Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Geoff Barrow

Geoffrey Paul Barrow (born 9 December 1971) is an English , , DJ, and best known as a founding member of the band Portishead. With vocalist and guitarist , Barrow co-formed Portishead in during the early 1990s, pioneering the trip-hop genre through their integration of electronic beats, samples, and noir-inspired aesthetics on albums such as Dummy (1994) and Portishead (1997). Beyond Portishead, Barrow has led the instrumental rock outfit , blending rhythms with atmospheric improvisation across multiple albums since 2009, and co-helmed the hip-hop project , which features beats produced under the alias Fuzzface for various MCs. He has also composed film scores in collaboration with , including soundtracks for directors like , contributing to works such as Ex Machina (2014) and Annihilation (2018).

Early Life and Influences

Childhood and Entry into Music

Geoffrey Paul Barrow was born on 9 December 1971 in Walton-in-Gordano, , . Following his parents' divorce at age eleven, he relocated with his mother to the coastal town of Portishead, near , where he developed an early interest in music amid the region's evolving sound system culture and influences. After playing bass in local bands during his teenage years, Barrow entered the professional music scene in 1989 as a tape operator at Bristol's newly opened Coach House Studios, starting from tea-boy duties and progressing through hands-on assistance on recording sessions. At Coach House, Barrow gained practical experience in studio operations while supporting projects by emerging Bristol acts, including assisting on Massive Attack's debut album Blue Lines in 1991. This period marked his initial forays into , where he self-taught techniques such as sampling and vinyl manipulation through experimentation during off-hours. By the early , these skills led to his first credited contributions, co-producing and co-writing tracks like "Somedays" and "Move with Me" for Neneh Cherry's album Homebrew, released in October 1992.

Key Influences and Formative Experiences

Barrow's engagement with began in his mid-teens, catalyzed by hearing Afrika Bambaataa's "Planet Rock" in 1982, which immersed him in the genre's foundations and crew culture. This evolved into a transformative encounter with Public Enemy's at a club around 1987, where the track's aggressive sampling and rhythmic density prompted Barrow to abandon rock pursuits for 's production rigor, applying chopped loops and layered percussion to forge the sparse, ominous beats central to his style. He credited producers like and for techniques that prioritized sonic "wrongness" over polish, enabling tense atmospheres through deliberate imperfections rather than seamless integration. Krautrock exerted a parallel pull, with Can emerging as Barrow's "perfect band" after discovering their 1972 track "" in 1991, which aligned with his shift toward repetitive motifs that accumulate emotional weight without relying on verse-chorus conventions or scales. This influence manifested in hypnotic, motorik-driven patterns that sustained unease, as Barrow drew from Can's avoidance of traditional songwriting to experiment with cyclical builds, fostering the droning textures that distinguish his output from contemporaneous . Film scores from the 1970s and 1980s, notably John Carpenter's minimalist synth compositions for Assault on Precinct 13 (1976), shaped Barrow's approach to tension via restraint, where sparse pulses and analog timbres evoke isolation without excess. He has directly linked Carpenter's functional simplicity—eschewing melodic flourishes for rhythmic propulsion—to his own preference for "degraded" signals and economical arrangements that heighten psychological strain, as seen in early production choices prioritizing efficacy over elaboration. The Bristol underground, steeped in post-punk's DIY imperatives and dub's echo-laden experimentation, reinforced Barrow's formative rejection of studio gloss in favor of raw, self-reliant methods amid the city's ethos. Hip-hop nights at venues like Studio club exposed him to unmediated sound systems, cultivating a causal emphasis on tactile, imperfect recording that mirrored the scene's punk-rooted autonomy over industry norms. This environment, blending radicalism with local soundsystem culture, directed his techniques toward atmospheric immersion derived from live, lo-fi capture rather than contrived perfection.

Career with Portishead

Formation and Debut Album (Dummy, 1994)

Portishead formed in Bristol, England, in 1991 when Geoff Barrow and Beth Gibbons met at an Enterprise Allowance Scheme course organized by the local unemployment office. Barrow, who had previously worked as a tea boy and junior tape operator on Massive Attack's Blue Lines album, began producing instrumental demo tapes inspired by hip-hop and film soundtracks. These demos featured looped samples and scratches, drawing Gibbons—who had a background in soul and jazz vocals—to contribute lyrics and singing, initially forming a core duo focused on atmospheric, downtempo compositions. To expand the sound, Barrow recruited session guitarist and saxophonist Adrian Utley in 1993, whose contributions added live instrumentation like distorted guitar tones and theremin effects to the mix. The band's debut album, , was recorded analog at Bristol's Coach House Studios using vintage equipment to avoid digital sterility, emphasizing hip-hop-derived techniques such as vinyl scratching by Barrow, looped drum breaks, and samples from 1960s and 1970s soundtracks for a noir-like tension. Tracks like "Mysterons" incorporated for eerie swells, while "Sour Times" blended Gibbons' emotive vocals over pilfered basslines and turntable manipulations, creating a signature "trip-hop" aesthetic rooted in Bristol's culture but distinguished by its cinematic melancholy. Released on August 22, 1994, by Go! Beat Records, the album comprised 11 tracks clocking in at 49 minutes, with Barrow handling primary production alongside Utley. Dummy achieved immediate commercial success, selling over 2.7 million copies worldwide by aggregating physical and digital units, driven by word-of-mouth and radio play of singles like "." It won the in 1995, selected from nominees including and , which boosted sales to over 825,000 certified units by 1996. This empirical performance, alongside critical acclaim for its innovative sampling and emotional depth, positioned Dummy as a foundational work in trip-hop, influencing subsequent acts through its verifiable market impact rather than stylistic labels alone.

Subsequent Albums and Live Performances

![Barrow performing with Portishead in 2011](./assets/Geoff_Barrow_-Portishead-Roskilde_Festival_2011cropped Following the release of their self-titled second studio album in 1997, Portishead issued on November 2, 1998, a live recording captured on July 24, 1997, at the in . The album featured expanded arrangements with a full band including strings and brass, diverging from the sparse, sample-heavy minimalism of by incorporating orchestral elements to suit live performance dynamics. Portishead's third studio album, Third, emerged after an 11-year gap from their previous studio effort, released on April 28, 2008, in the UK and April 29 in the US. Self-produced by the band and recorded across locations including Geoff Barrow's State of Art Studios in and Adrian Utley's home setup, the album marked a stylistic shift toward darker, more abrasive soundscapes, integrating influences such as vocal harmonies and improvisation. Barrow handled programming, mixing, and multi-instrumental contributions, emphasizing experimental production techniques over the trip-hop foundations of prior works. The prolonged intervals between releases stemmed from the band's perfectionism and creative dissatisfaction; Barrow has cited a loss of inspiration post-1997, leading to a hiatus where he pursued independent projects before recommitting to . Label pressures and internal debates further delayed output, as the trio prioritized artistic integrity over commercial timelines. Live performances remained infrequent, reflecting Barrow's strong aversion to extensive touring, which he has described as something he "absolutely hates." A notable return occurred in 2008, including a headline slot on Festival's Pyramid Stage on June 28, supporting the rollout of Third with tracks like "Magic Doors" debuted live during that period. Subsequent shows, such as at in 2011, underscored their selective approach, limiting tours to short bursts amid ongoing reluctance to overcommit to the road.

Critical Reception and Awards

Portishead's debut album Dummy (1994) garnered critical acclaim for its pioneering fusion of hip-hop sampling, noir aesthetics, and melancholic electronica, establishing the band as trip-hop innovators. Reviewers praised its unsettling emotional depth and atmospheric production, with Pitchfork noting its "coppery and bitter" tone that avoids comfort in favor of raw unease. The album's success culminated in winning the 1995 Mercury Prize, selected over competitors including PJ Harvey's To Bring You My Love and Oasis's Definitely Maybe. It also earned a nomination for Best British Newcomer at the 1995 Brit Awards. Later albums faced mixed responses, balancing innovation with critiques of inaccessibility. Third (2008), after an 11-year gap from Portishead (1997), was lauded for its bleaker, krautrock-influenced intensity and re-debut feel, as per Pitchfork's assessment of its darker lyrical territory. However, some outlets criticized its abrasiveness, lack of groove, and disjointed flow, with The Daily Nebraskan arguing it abandoned the band's signature cohesion for unflowing tracks. The protracted intervals between releases—spanning over a decade for Third—drew commentary on self-indulgence, as Classic Pop observed that Portishead's legacy owes more to imitators than their sparse catalog. Portishead's influence manifests empirically through samples and covers by artists in electronic and alternative genres, though direct emulation often highlights the originals' unreplicable tension. Third secured the Rober Awards Music Prize for Album of the Year in 2008, affirming its experimental merits amid polarized views.

Invada Records and Independent Ventures

Founding and Key Releases

Invada Records was established in 2002 by Geoff Barrow, Ashley Anderson, and Fraser Stuart, with initial operations in Australia before shifting primary focus to Bristol, United Kingdom, where Barrow resides and draws from the local music scene. The label serves as Barrow's independent outlet for championing experimental, underground, and "outsider" artists, prioritizing creative freedom over commercial viability from its inception. Label activities emphasize physical media, particularly limited-edition vinyl pressings that appeal to dedicated listeners and collectors, reflecting a commitment to tangible formats amid digital dominance. Key releases include Beak>'s self-titled debut album in October , recorded under strict constraints of improvisation and minimal production, and subsequent Beak> records like >> in 2012, alongside the Quakers' debut The Quakers in 2012, which showcased collaborative hip-hop and electronic explorations. These outputs highlight Invada's role in incubating Barrow-associated projects and aligned niche acts without mainstream distribution pressures initially. Invada's operational model eschews rigid profitability structures, instead fostering artist control and open-minded curation of non-conventional music, as described by label manager Redg in , enabling through selective releases rather than volume-driven . This approach has sustained the label into the , evidenced by ongoing output and a 2025 worldwide distribution agreement with Secretly Distribution, which expands accessibility while preserving autonomy.

Expansion into Film Production

In 2025, Geoff Barrow expanded Invada Records into production and distribution by launching Invada Films, a dedicated imprint aimed at developing and releasing independent cinematic projects, including those incorporating soundtracks from the label's roster. This pivot allowed Barrow to exert greater creative control over narrative-driven works, leveraging his experience in film scoring to integrate music more deeply into production processes. Invada Films' inaugural project, , marked Barrow's entry as a co-writer and of a feature-length film. Directed by John Minton, the thriller is set in the British rave scene of late summer 1993, following characters who steal a stash of money and drugs, leading to escalating paranoia, betrayal, and violence. Barrow co-wrote the screenplay with Rob Williams and produced alongside Deborah Rawlings, with the cast including Marc Bessant in the lead role and Jason Williamson of . The film wrapped production in early 2025 and premiered at the Mayhem Film Festival in on October 16, 2025, before a theatrical rollout in UK and cinemas starting November 21, 2025. The venture emphasizes , UK-centric , bypassing major studios in favor of localized distribution and festival circuits to maintain artistic . While Invada secured a global music distribution partnership with Secretly Distribution in March 2025, Invada Films operates as a self-contained entity focused on selective releases tied to Barrow's compositional output, without announced ties to larger film distributors like A24. This approach aligns with Barrow's history of prioritizing experimental, non-commercial projects over mainstream industry norms.

Other Musical Projects and Collaborations

Beak> and Experimental Work

Beak> (stylized with a greater-than symbol) is an trio formed in January 2009 by Geoff Barrow on drums and vocals, Billy Fuller on bass and vocals, and Matt Williams on keyboards. The band operates under self-imposed guidelines emphasizing analogue equipment, no overdubs, and recording entire albums in single takes to capture raw improvisation, drawing heavily from krautrock's repetitive, rhythms and hypnotic structures akin to Neu! and Can. Their debut self-titled album, Beak>, was improvised and recorded over 12 days in rural , released on October 26, 2009, via Barrow's Invada Records in collaboration with Templex Popping. Subsequent releases continued this ethos of and propulsion. The second album, >>, issued June 4, 2012, on Invada, features tracks like "Yatton" and "" built around pulsing basslines and analogue synth drones, eschewing digital production for a gritty, live-band feel. The third, >>>, arrived November 16, 2018, maintaining sparse arrangements with Barrow's drumming driving extended jams that evoke krautrock's endurance-testing repetition. Their fourth, >>>>, released May 24, 2024, on Invada and , incorporates woozy and relentless beats, recorded live to tape in Barrow's studio amid reflections on persisting outside mainstream industry norms. Beak>'s live performances embody , with sets often diverging from recordings through on-stage tempo shifts and extended explorations, prioritizing analogue fidelity over polished execution. This approach sustained the band through European and North American tours, but Barrow announced his departure on September 27, 2024, after nearly 16 years, attributing it to exhaustion from touring's demands; the group's final shows with him included a U.S. and run from March 22 to April 2025, culminating in . The band plans to continue without him, preserving its core experimental principles.

Quakers and Additional Productions

In 2009, Geoff Barrow co-founded the collective under the production alias Fuzzface, alongside producers 7-Stu-7 and Katalyst (later Supa K). The group, centered on Bristol's underground scene, assembled beats drawing from , , and samples to underpin contributions from over 35 rappers, including veterans like Guilty Simpson and MED. Their self-titled debut album, recorded over four years and released on March 27, 2012, via , featured 14 tracks emphasizing raw, sample-heavy production over polished pop aesthetics. A companion instrumental disc highlighted the producers' focus on beat construction, with Barrow's contributions showcasing his expertise in looped percussion and atmospheric textures derived from vinyl sources. Quakers released a follow-up, II - The Next Wave, in 2020, maintaining the collective's emphasis on expansive, collaborative with a 50-track beat tape companion, Supa K: Heavy Tremors, underscoring Barrow's preference for instrumental rooted in styles rather than mainstream trends. The project's output reflects Barrow's broader production ethos, prioritizing underground acts and experimental remixing over commercial ventures, with credits spanning remixes for Primal Scream's "Give Out But Don't Give Up" (1994) and Depeche Mode's "In Your Room" (1994 Jeep Rock Mix). Beyond , Barrow's production work in the 2000s and 2010s included full albums like ' Primary Colours (2009), where he applied Portishead-influenced layering to elements, and early remixes for acts such as and , demonstrating his skill in recontextualizing samples for darker, introspective tones. His logs dozens of such credits, consistently favoring niche electronic and alternative artists over pop mainstream, as evidenced by contributions to projects like remixes in 2017. This selective approach underscores a commitment to sonic experimentation grounded in analog techniques and crate-digging, avoiding industry pressures for broader appeal.

Guest Appearances and Remixes

Barrow contributed production and beats to the hip-hop collective, formed in collaboration with Australian producer Katalyst (Supa K) and engineer 7STU7, releasing a self-titled album in April 2012 on featuring 41 tracks from over 35 MCs including , , , Guilty Simpson, and M.E.D.. Operating under the alias Fuzzface, Barrow supplied raw beats uploaded to for rappers to record over, emphasizing organic, non-commercial crossovers with electronic undertones rather than polished industry standards. A follow-up, Quakers II: The Next Wave, emerged in 2021, with Barrow as executive producer alongside Katalyst and 7STU7, maintaining the collective's decentralized approach to beat-making and MC features. In remixing, Barrow altered source material by incorporating dissonant textures and trip-hop rhythms, extending his production style to alternative and hip-hop acts. Notable examples include his 2015 remix of ' "Close Your Eyes and Meow to Fluff," which layered abrasive electronics over the original's aggressive beats, and the 2018 Geoff Barrow Mix of Arcade Fire's "Comfort My ," infusing reggae-inflected with Portishead-esque atmospheric tension. These efforts aligned with Barrow's preference for experimental, non-mainstream interventions, avoiding tie-ins with major commercial campaigns as expressed in interviews on his production philosophy.

Film Scoring Contributions

Partnership with Ben Salisbury

Geoff Barrow and established their creative partnership in 2012 with the release of Drokk: Music Inspired by Mega-City One, an electronic album drawing from the Judge Dredd universe, marking Barrow's initial foray into collaborative composition beyond his Portishead work. This laid the groundwork for their film scoring duo, which Barrow approached as a self-taught process rooted in synthesizers, samples, and electronic experimentation, influenced by synth pioneers like and . Their method emphasized modular setups and analog gear to generate evolving textures, shifting Barrow from album-oriented production to time-synced cues that underscore narrative tension without overpowering visuals. Salisbury's established background in television and documentary composition, including Emmy nominations for projects like : Life Is But a Dream (2013), provided structural rigor that balanced Barrow's improvisational instincts, enabling a seamless transition for Barrow into film work. Barrow has highlighted how Salisbury's orchestration knowledge and experience with orchestral elements helped adapt his electronic palette to cinematic demands, fostering a workflow where they layer sparse, dialogue-responsive motifs—often minimalist pulses and drones—to heighten unease rather than dictate emotion. This duality allowed their scores to prioritize causal sonic realism, integrating sound design elements that evolve organically with scene progression. Their partnership thrives on complementary strengths: Barrow's raw, sample-driven paired with Salisbury's refined skills, resulting in cues that embed subtly within mixes for immersive effect. This approach reflects a deliberate pivot from standalone music releases to functional scoring, where Barrow credits the collaboration for honing his ability to compose under directorial constraints while retaining experimental edges.

Notable Scores and Techniques

Barrow and Salisbury's score for (2014), directed by , utilized minimalist synths and samples to underscore the film's exploration of deception and human vulnerability. Pulsing electronic motifs, derived from processed organic sounds, mirrored the escalating tension in human-android interactions, creating a deceptive auditory facade that aligned with the narrative's themes of manipulation. This approach prioritized sonic restraint, with sparse arrangements that amplified psychological unease without relying on conventional orchestral cues. For (2018), also directed by Garland, the duo crafted a haunting soundscape blending orchestral strings, synth layers, and manipulated effects—including distorted vocals and intricate —to evoke the alien Shimmer's transformative dread. These elements drove narrative progression by sonically representing and existential , with subtle builds that causally heightened immersion in the characters' deteriorating perceptions rather than overpowering the visuals with bombast. The score's experimental integration of human-like and otherworldly timbres distinguished it from traditional sci-fi scoring. Pitchfork ranked Annihilation's score 26th in its 2019 list of the 50 best movie scores, highlighting Barrow and Salisbury's cryptic, sample-infused style as emblematic of modern that favors atmospheric over emotive excess. Their techniques consistently emphasized auditory —where motifs propel plot-driven tension—evident in both films' avoidance of bombast in favor of modular, reusable sonic fragments that evolve with the story's causal logic.

Controversies and Industry Disputes

Sampling Conflicts with The Weeknd and Ye

In July 2013, Geoff Barrow publicly criticized for sampling the drum pattern from Portishead's ""—a track from the band's 2008 album Third—in the song "" from the album , without obtaining clearance. Barrow expressed his disapproval via , highlighting the unauthorized use despite the evident similarity in the beats. initially denied employing a sample, asserting the elements were original and not sufficiently similar to warrant permission. In May 2014, Barrow escalated the matter by posting online a copy of a formal clearance request letter from 's team, dated prior to the track's release, which had been denied by Portishead, thereby contradicting the denial and underscoring the lack of approval. The dispute resurfaced in public discourse in early 2023, with Barrow reiterating his frustration over the incident amid discussions of The Weeknd's career milestones, reflecting persistent resentment toward the handling of in such cases. Barrow has maintained that creators deserve control over their compositions, rejecting claims of mere "inspiration" as inadequate justification for direct replication without consent, a stance that challenges prevalent norms in and electronic music production where sampling is often treated as transformative . In August 2024, Barrow similarly condemned (formerly ) and Ty Dolla $ign for incorporating an uncleared sample of "" into the outro of "" on their collaborative album Vultures 2, released on August 3. Barrow tweeted "FFS Not Again" upon discovering the usage, labeling it a blatant infringement akin to the prior case and emphasizing the absence of any permission request or approval process. This incident reinforced Barrow's advocacy for rigorous sample clearance protocols, positioning unauthorized borrowing as a violation of artists' rights rather than a permissible cultural exchange, particularly when high-profile releases amplify the original without compensation or credit negotiation.

Views on Music Industry Practices

Barrow has critiqued the hype surrounding electronic genres like dubstep, stating in a 2009 interview that he was "most probably too old for it," as its impact depended heavily on club sound systems rather than transcending those environments. This stance aligns with his preference for analogue methods, including low-volume recordings with vintage instruments and BEAK>'s self-imposed rules against overdubs to capture organic live performances. He has resisted digital trends in favor of anti-produced sounds, viewing them as more authentic than polished, trend-driven outputs. Regarding touring, Barrow has highlighted its toll, with Portishead expressing division over it before their 2008 European dates and him taking a three-year break after the 1998 tour due to exhaustion. For BEAK>, he noted that festival appearances forced playing anticipated "bangers," undermining the band's foundational rejection of audience expectations and leading to a loss of identity. Portishead's infrequent live shows stem from this wariness of over-promotion, prioritizing quality over constant visibility. Barrow favors a DIY model via Invada Records, established in 2003, which enables full creative autonomy without major label interference, a path he intensified after Portishead's 2008 album Third. He has described this freedom as "utterly brilliant," contrasting it with industry pressures for radio-friendly conformity, such as avoiding simplistic marketing pitches to outlets like " Radio." In practice, he released BEAK>'s 2024 album >>>> without conventional promotion, simply making it available to fans. He has also criticized streaming economics, tweeting in 2015 that 34 million plays generated just £1,700 after tax, underscoring inadequate compensation in digital platforms. Addressing implicitly, Barrow embraces maturity in 2024 reflections, stating of BEAK>, "We’re old! We don’t give a ," rejecting youth-oriented industry norms for sustained, self-directed output. This control-oriented strategy, over chasing virality, has underpinned his three-decade career trajectory.

Legacy and Recent Developments

Impact on Trip-Hop and Electronic Music

Portishead's Dummy (1994), with Geoff Barrow as primary producer, codified key empirical markers of trip-hop through downtempo beats looped from hip-hop breaks, layered with vinyl crackle, theremin-like effects, and Beth Gibbons' brooding, melancholic vocals evoking noir isolation. Barrow's sampling of obscure 1960s-1970s spy and jazz-funk records, such as Lalo Schifrin cues in "Sour Times," fused causal rhythmic drive from East Coast rap with electronic melancholy, distinguishing it from contemporaneous Bristol sounds like Massive Attack's dub-infused grooves. This approach yielded verifiable genre hallmarks: sub-90 BPM tempos, heavy reverb on sparse instrumentation, and vocal delivery prioritizing emotional timbre over melody, as replicated in subsequent downtempo productions. Barrow's techniques influenced electronic subgenres like hauntology, where archival sampling evokes spectral futures-past; Dummy's grainy, looped nostalgia for mid-century media presaged this by repurposing forgotten library music into haunted atmospheres, impacting artists via shared production aesthetics rather than direct stylistic mimicry. Evidence includes Glory Box's interpolation in hip-hop tracks by uicideboy and Flatbush Zombies, extending Barrow's hip-hop-derived beats into modern trap-electronica hybrids, while broader sampling logs confirm Portishead elements in dozens of releases across rap and IDM. These causal chains—beat excavation to atmospheric layering—trace to Barrow's "hip-hop tuning" philosophy, prioritizing raw, detuned authenticity over polished electronica. Barrow has repeatedly dismissed the trip-hop designation as media-imposed nonsense that diluted their punk-adjacent aggression into perceived chillout passivity, arguing it stemmed from journalists equating Bristol's scene with easy categorization rather than innovative sonic warfare. This pigeonholing, per Barrow, constrained recognition of 's experimental edge—e.g., live instrumentation amid samples—fostering a legacy more of stylistic imitation than boundary-pushing evolution. Yet sustained causal impact persists in 2020s electronic revivals, where melancholy informs synth-driven acts drawing on Barrow's vintage gear ethos for textured, non-digital warmth.

Retirement from Beak> and Future Outlook

In September 2024, Geoff Barrow announced his retirement from , the krautrock-influenced trio he co-founded in 2009, effective after the band's ongoing 2024 UK and European tour dates and a final North American tour scheduled for early 2025. This departure concludes nearly 16 years of collaboration marked by the band's signature improvisational live sets and four studio albums. The farewell US tour, detailed in an October 2024 announcement, begins March 22, 2025, in and includes stops in major cities such as , , and before ending in on April 5, 2025, positioning it as Barrow's with the group. Beak>'s remaining members stated that new music and activities would proceed "when the time is right," signaling a shift toward a less frequent release schedule prioritizing quality over volume. Barrow's post-Beak> focus appears directed toward production, film scoring, and expanding Invada Records, the independent label he co-owns, which in March 2025 secured a global distribution partnership with Secretly Distribution to broaden its artist roster and archival catalog availability. No dissolution of Portishead has been confirmed, with Barrow's interviews indicating openness to selective collaborations rather than routine band commitments. This outlook underscores a deliberate curation of projects, avoiding overextension in an industry Barrow has critiqued for its pressures.