Morris's career, solidifying his reputation as a pioneering documentarian following works like The Thin Blue Line.[1] The film premiered at the Telluride Film Festival in 1997, where it garnered early audience enthusiasm, and was later screened at festivals including Vancouver, contributing to its growing recognition in independent cinema circles.[61] Although not prominently featured in major Sight & Sound polls, it has been cited in various critics' retrospectives as an influential documentary of the 1990s.[62]
Legacy and Influence
Cultural Impact
The documentary Fast, Cheap & Out of Control has exerted a lasting influence on documentary filmmaking through its innovative non-linear narrative structure and the introduction of the Interrotron, a device that enables direct eye contact between interviewer and subject during filming. Errol Morris's approach to weaving disparate stories without a traditional linear arc—juxtaposing interviews with a lion tamer, topiary gardener, naked mole-rat researcher, and robotics expert alongside archival footage and animations—pioneered a cinematic style that treats documentaries as art rather than mere reportage, inspiring filmmakers to experiment with fragmented, associative storytelling in non-fiction works.[63] The Interrotron, first prominently used in this film, has since been adapted in documentary and video production for more intimate, engaging interviews, allowing subjects to address the camera directly while seeing the interviewer, a technique that enhances authenticity and has been employed in educational media and independent filmmaking.[44]In the realm of artificial intelligence and robotics, the film's portrayal of MIT professor Rodney Brooks's philosophy of "fast, cheap, and out of control" robots—emphasizing simple, reactive behaviors over centralized control—anticipated key developments in modern robotics, influencing Brooks's own founding of iRobot and the broader shift toward behavior-based systems that prioritize adaptation to real-world environments. This approach echoes in the dynamic, autonomous machines developed by companies like Boston Dynamics, whose legged robots demonstrate emergent capabilities through distributed intelligence rather than top-down programming.[64] In the 2020s, Brooks's ideas featured in the film have been revisited amid AI ethics debates, particularly concerning the risks of uncontrolled autonomous systems in an era of rapid AI advancement, with Brooks himself critiquing hype around humanoid robots and advocating for grounded, ethical development.[65]The film has permeated popular culture through references to humanobsession and eccentricity, appearing in discussions of compulsive pursuits in non-fiction literature and media.[8] Scholarly analysis in film studies has focused on its postmodern structure, praising the rhizomatic editing and decentralized meaning-making that challenge anthropocentric narratives and reflect posthuman cultural shifts, as explored in dissertations examining visual culture's material imagination.[66] In 2025, retrospectives such as the American Cinematheque's "This Is Not a Fiction" series screened the film with Q&A sessions, underscoring its enduring relevance to themes of control amid contemporary technological anxieties.[67]
Modern Availability
Following its theatrical release, Fast, Cheap & Out of Control became available on home video through Sony Pictures Classics, with a VHS edition distributed in March 1999 and a DVD edition released on September 24, 2002.[68][69] The DVD presents the film in its original 1.85:1 aspect ratio with 16:9 enhancement but includes no supplemental features such as commentary tracks or deleted scenes.[69]By 2025, the documentary has achieved widespread digital accessibility, reflecting the shift toward streaming for older independent films. The film has been featured on the Criterion Channel, for example in a curated lineup of Errol Morris's work in October 2019.[70] For purchase or rental, it is offered in digital formats on Amazon Prime Video, Apple TV, Fandango at Home, Google Play, and Vudu.[71][72]Theatrical revivals persist in limited capacities, often as part of documentary retrospectives or film society programs, such as a scheduled screening at the American Cinematheque in April 2025.[67] No official Blu-ray or 4K UHD editions have been released, maintaining its primary availability through these streaming and digital channels.[73]
Soundtrack
Composition
The original score for Fast, Cheap & Out of Control was composed by Caleb Sampson, a founding member of the Alloy Orchestra, with the ensemble performing the music.[74] The Alloy Orchestra, known for its innovative live accompaniments to silent films, brought a percussive and eclectic approach to the soundtrack, blending traditional instruments such as percussion, winds, and keyboards with found objects and electronics to create dynamic, unconventional textures.[75] This fusion produced a sound that was both futuristic and organic, emphasizing rhythmic drive and hypnotic repetition to mirror the film's exploration of control, chaos, and human eccentricity.[8]The score shares stylistic similarities with minimalist traditions, including the repetitive layering seen in Philip Glass's work on prior Errol Morris documentaries, while incorporating the improvisational energy of silent-era scoring that the Alloy Orchestra specialized in.[76][77] Specific motifs, such as driving percussion for sequences of pursuit and wonder, underscored the circus-like atmosphere of the subjects' stories, from animal trainers to roboticists.[8]Recording took place in 1997 at Looking Glass Studios in New York, NY.[78]Sampson died on June 25, 1998, shortly after the film's release. This collaborative effort allowed the score to function as an integral atmospheric layer, amplifying the documentary's philosophical depth.[8]
Track Listing
The soundtrack for Fast, Cheap & Out of Control was released as a standalone CD in 1997 by Accurate Records, comprising 17 original tracks composed by Caleb Sampson with a total running time of 46 minutes and 36 seconds.[79][78]The album's tracks are instrumental pieces that support the film's documentary structure, often cued during transitions between subjects to build tension through percussive and orchestral elements. Key tracks include "Elephant Walk," which evokes the film's animal training sequences; "Robots Everywhere," aligned with robotics demonstrations; and "Lost City of Joba," suggesting the topiary gardener's fantastical landscapes. These selections highlight Sampson's eclectic style blending jazz, electronic, and classical influences to mirror the film's themes of control and chaos.[79]
The original CD remains the primary physical format, available through secondary markets with no major reissues to date. As of November 2025, select tracks are accessible via digital streaming on platforms like Spotify.[80][81]