Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Gender expression

Gender expression encompasses the outward manifestations of gender through behaviors, , mannerisms, and interests that signal , , or to others. These expressions are typically dimorphic, with biological males tending toward more assertive, object-focused activities and biological females toward relational, nurturing ones, patterns observable from infancy. indicates a substantial biological underpinning, including genetic estimated at around 60-70% for gender-typical behaviors and influences from prenatal hormone exposure that organize toward sex-differentiated traits. Cross-culturally, these sex differences persist despite variations in social norms, underscoring an evolutionary basis rooted in reproductive roles and adaptive pressures that favor distinct strategies. While culture modulates specific forms of expression, such as styles, core behavioral dimorphisms remain stable, challenging purely constructivist accounts. Notable controversies include debates over the extent of fluidity versus innateness, particularly in where atypical expression correlates with neurobiological divergences, and policy implications around enforcing nonconforming expressions in youth, which lack long-term empirical support for benefits. Overall, gender expression reflects a interplay of causal biological mechanisms and environmental cues, with most individuals aligning their expressions congruently with throughout life.

Definitions and Terminology

Core Definition

Gender expression refers to the observable ways in which individuals convey aspects of , , or through external behaviors, clothing, hairstyles, mannerisms, voice, and physical presentation. This presentation is interpreted by others within cultural contexts but often reflects underlying patterns of sex-typical behavior, such as greater and object-oriented play among males or relational and nurturing tendencies among females, as documented in developmental studies. Unlike , which is determined by genetic and anatomical factors including chromosomes (typically XX for females and XY for males) and reproductive structures, gender expression encompasses socially visible traits that may align or diverge from one's . It also differs from , the internal psychological sense of being male, female, or otherwise, which may not manifest outwardly in expression. , including longitudinal surveys, shows that childhood gender expression predicts adult patterns, with nonconformity associated with higher rates of same-sex attraction but stability in sex-typical averages across populations. While some variability exists due to individual and cultural factors, peer-reviewed analyses indicate persistent small-to-moderate differences in expressive domains like emotional display, with females showing greater overall expressivity. These patterns suggest a partial biological foundation, though direct genetic studies on expression remain limited compared to those on identity. Gender expression involves the external manifestation of traits along dimensions of and , where masculinity encompasses behaviors and appearances such as , instrumental orientation, and physical robustness, while femininity includes communal traits like , relational focus, and expressive demeanor. These dimensions are not opposites but exist on continua, with empirical studies showing average differences: men scoring higher on agency-related (masculine) traits and women on communion-related (feminine) traits across cultures and self-reports. A related concept is androgyny, referring to the simultaneous endorsement or display of both masculine and feminine characteristics, often measured via scales assessing balanced scores rather than extremes. Androgynous expression contrasts with undifferentiated (low on both) or sex-typed (high on one matching biological sex) patterns, and research indicates it correlates with greater psychological flexibility but is less common than sex-typical expression in population samples. Gender expression is distinct from gender roles, which denote societal expectations for behavior based on sex rather than individual presentation; while roles prescribe norms (e.g., men as providers), expression reflects personal enactment, which may conform, exaggerate, or deviate from those norms. Empirical data link childhood gender expression—early deviations from sex-typical play or dress—to later outcomes like , but stability varies, with most individuals aligning expression to over time. Another distinction lies with gender nonconformity, a subset of expression involving atypical presentation (e.g., feminine behavior in males), which studies associate with minority sexual identities but occurs in only 5-10% of the population, challenging assumptions of fluidity as normative. These concepts underscore that expression is observable and variable, influenced by both innate predispositions and context, rather than fixed ideological categories.

Biological Foundations

Innate Sex Differences in Behavior

Sex differences in emerge early in , often before extensive socialization, suggesting an innate biological foundation. Studies of infants as young as 12 months demonstrate preferences for gender-typical s, with boys showing greater interest in vehicles and mechanical objects, while girls prefer dolls and people-oriented items. These patterns persist across diverse samples and are robust in meta-analyses encompassing over 75 studies and 113 effect sizes, yielding moderate to large effect sizes (d ≈ 0.5–1.0) for toy preferences that hold from infancy through childhood, independent of parental encouragement or cultural context. Aggression provides another domain of innate divergence, with males exhibiting higher levels of physical from toddlerhood onward. Meta-analyses of observational data from children under age 6 report a consistent male advantage in direct (d ≈ 0.5–0.6), while verbal and relational forms show smaller or equivalent differences. These disparities align with rough-and-tumble play, which is more prevalent and intense in boys, serving functions like physical training that parallel patterns in nonhuman . Twin studies further support a genetic , revealing heritability estimates for aggressive traits ranging from 40–60%, with some evidence of sex-specific genetic influences amplifying male variance. Broader interests and cognitive styles exhibit parallel dimorphisms, rooted in evolutionary pressures such as and . Males tend toward "thing-oriented" pursuits involving systems and mechanics, while females favor "people-oriented" activities emphasizing and social bonds, patterns evident in longitudinal data and cross-species comparisons. Reviews of synthesize these as adaptations to ancestral environments, where male risk-taking and spatial enhanced and , contrasting with female emphases on nurturing and social cohesion. Quantitative genetic analyses, including large twin cohorts, indicate that while environmental factors contribute, sex differences in behavioral traits like interests and arise substantially from heritable mechanisms, with minimal evidence for purely cultural origins. Such findings underscore causal realism in interpreting behavioral variances as proximally hormonal and genetically mediated, rather than solely socially constructed.

Hormonal and Genetic Influences

Prenatal exposure to sex hormones, particularly androgens such as , plays a critical role in organizing toward sex-typical behavioral patterns that underpin gender expression. In humans, higher prenatal androgen levels are associated with increased male-typical play behaviors, including preferences for wheeled toys, , and spatial activities, as evidenced by meta-analyses of testosterone measurements. Females with (CAH), who are exposed to elevated prenatal androgens due to dysfunction, consistently display masculinized gender-typed behaviors, such as greater interest in boys' toys and activities, compared to non-affected females, with effects persisting into despite postnatal normalization. These findings support the organizational hypothesis, where early hormonal surges permanently influence neural circuits governing interests and social behaviors, rather than activational effects from circulating hormones later in life. Genetic factors contribute substantially to individual differences in sex-typical versus atypical gender expression, as demonstrated by twin studies showing moderate to high . For instance, a study of child and adolescent twins estimated 62% heritability for disorder traits, which overlap with behavioral nonconformity such as cross-sex toy preferences and , with the remainder attributed to nonshared environmental influences. Broader analyses of diversity, including nonconforming behaviors, confirm genetic contributions alongside unique environmental factors, with concordance rates higher in monozygotic than dizygotic twins. Genes on , beyond those determining gonadal sex, exert direct effects on and behavioral dimorphisms, influencing traits like , nurturing, and object versus people independently of levels in some models. Interactions between hormonal and genetic mechanisms further shape gender expression, as prenatal hormones can amplify or modify genetically predisposed pathways in brain sexual differentiation. Evidence from animal models and human proxies like digit ratios (2D:4D, a marker of prenatal testosterone) links combined genetic-hormonal profiles to persistent sex differences in , systemizing, and occupational interests, with males overrepresented in thing-oriented fields and females in people-oriented ones. While environmental can modulate expression, empirical prioritize these biological foundations as causal drivers of baseline dimorphisms, with estimates underscoring that atypical expressions often reflect innate variations rather than solely learned behaviors.

Psychological Development

Childhood and Adolescent Expression

Children typically display sex differences in gender-typed behaviors from toddlerhood, with boys favoring construction toys, vehicles, and , while girls prefer dolls, domestic toys, and collaborative pretend play. These patterns emerge around 12-24 months of age and are consistent across cultures, suggesting an innate component independent of explicit . Prenatal exposure plays a causal role, as evidenced by girls with (CAH), who experience elevated prenatal testosterone and exhibit increased male-typical play preferences, such as choosing trucks over dolls, compared to unaffected girls. Conversely, boys with lower prenatal markers show slightly more female-typical interests, though the effect sizes are moderate and modulated by postnatal factors. Longitudinal studies demonstrate stability in these childhood gender-typed behaviors into middle childhood and early , with correlations ranging from 0.4 to 0.6 between ages 2.5 and 8 years for preferences and activity choices. Boy-typical play in predicts stronger male-typical occupational interests by age 13-14, such as mechanical pursuits for boys and people-oriented roles for girls, indicating continuity rather than dramatic shifts. gender-typed behavior in childhood—defined as cross-sex or peer preferences—is observed in 5-10% of children and correlates with later orientation in prospective data, but for the majority, such expressions align with and persist without intervention. During , amplifies sex-typical gender expression through surges in gonadal hormones: testosterone in boys promotes increased , competitiveness, and spatial interests, while in girls enhances verbal fluency and relational behaviors. These biological shifts coincide with heightened peer and , often leading adolescents to conform more rigidly to sex norms in , grooming, and mannerisms, though variation persists. Empirical from population cohorts show that early gender-typed play trajectories forecast adolescent interests, with minimal of widespread "fluidity" in expression absent clinical disorders; instead, predominates, with deviations more predictive of than identity discordance.

Factors Influencing Stability

Longitudinal studies of gender-typed behaviors, such as toy preferences and play styles, demonstrate moderate to high stability from through . For instance, preschool-aged children's gender-typed play behaviors predict corresponding occupational interests in early , with correlations indicating persistence over nearly a decade. Similarly, sex-typical play patterns emerge between 12 and 24 months and maintain longitudinal consistency across childhood in general population samples. This stability holds despite some age-related increases in behavioral rigidity between ages 3 and 5, followed by greater flexibility in stereotyping, suggesting that core expressive patterns are resilient to developmental shifts. Genetic factors substantially contribute to the stability of gender expression, particularly in dimensions like nonconformity. Twin studies estimate heritability of childhood gender identity disorder—a marker of extreme nonconformity—at 62%, with the remainder attributable to nonshared environmental influences rather than shared family factors. Broader gender nonconformity traits show familial aggregation and genetic correlations with related outcomes, implying that innate biological dispositions underpin enduring patterns. Hormonal influences, such as prenatal androgen exposure, further stabilize sex-differentiated behaviors by shaping early neural development, as evidenced by consistent behavioral dimorphisms that persist despite socialization efforts. Nonshared environmental factors, including unique peer interactions and personal experiences, modestly influence but do not override biological baselines. Clinical observations indicate that while superficial expressions (e.g., clothing choices) may fluctuate with social context, core behavioral tendencies resist intervention, with parental or societal pressures showing limited long-term efficacy in altering trajectories. In contrast, shared environmental influences, such as family upbringing, account for negligible variance, highlighting the primacy of individual over collective in maintaining consistency. Daily fluctuations in expression occur but correlate weakly with underlying , often tied to transient psychological states rather than causal shifts.

Versus Biological Sex

is defined by an organism's reproductive role, determined primarily by type (small s for s, large for s), gonadal structure, and chromosomal patterns, with humans exhibiting a bimodal distribution where over 99.98% of individuals are unambiguously or based on these criteria. Gender expression differs as the observable behaviors, preferences, and presentations (such as clothing choices, mannerisms, and activity interests) that signal , , or to others, often influenced by cultural norms but not equivalent to itself. Unlike , which is fixed and measurable via objective biomarkers like or profiles, gender expression shows individual variability and can deviate from sex-typical patterns without altering one's . Empirical studies reveal consistent average sex differences in gender-typical expressions from early development, attributable to biological mechanisms including prenatal exposure and effects on organization. For instance, male infants display higher rates of and object-oriented activities, while female infants prefer face-gazing and relational play, patterns persisting across cultures and evident in non-human primates, indicating a partial biological foundation rather than pure social construction. These differences correlate with testosterone levels, where higher exposure masculinizes behaviors like spatial navigation and in males, and lower levels foster empathic and verbal skills in females, as shown in longitudinal twin studies disentangling genetic from environmental influences. Despite overlap and exceptions—such as feminine-expressing males or masculine females—population-level dimorphism remains robust, with effect sizes (Cohen's d) often exceeding 0.5 for traits like toy preferences (boys favoring vehicles, girls dolls) observed as early as 12 months. Claims minimizing these as solely cultural overlook evidence from , where XX females exposed to elevated prenatal androgens exhibit masculinized play and interests, reversible only partially by upbringing. thus causally constrains typical expression ranges, though social factors can amplify or suppress them; conflating the two ignores this asymmetry, as expression cannot redefine sex but sex reliably predicts modal expression probabilities. Peer-reviewed prioritizes these innate drivers over ideologically driven nurture-only models, which often fail to account for cross-species and developmental consistencies.

Versus Gender Identity

Gender expression refers to the external manifestation of behaviors, mannerisms, clothing, and other attributes that society associates with , , or , often influenced by differences in average behavioral traits such as play preferences and spatial abilities, which emerge early in development due to prenatal exposure. In contrast, is described as an individual's internal, subjective sense of being , , or neither, which may or may not align with or expression. These concepts are distinct, as expression is observable and culturally modulated while identity relies on self-perception, with empirical studies indicating that most individuals exhibit congruence between their , expression, and , particularly in non-clinical populations where sex-typical expression predominates. While gender expression can vary within sex-based averages—showing overlap but statistically significant dimorphic patterns rooted in genetic and hormonal factors—gender identity claims of incongruence (as in identification) lack robust biological correlates beyond rare conditions or hormone insensitivities, which affect less than 0.02% of the population and do not account for the majority of cases. on individuals often measures "" as alignment between expression and identity post-transition, associating it with improved , but these findings are correlational and predominantly from self-selected samples, potentially influenced by desirability or post-hoc rationalization rather than causal . For instance, a 2021 study found daily fluctuations in gender expression linked to mood in gender-diverse youth, but did not establish identity as a fixed biological independent of expression or . The distinction highlights potential causal disconnects: expression is more amenable to environmental shaping and empirical measurement via behavioral inventories, whereas identity's psychological basis invites scrutiny for malleability, as evidenced by high desistance rates (up to 80-90%) in children with who initially express incongruence but align with natal sex by adolescence without intervention. This contrasts with expression's relative stability tied to innate sex differences, underscoring that prioritizing over observable expression or may overlook empirical patterns where nonconforming expression does not imply identity mismatch in the general . Academic sources emphasizing identity's primacy often derive from advocacy-influenced frameworks, warranting caution against overgeneralizing from minority experiences to universal models.

Versus Sexual Orientation

Gender expression refers to the external manifestation of behaviors, mannerisms, and appearances typically associated with or , independent of an individual's . Sexual orientation, by contrast, denotes the enduring pattern of romantic or sexual attraction to persons of (heterosexual), same (homosexual), or both (bisexual). These constructs are conceptually orthogonal, as gender expression pertains to one's presentation relative to cultural sex norms, whereas sexual orientation involves the of preferred partners. Empirical research demonstrates a moderate association between atypical gender expression in childhood—often termed gender nonconformity (GNC)—and later homosexual orientation, particularly among males. A 1995 meta-analysis of 41 studies found that childhood cross-gender behaviors, such as preferences for opposite-sex toys and playmates, predicted adult homosexuality with large effect sizes (Cohen's d = 1.31 for boys, d = 0.50 for girls). More recent cohort studies confirm this link, with early childhood GNC scores on standardized assessments (e.g., ASEBA) correlating with diverse sexual orientations by adolescence. However, the association is probabilistic rather than deterministic: only a subset of gender-nonconforming children develop non-heterosexual orientations, and many homosexual adults recall gender-typical childhoods. In adulthood, correlations persist but weaken and vary by domain. , on average, exhibit more feminine mannerisms, interests, and occupational preferences than heterosexual men, with meta-analytic evidence linking self-reported gender expression to sexual identification strength (e.g., exclusively heterosexual vs. bisexual). Lesbians show smaller average deviations toward . Prenatal hormonal influences likely contribute to both traits via brain organization, explaining co-occurrence without implying causation between expression and orientation. Longitudinal data indicate that changes in self-reported gender expression do not predict shifts in , underscoring their independence. Critically, the overlap does not equate the phenomena: heterosexual individuals span the full spectrum of gender expression, from highly conforming to atypical, while homosexual individuals include many who conform to sex-typical norms. Attempts to conflate them, as occasionally seen in advocacy contexts, overlook this variability and the biological underpinnings of each. Studies controlling for find GNC independently predicts risks, suggesting distinct pathways. Twin studies further support partial genetic sharing but separable estimates for expression versus . Thus, while correlated, gender expression and sexual orientation represent distinct axes of human variation, neither reducible to the other.

Historical and Cross-Cultural Contexts

Pre-Modern Examples

In ancient society, as described by in the 5th century BCE, the enarees were biologically male individuals who adopted feminine attire, behaviors, and roles as soothsayers, interpreting omens through rituals possibly influenced by inhalation or a perceived divine curse from the goddess (equated with ). These figures were hereditary in some lineages and viewed as possessing a feminized condition, including softened voices and impotence, distinguishing them from typical male warriors in nomadic culture. Among the and later in the , the served as priests of the goddess (or Magna Mater), originating from around the 3rd century BCE and integrated into Roman religious practice by 204 BCE during the Second Punic War. They underwent voluntary self-castration during ecstatic festivals, donned women's clothing such as long robes and veils, wore makeup and jewelry, and performed ritual dances with tambourines, embodying a tertium sexus (third sex) that blurred male norms in a society emphasizing masculine dominance and penetration hierarchies. Roman sources like and depicted them with ambivalence, noting their social marginalization outside temple contexts despite official tolerance for the cult. In pre-modern India, hijras—eunuchs and intersex individuals forming a recognized third gender category—appear in texts dating to the 9th century BCE, with roles in and society as ritual performers at births, weddings, and royal courts, often involving and adoption of female dress and names. Ancient epics like the reference figures such as Arjuna's temporary eunuch disguise and the devotee of who became neither man nor woman, while Mughal-era accounts from the 16th century document hijra communities holding land grants and advisory positions under emperors like , reflecting institutional accommodation rather than widespread fluidity. Pre-colonial Native American societies across over 150 tribes incorporated cross-gender roles, often termed berdache in European accounts but encompassing spiritual intermediaries who combined male and female traits, such as winkte men dressing in women's clothing and performing healing or prophetic duties, or Zuni lhamana like , who in the (reflecting earlier traditions) wove textiles and participated in male hunts. These roles were typically assigned early based on observed traits or visions, conferring elevated status in matrilineal or animistic systems, though not universal or identity detachment from biology. Ethnographic records from the 16th–19th centuries, drawing on oral histories, indicate such figures facilitated social balance but faced disruption from colonial imposition of binary norms. These examples predominantly involved ritual, religious, or shamanic functions tied to specific cultural needs, such as or , rather than autonomous personal expression, and often entailed physical alteration or social , contrasting with sex-based divisions in most pre-modern agrarian societies. Primary accounts from historians like or Roman poets provide the earliest attestations, though interpretations vary due to ethnocentric biases in recording.

Modern Shifts and Influences

In the mid-20th century, , emerging prominently in the 1960s, challenged entrenched gender norms by critiquing the conflation of with prescribed roles in behavior, clothing, and demeanor, thereby encouraging women to adopt expressions previously deemed masculine, such as assertive mannerisms and professional attire. This period coincided with economic shifts, including women's rising labor force participation—e.g., UK maternal employment rates increased from 36% in 1974 to 58% in 2003—which correlated with more egalitarian attitudes toward gender expression, as evidenced by declining traditionalism scores (women: 2.85 in 1991 to 2.79 in 2007). Gender development research during the 1960s-1970s transitioned from biological essentialism to social learning models, highlighting environmental influences on expression stability and variability. The post-Stonewall from the late 1960s onward amplified visibility of gender-nonconforming expressions, such as and androgynous styles, fostering cultural acceptance of deviations from norms in public spheres like and . , gaining traction in the 1990s through works emphasizing gender's performative nature, further influenced academic and activist discourses by framing expression as a socially constructed act rather than innate trait, prompting experimentation with fluid presentations unbound by anatomical sex. Into the 21st century, digital platforms have accelerated these shifts, particularly among adolescents, by democratizing access to diverse expression models and enabling peer validation; for instance, and have facilitated and affirmation through shared narratives of self-construction. Algorithms amplify on , reversing top-down norm enforcement and correlating with reported surges in youth identifying outside traditional categories, though mechanisms include both revelation of latent variation and rapid dissemination of novel styles. These influences have intersected with , eroding uniform Western norms while introducing hybrid expressions via media.

Empirical Research and Measurement

Assessment Methods

Self-report questionnaires represent the most common method for assessing gender expression in , typically involving Likert-scale items that evaluate an individual's perceived , , or in domains such as clothing choices, mannerisms, voice pitch, and grooming. These tools, such as the Gender Self-Report, prompt respondents to rate their daily or typical expression, with studies demonstrating associations between more feminine expression in males and elevated internalizing symptoms, though primarily among men. Validity evidence for such measures includes convergent correlations with psychological adjustment outcomes, but reliability can vary by population, with test-retest coefficients often ranging from 0.70 to 0.85 in adult samples. Observer ratings provide an alternative or complementary approach, where trained raters evaluate visible cues like , , and attire on standardized scales, often in or naturalistic settings to minimize self-presentation . For example, in developmental studies of children, preferences and toy selections are coded as indicators of expression, yielding inter-rater reliabilities exceeding 0.80 in controlled observations. However, these methods face challenges in and cultural generalizability, as norms for masculine or feminine presentation differ across societies, potentially inflating observer subjectivity. Experience sampling and ambulatory assessment methods capture temporal fluctuations in gender expression through repeated, real-time prompts via mobile devices, allowing researchers to model within-person variability over days or weeks. In a of 75 daily assessments, participants self-reported expression alongside , revealing moderate day-to-day (intraclass correlation ≈ 0.50) and predictive links to , with reliable multi-item scales used for each prompt. Such intensive longitudinal designs enhance by isolating expression from stable traits like , though participant burden limits sample sizes, typically under 100. Specialized scales target subpopulations; for instance, the Gender Expression Measure for Lesbians assesses continuum-based via 14 items on appearance and behavior, showing reliabilities of 0.89 and correlations with minority outcomes. Experimental validations, such as tests of survey wording, confirm that phrasing (e.g., "feminine" vs. options) improves response validity and reduces measurement error in diverse samples. Despite these advances, many tools risk conflating expression with or , underscoring the need for domain-specific validation to ensure construct purity.

Key Findings from Studies

Longitudinal studies of children exhibiting —manifested as cross-sex behaviors, interests, or preferences—have consistently shown high rates of desistance, with 60-90% of such children aligning their expression with their by adolescence or adulthood, often identifying as rather than . These findings derive from clinic-based follow-ups, such as those tracking boys and girls diagnosed with gender identity disorder under prior criteria, where persistence was rare absent additional comorbidities like traits. Critics argue older studies inflated desistance by including subclinical cases without distress, yet replicated patterns hold in samples requiring diagnostic thresholds, underscoring that nonconformity alone predicts over persistent cross-sex expression. Prenatal hormone exposure exerts causal influence on gender-typed expression, particularly interests and play styles. Girls with (CAH), who experience elevated prenatal androgens, display increased male-typical toy preferences and , with effect sizes around 1.0-1.5 standard deviations from controls, yet these shifts do not extend to core or peer selection. Animal models and human proxy measures, like digit ratios (2D:4D) as markers of androgenization, correlate with similar behavioral masculinization in females, supporting a biological substrate for expression independent of social learning. Heritability estimates for atypical expression range from 20-60%, based on twin and studies, with nonshared environmental factors explaining the remainder and shared environment showing minimal effects. For instance, monozygotic twins exhibit greater concordance for cross-sex behaviors than dizygotic pairs, though genetic influences appear stronger for interests (e.g., things vs. orientation) than overt mannerisms. These patterns align with broader sex differences in expression, where accounts for 70-90% of variance in traits like or , per meta-analyses of behavioral data. Recent longitudinal data on broader samples indicate moderate stability in self-reported gender expression over 1-2 years, with correlations of 0.5-0.7, though fluidity increases during amid peer and media influences. Childhood nonconformity robustly predicts later same-sex attraction but not outcomes, with odds ratios 5-10 times higher for . Comorbidities like anxiety or moderate persistence, but baseline empirical evidence favors biological alignment over enduring divergence for most cases.

Controversies and Criticisms

Fluidity and Spectrum Claims

Claims that gender expression operates on a fluid posit that individuals' outward manifestations of gender—such as , mannerisms, and behaviors—exist along a unbound by male-female norms, with potential for significant shifts over time or contexts. Proponents, often drawing from qualitative self-reports, argue this reflects innate variability akin to sexual orientation fluidity, suggesting expression can fluctuate without pathological implications. However, such assertions frequently rely on anecdotal or survey-based data from advocacy-oriented samples, lacking robust longitudinal validation across diverse populations. Empirical studies on stability, which underpins expression, reveal high persistence rather than fluidity. In a longitudinal of over 2,000 youths, more than 80% exhibited stable trajectories from into early adulthood, with changes primarily among those initially identifying as but reverting to norms. Similarly, a five-year follow-up of socially transitioned children found only 7.3% retransitioned, indicating rarity of sustained fluidity even post-intervention. Adult data further underscore this, with changes reported in under 10% of teens tracked over time, contrasting claims of widespread malleability. These findings challenge fluidity narratives, as most variations in expression align with stable underlying identities rather than core shifts. Spectrum claims encounter biological scrutiny, as human —foundational to dimorphic expression patterns—is determined by production ( or ova), yielding a despite rare (DSDs) affecting approximately 0.018% with ambiguous genitalia. Peer-reviewed critiques assert that framing or expression as a conflates measurable traits (e.g., levels, which cluster bimodally) with ideological assertions, ignoring evolutionary pressures for reproductive dimorphism. Sources promoting spectra, such as certain outlets, have been rebutted for overstating DSD prevalence and variability without genomic or endocrine evidence of intermediate reproductive categories. Academic in affirms as the operative framework, with expression variations better explained by cultural overlays on bimodal biological predispositions than an unbounded .

Social Contagion Hypothesis

The social contagion hypothesis posits that the recent surge in presentations among adolescents, particularly those assigned female at birth, may be partly driven by social influences such as peer groups and online communities rather than solely innate factors. This idea gained prominence through Lisa Littman's 2018 study, which analyzed parental reports from 256 families describing adolescents with no prior history of who suddenly identified as during or after , often coinciding with increased time on platforms like and , where trans-related content proliferates. Parents reported that 62.5% of these youth had friend groups where multiple members simultaneously announced identities, suggesting peer reinforcement. The study characterized this as "rapid-onset " (ROGD), hypothesizing it as a maladaptive mechanism amplified by , distinct from traditional prepubertal-onset cases. Subsequent research has provided additional empirical support for social influence patterns. A 2023 analysis of 1,655 parental reports found that 60.6% of cases involved sudden onset after age 11, with 35.3% of youth belonging to friend groups where at least half identified as , and heavy use (average 7.5 hours daily) preceding the shift. This aligns with observed demographic trends: Gender Identity Development Service referrals rose from 97 in 2009 to 2,590 in 2018, with adolescent females comprising over 70% of cases by 2018–2019, a reversal from earlier male predominance. The 's Cass Review (2024) noted this "dramatic international trend" in female adolescent presentations, attributing it potentially to social factors like online exposure, though it emphasized the need for more rigorous evidence amid contested explanations. Critics argue the lacks direct causation proof and relies on biased samples, such as parents from sites skeptical of youth transitions. A 2022 study of Canadian youth found no disproportionate female increase in identification post-social transition, challenging claims. However, such counter-studies often draw from self-selected or clinic-based samples potentially underrepresenting desistance or parental concerns, and they do not refute the documented referral surges or clustering effects observed in larger administrative data. Proponents stress that mechanisms, akin to those in eating disorders or among teens, warrant caution in affirming interventions without addressing underlying psychiatric comorbidities, which co-occurred in 69% of Littman's cases. The remains debated, with calls for longitudinal studies to disentangle social from biological drivers.

Detransition and Regret Rates

Studies reporting regret following gender-affirming surgeries, such as those analyzed in a 2021 systematic review and of 27 studies involving over 7,900 patients, indicate prevalence rates of approximately 1% for transfeminine procedures and less than 1% for transmasculine procedures. A 2024 systematic review similarly pooled data from multiple studies to estimate an overall regret prevalence of 1.94%, with 4.0% for transfeminine and 0.8% for transmasculine cases. These figures are often contrasted with higher regret rates for other elective surgeries, such as knee replacements (around 20%) or cosmetic procedures (up to 15-20%). Detransition, defined as discontinuing or reversing aspects of (which may or may not involve regret), shows greater variability across studies. A 2021 U.S. survey of 17,151 and gender-diverse individuals found that 13.1% of those who had pursued gender affirmation reported a history of , with 82.5% citing external factors like family pressure or rather than internal dissatisfaction. In youth cohorts, a 2022 of socially transitioned children followed for an average of 5 years reported that 7.3% had retransitioned to their birth sex or another . A 2023 analysis of youth who initiated medical interventions noted 5.3% cessation of blockers or hormones within the study period. Methodological limitations undermine confidence in low reported rates. Many studies rely on clinic follow-up data, which suffer from high loss to follow-up (often 20-60%), potentially excluding detransitioners who disengage from gender clinics without returning. Systematic reviews acknowledge that estimates for detransition prevalence range from under 1% to 30% due to inconsistent definitions, short observation periods (rarely exceeding 5-10 years), and failure to capture non-clinic-based reversals. The 2024 Cass Review in the UK highlighted these evidentiary gaps, noting weak overall research quality for youth gender interventions and insufficient long-term outcome tracking, which obscures true detransition and regret incidences. Critics, including analyses from clinician networks, argue that institutional pressures in academia and medicine may incentivize underreporting, as dissenting findings face publication barriers or professional repercussions. Higher signals emerge in specific contexts, particularly among adolescents and young adults. A 2024 Finnish register-based study of initiators found discontinuation rates implying partial in a notable minority, often linked to unresolved comorbidities like or . Surveys of self-identified ers report internal realizations—such as misattributing same-sex attraction or to incongruence—as primary drivers in up to 70% of cases, challenging assumptions of permanence. These patterns align with evidence of fluidity in youth, where desistance rates from childhood exceed 80% without intervention, though direct causation remains debated. Overall, while surgical appears empirically low in captured samples, broader dynamics suggest rates may be substantially higher when accounting for evasive study designs and societal factors discouraging reversal.

Societal Impacts and Policy Debates

Reported instances of discrimination against individuals exhibiting gender non-conforming expression often encompass employment denials, harassment, and exclusion from facilities, with self-reported surveys indicating high prevalence among transgender and non-binary respondents. A 2024 Williams Institute survey of transgender employees found that 82% experienced workplace discrimination or harassment, including termination, denial of promotion, or verbal abuse linked to their gender presentation. Similarly, CDC data from 2024 revealed that 70% of transgender women encountered at least one form of discrimination in the prior year, though these figures derive from self-reports and may include perceived slights rather than verifiable legal violations. Empirical workplace audits and field experiments provide mixed evidence; while some studies document hiring biases against resumes signaling gender non-conformity, such as masculine presentation by female applicants, broader causal links remain challenging to isolate from confounding factors like overall job performance perceptions. Legal protections against discrimination based on gender expression are uneven globally and frequently overlap with those for , though distinctions persist in application. In the United States, the Supreme Court's 2020 decision interpreted Title VII of the to prohibit motivated by gender identity or non-conformity, extending "sex" protections to cover such cases. However, as of January 2025, the (EEOC) has rescinded certain Biden-era guidance expanding harassment definitions to include gender identity issues like pronouns and facilities access, prioritizing biological sex-based protections for women amid concerns over conflicts in single-sex spaces. EEOC charge data from fiscal year 2024 shows 88,531 total discrimination filings, with gender identity claims comprising a small but growing subset prior to these shifts, though exact figures for expression-specific cases are not disaggregated. At the state level, jurisdictions like explicitly ban employment discrimination on gender expression grounds since 2011, while others rely on broader LGBTQ-inclusive ordinances. In the , protections stem from Article 21 of the Charter of Fundamental Rights, which bans on but lacks uniform coverage for gender expression; member states vary, with some like incorporating it into general equality laws, while others lag. Advocacy reports note that explicit legal safeguards reduce reported incidents, yet enforcement remains inconsistent, and expansions have sparked debates over balancing with sex-based rights, such as in sports or prisons. Internationally, only select countries provide comprehensive statutory protections, with many relying on frameworks that courts interpret case-by-case, often privileging of harm over subjective claims. Public perceptions, as in a 2022 Pew survey where 57% of Americans viewed as significant, influence policy but do not substitute for verified incidence data. These frameworks continue to evolve, with 2025 U.S. executive actions emphasizing biological reality to mitigate unintended erosions of female protections.

Youth Interventions and Outcomes

Medical interventions for youth with gender incongruence, such as puberty suppression using analogues and administration of cross-sex hormones, have proliferated in recent years despite limited high-quality evidence supporting their long-term efficacy and safety. These approaches aim to alleviate distress associated with incongruence between and expressed , but systematic reviews indicate weak evidence for sustained improvements, with most studies suffering from methodological flaws including small sample sizes, lack of control groups, and short follow-up periods. The 2024 Cass Review, an independent evaluation commissioned by , assessed over 100 studies and found the evidence base for routine use of these interventions in adolescents to be of low certainty, leading to recommendations for a more cautious, holistic approach emphasizing and comprehensive assessment over . Puberty blockers, typically initiated at stage 2 or later, temporarily halt endogenous development but carry risks including reduced density, which may not fully recover even after discontinuation or hormone initiation, potentially increasing fracture risk into adulthood. A 2024 systematic review of 12 studies reported that 92% of youth on blockers progressed to cross-sex hormones within 12-36 months, suggesting limited diagnostic utility in resolving without escalation to further interventions, while evidence for psychosocial benefits remains inconclusive due to confounding factors like concurrent social transitions. impacts are profound, as prolonged suppression followed by opposite-sex hormones often results in , with animal models and limited data indicating potential permanent gonadal dysfunction; counseling on these irreversible effects is mandated but inconsistently applied. Cross-sex hormones, such as testosterone for females or plus anti-androgens for males, introduced around age 14-16 in many protocols, induce secondary characteristics of the desired but yield mixed outcomes, with short-term reductions in reported in some cohorts yet no robust demonstration of decreased suicidality or resolution of comorbidities like or when controlled for. Long-term data, spanning decades from earlier cohorts, show persistent elevations in psychiatric issues post-treatment compared to general populations, alongside physical risks including cardiovascular events, , and metabolic changes. Surgical interventions remain rare in minors but have increased in some regions, with outcomes data even scarcer and primarily highlighting complications like revision needs. Detransition rates, where individuals cease interventions and revert to identifying with their , are poorly quantified due to high loss-to-follow-up in studies—often exceeding 30%—but available from clinic cohorts indicates 2-10% within 5-10 years, with higher rates among adolescent-onset cases potentially linked to influences or unresolved underlying issues. A 2025 cohort study of adolescents found 4% discontinued hormones without restarting after initiation, though self-reported regrets may understate true incidence given and lack of systematic tracking. In response to evidentiary shortcomings, health authorities in (2022 guidelines) and (2020 updates) have restricted hormonal interventions to exceptional cases post-extensive psychological evaluation, prioritizing non-medical therapies due to the experimental nature of treatments and potential for iatrogenic harm in whose may desist naturally in up to 80-90% of pre-pubertal cases historically. These shifts underscore a broader European trend away from affirmative models toward evidence-based caution, contrasting with more permissive approaches elsewhere amid ongoing debates over causal factors in rising presentations.

Mental Health Correlations

Individuals exhibiting , characterized by behaviors, traits, or appearances diverging from societal norms, show statistically significant associations with elevated levels of common problems. A 2024 meta-analysis of 90 studies encompassing over 100,000 participants found small but consistent positive correlations between higher and increased generalized anxiety symptoms ( r = 0.06), depressive symptoms (r = 0.11), and suicidality, alongside lower ; these links were stronger among males than females. Similar patterns emerge in longitudinal data, where persistent adolescent predicts subsequent difficulties, with mediators such as peer victimization and family dynamics explaining part of the variance. In populations with , where distress over incongruence between experienced gender and often manifests in non-conforming expression, comorbidities with psychiatric conditions are prevalent. Systematic reviews report that adolescents and young adults with exhibit higher rates of depressive disorders, anxiety, , and self-injurious behaviors compared to peers, with self-harm prevalence often exceeding 50% in clinical samples. Among hospitalized with and suicidal behaviors, anxiety disorders affected 63.6%, with frequent co-occurrence of and other internalizing conditions. Neurodevelopmental conditions, including traits, also cluster at rates 3-6 times higher than in the general , complicating causal interpretations. These correlations do not imply unidirectional causation; cross-sectional designs predominate, limiting inferences about whether nonconformity precedes or vice versa, and minority stress from partially mediates outcomes in some models. Controlling for prior psychiatric history attenuates the predictive power of for mortality, suggesting that broader vulnerabilities drive much of the risk rather than gender-related distress in isolation. Evidence quality varies, with many studies relying on self-selected or clinical cohorts prone to , though meta-analytic syntheses provide robust aggregate support for the observed patterns.

References

  1. [1]
    Definitions, Development of Gender Identity - Medscape Reference
    Jun 26, 2023 · Gender identity is defined as a personal and internal sense of oneself as male, female, or other. Gender expression is defined as the way in which an ...<|control11|><|separator|>
  2. [2]
    Sex Differences in Early Life: A Cross-Cultural Perspective
    This chapter reviews cross-cultural literature on several early childhood sex differences in domains of development that have caught attention in the literature ...
  3. [3]
    [PDF] The Heritability of Gender Identity Disorder in a Child and ...
    In children clinically referred for GID, cross-gender interests and behavior typically onsets between 2 and 4 years, and a diagnosis of GID commonly occurs ...
  4. [4]
    Biological basis of gender identity - ScienceDirect.com
    Recent studies point toward a biological basis of gender dysphoria involving endocrine, neurobiological, and genetic factors.
  5. [5]
    Sex differences in early life: A cross-cultural perspective.
    In this chapter, we focused on play, gender identity, and gender expression to illustrate evidence and principles relating to early-life sex differences.
  6. [6]
    The Biological Basis of Gender Roles - Aporia Magazine
    Sep 5, 2025 · Evolutionary psychology provides a biological framework for understanding sex-based differences in human behavior, drawing on insights from ...
  7. [7]
    The Genetics of Sex Differences in Brain and Behavior - PMC
    In this paper, we will review sex differences in brain and behavior that are not due to the action of hormones secreted by the gonads—which has been the ...
  8. [8]
    The genetics and hormonal basis of human gender identity - PubMed
    Nov 6, 2024 · The biological basis of gender identity cannot be modeled in animals and is best studied in people who identify with a gender that is different ...
  9. [9]
    Evolved but Not Fixed: A Life History Account of Gender Roles and ...
    Jul 23, 2019 · In summary, evolutionary psychology and the biosocial model share some common insights regarding gender relations while disagreeing upon the ...
  10. [10]
    Understanding transgender people, gender identity and gender ...
    Mar 9, 2023 · Gender identity refers to a person's internal sense of being male, female or something else; gender expression refers to the way a person ...Missing: empirical | Show results with:empirical
  11. [11]
    Gender identity vs. gender expression: Definitions and more
    Mar 5, 2024 · Gender expression refers to how people may convey their gender to others through behavior and appearance. Gender exists on a broad spectrum and ...
  12. [12]
    Gender and Emotion Expression: A Developmental Contextual ... - NIH
    This article describes a developmental bio-psycho-social model of gender differences in emotion expression in childhood.
  13. [13]
    Sex Differences in Early Life (Chapter 6)
    This chapter reviews cross-cultural literature on several early childhood sex differences in domains of development that have caught attention in the literature ...
  14. [14]
    What Do We Mean By Sex and Gender? - Yale School of Medicine
    Sep 19, 2021 · In the study of human subjects, the term gender should be used to refer to a person's self-representation as male or female, or how that person ...
  15. [15]
    Neurobiology of gender identity and sexual orientation - PMC
    The present review discusses the relationship of sexual identity and sexual orientation to prenatal factors that act to shape the development of the brain.
  16. [16]
    Gender Expression and Its Correlates in a Nationally Representative ...
    Findings from another cross-cultural study suggest that the relationship between sexual orientation and gender-related traits is moderated by culture, with ...
  17. [17]
    Stability and Change in Gender Identity and Sexual Orientation ...
    Jul 15, 2025 · A 2022 Pew Research Center poll suggested that 2.0% of 18–29-year-olds in the United States identified as transgender and 3% as nonbinary (Brown ...
  18. [18]
    Gender, “masculinity,” and “femininity”: A meta-analytic review of ...
    Oct 11, 2021 · Gender, “masculinity,” and “femininity”: A meta-analytic review of gender differences in agency and communion. Publication Date. Oct 2021 ...
  19. [19]
    Traditional Masculinity and Femininity: Validation of a New Scale ...
    Jul 4, 2016 · In a seminal study on masculinity and femininity, Deaux and Lewis (1984) investigated the perceived relationship between gender and gender- ...
  20. [20]
    The measurement of gender expression in survey research
    This study examines the reliability and validity of survey questions about gender expression in a 2-by-5-by-2 factorial experiment that varies the question ...
  21. [21]
    Self-perceived gender expression, discrimination, and mental health ...
    Gender expression (appearance, clothing, behavior) operates on a complex and fluid spectrum involving elements of femininity, masculinity, and androgyny, and ...
  22. [22]
    3.3 Gender Expression - Open Oregon Educational Resources
    3.3 Gender Expression. Gender expression is how someone presents themselves outwardly through clothing, hair, makeup, practices, and so forth.
  23. [23]
    Daily gender expression is associated with psychological ... - Nature
    Apr 27, 2021 · One study provides early evidence: Girls who were more flexible in their gender expression when playing with other girls and when playing ...
  24. [24]
    Sex differences in infants' visual interest in toys - PubMed
    Consistent with primary hypothesis, sex differences in visual interest in sex-linked toys were found, such that girls showed a visual preference (d > 1.0) for ...
  25. [25]
    How Large Are Gender Differences in Toy Preferences? A ...
    Jan 27, 2020 · Our systematic review and meta-analysis combined 113 effect sizes from 75 studies to estimate the magnitude of gender-related differences in toy preferences.
  26. [26]
    (PDF) Sex differences in children's toy preferences - ResearchGate
    From an early age, most children choose to play with toys typed to their own gender. In order to identify variables that predict toy preference, we conducted a ...
  27. [27]
    Sex differences in aggression: a rejoinder and reprise - PubMed
    A meta analysis of observational studies of peer-directed aggression by children aged 6 and younger yields a highly significant sex difference.
  28. [28]
    Meta-analysis of Sex Differences in Aggression - ResearchGate
    Feb 4, 2019 · While verbal and relational aggression are more equally distributed between males and females, relational aggression is more common in girls and women.
  29. [29]
    Full article: Play fighting (rough-and-tumble play) in children
    Here we review what insights may be gained from research on play fighting in non-human species, main developmental trends in humans, definitional and ...
  30. [30]
    Sex differences in the genetic and environmental influences on the ...
    The present study uses a population-based sample of 6.806 adult twins from same-sex and opposite-sex twin pairs to examine sex differences in the underlying ...
  31. [31]
    Majority of human traits do not show evidence for sex-specific ...
    Aug 17, 2017 · Here we tested whether sex differences clustered within trait categories. Testing for heritability differences between males and females in 50 ...
  32. [32]
    The reality and evolutionary significance of human psychological ...
    Mar 20, 2019 · The evidence was positive for most features in most categories, suggesting evolutionary origins for a broad range of sex differences. Attributes ...<|separator|>
  33. [33]
    Mate Preferences and Their Behavioral Manifestations
    Jan 4, 2019 · This article reviews the science of human mate preferences and their myriad behavioral manifestations. We discuss sex differences and sex ...
  34. [34]
    Beyond Heritability: Twin Studies in Behavioral Research - PMC - NIH
    The heritability of human behavioral traits is now well established, due in large measure to classical twin studies. We see little need for further studies ...
  35. [35]
    Prenatal androgen exposure and sex-typical play behaviour
    These meta-analytic findings suggest that prenatal androgen exposure masculinises and defeminises play behaviour in humans.
  36. [36]
    Prenatal testosterone and sexually differentiated childhood play ...
    Jan 17, 2022 · We present an overview of the literature and a random-effects meta-analysis linking amniotic testosterone with sexually differentiated play preferences.<|separator|>
  37. [37]
    Evidence and Implications From a Natural Experiment of Prenatal ...
    Jun 18, 2021 · Studies of females with congenital adrenal hyperplasia (CAH) show how prenatal androgens affect behavior across the life span.
  38. [38]
  39. [39]
    Prenatal endocrine influences on sexual orientation and on sexually ...
    This article reviews the evidence regarding prenatal influences of gonadal steroids on human sexual orientation, as well as sex-typed childhood behaviors
  40. [40]
    Genetic and Environmental Contributions To Gender Diversity
    Sep 12, 2025 · Twin studies indicate both genetic and environmental contributions to gender diversity. These results are important to inform ongoing public ...
  41. [41]
    The genetic basis for sex differences in human behaviour - PubMed
    This review concentrates on the thesis that genes on the sex chromosomes other than those directly controlling sex determination, and whose functions are, at ...
  42. [42]
    The genetics of sex differences in brain and behavior - ScienceDirect
    This paper reviews the evidence for direct genetic effects in behavioral and brain sex differences.
  43. [43]
    Exploring sex differences: insights into gene expression ... - Frontiers
    This review summarizes sex chromosome effects on gene expression, epigenetics, and hormones in relation to the brain.
  44. [44]
    Patterns of Gender Development - PMC - PubMed Central
    Although studies of gender stereotypes in young children show that they attribute greater power to males and helplessness to females (Ruble et al. 2006), only a ...
  45. [45]
    Gender differences in children's play. - APA PsycNet
    Childhood play behavior differs between boys and girls, emerging early and persisting, with long-term implications. Early androgen exposure may play a role.<|separator|>
  46. [46]
    Prenatal androgen exposure and children's gender-typed behavior ...
    We report findings from two studies investigating possible relations of prenatal androgen exposure to a broad measure of children's gender-typed behavior.
  47. [47]
    Developmental Trajectories of Sex-Typed Behavior in Boys and Girls
    Aug 10, 2025 · Longitudinal studies have shown stability in sex-typical play across different stages of childhood (Golombok et al., 2008(Golombok et al., , ...
  48. [48]
    Preschool Gender-Typed Play Behavior Predicts Adolescent Gender ...
    Mar 22, 2021 · The present study investigated the association between gender-typed play behavior in early childhood and gender-typed occupational interests in early ...
  49. [49]
    [PDF] Childhood Sex-Typed Behavior and Sexual Orientation
    This article reviewed research examining the association between childhood sex-typed behavior and sexual orientation. Prospective studies suggest that ...
  50. [50]
    (PDF) Childhood Gender-Typed Behavior and Adolescent Sexual ...
    Oct 9, 2025 · ... empirical research suggest that individuals with different. sexual orientations may show different childhood gender-typed behaviors.
  51. [51]
    The Development of Gender Role Attitudes During Adolescence
    Jul 15, 2022 · Teenagers experience biological, cognitive, and social changes during adolescence that can affect their gender role attitudes (Eagly & Wood, ...
  52. [52]
    Is Developmental Change in Gender-Typed Behavior Associated ...
    Results showed that gender-typed behavior varied both within and between sexual orientation groups, as well as over time. For males, the differences in gender- ...
  53. [53]
    Rigidity in Gender-Typed Behaviors in Early Childhood
    Several studies have shown that children's gender stereotyping increases in rigidity from age 3 to 5, which is then generally followed by flexibility ( ...
  54. [54]
    Genome-Wide Linkage and Association Study of Childhood Gender ...
    Sep 13, 2021 · Childhood gender nonconformity (CGN) is one of the strongest correlates of homosexuality with substantial familiality.Results · Fig. 1 · Fig. 2
  55. [55]
    Common Genetic Factors among Sexual Orientation, Gender ...
    Homosexuality is a stable population‐level trait in humans that lowers direct fitness and yet is substantially heritable, resulting in a so‐called Darwinian ...Original Research · Abstract · Acknowledgment
  56. [56]
    Psychological and Medical Care of Gender Nonconforming Youth
    Dec 1, 2014 · Clinical observations have revealed that a child's gender identity is resistant to parental or social intervention, whereas gender expressions ...Gender Development · Interventions · Pubertal Suppression
  57. [57]
    Genetic and Environmental Influences on Sexual Orientation
    This study investigated whether childhood gender nonconformity and early-life adversities independently moderated individual differences in sexual orientation.
  58. [58]
    Daily gender expression is associated with psychological ... - NIH
    Apr 27, 2021 · Gender expression is the way in which an individual enacts their thoughts and beliefs about their gender, or their gender self-concepts, such as ...
  59. [59]
    Differentiating sex and gender in health research to achieve ... - NIH
    Sex usually refers to a person's biological characteristics, whereas gender refers to socially constructed roles and norms.
  60. [60]
    Biological Theories of Gender - Simply Psychology
    Jun 15, 2023 · Sex chromosomes primarily determine the biological basis of being male or female. In humans, males have one X and one Y chromosome (XY), ...
  61. [61]
    Measuring Sex, Gender Identity, and Sexual Orientation - NCBI - NIH
    Neither gender identity nor gender expression is defined by sex traits, however, and both can be temporally and contextually fluid. Gender is often ...
  62. [62]
    Perceived Gender Transition Progress, Gender Congruence, and ...
    Gender congruence is the extent to which an individual's gender expression is similar to or different from their gender identity [20]. Within adult samples, ...
  63. [63]
    Sex, gender and gender identity: a re-evaluation of the evidence
    ... gender expression, a social construct, a medical disease or a mental illness. ... defined by biological sex then the definition of gender identity risks ...Missing: distinction | Show results with:distinction
  64. [64]
    A Guide to Sexual Orientation and Gender Diversity Terms
    May 23, 2022 · One's sexual orientation has to do with whom one is attracted to, whereas one's gender expression reflects how one expresses their gender. Gay ...
  65. [65]
    [PDF] Childhood Gender-Role Nonconformity and Adult Psychopathology
    A meta-analysis of 41 studies conducted by Bailey and Zucker (1995) found that cross-gendered behaviors such as opposite sex toy and playmate preferences were ...<|separator|>
  66. [66]
    Gender Role Nonconformity and Gender and Sexual Diversity in ...
    Sep 25, 2023 · In this cohort study, ASEBA gender role nonconformity was associated with diverse sexual orientation, beginning in early childhood.
  67. [67]
    The relationship between self-rated gender expression and ...
    Apr 4, 2024 · These results indicate that self-ratings of gender expression are associated with the sexual identification (eg, as exclusively heterosexual, mostly ...
  68. [68]
    Gender Nonconformity and Minority Stress Among Lesbian, Gay ...
    Mar 1, 2021 · Gender nonconformity is more strongly associated with experiencing prejudice events among gay and bisexual men than among lesbian and bisexual ...
  69. [69]
    Gender nonconformity and common mental health problems - PubMed
    Sep 7, 2024 · There was no significant moderation by sexual orientation. While gender nonconformity is robustly associated with a range of common mental ...
  70. [70]
    Meta-analysis explores relationship between gender nonconformity ...
    Sep 27, 2024 · "There was no influence of sexual orientation on the pattern we found, which is unusual since gender nonconformity and being non-heterosexual ...
  71. [71]
    The Androgynous Shamans of the Scythians - Ancient Origins
    Dec 11, 2023 · Gender fluidity and spirituality came together with the priestly Enaree, spiritual practitioners who played a fundamental role within ...
  72. [72]
  73. [73]
    The Galli: The Cross-Dressing Cybele Cult Priests Who Castrated ...
    Oct 14, 2022 · Because of the galli's adoption of women's clothing and jewelry, self-castration, and preference for anal intercourse, all of which violated ...
  74. [74]
    Gender-nonconforming ancient Romans found refuge in community ...
    Apr 24, 2024 · Galli, unlike other men in Rome or its empire, were able to openly present themselves or live as women, regardless of their assigned sex or how ...
  75. [75]
    [PDF] Galli: Ancient Roman Priests
    Catullus refers to the galli as gallae (feminine plural), suggesting that the loss of their private parts has in fact perversely changed their gender, just as ...
  76. [76]
    [PDF] Historical Evolution of Transgender Community in India
    Transgender community comprises of Hijras, eunuchs,. Kothis, Aravanis, Jogappas, Shiv-Shakthis etc. Eunuchs have existed since 9th century BC. The word has ...
  77. [77]
    India's Relationship with the Third Gender – UAB Institute for Human ...
    Oct 29, 2018 · In ancient India, the Hijras were a community that was respected for being extremely loyal and were well trusted enough to be given important ...
  78. [78]
    Two Spirits, One Heart, Five Genders - ICT News
    Jan 23, 2016 · All Native American societies acknowledged three to five gender roles: Female, male, Two Spirit female, Two Spirit male and transgendered.
  79. [79]
    Case Study of the Native American “Two Spirit” People
    Sep 9, 2013 · Two Spirit people often take on wives and husbands of the opposite gender, but not always; they may have diverse sexual experiences with both ...
  80. [80]
    Two Spirit and LGBTQ+ Identities: Today and Centuries Ago - HRC
    Nov 23, 2020 · Research shows that more than 150 different pre-colonial Native American tribes acknowledged third genders in their communities.
  81. [81]
    [PDF] An Exploration of Ancient and Modern Constructs of Gender
    Dec 1, 2022 · Modern views see bodies as binary, while ancient examples suggest nonbinary bodies exist. Ancient Roman ideas used passivity/activity, not just ...
  82. [82]
    "The Gallae Transgender Priests of Ancient Greece, Rome, and the ...
    Although assigned a male gender role at birth, they ritually severed their own genitalia either in whole or in part, and afterward dressed in women's clothing, ...
  83. [83]
    Feminism: The Second Wave | National Women's History Museum
    Jun 18, 2020 · By the late 1970s, the second wave of feminism began to lose steam. As multiple sub-groups created new organizations for themselves, other ...
  84. [84]
    Changing gender roles and attitudes and their implications for well ...
    Thus, in the UK, there have been major changes in patterns of marriage and cohabitation, family formation, education and female employment since the mid ...
  85. [85]
    Gender Development Research in Sex Roles: Historical Trends and ...
    The late 1960s through the 1970s marked an important turning point in the field of gender research, including theory and research in gender development.
  86. [86]
    [PDF] The Feminist and Gay Liberation Movements for Freedom in Public
    Mar 2, 2020 · This history suggests that protections for sex, gender expression, and sexual orientation were mutually reinforcing. While the 1950s and ...
  87. [87]
    How has queer theory influenced the ways we think about gender?
    The aim of my analysis is to demonstrate the way in which queer theory not only influenced, but also gave the possibility to change and rethink how we approach ...
  88. [88]
    Researchers explain social media's role in rapidly shifting social ...
    May 29, 2024 · A new paper by UC Santa Cruz psychologists describes how social media has supported an explosion of diversity in gender and sexuality in America ...Missing: 20th | Show results with:20th
  89. [89]
    The psychology of sexual and gender diversity in the 21st century
    May 23, 2024 · The amount of empirical research on such topics as sexual fluidity and flexibility, kink identities and relationships, consensual nonmonogamies ...
  90. [90]
    The Gender Self-Report - NIH
    Jan 30, 2023 · Daily gender expression is associated with psychological adjustment for some people, but mainly men. Scientific Reports, 11(1), Article 9114 ...
  91. [91]
    What do measures of gender identity tell us about gender identity ...
    May 7, 2024 · Clothing preference is used frequently throughout the research literature as a means of observing and measuring a child's gender expression.Measures Of Gender Identity · Gender Stereotyped... · Results
  92. [92]
    Gender (mis)measurement: Guidelines for respecting gender ...
    Nov 15, 2019 · Gender measures that allowed participants to declare a nonbinary identity were classified as gender inclusive or as othering if the only ...
  93. [93]
    Studying Everyday Variability in Gender Identity and Expression: An ...
    Nov 25, 2024 · Ambulatory assessment methods can help researchers better understand gender at the level of daily, within-person variability. Conflicts of ...
  94. [94]
    [PDF] Development and Validation of a Gender Expression Measure ...
    Abstract. Gender expression varies considerably among lesbian and bisexual women and may be related to various stressors and health outcomes.<|separator|>
  95. [95]
    Review Measurement tools for gender identity, gender expression ...
    This systematic review identified 24 tools that have been used to assess gender identity, gender expression, or gender dysphoria in transgender children and ...
  96. [96]
    A Follow-Up Study of Boys With Gender Identity Disorder - PMC
    The persistence-desistance rates found in this study ... Childhood maltreatment, gender nonconformity, and adolescent sexual orientation: a prospective birth ...
  97. [97]
    Studies | SEGM
    ... gender nonconformity was associated with whether currently binary ... The high rate of desistance among gender variant children has been ...
  98. [98]
    A Follow-Up Study of Girls With Gender Identity Disorder
    Oct 9, 2025 · We observed some evidence that more gender nonconformity in childhood (e.g., more femininity in childhood among children living as boys) was ...
  99. [99]
    [PDF] Treatment for Pediatric Gender Dysphoria
    May 1, 2025 · Childhood gender-nonconformity is strongly associated with later homosexuality.26. Because childhood- or early-onset gender dysphoria (GD)27 ...<|separator|>
  100. [100]
    Hormones may affect girls' interests, but not their gender identity or ...
    Mar 1, 2018 · Prenatal exposure to male hormones influences which activities girls are interested and engage in, but the effects of those hormones don't extend to gender ...
  101. [101]
    Hormones may affect girls' interests, but not their gender identity or ...
    Mar 2, 2018 · Prenatal exposure to androgens is not associated with girls spending more or less time with other girls, but was associated with an increased ...<|control11|><|separator|>
  102. [102]
    Gender dysphoria in twins: a register-based population study - PMC
    Aug 4, 2022 · Some previous twin studies have provided evidence for a strong genetic influence in shaping gender identity. Candidate gene association studies ...
  103. [103]
    Genetic and Environmental Contributions To Gender Diversity
    Sep 12, 2025 · Cross-sectional and retrospective twin study on female sexual orientation, childhood gender typicality and adult gender identity. This study ...
  104. [104]
    Sex differences and nonadditivity in heritability of the ...
    In a more recent Australian twin study, Macaskill, Hopper, White, and Hill (1994) reported no sex differences in heritability of Neuroticism and higher male ...
  105. [105]
    What do measures of gender identity tell us about gender ... - NIH
    In the longitudinal part of this study, results showed moderate stability in the way that participants self‐identified using this spectrum measure over the 1–2‐ ...
  106. [106]
    Stability and Change in Gender Identity and Sexual Orientation ...
    Jul 15, 2025 · Stability in gender identity was by far the most common pathway for youths in all three groups, with over 80% of youths showing stability ...Missing: expression | Show results with:expression
  107. [107]
    Trajectories of Gender Identity and Depressive Symptoms in Youths
    May 22, 2024 · ... gender nonconformity. Second, our study indicates that youths who transitioned to TGD during the study (cisgender to TGD) experienced ...
  108. [108]
    Fixed or Fluid? Sexual Identity Fluidity in a Large National Panel ...
    Dec 14, 2023 · Our study shows that sexual identity can be fluid into adulthood and has implications for how we understand contemporary human sexuality.
  109. [109]
    Stability and Change in Gender Identity and Sexual Orientation ...
    Stability in gender identity was by far the most common pathway for youths in all three groups, with over 80% of youths showing stability throughout their ...
  110. [110]
    Gender Identity 5 Years After Social Transition | Pediatrics
    Jul 13, 2022 · We found that an average of 5 years after their initial social transition, 7.3% of youth had retransitioned at least once.
  111. [111]
    The Longitudinal Measurement of Sexual Orientation and Gender ...
    Among teens, who are developmentally more apt to change identity, 13.5% reported a change in sexual orientation and 9.3% reported a change in gender identity.
  112. [112]
    Biological sex is binary, even though there is a rainbow of sex roles
    Dec 21, 2022 · Biomedical and social scientists are increasingly calling the biological sex into question, arguing that sex is a graded spectrum rather than a binary trait.BIOLOGICAL SEX AS A... · THE VARIOUS... · CONCLUSION: DENYING...
  113. [113]
    Those “sex is a spectrum” articles, debunked | by Charles Arthur
    May 15, 2023 · While it used to be thought that there were just two sexes, male and female, there's now “a scientific consensus” that “sex is a spectrum”.
  114. [114]
    Parent reports of adolescents and young adults perceived to show ...
    One of the most compelling findings supporting a potential role of social and peer contagion in the development or expression of a rapid onset of gender ...
  115. [115]
    Rapid Onset Gender Dysphoria: Parent Reports on 1655 Possible ...
    Mar 29, 2023 · One influential if controversial explanation is that the increase reflects a socially contagious syndrome: Rapid Onset Gender Dysphoria (ROGD).Missing: contagion | Show results with:contagion<|separator|>
  116. [116]
    Cass Review Final Report
    No information is available for this page. · Learn why
  117. [117]
    Evidence Undermines 'Rapid Onset Gender Dysphoria' Claims
    Aug 24, 2023 · Littman suggests that female-assigned kids are more susceptible to the “social contagion” of gender dysphoria because they feel social pressure ...
  118. [118]
    Study of 1,655 Cases Supports the "Rapid-Onset Gender Dysphoria ...
    Mar 30, 2023 · A new study examining 1655 parental reports lends further credibility to the rapid-onset gender dysphoria (ROGD) hypothesis, first posited ...
  119. [119]
    Gender dysphoria in adolescence: examining the rapid-onset ... - NIH
    Rapid-onset gender dysphoria and social contagion​​ Dishion and Tipsord [63] define “peer contagion” as a process of reciprocal influence among peers that ...
  120. [120]
    Regret after Gender-affirmation Surgery: A Systematic Review and ...
    Mar 19, 2021 · The prevalence of regret for transfemenine surgeries was 1% (CI <1%–2%), and the prevalence for transmasculine surgeries was <1% (CI <1%–<1%).
  121. [121]
    Prevalence of Regret in Gender-Affirming Surgery - PubMed
    May 1, 2024 · The pooled prevalence of regret was 1.94%. The prevalence of transfeminine regret was 4.0% while the prevalence of transmasculine regret was 0.8%.
  122. [122]
    A systematic review of patient regret after surgery
    Regret after gender affirming surgery is less than 1 %. Regret after elective plastic surgery operations is significantly higher.
  123. [123]
    Factors Leading to “Detransition” Among Transgender and Gender ...
    Of these, 2242 (13.1%) reported a history of detransition. Of those who had detransitioned, 82.5% reported at least one external driving factor. Frequently ...Missing: 2020-2025 | Show results with:2020-2025
  124. [124]
    A retrospective analysis of the gender trajectories of youth who have ...
    Nov 22, 2023 · Rates of detransition are difficult to estimate because studies use different methodologies and samples, among other factors (Cohn, 2023). ...
  125. [125]
    Accurate transition regret and detransition rates are unknown - SEGM
    Sep 11, 2023 · A new paper by Cohn, “The Rate of Detransition is Unknown,” reviews common limitations of “regret” studies and demonstrates that hormone discontinuation, ...
  126. [126]
    Prevalence of detransition in persons seeking gender-affirming ...
    Dec 30, 2024 · Due to methodological inconsistencies across studies, estimates for the prevalence for detransition can range from <1% to as high as 30% ( ...
  127. [127]
    The Final Cass Review and the NHS England Response - SEGM
    Apr 11, 2024 · The Cass Report provides a scathing assessment of the gender-affirming approach in general, and the gender-clinic model of care, which ...
  128. [128]
    Discontinuing hormonal gender reassignment: a nationwide register ...
    Aug 19, 2024 · Detransition refers to people aborting their initiated transition and reversing it, totally or partially, to live in a sex-accordant role by ...<|separator|>
  129. [129]
    Detransition: a Real and Growing Phenomenon - SEGM
    May 30, 2021 · Only 13% of the respondents received help from LGBT organizations when detransitioning, compared to 51% when transitioning. A number of ...
  130. [130]
    The Gender Dysphoria Diagnosis in Young People Has a “Low ...
    Jul 19, 2024 · Youth diagnosed with gender dysphoria suffer from a high rate of mental health comorbidities. ... rates of medical detransition (10-30%). A ...
  131. [131]
    Why detransitioners are crucial to the science of gender care - Reuters
    Dec 22, 2022 · The results of these studies suggest a wide range of possibilities for rates of detransitioning, from less than 1% to 25%.
  132. [132]
    [PDF] Workplace Experiences of Transgender Employees - Williams Institute
    Most transgender employees (82%) reported experiencing discrimination or harassment at work (including being fired, not hired, not promoted, or verbally, ...
  133. [133]
    Prevalence of Discrimination and the Association Between ... - CDC
    Jan 25, 2024 · Seven in 10 transgender women experienced at least one type of discrimination during the past 12 months.Missing: expression | Show results with:expression
  134. [134]
    [PDF] Consistent Evidence of Sexual Orientation and Gender Identity ...
    This article summarizes social science data published during the past decade documenting discrimination against lesbian, gay, bisexual, and.
  135. [135]
    Landmark U.S. Supreme Court Ruling Prohibits Sexual Orientation ...
    Jun 15, 2020 · As of June 15, 2020, however, discrimination on the basis of sexual orientation or gender identity illegal by all employers covered by Title VII ...
  136. [136]
    Removing Gender Ideology and Restoring the EEOC's Role of ...
    Jan 28, 2025 · The agency is returning to its mission of protecting women from sexual harassment and sex-based discrimination in the workplace by rolling back the Biden ...
  137. [137]
    2024 Annual Performance Report - EEOC
    The EEOC received 88,531 new charges of discrimination in fiscal year 2024 alone, reflecting a more than 9% increase over the number of charges filed in fiscal ...
  138. [138]
    [PDF] Facts About Gender Identity or Expression Discrimination
    Apr 9, 2025 · Nevada state law protects individuals against employment discrimination on the basis of gender identity or expression.Missing: statistics | Show results with:statistics
  139. [139]
    Legal aspects of LGBTIQ equality - European Commission
    Legal basis. Article 21 of the EU Charter of Fundamental Rights explicitly prohibits discrimination based on sexual orientation.
  140. [140]
    Legal Protection | ILGA-Europe
    At ILGA-Europe, we work to ensure that rights of LGBTI people are protected within national constitutional and legal systems, as well as by European and ...
  141. [141]
    Americans' Complex Views on Gender Identity and Transgender ...
    Jun 28, 2022 · Overall, 57% of adults say there is a great deal or a fair amount of discrimination against transgender people in our society today. An ...
  142. [142]
    Defending Women From Gender Ideology Extremism And Restoring ...
    Jan 20, 2025 · Invalidating the true and biological category of “woman” improperly transforms laws and policies designed to protect sex-based opportunities ...
  143. [143]
    Interventions to suppress puberty in adolescents experiencing ...
    Apr 9, 2024 · This systematic review aims to synthesise evidence published to April 2022 that reports outcomes of puberty suppression in adolescents ...
  144. [144]
    Masculinising and feminising hormone interventions for adolescents ...
    Apr 9, 2024 · Conclusions There is a lack of high-quality research assessing the use of hormones in adolescents experiencing gender dysphoria/incongruence.
  145. [145]
    NHS England » Children and young people's gender services
    The Cass Review was an independent review of NHS gender identity services for children and young people, commissioned by NHS England in 2020.<|separator|>
  146. [146]
    Impact of gender-affirming treatment on bone health in transgender ...
    Results consistently indicate a negative impact of long-term puberty suppression on bone mineral density, especially at the lumbar spine.
  147. [147]
    Puberty blockers for gender dysphoria in youth: A systematic review ...
    Within a range of 12–36 months, 92% of individuals who received puberty blockers progressed to receiving gender affirming hormone therapy (proportion 0.92 (95% ...
  148. [148]
    Systematic review on outcomes of hormonal treatment in youths with ...
    Apr 19, 2023 · “In our review, we focused on psychosocial effects, bone health, body composition and metabolism, and therapy persistence in children (<18 ...<|separator|>
  149. [149]
    Current Concerns About Gender-Affirming Therapy in Adolescents
    Apr 14, 2023 · Unfortunately, these long-term data do not show that hormonal and surgical transitions result in lasting mental health improvements in ...
  150. [150]
    [PDF] Overview of Systematic Reviews
    May 1, 2025 · The study assesses at least one of the following: social transition, psychotherapy, puberty blockers (PBs), cross-sex hormones (CSH), or surgery ...
  151. [151]
    A Retrospective Cohort Study of Transgender Adolescents' Gender ...
    Jan 16, 2025 · This study found that 93% of transgender adolescents continued GAH, 2% restarted after discontinuing, and 4% discontinued without restarting, ...
  152. [152]
    Swedish Transgender Treatment Guidelines for Youth - SEGM
    Sep 24, 2024 · In 2020, Finland's treatment guidelines were the first to explicitly state that hormonal gender transition for youth is experimental. The ...
  153. [153]
    Finland Takes Another Look at Youth Gender Medicine
    Feb 20, 2023 · A recent interview with the country's top gender expert shows how out of step the American medical establishment is with its European counterparts.
  154. [154]
    Gender nonconformity and common mental health problems: A meta ...
    Gender nonconformity had stronger links to generalized anxiety symptoms, depressive symptoms, and self-esteem in men than in women.
  155. [155]
    Uncovering associations between gender nonconformity ...
    Sep 18, 2023 · Persistent gender nonconformity during adolescence is associated with subsequent mental health. Psychosocial factors play a vital mediating role in this ...
  156. [156]
    A systematic review on gender dysphoria in adolescents and young ...
    Sep 21, 2023 · Results showed that GD adolescents have more suicidal ideation, life-threatening behaviour, self-injurious thoughts or self-harm than their cisgender peers.
  157. [157]
    A systematic review on gender dysphoria in adolescents and young ...
    In summary, several studies have shown higher rates of suicidal and non-suicidal self-harming thoughts and behaviours in adolescents and young adults with GD ...
  158. [158]
    Gender Dysphoria in Pediatric and Transitional-Aged Youth ...
    Mar 21, 2023 · The prevalent psychiatric comorbidities in inpatients with gender dysphoria included anxiety disorders (63.6%), posttraumatic stress disorder ( ...
  159. [159]
    A 2020 Review of Mental Health Comorbidity in Gender Dysphoric ...
    Mar 8, 2021 · The purpose of this paper has been to investigate the prevalence of psychiatric disorders in gender dysphoric and gender non-conforming people.
  160. [160]
    Gender nonconformity and mental health among lesbian, gay ... - NIH
    Gender nonconformity was related to more mental health problems via increased experiences with homophobic stigmatization and to less mental health problems ...
  161. [161]
    All-cause and suicide mortalities among adolescents and young ...
    Feb 17, 2024 · Conclusions Clinical gender dysphoria does not appear to be predictive of all-cause nor suicide mortality when psychiatric treatment history is ...
  162. [162]
    A PRISMA systematic review of adolescent gender dysphoria literature
    Aug 8, 2023 · Childhood gender nonconformity, bullying victimization, and depressive symptoms across adolescence and early adulthood: An 11-year ...