Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Phoenix Television

Phoenix Television Holdings Limited is a Hong Kong-headquartered broadcaster specializing in Mandarin- and Cantonese-language programming, including news, entertainment, and cultural content targeted at global Chinese-speaking audiences. Founded in 1996 by Liu Changle, a former journalist, the network began as a satellite television provider and has expanded into an omni-media group encompassing multiple channels, online platforms like ifeng.com, and overseas bureaus in over 50 cities. The company's operations include flagship channels such as Phoenix InfoNews Channel for 24-hour news and Phoenix Hong Kong Channel, a Cantonese-language service launched in 2011 to cover local and regional affairs. It has received recognition for contributions to Asian television, including the International Emmy Directorate Award in 2008 and multiple listings among Asia's most influential brands. However, since 2021, state-owned Bauhinia Culture Holdings—linked to China's —has become its largest shareholder, shifting control toward and prompting criticisms of serving as a vehicle for state narratives. This ownership structure has led to notable controversies, including Taiwan's 2022 decision to revoke Phoenix TV's broadcasting license, citing effective control by the through investments from state entities. Operating from , the network maintains a degree of autonomy compared to mainland outlets but has faced accusations of aligning with official positions, particularly on sensitive political issues, amid Beijing's tightening influence over media post-2019 national security law.

History

Founding and Initial Launch (1996–2000)

Phoenix Satellite Television Holdings Limited was established on 31 March 1996 by , a former with ties to , through his controlled entity Today's Asia Limited (93.3% owned by him), in partnership with Asian Region Limited (a subsidiary via ) and China Wise International Limited (a Hong Kong-registered firm linked to interests). This joint venture structure reflected an early blend of international capital and governmental alignment, enabling satellite broadcasting approvals in despite foreign ownership restrictions. The founding aimed to deliver Mandarin-language content to communities, emphasizing cultural connection over adversarial Western media narratives prevalent in other outlets like the . The inaugural Phoenix Chinese Channel launched on the same date, replacing the prior and transmitting via to audiences in , , , and , with initial programming focused on , entertainment, and variety shows produced in Hong Kong studios. Broadcasts prioritized high-quality Chinese-language material, including imported films and local productions, to foster unity among viewers amid post-handover uncertainties in Hong Kong. By late 1996, the channel had secured landing rights in , reaching an estimated 300 million potential viewers through rebroadcast agreements, though actual penetration depended on access in regulated areas like . In August 1998, Phoenix expanded with the Movies Channel, debuting on 28 August as mainland China's first pay-TV movie service, featuring a mix of imports, Chinese blockbusters, and thematic blocks to appeal to urban subscribers via encrypted signals. This addition diversified revenue through subscriptions and advertising, targeting affluent households in restricted media environments. Operations during this period relied on as the base for content creation and transmission, navigating geopolitical tensions by aligning editorial tones with Beijing's preferences to maintain access. The company achieved public listing on the Stock Exchange's Growth Enterprise Market in June 2000, raising capital amid Asia's economic recovery and marking a in its shift toward commercial scalability while retaining foundational partnerships. By 2000, Phoenix operated two channels with growing viewership in expatriate hubs, though financial reports highlighted challenges from and with state broadcasters.

Growth and Expansion (2001–2010)

In early 2001, Phoenix Satellite Television significantly broadened its offerings by launching two new channels targeted at distinct audiences. On January 1, the Phoenix InfoNews Channel debuted as a 24-hour Mandarin-language service focused on international news, financial updates, and analysis, marking the company's first dedicated all-news outlet. Simultaneously, the Phoenix North America Chinese Channel commenced broadcasting on the same date, establishing a U.S.-based near to deliver localized content, including news, dramas, and talk shows, via satellite providers such as and , thereby extending reach to communities in the . These launches represented a strategic pivot toward specialized programming and markets, building on the core Phoenix Chinese Channel established in 1996. Throughout the mid-2000s, Phoenix continued infrastructural and geographic expansion to support growing operations. In 2006, the company inaugurated a new headquarters in , Hong Kong's , enhancing production capabilities for its expanding . This period also saw increased retransmission agreements in , where regulatory approvals allowed broader cable distribution, contributing to audience growth amid rising demand for Chinese-language media. Business reports from the era highlighted reinforced access to Chinese viewers, with operating expansions tied to and satellite infrastructure investments. By the late 2000s, further international tailoring emerged, including the September 2009 launch of the Channel Japan Edition, adapting content for Japanese cable and satellite audiences to capitalize on regional expatriate populations. Overall, these developments transformed from a single-channel broadcaster into a multinational entity with enhanced technical footprints, though growth was moderated by dependencies on regulatory environments and competition from . Annual filings noted steady revenue from and subscriptions, underscoring the viability of this expansion phase.

Recent Developments and Challenges (2011–Present)

In the 2010s, Phoenix Television underwent a progressive consolidation of ownership toward entities linked to the , reducing foreign influence from prior shareholders like , whose stake via was gradually divested. By 2018, principal shareholders included Beijing-connected firms such as China Wise International, reflecting a strategic alignment with mainland interests amid 's evolving political landscape. This shift coincided with operational challenges, including a 2016 broadcast of coerced confessions from detained booksellers, which drew international scrutiny for complicity in efforts. Financial pressures intensified during this period, with the broadcaster reporting persistent operating losses despite revenue from advertising and subscriptions; for instance, group-wide losses reached HK$245.3 million (approximately $31.4 million) in recent filings, attributed to declining traditional TV viewership amid digital competition and trends. Efforts to expand included a 2016 application for a license in , which raised alarms about potential mainland media encroachment but ultimately highlighted regulatory hurdles in a market wary of Beijing's influence. Internationally, Phoenix faced expulsion risks in , where authorities warned of delisting its services in 2022 over perceived pro-Beijing bias and failure to liberalize media investments for Chinese entities. The imposition of Hong Kong's National Security Law in June 2020 reshaped the media , benefiting as a pro-establishment outlet while independent voices diminished; it positioned itself as a counter to perceived "soft resistance" in local media, emphasizing balanced coverage aligned with central government narratives on events like the 2019 protests. Post-NSL, maintained operations with enhanced protocols common in the sector, yet encountered broader industry headwinds such as platform digitization and audience fragmentation. By 2025, initiatives included partnerships like the Financial New Frontiers Cooperation with the Treasury Bureau and celebrations of milestones, signaling adaptation through event-driven content and mainland-focused reporting.

Ownership and Governance

Ownership Structure and Evolution

Phoenix Television was founded on 31 October 1996 by Changle, a former political officer and journalist, who established it as Phoenix Satellite Television Company Limited with initial backing from international investors including (affiliated with Rupert Murdoch's ). retained significant control through personal holdings and related entities, while the company listed on the Stock Exchange's Growth Enterprise Market in June 2000 under Phoenix Satellite Television Holdings Limited (stock code 0823, later transferred to the main board as 2008). Early ownership featured gradual divestments by foreign stakeholders; News Corporation's stake, inherited by 21st Century Fox, was fully sold in October 2013 when Fox offloaded its remaining 12.15% interest to TPG Capital, reducing Western influence. Concurrently, state-linked entities increased their positions, with Communications Group Co., Ltd. accumulating approximately 19.68% and the of the holding 21% by the early 2010s, reflecting growing Beijing-aligned capital in the publicly traded structure. Changle personally controlled about 38.08% via investment vehicles like Today's as of 2021. A pivotal shift occurred in April 2021 when agreed to sell nearly his entire stake for HK$1.156 billion: 21% (1.05 billion shares) to Culture Holdings, a Beijing-based entity wholly owned by the state-controlled Publishing Group under the , and 16.93% to Ltd., a subsidiary of owned by (daughter of Macau casino magnate ). This deal, completed by June 2021, positioned Culture as the largest shareholder, amplifying direct governmental oversight, with no major subsequent alterations reported through 2025; state-backed holdings, including and prior PRC entities, now dominate the ownership pyramid. The company was renamed Phoenix Media Investment (Holdings) Limited in 2018 to reflect diversified assets beyond broadcasting.

Management and Key Executives

Xu Wei has served as Chairman and of Phoenix Media Investment (Holdings) Limited, the parent company of Phoenix Television, since June 22, 2021. In this role, Xu oversees strategic direction and operations, emphasizing the broadcaster's positioning in with a global outlook amid evolving media landscapes. Sun Yusheng acts as , , and , a position he has held since June 22, 2021. Sun, aged 64 as of 2025, leads editorial content and news operations, drawing on prior experience in . The management team includes Li Qi, appointed in May 2023, who manages day-to-day broadcasting and technical functions. Ka Keung Yeung serves as Director of Finance and , handling financial oversight at age 66.
PositionNameAppointment DateKey Responsibilities
Chairman and CEOJune 22, 2021Strategic leadership and operations
Deputy CEO and Editor-in-ChiefSun YushengJune 22, 2021Editorial and news direction
Chief Operating OfficerLi QiMay 2023Operational and technical management
CFOKa Keung YeungN/AFinancial management
The company was founded by Changle, who previously served as chairman and CEO before transitioning out of executive roles. Current reflects a shift toward executives with strong ties to media structures, influencing content alignment with Beijing's priorities.

Programming and Content

News and Programming

Phoenix Television's primary platform for news and current affairs is the Phoenix InfoNews Channel, a 24-hour Mandarin-language that debuted in January 2001 and delivers round-the-clock updates on international events, financial markets, and developments from a viewpoint. The emphasizes breaking news, press summaries, expert analysis, and live coverage of global summits, elections, and official briefings, utilizing feeds from wire services including , , , , and . It maintains bureaus worldwide and targets audiences across , , and beyond, with transmission via satellites such as AsiaSat 7 and 6B. Core news bulletins air frequently, including News on the Hour, broadcast 12 times daily for succinct global overviews, and specialized expresses like Phoenix Morning Express (weekdays 07:00–08:00), which integrates headlines, market analysis, and weather; The Midday Express (weekdays 12:00–12:25) for midday international and economic recaps; Phoenix Evening Express (weekdays 21:00–22:00, weekends 21:00–21:40) covering social, economic, and cultural stories; and Phoenix Midnight Express (Tuesday–Saturday 00:00–00:30) focusing on overnight developments from , the , and the . Weekend editions such as Weekend Morning News (Saturday–Sunday 07:00–07:27) prioritize and worldwide events. Current affairs segments extend to on-location reporting in Journalist on the Spot (Saturdays 15:30–16:00), drawing from over 40 international bureaus to highlight field experiences, and live formats like Live Focus, which logged 258 hours of unscripted broadcasts in 2015 alone for major events including press conferences from China's State Council and . Financial and specialized updates feature in programs such as Morning Financial News and Financial Journal, analyzing U.S., European, and Asian markets, while weather services like Phoenix Weather Forecast and Ocean Forecast (daily at 14:29 and 22:29) provide global and marine data integrated across bulletins. interruptions ensure immediate alerts on urgent international, social, or economic matters. These programs, anchored by journalists from , , and , underscore the channel's role in bridging official Chinese narratives with global sourcing, though coverage often aligns with Beijing's priorities as evidenced by landing rights secured in mainland China in January 2003.

Entertainment, Documentaries, and Other Formats

Phoenix Television produces and broadcasts content including dramas, shows, and films, primarily targeting Mandarin-speaking audiences in , , and communities through channels such as the Phoenix Chinese Channel and the Phoenix Movies Channel. Popular drama series and shows form a key part of the programming on the Phoenix North America Chinese Channel, alongside imported content adapted for cultural relevance. These formats emphasize themes appealing to diaspora viewers, such as family dynamics, historical epics, and light-hearted competitions. The network's documentaries often focus on Chinese cultural heritage, regional stories, and social issues with a positive emphasis on resilience and national identity. The 2022 character-driven series My Hong Kong Story weaves personal anecdotes from residents to capture diverse life experiences in the city. In 2023, Hong Kong Nature Stories launched to highlight the region's through nonprofit initiatives. More recently, the December 2024 documentary series profiled four influential women from ancient —such as Empress —examining their legacies in terms of reputation, endurance, and early notions of gender roles. Ecological and conservation themes feature prominently in standalone films like Never Too Late, which premiered on April 12, 2025, at the 49th and follows four individuals demonstrating personal impacts on human-nature relations. Other recent productions include Walking Homeland and Hong Kong Story, distributed via platforms like Video, which explore overlooked cultural and natural sites in to evoke local pride. Short-form entertainment series, such as the five-episode , debuted on in recent years as a nostalgic reflection on Hong Kong's prosperous eras, produced in collaboration with local entities. Overall, non-news formats complement the network's informational output, with content often sourced from in-house production or partnerships to maintain appeal amid regulatory constraints in broadcast markets.

Operations and Technical Infrastructure

Broadcasting Platforms and Technology

Phoenix Television relies on transmission as its core broadcasting platform to deliver - and Cantonese-language content to global audiences, enabling wide coverage across , the , , and . Its primary channels, such as Phoenix InfoNews Channel and Phoenix Chinese Channel, are distributed via direct-to-home (DTH) services, which facilitate feeds for and programming to over 500 million viewers worldwide. integration supplements reach, with entry into major systems in , , and overseas markets like the (via providers including , Time Warner, and ) and (via and pay-TV). In addition to traditional platforms, Phoenix employs IPTV and digital pay-TV networks for expanded distribution, including KyLin TV in and in , covering regions from major U.S. cities like and to European countries via Sky Digital. The network has pursued (DTT) capabilities, applying for a license in in 2016 to enable over-the-air alongside existing cable and satellite options. Technologically, it integrates encoding systems for internal monitoring and content preparation, supporting transitions to digital formats, while leveraging cloud infrastructure like for video storage, processing, and on-demand access. Streaming and mobile technologies form a key component of its omni-media strategy, with online platforms such as ifeng.com offering live and archived content, alongside dedicated mobile applications for and devices. These digital extensions enable and multi-device compatibility, enhancing accessibility for communities in areas like , , and . Overall, this multi-platform approach combines satellite's broad footprint with cable's reliability and internet-based delivery for targeted, high-definition programming.

Studios and Global News Operations

Phoenix Television's primary studio facilities are centered at its headquarters in the Industrial Estate, , , which serves as the core hub for production and broadcasting operations. This four-story complex, spanning 40,000 square meters and opened in 2009, houses advanced studios, production suites, and executive offices designed for high-volume Mandarin and Cantonese-language content creation. The facility supports multiple channels, including live broadcasts and international programming, with infrastructure enabling seamless integration of satellite feeds and digital workflows. In , Phoenix operates the Phoenix Center in Beijing's Chaoyang District, adjacent to Chaoyang Park, as a key multifunctional media production site covering 65,000 square meters for television studios, media communication, and exhibition spaces. Completed in 2014, this ring-shaped structure facilitates domestic news gathering and content production tailored for Chinese audiences, complementing operations with localized reporting capabilities. Additional facilities include head offices in , , supporting southern coverage, alongside correspondent offices in for eastern regional news. Globally, Phoenix maintains an extensive news operations network with approximately 60 offices and 63 correspondent stations worldwide, enabling comprehensive coverage for its InfoNews Channel and other outlets targeting communities. These bureaus, stationed across major cities in 60 nations, focus on events, economic developments, and diaspora-relevant stories, often relaying feeds to and studios for aggregation and analysis. A U.S. headquarters in , further bolsters North American operations, housing production and distribution for Western markets. This decentralized structure allows real-time global sourcing, though coordination remains centralized in to align with editorial priorities.

International Presence

Reach in Mainland China and Ties to Beijing

Phoenix Television's channels, including the Phoenix Chinese Channel and Phoenix InfoNews Channel, are distributed across via satellite, cable television, and IPTV services, enabling access for Mandarin- and Cantonese-speaking audiences. As of 2017, the network reached more than 150 million viewers in through these platforms. This distribution leverages regulatory allowances for Hong Kong-based broadcasters, allowing Phoenix to operate as a bridge between international content and domestic preferences while adhering to content guidelines set by authorities. The network's ties to Beijing are evident in its ownership structure, which includes significant stakes held by Chinese state entities. State-owned Culture Holdings became the largest shareholder in June 2021 after acquiring shares from founder Liu Changle, enhancing 's influence over operations. Additionally, , a state-controlled telecommunications giant, holds approximately 19.7% of Phoenix's shares through its subsidiary. Liu Changle, a former political officer and early journalist, founded the company in 1996 and maintained close relations with , which facilitated deals aligning the broadcaster with state priorities. These connections have positioned Phoenix as a state-aligned outlet, often promoting narratives favorable to the Chinese government, such as unified and policy support, in contrast to more independent . Regulatory scrutiny in other regions, including Taiwan's 2022 ban citing Chinese ownership, underscores perceptions of Phoenix as an extension of Beijing's apparatus, though it continues unrestricted broadcasting in under government oversight.

Operations in Hong Kong, Taiwan, and Overseas Markets

Phoenix Television maintains its core operational hub in , where the company's occupies a four-story building covering square meters, which opened in 2009. Broadcast facilities, including news studios designed for flexible camera positioning and integrated production spaces, support the production of and programming from locations such as . These operations encompass channels like the Phoenix Hong Kong Channel, distributed via satellite platforms including AsiaSat 7. In , Phoenix Television conducted operations for approximately two decades, maintaining an office and employing 25 staff members focused on local news gathering and broadcasting. However, in April 2022, Taiwanese authorities designated the network as a Chinese-funded entity under regulations restricting mainland investment in media, prompting the closure of its office by May 14, 2022, and the layoff of all local employees. This decision reflected heightened scrutiny of Phoenix's ties to , overriding its prior status as a Hong Kong-based operator. Overseas markets form a key component of Phoenix's global reach, targeting Chinese diaspora communities through dedicated channels such as the Phoenix North America Chinese Channel and Phoenix Chinese Channel. The European Channel is accessible via major cable systems and IPTV in countries including the , , and others in and . The network maintains an international news bureau with correspondents stationed in over 60 countries, enabling coverage from major cities like and facilitating content distribution via satellites such as China Sat-6B. This infrastructure supports Mandarin-language programming to audiences in , , and , emphasizing news and cultural content for expatriate viewers.

Controversies

Allegations of Editorial Bias and Propaganda

Phoenix Television has been accused of exhibiting editorial bias favoring the (CCP), with critics alleging it functions as a vehicle for Beijing's narratives, particularly in its coverage of sensitive political issues such as Taiwan independence, , and pro-democracy movements. These claims stem from the broadcaster's ownership ties to individuals and entities aligned with the CCP, including a reported 10% stake held by state-owned (CCTV), which reportedly influences content alignment. Founder and former chairman Liu Changle, a native and ex-People's Liberation Army political officer who previously worked as a for CCP-controlled outlets, maintained close connections to senior party officials, including membership in the , prompting assertions that Phoenix prioritizes regime-friendly perspectives over independent journalism. Instances of alleged propaganda include Phoenix's broadcast of televised confessions from detained Hong Kong booksellers in 2015, which U.S. congressional testimony described as coerced statements aired to legitimize CCP detentions abroad. Critics, including U.S. Senator , have labeled the network a "puppet of the " for disseminating state-approved internationally, leading to the Communications Commission's rejection of a Phoenix-affiliated radio license application on June 22, 2020, citing risks from foreign influence. In 2021, Liu Changle sold his controlling stake to Chinese state-owned Bauhinia Media, further fueling perceptions of deepened CCP control and editorial alignment. Taiwan's government designated Phoenix as CCP-controlled in April 2022, mandating cessation of operations there due to biased reporting that echoed Beijing's positions on . Phoenix has also been faulted for to sustain access to markets, as detailed in a 2005 Congressional-Executive Commission on China report on Liu's imposed political restraints to secure broadcasting approvals, resulting in avoidance of topics critical of the CCP, such as the 1989 events or Uyghur detentions. During Hong Kong's 2019 pro-democracy protests, the network's coverage was criticized for framing demonstrators negatively while emphasizing Beijing's support for local authorities, consistent with patterns identified by as blending entertainment programming with subtle promotion of CCP viewpoints to target audiences. Former Phoenix news director Chung King-fai resigned in March 2020, publicly accusing the outlet of systemic pro-CCP bias and lack of journalistic independence, though Phoenix denied state control, attributing decisions to commercial necessities. These allegations have been echoed in reports from bodies like the U.S.-China Economic and Security Review Commission, which highlight Phoenix's role in broader CCP influence operations, including reaching 79.5 million U.S. households with favorable coverage as of 2017 data.

Regulatory Scrutiny and Broadcasting Restrictions

In April 2022, Taiwan's National Communications Commission designated Phoenix Television as a Chinese-funded enterprise, citing its ownership links to mainland state entities such as Satellite Communications, which violated Taiwan's Anti-Infiltration and broadcasting regulations prohibiting direct Chinese investment in local operations. This classification, effective immediately, barred Phoenix from continuing its and broadcasting activities in , where it had operated for over two decades, requiring cessation by May 14, 2022. Phoenix responded by announcing the closure of its Taipei office, resulting in the layoff of all 25 local employees and the withdrawal of its programming from Taiwanese cable and satellite platforms. Taiwanese authorities justified the action as a measure to protect independence from Beijing's influence, pointing to Phoenix's editorial alignment with narratives on issues like Taiwan's sovereignty, though Phoenix maintained it was a Hong Kong-based entity not subject to such controls. The decision aligned with Taiwan's post-2016 policy shifts under the to restrict pro-Beijing outlets amid rising cross-strait tensions and concerns. No similar formal broadcasting bans have been imposed elsewhere, though Phoenix has faced informal scrutiny in democratic markets over its perceived ties to Beijing; for instance, in , media regulators monitored Chinese-language broadcasters including Phoenix for foreign influence compliance under the Foreign Influence Transparency Scheme since 2018, without resulting in restrictions. In contrast, Phoenix retains broadcasting approvals in , where it complies with state requirements for satellite feeds, including content alignment with official positions, as granted under agreements with the . These Taiwan-specific restrictions highlight geopolitical sensitivities rather than universal regulatory violations, with Phoenix continuing operations in and select overseas markets without equivalent disruptions.

Financial Performance and Business Model

Revenue Sources and Economic Challenges

Phoenix Satellite Television Holdings Limited derives its primary revenue from television broadcasting, which encompasses advertising, subscription fees, and ancillary services such as content licensing and event promotions. In the six months ended June 30, 2025, this segment accounted for 35.0% of the group's total revenue, reflecting a reliance on advertiser spending from both commercial entities and state-run enterprises in mainland China, alongside pay-TV carriage fees from cable and satellite operators across Asia and overseas markets. Additional income streams include program production and transmission services, merchandising, and digital platform contributions, though these constitute smaller portions amid a broader portfolio that historically emphasized linear TV operations. The company has encountered persistent economic pressures, including a 16.2% year-over-year decline in the first half of 2025, largely attributable to softening demand amid economic slowdowns in like and . This downturn stems from intensified competition from digital streaming platforms and , which have eroded traditional TV viewership and ad budgets, with audiences increasingly shifting to content over scheduled broadcasts. Regulatory restrictions on foreign media access and geopolitical tensions, such as U.S. scrutiny of Chinese-linked broadcasters, have further constrained and subscription growth, exacerbating operating losses in non-core segments. Despite efforts to diversify into online video and , the group's trailing 12-month stood at approximately $265 million as of June 2025, underscoring vulnerability to macroeconomic cycles and platform fragmentation.

Strategic Revamps and Adaptations

In 2021, Phoenix Media Investment (Holdings) Limited completed a shareholding that consolidated ownership among Beijing-linked entities, enabling intensified focus on core operations and overseas expansion amid declining domestic advertising revenues. This adjustment aligned with broader adaptations to geopolitical tensions, including the 2022 exit from the market, where Taiwanese authorities designated the broadcaster as Chinese-funded, prompting closure of its office and layoffs of 25 staff by May 2022. The withdrawal represented a strategic pivot away from politically sensitive markets, redirecting resources toward stable audiences in and . To modernize its brand and enhance viewer engagement, Phoenix TV undertook a comprehensive of its six major satellite channels—Phoenix InfoNews, Phoenix , Phoenix Movies, Phoenix , Phoenix , and Phoenix —completed in March 2025, emphasizing unified visual identity and content synergies across platforms. Concurrently, the group launched the "Phoenix Go Glocal" international event brand in December 2024 during the 19th ASEAN Marketing Summit, positioning itself as a platform for enterprises' outreach through events, cultural exchanges, and cross-border partnerships. This initiative built on earlier infrastructure upgrades, such as adopting Huawei's DC² solutions to support multilingual and real-time content distribution, accelerating adaptation to digital fragmentation and streaming competition. Phoenix TV further adapted its by deepening integration with its digital , Phoenix New Media, through renewed content licensing agreements; for instance, a 2024 deal granted exclusive broadcasting rights to Phoenix TV's video content for RMB 50 million annually, starting August 24, fostering revenue diversification via online platforms like ifeng.com amid traditional TV audience erosion. These moves, detailed in interim results for the six months ended June 30, 2025, underscore a shift toward multi-channel dissemination—combining , , and event-based —to leverage global Chinese diaspora networks while mitigating reliance on ad markets affected by economic slowdowns.

Reception and Impact

Achievements, Awards, and Global Influence

Phoenix Television has achieved significant global reach as a leading Chinese-language broadcaster outside , operating six channels that collectively serve Mandarin- and Cantonese-speaking audiences in , , , , , and beyond. Founded in and headquartered in , the network claims a potential audience exceeding 360 million viewers worldwide through satellite, cable, and digital platforms, positioning it as a key conduit for news, entertainment, and cultural programming to communities. Its international expansion includes dedicated coverage in over 190 countries and territories, with notable penetration in markets like (over three million viewers) and nations, enhancing its role in shaping narratives for the global diaspora. The network's influence extends to hosting prominent events that recognize achievements within Chinese communities, such as the annual "Influence on the World Chinese Awards" (established in ), which honors influential figures across fields like , , and , often in collaboration with other Chinese media outlets. This initiative underscores Phoenix's in promoting Chinese cultural and professional narratives globally. Additionally, milestones include winning the "People's Choice" award at the Association of International Broadcasting's International Media Excellence Awards for its programming impact. Signature programs like Secret Documentary and Panoramic Eyeshot have garnered recognition for investigative and panoramic coverage, contributing to its reputation in multimedia content delivery. Phoenix has received various industry accolades, particularly in Asia. In 2024, its programs secured finalist positions at the and , highlighting creative excellence in production. The network was ranked among the top three in the "China's Top 10 Influential Brands Going Global" in the media category, reflecting its outbound communication efforts. In 2025, it won the ESG Award from the Hong Kong Suppliers Council, as the sole media recipient, for and practices. Chairman Liu Changle was honored with the ' lifetime achievement recognition in 2015 for leadership contributions. These awards, alongside business honors like Liu's 2018 Business Person of the Year title, affirm Phoenix's operational successes amid competitive media landscapes.

Criticisms from Independent Media Watchers and Public Opinion

Independent media organizations, including , have characterized Phoenix Television as a pro-Beijing broadcaster that advances (CCP) narratives, particularly through its international programming aimed at communities. In reports on Beijing's global media strategy, Phoenix is cited for blending state-approved content with ostensibly independent , thereby facilitating dissemination without overt attribution to official sources. This assessment stems from observed patterns of favorable coverage on issues like Hong Kong's National Security Law and territorial disputes, where editorial choices align closely with . Critics from think tanks such as the U.S.-China Economic and Security Review Commission have highlighted Phoenix's role in inducing among media to conform to Beijing's political lines, noting a shift toward more aggressively pro-China content post-1997 handover. A 2009 U.S. , later released, documented Phoenix executives acknowledging adherence to Beijing's sensitivities on sensitive topics like and to maintain access in , framing it as business pragmatism but effectively limiting critical reporting. Public opinion in reflected these concerns, culminating in regulatory expulsion; in 2022, Taiwan's Communications Commission ordered Phoenix to cease operations due to undisclosed investments from mainland entities, violating broadcasting laws designed to curb CCP influence, a move supported by public wariness of pro-Beijing media amid cross-strait tensions. In , pro-democracy groups and protesters during the 2019 anti-extradition bill demonstrations expressed distrust, viewing Phoenix's emphasis on protester violence over grievances as biased toward authorities, though specific polls on viewership trust remain limited. Ownership transitions, such as founder Changle's 2021 sale to state-linked investors, further fueled perceptions of eroded independence.

References

  1. [1]
    凤凰卫视- 立足香港,面向全球华人
    凤凰卫视于1996年3月在香港创立,现已成为海外最大的全媒体华语文化传媒集团,旗下拥有凤凰卫视、凤凰网、凤凰都市传媒、凤凰周刊、凤凰秀、凤凰数字科技等品牌, ...六大频道 · 集团简介 · 凤凰名人馆 · 品牌矩阵
  2. [2]
    Milestones - 凤凰卫视
    Mr. Liu founded Phoenix TV in 1996, which now operates six satellite TV channels and has merged many other business fronts, including new media, outdoor LED, ...
  3. [3]
    Phoenix Satellite Television – ABU
    Founded in 1996 and headquartered in Hong Kong, Phoenix Satellite Television is a leading Chinese-language media conglomerate that serves global audiences.Missing: history | Show results with:history
  4. [4]
    Phoenix Hong Kong Channel - 凤凰卫视
    Phoenix Hong Kong Channel, a comprehensive 24-hour Cantonese channel, was launched on March 28, 2011. At present its coverage spans from Hong Kong, Macau to ...Missing: history founding
  5. [5]
    Phoenix TV - State Media Monitor
    Jul 28, 2025 · Founded in 1996 by Liu Changle, a former PLA political officer turned journalist, Phoenix Satellite Television Holdings Ltd. has seen its ...Missing: history | Show results with:history
  6. [6]
    Taiwan's ouster of Phoenix TV shows shift of view on Hong Kong
    Apr 13, 2022 · Chinese state-owned Bauhinia Culture Holdings became the largest shareholder of Phoenix TV in June last year, taking over stock from founder Liu ...
  7. [7]
    Hong Kong-based Phoenix TV faces being taken off air in Taiwan ...
    Apr 6, 2022 · Taipei said last year that investments from Bauhinia Culture Holdings and state-owned China mobile gave Beijing effective control over the ...
  8. [8]
    Phoenix TV quitting Taiwan after being listed as China-owned ...
    Chinese state-owned Bauhinia Culture Holdings became the largest shareholder of Phoenix TV in June 2021, which allowed the Chinese Communist Party to exert ...
  9. [9]
    Hong Kong Media Fall to Pro-Chinese Owners - Asia Sentinel
    Apr 22, 2021 · Beijing's increasing hold on Phoenix Television, which broadcasts news and entertainment in Mandarin and Cantonese, is underscored by the fact ...
  10. [10]
    Beijing-Linked Phoenix TV Seeks Hong Kong License as China ...
    Sep 23, 2016 · Phoenix TV has applied to run two network television stations in Hong Kong, as the ruling Chinese Communist Party tightens its grip on the city's once- ...
  11. [11]
    [PDF] Phoenix Satellite Television Holdings Limited - Irasia
    Following the formation of Phoenix Satellite TV, Mr LEUNG was again instrumental in the launching of the. Phoenix Chinese Channel and the Phoenix Movies Channel ...
  12. [12]
    News Corp. will reduce China stake - International Herald Tribune
    Jun 8, 2006 · The company gained an early foothold in China in 1996 through its investment in Phoenix Satellite Television, a Hong Kong based company that won ...Missing: initial | Show results with:initial
  13. [13]
    Phoenix TV - 凤凰卫视
    Phoenix has now evolved into an omni-media corporate group, with an internet website (www.ifeng.com), which is ranked top in broadcasting platform.
  14. [14]
    Phoenix Media Investment (Holdings) Limited - irasia.com
    "Phoenix TV" originated from Phoenix Chinese Channel which was launched on 31 March 1996, with the aim of offering high quality Chinese programmes to Chinese ...Missing: founding history initial
  15. [15]
    China's Phoenix New Media plans U.S. IPO Worth up to $200 mln
    Apr 21, 2011 · Phoenix Satellite TV, founded by Liu Changle in 1996, generated revenue of $80.1 million in 2010. It is one of the few broadcasters in China ...
  16. [16]
    Phoenix Movie Channel - 凤凰卫视
    Phoenix Movies Channel was launched in August 1998 as the first subscription movie channel in mainland China. Since then, it has been entertaining an extensive ...
  17. [17]
    HK Phoenix TV Station Initiates IT, American Channel - People's Daily
    Founded in March, 1996, and listed on the Hong Kong stock market in June, 2000, the company has built into a multiple platform consisting of the Chinese channel ...
  18. [18]
    Phoenix InfoNews Channel - 凤凰卫视
    Phoenix InfoNews Channel is the first 24-hour Mandarin-language foreign satellite television channel providing the latest news on international affairs.
  19. [19]
    Phoenix North America Chinese Channel - 凤凰卫视
    Phoenix TV. CORPORATE PROFILE; OUR BUSINESS. Satellite TV. Phoenix Chinese ... Launched on January 1, 2001, Phoenix North America Chinese Channel features ...
  20. [20]
    [PDF] Phoenix TV Upgrading to HD to Better Serve the Chinese-speaking ...
    After nineteen years, Phoenix developed beyond a one- channel station into a multichannel television broadcaster also serving the Cantonese speaking Chinese.Missing: growth 2001-2010
  21. [21]
    [PDF] Quarterly Report - HKEXnews
    Nov 8, 2001 · Our confidence in the future expansion of Phoenix's access to the mainland Chinese television audience has been reinforced by several recent ...
  22. [22]
  23. [23]
    Phoenix Television - Wikipedia
    Phoenix Television is a majority state-owned television network that operates Mandarin and Cantonese-language channels serving mainland China, Hong Kong, ...
  24. [24]
    Chinese broadcaster's free-to-air license application fuels concerns ...
    Sep 20, 2016 · Chinese broadcaster Phoenix Hong Kong Television's application for a free-to-air TV licence has sparked concerns about China's encroachment in the Hong Kong ...
  25. [25]
    The Impact of the National Security Law on Media and Internet ...
    Oct 19, 2021 · This testimony examines the shrinking space for media and internet freedom in Hong Kong since Beijing imposed the National Security Law (NSL) on the territory.
  26. [26]
    Firm stand justified against local media outlets' acts of 'soft resistance'
    Jun 29, 2025 · Hence, Hong Kong residents should also watch Phoenix TV and CCTV if they wish to have more balanced world news. I fully support the Hong Kong ...Missing: impact | Show results with:impact
  27. [27]
    Phoenix celebrates the first anniversary of broadcasting on HK's free ...
    Apr 22, 2025 · In April 2025 alone, Phoenix hosted two major events here - the global premiere of the documentary Never Too Late and the 2025 World Internet ...Missing: challenges | Show results with:challenges
  28. [28]
    Mr. Liu Changle | Our Leadership
    Liu Changle is Founder of Phoenix Satellite Television. He founded Phoenix Satellite Television Company Limited in 1996. Phoenix now operates six satellite TV ...
  29. [29]
    [PDF] results announcement for the six months ended 30 june 2025 - Irasia
    Aug 15, 2025 · Meanwhile, Phoenix TV presented a full range of prominent news of the Chinese-language world. Key reports on major news events in Mainland China ...Missing: 2011-2025 | Show results with:2011-2025
  30. [30]
    Phoenix Media founder sells almost all his shares to Beijing-backed ...
    Apr 18, 2021 · Liu Changle, the founder and chairman of Hong Kong-based Chinese broadcaster Phoenix Media Investment, has agreed to sell almost all of his stake in the ...
  31. [31]
    Phoenix Media Investment (Holdings) Ownership - Simply Wall St
    Top Shareholders ; Ministry of Finance of the People's Republic of China. 21% · 1,048,668,495 · US$31.2m · 31 Dec 22 ; China Mobile Communications Group Co., Ltd.
  32. [32]
    Phoenix TV Soars After Founder Agrees to Sell Stake to Bauhinia ...
    Apr 19, 2021 · Liu, who is also Phoenix Media's chairman, has agreed to sell 37.93 percent, almost all of his 38.08 percent stake, the 25-year-old media group ...
  33. [33]
    Phoenix Media Investment (Holdings) Limited - irasia.com
    The revenue of the Group for the year ended 31 December 2024 was approximately HK$2,235,129,000 (year ended 31 December 2023: HK$2,467,957,000), which ...
  34. [34]
    Phoenix Media Investment (Holdings) Limited - irasia.com
    Sep 10, 2025 · Mr. Sun Yusheng, aged 64, has been appointed as Executive Director since 22 June 2021. He is the Deputy Chief Executive Officer and Editor-in-Chief, Head of ...
  35. [35]
    [PDF] PHOENIX MEDIA INVESTMENT (HOLDINGS) LIMITED 鳳凰衛視 ...
    Mar 21, 2025 · As at 31 December 2024, the Group's equity interest in Phoenix New Media Limited (“PNM”) increased to 55.04% (as at 31 December 2023: 54.68%) ...
  36. [36]
    Phoenix Media Investment Holdings Ltd - Company Profile and News
    Executives ; Xu Wei. 6/2021-PRESENT. Chairman/CEO/Exec Dir ; Sun Yusheng. 6/2021-PRESENT. Deputy CEO/Exec Dir ; Li Qi. 5/2023-PRESENT. Chief Operating Officer.
  37. [37]
    Company Phoenix Media Investment (Holdings) Limited Shanghai
    Wei Xu CEO. Chief Executive Officer, 58 ; Ka Keung Yeung DFI. Director of Finance/CFO, 66 ; Qi Li COO. Chief Operating Officer, 46 ; Yu Sheng Sun PRN. Corporate ...
  38. [38]
    Phoenix New Media Announces Its CEO, Mr. Shuang Liu ... - SEC.gov
    Phoenix TV's six TV channels----Phoenix Chinese Channel, Phoenix InfoNews Channel, Phoenix Chinese News & Entertainment Channel, Phoenix North America Chinese ...Missing: founders | Show results with:founders
  39. [39]
    Phoenix InfoNews Channel
    ### Summary of Phoenix InfoNews Channel Programs
  40. [40]
    24/7 News - 凤凰卫视
    Phoenix InfoNews provides a comprehensive range of news information and current affairs programs presented by the best anchors and journalists from China ...
  41. [41]
  42. [42]
    我的香港故事 - 鳳凰衛視PHOENIX TV
    一個個娓娓道來的香港故事,交織成「港味」十足的人生百態。 My Hong Kong Story is a character-driven documentary launched by Phoenix Chinese Channel in 2022. Each ...
  43. [43]
    Upcoming documentary aims to showcase Hong Kong's biodiversity
    Apr 14, 2023 · Hong Kong Nature Stories, a nonprofit program aiming to display the city's biological diversity, was launched at Phoenix Television's ...
  44. [44]
    Series showcases strong women of ancient China - China Daily HK
    Dec 4, 2024 · Four famous females are topics of documentary that covers reputation, resilience and gender equality.
  45. [45]
    Phoenix TV documentary on ecological conservation holds world ...
    Apr 12, 2025 · "Never Too Late" follows four Hong Kong residents to show the relationship between humanity and nature, highlighting the impact of individual ...Missing: dramas | Show results with:dramas
  46. [46]
    HUAWEI Video unveils new Phoenix TV shows about Hong Kong's ...
    HUAWEI Video unveils new Phoenix TV shows about Hong Kong's hidden treasures: 'Walking Homeland' and 'Hong Kong Story' - TNGlobal.<|separator|>
  47. [47]
    Phoenix TV debuts new Hong Kong short-form series; Ben Lai's ...
    New Hong Kong short-form series, “All the Best”, premiered on YouTube at the weekend, recalling the special administrative region’s glory days.Missing: documentaries | Show results with:documentaries
  48. [48]
    [PDF] FORM 20-F Phoenix New Media Limited
    Indicate the number of outstanding shares of each of the issuer's classes of capital or common stock as of the close of the period covered by the annual report.
  49. [49]
    Global Coverage - 凤凰卫视
    Phoenix Satellite Television is the first Chinese language television broadcaster that entered the cable systems in all five of these cities.Missing: technology | Show results with:technology
  50. [50]
    Phoenix TV | Tencent Cloud
    Leveraging cutting-edge technologies like live satellite feeds, online streaming services, and mobile applications, along with traditional channels like cable ...
  51. [51]
    Broadcaster Phoenix seeks Hong Kong free-to-air television licence
    Sep 20, 2016 · Broadcaster Phoenix seeks Hong Kong free-to-air television licence. Communications Authority is considering application for digital service, ...
  52. [52]
    Digital Rapids - Internal IPTV Network at Phoenix Television
    Mandarin Chinese broadcaster Phoenix Television is using 40 Digital Rapids encoding and streaming systems as part of a new infrastructure for the monitoring of ...Missing: methods | Show results with:methods
  53. [53]
    Phoenix Satellite TV Headquarters - headarchitecture
    The Phoenix Satellite TV Headquarters, located in New Territories, Hong Kong, is a news broadcast center with production suites, executive offices, and studios ...Missing: Television | Show results with:Television
  54. [54]
    Beijing Phoenix Center - 凤凰卫视
    The new Phoenix Center is located in Chaoyang District at the southwest corner of Beijing Chaoyang Park in Beijing has a land area of 18,000 square meters ...
  55. [55]
    Phoenix International Media Center - KONE U.S.
    Phoenix is an open, multifunctional building providing 65,000 square meters of space for television production, media communication and commercial exhibitions.
  56. [56]
    Phoenix International Media Center, Designed by BIAD
    Jul 14, 2014 · The latest icon in Beijing is the headquarters of China's largest private broadcaster—and it wasn't designed by a foreign architect.
  57. [57]
    Phoenix Satellite Television Co., Ltd. response
    Through 60 news offices around the world, the Phoenix InfoNews Channel can ensure broad coverage of the Coalition's news and campaigns to generate wider ...
  58. [58]
    Phoenix Go Glocal! Phoenix TV launches Premier International ...
    Dec 6, 2024 · With 63 correspondent stations across the globe, Phoenix TV shares absolute advantages on universal presence, global coverage, and international ...
  59. [59]
    Phoenix TV American Headquarters - 凤凰卫视
    Phoenix TV American Headquarters is located at 3810 Durbin Street, Irwindale, CA 91706. It is a two story building with elevator service for convenient access ...Missing: bureaus | Show results with:bureaus
  60. [60]
    Phoenix TV Headquarters - 凤凰卫视
    The Phoenix Headquarters is located in the Taipo Industrial Estate in the Hong Kong New Territories. Phoenix's neighbors in the Industrial Estate include the ...
  61. [61]
    Phoenix Television - KT Wong Foundation
    Jul 23, 2017 · Phoenix Television is a Hong Kong-based broadcaster with 7 channels, serving Chinese mainland and Hong Kong, and reaches over 150 countries ...
  62. [62]
    Phoenix Satellite Television: The Art of Broadcasting in China
    Phoenix Satellite Television Holdings ("Phoenix TV") was established in 2006 as a joint venture with News Corporation's ("News Corp's") STAR TV unit and Liu ...Missing: transmission | Show results with:transmission
  63. [63]
    Phoenix Satellite TV Headquarters (HK) News Studio - Architizer
    A broadcast centre has numerous technical and AV considerations. Sound absorbent materials and concepts are used wherever possible. We needed to avoid too many ...
  64. [64]
    Phoenix Television Withdrawal Linked to Larger Issues Regulating ...
    Apr 7, 2022 · Bauhinia Culture Holdings Limited, which is owned by the Chinese government, became the largest shareholder of Phoenix Television last year ...
  65. [65]
    Phoenix TV faces closure in Taiwan - Taipei Times
    Apr 7, 2022 · The government yesterday designated Phoenix Television a Chinese-funded company, a move that should force the network to close its office in Taiwan.
  66. [66]
    Beijing's Global Megaphone | Freedom House
    Propaganda: How the CCP promotes its favored content and narratives abroad. The CCP employs a variety of methods to reach global audiences with approved content ...
  67. [67]
    None
    ### Summary of Sections on Phoenix TV, Ownership, Influence Operations, Self-Censorship, or Bias Towards Chinese Government
  68. [68]
    Sen. Cruz Applauds FCC Decision to Reject Phoenix TV License ...
    Jun 22, 2020 · The Federal Communications Commission rejected the application for a license enabling a radio station secretly used and maintained by Phoenix Radio.
  69. [69]
    [PDF] Angeli Datt Testimony
    Sep 8, 2021 · 47 In April 2021, pro-Beijing Phoenix Television founder Liu Changle sold his stake in the broadcaster to Chinese state-owned Bauhinia ...
  70. [70]
    Report on China's Only Government Authorized Private Television ...
    Sep 26, 2005 · The article detailed the political self-censorship that Liu Changle, Phoenix's founder, must impose to continue broadcasting. Liu, a former ...Missing: pro- bias
  71. [71]
    Is Phoenix TV of Hong Kong truly a private company or is it ... - Quora
    Apr 8, 2020 · Phoenix TV is on the surface controlled by Liu Changle, but under the surface——it is still too early to reach a conclusion. However, you can say ...<|separator|>
  72. [72]
    HK-based TV network Phoenix TV reportedly ceasing Taiwan ops
    Apr 7, 2022 · Currently, Bauhinia Culture (Hong Kong) Holdings takes control of about 21% stake in Phoenix Television, while China Mobile (Hong Kong) also ...
  73. [73]
  74. [74]
    Phoenix Media Investment (Holdings) Limited - irasia.com
    Revenue from television broadcasting, comprising advertising, subscription and other revenue sources, which accounted for 37.2% of the total revenue of the ...
  75. [75]
    Phoenix Media Reports Revenue Decline Amidst Competitive ...
    Aug 16, 2025 · Phoenix Media Investment (Holdings) Limited reported a 16.2% decline in revenue for the first half of 2025, attributed to decreased advertising ...Missing: performance | Show results with:performance
  76. [76]
    [PDF] PHOENIX - HKEXnews
    Apr 11, 2017 · Phoenix TV held an event to celebrate its 20th anniversary at the company headquarters in Hong. Kong. The Vice Chairman of the Tenth to Twelfth.<|separator|>
  77. [77]
    Phoenix Media Investment 2025 Company Profile - PitchBook
    Phoenix Media Investment (Holdings) Ltd is engaged in satellite television broadcasting and the provision of new media services.Missing: initial shareholders
  78. [78]
    [PDF] PHOENIX MEDIA INVESTMENT (HOLDINGS) LIMITED 鳳凰衛視 ...
    Mar 18, 2022 · In 2021, Phoenix completed its shareholding restructuring, intensifying the pace of its ... Phoenix Media Investment (Holdings) Limited (the “ ...
  79. [79]
    Phoenix Go Glocal! Phoenix TV launches Premier International ...
    Dec 6, 2024 · The international event brand "Phoenix Go Glocal" owned by Phoenix TV Group is officially launched during the 19th ASEAN Marketing Summit.
  80. [80]
    Phoenix TV Accelerates Globalization with DC² - Huawei Carrier
    Phoenix TV uses its four international media centers to broadcast programs and timely information to audiences around the world. These media centers provide 24/ ...Missing: methods | Show results with:methods
  81. [81]
    Phoenix New Media Announces New Program License Agreement ...
    According to the 2024 Program License Agreement, Phoenix TV grants the Licensee exclusive right to broadcast copyrighted video content of Phoenix TV.
  82. [82]
    凤凰卫视凤凰网2017-2018影响世界华人盛典
    Mar 30, 2025 · 黄旭华院士获颁终身成就奖 · 侯云德院士获颁终身成就奖 · 吴京获“影响世界华人大奖”. 向右. 核潜艇之父黄旭华:获华人盛典终身成就奖非常荣幸. 研制核潜艇 ...
  83. [83]
    Info Click - 凤凰卫视
    Phoenix New Horizons Series is a strong prime time line-up from Monday to Friday evening covering cross-strait politics, social, economy, finance, diplomacy and ...Missing: Television | Show results with:Television
  84. [84]
    [PDF] – 1 – PRESS RELEASE PHOENIX MEDIA INVESTMENT ... - Irasia
    ... success ... finalist awards at the 2024 Asian Television Awards, Asian Academy Creative Awards 2024 and 2024 ... Phoenix Satellite Television Company Limited. Mr ...<|separator|>
  85. [85]
    凤凰卫视荣登“中国出海十大影响力品牌”榜单前三甲!
    Dec 18, 2024 · 会上,“中国品牌年度大奖”(NO.1)有35个品牌脱颖而出,“中国十大影响力品牌”(TOP10)发布12个品类的十大品牌。其中,凤凰卫视作为传媒品类的唯一品牌,与Tiktok ...
  86. [86]
    凤凰卫视斩获2025香港厂商会“香港ESG奖”,是获奖企业中唯一传媒 ...
    Oct 17, 2025 · 凤凰卫视多年来在践行ESG方面始终履行媒体责任,多次荣获相关奖项,包括由香港上市公司商会颁发的“2024香港ESG卓越嘉许奖”及“2023香港公司管治与ESG卓越奖” ...
  87. [87]
    Phoenix Satellite Television Co. Archives - Television Asia Plus
    The Asian Television Awards 2015 committee has unanimously selected Changle Liu, Chairman and CEO of Phoenix Satellite Television Co. to be awarded the ...
  88. [88]
    Phoenix TV boss Liu named Business Person of the Year
    Jul 3, 2018 · He is a Shanghai-born former colonel in the People's Liberation Army with strong ties to senior Communist Party officials. Liu set up Phoenix ...
  89. [89]
    [PDF] BEIJING'S GLOBAL MEDIA INFLUENCE - Freedom House
    They involve deliberate efforts to conceal the source of pro-Beijing content and to censor unfavorable views.
  90. [90]
    Cablegate: Phoenix Tv in the Mainland - Self Censorship or Just
    Apr 29, 2009 · Cablegate: Phoenix Tv in the Mainland - Self Censorship or Just ... issues adhered so closely to Beijing's line, Pan replied that. Phoenix's ...
  91. [91]
    Gutting Hong Kong Broadcaster, Apple Concessions, Propaganda ...
    May 3, 2021 · Hong Kong: Website blocks, netizen arrests, journalist beating, and Phoenix TV ownership change · Taiwanese websites blocked: · Arrests and ...