Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Gender nonconformity

Gender nonconformity refers to behaviors, appearances, or identities that deviate from the norms typically expected of an individual's biological sex, as shaped by cultural and evolutionary influences on sex differences.^[1]^[2] Observed across human societies and historical periods, it manifests in variations such as cross-sex toy preferences in children or atypical mannerisms in adults, though prevalence estimates vary widely by age and measurement; for instance, one study of school-aged children found 23% of boys and 39% of girls displaying some nonconforming gender role behaviors.^[3] Empirical longitudinal research indicates high desistance rates for childhood-onset cases, with 60-80% of referred boys resolving nonconformity by adolescence without persistent gender dysphoria or transgender identification.^[4]^[5] These patterns challenge models assuming innate fixed identities, as desistance often correlates with puberty and aligns with biological sex-typed development, potentially influenced by prenatal hormones, genetics, or socialization rather than immutable incongruence.^[6] Nonconformity is associated with elevated mental health risks, including anxiety, depression, and suicidality, frequently linked to peer victimization and psychosocial stressors rather than the traits themselves.^[1]^[2] Controversies arise from debates over interventions, with affirmative approaches criticized for low evidence of long-term benefits and potential to disrupt natural resolution, amid concerns of ideological capture in clinical guidelines that downplay desistance data.^[7] Evolutionarily, sex-dimorphic norms reflect adaptive reproductive strategies—men favoring risk and status, women nurturing and consensus—suggesting marked nonconformity may signal developmental variance rather than normative diversity.^[8]

Definitions and Terminology

Core Concepts and Distinctions

Gender nonconformity refers to behaviors, interests, mannerisms, or appearances that deviate from the sex-typical norms expected by society for an individual's biological sex, which is defined by reproductive anatomy and gamete production (sperm in males, ova in females).^[1]^[3] These norms typically reflect average population-level differences between males and females in traits such as aggression, nurturing, spatial abilities, and verbal fluency, which have documented biological underpinnings including prenatal hormone exposure.^[9] Nonconformity exists on a spectrum, from mild variations (e.g., a biologically female individual preferring competitive sports over dolls in childhood) to pronounced expressions that elicit social scrutiny, but it does not inherently alter one's biological sex or imply a mismatch in self-perception.^[10] Key distinctions separate gender nonconformity from related constructs. Unlike gender identity—the internal, subjective sense of being male, female, or neither—nonconformity primarily concerns observable expression and adherence to social roles rather than an innate conviction of cross-sex alignment.^[11] Gender dysphoria, as defined in the DSM-5, requires clinically significant distress or impairment stemming from incongruence between one's biological sex and experienced gender, whereas nonconformity alone does not constitute a disorder and often lacks such distress; the APA explicitly states that gender nonconformity is not pathological.^[12]^[13] Transgender identity involves a persistent identification with a gender opposite to one's biological sex, potentially leading to medical interventions, but many nonconforming individuals remain cisgender (aligned with their sex) and do not seek transition; conversely, transgender persons may conform to their identified gender's norms post-transition.^[14]^[15] Measurement of gender nonconformity in psychological research typically relies on validated scales assessing deviation from sex norms, such as the Bem Sex Role Inventory, which rates endorsement of masculine or feminine traits on a Likert scale, or retrospective self-reports and parental ratings of childhood behaviors like toy preferences and peer play patterns.^[16] These tools quantify traits empirically linked to sex differences, with higher nonconformity scores correlating to outcomes like peer victimization independent of sexual orientation.^[17] Studies using such measures, often from longitudinal cohorts, emphasize that nonconformity is a behavioral dimension influenced by both genetic and environmental factors, not a categorical identity.^[18] While academic sources on these topics can exhibit interpretive biases favoring social construction over biological determinism, empirical data from twin studies and hormone research support innate components without necessitating depathologization narratives.^[9]

Historical and Cultural Variations

In ancient Mesopotamia, circa 3000 BCE, gala priests devoted to the goddess Inanna exhibited gender-nonconforming behaviors, adopting feminine attire, names, and linguistic dialects typically associated with women, while serving as professional lamenters in rituals—a role ordinarily reserved for females—as documented in cuneiform texts.^[19] These priests were characterized in sources as occupying an ambiguous position between male and female, often linked to cultic functions rather than everyday social integration.^[20] In South Asia, hijras—biological males who adopt feminine presentations and roles—trace origins to ancient Hindu texts such as the Kama Sutra (circa 400 BCE–200 CE), where they appear as a distinct category performing ritual blessings at births and weddings, outside the strict male-female binary.^[19] Anthropological records indicate hijras historically held semi-institutionalized positions in Mughal courts (16th–19th centuries) as guards and entertainers, though colonial British policies from the 19th century onward criminalized their communities under laws like the Criminal Tribes Act of 1871, disrupting traditional roles.^[21] Among Greco-Roman cultures, from the 3rd century BCE, galli priests of the Phrygian goddess Cybele underwent voluntary castration and cross-dressed in ecstatic processions, embodying a liminal gender state tied to religious devotion, as described by Roman authors like Lucretius and Juvenal.^[22] In Polynesia, particularly Samoa, fa'afafine—assigned-male individuals expressing feminine traits—have been documented in ethnographic studies since the 20th century, often assuming kin-caregiving responsibilities with familial acceptance, though their prevalence correlates with fraternal birth order effects observed in psychological data.^[23] ^[24] Cross-cultural anthropological reviews reveal that while such nonconforming roles appear in diverse societies spanning five millennia and six continents, they typically channeled atypical behaviors into specialized ritual or social niches rather than endorsing fluid identities broadly, with acceptance varying by context—higher in kin-integrated systems like Samoa but often marginalizing in rigid hierarchies.^[19] In pre-colonial Native American tribes, ethnographies from the 19th century record "berdache" figures (e.g., among the Zuni or Lakota) who adopted opposite-sex attire and labor, sometimes revered for spiritual mediation but frequently facing stigma or exploitation, though the pan-tribal "two-spirit" framing emerged only in 1990 as a modern reclamation term without uniform historical precedent across all groups.^[25] ^[26] Empirical life-history analyses suggest these variations stem from adaptive pressures balancing reproductive strategies, with stricter enforcement in high-risk environments favoring dimorphic roles.^[8]

Biological and Evolutionary Foundations

Innate Sex Differences and Gender Roles

Humans exhibit innate sex differences rooted in genetics, prenatal hormone exposure, and brain structure, which contribute to average behavioral patterns that underpin traditional gender roles. Males and females differ in chromosomal composition (XY vs. XX), influencing gonadal development and subsequent hormone profiles, with testosterone playing a key role in masculinizing traits during critical prenatal periods.^[27] These differences manifest early, as evidenced by sex-typed toy preferences observed in infants as young as 12 months, where boys preferentially engage with mechanical objects and vehicles, while girls favor dolls and social playthings, independent of parental encouragement.^[28] Prenatal androgen exposure, measurable via amniotic fluid testosterone levels, predicts these behaviors: higher levels correlate with increased male-typical play in both sexes, including rough-and-tumble activity and object manipulation, with effect sizes indicating substantial influence (e.g., d ≈ 1.0 for toy preferences).^[29] ^[30] Brain imaging studies reveal structural dimorphisms beyond overall size differences, where adult male brains average 10-11% larger than female brains, even after adjusting for body size, with regional variations such as greater male volume in areas linked to spatial processing and female advantages in connectivity regions associated with empathy.^[31] ^[32] These neural patterns align with behavioral divergences: meta-analyses of personality traits show males scoring higher on assertiveness (d = 0.50) and sensation-seeking (d = 0.30-0.40), while females exceed males in neuroticism, agreeableness, and tenderness components.^[33] ^[34] In vocational interests, a large sex difference emerges (d = 0.93), with males preferring "things-oriented" domains (e.g., realistic/investigative activities like engineering) and females "people-oriented" ones (e.g., social/enterprising roles like caregiving), consistent across cultures and persisting despite socialization efforts.^[35] ^[36] From an evolutionary perspective, these traits likely arose via sexual selection and parental investment asymmetries: males, facing higher reproductive variance, evolved propensities for risk-taking, mate competition, and spatial navigation suited to hunting and protection, while females prioritized nurturing and social bonding to maximize offspring survival in resource-scarce environments.^[37] ^[38] Gender roles—normative expectations of behavior by sex—thus reflect statistical aggregates of these innate dispositions rather than arbitrary constructs, as evidenced by cross-cultural universality in mate preferences (e.g., females valuing resource provision more than males) and persistence in isolated societies. ^[39] Gender nonconformity, involving deviations from these averages (e.g., feminine interests in males), occurs at rates of 5-10% prenatally influenced cases but does not negate the robust group-level dimorphisms driving role formation.^[40] Empirical data underscore that while individual variation exists, including greater male variability in traits like intelligence and interests, the directional sex differences remain reliable predictors of role adherence across populations.^[41]

Psychological and Neurodevelopmental Correlates

Gender nonconformity is associated with elevated rates of autism spectrum disorder (ASD), with meta-analyses indicating a pooled prevalence of ASD diagnoses among individuals with gender dysphoria or incongruence at approximately 11%, substantially higher than the 1-2% general population rate.^[42] ^[43] The odds of ASD are estimated to be 3 to 6.4 times greater in transgender and gender-diverse individuals compared to cisgender controls.^[44] Longitudinal and cross-sectional studies consistently report that autistic traits, such as social communication difficulties and restricted interests, correlate with feelings of gender incongruence in both clinical and non-clinical samples, though the direction of causality remains unclear and may involve shared neurodevelopmental pathways rather than direct causation.^[43] ^[45] Comorbidities with other neurodevelopmental conditions, including attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD), are also documented. Children displaying gender nonconformity exhibit higher levels of ADHD hyperactive-impulsive symptoms and conduct disorder traits, independent of parental support or peer relations.^[46] Reviews of transgender and gender-nonconforming youth highlight increased prevalence of ADHD alongside ASD, with these conditions potentially exacerbating social challenges that amplify nonconforming behaviors.^[47] Psychologically, gender nonconformity in childhood and adolescence predicts greater emotional and behavioral difficulties, including internalizing problems like anxiety and depression, persisting into adulthood.^[2] ^[48] Persistent nonconformity is linked to elevated psychological distress, with cohort studies showing associations mediated partly by peer victimization but also direct effects from underlying traits.^[49] Neuroimaging research on gender dysphoria—a subset of severe nonconformity—suggests atypical brain sexual dimorphism, such as shifts in cortical thickness or white matter microstructure toward the experienced gender, observed prior to hormone therapy; however, findings are inconsistent across studies and do not uniformly extend to milder nonconformity without dysphoria.^[50] ^[51] These patterns underscore potential neurodevelopmental underpinnings, warranting further longitudinal research to disentangle innate factors from environmental influences.

Manifestations Across the Lifespan

Childhood Expressions and Trajectories

Childhood gender nonconformity typically manifests in behaviors diverging from sex-typical norms, such as boys exhibiting preferences for female-associated toys, clothing, or activities like doll play and role-playing as female characters, while girls may display interests in male-typical rough-and-tumble play, vehicles, or short haircuts.^[52] These patterns emerge early, often by ages 2-4, and vary in intensity, with some children showing persistent cross-sex identification and distress qualifying as gender dysphoria under DSM criteria.^[4] Longitudinal cohort studies document that such expressions are more prevalent among children who later identify as non-heterosexual, with genetic factors contributing to overlap between childhood gender-atypical behavior and adult sexual orientation.^[53] Trajectories of childhood gender nonconformity reveal high rates of resolution or redirection by adolescence or adulthood. In a follow-up study of 139 boys referred for gender identity disorder (GID) in childhood, only 12.2% persisted in transgender identification at mean age 20.6 years, with 87.8% desisting and most aligning with male identity, often alongside homosexual orientation.^[4] Similarly, Dutch clinic data from the 1980s-2000s showed desistance rates of 61-98% among children with GD, with persistence linked to more intense childhood behaviors but still minority outcomes.^[54] Multiple longitudinal studies indicate that gender-atypical children frequently develop homosexual rather than transgender orientations, with over 70% of desisters identifying as gay or lesbian in adulthood.^[55] Factors influencing trajectories include behavioral intensity, peer relations, and comorbidities; persistent nonconformity correlates with elevated emotional and behavioral difficulties, including internalizing problems, though many cases remit without intervention.^[2] Early social affirmation of cross-sex identity may reduce desistance rates, as evidenced by a 2022 study where socially transitioned children showed 94% persistence after five years, contrasting historical clinic data.^[56] These findings underscore that childhood expressions do not reliably predict lifelong transgender outcomes, with empirical data prioritizing observation over premature medicalization.^[57]

Adolescent and Adult Patterns

In adolescence, gender nonconformity manifests as behaviors, interests, or expressions diverging from sex-typical norms, with prevalence estimates indicating that approximately 3-4% of adolescents exhibit nonconforming gender expression and 4% report variant gender experiences.30067-8/abstract) ^[58] Longitudinal data show that while some adolescent nonconformity persists from childhood patterns, a substantial portion—often over 80% in terms of gender identity stability—remains cisgender, though shifts toward nonbinary identifications occur in about 12% of cases among those initially cisgender.^[59] Persistence of intense childhood nonconformity into adolescence correlates with factors such as early behavioral intensity and sex differences, with natal females showing higher rates of continuation compared to males.^[60] However, desistance remains common, with only 5-20% of childhood gender dysphoria cases (often overlapping with nonconformity) persisting into young adulthood.^[61] Adolescent-onset nonconformity, distinct from childhood expressions, has been documented in studies tracking unhappiness with one's sex-aligned gender, peaking in mid-adolescence before stabilizing or declining by early adulthood.^[62] Gender nonconformity in this age group frequently associates with sexual minority orientations, where atypical behaviors predict later homosexuality or bisexuality in up to 80-90% of cases among those with marked childhood atypicality.^[63] Empirical patterns also reveal elevated risks for mental health challenges, including emotional difficulties, anxiety, and depression, persisting from childhood nonconformity through adolescence, independent of sexual orientation stigma.^[2] ^[64] Victimization, such as bullying due to perceived atypicality, mediates links to psychosocial adjustment issues, with gender-atypical youth reporting higher rates of PTSD (around 9%) and relational difficulties.^[65] These patterns underscore a developmental trajectory where nonconformity often aligns with innate traits rather than fixed identity shifts, though social influences may amplify expressions during peer-sensitive periods. Among adults, gender nonconformity typically presents as sustained cross-sex interests or mannerisms, with lower overall prevalence than in youth—estimated at 0.3-0.5% for transgender identities amid broader atypical behaviors—often linked to early-life predictors like childhood nonconformity.^[66] ^[63] Adults exhibiting nonconformity face heightened discrimination and health-compromising behaviors, particularly if expressions remain overt, leading to patterns of lower socioeconomic status and elevated allostatic load, though effects vary by sex (higher physiological stress in nonconforming women).^[67] ^[68] Strong empirical ties persist to non-heterosexual orientations, where adult effeminacy or masculinity in males and females respectively correlates with androphilic or gynephilic attractions, reflecting biological underpinnings rather than cultural invention.^[18] Mental health comorbidities, including generalized anxiety and depressive symptoms, show consistent associations with lifelong nonconformity, mediated partly by stigma but rooted in developmental trajectories.^[64] ^[69] Overall, adult patterns indicate relative stability for those with persistent traits, yet nonconformity does not uniformly predict transgender outcomes, as most individuals with atypical histories identify with their birth sex.^[52]

Associations with Other Traits

Links to Sexual Orientation

Childhood gender nonconformity exhibits a robust empirical association with non-heterosexual sexual orientation in adulthood. Multiple longitudinal and retrospective studies, drawing on self-reports, parental observations, and objective behavioral assessments, consistently find that individuals identifying as gay, lesbian, or bisexual report or demonstrate higher levels of cross-sex-typed behaviors and interests during childhood compared to heterosexual peers.^[70]^[71] This pattern emerges early, often by ages 2-4, and persists across diverse samples, including clinical and community cohorts.^[72] Objective evidence from blinded ratings of home videos corroborates self-reported data: prehomosexual boys and girls were judged as more gender nonconforming overall than preheterosexual children, with the effect observable in both sexes and independent of rater bias.^[73] For instance, in behavioral genetics research, maternal ratings of childhood gender nonconformity differentiated homosexual from heterosexual sons, though self-ratings within homosexual groups showed variability.^[74] A 2023 cohort analysis of over 1,000 participants linked adolescent gender role nonconformity—measured via items like "behaves like opposite sex"—to young adult diverse sexual identity (adjusted odds ratio 2.8; 95% CI, 1.9-4.2) and same-gender behavior (aOR 2.4; 95% CI, 1.6-3.5), with stronger associations among males.^[72] The association is bidirectional in prevalence but asymmetric in prediction: while 60-80% of gay men and a substantial proportion of lesbians retrospectively report moderate-to-marked childhood gender atypicality (far exceeding rates in heterosexuals, typically under 20%), most gender nonconforming children ultimately identify as heterosexual.^[75]^[71] This suggests developmental overlap in traits influencing both gender-typicality and erotic orientation, potentially rooted in prenatal hormonal or genetic factors, rather than direct causation.^[76] Peer-reviewed meta-analyses of dozens of studies affirm the reliability of this link, countering narratives minimizing it due to ideological preferences in some academic circles.^[77] In females, tomboyish traits similarly predict lesbian orientation more frequently than heterosexual outcomes.^[78] These findings underscore that gender nonconformity serves as an early marker for sexual orientation diversity, informing prognostic models in developmental psychology.^[59]

Comorbidities with Mental Health and Autism

Individuals exhibiting gender nonconformity display elevated rates of common mental health disorders, including generalized anxiety and depressive symptoms, with meta-analytic evidence indicating small to moderate correlations (r = 0.06 for anxiety; r = 0.11 for depression) in population-based samples.^[79] Systematic reviews of transgender and gender non-conforming (TGNC) populations report substantially higher lifetime prevalences of psychiatric comorbidities, such as mood disorders (up to 50-70% in some cohorts), anxiety disorders (40-60%), and substance use issues, exceeding general population rates by factors of 2-5.^[80]^[81] These patterns persist across studies, though attributions to external "minority stress" predominate in the literature; however, longitudinal data suggest that pre-existing internalizing disorders often precede overt gender nonconformity, implying potential causal contributions from underlying psychopathology rather than solely societal factors.^[82]^[83] Comorbidity with autism spectrum disorder (ASD) is notably elevated among those with gender nonconformity or related incongruence. A 2022 meta-analysis estimated the pooled prevalence of ASD diagnoses in gender dysphoric or incongruent individuals at 11%, representing a 3- to 10-fold increase over general population rates (approximately 1-2%).^[43]^[84] Population studies confirm bidirectional associations: ASD traits correlate with gender nonconforming behaviors, such as atypical play patterns in children, and gender-diverse adults show higher autistic trait scores, particularly among those assigned female at birth or identifying as non-binary.^[85]^[44] This overlap may stem from shared neurodevelopmental factors, including difficulties in social cognition and rigid thinking patterns that could manifest as intensified gender-related fixations, though diagnostic overlaps complicate prevalence estimates and raise questions about over-identification in clinical settings.^[86]^[42] Youth with co-occurring gender nonconformity and ASD face compounded mental health risks, including heightened anxiety, depression, and suicidality. A 2023 study of adolescents found that those with both conditions had significantly elevated rates of self-harm and eating disorders compared to either diagnosis alone, with odds ratios exceeding 2 for multiple outcomes.^[87] Peer-reviewed evidence underscores that autistic individuals with gender diversity experience more severe psychiatric comorbidities, such as bipolar disorder and insomnia, potentially due to amplified social and sensory challenges, though treatment outcomes remain understudied.^[88]^[89] Overall, these comorbidities highlight the need for differential diagnosis to distinguish neurodevelopmental influences from transient identity explorations.

Societal and Cultural Contexts

Historical Prevalence and Responses

Gender nonconformity, manifested as behaviors or identities diverging from sex-typical norms, appears sporadically in anthropological and historical records across pre-modern societies, typically as rare individuals occupying marginal or ritualistic roles rather than widespread phenomena. Anthropological reviews document instances spanning five millennia and six continents, often involving cross-dressing, adoption of opposite-sex roles, or third-gender categories, but these were not normative and frequently tied to spiritual or shamanistic functions. Quantitative prevalence data is scarce due to reliance on ethnographic accounts rather than population surveys, though such figures suggest low incidence, with gender-variant individuals comprising small minorities in documented tribes or communities.^[90] In indigenous cultures, examples include two-spirit individuals among over 150 Native American tribes at the time of European contact, who assumed mixed-gender roles in healing or warfare, and hijras in South Asia, referenced in ancient Hindu texts dating back over 2,000 years as a third gender involved in blessings or performances. Polynesian māhū and Indonesian Bugis recognized similar non-binary categories, often integrating them into social structures with specific duties, though these roles were exceptional and not indicative of broad societal gender fluidity. In ancient Mediterranean contexts, figures like the galli priests of Cybele engaged in ritual castration and cross-dressing, but such practices were cult-specific and not reflective of everyday prevalence. These cases highlight that historical gender nonconformity was often culturally framed as innate or supernatural traits in outliers, rather than fluid expressions encouraged across populations.^[91]^[92] Societal responses varied by cultural context, with acceptance in some non-Western traditions where gender variants held revered, albeit peripheral, statuses—such as two-spirit persons valued for mediating spiritual realms in Native American groups—contrasting with suppression elsewhere. In pre-colonial Africa and Asia, analogues to gender variance existed in ritual or kinship roles, but European colonialism often pathologized and dismantled these through legal bans, as with British criminalization of hijras under the 1871 Act. In Europe, responses were predominantly punitive; medieval Christian doctrines linked effeminacy or cross-dressing to sodomy or heresy, leading to ecclesiastical condemnations, while by the 19th century, over 30 U.S. cities enacted anti-cross-dressing ordinances between 1848 and 1900 to enforce binary norms amid industrialization.^[93]^[94] Historical evidence indicates that overt nonconformity elicited social controls to preserve sex-based divisions of labor and reproduction, with tolerance limited to functional niches; widespread affirmation was absent, and modern interpretations of these records as endorsing fluidity may reflect contemporary projections rather than empirical historical norms. In Abrahamic-influenced societies, scriptural prohibitions against cross-dressing—such as Deuteronomy 22:5 in the Hebrew Bible—reinforced institutional responses favoring conformity, contributing to underground or pathologized expressions until the 20th century.^[95]^[96] In recent decades, referrals to specialist gender identity clinics have surged dramatically, particularly among adolescents and young adults, with a marked shift toward natal females. In the United Kingdom, referrals to the Gender Identity Development Service (GIDS) increased from under 250 in 2010—predominantly boys under age 10—to over 2,500 by 2019, with 69% of new referrals being adolescent girls.^[97] Similar patterns emerged across Europe, where the number of children and adolescents referred to gender services rose sharply over the past 10-15 years, especially among those assigned female at birth post-puberty.^[98] In the US, self-reported transgender identification among youth aged 13-17 reached an estimated 3.3% (about 724,000 individuals) by 2022, compared to lower adult rates of 0.89% in 2023, reflecting a generational spike.^[99]^[100] These trends deviate from historical data, where gender dysphoria presentations were rarer and more evenly distributed by sex in childhood.^[101] This escalation has been linked to social and peer influences, including the rapid-onset gender dysphoria (ROGD) phenomenon, where sudden gender incongruence emerges in adolescence without prior childhood indicators. Parent surveys of 1,655 cases documented clusters of ROGD within friend groups and families, with 62.5% of affected youth having increased social media use prior to identity announcements and 86.7% belonging to friend groups where most members became transgender-identified.^[102] Peer-reviewed analyses describe this as a form of social contagion, involving reciprocal influences that amplify nonconforming expressions among vulnerable adolescents, particularly those with co-occurring mental health issues or autism spectrum traits.^[103] The UK's Cass Review (2024), an independent systematic evaluation, highlighted multifactorial causes for the youth surge, including potential roles for online communities and peer dynamics in Gen Z cohorts, while noting weak evidence for purely innate drivers amid the demographic inversion.^[104] Social media platforms have amplified these dynamics by facilitating exposure to gender fluidity narratives and identity exploration. Studies indicate that intensive online engagement correlates with higher rates of gender nonconformity reports among youth, potentially through algorithmic promotion of related content and virtual peer reinforcement.^[105] For instance, adolescents spending over three hours daily on social media showed elevated risks of internalizing nonconforming identities, intertwined with mental health vulnerabilities like anxiety and depression.^[106] UK primary care records confirm a fivefold rise in transgender notations from 2000 to 2018, peaking in ages 16-29, aligning temporally with widespread social media adoption and cultural shifts toward viewing gender as spectrum-based rather than binary.^[107] Critics of contagion hypotheses, often from advocacy-aligned sources, argue against causal links, but empirical parent and clinic data substantiate peer clustering beyond random variation.^[108]^[109] Broader societal influences, including educational policies and media portrayals, have normalized nonconformity, potentially lowering thresholds for self-identification. In England, gender dysphoria diagnoses among children climbed from 1 in 60,000 in 2011 to 1 in 1,200 by 2021, coinciding with school curricula emphasizing gender diversity and reduced gatekeeping for clinical access.^[110] However, this normalization has prompted scrutiny, as European health authorities in Finland, Sweden, and the UK have curtailed youth medical transitions due to insufficient evidence of long-term benefits and risks of iatrogenic harm from socially influenced presentations.^[104] While increased visibility offers support for innate cases, the disproportionate adolescent female trend—historically atypical—suggests contextual amplifiers over endogenous traits alone, urging caution against uncritical affirmation.^[101]^[103]

Interventions and Outcomes

Gender-Affirming Practices and Evidence

Gender-affirming practices refer to interventions intended to support an individual's alignment with their self-identified gender, particularly in cases of gender dysphoria linked to nonconformity. These include social transitions, such as adopting preferred names, pronouns, clothing, and social roles, often beginning in childhood or adolescence. Medical interventions encompass puberty suppression using gonadotropin-releasing hormone (GnRH) analogues, typically initiated at Tanner stage 2 (around ages 10-13), followed by cross-sex hormones (e.g., testosterone for females or estrogen plus anti-androgens for males) from around age 16, and, less commonly in youth, surgeries like mastectomy or genital reconstruction.^[111] These approaches are promoted by organizations like the World Professional Association for Transgender Health (WPATH), though guidelines have evolved amid evidentiary critiques.^[112] Evidence for social transition in youth is limited and inconsistent, with short-term studies suggesting possible reductions in dysphoria and improved mood, but lacking randomized controls and long-term follow-up; one review noted potential reinforcement of gender dysphoria persistence rather than resolution. Systematic evaluations, including those for the UK's Cass Review (2024), highlight that the overall evidence base for youth gender-affirming care is of low to very low quality, characterized by small samples, high bias risk, absence of placebo controls, and confounding factors like comorbid mental health issues.^[113] For puberty blockers, a 2024 BMJ systematic review of 12 studies (n=263 youth) found low-certainty evidence of no significant improvement in gender dysphoria, mental health, or psychosocial functioning after 12-36 months; 92% (95% CI 83-97%) progressed to cross-sex hormones, indicating limited "buying time" effect.^[111] Risks include decreased bone mineral density (up to 1-2 standard deviations below norms), potential fertility impairment, and unknown impacts on brain development and sexual function, with no high-quality data on reversibility.^[114] Cross-sex hormones show short-term evidence of reduced dysphoria in some adolescents, but long-term outcomes remain uncertain due to scant prospective studies; a NICE-commissioned review (2021, referenced in Cass) reported very low-quality evidence for mental health benefits, with risks including cardiovascular issues, thromboembolism, and infertility.^[113] Gender-affirming surgeries in youth are rare (e.g., none under age 13 in U.S. data from 2019), with reported regret rates around 1% in adult-inclusive meta-analyses, but these rely on short follow-up (median 2-5 years) and high loss to follow-up (up to 30-50%), underestimating long-term detransition; youth-specific data is even sparser, with median regret onset potentially 8 years post-surgery.^[115]^[116]^[117] In response to evidentiary gaps, several European countries have curtailed youth access: Finland's 2020 guidelines prioritized psychotherapy over medicalization for post-pubertal onset dysphoria due to insufficient evidence; Sweden's National Board of Health (2022) restricted hormones and blockers outside trials, citing risks outweighing unproven benefits; the UK, post-Cass Review, banned routine puberty blockers for under-18s in 2024, limiting to research protocols.^[118]^[119]^[120] These shifts reflect systematic reviews finding no clear net benefit over watchful waiting, especially given high natural desistance rates (60-90%) in pre-pubertal cohorts without intervention, though desistance data predates recent referral surges.^[121] Comorbidities like autism (prevalent in 15-20% of gender clinic youth) and mental health disorders often complicate outcomes, with affirming care not demonstrably superior to holistic treatment addressing underlying issues.

Desistance, Detransition, and Recovery Approaches

Desistance from gender dysphoria, particularly in childhood, is documented in multiple longitudinal studies of clinic-referred youth, with persistence rates into adulthood ranging from 2% to 39%, implying desistance in 61% to 98% of cases without medical interventions like puberty blockers or hormones.^[122]^[4] A 2021 follow-up of boys diagnosed with gender identity disorder in childhood found that 87.8% desisted by adolescence or adulthood, with most identifying as gay or bisexual rather than transgender.^[4] These rates are higher for non-clinic samples and those not socially transitioned early, as social affirmation appears to correlate with increased persistence; for instance, a 2022 study of socially transitioned youth reported only 7.3% retransitioning (detransitioning) after five years, suggesting lower desistance once affirmation begins.^[123] Critics of desistance data argue methodological flaws, such as including subthreshold cases, but reanalyses confirm substantial non-persistence even in strict cohorts.^[124]^[125] Detransition involves individuals halting or reversing gender-affirming medical or social changes, often citing unresolved comorbidities, trauma realization, or natural resolution of dysphoria.^[7] Reported rates vary due to limited long-term tracking and potential underreporting, with systematic reviews estimating 1% regret or detransition post-surgery, though broader surveys indicate 8-13% ever detransitioning and 10-30% discontinuing hormones.^[126]^[127] A 2024 German study of youth with gender dysphoria diagnoses found low diagnostic stability, with many later desisting or detransitioning after addressing mental health issues like depression and autism.^[7] In a Finnish clinic sample, detransition occurred in cases where underlying factors such as trauma or sexual orientation confusion were therapeutically explored rather than affirmed.^[128] The UK's 2024 Cass Review highlighted inadequate data on detransition but noted clinician reports of regret linked to inadequate pre-treatment psychological assessment, recommending improved follow-up to capture true rates.^[129] Non-affirmation recovery approaches prioritize exploratory psychotherapy and watchful waiting over immediate transition, focusing on comorbidities and developmental maturation to facilitate desistance. Watchful waiting, as practiced in some European clinics pre-2010s, involves monitoring gender incongruence without social or medical affirmation, yielding desistance outcomes consistent with historical data (up to 80-90% in aggregated studies).^[130]^[131] This contrasts with affirmation models, as early social transition correlates with persistence and potential iatrogenic effects.^[54] Exploratory therapy targets causal factors like autism (prevalent in 20-30% of gender dysphoric youth), trauma, or internalized homophobia, with case reports showing dysphoria resolution post-treatment; for example, a youth on puberty blockers desisted after 1.5 years via psychological support addressing family dynamics.^[132]^[133] The Cass Review endorsed holistic, non-directive assessments akin to watchful waiting for minors, citing weak evidence for affirmation's superiority and risks of medicalization locking in trajectories.^[134] Outcomes from such approaches emphasize reversibility and mental health integration, though randomized trials remain scarce due to ethical constraints.^[61]

Key Controversies and Debates

The rapid-onset gender dysphoria (ROGD) hypothesis, first articulated by Lisa Littman in a 2018 study published in PLOS One, describes a subset of adolescents and young adults who develop gender dysphoria suddenly during or after puberty, without a childhood history of cross-sex identification, often amid peer influence, social media exposure, and co-occurring mental health issues.^[108] Littman's analysis of 256 parent surveys—recruited from sites skeptical of youth transitions—revealed that 86.7% of respondents described their child's dysphoria as emerging rapidly, with 62.5% reporting friend groups where multiple members identified as transgender concurrently, and 86.7% noting increased online transgender content consumption prior to onset.^[108] The study, revised and republished in 2019 following methodological critiques, highlighted a predominance of natal females (82.8%) in this pattern, aligning with broader shifts in clinic demographics.^[135] Empirical support for social contagion elements draws from observed surges in youth gender dysphoria referrals, which cannot be fully attributed to reduced stigma or improved awareness alone. In the UK, referrals to the Gender Identity Development Service (GIDS) rose from 210 annually in 2011–2012 to over 5,000 by 2019–2020, with adolescent females comprising 76% of cases by 2019–2020, reversing prior patterns dominated by prepubertal males.^[136] Similarly, primary care records in England showed a 50-fold increase in gender dysphoria diagnoses among children and youth from 2011 to 2021, reaching a prevalence of 1 in 1,200 by 2021, concentrated in adolescents.^[137] The UK's Cass Review (2024), an independent evaluation of youth gender services, documented this "dramatic" rise—particularly among natal females—and noted clusters of cases within friend groups or schools, alongside high rates of comorbidities like autism (up to 20–35% in some cohorts) and mental health disorders, suggesting potential social and environmental amplifiers over purely endogenous causes. Parent reports in Littman's work indicated that 35% of cases involved friends coming out as transgender in close temporal proximity, with 20.2% describing outright mockery or social pressure from peers.^[108] The social contagion hypothesis extends ROGD by invoking mechanisms akin to those in eating disorders or self-harm, where peer imitation and online reinforcement propagate behaviors. Littman's findings showed 63.5% of parents perceiving peer influence as a factor, and 48.4% linking it to social media trends.^[108] A 2023 analysis of 1,655 parent reports corroborated these patterns, with sudden onsets in 70% of cases, female predominance (82%), and frequent exposure to transgender content online or via friends, lending further plausibility to contagion in non-traditional dysphoria presentations.^[138] Historical desistance rates—over 80% in pre-2010 cohorts followed into adulthood—contrast with recent youth profiles, where social factors may entrench identities less likely to resolve naturally, as evidenced by lower prepubertal histories (only 10.8% in Littman's sample reported childhood indicators).^[108]^[139] Critics, often from advocacy-aligned sources, argue ROGD lacks clinical validation and reflects parental bias, citing studies like a 2022 Pediatrics analysis of clinic data that found no excess female contagion. However, such counter-evidence relies on treatment-seeking samples potentially biased toward affirmative care seekers, undercounting undetected or unpresented cases, and overlooks parent-reported clusters absent from medical records.^[138] The hypothesis remains contested but gains traction from unexplained epidemiological shifts and parallels to documented contagions in youth mental health, urging caution in interventions for sudden-onset cases amid weak long-term outcome data.^[140]

Ethical and Empirical Critiques of Normalization

Critiques of normalizing gender nonconformity, particularly through social and medical affirmation models, center on empirical shortcomings in supporting long-term benefits and ethical concerns over potential harms to minors. The 2024 Cass Review, an independent systematic evaluation commissioned by the UK's National Health Service, concluded that the evidence base for pediatric gender-affirming interventions—such as puberty blockers and cross-sex hormones—is of low quality, with most studies failing methodological standards like proper controls or long-term follow-up. This review analyzed over 100 studies and found insufficient data to confirm that these interventions improve mental health outcomes or gender dysphoria persistence, while highlighting risks including reduced bone density, fertility impairment, and uncertain impacts on cognitive development. Similarly, a 2023 analysis in Current Sexual Health Reports emphasized that benefits of such treatments for adolescents remain highly uncertain, whereas harms to sexual function, reproduction, and overall health are well-documented.^[141] High desistance rates among children with gender dysphoria further undermine normalization efforts that prioritize early affirmation over watchful waiting or exploratory therapy. Longitudinal studies indicate that 61–98% of gender-incongruent children desist from dysphoria by adulthood without intervention, often aligning with their biological sex.^[54] For instance, a follow-up of boys referred for gender identity concerns in childhood showed desistance in the majority, with many developing non-heterosexual orientations but no persistent transgender identity.^[4] A German study of over 10,000 individuals diagnosed with gender dysphoria reported persistence rates as low as 27% in adolescent females, suggesting that rapid normalization may iatrogenically lock in identities that could otherwise resolve.^[7] Normalization models, by contrast, correlate with increased referral rates—particularly among adolescent females—potentially amplified by social influences, as evidenced by the exponential rise in cases post-2010 without corresponding etiological explanations.^[122] Ethically, normalization raises issues of informed consent and non-maleficence, as minors cannot fully comprehend irreversible consequences like sterilization or surgical complications. The Cass Review stressed that holistic assessments, including comorbidities such as autism (prevalent in up to 20–30% of gender clinic referrals) and mental health disorders, are often sidelined in affirmation-focused protocols, potentially exacerbating underlying distress rather than addressing root causes. ^[142] Critics argue this approach contravenes medical ethics by prioritizing ideological affirmation over evidence-based caution, with detransitioners reporting inadequate warnings of regret risks, estimated at 1–10% in limited studies but likely underreported due to loss to follow-up.^[117] A 2023 paper in Journal of Sex & Marital Therapy described an "iatrogenic harm cycle" wherein premature affirmation entrenches dysphoria, leading to escalated medical interventions despite weak prognostic evidence.^[143] Such practices, implemented without robust randomized trials, echo historical medical overreach, as seen in past unchecked treatments for conditions like lobotomies.^[143] Furthermore, normalization's empirical foundation falters when scrutinized against comparative outcomes: exploratory psychotherapy yields desistance comparable to historical rates without medical risks, whereas affirmation correlates with persistent mental health challenges post-transition.^[142] Ethically, this shifts burden onto society for lifelong healthcare costs and lost productivity, while sidelining family input in favor of clinician bias toward progression to medicalization—documented in clinic data showing 98% of youth on blockers advancing to hormones. Proponents of caution advocate for a "do no harm" paradigm, informed by first-principles evaluation of biological sex immutability and developmental plasticity, over uncritical acceptance of self-reported identities.^[104] These critiques, drawn from systematic reviews rather than anecdotal advocacy, underscore the need for rigorous, unbiased research to supplant current normalization paradigms.^[144]

References

[1]
Nonconforming Gender Expression and Associated Mental Distress ...
Sep 24, 2018 · Gender nonconformity describes when an individual's gender expression does not align with societal expectations of their gender (Table 1).
[2]
Gender non-conformity in childhood and adolescence and mental ...
Jul 5, 2023 · Gender non-conformity (GNC) describes the extent to which a person's behaviour, appearance and/or identity do not conform to culturally defined ...
[3]
Gender-Nonconforming Youth - an overview | ScienceDirect Topics
One large-scale study of children 6–10 years of age (Sandberg, Meyer Bahlburg, Ehrhardt, & Yager, 1993) found that approximately 23% of boys and 39% of girls ...
[4]
A Follow-Up Study of Boys With Gender Identity Disorder - PMC
Boys clinic-referred for gender identity concerns in childhood had a high rate of desistance and a high rate of a biphilic/androphilic sexual orientation.
[5]
Do children grow out of gender dysphoria? - Transgender Trend
On average 80% of children change their minds and do not continue into adulthood as transgender. Some of these studies are very old, the first being published ...
[6]
The Biological Basis of Gender Roles - Aporia Magazine
Sep 5, 2025 · Evolutionary psychology provides a biological framework for understanding sex-based differences in human behavior, drawing on insights from ...
[7]
The Gender Dysphoria Diagnosis in Young People Has a “Low ...
Jul 19, 2024 · Adolescent females aged 15–19 had the lowest persistence rate (27.3%), while young males aged 20–24 had the highest persistence rate (49.7%).
[8]
Evolved but Not Fixed: A Life History Account of Gender Roles and ...
Jul 22, 2019 · Our account maintains that gender relations are shaped by life history strategies that, on average, promote individuals' present or future reproductive success.
[9]
Neurobiology of gender identity and sexual orientation - PMC
Gender identity refers to a person's innermost concept of self as male, female or something else and can be the same or different from one's physical sex.Missing: nonconformity | Show results with:nonconformity
[10]
What Does Gender Nonconforming Mean? - Verywell Mind
Mar 26, 2024 · Gender nonconformity is simply not conforming to gender roles. In practice, it can mean things as simple as a woman wearing a tie or something ...
[11]
Gender Nonconformity and Minority Stress among Lesbian, Gay ...
Nov 6, 2020 · Gender nonconformity often consists of aspects of appearance, behaviors, or interests exhibited by an individual who identifies with one gender ...
[12]
Gender Dysphoria Diagnosis - American Psychiatric Association
The DSM–5 articulates explicitly that “gender non-conformity is not in itself a mental disorder.” The 5th edition also includes a separate “gender dysphoria in ...
[13]
Understanding Gender dysphoria and Gender Non-conformity
Nov 18, 2016 · This medical condition occurs when a child or adolescent experiences discomfort or distress, due to a mismatch between their biological sex and gender identity.
[14]
Understanding transgender people, gender identity and gender ...
Mar 9, 2023 · Transgender is an umbrella term for persons whose gender identity, gender expression or behavior does not conform to that typically associated with the sex to ...
[15]
Transgender and Gender Nonconforming Adolescent Care - NIH
Gender nonconformity describes an individual whose gender identity, role, or expression are not typical for individuals in a given assigned sex category. This ...
[16]
Socially assigned gender nonconformity: A brief measure for use in ...
One well-known example of this approach is the Bem Sex Role Inventory (BSRI), where individuals mark on a scale of 1 to 7 how well certain traits describe them.
[17]
Gender Nonconformity and Peer Victimization: Sex and Sexual ... - NIH
A significant gender nonconformity × biological sex interaction showed that biological sex moderated the relation between gender nonconformity and general peer ...<|control11|><|separator|>
[18]
[PDF] Childhood Gender-Role Nonconformity and Adult Psychopathology
Childhood gender nonconformity (CGNC) has been defined as a "natural variation of human gender expression" (Hidalgo, Kuhns, Kwon, Mustanski, & Garofalo, 2015, p ...<|separator|>
[19]
Transgender History, Part I: An Anthropology of Gender‐Nonconformity Across Ages and Cultures
**Summary of Gender-Nonconforming Behavior from Ancient Civilizations and Non-Western Cultures:**
[20]
Third Gender Figures in the Ancient Near East
Sep 1, 2016 · Gala & kalǔ Simply working as a professional lamenter categorized him as feminine because laments were typically performed by women. During the ...
[21]
[PDF] Hijras and South Asian Historiography - Wiley
Since the 1990s, scholars of South Asia have framed the hijra community in a variety of ways, for instance, as a third gender, a transgender group, ...
[22]
[PDF] transgender and intersex in antiquity: differences in ancient
Meanwhile, Greek religion displays a greater level of comfort with ambiguous gender, particularly demonstrated in the Greek proclivity for ritual transvestism.
[23]
What Can the Samoan "Fa'afafine" Teach Us about the Western ...
Aug 7, 2025 · In Samoan culture, fa'afafine are recognized as being distinct from the categories "boy/man" and "girl/woman." Their identity as fa'afafine is ...
[24]
Birth order and recalled childhood gender nonconformity in Samoan ...
Mar 6, 2017 · Although fa'afafine reported significantly more CGN than Samoan men, CGN did not mediate the FBO effect, nor did the FBO effect and CGN interact ...Missing: anthropological | Show results with:anthropological
[25]
The 'two-spirit' people of indigenous North Americans - The Guardian
Oct 11, 2010 · Most of the evidence for respectful two-spirit traditions is focused on the native peoples of the Plains, the Great Lakes, the Southwest, and ...
[26]
Debunking the Two-Spirit Myth - OBJECT NOW
Jul 17, 2020 · 'Two-spirit' was a new term deliberately created at a 1990 native American lesbian and gay gathering in Canada, mainly to replace an old, colonial, homophobic ...
[27]
The Genetics of Sex Differences in Brain and Behavior - PMC
This paper reviews the evidence for direct genetic effects in behavioral and brain sex differences.
[28]
Prenatal androgen exposure alters girls' responses to information ...
Feb 19, 2016 · These findings suggest that prenatal androgen exposure may influence subsequent gender-related behaviours, including object (toy) choices.
[29]
Prenatal testosterone and gender-related behaviour - PubMed - NIH
Prenatal exposure to high levels of testosterone has a substantial influence on sex-typical play behaviour, including sex-typed toy preferences.
[30]
Prenatal testosterone and sexually differentiated childhood play ...
Jan 17, 2022 · The magnitude of the sex difference for play behaviours appears to be particularly large for toy preferences, which is also larger than the size ...
[31]
Sex differences in the human brain: a roadmap for more careful ...
Jul 26, 2022 · While some studies argue there is little to no evidence for notable, consistent sex differences in human brain structure [1, 6, 7], others ...
[32]
Dump the “dimorphism”: Comprehensive synthesis of human brain ...
Males' brains are larger than females' from birth, stabilizing around 11 % in adults. This size difference accounts for other reproducible findings.
[33]
Gender differences in personality: a meta-analysis - PubMed
Males were found to be more assertive and had slightly higher self-esteem than females. Females were higher than males in extraversion, anxiety, trust, and, ...
[34]
Sex differences in sensation-seeking: a meta-analysis - Nature
Aug 30, 2013 · Men score higher than women on measures of sensation-seeking, defined as a willingness to engage in novel or intense activities.<|separator|>
[35]
a meta-analysis of sex differences in interests - PubMed
Results showed that men prefer working with things and women prefer working with people, producing a large effect size (d = 0.93) on the Things-People ...
[36]
(PDF) Men and Things, Women and People: A Meta-Analysis of Sex ...
Men showed stronger Realistic (d = 0.84) and Investigative (d = 0.26) interests, and women showed stronger Artistic (d = −0.35), Social (d = −0.68), and ...
[37]
Evolved gender differences in mate preferences - ScienceDirect.com
Evolutionary theorists have posited that contemporary men and women may differ in their specific psychological mechanisms having to do with mate selection ...
[38]
Evolved but Not Fixed: A Life History Account of Gender Roles and ...
Jul 23, 2019 · While different evolutionary psychology theories differ in their emphasis on various processes of sexual selection (e.g., male-male competition ...
[39]
Sex and Care: The Evolutionary Psychological Explanations for Sex ...
Apr 16, 2019 · The present article elucidates sex differences in terms of formal care occupational choices and care styles based on evolutionary psychological perspectives.
[40]
Prenatal androgen exposure and sex-typical play behaviour
These meta-analytic findings suggest that prenatal androgen exposure masculinises and defeminises play behaviour in humans.
[41]
Sex differences in cognition: A meta-analysis of variance ratios in ...
A meta-analytic approach was used to explore sex differences in within-sex variation across different versions of the Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children ...
[42]
Associations between autism, gender dysphoria and gender ...
A recent meta-analysis showed that the pooled prevalence of ASD among people with gender dysphoria or gender incongruence is 11 % (Kallitsounaki and Williams, ...
[43]
Autism Spectrum Disorder and Gender Dysphoria/Incongruence. A ...
May 20, 2022 · ... autism spectrum disorder (ASD) and gender dysphoria ... ASD traits in children or in mothers predicted high gender nonconformity in children.
[44]
Full article: Autism traits in transgender and gender-diverse adults ...
Jul 11, 2024 · The odds of being autistic are estimated to be 3-6.4 times greater for TGD individuals as compared to cisgender individuals (Warrier et al., ...Autism Traits · Tgd Vs. Cisgender Adults · Nonbinary Vs. Binary...
[45]
Gender dysphoria and autism spectrum disorder: A narrative review
The current literature shows growing evidence of a link between gender dysphoria (GD) and autism spectrum disorder (ASD).
[46]
Psychological Functioning, Parenting Stress, and Parental Support ...
Higher levels of gender nonconformity were associated with more attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) hyperactive–impulsive type and conduct disorder ...<|control11|><|separator|>
[47]
Mental Health of Transgender and Gender Nonconforming Youth ...
... anxiety, depression, and attention deficit disorders compared with their cisgender counterparts. ... Although the natural history of gender nonconformity ...
[48]
Uncovering associations between gender nonconformity ...
Sep 18, 2023 · The prevalence of gender nonconforming behavior may vary depending on study settings (Zucker, 2017), but past reports suggest that the ...
[49]
Childhood Gender Nonconformity and Recalled Perceived Parental ...
The association between gender nonconformity and psychopathology may be due to experiences of stigmatization during development. That is, negative childhood ...
[50]
Biological sex classification with structural MRI data shows ... - Nature
Apr 9, 2020 · Transgender individuals (TIs) show brain-structural alterations that differ from their biological sex as well as their perceived gender.
[51]
Structural, Functional, and Metabolic Brain Differences as a Function ...
May 6, 2021 · This review systematically explored structural, functional, and metabolic features of the cisgender brain compared with the transgender brain before hormonal ...
[52]
Childhood and Adolescence Gender Role Nonconformity and ... - NIH
Sep 25, 2023 · Approximately 5% to 15% of adolescents are sexuality diverse, and 0.5% to 2% are transgender or gender diverse, with wide variance due to ...
[53]
Common Genetic Effects of Gender Atypical Behavior in Childhood ...
Quantitative genetic analyses showed that variation in both childhood gender atypical behavior and adult sexual orientation was partly due to genetics.Missing: outcomes | Show results with:outcomes
[54]
Early Social Gender Transition in Children is Associated with High ...
May 6, 2022 · Of note, the 61%-98% (or the 85%) historic desistance statistic has been critiqued as inflated, by those who noted that some of the children ...
[55]
Full article: Childhood gender-typed behaviour, sexual orientation ...
Childhood gender nonconformity (CGN) refers to the behaviour exhibited by children who do not follow the social norms expected of their assigned sex at birth.Missing: expressions | Show results with:expressions<|separator|>
[56]
Iatrogenic Gender Dysphoria and Harm Cycle in Gender Affirming ...
Mar 27, 2025 · In follow-ups conducted five years after affirmation and social transition, the rate of desistance was only 6%, with 94% continuing to live as ...
[57]
Exploring Desistance in Transgender and Gender Expansive Youth ...
A critical commentary on follow-up studies and “desistance” theories about transgender and gender-nonconforming children. Int J Transgend. 2018;19:212–224 ...
[58]
Transgender children and young people: how the evidence can ...
Marked gender-atypical behaviour occurs in around 2–3% of the population, most of whom are not transgender. Further, many children who show gender dysphoria ...
[59]
Stability and Change in Gender Identity and Sexual Orientation ...
Jul 15, 2025 · We offer the first detailed longitudinal description of stability and change in gender identity in a large cohort of youths who socially ...
[60]
Factors Associated With Desistence and Persistence of Childhood ...
We found a link between the intensity of GD in childhood and persistence of GD, as well as a higher probability of persistence among natal girls.
[61]
Gender Dysphoria in Children - American College of Pediatricians
This means that 5 percent to 20 percent will persist in their GD as young adults.<|separator|>
[62]
Development of Gender Non-Contentedness During Adolescence ...
Feb 27, 2024 · We studied the development of gender non-contentedness, ie, unhappiness with being the gender aligned with one's sex, from early adolescence to young adulthood.
[63]
Gender Identity Disorders in Childhood and Adolescence - NIH
Multiple longitudinal studies provide evidence that gender-atypical behavior in childhood often leads to a homosexual orientation in adulthood, but only in ...
[64]
Gender nonconformity and common mental health problems: A meta ...
Gender nonconformity had stronger links to generalized anxiety symptoms, depressive symptoms, and self-esteem in men than in women.
[65]
Childhood gender atypicality, victimization, and PTSD ... - PubMed
Youth who were considered gender atypical in childhood reported more victimization and more current mental health symptoms. PTSD was found in 9% of youth ...
[66]
[PDF] A multidimensional exploration of gender nonconformity and gender ...
Gender nonconformity refers to a condition where an individual's gender expression or identity does not align with societal expectations associated with ...
[67]
The Social Costs of Gender Nonconformity for Transgender Adults
The results suggest that gender nonconforming trans people face more discrimination and, in turn, are more likely to engage in health‐harming behaviors than ...
[68]
The roles of non-heterosexuality outside of identity and gender non ...
Gender non-conformity in appearance is associated with higher AL for women, but lower for men, regardless of their sexual orientation. •. Heterosexual women ...
[69]
[PDF] gender nonconformity, psychosocial stressors, and psychopathology ...
Within sexual minority populations, gender nonconforming individuals report disproportionately more discrimination and animosity from peers than their gender ...
[70]
https://www.liebertpub.com/doi/10.1089/lgbt.2023.0203
[71]
Childhood gender nonconformity and the stability of self-reported ...
The prevalence of boys and girls who reported being gay/lesbian increased from 15.5 to 21 years old whereas the proportion of bisexuals was relatively stable ...
[72]
Gender Role Nonconformity and Gender and Sexual Diversity in ...
Sep 25, 2023 · In this cohort study, ASEBA gender role nonconformity was associated with diverse sexual orientation, beginning in early childhood.
[73]
(PDF) Sexual Orientation and Childhood Gender Nonconformity
Oct 9, 2025 · Prehomosexual children were judged more gender nonconforming, on average, than preheterosexual children, and this pattern obtained for both men and women.
[74]
Maternally rated childhood gender nonconformity in homosexuals ...
Within the homosexual samples, maternal and self-ratings of subjects' childhood gender nonconformity failed to correlate significantly.
[75]
Childhood gender non‐conformity, sexual orientation and mental ...
May 9, 2023 · Same-sex oriented individuals considerably more often report childhood gender non-conformity than heterosexual peers, and it has been suggested ...
[76]
A short review of biological research on the development of sexual ...
(2019) also found that FBOE was most likely to predict gender nonconformity in homosexual men. Overall, the authors concluded that their analysis supported ...
[77]
Is There a Causal Link Between Childhood Gender Nonconformity ...
A meta-analysis of 48 studies with sample sizes ranging from 34 to 8,751 confirmed that gay men and lesbians were more likely to recall gender-nonconforming ...Missing: percentage | Show results with:percentage
[78]
Associations with Recalled Childhood Sex-Typed Behavior and ...
Apr 24, 2025 · Same-sex attracted individuals report greater levels of sex-atypical childhood behaviors and adulthood occupational preferences when ...
[79]
Gender nonconformity and common mental health problems - PubMed
Sep 7, 2024 · We found that higher levels of gender nonconformity were associated with higher levels of generalized anxiety (r = 0.06) and depressive symptoms (r = 0.11).Missing: comorbidities systematic
[80]
A 2020 Review of Mental Health Comorbidity in Gender Dysphoric ...
Mar 8, 2021 · The purpose of this paper has been to investigate the prevalence of psychiatric disorders in gender dysphoric and gender non-conforming people.
[81]
A 2020 Review of Mental Health Comorbidity in Gender Dysphoric ...
The purpose of this paper has been to invesgate the prevalence of psychiatric disorders in gender dysphoric and gender non-conforming people.
[82]
A systematic review of social stress and mental health among ...
A systematic review of social stress and mental health among transgender and gender non-conforming people in the United States ... Comorbidity of gender dysphoria ...
[83]
The mental health of transgender and gender non-conforming ...
Zhao, M ∙ Xiao, D ∙ Wang, W ∙ et al. Association of sexual minority status, gender nonconformity with childhood victimization and adulthood depressive symptoms: ...
[84]
Gender Diversity, Gender Dysphoria/Incongruence, and the ...
Dec 4, 2024 · In other words, rates of autism diagnoses may be 3.03–10 times more common in gender-diverse samples compared to the general population (de ...<|separator|>
[85]
Gender-specific play behavior in relation to autistic traits and ...
Aug 28, 2024 · This study suggests a link between gender nonconforming play behavior and autistic traits as well as behavioral difficulties among children in a non-clinical ...
[86]
Autism Spectrum Disorder and Gender Dysphoria/Incongruence. A ...
The suggested overlap between autism spectrum disorder (ASD) and gender dysphoria/incongruence (GD/GI) has been much disputed. This review showed a relationship ...<|separator|>
[87]
Mental Health of Youth With Autism Spectrum Disorder and Gender ...
Nov 1, 2023 · The purpose of this study was to examine associations between ASD, GD, and MH diagnoses (anxiety, depression, eating disorder, suicidality, and self-harm)
[88]
The prevalence of coexisting mental health conditions in gender ...
Specifically, gender diverse individuals have been found to have a greater prevalence of anxiety, depression and suicide (Cheung et al., 2018, Wiepjes et al., ...
[89]
Autism spectrum disorder and gender dysphoria among adolescents ...
Oct 16, 2025 · These studies found a positive relationship between ASD and GD, but more research is needed across different populations (Corbett et al., 2023).
[90]
An Anthropology of Gender-Nonconformity Across Ages and Cultures
This review examines anthropological and historical records of trans, non-binary, and gender-nonconforming behavior spanning six continents and five millennia.
[91]
Exploring the history of gender expression - UCOP Link
Oct 14, 2019 · In this article, we'll explore cultures from around the world in which the boundaries between male and female gender expressions have been fluid ...Missing: peer- reviewed
[92]
Two Spirit and LGBTQ+ Identities: Today and Centuries Ago - HRC
Nov 23, 2020 · Research shows that more than 150 different pre-colonial Native American tribes acknowledged third genders in their communities.Missing: anthropological modern
[93]
A Map of Gender-Diverse Cultures | Independent Lens - PBS
On nearly every continent, and for all of recorded history, thriving cultures have recognized, revered, and integrated more than two genders.Missing: prevalence | Show results with:prevalence
[94]
'Gender hegemony': How colonialism distorted African perspectives ...
Mar 31, 2022 · The anthropological and historical records show clear examples of analogues to queer identity that existed in African society before colonialism.Missing: variance | Show results with:variance
[95]
[PDF] Sartorial Representations of Trans Men in the Post-Frontier West
Jun 12, 2023 · According to noted gender and dress historian Clare Sears, between 1848 and 1900, 34 cities in 24 states passed anti-cross dressing laws.19 ...
[96]
[PDF] Dressing and Gender Transgression in America 1850-1880
Apr 30, 2010 · Between 1850 and 1880, Americans obsessed over cross-dressing women. Many women donned the breeches: ruined young daughters of respectable ...Missing: rates | Show results with:rates
[97]
'An explosion': what is behind the rise in girls questioning their ...
Nov 24, 2022 · According to a study commissioned by NHS England, 10 years ago there were just under 250 referrals, most of them boys, to the Gender Identity ...
[98]
Gender services for children and adolescents across the EU-15+ ...
Background Over the last 10-15 years, there has been an increase in the number of children and adolescents referred to gender services, particularly among ...
[99]
How Many Adults and Youth Identify as Transgender in the United ...
Among youth aged 13 to 17 in the U.S., 3.3% (about 724,000 youth) identify as transgender. Of the 2.1 million adults who identify as transgender, 32.7% (698,500) ...
[100]
Transgender identity: How much has it increased? - Generation Tech
Sep 11, 2024 · Among all adults, identifying as transgender increased from .53% (5 out of 1,000) in 2014 to .89% (9 out of 1,000) in 2023. That's a 68% ...
[101]
Demographics of referrals to a specialist gender identity service in ...
Sep 12, 2023 · Trends in clinical referrals to specialist gender services historically comprised more assigned male at birth young people. In the last ...
[102]
Rapid Onset Gender Dysphoria: Parent Reports on 1655 Possible ...
Mar 29, 2023 · One influential if controversial explanation is that the increase reflects a socially contagious syndrome: Rapid Onset Gender Dysphoria (ROGD).
[103]
Gender dysphoria in adolescence: examining the rapid-onset ... - NIH
Rapid-onset gender dysphoria and social contagion Dishion and Tipsord [63] define “peer contagion” as a process of reciprocal influence among peers that ...
[104]
The Final Cass Review and the NHS England Response - SEGM
Apr 11, 2024 · The report acknowledged the likely multi-factorial basis for the current explosion of gender-dysphoric youth, with a focus on “Gen Z” and the ...
[105]
Analysis of Social Media Use, Mental Health, and Gender Identity ...
Jul 24, 2023 · This cross-sectional study examines the association between social media use and mental health among transgender, gender nonbinary, and cisgender youths in the ...
[106]
Researchers explain social media's role in rapidly shifting social ...
May 29, 2024 · A new paper by UC Santa Cruz psychologists describes how social media has supported an explosion of diversity in gender and sexuality in America ...
[107]
Transgender identity in young people and adults recorded in UK ...
Nov 28, 2023 · The rate of transgender identity recorded in primary care records has increased fivefold from 2000 to 2018 and is highest in the 16-17 and 18-29 age groups.
[108]
Parent reports of adolescents and young adults perceived to show ...
The purpose of this study was to collect data about parents' observations, experiences, and perspectives about their adolescent and young adult (AYA) children ...<|separator|>
[109]
Study finds no evidence of social contagion among transgender ...
Aug 3, 2022 · Study finds no evidence of social contagion among transgender youths | AAP News | American Academy of Pediatrics.
[110]
Gender dysphoria diagnoses among children in England rise ...
Jan 24, 2025 · Study of GP records finds prevalence rose from one in 60000 in 2011 to one in 1200 in 2021 – but numbers still low overall.
[111]
Puberty blockers for gender dysphoria in youth: A systematic review ...
Within a range of 12–36 months, 92% of individuals who received puberty blockers progressed to receiving gender affirming hormone therapy (proportion 0.92 (95% ...<|separator|>
[112]
[PDF] WPATH AND USPATH COMMENT ON THE CASS REVIEW
May 17, 2024 · The review took place after concerns arose around the increase in referrals, the evidence base for gender-affirming medical care, and the ...
[113]
New Systematic Reviews of Puberty Blockers and Cross-Sex ...
Mar 31, 2021 · Its major finding is that GnRH agonists lead to little or no change in gender dysphoria, mental health, body image and psychosocial functioning.
[114]
Puberty blockers for gender dysphoric youth: A lack of sound science
Sep 15, 2022 · Even less is known about the use of GnRH-analogs to halt normally timed puberty in youth with gender dysphoria; no long-term, longitudinal ...
[115]
Gender-affirming surgeries rarely performed on transgender youth
Jul 8, 2024 · The study found no gender-affirming surgeries performed on TGD youth ages 12 and younger in 2019. This was expected, the researchers said, as ...Missing: regret | Show results with:regret
[116]
Regret after Gender-affirmation Surgery: A Systematic Review and ...
Mar 19, 2021 · The pooled prevalence of regret after GAS was 1% (95% CI <1%–2%). Overall, 33% underwent transmasculine procedures and 67% transfemenine ...
[117]
Accurate transition regret and detransition rates are unknown - SEGM
Sep 11, 2023 · The median time for surgical regret has been reported to be as much as 8 years. Somewhat shorter average times (3-6 years) to detransition have ...
[118]
European Academy of Paediatrics statement on the clinical ... - NIH
Feb 5, 2024 · Several European countries, led by the UK, have recently reviewed the management of gender dysphoria in children and young people. Recognising ...
[119]
Youth Gender Medications Limited in England, Part of Big Shift in ...
Apr 9, 2024 · In 2020, Finland's health agency restricted the care by recommending psychotherapy as the primary treatment for adolescents with gender ...
[120]
Proper guidelines are needed for young people with gender ...
Sep 24, 2025 · In 2020, Finnish health authorities concluded that the evidence base for 'gender-affirming' medical treatment for minors is insufficient (39).
[121]
Denmark Joins the List of Countries That Have Sharply Restricted ...
Aug 17, 2023 · In Finland and Sweden, youth with post-puberal onset of gender dysphoria are not typically considered to be candidates for medical transition ...
[122]
False Assumptions Behind Youth Gender Transitions - SEGM
Dec 30, 2022 · Further, the high rate of childhood desistance from gender dysphoria before maturity, (61-98%) and growing evidence of desistance among youth ...
[123]
Gender Identity 5 Years After Social Transition | Pediatrics
Jul 13, 2022 · We found that an average of 5 years after their initial social transition, 7.3% of youth had retransitioned at least once.
[124]
A critical commentary on “A critical commentary on follow-up studies ...
The authors claim in the very beginning of their paper that the 80% desistence rate of gender dysphoria (GD) is a number that is largely drawn on estimates ...
[125]
The myth of persistence: Response to “A critical commentary on ...
Aug 7, 2025 · Furthermore, evidence suggesting a significant rate of desistance among children 1 with gender dysphoria complicates the ethical landscape.
[126]
What percentage of people who undergo gender transition either ...
Jun 29, 2025 · The percentage of people who regret their gender transition or detransition is approximately 1%, as reported in a systematic review and meta-analysis of ...
[127]
Detransition Among Transgender and Gender-Diverse People—An ...
This study found that the 4-year gender-affirming hormone continuation rate was 70.2% with 81% for the transfeminine group and 64% for the transmasculine group.
[128]
An Analysis of Nine Patients from a Gender Identity Clinic from Finland
May 20, 2025 · The detransition rate was 6.9% in a recent UK study (Hall et al., 2021) where 12 detransitioners were found among 175 patients in a GIC. An even ...
[129]
The Cass Review Into Gender Identity Services for Children - Part 4
May 10, 2024 · The Cass review refers to regret and detransition in many places, but focuses specifically on detransition about halfway through in section 15.
[130]
What Went Wrong at the Tavistock Clinic for Trans Teenagers? | SEGM
Jun 17, 2022 · Known as “watchful waiting”, this approach acknowledged some children with gender dysphoria would later live as trans adults, while the vast ...
[131]
Desistance Is Possible - Parents Of Desisters
In 11 longitudinal studies, on average 80% of children did not persist with a transgender identity into adulthood. The Detransition Rate is Unknown: Some people ...
[132]
the need for thorough assessment and treatment of gender ... - NIH
The profile of referrals has also undergone a major transformation: we have seen a reversal of the gender ratio from two-thirds male:female to two thirds female ...Missing: therapy outcomes
[133]
Desisting from gender dysphoria after 1,5 years of puberty ...
This case report illustrates that after treatment with puberty blockers desistance from gender dysphoria can occur.<|separator|>
[134]
The Cass Review Final Report (UK), 2024
May 29, 2024 · Cross-sex hormones “lack of high-quality research assessing outcomes.” “No conclusions can be drawn about the effect on gender dysphoria, body ...
[135]
Parent reports of adolescents and young adults perceived to show ...
Mar 19, 2019 · This study of parent observations and interpretations serves to develop the hypotheses that rapid-onset gender dysphoria is a phenomenon and ...
[136]
Factors shaping gender incongruence and gender dysphoria, and ...
Aug 2, 2023 · Referrals to specialist child and adolescent gender identity health services increased from 210 per year for 2011-12 to over 5,000 per year ...
[137]
Epidemiology of gender dysphoria and gender incongruence in ...
Jan 24, 2025 · There was a 50-fold increase in recorded prevalence of gender dysphoria/incongruence in children and young people in primary care in England ...
[138]
Study of 1,655 Cases Supports the "Rapid-Onset Gender Dysphoria ...
Mar 30, 2023 · A new study examining 1655 parental reports lends further credibility to the rapid-onset gender dysphoria (ROGD) hypothesis, first posited ...
[139]
Revisiting the “Age of Realization and Disclosure of Gender Identity ...
Dec 18, 2023 · “Rapid-onset gender dysphoria” (ROGD) describes a presentation in a recent cohort of adolescent and young adults who first became gender ...
[140]
First Do No Harm | The BMJ
Mar 10, 2022 · Evidence against includes the transient nature of gender dysphoria in the majority of individuals, the apparent element of social contagion in ...
[141]
Current Concerns About Gender-Affirming Therapy in Adolescents
Apr 14, 2023 · While the evidence of benefits is highly uncertain, the harms to sexual and reproductive functions are certain, and many uncertainties about the ...<|control11|><|separator|>
[142]
Gender dysphoria: Reconsidering ethical and iatrogenic factors in ...
Nov 9, 2023 · The independent Cass review 5 confirmed the limited evidence base for gender affirming care, concerns with systematic and protocol issues as ...
[143]
Iatrogenic Harm in Gender Medicine - Taylor & Francis Online
Jun 19, 2023 · Past accounts of iatrogenic harm illustrate the need for vigilant scrutiny of prevailing medical dogma (Genius, 2006) and when evidence emerges ...
[144]
Full article: The Cass Review; Distinguishing Fact from Fiction
Jun 6, 2025 · Most authors agree that gender incongruence and dysphoria arise through a complex interplay of biopsychosocial and cultural factors (de Vries ...<|separator|>