Phyllis Thede
Phyllis Thede (born February 23, 1954) is an American former politician and retired school administrator who served as a Democratic member of the Iowa House of Representatives from January 2009 to January 2023.[1][2] Born in Chicago, Illinois, and raised in Creston, Iowa, Thede resided in Bettendorf and worked for over two decades in the Davenport Community Schools District as an attendance secretary and para-educator before entering politics.[1][2] Thede was first elected in 2008 to represent District 81, later redistricted to District 93 in Scott County, encompassing parts of Bettendorf and Davenport, and served seven terms in total.[2][3] During her tenure, she focused on education policy, labor issues, and community advocacy, drawing from her background in public schools.[2] Married to Dave Thede since 1976, she is the mother of three daughters, including comedian and writer Robin Thede.[1][4] In the 2022 election, Thede lost her bid for reelection in the newly drawn District 94 to Republican Kenan Judge, ending her legislative career amid Iowa's shifting political landscape.[3][5] She later reflected critically on the Iowa Legislature's environment, describing it as progressively stagnant and challenging for Democratic priorities.[3] As one of a small number of African American legislators in the Iowa House during her service, Thede contributed to representation from urban Scott County districts.[5]Early Life and Education
Birth and Upbringing
Phyllis Thede was born on February 23, 1954, in Chicago, Illinois, to an African-American family that had migrated from the southern United States.[6] [7] Her early years were spent in Chicago before the family relocated to Iowa, where she was raised in Creston.[1] This small town in southwestern Iowa provided the setting for her childhood, reflecting a transition from urban Chicago to rural Midwestern life.[8] Details on her immediate family during upbringing remain sparse in public records, though later family connections indicate ties to Iowa communities, including ancestral links to Creston through her great-grandfather's work there.[8] Thede's formative experiences in Creston likely exposed her to the agricultural and community-oriented environment of rural Iowa, shaping her perspectives amid a predominantly white, conservative region during the mid-20th century.[1] By adulthood, she had settled in Bettendorf, Iowa, but her roots in Creston underscored an enduring connection to the state's heartland.[9]Formal Education and Early Influences
Phyllis Thede was born on February 23, 1954, in Chicago, Illinois, and raised in Creston, Iowa, attending local public schools there.[1][7] For postsecondary education, Thede attended Southwestern Community College in Creston, Iowa, and Westmar College in Le Mars, Iowa, though no degrees were completed or specified in official records.[1] Her early life in rural southwest Iowa, within an African-American family that had roots in northern migration patterns, oriented her toward community-oriented pursuits, culminating in a decades-long career in public schooling.[1]Pre-Political Career
Professional Roles in Education
Thede worked for over 30 years in the Davenport Community School District, primarily in administrative and support capacities within public education.[10] [11] Her roles included serving as a para-educator, providing classroom assistance and support to teachers and students across district schools.[12] [2] She also held the position of media secretary at North High School, managing library media resources and related educational materials.[2] Additionally, Thede functioned as attendance secretary at Williams Intermediate School, tracking student attendance and addressing related administrative matters.[1] [13] These positions encompassed a range of duties supporting instructional and operational functions in K-12 public schools, reflecting her long-term commitment to educational infrastructure before retiring in 2016.[11]Community and Union Activities
Prior to entering politics, Phyllis Thede held leadership roles in the union representing employees of the Davenport Community Schools. She served as president of the local union, as well as vice president, contract negotiator, and grievance chair.[12][14] As a member of the American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees (AFSCME), she acted as a union steward at Davenport North High School, advocating for workers in administrative and support positions.[15] Thede participated in numerous committees within the Davenport school district, including the superintendent search committee, contributing to administrative decision-making and policy implementation at the local level.[16] Her involvement extended to broader community efforts through her roles as a paraeducator and media secretary, where she supported educational initiatives and student services in the Quad Cities area.[1] These activities focused on labor rights, workplace equity, and school governance, reflecting her long-term commitment to public education employees prior to her 2008 electoral campaign.[13]Political Entry and Elections
Initial Candidacy and 2008 Victory
Phyllis Thede, a Democrat from Bettendorf, announced her candidacy for the Iowa House of Representatives District 81 in early 2008, emphasizing priorities such as improving health care access and enhancing education to better prepare children for post-school success.[16] She filed her candidacy paperwork on March 10, 2008, and faced no opposition in the Democratic primary held on June 3, 2008.[17] District 81, located primarily in Scott County, encompassed parts of Bettendorf and surrounding areas, and had been held by Republican incumbent Jamie Van Fossen since 2003. Thede's campaign positioned her as a challenger to Van Fossen, highlighting her background in education and community involvement against the incumbent's record. The general election on November 4, 2008, resulted in a Democratic gain, with Thede defeating Van Fossen by receiving 8,736 votes to his 6,951, out of a total of 15,711 votes cast—a margin of approximately 1,785 votes.[18] This victory contributed to Democrats expanding their majority in the Iowa House, reflecting broader national trends favoring Democratic candidates that year amid economic concerns and the presidential election.[19] Thede was sworn in on January 12, 2009, beginning her tenure representing the district.[2]Subsequent Re-elections Through 2020
Thede secured re-election to the Iowa House of Representatives in the 2010 general election for District 81, defeating Republican challenger Carla Batchelor by a margin of 5,397 votes to 5,164.[2] Following redistricting, she won re-election in District 93 in the 2012 general election against Republican Mark Nelson, receiving 9,679 votes (56.6 percent) to Nelson's 7,429 votes (43.4 percent).[2] In 2014, Thede retained the seat by defeating Republican Mark A. Ross, 6,381 votes (52.8 percent) to 5,699 votes (47.2 percent).[2] Thede's 2016 re-election in District 93 was narrower, as she defeated Republican Kurt Whalen with 8,470 votes (51.85 percent) against 7,865 votes (48.15 percent).[2] She faced no Republican opponent in the 2018 general election, securing victory with 9,660 votes (95.2 percent, including write-ins).[2] In the 2020 general election for District 93, Thede defeated Republican Mike Vondran, earning 9,530 votes (55.7 percent) to Vondran's 7,549 votes (44.1 percent).[2] These victories maintained her representation of Scott County areas, including parts of Davenport and Bettendorf, through the end of the decade.[20]Legislative Tenure
Committee Assignments and Roles
Phyllis Thede served on multiple committees during her tenure in the Iowa House of Representatives from 2009 to 2022, frequently holding the position of Ranking Member as the Democratic minority leader on key panels. These assignments reflected her focus on oversight, governance, and resource allocation issues.[1][14] In the 86th General Assembly (2015–2016), Thede was Ranking Member of the House Ethics Committee, overseeing investigations into legislative conduct and conflicts of interest, and served as a member of the Government Oversight, Local Government, and Natural Resources committees, addressing administrative accountability, municipal policies, and environmental management.[14] In the same period's 2015 legislative session, she also sat on the Appropriations Committee, influencing budget deliberations for state programs.[2] By the 89th General Assembly (2021–2022), her final term, Thede had advanced to Ranking Member of the Administration and Rules Committee, guiding minority input on procedural matters and legislative operations, while continuing membership on the Appropriations and Local Government committees to shape fiscal priorities and regional governance frameworks.[1] She additionally participated in the Public Safety Committee during the 88th General Assembly (2019–2020), contributing to discussions on law enforcement and emergency response policies.[21]| General Assembly | Key Committees and Roles |
|---|---|
| 86th (2015–2016) | Ethics (Ranking Member), Government Oversight (Member), Local Government (Member), Natural Resources (Member), Appropriations (Member)[14][2] |
| 88th (2019–2020) | Public Safety (Member)[21] |
| 89th (2021–2022) | Administration and Rules (Ranking Member), Appropriations (Member), Local Government (Member)[1] |
Sponsored Legislation and Key Votes
During her legislative tenure from 2007 to 2022, Phyllis Thede sponsored a limited number of bills as principal author, reflecting her focus on social services, criminal justice, and local governance issues, though few advanced in the Republican-majority Iowa House.[22] In the 86th General Assembly (2015-2016), she introduced HF 472, which proposed requiring population impact statements for bills, resolutions, and amendments to assess demographic effects. The bill did not pass. Similarly, HF 345 addressed provisions for elderly persons exhibiting aggressive or psychiatric behaviors in long-term care facilities, aiming to enhance safety protocols.[23] In the 87th General Assembly (2017-2018), Thede sponsored HF 2191, amending procedures for commuting sentences of class "A" felons serving life imprisonment under Iowa Code section 902.1, to allow for earlier eligibility reviews.[24] This criminal justice reform measure did not enact into law. Other sponsored efforts included HF 2344 in the 88th General Assembly (2019-2020), relating to filing requirements for property tax exemptions for certain societies and organizations, with an effective date provision.[22] Thede more frequently co-sponsored legislation, contributing to over 48 bills in one session alone, often aligned with Democratic priorities in education and labor.[22] On key votes, Thede's record demonstrated consistent alignment with progressive positions, earning low scores on conservative-leaning scorecards. In the Freedom Index 2021-2022 scorecard by The John Birch Society, which evaluated votes on constitutional and limited-government issues, Thede received a score reflecting opposition to measures like restrictions on federal overreach and fiscal conservatism.[25] The National Federation of Independent Business (NFIB) voting records highlight her opposition to pro-business reforms, including a "no" vote on SF 619 (2021), the Tax Reform Omnibus bill that reduced individual and corporate tax rates by over $1 billion to benefit small businesses and employees.[26] She also opposed property tax transparency measures in SF 634 (pre-2020 session), which aimed to increase accountability for local tax growth.[27] In the Club for Growth Foundation's 2021 Iowa House scorecard, analyzing over 600 floor votes for pro-growth policies, Thede's score indicated resistance to tax cuts and regulatory relief.[28]| Scorecard | Organization | Period | Thede's Score/Position |
|---|---|---|---|
| Freedom Index | John Birch Society | 2021-2022 | Low (opposed key conservative votes)[25] |
| NFIB Voting Record | National Federation of Independent Business | 2021 | Opposed tax reform (SF 619) and property tax accountability (SF 634)[26][27] |
| Legislative Scorecard | Club for Growth Foundation | 2021 | Low on pro-growth votes (17 House votes evaluated)[28] |
Policy Positions and Record
Stances on Education and Labor
Thede, a former paraeducator, attendance secretary, and media secretary in the Davenport Community Schools, prioritized bolstering public education through enhanced funding and resources during her legislative tenure. In her December 2021 reelection announcement, she highlighted the necessity of equipping Iowa students with sufficient books, curricula, and qualified teachers, observing that the state had fallen from its former top national rankings in education metrics. She backed proposals to permit school districts operating below allowable per-pupil spending levels to access additional reserves, as articulated in January 2017 discussions on revising Iowa's school funding formula. Thede also co-sponsored HF 383 in the 2019-2020 session, which addressed public school funding allocations, reflecting her commitment to stabilizing district budgets amid fiscal pressures. In a February 2023 reflection post-tenure, she attributed ongoing challenges in public education to Republican policies she viewed as systematically undermining the sector's viability. Thede's advocacy extended to opposing measures perceived as eroding educational equity, including resistance to expansions in non-public school options that diverted funds from traditional public systems. During the 2016 legislative session, she endorsed short-term funding adjustments to aid districts facing immediate shortfalls until a comprehensive formula overhaul could be achieved. Her 2022 campaign platform further linked education to economic mobility, proposing investments to support student success and debt relief pathways for working- and middle-class families via accessible public schooling. These positions aligned with her pre-political experience on school committees, including superintendent searches, where she influenced resource allocation decisions. On labor matters, Thede's background as president of AFSCME Local 751, along with roles as union vice president, contract negotiator, and grievance chair in the Davenport school district, informed her pro-union orientation. She actively supported collective bargaining rights for public employees, co-sponsoring HF 147 in the 2019-2020 session to address employment conditions, including bargaining processes and educator-specific issues. In October 2021, Thede participated in United Auto Workers picket lines in Davenport, standing with union leaders to advocate for fair contracts and worker protections amid labor disputes at manufacturing facilities. Her efforts emphasized safeguarding union authority in negotiations, drawing from her direct involvement in securing contracts for school staff prior to entering politics. Thede's labor stance manifested in broader endorsements of policies benefiting working families, such as her 2022 platform calls to raise wages, expand affordable childcare access, and reduce taxes on lower-income households to foster economic stability. She aligned with Democratic opposition to restrictive labor laws, though specific voting records on initiatives like the 2017 right-to-work legislation—enacted over union objections—reflect the partisan divide in Iowa, where she consistently prioritized union-supported measures in floor debates and committee work. These positions underscored a causal emphasis on collective representation as essential to countering wage stagnation and workplace inequities, informed by her firsthand union leadership.Positions on Social and Cultural Issues
Thede has consistently advocated for abortion rights aligned with the standards established by Roe v. Wade, opposing legislative efforts to impose restrictions or bans on the procedure. In a 2022 interview, she explicitly stated her support for the "50-year-old Roe v. Wade" framework in response to proposed abortion bans in Iowa.[29] Following the U.S. Supreme Court's 2022 overturning of Roe, Thede participated in local pro-choice commemorations marking the decision's 50th anniversary, emphasizing the need to protect access to reproductive services.[30] She also criticized policies limiting Medicaid reimbursements to abortion providers, arguing they undermined healthcare access during her legislative tenure.[31] On cultural issues related to race and education, Thede opposed Republican-led efforts to restrict discussions of systemic racism and diversity training in public institutions. During the Iowa House's 2021 debate on a bill prohibiting "divisive concepts" such as implicit bias training, she argued that topics like systemic racism required open dialogue, stating, "I understand all of these issues, but we cannot bury our heads in the sand."[32] This stance reflected her broader emphasis on addressing racial disparities, drawing from personal experiences as a Black legislator who encountered bias despite a stable family background. Regarding firearms policy, Thede acknowledged Second Amendment rights while supporting targeted gun safety measures, including enhanced background checks, age restrictions on purchases, and addressing mental health factors in gun violence. At a 2018 Davenport legislative forum on gun control, she described the issue as multifaceted: "It's a mental health issue, it's a background check issue, it's an age which to buy a gun issue, it's a second amendment issue."[33] Her voting record included opposition to certain expansions of gun rights; for instance, she voted against Senate Joint Resolution 18 in 2020, a measure favored by pro-Second Amendment groups to enshrine gun rights in Iowa's constitution.[34] Thede supported initiatives promoting safe school environments, including protections against discrimination that encompassed LGBTQ students, positioning herself as an advocate during controversies over youth conferences addressing sexual orientation and gender identity.[35] As a Democrat serving during Iowa's 2009 judicial legalization of same-sex marriage, her legislative alignment with party priorities indicated endorsement of marriage equality, though she did not sponsor related bills amid the court-driven process.[36]Fiscal and Economic Policies
Thede advocated for fiscal policies that prioritized tax relief for working families and investments in social programs such as affordable childcare, while opposing broad-based tax reductions and deregulation measures perceived as favoring businesses over labor. In her 2022 campaign, she pledged to lower taxes specifically for working-class households, expand childcare access to alleviate family financial burdens, and raise wages through strengthened collective bargaining protections.[29] She also backed a 2022 amendment establishing a tax credit program for developers of affordable housing units, capped at $15 million annually from state funds to address housing shortages in her district.[29] Her legislative voting record reflected resistance to Republican-sponsored tax reforms aimed at simplifying the code and reducing rates. Thede voted against Senate File 619, the 2021 tax reform omnibus bill, which lowered Iowa's top individual income tax rate from 8.53% to 6.50% over time, eliminated certain deductions, and delivered an estimated $1.8 billion in cuts by 2027, measures supported by pro-growth advocates for stimulating economic activity.[26] [28] Similarly, in 2019-2020, she opposed Senate File 634 on property tax reform, which sought to cap assessments and limit local government revenue growth to control homeowner costs.[27] On economic regulation, Thede's positions aligned with labor priorities, leading to low alignment with small-business advocacy groups. The National Federation of Independent Business (NFIB) rated her at 13% support for its agenda in 2019-2020, citing her "no" votes on Senate File 507 (workers' compensation reforms to reduce employer premiums), House File 327 (franchisee-franchisor liability clarifications), and House File 2627 (occupational licensing deregulation to ease entry barriers for workers and entrepreneurs).[27] She supported House File 220 allowing full expensing under Section 179 for business equipment purchases, a provision aiding small business capital investments.[27] The Club for Growth Foundation scored her at 8% in 2021, noting absences on several bills including SF 619 and opposition to House File 772, which provided targeted subsidies for healthcare workforce shortages amid economic recovery efforts.[28] Serving on the House Appropriations Committee from 2017 onward, Thede influenced budget allocations, emphasizing funding for education, local governments, and middle-class supports over spending cuts.[2] She publicly stressed the role of small businesses in community vitality and positioned the middle class as the "backbone of society," advocating policies to shield it from economic shifts like automation and wage stagnation.[2] Her approach contrasted with GOP efforts to prioritize tax competitiveness and regulatory relief, reflecting a Democratic emphasis on redistributive measures funded through sustained or targeted revenue sources.Controversies and Criticisms
Partisan Disputes and Public Statements
Thede frequently criticized Republican-led legislation during her tenure, characterizing certain bills as overly punitive or ideologically extreme. In June 2021, following Governor Kim Reynolds' signing of a law increasing penalties for rioting and enhancing police protections—commonly referred to as the "Back the Blue" bill—Thede, as a member of the Iowa Legislative Black Caucus, stated that the measure "sends a terrible, terrible message," arguing it disproportionately targeted protesters amid ongoing debates over police accountability.[37] Similarly, in February 2021, Thede joined other Quad-City Democratic lawmakers in denouncing Republican proposals on education and unemployment benefits as "radical" and "mean-spirited," contending they undermined worker protections and public services without adequate justification.[38] Partisan tensions escalated in public forums, exemplified by a January 2022 Zoom event organized by Iowa Democrats, where Thede and other speakers were interrupted by anonymous participants posting racist images, including a monkey overlay and epithets, alongside vulgar remarks. Thede described the incident as an attempt to intimidate Democratic lawmakers, highlighting the increasingly hostile partisan climate in Iowa politics, though no perpetrators were publicly identified.[39] In a February 2023 interview after her electoral defeat, Thede reflected on the legislature's atmosphere, declaring it "a terrible place to be" due to entrenched partisan divisions that she attributed to Republican dominance, which she said stifled bipartisan cooperation and exacerbated gridlock on key issues.[3] Conversely, Iowa House Republicans portrayed Thede's policy positions as out of step with state voters, releasing a October 2022 campaign video asserting that "Phyllis Thede's agenda is too radical for Iowa," framing her support for Democratic priorities like expanded labor rights and opposition to GOP social reforms as extreme.[40] These exchanges underscored broader ideological clashes, with Thede's advocacy for minority impact statements and resistance to restrictions on diversity training drawing Republican rebukes for promoting what they termed divisive ideologies.[41]Accusations of Radical Positions
Thede faced accusations from Republican legislators of endorsing divisive racial ideologies by opposing House File 802, a March 2021 bill that prohibited state agencies and contractors from incorporating "divisive concepts"—such as claims of inherent racism in American institutions or privilege based on race—in diversity trainings. During floor debate, Thede argued that topics like systemic racism and implicit bias required open discussion to address real societal issues, a stance critics equated with promoting critical race theory and Marxist indoctrination.[32][42] As a member of the Iowa House Black Caucus, Thede participated in statements labeling Republican legislative priorities— including prohibitions on defunding police departments and restrictions on curricula emphasizing racial inequities—as retaliatory against 2020's racial justice advancements. Opponents, including GOP leaders, portrayed this as alignment with far-left efforts to undermine law enforcement, particularly amid national debates over police reform following George Floyd's death. Thede criticized subsequent "back the blue" measures, such as Senate File 576 signed in June 2021, which increased penalties for crimes against officers, claiming they hindered accountability.[43][44][45] These positions drew broader criticism during her 2022 re-election campaign against Republican Ryan Ludwick, with conservative outlets and party ads linking Democratic support for racial equity initiatives to radical policies on crime and policing that allegedly prioritized ideology over public safety. No evidence indicates Thede explicitly advocated defunding police, as Iowa Democrats backed bipartisan reforms in 2020 enhancing officer training and use-of-force standards, but her caucus's resistance to GOP countermeasures fueled perceptions of extremism in a swing district.[46]Factors in 2022 Electoral Defeat
In the 2022 general election held on November 8, Republican challenger Mike Vondran defeated incumbent Democrat Phyllis Thede in Iowa House District 94, securing 7,512 votes (56.5%) to Thede's 5,793 votes (43.5%), a margin of 1,719 votes.[47] This outcome flipped the seat from Democratic to Republican control, contributing to the GOP's net gain of four House seats statewide, expanding their majority from 60-40 to 64-36.[48] Redistricting played a significant role, as Iowa's nonpartisan Legislative Services Agency redrew legislative boundaries following the 2020 census, creating new District 94 from parts of former District 93, which Thede had held. The revised district incorporated more rural areas in Scott County, shifting its voter composition toward demographics historically favoring Republicans, unlike the more urban-focused prior boundaries.[49] Vondran, a Davenport businessman and founder of an advertising agency who had previously challenged Thede unsuccessfully in 2020, capitalized on this by emphasizing local economic concerns in his campaign.[50] Statewide Democratic losses, including Thede's, were exacerbated by lower voter turnout among Democrats compared to Republicans, with Iowa's overall participation at about 55% but with evidence of disproportionate drops in Democratic-leaning areas relative to 2018 midterm levels.[51] Key issues such as inflation, education policy, and property tax relief favored Republican messaging on fiscal accomplishments under Governor Kim Reynolds, while Democratic warnings on abortion access post-Dobbs decision failed to mobilize sufficient opposition in competitive districts like Thede's.[52] Thede's long tenure since 2007 may have also contributed to voter desire for change, as Vondran positioned himself as a fresh alternative focused on business experience.[53]Personal Life
Family Background and Residences
Phyllis Thede was born on February 23, 1954, in Chicago, Illinois, to an African American family. She spent her early years in Chicago before her family relocated to Iowa, where she was raised in Creston.[1][7][6] Thede married Dave Thede in 1976. The couple has three daughters—Mackenzie, Acacia, and Robin—and four grandchildren. Her family has been involved in education and activism; both Thede and her husband worked for the Davenport Community Schools district from approximately 1980 to 2004, with Thede serving in roles such as para-educator and media secretary at North High School.[7][1][4][54] Thede has primarily resided in Iowa since childhood, transitioning from Creston to the Quad Cities area in adulthood. She has lived in Bettendorf, Scott County, for much of her professional and political career, representing districts encompassing Bettendorf and parts of Davenport in the Iowa House of Representatives.[1][9][2]Post-2023 Activities
Following her departure from the Iowa House of Representatives on January 1, 2023, Phyllis Thede has remained active in local Democratic Party organizations.[2] She serves as Affirmative Action Chair for the Scott County Democrats, a role focused on promoting diversity and inclusion within the party's operations in the Quad Cities area.[55] In July 2025, Thede publicly endorsed Democratic State Representative Jennifer Konfrst's reelection campaign, praising her as a "go getter, no nonsense, tough fighter" committed to advocating for Iowans.[56] This endorsement highlights Thede's continued engagement in supporting party candidates amid Iowa's competitive political landscape. No further public records indicate involvement in electoral campaigns, private sector employment, or other legislative pursuits as of October 2025.[57]Electoral History
Summary of Vote Totals and Margins
Phyllis Thede represented Iowa House District 93 from 2007 to 2023, winning multiple re-elections before redistricting placed her in District 94 for the 2022 cycle, where she was defeated. Her victories typically featured comfortable margins in Democratic-leaning areas of Scott County, though recent contests grew competitive amid shifting voter preferences and higher turnout in presidential years.| Year | District | Thede (D) Votes (%) | Opponent (R) Votes (%) | Margin (Votes) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2016 | 93 | 8,456 (51.8) | Kurt Whalen: 7,860 (48.2) | +596 |
| 2020 | 93 | 9,530 (53.7) | Mike Vondran: 7,549 (42.6) | +1,981 |
| 2022 | 94 | 5,793 (42.9) | Mike Vondran: 7,512 (55.6) | -1,719 |