Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Flutter valve

The Flutter valve is a small, portable, handheld medical device used in airway clearance therapy to mobilize and remove excess mucus from the lungs in patients with respiratory disorders characterized by hypersecretion, such as cystic fibrosis, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD), and bronchiectasis.^[1]^[2]^[3] Introduced in the early 1990s and originally developed in Switzerland by Scandipharm (now distributed by Flexicare), the device consists of a simple plastic pipe with a mouthpiece at one end and a tapered cone containing a stainless steel ball at the other.^[1]^[4] Its mechanism relies on oscillating positive expiratory pressure (OPEP): during exhalation, airflow causes the steel ball to vibrate rapidly within the cone, producing high-frequency oscillations (typically 6–26 Hz) that transmit vibrations to the airways, loosening adherent mucus, while the generated positive pressure (18–35 cm H₂O) stents open collapsible airways, accelerates mucociliary transport, and propels secretions centrally for clearance via coughing.^[1]^[5] Usage involves 5–15 minute sessions, often 2–4 times daily, in a seated or supine position; patients inhale deeply through the nose, hold briefly, exhale steadily through the device at various angles to optimize frequency, and follow with huffing or coughing to expel loosened mucus—no electricity or assistance is required after initial training.^[1]^[4] Randomized controlled trials and meta-analyses have demonstrated its superiority over traditional methods like postural drainage and percussion, yielding over three times greater sputum expectoration in cystic fibrosis and reducing COPD exacerbation frequency by up to 50% at six months, alongside improvements in symptoms, gas exchange, and quality of life.^[2]^[3] Although generally well-tolerated with minimal side effects, contraindications include untreated pneumothorax, active hemoptysis, severe tuberculosis, or acute right-sided heart failure, and it should be used cautiously in patients with facial trauma or recent surgery.^[1]^[4]

Overview

Definition and purpose

The Flutter valve is a small, portable, handheld medical device used in airway clearance therapy to mobilize and remove excess mucus from the lungs in patients with respiratory disorders characterized by hypersecretion, such as cystic fibrosis, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD), and bronchiectasis.^[1]^[2] The device consists of a simple plastic pipe with a mouthpiece at one end and a tapered cone containing a stainless steel ball at the other.^[1]^[4] Its primary purpose is to facilitate mucus expectoration by combining positive expiratory pressure with high-frequency airway oscillations, which loosen adherent secretions and promote their clearance, thereby improving lung function and reducing infection risk.^[1]

Historical development

The Flutter valve was developed in the early 1990s in Switzerland by VarioRaw SA and introduced by Scandipharm (now distributed by Flexicare) as an alternative to conventional chest physiotherapy for mucus clearance.^[1]^[6] Inspired by the need for a simple, patient-managed tool to aid in airway clearance for chronic respiratory conditions, the device was first studied in clinical trials in the mid-1990s, demonstrating efficacy in conditions like cystic fibrosis.^[2] Initial adoption focused on pediatric and adult patients with hypersecretory lung diseases, with ongoing refinements in design for better portability and ease of use. Commercial availability expanded globally in the late 1990s and 2000s, supported by evidence from randomized controlled trials.^[1]

Design and mechanism

Components

The Flutter valve is a simple, handheld plastic device approximately 10 cm long, consisting of a mouthpiece at one end connected to a central cylindrical chamber and a tapered cone at the other end containing a high-density stainless steel ball-bearing.^[7] The cone is enclosed by a perforated plastic cap that allows airflow while containing the ball. The entire device is constructed from durable, biocompatible plastic, is lightweight (about 28 g), and designed for single-patient use with easy cleaning by washing.^[4] No additional connectors or filters are required, distinguishing it from more complex respiratory devices.^[1]

Operational principles

The Flutter valve operates on the principle of oscillating positive expiratory pressure (OPEP), where exhalation through the mouthpiece creates airflow that lifts and vibrates the steel ball within the cone, generating high-frequency airway oscillations typically ranging from 6 to 26 Hz, adjustable by tilting the device 10–45 degrees.^[5] This vibration transmits to the lungs, loosening adherent mucus secretions. Simultaneously, the ball's movement produces positive expiratory pressure of 18–35 cm H₂O, which stents open collapsible airways, enhances mucociliary clearance, and propels mucus toward central airways for expulsion via coughing or huffing.^[1] The process relies on the patient's expiratory effort without external power, with optimal effect achieved at mid-to-high lung volumes and steady exhalation flows of 5–15 L/min.^[7]

Clinical applications

Indications

The Flutter valve is indicated for airway clearance in patients with hypersecretory lung disorders, including cystic fibrosis, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD), bronchiectasis, chronic bronchitis, bronchial asthma, and primary ciliary dyskinesia.^[1] It is particularly beneficial for mobilizing retained secretions in these conditions, helping to prevent respiratory infections and improve lung function.^[8] In cystic fibrosis, randomized controlled trials have shown it increases sputum expectoration by over three times compared to traditional chest physiotherapy.^[2] For COPD, it reduces exacerbation frequency and improves symptoms and quality of life.^[9] The device is also used in neuromuscular diseases such as muscular dystrophy and cerebral palsy where mucus clearance is impaired.^[7] Guidelines from organizations like the British Thoracic Society recommend it as an option for non-cystic fibrosis bronchiectasis.^[10]

Usage

The Flutter valve is a non-invasive, handheld device used in structured airway clearance sessions, typically lasting 5–15 minutes, 2–4 times daily.^[1] Patients should be in a seated or supine position with good posture. Inhale deeply through the nose, hold the breath for 2–3 seconds, then exhale steadily through the mouthpiece for 3–5 seconds while tilting the device at various angles (e.g., horizontal to 45 degrees) to optimize oscillations based on airflow. Perform 10–15 breaths per set, followed by forced expiration techniques like huffing or coughing to expel loosened mucus.^[11] Initial training by a healthcare professional is required to ensure proper technique and avoid fatigue. The device requires no electricity and can be used independently after instruction. Monitoring involves assessing sputum volume and respiratory symptoms; it is contraindicated in acute pneumothorax or severe airflow obstruction where insufficient exhalation is possible.^[1]

Advantages and limitations

Benefits over traditional systems

The Flutter valve offers key advantages over conventional airway clearance techniques such as postural drainage and manual percussion, primarily through its portability, ease of use, and independence from assistance. As a small, lightweight handheld device (weighing approximately 28 grams and 5 cm in length), it allows patients to perform therapy independently at home or during daily activities, without requiring a second person for positioning or clapping, which can be time-intensive and physically demanding for caregivers.^[1] Clinical evidence supports its efficacy in enhancing mucus clearance and clinical outcomes. In cystic fibrosis, randomized trials have shown the Flutter produces over three times greater sputum expectoration compared to conventional physiotherapy, with meta-analyses confirming improvements in lung function and reduced need for hospitalization. For chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD), use of oscillating positive expiratory pressure (OPEP) devices like the Flutter has been associated with up to 50% reduction in exacerbation frequency at six months, alongside better symptom control, gas exchange, and quality of life scores. These benefits stem from its ability to deliver high-frequency airway vibrations (6–26 Hz) and positive pressure (18–35 cm H₂O), which loosen secretions more effectively than gravity-dependent methods alone.^[2]^[3]^[1] Additionally, sessions are shorter (5–15 minutes, 2–4 times daily) and more tolerable, promoting adherence over traditional methods that may cause fatigue or discomfort from prolonged positioning. Studies in bronchiectasis indicate equivalent or superior secretion transport compared to positive expiratory pressure (PEP) masks, with the added oscillatory component reducing mucus viscosity without specialized equipment. This cost-effectiveness—devices are inexpensive (typically $20–50) and reusable after cleaning—supports broader access, particularly in outpatient and resource-limited settings.^[7]^[12]

Risks and complications

The Flutter valve is generally well-tolerated with few adverse effects when used correctly, but potential risks arise from improper technique or underlying conditions. Common minor issues include transient dizziness or fatigue during sessions, particularly if exhalation is too forceful, and mild discomfort from the mouthpiece or vibrations, affecting about 5–10% of users initially but resolving with training. Hyperinflation may occur if breaths are not controlled, potentially worsening air trapping in patients with severe airflow obstruction.^[1] Serious contraindications include untreated pneumothorax, active hemoptysis, severe tuberculosis, or acute right-sided heart failure, as the positive pressure could exacerbate these. Caution is advised in cases of facial trauma, recent surgery, or severe cognitive impairment, where device handling may be challenging. Studies report rare complications like increased bronchospasm in sensitive individuals, but overall side effect rates are low (<5%), with no significant increase in adverse events compared to standard care.^[1]^[7] Efficacy can vary; some trials show no superiority over active cycle of breathing techniques in stable cystic fibrosis, and improper angling may reduce oscillation effectiveness, underscoring the need for initial instruction. Monitoring involves assessing sputum volume and symptoms post-session, with discontinuation if pain or worsening dyspnea occurs. Patient education on cleaning (daily with warm soapy water) prevents bacterial contamination, though rare infections have been linked to poor hygiene.^[3]^[5]

Comparisons and alternatives

Versus traditional chest physiotherapy

The Flutter valve provides an alternative to traditional chest physiotherapy techniques such as postural drainage and percussion, which involve manual clapping on the chest and positioning to aid gravity-assisted mucus drainage. Unlike these methods, the Flutter uses self-generated oscillations and positive expiratory pressure during exhalation to loosen and mobilize secretions without requiring a therapist or specific body positions.^[2] Clinical studies, including randomized controlled trials in patients with cystic fibrosis, have shown the Flutter to be superior in sputum expectoration, yielding over three times more mucus clearance compared to conventional physiotherapy, while being equally effective in improving lung function and patient preference due to its portability and ease of independent use.^[2] In chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD), the device reduces exacerbation frequency by up to 50% over six months versus standard care, with benefits in symptoms and quality of life.^[3] The Flutter's advantages include reduced treatment time (5-15 minutes per session versus 20-30 minutes for manual techniques) and no need for assistance, enabling home use; however, traditional methods may be preferred in acute settings or for patients unable to generate sufficient expiratory flow. Both approaches are often combined for optimal airway clearance in bronchiectasis and other hypersecretory conditions.^[1]

Modern variants and devices

Modern variants and alternatives to the original Flutter valve include other oscillating positive expiratory pressure (OPEP) devices that aim to enhance mucus clearance through similar vibratory mechanisms but with design improvements for ease of use and hygiene. The Acapella device, for example, uses a movable plunger instead of a steel ball, producing oscillations (5-25 Hz) across a wider range of expiratory flows and being less dependent on device orientation compared to the gravity-sensitive Flutter.^[13] Another popular alternative is the Aerobika, a disposable OPEP device without moving parts, relying on fixed steel spheres to generate vibrations and pressures (10-20 cm H₂O) comparable to the Flutter, offering cost savings and reduced infection risk from reusability issues. Performance comparisons indicate similar efficacy in sputum volume and lung function improvements for cystic fibrosis and COPD patients, though Acapella and Aerobika may be easier for low-flow users.^[14]^[15] Advancements since the 2010s include hybrid OPEP systems with adjustable resistance settings and integrated nebulizers for combined medication delivery, such as the Pari O-PEP, which maintains consistent oscillations (10-20 Hz) regardless of flow. Guidelines from the Cystic Fibrosis Foundation recommend OPEP devices like these as first-line airway clearance therapies, with success rates over 80% in reducing infections when used 2-4 times daily.^[16] As of 2024, digital monitoring integrations, such as apps tracking adherence and flow metrics, are emerging to optimize therapy in telehealth settings for chronic respiratory diseases.^[12]

References

[1]
Current devices of respiratory physiotherapy - PMC - NIH
Application: Flutter device must be used in the sitting or supine lying position. The patient is instructed to inhale deeply and hold his breath for 2 to 3 sec.
[2]
Efficacy of the Flutter device for airway mucus clearance in patients ...
The Flutter is a handheld device designed to facilitate clearance of mucus in hypersecretory lung disorders. Exhalation through the Flutter results in ...Missing: medical | Show results with:medical
[3]
The Use of Airway Clearance Devices in the Management of ...
May 15, 2020 · Airway clearance devices can improve exacerbation frequency, sputum clearance, and symptoms in stable COPD.
[4]
Flutter • Clement Clarke - Flexicare
A small lightweight mucus clearance device. Flutter helps patients easily loosen the mucus in the lungs and airways. Gentle coughing then removes the mucus.Missing: valve | Show results with:valve
[5]
Structure and Function of the Mucus Clearance System of the Lung
The Flutter generates PEP in the range 18–35 cm H2O, and the angle at which the device is held determines the oscillation frequency, usually between 6 and 26 Hz ...
[6]
Heimlich valve and pneumothorax - PMC - NIH
A Heimlich flutter valve. When air passes through the valve, a distinct “flutter” sound can be heard, ensuring that the device is working properly. Absence ...
[7]
Heimlich valve and pneumothorax - Annals of Translational Medicine
This way pneumothorax is safely evacuated. By the same mechanism, the Heimlich flutter valve may also facilitate the evacuation of fluid. The inlet nozzle is ...
[8]
Caring for Your Chest Tube and Heimlich Valve
Your chest tube and valve let extra air, extra fluid, or both out of your chest. This lets your lung expand fully. Figure 1.
[9]
Dr. Henry J. Heimlich, Famous for Antichoking Technique, Dies at 96
Dec 17, 2016 · In a dime store, he found a Japanese-made toy noisemaker with a flutter valve. It worked in his device, and he took out a patent on what he ...
[10]
[PDF] The Life and Controversies of Henry Heimlich, MD
May 23, 2022 · In the early 1960s, Heimlich came up with a device to drain fluid and/or decompress a tension pneumothorax based on a Japanese toy noisemaker ...
[11]
A History of Thoracic Drainage: From Ancient Greeks to Wound ...
Apr 9, 2015 · The oldest known reference to thoracic drainage dates back to the fifth century BCE Hippocrates (c. 460-370 BC) (3) was a pioneer of a rational view of disease.
[12]
INSTRUMENT FOR DRAINAGE OF THE CHEST - Henry, Heimlich J.
Surgical drainage apparatus. H. J. HEIMLICH. Jan. 26, 1966 [Feb. 16, 1965], No. 3428/66. Heading A5R. [Also in Division F2] Apparatus used in surgical ...
[13]
Patient-Induced Complications of a Heimlich Flutter Valve - CHEST
... flutter valve system with consequent tension pneumothorax. ... Iatrogenic tension pneumothorax complicating outpatient Heimlich valve chest drainage.
[14]
Thoracic Drainage
The Heimlich valve was introduced in 1968 and is a flutter valve that is especially useful when emergency transport is anticipated [32]. The valve must be ...
[15]
Health | Heimlich: Still saving lives at 83 - BBC NEWS
Mar 9, 2003 · Dr Henry Heimlich invented the Heimlich Manoeuvre 30 years ago and it is still being used today to save lives across the globe.Missing: contributions flutter
[16]
[PDF] heimlich valve - hestomed + helbig
Materials. Heimlich Valve: PVC – DEHP free. Collection bag: PVC – DEHP free. Connecting tube: Synthetic Rubber. Latex free. Packaging. Sterile single package ...<|control11|><|separator|>
[17]
A Heimlich flutter valve. | Download Scientific Diagram - ResearchGate
The Heimlich valve is a small one-way valve used for chest drainage that empties into a flexible collection device and prevents return of gases or fluids into ...
[18]
Chest drain valve, Heimlich - Standard products catalogue IFRC ICRC
Dec 31, 2018 · Materials: PVC: Chamber including connectors. Latex: valve. Description: Valve: The Heimlich Chest Drain Valve is a specially-designed flutter ...Missing: components | Show results with:components
[19]
[PDF] Pediatric Chest Tubes And Pigtails: An Evidence-Based Approach ...
child, and adult sizes (infant, 10F–12F; child, 16F–. 24F; adult, 28F ... connected to a 1-way Heimlich valve, as long as the patient remains asymptomatic.
[20]
Cook Chest Drain Valve Set - Rapid Resource Medical Group
In stock 30-day returnsThis flutter valve (heimlich valve) is used with pneumothorax aspiration ... Tube Length 30 cm;Connecting Tube French Size 14 Fr. Cook Chest Drain Valve ...
[21]
Pneumostat Chest Drain Valve by Getinge Group
In stock 30-day returnsPneumostat chest drain valve is a disposable, single-use chest drain valve with a small, graduated 30-mL collection capacity with integrated 1-way dry seal ...Missing: materials | Show results with:materials
[22]
[PDF] Pneumothorax In Pediatric Patients: Management Strategies To ...
Size (French). Weight. (kilograms). Pneumothorax Transudate. Exudate. < 3. 8-10 ... a Heimlich valve. These 103 patients did not require inpatient care, had ...
[23]
[PDF] Heimlich Valve | prodimed
The medical device is latex-free and phthalates-free. Besides, it does not contain any tissue of animal origin. •. F. A. B. R. IQ. UÉ EN FR. A. N. C. E. •. M.
[24]
Chest Tube Drainage of the Pleural Space: A Concise Review for ...
All chest tubes are connected to a drainage system device: flutter valve, underwater seal, electronic systems or, for indwelling pleural catheters (IPC) ...
[25]
Chapter 6 Manage Chest Tube Drainage Systems - NCBI - NIH
Heimlich Valve. A Heimlich valve is an alternative to a chest tube drainage system. It is a small, specially designed flutter valve that is portable and ...Missing: mechanism | Show results with:mechanism
[26]
[PDF] One-Way Valve as Management of Chest Tube Ambulation in ...
The working mechanism of the Heimlich valve looks like Figure 2: the airflow ... an audible “flutter” sound that ensures the device is functioning ...
[27]
Malfunction of a Heimlich flutter valve causing tension pneumothorax
The Heimlich flutter valve has been developed for the release of pneumothorax and can be used in patients who are breathing spontaneously. It is constructed of ...Missing: Pneumostat | Show results with:Pneumostat
[28]
Chest drainage systems in use - PMC - NIH
This valve (also known as the Heimlich valve after its inventor, Henry Heimlich) is a rubber flutter one-way valve within a rigid plastic tube which connects to ...
[29]
[PDF] Management of Patients with a Chest Drainage Unit
Heimlich valve. ▫ One-way “flutter valve”. ▫ Removes air as patient exhales. ▫ Valve opens when pleural space pressure > than atmospheric pressure & closes ...<|control11|><|separator|>
[30]
Management of spontaneous pneumothorax using a Heimlich flutter ...
The flutter valve precludes the need for the cumbersome apparatus of under water seal drainage and therefore avoids the well-known possible dangers of ...
[31]
Comparison between flutter valve drainage bag and underwater ...
Jan 7, 2020 · The aim of this study is to compare the use of flutter valve drainage bag system as an alternative to conventional underwater seal drainage ...Missing: Bernoulli principle Coanda effect
[32]
Tube Thoracostomy Management Technique - Medscape Reference
Feb 12, 2024 · As a general rule, in an adult patient, 24-28 French is adequate for draining air, but 32-36 French may be necessary for draining fluid. Can ...
[33]
Pneumothorax Treatment & Management - Medscape Reference
Jan 22, 2024 · A Heimlich valve is a one-way rubber flutter valve that allows ... A small-bore catheter (eg, 7-14 French) is safe to use in most patients, ...<|control11|><|separator|>
[34]
https://www.boundtree.com/airway-oxygen-delivery/decompression-cric/cook-heimlich-chest-drain-valve-only/p/99994
[35]
The Heimlich Valve for Pleural Cavity Dr | AAS
The Heimlich valve is a feasible and cheap alternative method of chest tube drainage with high rates of success and very low morbidity.
[36]
[PDF] Heimlich Valve Chest Tube
Heimlich valve design by enhancing valve reliability and integrating digital monitoring capabilities. Digital chest drainage systems now provide real-time ...
[37]
[PDF] Heimlich Valve as an Ambulation Management of Persistent ...
May 29, 2021 · In 1968, Henry Heimlich introduced a flutter valve chest drainage, namely "Heimlich Chest Drain. Valve". It is a one-way valve for handling.Missing: refinement attachment
[38]
Comparing Outcomes of One-Way Heimlich Valve with ...
Oct 13, 2025 · While not statistically significant, trends suggested faster pneumothorax resolution and potentially shorter hospital stays. The Heimlich valve ...
[39]
http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/0003497596000343/pdf?md5=c7030391a8dd80977c0ff9bdb0c44a73&pid=1-s2.0-0003497596000343-main.pdf
[40]
Chest drainage systems
The classic underwater seal drainage system requires three bottles connected by tubing. ... They consist of a dry valve (often a flutter valve) within a drainage ...<|control11|><|separator|>
[41]
Randomised clinical trial of chest drainage systems. | Thorax
A chest drainage bag incorporating a one way flutter valve has been compared with underwater seal drains in a randomised clinical trial. METHODS: During ...Missing: comparison studies
[42]
comparison between flutter valve drainage bag and underwater seal ...
Conclusions: The results of this study suggest that flutter valve drainage system is a safe and feasible alternative in managing postoperative air leaks and ...
[43]
A physiological comparison of flutter valve drainage bags and ... - NIH
BACKGROUND—A study was undertaken to compare the relative physiological effects of underwater seal (UWS) versus flutter valve (FV) pleural drainage systems ...Missing: studies | Show results with:studies<|control11|><|separator|>
[44]
Management of spontaneous pneumothorax using a Heimlich flutter ...
Management of spontaneous pneumothorax using a Heimlich flutter valve. Thorax ... The flutter valve precludes the need for the cumbersome apparatus of ...
[45]
Underwater Seal Chest Drainage System - LITFL
Nov 8, 2024 · A system that allows drainage of the pleural space using an airtight system to maintain subatmospheric intrapleural pressure.<|control11|><|separator|>
[46]
[PDF] Atrium Express Mini 500 and Pneumostat
The Pneumostat Chest Drain Valve is a disposable, single- use chest drain valve with a small, graduated. 30 ml collection capacity integrated with a novel one- ...
[47]
Comprehensive Review of Chest Tube Management - JAMA Network
Jan 26, 2022 · A common type of small-bore chest tube is a pigtail catheter, named because the tip coils at the end like a pig's tail to prevent dislodgement.<|control11|><|separator|>
[48]
Thopaz+ after thoracic surgery and interventions - Medela
Thopaz+ accelerates chest drain removal, shortens ICU length of stay, and reduces overall costs.
[49]
PleurX™ Pleural Catheter System - BD
* The PleurX™ Pleural Catheter System is indicated for intermittent, long term drainage of symptomatic, recurrent, pleural effusion, including malignant pleural ...
[50]
Mobile chest drainage solutions from Atrium - EMS1
Mar 24, 2010 · It also incorporates Atrium's patented one-way valve for maximum patient protection. The Express Mini 500 can be used with suction or on gravity ...
[51]
Ambulatory management of secondary spontaneous pneumothorax
This randomised controlled trial compared ambulatory management using two types of flutter valves with standard care using a chest tube attached to an ...Missing: hospitalization | Show results with:hospitalization
[52]
(PDF) Effectiveness of Ambulatory Tru-Close Thoracic Vent for the ...
For primary spontaneous pneumothorax patients, the success rate of the Thoracic Egg was 76.6% and for iatrogenic pneumothorax, it was 100%. There were 2 ...
[53]
Remote-Controlled, Wireless Chest Drainage System
This experimental investigation was aimed at verifying the feasibility and safety of a remote-controlled wireless chest drainage system for in-hospital, ...Missing: directions | Show results with:directions